Author Archives: SHG

Confession of a Judge: “No More Than a Guess”

As hard as try to believe that judges, as finders of fact, possess magical powers to discern truth from lies, it’s just not so.  Rarely, however, is a judge honest enough to admit that the most crucial decisions made in the course of litigation, the very decisions that often result in life or death consequences for a party, are really “no more than a guess.”  In the Connecticut Law Tribune, Hartford Superior Court Judge Trial Referee Robert Satter comes clean.

From the bench, we judges see mainly the profile of the witness as he responds to the questions of counsel in front of him. And we know so little of the witness – what kind of person he really is; who his friends are; what his neighbors, his pastor, and his fellow workers think of him. In the witness chair, he appears two-dimensional. The third dimension of his character is rarely revealed.

If we are honest with ourselves, in the final analysis our determination of the credibility of witnesses is no more than a guess. If we are wrong in that guess, we are very likely dead wrong in our decision of the case. Nor do the losers have recourse on appeal. The appellate court always defers to the trial judge, who saw and heard the witnesses, and it never reverses on his assessment of credibility.

Thus when deciding a court case, the judge lives with the possibility of making a total, irredeemable mistake — even worse, of causing a grievous injustice. That is scary.

He goes on to tell an anecdote that drives the point home:Satter mug 032408


This came dramatically home to me once when I decided a court case on the basis of believing one party instead of the other. A few weeks later, I got a letter from the party I disbelieved, enclosing a news item that reported that the witness I had believed had just been convicted in federal court for drug dealing. The loser wrote across the clipping: “And you believed this creep instead of me!” I winced.

Notably, it was a civil case.  Would a wince have been enough if the loser had 25 years to think about the judge’s “irredeemable mistake?”

Lawyers steel themselves to survive in a world of ambiguity and injustice, because there’s no other way to survive.  Judges do the same, knowing in their private thoughts that their credibility decisions are sheer guesses, almost invariably going with the odds absent some smoking gun that makes a witness flagrantly incredible.  They use the language of burdens of proof, but the truth is that it’s just a gut feeling, like anyone else’s gut feeling, colored by the legalese required of the robe.

But judges don’t make credibility findings, juries do?  The vast majority of findings are by judges, in pre-trial hearings to suppress physical evidence or statements, the primary means to diffuse a case short of nuclear war.  Lose the hearings and there will be no trial.  The judge is your only hope, as you will never see a jury.  Not that juries are any better or different, despite the myriad tips for selection.  Twelve ordinary people (or thirteen on occasion) possess no greater magic than one robed person, with or without bowtie.

It’s rare to have someone who has sat on the big bench admit that his decisions, one of the most critical links in the chain of judicial reasoning, lacks any real reason at all.  Lawprofs teach law students that judges make decisions based on reason.  Lawyers tell clients that judges make decisions based on reason.  But Judge Satter admits that such credibility decisions are made for no good reason at all.  It’s hard to face a client facing a lifetime in prison and explain that it’s a wonderful system, but for its weakest link.

We could say that it reduces the system to some buttoned up form of voodoo, but it doesn’t.  The fact is that the judge will find the police officer credible, discounting the tailored testimony around the edges since everyone expect that anyway, as to the core of the crime.  Police officer, with nice going-to-court uniform and ribbons on his chest, versus scruffy, inarticulate defendant with rap sheet for pot and maybe some coke, no real job and even less education.  Officer wins, unless he screws something up royally.  They’re trained not to do that, though some are so arrogant that they still blow it.  But not too often.

The judge is the weakest link.  The defendant goes to prison for it.  And this is the best system we can come up with.

So Many Ways Not to Communicate

Like every hardcore lawyer dedicated to the service of his clients, I pay careful attention to anything Dan Hull has to say over at What About Clients?  Dan’s not just the brawn behind such late-1970s underground hits as Doing Miss Daisy and Dan Does Dallas (Yellow), but put the “hole” in holistic long before the word “clientcentric” was born.  When it comes to a human connection, no one knows better than Dan Hull.

Dan’s visit to his inbox struck home, as a lesson not only in the affirmative use of communication tools, but a tale of caution of how technology has given us so many new ways to screw up communication. 




I remember when I first got e-mail, back in the mid-1990s. I would rush home with great anticipation and dial in my 4800-baud modem and I would have…four messages from four very good friends….Now, of course, I get up in the morning and go to my computer and have sixty-four messages, and the anticipation I once felt has been replaced by dread.


–Malcolm Gladwell, The Tipping Point, in Afterword to 2002 edition, 274 (Little, Brown and Co.)


I receive between 70 and 90 non-spam e-mails a day. I write about one-third that many, most as replies. Usually short ones. They are often soulless, and easy to misunderstand, even when I try to be precise. As it’s been seven years since he wrote the above, and he is even more famous, Gladwell surely gets more than 100 each day. It’s a mantra now that communications technologies save time and money, including bucks on brick and mortar rents for business.

See Me, Feel Me, Call Me. But some of us don’t even talk as much to people we see every day at work. We do e-mail. What happened to voices, vibes, faces, bodies, winks, hand gestures, touching another’s hand or shoulder impulsively, stares, grins, frowns, hand-written thank you notes, human electricity, NOT-typing, non-virtual joking, yelling, ragging and flirting, occasional confrontation, intimacy and the “god-in-the-room” magic that starts with two breathing humans in one 3-D place? Or at least on the phone?


Let us count the ways we can personally communicate, and avoid personally communicating.  In person, by letter (overnight and snail), by fax, by email, by text message, by mass email,bulletin board/listserv, by instant message, by videoconference, by twitter, by telephone, telepathically.  If you doubt the last means, you are obviously not married.

Each of these has its own peculiar nature, with pluses and minuses.  Most of us have a favored method, subject to certain circumstances and change as the newer technologies become available and enjoy prominence.  We tend to grab hold of those that serve our personal needs best.

What we do not do is use the method that is most appropriate to our communication needs, which includes consideration of the communication needs of those with whom we are trying to communicate.  Remember, communication has two parts, the dissemination of a communication and the receipt of it.  If either one fails, there is no effective communication.

Just because a technology exists doesn’t mean it fulfills its purpose or is effective to suit every purpose.  Email is great.  For some things.  I’ve yet to truly understand that benefits of text messaging, except that high school teachers can’t hear you do it.  Twitter is cute, and has some very limited actual purposes.  But if you want to have a real, two-way communication that conveys both substantive message, tones, attitudes, subtlety, no technology has yet to replace talking to someone directly.

Telephones have become an annoyance.  They interrupt us when we’re doing something else.  They are intrusive.  They allow people to insert themselves in our day, our time, when we don’t want to talk to them or don’t really have anything to say to them.  No one can have a 30 second telephone call.  Propriety doesn’t allow it, and no one has ever been comfortable with a call limited to “What’s new?”  “Nothing.”  “Okay, bye.” “Bye.”  It feels so wrong.

Yet we frequently need the give and take of communications.  When you need to discuss, there options for immediate clear feedback preclude most technologies.  If you can’t look into the next office and ask, “so what do you think?” the telephone is your best bet. 

Most of us are awfully tricking when selecting a method of communication.  When we know that someone needs to speak with us, but it’s not in our interest to make it easy, we can select a method that makes communication as difficult as possible.  Emails are easy to ignore until your damn good and ready.  Twits can be ignored forever with impunity, there being no etiquette demanding a response.  We are so smart that we can play games to make us appear to communicate when we are cunningly avoiding it. 

But we’ve become so inured to the ease of our technological wonders that we often forget how to achieve communication when we want it and need it.  Do you really want to include that emoticon to let your email recipient know that you were being “tongue in cheek?” 

One day, some technogeek will discover the coolest, newest most innovative way to communicate.  F2F.  It will change everything.

Unstimulated

Never having experienced what can be done with nearly $800 billion, I leave it to others to explore the meaning of this package.  But I am very experienced at buying stuff.  I’ve been doing it a long time, and I’ve got a very good grasp on how it works.  Based upon this, I feel confident in this assertion:  If you want my business, do not try to make up for the crappy economy with me.

In the past few months, I’ve tried to do my part to stimulate economic growth.  Or at least take some excess off the hands of people before the CPSIA turns them into potential child killers.  What have I gotten for my efforts?  A slap in the face.  Earlier, I described the pleasure of trying to buy a Toyota Prius, which did not go swimmingly well despite the fact that Toyota suffered its first quarterly loss ever.  I still get emails from Toyota dealers almost every day, begging me to buy a car.  Guess what, Toyota dealers.  My old one will run just fine for another year, and we’ll see whether you’re still in business when next I feel like buying.  What’s that?  Your kids are hungry?  Bummer.

But it’s not just the car dealers.  It seems as if it’s everybody left in business.  Granted, I hear about all sorts of deals at the malls.  But then, I haven’t been to a mall in years, so I really can’t say.  I leave the malls to experts, like Brian Tannebaum, who are much more attuned to life at the shopping mall. 

Rather, I have gone to purchase the sorts of goods that I prefer, or the services I require, only to be told that the price has gone up, up, up, and I should consider myself fortunate that they are willing to take my money at all.  This comes as a surprise, as I know that they aren’t doing banner business.  I surmise that they are putting on a bold front to convince people like me (usually referred to in the trade as “marks”) of something that is obviously false.  But I don’t really mind the bravado.  I do, however, mind that they raise their prices to compensate for their lack of business and revenue.

When your business is in the toilet, it might not be the best time to raise your prices to make up the difference.  The chances are quite good that I will not be overcome with the need to buy your goods or services because you have psychologically drawn me in like a moth to a flame.  Instead, you have left me with the sense that you are lying scum trying to survive off of fools, and that you think I’m a fool.  Whether I am or not, I don’t want you to think so.

So a word of advice from a person who has bought stuff for many years.  Do not try to make up for your lousy business on my back.  Be fair with me and I’ll be fair with you, but toy with me and I’ll walk on you in a heartbeat.  Yes, I may want or need whatever it is you’re selling, but I can also get it elsewhere and you can bet there will be someone who wants my business and will show me a little appreciation for spending money rather than not.  And I’m a pretty patient fellow.  I’ll buy it eventually.  Probably soon after I buy a new car.  From the last surviving Toyota dealer on Long Island, if there’s any truth to karma.

And when the economy improves, and if you’ve managed to survive, I will remember who you are.

The Agony of Proving Innocence

Most criminal defense lawyers grow callouses.  Not on their hands, as happens with people who actually produce something for a living, but on their consciences.  We have to, as no one can withstand a career of watching the wrong thing happen to the wrong person, day after day, colored over by fine sounding words, and maintain any semblance of sanity.  It’s hard to maintain balance in an unbalanced world.

But Gideon at A Public Defender, every once in a while, bursts through the shell that protects us from crying ourselves to sleep each night, and he’s done so again.

In this line of work, I don’t think there’s anything more heart wrenching that sitting across from a likely innocent client and having to tell him that there’s no way to prove that innocence and then watching him hold back tears and decide between two morbid choices: accepting the plea offer and spend the next 15 years locked up or go to trial and risk 60 years.

Sometimes I feel overwhelmed

Whether we admit it or not, we’ve all felt this way.  Frustrated.  Overwhelmed.  Failed.  This is when the platitudes fail to comfort us.  We just can’t seem to hide behind the legal jargon and dearly-loved axioms that are supposed to justify what we do, even when everything goes horribly wrong. 

But the part of Gid’s post that struck me hardest is “that there’s no way to prove that innocence.”  When a defendant looks at you straight in the eyes, explains why he didn’t do that with which he’s accused, and tells you clearly why he believes he can prove his innocence, chances are awfully good that there’s no way it’s going to happen.  Most of the time, it’s a matter of his word against someone else, and the gist of his “proof” is that someone is lying.  As hardened as most people are, he asks you with utmost sincerity, “can they do that?”  Can they lie and get away with it? 

As I’ve told many a client, there’s no red light over the witness chair that goes off when a witness lies.  Many, particularly cops, can say anything they want with impunity.  Many believe that their are on the side of righteousness lying because they believe the defendant guilty and the lie to serve a greater good, the conviction of the defendant.  They have no qualms about lying whatsoever.

Even to call it a lie is somewhat confusing.  It need not be a total fabrication, but just enough color around the edges to make their point and cover the gaps.  Testilying is nothing new, yet it doesn’t quite register with people until it’s you they are testilying about.

I cannot possibly remember how many times I’ve heard judges characterize evidence as “overwhelming” when it’s nothing close.  It’s the way judges create a record designed to preclude disagreement or reversal.  “But counselor, the evidence was overwhelming.”  Just say the word and so it becomes real.  For those who have never argued an appeal, you cringe when the appellate judge throws the word back in your face, “but counselor, the trial judge said that the evidence was overwhelming.”

Over the course of many posts at Simple Justice, I’ve made clear that no criminal defense lawyer worth a damn cares whether his client is guilty or innocent when it comes to doing everything possible within the law to win the case.  This really is how we approach our cases.  We fight just as hard for the guilty as the innocent, so there’s no benefit to feigning innocence to “motivate” us, particularly since it tends to backfire by denying us critical information needed to fight the charges.

And no, we don’t always know who is truly guilty and who is truly innocent, or where along the spectrum in between a defendant might truly fit.  But we do know when things have gone horribly wrong and when we were ineffective to stop it.  We are brutally aware of the limitations of the system, and our own limitations in making magic happen when it’s needed most.  Some lawyers are full of bravado, claiming to be magicians to make sure that no one leaves their office with money in their pocket, but even those scoundrels know, in their hearts, that the lie is only for cash.  They know their limitations too,  They’re just willing to sell their soul in the process, possibly a way to assuage their sense of failure through the comfort of money.  Maybe.

But every criminal defense lawyer with any sense of honor and integrity has felt exactly as Gideon does.  He is brave to admit it and give us a glimpse of honesty underneath the callouses.

Lawyer to Geeks: YANAL

Every criminal defense lawyer has sat before a client in stunned bemusement listening to the client explain his understanding of the law.  Usually, the explanations are amazingly wrong, showing such a fundamental lack of comprehension that one wonders how they’ve managed to elude prison this long.  But sometimes, a client will present an understanding that is sophisticated, supported, well-reasoned and utterly wrong.  Still, it’s such a well-grounded argument that the lawyer has to shake his head and think about it for a few minutes to figure out why such a fine sounding argument is inherently flawed.  Some lawyers can’t figure it out until it’s too late. Uh oh.

Via Ambrogi at Legal Blog Watch, Paul Ohm at Freedom to Tinker has taken on the task of cleaning up the brilliant but wrong mess created and spread by geeks, who have decided that they have figured out how to game the system.  Paul calls them YANALs, standing for “you are not a lawyer.” 

With this post, I’m launching a new, (very) occasional series I’m calling YANAL, for “You Are Not A Lawyer.” In this series, I will try to disabuse computer scientists and other technically minded people of some commonly held misconceptions about the law (and the legal system).

I start with something from criminal law. As you probably already know, in the American criminal law system, as in most others, a jury must find a defendant guilty “beyond a reasonable doubt” to convict. “Beyond a reasonable doubt” is a famously high standard, and many guilty people are free today only because the evidence against them does not meet this standard.

The geek YANALs have apparently developed a series of theories and even technologies which they believe will insulate them from prosecution. 


When techies think about criminal law, and in particular crimes committed online, they tend to fixate on this legal standard, dreaming up ways people can use technology to inject doubt into the evidence to avoid being convicted. I can’t count how many conversations I have had with techies about things like the “open wireless access point defense,” the “trojaned computer defense,” the “NAT-ted firewall defense,” and the “dynamic IP address defense.” Many people have talked excitedly to me about tools like TrackMeNot or more exotic methods which promise, at least in part, to inject jail-springing reasonable doubt onto a hard drive or into a network.

People who place stock in these theories and tools are neglecting an important drawback. There are another set of legal standards–the legal standards governing search and seizure–you should worry about long before you ever get to “beyond a reasonable doubt”.

While I have no issue with this “advice”, it does suggest that their ideas are otherwise valid from the perspective of beating ultimate conviction.  I’m not so sure.  In fact, I have some serious doubts that life through the eyes of a computer geek will either comport with the reality of a courtroom, from evidenciary problems to “saleability” to a jury.  This is a hard thing to explain to people who are binary thinkers.  Their tolerance for ambiguity may be a bit limited.

Much as I admire Paul’s efforts to take on geekdom, his effort seems to suffer from some of the same misconceptions as his intended audience:


In addition, you will have been assigned an overworked public defender who has no time for far-fetched technological defenses and prefers you take a plea bargain, or you will have paid thousands of dollars to a private attorney who knows less than the public defender about technology, but who is “excited to learn” on your dime. Maybe, maybe, maybe after all of this, your lawyer convinces the judge or the jury. You’re free! Congratulations?

This is the depth of understanding one would expect from a client, not a lawyer, and certainly not a criminal defense lawyer.  But the blog is hosted by Princeton University’s Center for Information Technology Policy, and offers nothing to confirm that Paul Ohm is a lawyer (Ambrogi’s post says that he’s an associate professor at University of Colorado Law School, but that doesn’t exactly answer the question, now does it?), or if so, what type of law he practiced or how long he’s practiced.  Or if he’s practiced law at all.  Based upon the quote above, my guess is that he’s either never really practiced law, or he’s was a prosecutor.  What he is not is a lawyer who knows what he’s talking about when it comes to criminal defense lawyers.

My experience is that YANALs view the law as a series of hypertechnicalities, anyone of which will trip up the cops and prosecution.  They harbor a bizarre belief that the nice words appearing regularly in court decisions actually mean something, rather than present black letter law which is then torn to shreds by the thousand exception and the functional refusal to apply it in the trenches.  How does one explain to a binary thinker that a judge waves his arm and the law mysteriously disappears?  “They can’t do that!”  Oh yes.  They can.  They do.  Every single day.  Welcome to the real world.

We all have this problem with YANALs, many of whom post comments here that reflect pure unadulterated silliness based upon their lack of understanding of the law coupled with their belief that they have a better idea.  They often bring much to the discussion, challenging our preconceptions with their misconceptions, and every once in a while come up with a truly great idea.  It doesn’t happen often, but it does happen.  So we take the good, ignore the bad, and go on with our lives.  Sometimes we correct the YANALs and other time we let them rant.  Everyone needs a catharsis now and then.

While Paul Ohm’s effort to disabuse the YANALs is admirable, I hope that he’s got the background to make the right points from the right perspective.  I have serious doubts that he does, based upon this inaugural post.  It’s one thing to spread misinformation amongst a bunch of geek YANALs.  It’s another to correct them with information that’s only marginally better, but still far off the mark.

Wayne Tompkins Time Ran Out

Yesterday at 6:32 p.m., the State of Florida put Wayne Tompkins to death.  Unfortunately, this event in itself is not unusual, even despite the fact that Tompkins protested his innocence of the rape/murder of his girlfriend’s 15 year old daughter some 25 years earlier. 

What is notable about this execution is an email I received yesterday afternoon from the Innocence Project of Florida, sent a laundry list of blawgers seeking our aid in raising awareness of the possibility that Tompkins was an innocent man.


My name is Ryan Jenkins. I’m the Outreach Coordinator for the Innocence Project of Florida, an organization that works to find and free innocent people in Florida prisons. I’m writing because our organization is very troubled by the impending execution of Wayne Tompkins in Florida, scheduled for tonight at 6 PM, and we are looking for your help to spread awareness of the issue. We believe there are very serious doubts about whether Tompkins is guilty of murder – because the body in the case might not be that of the alleged victim, meaning no murder even took place. Several individuals have signed affidavits saying they have seen the victim alive since the alleged murder, but the Governor has failed to stay the execution.

Yesterday, we sent a letter to Governor Charlie Crist. Today, we filed a motion to preserve the evidence in the case, signaling our intent to go ahead with DNA testing, even if Tompkins is executed. One day soon, the truth will come out, and perhaps Governor Crist will become the first in US history to execute a man who was proven to be innocent.

What follows is our summary of facts and a call to action. Then we have Governor Crist’s email and his phone number. Attached are our press releases from yesterday and this morning. Please pass this along to your readers, as we are trying to generate support and an outcry from concerned citizens everywhere. We have less than 6 hours in which to act.


It’s the last line that got to me.  “We have less than 6 hours in which to act.”  The substantive argument is that the body found was not that of 15 year old Lisa DeCarr, that a jail house snitch was a set up and a pivotal witness had changed her story, making it impossible for Tompkins to have strangled the child.  The email doesn’t provide enough to assess the merits of the arguments, but suggests that actual innocence, for lack of a better description, may be provable.  I’ve included the body of the email at the bottom for anyone who wants to learn more about the substance of the argument.

But it doesn’t matter now.  Wayne Tompkins is dead.  As far as I can tell, only one blawg, Co-Op, posted about the email yesterday,  If there are others, let me know, but I’ve been unable to find any.  Don’t blame the blawgs or blawgers, as we aren’t sitting at the computers awaiting emergency calls to arms at all times.  We have work and lives too.  And frankly, it wouldn’t have mattered, coming mere hours before the execution was set to proceed.

Executions don’t happen overnight.  They take forever before the needle finally goes into the arm.  While each life taken by the state matters, most are a blip in the grand scheme of things.  They shouldn’t be, but they are.  There are simply too many wrongs on any given day to focus on every human being executed.  But those who do focus on it are well aware ahead of time that the date is coming.

The power of the blawgosphere is spotty.  Sometimes, we seem to be able to have an impact.  We can raise consciousness about a particular case or defendant, and it seems (though it’s never exactly clear) that we can provide some help in influencing those who have the power to make the critical decision over life and death.  Whether this is real or our imagination is hard to say.  Who knows that makes a court decide something, or a Governor stay an execution.  They don’t announce that they were swayed by public outcry, and certainly not the blawgosphere.  People would think they are nuts if they did.

But to the extent that we can offer some help, don’t do it this way.  Most of us really want to serve a greater cause, and one such cause is to save an innocent person from execution.  But this isn’t a six hour parlor trick.  If it’s going to work at all, give us a chance to do something.  Why did you not spread the word a week ago?  A day ago?  But 6 hours isn’t enough.

I have no clue whether Wayne Tompkins is an innocent man.  I pray he wasn’t because now he’s dead.  I have enormous respect for the Innocence Project of Florida, and that they asserted his potential innocence is good enough for me to give them the benefit of the doubt.  But like any good skeptic, I want to do a little checking before hitching my wagon to a cause.  There was no time to do so here.  I have no plans to do so after the fact as an academic exercise.  There are too many living people who are better served by our attention.

If you want to help stop an innocent man from being executed, you’re going to have to give us more than six hours.  Now, we’re left with a sense of having failed, but we might have been able to help.  We just didn’t have enough time.

More information from the email on Wayne Tompkins’ innocence:


On March 24th 1983, Barbara DeCarr, Lisa DeCarr’s mother, filed a missing persons report alleging her daughter ran away from home for no apparent reason.  She claimed Lisa was having some trouble at school but nothing that would have lead her to runaway and she did not take any of her belongings with her.




Over the next year, Barbara DeCarr maintained her story and reported to the police various sightings of Lisa she had been contacted about.  On June 6th 1984 a volunteer organization conducted a search of Barbara’s old house and underneath the front porch found a shallow grave containing human bones.  Police identified the bones as belonging to Lisa DeCarr based on information from her Mother and a partial dental records match on a single tooth.




Following the discovery of Lisa’s body, Barbara DeCarr told police that her former boyfriend Wayne Tompkins was the last person to see Lisa alive.  Based on this information Mr. Tompkins was indicted.  In March of 1985 the prosecutor contacted Kathy Stevens, Lisa’s friend.  Her initial story had been that Lisa had run away to New York and kept in touch with her however, after speaking with prosecutors she changed her story claiming she had witnessed Mr. Tompkins strangle Lisa on the Morning of March 24th 1983 around 8:30 am.  Prior to trial, Kenneth Turco, Tompkins’ cell mate, came forward alleging that Wayne Tompkins had confessed to the murder of Lisa DeCarr.  Turco had previously served as a confidential informant and his confession was so aligned with Kathy Steven’s story that the defense argued he must have had access to her statements.  At this point Barbara DeCarr changed her initial story that Tompkins took her son to school the day of Lisa’s disappearance and returned after 9:00 am to she left at 8:30 am and that Tompkins was still at the house, making Kathy’s story possible.




In the course of collateral proceedings exculpatory evidence has come forward which demonstrates Kathy Steven’s story may have been largely untrue.  In post-conviction proceedings Tompkins learned that Kathy had changed her story only after getting access to her incarcerated boyfriend and there were a number of witness’ statements in the school records which claimed that Lisa ran away when she became pregnant and had been seen in April and May of 1983. In 1989 Tompkins presented the testimony of Gladys Staley who testified she spoke with Lisa in the early afternoon of March 24th of 1983.  Gladys had informed the police of this interaction however the prosecution did not list her as a witness and the defense was not informed of her statements.  In 2002 Lisa’s boyfriend James “Junior” Davis contradicted Kathy Stevens account in a sworn affidavit that he had not seen Kathy the morning of the disappearance as she claimed.  On October 30th 2008 the state disclosed a sworn statement from Kenneth Turco, the jail house informant, which stated the prosecution told him to include the fact that Lisa was buried with a purse in his story, a major element of the prosecution’s theory, and then following his testimony Mr. Turco’s charges which he had already pled guilty to were dismissed. Mr. Tomkins maintains his innocence to this day.




Govenor Charlie Crist stayed the execution of Wayne Tompkins on October 6, 2008, to allow time for DNA testing. Such testing could show that the body that was found under the porch was not that of the victim, Lisa DeCarr, at all, meaning Tompkins was convicted of a murder that never took place. Now, he is only half a day away from being executed. The troubling aspects of this case are myriad. Involved are bad eyewitness testimony, changing stories after interrogations, a questionable jailhouse snitch, bad forensic science, DNA testing’s unprecendented probative value being ignored, and the possibility of actual innocence coupled with an impending execution. It’s hard to imagine a more convoluted and unreliable process of justice playing out in our system. Please take this opportunity to call or email Governor Crist. Florida could become the first state to execute an innocent man. Concerned citizens everywhere should act now.

The Love of Compromise

A curious press release came across the email yesterday from the Brennan Center For Justice at NYU Law School.

 










http://www.brennancenter.org/page/m2/64f58d73/2889677c/33850c31/6d448874/1139258429/VEsH/





http://www.brennancenter.org/page/m2/64f58d73/2889677c/33850c31/6d44887b/1139258429/VEsE/ Dear Friends,


It is now clear that our nation violated the rule of law and the Constitution in the fight against terrorism. Torture, warrantless wiretapping, extraordinary rendition are the most vividly visible examples. Yet the public still does not fully know what went wrong as well as what went right.


Some urge prosecutions; others urge doing nothing. There is another approach, proposed by the Brennan Center for Justice in testimony before the Senate and House Judiciary Committees last summer. Our chief counsel, Fritz Schwarz, proposed an independent bipartisan commission — modeled after the 9/11 commission — to explore and expose violations of the rule of law in counter-terrorism policy. The full proposal is here. 


This approach now has been embraced by the chairmen of the House and Senate Judiciary Committees. Rep. John Conyers has introduced legislation to launch such a probe. Yesterday, in a powerful speech at Georgetown University, Sen. Patrick Leahy rejected the path of prosecutions or of doing nothing. He said:



There is another option that we might also consider, a middle ground. A middle ground to find the truth. We need to get to the bottom of what happened — and why — so we make sure it never happens again….One path to that goal would be a reconciliation process and truth commission. We could develop and authorize a person or group of people universally recognized as fair minded, and without axes to grind. Their straightforward mission would be to find the truth. People would be invited to come forward and share their knowledge and experiences, not for purposes of constructing criminal indictments, but to assemble the facts.


Last night, at his press conference, a reporter asked President Obama about Leahy’s proposal. The President said, “I will take a look at Senator Leahy’s proposal, but my general orientation is to say let’s get it right moving forward.” Understanding what we got right — and what went wrong — with counter-terrorism efforts is an essential part of our moving forward with policies that protect the country while upholding the Constitution. 


Thank you.






Why, I asked myself as I read this, is the Brennan Center arguing for “another approach?”  The email starts out with the unequivocal statement that “it is now clear that our nation violated the rule of law and the Constitution in the fight against terrorism.”  So the answer is to put on a show?  To what end? 

While some might argue that it isn’t clear, I don’t see it that way.  But I similarly can’t understand this institutional compulsion to select a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, as Sen. Patrick Leahy seeks, as a compromise.  For those of use who are likely far too idealistic, we might hope that our President of Hope, Barack Obama, might do the right thing simply because it is the right thing.  But there’s no evidence of that happening.  Rather than have the issues of torture and wiretapping (forget rendition, since Obama has no plans to stop it during his tenure anyway) during the Bush administration fall off the face of the earth, they would prefer to put on a show.  “At least it’s something,” is the argument.

Watering down governmental misconduct is not the solution.  The use of language that appeals to focus groups, “compromise”, getting to the bottom of it,” “understanding”, makes it all seem so palatable, even desirable.  But if the United States engaged in torture, as the Brennan Center email says, should it be the subject of compromise? 

Once we accept compromise on these travesties, all is lost.  Is it better that nothing be done?  Yes.  This has not gone unnoticed, and reflects the institutional problem of the imperial presidency, where the anything a President does, by definition, must be lawful no matter how unlawful it is.  Anyone unaware of this now is hardly going to pay much heed to the report of a Commission years from now.  Who are we kidding?

But we can at least hold our heads high in the knowledge that we have not acquiesced in the compromise of torture.  If the foes of governmental torture do not believe that it is sufficiently worthy of holding firm, that it is not subject to some “middle ground,” then the line between right and wrong disappears.  There is no compromise on torture, warrantless wiretaps and even (sorry Obama) rendition.  We need no commission to tell us this, and we need not compromise everything in the name of expediency.  Some things are not to be compromised, even if it means that the government can’t put on a show.

Quien Es Muy Macho, Nordstrom or the Blawgosphere?

First, Randazza posted about it.  Then Ken posted about it.  Now I’m posting about it.  It’s a test.  Can the blawgosphere, a bunch of lawyers with computer access, do enough to right a wrong?  Let’s find out.

The wrong is that big, mean, nasty Nordstrom has chosen to crush a small, two-person business because they held the rights to a name that big, mean, nasty Nordstrom wanted to use.  As explained in this InformationWeek article, the US Patent and Trademark Office screwed up (shocking!) and opened the door to the giant corporation “steamrolling” a tiny business run by Ann Sather and Becky Prater, who had trademarked the clothing name “Beckons”.


Nordstrom, the retailer with the glorious public image, is using a screwup by the federal government’s Patent and Trademark Office to overwhelm a tiny online retailer via courtroom challenges that to date have cost the two women who own the small business $70,000. Reflecting the riskiness of IP issues, they tell the PTO, “Your office has ensured our demise.”


After Ann and Becky filed, but before their application was published, the Nordstrom retail chain filed applications for a trademark on the word “Beckon,” planning to use it as a house brand on women’s fashion apparel and accessories. The similarity between the two words and the identity of the product lines would have required the PTO to reject Nordstrom’s application, but it didn’t. Somehow, the examining attorney missed the fact that “Beckons” already was a registered trademark associated with clothing. He approved Nordstrom’s applications for publication.

So instead of continuing to build their business, Ann and Becky found themselves hiring lawyers to file an opposition to Nordstrom’s trademark applications, something they had to do to protect their mark. Because they were first to file and first to use, the law unambiguously gives them the right to their trademarked term “Beckons” and anything similar. But trademark law and trademark practice are two different things.

The strategy was simple: attrition.  Just keep lawyering these two women to death and eventually they will be crushed.   InformationWeek writes about this as a cautionary tale of the trademark process, which it most assuredly is.  But my take is that it’s a reflection of lawyers run amok, where we put aside all professionalism and honor to do harm for the party with the most cash on hand.  Wonder why people think the law and its practitioners are scum?

While Ann and Becky may lack the funds to afford to fight Nordstroms to the death, and will ultimately lose despite the fact that they did everything right, they had no hand in the government’s screw-up (shocking!), it seems that those of us who write daily about the injustices that our system perpetrates can pitch in the make sure that Nordstroms does not get away with this unscathed.  I don’t know whether there’s a chance to help the victims, but I bet we can smear Nordstroms pretty well if we all make a stink out of this.

If nothing else, let’s turn this mutt from a cautionary tale about the trademark system into a cautionary tale about big business using its resources to crush anyone who stands in its way.  Nordstroms disgraceful conduct should not go unnoticed, and perhaps the next big corporation out to crush it tiny opposition will think twice about the public relations fiasco that might follow.

It couldn’t hurt.  It might help.  Write about it.  Let see if the blawgosphere has enough clout to make a difference.

There is a Time to Stop Trying to Win

There’s an old lawyer joke:


Many years ago, a junior partner in a firm was sent to a far-away state to represent a long-term client accused of robbery. After days of trial, the case was won, the client acquitted and released. Excited about his success, the attorney telegraphed the firm: “Justice prevailed.” The senior partner replied in haste: “Appeal immediately.”

It’s what we lawyers do, appeal.  But this decision, like every other decision we make, should be subject to some small degree of thought and discretion.  That message comes from Judge Stephan Reinhardt of 9th Circuit Court of Appeals in United States v. Beltran-Moreno, courtesy of Eugene Volokh.


After pleading guilty to a multiple-count indictment charging, inter alia, two independent firearms counts under 18 U.S.C. § 924(c), Jose and Abraham Beltran-Moreno benefited from the district court’s erroneous construction of that statute at sentencing. They should have quit while they were ahead.

Appellate counsel argued that the sentence was excessive.  As a matter of law, the defendants sentence was below the mandatory minimum due to the requirement of consecutive sentences, and a lifetime below the guidelines.  But they appealed anyway.  As it turned out, no harm came of it because the government chose not to appeal the error and post-sentence caselaw precluded the court from increasing the sentence absent a government appeal.  That was just lucky.

Ken at Popehat also posts about this decision, and provides a great story of his own to go along with it.


Counsel, do you know what Satchel Paige said?

The title of this post is a line that Manny Real, a United States District Court judge in Los Angeles of some hard-earned infamy, likes to bark at lawyers before him. He’d utter it when a lawyer insisted on arguing a point when he or she had already won the issue. Judge Real was referring, of course, to Satchel Paige’s sage advice, “Don’t look back. Someone may be gaining on you.” This coy reference is intended to tell the lawyer to sit down and shut up and leave well enough alone. Few lawyers catch the reference; most stand there, terrified and gaping, until some merciful soul hisses to them that they’ve won and to shut up. Judge Real derives visible enjoyment from this process.


While it may be somewhat more difficult to realize when you’ve hit the point in argument where you’ve persuaded the judge to see things your way, most lawyers find if impossible to stop talking when there’s still air left in their lungs.  The other side argues something, and they feel compelled to stand and confront it.  Sometimes, the argument raised is foolish and unworthy of the court’s time, but it’s not always clear that the judge feels the same as he does, and so he goes on.

The problem in oral argument is that once you’ve won a point, more sound emitting from your mouth presents an increasingly strong potential to seize defeat from the jaws of victory.  Yet lawyers just can’t let go.  Even here, when someone raises a silly and obviously pointless argument in a comment, someone usually feels compelled to explain why the argument is ridiculous.  I usually ignore it, as further argument gives it more credence than it had standing alone.  Other people just can’t do it.  They just can’t leave well enough alone.

But on appeal, as opposed to Ken’s Manny Real story, there is no excuse.  The appellate counsel had all the time in the world to figure out, if it wasn’t obvious from the outset, that his argument was not merely a loser, but a killer.  For his own client.  Thus, pursuing it suggests two possibilities.  One, the lawyer was glaringly incompetent.  Two, the lawyer’s compulsion to pursue an appeal was an autonomic reaction, blinded from sound judgment.  Either way, it was just plain foolish.

Ken points out that many clients will chose to pursue an appeal even when it could result in a crashing blow, as this case had the potential to do.  He suggests that this might not be the fault of counsel, but the choice of the client.  While he may be right about the client’s misbegotten choice, it’s critical to remember that the lawyer, not the client, is solely responsible for the tactics employed in his representation, the choice of arguments and the pursuit of any particular avenue of redress.  The client may well have demanded the lawyer pursue this appeal, but the lawyer is solely at fault for having handed his responsibility over to the client.  If the client refuses to accept the lawyer’s performance of his duty, then the lawyer’s responsibility is to move to be relieved.  The lawyer does not get a free pass for being a bonehead at the client’s insistence.  We are not merely a client’s mouthpiece, and we are not saved from our failings because “the client said so.”

Judge Reinhardt’s decision is a lesson to remind all of us to get a grip on that lawyer bone that makes us engage in the knee-jerk reactions to do what lawyers do.  Sometimes, we are ahead of the game and need to say to ourselves and our clients, this is where it stops.  Yes, we could appeal, but to do so is to invite further damage.  Yes, we could argue more and address every silly point raised by our adversary, but to do so is to seize defeat from the jaws of victory. 

We need to know when to stop trying to win.  After all, now you know what Satchel Paige said.  And Judge Reinhardt too.

Cutting Down the School House Gates

The Avery Doninger case, Connecticut’s contribution to the death of speech for students, has taken yet another turn for the worst according to the New Haven Register.



[Doninger lawyer Jon] Schoenhorn noted Doninger wrote the characterization on her personal blog at home. But in his ruling, issued Jan. 15, Kravitz said in the new age of the Internet, “Off-campus speech can become on-campus speech with the click of a mouse.”



Kravitz also wrote, “Today, students are connected to each other through e-mail, instant messaging, blogs, social networking sites and text messages. An e-mail can be sent to dozens or hundreds of other students by hitting ‘send.’”


Whenever a judge refers to the “new age of the internet,” you can be assured that something bad is about to come.  It’s not the judges don’t like the internet, or don’t use the internet, but they don’t understand the internet and they most assuredly have no respect for it.  Very few judges are of the age that they surf.  Instead, their children surf, or maybe even their grandchildren.  Anything your children or grandchildren do is a game.  It’s not serious.  Whatever pastimes judges enjoy is worthy.  Kids play games.  Argue that golf is a waste of time and a game for idiots, and see how many friends you make in the federal judiciary.

In ruling Judge Mark Kravitz quietly turned the law on its head, all because of the internet.  “Off-campus speech can become on-campus speech with the click of a mouse.”  Not exactly, but close enough to reality to let pass.  The fact that speech, published on the internet, is theoretically accessible anywhere anytime does not make it on-campus anymore than a book published 300 years ago on another continent that sits on the library shelf is transformed into on-campus speech. 

The problem is the paradigm, where accessibility to information is no longer controlled exclusively by the grown-ups, and they just can’t stand it.  Having children, I completely understand, but the solution isn’t to demand that the paradigm shift back to something that fits our past way of thinking, but to adopt to changing realities.  If I can’t control the internet (and I can’t), then I teach my children to exercise good judgment and act accordingly.  I don’t punish them because the world is changing.

The old paradigm as created in Tinker v. Des Moines Indep. Sch. Dist., 393 U.S. 503 (1969), holding that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gates.”  This oft-quoted line, of course, hides the true holding, which is that speech changes from free to severely limited as a student passes through those very gates.

The “school gates” language is more than a mere quaint image, a throwback to the days when teachers rapped knuckles with a yardstick.  It provided a physical line for all to see, where the free speech rights of young people turned into the restricted speech rights of students.  According to Judge Kravitz, the internet obliterated this physical line, and in a peculiar way, he’s right.  Communication in the internet again transcends physical boundaries.

Where Judge Kravitz goes wrong is his mistaken effort to extend the restrictions within the gates to the world without, not because free speech for the young is any less precious a right, or because the 1st Amendment to the Constitution contains a hidden, super-secret clause readable only by judges and teachers that eviscerates speech that they don’t like.  Rather, when the schoolhouse gates no longer mark the real world from the school world, then the importance of allowing school officials to control the speech of the young trumps the limitations that once constrained their limited sphere of control.  In short, those gates gave kids a world to speak their mind, and allowed the schools their own turf to control.  Judge Kravitz gave school officials the rest of the universe when he tore the gates down.

As a matter of general principle, one might suppose that freedom of speech would be the ideal that a federal judge would feel most worthy of protection, it being all constitutional and such, rather than the overarching need for school officials to assert control.  Yet Judge Kravitz has chosen to elevate school administration control over the Constitution, a curious choice. 

But is it a choice that was necessary?  Clearly, Judge Kravitz felt that the “schoolhouse gates” analogy fails in the internet age and reflects an archaic barrier to school administration control.  It’s hardly that clear.  Information, communication and speech, as carried on paper, by mouth and in the hearts and minds of students, never respected this firm line.  The difference now isn’t the barrier, but that school administrators were able to learn of out-of-school speech due to their own internet access that historically would have been beyond their purview.  What the internet did was allow administrators to read the communications between students that would previously have been whispered only when they were out of earshot.

Thus, the real distinction is not that the internet has obliterated the “schoolhouse gates” boundary from the student side, but allowed school officials to eavesdrop on their students outside communications, to learn things that had always happened but were previously never available to them.  That these communications have hurt the feelings of the most fragile groups of pseudo-adults around, and thus compelled these officials to do whatever they could to control student thought wherever it happened, hardly seems like much of a reason to end free speech for the young.  Frankly, it seems like a great opportunity to tell school administrators to get a grip and grow up.  Do they think that students will love and respect them because they can smack a student who thinks otherwise?

Neither school administrators, nor a federal judge, is going to stop young people from thinking, and expressing their thoughts to others.  While it makes some sense to allow school officials to keep this out of the hallways, if for no reason than they are expected to maintain a degree of decorum for the protection of those students for whom it would interfere with learning, they cannot control the universe no matter how dearly they might try.  Nor should they. 

If it pains school officials to learn what Avery Doninger thinks of them, don’t look for it and don’t read it.  But the wholesale evisceration of free speech in the name of school administrative control turns respective rights on their heads, and the problem isn’t technology but school administrator sensibility.  If they don’t like what students have to say, either behave better or stop reading.  Don’t blame the transmittal mechanics because someone thinks you’re a douchebag.

And Judge Kravitz really needs to figure out which side of the Constitution demands the protection of a federal judge, no matter how deferential he feels toward school officials.  If he doesn’t care for the schoolhouse gates analogy anymore, let him come up with a better one.  But don’t give school officials the universe.