Author Archives: SHG

Symbiotic Monetization & Parasitic Blawgospheric Sequalae

From Legal Blog Watch, Bob Ambrogi posts about the Brill Plan to save newspapers, which definitely need some saving.  Brill refers to Steve Brill, “the lawyer, journalist and entrepreneur who, in 1987, founded The American Lawyer magazine” and that favorite of the chronically unemployed, Court TV, where people can pretend to be Biglaw associates without ever leaving the La-Z-Boy.

Almost simultaneously, Daniel Lyons has an article in Newsweek that blogging is no way to get rich.  While his point is somewhat obscured by the fact that he then runs down a handful of blogs with millions of readers and an equivalent number of greenbacks coming in, the fact remains that he failed to earn a living in his pajamas and that a bunch of others who thought they could make some serious dinero off the blogosphere have found out otherwise.

Brill’s idea is to take blawgers, to whom he has attributed the well-intended and, frankly, unduly cutesy name of “parasites”, and turn them (us?) into the energetic sales force for the digitally altered, former dead-tree journalistic motherlode.

The core of the plan will surprise no one: Charge for content. Brill proposes readers pay 10 cents per article or purchase subscriptions by the day, month or year, capping at $55 for the full-year price. The more unique aspect of his plan is a strategy for, as he puts it, “turning today’s parasites into tomorrow’s sales force.” He would encourage Web sites and blogs to link to NYT articles by paying them a referral fee. If a reader clicks through from a blog to the NYT and then buys something, the blog gets 5 percent.

Now I like the New York Times as much as the next New York blawger, and I’m happy to link to one of its stories from time to time, not because I have an underlying agenda to promote the Times’ existence but because it’s of interest.  And as it happens, I subscribe to the Times, though I would think they should send it to me for free given all I’ve done to promote it.  But I’m not exactly sure I’m ready to get into bed with it.  And I sincerely wonder whether the Times is ready to get into bed with me.

But on the other hand, if the New York Times is going to kick me back 5% (or a half cent per click through), and I can get a few million of you readers to click through here, maybe there is a way to make some dirty lucre off this blawg.  Lyons’ whining notwithstanding, a few have done it.


Now others seem to be riding the same downward curve, with euphoria giving way to exhaustion. Michael Arrington, whose TechCrunch blog empire attracts 6 million readers each month, has gone on a monthlong hiatus after three years of nonstop blogging. His break was prompted, he says, by burnout and by the craziness of the blogosphere (he says he’s been stalked, threatened and spat on) and not by the fact that he’s been trying to sell his company for a year and hasn’t been able to find a buyer who’ll pay his price, which is rumored to be $100 million. Gawker Media, a leading network of blogs, recently laid off all but one of its writers for Valleywag, its tech blog, which has struggled for three years. In January Pajamas Media, a collective of right-wing political bloggers, shut down its ad network, which CEO Roger Simon says “was a money loser for three years.”

You’ve got to love a guy who makes fun of a blogger because he can’t get his $100 million asking price.  I could make due with less.  Go ahead, make me an offer.

A friend of mine who runs his bush league law firm but pretends he’s a Biglaw-type partner sniffled at me a while back about how I ought to be able to monetize Simple Justice, spend all day in my pajamas and rake in the dough.  He’s fat and ugly, and I tell him that every chance I get.  He doesn’t care.  But the truth is that I’ve never found a way to make any money blawging.  I’m not talking about a few grand in ad revenue, or (God forbid) google adsense.  I’m talking real money.  As reader Shawn McManus once commented, “I like reading your blawg, but I wouldn’t pay for it.”  I’ve never met Shawn, but I bet he’s fat and ugly too.  It makes me feel better to think so.

Steve Brill is a visionary, if your vision tends toward apocalypse now.  While he’s not exactly wrong that blawgers (like me) are parasites, using the legwork of newspapers to provide the fodder for post, he failed to appreciate the symbiotic relationship between parasites and hosts.  Truth be told, I don’t regularly read the Rocky Mountain News, though I link to it when there’s some Rocky Mountain-type story that I wan to write about.  Some readers will then click through to it and read the article.  Like me, they would not be willing to subscribe to it.

But what if a reader had to pay a dime, one thin dime, to go back to the source material I relied upon?  Before you answer, consider that the same reader may check out a dozen or more blawgs, and posts may include a few links apiece.  Round it away and a reader could eat up $3 to $5 a day cruising the blawgosphere.  Today it’s a free diversion, and may actually be of interest from time to time.  Tomorrow?  It’s a Starbucks mocha-frappa-latte-cino.  Vente with low-fat.  Who’s ready to give that up?

I can’t disagree with Brill that the paradigm presents a problem.  We all need someone to gather the news.  Blawgers can’t do the legwork, since we need to work for a living.  We rely on reporters.  All of us rely on reporters, criticism of their work notwithstanding.  We’re still far better off with them than without them.  And there has to be a business model that will keep reporters employed.  But this plan sounds like it will not only fail to do the trick, but bring the blawgosphere down with it.

As for the carrot Brill offers the blawgosphere, the half penny per click through if only we can make the New York Times articles seem sexy enough, smart enough, ridiculous enough, but interesting enough that you, dear reader, are prepared to spend a dime to click through, my suspicion is that it will bring me slightly less cashflow than Lyons got through his judicious use of google adsense, assuming it works at all.

Look, when your favorite blawgers tell you that they are doing this for free, believe them.  There is no great glory to blawging, despite rumors to the contrary.  It has some pluses, but the cost benefit ratio for serious blawging swings heavily into the red.  If your dream is to buy silk pajamas and tap away at the keyboard while checks arrive daily in the mail, then consider Hugh Hefner as a better role model than me. 

For the time being, I can post at will and link to whatever article strikes me as worthy of discussion.  Make me part of your marketing team and that equation changes forever.  I don’t think I would pay a dime to read half the stuff I do now, and I doubt that you would either.  It’s not that we’re intellectual Philistines, or that we don’t appreciate the efforts of journalists to bring us the day’s events.  It’s that we’re all sick and tired of being half-pennied and dimed to death.

The End of the Rockefeller Laws? Don’t Count Chickens

Leave it to the few of our good buddies who have yet to be laid off at the New York Times to announce the death of the Rockefeller drug laws.  Except that it has yet to happen.  Ah, the devil is always in the details.

The New York Legislature finally seems poised to overturn the infamous Rockefeller drug laws. The impending change comes too late for the tens of thousands of low-level, nonviolent drug offenders who wasted away in prison because of mandatory sentencing policies when they should have been given treatment and leniency. But after years of building support for reform, legislative leaders now have it within their power to make wholesale changes in this profoundly destructive law.

“Seems poised” isn’t exactly something make book on.  “Seems poised” is the sort of description one uses when one wants desperately to believe something is true, but can’t quite get the voice out of one’s head that keeps muttering, “yeah, right, when pigs fly.”  I guess they left that line out of the editorial.

The problem is that New York State had one of its beloved commissions review the Rocky Laws.  The outcome wasn’t nearly as great as Shelly Silver hoped it would be:


The law has been especially disastrous for black and Latino offenders, who represent the overwhelming majority of those held in state prison for drug offenses. The Assembly speaker, Sheldon Silver, made just that point last week when he criticized a state commission that had been appointed to study the reform issue. The commission, which appears to have been dominated by prosecutors, called for more rational sentencing guidelines and allowing judges to send more offenders to treatment instead of prison. But it failed to get to the heart of the matter, which is a full restoration of judicial discretion.

Why does it surprise anyone that the Commission on Sentencing Reform “appears to have been dominated by prosecutors?”  Every commission in New York that has ever dealt with a criminal law issue is dominated by prosecutors.  Is this news?  Is no one paying attention.  Even when you put your Biglaw pretend criminal defense lawyer who was an AUSA last week on a commission, he’s still a prosecutor.  You love your blue ribbon commissions, and that’s who you select.  If you don’t like it, Shelly, put some real criminal defense lawyers on it instead of campaign contributors.

Before anybody gets too excited, the fact that New York State’s assembly and senate are controlled by the Democrats does not mean a thing.  They are scared to death to appear soft on crime, and there’s barely a spine to be found in the bunch when all put together. Dems or Reps, they want only to be re-elected and won’t for a minute consider taking a chance of risking their seat to help “criminals”.   Anyone who thinks otherwise is foolish and naive.

The only question now is whether they can sell this as a cost-saving method to the taxpayers of New York, making this into a positive for fiscal prudence rather than a negative for being a criminal-lover.  If so, there’s a chance.  But they still have the commission to deal with, which their opposition will shove in their faces to prove that the liberals will bring New York back to the days of a gunfight between drug dealers on every corner.

No, the Rockefeller Laws are not yet dead.  Not by a long shot.  They could be soon, if our politicians have the guts to do the job they’ve been sent to Albany to do, but what are the chances that will happen?

Curmudgeon’s Guide to Practicing Law: Does it Stand the Test of Time?

When Mark Herrmann’s attempt to play dutch uncle to every snot-nosed Biglaw wannabe first came out in 2006, the Jones Day partner and co-author of the Drug and Device Law blawg made sure that everybody who’s anybody got a copy to review.  I dutifully checked the mailbox every day, brushing the cobwebs out of the way, only to find a void.

Others, from Lattman (you remember him, don’t you? Dan Slater’s warm-up act?) at the WSJ Law Blog to Turk at the New York Personal Injury Law Blog, loved the book.  Now I can understand that Lattman got a copy, but Turkewitz too?  Even Anne at Court-o-Rama got one, and she doesn’t even practice.

I was pissed.  It’s not just that Herrmann blew me off, like I was some gob of goo on the sole of his Jones Day Biglaw partner Gucci loafers, but that he laid claim to being a curmudgeon.  A curmudgeon!  He wasn’t in the club.  Oh no, there was David Giacalone.  There was me.  There was no Mark “I’m such a big shot that I can’t be bothered sending Greenfield a book” Herrmann. For crying out loud, the guy’s from Cleveland!

But Herrmann has seen the light.  He’s a new man.  A visionary.  He finally sent me a copy.  I guess my original one got lost in the mail, right Herrmann?

The truth is, he wanted to join the Curmudgeon’s Club. Who doesn’t?  And his first step to membership was showing due respect to the real curmudgeons, that whippersnapper.
sdsadfasd
But this allowed me the opportunity to see if the Curmudgeon’s Guide to Practicing Law was a classic, or just another flash in the pan.  The problem, of course, is that the book has a great title, especially given that it’s published by the ABA, renown for its utter lack of humor and imagination.  Everybody loves a curmudgeon (especially cute young chicks), and Herrmann obviously tried to play the curmudgeon popularity card which, coupled with his boyish good looks, ensured him a few months of being the toast of every cocktail party in Cleveland.  Both of them, anyway.

But that’s not good enough for a classic.  A classic has to withstand the test of time, transcend the moment and carry its message to succeeding generations of lawyers with as much force and effect as it did on the day it was written.  Did Herrmann’s effort have the juice?

The Curmudgeon’s Guide is the sort of book that can be taken two ways.  On the surface, it’s just a darn good guide to some very basic rules for being a good lawyer.  Mark covers the essentials clearly and succinctly.  While some might think this is some Biglaw roadmap only, it’s how every lawyer should do the job.  These are the fundamentals of good lawyering that law school should, but never will, teach.  That’s why we have guys like Herrmann to fill the gap.

But on another level, the subtle humor and good nature of its presentation was brilliant.  For those associates who still watch Spongebob Squarepants, it probably won’t make a dent.  You’re not ready for it.  But for anyone who has shoes older than most first year associates, the wry wit that permeates the Guide will bring a twisted smile to your face.

It’s not laugh out loud funny.  It’s the sort of humor one finds from having lived, watched and experienced years of young lawyers who think they know it all get the occasional well-deserved smack.  Somebody has to tell them that they’re not as wonderful as their mommies have been assuring them all those years, and Herrmann does the job admirably.

Every law firm should have a partner like Mark Herrmann to mentor their youth and avoid the necessity of having to redo everything.  There aren’t enough Herrmann’s to go around, of course, which is why this Guide is so important.  For solos, read it because nobody every told you how to be a lawyer.  For Biglaw, buy a few hundred copies so you can hand them out to the next generation.  Don’t buy too many, however, since there’s no telling how long you’ll be around and it would be shame to waste them.

As for Herrmann, his membership application is currently under consideration.  So what, he wrote a good book.  There is still the little matter of sharing all the public adoration that comes with being a curmudgeon hottie.  We’re watching you carefully, Herrmann, and awaiting the invitation to the next cocktail party to be held in Cleveland, which should happen sometime in 2013.

Cruising The Neighborhood

The blawgosphere has a few posts that no one should miss, so without further ado, here’s what’s happening in the neighborhood.

At Overlawyered, Walter Olson has chronicled the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act (CPSIA), the civil version of laws that have devastated the criminal arena for decades.  The law, enacted in the wake of the Chinese lead paint scandals, attempts to “fix” one new problem by wreaking havoc across the boards.  It’s another example of what happens in the rush and zeal to appease public fears without proper thought of unintended consequences.  Sound familiar?

Walter has followed this law as it came closer to its effective date, noting what its consequences would be and have been, despite its enforcement stay as business, especially small ones, found themselves totally incapable of compliance.  He has put together a 50+ state list of what the CPSIA would do to America.

To get a feel for what Walter’s talking about, consider this :

Baby rag quilt

You may want to buy this cute item before the requirements of CPSIA go into effect on Feb. 10, when according to the Etsy listing its price will go up from $58 to $3,530 to cover the required testing

Now that businesses large and small are on the business end of a bad law, any chance they will gain some empathy toward those trapped in the government’s other weapons to “fix” the latest and greatest problems?  Unfortunately, not likely.  Everybody cares deeply about their own situation, but still defaults to screw the other guy.  At least it’s a tool to use for comparison.

And my brother from another mother, J. Daniel Hull of What About Clients? has finally woken up from his drunken stupor well deserved rest to bring us some comfort from the crushing weight of blawgospheric overload by providing his “must-read” blogs for all lawyers.


The Big Six lawyer sites to read. Since you are busy and, like us, self-important, you really should read or at least skim six (6) lawyer sites–all of these technically qualify as “blogs”–every week. All six are must reading. The first one, and for us The King, is Legal Blog Watch, last week’s Blawg Review host of No. 197, and one of the few sites for lawyers that always delivers. This past week LBW hosted from the LegalTech show in NYC. And then there’s Blawg Review itself, consistently a phenomenon, and a labor of love, by Ed. and his talented “Sherpas”, a Boston ADR specialist we respect, and a West Coast-based in-house counsel with dual Brit-Yank citizenship who writes as well as Flaubert when he’s in the right goddamn mood. We think Legal Blog Watch and Blawg Review cover, quickly and comprehensively, what’s happening in American and global legal markets for (A) news and ( new ideas.

The other four sites that supplement these two, and do the same thing if slightly less comprehensively? They are: newcomer and often visionary Law21 of Canada, the analytical Adam Smith, the enormously popular ear-to-ground Above The Law and WSJ’s Law Blog.


I agree with Dan, with two caveats.  For criminal defense lawyers, or any lawyer over the age of 12, ATL no longer makes the cut.  As much as David Lat created a place that brought federal judicial “hotties” and salacious lawyer news home, it’s taken a serious header off the high dive since Lat took off his bathrobe and put on a tie and is now the blog of choice for stunted adolescence and the Slackoisie.  If you don’t have a 12 year old of your own at home, and aren’t readily familiar with the current thoughts on infantile sexual humor, then you might enjoy the new ATL.  If you’re past reliving the glory days of elementary school, then ATL offers nothing new.  Take a pass.

Also, Blawg Review raises a red flag.  The nature makes each one sui generis, so there’s no blame on they mysterious Ed for this criticism, but still BR as a whole takes the rap.  Some Blawg Reviews are great, some even bordering on brilliant.  Others, less so.  And some are downright awful.  So I’m seizing this opportunity to slam a practice that I find reprehensible.  Some BR authors use their moment in the sun to “showcase” their little niche, or their state, or something unique to them, to the exclusion of the blawgosphere.  This is now Blawg Showcase, but Blawg Review.  If you don’t like the format, don’t do it.  But who gave you the right to change the concept to suit your own self-promotional whims?

I read Blawg Review every Monday, rain or shine.  It’s a great way to show the blawgosphere who you are and get people to appreciate your savvy.  It can also be the best way to make absolutely certain that as many people as possible think you are a blithering idiot when you try to pull off some crappy move to suit your personal agenda.  If nobody is reading your “fertile octogenarian” blog, there’s a reason.  Putting together a BR of only fertile octogenarian blogs is the surest way to guarantee that no one will ever read a fertile octogenarian blog again.  If it’s of no interest in mono, it’s definitely not interesting in surround sound.  Get it?

Much has been written about fallen hero and occasional toker Michael Phelps, but few have summed it up as well as reformed prosecutor  Robert Guest. 


The greatest Olympian of this decade is losing endorsement deals over cannabis use. I have a paltry ad budget, but I am willing to dedicate 100% of those funds to hiring Michael Phelps. Perhaps I could hire Michael to swim the Trinity with a Robert Guest.com speedo.

Michael, you are still an American hero. You have nothing to apologize for. Millions of Americans, including the current and two former Presidents, have partaken in the recreational use of cannabis.

When are we going to come to grips with America’s relationship to marijuana?  The President smoked it (as did any half-way normal person of a certain age, and anyone who says he didn’t is either a liar or such a fringe nerd that he’s unworthy of notice), yet we elect him because it’s just not the critical factor in determining who should be the most powerful man on Earth.  Yet a swimmer smokes it and he goes from hero to mutt?  It’s crazy.  We really need to grow up already. 

Watch the Saturday Night Live video on Robert’s blawg to gain a little perspective.  Humor has an amazing way of making a point, and this says it all.

And finally, Mark Bennett at the number 1 criminal law blawg anywhere, Defending People, reminds us that there are places on the periphery of America that still have traditional values, like racial prejudice, abuse of police power and rampant facial injustice.  In a throwback to the Mayberry days. there’s Tenaha.


According to the lawsuit filed in U.S. District Court, officers would stop non-white motorists for no legal reason, order them out of their cars, search their cars, call out dogs to search the cars, find nothing, interrogate the motorists, ask them if they had any money, seize the money, arrest them for “money laundering”, and then threaten to hold them prisoner and prosecute them for money laundering unless they would agree to forfeit the money.

It’s like discovery the last standing drive-in theater, or the last “whites only” drinking fountain.  Just when you thought you could never go back, you find out there’s a place that never left.  Granted, I occasional make good, clean fun of Texas for some of its more backward trends, but even the most strident Texaphile has to wonder how this one got away.  Word is that there’s a “welcome” sign as you enter Tenaha, Rotary on Tuesdays at the Dairy Queen and Ku Klux Klan on Thursdays at the Piggly Wiggly appetizer counter.

And some politicians would have you believe that traditional American values are dead.

Schools and Cops, A Dangerous Combination

The good news is that we don’t find stories like this every day.  The bad news is that we find them at all.  Skelly at Arbitrary & Capricious posts about the confluence of great minds in Idaho, a joint venture of school and police, that arrived at the brilliant solution of arresting, handcuffing and leading away an 8 year old girl with Aspergers Syndrome.  They must have been so very proud of themselves, nailing the perp.

And what heinous crime demanded such swift and severe response?


Spring Towry said she got to the school… just in time to see 54-pound Evelyn – who was diagnosed at age 5 with Asperger’s Syndrome, a high functioning form of autism – being walked to a police car with two officers at her side. “She started screaming ‘Mommy, I don’t want to go! What are batteries? What are batteries?'” Towry said. “She didn’t even know what she was arrested for.”

Towry, who lives in Ponderay, said Evelyn told her that she had been refused entry into a school Christmas party that had been delayed until after the holidays because of a string of snow days, because she refused to take off her beloved “cow costume” – a hoodie with cow ears and a tail.

That’s right, the old “cow hoodie” caper.  We can’t have 8 year old children wearing cow hoodies.  What’s next?  Go-go boots?

While the stupidity of this scenario lends itself to some obvious humor, this really isn’t funny at all.  This young girl had Aspergers, and required a little special handling to address whatever rules the adults from the school decided were so overwhelmingly important that they could not possibly allow her to enjoy the party in a cow hoodie.  As such, they should have known, and understood, how to manage an autistic child.  We expect the people who are charged with the care of children to know such things. It’s part of their job, their responsibility.  And frankly, while it takes a little bit of actual thought and understanding, two things in short reserve in schools, it just isn’t all that hard to do.

According to ABC News, here’s what our respected educators had to say about the incident:



Dick Cvitanich, superintendent of the Lake Pend Oreille School District, which includes the school where Evelyn was a student, said the school called police because “there was escalating behavior that resulted in what we perceived to be an assault on staff.”


At a hearing on the case Tuesday, the prosecutor “said that he didn’t think at this time it would be beneficial to pursue it because of her age and, of course, her condition,” Towry said.


Evelyn was at court for the hearing, but “she didn’t exactly know what was going on,” Towry said.


Cvitanich said Evelyn’s outburst Friday was the culmination of a series of incidents “that demanded staff intervention.”


“It’s definitely not typical,” he said of the decision to call police on a child as young as Evelyn, “and not something we particularly want to do or like to do.”


Rarely does one see as many wiggle words captured in the same facially ridiculous statement.  But the real story appears to be that a female teachers grabbed and held the child and the child pinched the teacher’s breast (not deliberately, but because it was the nearest body part to pinch) to be released.


The school’s response to Evelyn’s outburst and the string of events that led to it were completely inappropriate, says Dr. Pauline Filipek, associate professor at the University of California, Irvine, and pediatric nurse practitioner Teri Book, who share a practice specializing in pediatric neurology.

Book, the mother of a 17-year-old daughter with Asperger’s, said children with high-functioning autism create the illusion that they are capable of communicating in the same way as children who do not have developmental disabilities.

In reality, Book said, they may have an animalistic “fight or flight” mentality when it comes to confrontation. Many have “tactile defensiveness,” meaning they are hyper-sensitive to any type of unwanted physical contact.

In other words, the school created the problem and then blamed the child for trying to break free of their control.  And that’s really the crux of the matter.  The inability to maintain absolute control is, in itself, the most heinous crime that can happen to a teacher.  Whatever empathy may exist otherwise, do not challenge their control.  It’s their lifeblood, and the petty people who demand it cannot bear to lose it, especially to an 8 year old autistic girl.

As for why the police didn’t exercise the slightest bit of discretion in the handling of this disgrace, no explanation is offered.  If I was cynical, I would react that no explanation is needed and no explanation would matter.  But I can’t help myself from adding, did the big, tough cops feel proud of themselves for saving their fellow public employees from this vicious child?

Mortgage Fraud Costs Lawyer 30 Years of Files

From Newsday, lawyer and former Suffolk County Legislator George Guldi found what it’s like to be the object of Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota’s love and attention.  He stood idly by as detectives carried 30 years of files out of his Westhampton Beach law office.  According to his lawyer, they even took photographs of his children.


Guldi has a general law practice. [John] Diffley said detectives took matrimonial and criminal files from Guldi’s office, which he said “flagrantly breached” the attorney-client privilege.”

Whether this is a touch hyperbolic remains unclear, since it’s unlikely that Guldi has much in his files that would be privileged.  But it’s possible, and it’s likely that the detectives seized everything in sight with the intention of sorting it all out later. 

Given my experience with defendants and targets in mortgage fraud, I’m surprised that more law offices haven’t been the target of subpoenas and seizures.  Shocked really.  Not that what I’m about to say has anything to do with Guldi per se, as I don’t know him and suggest nothing about him, but I’ve come to realize that there are a bunch of real estate lawyers who ran closing mills and were integrally involved in the frauds of their mortgage broker clients.  The brokers referred them business, and often involved them directly in their scams by way of investment as well as straw-buyers,   They were hip-deep in fraud.

The lawyers made a ton of money participating in these schemes.  To call them lawyers is somewhat misleading, as they were doing secretarial work as far as the closing were concerned, and were far more interested in being a part of the scheme to defraud than they were in doing anything remotely approaching legal representation. 

What shocks me is that they have largely been ignored in the mortgage fraud investigations.  When law enforcement runs down the list of bad deals, whether because of fraudulent appraisals, fraudulent applications, straw-buyers or any of the other various mechanics of these schemes, they will find the same names appearing time and again.  The names of lawyers representing sellers and buyers.

Some of these lawyers were doing four or five closings a day.  Some were doing only one, but owned a piece of everything that was sold.  When they represented the buyers, they never mentioned they had an interest in the property being sold.  When the represented the banks, they never mentioned that they knew the buyers were strawmen, used to scam the banks out of mortgage money on a fake flip based on a scam appraisal showing a 50% increase in value in six months.

George Guldi stood there watching files walked out of his law office.  I have no idea what ran through his mind as he watched.  Was it, “oh crap, they got me,” or “oh my God, how can I protect my clients?”  But a laundry list of lawyers who made a ton of money out of mortgage fraud remain unscathed.  I’m no fan of cops going through the files of a lawyer, and agree with Diffley [full disclosure: I’ve used Diffley, a young criminal defense lawyer, to do some legwork for me in the past] that it raises terrible issues of privilege.

But I am also painfully aware of how lawyers willingly became integrally involved in these schemes to defraud and have, as far as I can see, avoided being tagged for their role.  Perhaps if it weren’t for the fact that the feds are so busy rounding up businesspeople for potential lead paint issues on minicycles, they would be rounding up lawyers for their role in the mortgage fraud that has ruined far more people on Long Island than Bernie Madoff or Nick Cosmo possibly could.

As painful as raiding law offices may be (and it is painful indeed), these people aren’t lawyers to me.  Their files aren’t legal files.  They are plain vanilla evidence of crime.

If Law Was Run By Non-Lawyers

There is a series of commercials by a cell phone company showing how certain functions would be different if run by outsiders.  There is Congress, run by firefighters.  There is an airport run by roadies.  They are funny, and make a point.  They also show quite clearly why it would be a miserable failure.


Speaker:  Need clean water guys?
All:  Aye
Speaker:  Easiest job I ever done. We’re outa here.

Of course, the question was never whether we need clean water, but how to accomplish it.  Not nearly as easy a job.  But it primarily demonstrates how those on the outside lack the understanding of what is involved to appreciate the difficulty, responsibility, concerns and issues.  Funny as it may seem when it’s not your responsibility, everything changes when it falls on your shoulders to get it right.

And so, reading another fascinating post from Jordon Furlong’s Law 21, I recognized a similar problem when people who aren’t lawyers, whether they are in marketing or systems or efficiency, try to recreate the practice of law through their eyes.  Well intended, and capable of thinking outside the box as they suffer none of the archaic constraints that shut our minds to innovation.  But also lacking the occasional understanding of the core of what we do.  Among many interesting suggestions, Jordon included this


It looks like many firms are missing an opportunity here to carefully and intelligently review their support needs and re-engineer both their personnel and their infrastructure investment accordingly. Simply cutting staff jobs provides only a short-term bottom-line assist while creating many other short- and long-term problems, whereas a more creative approach could both save money and improve the firm’s operations at the same time. Here are just a few possibilities.
*  *  *

Outsource or offshore functions like human resources, IT or even research and other quasi-legal tasks — firms have already done this, from West Virginia to India.

In the comments, Jordon was taken to task for this suggestion.  Research is a “quasi-legal task?”  Not in my office.  Apparently, not in anyone else’s either.  Research is a legal task.  Indeed, a primary legal task.  That it’s given to the youngsters in Biglaw is a test of skill, not a shunting off of inconsequential work. 

But it’s not Jordon’s fault that he misunderstood.  When we deal with non-lawyers, we need to be vigilant that we not be led down the garden path of efficiency to the detriment of our representation.  They aren’t lawyers.  They don’t know.  They aren’t supposed to know, because that’s what distinguishes lawyers from non-lawyers.  And we are responsible for our representation, not them.

The blogosphere is a swamp of ideas.  Some great, others not so great.  Some downright bad.  There are a number of great ideas from marketers that are dangerously wrong, even unethical, for lawyers.  It’s not that they aren’t brilliant, but we don’t sell Brillo and marketers, being marketers and not lawyers, don’t always understand the difference.  Indeed, some of the marketers are lawyers or have marketed exclusively for lawyers, and either have forgotten what it means to practice law or still don’t get it.

Do not be sucked in.  Do not be misled.  At no point in your career, or in your life, will you be able to tell a judge or a client that it’s not your fault, a marketer told you to do it, with a straight face.

The certificate on the wall attesting to your privilege to practice law has your name on it.  Never defer your responsibility to anyone else, whether a firefighter, a roadie or a marketer. 

Exonerating the Dead

Timothy Coles was innocent.  Timothy Coles is dead.  There are three shames here and each needs to be realized. 

From the AP, via Dan Solove’s post at Concurring Opinions :


A man who died in prison while serving time for a rape he didn’t commit was cleared Friday by a judge who called the state’s first posthumous DNA exoneration “the saddest case” he’d ever seen. . . .

[Timothy] Cole was convicted of raping a Texas Tech University student in Lubbock in 1985 and was sentenced to 25 years in prison. He died in 1999 at age 39 from asthma complications.

DNA tests in 2008 connected the crime to Jerry Wayne Johnson, who is serving life in prison for separate rapes. Johnson testified in court Friday that he was the rapist in Cole’s case and asked the victim and Cole’s family to forgive him. . . .

A double tragedy, for the rape victim and Timothy Coles.  Grits for Breakfast provides more details on the case and exoneration.

The third tragedy is expressed in Dan’s post, that the system exacts a terrible toll on the innocent defendant. 


This case illustrates how our criminal justice system punishes the innocent more harshly than the guilty. This phenomenon occurs because of several rules and practices:

1. The federal sentencing guidelines and sentencing guidelines in many states provides for reductions in sentences for “acceptance of responsibility.” The innocent defendant, who refuses to admit to the crime, will not receive this benefit.

2. An innocent defendant might often refuse to accept a guilty plea deal. When the innocent defendant defends his or her innocence at trial and gets wrongly convicted, that defendant will invariably receive a much higher punishment than that proposed in the plea deal.

3. An innocent defendant, by not admitting to his or her crime, might hurt his or her chance for an early release from prison.

This is not an accident, but by design.  Coles was offered probation if only he would plead guilty.  Coles had a shot a parole, if only he was acknowledge his wrong.  Coles was innocent.  The system cannot accommodate an innocent person.  Despite the rhetoric, it presumes everyone arrested is guilty.  It does everything possible to coerce a plea of guilty and punish anyone who tests the system.  It purports to demand truth, but only rewards lies when the defendant is innocent.  This is by design.

The argument in favor of this design is that the vast majority of defendant are guilty, at least to some extent, and hence the incentives push the right people in the right direction.  This is fine with folks who believe that an imperfect system, as long as it doesn’t touch them or their loved ones, is acceptable.  They are perfectly happy if a few innocent defendants are required take a bullet for the team.  It’s the price of putting all the bad guys away, and they are all too happy to pay the price with someone else’s life.

It has long been my belief that the degree of vehemence with which a defendant protests his innocence, in the face of evidence to the contrary, suggests that he’s either truly innocent or truly insane.  It’s not evidence.  It’s hardly the sort of thing one can use at trial to make the point.  It’s just a belief. 

We live with a legal fiction that tells us that a defendant who is convicted of a crime after trial is guilty.  We do this because this is the rule of the game.  It doesn’t make him guilty.  But he’s guilty nonetheless.  Until one day, he suddenly becomes innocent.  This is one crappy system, unless you belong to the group of people who find an imperfect system acceptable.  I do not.

While my belief that convicting innocent people is an unacceptable price to pay to get the bad guys may not be shared by all, perhaps even the other team can agree that the system need not exact so harsh a price from those who challenge it, who protest their innocence, who do not cave in to the overwhelming pressure to admit guilt for a crime they did not commit.  Just in case the other team is wrong.

Defending the Bully

Our hearts go out to the innocent victims of a wrong.  It’s human nature.  But it takes a particularly twisted perspective to turn the bully into the victim, especially when the spinner is someone who has dedicated his efforts to advocating for victims at all costs.  This is why Utah Lawprof and former federal judge Paul Cassell’s post at Volokh Conspiracy is so bizarrely shocking.

Without knowing the underlying details, I was ready, for the first time ever, to agree with Paul about a post:

CBS News “Analyst” Andrew Cohen has called Justice Scalia a “bully” for offering strongly-worded views on legal subjects in this column. Cohen’s views are absurd. There is a vast difference between strongly arguing one’s case and “bullying” someone. In fact, it is Justice Scalia’s well-known ability to offer lively, opinionated views on legal subjects is what makes him such a desirable speaker for many organizations.

Interestingly, the apparent flash point for Cohen’s column is the fact that Justice Scalia opposes televising Supreme Court proceedings — something that CBS has a vested interest in securing.

So, some knee-jerk liberal Nino-hater went after him for offering “lively, opinionated views on legal subjects?” Well that’s wrong.  Just because he’s not one of ours doesn’t mean he isn’t entitled to take the opposing position, and doesn’t mean that he should be denigrated for holding a different view.  After all, Nino is most assuredly lively and opinionated.  It’s one of the things I love most about him.

So I clicked the link, to see what this scoundrel Cohen was all worked up about.  What new dastardly deed had he unearthed?

Tuesday afternoon, Scalia showed again just how easy it is to set him off when a college student asked him a reasonable, even poignant question about accessibility to the workings of the Supreme Court. Here is how the Fort Lauderdale Sun Sentinel chronicled the incident :
Student Sarah Jeck stood in front of 750 people and asked Scalia why cameras are not allowed in the U.S. Supreme Court even though the court hearings are open, transcripts are available and the court’s justices are open enough to go ‘out on book tours.’ ‘Read the next question,’ Scalia replied. ‘That’s a nasty, impolite question.’

Wait a second.  Aside from this being old news, where exactly is the “lively and opinionated views on legal subjects” that Paul referred to?  This was a Supreme Court Justice who couldn’t handle a perfectly reasonable question from a student, and had to blow her off with a universally derided reaction.  This has nothing to do with Nino’s views on camera in the courtroom, a view that I happen to agree with, or any other view on any legal subject under the sun.  This was a Supreme Court Justice humiliating a student for asking a question he didn’t care to answer.  Even Nino’s staunchest conservative supporters blushed at this one.  Whether “bully” is the right word is subject to debate, but it clearly wasn’t Scalia’s finest moment.

The aspect most striking is hardly Scalia’s abuse at the hands of the evil Andrew Cohen, but the abject lack of intellectual integrity of Paul Cassell’s attempt to spin Scalia into the victim of this exchange.  Before, Paul was the hero of the victim, though his definition of victim was so far attenuated from what normal people would accept as to put him onto the distant fringe.  But now, it’s clear that he’s not above twisting his own victim-cred to use it to further a political agenda.

So much for taking the victim’s rights mob seriously.  When Paul Cassell sells his credibility this cheaply, he’s now relegated to the shill pile. 

Seeing, Believing, Getting It Wrong

Jamie Spencer at Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer posts about a fascinating experiment designed to test whether a person who recalls an event prior to being fed misinformation is more likely to recall it correctly later, and thereby not have his memory tainted by the misinformation.

As Jamie notes, it’s just common sense that a correctly recalled memory should enhance the likelihood that it will not be effected by some subsequent taint.  Ah, common sense, our old, reliable friend.


Except it ain’t so. The study proved just the opposite. (You’ve got to love science. The whole point of proving something using the scientific method can lead to unexpected results.)


A group of volunteers watched the first episode of “24” and then either took an immediate recall test about the show or played a game. Next, all of the subjects were told false information about the episode they had seen and then took a final memory test about the show…


The researchers found that the volunteers who took the test immediately after watching the show were almost twice as likely to recall false information compared to the volunteers who played the game following the episode.


Afterwards, both of you are given false information about what you watched. And then you are both tested on what you saw. You are re-tested; he’s asked for the first time.


Here’s the kicker… you are more likely than the other guy to repeat the false information:


The results of a follow-up experiment suggest that the first recall test may have improved subjects’ ability to learn the false information – that is, the first test enhanced learning of new and erroneous information.



The beauty of science is that it can provide us with answers to questions that “common sense” would have us believe need not be tested since the answers are obvious.  And wrong. 

I had a personal experience that tested this concept, and can attest to the power of post-hoc taint.  On July 17th, 1996, I was driving over the Westhampton bridge toward my summer house on Dune Road, with my kids in the car having just gotten them ice cream, when I saw what appeared to be a firework shoot up from the ocean into the sky and explode.  It was quite unusual to see, and I pointed out to the kids that someone on a boat must be shooting off fireworks.  My memory to this day is clear.

What I saw was the downing of TWA Flight 800.  I called the FBI and made a report the next day, after learning that wanted eyewitness reports.  I was never contacted about it again.  What I saw bore no relation to the official report of the incident.

Years later, I talked about this incident with a reporter friend of mine, who had covered it at the time.  He argued with me that I could not have seen what I did, explaining to me the various reasons why it couldn’t have happened that way.  He demanded that I rationalize my observation with the various other factors found in the investigation, asking me if I was saying that this was some sort of terrorist conspiracy.  I shrugged and demurred.  I didn’t have to explain what happened, I told him, but just what I saw.  I saw what I saw.  What it means is for someone else to explain. 

But the sense of need to fit the pieces together, to make sense of them with the other information I had subsequently learned, was compelling.  Gestalt grabs us by the collar and jerks us hard.  We want our observations to fit what we believe are facts, and we want to find a way to make sense of everything.  We need things to make sense.

I fought the impulse.  To this day, I remember the observation, my comments to my kids, and my subsequent doubt of my observations.  If anyone asks me now what happened, I answer that I don’t have a clue, but I do know what I saw.  If it were up to me to explain it, I would find myself locked in a dilemma because I can’t rationalize my observations with the facts as I’ve been told.  But I can hold firm to my observations, as long as I fight off the need to make sense of them.

How many witnesses are willing to fight the need to make sense, to explain, and just stick with their observations?  How many will do so when others “suggest” they are wrong?