Author Archives: SHG

Do It Or The Pony Dies

When posting on hot button issues, one anticipates drawing some nutjobs out of the digital woodwork.  It’s inevitable.  Many have no other human contact, and necessarily seek contact any way they can.  But these are usually the “enemy”, the ones who troll the blawgosphere looking to start a fight.  They relish the havoc they cause, the closest thing to love they experience.

But what of friends?  These are the people with whom one’s sympathies lie.  They support the same causes, see things the same way and want to enthusiastically scream “me too,” and more.  The problem is that they can be just as troublesome as the enemies when they don’t recognize the limits of propriety, but they can be harder to get rid of.  Like the guest who overstays his welcome, they can’t stop and they won’t go away.

When I posted about the Innocence Project of Florida, and its misbegotten email seeking support from the blawgosphere to garner support to stay the Wayne Tompkins execution a mere 6 hours before the execution was to take place, it was like catnip.  Out came the opposition to the death penalty, supporters of the Innocence Project of Florida and self-righteous one-trick ponies who saw this as their opportunity to jump on the soapbox and scream.

A couple of comments were posted, with monumental deletions, in the beginning.  When I realized that this perceived invitation could get out of hand, I just deleted further comments altogether.  Then the emails started, the arguments, the accusations, the challenges.  As the self-righteous are often wont to do, they demanded their right to post their screeds, at length, with links (to themselves and their one-trick pony friends). 

It starts with the belief that a shared opposition to the death penalty and generic injustice means that they have found an outlet for their views on a stage far larger than they would ever have on their own.  There are literally thousands of little websites and blogs announcing personalized incidents of injustice, often providing ad naseum details of every blow landed on the innocent.  No doubt some are true, though many reflect perceived wrongs which evaporate under scrutiny.  Regardless, the chance to get their issue spread across a broader stage was too much to bear.  And so they swarmed.

When I get the occasional swarm of nutjobs who lash out in favor of killing people, or in support of police misconduct, it’s fairly easy to laugh at a few and cut off the rest.  I have no misgivings about it.  But it’s harder to do so with people who appear to have a sincere belief in what I consider the right causes, but just lack the self-control and sensibility to conduct themselves properly. 

In the past week, Orin Kerr added to 2 new rules to the ever-expanding Volokh list.


General Guide to Blogging, #127: In a moderated comment thread, there is a 50% chance that any commenter who is given a warning for being uncivil will argue that they were not uncivil, demand an explanation of what exactly they did that was deemed uncivil, and seek an explanation of why others have not been warned when they did more or less the same thing.

General Guide To Blogging, #128: In a moderated comment thread, there is a 50% chance that a commenter who had an uncivil comment deleted will accuse the moderator of censorship and question the moderator’s commitment to free speech. (Because if the First Amendment means anything, it’s the right to do what you want with someone else’s private property without the property owner being able to clean up your mess.)

Ain’t it the truth.  I try to be fairly equal-handed in my approach.  I shut down friends as well as people I don’t know.  I shut down people who agree with me as well as people who think I’m a moron.  But even when I fall short of my efforts at fairness, I still retain total control over what appears here and what doesn’t.  My “enemies” don’t like it.  My “friends” absolutely hate it.  Of the two, the friends find it far harder to comprehend, and tend to be far more aggressive and nastier about it.  The reason seems obvious:  I’m supposed to be on their side, so how dare I not show them unconditional love? 

So for the sake of clarity, let’s review some basic concepts of life at Simple Justice.  No, you cannot post a comment attacking every case with which you have a problem.  No, you cannot ignore the post to which your comment is attached and use it as a jumping off point for your personal agenda, no matter how righteous you think you are.  No, you cannot use a comment to attack every judge, prosecutor or other official you believe has wronged you, your loved one or someone you know absolutely nothing about.  No, you cannot post links in a comment to your little one-trick pony blog to get it exposure because it’s really, really important that everybody knows about it.

And finally, no, I won’t be goaded into letting you have your way because you challenge my “censorship” of your really valuable and important things to say.  While we may well share many of the same views, you have no right to post anything here.  Zero.  No, you don’t have to agree with my decision, and no, I don’t need your approval or agreement.  No, you don’t have to understand why.  Your threats of excommunicating me don’t really bother me.

There are wackos on both sides of every issue, and the wackos never perceive themselves as such.  The only thing wackos seem to accomplish is to draw other wackos to their corner and push reasonable people as far away from them as possible.  The wackos never understand why this happens, and why they are so utterly ineffective in accomplishing their very important goals.  They are blind zealots, and they are a danger to their own one-trick pony cause.  They just can’t understand why.

Numerous readers/commenters were banned this weekend.  They were told they are not welcome here.  Not because I disagree with their cause, but because out-of-control “friends” are no more welcome than enemies.  This is not subject to debate, and it’s not going to change even if you threaten to kill the pony.

It’s Not Just the Stars

Jim Chen has written another MoneyLaw gem about the lesson to be learned from a b-ball player named Shane Battier.  Who?   


Shane Battier, a forward playing for the Houston Rockets, may be “the most abnormally unselfish basketball player.” Lewis calls him “the player who seems one step ahead of the analysts, helping the team in all sorts of subtle, hard-to-measure ways that appear to violate his own personal interests.” He is valuable not because of his raw athleticism, but in spite of his physical limits.

What matters about Shane Battier is that stars need people to support them.  There can be no effective Yao Ming without a Shane Battier.


It’s hard to overstate Battier’s value to the Houston Rockets. That team’s payroll having been committed, “for many years to come, to two superstars: Tracy ­McGrady and Yao Ming,” management needed to seek undervalued, underpaid players. “That’s the scarce resource in the NBA. . . . Not the superstar but the undervalued player.”

Jim makes the point for the purpose of showing the hidden value of the supporting player on a law school faculty.  I steal his point to say the same about the lawyers for the defense.  Many, perhaps even most, of my cases involve multiple defendants.  I represent one defendant, and other defendants have their own lawyers.  Aside from the lawyers pushing their clients to flip, the defense lawyers often have the opportunity to work together for the mutual benefit of all.  It frequently doesn’t work out that way.

There are two basic reasons for this phenomenon, one legitimate and one not.  Each lawyer has an individual client to represent, and to the extent that their defendant’s interest differs from that of a co-defendant, they are required to put their client’s interest ahead of all else.  But the fact is that much of the time, the interests of defendants are mutual, and it is in the defendants mutual interests to work together toward the common goal.  Still, lawyers don’t.  They can’t.  They simply find it impossible to put aside their personalities, their selfishness.  Each is a star, and stars cannot sublimate their interests for the common good.  It’s not in their nature.

This isn’t true of all lawyers.  Some are happy to be team players when it doesn’t interfere with duty to their client.  They will contribute selflessly, even though there will be no glory for them personally.  Somebody has to pass the ball to the star for the dunk.  They have grown beyond the  fear that no one will notice, or appreciate, their contribution.  Their contributions are invaluable, while the wannabe stars lounge about waiting for the hard work to magically get done so they can pretend they had something to do with it.

When I am not lead counsel in a case, I try to contribute this way.  There are a number of lawyers with whom I love to work, knowing that they will contribute this way.  There are far more lawyers who I know won’t, and will either disappear or drop the ball when time comes to contribute to the team work that wins cases.  I dread them being on a case with me.  They can be more dangerous to success than the prosecution.  At minimum, they are just a drag on the case, an additional needless burden to carry along the way.

Jim Chen’s sports analogy may not be perfect, but it offers much to think about for anyone whose playing field is a court.  No matter how much of a star you want to be, there are times that being like Shane Battier will be the most valuable contribution you can make.

When Justice Hits the Wall

United States District Court Judge Emmet Sullivan hit the wall.  Via Jonathon Adler at VC, from the Washington Post,

Stevens and his lawyers complained during the trial about prosecutors withholding information. In December, they asked for his conviction to be tossed out. As part of their request, they asked for the documents related to Joy.

During yesterday’s hearing, Sullivan repeatedly asked three Justice Department lawyers sitting at the prosecution’s table whether they had some reason not to turn over the documents. They finally acknowledged they did not, and Sullivan exploded in anger.

“That was a court order,” he bellowed. “That wasn’t a request. I didn’t ask for them out of the kindness of your hearts. . . . Isn’t the Department of Justice taking court orders seriously these days?”

Judge Sullivan held the three in contempt, and demanded to know who else at Justice was involved.  This was astounding.  At Jonathon Turley put it,


It was a rare moment in court. Federal judges routinely sanction private counsel for actions that are regularly committed by prosecutors without penalty. Judge Sullivan held all three attorneys in the courtroom in contempt.

But the question that remains from Judge Sullivan’s decision to hold the three in contempt was raised by Mike at Crime & Federalism:


The Washington Post needs to do a story on the prosecution’s outrageous conduct throughout the trial. It’s a scandal, even to people like me who think that Ted Stevens is a corrupt man.  Even the devil deserves his due, at least if we’re going to pretend to live in a nation of laws. 

Throughout the trial, issues were flying of government games, concealment of evidence, subornation of perjury and more.  The defense moved for mistrial, and the motion was denied.  The trial was allowed to run its course, and Senator Ted Stevens was convicted. 

Only after the trial has the Judge had enough.  Only after the verdict has the Judge decided that the government was too wrong, even for him to tolerate.  What does this mean for trial?  Exactly how much must the government do wrong before action is taken?

No one will argue that Judge Sullivan went off the deep end holding the government lawyers in contempt.  But it’s an unsatisfying outcome when so much wrong happened during trial and nothing was done.  Aside from the irony of a government prosecuting someone for doing wrong, while doing wrong themselves in the process, there must come a time when all the fine rules either mean something or mean nothing.  When trials go horribly wrong, with law violated wherever one looks, that the trial cannot be allowed to continue.

Now that Sen. Stevens is convicted, Judge Sullivan has had enough.  If only that had happened during the trial, before the jury was allowed to reach a verdict based upon the government’s scam case.

Piling on Bob Simels

When the indictment was announced, New York criminal defense lawyers shook their heads.  Sure, Bob Simels was a tough guy, a tough lawyer.  Criminal defense is no place for the weak.  But the allegations against him were astounding.  Eliminating witnesses?  That was tough to swallow.

Now it appears that the quiet in New York about Simels’ case was softly broken in Maryland, where the Baltimore City Paper posts about a grand jury has demanded information in an unrelated case about Simels’ involvement.

Meanwhile, in a Baltimore case that appears unrelated to Khan, another Justice Department attorney asked a judge to order Simels to cough up detailed information to a grand jury about how he’s getting paid to represent accused drug trafficker and money launderer Shawn Michael Green.

Just another day in the decades-long war between Justice and Simels.

The gist of the Maryland grand jury subpoena is for Simels’ records of fee payments with regard to Green, under the theory that Simels was being paid while Green was in the wind and engaged in drug dealing.  Like it or not, the payment of legal fees is not privileged information, though the government generally steers clear of the issue as a matter of comity more than anything else.


The specific information sought by the grand jury from Simels concerns “attorney fees and retainers received for the representation of Green, the amount of funds received, the identity of the individuals who provided such funds, and the dates and manner in which such funds were provided (i.e., cash, check, wire, etc.).”

The likelihood that Simels will have all the information demanded is slim.  We’re lawyers, not accountants, and as long as no IRS Form 8300 is required, record keeping is generally minimal.  There is just no good reason to keep extraneous records, the only purpose of which would be evidence against a client.  But if he was paid for representation of Green while he was on the run, it implicates Simels in facilitating his conduct.  Still, fee payments alone provide minimal, if any, information that directly bears on any relevant issue.  It’s just that they are an easy target for prosecutors to use to go after Bob Simels.

At the same time, according to the article, prosecutors in New York rebuffed Simels’ attempt to obtain the return of the security for his bond, claiming he was a danger to the community without a secured bond.  Simels’ attorney, Gerald Shargel, argued that there was no finding of danger or flight when the bond was originally set, thus precluding the government from arguing it now.


The prosecutors, Steven D’Alessandro and Morris Fodeman, went ahead and called Simels dangerous anyhow, while arguing that they are not required to prove that he is. In doing so, they restated the allegations–that Simels sought to bribe and threaten witnesses, including with violence–and note that Simels is wealthy, that the evidence against him is strong, and that his behavior was conducted in his role as an attorney.

“The Court can have little confidence,” the prosecutors continued, that Simels will not further obstruct justice “now that Simels, as opposed simply to a client, would benefit” from such crimes. Thus, they concluded, “there exists a palpable danger were the defendant released without significant pre-trial conditions,” such as the high bail set when he was first arrested.

While the allegations against Simels claim that he was involved in the neutralization of witnesses in a case, it’s not as if he walked the streets kicking puppies or pushing old people out of the way.  What “palpable danger” they are talking about is entirely unclear, but it certainly makes him sound awfully evil and dangerous.  It sounds like typical government hyperbole without any substantive basis behind it.  The question remains whether it will suffice, as it usually does.

Whether the government will next claim that Simels was responsible for the Lindbergh baby kidnapping remains to be seen, but it’s clear that the government has him in their crosshairs and has no intention of cutting him a break.  This very strange case remains very strange, and the zeal with which the government approaches Simels’ prosecution does not appear to be abating in the slightest.

H/T David Giacalone.

Is it Soup Yet?

With far too many things of interest for a Saturday, it seems like a brisk run around the blawgosphere is in order.

From Dan Solove at Co-Op, a small reminder that destroying pre-1985 children’s books won’t really improve the quantity of maggots in junior’s diet.

In its (falsely) reassuringly subtitled booklet “The Food Defect Action Levels: Levels of Natural or Unavoidable Defects in Foods That Present No Health Hazards for Humans,” the F.D.A.’s Center for Food Safety and Applied Nutrition establishes acceptable levels of such “defects” for a range of foods products, from allspice to peanut butter. . . .

Tomato juice, for example, may average “10 or more fly eggs per 100 grams [the equivalent of a small juice glass] or five or more fly eggs and one or more maggots.” Tomato paste and other pizza sauces are allowed a denser infestation — 30 or more fly eggs per 100 grams or 15 or more fly eggs and one or more maggots per 100 grams.

If this bothers you, wait until you read about what’s in your beer.  Hint: It isn’t “nubbly synthetic pretend-dinosaur-skin” that might interest a second-grader to learn to read.  We’re now protected from that danger.

From Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy, the 7th Circuit in U.S. v. England has shielded us from the harshness of being sentenced for things you might have done.  With a caveat:



Interestingly (and somewhat disturbingly), though the Seventh Circuit reverses the sentence in this appeal, it hints that the real problem was just that the district court did not have enough evidentiary support for its conclusion that the defendant would have committed attempted murder. 


In arriving at our decision, we want to underscore that we do not pass judgment on the reasonableness of the 210-month sentence imposed by the district court. As noted above, the able and experienced district court judge conducted a thorough and meaningful § 3553(a) analysis and the sentence that he imposed very well may be reasonable. The district court need not repeat this analysis at resentencing; it can adopt the § 3553(a) findings arrived at during the June 2, 2008 hearing. We only require that the district court make its sentencing determination without reliance on a finding that England would have attempted murder if out on bond unless further evidence is adduced which would justify such a conclusion.

Exactly what evidence the circuit will find acceptable as proof of future occurrences remains to be seen. 

Perhaps some of those weird psychic precogs can come testify at the next sentencing hearing against the defendant to make sure he does not get away with his “precrime” of attempted murder.

We can’t have people getting away with crimes that have yet to happen, now can we.

From Radley Balko at The Agitator comes Rep. Floyd Flake’s twit:


“11 hours to review a 1000+ page spending bill that spends nearly a trillion dollars? This is not Congress’ finest hour.”

Which leads to Orin Kerr’s observation at Volokh that there are some notable similarities between the stimulus bill and the USA Patriot Act.

[A] new President has declared a crisis that demands immediate action. The old policies of the past have failed, he announces, and it is time for far-reaching action that will expand the government’s power to combat the serious threats against the Nation. Time is of the essence, he declares: We must act now.

The opposing party tries to stop the President’s plan. They complain that the President and his minions in Congress are acting too fast and going too far. Sure, some kind of change is needed. But the President and his allies are going too far, they complain, passing a “wish list” to capitalize on the public’s fear of the crisis continuing. 

Even worse, no one seems to know exactly what is in the massive bill. Senators and Representatives in the minority party complain that they never even had time read it! The bill is hundreds of pages long, and it was impossible for anyone to read all that legislation in time for the vote.

The President is dismissive about their complaints, however. The opponents are stuck in the old discredited way of thinking: Change is needed, and quickly.

Trick question:  What year does this describe, 2001 or 2009?  Yes, there are far more differences than similarities, but that doesn’t make the similarities disappear.

Norm Pattis posts about the waiting, waiting, waiting for the jury to return the verdict.  Every lawyer who ever tried a case to a jury knows exactly what Norm’s talking about.

Waiting for a verdict in a criminal case is the closest I expect to get to Hell. That is not because I hope to ascend to Heaven at death. I simply don’t believe in an afterlife.

Classic Norm.  Of course, as painful as the waiting is, the pain is forgotten when the jury foreperson says the words “not guilty,” ironically captured in Norm’s follow-up “…And The Gods Smiled.” 

My client was acquitted today of all counts relating to the state’s claim that she drove while intoxicated. She was convicted of one count arising from the jury’s conclusion that one child was not in a mandated booster seat for a child under 60 pounds in weight. It is a good day.

Also classic Norm, his religious ambiguity notwithstanding.

And finally, I close with another terrible jury decision.  Fortunately, the egregious error does little harm.  A jury of automobile designers claims to have decided, once and for all, the “most beautiful car ever.”  The verdict?



The Citroën DS?  So they say.  Quirky?  Absolutely.  Fascinating?  Okay.  Most beautiful?  Now where does one appeal?

And with this, I wish all a happy Valentine’s Day, brought to you by Hallmark Cards and Godiva Chocolates.

What Black Thursday Will Mean Come Monday

By now, the readers of Above The Law, chronicler of all things Biglaw, have had the time to digest the week’s news.  About 828 associates and staff at large law firms learned that their services were no longer needed.  It was a bloodbath for Biglaw, and the message is clear that it’s not over yet.  Schadenfreude aside, it’s impossible not to sympathize with the young lawyers who thought they did everything right, only to find their world turned upside down.

But what does this mean to criminal defense lawyers, for whom this news had little direct meaning?  It could mean plenty.

With law firms laying off lawyers indiscriminately, and lawyers having bills to pay and mouths to feed, one can reasonably expect them to take their framed Law Review Certificates off the wall, put on some comfortable shoes and make a clean start of it in the trenches.  Why?  Because their options are limited.

Most will try their hand at some variation of the law they experienced in the wood paneled libraries of their former homes, but when they find that large corporations don’t frequently shop for counsel in the back alleys off Main Street, they will come to realize that they need to adapt.  The first adaptation will be that they will take any client who walks through the door.  The second is that they will take whatever fee the client can afford.  Hey, the ability to buy a cup-o-noodles is better than going hungry.

When Biglaw was king, meaning three months ago, a number of blawgers served as cheerleaders for the solo practitioners of the world.  Some sought to make a business of it, seeing a potential niche in turning miserable associates into happy entrepreneurs.  Others just sought the chance to elevate thereputation of solos for the purpose of showing that they were every bit as competent, worthy and important as the Biglaw Masters of the Universe.  But it’s unlikely that anyone saw this slaughter coming, where the very foundation of belief in the indestructibility of Biglaw would be shaken to its core. What law student is prepared to sacrifice his life on the alter of Biglaw now, when the chances are slim that he’ll be around long enough to pay off his student loans?

The next step bodes poorly for criminal defense lawyers, however.  As a thousand shingles will be hung come Monday, each represents another lawyer trying to take your clients.  Each new solo will tell their parents and friends that they need business, and they will let others know.  They will promote themselves online, and become stars on Avvo Answers.  They will present themselves as your competition, even though they may lack any competence.  This isn’t about competence, but about eating.

Late on Thursday, David Lat, one time Jersey AUSA cum blawging diva, twitted that he was scared by the day’s events.  I asked him what was to become of all the former AUSA that used to be absorbed by Biglaw, becoming overnight defense lawyers.  He never responded.  But we know what will become of them.  They’re going to hang out their shingle next door to you, because they can’t get a Biglaw job anymore either.  How many more “former prosecutor” websites will spring up to convince defendants that buying the inside track will get them that “special deal.”

It’s long been my position that we produce far more lawyers than any society can absorb.  It’s been the root cause of many problems for the profession, with lawyers debasing themselves to snare a client any way they can, and lawyers rationalizing their unprofessional conduct so they don’t have to admit that they’re debasing themselves.  But expect the bad news in Biglaw to flow downhill to bad news in the trenches.  Not only are they unprepared to do the work we do; not only are they hungry and desperate; not only are they full of the self-importance and arrogance bred of bonus babies fed expensive lunches, but these will be the ones who will do anything, say anything and stop at nothing in their effort to save their fortune.

Thursday was ugly at Biglaw.  Monday will be ugly in the trenches.  Say hi to your new colleagues. 

Tell It to the Children (Update)

It’s hard to figure out exactly where, along the spectrum of horrible acts, any particular wrong falls, but this is one of the most despicable I’ve ever learned about.  Two judges in Pennsylvania sold children into a private juvenile prison.  The names of these scum are Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and Michael T. Conahan.  Let them be forever memorialized in the blawgosphere, so that every search of these names shows what they did. 

The opening of this New York Times article captures the horror.



At worst, Hillary Transue thought she might get a stern lecture when she appeared before a judge for building a spoof MySpace page mocking the assistant principal at her high school in Wilkes-Barre, Pa. She was a stellar student who had never been in trouble, and the page stated clearly at the bottom that it was just a joke.


Instead, the judge sentenced her to three months at a juvenile detention center on a charge of harassment. 

She was handcuffed and taken away as her stunned parents stood by.

“I felt like I had been thrown into some surreal sort of nightmare,” said Hillary, 17, who was sentenced in 2007. “All I wanted to know was how this could be fair and why the judge would do such a thing.”


Forget the freedom of speech stuff.  I can’t think of an epithet strong enough to call the judge who did this.  This wasn’t an issue of higher order legal concepts, but the lowest order.  The judges sold children for profit.  $2.6 million.  How many children have to be sold to make that much?

Now that the judges have pleaded guilty to a deal of 87 months, a piddling sentence, and with every expectation that they will meet some folks in prison who feel that they were treated far too kindly by the prosecutors, let’s turn to the larger question.  How is it possible that a rogue judge could do this and no one was capable, or willing, to stop him?


For years, youth advocacy groups complained that Judge Ciavarella was unusually harsh. He sent a quarter of his juvenile defendants to detention centers from 2002 to 2006, compared with a state rate of 1 in 10. He also routinely ignored requests for leniency made by prosecutors and probation officers.

“The juvenile system, by design, is intended to be a less punitive system than the adult system, and yet here were scores of children with very minor infractions having their lives ruined,” said Marsha Levick, a lawyer with the Philadelphia-based Juvenile Law Center.

“There was a culture of intimidation surrounding this judge and no one was willing to speak up about the sentences he was handing down.”

An advocacy group, the Juvenile Law Center, tried to act upon the complaints, but were rebuffed by the courts.  After all, no judge could ever be so bad.  The black robes of silence surrounded their brethren to protect them from selling children into jail.


Last year, the Juvenile Law Center, which had raised concerns about Judge Ciavarella in the past, filed a motion to the State Supreme Court about more than 500 juveniles who had appeared before the judge without representation. The court originally rejected the petition, but recently reversed that decision.

How bold the Supreme Court is, to take it seriously only after the feces and fan collide.

Many lawyers believe that it is wrong to be critical of courts and judges; that it diminishes respect for the legal system.  They are often critical of me for doing so, clinging to platitudes about honesty and integrity, and how it’s the best system ever created, as if mouthing words of feigned respect changes anything.  Will your platitudes give these children back their lives?

This is what comes when anyone, any group, any function, becomes immune from critical oversight.  When a judge is able to create a “culture of intimidation” that protects his horrible crimes against children, there can be no question that the power in their hands is far too great.  When the appellate courts, whose only reason to exist is to oversee the lower courts, refuse to believe it possible that wrongs happening before their eyes, they share the blame and bear the disgrace for their failure.

I am sick to death of hearing people proclaim that judges try their best, and sincerely care, and deserve our respect.  They must earn our respect with every case, every decision, every life that comes before them.  Some judges do.  Some judges don’t.  Do not lump them into some group that is above scrutiny, inherently beyond reproach.  Judges are not gods, immune from the harm they do others.  The ones who possess integrity will take no issue with scrutiny.  The ones like Mark A. Ciavarella Jr. and Michael T. Conahan deserve no respect.

Who amongst you wants to lecture the children of Wilkes-Barre about the dignity of the judiciary today?

Update:  A helpful reader sent over this Scranton Times article :


In 2003, 778 of the 1,499 delinquent juveniles were placed in secure detention. In 2004, the rate was 914 of 1,369 and in 2005, 491 of 1,241.

If this was Manhattan, it would be shocking.  For Scranton, these numbers are astronimical.  In 2004, about 66% of all JDs were put in detention.  And nobody in the system noticed this?

Nordstrom: Don’t Hate Us Please (Idiot Version) (Update)

To be tested by Nordstrom twice in a week is either a testament to the power of information or a demonstration of their corporate belief that we are such blithering idiots that we will buy any piece of crap they throw against the wall.  Marc Randazza, a savvy lawyer, followed up on the Nordstrom attack on tiny little Beckons to crush them with a post entitled Nordstrom Redeems Itself.



It seems that Nordstrom has decided that perhaps it was being a bit dickish in its attempt to bully over a small business in a trademark dispute. It even went so far as to say that it is sorry.



“A customer of ours e-mailed us a copy of your story from yesterday expressing their unhappiness with how they feel Nordstrom has handled this issue. I’d like you to know our thoughts. Our intention from the beginning was to co-exist with Beckons in a manner that would enable Beckons to use their trademark on yoga merchandise, while we used the Beckon name for fashion apparel and accessories. We never intended to adversely affect Ms. Prater’s business and we are sorry if this has happened. We are reaching out again to Ms. Prater’s attorneys to reach a settlement that we are hoping she will find acceptable. When we have resolved this issue, which we are hopeful will be soon, we’ll get back to you to share the outcome.”


Maybe those new-dad hormones are still raging through Randazza’s tired body rendering him unduly kind, but saying sorry after costing two young women who were entirely in the right $70,000 in legal fees to fight over nothing just doesn’t begin to cut it.  Now that Nordstrom was outed in this InformationWeek post and across the blawgosphere, they’re “sorry”.  And it’s so sincere.  And all is forgiven? 

Not by me.  Brooke White, Nordstrom VP of Corporate Communications (yes, they have a VP just for corporate communications), sent an email to Global CIO Blog, and spread around by Michael Atkins at Seattle Trademark Lawyer,  His emails is crock of corporate nonsense.  Not even a well-designed crock, but a rather text-book email on how to deflect responsibility while saying absolutely nothing of substance.  Not even a cute little Hallmark Card, “Sorry we crushed your business, Have a nice day.”

The carrot is the amorphous hint of a settlement, with the self-serving stick of “our intention was to co-exist with Beckons in a manner that would enable Beckons to use their trademark on yoga merchandise, while we used the Beckon name for fashion apparel and accessories.”  Unless I missed something, this was the point of their efforts to crush Beckons in the first place.  They wanted 99% of the use of this tiny business’ trademark, and were willing to let them have the crumb they didn’t want in the first place?  Woo hoo.  What great guys they are. 

So all they want now is everything they ever wanted in the first place.  What a great basis for a settlement.  Ann Sather and Becky Prater should thank their lucky stars that Nordstrom is such a gentle giant.  And now that they’ve done the pro forma mea culpa, held out the promise of a settlement, let’s all forgive and forget Nordstrom’s disgraceful conduct and get back to buying chatkes at the mall. 

Perhaps I’m being too cynical, too distrusting.  Perhaps the empty, meaningless, utterly vapid rhetoric in Brooke White’s email masks a sincere desire to correct the injustice done to Beckons.  Not that I believe that for a second, but I could be wrong.  If so, here’s the “settlement” that I propose:



  1. Nordstrom drops any attempt to claim ownership of the trademark “Beckons”. 
  2. Nordstrom pays Beckons $70,000 to cover its attorneys fees. 
  3. Nordstrom licenses the name from Beckons for whatever clothing it wants to sell in its stores. 
  4. Nordstrom orders the entire output of the Beckons line of clothing for the time it held them captive to litigation. 
  5. Nordstrom publicly admits its abusive litigation practice intended to prevail by crushing small business.

Not only does this compensate Beckons for the harm done, but it puts the “Beckons” name inside Nordstrom.  After all, isn’t that all they ever really wanted in the first place?  Then I’ll believe they’re sorry.  Until then, I’m not buying.

Update:  Marc Jon Randazza (of the Gloucester Randazzas) has turned that smile upside down.  Thank God he’s back.  You were scaring me there, bro, all happy and nice and such.  Eeek.

What Precedes an Ice Cream Cone?

When blowing the raid and shooting the place up by accident become near daily occurences, what do you do? 








The choices are laugh or cry.  But every hard day at work deserves an ice cream cone, right?  Puppycide can’t be too far behind.

H/T Balko

Surveillance Nation: Cause and Effect

Yale lawprof Jack Balkin argues that we’ve become a   National Surveillance State:


In the National Surveillance State, the government uses surveillance, data collection, collation and analysis to identify problems, to head off potential threats, to govern populations, and to deliver valuable social services. The National Surveillance State is a special case of the Information State – a state that tries to identify and solve problems of governance through the collection, collation, analysis and production of information.

The War on Terror may be the most familiar justification for the rise of the National Surveillance State, but it is hardly the sole or even the most important cause. Increasing use of surveillance and data mining by public and private entities is a predictable result of accelerating developments in information technology. In fact, most surveillance in the National Surveillance State is likely to be in private hands.

I can envision everybody reading this bobbing their heads up and down in agreement.  But Volokh Conspirator/GW lawprof Orin Kerr disagrees.


In his recent Lockhart lecture, published in this journal as “The Constitution in the National Surveillance State,” Jack Balkin warns of a “new form of governance” that he calls “The National Surveillance State.” This brief response article argues that the changes Balkin details should be understood as a technology problem instead of a governance problem. We are witnessing a broad societal shift away from human observation and towards computerization. The widespread use of computers and the introduction of digital information have caused dramatic changes in how individuals can learn what others are doing. The government’s goals have not changed, but the technological playing field has. The law must respond because technology has changed, not because a new form of governance has emerged. Understanding the changes as a technology problem rather than a governance problem also suggests solutions that draw support from a wide political base rather than a narrow one.

I know.  Kerr’s response lacks the visceral tingle one gets after reading Balkin.  Same for me.  We want to have someone to blame.  We want to attribute what’s wrong to malevolent intent.  We all read 1984 and are just a little miffed that it hasn’t come to pass yet so we can have a clear cut date to start the revolution.

But if you give Orin’s rejoinder some thought, you have to admit he’s got a point.  How do you keep them down on the farm after they’ve seen Linux?  Just as technology has become an inescapable part of our lives, so to has it become the medium of government.  Whether it’s a weapon or a tool is a matter of perspective.  When it comes to delivering healthcare, is it any different than when it comes to intercepting private communications?  Not to a binary machine.  It’s all just a push of the button.

But the arguments appear to converge at the corner of cause and effect.  Balkin goes on the assert:

The question is not whether we will have a surveillance state in the years to come, but what sort of state we will have. The National Surveillance State poses three major dangers for our freedom. The first danger is that government will create a parallel track of preventative law enforcement that routes around the traditional guarantees of the Bill of Rights. The second danger is that traditional law enforcement and social services will increasingly resemble the parallel track. Once governments have access to powerful surveillance and data mining technologies, there will be enormous political pressure to use them in everyday law enforcement and for delivery of government services. Private power and public-private cooperation pose a third danger. Because the Constitution does not reach private parties, government has increasing incentives to rely on private enterprise to collect and generate information for it, thus circumventing constitutional guarantees. Corporate business models, in turn, lead companies to amass and analyze more and more information about individuals in order to target new customers and reject undesirable ones.

Orin’s reaction, presumably, is that the law must “evolve” to keep pace with technological advances that would produce the society Jack fears.  Not having access to the full 5 page response, I can’t be certain, but it would appear from Orin’s assertion that government has become no more evil than before that the governance concerns can be adequately addressed by law, presuming the government to be willing to actually comply with it.

This is where I fear Balkin has the better side of the argument.  Aside from being less sanguine than Orin about the government, as an institution, having the best of intentions, recent history suggests that someone, somewhere, will see the opportunity of technology and use it to the government’s advantage.  As Dick Cheney teaches us, the President is incapable of doing wrong.  Even when someone sits in the oval office we believe we can trust, we have no idea what runs through the minds of the more permanent occupants of cubicles in other government offices.

I can’t seem to muster enough faith in people, especially the sort of people who believe that what they do is inherently right, making the ends justify the means, to believe that they will let the law stop them from using all that fun technology around them.  And as for the private sector, for whom oversight and ultimate government appreciation and vindication for their kind assistance, is almost a foregone conclusion, I have no faith at all.  Have we already forgotten the free pass given the telecoms?

I find it surprising that someone with as libertarian a bent as Orin would repose such faith in the government.  No less a patriot than Dwight David Eisenhower warned us in 1961 of the military industrial complex :

In the councils of government, we must guard against the acquisition of unwarranted influence, whether sought or unsought, by the military industrial complex. The potential for the disastrous rise of misplaced power exists and will persist.


“We must never let the weight of this combination endanger our liberties or democratic processes. We should take nothing for granted. Only an alert and knowledgeable citizenry can compel the proper meshing of the huge industrial and military machinery of defense with our peaceful methods and goals, so that security and liberty may prosper together.”

Nothing has happened to allay the fear of unholy alliances between government and technology.  It exists, and therefore must be used.  Consider the FISA Court, for example.  Once an considered an outrageous deviation from constitutional protections, and today so utterly mainstream, even protectionist, given the government’s decision to circumvent even a star chamberish proceeding.  Constitutional entropy is deeply entrenched in the law, with a few sterling exceptions (i.e., Brown v. Board of Education, Miranda, Gideon) that are celebrated as marvelous advancements. 

Lacking the faith that Orin Kerr has in both the law as an effective shield and the government as an adherent to law when it conflicts with policy, the question of whether Jack Balkin’s future will be a result of a government leap off the edge or a technological shove.  Regardless, the government has tasted technology and can never be trusted with something so powerful and intrusive.  After all, it’s only human.