Author Archives: SHG

School Board Learns a Lesson from Students

Via Turley, the students of the Big Oak Flat-Groveland Unified School District have had enough, and they’re doing something about it.  From the LA Times :


The students organized the recall campaign as a civics project after the board of the Big Oak Flat-Groveland Unified School District voted to get rid of their popular math teacher, a former professional football player.

The latest controversy began in September after Supt. Mari Brabbin and the school board removed Ryan Dutton from his job teaching math at Tioga High over an allegation of plagiarism. He also lost his post coaching baseball.

Dutton, 31, who was studying for his teaching credential at Cal State Fresno, was accused of copying another student’s homework in March. He denied the charge.

It is unclear how the allegation reached the school district. The university said the allegation was unfounded, but the school board has refused to take Dutton back.

There is no group more official than a school board, incapable of error and ruling the school system with the iron fist necessary to maintain absolute control.  And, of course, it’s all “for the children.”  Those dopey little twerps who don’t appreciate how wonderful the school board members are for looking out for them, although they don’t deserve it. 

But this time, the twerps learned a little too much in civics class, something the school board members might appreciate the next time they decide that they know better than everybody else.


The students have appealed to the school board to rehire Dutton, but the members have declined, saying they trust the information about him that they received in private.

Most of the students are not old enough to vote or collect signatures, but parents and teachers joined in support of the effort. The campaign needed 910 signatures for each school board member and collected about 1,200, easily qualifying for the ballot.

Far too often, we find stories of students whose lives are turned upside down by the well-intended actions of the very “official”  school administrator or members of a school board.  The tales are legion.  But rarely are the students able to take it to the streets. 

It would seem that the University’s determination that the accusation against Dutton lacks merit should guide the school board’s decision, notwithstanding the “private information” it claims to possess to justify sticking to its guns.  But then, why should the members of a school board be subject to the University’s determination, when they are the rulers of their little fiefdom?

Way to go students.  Way to go parents.  When you’ve had enough of the petty tyrants, get rid of them.

LegalTech Dirtied by Lexis Lucre (Update)

You know something is for real when some corporation uses its cash to drag it down into the gutter.  And so the blawgosphere has entered the mainstream of corporate filth when Lexis/Nexis, ATM for that dinosaur Martindale-Hubbell, used its “sponsorship” to pull the plug on Kevin O’Keefe’s panel spot at LegalTech.

In that LegalTech is one of the premier legal technology events of the year, I readily accepted. It was an honor to be invited. I was to appear on a panel in the trek on how to use ‘Web 2.0 Technology to Gain a Strategic Advantage for Your Practice.’ The person from Incisive went so far as to say they were really excited to have me on the panel.

This morning I get a call from an Incisive Media employee that they’re very sorry but that the panel I was invited to speak on was full. They ‘didn’t know what to say,’ but were ‘very sorry.’

I responded that it appears that LexisNexis, the sponsor of the panel, did not want me on the panel because of my recent commentary on LexisNexis Martindale-Hubbell so bumped me. I doubt they ran out of chairs. Their response was basically ‘can’t comment on that, there’s a lot of politics involved.’

So now we’re “silencing the critics” in the blawgosphere, are we?  I’m not at all surprised that Lexis wants to shut Kevin down, given how badly he burned them and how much they deserved to be burned.  Honest criticism stings, and corporate wonks really hate it when someone gives them a nice, sharp well-deserved smack across the chops.  Kevin landed a good blow.

But what I don’t get is that LegalTech, put on by Incisive Media, owner of America Lawyer Media which is deeply involved in the blawgosphere, is willing to sell off its credibility for the price of a Lexis panel discussion sponsorship.  For crying out loud, ALM, if you’re selling integrity, at least get a decent price for it. 

Kevin, because he’s truly a really nice guy and believes that you catch more flies with honey than vinegar, tries to explain why Lexis is wrong to throw him off the panel because of his criticism of M-H, which he contends helps them to improve their product and hence keeps on top of their game.  I, on the other hand, prefer to ignore the flies altogether, so that I can write whatever I want without worrying about whether anyone invited me on a panel. 

This corporate politics approach is a disgrace, and the blawgosphere should do two things:  Let both Lexis/Nexis and Incisive Media know that we know that they are going to punish blawgers who don’t suck up to them.  Kevin O’Keefe is one of the most techno-savvy and knowledgeable guys I’ve ever met, and his absence from the panel is a near-condemnation of anything this panel has to offer.  You don’t toss the guy who knows what he’s talking about and expect to have any credibility.

The second thing to do is let Incisive Media know that they have a choice to make, whether to let web-wannabes like Lexis dictate their integrity by playing internal politics at LegalTech.  Frankly, if ALM doesn’t blow the lid off this crap, they are every bit as complicit in this effort to silence M-H critics as Lexis is.

A while back, an ALM blawger proposed that Simple Justice join the ALM “family” of blogs.  Failing to see any meaningful benefit to doing so, I respectfully declined, though my buddy Turk decided to sign up.  Now, I’m certainly glad I dodged that bullet.  While Kevin may feel constrained to make nice with the powers that run LegalTech in order to avoid burning another bridge, I still have the ability to call it as I see it.

Lexis is using cash to silence its critic.  Incisive Media is selling its integrity cheap.  And the efficacy of LegalTech hangs in the balance.  Make your choices, folks.  Just how much is your integrity and credibility worth?

Update:  Kevin O’Keefe is back on a panel at LegalTech:






Kevin OKeefe
kevinokeefe Am on LegalTech panel now – What’s Twitter? How do you use it? How do I use for client development? 3 pm, Monday Feb 2.

No, not the one “spnsored” by Lexis, but at least he’s back in the saddle.  I take complete credit for this, and am awaiting a little thank you from Kevin, though no need to thank me, Kev.  It was my pleasure.

Curmudgeons Unite! Don’t Blog for Profit! (Update)

Memo to David Giacalone :  We have a potential new member of the Curmudgeons Club, though he has yet to pass the initiation.

Via Slater at the WSJ Law Blog, 


Mark Hermann — a Jones Day Partner, the author of “The Curmudgeon’s Guide to Practicing Law” and the co-author of the Drug and Device Law blog — writes his version of “Why I Blog.” But rather than addressing the literary or journalistic merits of the form, Hermann homes in on a far more practical question (for lawyers at least): Can big-firm attorneys use blogs to bring in the bucks?

Referring to his blog, Hermann writes: “In our little niche, however, we’re pretty well known. To the extent that a blog of this type can generate business, we would have expected that to have happened during the two years we’ve been at this. . . It really has not.”

First, Hermann, I expect an explanation why you didn’t ask me to review your book.  Just what kind of a curmudgeon do you think you are when you try to pass off some book without peer review?  It’s not like you get to call yourself a curmudgeon for nothing.  I don’t expect to have this talk with you again. 

But Hermann is right, no matter what Kevin O’Keefe twits.  For every lawyer who claims that he started a blog two hours ago and already has 423 new clients, there’s a lawyer who is full of it.  No, seriously, for many, perhaps even most, purposes, do not expect to see any direct link between blawging and cash flow.  It’s a fool’s effort.


“What’s our advice?” he asks in conclusion. “Same as it’s always been: Blog for pleasure; blog to stay abreast of your field of law; blog to influence the public debate; blog to raise both your firm’s and your personal profile in a your legal niche. . . .But, if you’re a big-firm lawyer who typically handles large litigation or corporate matters, don’t blog for profit.

The same can be said for those criminal defense lawyers who do higher end work.  While it may prove helpful on some of the lower end work, such as DWI, so many of the newcomers to the blawgosphere truly believe that doing this is going to make you RICH, RICH, RICH!  You’re going to be very disappointed, and this is why so many new blogs fade into oblivion within the first year, as lawyers learn that the blawgosphere is not the promised land.

Have I gotten a ton of inquiries because of this blawg?  You betcha.  Have these inquiries turned into clients?  Nary a one.  I get disorderly conducts from Des Moines, whiners from Wisconsin and free-riders from Fredonia.  I can’t tell you how many people call to ask me to represent them for free because of this blawg.  Woo hoo!  You want a piece of that action?  Let me know and I’ll send them all over. 

And now back to our potential new club member, Mark Hermann.  If you think I’m going to buy your book to see whether you’ve earned the right to be a member of the Curmudgeons Club, forget it.  Curmudgeons don’t buy books.  We just complain about books that weren’t sent to us for free.  And your books sucks, even though I haven’t read it, because you didn’t send it to me.  Now that’s how you can tell that I’m a real curmudgeon.

Update:  Today, a copy of The Curmudgeon’s Guide to Law mysteriously appeared in my office with a note by Mark Hermann requesting admission to the Curmudgeon’s Club.  Just as I was about to propose membership to Giacalone, a new post from Drug and Device Law appeared on my screen.  There was Hermann, sucking up to the marketing masses, admitting “intangible” benefits (though omitting how he’s become unbearably attractive to young blog groupie women) and inviting the silly comments by those who feed financially off the misbegotten blogger extolling the “hidden” virtues for profit. 

I immediatly stopped typing my missive to Giacalone and will now have to actually read the darn book before deciding on Hermann’s curmudgeonly worthiness.  My gut tells me he lacks the fortutide to be a true curmudgeon, but we shall see.

Some Inside Thoughts on Madoff

As everyone knows by now, Bernie Madoff is not like the rest of us.  He was fabulously wealth as a result of running a fund that managed money for the biggest, wealthiest names around.  He’s accused of running a Ponzi scheme involving more money than constitutes the GNP of many smallish nations.  And he remains free on $10 million bond despite having $173 million in checks in his desk draw made out to his close friends and relatives.  Not too many defendants can say that.

Over coffee the other morning at Cardozo Law School, where the ITAP program was in full swing, judges and top trials lawyers from around the country talked about Bernie.  The judges were curious.  The lawyers were jealous.  This was the case to have, and since we were all sitting around drinking coffee, it meant that we didn’t have it.  But that didn’t stop us from talking. As if anything could.

The question began with how Bernie, given numbers so far off the chart that framing a sentence will require a flight of fantasy, made it out the door on $10 million bail in the first place.  Magistrate Ronald Ellis set the original number, and it seemed a shocking number indeed.  But as was noted, the initial sense was that Bernie was “cooperating”, and the implicit assumption was that Bernie’s cooperation would garner enough good will to buy him bond.  Mind you, for most people, $10M security would seem a high price.  Bernie paid it from his hip pocket.  He didn’t even need to dig into his crocodile wallet to cover the nut.

The argument against allowing a defendant to be free on bond tends to be a one-shot deal.  Once out, a defendant by his conduct either shows that the Magistrate made the right decision or not.  In other words, if the defendant hasn’t absconded or sold a kilo to pay his lawyer, he’s golden.  Of course, Bernie didn’t have to sell much of anything to pay for Ira Lee Sorkin, a one-man franchise in financial crimes defense, though his absconding seemed to be an eminent possibility given his age, wealth and likely disinclination to spend his golden years in Club Fed.  And golden they are.

Having set bond at $10 million, the question now changed, putting Mag. Ellis in a difficult position.  Bernie sent care packages to some relatives (who immediately ratted him out in what some suspect was a devious plot to create separation between Bernie and his family and keep them as far from this case as possible), and the government was pissed.  They demanded that Bernie be detained, claiming that this constituted “financial harm” to the community by deliberately dissipating his assets, contrary to court order.  Frankly, the million in trinkets is the least of the government’s problems if they are worried about having something left over for restitution, as the cost of dealing with this case will dwarf that amount many times over.

To credit the government, the argument that Bernie had caused “financial harm” is an imaginative effort, reflecting their need to find some way to undo the soft bond originally imposed when they believed Bernie was coming in from the cold.  The government was trying to right its own wrong.  Many around the coffee table at Cardozo thought that there would be far too much pressure to up the bond, given the publicity and scope of harm, and that this wedge, though questionable, was sufficiently sound to justify detention.

There was also significant doubt that the government’s allegations would turn out to be accurate.  No one was comfortable with the notion that a Ponzi scheme went on for 40 years, as they must, by definition, collapse under their own weight.  It smelled more likely that this was a fund gone bad in a problematic economy, and a manager with too much pride and hubris to admit it.  Only then, in an effort to bulldoze his way through the bad times, did he play too fast and loose, hoping that his force of will would somehow make the fund viable again before anyone found out.  It just didn’t happen that way.

To this end, perhaps Charles Green’s allegorical references (via What About Clients?) to good men gone bad explains the Bernie Madoff’s descent into corruption.  It doesn’t absolve Bernie, but it explains the path taken better than the simplistic belief that he was just a crook who got away with it for decades.  This cautionary approach is far more helpful than one that just separates the world into good and evil people, since most of us have the potential for both swimming around in our heads.  Had circumstances been different, perhaps statues would have been erected to Bernie’s memory one day for all the good he did for others.  That’s the way it happens.

To his enormous credit, Magistrate Ellis did not take the easy path of folding in the face of enormous government and public pressure.  He applied the law, concluding that there were conditions that could be imposed to maintain Bernie’s liberty while protecting the only two public interests involved.  And he imposed those conditions.  This decision is unpopular, and absolutely correct.

I still wonder why Bernie would want to stick around, since the odds are incredibly high that he will die in prison.  Certainly not the end one would expect for a Master of the Universe, and Bernie was a Master of all Masters.  Of course, it would awfully hard for Bernie to slip away unnoticed at this point, making flight rather difficult.  It used to be wonderful to be Bernie Madoff, because Bernie Madoff wasn’t like the rest of us.  He’s still not.

Magistrate Ellis stayed his order for two days to give the government an opportunity to take their position to the district judge. 

Nothing was Speedy, But Was It the State’s Fault?

Via SCOTUSBlog, the Supreme Court will hear argument tomorrow in Vermont v. Brillon, a speedy trial case out of Vermont with a twist.   From the AP via Bashman :



After he was charged with hitting his girlfriend in the face, career criminal Michael Brillon sat in jail without bail for nearly three years, going through six public defenders before being tried for assault.


The delays paid off – for Brillon: A Vermont court threw out his conviction and freed him from prison last spring, saying his Sixth Amendment right to a speedy trial had been violated.


The problem, of course, is that the delay, though substantial, was on the defense side of the courtroom, not the prosecution.  But since the defendant’s counsel(s) are assigned, and paid for, by the government.  The problem is that this creates a potential for defendants gaming the system.


The ruling outraged victim’s rights’ advocates and others, both because Brillon was freed and for fear that other suspects would take his cue, hoping for a similar outcome.

“The motivation would certainly be there,” said Erica Marthage, one of the Vermont prosecutors who will appear at Tuesday’s oral argument before the Supreme Court in Washington.

While the prosecution’s position, essentially a slippery slope argument, is understandable, this really doesn’t seem to present as difficult a scenario to address as they claim.  After all, all courtrooms have a person in a black robe sitting on a big bench, whose job it is to move cases forward with appropriate speed and ascertain whether defendants, in their interactions with their assigned attorney, are legitimate.  If a defendant is determined to be gaming the system, the court can refuse to relieve counsel despite the defendant’s objections and, more significantly, can ultimately determine that the defendant has waived his right to counsel by conduct designed to prevent a case from moving to completion.

The reason why this becomes a more significant determination is that states, as money to compensate indigent counsel becomes increasingly tight, will continue to overload public defenders and attorneys representing the indigent to the point where they will be unable to prepare for trial, and cases will languish while defendants rot in jail without bail.


Maureen Dimino, indigent defense counsel for the National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers, said cases like Brillon’s will become more common as cash-strapped states cut funding for public defender services, burdening those lawyers with so many cases that they seek more delays to prepare.

“This is going to become a bigger and bigger issue due to the economic crunch. The states are failing to fund these systems, causing these undue delays,” she said.

Thus, it strikes me as offering the Supremes a fairly clear path to addressing the problem by putting the onus on the judge to distinguish between the defendant whose delay is self-induced for the purpose of creating a speedy trial issue where none need exist, as opposed to the very real, very legitimate problems of systemic delays due to inadequate funding and a severe shortage of lawyers to represent the indigent.

Of course, since the victims rights people are outraged by Brillon’s “victory”, one can never assume the Court will see its way clear to expecting trial judges to do their job and thus preserve the defendants’ right to a speedy trial while finding the conceptual ledge that prevents the slide down the slipper slope. 

What the Trial or Plea Issue Shows About Sentencing Disparities (Update)

As the discussion about whether criminal defense lawyers should promote their clients going to trial or taking a plea continues to flow across the practical blawgosphere, with Kennedy and Fredericks joining Bennett, Bennett and Tannebaum in the debate, Matt Brown, the Desert Scorpion, of Chandler Criminal Defense adds a new wrinkle to the discussion.


I think a lot of defense attorneys are plea mills. Those attorneys definitely need to try more cases. However, trial is often too risky an option for many clients to seriously consider. I can’t blame them.

Exercising my authority to liberally reinterpret Matt’s point, the equation undergoes a marked shift relative to the disparity between the sentence a defendant will receive under a plea, versus the sentencing likely to be imposed after trial.  It’s the sentencing lottery, trading off a known outcome for an unknown, but one  which will exact a huge price for entering.  Lose after trial and suffer a sentence that may be multiples of the sentence offered in advance.

This raises a very important point to be considered when determining whether to go to trial: Are you prepared to face the trial penalty?

Theoretically, a person should not be penalized for the exercise of a constitutional right, for to do so would be to undermine and negate the existence of that right.  But how then can one explain why the same person, whose alleged criminal conduct is well known to prosecutor and judge alike in advance of trial, is offered a sentence of 5 years (for example) before trial, but should he lose at trial, will be sentenced to 20 years?  The only intervening event is a trial, a right guaranteed by the 8th Amendment to the Constitution.  The defendant has done nothing more than fulfill his duty as an American by putting the government to its proof.

The rationalization flips the relative arguments upside down.  Instead of recognizing the post-trial sentence as a penalty for the exercise of a constitutional right, the pre-trial sentence is deemed a “bonus” for having saved the government the time, money and risk of going through a trial.  In other words, we don’t penalize a defendant for going to trial, but give him a benefit for not going to trial.  Sophistry at its best.

What often goes unnoticed about this equation, plea offer versus post-trial sentence, is its impact on the legitimacy of sentencing itself.  If, and it’s a big if, the factors that justify the imposition of a sentence serve to legitimately justify the loss of freedom, or worse, of a person for the acts committed, why are these same purposes not equally important in advance of trial as afterward?

What this tells us is that the efficacy of sentencing, based upon the sentence to be imposed under a plea offer, reflects all that is needed to satisfy the legitimate purposes of a sentence.  After all, the crime itself is wholly unaffected by the fact of a guilty plea as opposed to a guilty verdict.  The only difference is that a trial occurred in between, and that has no bearing on any of the purposes justifying the imposition of sentencing.  If the crime was bad after trial, it was bad before.  If the defendant was evil after trial, he was evil before.  If the defendant poses a danger to the community, trial certainly doesn’t make him more or less dangerous.

This demonstrates that our system imposes a very hefty penalty on the defendant who seeks to put the government to its proof, with no cognizable purpose other than to dissuade a defendant from doing so.  The sad fact is that many defendant, indeed most, will decide against “rolling the dice” by going to trial, even though they may be innocent or have a good defense, because of the enormous cost of losing.  Twenty years in prison may not have much of an impact on the decision to engage in criminal conduct, but it can have an awfully big impact on the decision to take a case to trial.

This is of utmost concern when the defendant is innocent, or overcharged.  It may be bad enough for the innocent defendant to find himself in the position of facing prison for something he didn’t do, but to face an even longer stretch, multiplying bad to unbelievably horrible, for something he didn’t do is unfathomable to many people.  Thus, the innocent, whose faith in the system is usually slim to none by dint of being in the position of being falsely accused in the first place, wants nothing to do with trust, faith and principle, and wants only to get back to his family as quickly as possible.  The idea of taking a chance at winning, versus never seeing his children again without thick plexiglass in front of his face, is too much to take.

Systemically, courts cannot admit that there is such a thing as the trial penalty, for to do so would be to concede that the system is inherently wrong and, indeed, unconstitutional.  But as we all know, it’s real, it’s there and it’s a possibly the most significant part of the discussion between lawyer and client about whether to plead guilty or go to trial.  So when our “tough on crime” politicians and their supporters demand ever-increasing sentences of incarceration, it would behoove them to consider that these aren’t really the sentences that judges are expected to impose, despite all the ugly rhetoric about how we need to lock people away forever to protect ourselves and our children.  Rather, the top sentence is the wedge to be used to strike fear in the hearts of defendant, guilty and innocent alike, to forgo the exercise of their right to trial and, should they lose, be compelled to pay the trial penalty.

As for the demand for retribution and the need for deterrence (forget rehabilitation, as that went out with flower power), it should be remembered that 97% of all defendants cop a plea and obtain the benefit of doing so, never receiving that sentence we are told is absolutely necessary for the continued existence of humanity and the perpetuation of the Union.

And the person for whom this Hobson’s choice is most likely to apply is, of course, the innocent.  Factor that into the decision and see how comfortable you are with advising a defendant to take a plea.

Update:  As raised by our Hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, and showing a fortuitous symmetry, two of today’s posts meld perfectly as shown in the Vermont Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Brillon :


During the pendency of this appeal, the State agreed to a reduced sentence if defendant dropped his appeal, but, on remand, the district court refused to accept the stipulated settlement.  We now hold that the convictions must be vacated and the charges against defendant dismissed because he was not prosecuted in a timely manner.

So Brillon was so very evil, yet not so evil that the State of Vermont wasn’t prepared to overlook the extent of his crimes if he would only drop his appeal?  Yet again, integrity takes a back seat to expediency, all the while heated rhetoric whips the public into a frenzy in the need to make punishments increasingly more severe. 

Dean on Cheney, Or Why The President is Always Right

For those of us who lived through the Nixon years, we never get tired of learning more about how the mindset of the executive office worked from those who were inside the White House.  From our Hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen,  Harpers has an article about what former White House counsel John Dean’s thinks of our stalwart Vice President, Dick Cheney.

For some inexplicable reason, I was never able to lose the image of Cheney (along with chum Rumsfeld and some others) sitting in a small loft above the oval office pulling the strings that made President George W. Bush jump and twitch.  But Dean’s view, as published in the Daily Beast, is quite different.



For me, Cheney is the last of a dying breed of former Nixon aides and apologists who do not believe that the disgraced president set the standard for what should not be done, rather that he provided a “to do” list legacy. To understand Richard Nixon, as I believe I do, is to appreciate that Cheney has carried Nixon’s political DNA into contemporary Republican politics and governing.

Thirty-one years [after the Nixon-Frost interview], Wallace asked Cheney, “If the President, during war, decides to do something to protect the country, is it legal?” Without blinking, Cheney replied, “General proposition, I’d say yes.”


Like Nixon, Cheney operates best shrouded with secrecy. Cheney plays the enigma well. Unlike Nixon, however, who had intellectual heft, remarkable political acumen and a carefully developed world vision, Cheney has a small-bore mind along with a world-class Rolodex. At heart Cheney is and always has been the consummate “staff man”—an implementer of the ideas of others but neither an original nor analytical thinker. He started in Washington as a staff person and simply never grew beyond that role. As vice president, he was Bush’s super-head of staff, and when not doing Bush’s bidding, he was devoted to implementing Nixon’s vision of the presidency—a vision Cheney says he has held since Watergate.


The anticipation is that Cheney will keep himself busy following his White House stint, though with somewhat different motivations than many past office holders.


Cheney has no plans to retire, as he turns 68 years old ten days after leaving office. What better way to spend his time than on a book, for he has no eleemosynary inclinations about making the world a better place, like most Democratic holders of high office when they leave. Cheney does not need to earn a living, unlike his predecessors, with his net worth estimated as high as $100 million or more gained as Halliburton’s CEO. When he leaves his undisclosed vice presidential locations he will move into a new home he and wife Lynne are building in McLean, Virginia, along with their home in Wyoming, and their retirement estate in St. Michaels, Maryland (just a stone’s throw from his pal Don Rumsfeld’s property, who is working on his book.)

There, Dean predicts that Cheney will write a book, explaining why he’s right and the 87% of the country that dislikes with him isn’t.


It is not difficult to predict the underlying tenor and tone of Cheney’s book. There will have been nothing unconstitutional about the way they handled enemy combatants. Rather he and Bush got it right and the U.S. Supreme Court got it wrong by six to three in Hamdi v. Rumsfeld, by six to three in Rasul v. Bush, and five to four in Rumsfeld v. Padilla. Or as Cheney told Chris Wallace: “Sometimes the Court makes bad decisions.” No unlawful combatant detainees have been tortured, Cheney will again report, because the “enhanced interrogation techniques” employed on 33 detainees, with waterboarding used on three, were not torture. Cheney requested and received legal opinions from the Department of Justice. Cheney will not mention how these opinions redefined torture out of existence under American law, for he never does, nor does he report that these baseless Justice Department documents were withdrawn almost as soon as they publicly surfaced, because they were not legal analysis rather legal cover. Cheney will explain that the unbridled expansions of executive powers following 9/11 were, in fact, presidential restraint. Or as he told Wallace: “If you think about what Abraham Lincoln did during the Civil War, what FDR did during World War II, they went far beyond anything we’ve done in the global war on terror.” He will not mention that Congress had declared war in both those situations, and he will not explain, for he never does, how or why he equated the so-called war on terror with the Civil War, World War II, or for that matter the Cold War with its potential for world destruction. And on and on the excuses and incomplete explanations will go.

For those who rail with some great continuity about the death of due process, while eagerly awaiting the new season of “24”, this will be Cheney’s opportunity to explain why all the bellyaching is just unAmerican, and what it means to be the President of the United States of America.

While Dean only goes back as far as Nixon, this attitude is a bastardization of the “rugged individualism” of a Teddy Roosevelt without the moral compass that constrains the “doing whatever one has to do” ideology.  This would be a valuable lesson in American politics and government, but for the fact that we forgot about Nixon in the intervening years, and will likely forget about the Bush/Cheney years as well as we work ourselves into a frenzy for some new duo in politics that will save us from the other guys, whoever those other guys might be.

But it’s good to have John Dean’s thoughts available just in case there are any George Santayana fans around.

But Is It Worth Re-Tweeting? (Update)

For the brief, shining moment when twitting remains the newest, coolest, social media-est thing around, twitter remains on my radar.  This morning, a couple of twits raised my consciousness to an issue.  No doubt the twitcheerleaders will explain it away, but the rest of the world, disinclined to overlook all things twitterful, may not.

For those of you who, unlike me, are not twittering fools, there is something called “retweetting”.  Retweeting is when you take someone else’s twit and twit it again to the universe of twitterers who follow your twits. (By the way Lammers, just because convention is to call twits “tweets” does not require me to follow the pack in lockstep.  You tweet.  I twit. I only call it “retweet” because I don’t want any lemmings to be confused.)  It’s a way to pass a twit along to a broader group of twits.

But by doing so, one generally sends a message along with the retweet, that by retweeting is one endorses and thinks particularly well of its content.  In other words, you liked it enough to want to spread it farther and wider.

While I don’t follow many people in order to avoid having to wade through a ton of personal information about people I don’t know in order to find out the few things I would actually like to know, I pay particular attention to retweets.  If it’s being tweeted by someone I follow, then it ought to be worth my time to find out what they are talking about.  This is where things become problematic.

I have been alerted to some great pieces of news, fabulous stories and brilliant blawg posts via retweeting.  I have also learned that some people I thought were pretty darned smart have retweeted some stuff that was awfully darned silly.  Worse still, I have learned about some blog posts that were just plain scary. 

One additional piece of twitterific background before attacking the meat of my point.  Serious twitterers are deeply concerned with the number of followers they have.  I believe it be an anatomical substitute in the digital world.  The more, the longer, if you get  my drift.  So there are a bunch of twittering lawyers who encourage others to sign up as followers by showering twit-love upon them.  No doubt there is an etiquette to it all, but if so I don’t know it.

Hence, I found a retweet by a twit using the handle Rex7, who from what I can see is a bigtime twitterer. As of this very moment, he’s got 5613 followers.  The only place I have that many followers is the Manhattan phone book, and few of them care much about what I have to say.  So, I felt it appropriate to find out a bit more, given that so many others thought so highly of Rex7’s twits that they elected to get on that very, very long line.

Rex7, I learned, is not a lawyer, but a third year law student at Saint Louis University School of Law. and has a blog called Social Media Law Student, dedicated to “connecting lawyers to new technologies in hopes of making the practice of law easier – both inside and outside of the courtroom.”  What he may not know about lawyers he likely makes up for in knowledge of Web 2.0.

But this morning, I stumbled upon a retweet by Rex7 of a marketers blog post that made me realize the dangers involved.  This retweet sent me along to Bentley Tolk’s “Marketing for Attorneys, Marketing for Law Firms, and Marketing for Lawyers” blog (do you get the sense that he wants to make sure his SEO is covered?), and a post entitled Lawyer Marketing Should Involve “Critical Thinking Time.

As part of your lawyer and law firm marketing, do you make room for “critical thinking time?”  One of my mentors, Alex Mandossian, highly recommends that all marketers engage in “critical thinking time” on a weekly basis.  Critical thinking time involves taking an hour or half hour to be alone and simply think and strategize about a certain aspect or aspects of one’s business.

For example, if you would like to increase your business development for lawyers through social or new media, you could devote 30 minutes or an hour to strategizing about how you will do so.  Alternatively, if you would like to join the burgeoning number of lawyers on Twitter who are successfully leveraging that microblogging service in their client development efforts, you could devote a “critical thinking time” session to that topic.

You’re probably doing exactly what I did when I read this, trying to find the hidden link to the Onion.  Nope, there is none.  This is for real. 

Now I have no gripe about Bentley Tolk giving this advice.  It’s his blog and he can post anything he chooses.  My issue, however is with Rex7, who thought that this was such a worthy post that it deserved to be retweeted to his almost 6000 followers.  What was he thinking?  Is this was law students now consider deep, important thought?  Did Rex7 consider that I would now judge his discretion based upon his retweeting this post?

I retweet things when I think they are either really good or really important to know.  I am circumspect about what I retweet, as I consider them to reflect my judgment.  If I disagree strongly with a post, I may retweet with a comment to that effect, but I never retweet anything for the hell of it, or thoughtlessly, or to suck up to someone. 

If you retweet, you may be judged by it.  Think before retweeting.

Update:  Received via twitter (of course):



glambert

Reading @ ScottGreenfield ‘s But Is It Worth Re-Tweeting? http://tinyurl.com/8bm7ae – perhaps the meanest blog post of ’09 (so far)

The Politically Correct Jury

Via Deliberations Anne Reed, who should have blogged this story rather than twitted it, an Ohio homicide conviction is reversed because the jury included a hearing impaired person.  From the Beacon Journal :

An appeals court this week overturned the homicide conviction of the man accused of killing Barnett. Barnett drowned in Lake Erie after falling off — or being pushed from — a powerboat into choppy nighttime waters near Port Clinton.

The court concluded that boat owner Scott Speer of Fairlawn didn’t receive a fair trial because a hearing-impaired woman was on the jury and she couldn’t fully comprehend the vocal nuances in Speer’s 911 call, a key piece of evidence in the case.

The line of discrimination is often fuzzy and confusing on its own, and was made far fuzzier when a bunch of judges got it into their head that reverse Batson, being on a jury is not merely a duty, but a right, was a fine idea.  It’s absurd, and the family of the victim learned this upon hearing the decision.

What bone in their head compelled a judge to allow a hearing-disabled person to sit on a jury?  Actually, I know the answer.  It’s the same bone that allows blind people, non-English speaking, non-fluent-English speaking, incontinent, people with attention deficit with or without hyperactivity, and a variety of others to sit on a jury.  It’s the bone that makes them believe that pigs may indeed be capable of flight and people should not be defined by their challenges in every situation.

I abhor discrimination against people who are disabled.  But I similarly recognize that there is a reason why they are called disabilities.  There are some things that they cannot do well.  It’s not their fault, and they should not suffer for being disabled.  But they similarly should not be placed in situations where their disabilities preclude their ability to perform a function adequately.  I believe that sight and hearing and the ability to understand the words spoken and the ability to sit and pay attention do not belong on a jury.

But in our zeal to empower, we have failed to recognize reality.  We want to live in a fantasy world where all people are equal, rather than created equal.  All people are not, and some unfortunately lack the facility to serve as a juror. 

This is discrimination, of course.  But it is necessary discrimination.  The right to a jury is a right given in the Constitution to a defendant, a detail ignored by the reverse Batson crowd.  The right to a jury is a protection from the power of the state.  This right is not a political football, to be subject to the silly, transitory whims of those who are deeply concerned about discrimination but reject the idea that there are some things that disabled people just cannot do adequately for the purpose of serving as a juror.

In the Southern District of New York, we had a judge by the name of Richard Conway Casey.  Judge Casey, appointed by Bill Clinton in 1997, was blind.  He walked to the bench with the help of his dog.  His mind was sharp, as was his tongue when someone stepped on one of his jokes.  He was a humorous judge, and made it clear that he would be the only one allowed to say anything funny in his courtroom.  Did I mention he was blind?

Put aside the issues of Judge Casey’s reading papers and consider only evidentiary hearings before him, such as suppression hearings.  Part of the determination of whether a witness is telling the truth comes from observation of a witness’ demeanor.  We know this because judges so instruct juries, which makes it true.  A blind person cannot observe demeanor. 

Lawyers debated the propriety of Casey’s appointment at the time, as did the Senate.  Who would stand up and speak the obvious? 


“But Senator, the man can’t see.  Isn’t the ability to see a necessary component of being a judge?”

Apparently not, the Senate decided.  So in a courtroom, the blind can see and the deaf can hear, at least sufficiently to pretend that these things that had otherwise been held dear are now subject to pretending otherwise.

It’s unlikely that many people would go to hear symphonies played by the tone deaf, or ballets danced by the uncoordinated.  We prefer NFL quarterbacks to be able to pass the ball and Major League Baseball sluggers to have the capacity to hit a ball thrown at great velocity. 

The ability to serve on a jury is not an affront to the rights of the citizens to serve, but a debt owed by society to a defendant.  The ability to determine the credibility of a witness requires the use of three out of five senses minimum, as well as the absence of numerous other deficits.  This may be politically incorrect, but it beats living in a fantasyland.

The Fight Over the Fight

Yet another very interesting disagreement has reared its pretty head, this time between Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, Miami criminal defense lawyer Brian Tannebaum and Austin criminal defense lawyer Dax Garvin, on one side, and Georgetown criminal law professor Abbe Smith (via Jeff Deutsch) on the other.

The disagreement begins with regrets (cue Frank Sinatra):

The lawyers regret those cases where they failed to push their clients harder to go to trial rather than cop a plea.


I’ve lost at least my fair share of jury trials (more than most lawyers outside the criminal courthouse will ever try), but in every one it’s been my client’s choice to try the case, and in every one my client has been thankful for the opportunity to have his story told. I have had second thoughts about some of my decisions in some of those trials, but there are no cases I regret trying. Not one.

The lawprof regrets those cases where she failed to push her clients herder to take a plea rather than go to trial.


I’ve been doing this work for nearly 22 years now, and the only regrets I have as a lawyer are the instances in which I think I didn’t lean hard enough on a client to take a plea. Those are my regrets . . . .

If this was simply a chat about regrets, it would be too familiar, with lawyers crying in their beer about the ones that got away.  But it’s not merely about regrets, but about a call to action.  Bennett goes on to urge that the dividing line must fall on the side of trying cases rather than “nudging” innocent people to go to trial.


But there’s something to be said for sticking up for one’s principles. Is the truth worth forty extra years in prison? Some truths are worth dying for.

We trial lawyers are a curious breed.  So enamored with the fight, with principles, with the challenge.  We are bold.  We are fearless.  Into the Valley of Death we ride without any hesitation.  Except for one thing: We don’t pay the price of our decisions. 

There are only a few decisions that belong exclusively to the client.  Whether to go to trial or take a plea is one of them.  It is our ethical obligation to do two things: Inform our clients completely, honestly and as precisely as possible of the factors that should be considered in making the decision, and honor their choice.  Neither side in this disagreement appears to demonstrate a firm grasp of this duty.

As I’ve discussed many times before, lawyers have the ability to influence a client’s decision to go to trial or take a plea.  We can do it overtly or we can do it through the manner in which we inform them of the factors to consider.  We can persuade, manipulate and control the client’s free will.  We can bend them, twist them, shape them and mold them.  Both sides in this disagreement believe that it’s their right or duty to do so.  They are wrong.

We trial lawyers somehow fail to remember that when the battle is done, we go home and have dinner.  The defendant, on the other hand, lives with the consequence of the decision, no matter which way it goes.  The defendant’s spouse, children, parents, friends, live with the outcome.  Who are we to set ourselves up as God, to decide that our principles are more important than our clients’ free will?  Who are we to decide that our client’s life is worthy of sacrifice to the integrity of the system? 

Will we feed the defendant’s children when they are hungry?  Will we hold their hand when they need guidance, or comfort them when the trip and fall?  No.  We will have explained to our client that we fought the good fight, did the right thing, and will see them in 10 or 20 years.  Or maybe at their funeral.  And we will then leave the courthouse and return to our own homes, our spouses and children, and hold them close to us, comfortable in the knowledge that we will return home the next night as well.

It has become a foundational belief within the criminal defense bar that we play a role in shaping our clients’ choice on the critical question of trial or plea.  We believe that we know better than they do.  And to the extent that the question is resolved by the likelihood of success at trial, we clearly do.  Many defendants have a terribly poor ability to recognize their chances of success and failure, both substantially misapprehending how the system works and how the evidence against them will play with the jury.  It is our responsibility to explain this to them thoroughly and as accurately as possible.  But explanation is not manipulation.

In the dispute at hand, both sides approach the question with the best of intentions.  They arrive at their respective positions in the belief that it is in the client’s best interest.  Unfortunately, this is not the case with all criminal defense lawyers.  Some haven’t tried a case in years, while some have never tried a case.  Having been paid up front, they push for a plea to avoid the hard work of a trial, or the embarrassment of the client learning that they couldn’t try a case if their life depended on it.  This is blatantly dishonest and unethical.  It’s is also fairly commonplace.  Lawyers who do this should sit in the cell in lieu of every client they counseled to cop out.

But even when the attorney “nudges” the defendant with the best of intentions, he does wrong.  The attorney’s choice is never a substitute for the defendant’s.  The lawyer cannot substitute his risk tolerance, faith or dedication to principle for that of her client.  Not only does she not suffer the consequences, but she usurps the defendant’s fundamental right to make a truly independent decision.  We, who put such stress on our client’s right to free choice and criticize the police, prosecutors and system for denying that to defendants, are no more entitled to steal it from them than anyone else.

Sure, there are cases when our lawyer brains tell us that our client will crash and burn at trial.  We can inform them that, in our professional opinion, the evidence against them is overwhelming and they will be convicted.  And they will make their decision with that knowledge in hand.  But it must always be the defendant’s decision to plead guilty or go to trial.  Our duty is to be honest with them.

No doubt my brothers and sisters will remind me that many defendants are poorly educated, harbor disturbing misconceptions about the system and are ill-equipped to make such a monumentally serious decision.  They will tell me that they can explain the factors until they are blue in the face, and still face defendants who fail to grasp reality.  Some will go so far as to doubt the competence of certain clients to make a decision that will affect the rest of their lives.  All of this is true.

Still, it does not alter our ethical duty to explain first, then honor the decision of our clients.  Until we suffer the consequences of our hubris in believing that we are empowered to push our clients toward or away from trial, they alone own the decision.  The choice is theirs alone, and we must honor it.