Not that it’s rare for a Circuit Court to acquit a defendant for the abject failure of the government to prove a crime, but to give the prosecutor a good “dressing down” in the process is something that shouldn’t be missed. Even if the crime is the alleged mislabeling of salad dressing.
In United States v. Farinella, a 13 page decision from the 7th Circuit, Judge Posner takes us on a whirlwind tour of the world of salad dressing labeling, all the while exposing how the government played bait and switch with the very heart of its argument, that the “best if eaten by” date is the same thing as the “expiration date” on the label. As it turns out, it’s not, and the salad dressing has a shelf life similar to that of Twinkies.
There are some gems in this decision that could well be applied to many cases, and are worth keeping in your bag of tricks for future reference. At one point, the government called an FDA “expert” to testify what he thought the law should be. To this, the Court said:
If there is a requirement that the FDA’s approval must be obtained before a “best when purchased by” date may be changed, it would, to be a lawful predicate of a criminal conviction, have to be found in some statute or regulation, or at least in some written interpretive guideline or opinion, and not just in the oral testimony of an agency employee. It is a denial of due process of law to convict a person of a crime because he violated some bureaucrat’s secret understanding of the law. “The idea of secret laws is repugnant. People cannot comply with laws the existence of which is concealed.” Torres v. INS, 144 F.3d 472, 474 (7th Cir. 1998); see George Campbell Painting Corp. v. Chao, 463 F. Supp. 2d 184, 190-91 (D. Conn. 2006); Oppenheimer Mendez v. Acevedo, 388 F. Supp. 326, 335 (D.C. Puerto Rico 1974).(My emphasis, because it would be wrong to miss the incisive use of the word “bureaucrat” in any judicial opinion.) Certainly a classic point of law, applicable to so many other things, given the pervasive government reliance on “expert” opinion. And we’re not done yet.
After noting that the AUSA mislead the jury by arguing “expiration date” rather than “best by” date, Judge Posner related a question from oral argument (proof yet again that oral argument is always worth your time):
And finally comes the Court’s coup de grâce:We asked the government’s lawyer at argument what an appropriate sanction for the prosecutor’s misconduct might be. We are not permitted to reverse a judgment on the basis of a lawyer’s misconduct that would not have caused a reasonable jury to acquit, United States v. Hasting, 461 U.S. 499, 505-06 (1983); United States. v. Boyd, 55 F.3d 239, 241-42 (7th Cir. 1995), but in this case, had the government presented enough evidence to sustain a conviction, we would have reversed the judgment and ordered a new trial on the basis of the prosecutor’s misconduct. That sanction is not available only because the government presented so little evidence that the defendant is entitled to an acquittal. That does not detract from the gravity of the prosecutor’s misconduct and the need for an appropriate sanction. The government’s appellate lawyer told us that the prosecutor’s superior would give her a talking-to. We are not impressed by the suggestion.
Since we are directing an acquittal on all counts, the sentencing issues are academic and we do not address them, beyond expressing our surprise that the government would complain about the leniency of the sentence for a crime it had failed to prove
True, it was only salad dressing, but for any white collar practitioner dealing with fraud that’s predicated upon the government’s “interpretation”, this decision is gem. And a fun read to boot.
