Author Archives: SHG

Altered Cognitive States; Happy, Smart or What?

The ever-thoughtful Frank Pasquale at Co-Op weighs in on the controversy surrounding the new pharmacopeia.  Now that there are drugs that can enhance cognitive abilities, what of the natural tendency of bioconservatives to question what evil unintended consequences will flow?

In a recent editorial in Nature entitled Towards responsible use of cognitive-enhancing drugs by the healthy, distinguished contributors have endorsed a “presumption that mentally competent adults should be able to engage in cognitive enhancement using drugs.” Against various Luddites who worry about the rat races such drug use could spark, the editorialists argue that cognitive enhancement is here to stay: “From assembly line workers to surgeons, many different kinds of employee may benefit from enhancement and want access to it, yet they may also need protection from the pressure to enhance.” Instead of the regulation encouraged by Francis Fukuyama, they would have us rely on robust professional standards to guide “appropriate prescribing of cognitive enhancers.”

Or to put it in my less than scholarly way (as I’m no Frank), the genie is out of the bottle and she ain’t going back in.  The easy question is why not just give it to everybody, make them as smart as they can possibly be, and let the chips fall where they may?

The flip side has two problems.  First, not everybody wants to be altered, and there is the fear that employers, schools, court systems, might want to force cognitive enhancing drugs down the throats of those who prefer to be more picky about what reaches their insides.  Second, this could present some major productivity problems for those who gain sudden cognitive awareness that their jobs, tedious, repetitive and boring, suck.  And the fact remains that somebody has to do the boring work.

But then the flip side of cognitive enhancing drugs comes into play, conjuring up images of Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World.  Frank takes us down a different road traveled by Huxley to explain:



Bioconservatives may fear that cognition-dulling drugs presage a Brave New World–particularly Aldous Huxley’s futuristic vision of certain fetuses being routinely exposed to alcohol in order to ease their acceptance of low-caste membership. They tend to forget Huxley’s counter-image of a progressively technologized paradise, in Island, which “answers the authoritarian monoculture of Brave New World point by point”:
Biotechnology is present, but as a kind of ecologically wise agricultural system. . . . The nuclear family has been abolished . . . but only to increase human attachment among all its inhabitants . . . The novel . . . ends, exactly as it began, with the island’s mynah birds repeating the mantra they have been trained to mimic over and over again: “Attention.”

Like the happy inhabitants of Huxley’s Island, both cognition-enhancers and cognition-dullers can work together peaceably in a mutualism that discourages conflict.


That there are monumental bioethical issues involves in this pharmacological conundrum are clear, though the same is true of the medicinal use of opium.  Whether our society is capable of navigating the problems, and whether our government and business will cooperate, is another matter.

It’s unclear how this will be addressed going forward, but the fact that cognitive enhancing drugs are here to stay cannot be ignored.  I suspect that I would be happy to offer myself to science to test their efficacy, particularly given the fact that I can use whatever cognitive enhancements I can get my hands on.  As for the potential for harm, I feel better knowing that people like Frank Pasquale are watching carefully.

The Gray Lady and the Twinkie

Disagreeing with the New York Times is sport around here.  I do it regularly, as does pretty much anyone else who has ever read a copy.  There’s a lot in there, and it’s hard to agree with everything.

But rarely does one find disagreement so vehement and ridiculous as that of Karen Lee Torre, the Connecticut twinkie.  Why a twinkie?  Give her a poke and white goo pops out her orifices.  That’s all there is inside Torre.

Torre goes on a neo-con rant in the Connecticut Law Tribune.  That she’s spewing out the neo-con line is nothing new, as she’s a born-again Ann Coulter, except without the looks and without the balls.  More on that later.  Apparently, no one told Torre-come-lately to the position of rabid neo-con mouthpiece that it’s heyday was more than a decade ago, and it’s now relegated to a few religious zealots and third-grade dropouts. Instead, she has picked up the torch with the apparent expectation that someone would care.  Instead, she’s a three-day-old fish, stinking up the place.

Torre’s silly diatribe rails about the NYT’s failure to publish stories the way she wants them to come out.  Because of their arrogance in not following the news according to Torre, she whines:

I miss the New York Times, the old one, the great one. When it lurched far to the left, I still subscribed for I didn’t want to give up the Book Review, Arts & Leisure or the Connecticut edition. I just passed over the political and editorial sections. Reading the Sunday Times in a porch rocker with the coffee was my pleasure. But when the NYT ran 32 front-page headlines in a row on Abu Ghraib (and 70 plus in all), obsessing over a few bad apples while ignoring thousands of brave soldiers engaged in heroic acts, I couldn’t take it anymore. The Times appeared bent on undermining our military and national security and succoring our enemies. I canceled my subscription and haven’t read the Times, not once, in years. My relatives and many of my friends no longer read it. We won’t help finance Pravda.

The best support Torre can find for public outrage at the Times is that her relative and friends no longer read it?  Has it occurred to her that they never read it before, but just looked at the pictures?

From this overwhelming bit of irrefutable logic, Torre explains that the imminent demise of the Times is not a product of the economy, as is affecting almost all newspapers these days, but is reaction to its leftyism.


NYT’s share price plunged last year to less than five dollars. It has to mortgage its building to stay afloat. It accumulated a mountain of debt and acquired a new sobriquet – “rag sheet.” The Internet and the economy are not the sole factors. Data support the view of those who tie the spiraling downfall (a shocking 60 percent drop in value) to the NYT’s loss of prestige and status after obsessively trying to bring down the Bush administration beginning in 2002.

What data?  Come on, we’re talking about a twinkie here.  Isn’t dreaming it up in the back of her head sufficient data for you?  It is for her.  You see, while newspapers are dropping like flies across the country, Torre has decided that the Times is different, suffering the backlash of its anti-Bush agenda.  Apparently, no one told Torre that the rest of the country has figured out the President Bush isn’t going to have his face carved into Mount Rushmore. 

On the other hand, Bush will be pleased to know that he has one supporter left.  Torre isn’t much, but she’s better than nothing. Maybe she can get the shoeshine concession at the Bush Library, made up of a dozen of America’s finest comic books.  Bush really should reward her steadfast support, particularly in the face of every thinking person’s (and most breathing person’s) rejection in the past few years of his massive failures and near ruination of our country.  Or was that the lefty’s fault too, Karen Lee?

But why is Torre a twinkie, you ask?  Why she’s a fool is obvious, but wacky, ignorant extremists can still show the degree of fortitude to take criticism like a champ,  Ann Coulter just shrugs it off, though it may have something to do with the voices she hears in her head.  So why a twinkie?  I’m glad you asked.

When last I mentioned Torre, who was doing a radio debate with Norm Pattis, and argued almost as much nonsense as she writes in this deluded rant, poor Karen Lee started to cry.  Lacking the strength of conviction or intellect to take a punch, Karen Lee sent me an email whining about how unfair I was to call her a “Federalist Society wag.”  When someone spews the garbage she does, at least have the guts to take some minor criticism.  Instead, Torre’s head spun in circles and white goo started popping out of the many holes in her head.  There’s nothing worse than an ignorant spewing whiner, and Torre owns the Connecticut version of the niche.

There’s no real issue with Torre writing that the New York Times is collapsing under the weight of her ilk’s scathing cancellation of a subscription for not showing “W” the love she thinks he deserves.  That she’s the only one in America who hasn’t figured out yet that Bush wasn’t brilliant isn’t troubling either, since no one really cares that Karen Lee is pathetically behind the times (pun intended). 

But do us all a favor and stop gushing the white goo out.  When you publish something as ridiculous as this, expect to get poked.  It’s not a good enough reason for the rest of us to get smeared by your twinkieness.

Stand for Something or Stand for Nothing

Wanna be a blawger?  Then have something to say.  If you have nothing to say, then you don’t really exist.

From Jim Chen at BigMoneyLaw (formerly MoneyLaw until I learned how much a dean earns), a reminder that there were no neutrals in Harlan County.

They say in Harlan County
There are no neutrals there.
You’ll either be a union man
Or a thug for J.H. Blair.

Which side are you on, boys, which side are you on?

Written by Florence Reece in 1931, and performed by Pete Seeger (H/T Moshe Glickman and Joel “ Jdog” Rosenberg).

You don’t have to be a wobbly.  You don’t have to be Rockefeller.  You just have to be something. There are no excuses.

The Two Most Loaded Words in a Courtroom

When Jeremy Richey at the ECIL Blog began the conversation about the “ethics” of the “guilty” person pleading “not guilty,” it struck me as another cocktail party question, like “how can you defend those people.”  But then the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, picked up on it, prompting Jeremy to go another round, and thereby catching the interest of former CLTV star Ken Lammers, who spun it into a question of virgin morality. 

It is now my pleasure to chime in (giving a gratuitous wink to Brian Tannebaum who has yet to contribute to the conversation but seems so lonely in his plea for recognition that I would be remiss in not mentioning him), Now that that’s taken care of, I can focus on the blawgversation at hand.

Bennett and Richey have made clear that the plea of “not guilty” within a courtroom is not defined by the public’s understanding.  From Bennett:

But I’ve been thinking: in addition to the fact that any boob who has ever sat through an episode of Law and Order thinks himself an expert on the criminal justice system by virtue of that experience, one of the factors that helps make serious discussion of criminal justice issues radioactive is that people think that words in the criminal justice system have the same meaning as in The World.

In The World, “not guilty” means “didn’t do it.” Not so in the criminal justice system, where it means, “the government hasn’t proven it.”

From Richey:


I could see where the person was coming from, but he was wrong. He was taking the words “not guilty” too literally. Those words do not operate in a vacuum; they are part of our legal system. Our legal system establishes a presumption of innocence for every person charged with a crime and places a burden on the government of proving the accused guilty beyond a reasonable doubt. When a person utters the words “not guilty” in court, all the players (such as the judge, prosecutor, and defense lawyer) understand that the person is requiring the government to carry its burden.

While some of the comments to these posts demonstrated the inability of laypeople, and even lawyers, to appreciate the levels of depth in these two little words, it was to be expected given how facile the public views criminal “justice”.  And Justice is a tricky word as well, since we all want it but fundamentally disagree on what it means.

When former defense lawyer turned prosecutor Ken Lammers entered the conversation, however, the issue became more interesting.


Once a defendant has broken the law, the personal moral responsibility for the act lies at her feet. As such, she acts immorally if she denies that responsibility. A plea of not guilty is an attempt to deny responsibility. Therefore, a plea of not guilty is an immoral act.

It’s an easy syllogism, but it’s subject to a million modifications imposed upon it by the real world. Competing moral obligations are often put forth by defendants that have nothing to do guilt or innocence.

If I understand Ken, his having abandoned the “ethics” approach in favor of morality, he has stripped the moral issue of its worldly trappings (such as the technicalities of proof, constitutional compliance and such) and reduced it to its most basic question: If you did the crime, then you must morally accept responsibility for your act.  If you refuse to accept responsibility by pleading not guilty, then you may be ethically and legally correct, but you are morally bankrupt.

Ken’s point is well taken.  It’s wrong.  Having spent more than a quarter century listening to people explain why they did what they did, I cannot subscribe to the notion that morality is either clear or absolute.  I realize that theologians may disagree, but they don’t chat with the same people I do.  At least not in the same way.

The ability of human beings to justify their conduct is quite an amazing thing.  It reflects relative priorities, which differ from person to person and, using the sliding scale of human rationalizations, explains choices that others make when we would not.  While I may serve as an arbiter of morality to the extent I believe that it can be explained adequately to a jury such that my client’s view doesn’t land her in prison, I do not pretend to hold the key to what is right and wrong for others.  For myself, of course.  For others, not even close.

My problem with Ken’s approach is that it presumes that there is an absolute morality.  There are times when a person engages in conduct so inherently evil, so malevolent, so inexcusable and unexplainable, that it transcends any debate about morality.  For this person, Ken would be correct.  But this is hardly the norm.  Few people fall into this category of pure evil, though some of the more self-righteous would believe this category to include everyone with whom they disagree.

From my vantage point, the vast majority fall within a relatively gray area of morality, where they possess a rationale for their actions that may fail to comport with what most people would consider moral choices but which is not so far outside the box as to render them evil.  Wrong, perhaps.  Stupid often.  But not quite evil.  And sometimes, their explanations make surprisingly good sense, though from the outside they seem awfully bad.

As both Bennett and Richey have already made clear, none of this applies to the two most loaded words in the courthouse, “not guilty.”  These words are not a moral statement, but a legal one, encompassing the plethora of issues and challenged inherent in the criminal justice system.  To utter them in response to “how do you plead” in the courtroom is never to be immoral, for morality plays no role in the proceedings. 

To measure the words “not guilty” by some other yard stick is futile.  It’s not meant to suggest a philosophical or moral position, no matter how many episodes of Law & Order someone has watched.  While these words may include a response to absolute factual guilt or innocence, we do not compel defendants to face the judge as they would their “maker” on the day of final judgment.  So it ultimately doesn’t reflect any moral position at all, and while some who stand in the dock are the very personification of evil, they too are fully entitled to state loudly and clearly that they are “not guilty” without offending anyone else’s God.

Starvation in the Academy: Lawprofs Make What?

Like most working lawyers, I know little about what really goes on inside the oak-paneled walls of this nations many, many law schools.  Even though I’m close with many lawprofs, they’ve never shared the secret handshake.  And they get awfully defensive when trench lawyers suggest that they are churning out too many inchoate lawyers, putting competency aside.

Now I know why.  From Paul Carron, keeper of the lawprof truth:

Salary Chart  

Holy Moly.  Senior lawprofs, like David Papke, are making $330k and don’t have to deal with a single client?  They get paid this to write scholarly articles about due process at the Ministry of Magic?  All the time, churning out youngsters incapable of representing anyone?  Have I ever missed the boat.

Some wags have suggested that I’m a frustrated law professor, though this reveals their lack of understanding of lawprofs.  To the contrary, I have no tweed jackets with patched elbows, and prefer a beer to sherry.  Still, I am fully prepared to adapt, if need be. 

The end of this week will mark my return to Cardozo Law School as a faculty member of the ITAP program with Barry Scheck and Ellen Yaroshefsky, and a host of new law students seeking experience in trying cases.  I’m good with the students.  I don’t coddle them and provide them with a warm, nurturing environment.  But they seem to really get into having real lawyers teach them real skills.  Really they do.

The opportunity to write scholarly articles that other lawprofs will download from SSRN thrills me.  And none of that Ministry of Magic stuff for me.  I would learn to use words like “normative” and “pedagogical” in my everyday speech, and promise it will flow off my tongue as if these were words that everyone says regularly.  I can do it.  I swear I can.

The idea of never having to listen to another client whine about how unfair it is that his having sold 37 kilos of heroin to an undercover “isn’t like I murdered anyone” appeals to me.  Ditto with the momma who tells me about this other person she knows (via her friend’s cousin’s neighbor’s mailperson’s daughter) who did the same thing and got probation.  As fascinating as that used to be, it gets old.

Instead, I can stroll down the quiet hallways of academia, tweed jacket across my shoulders, patches covering my bony elbows, prepared to impart deep thoughts on the fertile octogenarian rule to eager young people.  I will give my all for three hours a week, restraining any impulse to provide practical information.  No student shall ever leave my charge knowing how to effectively argue a motion.  I promise.

And I’m not done.  Not by a long shot.  I would make a great dean.  Really, I would.  A dean has to keep all those feral lawprofs in line, and I’m just the hammer to do it.  They don’t want to teach on Friday?  Hah!  Think you’re getting a condo at NYU?  Get to your class!  I will show no fear, no reluctance to push the prima lawprofs to their limits.  I will motivate, cajole, compel them to teach like they’ve never taught before.  No sherry for you until you have a 100% bar pass rate!

And most importantly, I will cease all commentary designed to challenge the absurd output of tuition-paying students into the legal marketplace.  I was misguided until now, not appreciating the need for the ever-increasing student population to provide the wherewithal for lawprof compensation.  I now understand, and fully support law porn and the use of public monies to build law schools in distressed urban areas. 

To all those lawprofs (except Papke) who I may have insulted from time to time, I apologize profusely.  I want to be one of you.  I want to be your dean.  I want to be paid $430,000 for doing what I do now for nothing.  Please teach me the secret handshake.

When the Defense Becomes Part of the “Solution” (Update)

About ten years ago, I developed a theory that the criminal defense bar was doomed.  It first came to me during a bar association dinner, when I looked around the room and realized that I was the youngest one there.  This was a very bad sign, as I’m not that young (though I still carry myself with great vim and vigor).

What came to me was that younger lawyers were not capable of maintaining a private practice in criminal defense for lack of sufficient paying clients.  Or, to put that more accurately, lack of clients capable of paying adequate fees.  This wasn’t about the DWI crowd, a non-existent practice in New York City, but about the felonious guys who made up our bread and butter. 

Indictments fell dramatically after 9/11, as law enforcement priorities changed and cops were looking for terrorists under every rock.  They found a couple of potentially viable Muslims to charge, but the terrorists have no money for lawyers anyway.  This was happening in the midst of the 18b and CJA crises, when the fees were so low that lawyers lost money representing the left-over indigents.  But it was the only game in town for most, so they fought over representing poor people. 

The fees were raised to the point where lawyers could afford lunch at the umbrella stand, but would never get ahead.  Defendants, if they had cash, refused to spend it because they didn’t believe having a retained lawyer did them any good negotiating a snitch deal with the government.  The lawyers were hooked on government paychecks like hookers on crack.  They hated it, but saw no option.

I foresaw this as being the step off the edge of the slope that would ultimately result in the end of the real criminal defense bar.  Lawyers had become so dependent on government largess that they would do whatever they were told to keep the revenues, no matter how piddling, coming.  And when the day came that courts existed only to accept pleas, they would comply or starve.  They have mouths to feed, after all.

At the time, I imagined the end would come with a Machiavellian scheme to subjugate the criminal defense bar, leaving nary a handful of old timers to slog it out for the few willing and capable defendants left who were crazy enough to fight the system.  I now see a different end coming.

Cut fo Skelly at Arbitrary and Capricious, who brings us Matt Shirk’s ugly twin from Alabama, James Owens.  Is this how the criminal defense bar will be lost?  Through the election of public defenders whose avowed purpose is to superimpose their view of morality upon the criminal justice system, making certain the guilty receive their just retribution, the circle will be closed.  The two sides have become one for these nouveau defenders, who come to their post with a “higher” calling.

As the public defenders relieve the pressure on the system by walking their charges through the courthouse and into the jails at an ever-increasingly brisk pace, the need for outside criminal defense will subside and the efficient conviction of miscreants will allow for the smooth imposition of “justice” without the disruption that old-time criminal defense lawyers would cause.  The few who hold the position and maintain the archaic belief in defending their clients, raising a ruckus about their budgets and caseload, will be replaced by nouveau defenders who make swift work of the problem.

The private indigent defense bar will no longer be needed.  Thanks for all your help, but it’s now time to find other work.  The retained bar will still have a few high profile cases, over which they will fight tooth and nail, meaning by ever-more offensive marketing and lower fees, but when there isn’t enough work to keep them in Brioni, they too will quietly walk away toward wills and estates.  And the government will find no one left to disagree with them, making for a very effective criminal justice system from their point of view.

The defendants will give up all hope.  They will not believe that there is any purpose to putting up a fight, and they will not tender what’s left of their assets in the off-chance that they will be the one left standing.  They will see the death march of their friends and brothers, and they will assume their place on line. 

The beginning of the end is the election of public defenders whose role is to facilitate the prosecution and conviction of their clients.  They will drag us all down the slope with them, and will do so happily and with the full support of the “sick and tired” public, never thinking of the consequences until it’s their turn on line.  They will become the “solution”.

Sound crazy?  Check back in five or ten years and see the consequences of Shirk’s Disease.  It can be stopped, but only if we recognize the symptoms.

Update:  Eugene Volokh has kindly provided hope via this 1912 law:


An Act to provide for the support and maintenance of bastards in the District of Columbia

A Masterpiece for Our Time

As should be clear to any reader, I am a connoisseur of fine art.  While my taste tends to run toward the old masters, and some cubist and impressionist thrown in for good measure, I am often skeptical of new artists who want to break the bonds of artistic traditionalism by finding new, heretofore unseen ways of expressing themselves. Pffaw.

Plus, it is my hope to be deemed as worthy of fine taste as my heroes, Dan Hull and Oliver Holden, who commonly use What About Paris? to demonstrate their exceptional appreciation of fine art, leaving the rest of us to wallow in our Philistine dust.  They have moxie.

With that firmly in mind, I offer what I believe to be the quintessential painting of our time.  By artist Lucian Freud, “Benefits Supervisor Sleeping.”  This modern day Mona Lisa sold for $33.6 million at Christie’s auction house in London on May 13, 2008, setting a record for the most money paid for a work by a living artist.

Lucian Freud's 'Benefits Supervisor Sleeping'

No other image has captured the soul of our time as this.

Some may recall my post about the “Official Woman.”  Little did I know at the time that Freud knew her too, and would paint her essence on canvas.  This, dear readers, is fine art for our age.  Think about it.

Eliminating Plea Bargains for the Right Reasons

David Tarrell at In the Moment posts about the Gage County, Nebraska Attorney, Randall Ritnour’s new policy:  No more plea bargains.  From the Omaha World-Herald :


With the shadow of the “Beatrice Six” hanging over his head, Gage County Attorney Randall Ritnour announced Friday that his office would no longer offer or accept plea bargains in felony cases involving adults.

Six people were wrongfully convicted in a 1985 murder case in Beatrice, with four giving detailed statements — apparently false — confessing to their involvement in the brutal attack, rape and murder of a 68-year-old woman. Some later said they cooperated with authorities to avoid being charged with a crime that could send them to the electric chair.

David’s initial reaction, just another instance of prosecutorial grandstanding, gave way to the hope that this new policy was offered in good faith.

The reason I’m not skeptical after reading the article? Doesn’t it seem like a prosecutor who’s willing to speak this frankly deserves at least a chance to demonstrate that his policy is for the benefit of the system rather than his own reelection chances?

More of the explanation from Ritnour was encouraging:

“Our point is to do the right thing, and the right thing is to charge people with the crime they actually committed, not to bounce around making deals.”

The concept is to stop overcharging defendants in order to allow room to plead down.  By reducing the top end of the punishment that might otherwise be imposed, innocent defendants may be more inclined to roll the dice and go to trial, thereby reducing the possibility that they will plead guilty to crimes they didn’t commit rather than face the consequences upon a loss for a more serious crime.

All of this has a great deal of superficial appeal.  As David correctly notes, Ritnour is not running for office and may well believe that through the good faith application of this plan, the system will regain the integrity that has been lost over the many “tough on crime” years that demanded excessive charges and punishments. 

But will good faith and intentions be enough?  It’s not likely.

Whenever a policy is based upon something as subjective as “good faith,” it’s too variable to satisfy the different perspectives involved.  Will Ritnour’s idea of what to charge a defendant comport with David’s?  The “right thing” is a very personal thing.  Just ask a staunch Republican under indictment. 

And plea bargaining, for all its many flaws and horribly coercive nature, has a purpose.  Our legal system lacks the facilities and finances to try most cases, and depends on the vast majority of cases to “go away” via a plea to allow it to work.  While this may not necessarily be desirable, it is a reality that government relies upon in budgeting and building.  Change the equation by forcing the vast majority of cases to trial and the system can’t withstand the burden. 

What happens to the defendants who sit in jail awaiting trial when there are no courtrooms or judges available?  How long must delays be before justice is denied?  When one side of the equation is based upon something so nebulous as “fairness”, what are the chances that everyone will agree that the elimination of plea bargains are worth it?

This is not to say that prosecutors should adhere to a policy of overcharging defendants, or that politicians should continue to pander to the crowd by ever-increasing the punishment until jaywalking becomes a capital offense.  These are ploys that should never happen in a system that seeks internal integrity and intellectual honesty, but since no one except criminal defense lawyers and the occasional crackpot libertarian seem to care or notice, goes unchecked. 

Still, it serves as a reminder of how transitory good faith can be.  I doubt most prosecutors actively decided to start overcharging one morning, upon realizing that they would have to offer a plea to a defendant and might as well ramp up the charges so they would have a better bargaining position.  Even I’m not quite that cynical.  But I do believe that they see it as “playing the game,” and should they find that their even-handed approach seems to result in defendants walking away easy, will soon start pumping up the charges, little by little, to even the playing field.

It’s just a matter of perspective.  Even with the best of intentions, it’s a lousy system that never seems to be capable of finding level ground.

Collateral Murder for Negligent Homeless Man

In the past, we’ve noted cases where the collateral death of a responder was charged as murder despite the fact that it bore no causal connection to any criminal act, as well as the tendency to charge individuals who engaged in negligent conduct with crimes based on terrible outcomes.  This case puts it all together.

From NBC News via Turley :


A case in Elizabeth, New Jersey is raising some difficult questions about the limits of liability for injuries to emergency personnel. Emilio Vasquez, 19, a homeless man from Guatemala, is charged with breaking in a home and starting a fire to stay warm. The fire got out of control and the fire department was called. Firefighter Gary Stephens was one of those responding, but was killed when a fire truck backed into him. Vasquez has been charged with his murder.

It is terrible that anyone dies, no less a firefighter in the performance of his duty to help others.  And the homeless man, Emilio Vasquez, did commit the crime of breaking into a home, even though it was abandoned.  But he didn’t intend to commit arson.  He intended to stay warm.  He certainly didn’t intend to harm anyone. 

The accident itself had an additional twist.


The truck was moving at less than 5 mph when the truck hit the 57-year-old Stephens. The truck is equipped with a sensor that alerts the driver about objects while backing up, but it’s unclear if noise from the nearby New Jersey Turnpike played a role, fire officials said.

It will likely never be clear why Gary Stephens didn’t hear the beeping of the truck backing up.  Horrible accidents happen. 

Whether Vasquez deserves punishment for his entry into an abandoned home, usually considered a matter of simple trespass, is one issue.  But here he’s charged with the murder of Firefighter Gary Stephens, which lacks any logical legal or policy basis.  It’s just a matter of a dead body and someone having to pay. 

Usually, I agree with Turley’s assessment of the situation, but this time we apparently have taken separate paths.  Turley writes”


It appears that this was not an intentional act of arson but a homeless person trying to keep warm. Serious criminal charges are clearly warranted but a murder charge seems excessive despite our collective sense of loss with Stephens’ death.

Why are “serious criminal charges” clearly warranted?  It’s unclear why Turley thinks so, though by using the word “clearly” it appears that he doesn’t feel it necessary to explain something so obvious.  It’s not, however, obvious to me.  Not at all. 

What serious crime did Vasquez commit?  Trying to keep warm?  Since when did trying to stay alive warrant serious charges?  When a person dies, we lose perspective.  Death is horrible.  But death does not inherently beget a crime, and a criminal.  Should we punish Vasquez severely, there will be no gain.  He meant to hurt no one by starting a fire to save himself from the cold.  And stupid is not a crime, lest we all deserve life in prison.

As for the causal connection between Vasquez’s fire and Stephen’s being run over by a firetruck, the fact that the truck was there to put out the fire started by Vasquez is as deep as it gets.  But this is what firefighters do.  Fires happen, and firefighters put them out.  Sometimes, firefighters are hurt in the process.  Sometimes, they are killed.  Usually, it relates directly to the fire.  Sometimes, as here, it’s just a freak accident.

Had this been an arson, the intentional act of setting a fire, and a firefighter was injured or killed attempting to put the fire out, it would be fully appropriate for the felony murder rule to kick in.  It would serve the theory of the rule, the policy basis for holding a person responsible for the death of another caused by the commission of an intentional felony.  No such purpose is served here.

As awful as the death of Gary Stephens may be, and there is no question that it is terrible when a person dies needlessly, that doesn’t mean a crime must be somehow created and charged.  And when the gymnastics needed to convert Emilio Vasquez’s effort to stay warm into a murder charge are stretched this far, all reason is lost. 

There is no murder here, and there is no basis to charge Vasquez with any “serious” crime.  A terrible, unfortunate death occurred, but sometimes that just happens.

ABA Blawg 100: Beaten into Submission

The voting is over for this year’s beauty pageant, the ABA Blawg 100.  It was a test of clout, ultimately coming down to two players.  It was Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett against Simple Justice.  Mano a mano. Blawgo a blawgo.

Bennett pushed his fans to vote for Simple Justice.  I pushed for Bennett’s Defending People.  It was ugly.  No matter what I said, Bennett countered.  He punched and punched until he had pummeled me into submission.  I tried in vain to fight back, but Bennett was too much for me. 

The vote ended with Defending People at 225 and Simple Justice at 255 for Best Crime Blawg.

Bennett won.  As he should have.

Simple Justice was honored to be in the same category with the others, like Grits for Breakfast, Berman’s Sentencing Law & Policy and obviously Bennett’s Defending People.  The fifth, Steven Hirsch’s Courthouse Confessions, is a great website and brilliant concept, but not a blawg and was included as matter of ABA Journal vanity. 

Congratulations to all the category winners, particularly those for whom winning meant a great deal, and even those like Turley  who seek to use their primacy to take over the world.  But mostly, congratulations to Bennett for proving conclusively that his word carries more weight in the blawgosphere than mine.