Author Archives: SHG

Defenders of Truthiness

This comment by John Neff got me thinking.  Lawyers have this nasty habit of believing in the validity of our own methods.  We proclaim it, usually in some catchy phrase, repeat it incessantly, and then it becomes our truth.  Actually, truthiness.  It is because we believe it is.  One such belief is that we can determine who is lying and who is not.

This reminded me of Eugene Volokh’s post about the first court test of the fMRI, coming in a San Diego juvenile sex-abuse case.  Not surprisingly, it will be offered by the defense to prove that the defendant is innocent.  According to Wired :



The company that did the brain scan, No Lie MRI, claims their test is over 90 percent accurate, but some scientists and lawyers are skeptical…. The company’s report says fMRI tests show the defendant’s claim of innocence is not a lie.


Laboratory studies using fMRI, which measures blood-oxygen levels in the brain, have suggested that when someone lies, the brain sends more blood to the ventrolateral area of the prefrontal cortex. In a very small number of studies, researchers have identified lying in study subjects with accuracy ranging from 76 percent to over 90 percent (pdf). But some scientists and lawyers like [Stanford law professor Hank] Greely doubt that those results will prove replicable outside the lab setting, and others say it just isn’t ready yet….


[On the other hand,] even if the science behind a technology isn’t fully established, Brooklyn Law School’s Edward Cheng, who studies scientific evidence in legal proceedings, said it might still be appropriate to use it in the courtroom.


“Technology doesn’t necessarily have to be bulletproof before it can come in, in court,” Cheng.


It’s that last line by Cheng that should scare you.  Lawyers have an entirely different level of tolerance for ambiguity than scientists, largely because we have such an awful understanding of science and, more importantly, probability.  And don’t forget, judges, those gatekeepers of science in the courtroom, use to be lawyers before they went on the public dole.

Do we applaud the “No Lie MRI” scan?  Is this the miracle of modern science that will cleanse the courtroom of lies and deception?  After all, anything that proves a person’s innocence can’t be all bad, right?  And certainly no one can fault the defense for trying to find something, anything, to prove the defendant innocent when sincere but mistaken testimony would likely convict him otherwise.  But then, once the fMRI camel’s nose is inside the tent, it won’t be long until the test is used as a sword rather than shield, and defendants will be convicted based on their lies as well.

So what of the validity of the fMRI?  The hearing will consist of the proponents of the test showing that it is 90% valid.  Ninety percent is pretty good when it comes to lies or truth.  It’s certainly a high enough percentage, on its face, to raise a reasonable doubt.  Is it enough to eliminate a reasonable doubt?  Well, since no court has ever established a percentage belief required of a jury, that remains a mystery.  But if the scan is accepted into evidence, perhaps courts will be forced to decide whether a 90% valid test is sufficient to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Still, there’s a problem. One that wouldn’t occur to most lawyers or judges.  On its face, we look at a 90% accuracy rate and assume that to mean that it will be correct 9 times out of 10, and conversely have a failure rate of 1 in 10.  Hah!  More lawyerly truthiness.  We are so arrogant.

Unless you have some serious interest in probability, it would never even occur to a lawyer to consider that this number is simplistic and misleading, since, as noted here, tests have 2 basic accuracies and 2 predictive values.  Didn’t know that, did you.  But what about the Base Rate Fallacy, raised here?  Consider this example:


In a city with 100 terrorists and one million non-terrorists there is a surveillance camera with an automatic face recognition software. If the camera sees a known terrorist, it will ring a bell with 99% probability. If the camera sees a non-terrorist, it will trigger the alarm 1% of the time. So, the failure rate of the camera is always 1%.

Suppose somebody triggers the alarm. What is the chance he/she is really a terrorist?

Imagine that all 1,000,100 people pass in front of the camera. About 99 of the 100 terrorists will trigger a ring — and so will about 10,000 of the million of nonterrorists. Therefore 10099 people will be rung at, and only 99 of them are terrorists. So, the probability that a person who triggers the alarm is actually a terrorist is 99 in 10,099 (about 1/100).

Things aren’t as simple as they first appear, which gives rise to this generous conclusion :


When it comes to the accuracy of diagnostic testing, the cluelessness of lawyers and courts is staggering.

But given our tendency to truthiness, a test like the fMRI, should it be accepted by the judge, could well displace the fact-finding function and obviate the need for those icky, messy jury thingies.  After all, who needs twelve people to rubber-stamp what a machine has already concluded?  And if a judge decides that the fMRI is sufficiently accurate to be admitted into evidence, it then is sufficiently accurate, regardless of whether it can discern a lie from truth 9 times out of 10.

Cheng’s observation, that technology doesn’t have to be perfect to be admissible, is an accurate reflection of the law, which is why it should scare the daylights out of us.  This machine will, on its own, free or imprison people.  We know that juries love to shift the responsibility of deciding people’s fate elsewhere, and will defer to any “expert” at the drop of a hat.  We also know that jurors, like lawyers, judges and college students, are bored to tears with in-depth discussions of statistical analysis and probability, precluding the likelihood of counter-experts carrying any weight to challenge the conclusion of the fMRI.  And finally, we know that there is no viable definition of “beyond a reasonable doubt” (assuming the jury can follow the instructions at all), and that most convictions derive from the jury’s determination that a defendant is more likely guilty than not.

So in our quest for truth, we trade one version of truthiness for another, this one far more difficult to get around by argument than any we’ve faced before.  But hey, we’re lawyers!  There’s nothing we love more than legal fictions.  And since Daubert allows it, and if a judge will admit it, we’ll finally have that magic machine we’ve always dreamed of.  So what if it’s imperfect.  Isn’t everything in the law?

I Watch TV, So I Know

A call came in from a very lovely, but very distraught, woman.  Her husband had been arrested in a federal conspiracy case and she was beside herself because she believed that the lawyer she initially retained within hours of the arrest, at the suggestion of her next door neighbor, was totally incompetent.  After the arraignment, she had time to seek the assistance of more knowledgeable people, and ended up with my telephone number.  She informed me that she desperately needed me and had to get rid of the first lawyer.

Calls like this happen all the time.

After speaking to her calmly, and getting her to take a few deep breathes, I asked her why she thought the lawyer was incompetent.  She then explained that her favorite shows on television were lawyer and cop shows, and she knew things.  She was very sweet, deeply concerned and totally misguided. 

We then went through her impressions of the representation her husband was receiving by the attorney she retained.  While it may not have been exactly what I would have done, it was eminently competent and fully appropriate.  Much of her dismay stemmed from the expectation that within the first five minutes of the case, he should have a fully developed theory of defense and an answer as to whether her husband should win.  The lawyer, to his credit and her disappointment, responded to most of her questions, “I don’t know yet.”

This very lovely woman found this lawyer’s answers wholly unacceptable, enough so that she felt the need to reach out for new counsel.  I suspect that part of the problem was a lack of personal connection, as I doubt that she expressed her dissatisfaction to the lawyer.  Had she, he would have had the opportunity to clarify why his “I don’t know yet” response was honest and accurate.  Perhaps he was preoccupied or callous, which might have exacerbated her discomfort with his answer.  I can’t say and she wouldn’t be able to explain why she was uncomfortable with him.

My first order of business was to explain to my caller that her lawyer’s efforts were appropriate and competent, and that he was doing what should be done at that point in time and under the given circumstances.  I explained to her why he was doing what he was doing, and why it was premature to provide her with answers to her very important questions.  She accepted my explanations, and told me that she felt much more comfortable (with me) because I had explained everything to her so clearly.

But then, there was still a hesitancy in her voice.  I asked her what was wrong. 

Welllllll. . . but he’s the lawyer.  He should know.  I watch TV, so I know.

Know what?  That every case is resolved in an hour?  That every lawyer knows everything there is about a case by the first commercial?  What do you know?

I know that the innocent people like my husband don’t go to prison.  I know that the lawyer always figures it out.  I know.

This was a variation on a theme that permeates the mindset of everyone who becomes involved with the legal system in any capacity.  Between the reality-type shows, where the cops or the FBI or whatever agency is in front of the camera today, only serves truth, justice and the American way, and the dramas, where the heroes, even then tragic, remain heroes.  For criminal defense lawyers, we can’t begin to imagine how this messes with the heads of our own clients, their families, their friends, when we try to represent them.

I explained to my very lovely caller that television shows aren’t real.   Even the reality shows are edited, and they don’t like to show all the arrests gone wrong and mistakes made, because it doesn’t make for good television.  I told her this a couple of different ways, yet I’m quite certain she didn’t believe me.  Ultimately, she held tight to the belief that the lawyer should know what’s going to happen.


“If it was you, you would have known.”

I told her, “No, I would not have known.  Television has given you unrealistic expectations, and you want your lawyer to meet those television expectations.  I could have told you what you wanted to hear, but it would have been a lie.  I would not lie to you, even to make you happy.  Your lawyer wouldn’t lie to you either.  This makes him an honest lawyer, not a bad lawyer.”

What pains me most about this conversation is that I spend so much time and effort admonishing lawyers to be honest with their clients, for better or worse.  And yet, the image of Jack Nicholson screaming, “you can’t handle the truth” keeps flashing before my eyes.  Clients can’t stand the ambiguity that honesty brings, but misinterpret it to be incompetence because their education in the law comes from the screen of a television.

I repeat this conversation here as a reminder to criminal defense lawyers what our clients, and their families, have in their heads as we speak to them.  It’s hard to help people, given the influence of popular media molds their expectations of us and what we do.  Yes, it’s never been easy, and there have always been strange thoughts running through clients’ minds that we’ve had to recognize and address in order to render effective representation.  But it never hurts to repeat the message and remind ourselves that it’s still there and maybe more pervasive than ever.

What Do We Expect From a Jury Anyway?

Dan Solove at Concurring Opinions is not inclined to rants and depressing assessments of the law.  But it looks as if the story of State Senator/Law Professor Robert Martin of Seton Hall has put him over the top. Some doofus put Martin on a New Jersey jury, and he learned how the rest of the jury was essentially clueless and turned to him for the answer.  Martin wrote about his experience, exposing how our beloved legal fictions are nothing more than a sham.

The initial reaction of must, including Turley, was that this shows why lawyers have no business being on juries.  The idea that a lawyer on a jury would be merely one of twelve voices is dangerously naive, and it certainly lends itself to the mischief of a jury deferring to the judgment and expertise of a single lawyer, anathema to the basic concept.

But Dan doesn’t stop there.  He’s had enough of the fiction of juries altogether, and goes for the jugular:



But there’s another lesson to be learned from this case. We should have professional juries. I’m increasingly of the opinion that our jury system is a joke.


The process which Martin describes (and which indeed is quite common) is ridiculous is so many ways. First, it is ridiculous that juries are basically taught the law after hearing the facts of the case. If one is applying a rule, shouldn’t one know about the rule first in order to determine which facts are relevant and which are not?


Second, it takes law students three years to learn the law — or at least a semester to learn a specific subject like torts — and yet juries are expected to understand the law after just one brief lecture from the judge. Who are we kidding when we think that the jury is really applying the law? Juries probably have little to no idea about what the law is.



Third, many judges disallow note-taking. But in lengthy trials — or even in trials lasting a day or two — how are jurors supposed to remember the details? And in the case Martin describes, the jurors weren’t allowed to take notes about the law when the judge instructed it. I’d like to try an experiment — give a bunch of judges an hour lecture about a specific set of legal rules, not let them take notes, and then see how much they remember. This is difficult even for those with legal training — imagine how hard it must be for those without such training!


While Dan’s criticism of the viability of juries is clearly on target, his proposed alternative, professional juries, raises an entirely different list of issues.  I think Dan may have jumped the gun by offering an alternative in advance of his explanation of the problems, so I would prefer to separate the two and put the professional jury proposal on hold for a moment.

No honest trial lawyer will argue that they believe that juries reach verdicts for the right reason.  When we speak to them after a trial, regardless of whether we’ve won or lost, we invariably find that they totally misapprehended some crucial point in the case.  Sometimes this works to our benefit, but other times we want to punch a hole in the wall because it’s so frustrating to have a critical point, well developed, brilliantly argued and completely missed.

The entire concept of jury instructions is nuts.  Jurors truly want to do their job, well and honestly.  But the idea that they can sit for an hour and listen to the drone of unfamiliar words strung together and get the basic meaning, no less the nuance, is ludicrous.  Taking notes won’t help, and often hurts.  They are too busy writing to pay attention, and have no clue what is important to write down and what is inconsequential.

Even if the issue of the jury applying the law was removed from the equation, we have a more basic problem.  Jurors cannot discern truth from fiction, accuracy from mistake, a well-prepared lie from honesty, any more than anyone else.  Sure, we all think we can tell because we need to make decisions and move on in our lives, but the truth is that it’s purely a guess.  So even the most basic factual determinations, with the wealth of complex rules and high powered arguments, devolve to a sheer guess. 

What the jury system does provide, however, is civic trust.  We allow a bunch of people in robes to tell us that we have to go to prison, or have to pay out all the money we have, because we believe that society depends on having a system to resolve disputes.  We believe the system to resolve disputes has some element of integrity because the determination comes from a “jury of our peers,” an oft-repeated and curiously misapprehended phrase.  As long as we can say that we had our day in court and the “jury has spoken,” we collectively shrug and accept the verdict, no matter how much we may otherwise disagree.

No amount of perceived expertise will ever trump the faith we place in the jury.  It’s not necessarily that the jury deserves this faith, but that it’s an article of faith that, for better or worse, there can be no better method than to let 12 people pronounce our fate.  It’s almost religious in nature, a belief that defies all empirical evidence yet allows the only branch of government without guns to maintain a role of decision-making by sheer fiat.  It’s quite an amazing trick.

Having established that a jury of our peers is a wholly unreliable mechanism to both find facts and comprehend the law to be applied, we can now turn to the question of whether there is a better alternative.  I start with Dan’s proposal of a professional jury. 

Initially, neither a professional jury nor a judge for that matter is any better at fact finding than a peer jury.  Truth and lies remain blind guesses, as no one has the magic answer to distinguish one from another. 

A professional jury could be trained in the law so that the fiction that a jury can be given the law by the judge (after the fact, when it fails to provide a framework for them to differentiate between important facts and inconsequential facts) will no longer matter.  But then, professional juries, like lawyers, might know the law but similarly have their own sense of what parts of the law should be emphasized or ignored. 

Consider, if you will, the same law as viewed through the eyes of a prosecutor and defense lawyer.  The likelihood is strong that the two will have entirely different analyses of a given set of facts based upon their relative view of substantive legal propositions.  The law is not a monolith, and is often quite vague and subject to interpretation.  To believe that a professional jury will have a single view of the law is to fail to realize that the law isn’t quite that simple.

So, professional juries might well have the expertise in the law that a peer jury lacks, but it would also be like playing craps with loaded dice, based upon who got to pick the members of the professional jury.  Put a bunch of prosecutorial minded pros on the jury and you get a foregone conclusion in place of a verdict.  It eliminates the legal instruction problem, but it also undermines the possibility of a fair verdict. 

Moreover, professional juries would, by definition, hear cases again and again.  The impact of a brain damaged baby on a peer juror would be significant.  But would it matter much to a professional juror who has heard it a dozen times?  The professional juror will grow inured to the pain, suffering and harm presented.  It’s one of the few things that a peer jury does well, being virgins to the misfortune of others.  Jurors who are unimpressed with yet another injustice are just too cold to appreciate their role of providing redress. 

And finally we come to civic trust, something a professional jury can never provide.  One of the commenters to Dan’s post phrases this as civic trust and engagement.  I can’t get worked up about engagement, given how few people I’ve ever met who desire to sit on a jury.  While I suppose that there’s a place for citizens to play a role in the legal system, I suspect that this is more a theoretical concern than a practical one.  The question I’ve been asked most over my 25 years of practice is how to get out of jury duty.  I suspect that people would be quite happy with the legal system as long as it was someone, but not them, sitting on the jury.

Clearly, having the government “own” the professional jury would eliminate any element of civic trust.  Indeed, the government has already made its decision: It owns the cops.  It owns the prosecutors.  It owns the judges.  The case has received their approval already by virtue of getting to trial.  Adding a fourth layer of governmental approval really does nothing to instill faith in the integrity of the system.  Even if the professional jury was truly independent, a notion that no one would believe based upon our overwhelming lack of faith in the government as an institution that “serves” anyone except itself, we wouldn’t believe it.  Not really.  Not even members of the government would buy into that fiction. 

While I agree wholeheartedly with Dan Solove that the existing jury system is fundamentally flawed, and that it is systemically incapable of rendering a competent verdict, I don’t see professional juries as being a better solution.  I do believe, however, that we could significantly improve the competency of the jury system by chucking the legal fictions upon which it now depends and trying to come up with a process that provides peer jurors informs them of the things they need to know ahead of time, so that they can follow the testimony and evidence and distinguish the consequential from the inconsequential in real time.

I believe that jury instructions need to be radically changed to meet the comprehension levels of normal people who don’t have three years to spend learning the law before rendering a verdict, though given the difficulties in communicating concepts to a broad array of people, this could be an impossibility.  The sad truth is that most people are incapable of thinking conceptually anyway, so there is no mix of words that will ser
ve to communicate clearly, let alone communicate accurately.

But then, even if we could figure out a way to help peer jurors, once selected, to do their job properly, we’re still stuck with the problem of selecting fair and impartial jurors, which for all the discussion had here and elsewhere, remains a matter of pure and unadulterated voodoo.

If all this leaves one with the impression that trials are a bad game with ever-shifting rules, that just so happen to involve some of the most important issues and problems that any individual human being can endure, then you’ve gotten the message.  And if there was one insular group that should never been sitting in judgment of another human being, it would be those who believe that all the cute platitudes upon which our legal system relies are actually true.  It’s people like that who are the most dangerous to fairness, integrity and any potential for justice.  It’s a terrible system, and whether it’s better than all the others depends on whether today is the day that your ox is gored.

A Special Bonus of Our Own

While the townspeople raise their pitchforks over their heads and march toward their neighborhood AIG telephone support rep’s home, Long Island has it’s own little bonus bonanza quietly brewing in the Suffolk County fire district of Gordon Heights.  According to Newsday :


The Gordon Heights fire district – which some residents are trying to dissolve because it’s the most expensive in the state – approved using district funds Tuesday to buy a $1,019 bracelet for a commissioner and to spend $20,600 on an installation dinner, according to notes of the meeting taken by a resident.

Obviously, it would be undignified to have a spaghetti dinner when it comes to installation.  This is an important event, which could explain why, in a district with 50 volunteers, 190 people plan to show.


The Gordon Heights dinner is set for Saturday at Villa Lombardi’s restaurant in Holbrook. About 190 people are slated to attend, according to a woman answering the phone at the catering hall, who declined to discuss the menu. The department has approximately 50 volunteers.

I personally hope they get a choice of entrées.  Otherwise, it would be a rip-off.  Since this is taxpayer money paying for this dinner, it would be terrible if it was a rip-off, right?  I’m thinking, surf and turf at minimum.  And drinks should obviously be included.  Some of these guys like a drink with dinner, and why shouldn’t they?

And then there’s the bracelet.  I mean, how petty can you get.  Here’s a commissioner who’s worked very hard passing budgets and arranging installation dinners (the menus don’t pick themselves, you know), and she gets a bracelet for a grand as a little thank you.  You cheap ingrates, who would deny such a hard worker a little wrist candy.


James Kelly, chairman of the district’s board of commissioners, said yesterday that he saw no problem with the legality of buying the bracelet.

After all, that fire district lawyer, the one who swears that if he says it’s okay, it must be okay, knows better than to let that little thing in the New York State Constitution prohibiting the use of public monies to pay for private gifts get in the way.  Everybody does it, and it’s not like anybody’s going to stop you.  Laws, schmaws.  AG Cuomo’s too busy thinking AIG and the next election cycle to worry about how government’s openly buy gifts for each other.  And besides, it’s not nearly as bad as school district lawyer pensions, right?

It’s not quite that Long Island is a cesspool of waste, greed and illegality, though it might appear that way to the disinterested observer.  It’s just that we know how to show our appreciation to the people who really matter.  And somebody has to pay for it.

Law & Order Wins, And A Boy is Nearly Stomped to Death

A recurring theme in criminal law is whether law enforcement officials are subject to the same scrutiny as the rest of us.  If there was any doubt in your mind before, this may be just what it takes to push you over the edge.  Via Radley Balko comes one of the most horrendous stories ever, and one that everyone should know.

From the Denver Post :


Charles Porter is a 13-year veteran of the Denver Police Department who one night last spring, on a gang- unit detail, believed he’d seen Juan Vasquez, a 16-year-old boy, swigging an alcoholic beverage in northwest Denver. When he flipped on his flashing lights, the boy ran.

The chase was a short one. In the end, the boy lay prone and handcuffed on the ground with several of his ribs smashed, his kidneys half- pulverized and his liver lacerated.

The cops, a month later, came for one of their own and arrested Porter on a felony charge of second-degree assault. He went to trial a little more than a week ago. A jury acquitted him Thursday.

Of course it did.

There was a videotape.  The City paid the family $1 million.  But most shockingly, this was so outrageous that the unthinkable happened: Two fellow officers testified against Charles Porter.


“Officer Porter grabs hold of the fence with both hands,” Officer Luis Rivera, who was partnered with Porter that night, testified. “He jumps up, raises his knees and lands with both feet on the kid’s back.”


He then demonstrated the jumping to the jury, the loud thud of each jump reverberating through the courtroom.

Back in their squad car, Rivera said he questioned Porter as to why he jumped on the kid. “Officer Porter said, ‘I don’t know why I do that. It’s just something I do lately. I guess I just like the way they sound.’ ”


And the jury acquitted.

It appears from the story that the jury never considered whether it was wrong for Porter to stomp 16 year old Juan Vasquez.  The foreman, however, did have some hard questions about Vazquez’s testimony.


“When you look at how (the boy) testified versus other statements he made, there were far more inconsistencies in his testimony,” the foreman continued. “He had mentioned that it was more than one officer that committed the abuse. He was the only one who said that in any of the testimony.”

Not that there was any question that the kid got stomped, or that Porter did the stomping.  But then, what’s that got to do with anything when the man on trial is a cop.

I guess that we’re just going to have to suffer a few Juan Vazquez’s getting stomped if we want to enjoy law and order.  it’s the price we pay to show our devotion to cops.

Four Rules For Slackoisie Nirvana

At Trust Matters,  Charles Green  Mark Slatin has spelled out in detail what’s wrong with kids today, employing the kick ’em while they’re down theory of human resources, one of my personal favorites.


According to a recent NY Times article, the new kids on the block have a sense of entitlement…I have noticed the same phenomenon in the course I teach at Loyola University. A disgruntled student who received a grade commensurate with the final product shifted the blame to me, saying, “Well, I guess it is in the syllabus, so you technically can give me a lower grade.”

Michele Norris, a Tampa-based consultant, asserts, “If students have a sense of entitlement, it’s not entirely their fault. They are the product of “hovering” parents and an education system that is ‘results oriented’ to prove worthiness. Parents and coaches have rewarded them with trophies just for being on the team”.

“The world says, ‘You’re young, have fun!’ It tells us to ‘obey your thirst’ and ‘just do it.’ Or it tells us, ‘You’re great! You don’t need to exert yourself.’ But those kinds of mindsets sabotage character and competence,” says Harris.

[N]ew employees who want to roll into work with their iPods and flip flops around noon, but still become a CEO by… Friday,

[T]hese narcissistic praise hounds…

Oh man, that Charles is tough.  No rose-colored glasses can change his steely-eyed vision of a harsh and ugly future of narcissistic praise hounds, filled with entitlement and incapable of thinking beyond advertising slogans.  So what does he suggest?

In the finest Neville Chamberlain voice, he details the terms of unconditional surrender.  Not for the Slackoisie, but for the rest of us:



Coach vs. Boss
“It’s the boomers that need to hear the message, that they’re gonna have to start focusing more on coaching rather than bossing. In this generation in particular, you just tell them, ‘You got to do this. You got to do this.’ They truly will walk. And every major law firm, every major company knows, this is the future,” says Mary Crane, a millennial coach.


Other-Orientation
In order to be perceived as trustworthy, we must have a high “other” orientation. In the case of millenials, we need to speak their language. Be willing to lose the battles like wardrobe and time clocks, so long as they understand results matter.


Back Patting
They need more accolades. What does it cost to give it to them? Go ahead.


Give Trust to Get Trust
Lastly, to get trust, we must first give trust. Before we can expect them to understand and appreciate where we’re coming from, we must first take the time to make them feel understood.


Charles Green has chosen his path, and it is the path of least resistance.  Capitulation is so much easier than confronting the enemy and prevailing.  Let them pick and choose what matters, how they want to do it, and demand that you spend your every waking second devoted to overseeing their effort to do the absolute least amount necessary to pass, all the while patting them on the back, rubbing their tender bellies and whispering how wonderful they are and how much we truly appreciate them.  I know, let’s throw them a party!  After all, they showed up today, even if it was a little after twelve noon. 

There really is no good reason to demand that slavish concern for irrelevant details, like filing deadlines and crazy client calls asking why their work isn’t done yet.  Who cares if the client’s retch upon seeing the young people upon whom their existence depends looking like a cheap imitation of Amy Winehouse.  As long as we can prove to our demanding little entitlers that we trust them.  After all, they must feel “understood” or they won’t love us back.

Wake up.  They won’t love you back no matter how many ice cream parties you throw for them.  The world owes them, and that includes you.  By the time the last piece of ice cream cake (with those little crunchy things in the center) is scarfed up, they will be wondering when you’re going to install the PS3.  You can’t buy their loyalty, because they don’t comprehend loyalty.  The only question is what can you do for them next.

They want accolades?  Let them earn accolades.  They want trust?  That’s why they get a paycheck.  The fact that they can’t figure out why ripped jeans and flip flops makes clients “uncomfortable” isn’t a reason to excuse their mode of attire.  And if they were half as brilliant as their mommies told them, they wouldn’t need to demand constant attention and affirmation every time they went to the bathroom to make sure they wiped correctly.  Hooray, Jimmy.  You got it all!

Are we to blame for creating this monster?  Sure.  I’ll take the blame, though I will let you know that mine didn’t turn out this way.  But I can well see how the efforts to give them self-esteem, love, material pleasures and approval resulted in their warped view of life.  Now that we’ve established who caused the disease, let’s establish the cure.  Grow up.

Frankly, dear Slackoisie, we thought you would be sharp enough to realize that the Nike motto, “Just do it,” was just an advertising slogan.  The Barbie Minivan doesn’t really drive itself.  Didn’t you figure that out when we bought it for you?  When you were little boys and girls, we wanted you to have fun.  But now that you’ve finished your education and assumed ownership of the basement, we want you out.  You want another bag of Doritos?  Go buy it yourself, with your own money, from your own job.  Put the Wii controller down, and step away from the clicker.

Seriously.  You have a few lessons left to learn, even though you are absolutely certain you know it all.  Here’s one of my favs.  Have a child, and you’re going to find that they are even more demanding than you are.  They want to eat.  Every day.  Three times a day, at least.  And you have to feed them, even if you’re in the middle of the coolest Mortal Combat game ever.  Try arguing the point with a toddler.  Hah!

So when, Charles, do they get this message?  Even if our efforts in raising children properly were misguided all along, at what point do they take their place in society as adults, with the responsibilities that go along with the perks?  Do you really think that giving them all the benefits, appeasing their narcissistic appetite for accolades, is going to make them turn the corner of responsibility?  Or does this just suck the life out of it, with our Slackoisie demanding the next shiny object as soon as the glimmer has rubbed off the last?

For those who enjoy a fine three word platitude, try this one on for size:  Life is unfair.  Eventually, you will come to find that the world cannot survive if it has to revolve solely around you.  Imagine showing up at the Cheetos store, desperate for a fix, only to find that the Cheetos store employee only comes in when he feels like it, and today isn’t that day.  You are furious.  Outraged!  How dare the Cheetos store employee not be there when you need him to be there.  How can you possibly continue to play your PSP without a bag at the ready.  What about YOU!

See how a world of self-absorbed, demanding, entitled, narcissistic Slackoisie won’t work?  You will end up killing each other, and we will end up having to wipe up the goo afterward.  We’ve already wiped up your goo once, and are not inclined to do so again.

So it’s time to pick your role model.  Will you be Chamberlain?  Will you be Churchill?  We may have to endure the Battle of Britain before this problem is solved, but the future of the world depends on us.  Don’t fail our children again.

Elefant Keeps It Fresh

Carolyn Elefant has an important post at My Shingle which delves into the “freshness curve” that all lawyers go through, and where you should want your curve to end up.

After twenty years of practice, I can do an appeal from start to finish with my eyes closed.  I’m intimately familiar with the Three-Bears like requirements for timely filing (too early can render the petition incurably premature; too late and the petition misses the unforgiving statutory deadlines and gets unceremoniously bounced) to the arguments – standing, waiver, jurisdiction and harmless error – that appeals courts embrace.  I know which side of the aisle to sit and what to say when I open and how to prepare so that I never, ever need to look at my notes but can still cite to the Appendix, nonetheless.  In fact, I’ve grown so jaded that sometimes, I’ll write my opening sentence the morning of argument and most importantly, I no longer need to bite my lip to avoid giggling when the court clerk enters chanting “Oyez, Oyez.”

While many readers won’t have twenty years under their belt, my somewhat hazy recollection is that the phenomenon sets in at about five years, just about the time that you’ve gotten some real lawyering under your belt, you’ve done the same work a hundred times, and you are finally beyond feeling comfortable with your ability to perform a task and boredom starts to slip in.  You wake up at your desk and realize that you’ve just completed a motion in your sleep. 


But the excitement of the salad days and all of the firsts soon fades and inertia sets in.  Sometimes, it’s easier (not to mention more financially rewarding) to stick with the cases that you can process without thinking than seek out new challenges; to keep the same old system in place (because if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it) instead of striving for ways to improve; to avoid asking questions to avoid the embarrassment of not knowing it all.  And yet, if we don’t change, we run the risk of being left behind – like  the sixty six biglaw partners who now earn less than associates after their compensation was slashed or the old lawyer in the hallway. Being a fresh new lawyer may be tough in these trying times, but staying fresh is harder, hands down.

The first sense if one of satisfaction, that you’ve reached a plateau as a lawyer, fully able to do your job well, efficiently and, frankly, without a lot of effort.  You’re happy with yourself.  You’ve “mastered” the law.  You can crank out paper like nobody’s business, and it all perfectly acceptable work.  No muss, no fuss.  Enjoy it for the rest of the day.  You’ve earned it.

The next day, however, your momentary joy begins its inevitable slide.  If that’s it, and you’ve now grown all you need to grow to present perfectly competent work to the court and client, what do you plan to do for the next 20 years?  Looking at that path from the other side of the hill, let me tell you.  It’s boring.  It’s tedious.  And, in retrospect, the work is only competent, not masterful. 

Congratulations on reaching the first plateau.  But if you stop there, you will endure a career of misery and disappointment.  I know lawyers who have performed the same task, in yeoman fashion, day after day, year after year.  They are not happy people.  They are not proud of themselves for very long.  True, they have reached their first goal, but then they saw no more goals ahead of them, and they stopped growing.  They grew stagnant.  In time, they stopped caring, both about their work as well as their clients.  Life became mundane and routine.  They were just going through the motions of being a lawyer.

There are a number of plateaus you have yet to scale.  There is still the climb from yeoman to master, a place that very few reach and the place where lawyer who create law, who discovery solutions to the insoluble, reside.  This place takes many years and great effort to reach, and it’s questionable whether anyone truly reaches it.  But every morning the trek continues and brings with it new invigorating challenges.  Do what everyone says can’t be done.  Find a way.  Create a way.  Take the bad that everyone else shrugs off and change it.  At least try.

Another is the plateau of holistic lawyering.  Just as every motion begins to look alike, so does every client.  They are not, but the yeoman lawyer only sees a small part of the client, the part she’s been retained to represent.  But each brings a new bag of issues, problems, needs to the table, and you can make it your responsibility to help one human being.  Some will be frustrating, or tiresome, or difficult, but each is a person who, at the end of your representation, can be in better shape when you’re done than when you started.  True, we’re not therapists, but if we see clients whose legal issues stem from other problems in their life, we can help them deal with reality and steer them down paths that will help even non-legal problems.  We can make their lives better.

Whatever path you take, have a goal for yourself.  If you should reach that goal, come up with a new goal.  There is always another goal, a higher level, ahead of you.  While you may do it for your clients, do it also for yourself.  You don’t want to live a life of quiet misery, performing mundane tasks on autopilot and waiting for the end of each day to come.  It’s a miserable existence. 

And as long as you have a goal ahead of you, you will always have the excitement of firsts.  Remember how good that feels?

The Expert Cop’s Self-Cognition

Over at Rick Horowitz’s blog, subtly named Probable Cause, a very interesting discussion broke out in the comments when a sheriff’s deputy named Larry took issue with Rick’s assessment of police testimony:

After a few years of working criminal cases, I now believe that all police officers will lie on the stand if they feel it is important to help the case.  Most police officers will tell the truth, unless they think by telling the truth the case will be hurt, or unless they think by telling a lie it will help the prosecution.  Even the most trustworthy police officers I’ve seen on the stand seem unable to resist “spinning” their testimony.

This spilled over into the comments, where Rick provided further explanation :


In cases involving gang evidence, as just one example, officers’ jobs very much depend upon how they testify. In courts around the area I practice, I’ve seen — and there are numerous stories from other attorneys both within and outside my geographical area — officers transferred after a particularly bad “showing” at trial. And if officers were not paid to obtain convictions, then how do you explain the gang cops who refuse to testify for the defense when asked because they’re afraid they’ll lose their jobs?

Larry didn’t care at all for this view.  More importantly, Larry, who described himself as a “Gang Expert” (his caps), decided to educate Rick.


The fact of the matter is, if the crime was not a gang crime and did not require my testimony or my expert opinion I would not take the case in the first place. Almost all gang officers are promoted or transfered into those positions because of their personal knowledge of particular gangs and their expertise with those gang members. Not because of good testimony. I will concede being able to testify is extremely important especially in gang cases because you are deemed an “expert” by the court and therefor can offer an opinion. This means you must be able to testify competently.

As for refusing to testify for the defense you made comment about “defense experts.” I am a Gang Expert. Meaning “I am a Gang Expert” not a “defense expert” nor a “prosecution expert.” I am a Gang Expert. If you perceived officer’s as truthful (which you should assume after all you assume your client is innocent) then you should have no problem with my testimony. As I stated earlier, if this was not a gang case I would not have taken it and this would be relayed to the district attorney’s office that the case is not gang related. Unfortunately, my testimony probably will not help you or your client therefor you perceive law enforcement as untruthful, dishonest and bias and in turn, you hire a “defense expert” to say what you want a jury to hear and to offer a different opinion for the benefit of your client. However, you and I both know that if I was going to offer an opinion that would benefit your client you would have no problem allowing me to offer such an opinion. However, to offer such an opinion would indicate that your client is not a gang member or did not commit the crime to benefit the gang and therefor I would be uninvolved in the case anyway.

The finest of circular reasoning notwithstanding, Rick then proceeds to explain why Larry’s police training and experience does not give rise to expertise in anything other than police training and experience.  Certainly not gang expertise, unless Larry was holding out on us by failing to disclose his former life as a gang member.  This fascinating debate offers a wonderful opportunity to discuss what it means to be an expert, who gets to decide whether someone is an expert, and why.

Expert testimony allows a witness to offer an opinion and respond to hypothetical questions.  It can be enormously powerful, since it feeds conclusions to the jury that the jury might otherwise have to make on its own, and for which the jury is arguably unprepared to decide due to its lack of specialized knowledge or experience. Staying with the gang theme, absent a juror with an interesting background that escaped notice in voir dire, how would they know that wearing a red baseball cap was a meaningful sign of gang involvement, or a meaningful sign of favoring a particular baseball team?

The problem arises from the fact that prosecutors require someone to say things that fill in the glaring gaps in their proof, but for which no evidence exists.  Enter Gang Expert to state with authority that the red baseball cap signifies membership in a criminal gang, and who can then go on to “explain” how gangs function, etc.  Amazingly, this tends to be wholly consistent with whatever evidence that prosecutor has.  How fortunate!

The problem, of course, is that there is no such “expertise”, except in the mind of the cop (like Larry).  And Larry, coincidentally, agrees by definition with the prosecutors assessment since, as Larry expressly states, he wouldn’t be there if he didn’t.  But remember that we have a judge sitting on the big bench, and the judge is the gatekeeper of all things expert.  To be admitted as an expert witness, the cop must first pass muster with the judge.

To do so, the prosecutor will ask the witness about his training and experience.  He will testify about the Academy, his additional training programs and his lengthy (or maybe not too lengthy) experience working the streets as part of an anti-gang group, where he has made (insert large and totally unverifiable number) arrests.  The judge pauses, says “hmmm”, then rules that the cop may testify as an expert.

Here’s the judge’s dilemma.  He knows that the prosecutor can’t make his case without the expert testimony, explaining to the jury the significance of the details that comprise the case.  He also knows that there’s no such thing as a “gang” expert, but that the cop is as close as the prosecution can possibly find.  His decision, therefore, means the difference between the case getting before the jury and the defendant getting a trial order of dismissal.  Bottom lining it, the judge isn’t going to toss the case.  If the defendant wants to win, it will have to come from the jury.

But what is the cop’s basis for expertise?  He’s been told by his brother police officers that a red baseball cap means gang membership.  He’s been told by his brother police officer how gangs function.  He goes out on the street, sees the red cap and busts the “gang member.”  Therefore, everything he knows is true because he acted upon it, and he would never have done so if it wasn’t.  That would be wrong.

And where did this fictional brother police officer who trains other brother police officers obtain this information and expertise such that it can be bootstrapped into reality in the courtroom.  They dunno.  They just take the class.  They don’t challenge the teacher.  That would be rude.  Cops aren’t rude.  At least not to other cops.

I’ve no doubt that Larry, poor Rick Horowitz’s foil, truly believes what he says.  And that’s a large part of the problem.  He is quite certain that he is an expert, that he knows what he’s talking about and that, by definition, he must be right because he would never have done it if he was wrong.  He would never “spin”, as he informed Rick (like defense lawyers do), because he takes absolute comfort in the correctness of his position.  It’s good to be on the side of truth and justice, even if only in one’s own mind.

Will Larry ever understand the Dunning-Kruger Effect?  Of course not.  Why would he bother?  Will the judge seriously consider the fact that Larry has no qualifications to opine as an expert, as if there actually were qualifications for such expertise?  Maybe, but only if the judge was prepared to put his own butt on the line should the defendant walk and commit a(nother) crime. 

What’s the lesson to be learned?  The only one I can think of is don’t wear a red baseball cap around Fresno. 

Twitting With Grandma

As most of you know, I am considered one of the foremost authorities on Twitter, primarily because being an authority on Twitter has such a low threshold.  Still, I can tell you that it’s growth has been explosive, with 33% last month over 25% the month before, in apparent direct inverse proportion to my retirement portfolio.  Consequently, I feel compelled to stay on top of this phenomenon and, when news of import occurs, relate it to you.  I have news.

It all started when I happened upon a disagreement between @grantgriffiths and some lawyers over whether lawyers should twit for/with clients.  Grant argued that we should encourage potential clients to follow us on twitter, and that when we twit, we are de facto twitting to potential clients since everyone within out jurisdiction (at least) is a potential client.  This shook up the lawyers, who recognized that this changes the entire nature of twitting; No longer can they twit with abandon, but now they must exercise self-restraint and twit with the idea that a client, or potential client, will be parsing their twits.

In the past, the primary constraint of twitter was its limitation of 140 characters, meaning that twitterers were constrained to express themselves in short bursts, some even opting to use those abbreviations that make teenagers feel unique and kewl, despite the fact that it makes a balding, middle-aged, overweight man appear foolish.  But at least the worst that could come from a moment of levity was the loss of another dozen followers with good taste and discretion.  And they certainly weren’t going to retain you anyway.

But given these huge growth numbers, the days of twitting with abandon are gone.  This twittersphere is no longer the insular community of lawyers and legal marketers is was a month ago.  I see it personally, given the number of young women searching for love and companionship who have started following me, most of whom I anticipate will soon have need of a criminal defense lawyer.  My twits are an open book, the windows to my soul if you will.  Anyone can look inside and see the real me.

Of course, the downside of Grant Griffiths’ observation is that much of the tom-foolery and camaraderie that was fostered by the sense of quasi-public isolation will be lost to the formality and pretentious airs lawyers adopt when wearing the official lawyer business hat.  “Why yes, @underwearlawman, I concur that given the aforesaid circumstances, it would be res judicata” will replace “true dat, bro.”   Being lawyerly not only implicates a certain stuffiness, but takes a lot more characters, thus defeating the test of reducing all thoughts to the limits of the medium.

But I wondered, if Grant’s theory is true, then how far has this really gone?  How bad is it.  Is it worse than we realize?  My research began with my contacting the Altacaccas down in God’s Waiting Room, where I was given an audience with the head Yenta.  “I would like to speak to you about twitter,” I began, when she cut me off with a curt, “aaaahhhhhhh.”  “What? What?”  I was shocked by what came next.

“I twitted at that Rich Sanchez on CNN,” she began, “and he never even twitted back at me. He’s an idiot. He doesn’t know anything.  If his mother knew how he behaved, she would give him such a smack…”

“You twit?”  I couldn’t believe my ears.  My expectation was that she might possibly have heard of twitter, but the idea that she would actually engage in twitting was far beyond my wildest imagination.  “Of course I twit,” she responded.  “What? Am I old or something?”  Don’t go there, I thought to myself.  I feigned an incoming call from a proctologist and excused myself.

Not only are your clients on twitter, but so is your grandmother.  So before your fingers begin to sing with abandon, consider whether it’s something you  want your grandmother to read.  She’s already miffed with Rick Sanchez, and once she learns of your twitter name, there’s no telling what she will do.  Bear in mind, it’s not like she has a lot to do all day long. 

As for me, I am seriously considering using only Latin to twit in the future, making me appear far more lawyerly than ever before.  Cogito, ergo twit.  Grandma only speaks Yiddish.

We’re Not Worthy of Geeklawyer

Lawyers are a staid group, by and large.  Quiet.  Unassuming.  Bound by tradition and history.  So what could be more traditional than a image from the Victorian era.  Even if it is an orgy. 

This weeks Blawg Review comes courtesy of a Brit whose purpose in life is to test the limits of taste and refinement, the inimitable Geeklawyer.  To be blunt (which only seems right given that we’re talking about GL here), he’s profane, rude and unbelievably funny.  There is no taboo that he won’t cross.  Or at least none that we’ve yet found.  No one who has the slightest clue of what GL is all about would suppose that his Blawg Reviews, like his regular blog posts, would be anything else.  He did not disappoint.

In her tongue and cheek promotion of Blawg Review #203, Diane Levin at Mediation Channel decided to return the favor to GL by asking, Is it time for a No Asshole Rule for Blawg Review?  Written with an apparent straight face, this took many (including myself) by surprise.

Blawg Review, usually known for the collegiality that once inspired me to declare it an “18th century coffeehouse for the digital age“, takes a dark turn this week. Hosted by the notorious and anonymous Geeklawyer, Blawg Review #203, replete with images from Victorian era pornography and cheap swipes at legal bloggers, leads me to ask, is it time for a No Asshole Rule for Blawg Review?

Caution: this edition of Blawg Review is not workplace safe — unless you happen to work in a brothel. Click through with caution.
Few people try to one-up Geeklawyer, mostly because it never before seemed possible.  But hidden within this “attack”, is there a note of real caution?  Is it possible for Blawg Review to go too far outside the bounds of decency?  Whether the questions comes from some subconscious interpretation of Diane’s Freudian purposes or that of her readers, who were unable to see that she just gave Geeklawyer back a little of what he gives so freely, doesn’t really matter.  Now that the challenge has been raised, it’s out there, floating in the ether.

For those of us who would never write (or likely even think) the things that Geeklawyer comes up with, there’s a possibility likelihood that someone will take offense.  He is, if nothing else, offensive.  It’s his shtick.  And he does it better than anyone I’ve ever seen.  He is the Lenny Bruce of the blawgosphere, and just as Bruce was not everyone’s cup of tea, neither is Geeklawyer.

But for those lawyers who can’t handle the insult, the joke, the profanity, the porn, there can be only one solution.  Quickly avert your eyes.  I won’t criticize humorless lawyers, who likely would respond that they have extremely well-developed sense of humor, but that this is not funny.  Hey, you can’t please everybody.

Some will argue free speech, censorship, blah, blah, blah.  This has nothing to do with it.  Obviously GL can write whatever he wants.  And obviously, the anonymous Ed can chose not to let GL do a Blawg Review if he thinks it’s too over the top that it undermines his purpose or offends too many.  Ed has not only let Geeklawyer do Blawg Review, but had him do it over again.  Does that tell you anything? 

Few amongst us have shown the guts to have fun, make fun and take on anyone and anything as has Geeklawyer.  I wouldn’t miss his Blawg Review for the world, and there was no question up front that he would rip some hearts out and give us all a decent smack.  I looked forward to it, and I enjoyed it immensely.  No, it’s not the way I do things, but this is Geeklawyer’s day and way, so who cares how anyone else would handle it.  This was Geeklawyer’s Blawg Review, and he did it Geeklawyer’s way.

But that doesn’t mean there’s no merit in Diane’s proposed rule.  It’s just a matter of how the rule is defined.  For me, it would apply to those who seek to use Blawg Review to promote their clique of local friends, marketers, and unbearably pedestrian and boring blogs.  When taking on the responsibility of a Blawg Review is used as an opportunity to numb us into mindlessness, that would violate my interpretation of the rule. 

It’s not that every Blawg Review has to be a work of art, like Colin Samuels, Eric Turkewitz, Mark Bennett or, yes, Geeklawyer.  Most of us aren’t that good.  I’m certainly not.  But to use Blawg Review as a vehicle for personal and professional self-promotion, whilst ignoring the real blawgosphere to make certain that no substantive link outshines the crap a host puts out, is what I consider profane. 

As for Geeklawyer’s Blawg Review, no matter how many times I may cringe while reading it, I wouldn’t miss it for the world.  So pass the rule or not, Geeklawyer is here to stay.  If anything, we aren’t worthy of his effort.