Author Archives: SHG

The Good Unrepetent Mother

Tammy Gibson was a mother who cared enough about her daughter that she was ready to beat William Baldwin to death.  When everything was over, including her prosecution, she was ready to do it again.  And her hope is that next time, she will have greater success.  What do we do with Tammy Gibson?

Doug Berman asked the question at Sentencing Law & Policy, then asked some other blawgers what they thought about it.  It was a great question. 

According to police documents, Level-3 sex offender William A. Baldwin had moved into his uncle’s home in Tacoma in early June. Following his move, county deputies distributed flyers around the neighborhood to alert residents of his presence. On June 19, Gibson went to the house in the trailer park and asked for Baldwin.  When Baldwin stepped outside, she claimed she was going to kill him because Baldwin had molested her children. Gibson then proceeded to hit Baldwin repeatedly with her bat, the document said, leaving him with an injured arm. “I kept swingin’ and swingin’, and swingin’,” Gibson told investigators.

Contrary to what she had said to Baldwin, Gibson later told investigators Baldwin had not molested her children. But she did say that she recognized Baldwin from the flyer as the man who had chatted up her then-10-year-old daughter during the previous summer.  Baldwin is the memorable height of 7 feet, 3 inches tall. “For him to be right there, in front of my house and talking to my child — made me crazy,” she told KOMO. “And I told him I thought he was a piece of crap and I smacked him,” she added. “I just didn’t stop hitting him. I just told him that ‘if it were up to me, I’d kill ya.”‘… 

According to the ABC story, Gibson received a 3 month sentence for her efforts.  One of her daughters, Rachael Porter, reacted:

“I think it’s crap; that she was protecting her kids like she should have been. They locked her up for way too long.”

Protecting one’s children can be a very vague concept.  Tammy made clear that she was by no means deterred. 

“No, I’d do it again if not better,” she told ABC News Seattle affiliate KOMO-TV. “I don’t care if it hurts me, I don’t regret it. It got him away from my kids and all the other kids in the neighborhood.”

So many of the issues wrapped around sentencing, sex offenders, vigilantism and motherhood come into play here that this case is tantamount to a Rorschach test for criminal sentencing.  Which side are you on, boys. Which side are you on?

Criminal defense lawyers often talk of jury nullification, the sense of the ordinary citizen that a person should not be convicted for his conduct despite the fact that it is against the law.  This may be because the law is perceived as unjust, or the defendant is perceived as not being morally culpable.  In either event, we look to a jury to free the defendant from the technical yokes the law would otherwise require be applied.

The Tammy Gibson case is perhaps the antithesis of jury nullification.  It is institutional nullification, where the officials who make the wheels of the system grind, the police, prosecutors and judges, are unable to muster the degree of anger toward Tammy Gibson to do more than go through the motions.  A three month sentence for beating another person with a baseball bat is, under almost any other scenario, trivial.  Why should this be different.

The set up here clearly tugs at the heartstrings of the institution.  A mom who, whether technically right or wrong, is acting out of love and protection for her child.  A sex offender, an individual most despised by the institution of all.  One holds the status of moral righteousness in the eyes and minds of the institution, while the other is as worthless and morally disgusting as any person can be.  One is worthy. The other will never be worthy.  Is there anyone who, in the heart, can’t appreciate the feelings that ran through Tammy Gibson, believing that this man tried to go after her baby?

Of course, William Baldwin did not harm Tammy Gibson’s daughter.  William Baldwin was inside his home, doing nothing wrong, when Tammy Gibson chose to attack.  As much as Baldwin may be relegated to the human junk heap in the eyes of many, he was a human being entitled to exist without being the target of death of any person who felt entitled to pick up a bat and beat him to death.  Certainly, we can’t have moms trying to murder people at will for perceived wrongs that never actually happened.  Certainly, people can’t simply decided that sex offenders are perpetually fair game for harm.

Tammy Gibson’s reaction to her prosecution and sentence invokes two of the fundamental premises of sentencing, general and specific deterrence.  She is the poster child.  For many parents with perceived grievances against a sex offender, a three month sentence might be seen as a cheap price to pay to get in a good beating.  Rather than deter such crimes, it could prove to be an incentive.  If I felt that someone might harm my child, I would happily put three months at risk.  Probably a whole lot longer.

Adding fuel to the fire is Tammy Gibson’s challenge to the system, affirming her belief that she was right to attack and that she will not be deterred.  This is an intolerable position, regardless of what one thinks of her motives.  To ignore it is to invite her to take a second shot.  I suspect the judge realizes this, but isn’t overly concerned about losing sleep the night of William Baldwin’s funeral.

Doug expresses concern that a three month sentence isn’t “a truly effective or sensible sentence.”  I doubt it’s even in the ballpark of effective or sensible.  It’s the proverbial slap on the wrist, an extremely modest price to pay if one seeks to deter the beating of sex offenders by moms.  Clearly, it hasn’t done much to change Tammy’s mind, and knowing how protective I, as a parent, am with my children, it wouldn’t do much to me either if I felt the way she did.  Any half-decent parent will go to extreme lengths to protect their threatened child.  The problem is where the legitimate line of threat is to be drawn, and it seems clear that Tammy drew it in a place where few would, and no one should.

It’s hard to muster sympathy for a child molester, even when he’s paid his dues and caused no harm since.  It’s hard to avoid the sense of sympathy toward a parent who, even belatedly, perceived a threat to her child.  The ABC article doesn’t say what Baldwin did to merit the title “sex offender.”  But it’s enough in our society to simply have that title hung around his neck to make him unworthy of humanity.  It’s enough to render him unworthy of much protection from our institutions. 

And this apparently makes Baldwin, and anyone else forced to wear the title “sex offender” (many of whom have done little or nothing to deserve the moral culpability that goes along with this epithet) a lower breed of person, someone who can be beaten without serious consequence according to the sentence given Tammy Gibson. 

This is a dangerous and unacceptable message.  Tammy Gibson feels no remorse.  Another parent may well accept three months in jail for the chance to beat a sex offender.  The message to parents, and to sex offenders, is clear.  Sex offenders are fair targets and moms who beat them, or worse, deserve our understanding and sympathy. 

The story ends with one additional assertion that requires mention.  Tammy Gibson is not merely unremorseful, but sees herself as standing at the vanguard of parental righteousness.

Gibson said she hoped that the attention created by her case would lead to a change in the laws regarding released sex offenders.

“I would hope that me doing this and going to jail would change something, change some kind of law, change something where people like him can’t be standing around little kids you know what I mean?” Gibson said in her interview with KOMO-TV. “It’s not right, it’s not fair to the kids at all.”

In her mind, Tammy Gibson is the hero of this story, perhaps hoping for a law in her name entitling mothers to beat former sex offenders at will.  No, a three month sentence is not effective or sensible, and Tammy Gibson is not a hero.  Every sentence sends a message, and the message sent by this sentence is that sex offenders can be attacked with virtual impunity, even when they have done no harm.  This is a very dangerous message, and it was sent as clearly as possible.

The Race is On

Since 1975, Robert Morgenthau has been District Attorney of New York County.  A relic of the age of Patricians, when a family first earned its fortune and then served the public as a duty incumbent upon the upper class, Morgenthau is the last of his breed.  Lest anyone think this is a bad thing, Morgenthau’s tenure has been one of enormous integrity, professionalism and service in the truest sense of the word.  Not perfect, but possibly the best district attorney’s office there has ever been.

But Morgy, now 89 years of age, has decided that his day is done. 


“Some people are slow learners and it took me a long time to realize I was getting older,” Morgenthau said jokingly at a packed news conference. “I decided I wouldn’t push my luck any further and quit while I was ahead.”

Within hours of the announcement, I received an email from Campaign Snyder thanking Morgenthau for his years of service, and reminding him not to let the door hit him on the way out.  Leslie Crocker Snyder wants his job.  She tried for it last election in 2005, and lost.  Has her day come?

According to Newsday, this is the list of contenders:


Former Judge Leslie Crocker Snyder, who lost to him in 2005, appears to be a front-runner. Other challengers include Cyrus Vance Jr., a prosecutor under Morgenthau and the son of former President Jimmy Carter’s secretary of state; Richard Aborn, president of the Citizens Crime Commission; and Dan Castelman, Morgenthau’s right-hand man but perhaps better known for his cameo role in “The Sopranos.”

The latest word is that Cy Vance, Jr., a former ADA under Morgenthau, will be named heir apparent.  Not surprisingly, Vance is the new-breed Patrician, with a pedigree similar to Morgenthau’s to the extent such can still exist.  He had the smarts not to challenge Morgy, but rather to wait in the wings, showing proper deference to a legend, until the legend decided that it was time to leave.

Snyder, on the other hand, chose not to wait.  She left her seat on the bench, where she spent a quarter century proving that she had what it took to be a prosecutor, to go directly at Morgenthau.  She wasn’t getting any younger, and he wasn’t going anywhere.  Leslie decided that it was time to take her destiny into her own hands and seize the job that she had hoped would be handed her.

The problem with this tactic is that Leslie Snyder made some very real enemies along the campaign trail.  Staring down Morgenthau was a bold move, but one that offended current and former prosecutors throughout New York.  It wasn’t that everyone wasn’t aware that Morgy had overstayed, but that one doesn’t challenge a legend.  Leslie did, and paid for her hubris.

But now that Robert Morgenthau has taken his name out of play, will the hostility toward Leslie Snyder’s attempted coup abate, or will she be forever branded a traitor?  Better still, will Morgenthau have the clout to name his successor, or is the field wide open?  According to Black Star News, Morgy is walking Cy Vance around:


Opting against his promised “90 in ’09” run, longtime Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau has decided not to seek re-election this fall, City Hall has learned, and was sighted introducing Cyrus Vance to key players in the Chinatown community at a recent Chinese Consolidated Benevolent Association dinner. Vance has long been talked about as his preferred successor.

The nature of an election for District Attorney, where there just isn’t much to claim in order to promote one candidate over another, lends itself to two potential variables.  Experience and endorsements.  Leslie certainly has the campaign apparatus in place from 2005 (it was never dismantled, not even for a moment) and had hit the ground running even before Morgy’s announcement.  Whether Vance can crank it up, aside from the connections that Morgy can offer, has yet to be seen.

The Value of a Good Education

Amongst the many tenets of our American dream, a foundational principle is that every child deserves a good education, and with that education, anyone can grow up to be President.  While it is no doubt true today that anyone can, the corollary is that everyone can’t.  Nobody mentions this part.  It would be bad for business.

From Sarah Waldeck at Concurring Opinions, we learn that:


The National Center for Public Policy and Higher Education recently reported that college tuition and fees rose 439 percent between 1982 – 2007, while median family income rose only 147 percent. The Center’s president commented, “If we go on this way for another 25 years, we won’t have an affordable system of higher education.”

Yet the dream pushes student and parent to reach for the stars.  The reality is that they might do better to invest in lottery tickets.  Sarah suggests that distance learning, as yet a quasi-acceptable method of gaining a higher education, may be a solution, as it eliminates the need for physical plant, an obviously expensive proposition.  She notes that a student of Concord Law School, an online school authorized to grant J.D.’s, was recently admitted to the Massachusetts bar.  Mind you, he had to sue to do so.

Interestingly, Sarah doesn’t consider the salaries paid to lawprofs within the realm of possible solutions, particularly since they are putatively paid to teach when their true purpose is to publish to advance their personal standing as a scholar on the backs of law students’ tuition payments.  Perhaps if tuition wasn’t subsidizing their vanity, costs would be lower, particularly since so many ivy-covered buildings were long since bought and paid for.

The cries of new attorneys about the crippling burden of law school loans have been a source of dismay for a long time.  Coupled with the death of Biglaw as the pot of gold at the end of the rainbow, this might be an excellent opportunity to re-evaluate the entire approach of higher education and the law.  It costs too much.  It produces more lawyers than our society needs or can absorb.  It serves an ulterior purpose of dubious merit.  Law schools are another suck-hole burdening society while doing little to advance its purported cause. 

Internally, all those very smart boys and girls who want to be lawprofs refuse to see, or more likely acknowledge, that they are parasites.  They aren’t doing this to teach students to become lawyers, but to advance their own interests on the students’ dime.  Aside from Jim Chen and Jeffrey Harrison at MoneyLaw, few will even acknowledge the truth, no less engage in a serious discussion about it.  Some, like dear Marquette lawprof David Papke, are so enamored with their pseudo-intellectualism that they openly disdain the time wasted on such dirty, worthless efforts as teaching students to be lawyers. 


We don’t want law school to be lawyer-training school. When we cave in to demands of that sort from the ABA and assorted study commissions, we actually invite alienation among law students and lawyers. Legal education should appreciate the depth of the legal discourse and explore its rich complexities. It should operate on a graduate-school level and graduate people truly learned in the law.

The “we” that Papke refers to is the lawprofs.  I suspect that some of those students footing the bill for his having some place to go during the day might disagree.  Indeed, they might actually expect to be taught to be lawyers.  They might actually think that those escalating tuition payments are in exchange for that training.  Fools.

But it’s not just the failure of law schools to serve their purported purpose.  It’s their ever-increasing hunger for more warm bodies with cash or access to student loans to provide an adequate financial base to fund this lawprof vanity.  No one in academia asks whether we need more lawyers.  No one in academia has the balls to stand up and say, we are producing far more lawyers than this nation can use, can absorb, can support.  We are selling these students false hope.  There is no place for them to go.

Society, on the other hand, has been learning over the past few decades what a surplus of lawyers means.  Wild and crazy lawsuits filed by half-baked lawyers desperate to earn a fee has reduced the respect of what was once a profession to slightly below used-car salesman.  And lawyers have indeed become used-car salesman, spending far more effort on learning the art of huckstering than lawyering.  Young lawyers in particular have come to believe that success as a lawyer has nothing (not little, but nothing) to do with quality of service but with learning the tricks of marketing and search engine optimization.  It’s all about tricking people into hiring you. 

This is the new legal paradigm: Clients are the scarce resource the requires allocation, and allocation requires marketing.  Marketing, therefore, is king.  Today’s successful lawyer is not the one who demonstrates any competency in the practice of law, but excels in the practice of marketing.  The internet is permeated by lying lawyers, scamming the public about their qualifications and indulging in ethical violations up the wazoo, with neither shame nor concern.  They care only about getting the next case, and they will say and do anything necessary to get it.  A bit hyperbolic, but it’s intended to make a point. 

Couching lies in marketing lingo doesn’t make them less deceptive.  The apologists and rationalizers who explain why lawyers have to market and why everything we do is marketing will never restore honor and integrity.  They seek merely to excuse their own indulgence, and no one is fooled who doesn’t want to be fooled.

If Sarah Waldeck was truly focused on reducing the cost of law school, and was honest about what young lawyers needed in order to survive, she might consider reducing it to a six month course of study in deceptive marketing, the only admission requirement being a willingness to disclaim any interest in integrity, taught entirely by lawprofs sitting in boiler rooms in low-rent locations.  Should any student experience difficulty with the curriculum, there is always phone-a-friend.

Or, we can start a movement to revitalize the law as an honorable profession.  Lawprofs, at significantly reduced salaries, can spend their days teaching law students to be lawyers.  Law schools can cut their student populations in half.  The three year curriculum can be cut to two, maybe even one and a half, with the balance by apprenticeship where students can actually learn what lawyers do all day long.  And admission to practice, a privilege not a right, can be conditioned upon a waiver of the right to commercial free speech and the end of lawyer marketing.  

Or students can take those loans, to the extent that there will be any available under the current economic climate, and buy some lottery tickets.  There’s no shame in winning the lottery, and your chances of success at achieving great wealth are substantially better.

But For Video, Volume 36

This video of King County, Washington, Sheriff’s Deputy Paul Schene, 31, has saturated the blawgosphere, but if you haven’t seen it before, it’s important that you see it now.  Schene got angry with a 15 year old woman who appears to kick off her show toward/at Deputy Schene, and Deputy Schene gives this young woman a good tuning up.



Aside from the obvious, that the man with the shield who is trained and paid to serve and protect has shown this nasty young woman who’s boss, with a deputy in training at his side (who naturally had nothing to say about this occurrence, since it was certainly not the trainee’s place to criticize a veteran officer like Schene), there is another question that  demands an answer:  Was Deputy Schene unaware of the fact that his beating was captured on video?

From the Seattle PI, there is both good news and bad news about this nightmarish video.


The video of the Nov. 29 incident was disclosed Friday, one day after Deputy Paul Schene, 31, pleaded not guilty to misdemeanor assault in King County District Court.

 Schene, an eight-year veteran, works out of Precinct 4, which covers SeaTac, Burien and high crime areas in White Center and Skyway.


He is the third sheriff’s deputy since 2006 to face charges on allegations of excessive force. All three are from the Burien precinct.


A detective assigned to the girl’s case discovered the video Dec. 1 and immediately forwarded it to supervisors.


Schene had previously been in the news in 2006 after he fatally shot Pedro Jo, a mentally ill man, during a struggle after a traffic stop on Interstate 5. It was the second officer-involved shooting of his career.


On the plus side, this incident came to light because a detective had the integrity of bringing it to the attention of his supervisors. On the downside, he is the third deputy to face excessive force charges (mind you, only misdemeanor charges against Schene), and there’s a dead mentally ill man in his wake.  

Does the fact that Deputy Paul Schene was happy to beat a 15 year old girl on video for kicking her shoe at him (which he claimed caused him severe injury, naturally) indicate how little concern he had about being outed for this conduct?  Or was he so deeply angered that he just didn’t care?  Or was he so secure in the knowledge that it would be whitewashed as “justified” that he felt no fear?

We just keeping posting these videos on the internet in the hope that as many people as possible see them and say to themselves, this has to stop.  If enough people do, maybe we can make a dent in the cop culture that enables their belief that they are a law unto themselves.

The Death of Zeal

Come April 1, 2009, New York will have  new rules of professional responsibility. 


“It is a tremendous relief to now speak the same language as the rest of the country,” said Steven C. Krane, chairman of the New York State Bar Association’s Committee on Standards of Attorney Conduct, which proposed the revisions. “The code is dead. Long live the rules.”

The institutions of change love their own work so very much.  The new rules certainly go a long way toward clarifying how lawyers can avoid malpractice, and protecting lawyers from doing things like disclosing client confidences when it’s societally convenient.  Hooray for the new rules.  Our backs are covered.

But there’s one word you won’t find in the new rules.  Zeal.

No longer is an attorney obliged to zealously represent his client.  Zeal is dead.

The new rule requires a lawyer to be “competent”.  Rule 1.1(a) states:


A lawyer should provide competent representation to a client. Competent representation requires the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation.

No zeal.  As for competence, the new rules fail to provide much by way of beef, even watering down this tepid term with the words “reasonably necessary.”  Luke warm seems like it would be a step up from this new rule.  Zeal?  Not even close.  Competent representation means more than incompetent representation.  Is that it?  We’re ethical as long as we aren’t incompetent?  That’s how high the grocery clerks have set the new bar?  I’m so proud to be a lawyer.

I’m sure that bar association policy wonks will applaud this major improvement in consistency.  Consistency, after all, is one of their most prized goals.  Good or bad, it’s always best to be consistent from the standpoint of grocery clerks.

But gladiators fight to win.  They don’t fight dirty, but they do fight hard.  Is it “reasonably necessary” to fight hard?   For those of us who came of age in the law when the duty was to zealously defend our client, we knew that zeal required us to go above and beyond the mundane, yeoman approach.  It was not good enough to be simply good enough.  We considered it a personal disgrace to fail to give every case our best effort.

But that’s no longer the rule.  Zeal is dead, the new rules say.  Still, I plan to zealously defend my clients, and to write about our work as if zeal was still an obligation.  When the grocery clerks make it unethical to zealously defend our clients, limiting lawyers to mere “competent” representation, I will hang it up.  I don’t know how to do less than zeal.

Dan Abrams: Presumed Innocent is for Losers

It didn’t hurt Danny Abrams, young lawyer cum TV pundit, to have a father named Floyd as he sat at his desk in his rumpled shirt in the swamp lands of Secaucus, New Jersey.  He was a nice kid, though one wondered how someone without any real experience actually being a lawyer got to talk about it on cable television.  Not that there is anything unusual about that.

But when Danny became Mr. Abrams as he got kicked upstairs, it was unclear just what he brought to the table.  Dan has clarified this in his WSJ Op-Ed, and I wonder what happened to the kid with the rumpled collar.


People constantly complain to me about news coverage of criminal cases. “What happened to the presumption of innocence?” they ask at almost every turn. Well, I’m tired of it.

First, I seriously doubt that people constantly complain about this aspect of news coverage.  I hear just the opposite, so who is doing all this complaining?  But there’s a difference for Dan.  He’s now the Chief Legal Analyst for NBC News.  Put aside that his lack of legal experience, since this is entertainment, but since when is someone who is paid to be factually accurate entitled to grow tired of doing his job? 


As a citizen — or even a TV legal analyst — am I required to presume innocence, i.e., that the authorities arrest the wrong person in every case? Not a chance. Imagine how this might play out on television:

“So Dan, how bad is it for (insert name of minor reality-show celebrity here) that the authorities found a pound of cocaine and four ounces of heroin on his person and in his car, the entire arrest was captured on videotape and the defendant confessed the drugs were his?”

“Bad? Bob, I have to presume the defendant innocent, so I’ll presume those drugs were planted by corrupt police officers well before the car came into focus on the tape. And that confession? Well, it must have been coerced.” That would hardly reflect an effort to assess and evaluate the legal strategies and evidence as fairly and objectively as possible.

Citizens can hold any view they want, right, wrong or otherwise.  I assume that Dan learned in law school that the presumption of innocence applies to the law, not to public opinion.  As a TV legal analyst, one’s duty is accuracy.  Unless he witnessed the crime, he knows no more about it then he’s told, and hence lacks the basis for a conclusion as to perceived guilt or innocence. 

Worse, though, is Dan’s presentation of the options.  The presumption of innocence doesn’t demand that he presume the cops planted drugs, but that he not editorialize guilt as a concluded fact.  He can opine away with the caveat that it is based upon the information currently known.  I don’t expect legal analysts to be omniscient or have secret powers to know the future.  Does Dan?


Essentially we stack the legal deck in favor of the defendant. After all, the potential consequence (in most cases prison time) is so grave that we say we would rather let “10 guilty men go free than convict an innocent one.” But unless I am sitting in the jury box armed with that power I, and any other nonjuror for that matter, have no obligation, moral or legal, to embrace that legal fiction.

Only someone who has never noticed that 97% of all criminal defendants end up convicted can say that we stack the legal deck in favor of the defendant.  One would hope that a network legal analyst knew better. This is where hyperbole overshadows experience, and frankly raises some serious questions about Danny’s depth of understanding.  Remember, this is the guy who tells people about the law.  Eek.

While he’s under no constitutional duty to “embrace that legal fiction,” is he really free to substitute his own personal guesswork and bias for facts and reality?  Perhaps some NBC executive can best answer that based on what they expect from a legal analyst.  It would be my hope that words that come out of his mouth would be reasonably reliable, and the he would have a legal, if not moral, duty to make a stab at accurate reporting.


The same applies, for example, to hearsay evidence. It’s generally inadmissible in court, and yet most of us live our lives based on what people we trust tell us they heard or learned.

Now Dan is absolutely right when he says that most of us, in our ordinary lives, rely on hearsay.  But that’s not because hearsay is so wonderfully reliable, but because we have no other choice.  After all, we can’t get original source material for every decision or thought we have as we go about our daily business, so we are constrained to rely on probability.  But is Dan, the network legal analyst, saying he trusts cops, and if cops say so, then it must be?  Did he miss that day in evidence class where they explained why hearsay isn’t sufficiently reliable?


What about those like CNN’s Nancy Grace who seems to presume every defendant guilty? Criticize her if you like, but such behavior doesn’t mean the rest of us must feign ignorance. We can question police and prosecutors without necessarily presuming they are corrupt or misguided.

This quote is taken just because it makes no sense whatsoever, and it’s good to see that Dan, despite his lofty analyst position, suffers from the occasional non-sequitur just like the rest of us. 


Demanding that all of us presume every defendant innocent outside of a courtroom is to demand that we stop evaluating facts, thereby suffocating independent thought and opinion. There is nothing “reasonable” about that.

I suspect this is what happens to exceptionally inexperienced lawyers who are told that their every thought is meaningful.  Dan Abrams isn’t a bad kid, but he’s never had any experience in the trenches and operates under the mistaken impression that he knows what he’s talking about.  To the public, he’s a pundit.  To real lawyers, he’s simplistic and naive.  I always liked Danny.  But he would have done better to spend a decade in the trenches than on air. 

Time to Rethink…

the intrinsic value of assets.  Goods are only worth what someone will pay for them.  It doesn’t matter what it cost to manufacture them once they already exist.  It doesn’t matter if someone feels as if “they’re giving them away.”  As they sit, they age and deteriorate, while there are plenty of folks around who could use them.

newarkcars.jpg  

Unsold cars at Port Newark.

Home Foreclosure

Housing stock goes empty, while people live in tents?



Notice any disconnects?

These assets are not getting better, just older.  Will they sit and rot until they have no value whatsoever?   Will the banks holding mortgages refuse to renegotiate, while their capitalization fails, for fear that someone will beat them out of a dime?   We remain a world of plenty, but cannot match assets with needs as long as we hold firm to the belief that our “things” are worth more than anyone is willing to pay.  It’s been a long time since anyone had to seriously readjust their thinking, but now would be a good time.

If there was just some way that the people who have the assets, wasting away, could hook up with the people who need the assets, wasting away.  We have enough. 

Appearances Matter

Anne Reed at Deliberations posts about the impact of appearances.


These studies keep coming up, probably because it’s so hard for us to accept what they teach us.  It matters what you look like, and what your client and witnesses look like.  It matters so much that both children and adults can accurately pick the winners of real elections – in countries other than their own where they know nothing about the candidates – just by looking at the candidates’ pictures.

The point is clear.  You can argue until you’re blue in the face that the fellow who looks like a killer is innocent, that his appearance is irrelevant to the question of whether he committed the crime, that there is no rational connection between the way a person appears and the credibility of the person.  And you will still be wrong.

This is where harsh reality bites lawyers hard.  People (meaning jurors) attribute qualities to people based on appearance, no matter how wrong and superficial it may be.  And it’s not merely the defendant or witnesses who are at risk for the way they look, but us as well.

Some may recall my post on The Lawyer Look.  This post has been the subject of some of the harshest criticism and disagreement of any I’ve written.  And none has changed the fact that the way we look impacts on our ability to perform.  No matter how vehemently one wants to pretend that their appearance doesn’t matter, the notion is absolutely wrong.  Commenters screamed, yelled, stamped their feet and insisted that they will look any darn way they please, and anybody who disagrees should go to a flying leap.  And they are wrong.  Read the comments.  They really are quite funny.

For some, the impact of appearance is problematic.  There are some things one can change about their appearance, and some things one can’t.  No one forces you to dress in mod clothing, but your bug eyes are yours forever.  Does this matter.  Yes, it does, whether you like it or not.  No matter how much control you wish to assert over your own appearance, you can’t make someone else look at you and think, “No, he’s not as much of a jerk as he looks.”  They will see you whatever they chose, and you don’t get a vote.  Are they “wrong” in some existential world?  You betcha.  Does it change the outcome?  Not an iota.

So let me add my voice to Anne’s; when it comes to being a lawyer, and when your obligation is to provide effective representation of another human being, looks matter.  It may not be fair.  It may not be “right”.  It may not be fun.  But looks still matter.  Get over it.  If you insist they don’t, and that you have the “right” to be the “real you,” no matter how that “real you” comes off to others, find another job.  This one isn’t for you.

Newsday Goes from Bad to Worse

Like all dead tree papers, Newsday is in trouble.  Pull out the “extra” sections and you’ll see that the news and editorial part of the paper is mighty thin indeed.  Mighty thin.  As in it can barely paper the bird cage these days.  Such is the paper under the tutelage of the Dolans of Cablevision fame. 

And let’s not even talk about the Newsday website, possibly the worst of any major newspaper in this country.  Granted, it’s better than the Dolan’s other website for News 12 Long Island, for which I offer no link since you won’t be able to access it anyway.  You see, in order to get onto the website you need to input your Cablevision account number.  How many of you have your Cablevision account number memorized?  What?  It isn’t the most important number in your life?  Jim Dolan thinks it should be, and he puts commercials on TV to prove it, trying to promote its deep meaning in the life of Long Islanders while making it as difficult as humanly possible to use.  

With that in mind, welcome to the newest frontier of newspaper revenue: Newsday will soon have a brand new, spectacular, wonderful website.  And you will have to pay to enjoy it.



Cablevision Systems Corp plans to charge online readers of its Newsday newspaper, a move that would make it one of the first large U.S. papers to reverse a trend toward free Web readership.


The paper said in a statement late on Thursday that it is in the process of transforming the site into a locally focused cable service.


“Our goal was and is to use our electronic network assets and subscriber relationships to transform the way news is distributed,” he said on a conference call with analysts.


“We plan to end the distribution of free Web content and make our news gathering capabilities a service for our customers,” he added.


No, I have no clue what exactly this means either, but I’m fairly certain that it won’t be good.  Ironically, I’m both a subscriber to Newsday as well as Cablevision.  Will I have access to this new horizon of cable/newspaper/whatever it is, or will I have to pay?  Can I link to a Newsday story, or will that require a reader to pay to access the link?  Will this move mean that Newsday, in its effort to find new revenue streams, render itself a non-entity in the news world?

TechDirt picked up the Reuters story of Newsdays new initiative, and had this to say:


The quality of reporting in Newsday already paled in comparison to many other newspapers, so it just wasn’t worth the hassle — even once it removed the registration wall. I almost never visit the website any more — though, occasionally I check the sports pages there. Last year, Cablevision bought Newsday, and today, along with announcing it was writing down a huge chunk of that purchase, said that it’s going to start charging for access to Newsday online, making it that much less likely that anyone will care enough to visit Newsday’s website. The major area news is much better covered by the other newspapers, and various “hyperlocal” websites are popping up all over the place to cover the local specifics. Deciding to charge for Newsday online is basically a death sentence for the paper.

Unfortunately, I agree.  Newsday has already marginalized its worth by its negligble reporting, following journalist and editorial layoffs that have reduced its content to bare bones, if that.  And now they will chase away the few of us who remain by trying to suck out the marginal pennies? 

Newsday came out with its own report today as well, curiously noting that “specifics of the plan remain unclear.”  Probably not much reason to tell the good folks who still have a job at Newsday what’s going on.

Long Island is a large enough area to merit some local coverage, and that’s Newsday’s reason to exist.  But the Dolan’s attempt to monetize the Newsday website and somehow combine the cable television business model with the news distribution business model is doomed.  While Cablevision, for all its missteps and the abject hatred of its customers for its constant increase of fees and MaBell-like approach to customer service, enjoys the benefits of long-time monopolization (now changing since Verizon Fios came into the ‘hood)  making it akin to a cash machine, this isn’t going to work the same with Newsday. 

To the extent one can discern what all this is about, it appears that Newsday will cease to exist as an actual Newspaper and instead become some value-added benefit for Cablevision subscribers, as if it was a customer newsletter rather than a legitimate news source. 


Newsday publisher Timothy P. Knight said: “We are in the process of transforming Newsday’s Web site into an enhanced, locally focused cable service that we believe will become an important benefit for Newsday and Cablevision customers. More particulars will be forthcoming over the next few months.

As a general rule, whenever there are more adjectives than nouns in a phrase, it means they got nothing good to say.  There is a strong possibility that what Knight is actually saying is,


“We’re folding Newsday into Cablevision, and you will have to pay for one to get the other, even though Newsday won’t actually be a newspaper anymore and won’t be worth spit to you.  Oh yeah, and we’re increasing the price for cable because you’re now getting Newsday too.  Whether you want it or not.”

Of course, this is my interpretation.  I could be wrong.

No one needs Newsday that badly.  In fact, it’s questionable whether anyone needs Newsday, at its current state, at all.  We can get the supermarket advertisements elsewhere.  Newsday, say hello the Rocky Mountain News.

Must Every Harm Have a “Victim”? (Update)

This past week, the W.R. Grace Company went on trial in federal court in Missoula, Montana for environmental crimes, particularly mining vermiculite and releasing asbestos into the environs, in violation of the Clean Air Act.  By doing this, Grace is alleged to have “endangered” the local residents. 

Naturally, this means that Paul Cassell has wound up the victim machinery and sought to exercise the rights of some of the locally endangered under the Crime Victims Rights Act.  There’s a drawback, however.  No one has actually been harmed.  Endangered, perhaps, but not harmed.  But little details like this can’t keep a good victim down.

District Court Judge Donald W. Molloy rejected the “victims’ ” attempts to inject themselves into the trial, holding that the CVRA, which defines a crime victim as “a person directly and proximately harmed,” does not apply. 


This interpretation leads to the conclusion that because victims of the federal offenses alleged are not necessarily harmed, they are not necessarily victims under the Act, which are by definition person directly and proximately harmed.

This brought a quick writ of mandamus to the 9th Circuit.  Cassell argued:


First, the Superseding Indictment alleges that the Parkers have been placed in “imminent danger of death or serious bodily injury.” Being placed in grave danger is, ipso facto, a harm sufficient to trigger the protections of the CVRA. Any other conclusion would mean that there would be no “victims” of a whole host of federal offenses that involve threat of injury rather than actual physical injury, including not only the most serious environmental crimes but other federal offenses such as attempted murder, drive-by shooting, assault, child endangerment, and mailing of threatening communications. These offenses are not “victimless” crimes because they create fear and other emotional injuries. The Parkers have been harmed by the defendants’ crimes because of the obvious psychic harm stemming from being placed in the shadow of imminent death and serious bodily injury.

In other words, if there is a crime, there must be a victim, as there can be no crime, “ipso facto,” without them.  In the absence of physical harm, “psychic harm” will do. 

What does this mean to the victims?  It means the right to be present throughout the trial, to have input into the prosecution’s strategy and choices and ultimately, the right to compensation and restitution.  How can there be a victim without a cash payout at the end?  That would be unAmerican.

As of yesterday, the 9th Circuits writs have been fully briefed and ready for determination.  The defense challenge to victimhood presents a compelling dilemma:  How is one a victim of a crime before a crime is found to have been committed?  What are the bases for victimhood outside the allegations of the indictment?


This case, however, is anything but run-of-the-mill, and it perfectly illustrates the dangers of departing from the hornbook rule that the CVRA’s application to pre-conviction proceedings must be determined from the factual allegations in the indictment. That is so in part because the freestanding, postindictment allegations of harm made by Petitioners depend on complex scientific and medical judgments that are strongly disputed by Defendants—who will at trial vigorously challenge the Government’s assertion that their alleged conduct endangered any alleged victim of the charges at issue in this case. But it is especially so because the indictment utterly fails to specify both the particular conduct upon which its broadly framed charges are based and the particular individuals against whom the alleged offenses were committed, and because the statute of limitations sharply circumscribes the extent to which the indictment’s few particulars support chargeable criminal offenses in the first place.

Beyond the mere claims of victimhood, the defense contends that the “trial within a trial,” meaning the issues and allegations raised by the “victims” apart from the government’s indictment, have no place within the criminal prosecution.  This presents yet another problem with the CVRA, empowering victims to put the defense in the position of defending a collateral criminal attack apart from the prosecution itself.  But then, if the victims deserve to have this cornucopia of rights apart from the government, they have to be vindicated somewhere or they’re just illusory. 

This leaves the defense exposed to two separate prosecutions, the one mounted by the government and the one presented by the self-proclaimed victims, for whom no constraints exist at all.  The victims can throw everything they’ve got against the wall to see if anything sticks, while the defense is busy defending against the United States of America.

In a curious move, Judge Molloy has responded to the writ of mandamus as well, something that rarely happens.


I am absolutely convinced my pretrial ruling, based on the issues and complexity of the case, was correct. . . . In light of the testimony of the eight witnesses who have testified I have no doubt that if any of the witnesses is allowed to sit in the courtroom to listen before testifying, it will significantly impact the ability of any of all of the defendants to cross examine witnesses to point out lack of memory, bias, confusion, and any other matter inherent to the notion that cross examination and confrontation are the crucible in which the truth must be tested.

One of the most odious aspects of the CVRA is that it undermines the basic rules of fairness at trial, allowing trial witnesses to sit through the testimony of other witnesses before taking the stand.  But then, who cares about the integrity of the trial process when there are victims’ rights to vindicate?  Thankfully, Judge Molloy seems to care that the witnesses against W.R.Grace don’t get a free pass on tailoring their testimony in order to conform it to make sure that Grace gets crucified.  Whether Grace deserves to be crucified or not isn’t the point; They still get a fair trial.

Step by step, victims’ rights advocates like Paul Cassell are pushing the frontier at every opportunity, manufacturing victims where none exist and extending victimhood beyond any rationale basis.  For most of us, this has yet to present a real problem, as it hasn’t interfered with our cases and no one has moved that third table into the well of our courtroom.  But as legal entropy allows victimhood to expand, and as victims come to recognize just how much they can screw with the process, and screw up the process, it will come soon to a courtroom near you. 

Need more proof that it’s a very real problem?  How about Alan Hesketh, the former Pfizer VP who was ordered to pay $200,000 in restitution to the victim of child pornography based upon his conviction for possessing it.  Not making it.  Not distributing it, but merely possesing it.


Senior U.S. District Judge Warren W. Eginton said his ruling was the first in a criminal case in which someone convicted of possessing illegal images — but not creating them — is required to pay restitution.

“We’re dealing with a frontier here,” Eginton said, but he said judges have discretion with criminal restitution orders.

The rationale was purely rhetorical, that the victim suffered “exploitation” as a result of Hesketh’s conduct.  As revolting as Hesketh may be for his conduct, and as much as we may want to punish him for it, one thing is abundantly clear: He was not the cause of any actual harm to the “victim”.

Once harm is divorced from the concept of victim, there’s no stopping them.  Hey, I’m suffering deep psychic harm from environmental dangers too.  Where’s my seat in the well and when do I get my restitution check?

Update:  The 9th Circuit has spoken, and the victims are victims.  Apparently, if there is a crime, there must be victims. 


After review of the parties’ briefs and the record, the petitions for writ of mandamus are granted. The district court erred in denying petitioners’ motions to accord rights to victim-witnesses based on its finding that the 34 victim-witnesses identified by the United States as prospective victims do not meet the meaning of “crime victim” set forth in the Crime Victims’ Rights Act, 18 U.S.C. § 3771(b)(2)(D), and therefore are excluded from court proceedings.

Shut off the lights on the way out.