Author Archives: SHG

If You Had Your Pick of Associates

Above The Law has one of the rarest commodities around there days, a job listing for a new associate.  The ersatz employer, out of beautiful Stamford, CT, describes itself as follows:


Silver Golub & Teitell is a premier boutique trial litigation firm that handles sophisticated cases, primarily on behalf of plaintiffs, with trial lawyers included in “Best Lawyers in America” and other renowned publications.

Litigation, eh?  Well, talk about great fortune for SG&T, since it’s a subject that we know a little something about around here.  Courtrooms.  Trials. Cross-examination.  All the really fun lawyer-type stuff that criminal defense lawyers gain experience in by slaving day after day in the trenches of courtrooms across America.

And good fortune for SG&T as well, given the nature of the job market, attorney layoffs and hard-working young lawyers desperate to prove their worth and earn their keep.  In the past, a firm like this might have been forced to seek lawyers with spotty experience, perhaps even ill-suited to a “premier boutique” such as SG&T simply because of the great competition for top quality associates with proven competency in the trenches.  You know, the type of new lawyers who have shown that they can hack the rigors of trial work.  But today, the world is SG&T’s oyster.  They have their pick of associations.

So what exactly are they seeking?


Thirteen-attorney litigation firm seeks junior full-time associate with 0-3 years litigation experience, top tier undergraduate and law school education, preferably with clerkship and.or journal experience.

Oh my.  So zero years of litigation experience will do, but the candidate absolutely must have clerkship or journal experience.  No doubt because those are particularly critical when it comes to trying cases checking footnotes.  Apparently, SG&T is taking advantage of the Biglaw hemorrhage by scooping up the “best and the brightest” currently serving as a Starbucks barrista, likely due to the fact that these candidates have served Biglaw so very well.

Out of an excess of curiosity, I checked the backgrounds of the three named partners of SG&T to see whether they would have been qualified candidates for employment today.  Both Silver and Golub come by their vision honestly, having gone to Ivy League law schools, though their firm resumes fail to note whether either did a clerkship or blue-booked a journal. 

Ernest Teitell, on the other hand, might not cut the mustard.


He received his law degree from Loyola University in New Orleans and his undergraduate degree from Bethany College.

Uh oh.  Bethany College?  Please.  But wait.  If you read the rest of Ernie’s firm resume, you see that he has had an extraordinarily distinguished and successful career in litigation, even though he was Harvard undergrad and Yale law.  How is that possible?  Does Ernie carry around guilt and self-loathing for his failure to meet the Ivy League fantasies?  Or does he realize that what happens in the courtroom has nothing to do with the color stripe on his school tie?

One might hope that partners like Ernie would help partners like Silver and Golub remember that the qualities they seek in a litigation associate have little to do with their recruiting some Biglaw wannabe, but with the intangibles who, like Ernie, can one day excel in litigation.  Unfortunately, that isn’t going to happen at SG&T.  Forget your skills, your zeal, your fervor.  If you don’t meet the routine requirements for sitting in a Biglaw library, you have no hope of getting the job.

I wonder how Ernie would feel if he was looking for a job today.  I wonder how well SG&T would have done without him.

Pretense Exposed By Cop’s Fantasy

One of the few things the New York Times has done right is bring aboard a reporter with the street smarts of Jim Dwyer, who used to slum for Newsday and the Daily News.  Forget the Pulitzer Prize thing, Dwyer has always understood that the system is rotten, and it’s his role to expose it.  And in his expose of Vaughan Ettienne, body builder, NYPD Officer, and cop who beat Gary Waters and then planted a throw-away on him to cover the three broken ribs, Dwyer does it again.

Ettienne had Myspace  and Facebook pages, using the name “Devious”, where his “Internet persona” came out.  It wasn’t the police officer in the clean uniform politely answering questions on the witness stand. 


What seemed like a simple gun possession case became an undeclared war over reality: Was Officer Ettienne a diligent cop who found a gun after chasing an ex-convict weaving through traffic on a stolen motorcycle? Or was his story a “devious” facade in keeping with the ruthless character he revealed on social network Web sites?

“You have your Internet persona, and you have what you actually do on the street,” Officer Ettienne said on Tuesday. “What you say on the Internet is all bravado talk, like what you say in a locker room.”

Besides the “devious” mood setting, the jurors learned that a few weeks before the trial, the officer posted this status on his Facebook page: “Vaughan is watching ‘Training Day’ to brush up on proper police procedure.”

While it’s unlikely that the fantasy world crafted in cyberspace by a warped mind manifests itself daily on the street, it is similarly unlikely that the good cop persona, carefully crafted in the Police Academy, is any closer to reality.  Inside that dark, dank space between Ettienne’s ears is the tension that resulted in Water’s three broken ribs for his resisting arrest conviction.

What was particularly fascinating was how the trial judge saw the issue when Water’s defense attorney, Adrian Lesher, sought to introduce Ettienne’s online persona to counter his courtside manner.


The prosecutor, Kevin James, tried to persuade the judge, Joel M. Goldberg, that remarks like the one about “Training Day” had nothing to do with the arrest. “It goes into artistic interpretations to a movie, directorship, actors,” Mr. James said.

“I don’t think it’s enlightening.” The judge replied, “If you want to redirect and the witness says I liked it because of the cinematography, he can say that.”

(Note: Heard from Adrian Lesher and Jim Dwyer, that the quote “I don’t think it’s enlightening” was misattributed to the judge due to a pagination error, and was in fact said by the prosecutor.  Obivously, that changes everything as to Judge Goldberg’s response, and I’ve struck my comments below relying upon the quote)

Put aside the prosecutor’s imaginative argument, and consider the court’s reaction.  Had the defendant been on Facebook with a comment that he enjoyed some rap music about shooting cop or ‘ho’s, which pretty much covers any rap song every recorded, you can bet it would be admitted as evidence of something evil.  But while the judge allowed Lesher to ask the questions, he failed to see anything particularly “enlightening” about it.  That it revealed a hole so big in Ettienne’s carefully crafted courtroom persona that you could drive a Mack truck through it didn’t impress Justice Goldberg.  Even though the defense was about a cop who beat a perp and planted a gun to justify it, he still wasn’t moved. 

Lesher’s legwork in unearthing Ettienne’s “Internet persona” is quite impressive, and should put to rest those who try to create business by abusing public defenders.  He made the effort to dig and found gold.

Judge Goldberg, on the other hand, doesn’t appear to get it at all.  Perhaps he’s not attuned to life online (like I am, of course) and doesn’t realize that many secrets are revealed when someone feels the disinhibition of the vast web before them?  Or perhaps he’s just such a true believer in cross that no one witness, not even a body-builder cop, can withstand such crushing scrutiny? 

In any event, this appears to be a one-shot mistake for Vaughan Ettienne.


Officer Ettienne said he is now being careful to mask his identity on the Web and that he has curbed his tongue because of the acquittal. “I feel it’s partially my fault,” he said. “It paints a picture of a person who could be overly aggressive. You put that together, it’s reasonable doubt in anybody’s mind.”

The good news, of course, is that loose lips on the internet are there forever.  Whatever picture is painted, it’s always going to be a self-portrait. 

Is The Supreme Court Irrrelevant?

One of the problems with blogs is that they deal with immediacy and often get far ahead of themselves when it comes to reflection.  Thankfully, we have Adam Liptak at the New York Times to take up the rear, reminding us far after the fact to take stock of the pressing issues in the law.  And so he does again in his latest Sidebar Column on the most important case of the decade, District of Columbia v. Heller.


So far, Heller is firing blanks

That’s pretty clear.  With the vast attention given Heller, by interest groups, legal beagles (mavens, as Charon calls them, or thought leaders, as O’Keefe likes to say), not to mention every constitutional scholar across the nation, no case in the past decade has received the attention and energy of Heller.  For what? 

The true believers will tell you to give it time.  Eventually, courts, both state and federal, across the land will come to honor the decision stating, more or less, that possession of a weapon is a fundamental right under the Second Amendment to the Constitution.  Ten, maybe twenty, years from now, it will change everything.  That’s what they want to believe.  Of course, they put so much into this decision, this argument, that it’s painful to accept that they won the battle, but nobody bothered to notice the war.

Having watched the impact of the Supreme Court for almost 3 decades, and having a passing familiarity with some of the decisions made before it dawned on me to pay extemporaneous attention, I have reached an awkward conclusion.  Despite the supposed importance of a pronouncement of the Supreme Court, it has had extraordinarily little impact on the landscape of American law in the past two decades.  It has, in essence, become irrelevant.

What the heck are you talking about?  This is the Supreme Court!  Of course it’s relevant.  So you mutter as you read this.  I’ll explain.

As any practicing lawyer knows all too painfully well, the nuances that we argue about the merits of appellate decisions, and most particularly Supreme Court decisions, are almost laughably ignored at the trial court level.  Trial judges show no interest in the fine points of the law; they sweep with a broad brush, and they do it as fast as they can.  They have neither patience nor interest in hearing us argue the niceties of the auto exception to the 4th; it’s a car, you lose.  That’s the predominant reaction. 

The trick at the trial level isn’t knowing the nuance of the law, but getting the judge to give you the 90 seconds necessary to get the words out of your mouth before he denies your motion.  So all that studious effort, the detailed and footnoted memoranda, is an exercise in rhetoric if no one is listening.  Tell the judge “the Supreme Court said” and watch his eyes glaze over.

But the Supremes have largely done this to themselves.  Part of the problem derives from their split decisions; a stream of 5-4 rulings means that precedent can flip with the next political wave, rendering decisions transient rather than precedent.  Worse still, over the past two decades, the Supremes have imbued its pronouncements with so many wiggle words, so many qualifications, so little clarity, that no one is really clear what they are trying to tell us after the decision is finally issued.

Consider Booker,  its antecedents and its progeny.  How many decisions did it take for the Supreme Court to finally get district and circuit judges to accept the premise that the Sentencing Guidelines were, indeed, only advisory and not mandatory.  What of the thousands and thousands of defendants who were sentenced while the rules had purportedly changed but no one cared? 

Putting it in context, Booker sought to undo a congressional scheme that had been held unconstitutional by every court across the country until the Supremes held the Guidelines constitutional in Mistretta in 1989.  If they were merely advisory, wouldn’t it have been a better idea to say so 20 years ago?  Even so, the lower courts continued to slavishly apply the guidelines until the Supremes finally provided clarity.  And when a district judge varied, the circuit would make sure she paid for it,  

In the end, Booker merely “corrected” what the Supremes did in Mistretta twenty years earlier.  And this was hailed as a major breakthrough, rather than proof of its failure to fulfill its function in our society.  So many human beings sentenced to so many years in prison under the rote application of a grid, all because the Supreme Court dropped the ball at the beginning of the game.

Some, primarily Supreme Court sycophants, excuse this as judicial modesty.  Another fine euphemism to cover a screw-up.  How about Supreme Court clarity?  Don’t open the door to disaster and then tell us everyone is doing it all wrong 20 years later.  Think it all through in the first place.  Or at the very least, once you recognize that the decision missed a critical piece, or that no one understands what the Court was saying, correct it as quickly as possible. 

But the Supreme Court has further shown that its isolation, its very impressive building in Washington with its somber paneled rooms, keeps its justices from recognizing what more ordinary people (if one can call any federal judge ordinary) see.  Consider the Supreme Court’s first venture onto Youtube in Scott v. Harris, wherein Justice Scalia said during oral argument that it was  “the scariest chase I ever saw since ‘The French Connection.’ ”  Of course, this wasn’t the district judge or circuit’s view of life on Georgia’s highways, but surely someone riding in the back of a Washington limo knows more about dangerous driving than the local yokels.


“Eight of the jurors on this court,” Justice Stevens said, “reach a verdict that differs from the views of the judges on both the district court and the court of appeals who are surely more familiar with the hazards of driving on Georgia roads than we are.”

Why bother going through the motions when the Supreme can just watch the video and play de novo jury?  So much for judicial modesty.  Perhaps it shows that our justices are just frustrated trial judges, recognizing how little they affect anything and desperate for some hands-on evidence.

And so we return to the Heller decision, which includes the ignominious Section III paragraph penned by the most intellectually honest judge since William H. Rehnquist.


For example, the majority of the 19th-century courts to consider the question held that prohibitions on carrying concealed weapons were lawful under the Second Amendment or state analogues. See, e.g., State v. Chandler, 5 La. Ann., at 489–490; Nunn v. State, 1 Ga., at 251; see generally 2 Kent *340, n. 2; The American Students’ Blackstone 84, n. 11 (G. Chase ed. 1884). Although we do not undertake an exhaustive historical analysis today of the full scope of the Second Amendment, nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms. We also recognize another important limitation on the right to keep and carry arms. Miller said, as we have explained, that the sorts of weapons protected were those “in common use at the time.” 307 U. S., at 179. We think that limitation is fairly supported by the historical tradition of prohibiting the carrying of “dangerous and unusual weapons.”

Why, oh why, go through all the trouble of changing everything about the Second Amendment only to take it back with this doctrinally bankrupt paragraph?  For all the effort put into Heller, this lone paragraph, unhinged from any of the theories upon which scholarly people ponder, did as much to assure that it would be anything but earth-shattering. 

So in an odd way, Heller has driven home a critical constitutional point, just not one about the Second Amendment.  It has, however, made clear that the focus on the Supreme Court has produced so little of consequence that the carefully selected words, parsed by academics, mean nothing in the trenches where real people struggle. 

The Supreme Court has made itself irrelevant.  It’s a shame because we could really use a Supreme Court as final arbiter of the Constitution by providing clear and complete direction so the rest of us have a clue what the rules are.  Instead, we are all doomed to turn to Youtube for answers, or be left with nothing but a meaningless void.

A Mixed Message To Lawyers

It’s always fun to watch an appellate court wriggle out of its dilemma when two rote rules clash, and the Second Circuit’s decision in United State v. Pitcher is a case in point. 

Douglas Pitcher was indicted for his participation in a narcotics conspiracy in the Eastern District of New York.  As is typically the case, the government left the door ajar for Pitcher’s cooperation.  Pitcher chose not to walk through it, telling his lawyer that he was innocent (note, INNOCENT) of the charges and rejected the offer of cooperation.

According to defense counsel’s recollection of events, Pitcher “was not interested in cooperation and was adamant about his innocence. He steadfastly maintained that he did not commit the crimes for which he was indicted and absolutely refused to plead guilty.”

As regular readers know, the duty of defense counsel is to honor the defendant’s refusal to plead guilty, particularly when he adamantly asserts his innocence.  And the Circuit is well aware of this duty:


[W]e are wary of endorsing any precedent that could enable a defendant to benefit from lying to his defense counsel or that might suggest a duty on the part of defense counsel to arm-twist a client who maintains his innocence into pleading guilty. See Purdy v. United States, 208 F.3d 41, 45 (2d Cir. 2000) (“[T]he ultimate decision whether to plead guilty must be made by the defendant. And a lawyer must take care not to coerce a client into either accepting or rejecting a plea offer.”).

By now, I bet that most of you can see the set-up coming.  After Pitcher loses at trial, he argues (natch) that he received ineffective assistance of counsel.


On direct appeal, Pitcher admitted his participation in the charged offenses, but he argued that he would have pursued a cooperation agreement with the government but for the ineffectiveness of his counsel, who convinced him to spurn the government’s efforts to sign him up as a cooperator.

Pitcher further argued that his lawyer gave “an unreasonably optimistic assessment of Pitcher’s prospects at trial.”  Of course, on direct appeal, the 2d Circuit affirmed Pitcher’s conviction and rejected his IAC argument. But Judge Trager granted Pitcher’s 2255 motion on the basis of ineffective assistance.  Oh, what’s an appellate court to do.


Pitcher then filed his § 2255 petition in the district court, seeking to vacate his sentence on the ground that he would have received a significantly shorter sentence had trial counsel not misinformed him about the benefits of cooperation and the risks he faced by proceeding to trial. The district court held an evidentiary hearing in July 2004. At the hearing Jacobs testified he explored with Pitcher the possibility of cooperation but Pitcher had vigorously asserted his innocence.

The problem stems from the 2d Circuit’s firm belief that it is ineffective for any defense lawyer to fail to make clear to his client that cooperation is always the best route out of an indictment.  And as always, the duty falls on counsel’s shoulders, the defendant’s protestations of innocence notwithstanding:



The district court acknowledged that Pitcher lied to Jacobs about his involvement in the charged offenses, but the court found that this did not absolve Jacobs of his responsibility to persuade Pitcher to accept the government’s offer:



Although [Pitcher] did lie to his attorney, there is no basis for assuming he would have stuck to this story if Jacobs had provided reasonable advice concerning the serious danger of conviction and the comparative advantages of cooperation. Jacobs, by unreasonably telling [Pitcher] that his story was a good one, . . . and that the government’s case was weak, gave [Pitcher] precious little incentive to say anything else.


Id. at 263.


The Circuit’s solution is to reverse the grant of habeas on procedural grounds, holding that the legal and factual basis for the 2255 motion is the same as that already determined by direct appeal, and try to punt on the problem of defense attorney ineffectiveness in the face of a defendant who “adamantly” insists he is innocent and rejects cooperation.  But even the Circuit realized how hollow this sounds, and how contradictory their message.  And so they add:


Although we reverse on the grounds stated, we add that we are wary of endorsing any precedent that could enable a defendant to benefit from lying to his defense counsel or that might suggest a duty on the part of defense counsel to arm-twist a client who maintains his innocence into pleading guilty. See Purdy v. United States, 208 F.3d 41, 45 (2d Cir. 2000) (“[T]he ultimate decision whether to plead guilty must be made by the defendant. And a lawyer must take care not to coerce a client into either accepting or rejecting a plea offer.”).

So which is it?  If the defendant insists he is innocent, and tells his lawyer “facts” that he later admits to be lies, and the lawyer respects the defendant’s choice and relies on the defendant’s representations, then the lawyer remains obligated to convince the client to either plead guilty or cooperate, there being no reasonably competent advice to the contrary.  And don’t forget, but the lawyer can’t “arm-twist” the client to do so, wherever that line may be.

I trust that everyone is now muttering his or her appreciation to the Second Circuit for its clarification of the defense lawyers obligations.  And I can’t help but wonder whether Judge Trager granted the 2255 motion just to watch the Circuit squirm its way out of this one.

Even Rats Have Cellmates

Via Turley, it seems that payback came all too quickly for 23 year old Paul Duran Jr.  Apparently, Duran was not really much of a “people person,” having had a fight with his cellmate, requiring him to be moved to another cell.  Safety first, of course, is the motto of all correctional facilities.  There are few things worse than fighting inmates.

Duran was a guest stemming from his involvement in the Oklahoma City shooting of Billy Wayne Ray (you can’t make these names up #1), when he decided to take the plunge and snitch against his dear friend, Jesse James Dalton (you can’t make these names up #2),  Arrested, Duran proclaimed, “no mas” and promptly flipped.  He was led to believe that he has new best friends in powerful places.  This earned him a 28 year sentence.  Woo hoo!

But the fine officers in charge of Duran made a curious decision when they were forced to change cells in Duran’s best interest.  They decided that his new cellmate should be his former pal, Jesse James Dalton.  Fifteen minutes after the reunion, Duran was found beaten to death.

It should come as no surprise that things like this aren’t supposed to happen.  When one co-defendant flips on another, he should be segregated.  While this may prove very difficult in very large, multi-defendant drug conspiracy cases, simply because there aren’t enough wings to hold the various groups and individuals who might prefer not to have a face to face meeting  in the shower, it doesn’t seem that such a problem existed for Duran and Dalton.

Rather, this bears the smell of the corrections officers playing a little payback.  Whether for something Duran did to them while enjoying his extended vacation, or just because they hate snitches as much as everyone else, is hard to say.  But that of all the cells in the prison, they picked Jesse James Dalton’s, does not strike one as mere kismet.    

There are lessons to be learned here.  Some might call them life lessons, under the circumstances.  Lesson number one is that when you commit a crime and go to prison, you will not find it to be a nurturing environment. 

Lesson number two is that corrections officers do not care as deeply for you as your mother, girlfriend or baby-mama.  Lesson number three is that everybody hates a rat, and once a rat, always a rat. 

Lesson number four is that corrections officers don’t truly care if you emerge from prison a better person.  Indeed, they don’t necessarily care if you emerge from prison at all.  This is particularly true if you happen to be a rat.  (See lesson number three.)

I am not saying it should be this way.  I am not saying that it is always this way.  I am, however, saying that it can be this way.  Feeling lucky?

But It’s a Contract

I’m as big a fan of honoring contractual obligations as the next guy.  Maybe even more so.  As it happens, I also have a few shares of AIG papers to the bathroom wall.  And yet, I am trouble.

As the New York Times reported:


Word of the bonuses last week stirred such deep consternation inside the Obama administration that Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner told the firm they were unacceptable and demanded they be renegotiated, a senior administration official said. But the bonuses will go forward because lawyers said the firm was contractually obligated to pay them.

The “lawyers said” makes for a fine excuse.  Notice how everyone, even AIG Chairman Edward Liddy cares deeply about what the lawyers say?  It makes me feel so, so, lawyerly.  But I must admit, if I was the lawyer advising Liddy, that would probably be only a small part of what I had to say.  I would find reliance on my say to be disingenuous, bordering on deceptive.  I would tell Liddy that there are a multitude of ways to alter and modify these contractual obligations, created before the bailout and paid long after the taxpayers’ $170 Billion check had been cashed.  Yes, I would put my lawyerly mind to work.

Connecticut’s conscience, Norm Pattis, is not happy about it either.  This is important as he is far more likely to be eating next to one of these bonus babies at a fine Greenwich brasserie than I am, and Norm could sneak some extra salt on their steak au poivre when they get up to use the facilities.  I can do little more than think bad thoughts.


Did I read that right? The federal government out and out gave American International Group $170 billion to keep from folding, and the company now plans to give $160 million in bonuses? I understand the need to stimulate the economy, but tossing lard-drenched oats to the swine makes no sense. Don’t we ever make the pigs squeal for their supper?

Norm is deeply upset by Liddy’s explanation.


Listen to Libby: “We cannot attract the best and the brightest talent to lead and staff the A.I.G. businesses — which are now being operated principally on behalf of American taxpayers — if employees believe their compensation is subject to continued and arbitrary adjustment by the U.S. Treasury.” I am beginning to rethink whether balcony diving ought after all to be the fate of those who cannot face their failures.

The slimy shucksters who bobbed for our dollars by promising golden apples at the bottom of every barrel? Why are any of the “best and brightest” who waltzed we trusting suckers to the brink of disaster still working? Bonuses for this crowd? They’re lucky they don’t get bullets instead.

I wouldn’t want to get anywhere Norm and a salt shaker if you plan on paying for dinner with your bonus check.  But Liddy’s reliance on the “best and brightest” phrase, derived from David Halberstam’s 1972 book of that title, reminds us of the fallacy of his thinking, and his argument.  Are they the best and brightest, having driven AIG to need a $170 bailout?  Are the “best and brightest,” putting aside Liddy’s hyperbolic claim, worth $160 Million in bonuses?  Are they worth it under these circumstances? 

Liddy obviously believes so, and is willing to put AIG on the line to back up his view.  Jim Chen provides a reminder of what Halberstam’s “best and brightest” accomplished.  What makes Liddy think his will do better?  It’s not often that a phrase has been so successfully turned from sword to shield, masking its underlying point to the tune of $160 Million.  It’s up to us to decide whether we accept Liddy’s use of the phrase, and his decision based on it.

While I have little doubt that AIG has a coterie of fine lawyers, perhaps even the “best and the brightest,” at its beck and call, I nonetheless have a small bit of advice to offer.  Let us assume that Liddy, as a good and honorable capitalist, feels duty-bound to the good men and women due bonuses for the failure of AIG to fulfill their expectations.  Let us further assume that Liddy does not wish to be remembered as a singular target of greed, hatred and derision.  Here’s a quick trick for your bag, Ed.

Agree to pay out the bonus to each and every “B&B” employee, as contractually obligated, but inform them that if they do not waive their bonus, you will do so publicly, announcing their names, addresses and the amount of their bonus.  State that you are doing so because the “lawyers said” you had to, but that these people are undeserving of these bonuses, given the bailout of AIG by public funds, but have chosen to take the tax dollars of their friends, neighbors and family.  Of your friends, neighbors and family as well.  Of your tax dollars.  They have made the choice to demand compliance with their contracts in the face of AIG’s failure, and while others go hungry, they will eat too well.

Don’t worry about privacy concerns.   The money is the same color as that paid to the group of banks and brokerages already released.  When you are gasping for breath, privacy is the least of your problems.  Your bonus babies won’t complain, as they would never want to be viewed as whiners.  They are proud.  They are the best and the brightest, after all, and will certainly recognize that the use of public monies by a public company means public exposure.  Those who take their bonus will bask in their glory.

And one more thing.  Throw in a free dinner at Norm’s favorite restaurant.  He’ll make sure that some salt is rubbed in the wound.

Straight Into Solo, When There’s No Other Choice

Over the past few weeks, I’ve received numerous emails from law students telling me that they want to be criminal defense lawyers and go straight into solo practice.  The question posed is, how can they do it?

There is a huge schism in the blawgosphere about the merit of going straight from law school into solo practice, with some promoting it as the panacea of work-life balance and control over one’s life and career, and others, like me, admonishing that brand new lawyers aren’t yet capable of competently representing clients.  The two schools of thought are largely characterized by the focus we bring to the issue:  Those who promote it tend to be the ones who make a living off it.  Those who don’t, like me, tend to be concerned with professionalism and quality of representation.  Does that sound unfair?  It’s not. 

It had been my intention to teach others how to go about starting a solo criminal practice at Solo Practice University, but since my unceremonious dumping following my run-in with the majority of the faculty who came on board to sell their services to the students, that’s not going to happen.  The gist of SPU appears likely to focus on how one can market the newbie lawyer, unprepared to handle the most trivial prosecution, into the next best thing since Clarence Darrow.

Can this be accomplished.  Yes, I proclaim.  Well, maybe, at least.  As long as one squints, and doesn’t mind becoming the scum of the earth, lying, scoundrel in the process.  Well, that may be a bit harsh, but the fact is that marketing can make a sow’s ear look like a silk purse, but it won’t help new lawyers to be competent lawyers.  Having clients without competency is a recipe for disaster for all involved.

But following the implosion of the economy, and with it the disappearance of the job market for entering lawyers, the equation has changed.  Whereas once I argued that the notion of flying solo straight out of law school was decidedly wrong, the new reality is that many law students will have no choice.  Solo practice is the alternative to sitting at home playing Wii.  The latter is not an option.

I see the most dangerous pending proposition to be the focus of new lawyer solos as the quest for clients without a concomitant quest for competency.  The former is far easier to attain than the latter, since I do not believe that any criminal defense lawyer can even begin to fulfill his duty to his clients without a certain breadth of experience, which takes between three and 10 years to attain.  I fully expect new criminal defense lawyers to inform me that I am absolutely wrong about this, insisting that they are great lawyers and totally competent (if not excellent) in the performance of the representation.

And lest someone else make this point, experience alone does not turn an incompetent solo into a brilliant practitioner.  As the saying goes, an old fool is worse than a young fool.  Indeed, there are plenty of lawyers who suck after ten, twenty and more years of experience.  But that’s because they just aren’t any good at being lawyers, for whatever reason, and no amount of experience is going to change that.  We’re talking here about lawyers who can be good, and should be good, but just aren’t yet ready for prime time.

To suggest that new lawyers get a gig with the District Attorney or Legal Aid Society before hanging out the shingle would be facile and pointless under the circumstances.  Jobs aren’t there, and suggesting non-existent options is a waste of time.  I won’t insult you that way, especially after insulting you in so many other ways.

But I do have two options to suggest.  Neither is perfect, but under the circumstances both offer a greater likelihood of developing competency while not ruining the lives of whatever clients the marketers can drum up for you.


Option A:  Hook up with an experience, competent criminal defense lawyer

By this, I mean that new solos should establish a hard relationship with a strong criminal defense lawyer, providing support services in exchange for the “apprenticeship”-type experience that she can offer.  Handle the late-night arraignments.  Fetch the files from the clerk’s office.  File the papers.  And listen, learn and discuss.  The more experienced lawyer can hand off those small cases that she might otherwise reject, to give the new lawyer something to work on, and provide oversight and insight so that the new lawyer develops experience in handling matters that will create a level of depth that only time, or a stream of mistakes, can provide.

If the new criminal defense lawyer has the capacity, she will grow in the relationship, perhaps even to the point of a partnership if she proves worthy of the interest.  Shy of that, the respect will earn the new lawyer bigger case referrals, perhaps even co-defendants on multi-defendant cases, and the admiration of others who will see the effort and zeal she’s putting into her cases. 

On the other hand, if the newbie doesn’t have the juice, it will become apparent.  This is frank talk here, so don’t take this the wrong way.  Not everyone is cut out for solo practice, nor criminal defense, nor even the law.  Better to find out early, before you’ve destroyed too many lives and make yourself miserable.


Option B:  Find yourself a mentor

The word “mentor” has become ont the favorites of the solo promoters. It’s warm.  It’s friendly.  It’s a happening kinda word.  It’s also a decidedly second string concept, having two significant failings.  Anyone hyping mentoring should be carefully scrutinized for the illegal use of adjective (well, it should be a crime, anyway) to maintain that warm and fuzzy sensation despite these failings.  Remember, if you’re a desperate new lawyer embarking on a scary solo practice despite the fact that every synapse in your head is snapping, crackling and popping, you will grasp at any straw you can to bolster your decision.  It’s only natural. 

The first failing of mentoring is that you need continuous and reliable supervision.  Mentors are there to help you out when they can, meaning that they have their own lives and work, and you only get as much of their busy day as they are willing to give you.  Trust me, you do not come before their children.  Maybe not even close acquaintances.  You may be the center of the universe to yourselves, but you may not be to the mentor, and they are not prepared to sacrifice their lives and times to convenience you. 

The new practitioner has a million questions.  Answering a million questions takes up a lot of time.  This is time that could otherwise be spent by the mentor earning money and representing clients.  Something has to give.  Guess who that something will be.

Second, the mentor may be supportive, but supportive isn’t necessarily honest.  Someone has to tell you when you screw up.  Someone has to tell you that you blew it .  Someone has to tell you if you don’t have what it takes.  But whoever that someone is, you’re not going to like it (even if you think now that you will appreciate it) and you will turn on them.  The mentor has no reason to invite your angst.  The mentor is doing you a favor, and while she may be happy to help, she isn’t happy to argue the point.

Similarly, when there are too many questions, demands, issues, DRAMA, the mentor may quietly slip away, appeasing you by agreement while dying to get off the phone or avoid that cup of coffee.  You may need answers.  The mentor doesn’t need headaches.  Your needs and the mentor’s needs are not coterminous, but you won’t see it until the mentor refuses to take your calls anymore.

So if mentoring is so fraught with issues, why do I recommend it?  Because there aren’t any other options, and as much as it may be flawed, it’s better than nothing.  If the new lawyer bears these failings in mind, and conducts themselves within appropriate limits, it will facilitate the benefits of mentoring without invoking the problems.  Of course, it’s not easy for a new lawyer to perform such a metacognitive assessment, or to recognize other people’s limits until it’s too late.

For those new lawyers who hoped to learn how to fly solo at SPU, I feel confident that there’s no one over there who will tell you the downside of your plans.  You can expect plenty of cheerleading, but no one to pick you up when you crash and burn.  Sorry, but solo practice is real life, and no string of adjectives will cover your butt when real people demand that you fulfill the promises that marketers made on your behalf.  Indeed, some will get downright nasty when they realize that you’re all bluff and no substance.

Somebody had to tell you, and perhaps save you a bunch of money that you likely can’t afford to spend to find out that you can succeed by spending even more money on the marketing services of your beloved faculty members.  And nobody even mentions that you need to become a decent lawyer.

Do We Need Three Ways to Convict?

Subtitled, when the going gets tough, someone always thinks we need more laws.

Even though legislators are beginning to realize that the cost of creating a crime a day isn’t bringing the electoral dividends of the past, that doesn’t mean that some quasi-academic isn’t going to continue to feed the public frenzy by pursuing the ignorant notion that we could have avoided all the nasty crimes that brought out economy down around us by creating more crimes.  Exhibit A, this op-ed at Newsday, We need a bigger gavel.

The writer, Eugene O’Donnell, is a former police officer and prosecutor, teaches law and police studies at John Jay College of Criminal Justice of the City University of New York.   If you were sitting at the breakfast table slurping your morning coffee, wouldn’t you think he knows what he’s talking about.  After all, he’s got the credentials.  But that’s not all, he also feels our pain.


As a young Brooklyn cop, I was amazed at the trivial infractions that could result in a citizen’s being tossed into a holding cell for a day or more. A subway passenger who held the door for another, or who carried a coffee onto the train, or even dozed off, could be arrested. Later, as a prosecutor, it was amazing to see how much effort went into pursuing even the softest offenders.

The proffered reason for enforcing these rules, which swept up hundreds of thousands of people, was the now famous “broken windows” logic, which held that unaddressed minor misconduct could foster serious crimes.

Oh yes, Eugene, yes.  Of course, it’s just a bit unclear what you mean by the effort that went into “pursuing even the softest offenders.”  No doubt you’re referring to officers giving summons to subway coffee criminals, who would then pay a fine and stop spilling coffee on the seats.  But yes, the reason predatory lenders and Madoff got away with it for so long is that we were out nailing sleepy people on the subways.  If only Bernie and some predatory lenders drank their lattes or took a snooze on the subway, then they would have been taught a lesson or two and we would all be safe, right Eugene?

From this ignominious start, O’Donnell goes for the jugular:


Unsavory business practices germinate in an atmosphere of secrecy and confidence that prosecutors will rarely come calling. Despite heralded prosecutions of a tiny handful of big-ticket schemers at Enron and WorldCom, federal prosecutors have proven far more adept at promising action against titans of fraud than delivering on it. Complicating efforts at cleaning up the mess: Few law enforcement officials have the skills necessary to even comprehend these intricate shenanigans. And one single fraud, such as the Bernard Madoff case, can tie up legions of agents and prosecutors, with the possibility that the larger the scam, the greater the likelihood of forestalling (or avoiding) detection and prosecution.

Not only should there be a robust rethinking of white-collar criminal laws, but much more expansive and creative penalties should be developed for pursuing whole corporate entities. How can a company composed of thieving employees award bonuses to those not directly connected, even when the fruits of the fraud contribute to the bottom line? Why can’t the taxpayer and the victims get back the value of bank accounts, second homes and luxury cars? Perhaps we should even create a special corporate criminal court and a national fraud agency, which can substitute for the current uncoordinated hodgepodge of law enforcement agencies.

Wait a second.  Didn’t you just say that the problem was all the cops busy busting the “softest offenders?”  Now you say the solution is a “robust rethinking of what-collar criminal laws.”  What is amazing is that you’ve managed to get it wrong on both ends, which O’Donnell should likely have little difficulty accepting, considering how easily he is amazed.  Cops cleaning up the subways had no connection with the enforcement of existing fraud laws, most of which were federal while he was obviously a local cop and state prosecutor. 

Where’s the part of your op-ed where you admit that you “don’t know nothing about birthin’ no babies,” Eugene?  From your starry resume, one thing is quite clear: You were nowhere near the parts of the system relating to corporate fraud, and hence would have no involvement in their enforcement.  You, dear Eugene, were part of the subway slurper side of life. Now be honest and ‘fess up.

Despite the obvious, that the messenger is clueless, the message remains troubling.  It serves to suggest that someone whose background in law enforcement and prosecution knows that our laws are weak and meaningless, and plays upon the pain of those defrauded to call for yet another round of harsher laws and penalties, as if that was the root of our problems.  It’s an H.L. Mencken moment, 


“For every problem, there is a solution that is simple, neat, and wrong.”

Is O’Donnell arguing that the potential 150 years for Madoff is insufficient?  As Jeralyn Merritt put it, should he have been subject to a sentence of “life plus cancer” before we can achieve deterrence?  There is lack of laws to handle the problem.  There is no lack of severe penalties to serve as a deterrence.  Our laws already have laws, enough to nail a corporate fraudster three ways to Sunday.  When will people who present as if they should know what they are talking about shut their damn mouths and stop feeding the public inane solutions, adding to the panic and pain by promoting ignorance?

There is, and always has been, an enforcement issue.  The machines of law enforcement that are supposed to keep an eye on regulated industry have been deferential.  This may be a product of campaign contributions, fear of destroying the economy by putting large corporations under negative scrutiny or perhaps just the sympatico relationship between the wealthy and the powerful.  The beat cops of the NYPD, who according to O’Donnell, are too busy harassing subway coffee drinkers, don’t spend much time walking the hallways of major corporations in search of corporate broken windows. 


Hundreds of millions of dollars are spent on law enforcement to protect against terrorism. Why not adopt a similar approach to suite crime? At the heart of the ongoing financial meltdown is loss of the trust and confidence of millions of Americans, who feel they cannot turn their backs on once-respected companies without being taken.

A nation that can dedicate the effort and focus to arrest an errant subway passenger can surely summon the tools necessary to dismantle individual and business racketeers. This is a good time for some well-directed anger. Now is the time to legislate – and prosecute.

And thus falls the other shoe.  It’s not bad enough that we’ve thrown hundreds of millions in the toilet to create the fiction of safety from terrorism, while eviscerating the civil rights of Americans in the process.  Let’s do the same to corporate America, because we surely have hundreds of millions of dollars sitting around doing nothing, and we certainly don’t need these nasty corporations providing goods, services and jobs, and it’s certainly the same as arresting the “errant subway passenger.” 

If O’Donnell was running for office, I wouldn’t begrudge him his lapse into lunacy as he would come by his pandering honestly.  But as a quasi-academic (as if John Jay College of Criminal Justice was a real school), it’s difficult to forgive his employment of at least one logical fallacy per sentence in order to promote the absolutely wrong solution to the problem du jour. 

But I save my strongest criticism for the Newsday editors, for publishing such irresponsible, ignorant and absurd tripe as this, knowing that it feeds the public’s misperception that all would be fixed if only our lawmakers would create more crimes.

Is the Pool Permanently Tainted?

Trial lawyers rely on two bedrock legal fictions.  One is that the jurors will decide cases based solely on the evidence in court.  The other is that they will accept the legal instructions as given by the judge.  Is it time to put these fictions to bed?

At Co-Op and  PrawfsBlawg, lawprofs discuss how they use and fight television in attempting to teach criminal law.  It’s not that TV isn’t an influential tool, but that it’s almost invariably wrong, and they find themselves fighting the erroneous assumptions that law students bring to the classroom.  If law students don’t get it, what chance do others have in recognizing that their entire framework of criminal law is totally off base?

On the other side, Anne Reed at Deliberations posts about the juror who twitted about the $12 million verdict, and proclaims that jurors and social media are with us forever.  Rather than assume that it can be controlled, is it time to assume that it is part of normal juror life, and is happening whether we know it or not?

Between television, the internet and social media, have we lost any pretense at control over the jury pool?  Is it time to abandon our beloved legal fictions and come to grips with the fact that jurors are beyond our control?

Discuss amongst yourselves. 

The Real Risk is the Loss of Childhood Happiness

When I was growing up, the kid who lived in the house behind me was given a dirt bike for Christmas one year.  It was the coolest thing I had ever seen, and I envied that dirt bike like nobody’s business.  Whenever he took it out for a ride around his house, I would race out the back door to watch, hoping that he would let me go for a ride.  Every once in a while he did, but he mostly made me stand there watching him ride.  It tore my child’s heart to shreds to be so close to such extreme fun and be denied.

I begged my parents for a dirt bike.  Begged.  To no avail.  I was told that they were terribly dangerous, and that kids died from riding dirt bikes.  DIED!  Did I want to die?  Well, I was definitely ready to take the risk, but still they wouldn’t budge.  It just wasn’t to be for me, and the roaring sound emanating from my neighbor was like a knife in the heart every day. 

Thankfully, our government has made certain that no other child will have to suffer the sound of fun coming from the house next door, nor ignore the risk of imminent death.  Of course, my parents feared a crash that would rip my limbs off and leave my head rolling in the gutter.  That isn’t the risk the government finds compelling.  No, it is the risk of lead.

Walter Olson has tracked in excruciating detail the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act at Overlawyered, with its impact felt from books to  thrift stores to dirt bikes.  While the forces that favor the elimination of lead products in the hands of children following the lead-paint debacles of the past couple of years may be well-intended, and even have a very good point when applied with some level of thoughtfulness and constraint, the application of the CPSIA to dirt bikes is not merely inane, but just plain unAmerican.

The point is driven home by the Consumer Products Safety Counsel’s refusal to exempt dirt bikes from application of the CPSIA:


On Wednesday the CPSC confirmed that (per its lawyers’ advice) it was turning down an exemption for youth power vehicles, in that it could not certify what the law requires it to certify, namely that keeping them legal would not result in “any” absorption of lead by a person under 12, ever, or any other risk to public safety or health.

Now there are some sound arguments to be made about why children under 12 should not be riding around on dirt bikes.  Of course, no one would make those arguments if they were ever a boy under 12 who was forced to listen to the roar of a dirt bike coming from the neighbor’s. but there are some people who can suck the fun out of anything.  But of all the potential, theoretical, arguable risks one might raise, the absorption of lead is not one of them.  No, not at all, under any circumstance.  Not even close.

Put aside the concern that the application of the CPSIA to the motorbike industry has rendered $100 million in inventory unmarketable.  This goes far beyond mere dirt bikes, and to the giant sucking sound you hear when you consider the basic American notion of the pursuit of happiness.  In the name of absolute safety, they are sucking happiness out of our country.

The fact that absolute safety for children can never be achieved eludes those who believe that it is theory duty to try.  In their knee-jerk reaction to any threat, no matter how distant or improbable, the proponents of absolute safety demand that the government enact a law to preclude it.  As with the mindless use of criminal statutes to attempt to prohibit any act that might conceivably cause harm, whether real or imagined, the advocates of consumer protection cannot bear the idea that perfect safety might be at risk from any cause, no matter how minuscule or hypothetical.

Here is an unfortunate reality:  No matter how many laws are passed, or how many things that bring pleasure or richness into the lives of children are wiped from the face of the earth, some children will still get hurt.  There will never be a way to reduce our world to one of perfect safety from harm to a child. 

This is not to suggest that children be put at obvious risk, or that items that present a meaningful risk of harm be placed in the stream of commerce under a “buyer beware” philosophy.  This is especially true when the risk is latent, though latency is always subject to dumbing down to meet the needs of the most brick-like parent.  This is not a screed against child safety, but a challenge to the great sucking sound that will deny children the ability to run as fast as they can and risk falling down and skinning their knee.  It can and will happen, but there is no life for a child if government “fixes” the problem.  Don’t even ask about the risk of climbing trees.

No one want to see a child hurt.  But do we want to see childhood joyless?  There is risk in being a child, doing the things that children like to do.  No one, no government, can ever eliminate all risk and stop any harm from coming to a child, no matter how many laws, rules, regulations are imposed.  But they can legislate the joy out of childhood.  Is this really the life we hope to give to our children?  Will children be forced to live in a bubble before the forces of absolute safety are satisfied? 

I will never forget the few times that my neighbor let me ride his dirt bike.  It’s one of those childhood memories I cherish.