Author Archives: SHG

Not My Yob

The New York Times carries an email from AIG Executive Vice President Jake DeSantis to Edward Liddy announcing his resignation, and explaining his reasoning, as an Op-Ed.  DeSantis, who started with AIG in 1998 as a trader and worked his way up the ladder to head AIG Financial Products, provides a level of insight into the thinking of finance folk that we would rarely get to see.  Below are excerpts from the email:



DEAR Mr. Liddy,

It is with deep regret that I submit my notice of resignation from A.I.G. Financial Products. I hope you take the time to read this entire letter. Before describing the details of my decision, I want to offer some context:


I am proud of everything I have done for the commodity and equity divisions of A.I.G.-F.P. I was in no way involved in — or responsible for — the credit default swap transactions that have hamstrung A.I.G. Nor were more than a handful of the 400 current employees of A.I.G.-F.P. Most of those responsible have left the company and have conspicuously escaped the public outrage.

The profitability of the businesses with which I was associated clearly supported my compensation. I never received any pay resulting from the credit default swaps that are now losing so much money. I did, however, like many others here, lose a significant portion of my life savings in the form of deferred compensation invested in the capital of A.I.G.-F.P. because of those losses.


As most of us have done nothing wrong, guilt is not a motivation to surrender our earnings. We have worked 12 long months under these contracts and now deserve to be paid as promised. None of us should be cheated of our payments any more than a plumber should be cheated after he has fixed the pipes but a careless electrician causes a fire that burns down the house.

That is why I have decided to donate 100 percent of the effective after-tax proceeds of my retention payment directly to organizations that are helping people who are suffering from the global downturn. This is not a tax-deduction gimmick; I simply believe that I at least deserve to dictate how my earnings are spent, and do not want to see them disappear back into the obscurity of A.I.G.’s or the federal government’s budget.


On March 16 I received a payment from A.I.G. amounting to $742,006.40, after taxes. In light of the uncertainty over the ultimate taxation and legal status of this payment, the actual amount I donate may be less — in fact, it may end up being far less if the recent House bill raising the tax on the retention payments to 90 percent stands.  Once all the money is donated, you will immediately receive a list of all recipients.


Sincerely,


Jake DeSantis


On the one hand, this email shows that the management of AIG led its people down the garden path of expectations, fostering the belief that they should stick with the company and wait out the tough times.  On the other hand, however, it shows a level of self-serving naiveté that is simply astounding from someone, despite his youth, who holds a reasonably responsible position and receives compensation that would be sufficient to fund a small village. 

DeSantis received almost three quarters of a million dollars, after taxes, as his third payment of the 2008 bonus.  Do the math.  Any way you turn the tax issue, that’s a lot of money.  That he’s entitled to be paid for his work is beyond question, but to analogize it to “cheating” the plumber shows a monumental disconnect from reality.  Jake’s no plumber.

Had the bonus been half a million, it’s unlikely that anyone would have been screaming for blood.  And half a mill isn’t a bad take for a year.  Few families go hungry on half a mill, even in Connecticut.  But DeSantis’ email shows that he truly believes that he “earned” his money; he did something during that 12 month period that justifies the actual numbers. Not merely was this a matter of his having a contractual right to a huge payday, but a moral right to the payday he deserved. 

If you read the email in its entirety, you will see that DeSantis emphatically notes that neither he nor his department had anything to do with the horrendous credit default swaps that proved disastrous for AIG.  From this, he argues that he shouldn’t be penalized because somebody else screwed up royally.  He did his job.

What DeSantis fails to recognize is the inseparability of the taxpayer funding of AIG, the corporate entity, to assure its survival.  Had the government failed to shore it up, it would have gone bankrupt.  No soup for you, Jake.  The internal fault may have been the credit default swaps, but the dead carcass would have been AIG.  His success wasn’t enough to save the company as a going concern.  His company crashed.  His company failed.  AIG was his employer, not the financial products division or any of the divisions that similarly had no connection to the credit default swaps.  Had they locked the door to the building, all employees would have been shut out.  Not just the evil ones.

This ability to compartmentalize fault and blame, and thus proclaim that the fault wasn’t his, allows him to claim with a straight face that his ersatz bankrupt employer owes him big money, and had no right to make him the scapegoat for someone else’s screw up.  When a company fails, it fails for all its employees, the good ones as well as the bad. 

I can’t help but wonder whether the entitlement demonstrated by this email, the gross vision of self-worth, the ability to lay blame elsewhere and thereby remove any personal responsibility within a single entity, is the real culprit.  Sure, the bubble burst when the credit default swaps were revealed as bundles of crap, but the demand for ever-increasing new products, not to mention a piece of the real estate profit pie, was as much a driving force in the AIG profitability picture as old school equity trading.  It’s goal was to generate these huge bonuses that every worthy employee of AIG believed he deserved. 

It seems from the email that AIG misled DeSantis, leaving him to believe that he would receive his bonus, that he earned his bonus, and that the company stood behind him.  Now DeSantis feels betrayed by AIG.  Finally, he’s come to feel what the rest of us feel about the entire financial services industry.  Now that Jake quit, maybe he can land a decent job as a plumber.  Of course, being a plumber takes training and skill, and I doubt that Jake has the ability to do the job just yet.

But How Do You Feel About It?

Something bugs Frank Wu, and it bugs me too.  In his post at Concurring Opinions, the GW Lawprof writes:


In Professional Responsibility, we just covered Model Rule 3.4(e), which states in part, “A lawyer shall not . . . in trial . . . assert personal knowledge of facts in issue except when testifying as a witness, or state a personal opinion as to the justness of a cause, the credibility of a witness, the culpability of a civil litigant or the guilt or innocence of an accused . . .” I actually make it a point to mention this Rule in virtually every course I teach. I do so to counteract the common tendency among not only students but the general public to preface statements and arguments with, “I believe” or “I feel,” or as if it became more persuasive, “I strongly believe,” or “I really feel.”

Right on!  When I judge moot court, whether trials or appellate arguments, students constantly express their arguments in terms of what they believe or feel.  It drives me nuts.  During the critique period, I ask them why they feel compelled to phrase their arguments this way, and I am invariably told that it’s because they “really, really believe it.”

Who cares?  The advocates psycho-emotional state has no place in argument whatsoever.  Forget the Model Rule.  It’s totally unpersuasive.  Everyone assumes that the lawyer for the appellant believes that the appellant’s position should prevail.  This is not news.  Not even the most strenuous, fervent expression of your personal feelings on the subject make it any more convincing. 

Remember the classic line from A Few Good Men:  I strenuously object.  It was a joke, not a compelling argument. 

And it’s not just law students who indulge in the fantasy that their personal convictions matter to others.  Non-lawyers do it constantly, as if their personal beliefs provide a substitute for coherent reasoning.  Of course, laypeople are forgiven, as they aren’t trained in the art of persuasion and, more importantly, aren’t responsible for someone else’s freedom.  If they chose to make unavailing arguments, it doesn’t really matter since no one is paying any attention anyway.  But lawyer do it as well.  This is not good.

When a practicing lawyer, in the course of representation of a client, prefaces his argument with words that express a personal sense, he should be shot (metaphorically, not with real bullets, Jdog).  This is inexcusable coming from someone entrusted with the interests of another person, and is about as rookie and ineffective as argument can get.  Don’t think nobody notices.  Why do you see the judge grimacing?  Why do you think all the other lawyers in the courtroom have put their heads into their hands?  Well, at least the competent lawyers.  Why?

Mommy may have told you that your personal thoughts on every subject were fascinating, and to her they likely were.  To the rest of us, not so much. In fact, not at all.  If you’ve got reasons, state them.  Whether you feel strongly about them adds no weight whatsoever.  Reasons stand or fall on their own.  What matter is whether the person deciding agrees with your reasons.  It’s how they feel, not you.

There are, of course, matters that aren’t susceptible to rational argument.  Which tastes better, chocolate or vanilla?  If the judge asks your preference, it would be fully appropriate to say that you believe that vanilla tastes better.  It’s unlikely that the judge will ask you this, unless she plans of tossing an ice cream party after the verdict, but it could happen.  Aside from this situation, keep your feelings to yourself.

And as for Frank Wu, well done and keep it up.  As for any lawprof who allows her students to express themselves in terms of their feelings and beliefs, law school would be the perfect time to clear up this problem, before they embarrass themselves in court or, worse still, blow an argument in front of a judge or jury.

Lawyer +10

We often struggle to make a point which could be made simply, but for the fact that it would offend the very people you seek to persuade in the process.  So it is with my views on new lawyers going solo.  Whether phrased as “straight out of law school” or, more benignly, before they have the experience to adequately represent human beings, it’s a slap in the face to those who have done so, whether by choice or necessity. 

It’s not meant as a slight, but you know how those pugnacious Slackoisie hard-working young lawyers can be.  A very sensitive lot, they are.

After my post on the inevitable, succinctly noting my reluctant acceptance of the fact that newbie lawyers without any hope of employment will open up shop despite my sage advice to the contrary, Matt Little of the Chandler Littles posted that I was wrong.  His proof?  He went solo right out of law school.  Oy.


What I want to get across is that going straight into solo practice can provide as much training and supervision as a more traditional career path. The drawbacks Adrian and I encountered, like more liability, more expenses, more risk, longer hours, and less-than-steady pay at the outset, were things that affected us personally. They weren’t to the detriment of our clients.

In fairness to Matt, he took his own licking in certain ways, but still misses the primary directive.  But how can I explain this without offending, and I certainly don’t want to do that.  Matt may very well be the exception who proves the rule, the newbie lawyer with such raw talent and insight that he serves his clients with extraordinary skill.  Having never been to Chandler, I couldn’t say, and wouldn’t suggest otherwise.

But then South Carolina criminal defense lawyer  Bobby Fredericks added his two cents into the mix, by noting that he agrees and disagrees with everybody on the subject.  After noting Brian Tannebaum’s castigation of the new lawyer who sees a solo criminal defense practice as an “easy mark,” the “plead-em-and-weep” crowd, Bobby concludes:


My opinion is that if you are considering starting a solo criminal defense practice out of necessity, whether straight out of law school or not, because you can’t find a job doing something else – please don’t. When you accept a criminal defense case you are holding a person’s life in your hands, sometimes literally, and it is not something that anyone should be doing just to pay the bills or because there is no other job available at the moment. If you are considering starting a solo criminal defense practice because that is what you know you want to do, then go for it.

Thus, it’s a matter of “will” rather than “way”.  That the lawyer who truly wants to do criminal defense will come to his work with a zeal that can’t be matched by the lawyer who chooses criminal defense because he can’t get a real job is obvious.  But is it enough?  Are good intentions a substitute for strong skills and experience?

Of course, experience is also a tricky commodity.  As Jim Keech pointed out, there’s a big difference between 20 years experience and one year’s experience repeated twenty times.  It’s not the simple fact of time elapsing, but the breadth of understanding gained from experience, failures as well as successes, and the jurisprudential knowledge that comes with it.  Lawyers who want to be criminal defense lawyers, who desire to be great at what they do, will gain from experience.  Lawyers in it for the buck may not.

After much thought, I’ve arrived at way of expressing the problem in a fashion that will better make my point without offending those youngsters who have taken the plunge. 


Consider:  Will you be a better, more effective criminal defense lawyer five years from now?  Ten years?  I have no doubt you will be, and I would bet the farm that you expect to be better then too.  You will bring the desire you have today, couple it with the experience you gain tomorrow and the next day, add to it the maturity that life thrusts upon you, and be a far better lawyer than you are now.

No one is calling you a bad lawyer now, or suggesting that you are a menace to society per se.  But if you reverse the paradigm, you can see that what you will offer a client once you’ve gotten that experience under your belt is what you are not giving your client yet.  If you will better in five years, you are five years less than better today.  What exactly that means to the client is hard to say, though I suspect when you look back, if you look back, you will see opportunity that slipped under your radar, or choices that would have been made differently had you known then what you know now.  We all do, and we continue to do that as we continue to gain valuable experience.

Positive messages are taken far better than negative, but we’re trying to be adults here and sometimes the news isn’t always rosy.  Just as that first “guilty” verdict is a sucker punch to the gut, this is a profession of harsh realities.  We don’t get to pick our cases like civil lawyers do, cherry-picking the easy ones and letting the difficult ones walk.  We take our defendants as they come, and they always come with problems or they wouldn’t come at all.  Dealing with negatives is our way of life, and if you aren’t tough enough to accept that, criminal defense isn’t the right place for you.  Every good criminal defense lawyer has to be able to take a punch.

Like Bobby, I don’t question your good intentions or your desire to do everything in your power for your client, provided that your entrance into the glorious world of solo criminal defense practice is for the right reasons.  But I cannot discount the fact that there is more to holding people’s lives in your hand than good intentions.  Neither can you.

Where Bailouts Are Born

Our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen Casey, was curious why Washington showered its love on AIG.  So she followed the sage advice of Deep Throat and followed the money.  This is what she found:

By Kathleen Casey

On Monday, March 16, two days after the New York Times reported on March 14, A.I.G. Planning Huge Bonuses After $170 Billion Bailout – NYTimes.com, that word of the AIG bonuses stirred “deep consternation inside the Obama administration” a Washington-based nonprofit entity posted details of bonuses from AIG to members of the U.S. Senate and House of Representatives, 1989 through 2008, including President Obama’s Senate and presidential campaigns. During this 20-year period AIG has contributed more than $9 million to federal candidates and parties through PAC and individual contributions according to the Center for Responsive Politics, posting the details on its website, OpenSecrets.org., based on reports filed and released by the Federal Elections Commission.


“As long as everyone’s talking today about AIG’s payouts to its executives and foreign banks, let’s remember the payouts AIG has made over the years to politicians,” commented Massie Ritsch, communications director for the organization, described as nonpartisan with the mission of tracking money in U.S. politics, including campaign contributions and lobbying data, and its effect on elections and public policy. That’s enough to rank AIG on OpenSecrets.org’s Heavy Hitters list, only number 79 of “the top 100 contributors of all time.” It also reported that last year, AIG and its subsidiaries spent about $9.7 million on federal lobbying, down from an all-time high of $11.4 million spent on lobbying in 2007. According to the press release posted on the very serviceable website,


Over time, AIG hasn’t shown an especially partisan streak, splitting evenly the $9.3 million it has contributed since 1989. In the last election cycle, though, 68 percent of contributions associated with the company went to Democrats. Two senators who chair committees charged with overseeing AIG and the insurance industry, Sen. Chris Dodd (D-Conn.) and Sen. Max Baucus (D-Mont.), are among the top recipients of AIG contributions. Baucus chairs the Senate Finance Committee and has collected more money from AIG in his congressional career than from any other company–$91,000. And with more than $280,000, AIG has been the fourth largest contributor to Dodd, who chairs the Senate’s banking committee. President Obama and his rival in last year’s election, Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), are also high on the list of top recipients.

But in 2008 McCain was a distant third in rank as a recipient of AIG contributions to federal elections campaigns, $59,499, behind Dodd, $103,900, and Obama, number one by a nose, $104,332 according to the website. The revelations pile on:


AIG has been a personal investment for lawmakers, too. Twenty-eight current members of Congress reported owning stock in AIG in 2007, worth between $2.5 million and $3.3 million. Sen. John Kerry (D-Mass.), one of the richest members of Congress, was by far the biggest investor in AIG, with stock valued around $2 million.

About Us – CBS News describes “newsmagazine” 60 Minutes as “offering hard-hitting investigative reports, interviews, feature segments and profiles of people in the news.” But Steve Kroft did not hit hard with Obama On AIG Rage, Recession, Challenges – CBS News. Among details of life in the White House with Michelle and the girls, his interview was open-ended yet circumscribed about bailouts and bonuses, evading the elephant in the home office — the bonuses AIG has paid:


“…People want a lot of contradictory things. You know, the banks would love a lot of taxpayer money with no strings attached. Folks in Congress, as well as the American people, would love to fix the banks without spending any money. And so at a certain point, you know, you’ve got just a very difficult line to walk.”

“You need the financial community…to solve this crisis,” Kroft remarked. “Do you think that the people on Wall Street and the people in the financial community that you need trust you, believe in you?”

“Part of my job is to communicate to them. Look, I believe in the market. I believe in financial innovation. And I believe in success. I want them to do well. But what I also know is that the financial sector was out of balance. You look at how finance used to operate just 20 years ago, or 25 years ago. People, if you went into investment banking, you were making 20 times what a teacher made. You weren’t making 200 times what a teacher made,” Obama said.

“There is a perception right now, at least in New York, which is where I live and work. …People feel they thought that you were going to be supportive. And now I think there are a lot of people the say, ‘Look, we’re not gonna be able to keep our best people. They’re not gonna stay and work here for $250,000 a year when they can go work for a hedge fund, if they can find one that’s still working…and make a lot more,” Kroft remarked.

“I’ve told them directly, ’cause I’ve heard some of this. They need to spend a little time outside of New York. …where folks would be thrilled to be making $75,000 a year without a bonus, then I think they’d get a sense of why people are frustrated,” Obama said.

“…because of bad bets made on Wall Street, there have been enormous losses. I mean there were a whole bunch of folks who, on paper, if you looked at quarterly reports, were wildly successful, selling derivatives that turned out to be…completely worthless,” he added.

And they were insuring them.

“Now you know, gosh, I don’t think it’s me being anti-Wall Street just to point out that the best and the brightest didn’t do too well on that front, and that you know, maybe the incentive structures that have been set up have not produced the kinds of long term growth that I think everybody’s looking for,” Obama said.

As of Tuesday, the Center for Responsive Politics lists media citations to the AIG data, only three, on March 19, Critics Got Donations From Insurer – WSJ.com, and on March 18, ABC News: Will Obama, McCain, Dodd Return Contributions From AIG Employees? and Watching the A.I.G. Hearing on the Hill – The Caucus Blog – NYTimes.com, which reported:



A.I.G. Employees and Campaign Donations | 12:26 p.m. One other aspect of A.I.G.’s purported influence as a significant financial institution is its role as a mega-donor to political campaigns. The Center for Responsive Politics ranks A.I.G. employees among its top 100 heavy-hitters, based on the highest amounts of money donated to politicians over time.


Among those receiving large amounts were Senator Christoper J. Dodd, Democrat and chairman of the Senate Banking Committee, and Senator Max Baucus, Democrat of Montana and chairman of the Finance Committee. (President Barack Obama, Senator John McCain and Hillary Rodham Clinton also received hefty donations last year from A.I.G. during their presidential campaigns.)


None of this as an “aspect of A.I.G.’s purported influence” is a shocker so far as the Grey Lady is concerned, reporting about it only on a blog, and inconclusively concluding, in a prize of garbled syntax:


We’re not suggesting any quid pro quo, by the way. But the confluence of political donations, the near-collapse of the corporation and the amount of lobbying money that flows in and out of Congress as it makes decisions is something that has long been monitored.

Those of us living outside work-a-day politics and the media can understand that there is not and never was a rotation-in-office term limits amendment in our Constitution, and so career representation is to be expected. Moreover, congressional campaigns are media-controlled money monsters, and money-flush corporations are one source of large-block contributions. This is all bigness.


In comparison to the New York Times, the Wall Street Journal described the pretense that most any schoolchild can grasp, in the lead sentence of a real article:


WASHINGTON — Some of the most vocal critics of American International Group’s bonus payments are also the biggest recipients of campaign contributions from the company, including President Barack Obama and Senate Banking Chairman Christopher Dodd.

Near the end it prominently “suggested a quid pro quo,” and turned out a phrase:


AIG has run one of the largest political-influence operations in Washington in the past decade. The company has spent $72.6 million to lobby Congress and the administration since 1998, making it one of the top lobbying spenders among corporations, according to public records.

In October, after it received government funding to stay afloat, AIG said it would stop lobbying Congress and the Obama administration. Campaign donations dried up at the same time.

AIG has made $9.3 million in donations since 1989, placing it among the top 100 sources of campaign donations during that period, according to the Center for Responsive Politics. In addition, FEC records show that the company has hosted dozens of fund-raising events for lawmakers.

In an op-ed article he wrote and published in the Washington Post on March 18, AIG CEO Liddy threw a bone to the issue:


When I answered the call for help and joined AIG in September 2008, one thing quickly became apparent: The company’s overall structure is too complex, too unwieldy and too opaque for its component businesses to be well managed as one entity. …

What also became clear is that once AIG’s relationship with the government and taxpayers changed, our behavior as a company needed to change. So, of our own initiative, we suspended our federal lobbying activities and halted corporate political contributions.

Edward M. Liddy – Repairing AIG and Repaying the Public – washingtonpost.com


The Washington Post has reported nothing recently about the numbers and other details of AIG lobbying and political contributions, whether directly from the FEC or from the office where Massie Ritsch reports the numbers, which is, at 14th and L Streets, barely a block away from The Post. It’s not as though the paper hasn’t already done some digging, producing this about Maurice R. Greenman, AIG CEO for decades, early last October: AIG Founder Wielded Personal Influence in Washington – washingtonpost.com :



“They have long played this game like experts, and it’s certain that their pull on the political front plays a role in their access to support now,” said Sheila Krumholz, executive director of the Center for Responsive Politics. “AIG’s goodwill is legendary.”


AIG’s clout came in large part from Greenberg’s commanding persona. Wall Street called the hands-on chairman a genius, and at least four presidents sought his advice on international affairs and financial markets. …


Greenberg backed up his own influence with a board of directors that included members with deep ties to their respective political parties. Among them were President Bill Clinton’s defense secretary William S. Cohen and former U.N. ambassador Richard Holbrooke. On the Republican side, there was Carla Hills, who had been U.S. trade representative under President George H.W. Bush, and whose husband had been chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission.


One hand washes another you know. This is an insurance company.


So far as ABC is concerned, what the New York Times has dismissed as “the confluence” of money and Congressional decision-making is elemental to questions of integrity:



This raises two key questions: Was any bailout money used to make political contributions? And will the politicians who received AIG cash give the money back? …


Records indicate that AIG’s PACs stopped making donations, but contributions from AIG executives continued right up to the presidential election.


One suggestion: Perhaps the money could be paid back not to AIG but to the U.S. Treasury.


“A White House spokesman couldn’t be reached for comment” to the Wall Street Journal as of publication last Thursday. 60 Minutes could have reached the one and only White House spokesman for comment by airtime Sunday, if not by Kroft to his face, so as to give us answers in a “hard-hitting” interview, CBS’ adjective. But that didn’t happen. This was not ABC, after all. President Obama was not reached for comment.


 


 

US Attorney, SDNY, Proves Why It’s The Best

This just in (and no, it couldn’t wait) from Talking Points Memo via @radleybalko.

As part of their efforts to make the scale and scope of Bernie Madoff’s crimes clear to Judge Denny Chin in deciding the terms of his plea, confinement and eventual sentencing, the folks at the US Attorney’s Office for the Southern District of New York submitted emails from Madoff’s victims describing the injury they had suffered and the punishment they believed Madoff deserved.

Cut to page 36 of the government’s submission, and there you will find this heartfelt missive:


From: [redacted]
Sent: Saturday, March 07, 2009 6:38 PM
Subject: REPLY ME

My Name is Mr. [redacted] but my origin is from Republic of Congo. I have an inherited fund I want to invest in a business in your country with a help of a local. I don’t know about what business but I found it wise to invest the funds in your country with your collaboration with me.


Ever since I move to Dubai due to the problem in my country, I have not been able to invest the funds in Dubai due to security reasons. Now I am seeking foreign assistance to transfer the funds in your country based on the news of their development.


If you can assist, I am willing to give you 10% of the funds that is US$3.5Million. You will understand that my entire life and future depend on this money and I shall be very grateful if you can assist me. The major thing I demand from you is the absolute assurance that the funds will be safe and you will not sit on it when it is transferred into your account.


I will be willing to coming to your country once everything has been done and the funds are in your bank to discuss on lucrative investment in your country.


I hope to hear from you so that we might get to talk better on this issue. Please do give me your contact information in order for me to call you ASAP.


If this email offends your moral value, do accept my apology.


Hope to hear from you soon.


Best Regards,


[redacted]


It just doesn’t seem possible.  And let me be the first to congratulation AUSA Marc Litt on a fine job of serving the people.  I know I’ll sleep better tonight.

Please Retain Me

When Steve Kroft asked his target, President Obama, what was wrong with the idea of paying bonuses in the tens of millions of dollars to the “best and brightest” of the financial industry, the President’s response was that they need to get away from Wall Street once in a while and learn about life in places like Iowa. 


Speaking about discussions on limiting executive compensation and bonuses and how firms fear they might lose top talent due to lower pay, the president said, “I’ve told them directly, ’cause I’ve heard some of this. They need to spend a little time outside of New York. Because you know, if you go to North Dakota, or you go to Iowa, or you go to Arkansas, where folks would be thrilled to be making $75,000 a year without a bonus, then I think they’d get a sense of why people are frustrated.

Now I’m not the President of the United States, no less much of anything else, but that answer didn’t blow me away.  What difference does it make what folks in Arkansas think?  And, I note that the Walton’s might take issue with the President’s view.  Wall Street bonus babies aren’t seeking the approval of midwest middle managers, even if they knew they existed.

Their world isn’t quite as small as the downtown financial center.  Oh no, it extends all the way east to the Hamptons, then north to Greenwich.  But that’s where it ends.  It’s not quite a small group of people, but it’s not very large either.  It’s a bunch of men and women who operate in a shockingly small pond, and their only goal in that pond is to get one thin dime more than the next guy.  When you’re in that league, that’s the name of the game.

But one supposition seems to have gone largely unchallenged, even by our former lawprof President. 
The point was broached when he said that it was one thing when an investment banker made 20 times the income of a school teacher, but was 200 times really necessary?  But he never finished the thought.

The knee-jerk mantra of the financial sector is that they have to pay these astronomical amounts to their “best and brightest” (this was the specific phrased used by our Prez on 60 Minutes, the Lawrence Welk of news magazines) or risk losing them to some hedge fund.

Who?  Is there some hedge fund out there so flush with cash that it’s prepared to throw tens of millions in bonuses to every dissatisfied bonus baby on Wall Street?  Can they absurd the 10,000 investment bankers, highly skilled at drinking three cocktails while retaining the ability to deliver the perfect punchline to amuse the table.

I know a lot of these guys.  A few are quite bright.  Some are thick as a brick.  Some just have the right rep tie.  And many are currently unemployed.  Their hedge funds went belly up.  Their investment houses went under.  They are sitting at home waiting for the phone to ring with the offer of a $10 million retention bonus.  The phones are silent. 

The truth is that they weren’t really stars in the first place, but people fortunate enough to have gotten into investment banking at a time when most of us had never even heard of such a job.  They lunched, they drank, they stuck around long enough to make some friends, and they prospered.  They prospered in ways that the rest of us can only imagine.  But what they are not is in demand. 

Seth Godin, coincidentally, discusses the compensation issue as well.


After a million dollars or so in salary, the absolute amount that a person is paid has no real impact on their life. They can’t eat more meals in a day or wear more shoes. What matters to the manager is the relative amount. How much more would I make over there? Why does that company pay its CEO more than my company pays me?

Exactly.  Once one hits the upper echelons, it’s all score keeping.  It’s about where one stands in the pecking order of the wealthy.  It has nothing to do, as our President wrongly assumed, with how much salary is necessary to maintain a lifestyle, and even less with the need or retention.  It’s a compensation system out of control, and one in which all the decision-makers are vested.  After all, if you can’t give your stars $10 million bonuses, how can you justify the $20 million bonus that the board has just given you?

So let’s cut the malarkey and bust the myth.  No one needs to pay investment bankers, or CEOs, anywhere near what they have been getting for the past decade and more to keep them in the job, regardless of whether they did a great job or, as is true of most of them, they stunk up the place.  It’s not like they have anywhere else to go. 

Trust me, they will be happy to stay put for a tenth of what they were getting, because there isn’t a chance in the world that they could live with the alternative, actually working for a living for an ordinary income like the rest of us.

The Last Nail in the Coffin

It’s one thing for a lawyer’s work to be of less than stellar quality.  Not every lawyer is good at what he does.  Some lawyers, who have the ability, just don’t put in the effort on every case.  This isn’t acceptable, but it happens.  With amazing regularity.  But it’s another thing altogether for a lawyer to miss a critical filing deadline.  This is utterly inexcusable.

This story in the Houston Chronicle is sickening.


Three men on Texas’ death row — and six others already executed — lost their federal appeals because attorneys failed to meet life-or-death deadlines, essentially waiving the last constitutionally required review before a death sentence is carried out.

It seems as if this must be a joke, an impossibility.  It doesn’t seem possible that any lawyer, no matter how mediocre or lax, could possibly do something this shockingly stupid and irresponsible.  But it’s not a joke.  It’s just a disgrace.

Not only does it happen, but one lawyer, Jerome Godinich, has done it twice. 


In both cases, the lawyer waited until after business hours on the last day an appeal could be filed and then blamed a malfunctioning filing machine for his tardiness, according to a 5th Circuit Court of Appeals opinion issued last week. The court chastised the attorney for using the same excuse twice.

There is so much wrong with this “excuse” that it’s difficult to know where to begin.  First, the excuse of a “malfunctioning filing machine (what’s a filing machine?)” is utter nonsense.  While I don’t believe the copying machine was down, even if true it doesn’t matter. File electronically.  Second. what competent lawyer waits until the absolute last second to do his work when a person’s life is on the line?  Well, Jerome Godinich, obviously.  

And finally, why would court assign Jerome Godinich to represent a death row inmate after he’s already blown a deadline?  One that expects an execution and isn’t terribly interested in anything stopping the party.

So we’re clear, I believe that the one year limit on 2255 motions is total crap, the elevation of procedure over substance.  In my United States, potentially innocent people are not put to death because a filing deadline is missed.  Ever.  Filing deadlines are for grocery clerks; they are not more important than substance, and the judicial economy derived from a firm deadline never trumps due process.  So there.

But lawyers are well aware of this deadline, no matter how much we despise it.  It is inconceivable that any lawyer could miss it, but it is similarly inconceivable that any competent lawyer would wait until the last minute to get his work done anyway.  In death penalty cases, it is literally a life and death failure.  But even in non-death cases, there is no excuse whatsoever.  People’s lives depend on the lawyer doing his job, doing it effectively, doing it timely.  It’s not like filing deadlines come as a surprise.

And what of the defendants, who think that there’s a guy out there representing him and giving him his last chance?


Quintin Phillippe Jones, another Texas death row inmate who also recently lost his federal appeal because of an attorney’s tardiness, said he did everything he could to alert the federal courts to report problems months before his Fort Worth attorney blew his federal deadline. Jones wrote letters to the judge, filed two motions with the help of other prisoners in an attempt to get another attorney, and even sent two separate complaints to the state bar. Nothing worked.

“I heard he didn’t file (on time) through another lawyer,” Jones said. “I’m the one who pays for his mistake. It cost a lot, and I’m paying for it.”

So the lawyer screws up and goes home for dinner.  The defendant is executed.  This is just disgusting.

Reason To Blog Number 14: Meet Guys

We’ve long since identified the two primary, and occasionally contradictory, reasons to blog:  Self-promotion and desire for self-expression.  This is old news.  But a new reason has just emerged, one that would have been laughable.  Until now.

Law Professor Ann Althouse has announced that, after years of living a life of desperate solitude, she is engaged to be married to a man who she first met as a commenter on her blog. 


After 4+ years of writing at each other, we met in real life and found real love.

Those must have been some comments, as Althouse is a very popular blogger and not easily swayed by some snarky comment.  Congratulations, Ann.   Anticipate that for the next few months at least, she will be giving classes on the relative merits of various catering halls and bridal shops in the greater Madison area.

But as long as we’re talking about Althouse, let’s take a quick look at something else she had to say about blogging that’s quite relevant.  This comes in response to a post by conservative Gay Patriot asking why liberals hate Althouse.  “[L]eftists in the blogosphere today are so humorless so self-righteous that they can’t abide the least bit of mockery, criticism or a combination of both?” 


What they don’t get is that I a m a pure blogger, really a blogger, showing you what blogging is. I don’t think they really are bloggers. I don’t think they really are journalists either. I’m called deranged or whatever when I’m riffing in a bloggerly style that they obviously don’t understand or appreciate. They are journalists posing as bloggers, mucking up their journalism and simultaneously writing dull blogs.

In contrast, via  @kevinokeefe, the New York Times standards editor gave his view on how to blog:




  • What should be avoided in all of them is any hint of racist, sexist or religious bias, or any suggestion of nasty, snide, sarcastic, or condescending tone — “snark.”
  • If something could easily fit in a satirical Web site for young adults, it probably shouldn’t go into the news pages of nytimes.com.
  • Contractions, colloquialisms and even slang are, generally speaking, more allowable in blogs than in print.
  • Obscenity and vulgarity are not.
  • Unverified assertions of fact, blind pejorative quotes, and other lapses in journalistic standards don’t ever belong in blogs. 
  • Writers and editors of blogs must also distinguish between personal tone and voice and unqualified personal opinion. 
  • A blog or news column has to give readers the arguments and factual information that led to the writer’s conclusion — enough argument and fact on both or all sides of the issue to enable the reader to decide whether to agree or disagree
  • That does not apply to editorials or Op-Ed columns, which “are not intended to give a balanced look at both sides of a debate,” as the Readers’ Guide says.
  • Headlines on analysis should try to capture the debate rather than taking sides in it.
  • If the comments contain vulgarity, obscenity, offensive personal attacks, say that somebody “sucks,” or are incoherent, moderators are advised just to chuck them out. 
  • And this is why Ann Althouse found a man through blogging, and the New York Times is fighting off bankruptcy.  Got it?

  • The Old Briefcase

    When I started out as a young lawyer, the first thing I needed to buy was a briefcase.  This was long before anyone but hikers used backpacks, and the idea of carrying one’s briefcase on a shoulder strap was akin to wearing a dress to court.  Real men carried their briefcases.

    Generic leather briefcases abounded.  They were cheap looking and common, the sort of thing a commissioned salesman might carry on his way to the bar after work to make it look like he was above a Samsonite hardshell case.  The old style lawyer’s bag was stodgy and boring, And ugly.  It was functional, but looked wrong for anyone born after the Great War.

    My bag had to be tough.  Not just big enough to hold what I needed to carry to court every day, but rugged enough to stand up to being tossed on the bench, carried in the rain, scraped on the sidewalk and withstand vermin on the subway.  There was no doubt in my mind that it would have to be made of harness leather, the type that got better with age and abuse.  I couldn’t bear any fussy leather, where a scratch would make it look “damaged”.

    One day I saw it.  It was that belting leather that was meant to be scraped and scratched.  The style was the old messenger bag, the type that couriers used when bringing news from the generals to the men who might not survive.  It was . . . perfect.

    briefcase

    I’ve now carried this bag for more than 25 years.  It’s seen courthouses across the country, and more than a few foreign cities.  It’s been through rain, snow and brilliant sunshine.  I’ve stuffed it beyond capacity, making things fit when they clearly shouldn’t.  It was stretched in odd ways, but always held whatever I asked of it.

    It’s old now.  The leather is cracked, dry and worn.  The corners have worn out, revealing the old broken marker that I used at trial in the early 90s, the remains of a roll of peppermint lifesavers.  In the pocket are business cards going to back to my office in the Woolworth Building, and my old firm, Meyer & Greenfield, before Howie passed. There are a couple of decks of cards in there, in case I come across an errant inchoate poker game on a train.  There’s even a handmade deck on post-its, created in a moment of hilarious desperation.

    In the last few years, people have asked me when I was going to get a new briefcase.  As if this was an idea that should have occurred to me.  A client actually bought me a Louis Vuitton case, which he thought would be more becoming my station.  I hated it.  It was so metrosexual.  So not me.  But after the question was raised a few times, I looked into getting a new bag.

    My briefcase was made by a company called HH Brown, which has since been bought by Berkshire Hathaway and no longer manufactures bags. They now manufacture profits.

    If I could find a new bag with the soul of my old one, I would consider changing.  It’s not that I’m stuck in my ways.  It’s just that I haven’t found anything that I would consider to replace an old friend that has served me so well for so long.  And to tell the truth, even though other people see an old, beaten-up briefcase, it still looks damn handsome to me, scars and all.

    The Benefit of Appearances

    Jim Keech (a/k/a GreyBear) sent me two links the other day, which provide an opportunity play a game, Guess the Verdict.

    These are the facts of our first case:  Defendant shoots drunken man who turns toward him and points his hands, “as if he had a gun.”

    These are the facts of our second case:  Defendant shoots man with a history of violence toward defendant, making threats and moving toward a knife.

    Answer:  Defendant acquitted in the first case.  Defendant convicted in the second case.

    Why?  I left out a special detail.  The defendant in the first case was a cop.  In the second case, the defendant was an abused wife.  What difference does this make?  Apparently, it makes a world of difference.

    The jury acquitted police officer Jay Olsen because they accepted the defense that he had a reasonable fear that his life was endangered.  But when it came to Shellye Stark, whose husband forced her into a life of prostitution to pay off his gambling debts, the jury refused to give her the benefit of the doubt.  The verdicts came in mere days apart.

    It will likely surprise no one that our beloved peers will find it more palatable to believe that a cop deserves the benefit of the doubt.  Even though cops rarely get to sit on juries, thus making the veniremen more likely to associate themselves with the non-law enforcement person than the cop, they are surrounded by a myth that makes the rest of us credit their judgment far above mere mortals.  We doubt ourselves, and thus doubt others like us, in the ability to make the decision to take the life of another.  We believe that police officers, on the other hand, possess the judgment to make the right determination.

    We are told that police officers undergo rigorous training in the police academy.  We learn that they are toughened by experience on the street that the rest of us would never understand or appreciate.  We watch movies and television shows, we read books and magazine articles, that bolster the belief that they gain a sixth sense, a depth of understanding, that makes them capable of understanding things the rest of us will never grasp.  And we accept the premise that they are, at their core, there to protect us from those who would do us harm.

    We need to believe in police.  We need someone to serve the function of facing down the criminal, who would risk his own life for the benefit of others.  Police are killed in the line of duty, and they put themselves at risk when the rest of us would run and hide until the shooting is over.  This is certainly something worthy of recognition.

    To gain this benefit of having people on the street whose function is to protect us, we need to suspend reality just a bit.  We give them guns and authorize them to shoot, with the caveat that they do so only when necessary.  We must believe that giving them guns isn’t insanity on our part, and we therefore harbor the blind belief that they will comply with the caveat because they possess some sort of discretion or judgment beyond our own.

    There is much to admire in how most police officers perform their function.  Most go to work every day (well, at least for three days then two off, but that’s another discussion) with the purpose of serving and protecting, and the willingness to put themselves at risk for our benefit.  This is not merely admirable, but critical, and something for which we owe them a debt of gratitude.  That said, they are people.  Regular people, without any magical powers that enable them to leap tall building in a single bound. 

    Most police officers I know have a different perspective on the use of force, both because they are more comfortable with it in general, have far less fear of being subject to punishment should they do so, and most importantly, adhere to the prime directive: Make it home alive at the end of the shift. 

    What this means is that regular people are far more reluctant to shoot than a police officer, and require far more impetus to overcome that reluctance.  That doesn’t mean their perception of the impetus is as cool and reasoned as a cop, as perceived threats of violence tend to cloud the mind during the crucial period when decisions are made to pull the trigger. 

    In today’s game, the law applied to both cases was the same.  Was the perceived threat objectively and subjectively reasonable, such that the use of force in response was justified?  For all the discussion that might be had, we end up going back to the same old answer.  We give cops the benefit of the doubt that we won’t give ourselves.