Author Archives: SHG

Welcome to Part F

It seems like it’s been forever since I’ve been down to criminal court at 100 Centre Street.  There isn’t much reason for me to be here, as my days of representing defendants in misdemeanor state court cases is behind me.  But I was retained to go to Part F today, and so to Part F I went.  What a blast from the past!

For those who haven’t had the pleasure, New York calls it’s courtrooms “Part” something, usually a number.  I’m sure there’s a rich and amusing history to explain the use of the word “Part” when referring to a courtroom, but I have no idea what it is.  It’s just one of those local quirks that one gets used to.

Part F is the pre-indictment felony part, meaning that this is where cases go that are initially charged as a felony but have yet to be indicted.  Once indicted, they go to Supreme Court.  Until then, they sit in Part F or Part N, if a narcotics case.  Lawyers walk in and yell out names of the people they are there to represent and whom they’ve never before met. 

It’s a strange and wonderful place, with a very full docket and lawyers walking in and out all morning.  If you don’t get your name on the list early, you can spend all day sitting there waiting for your case to be called.  The good news is that you get to see plenty of people while sitting there.  The bad news is that most are painfully young.

But what makes Part F special is the proliferation of “one time only” offers.  As you step into the well, a very young official person reads the words on a note offering a “one time only” offer of a plea to (insert various penal law numbers here), meaning that the defendant can take it right there and then or suffer the threat of INDICTMENT.  It comes in all caps when spoken as well, as the young assistant assumes an ominous tone that if you eschew his kind offer, you will pay.

I had forgotten how this game was played in Part F, the fear that flowed through lawyer and client when they were told to take it or be INDICTED (shudder).  No time to talk, to think, to consider, to discuss.  This was noblesse oblige at its finest, the Executive deigning to give the downtrodden one chance at a break.  How kind of them.

I stifled a laugh when it was my turn.  I was just so nostalgically amused by it all.  I politely told the court how much I appreciated the prosecution’s very kind offer, but I was afraid that it would be impossible for me to accept it as I have not had an opportunity to discuss the offer with my client, and I would never accept a plea without my client being fully informed.  The assistant reacted by telling me that they would keep the offer open, provided that I waive speedy trial.

As warm as his accommodation made me feel, I was still inclined to pass.  I told the court that I couldn’t possibly waive speedy trial, that being a valuable constitutional right and my not having the slightest clue if my client had any interest whatsoever in any offer under the sun.  To waive a valuable right without good reason would be an offense to our founding fathers, and I would never want to offend them.  Not even when their dead.  It would be wrong. 

The judge adjourned the case for “grand jury action.”  The prosecutor asked if I wanted to provide cross grand jury notice.  I just smiled. He didn’t know what to make of my smile.  I hope he thinks I’m just a friendly sort of fellow.

And so the case was adjourned.  The ADA was nonplussed, moving swiftly to the next case and the next note.  And I thought about the old days, when “justice” was routinely done in less than 30 seconds by lawyers who called out the names to find out whether they had showed up that day in Part F, so they can plead them out.

Beware the Government’s Claw in the Back

While the name Ponzi continues to ring in our ears, as Madoff sits in his penthouse prison pondering his future, his former investors ponder theirs as well.  For many, the future may involve a gig as greeter at Walmart, as unpleasant as that may be.  But for others, the future may mean coming face to face with the ugly claw of justice.  The Department of Justice, that is.


In a legal action known as “clawback,” the special trustee handling the bankruptcy of Madoff’s firm has the power to try to recover the illusory profits reported and in some cases paid out to investors.

Officials will be seeking to recover false profits from those who received them over the years, attorney David Sheehan, who is assisting trustee Irving Picard, told scores of Madoff investors who met with him Friday in Manhattan.

While some reinvested their gains back into Madoff’s scheme, others took their profits and put them to good use.  Now, they are told that these weren’t profits, as they understood them to be and dutifully reported to the delightful IRS, but “illusory profits” subject to recovery by the Irving Picard, the court appointed trustee charged with marshaling and recovering the assets for the benefit of the victims.  Victims, suddenly, has a very different meaning.

This will most assuredly wreak havoc in the lives of those Madoff investors who cashed the checks sent out and used the money for other purposes.  These are individuals who relied upon the representations of great returns by Madoff, just like the people who reinvested and now find themselves eating spam.  The only difference is that they didn’t continue to play the game.  Does this create a second class of investor, somehow more culpable than the ones who continued to seek the high returns Madoff offered?  What did they do wrong by cashing the check instead of reinvesting?

The difference, from the government perspective, is that they didn’t lose as much as those investors who chose not to take their profits and run because they took profits out and hence received more than the mere paper benefit that others thought they received.  But that does little to shift the moral burden from one investor to another.  They are all in the same boat as far as any theoretical moral culpability for putting their money in to receive the promised high returns.  That they made different choices on the way out, to cash out rather than reinvest, is hardly a distinguishing factor that justifies ruining the lives of the people who made the better choice.  Actually, the less greedy choice, having decided to enjoy the high return without gambling for more.

Bear in mind, as I speak of moral culpability, that while the Madoff investers were promised, and enjoyed to some extent, high returns, this carefully crafted scheme promised returns that were very good but not so ridiculously good as to be incredible. Many, and I mean many, extraordinarily savvy investors bought into the Madoff scheme.  The returns were indeed possible, if Madoff was as good as everybody believed him to be.  It’s not as if these investors “knew or should have known” that they were part of a Ponzi scheme.  They believed that they were being very responsible investors, and doing a very fine job of it. 

This is a capitalist country, and people are allowed to seek and obtain good returns on their hard-earned money.  It’s not a crime to reasonably expect, and ultimately receive, a good return on an investment.  It’s not a crime to take your profits and go home.  Yet those who did may soon find the government’s claw deeply embedded in their backs.  As sorry as this may be for the investors who lost everything, their damage should not be vindicated on the backs of those other investors who salvaged something from their participation by reasonably relying on the validity of the profits received.

There are many victims of the Madoff morass, but the ones who took some gains out should not be singled out to suffer the government’s clawback.  There is no reason that they should be victimized a second time; once by Madoff and again by the government.  They’ve done nothing wrong, and they should not be made the scapegoats of this mess.

When Cops are Sorry

Radley Balko at The Agitator already has the story of three Atlanta narcotics cops who goofed bigtime, killing 92-year-old Kathryn Johnson in a botched drug raid and then trying to cover it up.  The three were caught, prosecuted and sentenced:

U.S. District Judge Julie Carnes sentenced former officer Gregg Junnier to six years in prison, Jason Smith to 10 years in prison and Arthur Tesler to 5 years in prison.

Not much for a dead 92 year old woman.  Not much for planting drugs.  Not much for violating their oath.  But hey, they were just trying to do their job, protecting us by getting those bad guys.  Stercus accidit.

What stood out, and demanded further notice, was one paragraph quoted by Radley from the Atlanta Journal-Constitution article :

Tesler said when he saw Smith about to plant baggies of marijuana inside Johnston’s home to make it look like a drug house, he shook his head in disapproval. Tesler said he falsified the police report and later lied about the raid because Smith told him to follow the cover-up script. Tesler said he wasn’t about to “rat” on a senior officer.

Radley attributed this mindset to the War on Drugs.  I wish I could pass it off so lightly, but I can’t.  Were there no war on drugs, the blue wall would still stand, as impermeable as ever.  Sure, drug raids have been a huge source of police crime, providing vast opportunities for theft, abuse and error.  But the problem is as old as the free cup of java at the corner grocery store.

This brotherhood amongst police officers has been the subject of many commentaries here and elsewhere.  There is a belief that flows through law enforcement that no matter what else happens, no cop can rat out another cop.  No, it doesn’t mean that they all desire to be dirty, or that they aren’t well intended in the performance of their duty, though some are every bit as much the criminal as any “mutt” on the street.  But so rare is the officer who will stand against his brothers that it’s movie worthy.

At its core, the death of Kathryn Johnson is a reflection of the sloppiness in policing that is now being encouraged by our Supreme Court in the name of expediency.  We can’t demand too much of our cops and prosecutors, or it would be a burden.  Sorry, Mrs. Johnson, that you had to die so that cops weren’t unduly burdened.

My purpose in pursuing this obvious line is to clarify that the Blue Wall, in and of itself, must come down before there will any chance of changing police culture.  As long as the “us versus them” attitude permeates law enforcement, and the prime directive remains that no cop shall rat out another, no matter how bad he may be, nothing will change.

This is not a product of the ill-conceived war on drugs, though it certainly offers much opportunity for rampant wrongdoing and, therefore, concealment.  This is a culture war between police and everyone else, and it is critical that this not be forgotten.

Until the culture of police demands that they uphold the law within their own ranks, there will be no change.

What Is It About Keeping Score on Twitter? (Update)

While sane people debate the relative worth of twitter, with opinions ranging from it being today’s version of the leisure suit to it being the worldwide water cooler, some have made the gathering of followers their goal in life.  Names omitted to protect the foolish.  Sure, there are some who urge twitter as the newiest and cooliest business-getter tool around (for a fee), but the obsession with numbers of followers has little to do with the quality of followers.

So when I happened upon this nonsense when I checked out one of my new followers, I was flabbergasted.  Folks, this is just insane.  No one, but no one, will go to heaven for having the most followers on twitter.  No one.  There will be no prize.  There will be no honors bestowed upon you for being the most followed.  You still have to pay to get on the subway.  Sorry, but that’s how it goes.

There are twitterers who have tens of thousand of followers.  I’ve taken a look at some of them, expecting to find twits so deep, so brilliant, that it would alter my philosophical view of the world.  Nope.  Their twits were pretty much like anyone else’s.  Some were substantially worse.  Some sucked.

What I did notice was that the twitterers with big numbers of followers similarly followed huge numbers of others.  Now perhaps I’m just a bit slow, but I fail to understand how anyone can gain anything from following ten thousand twitterers.  No one has the time to read that many twits, and even the time to try would consume whatever time was available for having a life.  Anyone who follows that many people is kinda weird.

Unless, of course, they aren’t reading the twits at all, but merely following others so they will follow them in return.  That aspect of the phenomenon became clear as I kept getting the new follower messages, only to see that my new followers dropped me a day later.  A wise twitterer explained that people follow you to get you to follow them, then drop you (since you don’t get a message about it) afterward.  Then there are some people who I like and respect, but whose twits were too numerous or off-topic for my tastes.  When I unfollowed them, they unfollowed me.  Apparently, twitterers take unfollowing very personally.

As for the new and cool, that ship has clearly sailed.  While watching Rick Sanchez on CNN, he pushed his twitting hard throughout the broadcast.  Nothing can be more uncool than when Rick Sanchez becomes part of it.  Twitter was also pushed during President Obama’s speech to the joint session of Congress.  Remember when George Bush got an Ipod?  Same deal.  It was the end of its cool factor.

And as of yesterday, every lawyer marketing consultant on the face of the earth is now officially selling the secret magic way to collect followers on twitter.  You too can have a million followers!  But you still have to pay to ride the subway.

At this very moment, I have 330 followers.  A bunch are marketers, and if they think that they have a chance of getting business from me, they are going to be sorely disappointed.  About 20 marketers were cleared out a couple of weeks ago, but they keep coming back.  They are nothing if not persistent.  By the end of this post, I expect to have 20 fewer followers.  At least.

I don’t twit a lot, and little of what I twit about is worth reading.  I don’t anticipate that I’ll find many major white collar federal criminal defendants searching for counsel on twitter, although I expect some persistently perky marketer to disagree and inform me that if I only new the magic secrets, I could quadruple my number of followers overnight and become rich! rich! rich!  I wonder why these former lawyers who know the secret to becoming rich! rich! rich! no longer practice law and prefer instead to be grubby little marketers.  But I’m sure it’s because they are great humanitarians, bent on helping the huddled masses of undervalued lawyers.

The chances of my having tens of thousands of followers is slim.  I’m just going to have to live with the knowledge that I will never win the prize.  On the other hand, at least I won’t be caught wearing a polyester double-knit leisure suit.  I’m cool with that.

Update:  Walter Olson’s take gives rise to another gem, reciprocity fetishes, definitely worthy of a special update.  I am such a sucker for a great phrase, and I believe we’ve got a winner here!

Collateral Consequences of a Plea Revisited (Update)

Via Carolyn Elefant at Legal Blog Watch, the Supreme Court has granted cert in a Padilla v. Kentucky which raises a variation on an old theme: What is the role of collateral immigration consequences of a guilty plea, and who takes the heat when things go wrong.

The facts from the Kentucky court’s decision are fairly straightforward. Jose Padilla (no, not that Jose Padilla) is a Honduran national and Vietnam veteran who lived in the United States for decades but never became a citizen. Padilla was arrested and charged with several drug-related counts including trafficking five pounds of marijuana. Padilla’s attorney negotiated a guilty plea under which all but the marijuana charge would be dismissed, and further, where Padilla would serve five years of an otherwise 10-year sentence. Padilla asked his attorney about the impact of the plea on his immigration status and his lawyer assured him that Padilla would not be deported since he had lived in the United States for so long. With that, Padilla accepted the plea. Two years later, believing that the government was preparing to deport him, Padilla filed a post-conviction motion to withdraw the plea, arguing that his attorney’s erroneous advice constituted ineffective assistance of counsel in violation of the Sixth Amendment.

When Congress decided in 1990 to make deportation an automatic consequence of conviction of an “aggravated felony,” a curious term since it didn’t necessarily require a felony and was only certain to aggravate the defense and judge, it created much heat and debate about who, if anyone, was responsible for advising non-citizen defendants that a guilty plea would result in deportation after a term of imprisonment was served, and that there were few, if any ways around it.

As set forth in the amicus brief for cert, there is a 27 to 3 split in state and federal courts on whether defense counsel has an affirmative duty to advise the defendant of the immigration consequences of a guilty plea.  But this case involves a variation on the theme, where Padilla asked his lawyer what would happen and the lawyer gave him the wrong answer.  Relying on that answer, Padilla took the plea.

Since the change in immigration law in 1990, the question of who is responsible for informing the defendant of the immigration consequences has been a subject of debate and dispute.  Nobody, including defense counsel, wants to be saddled with it, both because it gives rise to terrible arguments (“but how can I be deported when I’ve lived here for 50 years?”), leaving the lawyer to justify this insanely harsh and irresponsible consequence when it wasn’t his choice to begin with, as well as severely muddying up the decision-making process on whether to take the plea. 

Too often, a defendant would want the benefit of the plea bargain, but for the immigration consequences.  This would create a dilemma, given that the alternative was to reject the plea, go to trial, and suffer the consequences of a loss, including post imprisonment deportation.  It drove everyone nuts, as it was an extremely emotional problem, more so than just the imprisonment for the crime.  The idea of being deported to a country one left at age 2, after living here for decades and having a family, children, a business, whatever, at risk. 

While I personally undertook to explain this to defendants, I also contended that the responsibility for informing defendants of collateral immigration consequences should be on the judges’ shoulders.  Of course, judges didn’t want it either, knowing all too well of the problems it would cause in getting deals completed.  And so, collateral immigration consequences largely floated in the vapor, with many defendants finding out after it was too late.  Not that it rationally changed much, but it fell far short of a fully informed plea.

But the variation in Padilla’s case is quite different.  Here, it was not merely a matter of Padilla being informed, but of being misinformed.  The Kentucky Supreme Court held that since immigration consequences were collateral to the direct consequences of the guilty plea, the erroneous information given by the defense lawyer did not violate Padilla’s 6th Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel.  This is not say that Padilla’s lawyer should win an award for a job well done, but was the error of sufficient constitutional significance to compel the court to undo the damage.


The majority rejected Padilla’s argument, explaining that the lawyer’s advice on immigration status was collateral to the criminal defense component of his representation, to which the Sixth Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel is attached. The minority disagreed, finding that whether collateral to Padilla’s defense or not, the lawyer’s erroneous advice, in response to an affirmative inquiry by the defendant, was inexcusable and justified a hearing on the ineffective assistance of counsel claim.

The defendant’s decision to plead guilty, and consequently waive the array of rights theoretically due him, must be knowing, intelligent and voluntary.  While these three words are honored primarily in the breach, this is a case where the breach is raised directly.  Jose Padilla took the affirmative step of inquiring of his lawyer whether he would be deported as a result of his plea.  By so doing, he affirmatively established that this was a sufficiently important factor in making his decision that an answer was needed.  By providing the wrong answer, the defense counsel denied Padilla the ability to make a knowing, intelligent and voluntary decision.  Without this, there can be no valid plea.

The Kentucky Supreme Court’s decision, that the issue was collateral, seems to miss the point, by substituting their subjective judgment on what is a material issue to Padilla in making the decision to plead guilty.  The majority concluded that it was not an objectively valid direct consequence, which of course is consistent with the majority of courts that have considered the primary duty to inform a defendant of collateral immigration consequences.  However, that wasn’t the real issue in this particular case.

The decision to plead guilty or go to trial is a personal one to every defendant, and the relative importance of various factors to be considered is his to make, not a court’s.  Perhaps the defendant, for highly personal reasons, will put huge emphasis on a factor that most of us, and all judges, would consider silly or irrelevant.  So what?  The decision belongs exclusively to the defendant, and he doesn’t need anyone else’s permission or approval to reach his decision in his own way. 

A defendant is entitled to weigh the factors according to his personal needs and values, and make the decision that is right for him, whether anyone else agrees or not.  While there is no doubt a line beyond which a defendant’s inquiry, and an erroneous answer, is just not of sufficient consequence (or perhaps sanity) to merit a 6th Amendment challenge.  But deportation clearly is a real and meaningful factor. 

As Jose Padilla asked, he deserved an accurate answer.  He was grievously misinformed, and relied on that bad information.  His plea, therefore, simply cannot meet the threshold of knowing, intelligent and voluntary.  The fault clearly fell on his attorney, who gave him the wrong answer, and Padilla was entitled under the 6th Amendment to an attorney who would give him the correct answer to any question that impacted on his decision to plead guilty.  While some questions properly produce the answer of “I don’t know,” there is no excuse for being given a totally wrong answer, as happened here.

What’s the solution?  As I’ve argued since 1990, every judge should include in the allocution the collateral immigration consequences of a plea of guilty.  Even if it’s the defense lawyer’s practice to inform his clients, it remains the duty of the judge to make certain that the defendant’s plea is fully informed.  While I agree that deportation is a collateral consequence of a plea, and that there is certainly some lack of clarity about what constitutes an aggravated felony and whether criminal defense lawyers should be expected to have expertise in immigration law as well, the fact remains that a defendant is entitled to effective representation when he obtains an answer to a question in anticipation of a plea.

The moral of the story is that when you answer your client’s pre-plea questions, you are responsible for giving them the correct answer.  It really isn’t that much to ask.

Update:  Remy Orozco at Hostos Civitas and Bobby Frederick have joined the conversation, coming in on the side of the defense counsel being solely responsible for informing the client of collateral deportation consequences.


The fact is, no one knows the defendant’s situation like the defense attorney. The judge, and often the prosecutor, often do not know the defendant’s immigration status unless the defense attorney tells them – which does place the responsibility squarely on the shoulders of the defense lawyer. I agree with Remy that an attorney who ignores the fact that his client is not a legal resident, or does not inquire, is committing malpractice.

Therein lies my problem.  The defendant doesn’t need a cause of action for malpractice, but a way to address a 6th Amendment deprivation when defense counsel blows it.  I can’t fault either, of course, for their dedication to the best interests of the defendant.

Playing Catch-Up

Texas District Court Judge Samuel Kent wrote some incredibly funny, sarcastic decisions.  Who could ever forget:


The Court notes that this case involves two extremely likable lawyers, who have together delivered some of the most amateurish pleadings ever to cross the hallowed causeway into Galveston, an effort which leads the Court to surmise but one plausible explanation. Both attorneys have obviously entered into a secret pact-complete with hats, handshakes and cryptic words-to draft their pleadings entirely in crayon on the back sides of gravy-stained paper place mats, in the hope that the Court would be so charmed by their child-like efforts that their utter dearth of legal authorities in their briefing would go unnoticed.

Now he’s copped a plea for copping something else, resigned in disgrace and will get the chance to see just how funny the sentencing guidelines can really be.  Memo to federal judges: Nobody’s perfect, eh?  Perhaps you might want to take a harder look at the people who stand before you day after day, and wonder how you might feel if that person turned out to be one of your black-robed brothers.  It could happen.

Alfred Trenkler was convicted of a bombing and murder in 1993.  After reading a book by Morrison Bonpasse, “Perfectly Innocent,” three of the jurors who convicted Tenkler have changed their minds.


All three have written letters to U.S. District Judge Rya W. Zobel urging her to grant Trenkler a new trial or set him free.

Bonpasse’s manuscript convinced Sheridan Kassirer, the jury’s forewoman. After reading it, she wrote to Judge Zobel, “After studying the many details of the Alfred W. Trenkler case I am convinced that he is innocent. I hope you will see to it that justice prevails and he is released.”

How nice that the jurors are having second thoughts.  Twenty something years later.  But the question begs asking:  So what were you doing in that jury room in 1993 when you convicted the guy?  Was the food so lousy that you couldn’t spend the time to think really hard back then, before convicting?


“I’m just appalled that the system is in fact very flawed,” said Bonpasse, who lives in New Castle with his wife, a retired judge. “I’m appalled that the system is so slow and finds it so difficult to open its eyes and see what it’s done to so many people.”

Welcome to the club.

Attorney Mark and Rhonda Lesher were accused of sexually molesting one of Mark’s clients.  They were tried.  They were acquitted.  During the course of the prosecution, they were smeared.


DALLAS — Clarksville lawyer Mark Lesher may not know the identity of the people he’s suing, but he says his purpose is clear: To ensure that everyone who anonymously posted what he alleges are libelous comments about him on a Web site is held “responsible and accountable.”

“You can’t just spew venomous lies and be on a mission to destroy people,” he says. “There are laws to prevent that.”

The Leshers have obtained a subpoena against Topix, where about 25,000 posts relating to the Leshers appeared, to obtain the identities of 178 anonymous posters.  They hope to obtain the IP address of the 178.  And then what?  As in the AutoAdmit case, it’s time that we all grew up and realized that anonymous posting of such crap is meaningless and worthless.  I’m neither excusing nor apologizing for the ignorant slop that finds its way to the surface on the internet.  When hidden by anonymity, people post the most incredibly outrageous and vile crap.  We know it. 

Since there’s no way to seriously police comments for accuracy, and we are not inclined to eliminate the ability to post anonymously, there will be libelous posts.  Obviously the verdict of acquittal hasn’t done enough to let the Leshers feel satisfied that they, and not the anonymous posters, prevailed.  But they aren’t going to obtain the satisfaction they seek down this road.  The better route would seem to be the recognition that this is all mere garbage, unworthy of belief or recognition. 

People have an amazing ability to be ugly and stupid, and no lawsuit is going to change that.  When a credible source libels someone, action is necessary.  When it comes from the sewer, we need to be able to shrug it off as no better than its source.  The Leshers won.  They are not guilty.  The 178 posters are scum, and who cares what the scum have to say.

New York Supreme Court Judge Joseph Makowski doesn’t have to worry about judicial salaries anymore.  His went down the drain when he decided to help Buffalo Law School instructor Anne Adams, a former Erie County prosecutor and potential GOP District Attorney candidate.  She was drunk and tried to manufacture evidence to beat the rap.  Makowski first lied to help her, then recanted.


“Neither party to this pathetic episode committed violent crimes, nor have criminal records,” Sedita said. “By the same token, one of my most important duties as district attorney is to restore public confidence in the justice system. Accordingly, this type of misconduct, particularly on behalf of lawyers, judges and public officials, will not be tolerated and will not be overlooked by this office.”

Did it occur to anyone that the two are just too unbearably stupid to be tolerated?  By the way, if Adams drunken driving just so happened to end up with some dead child along the way, by sheer misfortune, she might have been tried as a murderer in some New York locales. 

And finally, Westhampton attorney George Guldi, whose office was ransacked by the cops in search of evidence of mortgage fraud, gets sued by Wachovia for allegedly pocketing $1.8 million in a scam sale on a Hamptons property.


When reached on Friday afternoon, Mr. Guldi said he had not yet reviewed his copy of the lawsuit, which he just received earlier in the day. “If someone gave me $1.8 million, I would have remembered it,” said Mr. Guldi before declining to elaborate further.

Anyone else wonder how many ways those words could come back to bite Guldi in the butt?  Memo to Guldi’s lawyers : A prepared client is a silent client.  That’s how experienced counsel handle media cases.  Then you won’t have to worry about wiping the sweet white filling off your face when you’re caught unprepared.

Phoenix Rising

David Giacalone has announced that he’s hanging up his keyboard.  His weblog (he never called it a blog or a blawg, but always a weblog), co-authored by his curmudgeonly alter ego, Professor Yabut, f/k/a, was simultaneously the conscience of the blawgosphere as well as the literary break from the awkward prose and self-serving posts that comprised the bulk of its output.  David was the safe haven for thought and continuity, never led astray by shiny new objects or self-aggrandizement.

p.s. Seven-Day Countdown: Speaking of feeling our emotions, getting things moving and setting ourselves free, the f/k/a Gang plans to stop adding to this weblog as of March 1, 2009.   It will remain online, with thousands of haiku and senryu, and a lot of law-related and cultural punditry. But, the last f/k/a posting will roll off your Editor’s fingers no later than Feb. 28, 2009. We’ll try to write a few more posts related to lawyer fees before we hang up our blawger sword; then we’ll be looking for something more enjoyable and less stressful to do online.  Naturally, we’ll have a little more to say when we sign off at the end of this week.

It’s not the first time that David decided to call it quits.  In his first incarnation, ethicalesq., David decided to leave the building, only to return as f/k/a.  This time, David’s resolve appears more firm.

But don’t think of this as the death of a weblog, but rather the rebirth of a great lawyer.  Times change and with it new goals come into our sights.  David has rededicated his efforts to other areas, and something must give way.  As it turns out, it will be the weblog. 

Some will miss David’s haiku and senryu.  Some will miss the clear-eyed skepticism which David brought to bear on every new toy the children of the blawgosphere found lying on th street.  Some will miss a fellow curmudgeon, who elevated the level of discourse through his insightful commentary and refusal to join the crowd because it was the path of least resistance. 

But not me.  I fully expect David Giacalone to keep his keen eyes peeled on the blawgosphere, chiming in whenever needed to remind us when we’re being foolish and trendy and self-serving.  In the meantime, I admire and envy David’s decision to dedicate his time to purposes more productive.  While I will miss f/k/a, this is no Requiem for a Heavyweight, but Phoenix Rising. 

Hope you have great fun on your next adventure, but don’t stray too far so I can find you whenever you’re needed.

When Schools Go to the Dogs

Few people want high school students involved with drugs.  But the mere incantation of the word “drugs”, or the even scarier word, “heroin”, seems to lead otherwise intelligent and thoughtful people to rush to the most simplistic solutions.  In Nassau County, the latest “do it for the children” scare has so shaken the Newsday editorial board that their brains are sadly addled.

In the editorial, A sad choice: dogs v. drugs, Newsday doesn’t bother with the effort to find a solution that might protect the innocent or respect the privacy of students.  They just jump in blind:


More and more, schools are using trained drug-sniffing dogs to examine students’ lockers, cars and book bags. The fear behind this is heroin – the cheap, available drug of choice for this school-age generation. There is demand, too, for dogs who search out gunpowder, and for portable metal-detectors. Fear of gang activity lies behind these searches.

These are sorry times that lead us to invade students’ space in these ways. The searches can create an atmosphere of distrust, but they are often necessary – and even wise.

What about these times are so sorry that they demand a Newspaper to ignore all consequences that turn the school house into the Big House, with dogs roaming the hallways in search of contraband?  If, as the editorial presumes, there is a horrendous drug problem in a school, then the solution is to address the problem, not turn the school into a prison camp and blindly undermine the privacy of all students. 


Sweeping schools also creates a safe haven for some kids who see drugs and weapons in their communities. One of the chief justifications for these searches is to deter kids from bringing that stuff to school.

Can anyone be this is naive?  Since when do dogs and their handlers roaming the hallways make for a safe haven?  Worse still, if the students live in communities where drugs and weapons are rampant, does it somehow fulfill a school administrator’s dream to know that her students are only shooting up or getting shot after school lets out?  As long as it’s not on school grounds, all is forgotten?


Schools that turn up drugs or weapons should make counseling available or require attendance at treatment agencies. The old-fashioned sanction of suspension from school only further ostracizes troubled students.

But to the extent there’s any rationale for this extreme, and unexplained, need for drug dogs in schools, it’s based on the belief that schools are rife with heroin.  So are they or aren’t they?  If no one knows, then where’s the compelling need to turn schools into prisons first?  Is this an example of “just in case” reasoning?  And if schools are rife with drugs, forget the dogs and get to some serious mandatory counseling now.  But if they aren’t, then there is no explanation for such extreme and harmful tactics as turning schools into prisons.  Which is it?


No one wants to live in a police state. But in this case, protecting children means tolerating more adult intrusion.

Protecting children is the mantra of adults too happy to throw away reason, ignore consequences and rush to the most simplistic solution available.  Newsday has fallen into the trap, and makes no pretense of presenting a rational argument in favor of a solution so fundamentally harmful, destructive of civil rights and deleterious to the educational environment that it should only be considered as a last resort, when everything else has been tried and failed. 

Bizarrely, Newsday doesn’t even try to make the case that it’s actually needed, that they know the problem exists and is of such severity that no lesser effort could suffice.  They support the immediate jump into the abyss of elimination of privacy and personal security while still questioning whether there’s a problem that requires the attention of school officials.

Everyone wants to see schools drug and weapon free. Then again, everyone wants to see students in schools that encourage education.  But how to accomplish this is a sensitive question, and one that would do far better by avoiding the knee-jerk reactions evidenced by this editorial.  It’s not enough to incant “children” and “heroin” to justify turning schools into prisons.  And if the feared problems of violence and drug use are that pervasive in the community, dogs in schools aren’t going to help these students anyway. 

Rarely have I seen an editorial so utterly devoid of reasoning, so reactionary and so happy to leap off the ledge of reason without the slightest consideration of the consequences.  Think harder, Newsday.  Do it for the children.


Do Not Call, Don’t Mean Squat (Update)

For a while, it was quiet.  The phone no longer rang with accented voices pitching things we would never buy.  It was quiet, peaceful, when we ate, chatted and relaxed.

No more.  It started with calls from “unavailable” numbers, computerized voices imploring us to push 1 if we wanted a credit card or to extend our auto warranty.  The calls continued, some with numbers which, when googled, revealed themselves as notorious violators of the Do Not Call Registry.  Complaints were filed, but the calls continued.

Then more calls, with real voices, about mortgages and credit readily available to us, no matter who we were.  When asked who they were, click.

This is the American entrepreneurial spirit hard at work, finding ways to circumvent laws and common decency, all because they can.  Whether the product of technological advancement, if one can call the ability to conceal one’s identity an advancement, it appears that someone is trying to make the most of bad economic times.

Someone must answer the phone and say to the person on the other end, “yes, yes, I want your service so very much,” or they wouldn’t continue to do it.  No one at my house says this, yet they continue to call, sometimes 20 times a week from the same vendor.   In the beginning, I would register a complaint.  It’s no longer worth the effort.

The Do Not Call registry does not work.  But for anyone inclined to cold call me in the hope that I might possibly listen to your pitch or, better still, purchase from you, don’t bother.  I won’t.

And if no one else does either, maybe they will go away.  But like promises of vast wealth from the Nigerian lottery, or Hong Kong businesses blindly seeking legal representation or amorphous police unions demanding donations if they want the cops to show next time a masked man appears at their door, there will always be someone who somehow doesn’t know to just hang up.

Update:  I should have included this in the first place, but had a CRS flare-up.  But here is the all-time best ever telemarketer prank:

The Hyperbolic Hyperlink

Brian Tannebaum is a wine lover, which might seem only natural when one considers that he’s from Miami.  Of course, then one would have to change the spelling of wine.  I was once a wine lover as well, and have the cellar to prove it.  Unfortunately, my intake is limited these days, which is good for the aging process but not so good for the consumption aspect.  It’s not that I have an issue with alcohol, but that tannins give me a headache these days.

One of the things that @miamicrimlaw (Tannebaum’s alter ego) twits about  ad naseum is the various screw-cap wines that he appreciates.  Since he has many followers, who am I to question his wine-cred.  But being the clear-eyed criminal defense lawyer that he is, his incessant wining has led him to an astute observation at his My Law License blog,  

It starts with a running description of a twonversation (note use of cute twitter wording, where every word must be changed to begin with “tw” to show twitter-savvy) between Brian and a twitting wine merchant, @toptenwines, who puffs his product as being a particularly good deal,  Brian, expert and skeptic all rolled into one, responds that his price is the same as everyone else’s, forcing the issue.  The wine merchant, rather than concede he’s a lying sack of used cork, respond by smearing the “provenance” of anyone selling wines for less.

Aside from the silliness of getting nailed for ones hyperbole and responding by calling one’s competitors butt ugly, this wino-seur from Columbia, Missouri has now been enshrined in the Tannebaum hall of shame.  Since Tannebaum has followers who care what he says, Top Ten Wines has now made hundreds of potential wine buyers aware of his puffery.

Now the proprietor, Paul Vernon, looks like a really easy going guy.  He claims not to be pretentious or a snob, and judging from his choice of t-shirt, I would have to believe him.  Frankly, when I was deeper into my wine-buying days, this was the sort of person I would gravitate towards when I looked for wines.  So how did this turn out so wrong?

The answer is obvious, and one that has no more to do with wine than with law.  When one markets, one takes a chance that someone is going to call you on it.  And one gets called on it, the choices are limited.

My bet is that Paul Vernon is just trying his best to sell one, and never meant to get into a battle with the likes of Tannebaum.  But rather than take the hit that his price was good, but no better than others, he took the aggressive path and chose to rip his competition by contending that anyone who sells for less than him must be selling an inferior product.  This is not merely a dubious response, but the sort that causes everyone to bristle because it relies on a false premise.  If they are bad, that makes me better.


There are lawyers who peddle their services through talent and confidence in their work, and there are those who lie to clients, and bad mouth other lawyers just to get the case.

Every good lawyer will say “I don’t bad mouth other lawyers.” The bad, desperate, talentless lawyers will make the potential client believe they are making a big mistake if they don’t hire Mr. Bad mouthing make me feel stupid lawyer.

There’s nothing wrong with engaging in a debate over fees and business philosophies. Just yesterday a potential client asked why he should pay me more than the other lawyers he spoke with. If I am charging more, I should be able to justify why. I should not make the potential client feel bad for asking, nor get arrogant or make him feel that his case will be poorly handled by another lawyer.

As you can see from Tannebaum’s love of one-sentence paragraphs, twitter is the perfect medium for him.  It’s an art to be able to frame one’s thoughts to fit within such a small place.  All bottles of wine are the same when shipped from the winery to the merchant.  The same can’t be said of lawyers, whose skills and experience can vary as much as a 25 year old Cabernet Sauvignon (preferably a certain premier grand cru from Pauillac) from a week old Beaujolais Nouveau.  Still, only a fool will make a choice based on smearing one’s competition.  It doesn’t make you any better by comparison.

As I click the links to lawyers’ websites, I see rampant hyperbole, mine included.  I hate it.  Mine included.  The nature of attempting to distinguish oneself on the internet lends itself to puffery.  After all, there doesn’t seem to be much point to market oneself by saying that you’re nothing special.  But when tested, you need to be able to justify yourself with the positives you bring to the representation of your clients, rather than the negatives of your competitors.  Every lawyer’s hyperlink is hyperbolic to some extent.  It’s a better medium for wines than lawyers.  But it doesn’t mean that you have to diminish others, whether wine or lawyer.

It’s a shame that Paul Vernon pushed the wrong button with Tannebaum, as he’s likely lost more than a few potential customers and doesn’t seem to be a bad guy otherwise.  I’m positive that wasn’t his intention when he got annoyed with Tannebaum for wasting his time.  I end every initial meeting with a potential client by wishing him well, and meaning it.  Not every client is right for me, and I’m not right for every client.  When they walk out that door, I hope they find the perfect wine to accompany their case, and sometimes a Merlot suits a client better than a Margaux.