Author Archives: SHG

Mothers Are Scary When They’re Deadly

The 3 month sentence Tammy Gibson was supposed to start a blawgversation at Doug Berman’s invitation, but it looks like only SJ and Sex Crimes took him up on it.  Even Doug wasn’t sufficiently moved to continue his own conversation.  But that doesn’t mean that others didn’t have something to say.  Quite the contrary.

At Parent Dish, the post on Tammy Gibson unleashed a torrent of comments, over 450 as of this writing, which did not merely support Tammy Gibson’s decision to attack a “sex offender” with a baseball bat, but vehemently urged her to make sure she did the job right the next time around.

For those who maintain the image of mom baking an apple pie, think terminator.  There is no issue about whether the mere mention of the word “sex offender” might not mean pedophile.  There is no question about whether maternal vigilantism in the absence of harm is justified.

The kinder, gentler moms merely want to castrate them all.  The meaner ones want to kill them all and eliminate them from our midst. 

The deal is, they aren’t taking any chances.  Once labeled a sex offender, it doesn’t matter why, what the person did, or whether he poses a threat.  He’s dead meat to the moms.  They aren’t interested in explanations, discussions, arguments.  If there is any chance, no matter how theoretical, that someone might conceivably pose a threat to their children, screw ’em.  They are dead.

Now I, perhaps more than most, have no tolerance for child molesters.  I don’t represent them, even though some of my peers think I’m wrong to refuse their cases.  But that does not mean that we take a fairly wide swathe of society, place a label on them that bears little relation to any threat to a child, and brand them for life as not merely subhuman, but the object of hatred and violence of well-intended but deadly mommies.

The ramifications of the attitudes expressed in the comments at Parent Dish are quite serious, and deeply disconcerting.  As SORA grows, cops hand out fliers and the mindless fear of locals grows out of control, are we due for a bloodbath across this nation?

When the mothers of our nation are ready to slaughter a group of human beings “just to be sure,” perhaps it’s time to revisit just how much hatred our government is prepared for foster in the name of fear and safety. 

Lawyers Against the Blawgosphere

Over the past year, we’ve had a number of “run-ins” with lawyers who were clearly unfamiliar with the blawgosphere, how it worked and how best to accomplish their purposes.  The latest salvo has just come to conclusion at Patterico’s Pontifications, where Kathy Kelly, the lawyer for Jimmie Duncan, the evidence against whom was the subject of an expose by Radley Balko at Reason, threw a hissy fit.

It seems that Patrick Frey at Patterico, by digging a little deeper into the story, stepped on Kelly’s toes, at least as far as Kelly was concerned:



I have heard from someone, however: the defendant’s lawyer, who is threatening to file a (completely baseless) State Bar complaint against me.

 The lawyer is Kathy Kelly of the Capital Post Conviction Project of Louisiana. That organization represents Jimmie Duncan, the Death Row inmate described in the article. In this comment to my original post, she implies that I have committed State Bar violations (which I most certainly have not) and threatens to file a State Bar complaint if I continue to contact witnesses on the case — in other words, if I continue to exercise my First Amendment rights. Excerpt from her comment:



As a lawyer you should no that you have no business talking to witnesses when you are not a party to this case. Cease immediately or I will file an ethics complaint with your state bar.


I told her : “I don’t intend to cease exercising my First Amendment right to speak about matters of legitimate public concern because some lawyer who is mis[re]presenting the content of my post threatens a bogus complaint to my State Bar.” I asked her to tell me what rule I had supposedly violated and she suddenly decided she had better things to do. After publicly implying that I had committed an ethical violation, she said : “I’m not discussing this publicly.” I demanded that she identify a specific rule I violated, or retract her comment, and she said that she was too busy to address the issue any more.


Naturally, the blawgosphere didn’t take well to Kelly’s threat, bringing the Streisand Effect down upon her.  To her great credit, Kathy Kelly, after taking a deep breath, realized that her attack was ill-advised, and offered this response :



To Mr. Frey, Regarding my comments as Mr. Duncan’s counsel this past Sunday. Do I regret it “Yes”. Does it appear I was wrong “Yes”. My intent was not to harm your reputation but I had concerns on protecting my client’s right to a fair hearing. I acted rashly without thinking about it first.


I’m willing to admit that I was wrong on implying you committed any type of ethic violations. Being criticized on blog sites doesn’t bother me. I agree with the fact it was foolish. My only hesitation on posting anything on your blog is that it will only continue to focus attention on me and continue this instead of ending it. The focus should be on Mr. Duncan’s case not me. I will not read or post any more comments on your site.


By de-escalating matters, Kelly showed both a level of maturity and tactical sense that far too few lawyers seem to possess.  I’ve seen far too many lawyers, all full of their self-importance and perceived power, trying to bully their way through the blawgosphere.  What clearly permeates these misguided efforts is that fact that they don’t grasp the fact that they are powerless to stop the flow of information, and that the blawgosphere, if it so pleases, could destroy them.  Usually they get a slap on the wrist initially, but the consequences become increasingly serious as they persist in their efforts to bulldoze their way through.

Granted, reading something on the internet can inflame a lawyer, who by nature feels compelled to lash out at any offense, real or perceived.  Often, they lack the depth of appreciation to allow them to understand exactly what they are dealing with, since they see only a handful of written words without the benefit of context that comes from a broader understanding of the blawgosphere.  But lawyers, particularly young lawyers, often let then fingertips move far faster than their brains.  After all, they are lawyers; they can demand anything and get it.

Well no, they can’t.  And if they make the mistake of thinking that by attacking someone in the blawgosphere they are playing on a level field, then they are not merely ignorant, but courting disaster.  Kathy Kelly was roundly castigated for her threats to Frey, and had she persisted, could well have ended up one of the blawgosphere’s top goats.  Instead, the kerfluffle will be forgotten and the issue will again focus on Balkos’ bad guys rather than someone who made herself appear to be twinkie. 

This brings me to an email received yesterday from a fellow who says he’s David Wold, with a hotmail address.  For those who may not remember, the name David Wold made blawgospheric fame with an eBay auction for his DePaul Law School diploma.  More than a year later comes this request cum demand that SJ, the ABA Journal, as well as a number of other blawgs, remove posts relating to the auction.  Was the auction a bold and controversial commentary on the value of a law school education, or a “malicious misrepresentation?”


My name is David Wold.  It has recently been brought to my attention that roughly a year ago each of your corresponding sites has published or republished an article related to a story that I attempted to sell my law degree on Ebay for the purposes of promoting an adult site.  I would like to make clear that I have never and would never attempt to sell my law degree.  I did not create the referred to listing nor write the accompanying argument.  This listing was created by an individual attempting to cause some kind of public embarrassment on my part by associating my adult work with my legal education.  While it is true that I do run an adult projects and work in the adult industry as well as having a law degree from DePaul University, I would never link an argument about education with a ridiculous auction listing in order to promote a web project unrelated to either.  Nor do I wish to devalue the very degree that helped give me the opportunities to do the work that I have done.


I have attempted to find the hosting sites that make reference to this defaming article, and would like to respectfully request that these articles/blog entries be removed from your sites.  I am not seeking an apology, and, frankly, would prefer the story not be revisited.  Below are links to your corresponding articles.  Your cooperation in attempting to correct this malicious misrepresentation would be greatly appreciated.


Sincerely,
David Wold


While the waters are now perpetually muddied as to whether this David Wold or that David Wold is the real David Wold, the email creates yet a new controversy that compels airing, likely the last thing this David Wold wanted.  What really puts this email on the map is the line, “I am not seeking an apology.”  And why would anyone consider apologizing, or for that matter, care what you’re seeking?  But the fact that the eBay auction most assuredly happened, and that the controversy swirling around it was both newsworthy and meaningful to lawyers, was the reason why it received such attention.  Frankly, the name David Wold could have been replaced with any other as far as the blawgosphere was concerned.  He wasn’t the point.

What this shows, yet again, is a misunderstanding of how the blawgosphere, and the internet, works.  If you are really David Wold, then here’s a bit of information:  If I was to delete the post now, it would continue to exist forever, cached in perpetuity.  That deal is done, and there’s nothing your could say to undo it, nor anything I could do to change it.

But more importantly, your email served to do the exact opposite of what you hoped of it.  No one in the blawgosphere holds any malice toward you, or bears some responsibility for whatever harm you believe you suffered.  Why would you take the approach that you aren’t seeking an apology?  Up to that line, I considered your request to be in good faith.  Your lame attempt to suggest that the blawgosphere did you a wrong, but that you are bigger person than to expect rhetorical recompense, is precisely the sort of this that makes your effort blow up in your face.

There are lessons to be learned here.  The blawgosphere can’t be bullied into submission, and if you become enough of an annoyance, you too can be twinkified.  As Kathy Kelly learned, take a deep breath when you think that someone has maligned you before going off half-cocked.  The blawgosphere isn’t out to get you, but it isn’t particularly forgiving if you think you are going to bully it into submission.  Again, take a deep breath. 

Drop the Barbie and Step Away

From Ken at Popehat, West Virginia House of Delegates Member Jeff Eldridge has offered legislation to criminalize sale of Barbie dolls.



H. B. 2918
(By Delegate Eldridge)
[Introduced March 3, 2009; referred to the Committee on the Judiciary.]


A BILL to amend the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, by adding thereto a new article, designated §47-25-1, relating to banning the sale of “Barbie” dolls and other dolls that influence girls to be beautiful.


Be it enacted by the Legislature of West Virginia:
That the Code of West Virginia, 1931, as amended, be amended by adding thereto a new article, designated §47-25-1, to read as follows:
ARTICLE 25. BARBIE DOLLS.
§47-25-1. Unlawful sale of Barbie dolls.
It shall be unlawful in the state to sell “Barbie” dolls and other similar dolls that promote or influence girls to place an undue importance on physical beauty to the detriment of their intellectual and emotional development.


NOTE: The purpose of this bill is to ban the sale of Barbie dolls and other similar dolls.


The glib reaction to this bit of obvious silliness is that West Virginia must have solved all of its serious problems, leaving legislators with too much time on their hands.  But the fact that this proposed law doesn’t “have a lot of teeth” brings me small comfort.  The use of criminal law for purposes of social engineering has become pervasive.  While initially, laws may have been thoughtfully designed to promote positive public policy, it has since devolved into a blunt object to appease political interest groups and obtain personal political recognition for their sponsors.

Ken is unimpressed with Eldridge’s purpose:


The proposal that Barbie dolls hurt little girls by forcing them to dwell on beauty over brains is a debatable one. I played with G.I. Joe dolls and Star Wars “action figures” as a child, and it does not appear that I was imprinted with the notion that martial prowess reigns supreme over intellect. Although I have worked hard to look like Jabba the Hutt.

This is the first, and likely the last, time I will mention Jabba the Hutt at Simple Justice.  But the idea that someone will propose a Jabba the Hutt Law doesn’t strike me as too far-fetched.  Sympathies to Ken, by the way.

The reason I choose to see this as more than a joke is that we have been inundated with laws, criminal laws, that are designed to give the appearance that government is doing something about a popularly perceived problem.  Note that these laws don’t give rise to a civil cause of action, or regulatory control, but criminal sanctions.  Consider whether Eldridge is really suggesting that the cops shoot to kill the store manager who refuses to take down the Barbie display in the mall window?

At one point in time, long ago in a galaxy far away, the creation of crimes was reserved for things that caused sufficient actual harm that they warranted punishment.  Legislators understood that the creation of crimes was reserved for only serious matters, and they did not try to burden the penal codes with daily annoyances, odd-ball situations or, as here, social engineering.  To do so would not only be considered inappropriate, but would reduce the legislator’s credibility to zero in the eyes of more serious colleagues.  This has all changed, to the point where someone would be goofy enough to propose outlawing Barbie without fear of never being invited to lunch again.

Eldridge claims that his purpose in proposing such a silly law, with no chance of passage, is to “start the discussion” about promoting physical beauty over intelligence.  Ken rips his head off for this:


A closely related specimen of legislative self-indulgence is the “I just want to start a dialogue” law — the bill proposed not out of a reasonable hope that it will be passed, but out of a hope that it will inspire discussion of some social issue the legislator wants to talk about. Once again, such legislators promote contempt for the rule of law — they use the legislative process as a plaything or a soapbox, not as a rule-bound tool for the people’s business.

Taking this in a somewhat different direction, the games played with penal law is making it impossible for anyone to know whether their conduct is lawful or criminal.  Yesterday’s lawful, and often universally accepted, conduct is tomorrow’s crime.  And real people get prosecuted for it, and often go to prison for it, despite the fact that it was common conduct before and hardly crosses any moral imperative.  Other times, these crimes when intentional are already covered by existing offenses, but include a twist that criminalizes accidental (which by definition means unintended) harm, another new frontier of the penal law for legislators who feel compelled to prove their bona fides.

Politics is indeed the place to have discussions about good policy and bad, and how government can promote the public interest and satisfy the needs of citizens.  But the resort to creating crimes as a regular practice, even silly ones like this Barbie law, as the mechanism has proven dangerous and destructive. 

We already have enough crimes to guarantee, if one looks hard enough, that every man and woman in this country can be found to be a criminal.  Do we really need to add children as well?

But What About Ruth?

When Ira Lee Sorkin tried to sneak in the bit about Bernie Madoff’s wife having a few assets of her own, some eyebrows were raised.  Actually, most eyebrows were raised, together with some fists.  It was an audacious move.  You gotta love Sorkin’s chutzpah.

According to reports, Ruth Madoff has her own assets that amount to about $70 million, including the prison/apartment where Bernie sits and waits.  It’s nice of Ruth to let him use it, considering that he’s absolutely destroyed any chance of her getting invited to any decent parties in the near future.

But after reading a half dozen reports of Ruth’s small wealth (in comparison to Bernie’s vast one), one question keeps bugging me.  How did she manage to amass such a nest egg? 

I know I’ve tried, and it hasn’t happened for me.  I showed Mrs. SJ the story and told her what a disappointment she’s been as a wife.  That Ruth Madoff must be one heckuva gal, since the only thing I can find about her was that she did some bookkeeping for Bernie’s business.

Now if Ruth was teaching people how to make some quick cash, I wonder what she would tell them.  Marry Bernie? 

Now it’s absolutely possible that Ruth has assets.  And it’s certainly possible that Bernie accumulated assets untainted by this case, though those assets might be subject to a couple of potential claims floating around out there.  But if Ira Sorkin is thinking that he’s just going to slip this past Judge Stanton, and nobody is going to notice, then he doesn’t know Judge Stanton.  Or the thousands of people who want Bernie’s head on a platter.

Ruth, you got some ‘splainin’ to do.

Wanna Be A Solo (or, Solo is the New Black)

For as long as I can remember, the goal of those nerds who would rather sleep in the library than throw back a beer bong with their “study” group was a signing bonus at Biglaw, the surest path to wealth and prestige the law had to offer.  But the massive associate and even partner layoffs, collapses of firms whose namesakes had died more than century ago, have changed all this overnight.  As Bob Ambrogi wrote at Legal Blog Watch, Solo is the New Soho.


If solo practice was a neighborhood, trendy restaurants would be opening next to long-established pizza parlors and coffee shops. A small art gallery would be setting up shop next to the old corner bar. Apartment buildings would be turning into co-ops and young urban professionals would be snapping them up. As big firms slice jobs, solo is suddenly hip, it seems.

Suddenly, solos are cool and happening.  Not so much because we’re cutting edge, but as we’re Plan B and Plan A just failed.  So those whose efforts at Biglaw prominence were unceremoniously thwarted need to come up with some philosophical justification for doing what losers do, go solo, while making it appear that they aren’t the stone rejects of the profession.  Whatever makes them sleep better at night.

With timing that couldn’t be better, Susan Cartier Leibel has announced that her baby, Solo Practice University, will open its virtual doors on March 20.  If ever there was a gap that needed filling, this was it.  Susan was pushing the solo practice envelope long before it became hip to do so, but is now positioned to be the solo practice messiah to all the Biglaw Philistines who need to find something to occupy their hands rather than sit home grasping the Wii controller and nunchuck.

The question remains, in light of this unanticipated turn of events, whether Susan’s brainchild will do the trick.  During the time since SPU was hatched and now, Susan has grown displeased with me.  She got angry with me when I was mean to one of her marketing buddies.  Even more so when I failed to show blind support of the hype behind SPU.  I went from being the first Professor at SPU to the first former Professor.  After that, Susan started to ignore me, even “unfollowing me on twitter.  I was now the enemy.

But that doesn’t mean that I harbor any anger toward Susan and SPU.  To the contrary, it has the potential to offer something that can not be found anywhere else, and it comes at a time when it is needed more than ever.  Rather than see myself as its critic, I see myself as its conscience.  On the verge of the solo explosion, will Solo Practice University be ground zero for a new breed of competent, passionate and excellent solo practitioners, or the gutter of sleazy lawyer marketing?

There is an extremely disturbing aspect that smacks one in the face at SPU.  The majority of the faculty consists of legal marketers.  Not merely legal marketers, but legal marketers who earn their keep selling to young lawyers desperate for financial success.  Like the sort of lawyers who might be inclined to become the students of SPU.  What lessons do these legal marketers plan to teach?

Not everyone on the faculty fits into this category, and there are some, like Carolyn Elefant and Jay Foonberg, who have dedicated great effort in the nuts and bolts of solo practice management.  To sit at their knee and learn what it takes to open and operate a solo law practice is worth the price of admission.  But will they be enough to counteract the far heavier weight of hucksters and salesmen masquerading as the solo practitioner’s best friend and savior?

The other side of SPU was intended to work on the substantive practice areas where solos plan to focus.  For the newbie lawyer and Biglaw emigre alike, committing malpractice out of the box is hardly a good way to make a name for themselves,  SPU has had significant difficulty in some substantive areas, with few on the faculty equipped to work the substantive end of the law.  Some have been hyped with a string of alluring adjectives to cover the scent of a turd beneath.  Some of the faculty would do far better to enroll as students themselves, yet they are puffed as experts in some amorphous way. 

Some are just “friends” and, frankly, have little to offer, whether because they have yet to learn how to be a solo practitioner themselves or have never attained any reasonable degree of success that would enable them to pass anything of value along.  Being an SPU faculty member is just another way to market themselves, as they must be worthy because Susan has made them an SPU Professor.  Just a tad circular, but logical reasoning isn’t the cornerstone of marketing.

This can be worse, than unhelpful, bordering on the dangerous by pushing the enthusiastic solo wannabe down the wrong road.  Attributed credibility is not a substitute for competence.

So it’s with a mix of both hope and trepidation that I watch as Solo Practice University greets its inaugural class.  Will it teach students that the only thing a solo practitioner needs to do is market the crap out of themselves, hype, hype, hype (and it wouldn’t hurt to retain the services of their professor to show them they way)?  Is solo practice only about getting clients, and puffing one’s virtues unmercifully to do so? 

Unfortunately, many believe exactly that. Who cares if they know what to do with the client once they get him to call.  Who cares if they haven’t the slightest clue how to go about the representation of a real client in a real court of law.  Who cares if the sum total of the lawyers skill set is the ability to promote themselves on a website or blawg.  I care.  Your client will care.  Your malpractice carrier will care.  The disciplinary committee will care.

This is not only a crossroads for new lawyers who want a different life than Biglaw had to offer, and Biglaw refugees who see no future sitting in a law library for a couple hundred grand a year.  This is a crossroads for Susan Cartier Leibel, her dream of Solo Practice University about to come true and a test of whether it will fulfill the purpose ascribed or be shown up as Solo Marketing University, a one-stop informercial for a handful of legal marketers who want to feed off the bones of desperate lawyers sucked in by the promise of going solo. 

As long as Susan remembers that being a lawyer is more than marketing, hype and self-promotion, SPU can serve a vital purpose to potential solo practitioners.  This won’t be done with adjectives and hyperbole, but a real focus on the practice of law rather than the marketing of lawyers.  I hope Susan is listening, even though she doesn’t like me anymore, and I hope SPU fills the gap.

Have Laptop, Will Travel

The saga of the searchable laptop continues with a decision out of the District of Arizona in United States v. Cotterman, via Orin at VC.  When last we left our border searches of laptop computers, our government had formalized its policy to seize at will, without probable cause, and detain as long as necessary.  After all, it was a border search and, despite the total lack of nexus between the rationale for permitting a warrantless search at the border and the government’s purpose in inspecting laptops for dirty pictures, it did under the dog lick theory.


In the Cotterman case, agents seized a computer at the Mexico-Arizona border and wanted to search it, but they apparently didn’t have a trained analyst nearby. As a result, they let the computer owner go on into the U.S., and in the meantime they drove the computer to a government forensic analyst in Tucson, about 170 miles away. The analyst in Tucson searched the computer two days later and found child pornography.

The Court held that by removing the computer from the place of the seizure to a distant location for the search, the agents lost the benefit of a border search and were required to show cause.


At some point, the discrepancy in time and distance will become so great that it is no longer an extended border search, thus requiring probable cause and a warrant. Again, there is no bright line test, but an examination of the totality of circumstances, including time, distance and law enforcement efforts is required. Alfonso, 759 F.2d at 736; United States v. Sahanaja, 430 F.3d 1049, 1054-1055 (9th Cir.2005). For instance, had the forensic examiner in this case placed the Cottermans electronics equipment at the end of the queue, conducting the examination in a month or two, it could be argued the search was so removed in time as to no longer be an extended border search. We need not reach that question here, where the facts show reasonable diligence and speed in conducting the computer forensic examination. Therefore, the Government need only show reasonable suspicion, not probable cause, to justify the search in this case.

Try as I might, I can’t make any sense of this rationale.  While search and seizure ordinarily happens at the same relative time and place, it seems that the court has accepted the proposition that the critical act is the seizure.  If the seizure was lawful at the border, and that no cause is required for the seizure, then any spatial and temporal issues are subject only to reasonableness review.  Adding more confusion, applying the markedly unhelpful “totality of the circumstances” test, the court then inexplicably waters down its own point by holding that mere reasonable suspicion is require, rather than probable cause, when they moved the laptop 170 miles away.

It seems that the court would have been on far firmer ground to conclude that the free ride given to border searches should require that both search and seizure happen contemporaneously, and that any need by the government for distant experts is the government’s problem, not the traveler whose laptop has been seized without cause.  Why the traveler should be denied his property for a moment longer than necessary remains unexplained, except by governmental convenience.  Then again, so much of our law is grounded on making things more convenient for the government that we’ve gotten pretty used to this as an explanation and rarely bother to question it as a rationale.

Of course, the true issue is the propriety of seizing laptops at the border for reasons wholly disconnected from the reason for border searches in the first place, but let’s not harp today on remembering the rubric while forgetting the rationale.  Let’s instead focus on how one bad idea breeds broader confusion and further irrationality. 

When Cotterman was allowed entry into the Land of the Free, it was sans laptop.  Whether his laptop sat in a room at the border or went by pigeon to a computer analyst a thousand miles away seems to be of absolutely no consequence to Cotterman.  Either way, his laptop was out of his hands and he was denied possession and use of it.  While the temporal component may make a difference to the person denied his property, the spatial component doesn’t seem to have any impact at all.

On the other hand, it seems as if the most obvious comparison, unmarked pills seized from a traveler at the border, was ignored.  Are they legal or illicit.  Are they prescribed or abused.  Do the border agents take the traveler’s word for what they are, or do they find out for sure.  The true content requires a chemist’s attention.  As most borders lack a constantly available chemist, substances seized are sent to labs for testing.  Does this ruling apply to limit the distance to the lab where such substances are sent?  Does it matter to the traveler (or the court) where the lab is physically located when determining the constitutionality of the seizure?  Not as far as I’m aware.

While laptop computers continue to strain the developed legal concepts around search and seizure, and while courts still can’t bring themselves to address the root of the problem, unrestrained border searches, we will continue to find courts trying desperately to ram square pegs into round holes.  Will a circuit, or even the Supremes, take this issue by the horns and address it at the point where the problem arises, or will courts continue to try to sneak around the back to circumvent the problem?  Time will tell, but I’m not hopeful.

Proof By Trick

Via Walter Olson at Overlawyered, is it wrong for an attorney who happens to possess the skills to perform illusions to use them in summation?



In one trick, [Steven] Leventhal [of Philadelphia’s Reger Rizzo & Darnall], who works exclusively for defendants, said he slowly folds a $1 bill while explaining to the jury that the parts of the plaintiff’s case just don’t tie together. When he unfolds the bill, he said, the astonished jury sees a bizarre bill that appears to have been cut apart and pasted together the wrong way, with the corners in the middle.


In another trick, Leventhal said, the slowly folded $1 bill is revealed to be a $100 bill and then, to the jury’s collective amazement, changes back to a $1 bill.


This isn’t as new an idea as one might think.  An old-time New York criminal defense lawyer, Mel Sachs, used to do tricks with a red ball in front of the jury.  It could have been used as a great means of showing the difference between reality and perception, and the limitations of human perception in the face of apparent certainty.  Mel just liked doing tricks.  The jury was often entertained, right up until the moment it returned the verdict of guilty. 

Steven Leventhal believes that his ability to perform “magic” shouldn’t be used against him.

“That the undersigned counsel opted to travel the globe to learn a special set of performance skills rather than wasting his brain cells drinking his summers away at the Jersey Shore should not be held against him,” Leventhal wrote.

His point is well taken.  Should the lawyer with greater rhetorical skills be handicapped because his adversary was a fixture on LBI?  We bring with us our bag of tricks, the skills we pick up throughout the course of our lives, when we walk into the courtroom, and we use whatever we have in the bag to do our job.  Leventhal has the ability to make a point through the use of illusion.  Others can do so through the use of vivid imagery, or excessive police power.  Why is one better or worse than another?

While I have my doubts about the use of illusion as an effective tool before a jury, particularly since most jurors are already aware of its existence (who hasn’t seen David Copperfield?), but distinguish an entertaining show from their similarly well understood belief that witnesses are capable of testifying truthfully and accurately, and the generic argument against the limitations of human perception fail when compared to the specific arguments of the individual who sat before the jury and gave testimony.

But having never seen Leventhal try a case, I am hardly in a position to question his effectiveness in his use of illusion to make a point.  As for his adversaries, there’s nothing stopping them from buying a magic kit at the local Walmart and boning up on their trial skills, if they are so deeply worried that Leventhal’s abilities will crush them.

The point is, we bring every skill we possess into the courtroom, and we use them as effectively as possible. This is what we should do, and there’s absolutely nothing wrong with it.  For the record, whining about one’s adversary is not a skill.

Illegal Use of the Hands

It’s not as if the San Francisco 49ers still have Joe Montana throwing passes, so they needed to do something to bring a little interest to the team.  Apparently, the best they could come up with is the pat down of patrons as they enter the stadium, via Turley.  Two season ticket holders, Daniel and Kathleen Sheehan took issue with the touching and sued.

The obvious legal response to the condition of entrance being a search by a private entity is consent, and that no one entering the stadium has a reasonable expectation of privacy.  Buy a ticket and go to a game, and the sports fan implicitly consents to a pat down on the way in.  Many fans approve of the search, preferring the safety of an unarmed audience to football fans left to their own sensibilities.  Think Cleveland.

At the trial and appellate level, the 49ers demurred, and prevailed.  Fortunately, they didn’t even need to get a first down.  The California Supreme Court, however, held that the whole notion wasn’t so crazy as to sustain the demurrer, and remanded for additional facts.

People certainly have, in general, a right not to have others pat them down.

The factual record of this case — which consists solely of the complaint — does not establish what the competing social interests are. Presumably, the NFL, and ultimately the 49ers’, adopted the policy to enhance spectator safety, but the record does not establish this or explain why the NFL believed the policy was appropriate. As evidenced by the circumstance that the pursuit of safety, like the pursuit of privacy, is a state constitutional right, the competing social interest of enhancing safety is substantial. Those who provide private entertainment venues, including the 49ers’ at NFL football games, have a substantial interest in protecting the safety of their patrons. But when the security measures substantially threaten a privacy right, courts review the policy for reasonableness under the circumstances. Here, we cannot do so because the record does not establish the circumstances of, or the reasons for, the patdown policy. The 49ers’ have not yet given any justification for its policy.

As a practical matter, I remember the first time I entered Giants Stadium following the institution of the search rule.  Nowhere on my ticket did it say that everyone entering the stadium would be searched.  Even if it did, I wouldn’t have known until after I had purchased my ticket, meaning that I was out the cost before I would be aware of the policy and capable of making an informed choice of whether to be searched or to sit in the den and watch on TV.  The idea of not watching the game was simply unacceptable.

It was somewhat shocking to have some fat guy from Jersey in a jacket that said “Security” on the back rub his hands against me.  Not quite threatening, but more gross.  The first time it happened, I was taken aback.  It was over very quickly and I went in to watch the Giants do what they do best.   I wasn’t happy about it, but similarly wasn’t sufficiently incensed to make it a big issue.

Did my entry into the stadium manifest consent?  Not a chance.  Did I find the reasoning for the search sufficiently heart-warming to take comfort in it?  Not a chance.  Was it just another indignity that came of our desire for safety and protection at the expense of being touched by a fat guy from Jersey?  Yeah, that was it. 

The California Supreme Court’s decision begs an explanation of why the constitutional right to privacy compels scrutiny of the pat down policy of the 49ers football team, a private entity.  Since when are private entities subject to constitutional limitations?  The Supreme Court explains:

“[t]hese generalized differences between public and private action may affect privacy rights differently in different contexts. If, for example, a plaintiff claiming a violation of the state constitutional right to privacy was able to choose freely among competing public or private entities in obtaining access to some opportunity, commodity, or service, his or her privacy interest may weigh less in the balance. In contrast, if a public or private entity controls access to a vitally necessary item, it may have a correspondently greater impact on the privacy rights of those with whom it deals.”

While still a remarkably vague explanation, when a bright line could easily be crafted and would serve well for the purpose of private entities maintaining exclusive or monopolistic control over public opportunities understanding what they are getting into, it’s an adequate explanation for why the 49ers NFL franchise is imbued with a quasi-public obligation to adhere to constitutional limitations. 

The public/private aspect strikes me as the more important issue of the case.  Like baseball, professional football has taken on a degree of consequence of governmental proportions.  Teams represent cities, as if they are indeed sponsored by them.  Teams ask for fan loyalty ( and currency), and use the willingness of its fans to support the widespread use of tax dollars to build stadiums with luxury boxes.  Teams enjoy the benefits of monopolistic turf, while remaining owned by private individuals and groups who are then subject to the dictates of a league.

Clearly, professional sports teams have taken on many of the attributes of government, and thus have little cause to complain that they are subject to some of the limitations imposed on government.  Whether this means that the intrusion of a pat down for the purpose of providing some small degree of safety to such a large gathering of people is justifiable is another matter.  But that the 49ers, as well as all other professional sports teams, cannot avoid scrutiny for their unilateral decision to invade the privacy of entrants to their stadiums to whatever extent they chose is a perfectly reasonable position.

I have no clue what weapons have been found via these searches, and whether it’s a reasonable reaction to a potential threat.  I know that it’s good for the beer sellers inside the stadium, and have a reasonably strong belief that the purpose of searches is really to make sure that no one can bring their leftover tailgate party beverages into the stadium and thereby avoid paying $7 per beer.  But that’s what remand is for.

And if you’ve never been touched by a fat man from Jersey, don’t judge me.

Retaining Millenials (Or Slackoisie Suicide)

Dan Hull at What About Clients? is in far closer touch with his nurturing soul than, say, his mirror image, Ernie Hemingway.  Yet even Hull has his limits, one of which was surmounted upon receipt of a solicitation from Rosie O’Donnell look-alike, Lisa Orrell.  No. not the typical drinks and a cheap motel solicitation that Hull is used to, but one far more insidious.  Lisa Orrell wanted Hull to hire her to learn how to Get a Grip on Gen Y.

Hull was intrigued.  Far too often, he would think he had some millennial firmly by the scruff of the neck, only to have the wriggle out and run away.  Much to his dismay, Hull realized that he misapprehended the type of grip Orrell was talking about.  He felt angry.  Cheated.  Used.  Dirty.

Orrell brazenly offered to explain the facts of life to Hull.

The Millennials were raised with unique values, and are turning many corporate cultures upside down. Companies are being forced to reinvigorate their recruiting strategies to reach and attract this generation, and front line managers are having to step up their game to successfully manage, motivate and retain their Millennial talent.

But what are smart companies doing? And what are successful managers and leaders doing to best communicate and engage with their Millennial team members? The short answer: A lot. Visionary companies, large and small, understand the US is facing a significant labor shortage of skilled and educated workers. To remain competitive, it’s critical to attract and retain Millennial employees.

Reading these words, over and over and over, Hull stiffened up like to board.  He didn’t begrudge Rosie her chance to scam a buck from whatever source she could, Hull being a died in the wool capitalist and true believer in the virtue of female entrepreneurs.  But to usurp his role as visionary was more than he could stand.

Want a vision, Orrell?  [photo of Hull at Geeklawyer party deleted] 

But Hull, ever the mother-lode of calm and contemplation, was not satisfied with mere visceral visuals.  He has chosen to present a counter offer to any entity struggling with the question of how to deal with the slackoisie and to express his thoughts on the receipt of Lisa Orrell’s solicitation:


I would gladly pay $249 just to never get that ad by e-mail again.  My course?  Starting with the interview, tell new recruits to zip it, listen and take notes.  Work-life balance and “I’m special” are officially over.  

Good advice.  No charge.  And new employees may actually do the job for which you’ve hired them without having to give them pretty balloons on Wednesdays.  How’s that for a solution.

Memo to Prosecutors: Cops Think You’re Dolts

When Mike posted about William Michael Olson, the drunken, hot dog stealing prosecutor, flashing his MasterCard and telling the cop who nabbed him that he really didn’t want to mess with him, I had to laugh.  When Ken ran with it, I had to laugh again.  Ken was once one of “them”, young buck filled with the pride of federal power, but clear-sighted enough to know that flashing the shiny thing to the wrong guy could be a problem.

And the problem crops up because it is a problem.  Not that young AUSAs or ADAs regularly get drunk and steal hot dogs.  But that they get into the ordinary sorts of tiffs that the rest of us get into, but have an ace in the hole.  Whether it’s the store clerk who treats you poorly or the pretend traffic cop who is going to tell you where to go, the urge is there to pull out that ace.  After all, you’re one of them.  Better still, you’re a more important one of them than they are, than they realize when they see some young pup in blue jeans looking like you’re average skel.  Not you.  You are a prosecutor.

Sorry to chuckle, but this is one of the schadenfreude things where both criminal defense lawyers and former prosecutors of all sizes have some fun.

Newsflash:  You aren’t a cop.  You aren’t one of them.  They don’t even like you, and take some pleasure in giving you smart-aleck, arrogant little pissant a darn good spanking.  Truth be told, they think you’re naive, obstructionist little dolts.  No, they don’t use the word dolt (ever), but I try to phrase things more kindly here than they do in the precinct.

At the very best, young prosecutors are the conduit through which their important work gets done.  Like little resisters, needing a serious jolt of high tension to push important stuff through your tiny lawyer brain that will never quite grasp how the real world works.  Consider the 18 year detective being lectured by the 18 month prosecutor on why his bust was bad and the evidence sucks.  Oh yes, the detective is so very impressed with your knowledge and experience.  He can’t wait to hear more from you, because you are just so very brilliant.  Or perhaps ram his club down your smarmy throat.  One or the other.

But there you are, shield in your pocket together with the unused condom from freshman year of high school, just begging to be shown.  Can you resist the urge?  Must you resist the urge?  It’s so hard to do when that symbol of power is right there, ready to be flashed and put you a step above mere mortals.  No one can do you harm when you have the shield in your pocket.

Popehat Ken asks a silly question:

Being a government lawyer definitely poses a risk of getting an entitlement complex. But where do people get the sense that it’s a good idea to waive government credentials around to get out of trouble?

Could it possibly come from the hundreds thousands of incidents each year where cops flash their shield to their brethren with the understanding that waving their “government credentials” is more than adequate to get them out of trouble, and indeed does quite well almost every time?

Except that’s about cops.   And they’ve been waiting for the opportunity to give you a little spanking.  You, young prosecutor, are no cop.  Smack.