Author Archives: SHG

Prep 1, Admin Convenience 0, For The Moment

When John Wesley Hall first pointed toward Ohio public defender Brian Jones being held in contempt for his refusal to go to trial on one day notice, it seemed beyond absurd.  It was therefore shocking to learn via Skelly that an Ohio appeals court agreed.  How often does that happen?


“Where a trial court denies a continuance in a criminal trial and, as a consequence, defense counsel refuses to participate in the trial for fear that the defendant would receive ineffective assistance of counsel and that counsel would be in violation of DR 6-101(A)(2) and 7-101(A)(3), the court may commit error under the circumstances of the particular case in finding defense counsel in contempt and in imposing a fine.” In re Sherlock, supra, at paragraph two of the syllabus. “Defense counsel should not be required to violate his duty to his client as the price of avoiding punishment for contempt.”

While this appeal might well have been decided in far fewer words, in my view, the fact that the court actually arrived at the conclusion that a court actually held that a lawyer is empowered to refuse to engage in ineffective representation without fear of contempt is heartwarming to say the least.

Of course, the right result doesn’t mean that the court demonstrated a complete grasp of the problem.


“The rights of indigent defendants to appointment and effective assistance of counsel are neither lofty philosophical ideals nor rights that only function to give us all faith in the criminal justice system. *** The rights to appointment of counsel and to effective assistance ultimately impact not only whether people are convicted of crimes based on fair processes but moreover, whether innocent people are convicted of crimes they did not commit. These are both outcomes whose probabilities should be reduced whenever and however feasible.”

Just to be clear, the probability of the conviction of innocent people should be “reduced whenever and however feasible?”  And when is it not feasible?  And does that mean that convicting innocent people is hunky-dory if it would really, really inconvenience the judge?

Perhaps I’m being a little too picky, expecting an appellate court to use language that expresses concepts that are consistent with the Constitution and the fundamental concepts of justice the provide any semblence of legitimacy to the criminal justice system.  Let’s not get crazy, right?  I mean, just between us, it’s not like we can completely stop innocent people from being convicted, and it would just gum up the works if judges couldn’t railroad an unprepared lawyer to trial when he had a totally open slot in his calendar and nothing else to do, right?  And really, isn’t this what people expect from our court system?

Rather than castigate an appellate decision for suggesting that this is all a big joke between friends, it’s far less skeptical to show appreciation for the court having at least gotten the holding right.  And they did.  Brian Jones did the right thing by his refusal to go to trial, “under the circumstances,” and all is well with the world.

And for those of you who are more cynical than I, and thus don’t find sufficient comfort in a correct outcome, bear in mind that this is Ohio, where the Lima police are heroes.

Sacrificing for One’s Craft

Eric Turkewitz, whose New York Personal Injury Blog was just edged out for the winner of the ABA 100 in the regional category by Dan Harris’ China Law Blog (because they are both so much alike) has taken to consoling himself by reading Craigslist in search of advertisements that will arouse a certain comforting interest.  He found this one.



Actresses needed to have sex with Cops! REALITY SHOW (Flatiron)




Reply to: [email protected]
Date: 2009-01-02, 5:30AM EST


Epileptic/Arson Productions is now casting actresses to participate in a new reality show about off duty NYC cops and their home life. Ideal candidates will be moderately attractive, have no more than 2 kids and 3 previous marriages, be able to take a punch dead in the eye without collapsing immediately and be able to curse like a sailor when their ship is under attack.

The show will focus on how cops act when they are not at work or on the take; their social lives, their loves, their money problems…etc.

Ideal candidates will hail from North Jersey or the outer boroughs of NYC, have only a high school education and have no more than 2 ass crack tattoos.

For more information view this website: COPBAR.TV

Finally, a show with redeeming social value!

Much, however, is left unexplained in this ad.  For example, how many actresses are needed, and how many cops must they have sex with?  It matters, you know.  Then, one must wonder whether the “no more than” related solely to the 2 kids, or similarly to the 3 previous marriages?  Would 4 marriages be over the line?  It matters too.

I would assume that the criteria for an open casting call such as this has been carefully defined to produce highly skilled actresses who will appeal to a broad array of law enforcement officers.  The finest actresses, naturally, are from North Jersey and the outer boroughs.  These guys know their stuff, and this is sure to be one great show.  I wonder if it will be on broadcast television or cable? 

And the big question, will it be hi-def?  I would assume so, since the number of tattoos really wouldn’t matter very much if they were so blurry that they could be easily confused with poor hygiene.

A New Year’s Shelf Life

Human beings have long differentiated one day from another by events, allowing us to have something to look forward to as well as something to put behind us.  They start a new time frame and end an old one.  They give us a fresh start.

But as David Giacalone, the Bard of Schenectady, found out, the shelf life of a New Year has dropped by one third.



January 3rd 
only the panhandler
says “happy New Year!”


… by dagosan


It looks like I’m going to have to edit that senryu I wrote a couple years ago.  This afternoon (January 2, 2009), the pretty and popular young check-out girl at our public Library was quite taken aback when I handed her the items I wanted to borrow and said “Happy New Year.”   A few hours into her first work shift of 2009, and the idea of offering good tidings for the new year to someone she sees and chats with a few times a week had already floated into “whatever” oblivion for the young college student and part-time civil servant.


Celebrating the eve of a new year has been out of the question for Mrs. Simple Justice and me for many years.  Something bad always happened when we tried to go wild and crazy, and thus began our family tradition of going to sleep at 9:30.  Of course, that’s when we go to sleep most nights, so it wasn’t much of a stretch.

The contraction of the Happy New Year greeting opportunity is a problem.  First, the start of a new year seems like an awfully good opportunity to break from the past and make a fresh beginning.  It’s a natural.  But we can’t see everyone we know within a 48 hour span, and so we’re constrained to continue to wish people well for at least a week or two.  With 52 weeks in the year, this hardly seem too much.

To do so, however, is to risk social disaster.  I would be pinned immediately as some sort of idiot who doesn’t realize that New Year was so yesterday, such old news, and be shunned.  Parents would tell their children to stay away from me as if they could catch some loathsome disease.  Was I unaware that my greeting must relate solely to this instant?  Did I not realize that time and tide wait for no man?  Happy New Year was old.  Clearly, so am I.  Giacalone is no spring chicken either, I might add.

In my observations of others, it has long become clear that we have become a people of immediacy.  We twitter in 140 characters rather than write complete sentences with fully-blown thoughts.  If it doesn’t fit, we can either contract our words or contract our thoughts,  Either way, it’s less than complete.

I have nothing against brevity, though I don’t practice it as much as I should.  But many of the ideas that this blawg, and criminal defense lawyers in general, seek to discuss don’t fit within the limits that hip folks now use.  This makes me (and us) decidedly unhip, and likely means that many people will quickly skim the first paragraph and then skip to the end to see if there is anything here that’s worth their time.  Meaning is lost.  Nuance is lost.  Words have long since lost specific meaning, and blended into some generalized sense.  It’s impossible to communicate anything worth saying when that’s the case, since most thoughts require more detail.

But one thought can be conveyed in less than 140 characters.  Happy New Year.  If only I had thought to write these three words before today, January third, since it’s now too late to be of any significance.

Name That Tune, Biker Version

A new criminal law blawg in the ‘hood opened up shop in Arizona last summer, but there was nary a word about it despite posting some great stuff.  When I finally found out about it, I saw a problem.  The blawg was great, but the name was “Brown & Little,” which also happened to be the name of the firm.

Matt Brown does most of the posting, apparently, as I haven’t seen any posts lately by his partner, Adrian Little.  So I emailed Matt and urged him to give his blawg a real name, maybe something like “Arizona Crime Guys,” along the Kevin O’Keefe theory of naming blawgs based on something that works well with search engines.  But using the firm name was just a little too promotional to get much link love, At least it felt awkward to me.

I wasn’t sure how Matt would take my suggestion, since no one asked me what I thought and what they chose to call their blawg really isn’t any of my business.  But since I’ve never been reluctant to stick my nose where it doesn’t belong, I figured it was worth a shot and might even be viewed as mildly helpful, as I intended it. 

Well, Matt kinda agreed, and now asks for input on what they should call their blawg.



It was recently brought to our attention by Scott Greenfield of Simple Justice that calling this blog “Brown & Little, P.L.C.” might be dissuading other blawgs from linking to us. I can see his point: it’s just too promotional. On top of that, it isn’t very creative. Personally, I’m the kind of guy who sees no problem naming a dog “dog” or a goldfish “goldfish,” but I have to admit a name change is probably in order.


We will officially change the name soon, but we’d first like to get some input. We keep getting stuck on Scorpion-themed blog names, as we’ve always wanted the kind of dignity and respect animal law firm mascots command. “The Scorpion,” “The Scorpion Kings,” “Scorpion Justice,” and “The Stinger” are all possibilities, but none of them seems quite appropriate. Neither does the “John A Kesler Report,” as only about ten people would get the joke, only about five of those people would think it’s funny, and I’m not entirely sure John A Kesler would be okay with it.


Can anyone suggest a good name? Scott mentioned “AZ Crime Guys.” We are also considering “BLinD (Blogging Lawyers in Defense),” “Defense in the Desert,” and “Desert Defense.” If you email us your suggestions or put them in the comments, we’ll pick our favorites and put up a poll to let you decide. Have fun.


How often do we get a chance to help out some brothers and have fun giving them a new name at the same time?

I’ve also learned from reading the “about me” that these guys ride motorcycles, though I’m having some trouble seeing Adrian in leathers (are there any photos?).  Nonetheless, it gave me pause to consider a different theme for Matt and Adrian.  What about “Scorpion Bikers for the Defense?”  Doesn’t roll off the tongue?  Fine.  Come up with a better name.

And welcome to the blawgosphere, guys. 

The Scope of Consent

Via Turley, this story of a Wisconsin man, Mark Jahnke, who covertly videotaped his girlfriend in the nude, leading to his conviction for violating the “video voyeur law.”  On appeal, Jahnke argued that by exposing herself to him in the nude, she had de facto consented to being videotaped.


Jahnke and the woman had an intimate three-year relationship. Using a video camera concealed in a pile of clothing, he recorded her on April 1, 2006. She later learned of the video, which was not shown to anyone else, and went to the police.


Wisconsin’s 2001 law makes it a felony to secretly record someone in the nude if they have not consented and it happens in a circumstance in which the person would have a reasonable expectation of privacy.


Jahnke argued that because his girlfriend knowingly exposed herself to him, she did not have the required reasonable expectation of privacy. The appellate court found that she did, since her expectation was not that her boyfriend wouldn’t see her, but that he wouldn’t be secretly recording her.


Jahnke had also argued that the court had found in a previous case that a reasonable expectation of privacy existed when a nude person reasonably believed he or she was “secluded from the presence of others.”


The court’s decision seems eminently sensible, but makes me wonder why courts aren’t equally sensible when the consent involved relates to a police search.  When an office asks if he can look in your trunk, and (foolishly) permission is given, he’s now got the keys to the kingdom, from the glove box to removing the fenders if he so chooses.  Once consent, any consent, is granted, there is no meaningful limitation of scope.

Of course, consent can be withdrawn, though I’ve never personally seen that successfully argued though I’ve tried it numerous times.

So why is consent viewed in almost polar opposite fashion when it’s the police versus anyone else?  Why is scope no concern?  Why doesn’t anyone care whether it is truly knowing, voluntary and intelligent? 

The obvious answer is that the system wold break down and fail if a consent search was truly limited to actual consent.  Ironically, it’s not that most people wouldn’t consent, just as they feel compelled to speak despite the clear warning to shut their yap.  It’s that the courts can’t take chances and give defendants half a chance for suppression.

The problem with videotaping people in the nude without consent was one without a legal solution for quite a while, and one that offended many because it was just wrong. Wisconsin’s handling could have been better, but I won’t quibble with the court’s reasoning.  I only ask that they consider applying it across the board.

No means no.  Consent means consent. 

The Right to Shoot, The Duty to Help

Susan Kuo at PrawfsBlawg asks an interesting question.  If someone harms another person in self-defense, do they then have a duty to save the person?


Instinct says, no, let the psychopath bleed out. Logic, however, says that I might need to hit ‘911’ on the dial pad. I would, after all, have had a hand in creating the peril that has befallen him. Even if he was the aggressor and I was justified in my use of force to save my own skin, this very same force has now put him in harm’s way.

This strikes me as a simpler question than it does Susan.  Our right to use force in self-defense isn’t because we’re entitled to exact punishment on our attackers, but to save ourselves from harm.  Once done, and we’re no longer threatened, the situation is no different than anyone else in need of aid.  In other words, we don’t get to enjoy the fruits of our self-defense by leaving our attacker to suffer, perhaps die.


I went a-hunting and found that at least one court has ventured down this path. The Montana Supreme Court, in Montana v. Kuntz, 995 P.2d 951 (Mt. 2000), held that, while folks who put other folks in peril need not risk bodily injury or death to help the imperiled, imperilers do have a legal duty to help or summon help. A failure to so aid, if it causes the aggressor’s death, is criminal. In the Montana case, Ms. Kuntz apparently stabbed her significant other in the chest in self-defense. She did not call for medical help, and her boyfriend died. The State alleged that she caused his death by stabbing him and by failing to call for medical assistance. Kuntz argued that her justifiable use of force nullified any duty on her part to assist. The trial and supreme courts disagreed with her argument, finding that the justification did not render her duty-free.

The argument that the right to self-defense “nullifies” the duty to aid sounds like the kind of rule they would come up with in the Republic of Texas.  There, they would probably insist that you put the poor mutt out of his misery.  They can be very tough down there.
But the defender is not a wrong-doer, which is why the duty to aid continues to apply.  Their entitlement is to protect themselves, not hurt someone else.  Nor leave them lying in the street to die.  As counterintuitive as that may seem to some.

Some, of course, would argue that the only problem is that the first bullet/stab/whatever didn’t finish the perp off, thus creating a problem that is easily solved by better aim.  This, of course, misses the point.  Some will live no matter what, so you can’t blame the shooter/stabber for missing a vital organ. 

You can, however, blame them for forgetting that the person who engages in self-defense does so because they are the good guy,  And good guys come to the aid of others, even when the others aren’t so good.

“A Mere Two-Tenths of 1 Percent”

“Chief Justice Roberts noted that “the nation faces pressing economic problems, resulting in business failures, home foreclosures and bankruptcy,” and he said the federal judiciary was doing its part to conserve resources. The federal judiciary’s budget of $6.2 billion, he said, “represents a mere two-tenths of 1 percent of the United States’ total $3 trillion budget.”

At the end of each year, the Chief Justice of the United States gives his State of the Judiciary report.  According to the New York Times, CJ Roberts once again raised the rally cry for a judicial pay raise.  Talk about lousy timing.


“I suspect many are tired of hearing it, and I know I am tired of saying it,” Chief Justice Roberts wrote, “but I must make this plea again — Congress must provide judicial compensation that keeps pace with inflation.”

“Judges knew what the pay was when they answered the call of public service,” he wrote. “But they did not know that Congress would steadily erode that pay in real terms by repeatedly failing over the years to provide even cost-of-living increases.”

Didn’t anybody tell him that 2008 was a bad year for the economy.  People can barely afford to keep up the payments on their Ferrari, and he’s calling for a pay raise?  It’s outrageous.  Smart governmental-types got their raises quietly, so no one would know and it wouldn’t make unemployed citizens feel bad.


This year, he said, every other federal employee, including members of Congress, received a cost-of-living increase. Only federal judges missed out.

Obviously, federal judges aren’t as smart as they think they are, or they would have gotten a raise too.  It’s hard to take a seat on the federal bench and then whine about the salary.  As Roberts correctly notes, it’s not a job one wants for the money.  And as he correctly notes as well, it doesn’t come with an oath of poverty.

But judges are a bunch of tough guys when it comes to us, and relatively gutless when it comes to themselves.  This isn’t the year to stomp for pay raises, and now isn’t the time to complain.  But when they have the chance, when cash was available and nobody would have blinked, they did little to serve their cause. 

Judges hide behind the dignity thing, claiming that going around hat in hand would be undignified.  Standing up for themselves would be undignified.  They want so badly to be dignified.  Of course, it’s hard to be dignified when first year  Biglaw associates made more than them.  And now that there are no more first year associates left to make fun of, all of them standing on bread lines waiting for crumbs from solo practitioners, the judges can’t even use them to justify a raise.

The third branch of government is not merely the least dangerous, but the least potent.  Not because it can’t do anything, but it won’t.  How did all those rough and tough street fighting trial lawyers turn out to be black-robed wussies? 

Just How Much Moral Turpitude is Too Much?

Eric Turkewitz at New York Personal Injury Law Blog answers the age old question, just how low must one go before a lawyer loses his ticket.


In a decision released today, a sharply divided panel of the Appellate Division, First Department determined that an admitted sex offender will keep his New York law license. A majority of three justices suspended the license of the admitted offender for three years. Two dissenters insisted he should have been disbarred. The case is Matter of Lever.

While others debate the hot button issue of SORA, when the miscreant happens to hold a law license, the courts suddenly get a bit mushy about the whole problem.

It seems that Steven J Lever likes little girls.  As in 13 year old girls.


“he engaged in sexually explicit conversations over an internet chat room with an undercover police officer posing as a 13-year old girl, followed by his attempted meeting with the presumed minor for purposes of sexual contact.” The then 30-year old patent lawyer, formerly at Kirkland and Ellis, had logged on to a chat room targeting older men and younger women. In six separate conversations over a period of three months he engaged in discussions with “significant sexual content” and then arranged to meet the girl at the Ronkonkoma train station in Suffolk County for the purpose of oral sex.

In most posts about people who engaged in conduct like this, we would be considering the propriety of his return to society after a reasonable prison stay, and the issue would be whether he is entitled to return to the community without others burning his effigy on his front lawn.  Not here. 

The only question before the Appellate Division, First Department, is whether he gets to keep his license, and the answer of the majority is . . . you betcha.


But the majority voted not to disbar since they saw a distinction between an attempt to have sex with the minor and actually doing it. The court wrote:


Given that most State’s penal statutes treat sexual contact with a minor as a higher-grade crime than an attempt to commit such a crime (as would be the case in a sting operation), there is no basis for us to ignore that distinction in attorney disciplinary proceedings. Respondent’s sanction should be premised on what he was convicted of doing, not what he might have done if circumstances were different.


The distinction is fine, and fully appropriate in determining the extent of penal sanction.  But admission to the bar, the ability to practice law, is not an aspect of sanction, but a privilege.  One of the foundational aspects of admission to the bar is to be of good moral character.  Lever isn’t.  Not even close.

Per the New York Law Journal, dissenting Justice James Catterson wrote, “I do not believe that we can reconcile the status of registered sex offender with that of a member of the bar in good standing.”  I really don’t think this requires a lot more explanation than this.  The bar isn’t a refuge for sex offenders, and the practice of law is not a right. 

When one assumes the responsibility of being a lawyer, one undertakes the responsibility of trustworthiness above and beyond others.  We aren’t close to being as trustworthy as we should (right Marc Dreier?) and should put our effort into being worthy of the license we hold, not trying to get 13 year old girls to engage in sex.  Lever’s conduct was sick, but the Appellate Division’s decision was simply wrong and disgraceful. 

So we now have our answer.  Lawyers will be summarily disbarred for messing with escrow funds, but 13 year old girls, not so much.  It’s good to know where the line of moral turpitude is located, just in case some lawyer with an urge to sexually molest young women needs to know.

Will Consumerist Go Legit?

Colin Samuels twitted about this New York Times story that Consumer Reports has bought the Consumerist.  Colin’s thought was “very cool.”  I wasn’t so sure, which earned me a “why so skeptical” twit.  Here’s why.

The blogosphere, despite all the marketers who would prefer to homogenize it and make it warm, fuzzy and profitable, remains the wild west.  It can get rough in here.  It can be crude.  We give punches, and take punches.  Many can’t take the heat and leave when they find out that it’s not so easy to get your brains bashed in on a regular basis.

But what will happen if the blawgosphere goes legit?  Will corporate owners really be willing, able, to throw a good punch?  What about the nasty language and nastier attacks.  Corporate wonks don’t want that stuff dirtying up their brand. 

The Consumerist is a great blog.  I happen to be a strong supporter of people taking a stand against getting screwed in the purchase of goods and services, and holding sellers accountable.  Ben Popkin, the guy charged with herding feral cats over at the Consumerist, has done a great job of keeping the place rough and effective, while keeping the loonies in line.  Can Consumer Reports allow this to go on?



The blog offers consumer tips, like how to return products and how to confound a telemarketer, and covers shopper complaints, like excessive retail markups.


It will become part of a new division of Consumers Union, and the current editors will remain. No plans are under way to change the coverage or to begin charging for the site. “We don’t want to acquire the Consumerist and then squelch it in some way,” said Kevin McKean, vice president and editorial director of Consumers Union.


Well yeah, the Consumerist does that, but what it does best if rip the heart out of businesses that screw the consumer, that treat the consumer like fungible dirt and take money and deliver crap in exchange.  I love it.  Without blogs like the Consumerist, places where ordinary people can fight back, rage against the machine, we are individually lone voices competing with the massive marketing campaigns designed to make us believe that these corporate sellers actually love us and respect our concerns. 

Consumer Reports, on the other hand, presents a positive view on goods and services.  It’s very helpful, and a long time favorite of Mrs. Simple Justice, who carefully and obsessively reviews the ratings before buying anything.  But what it does not do is rip the lungs out of thief’s, liars and cheats.

It’s good to know that the blogosphere is being taken seriously, and treated with a legitimacy that is usually reserved for butt kissers.  But if it takes the edge off the wild west, then we will have traded respectability for purpose.  If so, that would be a lousy trade.

That’s why I’m skeptical.  I’ve seen the nasty outsiders get co-opted into the mainstream before.  It’s never pretty.

Another Good Judge Gone

Via the New York Lawyer, Acting Supreme Court Justice Charles Tejada died on December 24th.  He was one of the good ones.

I had the honor of trying a few cases before Justice Tejada.  He not only gave me a good trial, but he was a pleasure to work with.  A judge of utmost integrity and intelligence, and a pleasant and respectful man as well.  When I called him “your honor,” I meant it.

Justice Tejada was 64, but looked 50.  Thin and fit, I would have never expected him to die so young.  I didn’t know him well enough to have any personal knowledge of his health, but I knew him well enough to know that when a case was sent before him for hearing and trial, it was your lucky day.  You were assured that he would give you a fair shake and if you made your case, would suppress, dismiss, whatever was right.  This is a rare attribute.

Justice Charles Tejada will be missed.