Author Archives: SHG

Advice to Young Lawyers from the Big Kahuna

There’s a reason why lawyers voted Mark Bennett’s Defending People the best criminal law blawg in the universe.  It’s because it provides such outstanding, down to earth, easy to digest, nuts and bolts advice to young lawyers who want to start a criminal defense practice as this. 

Bennett’s list covers a broad gamut of things that every lawyer needs to know.  And, I might add, some more experienced lawyers need to remember, as many in their zeal to pocket a few bucks have forgotten what they are here for and the rules of the game that distinguish good lawyers from the bad.  Yes Virginia, there are lawyers who are more concerned with getting your loot than helping you.

Some of these “rules” are provincial, and in various parts of the country don’t necessarily apply.  As with anything on the internet, a certain degree of local adaptations is critical, recognizing the circumstances vary from place to place and there’s no point in making yourself the perfect image of a lawyer from the Republic of Texas when you practice in Minneapolis (right J-dog?).  But if you’re smart enough to have found your way to Defending People, you’re smart enough to realize this and make the necessary modifications.

Still, there are a few that are universal, and that merit further emphasis:

Treat every case like a serious felony case. It may not seem like a big deal to you, but it’s likely the most serious thing that your client has ever faced.

One of the most dangerous traps faced by young lawyers, both defense and prosecution, is to adopt that jaded demeanor worn by the tired old guys who sit in the courtrooms hour after hour that some cases are trivial, no big deal.  Oh, doesn’t that make you feel like your part of the club, shrugging off misdemeanors or DWIs because it’s no double homicide or 50 kilo seizure.  Big time lawyers don’t get all twisted over such small potatoes, right?

Wrong.  When you take a case, you take it for real.  No matter how big or small, high profile or low, you represent a human being, and the case matters to that human being, to his spouse and children (and maybe even their children) when they don’t go to college because daddy can’t get a job because of cheapola plea on this crappy trivial misdemeanor.  If you think you’re too important to handle it as if it was life or death, then don’t take it.  But treat your smallest case as seriously as your biggest.  Every time.

And for prosecutors, this goes double for you.  That trivial misdemeanor plea on that crappy bust is going to ruin someone’s life.  Does it make your chest burst with pride that you, you 24 year old mama’s boy from whitebread suburbia. have enjoyed the power of the state to ruin someone’s life so you have something to gloat about over a beer after work?

Don’t lie to your clients.

This one is a killer.  It’s just so easy to do, and can be so lucrative.  I’ve thought about the money I could have made if only I was willing to lie to my clients.  I know what they want to hear.  I know the magic words that will make their faces light up and their wallets open wide.  I can say those words.  I have the ability to open my mouth and utter them aloud.  All I needed to do was softly, gently, whisper the words they want to hear and I could have put my family in the lap of luxury.

Other lawyers do it.  I know they do.  They’ve told me.  Clients have told me.  I’ve heard it with my own ears.  Just make the promise.  Give them the “guarantee” they so desperately seek.  Don’t worry about it, because later, when things don’t turn out they way you said they would, it’s a snap to come up with some story, some excuse, that will bail you out.  We’re lawyers.  We can lie like nobody’s business.  We can spin the clients’ heads around so they don’t know whether they’re coming or going.  And we can collect a fee on each and every pass.  There’s nothing to it.

But . . . we’re lawyers.  Your mother may have told you that the only thing you have is your education, and nobody can take that away from you.  She was wrong.  The only thing you have is your integrity.  When you lie to your client, you lose it.  You’ve given it away and you cannot get it back.  You know it, even if the client doesn’t.  Unless you think Bernie Madoff was on the right track, a deal with the devil will be the last time you ever respect yourself.  Don’t do it. 

Of course, some clients want to be lied to.  They want you to paint the future rosy, even though they know it’s black.  Their eyes plead for some ray of hope, some straw to grasp.  Just as it’s facile to confuse honesty with undue optimism, it’s not necessary to replace integrity with negativity.  Just remember that you’re not Jimmy the Greek, so when you’re asked to lay odds, and there’s cash on the line, don’t fudge the truth.  Be the lawyer you want to be on the day you die.  Be it every day.

Keep your overhead as low as possible.

Young lawyers are particularly susceptible to the trappings of office, and I mean that in every sense.  They want the corner office to impress clients.  They want the ego wall to show clients how well educated they are and how many framed things with their name on them they can hang.  When you’re young, these things make you feel like clients will take you seriously and treat you with respect.

This is one of the primary reasons that young lawyers join the various bar associations available to them.  Most of the public is unaware that bar associations have nothing to do with attorney admission or licensure or ethics, but with the payment of a fee.  Most of the lawyers who pay the fee have nothing to do with the bar association beyond that.  Maybe the go to the annual award dinner, to meet and greet or see their favorite big name lawyer receive his 32nd award for still breathing and, as it happens, brining in a couple tables of guests. 

While a certain amount of brick and mortar is necessary to show you exist, just as there might be a lapse of faith in an electrician working out of the trunk of his ’94 Taurus, be cautious how you spend your money.  The less you piss away, the more you earn.  The less you piss away, the less you need to charge.  The less you piss away, the more time you will have to treat every case like it’s the biggest case in the world.

Your best means of building a client base is satisfied clients.  Your best means of satisfying clients is by doing everything in your power to help them.  A referral from a satisfied client means far more than paper on the wall, or where along the hallway your office is located.  And there’s no out-of-pocket cost to it, nor legal marketer who can do it for you.  Go figure.

Learn Spanish.

I wish I could speak better Spanish.  I really do.  Yes, judges speak English, but there are many clients who don’t and they are entitled to understand what’s going on despite the fact that they aren’t fluent in English.  But even if and when you learn Spanish, do not assume that you speak it well enough to fully convey the meaning of what is happening.  Just as clients often tell us that they speak English when they really don’t, or that they understand when they haven’t a clue, don’t think your pidgin Spanglish is an adequate substitute for real communication.  You owe your clients better.

For the rest of Bennett’s advice, go to the Big Kahuna’s post itself.  He’s got plenty more to say, and it’s all important to know.

United States to Ben Kuehne: It’s Not Over Yet

Just when you thought it was safe to go back in the water and practice criminal defense, the government (that would be our government) has decided that it’s not go to take the decision of Southern District of Florida Judge Marcia Cooke lying down.  Oh no, they are here to save us.  According to the AP, the Department of Justice has filed notice of appeal of Judge Cooke’s decision to dismiss the top count of the money laundering indictment against Kuehne.

This can be viewed as a face-saving measure, given that the dismissal of the conspiracy count against Ben Kuehne, probably the most squeaky-clean lawyer in all of Florida, makes the United States Attorney look like the bullying blithering idiot that he is.  And government officials hate to be revealed for what they are.  It makes them so very unattractive.

This can also be viewed as real attempt to obtain a reversal, given that federal appeals courts are not generally considered a defendant’s best friend and bulwark against overpowering government fiat.  Yes, it’s true.  Our constitutional stopgap is often more gap than stop.

But this may well be a lesson to the criminal defense bar, the ones who represent particularly notorious criminals and thus stand in the way of our heroes in government from doing their duty to the public of cleaning the streets in whatever war is on the government’s agenda today.  Represent these scum and we will indict you.  Beat the indictment and we will appeal.

So what’s the big deal with an appeal?  Well, aside from being under the taint of criminal charges for the past year, and now for another year to come (at least), the cost of fighting these spurious charges is financially ruinous.  It’s that way for every defendant, and Ben Kuehne is no exception.  I assume that this has destroyed his ability to practice, and I assume that his defense isn’t a gift from adoring fans.  And before some jerk spouts that it’s the lawyers fault for charging, we don’t bring the charges (or the appeal), and we work for a living just like you.  So unless you plan to send my kids to college, keep it to yourself.

This is a war of attrition, and the government has the biggest arsenal available.  We may be in an economic crises.  We may not have enough money to feed the hungry and heal the sick.  But our government has plenty of cash to keep the street safe from the likes of Mr. Squeaky-Clean, Ben Kuehne. Does Kuehne have the wherewithal to keep up the right?  Certainly not as deep as our government’s pockets.  Whew.  We can unlock the windows again.

In some alternate universe, where money and life and livelihood is no factor, the appeal of Judge Cooke’s decision would be an interesting topic of discussion.  Perhaps the lawprofs can argue about it, and maybe there’s even a law review article in it.  But in the world of working lawyers, this is a smack in the face, and a damn hard one at that.  This will teach us to represent notorious defendants.  This will teach us not to cross the government.

And it’s all to protect us.  On our dime.  Maybe even to save our immortal soul?  Or maybe just to make the criminal defense bar go away.

If Avvo Leads, Then It Has to do Far Better

Just as there remains a large swathe (overly large in some eyes) of the blawgosphere dedicated to lawyers servicing other lawyers’ needs to “package” and market their online personas and make the “best use” of “social media” on the internet to obtain business, there is a concomitant duty to be responsible and honest when doing so.  (Even law students are consumed by this social media trend, when they would do better spending their waking hours learning how to be lawyers rather than lawyer marketers.)  This duty is constantly being pushed to the edge, and often beyond.

One of the major arteries on this road to ethical perdition is Avvo, with its love/hate relationship with the bar as well as legal marketers.  Those lawyers and marketers who benefit from Avvo’s existence say kind things.  Others castigate it.  Both are wrong from the perspective of a businessperson, since Avvo’s only interest is to draw more eyeballs and monetize them.  Even critics (and I have been known to be critical of Avvo on occasion) help by drawing attention to it, adding to its credibility by posting about it and sending more eyeballs its way, even if only to watch the car wreck.

But as Avvo Marketing man, Conrad Saam, claims now that Avvo is “closing in” on Lawyers,com, a new issue arises that flies in the face of its claims and calls into question its accuracy and vitality.  When New York lawyer, Steven Lever, was outed as the first known child sex offender to retain his law license, Eric Turkewitz put two and two together and noted that Avvo still had Lever listed as being of no disciplinary concern.  Either Avvos idea of concern differs from most of us, or this is a systemic glitch in their system.  I trust the latter.

This glitch reveals, however, and gaping hole in the Avvo process.  In New York, lawyer discipline is a private matter unless and until a departmental disciplinary committee has determined that an attorney has violated the Code of Conduct and determined the proper sanction to be either disbarment or public reprimand.  This is a hole so big that you can drive a Mack truck through it.

The problem is two-fold.  First, an attorney who has been the subject of a few, or dozen, or hundred, disciplinary complaints will continue to be viewed from the outside world as being of “no concern,” to use Avvo’s phrase, to the consumer seeking to determine whether to send in the retainer check.  As investigations can pend for years, these are years of “no concern” when there is plenty of concern, tons of it, and the consumer won’t have the slightest clue.  And the more complaints, the longer the investigation, and the longer the attorney avoids the potential for public consequences that would reveal the problem to the world.

But, you say, since the disciplinary committee has yet to determine that the complaint has merit, and there are certainly many complaints filed that are utterly meritless and, worse still, used for the improper purpose of trying to extort the return of fees from lawyers, so it would be unfair to taint lawyers with unproven accusations.  There is no doubt this is true, and the rationale for keeping unproven complaints private is strong.

On top of this, the range of sanctions available for disciplinary violations includes censure and private reprimand, as well as fee dispute arbitration, which comprises the vast majority of sanctions imposed and never sees the light of day.  This means that an attorney could well have been determined to violate the Code many times, but there is no public record available.  This too is an appropriate tool, as some violations are anomalies, trivial or so highly unlikely to ever happen again that any public disclosure would result in a strong possibility of unnecessary and inappropriate taint.  Of course, that’s in the judgment of the disciplinary committee, but the alternative would be the judgment of the public/marketplace, which isn’t always capable of assessing the relative significance of a minor disciplinary violation.

The problem doesn’t arise because the departmental disciplinary committees don’t reveal mere allegations, but from one additional fact that is totally outside its control.  Businesses like Avvo take the initiative to assert an affirmative position on an attorney’s ethics and disciplinary record by its “no concern” statement.  They intentionally state this to an unsuspecting public as part of their business model of being the “source” for accurate information about lawyers. 

The combination of these two things, private proceedings and sanction, and Avvo’s public affirmative claim that an attorney poses no concern of disciplinary or ethical issues is what creates the dilemma.  It promotes a belief in the public that an attorney has been given a clean bill of health when the truth is the opposite.  It promotes a lie.

Now some Avvo wag might respond, so how do we do better if the state’s won’t tell us that there are complaints or sanctions against an attorney unless they go public?  Hey, this is your business model to make you money, not mine.  I’m not getting the big bucks from Avvo to figure out how they can run their shop without running into trouble, so don’t ask me how to fix your problems.  I don’t have an answer on the tip of my fingers, and have no plans on spending the time it would take to try to come up with one on the cuff.  But since this is your business model, and you’re the ones depositing those advertising checks, deal with it.

And as long as I’m thinking about Avvo and the lawyers who love it, allow me one more beef: One of the newer come-ons is Avvo’s Legal Guides.  These are lists or short essays by lawyers that purport to provide “how-to” information about the law to non-lawyers.  The lawyers who post these guides do so as a promotional tool, to further their facetime before potential clients and build a reputation as a Helpful Lawyer, Thought Leader and Maven.  It’s free to the public, and the public gets their money’s worth.

I’ve read through a few of these guides.  Some aren’t terrible.  Some are downright dangerous.  None are appropriate.  I realize that the public hates the fact that competent lawyers actually do serve a purpose, since that means they would actually have to pay for competent counsel, but that’s just the way it is.  There’s no “how-to” list for do-it-yourself brain surgery for a reason.  Some things are better left to people with a clue.

These legal guides are no doubt popular with members of the public who would prefer not to shell out bucks to a lawyer.  They are similarly popular with lawyers who, after 12 minutes of strenuous effort, can produce a “guide” that smells like it should be helpful to someone who knows nothing about the legal system, and just happens to simultaneously allow the lawyer to become a hero to the great unwashed.  And the great unwashed, once they have employed the guide to defend their own federal prosecution, will most assuredly need a lawyer to clean up with horrible mess left behind, hopefully turning to their hero for solace and defense.  For a fee.

Some may
claim that this is what we don in blawgs all the time, and it’s true.  However, blawgs are subject to peer review and scrutiny, and when we discuss a subject and miss the mark, there are a few hundred thousand lawyers out there who can gently explain why the advice may be wrong.  Or how it differs in another jurisdiction, a whole different problem that pervades Avvo’s simplistic approach.  Avvo’s guides have places for comments, but why would any lawyer read them?  I only know they exist because Avvo CEO Mark Britton promotes them on twitter (thanks Mark).

The marketing mantra is that all of this empowers the public by providing access to information.  Information is one of those loaded words that is perceived as invariably good.  The problem is that false or inaccurate information can be a killer.  Literally.  When it’s Avvo that’s spreading misinformation, then it’s Avvo that’s responsible.  And when it’s lawyers who, in the name of self-promotion, are providing the misinformation that Avvo spreads, they’re complicit.  

Is the price of self-promotion worth it?  For Avvo, it doesn’t matter.  Avvo is a business, and it will take its eyeballs and deposit its advertising checks from wherever they come.  For Avvo, it’s truly “no concern.”

Prosecutors: Some Do Right, Some Kinda

Three quick takes from the other side of the fence:

An Ohio prosecutor takes a salary cut and takes a part time job in order to keep staff when times are tough.  You’ve got to respect someone who puts their money where there mouth is.

The Arizona prosecutors on the case of the 8 year old boy (who turned 9 last week) charged with murder have announced that they will not oppose a motion to suppress statements taken without an attorney or parent present, but only on condition that they can use it on cross if the child says something different.  What a deal.  As if the defense needs the prosecution’s approval.

Prosecutor Tom McKenna, who blogs at Seeking Justice, informs that the failure to obey laws, all laws, is an act of immorality.  That means that nothing is really mala prohibita.  I always wondered whether that “keep to the right except to pass” thing should have been part of the 10 Commandments.  Now I know.

As Tom puts it, if we can start breaking laws because they aren’t immoral, where does it stop? 


And when a habit of casual disrespect for the law is winked at, or worse, elevated as some kind of “I did it my way” statement against “the Man,” one wonders where the line will ultimately be drawn with respect to which laws must be obeyed.

This is the “but for” version of morality, brought to you by your favorite moral Congress and Legislature.  So be careful and don’t piss off your deity by jaywalking today.

Norm is Back, At Least for Now.

Shhh!  I don’t think he wants everybody to know.  But Norm Pattis couldn’t keep all those words bottled up inside.  He’s using the big ones.  He’s using the small ones.  But he’s back.

I don’t think he wants anybody to make a big fuss about it.  No parade or anything.  And there’s no telling how long he’ll be back.  He could be gone again tomorrow.  But for today, Norm’s back.

ABA Blawg 100 Results are Official: Bennett Wins!

When the voting ended on January 2nd, we thought it was over.  But no, not by a long shot.  According to the ABA Journal, the ballot boxes were stuffed to the gills.  So after the voting was all over, the little elves in the backroom conducted a recount and have now announced that the winner of the Crime category was the one who should have been the winner all along, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett of Defending People.

In the crime category things were fairly tame compared to some of the other categories, where thousands of votes were changed, dropped and rejected.  It just goes to show that criminal defense lawyers are far more honest than civil lawyers.  And by the way, to everybody who voted for SJ early and often, thanks but I voted for Bennett (twice).

And while I really haven’t got a clue how the ABA Journal came up with the numbers they did, and they may very well be totally legit, changing around all the numbers in the backroom after the fact smells awfully bad.  Even for folks from Chicago.

The only thing we know for sure is that the right blawg won in the Crime category, and my congratulations to my friend and brother, Mark Bennett.

Will Twitter’s Popularity Be its Demise?

I now twit.  I’m not proud of it, but I do.  I do it because many of my friends in the blawgosphere spend more time twitting than blogging.  They comment about blog posts on twitter, and if you don’t read twitter, then you won’t see their comments.  In the process, twitter has become incredibly mainstream for lawyers, particularly with twittercheerleader Kevin “Give me a ‘T’…” O’Keefe pushing to process forward.

But the momentum of twitter seems to headed in a direction that may spell its early and unceremonious demise.  Rachelle Cunliffe at Mashable posts about the 10 ways that twitter will change blog design in 2009.  To sum it up in one “way”, she contends that twits will become integral components of blawgs, viewable and responsive, in the near future.  Uh oh.

For the moment, twitter is something of a refuge, even for those for whom desperation marketing is their prime motive for blogging   Twits come.  Twits go.  They can have a twitchat with others without fear that it will frame their marketing persona, carefully crafted on their blog to gain maximum self-promotion. 

This means that their twittering, both to others and amongst themselves, must change from actual communication to yet another vehicle for self-promotion.  Yesterday, somebody could happily twit that they were taking great pleasure in reading a few Archie comics in their leisure time (That Veronica is such a meanie!).  Tomorrow, it will be War & Peace, lest their potential targets think their choice in literature inappropriate.

Appearance is everything when marketing.  Once twitter is firmly ensconced in the broader marketing scheme, it too must maintain the appearance of professionalism, decorum and probity.

And then it will be a bore.  And we will stop twitting.  And twitter will die.  And there will be no one left to notice or care.

Third-Hand Junk Science Condemns Third-Hand Smoke (Update)

When I was a kid, every room had an ashtray.  Everyone smoked, on TV, in the movies, in the kitchen.  We made little ashtrays out of clay to bring home to our parents as gifts for the holidays.  They oohed and aahed over our craftiness, and we were proud of the fact that they didn’t realize that all we did was stick our thumb down into the wad of clay.  Parents were so clueless back then.

But what we didn’t have then was anywhere near the volume of children suffering from a variety of vague but very real and debilitating syndromes that now plague us, from ADHD to autism.  Yet this little detail evades detection in the current facile analyses of smoking problems.

It is clear that many people hate cigarettes.  It’s a filthy and offensive habit.  Cigarette smokers have few supporters, and rightfully so.  It is beyond question that it presents terrible health problems.  And so empowered, anti-smoking forces will push until they have eradicated smoking altogether.

But in doing so, the mechanisms employed have been the same that are used regularly, and with unfortunate success, in delimiting personal freedom and constitutional rights in general; the slippery slope, the tyranny of the majority and junk science.  Each of these old, familiar friends reminds of us of how subterfuge and illogic can be used to achieve an end.

The latest salvo is ” third-hand smoke,” apparently because second-hand wasn’t good enough.  From Turley :


After courts and commentators have wrestled with the dangers of second-hand smoke, it appears that there is now third-hand smoke: the smell that lingers on smokers when they come back into a house or office. Experts are warning that third-hard smoke can be harmful — a finding that might move businesses to get rid of smoking areas outside of buildings.

We are not yet at the point to have chemical showers and hazmat tents for smokers coming back into buildings. However, the recent campaign on third-hand smoke might push some companies to reexamine their policies and even bar smokers entirely from employment.

Experts are warning that smokers bring back heavy metals, carcinogens and even radioactive materials after smoking and create a particular danger to young children.

But even a skeptic like Turley can be taken in by the “experts”.  The single study, to be published in the Journal of Pediatrics, offers this admonition:


The toxicity of low levels of tobacco smoke constituents has been proved. … Thirdhand smoke may remain inside even when smoking took place earlier. Similar to low levels of lead exposure, low levels of tobacco smoke markers have been associated with cognitive deficits among children. The highest tobacco exposure levels were associated with the lowest reading scores; however, the lowest levels of exposure were associated with the steepest slope in the decrement in reading levels. These facts underscore the possibility that compounds in tobacco smoke are neurotoxic at extremely low levels…

Sounds pretty damning, doesn’t it?  Certainly not the sort of risk one ought to take, given the “experts” obvious concerns.

But it turns out that even staunch anti-smoking advocates are choking, not on third-hand smoke but on this study.  Physician Michael Siegel, whose blog, The Rest of the Story: Tobacco News Analysis and Commentary, is dedicated to the war against smoking, has hit the wall on the junk science underlying the third-hand smoke barrage.

This all-or-nothing philosophy may undermine the harm reduction approach, and may actually result in smokers deciding not to bother to smoke outside the home. If their children are going to be exposed to toxins anyway, then why bother going through all that trouble?

But most importantly, I question the accuracy and the scientific support behind such a health claim. It’s not clear to me that if a smoker is careful never to smoke inside the home, that merely hanging up their coat on a hook inside the home will cause harm to his children from toxins that offgas from the coat. I just am not aware of any evidence that this represents a significant health risk.

Those who know my position understand that I believe the effects of secondhand smoke are enough. I do not believe that we need to invoke ever-so-shaky scientific evidence to try to now scare people about the effects of thirdhand smoke. Not only is this approach scientifically unsupported, but it may also backfire by undermining people’s appreciation of the documented hazards of secondhand smoke.

This is not to advocate smoking.  Dr. Siegel is certainly against it, and I wouldn’t presume to suggest that anyone run out and buy a pack.  It is, however, to argue that we not be taken in by the wealth of vapid and agenda-driven “expertise” that is deceptively used to manipulate our values.

If anti-smoking advocates want to make smoking illegal, then that should be their open and clear position.  To covertly abuse science in support of their goal is no different than the little black boxes that magically put people in jail, even prison, for drunk driving. 

Similarly, while I am deeply concerned for children with ADHD, Autism and the variety of underlying causes that have resulted in a generation of ever-increasing learning disabled kids, it offends me that these very serious problems are being used to manipulate us into believing that we can stem the tide by eliminating whatever personal evils advocates chose to associate. 

This new study, filled with horrible sounding jargon connected by wiggly words demonstrating that it proves nothing, is precisely the sort of nonsense that people cling to when they need a way to justify eliminating the rights of others who do things they don’t care for.  Turley wonders how long it will be before anti-fragrance laws will be on the books.  I think that body odor in the third degree can’t be that far off, and I happen to know a few violators. 

But more importantly, our willingness to defer to the value judgments of “experts” as to how much personal freedom we should retain is at risk.  For those whose values agree with the experts, usually because their rights aren’t the ones at stake, they happily jump on the bandwagon,  But what will they do when the experts turn on them, piece together some junk science study filled with insipid jargon that puts their freedoms in the cross hairs?

Again, this is not to suggest that smoking, especially anywhere near children, is a good idea.  It’s an incredibly stupid idea, if for no other reason than it’s completely unnecessary to put children in that position regardless of how potentially harmful cigarette smoke is.  There’s just no reason to do it.

But the use of junk science to backup the value judgments of the majority needs to be recognized.  Today it’s smoking.  Tomorrow, it’s whatever a couple of Boston docs decide they don’t like next.

Update: Via our hinterlands correspondent, Kathleen, comes this story about “smokeasies”, the modern day variant on speakeasies.  So what is the liberatian take?


As Cleveland police Detective Tom Shoulders put it, “You put too many restrictions on people, they’re going to find someplace else to go for their entertainment.”

Wisdom from the mouths of enforcers.

Prohibitions don’t work because no penalty is harsh enough to make unwilling people obey. Nicotine Nazis follow in the footsteps of drug warriors who walk the same path picked by Prohibitionists. All have tried to bend people to their will, and all have failed.

They do damage, though. Bans and restrictions inflict fines and prison time on people (and sometimes death). Nanny-staters often escalate their efforts rather than surrender to reality. By raising the stakes, enforcers empower criminals, who are best suited to profit from governments’ authoritarian missteps and to undermine law-enforcement efforts.

The comments, including one from our dear WindyPundit, are particularly interesting.  No matter how hard the health police try, there will always be bastions of freedom. 

The Devil in Metadata

While the word metadata has been liberally spread around, few have much of a clue what it is and why it’s a problem.  Worse still, most criminal defense lawyers have little reason to believe that it’s got anything to do with us.  That could be a disastrous mistake. 

Forensics expert Larry Daniels
has provided an incredibly good explanation of what it is and what it means and its ethical implications.  This is something that every lawyer needs to know. Better still, its written in sufficiently plain English such that an idiot, even a lawyer, can understand it.

Rather than quote portions of this article, which means that some of you will read snippets and think you’ve got the idea, it would be far more effective if you went to the article itself. 

It should be noted that the “protection” against use and abuse of metadata, at present, relies upon ethical obligations imposed to some states limiting an attorney recipients “mining” of metadata, though it offers no protection from mining by police or investigators.  Does that make you feel comfortable?  Do you know what you can do to protect against metadata mining?

For those of us who hold client privilege dear, and understand the implications of inadvertent disclosure and what that can do to a defense, this is a must-read article and a duty we have to protect our client’s privilege.

When It Really Is About the Children

One of the tried and true rationalizations for shoving regulation down our throats is to invoke our love of children.  Everyone loves children, though some too much.  Sometimes there is a real connection, but often it’s an excuse to impose arbitrary controls, invoking the name of a child so that sympathy overcomes reason. 

While some invoke children to manipulate the system, some actually put children ahead of their own self-interest and do something real: For the children.  Meet Jennifer and Mark White, formerly of Chicago and now of Michael, Illinois, very close to St. Louis.


Husband and wife Jennifer and Mark White are realizing their dream of helping at-risk youths in Calhoun County with the Dare to Dream Institute, School of Self Knowledge.

Jennifer, a former special education teacher, realized that there was a large swathe of students who were doomed to failure within the regular system, and decided that she would do something about it.  With husband Mark, they put their money (and lives) where their mouth is:


Their successful alternative educational program targeted at-risk students and those who either failed or were expelled from traditional educational systems, and included an esteem- building summer vocational program where the students were paid to learn to cook deserts and bake breads sold through the school’s catering business as a fund-raiser.

In Calhoun County, the Whites began fall and winter tutoring courses for at-risk students last year, and have done some limited bread baking fund-raising of the students’ products at the farmer’s market in Alton, but have found they have had to readjust their two-year goal of being fully operational in regard to their dream of having a year-round program for at risk children ages 16 to 21.

The Whites have taken their program a step further, by starting up Oz, an artisan bakery in Alton, Illinois.


“We learned very quickly that the paycheck is really the hook for most students to achieve the goals of their individualized educational plans we construct with them and their parents or the court system,” Mark White said.

Their budding business, profiled in The Telegraph, is the classroom, laboratory and funding source for their efforts to bring at-risk kids into the mainstream.


“Baking provides a job which is critical because it’s the only way to reach kids who have given up on any other type of learning,” Mark White said. “After a while, they get satisfaction once they realize that it’s their own skill that has created the products.”

To inspire their students to dream, the bakery’s name makes a deliberate reference to the perennially favorite book and movie.

“Oz is a place to go to find yourself,” Jennifer White said. “Everybody has got the ruby slippers, but you have to go out into the world to find out what’s inside you.”

So next time somebody spouts about how the justification for some new offense is “for the children,” contrast it with the Jennifer and Mark White, and ask them whether taking drop-outs and expelled children and giving them a place where they can find that there is a place for them in society does greater good.  And then ask them how much money they plan to waste on their latest campaign, when the Whites are constrained to make this work on their own.

If you happen to be anywhere near Alton, Illinois, you might want to stop by the Oz Artisan Bakery at Mississippi Landing.  Word is that the baked goods are excellent, and the benefits for kids aren’t too shabby either.  Better still, if you want to actually do something for the children yourself, I’m sure Jennifer and Mark would appreciate any outside help to fund this venture.  After all, it’s for the children.