Author Archives: SHG

Even Cops Need Some Sleep (Update)

Schenectady police officer Dwayne Johnson made good money.  Really good money.  From the Daily Gazette :

Dwayne Johnson, who was the city’s highest paid officer last year with earnings of $168,921, spends most Tuesday early mornings in an apartment at the corner of Queen Philomena Boulevard and Sir Benjamin Way, near Kings Road. Although Johnson is typically scheduled to patrol the city until 8 a.m., he parks his marked police car on Sir Benjamin Way just before 4 a.m. and remains indoors for several hours.

It’s hard work making all that money.  It can wear a man down, and no one wants a worn down cop, right?


The eight-year veteran of the department was observed by a Daily Gazette reporter and other witnesses as he entered and stayed in the apartment on five Tuesdays in a row this year. The Daily Gazette a week ago reported the matter to the Police Department, which confirmed Johnson’s absence from patrols through the city’s new GPS units. Chief Mark Chaires said Johnson’s Tuesday absences from duty have been recorded by the new units nearly every week since they were installed in November.

Chaires was disgusted to learn of yet another case of an officer not working during his shift.

“Here we go again,” Chaires said. “How dumb can you be? You know you have a GPS in your car. Why would anybody do that?”

It’s always fun when the Chief asks a question like this, because it makes people think about it.  Let’s see; there are GPS units in patrol cars that cost $22,00 apiece.  There’s a cop making triple his salary, highest paid on the force.  He’s ditching patrol and going to some apartment every Tuesday (maybe he doesn’t need a snooze on Thursdays?).  And neither Chief Chaires nor anybody else on the force thinks that somebody ought to take the occasional gander at their top earner, the big money man, to make sure they are getting their money’s worth?

How dumb indeed. 

Had the Weekly Gazette reporter not investigated and followed Dwayne Johnson, he would still be happily in the apartment at the corner of Queen Philomena Boulevard and Sir Benjamin Way, near Kings Road, the GPS system notwithstanding.  He would still be clocking 70 hours a week.  He would still be pulling down the big overtime money.

How dumb?  Not as dumb as you, Chief.

But don’t fear that Johnson will go unpunished.  My bet is that his wife will have a few questions about what he was doing in that apartment every Tuesday morning.  If he wasn’t sleepy going in, I bet he was coming out.


Update:  Giacalone, who enjoys the occasional nap himself, provides some additional insight:



(Feb. 20, 2009): The Gazette tells us this morning that Officer Johnson was “suspended without pay Thursday while the department investigates the extent of his absences during his overnight patrols.”  He apparently will have to be paid if kept on suspension longer than 30 days. “Absent officer out for month : Bennett begins cop AWOL probe; union issues cited” (Feb. 20, 2009).  I’m surprised that Public Safety Commissioner Wayne Bennett believes “it will take well over a month to finish the investigation into Johnson’s absences. Also under review are the supervisors who did not notice them and the officers who may have tipped him off when internal affairs attempted to catch him in the act early last Tuesday.”  I’m not surprised that he expects the police union to argue napping has become a “past practice,” approved regularly by lower-level supervisors, that cannot be changed without union approval.



The Gazette notes that “Some officers, who spoke anonymously, say everyone who works long shifts takes naps, beginning at lunchtime. They argued that an unspoken rule in the department allows napping to continue after lunch as long as police get up as soon as they get a call.”  Bennett says: “If someone had the absolute and unmitigated gall to call [napping] a past practice, well, supervisors do not have that kind of authority to authorize that.”


The new frontier for police contracts: Napping Clauses. 

H/T Giacalone.

National Academies of Science: Trust Nothing

The ancient Greek philosophy of Skepticism posits that there is no such thing as truth or certainty.  The National Academies of Science has released its long awaited report, “Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: A Path Forward.”  Skeptics are throwing parties.

The report is long, and only available to read on the NAS website on a painfully limited basis unless you prefer to purchase it.  I have yet to read more than portions of the summary and the press release, but it’s enough to get a flavor.


Forensic evidence is often offered in criminal prosecutions and civil litigation to support conclusions about individualization — in other words, to “match” a piece of evidence to a particular person, weapon, or other source. But with the exception of nuclear DNA analysis, the report says, no forensic method has been rigorously shown able to consistently, and with a high degree of certainty, demonstrate a connection between evidence and a specific individual or source.

In other words, everything that was taken as true, as real, as a necessary and inherent part of almost every criminal case, is no longer worthy of scientific reliance.  From drug tests to strange little black boxes that magically provide evidence that convicts people, the entire forensics paradigm is now suspect.  They aren’t saying that science doesn’t work, or that science isn’t real.  They are saying that the science used in courtrooms across our nation is not trustworthy.


Rigorous and mandatory certification programs for forensic scientists are currently lacking, the report says, as are strong standards and protocols for analyzing and reporting on evidence. And there is a dearth of peer-reviewed, published studies establishing the scientific bases and reliability of many forensic methods. Moreover, many forensic science labs are underfunded, understaffed, and have no effective oversight.

I can hear every “expert” across the country saying, “maybe someone else, but not me.”  How many will raise their hand with a sheepish grin across their face, admitting that their testimony is what the NAS is talking about?  I don’t see any hands raised.  I didn’t expect to. 

So the cat is out of the bag.  Decades of reliance on forensics are now in doubt.  But this isn’t the first time, and won’t be the last.  As scientific knowledge and tools developed, we kept getting the “new improved” version of whatever tools existed to prove facts.  Of course, if a scientific tool was so reliable that it could put a man in prison for life, what did it say when a new tool came along that was that much more reliable?  Courts embraced the new tool, confident that it was the latest and greatest in scientific proof, and lost no sleep over the demise of yesterday’s absolutely certain scientific method.  No one got hot and bothered by the conundrum.

So the NAS rips existing forensic practice to shreds and offers a roadmap to correcting junk science going forward.  In a rational world, somebody would ask, “What do we do with all those people who have been convicted on science that we now know to be so flawed as to be unreliable, or at best cannot be sufficiently certain is reliable to admit as evidence in court?”  By somebody, I mean a judge. 

The answer is that the prison doors will not be thrown open, with tens of thousand, hundreds of thousand, told that they are free to leave.  Society couldn’t possibly tolerate such a thing, and it would no doubt wreak havoc with public safety since it would allow the release of violent, dangerous and sociopathic prisoners.  And some of the innocent people wrongfully convicted in the process too.  It can’t happen, and it won’t.  Someone will craft a very thoughtful explanation about the finality of convictions, even in the face of pervasive scientific doubt, and the past will fade away.

The future is an open question.  As I earlier contended, judges are particularly poor gatekeepers when it comes to science.  They defer because they lack the ability to make a meaningful assessment.  Of course, the NAS report suggests that our nation’s “scientific experts” may be no better at making that assessment either, supporting their own personal disciplines for their own personal reasons while ignoring or dismissing the rampant flaws that permeate their expert opinions.  Perhaps there is no one left to trust.  Perhaps there is no truth to be found, whether by judge or scientist.

To the extent one can appreciate the depth and scope of the report without actually reading it in its entirety, it would seem to demand that there be an immediate stop to all use of forensic testimony in the courtroom until such time as the flaws are addressed and its reliability and consistency is satisfactorily established.  I do not suspect this will happen.

For those who wonder how many guilty men should go free lest an innocent be convicted, the answer has just philosophically risen to infinite.  We now know that the evidence routinely used to convict people is unreliable, both legally and scientifically.  The NAS has done its job, and the issue is now kicked to the courts. 

In a rational world, judges would refuse to admit scientific evidence from today forward, until such time as the evidence is proven legal reliable.  But today, judges will continue to allow the same evidence admitted yesterday and the day before, even though today we know it is not reliable.  They do this because to do otherwise would shut down the system, and that can never happen. 

So an ugly truth is shown, clearly and irrefutably:  Rhetoric about evidence and proof and reliability and integrity notwithstanding, it is more important that the wheels of the criminal justice system continue to grind, even if it means that bad evidence is used to convicted innocent people.  The ancient Greek Skeptics were wrong; we know with certainty that there is no such thing as justice.

Blawgversation:  Check out Grits post on the report as well

Twitter: Profit in 140 Characters or Less

As the Twitter train continues to roll, one obvious question remains unanswered.  How exactly is this free service, enjoyed by many and abused by others, going to cash out?  Newsday published an  AP article raising the obvious:


One vital ingredient has been missing so far: revenue. That raises questions about whether the nearly 3-year-old service can make the leap from intriguing fad to sustainable business.

Twitter Inc. intends to start testing ways to make money this spring. Co-founder Evan Williams promises it won’t drive away the more than 6 million people who have at least set up accounts.

Can we hold him to this promise?  It’s a good question, because as much as I have become a reluctant twitterer, I have no plans on paying for it.  Not even on a per twit basis.  They are welcome to advertise all they want, but I’m no more likely to click on their ad than on anyone else’s, except for my errant occasional keystroke.  So what’s the plan?


“We don’t see any reason why this can’t be a very large and profitable entity,” said Williams, the San Francisco-based company’s chief executive.

Williams, 36, won’t say what he has in mind besides selling ads, but he and the handful of others who own privately held Twitter seem confident the mystery strategy will pay off, even as a devastating recession destroys much-larger companies.

Well that clears things up.  Not.  We’ve heard other internet business make similarly promises in the past, generally within months of their crashing and burning, meaning cash burn as the venture capital gets spent in the absence of any executable plan to bring revenue in.  As much as we may love the technology, our love doesn’t  pay the bills.

But it’s not as if Evan Williams is worried about where his next meal is coming from.  He’s got prospects:


Just three months ago, Twitter rejected a $500-million takeover offer from Facebook Inc., the owner of the world’s largest online hangout.

Although shooing away Facebook was risky, Twitter isn’t under immense pressure to generate revenue. The 29-employee company has already raised $55 million, including a $35-million round recently completed with Benchmark Capital and Institutional Venture Partners.

Memo to Facebook:  Since you have half a bil in loose change to spend, there’s a very nice blawg that just might be available.  And I’m fairly certain you could nail it down with a mil or two left over.

In my perpetual effort to be helpful to others (because that’s the kind of guy I am), let’s run a contest.  Anybody with a way for Twitter to make some money, post your idea in the comments below and if Twitter uses it and becomes fabulously financially successful, Kevin O’Keefe, who is personally responsible for almost every person on twitter, will do everything in his power to make sure that Williams splits the baby with you.

Don’t be shy and no idea is too crazy.  It’s impossible to get too crazy when it comes to Twitter turning a profit.

The D.C. Bar’s Avvo Issues

I haven’t always had nice things to say about Avvo.  I hate Avvo Answers, and don’t think much of their new paid lawyer advertising business model.  And for me, Avvo has been far more of a time drain than benefit.  But that said, Avvo has a place and serves a purpose. 

Others have gotten good clients, good case, through Avvo, and just because that hasn’t been my experience doesn’t mean I should ruin it for anyone else.  And it does provide an appropriate forum for people to check out lawyers, even if substantially less than perfect.  The bottom line is that Avvo should exist, and my critiques are nothing more than one lawyer’s effort to help guide Avvo away from perdition.  Don’t thank me Avvo, it’s the least I can do.

But the D.C. Bar doesn’t share my love.  They want to destroy Avvo.  The reason is simple.  Avvo data-mined their members and they got nothing for it.  Most people assume that bar associations exist to help their members.  Not me.  I believe bar associations exist to generate money to continue their existence.  Not all, but most.  Apparently, the D.C. Bar Association falls into the most category.

Carolyn Elefant, perhaps the most reasonable and even-keeled lawyer I’ve ever met, who just happens to be a member of the D..C. bar, has challenged this attack on Avvo.

So why does the DC Bar want to shut down Avvo? Well, from what I can tell from its explanation, the Bar is ticked off at Avvo for downloading public information on its website regarding member names, business addresses, membership status and disciplinary history.  So what?  Isn’t that information supposed to be free so that the public can learn about lawyers?  And if it’s already public, then companies like Avvo ought to be able to capture it and aggregate it. 

The DC Bar’s timing couldn’t be any worse. Of all the times to lash out at Avvo, why now when it provides a service that lawyers can use to find work?  With unemployment in the legal profession on the rise, more and more lawyers, from new graduates to former biglaw associates are considering the option of starting a law firm.  Cash-strapped and debt-ridden, many lawyers will be forced to hang a shingle on a shoe-string, looking for the most economic ways to build a practice. 

Granted, Carolyn is fonder of Avvo’s features than I am, and far more supportive of its marketing purposes than I could ever be.  But we need not agree on the efficacy of Avvo to agree that, for better or worse, it’s there, it’s something, and it’s far better than nothing.  And, as Carolyn notes, as bar associations do nothing to help lawyers during the tough times we’re experiencing, Avvo at least offers the potential to help.  Whether it works for me is irrelevant; the laid off Biglaw lawyers who chose not to smarten up and find an alternative career path need options right about now.  Avvo offers options.  Bar associations offer squat.  And you have to pay dues for the pleasure.

I expect that one day in the near future I’ll have something to say that will keep me off Mark Britton’s dinner invitation list (again).  But for today, it strikes me that the member of the District of Columbia Bar Association need to grad their offices by the scruff of the neck and shake them hard.  The attack on Avvo is not merely ludicrous from a legal standpoint, but wrong for the benefit of its members.  While Avvo may not help nearly as much as Carolyn suggests, it most assuredly offers greater aid to the lawyers who need it most, when they need it most, than anything the D.C. Bar could conceive.

And as for my belief that the true motive of this scheme is to sucker some cash out of Avvo for the coffers of the bar association, which I understand is simultaneously raising its dues (always a good idea when the financial fortunes of its members turn south), this might also be an awfully good time for lawyers to assess whether the cost of maintaining bar associations is justified by the benefits they provide.  Not the rhetorical ones that fill the porn they mail out when your dues payment is late, but the real membership benefits that actually provide help and support to the bar.  Considered in that light, Avvo looks awfully good and bar associations, like the one in D.C., may not fare so well.  Viva Avvo, for better or worse.

The Dorm Doctrine at Amherst (Update)

After the War of Northern Aggression ended, the good people of Massachusetts believed themselves to be of a better ilk than their erstwhile brethren in the beaten lands down south.  After all, not only had they won a way, but they conducted themselves in a better, more highly evolved fashion toward men with darker skin.  Or so they wanted to believe.  

Yet what happened to Jason Vassell, a student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, would make a fine 1950s apology tale, providing it ended the right way.  As it’s happening at the moment, it’s impossible to know how it will end just yet, but the drama is building, the tension is mounting, and the district attorney is being put to the test.  Can a black man at Amherst, subjected to an overtly racist attack, be treated justly for defending himself.

Ironically, this is a basic variation on the Castle Doctrine, beloved in such southerly hotspots as Houston for its authority to shoot at people who “need killin’.”  Us northerners don’t always appreciate the concept, but we can still recognize the desire and right to remains alive and relatively intact when someone comes into our home with bad intent.  The natural reaction is to survive first and argue about it later. 

So what happened to Jason Vassell?

Early on the morning of February 3, 2008, Jason, an African American student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, was in his dormitory. Two intoxicated white men, Jonathan Bowes and Jonathan Bosse, [neither of whom attended the college] approached Jason’s dormitory window repeatedly referring to him as a “nigger” and breaking in the window. They then forced their way into the dormitory lobby where they assaulted Jason, breaking his nose and giving him a concussion.

Under this continuing assault Jason was forced to defend himself with a pocketknife, injuring his assailants. As a result of defending himself against this unprovoked assault Jason, the victim of the attack, was charged with two counts of aggravated assault with a dangerous weapon. These charges carry a possible thirty year prison sentence. One of the perpetrators, Jonathan Bowes, was charged only with misdemeanors carrying a maximum eighteen month sentence. The other, Jonathan Bosse, was not charged at all.

The attack happened about a year ago, on February 3, 2008.  The case is about to go to trial in Hampshire Superior Court, with a motion to dismiss pending.  Northwestern District Attorney, Betsy Scheibel, sees no problem. 

According to the Boston Globe, Jason, who withdrew from UMass after the attack, has no priors and now lives with his parents awaiting his fate.  But he’s still black and about to go to trial for defending himself from attack.  Many students and professors on the Amherst campus have rallied to Jason’s support.  Others say they will await the trial, when the truth will come out.  Right.


Efforts to reach prosecutors yesterday were unsuccessful.

Well, that much is painfully clear. 

In Texas, Jason would be a hero.  In Amherst, he’s just an ex-student with a once-broken nose, a concussion, and a case going to trial for trying not to be the victim.  But no need to worry for Jason, since the truth will come out at trial and no doubt they will give him back the year of his life lost to being attacked for being black.  Then we can make that movie, once we have the happy ending.

Update:  Joel Rosenberg does a thorough and thought-provoking analysis at WindyPundit.  Definitely mandatory reading.

Getting Along or Getting It Right

Following the fascinating discussion on congeniality versus  “brilliance” in the Academy between Jeff Harrison and Jim Chen at MoneyLaw comes David Giacalone at f/k/a, reminding that there is no reason why one needs to sacrifice congeniality to assure brilliance.

A call came in shortly before reading David’s post from a potential client who sought new counsel on an ongoing case.  Why is always the first question.  The answer was that he didn’t like his lawyer.  He questioned what the lawyer was doing for him, and challenged the lawyer’s tactics.  But mostly, he didn’t like the lawyer.

After some discussion about his issues, two things became abundantly clear.  First, the lawyer’s representation was first rate.  The lawyer was not merely doing everything possible, but going above and beyond.  Second, the lawyer’s tactics were not merely competent, but exceptionally thoughtful and effective.  The client was receiving superlative representation.  And I told him so.

But, the potential client responded, “he’s not nice to me.”   And so we delved into that issue.  The client had certain expectations, ranging from his desire to have someone hold his hand and tell him he would be alright, to being involved in routine decision-making, which would require the client to climb a very steep learning curve.  But the primary problem was that the client was a screw-up when asked to do anything.  The client had a million excuses, but the fact was that he failed miserably to perform the few acts needed of him in the course of his defense, and the lawyer called him on it every time.  No, the client didn’t like his lawyer.

Was the lawyer a “jerk”?  Maybe.  But he was also doing an excellent job for his client.  I wondered how this fit into the discussion, and David’s point that competence and congeniality are not mutually exclusive. 

Within the Academy, congeniality amongst the faculty makes for a more pleasant atmosphere and, potentially, more productive team.  Certainly, lack of congeniality can create rancor that eats up time and effort that could better be spent in other ways.  But then, is the point of law school to have a happy faculty?  If the goal is generation of scholarship, as in Law Review articles and panel discussions, then a faculty that can work together is likely more important than having individual superstars.

On the other hand, if the point is teaching students to be lawyers, then what difference does it make if the faculty can share their thoughts and feelings in comfort.  This isn’t to suggest that an unpleasant working environment is a good thing, but that maintaining a pleasant one may not trump great teaching.

In the trenches, however, the situation differs.  While collegiality has its value in multi-defendant cases, it is a problematic consideration in the attorney-client relationship.  The only criterion that matters is effectiveness.  A defendant retains an attorney to fulfill a discrete function, to represent him in a criminal prosecution, the goal of which is to put him in prison to a long period of time.  It is preferable that the defendant despise his lawyer for the brief period of time he represents him until his case is concluded successfully, than like his lawyer very much for the twenty years he spends in prison.

Whether the lawyer and client become close personal friends after the case is over is not the point; The desire, and concomitant effort, to be liked by clients can, and often does, conflict with the duty to zealously represent.  It’s not that it must inherently conflict, but that when it does, and if often does, the lawyer must be prepared to burn his likability quotient in order to defend his client.  Too often, lawyers fail to make this hard choice because of their desire for future business from happy clients.  Happy is defined as clients who like the lawyer, as opposed to clients who won their case.

Toward the end of my telephone call with the potential client, I explained the facts of life.  His lawyer wasn’t mean or evil.  His lawyer was trying to save the defendant from himself, as lawyers are often forced to do.  I was sure that the lawyer took no pleasure from his stern rebukes to the client.  There was no pleasure to be had in any event.  Rather, the lawyer took his representation with the utmost seriousness, had dedicated enormous time and effort to provide the defendant with the best defense, with everything he had, and kept hitting brick walls constructed by the client himself.  The lawyer was doing his job.  That the client found it unpleasant was tough.

When things go swimmingly well in the course of representing a criminal defendant, it’s easy to be likable.  Few people chose to be dislikable; almost everyone prefers to have a pleasant atmosphere around them.  But when congeniality stands in the way of making the hard choices, it must give way.  Trench lawyers don’t have the luxury of a discussion over sherry about the personalities and sensibilities of their colleagues.  Shy away from our responsibility and a very happy client may spend the rest of his life in prison.  Trust me, he won’t be very happy for long.

The commercial said that it takes a tough man to make a tender chicken.  It’s true.  Be congenial whenever possible, but never let the desire to be like stand in the way of performing your duty.  Ultimately, every client appreciates the “jerk” lawyer who wins more than the “nice” lawyer who loses.

This Blawgosphere Ain’t Big Enough for the Two of Us

Reading the Mark Bennett’s monumental Blawg Review #199, I sat in awe of the Texas Tornado.  No, not just for its thoroughness and depth, which is what I’ve come to expect from Defending People, the best criminal law blawg anywhere. Bennett took his tome a step farther, using it for good as well:


Speaking of outsourced legal ethics, one thing that I love is to mess with internet legal marketers. Knowing this, some kind soul submitted for my Blawg Review consideration this crassly self-aggrandizing post on a crass advertising blog (I have edited away any possible SEO value): Mchigan Trock Acsident Atturney is the Authority for Trock Acsident Victims | Michgan Auto Law Blog. . .  Oh, and by the way Grant Griffith wants to teach you to blog for profit for profit (that is not a typo); he has manufactured a scarcity of 250 “members.” I wish he had set the number considerably lower, like zero — I don’t believe the world needs another 250 Michgan Trock Acsident-type atturneys who are “blogging for profit”.

There aren’t many who have the balls to use their BR for good instead of evil.  But soon after reading this, the issue ripened with Carolyn Elefant’s post about Blawging Lawyers.  Naturally, Bennett got to it ahead of me (because that’s what the best does), and went to town.  When Carolyn asks why both substantive blogging and marketing blogging can’t peacefully co-exist, Bennett analogizes it to a book store.


You’re going to the law bookstore looking for some interesting reads. You browse the spines of the books, pick one, and pull it down off the shelf. It’s three hundred pages; every page ends with a call to action — “if you’ve been injured, call me.” Skimming the text, you notice that the words “truck accident,” “lawyer,” “attorney,” and a few others are mentioned over and over and over again. You put that book back and try another. It’s got more of the same, except instead of “truck accident” it has repeated references to “DUI.” You’d be interested in learning about both topics, but the writing with all those repeated phrases is hackneyed, and you don’t care to be sold. That one goes back on the shelf.

The next book you choose has interesting information without the marketing; you put it in your basket and continue. After about fifteen minutes you realize that 75% of the books in the store are thinly disguised advertising. The other books are what you’re looking for, but they’re hard to find, and it’s frustrating.

Will you ever return to that bookstore?

My normal M.O. is to grab someone else’s ball and run with it.  This time, I’m too late.  Bennett has said all that needs to be said.  When the  blawgosphere is filled to the rim with blatant self-promotional blawgs that make readers want to puke, it will die.  No one wants to return to a bookstore than only sells advertisements. 

Grant Griffiths and Michael Martine are in the business of selling “the promise of success” to lawyers who are apparently too stupid to figure out how to blog on their own. (Hint: write good stuff. That’s all there is. No charge.) The “limited to 250” nonsense is a pathetic and obvious come-on, and anyone who falls for it deserves to pay Griffith and Martine for their services.  Once the blawgosphere has suffocated under the weight Blawging Lawyers, the salesman will move on to the next marketable object, maybe Twitting for Profit.  Regardless, it’s about getting money from lawyers foolish enough to fall into the marketers claws.  Lawyers are suckers for get rich quick schemes. 

So why can’t we all get along?  Because the marketers don’t care about the blawgosphere.  They care about the quick buck and scheme.   They will turn the least competent lawyer into the warmest, most sincere, most qualified lawyer in all of Dubuque to the detriment of society.  And they will churn SEO to clog the blawgosphere with enough garbage to choke it to death.  And when the blawgosphere dies, the good go down with the rest of it.

No, I don’t think the blawgosphere is big enough for all of us.  I think the marketers, given half a chance, will suck it dry, then watch it die.  And I thank Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado, for joining me in trying to do something about it.

Are Attackers “Awesome” to Feminists?

I never visited AutoAdmit.  I never read the crap that filled its discussion boards, where the “best and brightest” were given uncensored freedom to say what the would.  What they said was disgusting and ridiculous, replete with vicious attacks and smears.  No one with half a brain took any of it seriously, as it was just too bizarre and obviously baseless. 

So much for the great minds that may one day sit on the Supreme Court.  The students of our most prestigious law schools are as scummy, if not more so, than the rest of us.  Free speech, in its rawest form, can be really ugly. But wholly uncensored speech was the primary reason for the existence of the discussion boards at AutoAdmit, for better or worse. 

But two young women did, and were deeply hurt by things that were said about them.  The story of Brittan Heller and Heide Iravani is old to the blawgosphere, but was given new life in a Portfolio article, which formed the basis of a post in Ann Bartow’s Feminist Law Professors.  Bartow says these young women are “awesome”. 

While Heller and Iravani started out as the victims of malicious slurs on the discussion boards, they turned it around and went on the attack.  The problem isn’t that they stood up for themselves, though many questioned their motives, calling them two elitist, self-centered brats who couldn’t bear not being in control of others.  Some suggested that it was this demeanor that gave rise to their problems, bringing the ire and disdain of their classmates down on them like a hail of feces.  After all, the attacks against these young women appeared to come from the same people they sat with daily.  Maybe, just maybe, some of their classmates at Yale Law School didn’t think as well of them as they thought of themselves? 

But even if we assume that they are “awesome” for having stood up to the cyber-bullying, our “awesome” heroines switched roles when they went on the offensive.  And offensive it was.  Autoadmit was run by Jarret Cohen, who employed Anthony Ciolli, a Penn law student, to research law school rankings and law firms.  Cohen was in charge of the rest of it.  But when Heller and Iravani decided to go after someone, AutoAdmit and Cohen couldn’t be touched. 

So the young women wanted blood for their tainted names.  Apparently, they weren’t too concerned with whose blood it was.


In the 21 months since they filed suit, the women have already made some headway. But there are also accusations that the victims are becoming victimizers. Some of the defendants say the case amounts to an all-expenses-paid elitist temper tantrum in which two privileged women have cast an overly broad net, thus failing to differentiate between the really wicked and some of the tamer flamers, and have jeopardized careers in ways far more serious than theirs ever have been. One way or another, their suit highlights a culture and a legal system that still aren’t quite sure how freely people can or should speak online, how seriously to take what they say, and whether they can or should be sued for saying it.  

The fight went to the firm that had offered a job to Ciolli after graduation, Edwards Angell, pressured to withdraw its offer.  It did, and he was out of job.


Some concerned Yale students weighed a number of options. One was finding out the firm where Ciolli would be working upon graduation and pressuring it to withdraw its offer. It turned out to be the Boston law firm of Edwards, Angell, Palmer & Dodge, which in April rescinded its offer. The message board violated “principles of collegiality and respect that members of the legal profession should observe in their dealings with other lawyers,” the firm’s managing partner, Charles DeWitt, wrote Ciolli.

Then the lawsuit came.


Under Section 230(c), AutoAdmit and Cohen could not be sued. Neither, theoretically, could Ciolli, but he was nonetheless listed as a defendant—the only one charged under his real name. According to Lemley, the plaintiffs believed Ciolli had written some of the defamatory postings, making him vulnerable to a lawsuit. Ciolli counters that he was included either out of spite or to be held hostage until Cohen, over whom the women otherwise had no leverage, cleaned up his website. In November, without any explanation, Ciolli’s name was dropped from the case. “Even a middling law student at an unaccredited law school could figure out within five minutes of research that under Section 230(c), Anthony had complete legal immunity,” said his lawyer, Marc Randazza.

Since Ciolli was the easiest target, these “awesome” young women set about destroying his life. That he wasn’t the cause of their angst was of little concern.  By falsely claiming he might have been one of the posters, they sought to use Ciolli to extort control from Cohen and force the removal of the offending comments.  Ciollo was the pawn in their game, and they were more than happy to sacrifice the helpless pawn to get to the king.  The victims became the victimizers, and Ciolli was the target.


Sickening their experiences undoubtedly were. But had anything anyone posted actually been illegal? A judge or jury might view some posts, like the specific calls to harass Iravani, as intentional infliction of emotional distress. But many other posts, however cruel, might not be seen as extreme or outrageous enough to lose their First Amendment protection. As for defamation, the overwhelming majority of the comments could be construed as opinions, which are protected. True, some statements, such as the ones claiming that the women had venereal diseases, were by definition libelous. But even here, context matters: Courts have held that given the juvenile and hyperbolic quality of chat-room rhetoric, online comments cannot be taken as seriously as those made in real life. Matt Zimmerman of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which defends old-fashioned free-speech rights in the online world, called most of the plaintiffs’ claims “extraordinarily, extraordinarily weak.” Their argument, he said, amounted to liability by association: that simply by participating in chats theoretically containing some unprotected speech, all posters were thereby culpable. He called that claim “wrongheaded and dangerous.”

Eventually, the action against Ciolli was dismissed, after his job was lost, he was put to the defense of a frivolous claim and his bar admission screwed up.  So the only person who has suffered actual harm as a result of all this is Anthony Ciolli, at worst a bystander to free speech who failed, in the eyes of these two women, to obey their commands. 

For those who believe that free speech is a worthy value standing alone, the ugly comes hand in hand with freedom.  Ann Bartow enjoys her free speech when she posts about the “awesomeness” of her two heroines, omitting the details about the harm they caused.  Where are the qualms about her two heroines’ efforts to undermine free speech for others?  Does feminism demand that free speech be a one way street, going only in its direction?  But speech is a right, no flesh or blood attached.  It’s an easy victim, as it can’t scream out in pain.  What about Ciolli?

Now I may be a bit blind to something, not being as politically correct as some, or perhaps not being as myopic as others, but I fail to see how anyone, regardless of one’s blind devotion to feminist orthodoxy, can call two women who wrongfully and disgracefully destroyed the life of a young man solely because he was the only one they could find to hurt “awesome”.  Is there some disease that infects the feminist law professor mystique that relishes harming an innocent 20 year old male, no matter what? 

Wow, Ann.  Really “awesome”.


The Charter of its Own Existence

In the New York Times Editorial Notebook, Adam Cohen takes on the impending death of the exclusionary rule, as predicted after the Herring and Hudson decisions from the Supreme Court.  Noting that Chief Justice John Roberts, in his former life in the Reagan administration, had it out for Mapp v. Ohio, Cohen adds fuel to the fire that the end is coming.

The court carved out exceptions over the years, but the basic rule laid down in Mapp has endured for nearly five decades. Now, Chief Justice John Roberts’s conservative majority on the Supreme Court is working to undo the exclusionary rule in a more fundamental way. It’s been a longstanding interest of Mr. Roberts’s. As a young Reagan administration lawyer, he worked on what he described in a memo as a “campaign to amend or abolish” the rule.

Not surprisingly, Cohen takes the position that exclusionary rule must stand, despite its “flaws”.


There is no denying that the exclusionary rule allows a small number of criminals to go free because the police have blundered — which is certainly no minor matter. But the more faithfully the rule is applied, the more likely the police are to collect evidence lawfully.

As important as it is to convict criminals, the Supreme Court in Mapp rightly insisted that the Constitution must not be trampled in the process. “Nothing can destroy a government more quickly,” the court noted, “than its failure to observe its own laws, or worse, its disregard of the charter of its own existence.”

While I can appreciate the need for balance, acknowledgment that excluding unlawfully obtained evidence is not a perfect solution, this was about as weak an argument in favor of the exclusionary rule as I can imagine.  That’s it?  A platitude about disregarding “the charter of its own existence?”  Granted it’s true, but the charter of its own existence contains many demands on our government, including the protection of the safety of the citizenry.  What about the rest of the charter?  If that’s the best we can come up with, we can kiss the exclusionary rule good-bye.

Cohen’s limp defense of the exclusionary rule ignores far more serious, and pervasive, reasons to demand not only that the exclusionary rule remain vital, but robust.  The current Court’s watering down of the rule, beefing up the exceptions, establishes authority of the government to not merely ignore its own law at will, a proposition that some believe is entirely correct, but flies in the face of the express limitations imposed on government in its formation to prevent it from devolving into tyranny.  Hey, having fought a revolution to break from the economic binds of England, our founding fathers weren’t about to trust some new leader, whether Washington or Obama, with enough power to break down out doors.

The 4th Amendment is not a technicality to provide police with an incentive to behave themselves.  It is a shield for the ordinary citizen from government power.  While the Supremes justified Weeks and Mapp with the expectation that it would compel police to act accordance with law, that’s the sort of pap that makes for palatable doctrine when the reality on the street can’t be openly admitted.  Cohen briefly acknowledges this reality when addressing Justice Scalia’s “new professionalism” argument.


Despite Justice Scalia’s claims, police misconduct is rampant. In the last few years, the Atlanta and Oakland police departments have had major scandals over officers’ lying to obtain search warrants. In this same period, of course, the federal government engaged in an illegal domestic wiretapping program, the extent of which is still unknown.

But Cohen fails to connect the dots in his own point.  If five decades after Mapp the police still can’t manage to abide the law, then the exclusionary rule has failed to fulfill its salutary purpose.  This is false, of course, because its stated rationale never reflected its true purpose, the protection of people from police.  The Supreme Court’s recent reliance on the rationale to further eviscerate Mapp proves the point that the rationale is a fiction while the truth continues to smack real people upside the head everyday.

The exclusionary rule must exist for one very real, very hard reason:  Without it, we have absolutely no means of stopping the cops from breaking down our door at will.  Until someone devises a better way to prevent tyranny, we need it.  We need it desperately.

The Good Elected Judge

I asked for a spy book, something that would require no brain cells.  Instead, she bought a copy of John Grisham’s The Appeal, a book that held some promise until it wrapped up with a pat conclusion that made me wonder what happened to the spy book.  It was Grisham’s editorial on Don L. Blankenship, CEO of Massey Energy, and his pet, Brent D. Benjamin.

Even though this story has been around long enough for Grisham to write a book about it, it finally appeared on Adam Liptak’s radar this weekend and made its way into the New York Times.  Cutting edge, as always.  The short story is that Blankenship bought Benjamin a seat on the West Virginia Supreme Court so he could reverse a $50 million judgment against Massey Energy.  It cost Blankenship about $3 million for the seat, making it a decent investment.  Benjamin won and did his job. 

My old buddy Mike from the train always said, an honest politician is one who gets bought and stays bought.  Mike must know Blankenship too:


“I’ve been around West Virginia long enough to know that politicians don’t stay bought, particularly ones that are going to be in office for 12 years,” he said, referring to the terms of State Supreme Court justices. “So I would never go out and spend money to try to gain favor with a politician. Eliminating a bad politician makes sense. Electing somebody hoping he’s going to be in your favor doesn’t make any sense at all.”

Benjamin, now the Chief Justice, stayed bought long enough, apparently.  The issue before the Supreme Court is whether Benjamin should have recused himself from the Massey Energy case.  After taking the case, Benjamin recused himself from hearing any further Massey cases because it would be “disrespectful”. 

Given time, every evil man can invent reaches its logical extreme.  Granted, this one is so unbearably flagrant and ugly that most people would find it hard to believe that Blankenship could be so crass.  They underestimate people.  But it presents a window on a far larger problem.


The case, one of the most important of the term, has the potential to change the way judicial elections are conducted and the way cases are heard in the 39 states that elect at least some of their judges. In many states, campaigns for court seats these days rival in both expense and venom what goes on in, say, a governor’s race. Yet it is commonplace in American courtrooms for judges to hear cases involving lawyers and litigants who have contributed to or spent money to support their campaigns.

Though most judges would never view themselves as bought and paid for, and refuse to view campaign contributions as a quid pro quo for their good graces (and proper decision), the stink is already upon us.  Who do you think contributes the cash that pays for judicial elections?  It’s lawyers, law firms and litigants.  Frankly, no one else (except grandma) cares, or even has a clue who these judicial candidates are.  What possible motivation does anyone have to help finances a judicial campaign aside from an agenda, whether specific to a case or general to a personal disposition.  We all want judges who see things our way.  Occasionally, we contribute to the campaign of a friend, with whom we don’t really agree but we would feel rotten if we didn’t help.  But that’s the odd situation, not the norm.

If the Supreme shut down the Massey loophole, then who can contribute?  Will judges be required to recuse themselves whenever a campaign contributor walks into the well?  They should, not because they are necessarily influenced but because of the appearance of impropriety flowing from Massey Energy.  But that will make it impossible to practice law, preventing lawyers from appearing before the judges they like and leaving only the judges they don’t untainted.  That’s kinda crazy.

The case will be argued on March 3rd.  Despite the superficial clarity of the issue, Liptak argues that the merits briefs, however, show that it’s hardly as simple as the obvious ethical question.


The briefs on Massey’s side add that states should be allowed to run their legal systems as they see fit. It would be impossible, they say, to fashion a sensible rule to determine when contributions or independent expenditures should require recusal under the federal Constitution’s due process clause. The other side says it has no problem with elections or financial support. But in rare cases involving especially large amounts from the people involved, they say, judges should be required to disqualify themselves.

The Massey side has the better position; that there is no way to fashion a rule.  The opposition’s wiggly position begs the question of the price of impropriety, or its appearance.  If a case involves a mere $1 million, do we close our eyes to impropriety and pretend it’s entirely different?  What about  life without parole?  Can we buy convictions or acquittals, even though there’s no price tag? 

The answer, clear to anyone who isn’t desperately seeking a way out of the doctrinal conundrum, is that impropriety is impropriety, regardless of how much money is involved, and that judicial elections are inherently subject to impropriety.  But then, the second prong comes into play, with the Supreme Court left to dictate to states how they should run their legal systems.  Would SCOTUS even consider such a bold and invasive move?

Given the economy and the status of judicial salaries, I’m watching the case closely.  I’ve still got some pocket change left and am considering whether to buy a judge of my own.  But I want an honest one; one who stays bought.