Author Archives: SHG

It Takes A Dominatrix

My first post about George Guldi, the real estate lawyer and former county legislator, back in February was decidedly provincial in interest.  A local story about a local lawyer who may have had a finger in some nasty mortgage/real estate business.  As Monty Python would call it, “nasty bits.”  About the only cackles raised were those of Guldi’s very zealous, if somewhat misguided, young attorney, who argued strenuously that I failed to appreciate the seriousness of the seizure of legal files from Guldi’s office.

Suddenly, the story of Guldi has captured  broad interest, even the eye of Bob Ambrogi who has his pick of the litter when it comes to legal stories.  Was it the allegations of widespread use of strawbuyer buyers to scam mortgages?  Nope, that wasn’t it.  Was it the civil suit filed by Wachovia Bank for the alleged theft of $1.8 million, to which Guldi responded that he would have known if he had stolen $1.8 million?  Nope, that wasn’t it either.

One might think that stories about mortgage and real estate scams would be sexy enough on their own to merit some degree of interest.  But the real estate implosion is old news already, and the fact that prosecutors are only now first getting to work on dealing with the pervasive underbelly of the real estate boom, including the role played by lawyers, seems to hold little interest of itself.  Whether the focus is on the nature of real estate scams, the involvement of lawyers or the failure of banks and prosecutors to notice that this was going on for years under their noses, and was painfully flagrant if anyone had bothered to look, no one seems to care.

What made George Guldi into a real story was this:



Three Long Island lawyers stand accused of teaming up with a Manhattan dominatrix and a Manhattan fetish club to run a $50 million mortgage scam.


The fake buyers were recruited from among the clients of Arena Studios, a sexual fetish fantasy business owned by dominatrix Carrie Coakley and her husband, Donald MacPherson, prosecutors charge. The business provides a “beautifully decorated and fully equipped private dungeon” where clients and dominatrixes can meet.


Add a dominatrix to the mix and suddenly we have a story of interest.  Even lawyers can be interesting when there’s a whip and woman in leather and high heels involved.

Lest Guldi’s lawyers have too much free time on their hands, let me state that my repetition of this story is not intended to suggest that George Guldi is guilty of anything.  What’s obvious to the rest of us seems to strain Katherine Huang’s rather tightly strung sensibilities, with her demanding that it be spelled out in painful detail or I will suffer another of her harrangues.  And since I have no reason to suggest otherwise, or desire another round of silly goo popping out of Huang orifices, it’s easy enough to state the obvious and satisfy her simplistic demands.  Besides, I hope that she’s putting all her energies into defending her client, which no doubt demands a challenging use of whatever skills she possesses.

But it’s disturbing that it takes a dominatrix before anyone shows serious interest in what went so very wrong in the real estate market, and the role played by attorneys.  In our little cyber cocoon, lawyers are busily establishing how competent, likable and trustworthy we are.  We are great humanitarians.  Love us.  Respect us.  Trust us. 

Regardless of whether the lawyers in this indictment are guilty as charged, or guilty of anything, the fact remains that some real estate lawyers were deeply, and I mean deeply, engaged in overt, flagrant, outrageous schemes.  It was so easy to do, given the greed of banks and the trust afforded lawyers.  The problem doesn’t begin and end with Marc Dreier raiding his firm’s escrow accounts.  The problem exists with your friendly local real estate lawyer dipping his fat little fingers into the mortgage and housing pool, mustering all the integrity his title affords to obtain reliance that the numbers and names he writes on a closing statement are real. 

Boys and girls, if you want to the public to trust us as lawyers, to have sufficient faith that they can believe what we put on paper, what we represent to others, that there is enough cash in the escrow account to pay out what’s due, then we need to take the lead on recognizing the dirt within our profession and cleanse ourselves of those who use the title “lawyer” as a stick-up weapon. 

We’ve done a horribly poor job of acknowledging that there are members of the bar who are untrustworthy, even criminal, using their law licenses as a license to steal.  If we don’t stand up to our own, then we do not deserve anyone’s trust.  For those of the brethren out there who want to place themselves on the pedestal of integrity, get off your bums and speak out against unethical, untrustworthy, and criminal conduct perpetrated by lawyers.  If you maintain silence, for fear of holding the profession in disrepute or just to avoid the mixed message while you busily hype the crap out of yourself, you are complicit in this conduct. 

It’s past due that the legal profession gets a good whipping, takes its lumps and cleans itself up.  The public deserve integrity from us, and now would be a very good time for all of us to take a stand, even if it mars your marketing campaign.

P.S. Within minutes of finishing this post, I saw that Jonathon Turley has posted about Guldi as well, again with the dominatrix hook.  Why aren’t allegations of dirty lawyers enough to spark concern?

Call First. I Repeat, Call First

When I arrived home after a lovely dinner involving a nice Chianti (sans fava beans), there was a message waiting from my office.  It being late, for me anyway, on a Friday evening, messages tend to mean that something bad has happened to someone.  I immediately got the message and learned that a distraught young woman needed me. 

Despite the hour, I returned the telephone call and asked to speak with the distraught young woman.  In a voice that suggested fear and desperation, she got right to the point.  She needed a lawyer to represent her husband.  Her husband, she explained, was arrested on Tuesday for a violation of probation and went to court on Thursday, when he was sentenced to 2-7 years in prison. (I’m sure she meant 2 and a third, since there is no such thing as a 2 to 7 sentence).  I was not her husband’s lawyer in the case previously.

The conversation from this point went something like this:

Me:  Why didn’t you call me before he went to court?

Her:  There was no time.

Me:  You didn’t know he was arrested on Tuesday?

Her:  I was there, and I called the court, and they told me he would go to court on Thursday.

Me:  Did you have a working telephone between Tuesday and Thursday?

Her:  Yes, that’s how I called the court.

Me:  So why didn’t you call me between Tuesday and Thursday?

Her:  There was no time.

I then explained to her that her husband, having pleaded guilty to the violation of probation, which he would have had to do in order to be sentenced, no longer needed a lawyer.  It was done.  Perhaps he was represented during his underlying case by a public defender or an indigent defender, and whoever represented him in the first place would have been notified of his arrest and directed to appear for the violation.  That lawyer would have stood next to her husband on Thursday, advised him on what to do, and upon his guilty plea, represented him for sentencing.  Lacking any details, I couldn’t venture a guess as to whether the representation was brilliant or terrible.  It doesn’t matter much now.

Having received this call a hundred times over the past 25 years, let me interpret what really happened.  When the husband was arrested on Tuesday, my caller decided to wait and see whether the situation was “serious”.  Whether because of denial or ignorance, people tend to harbor a hope that problems will disappear or at worst result in a firm lecture and a slap on the wrist.  If that’s the case, then they get to save the money that would otherwise have been spent on legal representation.  In other words, they roll the dice to see if it’s their lucky day.

Thursday was not this woman’s husband’s lucky day.  She learned that she rolled craps.   On Friday, she sought me out to retain me to unroll her dice.  Unfortunately, dice cannot usually be unrolled. 

While I’ve said this before, as has just about every other competent criminal defense lawyer everywhere, if you want to retain an attorney to represent a defendant in a criminal prosecution, do so immediately.  If you wait until after you learn that the case is serious, it’s often too late.  Call the lawyer first.  Call the lawyer first.

I understand that hiring a lawyer can be expensive.  So can not hiring a lawyer.  The difference is that sometimes, as here, there is nothing left to do by the time you realize that it is indeed a serious matter, worthy of the expense of a lawyer.  Even if the case is not concluded, it is likely that opportunity to take action to help the defendant has been squandered by the time that you finally retain counsel.  You taken away part of your lawyer’s ability to help you by this loss of opportunity.  Don’t do it.  Call the lawyer first.

My role is often that of the second lawyer, the one people go to after the immediacy of arrest and arraignment is past and they find themselves dissatisfied with their current lawyer.  This is largely because I handle a limited number of cases, primarily the most serious, and charge a healthy fee for my services.  I do not seek to be the lawyer for everyone; indeed, I reject far more cases than I take.  You will not find my name gracing a storefront sign, screaming “hire me, hire me!” 


As a result, I am often called upon to pick up the pieces of a botched defense in a very serious or complex matter.  If the current attorney has done a good job, I will let the client know and advise them to stick with their current lawyer.  Many clients lose confidence in their lawyer for the wrong reason, and need nothing more than an independent voice to help them to appreciate that they are receiving good representation.  Since I’m not chasing cases, I’m quite happy to save them my fee and provide them with the comfort of knowing that their lawyer isn’t quite the buffoon they think she is, if that’s the case.

The flip side of the role of a second attorney is to see the mess people have made of their cases, seizing defeat from the jaws of victory with shocking frequency.  Whether from hiring inappropriate counsel, to using a public defender when they could well afford their own lawyer, to deciding that they can do better than any lawyer and demand to make their own decisions, to rejecting competent advice and making terrible decisions for themselves.  It runs the gamut, but invariably produced disastrous results.

So while I may sound like a broken record, it bears repeating.  Hire the right attorney for the case, and retain the lawyer as soon as possible.  Real time, not after it finally sinks into your consciousness that it’s serious and you really, really need a lawyer.  By the time you realize it, it’s too late.

And as long as I’m on my soapbox, let me add another recurring detail:  consider the amount of the legal fee relative to your expectations of what the lawyer will do for you.  The numbers don’t lie, and there’s no magic trick involved.  If you are charged with a serious crime and the lawyer asks for a ridiculously low fee, it’s because he anticipates a quick guilty plea.  If you are looking for a quick guilty plea, then you’ve found the right lawyer for you.  If you hope to win the case, then you’ve screwed up. 

But regardless of everything else, there is no point in calling the lawyer after the damage is done.  So I repeat, call the lawyer first.

Searching and Seizing a Digital World

Volokh Conspirator Orin Kerr has been hard at work trying to create a framework for the application of the 4th Amendment to the internet, one of the stickiest problems confronting criminal law in the past decade.  He has produced an upcoming article, Applying the Fourth Amendment to the Internet: A General Approach, and given the respect shown Orin, it is well worth our while to consider whether he’s got it right or out of his mind.  It may well be the difference between suppression and admission for our clients for a long time to come.


 In my new paper, I start with an assumption I call “technology neutrality.” The idea here is that the Fourth Amendment should apply to the Internet much like the Fourth Amendment applies to the physical world. I therefore start with the role that the Fourth Amendment plays in regulating traditional physical investigations, and I look for ways that the Fourth Amendment should be applied to try to replicate that role online given the very different facts of the Internet. Thus, the goal is “technology neutrality”: Ideally, The Fourth Amendment should play the same role regardless of whether a criminal investigation occurs via an investigation in the physical world or whether it occurs via an investigation over the Internet.

The parameters of Orin’s “technology neutrality” approach are somewhat hard to get one’s arms around.  If I understand him correctly, his point is that existing 4th Amendment doctrine, developed and applied to the brick and mortar world, should be applied with equal force to the digital world.  I gather this would be done by analogizing technological wonders to existing hardscape.


At the same time, I think the assumption is a helpful one to make for a good practical reason: It’s what judges and Justices today think the Fourth Amendment requires. That is, the assumption of technology neutrality captures the general understanding among judges and Justices about how the Fourth Amendment is supposed to be interpreted. This understanding follows a trio of cases in 1967: Berger v. New York, Katz v. United States, and Warden v. Hayden. In all three cases, the Supreme Court had to choose at a conceptual level between the Fourth Amendment as a specific set of protections grounded in history and the Fourth Amendment as a general tool to make that make sure the police don’t have too much power. In all three cases, the general view won out.

Rather than start from scratch and develop a 4th Amendment jurisprudence designed for the novel issues that arise from digital reality, and I would also assume the accoutrements of technology such as border laptop searches, hard drive mirror imaging and the like, Orin proposes that we stick with the overarching Katz reasonableness paradigm and shove it into whatever hole fits best.

This scares me.  Not only has the Katz reasonableness test led to the road to perdition, proving time and again how the vague concept of objective reasonableness is so easily manipulated by rhetoric, with whoever can come up with an argument that suits the courts’ bias prevailing, but it has given us exceptions that have swallowed the rule whole, like the automobile exception.  Given how poorly judges adapt to technology, Judge Kozinski aside, and our incredibly poor experience with ignorant precedent guiding us to inappropriate and irrational application of law to developing technology, there is no end to the mischief this could cause.

I can appreciate Orin’s concern that judge’s familiarity with the existing law will make it easier for them to apply it to novel and developing technologies, but I’m unconvinced that “ease of use” should be the most important factor as a whole new area of 4th Amendment law comes into existence.  One day all the current judges will be gone, but we’ll still be stuck with 19th Century legal concepts applied to 21st Century technology.  Facilitating today’s judges hardly seems like the most critical issue over the long run.  Even these old dogs can learn a new trick if they have to.

But the bigger issue is whether analogizing old applications to entirely distinct situations is viable.  The problem is that there is rarely a good fit, with things like the file cabinet analogy showing it’s age in this comment to Orin’s post.   Granted, recreating the 4th Amendment on a sui generis basis would be difficult, confusing and likely to produce some wildly differing results.  It would certainly lack for clarity for a while, as different judges hash out their understanding of technology and try to find the most “reasonable” way to deal with it.  But at the end of the day, we might find ourselves with law that makes sense, rather than law that’s a close fit.

Orin’s approach has some strong institutional arguments in its favor.  What it does not have is the security of knowing that it’s correct, and honors the purpose of the right of citizens to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures.  Given how the law goes from rule to mangled and distorted exception, and how we now stare down the exceptions on a daily basis in our effort to breath some life into the 4th Amendment, I cannot believe that the best we can do is take a moribund right, apply it to the future, and live with the consequences.


Had Ryan Moats Lost His Cool

By now, everyone knows the story of Ryan Moats, racing to the hospital to see his dying mother-in-law and being stopped and detained by Dallas police officer Robert Powell.  For about 15 minutes, Powell puffed out his chest and showed the Houston running back that he was strong, tougher, more powerful than Moats, and could make him bend to his will. 

That it happened just this way is shown courtesy of the dash cam and Youtube, so clear that Dallas Police Chief David Kunkle felt constrained to apologize for Powell’s lack of common sense and discretion. 


His behavior, in my opinion, did not exhibit the common sense, the discretion, the compassion that we expect our officers to exhibit.

But the story ignores a few key factors that could have changed everything.  Notably, while Moats, the driver, stayed outside the hospital as commanded by the very important enforcer of public order, his wife, Tamishia, ignored Powell’s command and ran inside.


She arrived at her mother’s bedside just as 45-year-old Jonetta Collinsworth died.

After being the object of hatred and scorn everywhere, Powell has apologized :


Powell, 25, said he had tried to contact NFL player Ryan Moats and his family to apologize directly but so far had not reached them.

I wish to publicly and sincerely apologize to the Moats family, my colleagues in the Dallas Police Department, and to all those who have been rightfully angered by my actions,” he said in a written statement issued by his attorney.

His sincerity is overwhelming.  I’m sure you’re as deeply moved by this as I am, and are shocked that Moats didn’t have him over for an cool drink to discuss how badly he feels.  And now that we’ve wiped the tear from our collective eyes, back to the point.

What if Moats had done the same? What if Moats had decided, in that split second when the officer commanded him to stay, that he would not comply and miss his last opportunity to see Jonetta Collinsworth alive?

Now many have wondered whether it would be reasonable for Moats to claim that he was so overcome with the need to say good-bye to his mother-in-law.  She was, after all, his mother-in-law, and such a need is perceived by many to be, well, too weird to credit.  To remove this issue, let’s assume that it was his mother.  This was his last chance to see his beloved mother, the women who carried him for nine months, bore him, fed him, wiped his brow after football practice, and he loved her dearly.  What if he decided that no pompous child-cop was going to stop him from telling his mother that he loved her one last time before she died?

Would the headline of the story have been Running Back Moats Fatally Shot For Disobeying Cop?  How would we feel about the story then, knowing that Moats had made the decision that it was more important to see his dying mother than to obey the whimsical command of the cop?

Frankly, it’s rather amazing that Ryan Moats kept his cool as well as he did.  Football players are not renown for succumbing to the will of inconsequential people, even when they wear uniforms with shields.  Some of them don’t even pay heed to consequential people. 

And this was a stop for a traffic infraction.  We know, from lore and video, that police tend to take themselves very seriously during traffic stops,  It’s not that they would shoot (or taze) someone for running a red light, no biggie in the pantheon of bad acts, but for failing to obey.  There is no offense that will rile an officer worse than failure to obey.  

While no police officer could get away with shooting a person for committing a traffic infraction, courts have long upheld their right to shoot for the refusal to heed a police officer’s command.  This is the crux of order, and society would crumble without it.  The underlying cause for the command fades to inconsequence, and the only point worthy of note is that the dead or wounded did not immediately obey the lawful order of the cop.  For that, he deserves whatever he got.

If it was you, and it was your mother about to die in a room 100 feet away, and some punk cop commanded you to stand there and obey him to prove that he was mightier than you could ever hope to be, would you?  This was a one-time opportunity to say good-bye to your mother; there was no option of obeying the cop and ever seeing your mother alive again.  Would you?  Would you risk a bullet in the back of your head to do something critical, that could never be done again?

To call Police Officer Robert Powell the poster-boy for the abuse of petty power by a fool with a gun is easy.  Even his chief is disgusted by his monumental indiscretion.  So do we applaud Moats for having kept his cool, having stopped and obeyed rather than ignored Powell and tried to go inside to his mother-in-law’s bedside?  Was his choice, missing the one opportunity to say good-bye to a dying woman, the right one given the possibility that Powell would have been so very upset at not being shown the obsequience due him that he would have physically subdued, perhaps even shot, Ryan Moats?

There’s no need to face these hard questions in this specific case, because Ryan Moats didn’t ignore Powell and go to his mother-in-law’s bedside.  But others have made a different choice, and paid the price for it.  Had it happened here, would Kunkle have circled the wagons around his officer?  Would the public have felt the same sympathy toward Moats?  Would it have been a righteous shoot?

Chief Kunkle explained that officers aren’t trained on how to handle exigent circumstances like this.  Nor is the public, I might add.  Maybe it’s time we reached some agreement on where this line should be drawn so others aren’t pressed to decide whether to obey or risk death for saying good-bye to a dying woman.

Leaving One on the Table

I tend to adhere to Shakespeare’s notion that I don’t know what I think until I see what I write.  Some say that I write a lot.  I’ve even been called prolific, though mostly by hacks and those suffering from typing disabilities.  But the truth is that every time I begin to write a post, I am never quite sure where it will end up.  It’s as much an adventure for me as for anybody else.

During the course of a regular day, I may see a dozen things that capture my interest, whether news, commentary, decisions or something entirely unrelated to anything else I’ve ever written about.  I save them up for the hour I spend in the early morning writing this blog.  Sometimes, there will be a dozen, even two, items that make it onto my radar.  I then pick which ones still interest me enough to write about them.   They don’t interest you?  That’s cool.  I don’t write to “build audience,” become a “thought leader” or increase my google page rank.  I don’t even know what my google page rank is.  If my posts are boring or irrelevant to you, why not start your own blog and write about things that interest you?  You’re allowed.

But once I’ve decided to write about a subject, I find out for the very first time where it’s heading.  Naturally, I have an idea beforehand where I think it’s going to go, but as I write the post things often go in unanticipated directions.  Sometimes I come to realizations about issues that the cold, hard words on the computer screen force me to accept.  The mind has the amazing ability to make tacit logical leaps, but the flaw in thinking is immediately revealed by the written word.  There’s no getting around the logical gap when it’s staring you in the face.

While it doesn’t happen often, it does happen.  After ten minutes of solid writing, I stare at the words and realize that I hate what I’ve just done.  It’s there, but it’s wrong.  The words don’t reflect my thoughts.  The reason is fundamentally flawed.  The post sucks.  I hate it and I want nothing to do with it.  It’s just plain awful.

I grant you that not every post at Simple Justice is a stroke of brilliance. Indeed, the best bet is that none meet that standard, though I think I’ve got some good stuff stashed away in the more than 2000 posts here at the moment.  But I stand behind each and every one, for better or worse.  Sure, some are more interesting that others, and certainly some are better written. But they are mine, warts and all. 

When I look at what I’ve written and ask myself what was I thinking, I know that I’ve gone seriously awry.  It happened again yesterday, as I put the finishing line on a post about the Rockefeller Drug Laws after reading a story in the New York Times announcing, for the 43rd time, its death.  These stories make angry, both because they are simply false and due to the utter absence of any substantive information about the changes on the table.  So may reports are replete with rhetoric and devoid of fact.  I see this all the time, and I always wonder if anybody else is bothered.  Does anybody else notice?  I’m sure others do, but you don’t read much complaining about it.

Sometimes, I feel as if I need to put the post down and step away.  I save it as a draft with the intention of going back later, reading it over, and then making a decision as to whether it deserves to see the light of day.  Rarely does this sequence of events actually happen.  I know that the post is no good and should never have been written, and going back later just reminds me of what a lousy post I wrote and how awful it is.  It doesn’t get any better with age.

When you crank out as many blog posts as I do, you have to expect some to be mutts.  In some instances, I know in advance that the subject matter will be of only limited interest, and that few people will bother to read it.  That’s fine, since it reflects my interests and was never intended to capture the imagination of some mythical audience.  As much as I appreciate the fact that people spend a few minutes here reading what I’ve written, I don’t write for you. 

[Hint: For the latest crowd of people who are upset with me because I won’t let you use the comments here to launch your self-promotional exposure in the blawgosphere, or seize upon a tangential point in one of my posts in order to promote your own quasi-unrelated agenda, the fact that Simple Justice exists as a platform for me to write should clue you in.  This is not a democracy, and I don’t give a damn what you think the purposes of a blawg should be.  Push me and you’re out of here, and both of us will sleep well tonight either way.]

About an hour after I saved my Rockefeller Drug Law post yesterday, and after I did a host of obligatory duties that have a passing relationship to how I pay the bills, I came back to the place on my blawg where I can control what gets published and what does not.  I deleted it.  Poof.  It’s gone.  It never happened and it will never exist again.

In a funny way, it’s painful to have a story that interests me enough to write about it, only to delete it afterward.  The story is left on the table, to fade into the great black hole of things that warranted my thought but never made it to publication.  While I have no doubt that my decision to delete it, to make it disappear, was the right one, I’m still bothered that I left it on the table.  In the back of my head, I think that I could have done better and I’m disappointed in myself.

Killer Keller’s Got Her Shoes on Backward (Update)

As the saga of door shutting Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Presiding Judge Sharon Keller moves forward, at least we get a good laugh out of it.  Judge Keller has submitted her response to the charges levied against her by the Texas Commission for Judicial Conduct, and the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, has had a field day enjoying the image of Sharon Keller twisting in the wind.

Bennett’s favorite part of the response is the part where Keller whines about the state’s refusal to pay her law firm’s customary fees to defend her:


The net effect is that these two arms of Texas government are forcing Respondent to an election; either defend herself pro se or risk a financially ruinous legal bill to defend against these charges which are without merit.

The irony is overwhelming.  So Judge Keller is horribly upset at the prospect of facing financial ruin to defend against meritless charges?  How nice to see the shoe on the other foot.  I wonder whether she has the slightest clue that she’s getting a taste of the medicine she’s rammed down the throats of Texas defendants regularly.

But what’s particularly disturbing about Killer Keller’s defense is that it’s an indictment in reverse.  Her “defense” to the charges that she slammed shut the door of the courthouse as a defendant faced the executioner bears a striking resemblance to the type of visceral, prejudiced, irrational attacks on criminal defendants in general that have long been used to overcome the absence of fact and logic and rely on stereotyped hatred.

Keller argues that, at length, that Michael Wayne Richard, the man whose fate she sealed, was a bad, evil man.  Obviously, her point is that he deserved to die anyway, so no harm, no foul.  Does she suggest that he’s unworthy of her judicial concern or time? Yes, that’s what she suggests.  She plays the old “he’s guilty anyway” card, and needed killing.  Great concept from a judge, right?

Next she recites all the “due process” he was given, to show that he had his day in court and one more shot (notwithstanding the Supreme Court’s decision that very morning to grant cert. in Baze v. Rees).  Even though the defense was clearly entitled to raise this argument anew, the point of Keller’s argument is that it wasn’t like he didn’t deserve to die.  Indeed, she also argues that any stay based on Baze would have been an objection to the method, not the fact of execution.

And finally, she blames everyone else involved, from defense lawyers who could have submitted their papers earlier in the day, or could have broken a window to find a way into the courthouse even if the doors were locked, to her own general counsel Ed Marty, who could have explained everything to her using smaller words so that she would understand him better as she waited at home for the (refrigerator?) repairman.

Not that the mere fact that Judge Sharon Keller is so callous about the fact that her hand shut the courthouse door on a man about to be executed, a fact that obviously doesn’t disturb her in the slightest, but her overt hostility toward the defendant and her utter lack of care for either the law or a human life mark her as one stone cold woman.  If she loses her job as judge, maybe she can find a new one pushing down the plunger.

So what does all this mean?  In Texas, my guess is that, if she can beat the rap, it assures her re-election victory by a landslide.  After all, Michael Wayne Richard needed killing.  But at least for now, we can enjoy watching Killer Keller with the shoe on the other foot.  I sure hope they don’t pinch.  Too much.

Update:  Bennett’s got more on the subject, this time from the Houston Chronicle’s Rick Casey.


The judge should know better, especially in these tough times, than to ask us taxpayers to agree to a lawyer whose usual and customary fees can lead to a ruinous legal bill. However, I personally would be willing to chip in for the kind of lawyers whom Keller has found acceptable for people whose lives were at stake.

Looks like everybody’s jumping on the irony train.  Don’t let it leave without you.

Coercive Pleas Get Another Slap

Only a few weeks ago, the Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed a plea as coerced when the defendant was given the choice of remand or a guilty plea and probation.  It seems that the plea coercion bug has migrated north, according to this post from the NY Criminal Defense Blog, with the Fourth Department reversal in People v. Flynn.

What’s remarkable about this decision is that the trial court’s arm twisting was so fundamentally mundane, of the sort seen daily for as long as I can remember in the bowels of courts across the state.


At the plea proceeding, the court stated that it would treat defendant “very differently as far as the sentence is concerned” if he exercised his right to a trial and that his sentence after trial would be “nothing like the sentence that [he] would get if [he] stood up and accepted [his] responsibility.” The court further stated that defendant was “going to be sentenced [to] substantially longer than” the agreed-upon term of six years of imprisonment if he exercised his right to a trial.

The Memorandum decision offers little insight as to why this plea, as opposed to almost every other plea ever coerced taken from a defendant, stood out.  Or, could it be that courts have finally had enough of the decades of manipulation of defendants minds and hearts during that 30 seconds standing before the court to move their cases along.  The closest the court comes to offering a rationale is this:


We agree with defendant that the court’s statements do not amount to a description of the range of the potential sentences but, rather, they constitute impermissible coercion, “rendering the plea involuntary and requiring its vacatur.” (citations omitted)

Adding to the mystery, this was an unpreserved argument, reached under the court’s discretionary “interest of justice” jurisdiction, the one pulled out when the court chooses to do its job even though a lawyer failed to mouth the requisite words at the right time.

While the court’s explanation is obviously correct, and the overt threat of “substantially longer” time if the defendant “exercised his right to trial” bore no similarity to the benign “description of the range of the potential sentences,” it’s not like this isn’t de rigor in the trenches.  Does this signal the end of basic everyday plea coercion? 

Of course, consider the flip side of this decision, where the defendant was represented by my old friend Gary Muldoon.  His conviction is reversed, his guilty plea withdrawn, and he’s back on the docket for trial.  Decisions like this are more likely to pull the defendant out of the frying pan and into the fire, unless the defendant now feels confident that he’s got a better defense than he did with the job staring him down the last time. 

While the Flynn decision is a wonderful doctrinal advance, and the management of plea discussions by lower court judges is long overdue for the elimination of coercive and manipulative treatment of defendants, I wonder whether it will have any real effect on how judge’s function in the ordinary course, assuming of course that anyone reads the decision.  While criminal defense lawyers would do well to be very aware of the ruling, in order to “remind” judges when they start threatening defendants that they will spend the rest of their lives in prison if they fail to cop out, the flip side of appeal and reversal doesn’t necessarily offer much of a benefit to the coerced defendant, and might well backfire should the players not feel as kindly on the next time around and the defendant not have much trial leverage.

Still, any decision that diminishes the coercive nature of plea discussions, and particularly threats by the judge, is a good and welcome decision.  Plea bargaining will still be a part of the everyday game in courtrooms, but this trend toward more deliberate and less coercive pleas is long overdue.

Defending the Defenders

Norm Pattis was getting a little annoyed with the brethren who felt it necessary to criticize him for representing a cop.  Now that it’s over, the time has come to put the question on the table.  What’s wrong with defending a cop?



“What’s the matter with you?” The speaker is a good friend and a well-known member of the criminal defense bar. “Why are you representing people like that?”

He was calling into question my representation of a former police officer. The cop was fired from his police force after being videotaped pummeling a man during an arrest. We entered a guilty plea to misdemeanor assault and no jail time last week.

Norm then does what we all do, explaining why he thinks his client isn’t nearly as horrible a person as everyone else does.  I can forgive him this delusion, as it’s one of the protection mechanisms we use to keep our sanity knowing that some of our clients aren’t the finest of human beings.

But even if he was the lowest scum of the earth cop, what’s wrong with that?


But here is the rub: I am a lawyer. I know I have choices and that I am not obliged to represent everyone who walks in my door. But I do not draw distinctions between folks accused of crimes. I represent people accused of abusing children, dismembering bodies, burning down homes, robbing banks; why, shocking to some, I even represent police officers. Indeed, this morning when I checked my messages, I see another cop has called. This is an officer I sued for false arrest 12 years ago. I won the case.

We defend people accused of crimes.  Some are really bad people.  Some are cops.  Is there a problem?


Quite frankly, I am troubled by the sporting view of law which pits one “team” against another. One of the reasons I fled Gerry Spence’s Trial Lawyers College, and there were many other reasons, was the cult-like exclusivity of the program: No prosecutors or insurance defense counsel allowed. That’s just plain stupid.

Lawyers are mere ambassadors for other people’s troubles. I don’t have causes that transcend a particular case. When my agenda conflicts with that of my client, I may have a conflict that impedes my representation.

It is indeed a fascinating phenomenon, that some lawyers will happily defend a child molester but refuse to represent a cop who has ruthlessly beaten a child molester.  Here’s the rub for me: Neither one sits at the right hand of God, so let’s not pretend that there is anything more righteous on one side then the other.  The only sticking point is that personal conscience that may make us incapable of fulfilling our duty to our client, in which case we take a pass on the case.  But the pass is personal, not professional.  That the defendant is a cop means nothing.

I’ve represented a couple of cops in my time.  Not too many, as the business is largely locked up by the PBA with a few “special lawyers.”  I’m not one of them.  But I’ve never felt the slightest qualm about defending a cop, or befriending a cop frankly, when circumstances were appropriate.  The cop is a defendant in need of my services, and he will receive them as I would provide them to any client.  Exactly the same. 

There’s nothing wrong with what you’re doing Norm.  Of course, you already know that.  So the true believers will think us traitors to the cause again.  We’ll survive.

Spare the Rod in Black and White

Corporeal punishment (a/k/a “a good whupping”) was once the rule in child rearing, but our society has since become enlightened, with advocates for children deciding for parents everywhere how they may deal with youthful indiscretions.  Just ask any enlightened child advocate, and they will be happy to tell you why they know better.

Two stories this week, however, show that some variations remain in this age-old American tradition.  One comes via Walter Olson, with the other from David Giacalone.  Both add up to the confusion we face as parents seek to deal with their wayward kiddies in the face of modern philosophies.

From the Chicago Sun-Times,



[A]6-year-old boy had gotten five write-ups for bad behavior during the summer program. A phone call was made to his mother, and his aunt picked him up.


The aunt asked Schandelmeier-Bartels “where the bathroom was.”


When she returned to where she left the boy and his aunt, Schandelmeier-Bartels said she heard “Whack” “Ow” “Whack” “Ow” “Whack” “Ow” several times, according to the suit. She reported what she considered abuse to the state and the police.


It seems that summer program director Cathleen Schandelmeier-Bartels was unaware that such a whupping was a “black thing,” and was unfamiliar with the concept of a “bathroom whupping.”  She was fired for her racial insensitivity, sued and recovered $200,000 for her wrongful termination.  But was she right to report this to the police?

When it comes to abuse, Schandelmeier-Bartels is probably more sensitive than most. She has worked with the International Society for the Prevention of Child Abuse and Neglect, and in 1996, she coordinated a video for the organization that got global attention. “I don’t believe in ever spanking or hitting a child no matter what,” she told me. “If someone else other than me had been outside that bathroom that day, I doubt that the incident would have been reported.”

The critical point is that she doesn’t believe “in ever spanking or hitting a child no matter what.”  Since that’s what she believes, it must be criminal to do so. 

But this story from Schenectady breaks through stereotypes, with a white father administering a whupping of his own.

Police say Fisher committed felony assault on March 13. He whipped his son with a belt after the 13-year-old was kicked out of school for stealing from teachers, hitting other children and cutting a girl’s hair.

But supporters of corporal punishment say that the few short-lived welts on the boy’s butt might be just what he needed.

His father, however, now faces jail time if found guilty. He plans to take the case to trial to argue that a one-time belt-spanking for inexcusable behavior is well within a parent’s authority.

“I was just trying to be a parent,” Fisher said. “He’s 13 now. I’m trying to raise him to be a man. I couldn’t just sit back and watch him going down the wrong road.”

And Lloyd Ray Fisher now faces felony assault charges.  Or, a medal for being an exemplary parent, according to who you talk to.

At the extreme ends, the question of parents administering a good whupping seems fairly easy to resolve, even though the most zealous advocates would argue that any spanking is an assault and child abuse.  But where should the line be drawn?  If the parents play a role in a child’s bad, even criminal, behavior, what exactly do we expect them to do about it?  Fisher tried the alternatives first.  They didn’t help.

“I’d tried the Dr. Phil method. You sit him down, you talk, you go out for ice cream, you go on long walks,” Fisher said. “But he was in continuous trouble. It’s like an everyday, regular thing: The judge said stay out of trouble for a month, and six hours later he stole again. He was hitting girls — I sat him down and said, ‘Dude, that’s the most disrespectful thing you can do.’ The last thing you want is your kid beating up girls. I have little girls and I can imagine — that’s as low as you can go. And he kept doing it.”

We’re happy to blame parents for doing a lousy job, but we’re also happy to prosecute them for trying to fulfill their responsibility of raising law-abiding children.  While the true-believers, for whom no corporeal punishment is acceptable, offer a bright line test, most people, black and white, rich and poor, still believe that parents have some role to play in the rearing of their children.

What is not at all clear is how to develop a rule for parents to understand where the line is drawn between good and responsible parenting and child abuse.  Do we want to leave it up to the nearest Schandelmeier-Bartels, making the determination of whether one happens to have a zealot close at hand to call the cops any time a parent behaves in a way in which she disapproves?  But then, we are also aware of many instances of serious child abuse by parents, resulting in death and disability of children that leaves us asking how this could happen without anyone intervening.

Where is the line?  Both parents and children deserve to know.


Schools Have Rules, Supreme Court Edition (Update)

Long time readers will recall my first post about Savana Redding, the 13 year old 8th grade honor student who was subject to a strip search and body cavity inspection at school for fear that she possessed ibuprofen. The case will be argued before the Supreme Court on April 21st, and Adam Liptak garnered a front page piece about the case in yesterday’s New York Times.

The case will require the justices to consider the thorny question of just how much leeway school officials should have in policing zero-tolerance policies for drugs and violence, and the court is likely to provide important guidance to schools around the nation.

You betcha.  For those of you unfamiliar with what happened to Savana, here’s a synopsis:



Savana Redding, an eighth grade honor roll student at Safford Middle School in Tucson, Arizona, was pulled from class on October 8, 2003 by the school’s vice principal, Kerry Wilson.  Earlier that day, Wilson had discovered [drugs] in the possession of Redding’s classmate….Under questioning and faced with punishment, the classmate claimed that Redding, who had no history of disciplinary problems or substance abuse, had given her the [drugs].

 


After escorting Redding to his office, Wilson presented Redding with the [drugs] and informed her of her classmate’s accusations. Redding said she had never seen the [drugs] before and agreed to a search of her possessions, wanting to prove she had nothing to hide. Joined by a female school administrative assistant, Wilson searched Redding’s backpack and found nothing. Instructed by Wilson, the administrative assistant then took Redding to the school nurse’s office in order to perform a strip search. 


In the school nurse’s office, Redding was ordered to strip to her underwear. She was then commanded to pull her bra out and to the side, exposing her breasts, and to pull her underwear out at the crotch, exposing her pelvic area. The strip search failed to uncover any [drugs].


The 9th Circuit held that the school violated Savanna’s 4th Amendment right to be free of unreasonable search and seizure.  Somehow, that doesn’t quite capture the wrong here for me.  Not even close.

Had Savanna been my daughter, and some school district grocery clerk explained to me that he had to have my daughter strip searched because of their zero-tolerance policy on drugs, I might consider asking Jdog if I could borrow some blued-steel for an hour or two.  I am not a violent man, but there are places that no school official should ever go.  This is one of them.

The district provided further explanation about why Savana was a potential threat to others in justification of their actions.


In a sworn statement submitted in the case, Safford Unified School District v. Redding, No. 08-479, Mr. Wilson said he had good reason to suspect Ms. Redding. She and other students had been unusually rowdy at a school dance a couple of months before, and members of the school staff thought they had smelled alcohol. A student also accused Ms. Redding of having served alcohol at a party before the dance, Mr. Wilson said.

Now I’m no expert on effects of ibuprofen, but I am unaware of the causal connection between students  being “unusually rowdy,” whatever that means, months before and the theoretical ingestion of Tylenol. Are they suggesting that ibuprofen is the new heroin?  As for the the claim of alcohol, again raising the causal connection problem, it seems that any accusation is good enough around this school.  No need for anything more.

So what does Savana say about these accusations of horrible conduct:


Ms. Redding said she had served only soda at the party, adding that her accuser was not there. At the dance, she said, school administrators had confused adolescent rambunctiousness with inebriation. “We’re kids,” she said. “We’re goofy.”

Thirteen year old girls act “goofy”?  Is that possible?  Could that happen?  Well, we certainly can’t expect grocery clerks to believe the accused, since honor students are so naturally inclined to lie to cover their substance abuse.  And besides, then they wouldn’t have gotten the chance to strip search Savana, and what fun would that have been?

But cooler heads than mine have a different take.


Richard Arum, who teaches sociology and education at New York University, said he would have handled the incident differently. But Professor Arum said the Supreme Court should proceed cautiously.

“Do we really want to encourage cases,” Professor Arum asked, “where students and parents are seeking monetary damages against educators in such school-specific matters where reasonable people can disagree about what is appropriate under the circumstances?”

It’s unclear to me what Arum is trying to say.  Is his problem with monetary damages?  Is he just an educator sycophant, believing the school officials can do no wrong?  Or perhaps he gets his jollies thinking about 13 year olds being strip searched?  It’s unclear.  But he is dead wrong about one thing.  Reasonable people cannot disagree that this was sick and abusive.  No reasonable person can believe that a school official was reasonable in strip searching Savana in search of ibuprofen.  Mind you, there was no evidence beyond the claim of another student that she got prescription strength ibuprofen (the equivalent of two non-prescription Tylenol), but this doesn’t factor in as a critical piece in any event. 

The school district’s argument is based on the knee-jerk love that grocery clerks have for zero-tolerance.  It makes for fabulous rules, and grocery clerks love rules.  It makes them powerful and clear, and grocery clerks love to be powerful and clear.  It allows them to do anything they “have to do,” and this “just had to be done.”  Why?  It was the rule.

It will be interesting to see whether the Justices focus on the search and seizure issue, the legal basis for the 9th Circuit’s ruling, or the broader, more meaningful issue for the real world.  What business do school officials have strip searching students?  If there is something so dire, so mission critical, so threatening to the health and safety of other students, that it demands such extreme action, then why not turn it over to the police to handle. 

While an awfully good argument can be made that the police are more dangerous to young women than school grocery clerks, a secondary commentary on how our protectors in government treat the vulnerable in their care, there are similarly more appropriate safeguards and remedies imposed on those trained and charged in law enforcement as opposed to grocery clerks all swollen with the power and importance.

The fact that this happened, that it is a subject of any debate at all, is a reflection of our diseased vision of personal autonomy and integrity in the age of fear.  Let this happen to your daughter and see which side of the line you support.  Short of having damn good reason to believe that a student is concealing a deadly weapon on his person with imminent intent to use it, and I have some difficulty picturing that circumstance ever occurring, I can think of no situation where a school official should ever have the authority to do this to a child.  There is a depth to which no one is entitled to go, and what was done to Savana Redding went there.

Let’s hope that someone, maybe even a majority, on the Supremes sees clearly that our schools, in the name of fear, have gone off the deep end and put a stop to it.  We don’t send our children to school for this.

Update:  I realize that some of you feel that I may be, well, a bit shy about expressing my opinions.  I know, but it’s hard to come out of my shell.  So for those of you seeking a less circumspect approach, I offer this view from Just a Girl in Short Shorts Talking, located by my ever-vigilant hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen.  Short Shorts Girl includes some valuable insight that I was unable to bring to the discussion, such as:


We shouldn’t be surprised. The nation’s fine educational system is being systematically undermined by hordes of middle school kids gulping Ibuprofen pills, which have been secreted in the vaginas of little girls.

Who knew? Then there’s this hidden camera photo of Nurse Peggy, who is charged with personal inspections below the waste after Office Secretary Helen makes sure there are no weapons down there.

Peggy Schwallier

But on a more serious note, this little throw away to the hard right:


[The School District is] represented by famed pannysniffer Ken Starr. Lets hope that SCOTUS makes short order of this, so that Judge Starr can get back to his true mission–for surely somewhere in the country there is a politician engaging in illicit blowjobs.

In light of this high-powered, and SCOTUS loved advocate, Short Shorts Girl fears that this case could create the “Advil Exception” to the Fourth.  Keep your eyes peeled.