Author Archives: SHG

Walking With Senator Stevens (Update)

Two government prosecutors withheld statements and documents, lied about it and fought the consequences of it by trying to cover it up.  The Department of Justice has decided to come clean and, in a fit of conscience, moved to vacate the conviction and dismiss the charges.  This should be a huge victory for those criminal defense minded folks everywhere, but it doesn’t feel nearly as good as it should to me. 

The defendant in this nightmarish prosecution was Alaska Republican Senator Ted Stevens.  The story of the DOJ change of heart has been covered extensively around the blawgosphere,  The government has been roundly castigated for its fundamentally unlawful handling of the prosecution.  Issues have been raised about what the government plans to do to its own prosecutors, who broke the law in their effort to convict a senator.  But the part that kills any inclination toward gloating is this from Popehat :


And while I’m sure that this time Ted Stevens is laughing, he’s hardly the only fool.  Now the joke is on the United States courts, the Senate, the people of Alaska, and most especially the American taxpayer.

You see, the horrific handling of this case by federal prosecutors is an indictment of the Government, but not a vindication of Ted Stevens.  In the usual course of a federal prosecution, the worst that comes of a botched prosecution is that one more criminal remains on the street. But Ted Stevens isn’t just one more criminal.  He was a United States Senator.  He was a Senator making our laws, haranguing the values of others, while selling his vote. 

The government could have convicted him after a fair trial, complying with all the rules and duties that the law imposes.  But that would have meant a fair fight, which apparently they were unprepared to do.  The government prosecutors wanted to win, and were prepared to play the system by using the Brady gambit to make sure that Stevens didn’t have the ammunition to fight back.  The government never wants a fair fight.  It’s hard to say how often this happens, but it’s easy to say how frequently this outcome follows.  Never.  Until now.

Thankfully, Ted Stevens lost his seat in the Senate, so we need not tolerate the unseemly show of him returning to Washington as the victorious hero.  But had the defendant not been Ted Stevens, would this have happened at all?  As the New York Times wrote:


The collapse of the Stevens case was a profound embarrassment for the Justice Department, and it raised troubling issues about the integrity of the actions of prosecutors who wield enormous power over people they investigate. Mr. Stevens’s case was handled by senior officials of the department’s Public Integrity Section, which handles official corruption cases.

Was Ted Stevens the only victim of this disease?  Will judges now take seriously claims by the defense that they’ve been denied Brady, that witnesses lied, that representations by prosecutors aren’t the gospel?  Will judges at least consider the possibility that the word of a prosecutor shouldn’t be accept at face value, while the word of a defense lawyer be dismissed and ignored?

Or is this just another isolated incident?  Former United States Senator Ted Stevens gets a walk.  Will there be anyone walking with him?

Update:  From our hinterlands correspondent. Kathleen Casey, comes the New York Times’ entry into the debate, covering the full panply of thought on the subject.  Let’s see, there’s:


David Alan Sklansky is professor of law at the University of California, Berkeley, and faculty chair of the Berkeley Center for Criminal Justice.

Okay, a law professor.  Fair enough.  And then there’s:


Barry Coburn, a lawyer, is a former federal prosecutor.

Sure, a former federal prosecutor seems appropriate.  And then:


Stephen Gillers, a professor at New York University School of Law, is an expert in legal ethics.

Another law professor.  So one wasn’t enough?  Okay, and then there’s . . . no one.  That’s it folks.  That’s all she wrote.  So anybody notice what’s missing from the full panoply of thought here? 

I bet that the Editors tried valiantly to find a criminal defense lawyer, perhaps even a federal defender, to express some thoughts on the subject, but they were all unavailable for comment because they were too busy waxing their Ferraris.  Yeah, I’m sure that’s it.  Because the Times, you know, would never deliberately neglect an entire side of the picture from those who see it daily.

Taking Offers: The Turk Goes to Auction

It’s a sad day when my personal blawging muse, Eric “The Turk” Turkewitz decides to hang up his blawging shingle.  But it was bound to happen, ever since he realized that the tertiary syphilis was beyond cure two and half years was enough for any man.  Turk has put his blawg, The New York Personal Injury Law Blog, up for auction.

Ignoring my pleas that he try to broker a back door sale to Walter Olson at Overlawyered, or a really back door sale to the Flea, Turk has decided to offer his blawg on eBay with an opening bid of $1 Million. 


Yes, I know some folks will think that is high, but let me explain a bit. If the new owner decides to monetize this blog by using it in an advertorial manner, then s/he only has to get a couple of decent cases to make the investment pay off. If done right, it could pay for itself in as little as a year or so. I therefore believe the actual sale price could be significantly higher.

Turk goes on to suggest a bunch of great ideas to facilitate the continued greatness of the blawg, ranging from SEO optimization to link swapping to having some kid from Bangalore write it for the winning bidder.  He’s got all the bases covered.

But I have been duly authorized, through some creative email editing, to serve as the Turk’s honest broker in negotiating a deal and thereby avoiding eBay’s outrageous final value fees, which are nearly as bad as lawyer referral fees.  We can negotiate the heck out of this in minutes and have you up and blawging by tomorrow morning.  By the end of the day, you’ll probably have a dozen new major car crashes in your pocket, enough to pay back that Biglaw loan plus cover your law school student debt and buy your momma a new McMansion.  It’s like free cash.  And you can even work at home.  In your pajamas.  It doesn’t get any better than this.

Don’t duke it out with the riff-raff on eBay, only to see your hopes dashed by some last minute sniper from Iowa.  You know how sneaky those Iowans can be.  Get ahead of the curve by letting me negotiate your deal for you.  I’ve got the inside track, because the Turk knows that I would never steer him wrong.  There’s always a “buy it now” price hiding behind that opening bid, and I can make sure you nail this down before some zero-feedback joker gloms it up while you’re waiting to select.  I am there for you.

So if you want to buy your way to blawgospheric greatness overnight, chances are that you will never see an opportunity like this again.  Trust me.

Also, a negligible portion of this sale will go to the Holden H. Oliver Memorial Fund for wayward children.

The Best Defense

There is no one outside of the Wyoming County, Pennsylvania, District Attorney’s office who thought that it was a good idea to threaten to prosecute a young woman for “sexting”.  But seeking, and obtaining, injunctive relief to prohibit District Attorney George Skumanick was a stroke of genius.  And it worked!

Granted, it was plain old idiotic to promote the idea that a teenager could be a sex offender against herself, but idiotic things seem to happen all the time in courtrooms across the country, so that alone didn’t distinguish the case.  And Skumanick had a superficial argument, that a deterrence was needed to stop young women from sending nude photos of themselves to others, for their own good.  No doubt, few parents would take issue with the idea that they would deeply prefer that their daughters not do so, though the survey says that only half were prepared to put their kids into prison or on the Sex Offender Registry to accomplish such a lofty goal. 

Now that the ruling is out, Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy has made a provocative suggestion:



Based on the theories sustained in Miller v. Skumanick, a state murder defendant being threatened by a local prosecutor with a capital indictment as part of plea negotiations might now consider running to federal court to assert various constitutional claims in order to try to preclude the local prosecutor from pursuing a state capital prosecution. 


Similarly, perhaps Second Amendment advocates can and should be able to use the ruling in Miller v. Skumanick to try to thwart any efforts by aggressive state prosecutors to pursue any kind of constitutionally questionable gun prosecution.  In fact, with Plaxico Burress having a hard time getting a favorable plea deal (basics here), his lawyers perhaps out to seriously consider heading over to the federal courts in Foley Square to assert Second Amendment claims in an effort to force New York state prosecutors to back off.


Crazy?  Maybe a little, but not crazy enough not to give it some serious thought.  Why not take the aggressive position and go after the prosecutor rather than sit back and wait for the smack you know is coming.  As a defendant, we’re invariably fighting our way up the hill.  But as a plaintiff, we can seize the initiative and go after the prosecution on our own terms.  If the prosecution has a constitutional component that appears about to be violated, do we not have a duty to uphold the Constitution?  We swear to it when we’re given out ticket, so why not do something about it?

There is, of course, a strong possibility that federal judges will not be thrilled at the prospect of even more cases clogging their docket, or the hallways filling up with the types of people who are usually found hanging around the 11th Floor of 100 Centre Street.  After all, they have such nice new wood-paneled courtrooms in Foley Square, and they really aren’t set up for a mass of state court defendants putting their feet up on the mahogany tables.  But that’s not our problem, right?

And since I have no doubt that Ben Bronfman is getting a very healthy, though certainly not unconscionable, legal fee from Plaxico, and since he’s a leader of the criminal defense bar, he does indeed seem like the perfect lawyer to lead the way.  Go for it Ben!  We’re right behind you.

Open Season on Peremptory Challenges

There have long been a few things that a defendant could count on at trial.  That the judge would be far more polite and happy in front of the jury.  That the police officer would wear his “going to court” uniform, without the blood stains and with the sleeves rolled all the way down to cover his “Death to Defendants” tattoo.  That all the jurors would swear they could honor the defendant’s right not to testify, but didn’t mean it.  And that if one of the jurors gave you the evil eye, you could bump them off the jury with a peremptory challenge.  That changed yesterday.

The Supreme Court issued it’s decision in Rivera v. Illinois.  As described by Anne Reed at Deliberations, the facts were not only simple, but undisputed:

Rivera tried to strike a juror in his Illinois state court trial.  The trial judge said no, finding a Batson violation, and seated the juror.  All sides agree now that was a mistake, and the peremptory strike was proper.

The juror was seated despite the strike, and (natch) made the foreperson.  Rivera was convicted of first degree murder.  There was no claim that the judge who made the erroneous ruling acted out of malice or engaged in some other impropriety.  He just blew the call.  This happens all the time, and provides the best explanation for why we waste all that money on appellate courts. 

So the question in Rivera was clear:  A stricken juror was seated and the defendant convicted.  What now?

From a unanimous Supreme Court, in a decision written by Ruth Bader Ginsburg, the answer rang out:  Nothing.  The salient points, via Anne, can be quickly excepted:


“If a defendant is tried before a qualified jury composed of individuals not challengeable for cause, the loss of a peremptory challenge due to a state court’s good-faith error is not a matter of federal constitutional concern. Rather, it is a matter for the State to address under its own laws.”

“[T]his Court has consistently held that there is no freestanding constitutional right to peremptory challenges.”

“Because peremptory challenges are within the States’ province to grant or withhold, the mistaken denial of a state-provided peremptory challenge does not, without more, violate the Federal Constitution.”

So that no one makes a mistake, there is no constitutional right to peremptory challenges.  They are a creature of statute, and any error in a ruling about a peremptory does not rise to constitutional proportions, meaning that there is no constitutional remedy.  You lose.  Since there is no scenario, aside from the truly bizarre (which could happen but can’t be relied upon), that would enable a defendant to show actual prejudice or denial of a facially qualified jury, there is no way around the problem.  Peremptories are a gift from the state.  The state giveth, and the state taketh away. 

The irony of this case comes from the cause for the defendant being denied his strike, the glory of reverse Batson.  In typical SCOTUS brilliance, the Supremes have given a jury right to the People.  Just not the People who happen to be on trial.  Rather, it’s the right of the People to be on a jury.  You know, that right that almost every red-blooded American wants desperately to exercise, to waste a few days/weeks of their lives to listen to lawyers ad naseum and then pass judgment over their fellow Americans.  It probably makes your mouth water just thinking about it.

So the strike is negated by the judge because of the right of the People to be on a jury, even though it was all a silly mistake in your average first degree murder prosecution, but there is no right of the defendant to exercise a peremptory challenge to remove a juror who he believes holds a latent bias against him.  While the argument can be made that Batson makes sense applied against the prosecutor, as an officer of the state, it makes absolutely no sense when applied against the defense, who owes no constitutional fairness to anyone.  Of course, there is a statutory “right” to strike the juror, but what’s a right without a remedy?  As Justice Ginsburg made clear, nothing.

Yet another reason why reverse Batson was one of the most bone-headed decisions ever.

Another Senator Guns For DataTreasury

After bank stock owning Senator Jeff Session’s (R-Ala)  gave up on his quest to divest DataTreasury of its patent rights, maybe some believed that the idea that patent owners would be shown some respect when banks infringed at will.  But not Arizona Republican Senator Jon Kyl. From the Dow Jones Newswire :


The Judiciary panel is scheduled to take up a bill Tuesday to overhaul the nation’s patent system. Two industry sources said Sen. Jon Kyl, R-Ariz., has circulated a possible amendment to colleagues that would shield banks from having to pay money damages if they infringe on checking-imaging patents.


Kyl’s proposal is similar to a provision offered last year by Sen. Jeff Sessions, R-Ala., another member of the Judiciary Committee.


Sessions’ amendment proved controversial because it targeted ongoing litigation and because Sessions owned stock in two banks that stood to gain from the provision.


Sessions said at the time that the legislation was necessary because DataTreasury had abused the patent system, but he later withdrew his support for the provision and expressed doubts about its legality.


The patent bill containing the Sessions provision died last year in the Senate.


It’s baa-aack.  Anybody want to bet that out banks, on publicly funded life support for doing such a fine job for our nation, will use the few pennies they have left to engage the shills to go around smearing DataTreasury like they did last time out?  But this time, Kyl will have an extra special trick in his bag, one that didn’t cost the banks a cent.

When last we left our patent-infringing banks, they were still the omnipotent giants of finance.  This time, they are sniveling runts, barely able to move on their own (at least without new private corporate jets).  And so, as we infuse them with large amounts of cash to maintain their liquidity and save them from their “toxic assets,” our savior, Senator Kyl, can invoke the need to protect the public till from the terrible cost of paying the patent infringement tab. 

In other words, before the Senate was protecting the banks from having to pay for their unlawful conduct.  Now, they can claim that they are protecting the public from covering the cost to the banks of having to pay for their unlawful conduct.  The smell is no better, but the question is whether it will get traction because of whose pocket will pay the damages.

Isn’t it ironic that the banks never seem very shy when it comes to us paying their fees?  And now they want our sympathy?

Searching and Seizing in a Digital World, Part II

Orin Kerr has posted  the second part of his technology neutral approach to applying the 4th Amendment to the motherboard over at Volokh, and provides some greater insight into his plan for the future of search and seizure law as applied to the digital world.


So imagine you’re trying to apply the Fourth Amendment to the Internet so that it plays the same role in Internet crime investigations that the Fourth Amendment plays in traditional physical investigations. How can you do that? 

The first step is to realize that the Fourth Amendment in the physical world is based on a fundamental distinction between inside surveillance and outside surveillance.

Online, the distinction between “inside” and “outside” no longer makes a lot of sense. Some new distinction is needed to replace the function of the outside/inside distinction.

My article proposes that the online distinction between content and non-content information should replace the physical distinction between inside and outside surveillance. The contents of communications, such as e-mail messages, subject lines, and remotely stored files, should be presumptively protected by the Fourth Amendment. Absent special circumstances such as consent or posting documents on the Internet, the Fourth Amendment should regulate government access to contents. On the other hand, non-content information, such as IP addresses mail header information other than the subject line, should not be protected.

Well, that didn’t take long.  The analogy approach that Orin advocates relies on the inside/outside distinction.  This is grounded in the “plain view” doctrine, that things observable by police without requiring their acting are in plain view, therefore holding no reasonable expectation of privacy.  This is sensible doctrine, provided that things in “plain view” are indeed in plain view, but that’s a problem for another day.

Orin takes the leap from inside/outside to content/noncontent without any cognizable reason.  Why is “noncontent” in plain view?  Indeed, it’s no more viewable than content, and hence every bit as worthy of privacy as anything else.  But the flawed analogy runs far deeper, and in two separate insidious directions.

If we are to utilize the existing 4th Amendment law to provide a framework for searches in the digital world, why then does plain view not stop at anything observable on the outside of your computer?  If the police are required to touch a button and boot the sucker up, then they’ve gone inside.  If the computer is already on, and anyone can see the screen, then arguably whatever is on the screen is outside.  But the second the press a button to open a program, file, or merely maximize a minimized screen, they’ve gone inside.  Why does Orin presume that the police are entitled to see anything, anything at all, in the digital guts of a computer? 

But there is a collateral issue, for which no good analogy exists, confronting the privacy of our digitalia, and the unique nature of how communications fly through the air from our computer to everywhere else in the world.  For the purposes of this point, I’m begging any technogeeks to suspend their brilliance, as this point needs to be developed on two separate levels.  At the surface level, there is the issue of what normal people (as in, those who are so naive as to believe that there is any security in the digital world and that their communications are private) believe when they send an email. 

At the other end of the spectrum is what really happens when we hit the send button, with whatever technological marvels the government (and it’s telecommunicating analogs) possess.  We must recognize that there is a monstrously huge gap between what normal people think is secure and techno-reality, where security is a figment of ordinary people’s imagination.  Even if the government can’t access every single thing at the moment, whether because of encryption technology or otherwise, we do well to anticipate that they eventually will be able to “observe” everything that goes in or out of our computers.  Whatever we think the government is capable of doing, we frankly have no clue what they have and what they aren’t telling us. 

In explaining his position, Orin notes in response to a question posed in the comments,


[Y]ou appear to be assuming that a “reasonable expectation of privacy” is what a reasonable person would expect would remain private. It’s not.

This is, of course, unfortunately true, and part of the problem with using the Katz “reasonable expectation of privacy” rubric as eviscerated by every subsequent decision to mention it.  While the subject expectation of privacy is essentially meaningless, the problem is magnified in the digital world by the normal person’s inability to be aware of, and comprehend, the cutting edge of technology.  While today we may (and I use the word “may” reluctantly) have a modicum of privacy based on encryption technology, is it objectively reasonable to expect that we will tomorrow? 

The government can easily show, through the use of a storefront computer geek, that our ISPs and any other central hubs of digitalia have unfettered access to all sorts of information contained in our digitally transmitted communications, absent encryption.  Accordingly, there is no objective expectation of privacy in much of anything we send, and we ought to know that.  At minimum, that will be the exception that dismisses what normal people think ought to be private.

This process is analogized to the delivery of mail or packages, as in the Fed Ex guy.  If you send something to another person in the real world, you realize that the people handling the delivery can see who you’re sending it to. the size and shape of the package, and can shake it to see if anything inside jiggles.  If an envelope, they can hold it up to the light to see the shape of what’s inside, and whether any part of it can be seen through the wrapper.  So if that’s the case in the real world, why shouldn’t it be the same with anything you send over a network?

The answer, of course, is that physical things are readily observable and understandable by ordinary people.  A child realizes that an envelope held up to the light will reveal something about its contents.  Then again, the snarky analogy is that a child is more likely to realize how unreasonable it is to expect privacy on a network than an adult.  But the real problem is that this paradigm essentially gives carte blanche to the government to obtain anything they want from our transmitted communications.  If this is what people want, then it can be accomplished without a techno-neutral theory by simply announcing that nothing sent by email or transmitted from your personal box over the internet should be deemed private.  Announce the rule and then nobody can complain later that they didn’t know.  Fall back on the existing law and reasonable people are misled. 

On the other hand, the mere fact that the government has the technology to intercept everything we send across the airwaves does not make it the correct application of the 4th Amendment.  Why should we not be secure in our emails and internet transmissions?  Why should the analogy of package delivery constrain our privacy in digital transmission if we, the people, don’t want it to?  Why does the authority of law enforcement to exercise every iota of their technological might result in our having no privacy online?  One answer is because they can, and many are happy to give away any aspect of privacy in our network communications under the assumption that the government will only be searching and seizing the communications of “those bad guys” and not ours.  After all, we’re good guys, and why would the government possibly want to know what we’re up to?

The other answer is the one Orin proposes, which is to take existing 4th Amendment law and apply it by way of dubious analogy to the new digital world.  Does the Fed Ex analogy really fit sending an email?  When we send a real package to be delivered, we can tape it up, cover it over, put a box inside a box, send it to a post office box or some other dummy location, if we want to conceal its contents and keep its recipient private.  We know that we’ve done whatever we think we’ve done because we can see what we’ve done.  Can’t do that online.  At least normal people would have some problems with doing it.

So is the real message that we’ve given up all “non-content”, as defined by Orin, privacy by entering the digital age?  If so, it’s not the model that makes me feel all warm and fuzzy about the vitality of the 4th Amendment.  As much as I think highly of the internet, and appreciate that something called a network exists so I can send stuff out to others, I am not prepared to trade off what little remaining privacy I have to enjoy it, and I would appreciate others not giving it away for me.

Because You Just Can’t Shoot People

Grandma Margaret Johnson packs a gun.  A big gun, in fact.  A.357 Magnum, which is quite a gun for a granny to carry, And she is clearly not afraid to use it, according to that pinnacle of anti-sensationalism, the New York Post.  Via Walter Olson at Overlawyered,


Deron Johnson, 48, a man “with a lengthy rap sheet”, denies that he was trying to rob Margaret Johnson, 59, of her purse and gold chain when she shot him from her motorized wheelchair with her licensed .357 Magnum. Cops grabbed him but he won acquittal at trial and he’s now suing her and the landlord of her Lenox Terrace housing complex in Harlem, asking millions.

What’s wrong with this picture?  Plenty.  It sounds just awful that this terrible Deron Johnson, the man “with the lengthy rap sheet,” went after this wheelchair bound granny who merely tried to defend herself.  But then, he was acquitted.  You see, Johnson had a different explanation:


He said he kicked the woman’s Shih Tzu, Malika, after it attacked him, and the gun-loving granny shot him.

That’s the funny thing about granny’s with guns.  Sometimes they use them.


“I’m a peaceful person. I wish that I had killed him,” said Margaret Johnson, 59, whose grandfather, Ellsworth “Bumpy” Johnson, once ruled Harlem’s underworld and was immortalized in several hit movies.

But the real flaws of this story have yet to be discussed.  This happened in Harlem, a lovely area in the northerly part of Manhattan, which is part of New York City.  In NYC, it’s easier to win the lottery than get a carry permit.  Now the story says that her .357 Magnum was “licensed”, but it doesn’t exactly say that she was licensed to carry a concealed weapon as she scooted to Lenox Avenue and 133rd Street in her motorized wheelchair.  It is inconceivable that she would have a carry permit.  So what happened to the part of the story where the shooter was illegally carrying a concealed weapon?  Notably, there’s nothing in there about her being arrested for the unlawful possession of a weapon.

Every criminal defense lawyer knows that the “lengthy rap sheet” excuse is the reddest of herrings around.   What are the offenses involved, jaywalking or murder? He had  nine “previous arrests,” but no mention of how many convictions.  A gilded lily perhaps?

Apparently, since whatever he did, if anything, wasn’t so terrible that it landed him in prison for life, as he was strolling down Lenox Avenue that fine day.  And aside from all else, does that mean that people with “lengthy rap sheets” can’t protect themselves when attacked by a little puff ball dog?  His purported propensity bears no causal connection to anything that happened here.

On the other hand, as this photo of Margaret Johnson in a happy moment shows, she does like her Uzi, a weapon preferred by many in uptown Manhattan, though usually frowned upon by the New York Police Department.


She is not bashful about her love of guns, especially the .357 Magnum.

“I love that gun. It’s so powerful,” she said. “I don’t know too many women who can handle that gun. I almost fell on my butt when I first fired it.”
But  granny’s story doesn’t smell all that good. If Deron was trying to snatch Margaret’s purse, an act which takes a fraction of a second, how did Granny find the time to whip out the Magnum and shoot?  It seems likely that the gun would be in the purse, meaning that she would have had to go into the purse and pull out the gun before he grabbed the purse and pulled it away from her.  Frankly, unless she was holding the gun in her hand when Deron allegedly tried to mug her, it strains credulity that she was able to shoot before he grabbed whatever he wanted to grab and ran.  It just doesn’t take long enough to react that way.

And finally, we get to the bottom line of this curiously reported tale.  The law in New York is quite clear that a person cannot lawfully use deadly force except in the protection of a human life.  While granny complained that Deron of the “lengthy rap sheet” (did he have it tattooed on his forehead for all to see?)  was trying to snatch her purse and gold chain, she fired a round into his left elbow.  She shot him in order to protect her purse and gold chain.

Even if we assume Margaret’s claims to be true, you just can’t shoot people on the street for trying to snatch a purse.  At least not in New York City.  No matter how much granny loves her guns.


Cheap At Half the Price?

Carolyn Elefant has a very provocative post at My Shingle on the subject of volunteers.  The impetus for her post is a story in Newsday about how my very own Nassau County Attorney’s office has opened its doors to volunteers (read currently unemployed) attorneys in order to keep them off the streets.  Remember, idle lawyer hands are the devil’s workshop/tools/playthings (pick ’em).  Of course, my beloved Nassau County can always be counted upon for a Menckian solution.


I realize that on the surface, the prospect of free labor sounds eminently attractive. 

I’m just not a fan of free labor.  I’ve had one or two free volunteers at my practice over the past 15 years, but mostly, I’ve paid even though when I started out, it usually meant a $10/hr salary, with the intern or clerk receiving payment before I did.  In at least one case, I found the free employee unreliable and not really very motivated, but because I wasn’t paying her, I didn’t feel that I could crack down on her as much as I would have if she’d been paid.  And assuming that  a diligent volunteer were working for me, I’d feel as if I were taking advantage even if I were teaching him or her the tricks of the trade.

Carolyn’s problem, obviously, is that she’s a softie.  Ironically, she takes it out on the inchoate volunteers because they make her feel guilty.  Not me.  I’m neither a softie nor do I feel guilty about it.  This isn’t involuntary servitude.  No one makes them volunteer, and if they want to do so, then I expect them to produce the same quality as anyone else.  I have no place, and no use, for slackers.  That’s what the Nassau County Attorney is there for.

Like Carolyn, however, I too am not a fan of free labor.  From the perspective of the outsider, the availability of a free piece of meat competent lawyer is indeed “eminently attractive.”  But that’s all it is.  The paycheck is just one cost to me of an extra body in the room.  There are others, far more expensive, that need to be considered.

New people require time, attention and energy, three very expensive commodities in my practice.  There’s a way I want things done.  I mean, every thing that I do.  It’s not that it’s necessarily a peculiar way, as much as the “right way” as far as I’m concerned.  And since it’s my shop, my way is the right way.  I do not run a democracy. Anyone who touches anything that happens in my shop needs to do so my way.  You know all those practice management gurus who tell you to “encourage your employees to explore” new directions, and “empower” them to seize “positive greatness?”  Screw ’em.  I want excellence.  Whether they are pleased with themselves doesn’t cut it.

So while volunteers may have no direct out of pocket cost, they most assuredly have a cost in my time and attention, taken away from the focus on my clients in order to deal with the needs of the new warm body.  Unless there’s a very good reason for me to pay this price, the freebies cost me more than I care to spend.

Secondarily, while I have no qualms about directing volunteers or providing them with my own special brand of “guidance”, because I’m not anywhere near as nice as Carolyn, most volunteers have a belief, whether conscious or not, that they are doing you a favor.  Somehow, somewhere, this will manifest itself.  It’s only human for volunteers to feel that their efforts have value to you, and that you’re getting that value for free, and that provides them with sort of entitlement.  Sometimes, this entitlement shows in inconsequential ways, such as seeking a pat on the back for a job well done.  Other times, however, this results in a passive aggressive reaction which will impair my representation of clients.  We can’t have that.

I’ve tried volunteers, including a stint with law students as part of a mentoring program with a law school.  The drain on my time from these very eager lawyers was exhausting, and could eat up time like nothing until twitter.  In the end, I’m with Carolyn.  Thanks, but no thanks.  When I need someone, I will invest in them, both by paying them for their time as well as giving them of mine.  Until then, I can only thank the Nassau County Attorney for keeping the unemployed off the streets. 

Finally, A Marketing Concept That Helps

Notwithstanding my curmudgeonly perspective on all things marketing, I’ve come to be a huge fan of Seth Godin.  Not because I’ve changed my mind about marketing (I haven’t) and what it’s done to diminish the profession (I haven’t), but because I think he loathes the simplistic, deceptive, smarmy marketers as much as I do.  He’s just more constructive about it.

Seth makes a point in this post that provides an important perspective for lawyers, and criminal defense lawyers in particular.  That’s not easy to do for a marketing guru, by the way, since we tend to defy most of the rules of the game.


Almost all [marketers’] actions are driven by the search for more customers.

The reason this is a mistake is simple: it’s expensive. Attracting a new customer costs far more than keeping an old one happy. Not only that, but an old customer is far more likely to bring you new people via word of mouth than someone who isn’t even a customer yet.

Which is why share of wallet makes so much more sense than share of market. . . [M]arketers are so focused on more that they forget to take great care of what they’ve got.

The only fly in the ointment is that it’s not marketers’ concern that you take good care of existing clients.  Just as surgeons cut, marketers market.  Lawyers, on the other hand, represent human beings.  The crux of Seth’s point is that wallet share, not market share, is the more important goal.  So what’s “wallet share?” Seth explains it this way:


How much does each of your existing customers buy from you? Do they count on you for all the things they buy in this market, or just some? Does Toyota sell me every car my family drives? Does Chubb get to insure every single thing I own? Usually not.

While it requires some twists and turns to make it directly applicable, let’s apply to this to criminal defense lawyers.  When a client seeks our services, which is by definition a matter of need more so than desire since they are facing prosecution and potentially prison, and the problem won’t go away on its own, there remains one huge issue to address.  The legal fee. 

Our ethical responsibility requires us not to charge an unreasonable (defined as unconscionable) fee, and with some notable exceptions, most of us don’t have that issue. Indeed, the problem is quite the opposite.  Many criminal defense lawyers want the business badly enough that they set a fee that is inadequate to compensate them for their time plus pay their overhead.  This leads to two major problems, too much business to competently handle in order to get a small profit out of the practice, or incompetent representation, meaning the quickie plea to dispose of the unprofitable client without regard to its appropriateness.  Yes, Virginia, these things do happen.

When we undertake the representation of a client, wallet share, meaning how much of a client’s worth he is willing to commit to his defense, is crucial to our ability to do our job.  Too little and we’re in deep trouble.  Too much is rarely a problem, but one that is easily resolved by our adherence to our ethical responsibilities not to overcharge. 

Thus, the critical marketing effort is to help our client to understand that legal representation is not a commodity, that lawyers are not fungible, that the effort to achieve their goals will require work and that the legal fee reflects the value of the work to the client.  Not marketer can do this for you, but your failure to understand this will severely impede your ability to either function competently or avoid starvation.  If you’ve got potential clients knocking down the door, but none willing to pay you an adequate fee, you’ve got a problem.  Recognize it.

But there is still one additional factor to consider, known in retail circles as the “loss leader.”  Let’s assume that you’ve blown it bigtime and taken on a case where the fee is grossly inadequate.  It’s easy to do, since fixed fees up front are based on information known at the time, and we later find out that our information is wrong or that the situation has changed.  It happens, with unfortunate frequency.  Nonetheless, we’ve sign on to the case and, assuming we honor our ethical duties, are looking at a zealous but costly defense ahead of us.  Think “loss leader.”

Word of mouth is by far the best source of clients.  They come with respect for your efforts, and seek you in particular for the confidence you’ve inspire in the referral source.  They want you.  So once you’ve found yourself representing the “loss leader,” you’ve got the opportunity to provide turn a financial disaster into a marketing boon.  Provide your “loss leader” with excellence and make them your biggest supporter.  Make lemonade.

Make sure that they understand that the representation you’re providing would ordinarily cost twice, ten times, whatever, what you’ve charged them, but that they are your client and no client of yours will receive anything short of excellence.  That’s just how you roll.  The reason you need to add in the shortfall part is so they don’t go on the street and tell their friends that you are not only great, but cheap as can be.  What you do not want to be is the great lawyer who only charges a fraction of the cost.  Those referrals you don’t need, and it backfires in terms of the relationship you will establish with your clients, as people are inclined to have substantially less appreciation for your efforts when they don’t perceive them to be valuable.  If you’re undercharging, you’re not going to be shown the respect your efforts deserve.

What wallet share comes down to is quality over quantity.  Marketers get paid for head count, bringing in numbers, and that’s how they see the world.  Wallet share, on the other hand, reflects quality and how your efforts are valued.  Trust me, representing one client for $25,000 and providing excellence beats the crap out of representing five clients for $5,000 and providing mediocrity, if that.

Congress Discovers: It’s Broken, And We’ve Got The Solution! (Update)

Today’s New York Times lead editorial:


America’s criminal justice system needs repair. Prisons are overcrowded, sentencing policies are uneven and often unfair, ex-convicts are poorly integrated into society, and the growing problem of gang violence has not received the attention it deserves.
Whenever the New York Times announces an epiphany like this, I cringe.  Hasn’t anybody over there been paying attention?  Did this just happen?  It’s a newspaper, for crying out loud.  Wouldn’t you think they would be following the news all along, at least to some small degree? 

If they had, whoever penned the editorial would know that they’re nipping at the edges of the problem.  Is America’s criminal justice system broken?  You betcha.  But the problem doesn’t start after conviction, as per their first two examples, or is limited to inner city urban gangs.  Dear New York Times folks, there is a far broader, system problem.

How about them lying cops?  How about those innocent people being convicted.  You include stories about the DNA exonerations, and somebody over there has to extrapolate that there may be a few innocent people in prison for whom DNA doesn’t apply.  And then there are problem with our protectors and servers flexing their pectorals to make sure that people don’t get to see dying relatives. How many Texans fill the prisons for that?

But the point of the editorial isn’t to show how astute the New York Times is when it comes to being on top of the most cursory understanding of a complex and flagrant problem.  This is just a pleasant side issue.  The point of the editorial is the Times’ promotion of the SOLUTION to our broken system.


For these and other reasons, a bill introduced last week by Senator Jim Webb, Democrat of Virginia, should be given high priority on the Congressional calendar.

The bill, which has strong bipartisan support, would establish a national commission to review the system from top to bottom. It is long overdue, and should be up and running as soon as possible.

So the solution to our broken criminal justice system is to form a national commission, a solution that I like to call, “let’s put on a play” from my adoring childhood memories of Spanky and Alfalfa’s solution to every problem.  And maybe it will be as good as the last play Congress put on, the United States Sentencing Commission.  You remember them, the guys charged with eliminating unfairness and unevenness in our criminal justice system.  The guys who were going to make sure that our national policy of making sure that criminals went to prison, and went for the same good long time in the northeast as they did in the southwest.  This went along with Congress’ brainstorm to eliminate parole in favor of supervised release, since changing names is almost the same as fixing things.

So it appears that this national commission concept has some traction, if it’s receiving bipartisan support.  And why not, since all it does is create a committee.  Washington loves committees, as it creates places to put people into.  Once it’s created, some very important person can say that she’s on the committee.  No doubt it will be a blue ribbon committee to boot, consisting of very serious men and women above reproach. 

We will know that because they will all have credentials like Biglaw, bench and United States Attorney on the resumes.  We can trust them because they are solid citizens.  And they will all be promoted as people who know the legal system inside and out, as all former US Attorneys (and their minions) most assuredly do.  You want to know who is never asked to be on blue ribbon committees?  Guys like Bennett.  Pattis. Gideon.  Me. 

After all, we’re just trench lawyers, the guys who work in the well of the court with the brilliant systems devised by far more important people than us.  Why would you want someone who has tried a few hundred cases when you can have some Biglaw partner who has tried 3 cases, or some political appointee whose life has been spent doing everything possible to put as many people in prison as humanly possible, while every smidgen of the system is carefully designed to facilitate their goals

Of course, one of the problems is that trench lawyers don’t tend to be good committee members.  We take positions.  We hold beliefs.  We are not satisfied with crafting a camel to appease the various interest groups and political agendas that present themselves on a committee.  We tend to do the unthinkable, explain why their ideas are foolish and won’t work.  They love unworkable ideas, wrapped up in pretty bows.  In fairness, they don’t realize that their ideas won’t work, because they don’t actually have a clue what they’re doing.  But they are blue ribbon committee-type people, and that’s far more important than people who get their hands dirty doing the work they have only read about.

Assuming this solution moves forward, there are two things we can all rely upon.  First, nothing will be done for the next 4 years, since it will take that long for the committee to meet a few times, engage a study, hold hearings, ask lawprofs what they think, review and reject the study, arrive at the camel they will propose, and send it off to Congress for approval.  Only then will Congress reinvent their own wheel, as each congressman and senator will have to prove that he knew more about the problem than the committee all along, so he can prove that he’s worthy of re-election to his constituents.

Why am I so down on the idea?  Certainly, we have a broken system.  Certainly it needs repair.  So why not strive to do better, support the committee, work to improve,  Because we’ve been here before, and it’s never helped.  In fact, it’s invariably made things worse.  Which is why we need another committee.

Update:  Via  Balko Glenn Greenwald at Salon applauds Webb for doing something “courageous and principled.” 


There are few things rarer than a major politician doing something that is genuinely courageous and principled, but Jim Webb’s impassioned commitment to fundamental prison reform is exactly that.

What’s most notable about Webb’s decision to champion this cause is how honest his advocacy is.  He isn’t just attempting to chip away at the safe edges of America’s oppressive prison state.  His critique of what we’re doing is fundamental, not incremental.  And, most important of all, Webb is addressing head-on one of the principal causes of our insane imprisonment fixation:  our aberrational insistence on criminalizing and imprisoning non-violent drug offenders (when we’re not doing worse to them). 

So putting on a play constitutes courage?  I guess that’s what comes of extremely low expectations.