Author Archives: SHG

The Yoda Factor

A tiff broke out at the Harris County Criminal Law Center.  The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, posted at Defending People that former adversary, now colleague following an unceremonious dumping, Murray Newman, wasn’t “thinking like a criminal defense lawyer.”  Murray, despite his now having three months on the side of truth and justice, took issue.


I guess my question is, who exactly appointed Mark to be the Yoda of the defense bar? Does being President of HCCLA really make him the Gatekeeper for those who are or are not worthy of being a true member of the Defense Bar? Or, is Mark, in his attempt to be provocative, just being a tool (like I was being to Mr. Dyer)? The things that he (and folks like Mr. Judicata) post on the web have questioned my ability to do my job based on what I write.

I think that Murray has made a foundational mistake in his question, as criminal defense lawyers are more akin to feral cats while prosecutors bear a remarkable likeness to lemmings, and Murray’s expectation of nurturing acceptance and support amongst his newest brethren may be somewhat naive. 

Within the criminal defense bar, we disagree with each other all the time.  And unlike the secret society of prosecutors, we tend to say so. Bennett has openly disagreed with me with some frequency, and it never bothers me when he demonstrates publicly that he’s wrong (see how that works, Murray?).  I don’t take it personally.  We’re friends.  Very good friends.  And we can disagree and then joke about it afterward.  No hard feelings.

But the question Murray asks, who made Bennett the Yoda of the defense bar, remains a valid one.  The same could be asked of me, or Gid, or Norm, or Jon, or any other criminal defense lawyer with a keyboard and dream.  We write blawgs.  We pontificate. We scrutinize what others say and do, and comment.  Sometimes our comments support others.  Sometimes our comments disapprove.  Stercus accidit.

Did anyone elect us to be the overseer of the criminal bar, to deem others worthy or not?  Nope.  We neither asked for, nor received, permission to critique anyone else.  If we are Yodas, we are entirely self-anointed. 

But we’re not Yodas.  Our words and thoughts carry no greater imprimatur of worthiness than anyone else’s, except to the extent that anyone bothers to read them.  What’s the sound of a man writing an unread blawg?  The fact that others do come and read the meandering thoughts we put to keyboard, and therefore ascribe a degree of credence to the thoughts we write, isn’t an indication that we believe ourselves to be a Yoda, but that others find some greater or lesser amount of worthiness in what we write to spend a small amount of their time reading it.

Not too long ago, Bennett won the ABA Beauty Pageant for having the Best Criminal Law Blawg in the Universe, a prize he well deserved notwithstanding the dubious authority of the ABA Journal to judge such matters.  To answer Murray’s point, the many people who voted for the Texas Tornado asked him to be Yoda.  The many people who read Defending People asked him to be Yoda.  And still, Bennett is too modest to use his bully pulpit, gently handed to him by those who appreciate his efforts, for self-aggrandizement.  Instead, he just writes about the things that concern him, always true to his belief as to what’s good and bad, right and wrong, and never in fear of attacking a sacred cow or covering up, even for a friend.

So, there are no real Yodas here, and readers can stop reading any time they please.  The second that cease to find the posts interesting, informative, maybe provocative, they can go elsewhere or, if they find them too long and tedious, can even twit.  Whatever suits them.  We have no control over anyone giving credence to our posts, whether due or not, and they will stand or fall on their own merits, and they will be judged again every day.

But Murray, we’re not like prosecutors.  We are tested by each other, challenged and questions and yes, sometimes attacked.  We disagree and dispute, and sometimes we make each other angry.  It happens.  What real criminal defense lawyers do not do is hide behind the pin-striped wall of collegiality to hide our errors, our disagreements, our dispute.   We air them out and then move forward, hopefully the better for it.  This is one of the reasons why not everyone is cut out to be a criminal defense lawyer.  If you want the brotherhood to circle the wagons around you, then become a cop.  If you are capable of facing the challenge, then don’t get all twisted by Bennett disagreeing with you, and face the criticism head on. 

And for the record, there’s much you can learn from Bennett about criminal defense.  He may not always be right, but little you learned as a prosecutor translates into criminal defense.  You could probably use a Yoda, and Bennett would make a very good one for you.  But if you fight with Yoda, you can end up back on the dark side.

Bail and Plea Don’t Mix

The issue of coercive plea bargains has long been a sore point in the course of criminal proceedings, not to mention a frequent subject of discussion here as regular readers are aware.  But in the case of dentist and former Hempstead School Board member, Terry Grant, a variation on this theme was more than the Appellate Division could handle.

The Second Department reversed Grant’s conviction when Justice George Peck, clearly getting annoyed with the defendant for his failure to take up a plea offer of probation and restitution for a 40 count indictment changing, inter alia, grand larceny and insurance fraud:


On December 18, 2006, the court stated that the case was “getting old meaning it’s going to be either disposed of soon or it’s going to be tried soon.” The court then told the defendant that it had reviewed the minutes of the grand jury proceedings and had concluded that, in view of the “overwhelming” proof presented, his chances of prevailing at trial were slim. The court advised the defendant that, if he were convicted after trial, he would be sentenced either “to a short period of upstate time . . . or downstate time for a long period . . . [such as] one year or consecutive nine-month sentences or something like that.” The court stated, however, that, if the defendant were to plead guilty within the next two days, it would order a pre-sentence report and then either sentence him to “probation coupled with restitution” or, if it “had to impose jail,” it would permit him to withdraw the guilty plea. The court warned the defendant that “[t]he time has come for you to fish or cut bait.” The court said it would adjourn the case for the defendant to decide whether or not to accept the plea offer, and that, if he did not, the case would be “farmed out for trial.”

But Grant didn’t bite.  This doesn’t often happen after the judge makes clear that the evidence is “overwhelming” and the defendant isn’t going to win, which has a surprising tendency to crush what little spirit a defendant might have to fight.  As it’s meant to do.

So what does a judge do when his “overwhelming” speech doesn’t fly?


“THE COURT: That’s—that is a situation that has to be addressed and I will address it right now. If he wishes the plea deal, then I will—and he takes this plea, I will continue him in the bail status that he is because if he violates the terms of his bail while he is pending sentence, I will not be bound by my commitment. If he doesn’t take the plea deal today, I’m going to remand him until Monday…

Ahem.  Just in case you missed that little fist in the velvet glove, the offer was take the plea to probation now, or be remanded (held without bail, for those of you who aren’t lawyers) until you do take the plea.  Well, that’s a nasty little deal, isn’t it.

Shockingly, Grant decided to take the deal and remain free, rather than be tossed in jail for his refusal to plead guilty.  Thankfully, this was too much for even the appeals court to tolerate.  After paying due acknowledgment to the role of plea bargaining in the criminal process (yawn), the J.P. Steven Fisher held:


Moreover, it is hardly befitting a legitimate system of plea bargaining to require a defendant, in effect, to choose between, on the one hand, admitting guilt and remaining free, and, on the other, maintaining innocence and going to jail (see People v Sung Min, 249 AD2d 130, 132).

Because an immediate change in the defendant’s bail status is not an appropriate consideration in plea negotiations, when the court threatens to increase bail or remand the defendant unless a guilty plea is entered, any resulting plea cannot be deemed voluntary because the defendant’s decision to plead guilty would no longer represent a free choice among legitimate alternatives. We hold, therefore, that a threatened change in bail status may not be used by the prosecution or the court as a “bargaining chip” to persuade a defendant to plead guilty.

As the view from the trenches is that trial courts have to move a lot cases to meet standards and practices, which means that they need pleas, pleas, pleas to keep the system working, we recognize that judges may forget that defendants still get to decide whether to cop the plea or go to trial without the full coercive weight of the court coming down on their heads.  But that’s no excuse, ever, for using remand as a weapon to force a plea.  Indeed, no plea should ever be forced, as inconvenient as that may be to the lower court judge desperate to push cases through the system.

What’s striking about this decision is not that it came out the right way, but that the use of coercive methods remains alive, well and essentially unchecked.  It’s so common as to be taken for granted by both judges and lawyers, and it’s important that both see a decision like this as a reminder that coercing pleas, even pleas that the judge thinks are really sweet deals and can’t be passed, is antithetical to everything we do.

Yes, cases that take too long clog the system.  Judges who don’t move cases along get a stern “talking to” for their failure to comply with standards and practices.  So what?  If the defendant doesn’t want to take the plea, move the case to trial.  Set a firm trial date and the defendant will have to fish or cut bait.  Nothing wrong with that at all.  The lawyer wants to delay the case because he got paid bupkis or can’t actually try a case and will be humiliated?  Tough noogies.

But using coercion to force a plea, even a good plea, is never the right solution. 

Law School, Revealed

Having written of the ugly underbelly of legal academia, and leaving that nasty taste in one’s mouth, Louisville Law School Dean Jim Chen provides the MoneyLaw pepto bismol to sooth the burn.  His inspiration comes from the movie Breaking Away.


It’s the thirtieth anniversary of one of my all-time favorite movies, Breaking Away. As this musical tribute suggests, it’s an extremely sentimental movie about growing up, intergenerational conflict, class warfare, and an underdog who (in the parlance of European pop music) ultimately gets everything but the girl — and doesn’t crash and burn over that outcome. F. Scott Fitzgerald, eat your heart out. Even though I now run the asylum after having served several unhappy sentences in American higher education, and even though the pickup line par excellence has shifted from Posso ofrirti qualcosa da bere, signorina? to Σ’αγαπώ πολύ, κορίτσι μού, I still love Breaking Away. Always did, always will.

Jim confront’s the retort to Jeffrey Harrison’s challenge that was earlier posted by Co-Op’s own Dave Hoffman, itself in response to Jim’s post about Shane Battier :


The problem with the Moneylaw approach to faculty rewards is that it has failed to fully define what universities are designed to maximize. That’s not an easy question to answer, obviously, and I don’t think there’s just one approach. For a few law schools, like Florida-Coastal, that answer is obvious: to make money. For others, law school’s function as a profit center within a larger university umbrella. . . . But for most law schools, the ultimate criterion of faculty success is just unclear. Giving students a return on their investment is much of it, but it’s not the whole story, since tuition doesn’t pay nearly all the bills. We’ve responsibilities to alumni donors, to the State, to the Bar, etc. Shane Battier just needs to help his team win games. We don’t know what winning is. We don’t know what game we’re playing. And who’s our team again?

Hard questions?  Indeed.  But true to his beliefs and inspiration, Jim provides an answer:



In a MoneyLaw world, law schools win if their students — at graduation, five years out, whenever — don’t ask for a refund. Here’s the thought experiment that explains what I mean: Imagine that every law student, upon matriculation, gets a magic button. At any moment, before and after graduation, if a student wishes that she or he had done anything but go to law school, that student can mash the magic button and thereby get a refund. Of course, the legal education and everything it confers — the degree, the subsequent bar passage (if any), the eventual career (again, if any) — will vaporize in that instance.

For every student who would elect this option, MoneyLaw regards this choice as a devastating loss for the school in question. This is what it means to “win” in higher education: running your school so that your students and graduates never regret having set foot on your campus.

This is not merely a matter of remembering why they erected all those ivy covered buildings, but revolutionary.  It’s all about the students.  That’s what law schools, deans and lawprofs need to worry about.  You make them lawyers and we’ll take it from there.

But I offer a few caveats to put some flesh on those bones.  Stop taking on students because they mean another tuition payment, and start admitting only those kids who truly want to be lawyers, who have a clue what being a lawyer means and what a lawyer does.  You sow the seeds of your own discontent by allowing the law to become the profession of last resort, merely to glom up the student loan loot.

Cut your numbers.  By half.  One factor that brings enormous disrepute, and disappointment, is that we have far more lawyers coming out of law schools than our society can absorb.  When law students emerge from your halls into ours, they will be smacked in the face with this reality and demand that refund.  There won’t be enough high-paying jobs for them.  The jobs won’t be fun.  Their future won’t be secure.  Their loan debt won’t be easily paid off.  They won’t be happy with their choice. You know it.  We know it. They need to know it too.

End the stranglehold of “publish or perish.”  Let’s talk honestly here.  Can anyone really justify law review articles on due process at the Ministry of Magic?  But force lawprofs to write for their meal ticket, and write they will.  It’s not merely embarrassing, but diverts attention and the perks of performance from their now-forgotten purpose, teaching students to be lawyers.  Law schools have long since eschewed the Socratic Method (it hurts students’ feelings) and law taught by lawyers with experience (they aren’t sufficiently scholarly), because they don’t play well at US News and World Reports. 

It’s been made painfully plain to me by a number of my lawprof “pals” in the blawgosphere that you don’t appreciate hearing from real lawyers, telling you how to run your shop or what’s wrong with the Academy.  Tough.  We live with the results of your mess, and the fact that you would prefer to hide in the Ivory Tower than confront the criticism doesn’t mean that the dissatisfaction isn’t happening and isn’t real. 

Instead of sending me “private” emails asking me to tone down the criticism, and that I don’t get it because I can’t possibly understand the pressures of academia, make your case in the comments and see if it can withstand “peer” scrutiny.   If you’ve got the guts.

Law School, Exposed

Jeffrey Harrison has written a scathing exposé at MoneyLaw on what really drives law professors, and the institutions for which they labor, in the age of U.S. News and World Reports rankings.  If you thought it was bad before, read Jeffrey’s post and learn that it’s likely worse than you thought, where the show has become so driven by the applause that they’ve perhaps forgotten why they put on a show at all.

For those of us not fortunate receive a lawprofs’ paycheck at the end of the week, this post may come as a bit of a surprise.  After all, jaded and cynical as lawyers tend to become, most of us harbor a hope that things aren’t as ugly as we think.  But Jeffrey didn’t write this post for our benefit as an expose, but as a challenge to the Academy to remember why they bothered to open law schools and become lawprofs in the first place.  In do so, he held no punches.


Teaching evaluations have result in altering teaching styles not in the direction of ensuring that today’s student is even better prepared than their predecessors but so the teacher can score a higher number. Some faculty obsess over a tenth of a point here and there. I’ve had colleagues freely admit that they decided to be funnier to raise evaluations.

Foreign programs have gone from opportunities for students to products that are sold to them oft times in hopes that the professor will get to go and not because there is some gaping hole in educational opportunities for students.

The writing requirement which I suppose at one time was instituted in hopes that people with freedom to study law would “discover” things much like a scientist has largely been diluted to a hurdle, almost a form of hazing, in order receive tenure. 7000 plus articles a year, few of which are read and even fewer of which are written because of inspiration. Instead there is a great deal of casting about — what can I write about now? Does this edited book of reading count? If is refereed if someone asked me to do it for a symposium?

Grades are inflated in part because, as it has been expressed at my school, 1) We have to give high grades so our students can compete. 2) It hurts the students’ feelings to get a C (and increasingly a . Student ask why not raise grades even more so we can be even more competitive.

All of this is driven by the demand to increase a school’s USNWR ranking, the primary driver of all things law school these days.  Would anyone have imagined that so many smart people, so many respected schools, would drop their trousers on demand to please the USNWR gods?  As Jeffrey analogizes this to the tail that wags the dog:


If you peel away all of the tails, would we find a dog? I assume this means 1) teachers who do their best to produce students to whom they would entrust the fates of future clients — even their parents- regardless of the impact on evaluations, 2) writing only when you feel a pressing need to express something that may actually make a difference, 3) honestly evaluating every program to determine what it produces for the students and other stakeholders, 4) admitting students (at least to a state school) so the subsidization is fairly given to those with promise regardless of the USN&WR-affecting LSAT.

My sense is that we would find a dog. My fear is that it may be a chihuahua.

The deepest shame of this academic disaster is that the deans, the lawprofs, all know this to be true, but lack the guts to take a stand and say “enough”.  While each may individually profess to hate it, none will be the first to stand up and reject rankings as their law school’s driving force.   And apparently, academic collegiality ends at the door to the admissions office, where the first checks start rolling in. 

And if law schools, deans and professors, lack the balls to say “no”, then why not the Biglaw hiring partners who are the intended victims of grade inflation and rankings scams.  Real lawyers in the trenches know that no jury ever reached a verdict based on the school a lawyer attended or the number of law review articles written by his torts prof.  Oh, I forgot.  Your prestigious Biglaw associates don’t try cases, do they.  They write memos that no one needs.  Or at least they did when you could afford to keep them.

Maybe chihuahua overstates the case, for law schools and Biglaw.  Huge props to Jeffrey for showing the guts to speak out. 

Handicapping Madoff (Update)

When it was announced that Bernie Madoff agreed to prosecution by information rather than indictment, the message was clear:  A deal has been cut.  This must have been the easiest $10 million Ira Lee Sorkin ever earned (did I get the number right, Ira?).  But the question remains, if you represented Madoff, what would make for an acceptable plea?

Thinking as hard as I can given the fact that Bernie didn’t have the good sense to put me on his defense team, I can think of three primary goals that Sorkin might have considered in working out a deal:



  1. Get Bernie out of prison before he dies
  2. Keep Bernie’s wife Ruth and kids from being prosecuted
  3. Leave Ruth and the kids with some loot so they don’t go hungry

Aside from these three goals, there isn’t much more that one could conceivably expect to get out of the government under the circumstances.  It’s not like the feds would go for a proposal to make Bernie the Treasury Secretary to fix the economy and generate enough cashola to pay back all his very close friends.

Playing Saturday morning speculation, let’s consider the chances that Sorkin was able to earn his keep.

Get Bernie out of prison before he dies

Madoff, at 71, is no spring chicken, and even if the deal is to a single count of securities fraud, it carries a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison and a $5 million fine.  While it’s possible that Bernie could outlive expectations (since only the good die young), chances aren’t great that he’s going to reach his 92nd birthday.  So could Sorkin have gotten him a deal that would provide a guidelines sentence that would get him out in less than 20?  After all, he’s a criminal history level 1, right?

Here’s the thing: If ever there was an individual who exemplified the person who should get the maximum sentence allowed by Congress, isn’t it Bernie?  Whether the total loss is $50 billion or a mere $20, as has been suggested, it’s still off the charts.  At what point does the max mean anything if it isn’t used when the single biggest securities fraud ever doesn’t deserve it?

From a general deterrence point of view, how many people would consider a $20 billion fraud if it only costs them 10 or 15 years?  Hey, people do that much time for an awful lot less, so the only lesson is to do it earlier in life so you have enough time to enjoy the south of France in your twilight years.

Still, a plea is a plea, and the routine is to cut some time off the top to make the deal work.  So I would expect the deal to include something shy of the maximum, maybe 3 to 5 years less, with the government betting that the food at Club Fed won’t agree with Bernie’s refined tastes, thus trying to get the time back by shortening his lifespan. 

Keep Bernie’s wife Ruth and kids from being prosecuted

Blood is thicker than water, and even though Bernie showed no reluctance in burning his own as he screwed philanthropies right and left, the love of one’s family is a bond far stronger than any other.  Given that Bernie has been the lightning rod for his massive fraud, the victims might be willing to overlook the ongoing questions swirling around Ruth and the boys, Mark and Andrew, or even his extended family, his brother Peter, his nephew Charles, his niece Shana, all of whom were feeding at the trough.

It’s inconceivable that none of the family knew that this scheme was going on, if the allegations are true, given their roles in compliance and trading.  This is why rumors circulated when they snitched on Bernie for shipping off the family jewels, so that they could manufacture distance from the scheme and try to create some plausible deniability.

It’s hardly uncommon for the government to focus on the central figure in cases and let family members, despite obvious culpability, off the hook on the theory that they were just going along for the ride.  After all, absent the motivating force, in this case Bernie, would they have engaged in this massive fraud?  Mostly likely not, and hence they bear some reduced sense of culpability.

My bet is that the family gets a walk while Bernie takes the weight.  As long as they have a Saddam of Fraud, the townsfolk will be pacified and the deal can be cut.  We are, if nothing else, all about putting a face on crime, and Bernie’s alone works just fine.

Leave Ruth and the kids with some loot so they don’t go hungry

This is something of a corollary to the second goal, since there isn’t much point to solvency if they’re all sharing the family sized cell.  But no one really believes that either the government or the lawyers feeding off the victims will ever unearth all the assets that the Madoff’s squirreled away for a rainy day.  On the other hand, it isn’t easy going from having billions in the bank to mere millions.  How is one expected to live on so little?

This is likely to be one of the most difficult aspects of the plea negotiations, as Judge Denny Chin is required to order restitution to the victims, and any effort by the government to allow the Madoffs to protects assets to some degree could spark armed insurrection.  As hurt as the victims are, only cash will sooth the pain.  After all, this was all about money from the start.

It’s hard to fathom how the government could justify a plea that allows Ruth to keep the apartment and her $62 million in mad money.  I bet that most of us could live quite well off a tag sale of the clothing in her closet, not to mention the rugs on her floor.  But while the government may be hard pressed to concede any financial security to the Madoff kinfolk, chances are awfully good that they will be quietly left with sufficient wherewithal to make sure that Ruth and the kids are able to buy their next tin of Osetra.

But what about the victims?

The New York Times article provides a glimpse as to the government’s concern for the victims of the Madoff scheme.



Marc Litt, an assistant United States attorney, proposed that victims be kept informed about pending hearings — including the one on Thursday — through notices posted on the United States attorney’s office Web site. Links to that information would also be provided on a Web site maintained by the court-appointed trustee handling victim claims.


Judge Denny Chin of Federal District Court in Manhattan approved the proposal, specifying that “any potential victim who wishes to be heard” must send an e-mail request to the prosecutor’s office by 10 a.m. Wednesday. “The court will rule on whether, and the manner in which, victims may be heard at the proceeding,” Judge Chin noted in his order.


What’s notable about this is where the victims fit in before the deal was cut, and whether the victims (or lawyers for the victims) were on board with the government’s plan.  When there are as many victims, and victims as angry, as here, it’s almost impossible to create a consensus.  No matter what you come up with, it won’t be enough for some.  Of course, this may be very much the case, and the victims who oppose a deal may well have a point.  Why cut any deal with Madoff?  Why give him anything?  Why note indict, try and nail him (and everyone who enjoyed the benefit of his scheme) to the wall?  It’s a very good question.

If ever there was a case that called for full exposure, not merely for its catharsis and lesson, but because the perpetrator is undeserving of any concession, this could be it. 

But there’s one nagging question that bothers me.  Where are the victims’ rights advocates on this one?  Not a peep out of Volokh Conspirator  Paul Cassell.  This is the motherlode of victims, and there’s not the slightest doubt that they are indeed victims, and yet none of our Patron Saints of Victimhood has questioned whether the government has adequately complied with the CVRA or shown adequate deference and concern for the thousands who have been wiped out by the scheme?

Not that the government’s deal binds Judge Chin’s hands, which Sorkin I’m sure knows all too well, leaving quite a bit up in the air when it comes time to look Bernie Madoff in the eye and ask how anyone could hurt so many people, so many causes, so many of his own.  But if ever there was a time for the victims’ rights forces to gear up for battle, this would be it.

Update:  More on Madoff from the victim’s perspective from ABC News via Doug Berman.


Madoff’s investors are not happy to hear the he may cut a deal. 92-year old Zsa Zsa Gabor is one of them. Her husband Prince Frederick Von Anhalt said the couple lost their $10 million life savings to Madoff.

“It’s not enough” for Madoff to just plead guilty and go to jail, Von Anhalt told ABC News. “That’s what he wants, he wants to go to jail, his life is over. He wants to protect his family, his wife, his children.” Von Anhalt also wants to see Madoff’s wife, Ruth, and his sons arrested and put in jail. “What nerve she has, to say that she wants to keep all that money. That’s our money! Screw her!”

What?  You thought princes were more dignified when their money is stolen?

Bloggers’ Rights Hang by a Skank

Via @walterolson, a reminder that the rules of the game are invariably made under the worst case scenario.  In this one, the worst case is bad indeed, where model Liskula Gentile Cohen is suing to learn the identity of the blogger of Skanks in NYC.  Seriously, someone felt compelled to start a blog called Skanks in NYC! 

The blog appears to be obsessed with Cohen, and quite derogatory.  She’s identified by our mystery blogger as New York’s “skankiest” and a “”psychotic, lying, whoring … skank.”  And in these hands lie the fate of blogging anonymity and first amendment rights?  Spare me.

But skank-blogger has appeared by counsel to challenge Cohen’s efforts to pierce the veil of anonymity, and Citizens Media Law Project is impressed by the effort to put the blog’s contents into perspective:


With the increasing prevalence of email, chat rooms, social networking websites and web logs (“blogs”), the Internet has become essential to the free exchange of ideas and opinions, however absurd, insulting, profane or rhetorical.  Petitioner’s Application threatens this free exchange . . .  Despite its seemingly petty underpinnings, this action is important and involves fundamental First Amendment rights that Petitioner seeks to destroy.  If granted, Petitioner’s Application would have a dangerous chilling effect upon what has become a predominant forum for free speech in modern society. . . .

A good lawyer can make even the skankiest blog sound relevant, which is good because otherwise this blog is absolutely disgraceful.  In fact, the secondary argument is that:


no reasonable reader of the blog would understand the statements referring to Cohen as a “skank,” “skanky,” or “acting like a ho” to be asserting or implying verifiable facts about her.

In other words, the content is so ridiculous as to be obviously unworthy of credit.  Of course, if this is true (and I have no doubt whatsoever that the content of this blog reflects one of the low points in the waste of English words), then why would anyone go to the effort to create and maintain it?  Clearly, the blogger is one monumental, perhaps even psychotically obsessed, jerk.  As for Cohen, I have a hard time blaming her for being angry about the obsessive focus of this blog.  It really is offensive.

So once again, the freedom of speech of Americans comes down to the sensibilities of the lowest scuzzball around.  It certainly brings me, as a blawger, great comfort to know that my rights are in this skank-blogger’s hands.  I’m just thankful he hired a good lawyer.

But America is the Center of the Universe

I couldn’t pass up this bit from  Reuters via Eugene at Volokh Conspiracy, showing yet again how the true American spirit shines in our understanding and sensitivity in world affairs.

U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton met Russia’s foreign minister on Friday, symbolically presenting him with a red “reset” button to improve ties that sank to a post-Cold War low during the Bush administration….

“I would like to present you with a little gift that represents what President Obama and Vice-President Biden and I have been saying and that is: ‘We want to reset our relationship and so we will do it together,[‘]” said Clinton, presenting Lavrov with a palm-sized yellow box with a red reset button.

Clinton and Lavrov had dinner on the 18th floor of the Intercontinental Hotel in Geneva.

They joked about the Russian misspelling of “reset” on the button before sitting down at an oval table with aides. “We worked hard to get the right Russian word. Do you think we got it?” Clinton asked. “You got it wrong,” said Lavrov, telling her “Peregruzka” meant “overcharge.”

Considering the fact that our nation dedicated nearly half a century to knowing everything, and I mean, everything, there is to know about Russia, is it possible to come off more ignorant and incompetent than this?  Within about 8 minutes, Eugene’s commenters had the correct information posted.


«перезагрузкa» – reload
«перегрузка» – overcharge

Perhaps we could do away with a couple hundred analysts at the CIA and just post stuff at VC whenever we need some info on the Ruskies?  Even after they kick a little back to Eugene, we’d still be ahead of the game by a few billion.  On the other hand, if Hillary was a little quicker on her feet, she could have told Lavrov that “overcharge” was the new American motto.  They could have laughed over that one for hours.

The inability of Americans to accept the premise that we’re not the center of the universe is a running joke throughout the rest of the world.  Here, it never dawns on us that it’s an issue.  Hey, everyone speaks English, right?  As a friend of mine once quipped while we were watching children play in Paris, “It’s amazing how all of them speak a second language.”

This reminds me of a story I first wrote about here after Dan Harris at  China Law Blog got me all juiced up one day on cultural divides.


A long time ago, I represented a Chinese defendant in a narcotics conspiracy in the Southern District of New York.  After he was arrested, one of the agents who spoke some Cantonese gave the defendant his Miranda warnings.  The problem was that the defendant didn’t speak Cantonese.  He was from the Fuchan province, and aside from his native dialect, spoke fairly good Mandarin.  But the agent didn’t speak Mandarin, only Cantonese.

We ultimately had an evidentiary hearing before a district court judge.  I put an acknowledged expert interpreter on the witness stand to explain the differences in the Miranda warning between Cantonese and Mandarin, and why the defendant would not have understood what he was being told.  The federal judge’s initial reaction, in light of testimony that not all the words were different, was whether a defendant needed to understand ALL the words in the Miranda warning, or whether some of them were enough.

After argument as to why all the words mattered, the judge, in frustration, asked the interpreter-witness to say the warnings, first in Cantonese and then in Mandarin.  The witness did as he was told.  After listening intently, the judge smiled, sat back and announced, “They sound the same to me.  Motion denied!” 

If we can do it to the Chinese, why not the Russians?  Don’t they all realize that America is the center of the universe?

The Pinochle of Substantive Knowledge

When I posted about Bob Ambrogi’s “Solo Is the New Soho,” I failed to note the significance of a curious paragraph thrown in the middle.  Fortunately, Miami’s best criminal defense lawyer, Brian Tannebaum, caught it, proving yet again that even blind squirrels can survive.

Bob picked up on this quote from Ross Kodner :


Technology consultant Ross Kodner has come up with a name for this new breed of large-firm refugees who start their own firms — the BigSolo. “These folks aren’t ordinary solo practitioners in the way we’ve come to think of the category … BigSolos have pinnacle level substantive knowledge in their single chosen practice area,” Kodner says.

When I read this passage the first time, I understood it to mean that former Biglaw associates tended to have an in-depth knowledge of minute points of law, having spent inordinate amounts of time researching and writing memos on pinpoint, perhaps even arcane, issues of law.  This did not strike me as a good thing to promote, reflecting their lack of sufficient breadth to actually handle the representation of anybody competently from start to finish.  It wasn’t that they weren’t necessarily smart, but that their experience was, if I can put this kindly, extremely limited.

This paragraph, much to my surprise, turned out to be quite controversial, based upon the comments left at Legal Blog Watch. Aside from the obligatory thanks from Susan Cartier Leibel (Esq., as she included) for a post that promotes her new baby, there were some angry substantive comments that challenged Ross’ statement.

Ross explained that his quote was taken out of context from his post at TechnoLawyer.


At a minimum, it’s critical to finish the thought you posted – where I said that while a BigSolo might have “pinnacle” level substantive knowledge, most have little or no knowledge of running a law practice as a business. And to address one of the commenters, I did NOT mean to imply that ALL BigSolos have “pinnacle level knowledge.” The ones I’ve worked with do seem to be at that level, however.

Talk about jumping from the frying pan into the fire.  He might as well have said that while former Biglaw associates are much better lawyers, solos know the best stores to shop for bargains.  This explanation did not help matters any.

Ambrogi jumped back into the fray to explain that his understanding of Ross’ quote was similar to mine, though he adds some spin to the end to try to bridge the gap and bring peace to the valley:


Interestingly, I read the now-controversial quote quite differently. I thought that Ross’s point was that big-firm lawyers who turn solo tend to be highly specialized in a narrow area of law. By contrast, many long-time solos are either generalists or have much broader skill sets. I did not read Ross’s comment to be a slight towards either these nouveau solos or towards more established solos. Rather, it was simply an observation. He gives the example of a big-firm refugee who has one specialty – securities litigation. He contrasts her to other solos who have more general practices. Ultimately, Ross’s point is that these BigSolos lack many of the management and technology skills that longer-term solos learned over time.

It strikes me as obvious that no Biglaw emigre will step out with the management skills needed to run a viable solo practice, but that’s damning with faint praise.  It’s not brain surgery, and if business management skills are the best one can say about solo practitioners, then we are the Bruno Magli’s of the legal world.  That’s total baloney, and Tannebaum (as well as Bennett and Mike) is quite right to take issue. 

While true that many solos, particularly those who operate in areas without 179 lawyers per square mile, maintain a general practice.  It’s also true that many solos are highly specialized.  The assumption that a solo practitioner’s knowledge of law merely skims the surface, while Biglaw has depth and breadth, however, is ridiculously misguided.  Indeed, the solo is compelled to be smarter, know more, work harder than the Biglaw lawyer because he has a far greater need to prevail (survival) and lacks the diffusion of responsibility that Biglaw enjoys.  To be blunt, the successful solo must be a better lawyer.  That he’s a better businessman may be true, but isn’t nearly enough.

This doesn’t mean that former Biglaw associates can’t or won’t become great solo practitioners.  Some have in the past, and no doubt some will in the future.  Not all, but some.  But the attribution of some cute name, like BigSolos, together with the grossly erroneous assumption that they possess some “pinnacle level of substantive knowledge,” if that’s to be defined as greater or better knowledge of the law than solo practitioners possess, bears the stink of some new-fangled marketing effort.  It gives rise to an image of a legal marketer getting down on his knees and sucking for all he’s worth, hoping to snare some of that Biglaw severance pay by telling the laid-off losers that they aren’t the turds everyone thinks they are.  Are they really that stupid that they’ll buy this crap?  If so, then they are in far deeper trouble than anyone realizes.

Let’s not start yet another class of warfare within the ranks of established solos and the latest marks of the legal marketers.  Biglaw emigres come out of the library lacking the legal knowledge demanded of the successful solo practitioner.  If this is what Ross means by “pinnacle”, as pin-sized scope of legal knowledge, then we have no issue here.  But if Ross is trying to claim that lawyers who have successfully litigated against Biglaw for years, for decades and prevailed, somehow lack the legal acumen that a former second year associate who can’t find his way to the courthouse without map, he’s dead wrong.

As for business management skills, there’s another lesson to be learned.  These same solos are not merely better lawyers than their Biglaw counterparts, but can provide legal representation at a fraction of the cost, as they don’t have to split the receivables with a gaggle of associates who add nothing to the case and are going to school on the client’s dime.  There’s a cost to the marble reception rooms and redwells with gold-leaf monograms on them.  No client ever won a case because of the reception room.  Learn how to win cases and you’ll most assuredly get more clients than the guy with the fancy redwells.

So is there a need for a new name for former Biglaw associates who now find themselves constrained to hang out their own shingle? Sure.  How about rookie solos, struggling to learn how to be good lawyers capable of deserving the right to represent people in their own solo practice.  Let’s not try to pretend that they bring something special to the mix, no matter how much legal marketers want to capture their business. 

And let’s not demean the solo practitioners who have been there and done that long before the phrasemakers focused in on their new targets.  It’s nonsense and the rest of us are not inclined to put up with it.





A Lawyer and His Pen

Many years ago, I was given a Mont Blanc MEISTERSTÜCK ballpoint pen by an appreciative client, who felt that I should not be writing with whatever pen happened to be close at hand.  Granted, no pen makes its output better, but when I grasped the thick, warm black plastic pen in my hand, it just felt right.

Now it isn’t easy for a guy like me to love a pen.  Aside from the fact that it’s a silly affectation, and I’m a very practical guy, most pens present a problem for me.  You see, I’m one of the quirks of nature who writes left-handed and does everything else right-handed.  Lefties rub the sides of their hands over the newly written words, smearing them unmercifully.  If the ink doesn’t dry instantaneously, my writing looks like it was done by a three year old.  With “issues.”

The thick, black Mont Blanc pen worked like magic.  It didn’t smear.  I wasn’t left feeling as if my signature was a blob of black, but merely entirely unreadable squiggles.  I never dreamed it could look so good.  I was hooked.

One day, while riding the Long Island Rail Road train home, in the midst of the longest-running traveling poker game in the world, someone asked to borrow my pen.  Like a fool, I gave it to him.  Like a fool, I expected him to return it.  I never saw the pen again alive (or dead).  It was gone.

So I went to the Mont Blanc store.  They actually have Mont Blanc stores, which came as a surprise to me, given that I was unaware that there were enough people who wanted to buy thick black plastic pens to keep a stand-alone store in business.  I learned otherwise.  They were quite formal and hushed in the store, as if it was a religious experience.  Pens were laid out as if pieces of art, jewels to be individually admired and appreciated.  I told the lovely young saleswoman that I wanted to buy a pen.

The pen cost a fortune.  I can’t remember now how much, but I started to choke, then sputter the words, “for a pen?”  The lovely young saleswoman then lapsed into indecipherable sales-speak about the “fine writing instrument.”  As the hum continued, I tried to calculate how many BIC pens I could buy for the price of a single Mont Blanc pen.  I stopped after a zillion, accounting for the free ones I could pick up off counsel table where others had left them behind.

Mrs. SJ, who came with me to provide ballast, told me to just buy the darn pen so we could get out of the store.  She was getting hives, apparently.  So I did, with my eyes closed tightly in order to pretend that I had no idea how much money I had just spent on a pen.  She said I was a lawyer, and wrote a lot, and could manage to buy a decent pen without being a baby about it.   She uses the “baby about it” thing whenever she wants me to do something.  It always seems to work.

It’s been about two years since I wasted my money on bought the new Mont Blanc pen, and the new pen was every bit as comforting as the one lost to poker.  Until this week.  When I gently caressed my pen to put into the breast pocket of my suit jacket, I felt a rough, unexpected, unwanted ridge in the black plastic bottom part.

I inspected the pen closely, and saw that the black plastic had broken, cracked.  A chunk toward the gold piece at the bottom appeared to have snapped apart, though it remained in place in its cracked state.  I was devastated.

But as I shook off the loss, I realized that this was no ordinary pen, but a hand-crafted fine writing instrument.  Surely, the good folks at Mont Blanc would understand my devastation, would be appalled to learn that their pen had broken and would cure this disaster immediately.  I could imagine septuagenarian craftsman crying in the background, distraught at the thought of one of their beloved fine writing instruments failing.  So I called Mont Blanc.

I can’t say for certain that the young woman who answered the phone was lovely, but she certainly sounded so.  I explained my situation, my devastation, and awaited her comforting words.

Sir, you will have to send your  MEISTERSTÜCK fine writing instrument in to be inspected by our master craftsmen for service.

But I already know what I need, just that bottom black plastic part.

Sir, our writing instruments are not made of plastic, but of the finest resin.

Fine, so your finest resin broke.  Maybe it’s not that fine after all. Can’t you just send me a new piece of finest resin?

Sir, if the black resin broke, then it must have been because of customer abuse.

Hey, wait a second.  I’m not that kind of a guy.  At least not with a pen.  That’s disgusting.

And your fine writing instrument is not warrantied against customer abuse, so there will be a charge for the repair.

Huh?  I spent more than some people’s weekly salary on a pen, and you won’t stand behind the cracked plastic?

Fine writing instruments can break if dropped or even banged around in a brief case, and we can’t possibly repair damage caused by such abuse.

You mean that they’re only good if you keep them locked in a vault?  And I never dropped my pen, either.

So after a thorough inspection, we can replace the black resin for a nominal charge.

Nominal?  I hate that word. It always means I’m about to get screwed.  The charge for a new piece of black plastic was $80, plus shipping by personal courier in a stretch limousine with necessary food and drink.  I passed.

I told the young woman on the phone that I was deeply disappointed to know that Mont Blanc charged such ridiculously high prices for its pens, and then tried to nail me again when their pens failed.  At the very least, I should be able to enjoy the use of the pen until a poker player steals it from me, rather than when the black plastic breaks despite the love and care with which it was treated.  Is that too much to ask?

I told the young woman that the message I was receiving was that I was foolish to spend an inordinate amount of money on their pens in the first place, and that this failure to stand behind their “fine writing instrument” has driven away a customer.

Sir, is there anything else I can do for you? Thank you for calling Mont Blanc. [click]

I still keep my Mont Blanc pen on my dressing table, hoping that it will heal naturally but expecting nothing.  In the meantime, if you receive something from me with a blurry, smeared signature, you will know why.  I really did love that pen, silly as it may seem.

Reducing Peremptory Challenges? Too Clever By Far

Walter Olson twitted about the subject of this WSJ Story, and started a snowball effect on the topic of peremptory challenges.  It seems that some lawprof from Iowa named David Baldus came up with a brainstorm to limit strikes without cause to three.  Why 3? Because it’s less than we have now, and greater than none, which everyone agrees would never happen. 

Why any change?  Because Baldus thinks peremptories are unfair to jurors.  Why does that matter?  Because fairness is its own virtue in the Academy.  It’s one of those ideas that one simply accepts blindfolded, as if the world has forgotten why we have juries, why we have peremptories and why anyone hangs out at the courthouse in the first place.  Ultimately, all concepts become homogenized until we’ve forgotten why they existed in the first place.  I doubt that Baldus every tried a case, but if so, it’s a vague memory at best. 

So what’s the problem?  After all, arbitrary compromise is the cornerstone of American law, right?  Well, not necessarily.

Walter Olson, who has been on the vanguard of much of what’s wrong with the law and lawyers, fears that the use of peremptories is one of those things lawyers manipulate to turn the search for justice into a game won by trick.  He’s right to fear, but is the reduction/elimination of peremptories part of the solution?  I think not.

Walter raised two distinct points (note that these were twitted, and appear somewhat stilted given the inherent limitations of twitting). 


Gamesmanship on perempts not only tilts to cleverer lawyer, but could increase lottery effect by ousting skeptic voices.

Quality of delib’ns may droop if not even 1 true-blue left on one side or loyal-red on other. Or is your fear hung juries?

So in the societal interest of a fair outcome, Walter suggests that there are two separate evils caused by the use of peremptory challenges.  First, it works to the advantage of the “cleverer lawyer,” and second, it impairs the “quality of deliberations” by drawing jurors from only the “middle third” of society, thus ousting the left and right thirds from having a voice.

The twits came fast and furious, and so I suggested a blawgversation.

Patrick at Popehat posted first, arguing that trials belong to the participants, not society, and that the use of peremptory challenges by both sides will create, at least, the perception of fairness to the participants:


in the interest of perceived fairness as much as anything else, we allow attorneys to remove potential jurors they suspect might not be able to judge the case fairly.  Since the trial process is adversarial, we can assume that both or all parties will similarly exercise their peremptory challenges to remove jurors who might be partisans for the opponents to arrive at some level of perceived fairness.

As Patrick correctly notes, we can’t say for sure if it’s true that participants receive a fairer verdict since there’s no way to test the thesis, but our acceptance of the legal system as a substitute for bloodshed in the street relies in large part on the belief of the parties that the outcome of a trial will produce a reasonably fair result.

Next to chime in was the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett at Defending People, who notes that it’s way too easy for a potential biased juror to avoid being challenged for cause by saying some magic words.


It’s not hard for a potential juror to say all the right words to avoid a challenge for cause; if the juror says those magic words, no matter how much nudging and winking he’s done, he’s not challengeable for cause (unless the judge is aberrantly concerned with fairness).

So without peremptories, we are left with a random group of people, but not quite the theoretically random group who would reflect the cross-section of society that might arguably be a fairer judge of outcome.  With only 12 on the jury, they reflect a “smallsampleocracy”, too limited to offer a true microcosm of society.  The hope that the group would bring all points of view to the jury room is just that, hope, without anything approaching a legitimate basis to belief that any random group of 12 represents a fair cross-section.  Thus,


Reducing the number of peremptories to three isn’t a “compromise”; it’s a random gutting of the adversarial system that helps protect us all from the random error of smallsampleocracy.

Next, Popehat’s Ken jumped into the mix, providing some of his experiences in the well:


I think they are the worst system possible save for all of the others. Jury selection is an art and not a science, no matter how much high-priced consultants would like to convince you otherwise. But it is, on occasion, a useful art. It’s rare to have someone as patently unsuitable as my potential juror who was open in her scorn of blacks wanting to be called African Americans. But it happens, and peremptory challenges are the only reliable way to get rid of such people, given how lax the standards are for challenges for cause. On plenty of other occasions, potential jurors simply rub me the wrong way.

You will have to read the rest of Ken’s post to get the full story from his experience as a G-man, but his point is spot on.  Despite all the advice for thinning the jury heard, the hard fact is that it’s rare to have a juror say something that will get him tossed for cause, and easy to rehabilitate a juror if you want to keep him on the jury.  All that need be asked is, “can you be fair?”  Few people respond, “why no, I can’t.”  Most people believe they are fair, though their definition of fair may vary by miles from the next bloke’s. 

And while these guys were busy blogging, Walter let us know that he was too busy to blog about it, so we’re on our own.  I offered to write Walter’s side for him, but I don’t think he felt comfortable about it. 

So now for my 2 cents, to the extent that whatever worthy thoughts I might have aren’t already better developed by those who came before me.  I’ve made clear in the past that jury selection is more art than science.  Actually, more voodoo than anything else.  That said, every trial lawyers knows better than to believe that a juror will be fair simply because he says so.  He may be hiding his bias, or not have the slightest recognition of his bias, but his say-so doesn’t help anyone except the judge who’s trying to move the case along.

Does our use of peremptories always make great sense?  Nah.  It is, as Ken suggests, largely a matter of gut, of instinct.  Are we right?  Who knows.  But to leave it either to random selection or a judge’s willingness to strike for cause leaves both sides believing that they’re screwed. 

This parity is one of the keys to why the fear of peremptories is overblown.  Both sides get peremptories, and are constrained to use them judiciously so that one side doesn’t use theirs all up while the other keeps a bunch in their pocket.  Should that happen, the potential for a severely skewed jury becomes very real, with the other side incapable of tossing any potential jurors who seem particularly troubling.  This isn’t some trick that only a handful of lawyers know, but the most basic approach to jury selection. 

No trial lawyer worth his salt believes that he can use peremptories to get the jury of his dreams.  The best we hope for is to not get the jury of our nightmares.  This goes to Walter’s comment about the “cleverer lawyer,” which I believe may reflect one of the most  troubling and true fears about the legal system in general and juries in particular: That it’s not about justice, but about who has the better lawyer.

Every client hopes he has the cleverer lawyer.  Any client who doesn’t is a fool.  Lawyers are not fungible.  We’re not just suits with heads attached, easily replacing one for another without any notable difference.  Lawyers run the gamut, from “cleverer” to grossly incompetent.  It shows in our argument, our questioning and, yes, in our jury selection.  It shows in everything we do.  It is impossible to level the playing field.  The solution isn’t external, such as limiting peremptories, but retaining the best counsel one can.  
 
Should a lawyer be burdened because his skills are better, mind is quicker, experience is broader and deeper, than his adversary?  There is no cause for complaint when a party retains the legal equivalent of the village idiot.  You have a choice. Make it wisely.  Contrary to Walter’s issue, having the “cleverer” lawyer is something to strive for, not avoid.  The law does not demand that lawyers perform to meet the lowest common denominator, and if that allows one party to gain an advantage in jury selection, or any other aspect of trial, then the fault lies not with the lawyer, nor the system, but the choice of the party represented by the village idiot. 

I doubt, however, that this is where the argument ends.  I suspect the thought is that the advantage of the “cleverer” lawyer is unfair.  While the skill level of the lawyer can’t be helped when it comes to argument and examination, the composition of a jury should not be one of those things that’s subject to the manipulation of the “cleverer” lawyer, and can be fixed by the vissitudes of the draw.  Take your jury as you find them, for better or worse, and remove lawyerly manipulation from the mix.

As Ken wrote:


There are no crazy-filters on jury service. Of the first twelve people to show up in the box, three may be gadflies, grudgeholders, or nuts. Absent my ability, and my opponents’ ability, to weed some of those people out, that handful of people may shape the experience for everyone in the courtroom. That’s not the way to get a fair trial on the merits for anyone.

This is how real trials look to real lawyers.  This isn’t some theoretical vision of juries being comprised of kind, well-intended regular people, or some imaginary perfect jury for the other side.  We are all afraid of what goes on in the minds of the twelve people who ultimately get called, and never really know what they are thinking, or the baggage they are bringing, when we accept them as jurors.  But when pressed to try to understand this random group of twelve, there is one universal belief that every experienced trial lawyer holds:  There are very few normal people out there. 

As much as we may want to believe that the vast majority of people are normal, reasonably intelligent and capable of faithfully following the instructions of a judge, trial lawyers are forced to test the thesis, and find it wanting.  As pessimistic as this may sound, it’s true, as any lawyer who has chatted with a jury after a verdict will tell you. Not that lawyers are any more normal, but it remains our job to make the choices for our client.

So does our exercise of peremptories fix the problem?  Not for us.  Not for Walter.  Not for anybody.  But without it, the lawyers and parties would most assuredly doubt that they’ve got a fair jury.  With peremptories, the comfort level is slightly higher.  And until we come up with a better way, that’s the best we can get.

When Professor Baldus arrived at his three peremptories compromise, it was largely in the name of ending discrimination in the selection of juries.  He’s right about that.  We often make gross assumptions about groups of people, whether racial, sexual or otherwise, because the tools available to unearth hidden prejudice are too limited to do better.  But we try our best not to do so, because we can’t afford to lose a good juror simply because he’s white and wealthy and the defendant is black and poor. 

It doesn’t make peremptory challenges any more scientific, or our choices inherently better.  It’s just the last best chance to protect our client from the nightmare juror.  The exercise of peremptory challenges isn’t about manipulating the system to our benefit, but protecting the integrity of the jury, to the extent humanly possible, from the worst case scenario.  That’s the best we can do, and it’s a good thing for all involved.  Even society.