Author Archives: SHG

Second Circuit Sets Up Second Amendment Showdown

For those (like me) who were terribly disappointed in the wiggly, intellectually barren and doctrinally bankrupts decision in D.C. v. Heller, take heart.  The Second Circuit decision in Maloney v. Cuomo is the closest thing yet to a perfect set up for the Supremes to give the Second Amendment a real thumbs up or not.

The appeal seeks declaratory relief holding that New York law prohibiting the possession of “chuka sticks” (a/k/a nunchucks for you Wii users) in one’s home is unconstitutional as violative of the 2d Amendment, as well as irrational.  Nope, says the Circuit.  Not until the Supreme Court holds that its Heller decision applies to the states.

Heller, a case involving a challenge to the District of Columbia’s general prohibition on handguns, does not invalidate this longstanding principle. See Heller, 128 S. Ct. at 2813 n.23 (noting that the case did not present the question of whether the Second Amendment applies to the states). And to the extent that Heller might be read to question the continuing validity of this principle, we “must follow Presser” because “[w]here, as here, a Supreme Court precedent ‘has direct application in a case, yet appears to rest on reasons rejected in some other line of decisions, the Court of Appeals should follow the case which directly controls, leaving to the Supreme Court the prerogative of overruling its own decisions.’” Bach, 408 F.3d at 86 (quoting Rodriguez de Quijas v. Shearson/Am. Express, Inc., 490 U.S. 477, 484 (1989)) (alteration marks omitted); see also State Oil Co. v. Khan, 522 U.S. 3, 20 (1997). Thus, N.Y. Penal Law §§ 265.00 through 265.02 do not violate the Second Amendment.

So there you have it.  In the home, chukka sticks (not a pistol, but better than a machine gun) and New York to boot.  It doesn’t get better than this.

Back to you, Nino. 

Why Malcolm Maims (Update)

A press release came across the email yesterday about a new scholarly article from March issue of Social Science Quarterly.  Usually, I just check it out for the photos of hot chicks, but this one caught my interest.


Adolescents with Unpopular Names More Prone to Committing Crime


 


Shippensburg, PA – January 28, 2009 – A new study in the journal Social Science Quarterly examined the relationship between first name popularity in adolescents and tendency to commit crime. Results show that, regardless of race, juveniles with unpopular names are more likely to engage in criminal activity.


 


David E. Kalist and Daniel Y. Lee analyzed state data by comparing the first names of male juvenile delinquents to the first names of male juveniles in the population.


 


Researchers constructed a popularity-name index (PNI) for each name. For example, the PNI for Michael is 100, the most frequently given name during the period. The PNI for David is 50, a name given half as frequently as Michael. The PNI is approximately 1 for names such as Alec, Ernest, Ivan, Kareem, and Malcolm.


 


The least popular names were associated with juvenile delinquency among both blacks and whites. While the names are likely not the cause of crime, they are connected to factors that increase the tendency to commit crime, such as a disadvantaged home environment, residence in a county with low socioeconomic status, and households run by one parent.


 


Also, adolescents with unpopular names may be more prone to crime because they are treated differently by their peers, making it more difficult for them to form relationships. Juveniles with unpopular names may also act out because they consciously or unconsciously dislike their names.


 


“First name characteristics may be an important factor to help identify individuals at high risk of committing or recommitting crime, leading to more effective and targeted intervention programs,” the authors conclude.


Naturally, Johnny Cash’s song, “A Boy Named Sue” came immediately to mind, but I immediately felt that I was being too frivolous.  I requested that the flak send me the full article, but heard nothing back, so I’m left to deal with this bizarre finding on its face.

The findings, that boys with unpopular names are more prone to commit crimes but that the authors contend that the names are not the cause of crime, leaves me scratching my head.  So what’s their point?  Either the names cause crime or they don’t.  If there is a direct correlation between the two, then they do. But the authors say they don’t.  Which is it?

The explanation offered is that they “may be more prone to crime” because (a) they are treated differently or (b) they hate their names and therefore become criminals.  Both seem to suggest that names then do cause crimes, though through slightly attenuated routes.  Frankly, neither hypothesis smells right.  Keith doesn’t necessarily kill and Malcolm doesn’t inherently maim.  Some Henry’s are hated and some Loyds are loved.  I find it extremely hard to believe that the popularity of a name carries that much influence on future criminal conduct.

And yet the authors find a direct correlation, even to the point that it crosses racial lines.  Does this mean that the new argument at sentencing is that Bruce is less blameworthy than Brian?  Is the answer that new parents should all name their children Michael from now on, just to be safe?  Or should schools create at risk classrooms for all the kids with names that don’t make it into the top 10 for their birth year?

This is one strange study. 

Addition:  While I may have been reticent to file this under “A Boy Named Sue,” others felt differently.  James Joyner at Outside the Beltway parsed the song for its relevance,


I would not dismiss out of hand the causal relationship, which was anecdotally suggested decades ago by Shel Silverstein’s story song about a “Boy Named Sue” who, because of said appellation, “grew up quick” and “grew up mean” and whose “fist got hard” and “wits got keen.” Indeed, he even vowed to “kill that man who gave me that awful name.”   Ironically, Johnny Cash recorded the song in his famous concert for the inmates at San Quentin prison.

Regardless of the generalizability of the causality, the concluding advice of that song, it seems, was apt: “If I ever have a son, I think I’m gonna name him… Bill or George! Anything but Sue!”

Probably good advice under any circumstances.

H/T Radley Balko

Update:  I just received a copy of the full article, and will read it as soon as possible to see whether there’s beef behind this curious conclusion.  For anyone who wants to read it now, This entry was posted in Uncategorized on by .

Ugly Reality Strikes the Blawgosphere

Michael Arrington of TechCrunch is a leader, and as such is a lightning rod for the good, the bad and the ugly.  And so it happened.

Yesterday as I was leaving the DLD Conference in Munich, Germany someone walked up to me and quite deliberately spat in my face. Before I even understood what was happening, he veered off into the crowd, just another dark head in a dark suit. People around me stared, then looked away and continued their conversation.

While the reason for this attack is unclear, Arrington’s involvement with startups and venture capital is presumably the match that lit someone’s very short fuse.  This isn’t one of the risks one assumes when blogging.  This goes beyond the pale, and Michael Arrington has decided that he needs to consider his options.


I’ve decided the right thing to do is take some time off and get a better perspective on what I’m spending my life doing. I’ll be taking most of February off from writing, and decide what the best future for me is while sitting on a beach somewhere far away from my iPhone and laptop.

This post came across my radar from Mark Britton, the CEO of Avvo, who twitted the link, together with a comment, “and I thought we got beat up a lot at Avvo.” My initial reaction was to think this comment somewhat disingenuous, given what happened to Michael Arrington compared to Avvo and Mark getting rightfully beaten up over a dubious business model and some rather desperate self-promotion. 

But upon further reflection, I realized that Mark’s off-hand comment probably masks a very serious problem.  As Avvo CEO, he stands a very real probability of being the eventual target of a disgruntled Avvo user, who mistakenly assumes that he can rely on an Avvo Answer and winds up with a love one in prison for life.  What are the chances that Mark gets blamed?  Pretty good.  What are the chances that some psycho decides to take his anger out on someone?  Pretty good.  What are the chances that the risk of this business model will eventually find its way back to the Avvo CEO?  Unfortunately, pretty good.  Mark has good reason to be concerned. 

People don’t realize what comes of the exposure a person gets from blawging.  There are emails and phone calls from people who “demand justice,” and have decided that a blawger is just the one to get it for them.  We write about it.  They need it.  Therefore, it becomes our responsibility, in their eyes, to get it for them.  And when they figure out that we will not dedicate our lives to their cause, they get angry with us.  We are to blame.  They turn vicious and threatening toward us.  You can’t imagine some of the wild reactions I get from people I’ve never heard of who believe that I owe them something.  I cannot emphasize this enough: There are crazy people out there.

As much as I enjoy razzing Mark Britton about some of the initiatives Avvo has introduced in its quest for survival, not to mention the faint praise of his promotional posts about how somebody in Podunk scored two new cases from Avvo in their first week (because the rest of us who have been on Avvo have enjoyed the 500 phone calls from people who want to know if we can be their lawyers for free case they’re innocent and broke and need a lawyer “really, really bad”), I also appreciate that Mark’s efforts could put a target between his eyes.  This is where the fun stops and this online existence turns bizarre.

From a risk assessment perspective, one would think Michael Arrington to be relatively safe.  After all, he deals with cutting edge technology, and even if critical, he’s not advocating that loved ones be executed for an ugly interface.  Britton falls higher on the risk scale, as his business involves more personal and critical issues to certain members of the public (and lawyers), and tends to attract a more desperate and needy user.

But in the criminal law blawgosphere, the risk is great.  For those of us who take strong and clear positions, we can be lightning rods for people filled with anger and frustration.  We can be seen as their last hope, and our failure to be their savior has huge potential to shift their hostility away from its primary target onto us.  I’ve seen this happen regularly with emails, and I’ve been threatened from time to time for my refusal to fulfill whatever demands people make of me.  Half the time, I don’t even know what they’re talking about, as some of these folks are so self-centered that they truly believe the entire world is focused on them and their issues, and we all know everything about it.  Some are just incomprehensible.

Criminal defense lawyers, by their nature, take the potential of threats in stride.  It’s something that’s assumed due to the nature of our work, as defendants need someone to blame because of an unjust system, and we’re the closest warm body around.  But in the virtual world, there’s a sense of distance from the flesh and blood.  We don’t know who is reading our words and what is running through their mind as they do.  Expectations are attributed to us online that we know nothing about, and should we fail to meet those expectations, people we don’t know can get angry with us.  Some will get very angry.  Some may feel compelled to act out their anger.

What happened to Michael Arrington is a reminder that there are real people out there who will project their feelings and expectations on us, regardless of whether they have any right or cause to do so.  So to Mark Britton and my fellow blawgers in the practical blawgosphere, be careful out there.  And to anyone who stumbles on a post here, and assumes that it gives you the right to demand my time and attention for your cause, I’m sorry if I disappoint you but I cannot help everyone. 

The Lifecycle of Comments

The blawgosphere lives.  Which also means it evolves, and it’s evolving right before our eyes.  What started as a discussion has evolved, little by little, into a form of ordered chaos, and is now changing again into more limited and less interesting conversation.  It’s a shame, and it’s a necessity.

Above the Law posted a major change to its comment policy.


As the Above the Law community continues to grow, more people are posting absurd, inane, and arguably offensive comments. And more people are complaining about those comments — in the comments, as well by email and other means.

There isn’t a great deal of overlap between readers of Simple Justice and Above the Law.  For those unfamiliar, ATL deals largely with issues that interest younger associates at Biglaw, focusing on layoffs and bonuses, with a side order of infantile sexual issues amongst young lawyers.  It’s devolved since David Lat handed over the reins to Elie Mystal, whereas it once looked closely at the sex lives of hottie judges, it now discusses the dating problems of associates with acne.

Despite, or because of, this focus, ATL has a huge audience, dwarfing blawgs like Simple Justice.  One might suspect that these “best and brightest” of the Slackoisie would offer some thoughtful comments, challenging each other to show who was the bestest and brightest.  Nope.  Instead, their comments prove that even the former editor of law review is blithering idiot.  The comments section was a wasteland of childish stupidity, with the first half dozen usually relegated to the commenter who desperately hoped to be “first” to the latter commenters randomly inserting the meaningless language for which one would smack their fifth grader.  It was not merely worthless, but truly embarrassing. 

At the same time, Lawprof Jack Balkan had enough of the vitriol in comments at Balkanization, and decided that the new default status would be to close comments altogether.


[T]he comments sections are populated by regular trolls and many threads have turned into little more than name-calling. There is very rarely any serious analysis; mostly there is point scoring and vitriol. Many regular readers have written to say that they find the comments section a distraction and think the blog would be far better without it.

Dan Solove at Co-Op notes the decline in worthiness of comments, but that the “comment culture” of various blawgs differ so greatly.  His blawg, which is far more academic in tone and content, has yet to see its commentary devolve to the point of being problematic, while Orin Kerr at Volokh and Walter Olson at  Secular Right have had very different experiences.  I’ve thrashed about to find a way to encourage discussion while discouraging problems.  I’ve been largely unsuccessful, in that no one thinks they are a problem and many demand their right to post whatever they want.

Here, the trend has taken another curious shift in the past few weeks.  This time, the evolution has been closer to revolution, as it has happened with such ferocious speed that it was impossible to miss.  Despite more than 8000 comments at Simple Justice since its inception, there has been a sudden falling off of discussion by many of the “regulars” on the internal comment section here.  It seems that the community that developed has moved from Simple Justice, and blawgs in general, to a new home: Twitter.

It’s not that the subjects aren’t being discussed, but that they are being discussed elsewhere.  This presents a problem for blawgs, as the discussion on twitter about subjects on blawgs means that many are left out, the discussion isn’t memorialized along with the post and the depth of discussion is necessarily shallow, given the limitations twitter imposes on anything resembling actual thought.  If all of your ideas can be stated in 140 characters or less, you are either the most succinct writer in the world or your thoughts aren’t very profound. 

The reason for this shift is clear:  community.  My primary community, the criminal defense lawyers in the practical blawgosphere, spends a lot more time on twitter these days.  Some can be found there every evening, twitting away.  I tend to jump in and out in short bursts, then move to another activity that involves flesh and blood people, but that’s my choice.  Others find the virtual community more comforting, more addictive. 

Unlike the comment section on blawgs, twitter is self-moderating.  If someone’s twits either lack interest or annoy, you simply unfollow and, poof, they disappear from your screen.  To the extent my efforts to clamp down on comments stifled people who had things that needed saying, twitter provides a place where no one can stop them.  Now every person has their very own soap box, and they can twit to their heart’s content.

Of course, as the lifecycle of twitter is far more accelerated than anywhere else online, there have been mass deletions of spammers from time to time, who comprise many of the “followers” of lawyers in the hopes that you’ll follow them in return as a matter of etiquette.  Just yesterday, twenty of my “followers” suddenly disappeared, all of them spammers.  The twittersphere is rife with abusive potential, flagrant marketing, self-promotion and lies.  But no one can make you follow anyone you don’t want to, and most of the more aggressive marketers look far more painfully desperate than they realize, giving rise to some humor and little persuasion.

This plus for twitter, though, is a minus for the blawgosphere.  It reduces the value of blawgs by siphoning off the valuable discussion and leaving either a void or a palette to be painted by the nuttier folks who file in and out.  There are still plenty of nuts around to comment, even if the more thoughtful people have gone elsewhere for their discussions.  Statistics here show that readership remains high, and increasing, while discussion wanes. 

Ironically, other blawgers who have been less successful in gaining readership have had far greater success gaining exposure on twitter.  Twitting requires little thought and a happy face for someone to succeed in becoming popular.  Twit regularly and be supportive of other twits and people will follow.  It’s the perfect laboratory for observing the mechanics of positive human interaction, despite it being a substantive wasteland.  But community doesn’t require substance, just pleasant co-existence.

I don’t know what this means for the blawgosphere, where the discussion was a large part of the fun.  I don’t find the twittersphere anywhere near as fulfilling as others do, and have no plans to spend my evenings twitting from now on.  Perhaps this is a leading indicator of the death of the blawgosphere, even as those marketing to lawyers who are terminally behind the curve that they need to start a blawg to market themselves to death.  If you have to “sell” people on using new technology, it’s probably neither new nor cool anymore, and the cook kids have moved on to something else.

Be thankful that the readers/commenters at Above the Law haven’t brought their idiocy to twitter yet.  Check out the comments to the change notification post to get a sense of just how awful they are and how little they contribute.  And these children are paid $160,000 base salary?  Would they follow each other on twitter to see who wrote “first” or “asslobster” (one of the favorite expressions, apparently, amongst the Slackoisie)?  I can’t imagine that anyone would tolerate this nonsense, but then I’m not a card-carrying member of the Slackoisie. 

As I write for the sake of writing, I may well be the last person standing in the practical blawgosphere when all the cool kids have long since moved on.  But like the others who have suffered the evolution of blawg comments, I am sorry to see the discussion either devolve or flow elsewhere.  It’s part of the benefit and enjoyment of blawging.  But the good people will go where the community exists, and if it ceases to be here, then there’s little that can be done about.

As twitter (at least for the moment) continues its spectacular growth, it drains the blawgosphere of life.  Whether this means the blawgosphere is nearing the end of its lifecycle, I don’t know.  But it is most assuredly evolving.

The Agape Scheme; Smacking the Little Guy

Nicholas Cosmo is alleged to be a very persuasive fellow.  So persuasive that he managed to amass $370 million to purportedly be used toward construction bridge loans, and which would provide a return to investors in the area of 14%.  That’s huge.  Not so huge as to be impossible, but huge enough to light a fire under an investor sitting on some underutilized savings.  So the feds say it was a Ponzi scheme and busted Cosmo, bringing his company, Agape World, Inc. crashing down.

Cosmo operated on Long Island, a hometown version of Bernie Madoff, if you will.  He didn’t manage the megabucks, the pension funds and the university endowments and the charities that Madoff had, but the savings of well-to-do Long Islanders who wanted a bigger bang for their buck.  As dividend checks started rolling in, word spread of Cosmo and people wanted their piece of the pie.

It’s easy to see how Long Islanders believed in Cosmo.  Construction of new homes, McMansions, was all the rage.  Builders were putting them up on every patch of land available, and people were buying these ugly monstrosities, built of spit and glue, like it was their last chance for salvation.  It became a religion on Long Island that no one lost money in real estate, and this was just another way to cash in on the trend.  Cosmo saw greed, and he filled the niche. 

Many of the investors who now sit at home in a darkened room, wondering how they will survive without their life savings, should give some thought to what they did with the 14% returns they were receiving along the way.  It doesn’t take long to eat up a lot of principal when it’s going out to others in those beautiful monthly checks.  But some investors took their profits and bought the obligatory Mercedes or traveled to exotic lands.  No one can take away their memories.  Others plowed them back into Agape.  They now own a huge share of nothing.

While it’s easy to look at the bilked investors of Agape and blame them for their own greed, this scheme wasn’t so far outside the pale as to suggest that they are total fools.  Bridge loans bring much higher interest rates and are difficult to get.  The scheme was well crafted to appear legitimate, and made a great deal of sense given the construction fever on Long Island.  In fact, maybe it was real and just crashed when the market died and showed so many to be fools.  It’s too soon to say, despite reports to the contrary.

The friends and neighbors on Long Island who once flew high with Agape are now scratching around for salvation.  Inquiries are coming fast and furious about what they can do to recapture their lost assets.  When things go south, people turn to lawyers for help.  This is as it should be.  It’s what lawyers do.

But this is a test for lawyers.  The feds will have an administrator appointed by the Court to amass whatever assets are left or can be found and distribute them, pro rata, to the investors of Agape.  Should Cosmo be convicted, restitution will be ordered.  Whether it will be paid is another matter, but it will be ordered.  Beyond that, there is nothing that any individual investor can do to protect his interests.

While a lawyer can help the investor to coordinate his claim and provide a conduit of information about the status of the case, there is little else the lawyer can offer.  Sue Cosmo?  Get on line.  Jump up and down and scream a lot?  Nobody cares, and nobody is listening.  Whatever can be done, will be done.

Yet some lawyers on Long Island see this as an opportunity to get their own slice of the pie out of these bilked investors.  Hey, if they were stupid enough to be victims once, why not go for two?  In one instance, one local lawyer has already crowed publicly that he’s scored a huge fee out of this morass.  The claim is nonsensical, of course, because a third of nothing is nothing.  But the notion that this lawyer will happily grab a third of whatever pittance is returned to investors, for doing bupkis, hardly makes one a hero.  Leave it to lawyers to find misery and then exploit it yet again.

The Agape investors aren’t the same as the sophisticated major leaguers that were worthy of Bernie Madoff.  They were regular folks, the little league coach, the barbecuing neighbor, the middle-level executive who went to school board meetings.  These are people who worked for their money, and just wanted to do the best with it they could.  A little greedy, perhaps, but not so greedy as to be blameworthy in the process.  Not so greedy as to be unworthy of our sympathy.

Whatever they get back from the marshaled assets that remain will come to them regardless.  A little legal advice would be helpful, as people have an uncanny ability to screw up the simplest of official tasks.  But to crow about the opportunity to grab a third of their recovery isn’t merely tacky, unprofessional and disgraceful.  It’s fundamentally wrong, unethical and tantamount to raping them yet again.  This is nothing to be proud of.

Do Constitutional Rights Have an Expiration Date?

Milk goes sour.  Fish stink.  Nothing lasts forever, right?  So argues Maryland when MIchael Shatzer invoked his right to counsel during interrogation in 2003.  When another cop decided to interrogate Shatzer in 2006, and obtained a signed waiver, the state contends that his earlier invocation had “expired”, allowing the second cop to do a mulligan.  The Supreme Court will now decide the case. 

From the Baltimore Sun :


He appealed on the basis that his statement should be thrown out because he had never been granted an attorney from his earlier request. In August, the Maryland Court of Appeals agreed, with five of seven judges overturning the guilty ruling. Two judges dissented.

“Once a suspect in custody states that they need help from an attorney, then no questioning should take place until they’re provided with an attorney” even if nearly three years have passed, Davis said. “Mr. Shatzer asked for help and never received it.”

Maryland Attorney General Douglas F. Gansler, who plans to argue the case before the high court, said the issue was “ripe for the court’s consideration.”

“There’s been a lot of discussion about what is the length of time permissible here,” he said. “After the defendant invokes the right to counsel, is there an expiration date or is it a lifelong invocation?”

This particular issue is rather close to my heart, having been engaged in a murder case where, 15 years elapsed since the start of my representation until the prosecution decided to take a second stab at it.  Out of the blue came the phone call asking, “do you still represent this guy?”  As it turned out, they had simultaneously sent an officer to ambush and question my client at that moment.  “Why yes,” I responded. “Yes, I do.”  I hadn’t spoken with my client in years, but as far as I was concerned, he remained my client and I remained his lawyer, and nobody, but nobody, was going to question him.

The issue strikes me as facially quite simple.  Once a defendant has invoked his right to counsel, it remains invoked in perpetuity in the absence of an intervening event that changes the situation.  It has nothing to do with the length of time that passes, which has nothing to do with the subject of the interrogation, as he doesn’t chose when a cop comes to chat.  Is he to send the police little notes annually to advise that his invocation remains in full force and effect, just in case they may want another bite? 

Of course, given the facile elimination of rights coming out of Washington lately, it would hardly be shocking if the argument goes awry.  To hold that an invocation of rights last forever seems so . . . so . . . nice to a defendant.  It must be wrong.  It’s no stretch to imagine a decision stating, “Clearly, an invocation of rights cannot last forever and must, at some point, give way to the overarching need of law enforcement to protect the children by testing again whether the subject of an interrogation is willing to answer questions.”  Doesn’t that sound sufficiently judicious? 

But why shouldn’t an invocation of rights last forever?  At the risk of beating a dead horse, the government has no “right” to interrogate individuals.  Rather, the government has authority to do so, subject ot the limitations of the Constitution.  Not a single amendment in the Bill of Rights comes with an expiration date.  A right, once invoked, is a right now, three years from now and thirty years from now.  That police decide to revisit an investigation some day in the future provides no reason to assume that an invocation of rights has waned with the passage of time. 

More to the point, even if the court takes the position that it seems wrong that an invocation of rights lasts forever, what is the conceptual ledge to distinguish a fresh invocation from a stale one?  One year?  Five years?  Why?  What magic happens over what period of time that provides a rational basis to say that a valid invocation yesterday is stale today? 

What I fear most is the potential use of the bogeyman, the “new professionalism” by my fav justice, Nino Scalia.  This is the argument that Miranda is an anachronism, based on the old flat-foot cop image that, per Scalia, has since been replaced with our “new professional” police who would never beat confessions out of suspects.   Clearly, the bad old cops have been replaced by the bad professional new cops.  The argument could then be extended to allow police to “merely make inquiry” of the suspect who previously invoked his right to counsel, to just “find out” if he still feels that way.  I could see this happening very easily.

Of course, the “new professionalism” argument is certainly true in one respect.  Our “new professional” cops are far more sophisticated in the psychological pressures and tricks to obtain statements and confessions than they ever were when their only means of persuasion was a rubber hose.  More effective and nary a bruise.  Now that’s professionalism.

And as long as we’re talking about the invocation of the right to counsel, I would be remiss if I ignored this opportunity to remind every reader that the reason this issue is so critical is that there is nothing one can do that will better serve your interests upon interrogation by police  than to heed the warnings of Miranda:  State clearly and without equivocation that you do NOT want to answer questions and that you DO want to speak with an attorney.  Then stop talking.  In a rational world, this will serve you well for the rest of your life.

The Oscar Grant Punch; Packratt Knew It

For most of us in the blawgosphere, myself included, the biggest risk we take is that we write something foolish or boring, and someone calls us on it.  But there are others who have put themselves on the line to blog, at real personal risk, by chronicling the details of abuse and harm caused by a specific group of police officers.  These cops are not happy about it, and know exactly who is doing it.  One such brave soul is Packratt.

When the murder of Oscar Grant came to light, Packratt was on it.  But unlike others, he saw the punch that preceded the murder that no one else seemed to see.


As I reported on 01/11/09, my analysis of the publicly available BART shooting videos clearly indicated that a second officer could be seen punching Grant in the head prior to the shooting… we published that analysis a full two weeks ago, and finally it seems as though others are reaching the same conclusion that I did, as KTVU reported yesterday.



Photo of a security officer named Tony Pirone taken in 2004 at California’s Lawrence Livermore Labs (pdf) matching the build, facial profile, and hair style of the officer seen in videos punching Grant and kneeling on his neck.


I also argued that it was this same second officer, now identified as officer Tony Pirone by The San Fransisco Chronicle, also appeared to be the same officer who “took a knee” on Grant’s neck while he was laying face-down on the platform which would have caused enough pain to make in involuntarily squirm, which would explain what others are describing as a struggle, when it was clear he was cooperative up to that point.

While I don’t extrapolate from yet another “isolated incident” of a kid being executed that everything in the system is horrible and everyone corrupt, it begs the question of how it’s possible that Officer Tony Pirone has escaped notice in the course of BART cop Johannes Mehserle, the shooter. 

The trend cannot be denied: When cops do wrong, they are taken down a very different path than everyone else in this society, and that path encourages and perpetuates the culture of abuse, corruption and concealment that characterizes the chasm between police and the citizenry of America.

But now that the rest of us have caught up with Packratt, the question is front and center:  What will be done about it?

From all appearances by Alameda Country District Attorney Tom Orloff, the answer is nothing.

Coach Was Wrong, But Was He Criminal?

The death of any young person is tragic by definition.  The death of a young person in the course of football training, a game, is horribly tragic.  But whether that makes the coach who is alleged to have denied his players water criminally liable is an entirely different question, and one that will be addressed in the prosecution of Pleasure Ridge Park, Kentucky, football coach Jason Stinson.

From the WSJ Law Blog :

Not many facts have emerged. But it seems that the coach, David Jason Stinson, was directing practice on August 20, during 94 degree heat, when Gilpin collapsed and was brought to the hospital with a body temperature of 107 degrees. No autopsy was performed, reports the AP, but it appeared Gilpin died from complications from heat stroke, according to the coroner’s office. According to a report on MSNBC, coaches had refused to let players take water breaks.

It’s critical to recognize from the start that the coach’s decision to not let players take water breaks may well be seen as foolish and unreasonable, even though some high school football aficionados might well argue that this is not a game for sissies, and training to play through adversity is part of the deal.  Similarly, it could be argued that no student was forced to practice at gunpoint, and could have walked off the field at any time.  But aside from the unrealistic expectations, that doesn’t absolve an adult, into whose hands people entrust their children, from exercising good judgment.

None of this, however, explains the conversion of this tragedy from negligence to a crime. 


For a brief tutorial on Kentucky’s criminal law and an opinion on the strength of the case against Stinson, we rang U. of Kentucky Law’s Andrea Dennis, a crim law prof. She told us that reckless homicide is the lowest level of criminal culpability in Kentucky. In other states, she says, the same charge might be called negligent homicide or gross negligence. A person acts recklessly, she says, “when he fails to perceive a substantial and unjustifiable risk that the result will occur.” Failure to perceive the risk must be a gross deviation from the standard of care.

Was there a “substantial and unjustifiable risk” involved that the coach failed to perceive?   Andrea Dennis apparently thinks so.


“If it’s true that there was water denied, that strikes me as problematic,” said Dennis, a former defense lawyer. “What we’re talking about is coaches entrusted with the care of children. This kid was 15. And 15 year-olds aren’t always the most cautious people. They want to please their coach and their parents and show off to their teammates. So a reasonable person should know about the limitations of a high school athlete, and should know that a kid might not necessarily ask for water if he’s being told not to.”

While I can’t disagree at all with her assessment of 15 year olds, her discussion has no bearing on whether the risk was substantial and unjustifiable. 

According to this AP story, via Turley, the football players were doing “gassers”, sprints up and down the field.


Sophomore Max Gilpin and his Pleasure Ridge Park teammates spent the tail end of a three-hour practice on a sweltering August day in Louisville running the drill that is a coaching staple across the country, hoping to impress enough to earn varsity playing time that fall.

If “gassers” are a staple of high school football training, how then can Coach Stinson’s use of them constitute a substantial and unjustifiable risk?


They sprinted 12 times in what felt like 94-degree heat, sometimes with helmets and pads, as the coaches pushed them to go harder and harder. It was a drill like those on many high school football fields, until Gilpin, a 6-foot-2, 220-pound offensive lineman, collapsed to the turf just 15 minutes after a teammate went down.

This detail, that another player went down 15 minutes earlier, provides the first glimmer that there was a substantial and unjustifiable risk, and that the coach may have chosen to ignore it. 

Some of the initial “expert” reactions, like Dennis and Jeffrey Toobin,


“If he denied him access to water, that’s really, really serious,” said CNN senior legal analyst Jeffrey Toobin. “I can see the case moving forward.”)

fell short of persuasive, The prosecutor’s explanation was a similarly inept analogy.


The best example I can give you is like someone shooting into a building not knowing anyone is in there, then killing somebody,” Commonwealth’s Attorney R. David Stengel told WHAS. “They didn’t know they were in there, but they should have known that shooting into a building where people normally are is something dangerous.”

This is nothing like shooting a gun into a building on any level, which is the classic explanation for criminal recklessness.  And had the coach simply pushed “gassers” as high school coaches everywhere do, and have done, and will do, in the course of training high school football players, no rational basis would exist for this to be converted into a crime.

But that another player had collapsed, and yet the coach continued to push the ‘gassers”, makes all the difference in the world.

Supporters of the coach talk about what a great person and coach he is.  There’s no reason to doubt that, but being a great person doesn’t mean you didn’t commit a crime.  That Coach Stinson is heartbroken over the death similarly doesn’t change anything.  I’ve no reason to doubt the absolute sincerity of his feelings.  And he may well have pushed the envelope too far when the first player went down, from a civil negligence perspective, but his continued pushing in light of that may well meet the threshold for a “substantial and unjustifiable risk” that he failed to perceive.

Coach Stinson isn’t being charged with a crime because this was a tragedy.  He’s being charged because he ignored the warning that a tragedy was about to happen.  Whether this is enough to convict for a crime is left to judge and jury, but that he’s been charged isn’t as far-fetched as it would otherwise seem.

Another Bad Day at SCOTUS (Update x2)

After the hubbub following the Supreme Court’s Herring decision, and debate as to whether it’s the end of the world or just an acorn falling from an old, ugly, nasty, gnarly oak, we could use a break.  We didn’t get it.

Two decisions issued yesterday, both of which affirm a singular notion: The government is all-powerful.  The individual is dog meat.

Van de Camp v. Goldstein

As previously discussed, this case involved a systemic failure to keep track of the deal of some jailhouse snitch, so that Goldstein, an innocent man who spent 24 years in prison because he was denied Giglio material, never knew that the snitch who testified against him was a liar and was paid off for his testimony.  So he sued the District Attorney under section 1983 for its administrative incompetence in having no mechanism to keep track of the deals it cuts with its snitches. From the syllabus:

Because better training or supervision might prevent most prosecutorial errors at trial, permission to bring suit here would grant criminal defendants permission to bring claims for other trial-related training or supervisory failings. Further, such suits could “pose substantial danger of liability even to the honest prosecutor.” Imbler, 425 U. S., at 425. And defending prosecutorial decisions, often years later, could impose “unique and intolerable burdens upon a prosecutor responsible annually for hundreds of indictments and trials.” Id., at 425–426. Permitting this suit to go forward would also create practical anomalies. A trial prosecutor would remain immune for intentional misconduct, while her supervisor might be liable for negligent training or supervision. And the ease with which a plaintiff could restyle a complaint charging trial failure to one charging a training or supervision failure would eviscerate Imbler. Pp. 8–11.

Yes, it would most assuredly be a burden on prosecutors to be held responsible for their administrative incompetence.  Heck, everybody would like to be able to say, “So what?  I goofed.”  Especially defendants.  We now learn, however, that when it’s the government that “goofs”, such a burden would be “intolerable”.  And why is that?



Moreover, were this claim allowed, a court would have to review the office’s legal judgments, not simply about whether to have an information system but also about what kind of system is appropriate, and whether an appropriate system would have included Giglio-related information about one particular kind of informant. Such decisions—whether made before or during trial—are “intimately associated with the judicial phase of the criminal process,” Imbler, supra, at 430, and all Imbler’s functional considerations apply.


So the “intolerable” part is that the Court fears that it might compel lower courts to become involved in picking out office systems?  Oh, come on.  They need not solve the prosecutions’ administrative issues, but merely determine if they are reasonably effective to fulfill their function.  Beyond that, it’s entirely up to the government to do its job competently. 

The lesson, loud and clear, is that saving prosecutors from responsibility for incompetence is more important than innocent lives or providing incentives for the prosecution to do its job well.  We can joke all we want about our low expectations of government being constantly met, but this really isn’t funny.  It is about the protection of incompetence and failure from scrutiny and responsibility.  It is about the court protecting prosecutors who fail to fulfill their constitutional responsibilities from consequences.  It diminishes our respect for government by embedding the principle that government incompetence and failure is beyond reach.

Arizona v. Johnson

Not that there was much left to protect when it comes to the 4th Amendment and cars, but this decision fills a gap left behind in the destructive wake of Mimms and its progeny.  Here, a car was presumptively lawfully stopped, and an officer engaged a passenger in discussion because he wore a blue bandanna, which she thought to be gang colors.  She then “asked” the passenger to get out of the car, frisked him and found a gun. 

The opinion, written by Justice Ginsburg of all people, slides right down that slippery slope of offering up any hope of physical autonomy to police when a car is involved.  To the extent that one might have thought that a passenger in a car stopped for a traffic violation, might retain some semblance of personal freedom, forget it. 



It is true, the Court acknowledged, that in a lawful traffic stop, “[t]here is probable cause to believe that the driver has committed a minor vehicular offense,” but “there is no such reason to stop or detain the passengers.” Ibid. On the other hand, the Court emphasized, the risk of a violent encounter in a traffic-stop setting “stems not from the ordinary reaction of a motorist stopped for a speeding violation, but from the fact that evidence of a more serious crime might be uncovered during the stop.” Id., at 414. “[T]he motivation of a passenger to employ violence to prevent apprehension of such a crime,” the Court stated, “is every bit as great as that of the driver.” Ibid. Moreover, the Court noted, “as a practical matter,the passengers are already stopped by virtue of the stop of the vehicle,” id., at 413–414, so “the additional intrusion on the passenger is minimal,” id., at 415.


This isn’t a rationale, but a value judgment that holds police officer safety higher than the right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. Because of the possibility that a violent encounter could, theoretically, come from a traffic stop, and because the Court has deemed the need for police officers to control the scene more important than the right of passengers to be free from the “minimal” additional intrusion of a frisk, the Court has nailed down the coffin top good and tight.

The trade-off here is obvious, but less than clear.  What this decision says is that since a passenger in a car lawfully stopped for a traffic infraction is already seized anyway, as in he’s not really free to leave even though he hasn’t done anything wrong whatsoever, subjecting the passenger to a frisk as well just isn’t that big a deal.  Consider that trade-off next time a cop rubs his hands all over your body after stopping you for speeding, just to be sure you’re not packing.

The problem, of course, is that the evisceration of rights by baby steps invariably leads to the evisceration of right.  Sure, each baby step seems like such a little thing when contrasted with the rights already lost, and calling it minimal makes it far more palatable then if the Court were to announce, the People have given up all rights to personal freedom when they get into a car.  That would sound just awful, yet by doing the same thing bit by bit, they’ve arrived at the same place.

So no, yesterday was not a good day at the Supreme Court.  Not a good day at all.

Update:  I’m informed by a reliable source that my posts sound rather morose today, so I’ve decided to try a more positive take.

On Van de Camp, this is great news for prosecutors who need no longer waste valuable time worrying about their liability for incompetence, and can now put that time to better use trying to avoid truly malevolent violations of the Constitution.  Woo hoo!

On Arizona v. Johnson, at least we have a new weapon to assure that cops finish their shift safer than before by protecting against the auto passenger who might pull out a gun.  This is good, as we certainly don’t want to see anyone shot.  And as for cops wives having the hands of other cops touching them all over their bodies because they happened to be a passenger in a car stopped for tinted windows, they can always flash the PBA card that will give them a pass when another cop feels constrained to “cop” a feel of the Missus.  And as long as your wife or daughter isn’t the one getting poked, it really is a minimal intrusion, right?

See how I’ve turned my frown upside down?  Happy now?

Update 2:  From the dark side, Kent at Crime and Consequences offers the prosecutorial perspective on the day at SCOTUS.  He calls it two wins for law enforcement.  It’s a shame that two wins for law enforcement has to come at the expense of two losses for Americans.  But if there was any doubt that there are two sides in the battle, Kent makes it clear that the battle is between cops and prosecutors, on the one hand, and the rest of us on the other.  Odd that the pro-law enforcement side never considers the possibility that it exists and serves for the benefit of the very people it trashes and seeks to subjugate. 

Forces Join to Attack Overcriminalization

Via Walter Olson at Overlawyered, the Heritage Foundation has joined in the effort to put a stop to Congress’ finding a crime under every rock, according to the DC Examiner.  While it’s a truism that politics makes strange bedfellows, it’s heartwarming to see that even groups with such fundamental disagreements as the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers and the uber-conservative Heritage Foundation can join together to attack this danger.

To its great credit, the Heritage Foundation’s purpose is to stave the criminalization of regulatory conduct that was caught up in the “tough on crime” zeal when politicians ran out of real crimes to create.

“Our ultimate goal,” he said, “is to restore the criminal law to what it has traditionally been used for. That is, to protect the public safety and to deal with real crime – and to avoid what has occurred, which is the multiplicity of laws and regulations that carry criminal penalties which have ensnared ordinary, law-abiding citizens in the criminal process for things that nobody would anticipate are actually crimes.”

“What has happened,” he continued, “is that a lot of special interest groups have urged Congress to attach criminal penalties to regulatory legislation to, quote, ‘show its importance.’… Therefore the criminal process is being abused when normal civil proceedings or administrative actions would suffice to protect public health and safety.”

For those doing white collar criminal defense, we realize how bizarre real this has become.  America has a regulation for just about everything.  Often, the regulation has a sound reason for its existence, and is a well-intended effort to protect the public.  The problem is that regulatory violations sometimes result in fines and orders to change procedures, but other times result in criminal prosecutions resulting in extraordinarily harsh prison sentences for people who make a business mistake.  Neither malice, nor even gain, need necessarily be involved.  Some of these prosecutions will blow your mind.  I know that the defendants prosecuted can’t fathom their reality.


There was the case where seafood importers spent eight years in jail because their lobsters were improperly packed in plastic rather than cardboard. “Zero tolerance” policies that land children in jail for making paper guns in school or having small knives in the trunk of their cars on campus after moving some boxes that needed opening. The 61-year-old cancer patient sent to jail because her hedges were too high. Law enforcement run amok, again and again and again.

Most of the public applauds criminalization under the misguided belief that if the government calls something a crime, then a crime it must be and a criminal its perpetrator is.  And every criminal must go to prison.  But the criminalization of these regulatory crimes, utterly malum prohibitum and almost invariably lacking in mens rea, save no one and create a class of “criminal” from businesspeople who do no more than make a mistake.  Yes, harm can sometimes occur as a by-product of a business mistake, but that doesn’t convert the businessman to a criminal unless that was his purpose.  But more often, no harm ensues and the violation is purely technical.  No one is saved, but someone spends years in prison and the upstanding people next door suddenly find themselves a felon’s family.

As the Heritage Foundation says, let’s return criminal law to what it was always meant to be, and stop creating a crime for everything.