Taking an early morning flight to LAX, so talk amongst yourselves. Joel and Gid will be in charge of comments. No making fun of Tannebaum without me. Bennett will handle all marketing duties until my return to the blawgosphere.
Special to Windy: I’m okay. No need to worry.
Author Archives: SHG
The Three Wise Men of the Blawgosphere
Blawging requires one to be a watcher as well as a writer. Our existence in the blawgosphere does not continue for long if we are isolated from others, and that results in the growth of communities of interest and relationships with others in the blawgosphere. Within these communities emerge some special individuals who keep them vibrant and alive.
From my observations, there are really three blawgospheres. They overlap from time to time, but can be described as distinct from one another and have characteristics that distinguish them from the other two. Within these blawgospheres, there have emerged wise men and women. They are respected, even by those who disagree with them. They didn’t pronounce themselves to be wise men and women, They never asked for the job. But by virtue of their intelligence, thoughtfulness, inquisitiveness and integrity, wise men and women they became.
First, allow me to describe the three blawgospheres I know. First is the academic blawgosphere, which is distinguished by its curiosity and self-deprecation. Law professors have no cause to drum up clients, and because of this offer pure thought and argument, untainted by the mundane pressures that influence others.
The second is the marketing blawgosphere, consisting of those who have found a tool to convey a message and for whom the tool is omnipresent in everything the blawgosphere offers. The marketing blawgosphere consists of those whose purpose in joining is to present themselves and their services to the broader world, to offer services needed by those who wish to do so, and to engage in a synergistic existence with everyone else who can help them to achieve their goals.
While I have been critical of this part of the blawgosphere for its effort to extend its reach into the third blawgosphere, and its refusal to accept the premise that just because the marketing blawgosphere believes itself to be the core, I recognize that it is real, that it serves interests that it believes to be legitimate and that it means to be a helpful and productive part of the blawgosphere, and is integral for many members of the blawgosphere who believe in its purpose.
The final blawgosphere is the practical blawgosphere, consisting of practicing lawyers who write of their legal experiences in the trenches, philosophies, victories and defeats. They offer a vision of life as a lawyer to be shared with anyone interested.
The title of this post is three wise men, but that’s just a Christmas vanity. There are many wise men and women that I’ve encountered in the blawgosphere. Here are some of their names.
Mark Bennett, Dan Hull, David Giacalone, Kevin O’Keefe, Susan Cartier Leibel, Gideon. Mark Draughn, Joel Rosenberg, Carolyn Elefant, Eric Turkewitz, Eugene Volokh, Orin Kerr, Dave Hoffman, Frank Pasquale, Dan Markel, Dan Solove, Ken, Ken Lammers, Anne Reed, Howard Bashman, Walter Olson, Marc John Randazza, Jim Chen, Charon, Radley Balko, Geeklawyer, Jamie Spencer, Skelly, Jon Katz, Jonathon Turley, Lyle Denniston, Douglas Berman, Scott Henson, David Lat, Niki Black and the departed Norm Pattis.
I’m sure I’ve left some off, because I am not as wise or thorough as those I admire. Some in this august group I call friends. Some don’t even know I exist. Some have linked to me regularly, while other have not and never will. Some have said nice things about me, and others have expressed nothing but disdain.
My appreciation of wise men and women bears no connection to what’s in it for me, and I have no expectation of gain for putting someone onto this list. It is the list of people whom I believe are wise based on my observations. It is not a list of people with whom I necessarily agree or wish to curry favor. They certainly do not need someone like me to put them on a list, as my list is of no consequence to what they bring to the blawgosphere.
The blawgospheres have expanded and contracted over the past year. Some changes present interesting challenges to its ongoing existence and vitality. Much as there are wise men and women, there are many fools. The fools desire prominence for their own ends, and present one of the greatest challenges to the blawgosphere, as they want the wise men and women to be fools as well, so that no one will notice how foolish the fools are. The wise men and women will simply continue to do what they do for as long as it seems worthwhile.
It’s an honor to be a part of the blawgospheres, and the blawgospheres exist because of the wise men and women who have made it a place worthy of being. Thank you for your efforts, which have allowed me to contribute my small piece.
Waiting for the Paper on Christmas Day
Every day that an innocent man spends in prison is a hard one, but today must be particularly hard for James S. Anderson. It’s not that it’s a new experience, as this is his 5th Christmas in prison. It’s that he has now been found to be an innocent man. It’s a done deal. He didn’t do it. But he is still in his prison cell. According to the AP :
A state appeals court erased the 31-year-old’s conviction for armed robbery this month, saying new evidence uncovered by a law school student corroborates what Anderson has always said: He was another state when a group of men hit a Tacoma grocery store in 2004.
Prosecutors joined Anderson’s lawyers in asking for his immediate release, but severe winter storms closed the court and helped delay the necessary paperwork.
There is no reality without a piece of paper being given by one cog in the wheel to another. I would imagine that there’s a person at Walla Walla Prison who knows all about Anderson’s being innocent, conviction vacated, about to walk out the front door a free man, and is just waiting for the paperwork. Just waiting. Anderson is just waiting too.
Most of the time, the defendant who is about to walk out of prison a free man is far too happy about his sudden collision with justice to complain. Having spent years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit, a few more days won’t kill him. Well, hopefully it won’t kill him. The guards are unusually generous to such a prisoner, knowing that his release is imminent. It matters that he’s leaving because of innocence. He’s no longer one of them, as he was the day before.
Few people think much about the mechanics of a man walking out of prison after his conviction has been vacated. It’s an experience that all of us want, but few of us get. Having suffered through it, I can tell you that it’s a mass of confusion. After the sudden elation of the reversal of a conviction, everyone looks around with a quizzical stare. Now what? A piece of paper from the court seems to be an incredibly important piece of the puzzle, but in a bureaucracy like the criminal justice system, paper is god. Each person along the way has his own piece of paper that must be perfect of nothing moves.
One would think technology would alleviate some of the waste, but raised seals and original signatures still matter. No one, but no one, wants to be the person who does something wrong, so each insists that every “i” is dotted. If only they were so concerned about perfection when putting people into prison.
That there is a storm in Washington that’s closed the courthouse, kept the judge or clerk from the shifting of papers from one hand to another, on the day before Christmas can’t be helped. Storms happen.That paperwork is necessary before a man is released from prison, even an innocent man, can’t be helped. Paperwork happens. But that a piece of paper is all that stands between an innocent man and his waking up at home on Christmas morning still stings.
Merry Christmas, James S. Anderson. And Merry Christmas to the prison guards who may show you some greater kindness today because you are an innocent man in prison, and everyone at Walla Walla knows it. Please protect Anderson until the piece of paper arrives.
I Got Sunshine on a Cloudy Day
As much as I could easily segue into the irony of my former governor’s comment that “sunshine is the best disinfectant,” I will restrain myself in an effort to bring posting for the day to a close on a more positive note than dead puppies. Instead, I will be guided by the commentary of Connecticut criminal defense luminary Norm Pattis.
Norm’s holiday commentary appears in the very same version of he Law Tribune that contains this brilliant interview of none other than my dear blawging neighbor, Gideon, who details his blawging inspirations:
Gideon also reads other legal blogs. His favorites include Scotusblog, Second Circuit Blog, Fourth Amendment Blog and Capital Defense Weekly. Gideon often goes to them after reading an important court decision. “I’d turn to one of the criminal law blogs to see their take on how it impacts our practice. And usually these posts are up within a day or so of the opinion being issued, if not hours,” Gideon said.
But enough about Gideon’s excellent taste and discretion, and back to Norm.
The Christmas season is often a time of cheap and easy sentimentality. We take a hiatus from our private imperatives and pretend, if only for a moment, that good will govern our affairs. We greet strangers with a kiss and think it not strange.
Economists keep telling us things will get worse before they get better. Some folks will lose jobs, others homes; we have to recover from something like a national drunk, now paying an overdue tab for pleasures long since passed.
But, truth be told, it isn’t really all that bad. My wife and I sat the other night working over our holiday gift list, reflecting on all the good things that folks have done for us in the past year. We want to express gratitude and thanks. So we check off items on a list scaled back in part by fear of hard times to come.
I know. Almost made me cry too, it’s so filled with warmth and love. How Norm ever picked criminal defense lawyer over inspirational speaker I’ll never know. It’s our loss.
While I’m left with no choice but to toil in Norm’s warm and fuzzy shadow, I still offer my best wishes to all of you. As Norm put it so very well, “it isn’t really all that bad.” If I may add, we’re doing just fine. If the sun isn’t shining today, it will be another day. That’s how it works.
Happy Holidays. And I sincerely mean that.
Attack of the Puppies
Not being a big fan of pets regardless of species, I can’t lay claim to any particular soft spot when it comes to puppies, kittens or other critters. On the other hand, it strikes me as inconceivable that any person with a healthy mind would harm animals except when absolutely necessary. But what do I know?
Balko, pushed by yet another instance of puppycide, has put together a compendium of doggy murders :
Three weeks ago, police in Waldorf, Maryland shot a family dog in front of two small children while attempting to serve papers on a man who no longer lived at the address. They claim the dog charged them. Last month, police in Indianapolis put nine bullets in a German Shepherd. They ignored warning signs about the dog posted on the property before walking in to serve a warrant on a man who hadn’t lived at the address in years. Just last week week, police in Gwinnett County, Georgia shot and killed a Dalmatian after entering the wrong garage to serve a warrant in a gang-related case.
Milwaukee resident Virginia Villo is suing that city for the 2004 police shooting of her lab-springer spaniel mix, Bubba. As part of her lawsuit, she requested police reports of every dog killed by Milwaukee police over a nine-year period. The request turned up 434 dead puppy reports, or about one every seven-and-a-half days.
See more puppycide stories from recent months here, here, and here. Or browse stories from the last couple of years here.
Many have asked why the killing of a dog strikes us differently than the killing of a human being. It may be that we can more readily attribute malevolence toward people, whereas dogs are “man’s best friend.” Absent some hard reason to believe that they are about to do actual harm, they possess no malice and cannot be blameworthy. In other words, they are just being dogs.
The fact that so many police officers, faced with nothing more than a pet behaving like a a very ordinary pet, engage in an immediate reaction of shooting the dog. Take no chances; take no prisoners. See a dog, kill it. Even if the officer has come onto the property of a law-abiding citizen, without cause or belief that any wrong-doing has occurred, the immediate reaction to a dog is murder.
Are police trained to do this? Is the philosophical underpinning that a police officer’s safety is so special, so at risk, so worthy, that the murder of a pet is so utterly inconsequential in comparison? Is this a reflection of a pervasive mental health defect that has long gone unrecognized?
It’s fair to wonder why this troubles me, given my lack of sensitivity toward pets in general. The reason is that this belies an attitude of police officers that dismisses the importance of the life and safety of living things aside from themselves. It’s not that they won’t save your life (and get a medal) under certain circumstances. Indeed, when they find themselves in a “hero” situation, nothing brings them greater honor than to do the heroic thing. Yet when they see a dog running toward them, they pull their weapon without a moment’s hesitation and shoot Fido in the head. How do you reconcile these actions?
Radley suggests that the solution lies in better training:
Police departments should be training officers how to deal with dogs in ways other than filling them full of bullets. Cops should be taught, for example, how to tell a charging dog from a bounding one; an angry dog from a barking but playful one; and that a curious or territorial bark is much less threatening than a snarl. Mailmen, firemen, paramedics, and the rest of us non-badge-wearing citizens manage to visit private homes and deal with the dogs that may reside in them without resorting gunfire. It’s odd that not insignificant number of police officers can’t.
I don’t think that lack of training is the problem. Police officers don’t generally shoot to kill all dogs they encounter while off-duty. They can tell a threatening dog from a playful one. But put on the uniform and something snaps in their heads, allowing them to become disinhibited and resort to murder as the initial course of action.
So many of the issues discussed here call into question the psychological profile of the men and women to whom we give guns and shields, together with the power to use them. While arguments can, and usually are, made to justify the shooting of person after person, it becomes far harder to explain how police suffer the constant need to kill pets. Maybe this is the wedge to raise the issue of some cultural-psycho issue that might allow us to address the broader array of issues in the “police versus everyone else” mentality.
No mentally healthy person’s first reaction to a pet is to kill it. It’s just sick.
Addendum: Rick Horowitz has picked up the ball on this as well, arguing that today puppies, tomorrow your mother-in-law, in his post They Shoot Puppies, Don’t They? Rick tends more toward the governmental conspiracy view, arguing:
Although “government of the people, by the people, for the people” has been much touted since Abraham Lincoln, the truth is that our government is increasingly oligarchic and in opposition to the rest of us. “Our” government pushes us into war without considering what’s best for the people. “Our” government deregulates businesses which take advantage of us via the “free market.” Thereafter, we discover that the market was free for them; extremely costly to the rest of us thanks to the oligarchy which actually reigns as an extension of corporate America. (It will be interesting to see if this changes following the inauguration of our new Messiah.)
Accompanying the increasing separation between us and “our” government, there has been an increasing militarization of local police agencies. And officers who refuse to go along get a beat-down themselves.
Who knows, maybe the police are the tool of the oligarchy. It’s not like they tell me what they have up their sleeve.
Cop to Cop: Don’t Call Me Grunt
Just as anyone with a computer can access a bunch of lawyers chatting amongst themselves, showing that we are not (as conspiratorial theorists suppose) a cabal with plans for world hegemony, so too can we see into the world of police officers. And it’s a lot of fun!
Via J-dog on twitter came this post at Officer.com, “where law enforcement officers let their hair down and beat the living crap out of one another,” by a retired cop, Jim Donahue, who now serves as a consultant to police departments on the tactical use of police vehicles. But this post had nothing to do with his area of expertise. Rather, he was P.O.’d.
(Author’s Note: I originally wrote this article while I was still pretty steamed-up over the incident. I named names and pointed fingers and specific agencies and people. My always gracious editor suggested that I cool down and reexamine the writing. In the interest of peace and harmony, I’ve removed the specific names while attempting to retain its original fire.)
And what got him so steamed?
As I arrive at the front of the cars, there are two civilians who, like me, have emerged from their cars and are visiting with each other while they wait. There is a grunt cop standing in the immediate area, near his vehicle.
I politely inquire, “Is there an estimate on how much longer the crew will be?”
The cop looks straight at me, but as though he doesn’t see me, turns around, and walks a short distance away towards his unit. To say that I we perplexed at this behavior is fair.
When the cop takes up a new position, I make the same inquiry again. He proceeds to look away as though he doesn’t hear me.
WHAT THE HELL ARE WE DOING?
I was pissed at his behavior. The agency is known as being arrogant, often displaying a smell me attitude with the citizens and other cops, alike, but, this was simply rude and blatant beyond anything I could have anticipated.
Clearly, Donahue is a person of limited anticipation. The “grunt cop” could have pistol whipped him, arrested him, charged him with attempted murder of a police officer. There was plenty he could have done to be even “ruder”.
But as pointed out by one of the commenters, Donahue’s concern may not have been limited to the cop’s simple lack of common courtesy to a civilian. Donahue describes himself thusly: 
I am wearing my only sweatshirt, which has a breast emblem from my previous department in Michigan. I just got my “high & tight” haircut tuned up yesterday. It would not be a great leap of faith to think that I may be a retired cop, a current cop, or minimally, related to law enforcement based upon my appearance and demeanor.
The commenter, in turn, notes:
In reading the article, it appears to me that the writer was more insulted that he was not recognized as a former officer. How many former officers have we known throughout the years that forgets that they are no longer an officer, thus perhaps are not privied to certain information. Seems to me every former officer I’ve ever come in contact with thinks information about whatever should be given to them because of who they were. Yet, thats just it…who they were.
I wonder if that smack mussed Donahue’s “high & tight” hairdo? And other commenters as well were less than impressed by this critique of one of their own by some former cop. The lesson, of course, is that a former cop is a former cop, and no longer a member of the fraternity, no matter how much they believe that the mini-badge in their wallet should count for something.
While there aren’t usually many lessons to be learned from these law enforcement websites that we haven’t already learned in spades from the representation of our clients and cross-examination of police officers, it’s always fun to have our best and worst fears confirmed. There is no situation where a police officer can’t invent some justification to protect a fellow officer, and the bottom line is that, while believing that they are truly the last bastion of order for the civilized world, they really do hate the rest of us, and the rest of us apparently includes former cops as well.
I really hope Santa brings me that Minneapolis Police Department t-shirt for Christmas.
H/T Kathleen for this very attractive pic of Jim Donahue. I think the glasses make him look a bit like John Lennon.
“Overshared” is the Word of the Year
According to Switched, the editors of Websters New World Dictionary have announced that “overshared” is the word of the year.
Mike Agnes, the dictionary’s Editor in Chief defines ‘overshare’ thusly:
Typically a verb, but also used as a noun, it is the name given to ‘too much information,’ whether willingly offered or inadvertently revealed. It is the word for both the tedious minutiae on personal Web sites and blogs, and the accidental slips of the tongue in public.
What a great word! While it falls somewhat below the brilliant phrases created by the Bard of the Practical Blawgosphere, Mark Bennett, it still captures one of the fundamental realities of life online, that there is far more information provided, whether intentional or otherwise, than we usually need or want to know.
One of the other choices, cyberchondriac, also struck a note with me. I think we need to craft a parallel word or phrase to describe lay-people who think that they’ve become lawyers by virtue of reading blawgs, statutes and caselaw. Any thoughts?
The Death of AV (Update: MH Responds)
Kevin O’Keefe reports that Martindale-Hubbell, the grande dame of lawyer raters, appeared to have given up. Game over. Pack your bags. Time to mop the floor. It’s done.
It’s unclear that MH will stop listing its AV ratings, but apparently the bunch of folks at MH that decide on ratings have been told to seek new opportunity elsewhere. That doesn’t bode well for the rating system as a whole.
What does this mean? Who knows. Way back when, when Martindale-Hubbell was the only game in town and lawyers really didn’t have much access to information about other lawyers from other places, an AV rating provided some level of confidence that the lawyer was respected within his local legal community. Whether well deserved or not, it gave some degree of security that the lawyer wasn’t a total mutt.
Today, things are different. The internet provides a wealth of information about lawyers, and we can gather as much info about a lawyer from Seattle as we can about the lawyer in the next office. Location is irrelevant. Information is everywhere. The old AV rating (and why did they ever pick “V” rather than “+”?) is more of a nostalgia thing than a meaningful indicator of competence, right? Well, not exactly.
For better or worse, we took the Martindale Hubbell peer review ratings seriously. We may have been wrong to do so, but we did. Unlike the fluff of marketing ploys like SuperLawyers, there was a degree of faith in an AV rating that meant something across the boards. We believed it to be real. Maybe we just needed to have something to believe in, but we did.
New players entered the fray in the meantime. Avvo made a big splash with its numerical ratings, but was subject to severe criticism from within the bar for its secret algorithmic methodology that burned younger lawyers and experienced lawyers who couldn’t be bothered to play its game. Then Avvo gave up whatever credibility it might have had by selling paid lawyer advertising on the same page as its putatively consumer-useful informational pages, reducing itself to just another “business model.” And I thought Avvo had such promise.
Perhaps MH lost it’s purpose to Google, since searching a lawyer’s name provides far more information than MH ever could. But aside from information overload, there is no way to determine the accuracy of this wealth of information, or to put it into some succinct useful form. In exchange for volume, we gave up reliability. There’s little way to tell whether our bits of information garnered from searching is the product of meaningful assessment or ignorance, or even hatred and deception. There’s a lot of junk online.
It’s understandable that Martindale-Hubbell, the dinosaur, moved too slowly to adapt to a changing world and was doomed. It’s just not clear that anything better, or even equal, exists or will come into being in the future. Current evidence suggests that it won’t, and that we will be saddled with too many SuperDuperLawyer websites or Avvo-type magic-ratings, but no one in whom the profession can put its trust.
So the Martindale-Hubbell age has past. What are we going to do now?
Update: Martindale-Hubbell has responded to “the rumors” of the death of its ratings, claiming the reports of its demise “have been greatly exagerated.” So what does it mean when you fire all the people who handle the ratings? They say they are “fully committed” to continuing the ratings, plus a whole lot of other new initiatives that will bring “transparency by practice area, narrative feedback and validated data from third parties that provides examples of an attorney’s experience.” What that means is anybody’s guess.
To provide even more focus, we will name a new VP/ Product Champion of Ratings who will help us spread the message about our transformation. We are also increasing the current number of Martindale-Hubbell Specialists in the market in order to educate our firms about all the new offerings, including enhanced ratings services. We are adding a product marketing team for a more consistent flow of information and wider communication and we have expanded the current responsibilities of our inside Ratings Support team.
After careful consideration and a long period of deliberation, this change also included a change in the role and responsibilities of the ratings specialists. While this was a truly difficult decision, it is one that we felt necessary to best meet client needs.
After cutting through the rhetoric, I believe that this means they fired all the ratings people and replaced them with marketing people, who will now spread out across the country to bring us transparency through marketing. After all, there is no better way to “meet client needs” then sell them stuff.
No Jeopardy. None At All
While the criminal justice system is mediocre at dealing with cases that follow the usual path, it is absolutely horrible when a case comes along where things go systemically wrong. Via Ken at Popehat, who revisits his childhood as an AUSA by remembering Sol Wachtler’s admonition about indicting a ham sandwich, comes this incredible story of a little screw up by the Jefferson County, Oregon District Attorney.
In a nutshell, the Jefferson County district attorney’s office prosecuted Simmons that fall on four counts of felony third-degree rape and two counts of felony sodomy for sex with his girlfriend dating back to September 2005, when he was 17 and she was 14.
But that grand jury declined to indict Simmons. Apparently, however, nobody read that section of the indictment.
“Not the prosecutor, even though he signed the document 1 inch below the line that said ‘Not a True Bill,’ ” Richkind said outside the courtroom Tuesday. “Not the court clerk, who filed it. Not the judge, not Mr. Simmons’ defense attorney.”
Instead, all proceeded as if the 18-year-old had been indicted.
The problem, of course, is that the idea of a grand jury returning a “no true bill” is so shocking that it never dawned on anybody that it could possibly happen. Now this would just be an apocryphal tale of making sure the indictment was in proper order, but for the fact that the defendant pleaded guilty and everybody walked away. By a twist of fate, though, someone happened to notice.
Simmons might have spent the rest of his life with two wrongful felony convictions on his record. But Greer, the jury foreman, happened to read a newspaper account of the plea deal. Shocked, he confronted prosecutor Steven Leriche, who in turn contacted Simmons’ then-defense attorney Jennifer Kimble.
Consequently, the court vacated the conviction for the unindicted crimes. But that wasn’t the end of it. The defendant was charged with misdemeanors for the same crimes, thus avoiding the sandwich of rotten ham.
Simmons retained Richkind, who filed a motion for dismissal of the charges on the grounds that they constituted double jeopardy. But another judge for the Oregon Circuit Court serving Jefferson and Crook counties denied that request. Judge Gary Thompson agreed with Assistant Attorney General Darin Tweed that the second prosecution was legal because the first one occurred in a court that lacked jurisdiction over Simmons — if only because the Jefferson County Grand Jury had not indicted him.
Richkind appealed that decision to the Oregon Supreme Court, which declined to take the case.
As Ken pleasantly points out, Youssarian had nothing on this catch-22. Despite having been subjected to prosecution and being imprisoned, the court’s conclusion was that the lack of an indictment precluded its jurisdiction, thus rendering the entirety a nullity and providing the prosecution with a clean slate to go after the defendant as if nothing ever happened. After all, what’s a little prison between friends?
The decision to permit the defendant to be subject to prosecution after being previously prosecuted under a defective instrument smacks of absurdity, and leaves one to wonder whether the attack on double jeopardy was somehow lacking or whether there is some quirk in Oregon law that could use a fix. That the court assumed jurisdiction, even though it may not lawfully have possessed it, should have been more than sufficient to invoke double jeopardy. This was a matter of harsh reality, though reality is often trumped by legal fiction. And the fact that the Oregon Supreme Court refused review speaks volumes.
The lesson of this inane case is rather hard to explain. The law presumes regularity, meaning that things happen the way that they are supposed to happen. Procedural laws are written with normalcy in mind, and often fail to provide a mechanism to deal with unanticipated problems. Lawmakers, of course, can’t anticipate all the screwy things that can happen in the course of legal proceedings, invariably leaving us with a mess without a solution.
This is where some of the broader legal concepts, such as due process and equal protection, usually come into play to save the day. This case, apparently, fell through the legal cracks.
A Christmas Gift from Fabio (Ochoa)
Few of us expected a present from the former head of he Medellin cartel this holiday season, but Fabio Ochoa gave us one anyway. Southern District of Florida Judge Marcia Cooke dismissed the first count against Ben Kuehne, the squeakiest clean lawyer in Florida, charging him with a money-laundering conspiracy for vetting the funds paid by Ochoa to Roy Black and concluding they were legitimate, when the government thought otherwise.
The defense moved to dismiss pursuant to 18 USC §1957(f)(1), and Judge Cooke agreed, holding that “the funds were for legitimate legal services.” Despite the simple language, this holding is of huge importance for the criminal defense bar, and hence a present for all of us.
I can’t help but wonder whether this ruling might have been different had the government not made the horrendous tactical error of prosecuting Ben Kuehne for the crime, rather than someone whose reputation for integrity is less stellar. While the law would have been no different, the fact that the government picked someone like Ben Kuehne as the target, creating such a huge groundswell of support for him and picking a lawyer who was so capable of putting together as strong a defense as possible, was a gift to the rest of us that rarely occurs.
Judge Cooke further held :
The dismissal of Count One of the Indictment does not prevent the Government from properly prosecuting attorneys for money laundering related crimes, nor does it totally negate criminal liability for an individual who may conspire to launder tainted funds to pay legal fees. The government’s concern that application of the § 1957 exemption would hinder or bar prosecution of anyone who had contact with tainted funds that were eventually used to pay criminal defense fees is unfounded. The Indictment, in Counts 2 through 6, also charges Defendants under 18 U.S.C. § 1956 with money laundering concealment conspiracy and concealment money laundering. There is no exemption contained in § 1956 for transactions necessary to preserve a person’s right to representation as guaranteed by the Sixth Amendment to the Constitution. None of these Defendants have moved to dismiss Counts 2 through 6. For good reason. Accepting the allegations in the Indictment as true, as required at this juncture, the crimes are appropriately plead and any further determination of the charges should be made on a Rule 29 motion.
This, of course, is entirely appropriate. Lawyers are no more entitled to commit crimes, including money laundering, than anyone else. But we should not be put at risk by simply accepting a fee for representing criminal defendants.
It’s been almost a year since news of Ben’s indictment broke, and has no doubt been a very unpleasant time for him. Judge Cooke’s decision no doubt will make this a special holiday in the Kuehne house. But for many criminal defense lawyers, the threat of prosecution for doing the job we are here to do has also haunted us over the past year.
While we are happy to play by the rules, we need to know what the rules are. This indictment changed them, and Judge Cooke’s decision has now changed them back. With this decision, we have returned to some semblance of equilibrium, so criminal defense lawyers can again be retained to represent defendants without fear of prosecution.
This is a great victory for Ben, and through him, all criminal defense lawyers, coming to us via the largess of Fabio Ochoa. Thanks, Fabio.
