Author Archives: SHG

What the Government Has to Hide

The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, has a great post about the comparison between two local prosecutors, one who happily provides the police offense reports to the defense and one who refuses to even let the defense read them until trial.  From an editorial in the Austin American-Statesman, the conclusions to be drawn could not be more clear:


A prosecutor whose sole aim is to see justice is done is unafraid that his adversary may be reading from the same report — after all, an accurate and thorough investigation convicts the guilty and protects the innocent. Unfortunately, maintenance of secret police reports is still the norm in some jurisdictions, such as Williamson County.

This attitude reflects a neurotic insecurity about the talent and skill of its own prosecutors as well as distrust of the honesty and competency of local law enforcement. Worse, it suggests a need to hide police reports to maintain an unfair advantage, a policy elevating conviction rates above the interests of justice.

The juxtaposition of these two approaches brought me immediately to the differences between state and federal prosecutions, and a long-standing argument that has been rejected by federal judges time after time.  In New York State courts, discovery is extremely limited, controlled by statute, but exists.  The law makes provision for a bill of particulars to the indictment, which is routinely granted.

The problem with a state bill of particulars, at least in New York City, is that few prosecutors take it seriously, and almost invariably respond by reference to the “Voluntary Disclosure Form” that is handed out at arraignment.  The form contains some of the particulars, but has a few flaws. 



  • It’s not sufficiently detailed to provide the level of information necessary to prepare a defense against the accusation. 
  • It often contains erroneous information, and judges routinely ignore this defect when time comes for trial and the details turn out contrary to what was disclosed. 
  • And the form often provides that the prosecutor will turn over materials that he’s obliged to turn over “at a mutually agreeable time.” 

Well, that time is upon demand, and there’s nothing in the statute that provides that the ADA has to find it agreeable.  More to the point, actually getting the disclosure from the ADA is like pulling teeth.  And again, judges avoid involvement like the plague, neglecting their duty to compel the prosecution to comply with their statutory obligations.  The VDF has become an institution in itself, too often used to stone-wall discovery than provide it.

But as bad as state court discovery is, it looks downright fair in comparison to federal.  Rule 16 turnover is the legal equivalent to pump and dump, where the government will provide you with a million pages of garbage and leave it to you to sift through the dreck to find the one page of discovery that actually matters.  This isn’t an accident.

Worse still, the discovery doesn’t come cheap.  The offer is to see it at the United States Attorney’s office or to pay 25 cents a page for a private company to copy it for you.  By the way, the copy business for government disclosure is the best game in town.  If you get a chance to do it, you will, without a doubt, get rich.

None of this, however, provides a clue as to what the government is basing its prosecution on.  The theory, the evidence, the attack is often a huge mystery, leaving a defendant to wonder what he will meet at trial.  While there is a theoretical potential for a bill of particulars, you would think the judges have to pay for it themselves by how rarely one is permitted. 

The argument is that the government would be unduly prejudiced if required to disclose its theory of prosecution.  My argument in response has always been, “how can the government be prejudice by disclosing the truth?”  It’s been rejected time after time.

Of course, the prejudice is that the government would lose its advantage of denying the defendant a chance to prepare.  We can’t have that.  If the defendant knew what the government’s theory was, he might win.  That would ruin everything.

So our big, bad government, with all its money and might, with its army of Special Agents, with its favorable institutional bias, with its access to our inner-most thoughts and acts, is still so afraid of criminal defense lawyers and thinks so poorly of its AUSAs that it must conceal everything possible lest the defendant be given a fighting chance. 

Maybe the government should consider some therapy to address that “neurotic insecurity?”

Caveat:  While this is generally the case in New York City, your mileage may vary.  Some AUSAs and ADAs provide great discovery, happily and in the finest tradition of the prosecutorial function.  These are the ones who are respected for their integrity.  They may play hard, but they play fair.  That’s all we ask.

The Lawyer Rat (Update)

Bobby Frederick at South Carolina Criminal Defense Blog posts about a dirty Ohio lawyer who decided to take it to new depths.  From the Akron Beacon Journal, the story of Frank Pignatelli.

According to court records, Pignatelli was facing his own indictment as a co-conspirator when he agreed to work undercover for federal drug investigators more than three years ago.

With Pignatelli’s help, federal agents have arrested 30 people from Akron and Cleveland, and seized hundreds of pounds of marijuana and cocaine, along with cash and property totaling more than $3 million.

Many of the charges have led to convictions, which could not have happened without the former Akron lawyer’s help, attorneys said.

It is, quite plainly, about as inconceivably ruinous to the integrity of the criminal justice system for a person masquerading as a criminal defense lawyer to use the information obtained to rat people out.  I say “masquerading” as a rat cannot, by definition, be a criminal defense lawyer.  It would be a contradiction in terms.  He can wear the suit, talk the talk, but he cannot be a lawyer, no less a criminal defense lawyer.  It isn’t possible.

That Pignatelli became embroiled in his clients’ conspiracy isn’t exactly shocking.  Criminal defense lawyers have long found themselves around huge amount of proceeds, tempted by the allure of easy wealth and willing to sell their souls to enjoy it with their clients.  Most lawyers realize the line between lawyer and defendant and scrupulously honor.  A few, like Pignatelli, cross it, and they should face the consequences.

But there is no place horrific enough in the bowels of hell for the soul of a lawyer who would flip on his clients to save his sorry criminal butt.  Then again, as he’s already made the choice to sell his soul for a pile of cash, he’s lost any hope of integrity and the step to being a rat is a small one in comparison. 

But what of the government’s use of this scum-lawyer’s information?  Regardless of the lawyer-turned-criminal rationalization, which serves well to impugn the lawyer, it offers no consolation to the defendant who engages the lawyer, speaks to the lawyer, places his faith and trust in the lawyer, because he’s a lawyer.  How is the defendant’s privilege changed by the lawyer’s descent into crime? 

The article offers no explanation or discussion of this issue, and aside from the argument that it’s Pignatelli, not the government, who violated privilege, none comes to mind.  The flaw with this facile rationale is that it is not the lowest of lawyers who is the last defender of the privilege, but the Court.  The court is the stop-gap when the lawyer does wrong, and steps in to protect the integrity of the system when the lawyer fails.  Where is the court on all this?  Why is the court allowing the government to use Pignatelli’s privileged information?  There’s no answer given.

To add insult to injury, Bobby concludes on a painful note. 


According to the article, he is now practicing . . . federal criminal defense?


Pignatelli’s law license in Ohio is inactive. He works as an attorney in Denver, a private practice that includes defending alleged drug dealers in federal court.

Such a good rat, Pignatelli was never indicted for his conduct and instead was left to ply his trade elsewhere.  I bet he wanted to get far away from Ohio very quickly.  Very quickly indeed.  Of course, Colorado should now be aware of this fine attorney in its midst, and hopefully the local defendants will learn what type of person this faux-lawyer Pignatelli is and conduct themselves accordingly.

The Beacon Journal reporter tried to interview Pignatelli, but he “declined comment.”  Suddenly, he doesn’t want to talk.

Update:  Bennett adds another dimension to the Pignatelli story when he asks, what kind of schmuck would hire Frank Pignatelli?  He cuts Pignatelli more slack than I would (or do), by allowing for the possibility that he wasn’t really dirty and just “got spooked,” a possibility that is both too far-fetched and precluded by the fact that he was never prosecuted because he turned snitch as fast as he could to be worthy of serious consideration, but could be true under the “pigs could fly” theory.  In any event, Bennett’s point is worthy of reiteration.  If a client thinks a lawyer who plays dirty is a good thing, let Pignatelli remind them that a dirty lawyer will play dirty for the other team as well. 

One final note: The possibility also raised is that Pignatelli didn’t give up privileged information, but only information obtained during the course of his own commission of crime.  While this flies in the face of the “just got spooked” theory, since then he didn’t commit crimes and only gave up his clients, it’s a hair-splitting argument at best.  Pignatelli wasn’t accused of committing crimes independent of his law practice, but as a part of his representation.  He wasn’t going out on the street to snatch chains during lunch, but helping his clients buy stash houses. 

The fact that Pignatelli went over the line doesn’t change the fact that his clients thought their discussions with him were privileged because he was their lawyer.  The clients aren’t responsible for Pignatelli’s crossing the line, and their confidences aren’t waived because of Pignatelli’s choices.  Nope, there’s no credible way to explain away this one. 

First Impression of The Lextweet Reflection

Kevin O’Keefe is always on the hunt for the next big thing, and what to do about it.  His latest creation is Lextweet, billed as means to “follow legal community members who use Twitter to discuss the law and much more.”  As Kevin is thrilled to say, the Lextweet community has grown enormously in the few weeks it’s been in existence, both by people chosing to join and Kevin’s inclusion of known members of the community to get the ball rolling.  And rolling it is.

Being one of those highly ambivalent twitterers, Lextweet seemed to offer a valuable service, a way to see what other lawyers were twitting about without having to follow them, and thus suffer the crash of a zillion twits in order to check out the handful that I cared to receive.  It was a matter of both time and interest, and Lextweet provided a mechanism to check out the broader legal twittersphere without commitment.

Though still a work in progress, Lextweet seems to do exactly what it should.  Pull it up and there we are, lawyer twits galore.  Twits from lawyers I don’t know, never heard of, recognize, care about.  Twits about lawyer’s aunt’s midlife crises.  Twits about lawyer’s lunch meat.  Twits about important blog posts and breaking news.  Twits, twits and more twits.

Indeed, if you look at the sidebar, you see that twitterers are judges by the number of their followers.  Yet another affection of keeping score by irrelevant numbers, but one that permeates the blawgosphere as well as twitter, so hardly surprising.  I don’t think this is a good measure of twitter success, but the numbers show that tends of thousand of people disagree with me and desperately want to “win” the game by accumulating followers.  Whatever turns them on.

There are some issues, naturally.  The “legal community” is not, as some would expect, limited to lawyers.  There are those who live in the ancillary world, whether interested in the law, involved in the law or marketing to the law.  If you think this is the twitter version of a lawyer listserv, you will be disappointed.  It’s full of non-lawyer stuff, which is no doubt why Kevin included the “and much more” language.  But then, the is a forum for twits by the legal community, not vetted by legal content and interest.  Kevin provides the mechanism, and we provide the twits.

Another problem is that it doesn’t update automatically, though it would seem that if it did the twits would whiz by so quickly that it would all appear a blur.  On the other hand, when you refresh the page to see what’s new, the original top post may end up on page 3, making it a lot of work to keep abreast.  Again, a problem, but unlikely to be one that is solvable by Kevin, since he doesn’t control how many twits per second come out of the legal community.

But the biggest issue has nothing to do with Lextweet at all.  The vast majority of twits are, how do I say this nicely, worthless to the general lawyer audience.  Nothing personal, but intimate details of your personal hygiene don’t interest me.  I don’t know your family (I don’t even know you) so it’s really of little concern what they’re having for breakfast.  But this is what people twit about, and what shows up on Lextweet whether it matters or not.

There’s no fault to be placed for the fact that lawyers twit about ordinary stuff along with the legal stuff.  It’s their twitter too, and they can twit about anything they want.  But since it’s getting picked up on Lextweet, and disseminated to the broader audience of the legal community, it creates a huge clutter for those who are looking for twits of legal interest, and may give the false appearance that some lawyer, who’s minding their own business having a nice twitter chat with a friend, is having that chat rebroadcast to the nationwide legal community.  This likely isn’t what they had in mind when discussing their favorite brand of baby formula.  And they are allowed to discuss that without having to explain the issue to lawyers nationwide.

Finally, there’s one additional piece that was striking about Lextweet.  Some lawyers who are twitting about legal topics, and most often by twitting a link or retwitting a post, should consider that their twits on Lextweet shoot far beyond their list of followers, to an array of lawyers they don’t know and who don’t know them.  Reputations are built and destroyed based on impressions, and impressions are made by what you think is content worth distributing.  If you twit that something is “great”, and it’s grossly simplistic, wrong, old and obvious, whatever, then you’ve just branded yourself to a swathe of lawyers as a dolt.

Some, perhaps many, twit rather mindlessly, apparently believing that it’s better to be a constant twitterer than to be selective about your twits.  I think most of us can blow past the baby formula posts without it influencing our ideas about someone, but it’s a lot harder to ignore a substantive twit that shows you’re anything but substantive.  Of course, this is a truism, so should come as no surprise.

All in all, I think Kevin’s got a winner here, in that it provides a huge service that alleviates the pressure to follow a bunch of people you don’t know and likely would clog up the twitterworks.  Now if there was a way to effectively filter the non-legal and  marketing pieces out, so that we can choose to see the lawyer twits and let people have their baby formula twitversations in private, Lextweet would be a killer. 

To the extent that Lextweet has issues, it’s not so much a reflection of Lextweet, but a reflection of us.  If you want to enjoy lawyerly twittering, then twit like a lawyer.  If you want to twit about lunch meat, don’t complain that others do so as well.

The Rush to Kill (Update)

Another execution scheduled in Texas.  A claim of actual innocence, bolstered by four experts.  A prosecutor who responds that it’s “only opinion.”  A court that rejects the habeas corpus petition on procedural grounds (only one per customer).

From Grits for Breakfast and Talkleft comes Larry Swearingen’s long walk.  He’s convicted for the 1998 rape-murder of a Montgomery County, Texas, coed.  Put aside your shock that the death penalty in Texas hasn’t deterred people from committing rapes, murders or rape-murders.  The fact remains that executions are still considered a parlor game, enjoyed by true-blue Texans and subject only to the ridicule of outsiders like me,  I’ve been told before that a New Yorker has no business criticizing Texas.  Unfortunately, Texas remains a nominal part of the Union, so I can’t just ignore it.

I take no position on the validity of the science behind the four pathologists who are of the view that Swearingen was in jail at the time the crime was committed, thus precluding any possibility of guilt.  From the  Austin American-Statesman :

The four include the medical examiner whose testimony helped secure Swearingen’s guilty verdict. That medical examiner now says college student Melissa Trotter’s curiously preserved body could not have lain in the East Texas woods for more than 14 days — and probably was there for a much shorter time.

The results mean Swearingen was in jail [on traffic warrants] when the 19-year-old’s body was left behind, the pathologists say.

In short, the state’s pathologist, who testified that the body had been in the woods for 25 days, which coincidentally happened to be the exact amount of time she had been missing, was scientifically wrong.  Even so, prosecutors are unconvinced.


Prosecutors disagree, saying compelling evidence ties Swearingen to the crime, including a match between the panty hose leg found around Trotter’s neck and the stocking remnant found in a trash dump next to Swearingen’s mobile home. Also, hair and fibers show Trotter had been in Swearingen’s truck and mobile home in Willis, about 40 miles north of Houston.

Slightly short of compelling evidence perhaps, but evidence nonetheless.  So here’s the question: Why wouldn’t the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals prefer to figure out whether this guy is innocent before executing him?


Thus far, only the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals has seen the opinions from the four forensic pathologists.


The state’s highest criminal court, however, did not rule or comment on the information. Instead, the court dismissed Swearingen’s petition for violating state laws that limit death row inmates to one petition for a writ of habeas corpus unless lawyers uncover information that was not available when the first appeal was filed.

Can’t you just hear a judge muttering to herself, “rules are rules, ya know.”  And it’s far more important to the integrity of the system that we adhere to the rules than execute an innocent man?  I wouldn’t want to take a vote in Texas on the issue.

But perhaps even the bluest of true-blue execution enthusiasts can agree that it would be a pretty good idea to hear this evidence out, which may conclusively prove that this traffic-warrant scoundrel is not a raping murderer?  Maybe, just maybe, there might be an iota of concern about the fact that if he didn’t do it, the raping murderer is still walking around Montgomery County. 

Is the Republic of Texas really in that much of a rush to put Larry Swearingen to death that it can’t decide first if he’s innocent?  Come on, Texans.  Watch an old CSI episode next Tuesday.  Someone else will be executed soon enough to make you happy.

Update:  Swearingen’s execution  has been stayed by the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals.  Notably, it wasn’t stayed by the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals.

The System Works Just Fine, Thank You Very Much

Another voice chimed in on the discussion of whether it was advantageous to work both sides of the fence before deciding where to spend the rest of your life, defense or prosecution.  I wasn’t aware of it until I received an email from Bennett asking me what I thought. My reaction was that I thought it called for a post.

Prosecutor Tom McKenna, at his ironically-named  Seeking Justice blog, decided that it was his job to judge Bennett.  His verdict?  Guilty!  Bennett was indicted for naiveté. He committed the offense of expecting the criminal justice system to fulfill the function demanded of it.  McKenna scoffed:


What’s truly remarkable about this oft-encountered sentiment (encountered amongst defense-oriented blogs, anyway) is how little understanding it reveals of what the system IS (never mind the mastubatory, self-congratulatory, revolutionary chic rhetoric).

News flash: we live in a world full of imperfection and sin. This encompasses both the criminals and the flawed people who run “The System.”

It’s the face-off of cynicism and idealism.  The defense doesn’t “get it.”


But if one understands that the system itself impliedly allows for the potential of a certain number of innocent people being convicted (by not demanding a standard of “absolute proof” or “proof to a metaphysical certitude”) then it can be understood that the system is no way broken simply because some very small number of mistaken convictions occur.

In sum, we do not, and have never had, a system that adopts the old saying of Blackstone, “better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer” in the sense that we fashion our system to be absolutely infallible in assigning guilt. There is, in effect, a built-in error rate inherent in the process.

It’s not that McKenna is alone in that fact that he’s perfectly comfortable with the idea of factually innocent people being convicted.  My old train buddy Mike always said, “somebody has to take one for the team,” though he was clear that it shouldn’t be anybody he cared about.  That would be unjust.  Mike knew the price of everything, by the way.

In an odd way, McKenna’s perspective is completely understandable.  If he had integrity, he wouldn’t be able to sleep at night, which would render him a very tired prosecutor.  You see, it’s hard to be part of a system that fails.  Day in and out, we toil toward an end, knowing that some will wrongfully suffer no matter what we do.  As much as we care, our heads would explode if we couldn’t find a way to deal with the harsh reality and still go back to work the next day. 

For both prosecutors and defense lawyers, the saving grace is the belief that we must keep trying to do better, despite the system.  At least for most of us.  Not Tom McKenna.  He’s just fine with some collateral damage, because he “gets it.”  The difference is that he knows better than to succumb to the idealistic platitudes of Blackstone (and the millenia of other voices) expressing a vision of a system that prefers to let a guilty man go free rather than suffer collateral damage.  That’s for fools and children, according to McKenna.  It happens, and he’s okay with that.  It’s not that he wants it to happen, but only a fool like Bennett would call that a broken system.


While no one wants to see an innocent person convicted (and thankfully the error rate is extremely low), society has seen fit for a very long time to risk the small error rate, rather than create a system that would release many more factually guilty offenders and create very little deterrence for criminals. That there is much dissatisfaction with “The System” among defense lawyers is not surprising… no one likes losing a lot, and defense attorneys frankly lose a lot.

What is more disturbing is the approaching loss of public confidence that “The System” convicts and adequately incarcerates enough of the guilty

McKenna is quite right about his claim that the public thinks the system doesn’t incarcerate enough of the guilty.  After all, imprisoning a full 1% leaves another 99% free.  Having the highest incarceration rate in the world isn’t good enough.  After decades of being told that crime is rampant and instilling a sense of fear amongst the populace, who can blame them for wanting everyone they don’t know, or who just generally annoys them, to be incarcerated.  McKenna also knows the price of everything, just like my buddy Mike.

But he’s wrong about the innocents, and his claims are vapid.  He also assumes blindly accepts imprisonment is the cure for anyone who has broken the rules.  But most of all, he’s wrong in his denial our nation was founded upon principles, and they aren’t up for grabs by every two-bit prosecutor who thinks that basic American principles are a joke. 

If Tom McKenna rejects the notion that it’s better for a guilty man to go free than for an innocent man to be convicted, then he rejects America.  And he has no business stepping foot in a courtroom, and certainly no business being a prosecutor, whose duty is to do justice.  So Bennett is idealistic.  Me too.  But McKenna is a threat to American principles, and I’ll take idealism over a threat any day.

Gillibrand Takes Manhattan

When Governor David Paterson named Kirsten Gillibrand as New York’s junior Senator, I received an email asking what I thought of the selection.  I said, “who?”  I was still pondering Caroline Kennedy’s sudden withdrawal from consideration when this struck.  It’s a big state, and it’s hard to know everyone.  But being tagged as Senator is pretty big, so it seemed that it should be someone with whom there was some general familiarity.

Kirsten Gillibrand, the Democratic congresswoman from the 20th District, was elected in 2006. Gov. David A. Paterson selected her to fill the United States Senate seat vacated by Hillary Rodham Clinton.

Ms. Gillibrand comes from a politically sophisticated family: her father was an attorney and lobbyist with ties to George Pataki; her grandmother was a prominent Democratic activist in Albany who brought Ms. Gillibrand along with her on the campaign trail.

The sprawling 20th Congressional District of New York clamps around the Albany metro area and includes much of the Hudson Valley—the grand river south of Albany and the smaller river, freshly fed by the Adirondacks, to the north.

Aha!  The old sprawling 20th.  What was I thinking?  An interesting district, comprised of 27 farmers, some cows and a goat.  The perfect pool from which to pluck a one-term congresswoman with top-notch NRA credentials.

Caroline Kennedy, lack of experience aside, has long been a respected participant in the affairs of New York.  Experienced in government?  No.  Experienced in dealing with the upper echelons of power?  Quite.  Respected? Very.  And with the high profile that one would come to expect from a Senator of the State of New York.

It’s not that New York is too good, too important, to have an off-brand Senator.  It’s just that they don’t get the job without having to put themselves on the line by running for the post in a general election.  By definition, when one is done with a statewide election for Senator, we know who you are. 

When I first heard the news, visions of Sarah Palin popped into my head. The surprising unknown quantity, sprung on us about 12 second after Caroline ditched.  A quickie choice to replace a last-minute pull out, without time for serious reflection.  Someone without breadth of knowledge about the State (as if Hillary was a dyed-in-the-wool New Yorker). 

I read that she was a conservative Democrat.  Smart, a good campaign money-raiser, a security’s lawyer.  She was pro-gun, but also for restrictions.  She spoke out in favor of gay marriage, alarming to most of the cows in her district.  And she had one term in Congress, meaning she had yet to get the juice to dole out any serious money yet.  Not much to go on, really.

My initial reaction was that Paterson should have appointed someone with a far higher profile, whose name would mean something to New Yorkers, whose background was known, who reflected the level of prominence we hope for in a Senator.  My sense was that Paterson’s running for Governor, and wanted to buy some upstate love.

But on the other hand, New York has had a history of show pony Senators, always available for a press conference or photo op, and particularly adept at quotable statements.  Heck, we elected Hillary, who needed a map to find her way to her Chappaqua home. 

Maybe Kirsten Gillibrand is an excellent choice, and the fact that we don’t have a clue who she is means that we just haven’t come to appreciate her yet.  One of her first adventures was to hold Chuck Schumer’s hand and go to Sylvia’s in Harlem.  Smart move, though she should have eaten there instead of just kissing babies.  But an interesting exchange happened during the visit:


Ms. Gillibrand answered questions from reporters after her speech at Mr. Sharpton’s headquarters, but it was a question from a man in the audience about Sean Bell that provided an awkward moment. The man asked her if she thought the police shooting deaths of Mr. Bell, Amadou Diallo and Oscar Grant III — a young, unarmed black man shot and killed by a transit officer in Oakland, Calif., on New Year’s Day — were murders.

“I think each of the cases were terrible instances of things we need to right in our community, and I think that your concern and your anger and your outrage is valid, important and just,” Ms. Gillibrand replied.

The man pushed further, asking her again if she thought the shooting deaths were crimes and if she had seen the videotape of Mr. Grant’s shooting, which has been shown on Internet and news sites. “Based on the videotape, it looked like a crime to me,” she said.

Only two tries, and she answered the question.  The first response was the politician’s.  The second response was the human’s.  So there is a human being inside there.  That’s important to know.

It may not be a bad thing for New York to have a new Senator without a household name.  Someone who’s position isn’t based on family prominence.  Someone who can respond like a real person with only a minimum of prodding.  Maybe she hasn’t been soiled by life in politics, always concerned about how the public will react to her words rather than what she has to say.  Politics ruins people, and they’ve usually been through a lot of it before they’re allowed inside the Senate Chamber.  Is she our Mr. Smith?

It’s too early to draw any conclusions about Kirsten Gillibrand, although this will be a very telling choice for David Paterson’s political future.  If she turns out to be the Senator New York needs, even though she’s brand-X, then he’s brilliant.  As for me, I would be happy if she turns out to be a real person, with actual beliefs and the willingness to reason.  If she is, we’ll learn her name and she’ll deserve her appointment.




 

Joe Bruno, Politician

In the triumvirate that controls New York State, there was no one more powerful than Joe Bruno.  As leader of the Republican controlled State Senate, with a Republican governor, he was the sphincter of New York government.  Nothing passed without his approval.

But even rulers need some walking around money, and Joe Bruno was no exception.  From the AP :



Joseph Bruno, the former majority leader of the New York Senate and for a time the most powerful Republican in state politics, was indicted Friday on federal corruption charges.


Bruno, who retired from the Legislature in July after more than a dozen years leading the Senate, is accused of using his position to steer contracts and grants to businesses that paid him a total of $3.2 million in consulting fees or other compensation from 1993 through 2006.


Bruno exploited “his official position for personal compensation and enrichment” in dealing with companies and 16 unions with business before the state, according to the 8-count indictment brought by the U.S. attorney for the Northern District of New York.


Bruno has yet to be proven to have committed any crime.  But when you’ve got the power that rested in Joe Bruno’s hands, a nod, a wink, even just a glance, would be sufficient to make huge corporations crumble to his perceived will.  New York spends a lot of money, and the good graces of Joe Bruno is something that any enterprising business would desire.

If Joe Bruno enjoyed the benefits of power, he did so because we have a government that promotes such abuse.  Our Senators and Assemblyman are “part-timers,” paid a pittance and expected to dole out twice as much working just the charity circuit in their districts.  We’ve allowed two chamber leaders to maintain their iron-clad control over their worker bees, making their whims the stuff of fortunes for anyone doing business with the state, or an agenda to promote. 

And who can blame a person with an ego large enough to want to be an elected official for wanting to enjoy a bit of financial independence?  Hey, they pal around with other powerful people.  Would you want to be the only person on the block without a $6,000 shower curtain?  How humiliating.

Did Joe Bruno have to do much to “exploit” his position as majority leader to get people to throw cash at his feet?  I would imagine he wouldn’t have to do anything.  Nothing at all.  They would throw that money at him no matter what he said or did.  I bet that they would throw that money at him even if he told them not to.  He was the sphincter of New York government, and everybody knew it.  There was nothing he could do to stop those who wanted influence from throwing money his way.

If he actively caused people to throw him the loot, then perhaps he has committed crimes and exploited his office for personal gain.  If it just worked out that way, perhaps he’s done nothing more wrong than simply being Joe Bruno, the sphincter.

But if this indictment puts a sour taste in ones mouth, then don’t blame Joe Bruno.  Somebody has to be the majority leader of the New York State Senate, and she’s going to enjoy the perks of office whether she wants to or not.  Change the system that provides the incentive for this to happen.  The positions should be full-time, appropriately compensated, and held to a strictly enforced ethical code that prohibits outside compensation rather than encourages it.

This isn’t a Joe Bruno problem as much as it’s a New York problem.  When we refuse to increase the salaries for our legislators, we invite others to fill the gap.  If you find that unsavory, then change it.

First Night on the Rock

Rikers Island holds a number of detention facilities, affectionately aggregated under the name of “The Rock.”  When someone is arrested in Manhattan, they will spend about 24 hours awaiting an opportunity to go before a judge for arraignment.  They will start out in a precinct holding cell, be transferred to Central Booking and ultimately find themselves in a large holding cell in the bowels of 100 Centre Street, until brought to one of the two arraignment courtrooms.

Most defendants walk out of the courtrooms through the back doors.  Some do not, whether because they are deemed to require custody or simply can’t make the “nominal” bail that a criminal court judge decides they should pay.  As if $500 means the difference between fleeing to one’s Bahamas manorhouse or returning to court.  From the courthouse, many will be taken to Rikers Island to await their next court appearance.

Via Turley and the Daily News, another dirty little secret from Rikers slips out.


Correctional Officers Michael McKie, Khalid Nelson and Denise Albright have been arrested on charges that they organized a fight club of inmates called “The Program.” Using teen enforcers called “The Team,” they allegedly oversaw a system of beatings, extortion, and terror at Rikers prison in New York. They even allegedly held classes on how to beat prisoners to leave as few marks as possible.

Ah, Rikers.  Ah, corrections officers.  Ah, jailhouse beatings.  Rarely are they so well organized, but they have always been with us.

The career path to criminal court judge usually goes like this:  Law student  –>  assistant district attorney –> criminal court judge.  Chances are that they’ve never sat with the wife or mother of a defendant who was beaten at Rikers.  Chances are that they’ve never talked to some nice suburban kid who got popped for selling pot in Washington Square Park and was confronted by a crew from 169th and St. Nicholas at Rikers who decided that they liked his sneakers. 

When they make the decision to impose bail, do they think about how the person will fare in a jail like Rikers?  Whether he’s done something wrong or not, whether he will ultimately be convicted and go to prison or not, they have condemned the defendant to experience the world of Rikers.  Some don’t get it.  Some don’t care.  Some rationalize their decisions by saying, “that’s just they way it goes.”

It’s bad enough when a street kid from uptown is thrown into this world.  Many feel no sympathy toward them, calling them “thugs” or “gangbangers”, and thus dismissing the wrong because these human beings are unworthy of their concern.  But these kids at least know how to handle themselves in a fight.  Softer people are helpless.  Nothing in their lives prepares them for a night on the Rock.

I’ve long believed that every young man and woman who becomes an assistant district attorney should be required to take off their fancy lawyer clothes and put on a saggy jeans or a jumpsuit and spend a few days in Rikers.  They should experience the world to which they glibly condemn others.  They should possess the knowledge they attribute to themselves, but for real rather than through the stories of cops and prosecutor lore. 

How many of them would survive a night on the Rock?  How many of them would survive “The Program?”  Let them bring this experience with them as they sit at arraignments, doling out $500 bail to people too poor to eat.  Before they condemn these “innocent” defendants to Rikers, they should appreciate the consequence of their flippant decisions.

Free Stuff

Simple Justice is a blog.  Read it if you want. Or not.  It’s here for the reading, should you so desire.  And best of all, it’s free.  If you enjoy it, or find it helpful or interesting, that’s great.  If you don’t, at least it didn’t cost you anything.

Other sources of news and commentary charge for the pleasure of reading.  That’s necessary, as they provide a different service.  Whether news gathering or reliable source of data and information, they need to pay people to do it and charge people to read it so they have money to pay the people who do it.  It’s a perfectly reasonable model.  But the models two are distinct. 

I frequently receive requests to do essays and Op-Eds for publications that charge their readers, and I appreciate receiving those requests.  Most of the time, I’m happy to write the pieces they seek.  But if they charge their readers, then I expect to be paid for my writing.  Most papers pay Op-Ed writers.  Some negligible amounts, and others fairly well, but they have no expectation that they can ask someone to create without compensation the content that they put in their periodicals and sell.

A few, however, do.  They send very sweet emails or letters or call on the phone, and very nicely ask that for the creation of a piece that they would “really, really” like to publish.  They flatter.  They explain that thousand of people will read it and be so very impressed with my thoughts.  They tell me how wonderful it will be for me to receive such recognition, and how very important I will be for having a say in their prestigious publication. 

In response, I ask two questions:  Do you charge for your publication.  If so, what are you offering to pay me for the piece.

Silence.  Well, we don’t pay lawyers for Op-Eds, they explain.  It’s never clear to me if it’s just lawyers, or they don’t pay anybody, but the implication is clear.  They want to make money selling papers, and they believe that lawyers will always be available to provide them with free content, with which they can fill their pages.

Sorry, I reply.  I write Simple Justice for free.  You have to pay. 

People come here all the time and make demands or requests of me.  PR flaks want to hype their latest client.  Anonymous commenters demand that I prove something to them.  Newbie bloggers want a spot on my blogroll, or worse still, a chance to “guest blog” about themselves.  Businesses selling toilet paper want me to put a badge to their website on the sidebar.  Everybody wants something.

Every morning, I crawl out of bed, make coffee and read the news.  If something strikes me, I write about it.  If there’s something on my mind that I feel is worth putting on a computer screen, I write about it.  If there’s a conversation going on around the blawgosphere that interests me, I join in.  But that’s as far as it goes.

Not every post is going to show a glimmer of brilliance.  Some may be fairly awful.  It happens.  Since I’m not here to please anybody, I can live with it.  If someone reads a post and feels that they’ve wasted their time, they don’t get a refund.  Someone once posted a comment to the effect of “that’s five minutes of my life I’ll never get back.”  Screw you.  I banned the jerk.  He violated my “no assholes” rule.

At the moment, there are some desperate people in the blawgosphere.  They are hyping themselves and their “product” unmercifully.  Shamelessly.  It’s glaringly obvious.  It’s painfully sad.  Their friends in the blawgosphere are pushing the hype, like the rule of thumb for an old-time con game: One lies and the other swears to it.  There are many in the blawgosphere who are too young to know how old-time con games operate.  They believe because they don’t know better.  They too are obvious, but they deny it because they don’t realize how they are being taken in by the scam.  Or perhaps they are willing participants because they want to be loved in the blawgosphere.  Collecting support has become the measure of success, even if it has no meaning.

Keeping score in the blawgosphere is very important for some.  Whether it’s winning an award, or being on someone’s “best of” list, or one of the hundred rankings available.  Recognition fills some human need to know that there’s someone out there who cares.  Most of the blawgosphere is totally hung up on recognition, to the exclusion of substance.  It’s just not enough to write a blog for the sake of writing a blog. 

For many, it’s the self-promotion.  Some bloggers tell tall tales about their prowess, their importance, to scam potential clients into believing their great lawyers and great humanitarians.  Some are bald-faced liars.  I don’t like liars.  Yet other bloggers will believe anything written, and I’ve actually had people who will seize upon a lie and argue that it is absolutely true because someone said so.  As I said, there are many young, naive people in the blawgosphere who want so much to be loved that they will accept anything.

My reach extends only as far as this blog.  I write the truth as I believe it to be.  Others will disagree with me, and I’m okay with that.  At my age, I realize that reasonable people differ and my “manhood” isn’t on the line every time someone challenges me.  Believing is seeing, and I may well see things differently than others.  Value judgments color our understanding, and I don’t begrudge others their values, but won’t let others interfere with mine.  That said, I still have little tolerance for jerks, and there are many.

So Simple Justice is what I do in the mornings while drinking my cup(s) of coffee.  It’s received a good measure of recognition, and I appreciate that, even though I think that it’s fairly silly.  I would probably receive far more recognition if I sucked up to others, kissing butt and “supporting” friends even when I disagree or think something is vapid.  I think much of the blawgosphere is banal and insipid.  I think many blogs demonstrate the lack of intellectual depth of their authors.  Some are facially dishonest.  Sometimes I say so.  This is not what Dale Carnegie would do.

I’m tiring of the exertions in some parts of the blawgosphere.  I’m growing increasingly uncomfortable with my surroundings, the hyping and lying and intellectual wasteland that the blawgosphere has become.  I’m disturbed that lawyers are too willing to use the blawgosphere as a street corner, where they stand in hot pants hoping to attract the next comer. 

I have no doubt that those lawyers who see the blawgosphere as the lure for their next meal ticket would be happy to write Op-Eds for publications that charge their readers for the pleasure.  But then, the publications don’t ask you to write for them, do they?  That’s the irony.  Think about it.  I hope you don’t sprain anything.

Simple Justice is free.  If you like it and read it, great.  If it’s not your cup of tea. that’s fine too.  But this is all I’m offering for free, folks, and if it’s not good enough for you, then there’s a big blawgosphere out there, filled with lawyers who will show you far more love than you will find here.  Go for it.

Epilogue:  It’s early on a Saturday morning as I write.  The place if quiet.  I tend to think indulgent thoughts on weekend mornings, and often end up putting them in writing.  Some will see themselves in this post, while those who should probably won’t.  There is a substantial group of bloggers who take issue with what an even larger group of bloggers do and say.  They tend to dislike my indulgent posts because they feel guilty about using
the blawgosphere for hype and lies.  Not badly enough to stop doing so. 

My indulgent posts remind them that some of us know what they are doing, even if they can pull their scam off on others.  No one likes the fact that others know about the scam.  They want to pretend that they have concealed it well, that they’ve gotten away with it.  They haven’t, and I write these posts to make sure they know.

If all of this sounds like gibberish to you, then you aren’t sufficiently engaged in the blawgosphere to appreciate why this post is written.  I would tell you to go read something less involved with the internal workings of the blawgosphere, but you’ve made it this far and it’s too late.  Have a great weekend.

The Weakest Link in the Corporate Chain of Criminal Liability

For some of us, the very notion of corporate criminal liability doesn’t seem to make a great deal of sense.  Corporations are fictitious entities, existing because law says they do.  They don’t think or breath.  They don’t “do” anything. That includes committing crimes.  It’s not that individuals within corporations don’t commit crimes for the benefit of their interest in the corporations.  That clearly happens.  But one doesn’t blame the chair for being too weak when it strains and breaks under too heavy a weight.  It’s just a chair.

In an effort to make some small amount of sense out of corporate criminal liability, a “novel” argument was raised before the 2nd Circuit in U.S. v. Ionia Management, according to the WSJ Law Blog.  And the Circuit responded in a per curiam opinion with a resounding “NO!”



On appeal to the Second Circuit, former Enron Task Force head Andrew Weissmann, now of Jenner & Block, filed an amicus brief on behalf of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and others. In what some viewed as a possible harbinger of good things, the court allowed Weissmann a few minutes to explain his position at oral arguments.


Weissmann argued that the trial court wrongly instructed the jury that a corporate defendant could be criminally responsible for acts committed by a single employee, even if those acts were committed against the company’s policies. Weissman argued that for nearly a century, judges, prosecutors and defense lawyers had misconstrued a 1909 Supreme Court decision, called New York Central and Hudson River Railroad v. United States, which allowed a company to be held criminally liable any time an employee commits a crime intended to help the company.


A ruling in Weissmann’s favor would have done “a lot to influence the balance of power between a prosecutor and a defense lawyer representing a company,” said Jonathan Polkes, a defense lawyer at Weil, Gotshal & Manges, to the WSJ’s Amir Efrati last fall.


To rephrase the problem, a corporation’s criminal liability is captive to whatever brainstorm pops into the head of some low level employee.  Perhaps the problem is that a department’s budget comes up short, and the employee comes up with an idea to circumvent some regulation that takes out a bite.  It may very well be an important regulation.  The damage caused by the conduct may be very serious.  But should the corporation be liable?

The argument of amicus was that before respondeat superior should condemn the corporation, the government should be required to prove that the corporation “lacked effective policies and procedures to deter and detect criminal actions by its employees.”  In other words, that the corporation did not do everything within its managerial power to make sure that the loading dock foreman wasn’t selling computer chips to the Russians. 

The Circuit’s reaction was to call this position “meritless”, the basic response to all arguments for which there is no really good reason against it but the Court just isn’t buying. 

While the general sense of justice from the criminal defense bar often leaves issues of corporate criminal liability on the sidelines, particularly since these cases are handled by the Biglaw, ex-AUSA, “we’re cooperating fully,” crowd, this is still part of criminal law and still facially wrong.  We may not feel terribly sympathetic toward corporate defendants, but there are some human beings holding shares in their retirement account who might be worthy of our concern.

Imposing sentence on a corporation fails to serve the same purposes as it does with an individual, rendering the concept of corporate criminal liability dubious in the first place.  Acts are done by people, not legal entities.  The only punishment that matters to a corporation is money, and that can be more easily imposed through civil than criminal process.  To call a corporation criminal is just plain silly, unless the entire enterprise exists for the purpose of crime, in which case there are bigger problems than corporate criminal liability, and these problems are still better addressed through prosecution of the individuals who perform the criminal acts, and those who may have directed them to do so.

But if we take the basic corporate entity, designed to engage in a lawful business in a lawful manner, with real policies and procedures in place to do everything within its power to make sure its employees aren’t shooting the customers, what more, exactly, would the government have it do?  Would they have a lawyer watching every employee to make sure each and every person on the payroll toes the line?  People, being people, come up with some peculiar ideas of propriety from time to time.  Corporations with tens of thousand of employees have tens of thousand of chances for one of them to commit a crime, thinking it’s a good idea for the corporation.  How does one prevent that from happening?

This is not absolve the crimes committed in the “name” of the corporation.  Not in the slightest.  But it is to suggest that corporations be recognized for their efforts to stop internal crime, when those efforts are real, effective (even if not perfect) and truly intended to reflect a corporate policy of compliance with the law.

The only other truly fair solution is to limit corporate punishment to imprisonment.  Can’t you imagine a cell block filled with corporate kits, each with jailhouse tats and singing the blues?