Author Archives: SHG

If Rocky’s “Dead”, Then What?

The Center for Community Strategies sent out a blast-email yesterday both announcing the changes to the Rockefeller drug laws and providing a great chart to show the impact of the changes.  It’s been picked up by the New York Criminal Bar Association and later by the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, and emailed around by them as well. 

But for those of you who figure that you have better places to spend your money than on bar association dues, you deserve access to this great piece of work as well.  I suggest you save this chart and keep it handy as a reference.  If you do New York drug defense, it should prove indispensable.






I can’t vouch for its accuracy in every respect, or every application, and thus remind everyone to do their own research to be certain that it’s correct in any specific case, but it’s certainly a great overview.  And thanks to the Center for Community Strategies for putting in the effort to prepare this chart. 

Score One for Henry Hyde

When Illinois Congressman Henry Hyde stuck an amendment into an appropriations bill in 1997, the Department of Justice went bonkers.  The Hyde Amendment (18 U.S.C. 3006[A]) was intended to create a penalty for prosecutorial abuse, an odd choice of concerns for a Republican at the time, but Henry Hyde was an unusual type of Republican, and didn’t let the law and order spirit blind him to the overbearing power of government, or its abuse.

The problem was that the Hyde Amendment, which provided for a defendant to obtain attorneys fees from the government, was limited to instances where the government’s conduct was “vexatious, frivolous, or in bad faith.”  That’s an extraordinarily high legal bar to meet, requiring not only the most egregiously bad faith acts one can imagine from the government, but a judge willing to agree.  It’s incredibly easy to beat the Hyde Amendment by the mere incantation of words that showed the slightest degree of either factual basis or good faith.  Most judges are notoriously reluctant to conclude that any government attorney was so totally evil as to invoke the Hyde Amendment.

Florida federal Judge Alan Gold, however, proved himself one of the rarest of the rare by his decision yesterday in U.S. v. Shaygan.  It took 50 pages of mostly tedious legal writing to spell out the details that led to his conclusion, that the actions of a handful of AUSAs in Miami, in taping communications with the defense attorneys, in concealing the reports of their conduct, in deceiving the court and in trying to whitewash their conduct, met that exceptionally high bar.  Judge Gold awarded the defendant the sum of $601,795.88, more than half the cost of his defense in the case. 

Despite the fact that Dr. Ali Shaygan was acquitted on every one of the 141 count indictment after a mere three hours of deliberation, itself a shocking outcome, that wasn’t nearly enough to invoke the Hyde Amendment.  It required some hard conclusions by Judge Gold, and he gave them.  That his decision is a somewhat painful read is unfortunate, but necessary to withstand the appeal that the government will most assuredly seek.  When a judge comes down hard, he needs to make his order bullet-proof, even if that takes some of the zing out of his words.  (Brian Tannebaum says that this is a decision every lawyer should print out, carry around with him and read. I doubt that many are so masochistic, so I suggest the Sun Sentinel’s more palatable recap.)

Still, he had a few goods lines in there, which are all the more poignant in light of the well-publicized words of Alaskan Judge Emmet Sullivan in the Ted Stevens and Dr. Ayman Saeed Abdullah Batarfi cases.

The various deficiencies in [AUSA] Cronin’s conduct constitute unethical behavior not befitting the role of a prosecutor. As an initial matter, Cronin’s displeasure and ill-will toward defense counsel as a result of Defendant’s Motion to Suppress, as evidenced by his “seismic shift” comment, led to the filing of a Superseding Indictment that significantly defense. Such a “threat,” regardless of how Cronin now argues it should be interpreted, is inappropriate in the face of a legitimate motion by the defense, one on which the defense ultimately prevailed. Further, the collateral investigation was unfounded, motivated in part by Cronin’s personal animus against the defense team and fueled by his deliberate failure to exercise independent and objective judgment regarding the basis for such an investigation. Indeed, although Wells only expressed concerns that Tucker may be “going south” and that she needed to be “settled down,” Cronin unilaterally proceeded to explore the possibility of a “witness tampering” investigation. The pursuit of the collateral investigation further evidenced Cronin’s central role in attempting to improperly secure incriminating evidence against the defense team to his advantage.

Finally, Cronin, along with Hoffman, did not intend to bring the existence of the collateral investigation to my attention. As detailed above, Gilbert brought this matter to my attention on February 23, 2009, who had found out by sheer coincidence when socializing with Cronin and Hoffman on the evening of February 19, 2009 that Clendening had mentioned his recording during cross-examination. While the existence of Clendening’s second recording was unknown to all involved, Cronin and Hoffman’s failure even at this point in time to realize the need for disclosure of the collateral investigation and the cooperative involvement in the investigation by two central witnesses for the prosecution – Vento and Clendening – is an egregious abdication of their ethical obligations. While Gilbert proclaims that the government in good faith brought these matters to my attention expeditiously after immediate consultations with Messrs. Senior and Sloman, her sentiment does not disguise the fact that Cronin and Hoffman did not believe there was a need for disclosure or otherwise go to anyone to ask for direction on how to proceed. Had Gilbert not met Cronin and Hoffman socially on the evening of February 19, 2009, none of the disclosures before me would have transpired, and the jury may well have reached a different result. In sum, Cronin, as aided by Hoffman, exhibited a pattern of “win-at-all-cost” behavior in the conduct of this investigation that was contrary to their ethical obligations as prosecutors and a breach of their “heavy obligation to the accused.”

What’s striking about Judge Gold’s recitation is how the personal hatred between the assistant in charge of the prosecution, stemming from the defense lawyer doing his job, motivated him to fabricate a “witness tampering” allegation, which then justified his recording calls with David Markus, Shaygan’s lead lawyer, then conceal and deceive to cover his tracks.  It all started with the arrogance of anger because the defense lawyer challenged AUSA Sean Cronin, and one little pissant assistant decided that he had the power to make Markus pay for his insolence.

All the polysyllabic words that appear with annoying regularity in court decisions, and all the platitudes that judges and stiff-suit lawyers love to fall back on to uphold the majesty of the law, mask a very sorry reality in the trenches:  The integrity of the system inevitably comes down to someone, somewhere, making the decision to do the right thing or not.  Sometimes they can’t tell what the right thing is, though they want to do it.  Sometimes, as here, it comes down to one Assistant United States Attorney deciding that he is going to teach defense counsel a lesson because he’s pissed.  The entire majesty of the law, the United States and it’s unbearable power is no better than one angry man.

Before anyone gets too worked up about how great this all worked out, bear in mind that Shaygan had to go to trial before he was found not guilty of 141 counts.  That wasn’t nearly as much fun as it sounds.  He may have been awarded over $600k by Judge Gold, but that’s only a portion of the more than a million dollars the defense cost him and he hasn’t received a dime of it yet and, should he get it at all, it will be a long time before he sees it.  His life is likely in shambles, his name is ruined and his medical practice destroyed.  And he was acquitted the first time around.  This is the best it can get in our legal system.

Judge Gold found this scandalous conduct “profoundly disturbing,” as well he should.  Maybe this is the start of a trend of federal judges beginning to have a glimmer of the damage that can happen when they wink at the government daily.  But the damage is far more profoundly disturbing than this decision acknowledges.  Even the dreaded Hyde Amendment can’t undo the harm cause Dr. Shaygan by the animus of one assistant, schooled in the “win at all costs” culture of federal criminal practice.  And it does nothing for the many thousand of others who were less successful fighting against the overbearing power of the United States government.

Still, it’s a start.

Admit It! It Sucks! (Secret Wexler Photo Update)

Jay Wexler started it at PrawfsBlawg.  It being all curmudgeonly, I couldn’t resist.


Fans of Joe Queenan will recall a series of articles he wrote for Spy Magazine in the early 90s called “Admit it!  It Sucks!” in which he skewered various things–jazz, “San Francisco”–that all good serious cultured intellectuals are supposed to say they love but that, if they were honest with themselves, would admit actually suck. 

As ridiculous as it seems, this is definitely worth a meme.  List three things that everybody says they love but really, if truth be told, suck.  Then pass it along to three blawgers who you either love or hate, according to how you feel about memes.

Here goes.

Sushi.  It’s raw fish, for God’s sake! It’s what you would step over so as not to get it on your shoe.  And people not only eat it, but pay to eat it.  If I was trying to torture someone, I’d give sushi serious consideration.  It sucks.

Pinot Grigio.  It tastes like petroleum detritus.  But if enough people say a wine tastes good, all the people who can’t tell the difference will agree.  Whoever started people on drinking Pinot Grigio must be laughing awfully hard.

Soccer.  The perfect game for people who think baseball is too exciting. 

I wonder what Bennett, Gideon and Tannebaum will have to say?  Of course, Tannebaum may not be familiar with things cultured intellectuals are supposed to say they love.  We’ll see.


My Photo

Update:  Hidden camera photograph of Jay Wexler happily eating giant killer asparagus after cricket match.  Crystal stemware glass filled to the brim with Pinot Grigio not pictured.

The Whole Spoiled Bunch

Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy raised a fascinating question about whether the Ted Steven debacle reflects another “one bad apple” scenario, or whether this will be seen as the tip of the iceberg.



For example, the Wall Street Journal has this piece, headlined “Justice Department Unit Is Again the Focus of Scrutiny,” which includes this notable passage:



Todd Foster, a former federal prosecutor in Tampa and Houston and a former Federal Bureau of Investigation agent, questions whether the case would have been re-examined as closely if it hadn’t involved a U.S. senator. “My question is what happens to the rest of us?” he asked. “What happens when the person doesn’t have the resources Sen. Stevens had?  What happens to those cases that don’t reach the attorney general?”


I don’t think anyone who toils in federal courts doubts that the fact that Stevens was a Senator played a monumental role in the outcome.  Not preclusive, as I’ve had cases involving defendants who were held neither great power nor wealth, which ended with the courts recognizing massive impropriety.  But as has any other lawyer in federal courts, I’ve had many more cases where the word of the prosecutor was taken as per se truth for no better reason than they were the government.

Still, is this the case, the epiphany, that will shake the foundation of the federal system and make everyone wake up and smell the stench?  Or is there really no offensive odor, and just a few wild cowboys using the vast power we’ve entrusted to them improperly.  Is the fact that they’ve been exposed evidence that the system worked and they failed in their effort to undermine the system and violate their trust?


And Politico has this lengthy and effective article by Josh Gerstein headlined “Fed judges are fed up.”   It includes these potent quotes:

One veteran trial lawyer who practices in Washington said long-serving judges like Judge Sullivan are often deeply outraged by government misconduct because they realize how many defendants have seen their fates sealed based on promises or assurances from prosecutors. 

“Judges that have been on the bench that long rely on the prosecutors, they rely on the government attorneys, because they have to,” said the longtime litigator, who asked not be named. “When their confidence is shaken because of something they’ve seen, suddenly it dawns on them that they’ve been presiding over all these cases all these years and this might be the tip of the iceberg, maybe the wool has been pulled over their eyes. It’s disconcerting.”

Others said the failings were likely to be more widespread than just the Public Integrity Section, at the heart of the Stevens prosecution. ““You would think if any section of the Department of Justice would know how to comply … it would be that section,” said a lawyer who regularly faces off with DOJ attorneys.


We’re now getting into the deeper problems that not only cause prosecutorial misconduct, but allow it to persist.  Doug “tend[s] to view a lot of misconduct as the result of a bad culture rather and not just bad apples.”  I agree, having known AUSAs of extraordinary virtue, even though occasionally quite wrong about their beliefs.  After all, many are young, remarkably inexperienced (in the worldly sense)  and incredibly arrogant, but not at all malevolent.  I’ve even met AUSAs who put their own careers on the line when they came to realize that wrongdoing was happening, and others who stepped into the breach to protect and commit wrongdoing when the honest AUSA refused.

But the statement about judges being on the bench too long is what troubles me most.  The AUSAs come from an internal culture that puts enormous pressure on them to convict with any means.  Even the well-intended AUSA sees the world through prosecution-colored glasses, and believes in the propriety of putting those she believes to be criminal in prison.  It’s the overarching directive.  Only by this mindset can one who hated a defendant as the worst human being alive yesterday, believe in the same defendant with all their heart and soul when they become their cooperator today.  Or at least feign belief before a judge.

It’s the judge who sits on the big bench who has failed in his responsibility to question and doubt.   I cannot agree that it’s a matter of longevity on the bench.  Some are like that on day one.  Some come to realize over time that their faith in the prosecution is misplaced.  Most believe whatever the prosecution says from day one until the day they step down.

A commenter to Doug’s post sums it up well:


“Judges that have been on the bench that long rely on the prosecutors, they rely on the government attorneys, because they have to,”,


No, actually they don’t have to do that; they choose to do it. The judge is a neutral arbitrator of the truth and a defender of the process. The word of the prosecutor is no better or worse in the abstract than the word of the defense attorney. I don’t think the problem is the prosecutors themselves so much as it is the willful blindness of federal judges, a large percentage of which a former prosecutors themselves. I think it is too little remarked upon that judges face significant challenges when they go from the role of a prosecutor to the role of the judge. Those roles require very different things out of people and a very different attitude to the law and what’s happening in the court room.


“suddenly it dawns on them that they’ve been presiding over all these cases all these years and this might be the tip of the iceberg, maybe the wool has been pulled over their eyes.”


If the wool was pulled over their eyes, they need to look to their own behavior first. The prosecutor and government attorneys may have supplied the wool, but it was the judge’s own two hands that were doing the grabbing and pulling.


It is beyond frustrating to try to persuade some federal judges that the government’s view of the facts, of the honesty of a particular witness, usually a cooperator, is just plain wrong.  Sitting in a courtroom, listening to a judge expound on the facts, day becomes night, black becomes white.  The real world gives way to a judicially found fiction, and that fiction becomes the reality upon which the judgment of a court is founded.  There is no more surreal experience.  There is no explanation, except the cynical, to tell a defendant why everything they know to be true, that you know to be true, has just ceased to exist.

So while the prosecutors in the Ted Stevens case were likely outed to a large extent because of the profile of the defendant, and while Judge Sullivan’s epiphany was likely real, and while the culture of the Department of Justice, and it’s United States Attorneys’ offices throughout the country, all played a role in this latest debacle, the very existence of the federal judiciary as the stop-gap against the government’s power has proven to be largely a failure.  The judges chose to accept the government’s word, to squint their eyes when needed to make sure the system runs smoothly and to shrug off the cues that should tell them that there is something very wrong happening right in front of them.

As I, and others, have noted that despite Judge Sullivan’s conversion to doubt, he offers no explanation for his failure to address any of the clear signs of impropriety throughout the Stevens trial.  While it’s good that Judge Sullivan eventually came to realize that he was played, it doesn’t change his failure as a judge to have addressed it during the course of the trial. Sure, the situation worsened significantly with post-trial disclosures of impropriety, but it serves only to highlight that there were clear allegations of impropriety during the course of the trial that were noted by the judge, and yet he did absolutely nothing beyond spouting some cautionary words about it.  He had the chance to do something, to act upon what was happening right before his eyes, and he chose to do nothing.

Until judges stop viewing the government as being inherently right, inherently trustworthy, inherently deserving of the benefit of the doubt (and far beyond the mere doubt), they are the pivot point of a corrupt system.  It is the function of the judge to ensure the integrity of the criminal justice system.  As long as judges favor the prosecution, they cannot fulfill that function. 

Prosecutors can be bad, and that’s why we have judges to rule against them.  If judges won’t do that, then why do we play this game?

Someone Is Keeping Score

I’m embarrassed to say this, but I didn’t know that Packratt, proprietor-at-risk of Injustice in Seattle, was a twitterer.  Until yesterday, when I had to learn from Radley Balko that he has a twitter feed.  Why is Balko always at least one step ahead of me?

So naturally, I immediately followed Packratt and was amazed by the scope of information he’s putting out there.  Check this out:



If you are interested in keeping abreast of developments in law enforcement misconduct, this is the motherlode.  Packratt is doing an unbelievable job of marshalling and disseminating reports from across the country.  If there’s anyone you need to follow on twitter to keep abreast of the subject, it’s Packratt.  His twitter feed is @Injust_Seattle, and he has my admiration and appreciation for his efforts.

Judge Sullivan is Pissed. For Real

The words that were spoken as United States District Court Judge Emmet Sullivan grew tired of the Justice Department’s foot-dragging were extraordinary.  From the Legal Times, which has followed this closely, as has Mike at Crime and Federalism :



At a hearing Tuesday morning in the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia on the government’s motion to dismiss, Sullivan said Stevens’ case was symptomatic of a larger trend of misconduct.  The judge urged his colleagues around the country to enter exculpatory evidence orders at the outset of every criminal case, and to require that exculpatory material be turned over in a usable form.


The judge said Attorney General Eric Holder Jr. should train new and veteran prosecutors on the rules of evidence.  He further suggested that President Barack Obama obtain the commitment of prospective U.S. attorneys to abide by these rules, and that the Senate Judiciary Committee push nominees on this point during confirmation hearings.


“We must never forget the Supreme Court’s directive that a criminal trial is a search for the truth. Yet in several cases recently, this court has seen troubling failures to produce exculpatory evidence in violation of the law and this court’s orders,” Sullivan said.


Strong words, backed up by strong actions, almost unheard of in federal court.  But still, the nagging questions of why Judge Sullivan did nothing about this during the trial itself, and the fact that the case happened to involve a United States Senator, might take some of the bloom off the rose. 

But there is a second story about Judge Sullivan that gives real meaning to his admonition.  Via Turley and Jeralyn, Judge Sullivan is bringing the hammer down in the case of Dr. Ayman Saeed Abdullah Batarfi, a Gitmo detainee who brought a habeas petition.


The Justice Department improperly withheld important psychiatric records of a government witness who was used in a “significant” number of Guantanamo cases, a federal judge has concluded.


The government censored parts of the records, but enough has been made public that it’s clear that the witness, a fellow detainee, was being treated weekly for a serious psychological problem and was questioned about whether he had any suicidal thoughts. The witness provided information in the government’s case for detaining Aymen Saeed Batarfi, a Yemeni doctor who the government announced last week it would no longer seek to detain.


And Judge Sullivan made clear that he’s had enough of the government:


During a hearing last week, Sullivan castigated the government for not turning over the medical records and ordered department lawyers to explain why he shouldn’t cite them for contempt of court.


“To hide relevant and exculpatory evidence from counsel and from the court under any circumstances, particularly here where there is no other means to discover this information and where the stakes are so very high . . . is fundamentally unjust, outrageous and will not be tolerated,” Sullivan said, according to a transcript of the hearing.


“How can this court have any confidence whatsoever in the United States government to comply with its obligations and to be truthful to the court?”


And he’s not putting up with it anymore:

…”I’m not going to continue to tolerate indefinite delay on the part of the United States government,” Sullivan said. “I mean this Guantanamo issue is a travesty . . . a horror story . . . and I’m not going to buy into an extended indefinite delay of this man’s stay at Guantanamo.”

“The sanction is going to be high,” he said. “I’ll tell you quite frankly if I have to start incarcerating people to get my point across I’m going to start at the top.”

Batarfi is no Senator.  Gitmo detainees don’t generate a great deal of public sympathy, nor even much press attention, so barking at the government has little beneficial payoff.  This makes it all quite real for Judge Sullivan, and his statements and actions, both disclosing what is increasingly appearing to be widespread misconduct and actually doing something about it are, well, shocking.

It’s premature to suggest that Judge Sullivan’s epiphany will spread across the federal judiciary, district by district, judge by judge, to force others to realize that the games the government has been playing forever, and which judges have routinely ignored, are really happening and have rendered the criminal justice system a farce.

But it’s a start.  Had it just been Ted Stevens, I would be reluctant to gush about Judge Emmet Sullivan’s statements and actions.  Stevens was just too easy to fall into the isolated incident category.  But with Judge Sullivan’s words and deeds in the Batarfi case, I believe he means business.  Given the nature of the federal judiciary, this is quite a brazen act of bravery. 

The Winds of Change in New York Are Blowing

It’s odd how we fight for years over incremental change, then all of a sudden there’s change everywhere you look.  Last week, New York finally made some tweaks to the draconian Rockefeller drug laws, providing ridiculously harsh sentences for small as well as large drug offenses that filled prisons beyond capacity but did little to stem drug sale and use.

While falling far short of the “death” of the Rockefeller laws, it was a significant improvement, at least for the lower level offenses, and for the first time took treatment alternatives out of the hands of prosecutors and put them into the hands of judges.  While the top of the range still holds minor league drug dealers and possessors as if they were drug kingpins, and sentences them as if they were murderers, at least it offers some relief where it’s been long known that the laws had failed in their purpose long ago.  Naturally, the opposition to the change was form upstate legislators whose counties were the home to prisons and prisons provided their larger employers.  A great reason for incarceration.

Then, the New York State Bar Association, which provides the straight-laced voice of the legal profession in New York, approved a task force’s recommendation for videotaping identifications and interrogations.


The state bar leaders approved the findings of the task force on wrongful convictions Saturday without opposition in an Albany meeting. Recommendations include videotaping all eyewitnesses as they make identifications, and all defendants’ statements to law enforcement officials, if possible.

The task force recommendations, led by newly minted criminal court judge Barry Kamins, stated that the entire criminal justice system suffers whenever an innocent person is convicted.


“It is difficult to imagine what individuals must endure mentally, physically and emotionally after being incarcerated for months and years for crimes they did not commit,” Judge Kamins said. “In addition, every time an innocent person is arrested, convicted and sent to jail, law enforcement officials and prosecutors are distracted from locating the real perpetrator – who may never be brought to justice.”

While the lege has yet to act on this NYSBA’s recommendation, it carried sufficient legitimacy and clout to make the state take notice, giving New York a very real chance of changing procedures that have proven conducive to mistaken identifications and false confessions.

To top it off, the state legislature enacted a law the provides for the Chief Administrative Judge to cap caseloads for public defenders in New York City.


Under the law, New York State’s chief administrative judge would be required to establish new caseload standards for public defenders by April 1, 2010. The judiciary would then have four years to phase in the limits and ensure proper funding. Despite the state’s grim economic condition, the judiciary’s budget for the current fiscal year remained stable at $2.57 billion.

While it’s unclear where the cap will be, or how the cap will apply to individual lawyers, or why they have given the Chief Administrative Judge a five year window to deal with  a problem that exists today, at least this provides recognition that the least powerful amongst us, the indigent defendants and the lawyers charged with defending them, must be provided with meaningful representation. 

The plan has raised certain concerns, with Brooks Holland, a former Bronx Legal Aid lawyer and current lawprof, raising the specter of external court scrutiny over the caseload management of individual public defenders. 


With this new external enforcement of caseload standards, could greater external scrutiny of individual attorney “productivity” come with it? I’m hard pressed to think that some inquiry into individual attorney work practices wouldn’t be expected and even necessary for the judiciary to determine what caseloads reasonably can be managed by diligent and attentive lawyers. But public defenders understandably should be expected to resist external scrutiny of individual attorney case management, in part because of its potential to interfere with attorneys’ independent professional judgment, see N.Y. Code of Prof. Resp. Canon 5 and EC 5-1, and in part because public defenders already battle against many clients’ impression that we already answer to the government.

While Brooks has a point, given government’s general inability to keep its nose out of things it doesn’t understand, plus the grocery clerk’s tendency to oversee something as variable as legal representation by use of a checklist, it would be hard to imagine the legislature and courts not trying to interfere with the level of services needed. You can’t expect a grocery clerk to understand that felony trials take longer than misdemeanors, right?  But that’s the giveback; The bureaucracy giveth and then makes life miserable.

Will this prove to be a tsunami of real change, a breeze of fresh air or just a quick blow?  Time will tell.  But it’s been a very busy week for criminal law in New York, busier than any week I can think of in the past 25 years. Now it’s time to keep an eye on things and see whether these changes are for real.

Resist the Urge

From Ken Lammers’ sidebar of bizarre prosecutorial tricks comes this important bit of news via the AP :



A federal judge sentenced a Sioux Falls man to probation, a fine and restitution for sending a letter containing animal feces in the mail. Jeffrey Dezeeuw, 45, pleaded guilty to a count of mailing injurious articles.


Prosecutors said he smeared the excrement on a traffic citation, a note and cash that he sent to the Minnehaha County Clerk of Courts on July 21.


Dezeeuw was sentenced to three years of probation, a $500 fine and ordered to pay restitution of $451.


It’s the mail.  It’s a federal offense.  But most importantly, the person who has to open the letter and touch all that yucky stuff is not the cop who gave you the citation.  In other words, no matter how good you think it feels, you’re getting the wrong person.  And before Jdog asks, I do not think the type of animal from which the feces was derived is relevant.

As a corollary, please wash your hands both before and after mailing in your traffic citation.

Cooperate, As a General Rule

From Balko, the Transportation Safety Administration has posted a response to the airing of its employees handling of Steve Bierfeldt, the Campaign for Liberty staffer who tried to board a plane with $4700 in cash.  If there’s anything better than the surreptitious recording of the interactions between a citizen and a government employee, fresh out of his job at Dairy Queen and with a shiny set of handcuffs at his waist, it’s the government’s attempt to explain itself.


At approximately 6:50 p.m. on March 29, 2009, a metal box alarmed the X-ray machine at Lambert-St. Louis International Airport, triggering the need for additional screening. Because the box contained a number of items including a large amount of cash, all of which needed to be removed to be properly screened, it was deemed more appropriate to continue the screening process in a private area. A Transportation Security Administration (TSA) employee and members of the St. Louis Airport Police Department can be heard on the audio recording. The tone and language used by the TSA employee was inappropriate. TSA holds its employees to the highest professional standards. TSA will continue to investigate this matter and take appropriate action.

Movements of large amounts of cash through the checkpoint may be investigated by law enforcement authorities if criminal activity is suspected. As a general rule, passengers are required to cooperate with the screening process. Cooperation may involve answering questions about their property, including why they are carrying a large sum of cash. A passenger who refuses to answer questions may be referred to appropriate authorities for further inquiry.

Now I’m not exactly a stickler about personification, but I still can’t imagine how an X-ray machine can be alarmed.  Does it get scintillated when it sees racy underwear?  The possibilities are scary, and I’m now concern about what my possessions do to the machine, both because I expect X-ray machines to be fairly expensive and I wouldn’t want to break one, and because I fear that my things will bore the machine to tears.  Do machines cry too?  But I digress.

It’s always curious that a government agency, when confronted by indisputable evidence of its wrongdoing, responds that it will continue to “investigate”.  Investigate what?  Once you possess the information necessary to know that your people screwed up, it seems that the time to investigate has past.  I suspect there’s a rule in every Law Enforcement Union contract that requires all governmental agencies to use the word “investigate” at least once in every press release, and they have trademarked the word and get a royalty each and every time.  If so, it’s brilliant.

But the bigger question left hanging by the TSA’s statement is why, from the point of view of our government, is the mere possession of cash a reason to suspect criminal activity?  As a commenter at the TSA’s blog noted, is $4700 the new threshold for the amount of cash a person can carry before becoming a target?  Another questioned how carrying cash in any way implicated the TSA’s mission, as well as the presumption that just because some TSA employee asks doesn’t mean that citizens are obliged to answer.

But the focus on the TSA may push us off course a bit.  Just as our customs inspectors aren’t charged with general law enforcement duties, it hasn’t stopped them from checking laptops for porn.  What makes us think that our many and varied quasi-law enforcement personnel haven’t all suffered from mission creep, seeing themselves as the protectors of some vague governmental interest in ferreting out evils wherever they’re found?

As any merchant will tell you, cash is king.  As any governmental employee will tell you, cash means you’re presumptively a criminal.  This absurd response from the TSA, lacking even the slightest recognition that its role is not to excuse its staff from making up rules based upon the sensibilities of each and every former burger flipper in a blue shirt and enforce them against people who pose no threat to aviation.

Consider this line from the statement:


As a general rule, passengers are required to cooperate with the screening process. Cooperation may involve answering questions about their property, including why they are carrying a large sum of cash.

As Steve Bierfeldt asked, in a polite tone, over and over, says who?  The question remains unanswered.

CDL Tip of the Day: Check for Video BEFORE Commenting

The list of potential ways a criminal defense lawyer can make himself appear foolish is inexhaustible, but given current technology, some are just more likely than others.  Video.  It’s a killer.

By now, the video of the raid on Jose Duran’s bodega in September, 2007 by the Philadelphia narcotics squad has made it’s way across the blawgosphere, and we’ve all been treated to the still of a police officer cutting the wire to the video camera prior to looting the place.  But the part of the story that struck me wasn’t the obvious, that narcotics cops lie, cheat and steal.  It was the part where Officer Jeffrey Cujdik’s lawyer saw an opportunity to get his name in the paper. 

Told of the new allegations, George Bochetto, an attorney representing Cujdik, said that he stood by his earlier response:

“Now that the Daily News has created a mass hysteria concerning the Philadelphia Narcotics Unit, it comes as no surprise that every defendant ever arrested will now proclaim their innocence and bark about being mistreated.

“Suffice it to say, there is a not a scintilla of truth to such convenient protestations.”

First, never, but never, use the word scintilla when talking to the media.





Main Entry: scin·til·la
Pronunciation: \sin-ˈti-lə\
Function: noun
Etymology: Latin
Date: 1661

Spark, Trace <not a scintilla of doubt>
Nobody uses words like “scintilla” except lawyers.  And even “iota” should be avoided like the plague.  Even if your purpose is to show your friends and neighbors what a wonderful latin-derivative vocabulary you have, scintilla wouldn’t be the way to go.  This might have been the perfect occasion to use, stercus accidit, with a wink on the back end.

As to the rest of Bochetto’s comment, doesn’t he look like a fruitcake now?  The old Ronnie Reagan line, “there you go again,” isn’t easily delivered and is often overplayed.  You see, when there’s video of your client doing the dirty, it takes the some of the pizazz out of a perfectly good statement.

Contrary to popular lawyer belief, you are not under an obligation to make a statement to the media just because someone gives you a jingle.  Sometimes, when you have something particularly profound to say, it could work out well for you.  Other times, not so well.  But the problem with most lawyers is that they don’t engage that part of their brain that is commonly used in the defense of clients when they are on the receiving end of a reporter’s phone call.  Instead, the self-promotion lobe kicks into gear, and they see the headline with their name in bold, the hero of the day. 

What is it about lawyers who so badly desire publicity that they will speak to the media no matter what the situation?  We are, if nothing else, a desperate bunch, trying anything we can to distinguish ourselves from the crowd.  Toiling day after day in the trenches, the dream of prominence clouds our ability to say the right thing at the right moment.  Just spell our names right, we think to ourselves.

George Bochetto got his name in the paper.  But I can’t say that it impressed me much.  Given the existence of the video that shows that there are a whole buncha scintillas that the “protestations” against his client are awfully well-founded, the only “mass hysteria” seems to be Bochetto’s belief that his statement was going to make him look like anything other than a fool.

I hope that George doesn’t “bark about being mistreated” when he sees this.  I’m just trying to help.