Austin criminal defense lawyer Jamie Spencer asks a question that has always bothered me as well. Why do solo practitioners answer the phones, put on signs and letterhead, that they are “law offices?” If you are one person, with one office, does it make you feel bigger and better to pretend that there are more of you?
I remember a post by Bennett (of the Houston Bennetts) about some lawyer down in the Republic of Texas who pretended to have a dozen offices (link to be added when Bennett finds it for me) as if he was some major player. Instead, he just looked goofy and disreputable. Why exaggerate? Granted, this guy’s attempt to feign importance was borderline pathologic, but perfectly fine lawyers who have solid reputations and provide excellent services also play the game, albeit to a lesser extent.
I’m a solo. I have an office. I do not have offices, although at the moment I am operating out of my Palm Springs office (but for the fact that I’m not admitted to practice here), and yet I will not pretend that this is anything more than a transitory stop in my career. When I leave, I will still have but one office. And that’s good enough for me. No, not good enough, but perfect. It is what I am. I am a lawyer with one office, and damn proud of it.
So why do my brethren feel diminished by having only one office. Why do they feel that presenting the appearance of being bigger and grander than they are makes them bigger and grander. As Jamie points out, clients want your services, not the services of some unknown, unseen elf in the backroom. Tell them that you will be performing all work on their behalf and they’re happy. That’s what they want from you. So it does you no harm to admit the truth.
When asked for the name of my law firm, I give my name. When the quizzical look comes over people’s faces, wondering what happened to the 5 other names they expect to have strung on the end, I explain that it’s just me. I do not do so with shame or guilt. I do not justify why I practice alone. And I never try to give the appearance that there are more of me than there are. I’m a solo. And I’m good with that.
So why do others claim to have “law offices” and they don’t?
Author Archives: SHG
The Tradition of God in Office
Eugene Volokh posts about Michael Newdow’s latest effort to separate church and state. Newdow last sought to eliminate “under God” from the pledge of allegiance. He now seeks to preclude Chief Justice Roberts from telling President-elect Obama to repeat the words, “so help me God.” Not that Obama shouldn’t say the words, but that Roberts should ask him to say them. Newdow also seeks to stop the prayers offered during the inauguration, the invocation and benediction. Details of the lawsuit can be found at Religion Clause.
Eugene dismissed the argument against prayers during the inauguration quickly.
The lawsuit’s Establishment Clause argument about the inaugural prayers is foreclosed by Marsh v. Chambers (1983), which held that legislative prayers are generally constitutionally permissible, even to the extent they may endorse religion, because of the long tradition of such prayers dating back to the same Congress that proposed the Establishment Clause.
This sets forth two of the worst reasons for perpetuating the inclusion of prayer in government, which causes such general confusion and renders the otherwise sound arguments Newdow offers silly. Why bother to fight this issue when any victory does nothing to provide for a rational separation all the way down the line.
The two nasty reasons are tradition and precedent. Tradition isn’t a reason, but a historical fact connected to sentiment. While there is no doubt that our founding fathers invoked God, the nature of religious observance was different then, and their notion of a pluralistic society was letting Catholics close to the campfire. But they did it, and now we’re stuck with it forever.
Why? Precedent. One court said that separate is equal tradition trumps reason, and that’s the whole ball of wax. The intertwining of religion and government has perplexed many of us, who regularly ask the question of how one can rationally uphold the establishment clause while sentimentally ignoring it whenever there is some long-standing but irrational tradition of invoking religion. We aren’t that persuaded by precedent that irrational connections are the equal of sound logic.
But Newdow’s other point about the oath of office is a very powerful one. There is no reason why Obama, as a human being elected to public office, should not bring with him his personal belief in God. He just shouldn’t be told to say so, and if the words come out of his mouth, they will do so because he chooses to say them.
Except, of course, tradition.
At the Top of the Gizmo Scale
I awoke this morning in a lovely home in Rancho Mirage, with breathtaking views of snow-capped peaks in the distance, framed by waving palm trees and cacti. As it was still a bit early in the morning for left-coasters, I decided to brew a cup of joe so I could sit outside in the early morning dew just like they do on TV commercials for girlie coffees.
But this wasn’t an ordinary house. I was here as a guest of my former CEO of a telecom, who was here as a guest of a former CEO of a defense contractor, who was staying at one of his other homes on some other coast somewhere. So needless to say, there was no Mr. Coffee in the kitchen. There was a magnificent, sophisticated, complex machine designed to brew the most wonderful, perfect, aromatic coffee ever. I was screwed.
While I’m hardly technophobic, I admit to being somewhat less engaged by gizmos than others in the blawgosphere. But I can press a button with the best of them. Unfortunately, this skill does me little good when there are many buttons available for pressing. This coffee maker could have made NASA proud. But I was stymied. Worse still, if I pressed the wrong button and it exploded, I would have waken everyone else up. They would have not only witnessed my error, but been predisposed to being miffed with me. A bad combination.
The house in the stretch of desert between the snow-capped peaks had many such gizmos. It had a refrigerator that could inform one of the instant that peak crispness in celery was about to elapse. There were buttons and lights and grids along the wall where a light switch should have been. It was very impressive. I prefer to sit in the dark anyway.
From this, I realized that the best job in the world is to be a former CEO. Not just a CEO of anything, but of a big corporation. After all, you can’t give yourself a golden umbrella. And that’s what makes this the best job ever. You get paid entirely up front (much like criminal defense lawyer, but with many more zeros). And then, you discuss all the people you know and the companies they used to run. You have to go through the “run the company” stage in order to get to the really good stage, the former stage. It’s paying one’s dues.
Once you achieve success as a former CEO, you get to play for keeps on the gizmo scale. Your days are filled with accumulating gizmos and learning how to use them. Some take a few days to learn while others take months, even years. There are gizmos here that no one knows how to use, but look spectacular. I don’t know what they do, but I want them.
I cannot get them, of course, as I am not a former CEO. I have no paid my dues. I have never run a company, and wouldn’t even begin to know how to properly fulfill the position of former CEO. Seriously, I wouldn’t even know where to go to buy some of the things they take for granted. They don’t sell them in the stores I frequent. They are never on sale either, but even if they were, they wouldn’t buy them. A former CEO knows that if you can go to two stores, one where a gizmo is available for less and one for more, it’s crucial to go to the one where it’s sold at a higher price. If you have to ask why, you are not a likely candidate for former CEO.
I’m very happy to be friends with some former CEOs, and bask in the reflected glory of their gizmos. Did I mention the $6000 shower curtain? It is so worth it.
Why I’m a Better Business Model Than Biglaw
Being a criminal defense lawyer, my business model is relatively simple. A fee is determined and paid to retain my services. Sure, there are expenses along the way, and sometimes fees vary based upon how the case progresses (such as a fee for trial), but in essence the business model remains straightforward. The one thing that the business model does include is financing the client.
This means that some clients will not be able to retain me, no matter how much they might want to. For a variety of reasons, that have been explained elsewhere in this blawg, I avoid creating conflicts with clients that will damage the relationship. I avoid charging a fee and not getting paid. There are time when problems arise no matter what, but they are rare, and when they do, the impact on my business model is minimal. I keep it simple.
But as I learned from the Securities Law Blog, via Tannebaum’s twit, Biglaw has a different business model. Ever wonder how Biglaw can pay its first year associates about $200,000 a year (which, I learn, is billed out at $495,000 a year)?
You see, BigLaw finances all of this. BigLaw borrows money from BigBank to meet monthly expenses, salaries and partners’ draw. Silly business model, but apparently a necessary one. Heaven forbid one should pay expenses out of cash flow. No, you borrow money from the bank to pay the rent, and the salaries and the overhead. You then repay the bank with your receivables, and start all over again.
Sorta sounds like a ponzi scheme, doesn’t it? Not really, and it all works; until a recession comes along.
BigLoans meet Uncollectible Receivables. Add a dash of credit crunch, and its bye bye BigLaw.
So Biglaw has been paying all these fine young lawyers on borrowed money, waiting for their corporate clients, their well-heeled CEOs, to mail the check. But when very large corporations become very large rocks, there’s no blood to be had. When the bank shuts off the faucet, there’s no loan. That big sucking sound is Biglaw going down the drain.
Many lawyers think that solo practitioners who practice criminal defense are archaic in their expectation that legal fees be paid in advance. They laughed at us. Hah!
But my practice remains financially viable and sound. Not bad for a dinosaur. And I have no plans to hire any first year associates for anything close to market rate. It’s not the money (though I wouldn’t pay that even if I could). It’s that they don’t know how to practice law.
ER Docs: Cops are Too Violent
According to this study of emergency room physicians, 99.8% believe that police use excessive force in effecting arrests.
OBJECTIVE: To determine the clinical experience, management and training of emergency physicians in the suspected use of excessive force by law enforcement officers.
METHODS: Surveys were mailed to a random sample of academic emergency physicians in the USA.
RESULTS: Of 393 emergency physicians surveyed, 315 (80.2%) responded. Of the respondents, 99.8% (95% CI 98.2% to 100.0%) believed excessive use of force actually occurs and 97.8% (95% CI 95.5% to 99.1%) replied that they had managed patients with suspected excessive use of force. These incidents were not reported by 71.2% (95% CI 65.6% to 76.4%) of respondents, 96.5% (95% CI 93.8% to 98.2%) had no departmental policies and 93.7% (95% CI 90.4% to 96.1%) had not received training in the management of these cases.
CONCLUSIONS: Suspected excessive use of force is encountered by academic emergency physicians in the USA. There is only limited training or policies for the management of these cases.
A random sampling of criminal defense lawyers would have given similar numbers, but no one would believe us.
What’s surprising about this is that docs are not particularly big supporters of criminal defendants, particularly compared to cops. This comes across loud and clear in the comments at this ER doc blog. Clearer still is this blog from a paramedic, Rogue Medic, who isn’t buying into this at all.
I have to deal with some of the same abuse that the police deal with on a regular basis, just much less frequently than they do. The police do a great job of not overreacting to the conditions of the job. That does not excuse excessive force, but it does mitigate excessive force to some extent.
We all have bad days, even the police.
The cuffs too tight? They are supposed to be tight. Otherwise they do not do what they are supposed to do, which is keep the suspect from being able to escape, or hurt others (such as the ED doctor). It is rare that I do not hear, from someone in custody, that the cuffs are too tight.
I know, the empathy is overwhelming. But this is expected, particularly given the close working relationship between paramedics and cops. What curious about this guy, however, is that he has apparently enjoyed a little police love in the past.
I have been on the receiving end of handcuffs and I have been hit while in custody. After I was hit, the rest of the police in the room were just trying to restrain me. They were not trying to hurt me. I do not know what they did about the bad cop. I don’t know if they reported this, but they were not participating.
Amazing how the mind works, compartmentalizing the good guys and bad guys to avoid needless cognitive dissonance.
While the ER docs apparently know that the police tend to use excessive force, don’t expect them to be particularly worried about it. While almost all responded that it was happening, few every reported it. But then, it’s not like it was happening to them, and, as our friendly paramedic reminds, it’s only the bad apples.
H/T Walter Olson
Does Rehab Do Rehab?
The very word “rehabilitation” brings a smile to everyone’s face. We want addicted people to be rehabilitated. We want them clean. If only we had more rehab, we could eradicate the horrors of drug addiction. It’s that simple. So I’ve decided to start a new drug rehab program. You click your heels three times, say “I’m not addicted,” and we I give you a diploma and send you on your way.
What? You don’t think it will work. So what, it makes as much sense as many of the rehab programs that receive the $20 billion spent on it each year, according to the New York Times. As a lawyer or judge, we really have no clue whether these programs offer any empirically proven help to a very serious problem, but we do know that we would much prefer to help addicts. Someone asks, “is there a program” and when a spot comes open, we all clap. Hooray! We’ve cured another one. We mumble about how they have to “want” to be helped. We give a stern lecture. Then we send them on their way with our best wishes.
What no one ever asks is how they do that voodoo that we hope they do so well. We don’t care all that much about which program it is, as long as it’s a “program”. That’s the magic word. He went into a “program”, and we all expect that he will magically come out the other side cured of whatever ails him.
Every year, state and federal governments spend more than $15 billion, and insurers at least $5 billion more, on substance-abuse treatment services for some four million people.
Yet very few rehabilitation programs have the evidence to show that they are effective. The resort-and-spa private clinics generally do not allow outside researchers to verify their published success rates. The publicly supported programs spend their scarce resources on patient care, not costly studies.
The truth is, any program that serves as an alternative to incarceration is a good program. Sure, we hope that addicted clients are cured, but that’s not in our hands. That’s up to the program, for better or worse. We don’t dabble in the therapy, just getting our guy into a bed. That’s where out involvement stops. We’re really not qualified to judge whether the program is evidence based or total crap. Certainly the official women at intake think they doing something important, and we’re nice to them as long as they agree to take our guy in.
But I’ve long had doubts that most of these programs are self-promoting money machines that don’t actually do much of anything other than provide an alternative to prison. I remember one client calling me from his program and telling me that there were more drugs there than on the street. I asked him if he would rather be in prison, and he decided that the program wasn’t all that bad. It was the lesser of two evils.
Like so many of the silver bullet solutions to society’s problems, the word “rehabilitation” has come to capture our uncritical belief that it actually works. There are always anecdotal stories about people whose lives were turned around by rehab, and we extrapolate that into the belief that all rehab is good rehab, and that any failure is attributable to the “patient” not really wanting to be cured badly enough.
It would be nice if rehab served a purpose beyond simply keeping a client out of prison. Most of us really want to see drug addicts change their lives. But whether these programs actually do anything useful is beyond our knowledge. It’s just another leap of faith.
10 Things That Every Hotel Should Have
10. Enough towels for every registered guest.
9. The ability to control room temperature.
8. Room in the refrigerator for a bottle of water.
7. Free parking.
6. A clean bathroom. I mean, really clean, not just kinda clean.
5. Soap that is not scientifically altered to smell like a fruit.
4. Shampoo that is not intended for dry and unmanageable hair.
3. WiFi
2. Free WiFi
1. Coffee, anytime, anywhere.
This is premised on the Motel 6 theory, that being that if Motel 6 can do it for $49.95, the friggin Hyatt Regency Century Plaza can do it for $479.95. I’m shocked they don’t charge a nickel for every piece of toilet paper, given how they nickel and dime everything else in this joint. And then still screw it all up. My personal favorite is the ball of someone else’s used dental floss in the corner of the bathroom under the sink. Gag me.
The correct answer to “is there anything else I can do for you, Sir,” is “you would have to do a first thing for me before you can do ‘anything else’.”
Trying Cases in Other Time Zones
In New York, my typical wake up comes at about 5:00 am. Apparently, the gene that might have made my forebearers good farmers was so well-developed that it has stayed with me well past its usefulness. I enjoy having a couple of hours of quiet before the rest of the world turns on the coffee pot, and find it a very productive time. But that’s me.
The rest of the world, by and large, disagrees. I’m used to that. As I awoke in Los Angeles this morning at my usual hour, it was slightly earlier in California time. Los Angeles is not like New York. New York is the City that Never Sleeps. Los Angeles is the City that Sleeps Late. Try to get a cup of coffee in LA at 3 am. Ha! Silly New Yorker.
But this isn’t just a little coffee issue when you travel around the country for work. I tried a few cases in Anchorage, Alaska a while back, and learned just how bizarre this can turn out to be. Imagine, waking up at 2 am local time and sitting in the Capt. Cook Hotel waiting for room service to open for the day. Still four hours off.
Imagine finishing up cross-examination at 5:00 local time, and being ready to go to sleep for the night. Everyone else wants to go out for dinner and drinks, and all you can think about is climbing into the sack. After all, it’s 10:00 pm according to your head. You ate breakfast and lunch before the courtroom ever opened, and dinner was the burger you had during the lunch break.
There’s a reason that a typical trial day ends at 5 pm. That’s about as far as a mind can get while still retaining the level of acuity needed to make an FBI agent cry during cross. When their 5 is your 10, the mind is only good enough for the final of a reality show or maybe a melodrama best suited for teenagers. Even a decent mind has its limits.
I awoke this morning to a Los Angeles that was still fast asleep. There was no coffee to be had. There was no one to beg for coffee. At least I could get the people at the Capt. Cook Hotel to bring me coffee at 2:00 am. Next time I come to LA, I’m going to find a Motel 6 with an all night coffee pot.
Acquitted Conduct Sentencing, By the Numbers
Via Doug Berman, the 6th Circuit gave its Christmas present with its December 24th en banc decision on the constitutionality of acquitted conduct sentencing in United States v. White, Here’s a hint as to the 7-6 outcome; don’t invite the majority to your holiday party unless you are desperate for a really bad time.
For those who might not yet be aware of what acquitted conduct sentencing is, consider this: Defendant is charged with 3 counts in a federal indictment and goes to trial. On two counts, the defendant is found not guilty. Guilty on one count. The defendant is thereafter sentenced based upon all three counts in the indictment. Sounds crazy, doesn’t it?
It may be wrong, but it’s not exactly crazy. At least not if one understands the odd mechanics of legal precedent and reasoning, particularly as employed in the majority decision. Put together these concepts, which relate well under many circumstances.
1. The judge may consider, at the time of imposing sentence, all conduct relevant to the conduct for which the defendant has been convicted.
Watts regarded acquitted conduct as providing the sentencing court with “[h]ighly relevant—if not essential . . . information.” 519 U.S. at 151–52.
2. The standard of proof at sentencing as to the occurrence of conduct under consideration is preponderance of the evidence, rather than beyond a reasonable doubt as it would be at trial.
Relying on the different standards of proof that govern at trial versus sentencing, the Court concluded “that a jury’s verdict of acquittal does not prevent the sentencing court from considering conduct underlying the acquitted charge, so long as that conduct has been proved by a preponderance of the evidence.”
3. Along came Booker, holding that the federal sentencing guidelines were advisory, not mandatory, and Booker didn’t expressly overrule Watts.
Mendez accords with the view expressed by each of our sister circuits that Booker did not alter the Watts position on acquitted conduct: “Watts remains good law.”
4. While Watts rejected a 5th Amendment double jeopardy challenge to use of acquitted conduct sentencing, White is a 6th Amendment, right to jury case, challenging whether a judge can find facts (that the acquitted conduct occurred) when the jury did not.
As Booker itself recognized, Watts’s rejection of a double-jeopardy challenge to the use of acquitted conduct at sentencing did not close the door on subsequent Sixth Amendment challenges to sentences based on judge-found facts. Booker, 543 U.S. at 240–41 & n.4. Thus, although a court may properly look to facts underlying acquitted conduct in sentencing, the Sixth Amendment remains a backstop.
5. But the right to a jury determination of fact only applies if it produces an increase in the sentence to be determined based on mandatory sentencing guidelines.
Had the district court in this case relied on acquitted conduct in determining the range under a mandatory guidelines regime, that sentence would have violated the Sixth Amendment as interpreted in Booker. For the same reason that Booker precluded district courts from finding sentencing facts that ratcheted up mandatory Guidelines ranges, it would have prevented district courts from doing the same thing with respect to findings related to acquitted conduct.
6. If the sentencing guidelines are merely advisory, then the lower, preponderance standard prevails and finding of relevant conduct by a judge alone is sufficient.
For the same reason that Booker precluded district courts from finding sentencing facts that ratcheted up mandatory Guidelines ranges, it would have prevented district courts from doing the same thing with respect to findings related to acquitted conduct.
But these observations do not show that the Sixth Amendment prevents a district court from relying on acquitted conduct in applying an advisory guidelines system.
7. This is so because Post-Booker, the relevant limit for a 6th Amendment determination is the statutory maximum sentence, not the advisory guidelines sentence. So if the statute carries a max of 20 years, and the sentence doesn’t exceed 20 years, no harm, no foul.
In the post-Booker world, the relevant statutory ceiling is no longer the Guidelines range but the maximum penalty authorized by the United States Code. See United States v. Sexton, 512 F.3d 326, 330 (6th Cir.) (“Since defendants were sentenced under an advisory Guidelines scheme, the maximum statutory penalty that the district court could impose was determined by the statute of conviction, rather than by a Guidelines range calculated using only jury findings.”).
It’s hard to fault the reasoning, given how legal reasoning works. Sure, it’s disingenuous, since acquitted conduct sentencing was the norm under the sentencing guidelines when they were mandatory, and are now permissible because of Booker making them merely advisory. But you can’t blame sophists for doing a great job of it.
The majority takes comfort in the argument that since the statute provides for a 20 year sentence, and the defendant’s sentence, though more than double what it would have been without the acquitted conduct, falls just shy of that 20 years, he has no basis to complain. The circularity of this comfort is frightening, given that these are people who are asked to make decisions about other people’s lives. That Congress stuck an arbitrary 20 years on the back end of a statute offers no justification for using it whenever possible. Worse still, they know that and don’t care.
The line of reasoning is complete, in a world where precedent fills in logical gaps and decision-makers are more concerned with producing a consistent and unbroken line of caselaw than reaching a result that is almost universally considered fundamentally wrong.
The dissent offers a simpler argument: Using acquitted conduct to sentence a defendant is wrong, and the defendant received a sentence of more than twice what he would have but for use of acquitted conduct. When a jury rejects a charge, it must have meaning or the right to a jury trial itself has no meaning. No amount of sophistry changes the clear, basic sense of wrong that accompanies a sentence based upon the very conduct that a jury just rejected. This society is not prepared to accept such an outcome, no matter how symmetrical the legal reasoning supporting it.
The significance of a not guilty verdict is not merely in hearing the kind words, but in not going to prison for the underlying conduct anyway. The dissent understood that. As its asks, how does this promote respect for the law? The answer is obvious, It’s not just not the primary concern of the majority.
This case seems to be perfect for determination by the Supreme Court, with its 7-6 en banc split. But the better question is whether we want the reasoning of the majority enshrined in Washington. Remember, the Supremes aren’t always in perfect tune with fundamental fairness as understood by lesser people.
Some Christmas present.
Marquette Law School: Training Lawyers is Beneath Us
No matter how much one might have hoped that attending Marquette Law School might prepare one for a glorious career as a lawyer, prepare to have your hopes dashed. After noting that there is an “issue” with the pedagogical sensibilities of a certain faculty member, things went from bad to worse.
In a subsequent comment on the offending post at the Marquette Faculty Blog, we learn that the expectations of lawyers (note, not law students, not lawprofs, but lawyers) that law school would prepare a student for the practice of law was, well, foolish:
However, I strongly agree with Chris King’s sense of the proper relationship between legal education and the practice of law. We don’t want law school to be lawyer-training school. When we cave in to demands of that sort from the ABA and assorted study commissions, we actually invite alienation among law students and lawyers. Legal education should appreciate the depth of the legal discourse and explore its rich complexities. It should operate on a graduate-school level and graduate people truly learned in the law.
I would like to challenge this directly, but such vagaries as “the depth of legal discourse” and “its rich complexities” mean so little as to be beyond reproach. To a fault. So while I have no clue exactly what it is that this professor believes should be taught, one thing is clear, it isn’t how to practice law.
Imagine, the dirtiness of a law school teaching law students how to practice law. Disgusting. Revolting. How beneath the dignity of such a distinguished scholar. Instead, they should be taught . . . what?
The comment to which the quoted comment so strenuously agrees proposes that law school not be bothered training lawyers either.
I think its important to remember, like Professor Papke notes, that law school is an academic experience, if we want law school to be more of an apprenticeship then that is an entirely different discussion than perceived shortcomings of law school.
So where exactly do budding lawyers go to learn how to be full-fledged lawyers? Certainly not Marquette Law School. They don’t want any dirty, grubby lawyers coming out of there. Apparently, they are much happier producing graduates incapable of practicing law, but very popular at cocktail parties discussing the depth of it and its complexities.
And yet they still crank out law students who are expected to take the bar and hold in their scholarly little hands real people’s lives.
Of course, this could merely be the rambling of one faculty member, with the obsequious support of some of his more junior colleagues awaiting tenure and one law student who serves as his expert on public defenders due to a 6 month internship. But then, where are the lawprofs who actually have a clue what they are doing teaching law school? If I’m wrong, it would certainly be nice to have someone straighten me out.
PS: For the Texas view, see Mark Bennett’s post :
In fact, I propose a new motto for Marquette: If you want to practice law, go somewhere else.
Catchy, no?
