Author Archives: SHG

Bean Bag Bingo

The truth is, I’ve been somewhat hard on Tasers.  After all, they aren’t nearly as deadly as a magnum in the hands of someone who can shoot straight. But what if there was a “weapon” that was less lethal, more friendly-sounding, almost like a child’s toy?  Hey, what about bean bags?



A motorist who failed to yield to Fresno police died after a confrontation with several officers early Monday morning in south Fresno, police say. The man, who fought off less-lethal bean-bag rounds and electronic shock darts, stopped breathing after he was wrestled to the ground by four officers and handcuffed, Fresno Chief Jerry Dyer said.


The unidentified man was pronounced dead at Community Regional Medical Center.


The Taser is described as non-lethal, but the Fresno Bee describes bean-bag “rounds” as less-lethal.  It’s not quite clear what they mean by that.  Does that mean that the chances of surviving a bean bag attack is 50%?  Or maybe it has to do with where the bean bags (it seems that calling them bean bag rounds is redundant) strike, with a shot in the kisser being fatal while a strike in the humerus less so.


It began when officers spotted a car that ran a stoplight at Jensen and Cedar avenues, Dyer said. Officers turned on emergency lights and followed the car in a low-speed pursuit to Jensen and East avenue, where the driver pulled into a Shell Service station and got out. The driver was “combative and belligerent,” Dyer said, prompting officers to fire “several” beanbag rounds at him to no effect. Officers then fired electronic stun darts at the driver, who pulled one of the darts from his body.

Since I don’t practice in Fresno like Rick Horowitz, I can’t claim familiarity with common knowledge of drivers following a proper traffic stop.  Maybe drivers are well aware of police shooting bean bags at people who are “combative and belligerent,” which sounds far more ominous than saying the driver told the cops to take a flying leap.  Maybe he was temping the cops to fire some bean bags at him to see how less-lethal they are.  So many “maybes”.  I can’t help but wonder whether this death could have been avoided if the police kept the whole bean bag thing to themselves.  I wonder if the next less-lethal victim will be some child, mistakenly believing that the police are offering free toys for tots?

It seems as though a lot of people who break traffic laws end up dead.  While I’m not a fan of people who drive slowly dangerously, I really don’t think that it’s worth a life to stop them.  It seems that many police officers disagree with me.  Some are more ambivalent about it, and therefore chose to employ less-lethal force to shut down uncooperative motorists.

Somehow, the deployment of less-lethal bean bags against a belligerent driver doesn’t seem like such a terrible thing to do.  Until he dies.

H/T @radleybalko

No Future Here

In the background, you can hear the “hosannas” swelling from the choir.  A new day is dawning, they sing.  Their hands wave over their heads and the fervor spreads through the crowd.  The audience is on its feet, swaying with the sound, eyes rolling back in their heads in rapture.  The new age is almost upon us.

At Spamnotes, Venkat Balasubramani has been watching and waiting for the revolution, only to find that it’s a dud.


In short, I don’t claim to have any expertise in this, but I’ve been participating enough to make an informed call on when someone is being overly exuberant.  (In colloquial terms, let’s just say I know enough when to call bs.)  Through my participation in social media, I came across a book written by Richard Susskind that comments on big picture changes coming to the legal profession.  Susskind wrote a book (which I have yet to read) which predicts that the lawyering profession will be so fundamentally changed in the near future that we will not recognize lawyers, or at least law firms as we know them today.  I don’t know that I would have come across Richard Susskind or his book “The End of Lawyers” through another channel.  If so, I certainly would not have paid as much attention to it. 

Advocates see it as a revolution.  For those who believe it, it’s become a religion.  For those who simply wonder what the choir is singing about, it’s some vagary that appeals to those who don’t seem to notice the absence of substance. 

Susskind spoke at ABA Legal Tech, and his followers swooned, twittering about his genius and about how very right he was. Venkat followed closely:


So I was excited to see that Nicole Black posted a collection of tweets from Susskind’s keynote.  I thought this would be an opportunity to see a collection of the most poignant quotes and reactions from Susskind’s talk, in realtime, using social media, as relayed by the cutting edge participants in the revolution.  What more could someone ask for?  I was disappointed.

The tweets are basically a collection of buzzwords that will give any dot com marketing brochure a run for the money.  I came across such gems as “be proactive – invent the future – make it happen,” and “as we move from customization to commoditization quality goes up.”  I didn’t come across a single example or piece of advice on how technology will fundamentally reshape the legal profession and what the people in the room could do in order to make sure they participated.

Perhaps the greatest failing of the blawgosphere, not to mention the twittersphere and whatever ‘sphere will be next week’s marvel, is that there are a host of otherwise nice enough folks who are so dedicated to the religion of social media that they spend most of their time prosteletyzing the desperate and uninitiated to believe that social media is the future of law. 

As expected, a challenge to the new orthodoxy brought out Joan of Ark, defender of the faith.


I’ve only read the very beginning of his book, but I expect it will be illuminating in terms of examples of the main points that he sets forth therein.

That being said, the examples you set out in the end of your post are exactly what he’s talking about, as I understand it, and as I see it, from my own perspective.

The practice of law and communications between lawyers and clients will be increasingly conducted online. Many functions will be outsourced (paralegals, assistants, associate research and writing)–as in occurring outside of the office-thus saving overhead.

Clients will use online services and forms for basic document drafting rather than lawyers.

Lawyers will engage on sites like JDSupra and Avvo–as will potential clients, thus creating a type of “social network” envisioned by Susskind.

There’s no way to accurately predict where the legal field and technology will go in the future. I agree 100% with Gary Vaynerchuk when he says that the smart business person, rather than trying to predict, is very observant and notices trends and capitalizes on them before anyone else.

This comment clearly expresses one vision of the future.  It’s not my vision.  It doesn’t matter how many marketers are teaching young lawyers that the practice of law is all about marketing themselves like laundry detergent.  I do not see my future as a lawyer tied to being the King of Free Advice on Avvo.  Or perhaps you can join the ranks of the many so-called “practicing lawyers” who are now available for consultation and speaking engagements on the subject of social media and the future of the law.  It’s the newest cottage industry for those who have nothing better to do with their time.  Like representing clients.

I agree the you have to notice the trend and capitalize on it.  While the converts to social media as the future of the law are busy trying to find their place amongst the deceptive and mediocre, distinguish yourself as the honest and excellent. 

Has anybody gained wealth and prominence as a lawyer by twitting?  Anybody?  Has it made anybody a better lawyer?  Anybody?

Social media can be a fun way to kill some time, but it is not the future of law. 

Reinventing Miranda

From SCOTUSBlog, Lyle Denniston discusses whether the Supremes will take a case, which Justice Thomas appears pretty hot on, out of Florida on whether Miranda requires the police to inform the suspect prior to interrogation that he has the right to have an attorney present during the interrogation, or merely that he can consult with an attorney before answer questions.  Of course, all this presumes that Miranda warnings are given at all, which sometimes doesn’t happen even though the cops remember it distinctly when hearings and trial roll around.

But Lyle’s post got me thinking.  Given that Miranda was made up  from whole cloth in the first place, essentially a Supreme Court Justices vision of good stuff to say to make clear to the subject of an interrogation that he really, really should keep his mouth shut, and given that it’s turned out to be a boon to the police and failed miserably to fulfill its purpose for defendants who simply cannot control the compulsion to have noise emit from their yaps, what if we had a shot at reinventing MIranda?

What would you want to include in the Miranda warning?  The current generally accepted warnings (long form) are as follows:



  1. You have the right to remain silent. Do you understand?

  2. Anything you do say can and will be used against you in a court of law. Do you understand?

  3. You have the right to consult an attorney before speaking to the police and to have an attorney present during questioning. Do you understand?

  4. If you cannot afford an attorney, one will be appointed for you.  Do you understand?

  5. Understanding your rights as I have explained them to you, are you willing to answer my questions?

Notice that there is nothing in there about, “so, if you don;t want to answer my questions, what are you afraid of?”  And, of course, there is no requirement that the defendant sign off that the rights have been given.  But putting these minor details aside, what else should be in there?

Here’s some additional thoughts that I think should be considered for inclusion:



  • If you want to exercise your right to an attorney, the only thing you need to say to me is “I want an attorney now” and I will stop the interrogation until you have an attorney to represent you.  Say something different, however, and I will continue to interrogate you.


  • No matter how good your story is, I am not going to let you go afterward.


  • I may pretend to like you, but I really don’t.  It’s just to get you to talk to me.


  • This interrogation is not being recorded, so my recollection of what you say is the only one that counts.  And sometimes, I don’t remember things the same as other people.


  • Everything you say, even if you think you’re being funny or just filling the uncomfortable silence, is going to be used against you.  And words spoken in jest don’t sound nearly as funny at trial.


  • If you ask me questions, like should you have a lawyer or should you answer my questions, I will lie to you because the law allows me to do that.


  • If at any time you decide that you no longer want to answer my questions, you can tell me you want me to stop asking questions and I will end the interrogation immediately.  But if you don’t say the magic words, I will continue to question you until I’ve used up the entire overtime budget, because I can.

I’m sure there are many other questions, and indeed many other approaches to the problem.  Unfortunately, I am limited by my personal Miranda Myopia.  Any other ideas?

“The Attorneys At Our Firm” or Why Lawyers Can’t Count

In the land of hype, the shameless man is king.  Even though I’m on the road this weekend, I take a few minutes to check my email and keep abreast of things.  One thing that came across bothered me, mostly because it was an effort I admired while simultaneously presenting an issue that made me cringe.

I received an email from a young attorney trying to get himself on the misdemeanor indigent defense panel seeking the opportunity to second seat at trial.  This is exactly what he should be doing, with the obvious caveat that the first seat have a clue, but that’s not within his power to control.  Since I support efforts like this, I checked out the young attorney’s website.  It wasn’t good.

The website spoke to the “attorneys of the firm,” “their vast experience” and “excellent results.”  All total nonsense.  All lies.  This was a one man shop with almost no experience whatsoever.  I understand, though I do not condone, the exaggerated claims of experience.  No client wants to pop a lawyer’s cherry.  But why the lies to suggest that there are multiple lawyers at the “firm”?  Multiple personalities comes to mind, but I doubt that he can claim psychosis as an excuse.

I occasionally indulge in the royal “we” here from time to time, and can always rely on someone like Gideon or Bennett to give me a good smack for doing so.  No matter how many times I look in the mirror (always a sobering experience), I’m still just one person.  I’m fortunate to have good friends to keep me honest.

So what is it about lawyers who feel compelled to deceive clients to pretend that they have some large law firm, with busy little bee lawyers running around doing their bidding?  Clearly, many clients take comfort in the idea that there are “resources” available should they hire this lawyer, a naive notion on the part of clients but one that persists nonetheless.  But the fact that clients like lawyers with lots of other lawyers surrounding them, it doesn’t change the fact that this is a figment of the lawyer’s imagination.  Or, to be more precise, a lie crafted to create the positive impression of substance where none exists.

Is this acceptable? Tolerable?  Understandable?  The answer, no matter how hard you squint, is that it is a deliberate deception.  It’s calculated to make a client believe something that you know to be false.  It’s certainly easy enough to do, and adding the plural to every attorney reference in the website creates the sort of impression that will make potential clients feel more secure about retaining your services, especially if you’re a kid lawyer who can’t manage to get on the misdemeanor panel yet.  But it’s a lie.

Granted, it’s not the sort of lie that will make other lawyers rat you out to the disciplinary committee.  There are plenty of lawyers doing far worse who will never receive a complaint letter, and you aren’t even in the ballgame of bad lawyers.  At least not for using the plural.  But I will remember you as being a lawyer who lies.  I will remember that you are the sort of person who will deceive your own potential clients to get their money. 

Or is your problem that you can’t count?  My problem is that I can’t count on you.  The young lawyer will now be marked as someone who would lie to get a client, and I don’t want him sitting next to me at trial.  Maybe you can second seat one of the many lawyers who comprise your law firm, but you can’t sit next to me.

Memo to Bloggers: Beware and Stand Up

It’s axiomatic that the pen is mightier than the sword.  But the sword still hurts, and don’t ever forget it.

From Carlos Miller at Photography is Not a Crime :



Phoenix police raided the home of a blogger who has been highly critical of the department.  Jeff Pataky, who runs Bad Phoenix Cops, said the officers confiscated three computers, routers, modems, hard drives, memory cards and everything necessary to continue blogging.


Maricopa County Judge Gary Donahoe gave the cops a search warrant for Pataky’s home to seized evidence of the crime of harassment.  He was harassing the cops but disclosing inside information about them. Any chance there’s a Judge Donahoe around your neck of the woods?

Packratt of Injustice in Seattle wrote about Pataky’s search on March 25, ahead of the pack again.  Like a bunch of citizen bloggers who try to keep track of police misconduct and spread the news, having themselves been the victim and wanting to make sure that it does not go unnoticed, he takes a risk.  He’s been threatened.  He’s been harassed.  He’s been told that they will get him for what he’s doing. 

They got Pataky.  Hardly a death blow, but enough to make things unpleasant.  It’s apparently just added fuel to Pataky’s fire, but then, perhaps they will make the next blow more painful.

Those of us who practice criminal defense see our exposure and discussion of police misconduct as a professional imperative.  We aren’t afraid, as we do this day in and out, as a matter of our professional choice.  Regular citizens don’t.  They take significant risks by doing what they are doing, and every once in a while can anticipate being the subject of an aggressive police response, like Pataky.

At the very least, there are two things we need to do.  First, is recognize that these bloggers are taking a very real personal risk by speaking out on the subject of local police misconduct and appreciate their bravery.  Second, make sure that we are doing everything we can to support their efforts, whether by being available for their defense or simply spreading the word about outrageous police conduct directed against those who seek to expose misconduct.  Let the police know that we are watching them as well, and that if they attack a blogger for writing, their misconduct will be exposed as far and wide as possible.

For those of you obsessed with blogging so that you can seek out new business and impress as many drunk drivers as possible with what a great job you will do for them, put aside the hype machine long enough to do something useful.  For those who focus only on the peculiar issues that seem to interest your readers, you can spare the bandwidth to do something for the greater good.

It is outrageous that a “police misconduct” blogger should be subject to search.  It is outrageous that the blawgosphere doesn’t raise hell about it.  Let’s put this bully pulpit to use for the greater good once in a while.  It won’t kill you.  This Phoenix raid should have been the subject of a post by every criminal defense lawyer blawger across the country this week.  Our silence was disgraceful.

Judge Rips Head Off “Hero Mom”

When the story of Doreen Guiliano’s efforts to save her son, she was hailed as the “hero mom.”  Apparently, Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Alan Marrus didn’t think as highly of her as did Christopher Ketchum at Vanity Fair.  From the New York Law Journal,

Brooklyn Supreme Court Justice Alan D. Marrus emphatically rejected the motion.


Citing the threat posed by such “vigilante” actions, Justice Marrus called on the Legislature and appellate courts to ramp up the protections afforded to juror privacy.

“Every juror who has served or will serve in a case should be alarmed by the conduct of the defendant’s mother in this case. Years after rendering a verdict, any juror could be the subject of a ‘sting’ operation by an associate of the party the juror voted against at the trial. The extraordinary actions of Giuliano to invade the privacy of jurors require a decisive response which sends a clear message that New York courts will protect its jurors,”

The decision in People v. Giuca goes to extraordinary lengths to show that Guiliano, and not “juror eight” poses the greatest threat to the integrity of the system.  And Justice Marrus misses no opportunity to slam her, again and again.


Most strikingly, however, the defendant’s motion reveals extraordinary misconduct, not by a juror, but by the woman who generated this motion — the defendant’s mother.  Acting as a self-appointed juror misconduct vigilante, with the obvious intention to destroy the credibility of a jury verdict that went against her son, the defendant’s mother violated the privacy rights of a juror and sought media coverage to support and glamorize her deceptive conduct before this motion was even filed in court.

Aside from Justice Marrus’ rejection of the tape recordings proffered in support of the motion, which he inexplicably rejected out of hand as failing to meet the requirements for admissibility into evidence even though he was wrong about the requirements and, more significantly, wouldn’t come into play until an evidentiary hearing was had, the judge spent a great deal of effort to show his outrage at Guiliano’s conduct.

One of the more curious arguments made by the court was that juror eight could not have withheld knowledge of the people involved because he asked the panel during voir dire whether they knew anyone, and he didn’t speak up.  Oddly, most people would have viewed this omission as the crux of the problem, rather than proof that there could be no problem.  But of course, if the court asks, and a juror sits mute, then it proves conclusively that there can be no juror misconduct,  After all, the court did ask.

While I had reservations about the tact taken by Guiliano from an institutional perspective, as if spending years tracking down jurors in the hope of catching them in a comment that could be used to undermine a verdict was an inherently good idea, it seemed that in this particular case she had struck gold.  According to the judge, however, she only struck a nerve.

On the other hand, Justice Marrus has gone a bit off the deep end at the other end of the pool, lashing out a mother who is trying save her son, a son she believes with all her heart is not guilty.  Does this really so offend Justice Marrus’ sensibilties that a mother of an innocent son would do whatever she could to vindicate her son?  Does it strike Justice Marrus as so impossible that Doreen Guiliano is right?

It would seem from the decision that as obsessive as Doreen Guiliano was in trying to help her son, Justice Marrus was her match in trying to impugn her.  If the dignity of the system is diminished by those who would disparage it, as Guiliano did, then it’s hardly enhanced by those who would disparage a mother trying to save an innocent son, as Justice Marrus did. 

TSA: What’s In Your Wallet?

As every law-abiding American knows, if you carry cash around in your pocket, you’re either a terrorist, a drug dealer or an honest liberty-loving citizen.  And the Transportation Safety Administration wants to make sure it knows which is which.  From Radley Balko at the Agitator comes this incredible tape of an interaction between some our friendly, highly-trained airport security folks under the tutelage of the TSA and a guy who just happened to have some cash.

While it’s been the case for quite a while that anyone traveling outside the country carrying more than $10,000 in currency must declare it,  It’s troubling, of course, but intended as a way to catch money laundering, particularly by drug dealers, and the requirement is merely to declare it, not turn it over. 

But it remains lawful in the United States to carry cash.  Some people still do it, preferring not to live on plastic, and in some instances, not to have either a bank or anyone else be in a position to track their whereabouts and expenses from a bank statement.  This explains why the mint still prints up those funny colored rectangular pieces of paper.  Apparently, the mint and the TSA don’t get along well, because the TSA folks don’t like people enjoying the handiwork of the mint.


[Ed. Note: Code isn’t working properly at the moment, and I’m trying to fix it.  Until then, use the link above to see the video.  It’s a great one, and it would be a shame to miss it.]  Aren’t cellphones amazing?  I wish I could figure out how to make mine record with just a touch.  Actually, I wish I could figure out how to make it record at all.

There’s a question of whether this was a targeted approach, due to the fact that Steve Bierfeldt was carrying $4700 in cash from a Campaign for Liberty function, clearly a subversive group of people bent on one of the most hated of all American attributes, freedom.  But to think so would be to attribute a substantial amount of thought to the TSA employees, which I am both unprepared to do and which has no basis in anything they’ve ever done before.  No, I suspect they saw a wad of cash and went into action.

What’s fascinating is that despite his calm, reasonable reaction to the TSA folks, they come off as nasty, brutish and stupid.  As I listened to the encounter, I was imagining how there testimony would be on the stand describing what happened. 

Yes, your honor, we politely requested that the perpetrator provide us with the source of the $3700 (no typo) of illegal funds and he responded that we would be sorry we ever messed with him, at which time we requested that he come with us for further investigation, to which he agreed.

The good news it that they didn’t beat the guy.  That happens sometimes, you know.

But there’s one pressing question that remains unanswered.  What was John Stossel doing there, and what did he contribute?

Fitting Round Technology Into A Square Hole

Following the discussions of Orin Kerr’s “technology neutral” approach to the application of the 4th Amendment in a world of new technologies comes this apocryphal post by Nicole Black.


Last week, the New York State Court of Appeals heard oral arguments regarding that very issue. At issue in People v. Weaver was the admissibility of evidence obtained without a warrant by law enforcement through the use of a GPS tracking device.

The courts below concluded that the evidence was admissible. In People v. Weaver, 52 A.D.3d 138 (Third Dept. 2008), the majority held that the defendant had no expectation of privacy regarding public movements that would have been visible via the naked eye:


Inasmuch as constant visual surveillance by police officers of [the] defendant’vehicle in plain view would have revealed the same information and been just as intrusive, and no warrant would have been necessary to do so, the use of the GPS device did not infringe on any reasonable expectation of privacy and did not violate defendant’s Fourth Amendment protections. See People v. Wemette, 285 AD2d 729, 729- 730 (2001), leave denied 97 NY2d 689; People v. Edney, 201 AD2d at 499.

 This decision belies the point that old law and new tech don’t mix.  There is nothing wrong with the logic of the court’s rationale.  Public movement is certainly available for any on-looker to see, and the good old “plain view” doctrine seems to cover the idea that we have no reasonable expectation of privacy as we travel about in the open.  But of course, that ignores the salient detail that distinguishes what happened here.  The defendant wasn’t tailed, but was followed by use of a GPS device planted on a car.  Is it really the same?

As the Weaver case shows, technological advances present very real problems for courts.  Do they really fit the old paradigm, or are courts trying desperately to shove round pegs into square holes to maintain the appearance of precedent and consistency?  Consider the Weaver dissent:


Judge Leslie E. Stein, issued a lengthy dissent, opining that a warrant should have been required since technology increased the intrusiveness and duration of the monitoring, necessarily altering the analysis:
[W]hile the citizens of this state may not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in a public place at any particular moment, they do have a reasonable expectation that their every move will not be continuously and indefinitely monitored by a technical device without their knowledge, except where a warrant has been issued based on probable cause. … At some point, the enhancement of our ability to observe by the use of technological advances compels us to view differently the circumstances in which an expectation of privacy is reasonable. In my opinion, that point has been reached in the facts before us.

 We are already at the stage where technology allows for any target of government interest to be given the legal equivalent of a 24/7 colonoscopy.  There is no place left to hide.  There is no longer a reasonable expectation of privacy in much of anything, from our movements to our finances to our communications, regardless of medium.  This is the product of applying a concept that worked reasonably well in the past to a future where everything is in plain view.

And as Niki points out, we’re still in the infant stages of technology.  What advances will the next decade bring?

The Weaver case presents a situation where the “technology neutral” paradigm leads to an outcome that many will find unpalatable, that little black boxes will eliminate the few remaining vestiges of privacy that we want to keep to ourselves.  Putting aside the question of whether one can trust the government to use technology wisely and honestly, a huge question but one that is answered more by faith and sensibility given that most people repose blind faith in the integrity of law enforcement despite all evidence to the contrary, we need to decide whether we want our personal privacy held captive by each new black box to come down the pike.

There is no way to stop technology from developing.  There is a way to stop it from eliminating our privacy rights, bit by bit.  It will require the law to develop new approaches to addressing how the 4th Amendment applies to developing technology rather than relying on the tried and true concepts that have guided it in the past.  Technology neutral isn’t neutral at all.

Poverty in the First Degree

Debtors prisons are back in style in Michigan, but the ACLU has decided that it is less than enamored of the latest trend in prison hemlines.


In December 2008, Ms. [Edwina] Nowlin’s 16-year-old son was sentenced to the Bay Pines Center and Ms. Nowlin was ordered to pay $104 per month for his lodging. At the time of this order, Ms. Nowlin was homeless and working part-time with a friend after being laid off from her job. She told the court that she was unable to pay the ordered amount, however the judge found her in contempt for failing to pay. In addition, Ms. Nowlin’s requests for a court appointed attorney were denied.

Since March 3, 2009, Ms. Nowlin has been serving her sentence at the Delta County Jail. On March 6, 2009, she was released for one day to work. Once released she picked up her $178.53 check from work thinking that she now could pay the $104.00 to get out of jail. However, upon her return to jail that evening, the sheriff forced her to sign over her check to the jail to cover $120.00 for “room and board.” She was also charged $22 for a drug test and the booking fee.

It’s almost as if the criminal justice system was run by credit card companies.  But as bizarrely ironic the Catch-22 created by Michigan may seem, it’s merely the off-shoot of measures that many believe are entirely appropriate in the system.  Why should the public pay the cost of warehousing criminals serving their sentences?  If they did the crime, they should pay for it.  Literally.

And so, the Michigan system provides a wonderful circularity, with poverty making it impossible to pay the costs of  incarceration, thus breeding more incarceration for failure to pay, and more and more.

While the Nowlin case provides one of the clearest, and most ridiculous, examples of how the trend toward making the criminal pay bears out, there are more subtle problems, as hinted in the ACLU’s press release.  Edwina was too poor to pay for a lawyer, but denied free counsel.  So there was no one to fight the contempt order.  And she was then incarcerated and compelled to pay for her own, as well as her son’s, cost of jail. 

The availability of a lawyer is but one more subtle problem.  What about the availability of competent investigators for indigent defenders?  What about the cost of audiotapes and copies of discovery documents that the government requires a defendant to purchase if they want to obtain them?  These costs can add up quickly, and in some cases, start out astronomical.    There are a laundry list of costs imposed on the presumptively innocent defendant, and the defendant’s inability to pay the freight along the way to his defense has a huge impact on his ultimately becoming incarcerated, and then having to pay the cost of that.

These problems aren’t some Michigan quirk, but happen in courtrooms across the country daily.  It takes money to defend oneself against the government, whether it’s the defendant’s or the state’s in providing and maintaining a viable indigent defense system for the poor.  Or, on the other hand, we just let the poor dangle in the wind for lack of ability to defend, so they then become criminals and then prisoners, where they can enjoy the circular experience of Edwina Nowlin.  The worst part of this is that I can imagine many not being particularly disturbed by the return of debtors prisons.  Indeed, I can see the truly ignorant applauding, thankful that the burden of “those people” has been shift off the back of “hard-working Americans.”

There is a cost associated with our law and order, jail ’em all, societal view of criminal justice.  Somebody has to pay it.  Tevye said it’s no crime to be poor, but then he was never under indictment.