Author Archives: SHG

For the Love of Prosecutors

I spend the morning yesterday judging the regional semi-finals of a national law school mock trial competition which, fortunately for me, dealt with a criminal trial.  The judges consisted of a former trial court judge, a former AUSA (fresh out of the office), a former ADA (who left the office 25 years ago to take up med-mal defense) and a criminal defense lawyer.  It was fascinating to see how differently we saw the same thing.

As always, the law students did a great job, showing great presence and a remarkable facility to question and argue.  While their approach was generally overly rule-based, showing why the difference between good and great trial lawyering is found in the art rather than science of the job, they still performed far better than many lawyers who hold real people’s lives in their hands.  It’s gratifying to see that law schools can offer students the opportunity to learn some of the actual skills needed to practice, though they may fall far short of offering enough students the chance to learn to be lawyers.

The judging of these competitions often comes down to some highly nuanced takes on what the students can, and should, do with the fact pattern given and the available weapons.  This is where the bias of the judges came into play.  The judges were instructed to score the participants without discussion and then decide on who “won” the trial, with each of us left to our own perspectives before we had a chance to see what the others thought. 

What was initially striking was the former (now retired) judge’s view that the fact pattern heavily favored the prosecution.  At first blush, one might think this showed a bias in favor of the defense, as I mistakenly thought.  I was wrong.  What she meant was that not that the fact pattern was unfair, but that the evidence of guilt was so overwhelming that the defense couldn’t possibly prevail.  The problem was that the fact pattern and rules of the game were hardly overwhelming, and intentionally designed to provide gaping holes in the prosecution, so that the defense had plenty to work with. 

The former judge saw none of this.  She saw guilty from the start.  Not that she wanted to see things that way; this was moot court and there was no real criminal to be hung out to dry.  It was just that smoke meant fire, and she couldn’t get past it.

The former AUSA and ADA focused far more on the advocacy and interrogation skills of the students than the content of the fact pattern when it came to judging, The ADA, sitting next to me, jokingly muttered “guilty” after every question, but he was just poking me for fun.  The scoring remained close from opening through the last witness, with neither team scoring a coup and both doing a yeoman’s job.

It came down to summations for a real winner to emerge, much like it does in real life.  Both teams struggled with summation, hitting the theme from their opening statement, just like the lawprofs told them they should do, but neither down their case.  The prosecution appropriate raised the evidence, piece by piece, through it’s closing, but never distinguished the critical point of why it showed more than a possibility that the defendant committed the crime rather than proof that the defendant did, beyond a reasonable doubt.  This hole was big enough to drive a Mack truck though, and I marked them relatively low because of it.

The defense summation was long on rhetoric and decidedly short on substance.  The prosecution had just failed to preclude the built-in possibility of innocence, and the defense closing ignored it.  The flaw of excess preparation reared its ugly head.  The defense scored lower than the prosecution for having failed to notice the gaping hole.

At the end, the judges, aside from scoring the participants, were to decide who “won” the case.  This is where our bias showed through, loud and clear. 

Bennett posted yesterday about how a former prosecutor was unable to leave behind his inherent belief that the prosecution is the “good guys.”  In his post, a former Texas AAG who took up a post with the state disciplinary commission asks prosecutors to “help” him do his job by forwarding the names of lawyers who they think should be disciplined.  He concludes:


I still think prosecutors are the best bunch of people around and I am proud to know so many of you! Keep up the great work!

It’s hard to get past the notion that when one side is ascribed righteousness, the other is doomed.  No doubt the former AAG means well in his request, he is unable to see how he has turned a blind eye to his friends and targeted his former adversaries. 

The mock trial ended with a 3 to 1 win for the prosecution.  Guess who was the only person to vote for the defense?  After, we talked about why we decided as we did.  The others picked the prosecution primarily because the defense’s summation failed to pick apart the evidence, failed to point out the evidence in favor of innocence and failed to show up the prosecution’s failure to distinguish between the possibility of guilt and the burden.

I pointed out that while I agreed completely with their criticisms of the defense closing, the burden remains on the prosecution.  Even though the prosecution did a better job on summation than the defense, it failed to meet its burden based on its failure to offer a persuasive argument that it’s evidence precluded reasonable doubt.  This never occurred to the others.

Even though I was there early on a Sunday morning to help out a bunch of law students, it was a learning experience for me as well.

A Right, A Writ, and Then What?

The Supremes are scheduled to hear oral argument today in Rivera v. Illinois, finally addressing the issue of what do about a wrongfully seated juror.  This case deals with one of the back-end questions raised by the fundamentally misguided reverse Batson rule, limiting the defense’s right to peremptory challenges based upon the inane jurors “right” to sit.

At the trial, Rivera’s defense lawyer exercised a peremptory challenge to try to block the seating of Deloris Gomez, after discovering during questioning that she worked at Cook County Hospital and had some contact with patients who were gunshot victims. He thought that might make her less willing to hear Rivera’s defense sympathetically. The judge would not allow the challenge, concluding that the defense lawyer’s real reason for seeking to bar Gomez was that she was a black woman. The defense lawyer denied that, but the denial did not change the judge’s mind.

Gomez not only was seated; she was chosen as foreperson. The jury convicted Rivera of first-degree murder, and the judge imposed an 85-year sentence. Rivera’s appeal did not challenge the evidence against him at trial, but claimed the seating of Gomez, despite the defense’s peremptory challenge, was invalid. The error could not be undone, his lawyers argued, since Gomez sat throughout the trial – all the while knowing that the defense had tried to keep her off the jury. Thus, the defense contended, the conviction had to be overturned.

The Illinois Supreme Court agreed that the trial court’s failure to accept the defense explanation for its challenge was wrong, but held that it was “harmless error” as the evidence against Rivera was so strong that “no rational jury – or juror – would have” found him not guilty.  Thus, two misbegotten legal rules, reverse Batson and harmless error, used in tandem, have reduced another right of the defense to a nullity and much of our trial effort to a farce. 

The issue presented really does raise some challenging problems, since Rivera’s attorney failed to argue that his trial was unfair, aside from the seating of Gomez.  On the other hand, it only takes one out of twelve to hang, and that twelfth juror was lost to the erroneous determination of the trial judge, who decided that the defendant’s right to a jury trial was secondary to both the silly notion that jurors have a right to sit and the judge has the ability to decide the defense’s secret motives.

Lyle Denniston’s take at SCOTUSBlog is that the Supremes will avoid the constitutional implications and punt it back to the states.


The harmless error rule is one that the present Court seems to find quite appropriate when the flaws in criminal trials fall short of being constitutional violations. In view of that, the Court may be inclined to conclude that wrongfully seating a single juror, without further evidence that the juror’s presence actually introduced a significant element of unfairness into the trial, is no more than the type of “trial error” that can be left to the states to correct.

The problem, of course, is that it is impossible under almost any normal circumstance to show that the presence of a single juror “unfairly” turned a trial.  Is the defense to go inside the jury room to question whether the improperly seated juror was unduly persuasive or overtly prejudiced?  Short of some mid-trial wrong-doing, or post-trial revelation of over impropriety, what exactly is a wrongly seated juror supposed to do to overcome invocation of harmless error?  In the ordinary course of things, it’s not in the nature of a juror’s function to wreak flagrant havoc.

The real problem, of course, is institutional.  The judge having rules, and the trial having proceeded, no court wants to be forced to retry the case, causing additional expense and changing the dynamic, because of a flaw at the outset that can’t be cured otherwise.  But the question remains, if a defendant has a right to a fair jury, and that right is denied by interference of the trial judge, then what does the court do about it?

Short of a reversal and retrial, there is no remedy for the seating of a properly challenged juror.  It’s an all or nothing proposition, and may well result in the freeing of a defendant who has been otherwise convicted of a heinous crime should a critical witness or evidence be unavailable for the next go ’round.  This too is institutionally unacceptable.

A final subtext consideration is the potential that this is all much ado about legal rhetoric with no actual harm at all.  The facially prejudiced jurors (who haven’t otherwise been rehabilitated by the judge) are tossed for cause, and the use of peremptory challenges is an exercise in legal voodoo, lawyers pretending to know who is fair and who is not.  Should murderers be retried, or possibly freed, as a tip of the hat to a quaint, historic supposition that lawyer “hunches” produce a fairer jury?  It’s a high price to pay for a legal fiction.

The answer seems to be found in the most basic aspect of Rivera v. Illinois, and the one least likely to appeal to the current Supreme Court majority.  Rights without remedies are not rights.  As this has become of increasingly less concern in the context of 4th Amendment issues, there’s no reason to suspect the Court to get upset about giving up the defendant’s right to pick his jury.  And so, expect another right to fall as a consequence of the ill-conceived reverse Batson rule and the odious harmless error analysis.

No President is Untouchable

When the New York Post published a political cartoon of a chimpanzee, a subject of some discussion in the New York area for somewhat obvious reasons, the good Reverend Al went nuts.  It didn’t help that it was the Post, knee-jerk reactionary tabloid that it is.  But it shows two things.

First, that the Rev. Al has too little to occupy himself now that the White House is occupied by a black president.  Second, that Rev. Al has yet to come to grips with equality.  The funniest part of Al Sharpton’s outrage is his call for a boycott of the Post, as if he’s every paid for a copy.

New York Governor David Paterson tried to take a more even-handed approach, according to Newsday :


“It might be a time to open up a dialogue on just where that line is, where good clean fun and degradation are,” Paterson told reporters.

But even this misses the mark.  The cartoon may well have incorporated ago-old racist overtones, using the monkey epithet to tar a black president.  But editorial cartoons are supposed to be gross exaggerations and have been since their inception.  Once the discussion turns to what is “acceptable” in political satire, it will no longer be satire. 

Political cartoons has always used physical features to both portray and offend the powerful.  They made fun of people.  They abused people.  They made their point through visual exaggeration.  What does it say that, for the first time in American history, there is an outcry that we need rules?  Since when does satire need to be fair?  What use is satire that’s inoffensive? 

This debate isn’t about cartoonists attacking the downtrodden, the powerless, the abused in our society.  It’s about attacking the President of the United States.  You remember him, the most powerful man on earth?  When it comes to satirizing the president, there can be no limits or rules of safe conduct.  Everything must be fair game.

New York Post cartoon
The mechanics of political cartooning don’t mesh well with the fear that cartoonists are standing on the new boundary of propriety.  From Breitbart.com :



Scott States, editorial cartoonist for The Birmingham (Ala.) News, said he received several complaints this week that his Obama drawings look “simian.” As a conservative in a city that’s 77 percent black, States has learned to consider the feelings of his audience.

“Being the typical American editorial cartoonist—doughy, white, middle-aged—I’m more than willing to accept that I don’t know what may or may not be offensive,” he said. “But editorial cartoons are supposed to be offensive, and provocative. We’re entering new waters here. What can you use or not use?”

“All my characters look simian,” he said. “I don’t make Obama look nearly as simian as our former governor Mike James, who I DID draw as a monkey, on more than one occasion. And he’s a white guy … I’m sorry, but when it comes to African-Americans, you just don’t draw monkeys.”

Ted Rall, president of the American Association of Editorial Cartoonists, said that Obama’s race has affected how his colleagues do their jobs: “Without a doubt, people are stepping more gingerly. People are tiptoeing their way through this.”

Rall, who is liberal, said it’s harder to take shots at Obama because he’s smart, charming and handsome, “so when you attack the personality, people suspect there’s only one reason: It’s gotta be his race. My conservative cartoonist friends find it very frustrating.”


Never before in the history of the United States has there been such a constraint on political speech.  Political cartoons have long been an exceptionally effective means of communicating a political message, and the freedom of cartoonists to make their point has been critical to our ability to challenge, and laugh at, political orthodoxy.  Until now.

Barack Obama earned the Presidency.  He won it, fair and square.  There is no reason for any group to question the legitimacy of his holding the highest political office in America.  Is this not enough?  Is Obama’s authority so fragile that he needs the likes of Al Sharpton to scream racism when Obama’s subjected to the same scrutiny as every president before him?

Attorney General Eric Holder said we’re a nation of cowards when it comes to discussing race.  He’s right.  if we’re ever going to get past race, as many hope can happen now that America has shown that it will elect a black man to the office of President, then we need to get past the fear that chains us to the past. 

Sean Delonas’ cartoon was, in my humble opinion, neither particularly funny nor effective.  He’s done some great ones, but this wasn’t.  So slam him all you want for producing a crappy cartoon.  But Barack Obama is the President of the United States, and the chilling effect of the cries of racism may do more harm to both racial equality and political discussion than any lousy political cartoon the Post could publish.

Obama is fair game.  Obama cannot be untouchable.  No President can be untouchable.  No political commentary should be subject to rules. And who cares what Rev. Al has to say anyway.

So You Ruined Gary Condit For Nothing? (Update)

When Chandra Levy’s body was found, everyone knew who did it.  Dominick Dunne, purveyor of all salacious truth, told us.  The police had no doubt.  It was a made for TV murder.  The culprit was . . . wait.  Representative Gary Condit was smeared far and wide for his affair with Levy, every orifice of his personal life revealed for all to see, and universally branded a murderer who got away with it.

But today, a mere 8 years later, it turns out that the suspect is Ingmar Guandique?  But that’s no fun.  There’s no politician to smear.  The one-size fits all answer to murder investigation fails.  Our faith in justice is shaken.

Not that I was a fan of Gary Condit’s conservative flavor of Democratic politics, nor an admirer of a 53 year old man messing around with a 23 year old intern.  But he was pronounced a murder far and wide, and for all that he was, a murderer he was not.

Having enjoyed (on behalf of clients) the knee-jerk police jump to conclusion that the spouse/lover is always the prime suspect when something bad happens, the idea that cops now think that it was a random act of violence by some unconnected person is like a bad joke.  Trying to find, no less gather actual evidence, of the perpetrator of a crime is much, much harder than deciding who the bad guys is first and then trying to construct a case against him. 

Arguing that maybe, just maybe, their knee-jerk assumptions ignore the potential that something happened which they might possibly learn about if only they actually investigated the crime instead of the pre-determined criminal, is a waste of breath.  Cops know everything.  Just ask them.  They’ll tell you.

Sadly for the cops, sometimes they can’t just pin the crime on the easiest target.  Then they actually have to earn their keep, which can interfere with a well deserved nap. 

Sadly for Gary Condit, it only took the police an extra 8 years to find someone else to target.

Sadly for Dominick Dunne, he hasn’t changed a bit.

Update:  While I tend to avoid using psycho-social jargon, mostly because I fear that I would use it wrong, Mike at Crime & Federalism wields it like a scalpel and, for better or worse, it better captures the problem than my fumbling about in the darkness.

How many narratives make perfect sense?  How often do we see patterns that do not exist?  How often are we fooled by randomness?

Also, might the police have found Ms. Levy’s killer earlier if they hadn’t concluded that Gary Condit was somehow involved?  What evidence do we overlook once our minds have already been made up, once we’ve already reached a conclusion? 

I don’t pimp books on cognitive bias because I think those books are fun and games.  Some are a collection of graduate-school level articles.  It ain’t pop corn for the mind.  An ignorance of the biases that blind our thinking can have devastating effects.  People lose their jobs and go to prison based on simple thinking errors.  

Can you say confirmation bias?

In this comment below, Anne Skove “explains” it (though not endorsing the explanation), unintentionally proving the point.  “They” look for the things “they” expect to find for the reasons “they” believe are good, thereby not looking at the crime without a bias and instead solving it.  What Anne omits, and Mike recognizes, is that “they” solve the crime first and only thereafter consider the evidence.

Economics 101 (Slackoisie Version)

The griping entitlement of the Slackoisie, Gen X and Y to the uninitiated, may have hit the wall with the death of guaranteed Biglaw bonuses.  All those self-proclaimed brilliant young lawyers for whom the career path to fabulous wealth and importance was clearly promised are now shaking.  Where will their next bag of cheese doodles come from?

The Slackoisie will now experience something that their parents and grandparents enjoyed.  Economic disaster.  Before, they felt needed, wanted, the only game in town.  As the newest lawyer stepped out of the law school door, the profession had to adapt to them as they were the only game in town.  When a law firm needed some new young associates to prepare memos or cull deposition transcripts, they had only the Slackoisie to chose from.  They had to capitulate.  Either let them come to work in flip-flops or do the work yourself.

But as markets contract and kids in blue jeans with outstanding loans are politely asked to gather their belongings, the equation has changed.  No longer are you in a position to dictate the terms and conditions of your employment.  You cannot demand balloons and parties simply because you deigned to show up before 9 a.m.  Your philosophical aversion to following the directions of the gal signing your paycheck will no longer be tolerated.  No one wants to hear your opinion on how the firm should be run.

Yes, these are difficult times for young lawyers.  Yes, you have crushing obligations.  Yes, you can blame this horrible world on Boomer Bush, because all baby boomers are of one mind and have a secret handshake, which is used immediately before coming up with new ways of exploiting you and interfering with your happy days of playing Halo 3.

One option available to you, which may force a seismic shift in your paradigm, is going solo.  This is not an option for the timid or lazy, however.  You will have no one to complain to or about.  Your clients, if you have any, won’t care how you feel about things because they are far too busy caring about how they feel about things.  That’s how clients work.

If you are fortunate enough to have clients, they will expect you to perform for them in exchange for paying you.  This is not a novel concept, no matter how foreign it may seem to you.  This was how your old bosses did things, while you were insulated from the harsh business aspect of the practice.  Your clients will call you or come to you with the expectation that you will provide legal services.  They will expect your services to be timely, professional and minimally competent.  They will not care about your work/life balance, and your need to take a “mental health day” off at the expense of a filing deadline will not be understood or accepted.  Clients can be so darned unreasonable.

Worse still will be those who go solo but obtain no clients.  Here’s a bit of a secret: All the blawging for profit claims in the world will never substitute for being a good lawyer.  Search engine optimization is not the quintessential element of professional success.  Even if you do get a client or two, they will soon realize that your highly ranked blog or website masks an incompetent who cannot perform their legal work.  They will not love your beautiful blog enough to suffer your incompetence. 

The sad truth is that most of you will not succeed as solo practitioners, whether because of your lack of entrepreneurial spirit and work ethic or because there are just too darned many lawyers and not enough paying clients.  Some people just aren’t suited to wondering whether the phone will ring today, and someone with money in the bank will be on the other end.  Solo practice can be a far more difficult road than its proponents let on, and not everyone has nerves of steel.

For those lawyers for whom solo isn’t going to work, there is always the option of getting a job.  But this time around, the job may be very different.  Your ersatz employer will expect you to come to work on time, dressed appropriately, and perform the tasks demanded of you.  The partner will give you instructions, and you will keep your mouth shut and listen.  He is not interested in how you feel about his instructions, or whether you are in the mood to comply or argue the point.  There will be no party for you during the lunch break.  Indeed, there may not even be a lunch break.  And the awards ceremony at the end of the work day has been permanently canceled.

So I offer this advice with the hope that you will take it in the spirit in which it given:  Get to work.  If you don’t, there are ten other kids who have loan payments coming due who will happily take your job.  And this time around, your choice is either do as you’re told or take a hike.  Your 15 minutes are over, your mommy doesn’t want you back home since her retirement account dropped by half and we’re all sick a tired of the whining.  

Either get to work or get lost.  You will thank me for this some day.

Are Bar Associations Worth It?

Carolyn Elefant has done the heavy lifting in her review of the member benefits of voluntary bar associations.  The verdict:


Back in 2002, when I first survey, I concluded that the bars were serving the needs of solos and small firm lawyers fairly well.  At that time, most bars had a robust web presence (at least for that time period) and offered a variety of online guides and forms to help solos get their practices off the ground.  Unfortunately, times have changed, but most bar associations haven’t.  In the six years that have transpired between the two surveys, there hasn’t been much progress at the bar sites.True, most of the solo guides remain online, but few have been updated to reflect new developments like outsourcing, social media or software as a service tools.  

Regular readers know that I spent many years serving on the board and as a VP of the New York State Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers.  I ultimately resigned, twice, from the Board.  While I was happy to spend my time and effort contributing to something that served my profession and my friends, I had no interest in being involved with a group without purpose.  It had no mission.  It served no purpose.  It simply existed.

The closest the association came to having purpose was to generate enough money from member dues and CLEs to pay for its Executive Director, whose job was to collect the dues and run the programs that generated the money that paid for the Executive Director.  Not a good enough reason for me to be a member, no less a board member.  And no one else seemed to notice that it was an exercise in futility. 

For some, there was a strong motivation to claw their way up the ladder of bar association success.  A few wanted desperately to become President so that the world would know how important they were.  This was perhaps the dirtiest secret, that little people of dubious merit were living off the dues of their brethren for their own self-aggrandizement.  The vanity of the insiders is hardly a good reason for membership.

Like most lawyers, I was a member of numerous specialty and general bar associations.  I sat myself down and asked what I got for my dues.  The answers ranged from little that meant anything to me, a private solo criminal defense practitioner, to nothing.  While the rhetoric of “member benefits” grew increasingly hyperbolic to compensate for the total lack of substance, the simple fact was that these bar association made absolutely no difference in my practice. 

Historically, lawyers joined bar associations.  Lawyers are nothing if not slaves to tradition, and so new lawyers would sign up because it was the thing to do.  Old lawyers would continue paying dues because they always paid dues.  Few gave it a second thought.  Fewer still actually considered whether they were receiving anything of value for their dues payment.  And only a couple realized that many of these bar associations had devolved to the point of existing merely to exist.  They did nothing to enhance their practice of law. 

My lack of support has made many of my friends in the bar view me as a traitor.  I refused to keep their secrets, and occasionally did the unthinkable of revealing that they were buck naked.  When there was impropriety, I wrote about it.  When there was cowardice and irresponsibility with the members money, I disclosed it.  No one gave me an award for honesty. 

The one thing that bar associations do well is throw a dinner, a chance for old friends to get together over a cocktail and talk.  I always enjoyed the cocktail party before the speeches began.  Then the awards portion of the program would spoil things, reminding me yet again that the bar associations lacked any purpose.  As awards were given to the usual suspects who had done nothing worthy but could bring in a few extra paid tables, I was again confronted with the hard reality that the purposes of the founders, clear and well intended, had long since been forgotten.

In tough economic times, reassessment of bar association membership is due for the benefit of lawyers and bar associations alike.  If a bar association serves no real purpose, then why are you a member?  Are the ever-increasing dues worth it?  And if they members stop paying, the handful of pseudo-official people who pretend to run it will be constrained to come to grips with the lousy job they’ve done as stewards.  Only then will the hard choices be made; either serve a purpose or cease to exist. 

Take a hard look at the dues you’re paying, and if you’re not getting any real value for it, vote with your wallet.  We need bar associations now more than ever, and it’s time to stop enabling bar associations to fail to serve its members.

First Lattman, Now Slater?

Many readers here refuse to read the Wall Street Journal Law Blog as a matter of principle.  Not me.  I read it every day, as it’s on Dan Hull’s “must-read” list and that’s good enough for me.  True, last February when Peter Lattman announced he was going straight, I was tempted to drop it, but I figured I would give the new kid, Dan Slater, a chance.

Turned out that Slater was pretty good.  It took him a few weeks to get up to full ramming speed, but once he got there, he stayed there.  Until now.

A mere year after Slater took the helm, he’s out.  Yesterday, Slater announced that it was his last day at the helm of the WSJ Law Blog.



Today is my last day as the Law Blogger.


Writing the blog for the past year has been a privilege. And I’m happy to report that the Law Blog will remain strong under the guidance of longtime LB editor Ashby Jones.


All the best,
Dan


A man of mystery until the end, Slater’s farewell offers no clue as to why he’s done or where he’s going.  Generally, that’s a bad sign. 

Slater was in litigation at Kaye Scholar before jumping ship to blawg for profit.  Certainly a financial commitment on Slater’s part, leaving the lucrative and stable practice of Biglaw.  Well, at least that was how it was a year ago.  Could it be that the venerable chronicle of capitalism can’t afford to keep Slater on staff?  It seems that way.  The lack of mention of why and where suggests that Slater became a statistic, as he certainly wasn’t tossed on his ear for not doing a great job.  He did a great job.

What should one take from this.  Is all that hype about blogging being the wave of the future collapsing when it comes time to decide whether it’s worth a few corporate shekels to pay the blawger?  Has the blawgosphere’s promise remained merely a promise, never to produce a dime aside from those charging for the dream?  Does Dan Slater’s ouster portend capitalism’s abandonment of the blawgosphere as profit center?  Beats me. 

The WSJ has paper to pay for, and Slater may be nothing more than the victim of dead tree mentality.  Or maybe in the fast paced world of Web 2.0, the old-timers can’t see the point of commitment.  My newspaper friends think that if there’s no cash left to pay for reporters, there certainly can’t be any around for blawgers.  Maybe an explanation will be forthcoming, but I don’t know if I would believe it either way.  Nobody likes admitting that they’re in trouble.

I was sorry to see Lattman go.   I’m now sorry to see Dan Slater go.  I hope his parting is amicable and he’s got a new home, with a big yard and white picket fence, all lined up.  Thanks for a great year of work, Dan, and best of luck to you.

The Same Stories, Again and Again

It occurred to me this morning as I wrote about science and the law, promoting Radley Balko’s extraordinary Reason post, that so many of the posts here sound like a broken record.  It’s tiresome. 

I wanted to highlight Radley’s post because it’s something that should be spread as far as wide as possible.  And because the intersection of science and evidence, and its massive failing, is something that has long pained me.  But now I’ve said it.  A few times.  More than a few times.  And there’s little more I can add to it.

People who happen upon Simple Justice for the first time are unaware that subjects, cases, issues have been covered before.  I know that people won’t, and don’t, check to see what I’ve posted in the past.  Nothing exists outside of whatever is on their computer screen at that moment.  So the worth of reading the blawg exists at the top of the front page or not at all to readers.  But to me, new posts start to sound like old news.

I have some faint memory of things I’ve written in the past.  And it gets tedious writing about another bad cop or another puppy murder.  The same story, different names.  Nothing changes.

I received an email from a commenter this morning asking what happened to comment he posted.  While acknowledging that it’s my blawg and I can do whatever I wish with comments, he made the point that he doesn’t care to have his time waste composing a comment if I’m just going to take it down.  He’s quite right.  The comment I removed happened to be a link to Balko’s post, which I removed because I don’t let commenters link to other people’s posts.   

But I completely understand that commenter’s point.  I too have grown weary of composing posts that disappear in the vapor, only to be challenged by whoever stumbles upon Simple Justice about why I won’t do their bidding.  I’m beginning to bore myself.  That’s not good.

Science, Law and Manufactured Convictions

With timing that couldn’t be better, in light of the National Academies of Science release of its report on the subversion of science and law through the use of junk science and junk experts in court to undermine the integrity of the criminal justice system, Radley Balko has posted at Reason one of the most damning investigative reports I’ve ever seen. 

The article chronicles how two Mississippi doctors, Steven Hayne and Michael West, successfully used their degrees to create evidence to convict, to disseminate it and to subvert the system.  Radley’s report is a difficult one to read, and a particularly difficult one to view, containing autopsy video and photographs of a young child, Haley Oliveaux.  But with these images, there can be little doubt that these men manufactured the evidence needed to convict Jimmie Duncan.

While its unclear what motivated Hayne and West, though the suggestion is that Hayne had created a cottage autopsy industry for himself, and sought to increase his business in Louisiana, where he was hired to perform his special brand of magic in the Oliveaux murder case.

Hayne testified that during an initial examination of Oliveaux’s body, he was able to find bite marks that at the time no other medical professional had noticed—just as he’d done in the Brewer and Brooks cases before. And just as it happened in the Brewer and Brooks cases, Hayne’s discovery of potential bite marks gave local authorities probable cause to obtain a plaster dental mold of the defendant’s teeth, in this case Jimmie Duncan. Hayne then called in West to perform his unique brand of “analysis.” West concluded that the marks were made by human teeth belonging to the man police and prosecutors suspected of killing the child.
Balko exposes Hayne’s scam.  The NAS report exposes the scam of forensics in general.  But we’re still left with the overarching problem:  There’s an ongoing system out there, rendering what is perceived to be irrefutable scientific opinion of guilt, that’s a total load of crap. 

In Hayne’s case, bite-mark evidence enjoyed its day as proof of identity.  Today, we recognize it as complete nonsense, exposed as snake-oil.  And yet we continue to accept and believe all manner of scientific “proof” as articles of faith in the law rather than an empirically tested methodology.  And no one says “no, this isn’t going to happen in my courtroom.”

Just as people want to believe that physicians have a pill that will cure anything, pop culture pushes people to believe that science has evolved to the point of absolute certainty.  Those behind the science enjoy the prestige that comes from being the exclusive handlers of their own little piece of truth.  Those charged with preventing the charlatans of science from holding sway have failed.

Police and prosecutors want to convict those who they believe are guilty.  If a scientific method helps them to do that, they embrace it.  That the method is nonsense is not their problem. 

Criminal defense lawyers often lack the wherewithal to dispute the prosecutorial charlatans, and even when they can locate a witness willing to testify, and have the funds necessary to pay for him, they are left with an uncooperative judge who will either not permit, or severely limit, the scope of the defense testimony.  The validity of the underlying science is collateral to the issue in the case, and judges view challenges as a waste of time, since the issue of admissibility is already decided, and they now want to get on with the trial and home for dinner.

Judges are the gatekeepers of evidence, including expert and scientific evidence.  By and large, judges have failed miserably.

What is it that drives courts to fall in love with scientific proof?  It relieves the system of its most basic flaw, that all platitudes aside, it’s a horribly ineffective way to discern truth from falsity.  By holding out something that appears to provide objective empirical truth, judges and juries are not required to engage in the magical determination of deciding who is lying and who is truthful.  It’s wonderful to be able to shift the problem to some expert, who can tell truths through science.  The system is infatuated with any answer that gives the appearance of having greater validity than voodoo. 

The rest of us understand that the system is no better than guesswork, masked to conceal that it’s a game with a million rules that allows everyone to cheat.  But if we have science to rely on, then our system gains the integrity that we cannot offer it.  Or so we would like to believe.  It becomes far more difficult to maintain that faith after Balko’s piece. 

Sorry if this bursts your bubble, and no, I don’t have an alternative solution that will make it clean and easy to secure convictions, but  the fact remains that the system is severely flawed.  But piece by piece, bit by bit, we are confronted with the harsh reality that the criminal justice system’s facile reliance on science to fill the void of proof is a subversion of justice.  We need to admit this and deal with it.  We need to stop hiding our heads in the sand, pretending that science will save us.

What Time Will the Doors Close on Sharon Keller

When Texas Criminal Court of Appeals Judge Sharon Keller directed that the doors to the clerk’s office be slammed shut to prevent the Texas Defender Service from filing a last minute application to stay the execution of Michael Wayne Richard, she drew a line in the sand.  Did Killer Keller personally own the power of life and death?

For a while, it appeared that the answer was clear.  She did.  Richard was executed and Judge Keller continued to wear a black robe.

Now, the line may be blurring, as the Texas Commission on Judicial Conduct has brought charges against Sharon Keller for her handling of this execution.  The complaint provides the details of how Killer Keller ignored the court’s own Execution Day procedures, disenfranchised another sitting judge, Cheryl Johnson, who was assigned to handle the last-minute stay application, directed the court’s “counsel”, Edward Marty, to make sure the clerk’s office closed at 5:00 p.m. knowing that the application was on its way, and assured that Richard would die.

Ironically, Keller did all of this from home, as she had left the courthouse early that day to meet a repairman at home.  She understood priorities.

As Mark Bennett notes in his discussion of the Judicial Conduct Commission’s inquiry, Sharon Keller could have been stopped.  CCA Counsel Marty could have refused the command to close the courthouse doors, but he didn’t.  He could have alerted Judge Johnson, or any of the other judges, but he didn’t.  He could have simply followed the court’s Execution Day protocols and not reached out to Killer Keller at home, interrupting her very important repair, but he didn’t.  Powerful people like Sharon Keller need the assistance of official women like Edward Marty to do their bidding.  That way, they can assure that someone dies even when the dish washer needs fixin’.

The New York Times chimed in with an editorial about a Texas legislator seeking impeachment of Keller. 


If the facts are as reported, Judge Keller should be removed from the bench. It would show monumental callousness, as well as a fundamental misunderstanding of justice, for a judge to think that a brief delay in closing a court office should take precedence over a motion that raises constitutional objections to an execution. If the facts have been misreported, the impeachment process would allow Judge Keller to set the record straight.

The facts were never in dispute.  It’s a shame that the Times was unaware, particularly since it had run a story about it shortly after the execution.  They noted in the article that complaints were filed by the Harris County Criminal Lawyers’ Association and others. 

Judge Sharon Keller’s reaction to the outcry at the time was underwhelming:


The Austin American-Statesman quoted Judge Keller on Oct. 3 as defending her decision to close, saying she had asked Mr. Richard’s lawyers why the court should stay open “and no reason was given.”

“I just said, ‘We close at 5.’ I didn’t really think of it as a decision as much as a statement,” the newspaper quoted her as saying.

What appears from the Judicial Conduct Commission’s inquiry is that this was false.  She spoke with Counsel Marty, not the lawyers for Richards.  She was told that the TDS was experiencing computer problems, and that they needed another 20 minutes to file the papers.  Judge Johnson was sitting in her chambers awaiting a stay application.  Counsel Marty had already drafted the decision.  Killer Keller was busy with the repairman.  Executions are usually worth thinking about.  Even in Texas.

It’s surprising, maybe even shocking, that there is an inquiry at all.  The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals is the final word in criminal cases in Texas, and to have a judge sitting on that court subject to inquiry at all is quite an astounding feat.  But even so, there is something so monumentally underwhelming about this remedy.  Michael Wayne Richard was executed, and no inquiry will change that fact.  While removal from office would be an extraordinary remedy, should it happen, it remains viscerally inadequate.

A system that would allow Judge Sharon Keller to utter a few words and seal a person’s death in this way must shock us.  With the enabling Counsel Marty, we realize how few safeguards exist and how easily they are circumvented.  Texas had a protocol, and it was ignored.  The abject faith we repose in this system was exposed as child-like; it ultimately depends on the willingness of a judge to be judge rather than executioner.

The complaint against Killer Keller makes a very clear case against her.  It tacitly condemns Edward Marty in the process.  But what it mostly does is force us to recognize how little stands between one person with an agenda and the subversion of our fabulous legal system.  Bit by bit, we realize how fragile the system is, and how little it takes to make it fall apart.

One can view the complaint against Sharon Keller as warning to other judges not to subvert justice to their own will.  One can also view the complaint as an lesson on how to subvert the system without getting caught.  Was Killer Keller’s fault that she assured the death of Michael Wayne Richard by slamming shut the courthouse doors, or that she wasn’t smart enough to cover her tracks?

The outcome of the inquiry will be interesting, to see whether the Commission has the guts to truly confront a sitting CCA judge, and if so, what they do about her.  But there will be another Killer Keller down the road.  Will we figure out a way to prevent the next judge with a broken household appliance from making sure someone dies?