Author Archives: SHG

What to Do about Bernie Madoff

When someone is alleged to have stolen $50 billion, it’s the birth of an industry.  Previous financial felons like Jeffrey Skilling of Enron fame, $1 billion and 24 years, or Bernie Ebbers of Worldcom, $2.2 billion and 25 years, look like pikers in comparison.  So what do we do with him?

The first issue is bail.  Ken at Popehat provides a great discussion of the law pertaining to release from federal custody in contrast to this stroke of genius from The Corner at the  National Review.



A Despicable Decision   [ Larry Kudlow]



It was Federal District Judge Gabriel Gorenstein who released big-time, $50 billion scam-artist/fraud/crook Bernard Madoff. He is the one who did it. This ruling allows Madoff to stay out of jail, even though he couldn’t meet the original bail conditions that he provide four co-signers to his $10 million bond.

Write Judge Gorenstein. E-mail him. Call his office. (Contact info here.) Let him know what a terrible injustice he has done to every law-abiding citizen in this country, not to speak of the victims of this incredible fraud.

It is an outrage to me that Madoff is sitting back home in his $7 million Park Avenue pad after what he did to this country. What a joke. It is a complete and utter outrage. 


Don’t get too close to Larry Kudlow, or some of that foam around his mouth is likely to spray you.  As Ken ably notes, Kudlow’s venom may be well placed, but premature.  We try to convict first, then punish.  Bond is an entirely different matter, having nothing to do with punishment.  Of course, one can’t help but wonder when someone with Bernie Madoff’s resources, and at his age, might have an incentive to take an extended vacation in the south of France.  Bond secured by $10 million would likely keep most of us put, but this is what Bernie spends at El Posto for appetizers, and may not mean as much to him as to others.

Should we eventually get to the point of conviction, however, there remains a troubling question.  How does one sentence someone like Bernie Madoff?  Harlan Protass at Slate argues that we’ve lost all perspective.  While accepting the premise that more drugs should mean a longer sentence, he questions whether more money stolen means the same.

Tying jail terms to the amount of money lost also puts way too much power in the hands of prosecutors. It gives them the muscle to threaten long prison stretches in order to coerce guilty pleas. If it weren’t for the risk of lengthy sentences if convicted, many defendants might opt to test the government’s evidence before a jury.

Linking jail time to dollars lost also severs many of the ties to factors courts are supposed to consider when determining and imposing sentences. For example, a relatively short prison term—years, not decades—can be enough to deter prospective financial fraudsters. And economic offenders pose little future threat because they’re generally stripped of powers that would permit continued criminal conduct. Also, aren’t there more fitting and useful ways to punish the titan fraudsters of Wall Street? Strip them of their wealth. Make them work to pay back those they ripped off or to serve the public good.

The gist of Protass’ disconnect seems to connect more to the relative severity of sentence between white collar and street crime. How does one compare a murder to a billion dollar theft?  How does one compare the harm done to one person, and all those who are related to that one person, versus the 10,000 people whose lives are left in shambles as a result of a crime? 

Protass focuses almost exclusively on the individual deterrence factor, and is likely right that these defendants will never have an opportunity commit a similar crime again, ending any concern about recidivism.  But that’s not the only factor to be considered.  General deterrence seems a far larger concern here, and that may well be a numbers game of some concern.  Would you risk a five year prison sentence for $10 billion?  Many people would, and frankly wouldn’t be all that upset to serve it if they’ve hidden their assets well enough so that they (and their family) can enjoy the benefits in their golden years.

Doug Berman, naturally, has much to say about Protass’ sentencing issues.


For me the core problem with an obsessive concern with loss amounts is that, in many settings, the quantifiable amount of “loss” under the guidelines often has little or no connection to offenders’ culpable mental states and subjective culpability.  There are suggestions, however, that Bernie Madoff was in fact very culpable (perhaps for a very long time), and that the high loss levels in his case may have a direct relationship to his subjective culpability.

Moreover, Harlan’s effective commentary still effectively ducks in the hardest question: exactly what punishment levels should be the norm in large-scale frauds involving public companies.  He suggests that years and not decades may be the right ballpark, but there is a huge gulf between say three and thirty years imprisonment.  These cases are so hard — and the current guidelines are so inadequate — because we do not have a ready metric or shared moral sense of how best to assess these kinds of crimes.  But, as suggested above, I do think subjective culpability should be more important and that “loss” concepts are too important in the current federal sentencing scheme.

There’s no doubt that the existing guidelines are inadequate to handle cases such as this, truly beyond the anticipation of the United States Sentencing Commission.  But Doug’s point, that there is no rational metric to judge how much time in prison is proper for conduct of this magnitude, is certainly true.  Is it even possible?

From my standpoint in the trenches, the one troubling aspect of the Bernie Madoff case has been the tossing about of the $50 billion number.  As Harlan Protass notes, the sentencing guidelines put too much sentencing power in the hands of prosecutors when sentence is determined based upon financial loss.  Right now, we haven’t a clue whether this $50 billion is real or sheer hyperbole, yet it’s already so ingrained in the myth of the case that it’s got Larry Kudlow spitting.

Many of these cases leave the subject of loss amount wide open, almost impossible to ascertain with any degree of precision.  Rob a bank and we know how much was taken.  But sophisticated schemes involve all sorts of calculations, many in dispute, and reflect money in and out all over the place.  The government tends to only add up the money going out, without adding back the money coming in.  It’s too much trouble and doesn’t help their position. 

The guidelines are awful when it comes to determining loss amount for white collar crime.  Rather than provide for anything approaching a sophisticated assessment of actual loss, it basically punts and allows the court to estimate the loss in the most simplistic fashion.  Regardless of whether numbers are small or huge, they rarely have much foundation in actual loss.  With a good old murder, at least we have a body count.

Caselaw has helped on an ad hoc basis, narrowing the definition of loss to the actual amount gained in certain instances, but hardly enough to cover the problem with plea agreements that provide for an agreed-upon loss.  Typically, the more accommodating members of the white collar criminal defense bar will accept a plea that overstates the loss amount by millions because it’s what their buddies (and former co-workers) at the United States Attorneys office put on the table.  Once it’s accepted, there’s no longer an issue.  And we certainly wouldn’t expect them to turn down a plea over a few million, here and there.

But this case, if one accepts the myth as true, is so far beyond the outer limits of the guidelines that there is nothing with which to compare it.  Given his age, it’s likely that Bernie Madoff, bastion of NASDAQ, will end his life in prison.  But if Skilling and Ebbers received about a quarter century for their crimes, does Madoff get a millennium?  Still, it’s not like he killed anyone.  Or is it?

News of late has made it painfully clear how strong a motivator pathological greed can be, and the crimes it’s produced are of a magnitude that no one would have believed possible.  Contrary to Protass’ view, the sentences handed out are insufficient to provide general deterrence on the upper end of the scale.  People will take a lot of risk for a few billion. 

And a few billion loss hurts a lot of people. 

It still doesn’t answer the question of what constitutes a proper period of time in prison for a crime such as Madoff’s, and there is no calm and thoughtful consensus to guide us.  But this may open the debate about how many murders equals a billion dollars of loss, and whether there is any rational basis to connect the two together.  Given the nature of white collar crime of late, this is a discussion that must be had.

The Video Stars of Tomorrow

The pervasiveness of video has changed everything, and the ability of any 10 year old to upload a video to Youtube and turn Sgt. Friday into an international “star” has fundamentally altered the dark ugly secret of official misconduct and abuse.  So what do cops think about it?  The New York Times, finally figuring out that this is going on, decided to ask.


“People tape all the time,” said an eight-year veteran of the department, a female officer in Downtown Brooklyn who, like other officers questioned for this article, spoke only on the condition of anonymity because she is not authorized to speak to reporters. “It makes you uncomfortable, but that’s their right. You can’t stop them from taping.”

A search on YouTube unearthed dozens of encounters with New York police officers that often show the daily realities of policing at its most mundane.

A cadre of citizens have taken to regularly videotaping police officer in the performance of their duty.  For the most part, it’s a crashing bore.  But they want to capture that one moment when an Officer Pogan does “the Great Shove” and nails Critical Mass cyclist Christopher Long.  Why?  For the pride of “the 1,784,775 views of the video.” 


Several videos were made by a man calling himself Jimmy Justice, and they follow a similar formula: he confronts a police officer in the midst of some sort of apparent parking or driving violation. The traffic officer in the deli drove away from Mr. Justice with a smile, but others appeared to be more irked.

The unwitting star of a video titled “Traffic Cop Makes Illegal U-Turn” tells Mr. Justice, “Arrest me,” and encourages him to call 911. She finally concludes, “Step out of my face.”

In another video, “N.Y.P.D. Traffic Enforcement Sergeant Parks Illegally” (the titles of the videos are often benign compared to Mr. Justice’s hostility and obscenities that follow), Mr. Justice confronts a sergeant who parked beneath a no-parking sign to get money from an A.T.M.

“What was I supposed to do?” the sergeant says. “Stay hungry all day because of you?”

Hardly a top notch misconduct opportunity, but it’s telling.  Most officers seem to take the existence of video in stride, recognizing that it’s hear to stay and focused on them.  But not all:


An officer directing traffic in Brooklyn asserted that it is illegal to tape police officers. “If I know that he’s taking video, I’m going to walk up to him and stop him,” the officer said.

Now that might make for a more interesting video.  But the official PD word is otherwise:


That is not necessarily true, said Paul J. Browne, a police spokesman. Filming itself is not illegal, but interference with a police officer’s work can lead to arrest, he said. “Interference beyond just merely being obnoxious,” he said.

As the articles notes, videos are similarly useful to the police in capturing crimes occurring, and may well prove to be of great help to the police in identifying people committing crimes and providing evidence against them.  And since no police officer knows for sure that he’s not about to become the next international video star, the fact that officers know they may be on candid camera may not deter all misconduct, but will certainly have a positive influence on their choices.

And if you think Jimmy Justice is silly for videotaping such trivial misconduct as parking violations, just bear in mind that the cop might have given you a ticket had you done the same.  There’s nothing wrong with keeping them honest.


An officer in his patrol car in Harlem shrugged off the cameras. “It’s a brave new world now,” he said. “They’ve got all kinds of things. You could be recording me right now.”

Exactly.

Forward: The W Presidential Library

Taken wholesale from Lawrence Cunningham at Co-Op, because every President of the United States of America should get his due.


Dear Fellow Constituent:


The George W. Bush Presidential Library is now in the planning stages and accepting donations. The Library will include:


1. The Hurricane Katrina Room, still under construction.


2. The Alberto Gonzales Room, where you forget everything.


3. The Texas Air National Guard Room, where you don’t even have to show up.


4. The Walter Reed Hospital Room, where they don’t let you in.


5. The Guantanamo Bay Room, where they don’t let you out.


6. The Weapons of Mass Destruction Room, though no one has been able to find it.


7. The National Debt Room, which is huge and has no ceiling.


8. The Tax Cut Room (only the super rich, if any are left, can enter this one).


9. The Economy Room, which is in the toilet.


10. The Iraq War Room. (After you complete your first visit, the stern librarians make you go back for a second, third, fourth, and sometimes fifth visit.)


11. The Dick Cheney Room, in an undisclosed location, but complete with shooting gallery.


12. The Environmental Conservation Room, still empty, though full of promise.


13. The Supreme Gift Shop, where elections may be on sale.


14. The Airport Men’s Room, where some Senators have been observed hanging about.


15. The Decider Room, complete with dart board, magic 8-ball, Ouija board, dice, coins and straws.


The library will include many famous Quotes by George W. Bush, including the following:




1. ‘The vast majority of our imports come from outside the country.’


2. ‘If we don’t succeed, we run the risk of failure.’


3. ‘Republicans understand the importance of bondage between a mother and child.’


4. ‘No senior citizen should ever have to choose betweenprescription drugs and medicine.’


5. ‘I believe we are on an irreversible trend toward more freedom and democracy – but that could change.’


6. ‘One word sums up probably the responsibility of any Governor, and that one word is ‘to be prepared’.’


7. ‘Verbosity leads to unclear, inarticulate things.’


8. ‘I have made good judgments in the past. I have made good judgments in the future.’


9. ‘The future will be better tomorrow.’


10. ‘We’re going to have the best educated American people in the world..’


11. ‘One of the great things about books is sometimes there are some fantastic pictures.’ (during an education photo-op)


12. ‘Illegitimacy is something we should talk about in terms of not having it.’


13. ‘We are ready for any unforeseen event that may or may not occur.’


14. ‘It isn’t pollution that’s harming the environment. It’s the impurities in our air and water that are doing it.’


15. ‘I stand by all the misstatements that I’ve made.’…George W. Bush to Sam Donaldson


PLEASE GIVE GENEROUSLY!


Sincerely,


Jack Abramoff, Co-Chair
G.W. Bush Library Board of Directors


It’s going to be a difficult year for donations, but think of all that President Bush has done for us and return the favor.



The $605 Question

Times are tough for Biglaw.  Layoffs.  Firms folding.  Offers rescinded.  Bonuses cut in half.  So what’s the deal with this?



Judge Chin, in a polite and judicious order, asked Dewey [& LeBoeuf] to provide a bit more information on its fees:



It is difficult to evaluate the reasonableness of the hourly rates for most of the lawyers listed. For example, [five attorneys] — all simply described as “Associate” — have substantial hours billed at hourly rates of, respectively, $605, $605, $550, $605, and $605. Without knowing anything about their backgrounds, it is difficult for the Court to determine whether the requested hourly rates are reasonable. While I do not need descriptions of the backgrounds for all the lawyers, it would be helpful to have them for the lawyers who spent substantial amounts of time of these matters.



While I accept the representations that the requested hourly rates are D&L’s standard hourly rates for the individuals involved, I wonder whether the rates are high for legal services rendered in connection with a securities receivership proceeding. Is it reasonable to bill at hourly rates of $700 to $950 to $950 for partners and $425 to $550 to $605 for associates in the context of a securities receivership? Is it reasonable to bill at hourly rates of $285 for summer associates & $175 to $275 for paralegals?


Now I can well understand why Biglaw needs to bill out summer associates at $285 an hour, particularly.  The lunches and parties thrown in their honor aren’t free, you know.  But what’s with the $605 for associates?  How did that extra $5 get in there?

Yes, I know that they have student loans to pay off.  All the public defenders and assistant district attorneys, all the small firm lawyers, all the public service lawyers, must have gotten their education for free.  Lucky bastards. 

Lest anyone think that Dewey is taking advantage of the situation, consider this:

Dewey submitted an application to collect compensation and expenses for the first twenty or so days it served as receiver. Dewey’s tab? Approximately $2.2 million.

It’s not like it billed $2.2 million per week or anything.  That would be greedy.

And what if the bill isn’t paid?  There is always the Geeklawyer method of bill collection.  They could probably use a drink.  Bottoms up!

The SEO Revolution

When a niche blawger like me says something, nobody listens.  But when a Master of the Internet speaks out, his voice is heard throughout the blawgosphere.  Kevin O’Keefe has called for a Revolution.  I’m with him.

As everyone with eyes knows, Kevin is the Big Guy at Lexblog, home of the Lexblog family of Lexblogs.  His goal is to put a blawg in every lawyer’s hands, and if they all happen to be created by Lexblog, like Iowa Dirt Lawyer (his latest and my favorite new blawg name), the better.  But there is a line.

I’m getting sick of lawyers leaving comments here under the name ‘DC Divorce Lawyer’ or ‘Injury Lawyer.’ Is that what your kids call you? Is that how you get introduced when speaking to a group? You mean you use your real name. Amazing.

Why not have the decency to use your name when participating in conversations on my blog and other blogs around the net? Blogs really are conversations.

Even if you don’t care whether you look like an idiot, lawyers publishing blogs aren’t blogging for the benefit of sleazy lawyers looking for a free way to get SEO for their blog or website. It may sound unbelievable, but lawyers are blogging to provide value to a growing Internet discussion, not for SEO to get traffic to a website.

Kevin and I have had a number of discussions about the future of the blawgosphere, and how what we do now impacts on how bright, or dull, the future looks.  We disagree about a couple of things.  But we agree about one very important thing.  The vitality of the blawgosphere depends upon lawyers using it to offer substantive content.   Put another way, if the blawgosphere exists to serve as a big, ugly, nasty infomercial, no one will come.  No one should come. 


Kok_cubs_pic


When someone comes to Kevin for a Lexblog, he implores them to use this tool carefully.  It is not, he tells them, a bludgeon to beat potential clients over the head.  It is a scalpel, they are told, with which to surgically dissect the legal world in fascinating ways by providing interesting, informative and entertaining reading.  Write things that people want to read is the mantra of Lexblog, and you will attract readers.  Write crap, or worse still, write about how wonderful you are, and you will be very lonely.

Kevin markets Lexblog to lawyers who want to market in the blawgosphere.  Yes, it leaves a sour taste in my mouth.  But I’m not so foolish as to think that my aversion to marketing will change lawyers’ motivations, and I am not against lawyers having clients and making a living, even though I don’t think this is the right way to go about it.  Nonetheless, I admire Kevin’s position that substance is the right path.  After all, had Hemingway written novels for no other reason than to get pocket change for his next drink, would his stories be less macho?  Of course not.

Of all the horrors perpetrated on and by lawyers seeking to elevate their online presence, aside from the mass emails seeking link exchanges and faculty positions at Solo Practice University, the most nefarious is the commenter who seeks SEO supremacy.  And of these, the lowest is the one who pays the legal marketer to have some starving third-world child spam comments on their behalf. This is the true nadir of the blawgosphere.

It outrages Kevin.  It outrages me.  It should outrage you as well.  But do you see it?  Do you get it?

Lawyers can be a funny breed of human being.  Many possess agile minds, which allow them to perform their functions well in the face of adversity.  This same skill, however, also allows them to construct arguments that rationalize their own behaviors, deny that they are doing what they claim to despise in others.  Sometimes the dissonance is real, whether by intent or distinguishing act, and sometimes it’s just a lot of hooey. 

Indeed, the irony is made plain in the comments to Kevin’s post, where one commenter so fundamentally missed the point that he posted under the name of some blog rather than a real name, as did all others.  Yet, this comment was directed at distinguishing evil blawgers who market shamelessly from legitimate blawgers who market shamelessly.  One can only assume that this blogger places himself in the “good” category, evidence to the contrary notwithstanding.

Now that the Master of the Blawgosphere has called for Revolution, I echo (or retweet if this was tweeterville) his cry.  Join us.  Spread the word.  Save the blawgosphere.  And I join  Grant Griffith in saying, thanks Kevin for taking the lead. 

Lawyer Fashionista: The Naked Head

That’s right, it’s time again for me to assist you with fulfilling your dreams of sartorial splendor.  Today is headwear day at Simple Justice.  There once was a time when every well-dressed man and woman wore a chapeau.  As a result, rules were developed to distinguish when it was appropriate and when it was not.  These are very important rules, and surmount such mundane concerns as religion.  Of course, back then everyone was Christian, so it really didn’t implicate any external concerns other than hat head,

While the fedora days are done (boater in the south), the rules remain.  Lisa Valentine, according to the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, via Court-o-Rama (the least dangerous blog), thought she need not concern herself with proper headwear etiquette, apparently assuming that her Muslim belief in headcovering absolved her of fashion compliance.  Let that be a lesson to all:  Proper dress surpasses such trivialities as religious demands.  At least in Georgia.

Valentine said she was accompanying her 19-year-old nephew to address a citation Tuesday morning when she was stopped at the metal detector and told she would not be allowed to enter the courtroom with a head scarf.

Valentine, an insurance underwriter, told the bailiff that she had been in courtrooms before with a scarf on and that removing it would be a religious violation.

Frustrated, she turned to leave and uttered an expletive. She said the bailiff then told her she could take the matter up in front of the judge. She said she was handcuffed and taken into Rollins’ courtroom.

“They were putting me in there like I was some sort of criminal,” she said.

The judge ordered her to serve 10 days in jail, where she was forced to remove her headscarf.

Like some sort of criminal?  Am I the only one who noticed that she’s an “insurance underwriter?”  Does AIG ring a bell?  Connect the dots, people.  Exactly how many billions of dollars must be lost before we recognize a headwear conspiracy?

The rule prohibiting headwear in a courtroom has been ridiculed as capricious by such luminaries as Eugene Volokh, who writes : 


And this, it seems to me, makes perfect sense, especially when the concern is simply about decorum and not juror prejudice. (Note that this case didn’t involve a jury trial.) Whatever might be the symbolism of wearing a normal hat indoors, surely there’s no disrespect that’s usually intended, or likely to be reasonably perceived, when someone is wearing religiously mandated garb. A judge need not feel insulted by an Orthodox Jew’s wearing a yarmulke, or a Muslim woman’s wearing a hijab.

Apparently Gene is unaware of the Hasidic command that all New York Yankees baseball caps be worn slightly askew.  That may be fine with him, but must the rest of us be subjected to this reverse religious discrimination?  Hmmmm, I think not.

Of course, for all the hubbub about this hijab, inadequate attention has focused on Ms. Valentine’s verbal reaction when told by the court officer to take a hike, whereupon the turned and “uttered an expletive.”  Notably, the bailiff only then acted, as she was on her way out the door to take up the issue with the ACLU, no doubt on retainer with a local haberdasher.

Might the expletive have had a little something to do with her being handcuffed and held in contempt?  We don’t know what she said to the bailiff, though Eugene takes a vicious stab by attributing a Randazza-like word that is highly unlikely to come from the lips of a hat-wearer. My guess would be that the word was much more benign, though I am too refined to tell you which one it is.

My issue with accepting at face value the claim that it was the hijab that brought a 10 day contempt sentence down on Ms. Valentine’s head was that she had reluctantly acquiesced in adhering to this most critical rule in the prevention of society’s descent into anarchy by leaving.  No harm, no foul.  On the other hand, no self-respecting Georgia Bailiff will allow a woman to utter such language in his presence unless she is also possessed of ample décolletage.  Lacking a photograph of Ms. Valentine, we will assume that she bears no likeness to Daisy Duke.

While the use of epithets is constitutionally protected in 27 of 50 states, one’s understanding of its impact on the fragile psyche of a courtroom bailiff must necessarily be taken into account.  After all, this woman was an insurance underwriter.  To expect the bailiff not to crack under the pressure asks far too much.  But as has become far too commonplace these days, the main stream media would prefer to blame it on the headwear, being comprised as it is by fashion Philistine liberals.

Is Somebody Running for DA?

Many of my friends would be astounded to know this, but since Leslie Crocker Snyder left the bench to assume her rightful place as successor to legendary Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morganthau, she and I have become great friends.  You don’t believe me? Ha!  Check this out:
 
















Leslie Crocker Snyder for Manhattan D.A.


December 16, 2008 


Leslie Crocker Snyder


Dear Scott,




With the bustle of the holiday season upon us, I just wanted to take a moment to thank you for your continuing friendship and support.  Despite the difficult times we face, this has nonetheless been an amazing year for our country.   We head into the New Year with a renewed sense of hope, despite the challenging times ahead.


This has also been a year of planning for me.  We have begun gearing up for the 2009 election, with a great deal of success.  I am grateful for all the support I have already received (and thanks so much to those of you who joined me for our wonderful holiday event on December 8th) and humbled by my recent law enforcement endorsements.  With all that has been going on this year, this early support has meant so much. 


But we are just beginning, and I plan to hit the ground running after the New Year.  I am excited to have you on this journey with me and hope that you will consider taking an active role as we go forward.  If you have not yet signed up to volunteer and would like to do so, please visit my campaign’s website at www.snyderforDA.com .  We will be contacting you soon. 


However, this is a time for friends and loved ones.  I wish you and your family a happy and healthy holiday season, and I look forwarding to speaking with you in the New Year.


Best wishes,


Leslie


 

 

You think Leslie sends holiday greeting to just anybody?  I’m special.  Notice how she says she will be contacting me soon?  I think she wants to invite me to dinner.  Something quiet, intimate, where we can discuss her plans for the future and I can be one of her most trusted advisors.  Yeah, that’s probably it.

I guess she’s gotten past that whole 60 Minutes thing.

 

Why Good Judges Matter, Part 2

Via Turley, an effort by John P. Roache, a private attorney representing the City of Boston, to have United States District Judge Nancy Gertner disqualified from sitting on a case involving the Boston Police Department is rebuffed by the 1st Circuit.


The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit has refused to disqualify US District Judge Nancy Gertner from a lawsuit against the Boston Police Department for a wrongful conviction in three rapes. Counsel for the department charged with her showing “deep-seated favoritism and antagonism” in comments made in court.

What did Judge Gertner do that was so awful?  According to Boston.com,


At an Oct. 8 hearing in her Boston courtroom, Gertner questioned whether plans to deport the plaintiff, Ulysses Rodriguez Charles, to his native Trinidad soon were “somehow related” to his lawsuit. His suit is scheduled to go to trial in April, and Gertner urged federal authorities to delay deporting him until May.

Imagine.  A Judge doing her job.  That’s outrageous.  It outraged Roache sufficiently to submit a 21 page memorandum seeking to remove herself from the case, alleging that she


disparaged his client recently by voicing “wholly unfounded suspicions” that federal immigration authorities might have colluded with the city to try to deport Ulysses Rodriguez Charles before his suit goes to trial in April.

Now here’s the real story.  The problem with Judge Gertner isn’t that she is biased, but that she’s not.  She doesn’t default to the “cops are always right” position.  She doesn’t assume that cops can’t be wrong.  She actually, really, honest-to-Godly, considers the possibility that the defendant might be telling the truth or, oh no!, innocent.  It’s an outrage.

The system has relied upon judges, by default, siding with the government.  When a judge doesn’t play that game, the government doesn’t see the judge as fair and neutral.  The government doesn’t want a judge who’s fair and neutral.  The government expects to waltz into court with a leg or two up on its adversary, and a judge who knows that it wins every close call every time. 

When a judge comes along who is disinclined to cut the government a break as needed, she becomes the enemy of the government and is therefore, in the government’s eyes, biased against it.  If you’re not for them, you’re against them.  Since Nancy Gertner isn’t for them, she must be biased.  At least as far as the government is concerned.

Why Good Judges Matter, Part 1 (Update: The Lawyerly Excuse)

Via @joelrosenberg (that’s his twitter name, in case you didn’t know), though around here he’s generally known as J-dog, comes this horrific story from the St. Petersburg Times.



For two days, a Hillsborough judge watched a young lawyer struggle through a murder defense and lose.


Then, as a deadline loomed, Circuit Judge William Fuente waited for customary defense motions to overturn the Dec. 4 conviction or request a new trial.


No motions came.


Finally on Monday, Fuente took the rare step of initiating his own order of a new trial for defendant David Rolon, saying defense attorney Byron T. Christopher “did not render effective assistance” and didn’t adequately prepare for trial.


“The defendant, through no fault of his own, did not receive a fair and impartial trial,” Fuente wrote in a four-page order.


It isn’t supposed to happen this way.  Defenders of the faith swear that lawyers, duly admitted to practice, cannot be incompetent.  Yet they sometimes are.  Thankfully, and I mean that in an extreme sense, Judge Fuente did his job and protected the defendant from his own lawyer’s incompetence.  Other judges might have decided that the defendant made his bed, so screw him.

So who is this lawyer, defending a man accused of murder?


Christopher, 30, privately retained as Rolon’s attorney, didn’t return calls for comments. Numerous other attempts by the Times to reach him Tuesday were unsuccessful.

The Florida Bar Association lists Christopher as a member of its Young Lawyer’s Division. Public records show he began work as an assistant Hillsborough state attorney in April 2005, the same month he was admitted to the Florida Bar. Five months later, Christopher no longer worked for the Hillsborough State Attorney’s Office. It was unclear Tuesday why he left.

Privately retained.  Former state attorney.  Member of the FBA, Young Lawyer’s Division.  I wonder what his marketing blawg would look like?

A while back, there was a heated debate here about whether it was demeaning to the bar to state that there are lawyers out there who are not competent to serve the purpose for which they were retained.  The sad fact is that the defendant in this murder case no doubt believed that he had retained competent counsel to represent him at trial.  He was wrong.  He was disastrously wrong.  But for the Judge’s willingness to step into the middle and protect this defendant’s 6th Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel, sua sponte, he might well have the rest of his life in prison to ponder just how wrong he was.

Some cases, it gets this bad.  And some trials, there won’t be a Judge Fuentes to make sure that the defendant is not convicted in the absence of effective assistance of counsel. 

Update:  Florida attorney Byron T. Christopher will not be publicly humiliated without fighting back.  Oh no.  From the Other Times :


“I feel like he wanted to embarrass me,” Christopher, 30, said of an order filed Monday by Circuit Judge William Fuente, calling for a new trial because Christopher hadn’t rendered effective assistance to his client.

Christopher said Rolon found him through word of mouth, which is how he says he gets 98 percent of his clients. 

“I’m an excellent attorney,” he said. “But when you can’t put on a defense, what can you do?”

He said Circuit Judge Ronald Ficcarotta denied a request to withdraw from the case after Christopher complained Rolon paid only 25 percent of what he owed.

Christopher said he spent 40 hours preparing a defense for Rolon that Fuente ruled inadmissible just before the Dec. 3 trial began. Despite the setback, Christopher said he “gave 110 percent” to Rolon’s case.

Oh, this smells like it requires another post on the subject of getting paid versus doing your job.  But there is one additional aspect that shouldn’t go unnotice:


Fuente noted in his order that Christopher told jurors he had spent less than five minutes reviewing Rolon’s testimony before putting him on the witness stand. Christopher said he did so to show jurors that Rolon hadn’t been coached into what to say.

Alternate juror Delores S. McCain told the Times that it appeared Rolon had poor legal representation. She said Christopher fumbled with his note pad and his questions seemed to confuse the defendant.

“I think the jury’s perception of me was based on the way the judge was treating me,” Christopher said.

Somehow, I think that Chistopher may be wrong about this. 

When Lawprofs Wear Black

Rick Hills is at it again.  Over at PrawfsBlawg, he’s up to his old tricks of trying to argue that the law professors should stop ripping each others’ heads off and start supporting each other for judicial appointments.  Remember the last time, when he proposed the lawprof “non-aggression pact?”


Here are the terms of the pact: Law profs agree to support any academic appointment to the federal district or appellate bench, full stop. Left law profs will endorse, say, Professor Doug Kmiec for the Ninth Circuit when a Republican occupies the White House; Right law profs will endorse, for instance, Dean Elena Kagan for the D.C. Circuit when a Democrat occupies the White House.

Despite my calm and thoughtful explanation of why this wasn’t a great idea, Hills has been emboldened by the unanticipated support of another lawprof, Carl Tobias, over at Findlaw, who presents a relatively short piece on why lawprofs would make particularly good appellate judges.


Much of the work that law professors undertake strikingly resembles the responsibilities that appellate judges discharge. For example, when conducting scholarship, academics objectively analyze, synthesize and criticize a series of case precedents, attempt to evaluate relevant legal issues from a “big picture” viewpoint, and proffer suggestions for improvements in the law. Appellate judges, in turn, frequently read, evaluate and synthesize a line of opinions and apply their legal reasoning to the facts of specific cases.

Just so we’re clear, this addresses only one aspect of Hills’ proposal, that lawprofs are particularly well suited to be appellate judges, and not the other aspect involving lawprofs ignoring each others ideological positions by sitting silently as part of a non-aggression pact. 

I’ve no doubt that there are some lawprofs who would make great judges.  I’ve no doubt that some would be awful.  But the blanket argument that lawprofs should be a feeder job to the appellate bench is not just problematic to real lawyers, but not well received by other lawprofs.

Doug Berman says:


I fear that too many modern legal scholars, perhaps especially many modern constitutional scholars, tend to give far too little attention and thought to a broad array of criminal justice issues that regularly occupy the day-to-day work of the federal judiciary.  Put another way, I fear that too many criminal justice issues tend to get second-class treatment in the modern legal academy.  I would hate to have a federal appellate bench filled with academics inclined to give criminal justice cases second-class treatment on appeal.

Orin Kerr says:



Perhaps, but there are also reasons to be cautious about this approach. To get a flavor, see this post from back in 2005 about whether law professors should be picked for the Supreme Court:



My instinct is that extensive experience as a law professor probably isn’t very good training for service as a Supreme Court Justice.
Here’s my thinking. As most practicing lawyers know, academia can be a little bit, well, quirky. Law professors generally are rewarded for being clever, or for catching a wave of fashionable ideas and writing a lot about them. Within the academy, it’s frequently better to be gloriously wrong than modestly right.
In my opinion, the qualities of a good Justice are very different. I side with Learned Hand on this one: “The spirit of liberty is the spirit which is not too sure that it is right.” Being fashionable, exceedingly clever, or gloriously wrong aren’t assets for judges.


After Hills’ first stab at this idea, fellow PrawfsBlawger Paul Horwitz said:

It is possible that law professors are less likely to be “corrupt” than these other lawyers, depending on how you define the term, if for no other reason than that they are less likely to be worldly, or at least successfully worldly. But there are all kinds of ways for judges to be corrupt. One of those, and the most important, is to lack impartiality; and I see no reason for assuming that law professors will be impartial than any other lawyer, particularly once you factor in partiality based on political ideology.

An anonymous commenter at PrawfsBlawg says:

Are you kidding me? Under this “logic,” the entire legal academic community would have had to support Yale professor Robert Bork’s appt. to the Court! (Or how do you feel about Boalt’s John Yoo appointment to the federal judiciary?) Come on.

According to Rick Hills, I called him “elitist”.  Nu uh.  It was more along the lines of “nutsy-fagan”.  I try to avoid words that have three syllables in only seven letters.  That’s probably why he didn’t include a link to my post, so that no one would notice that he’s put scholarly-type words in my mouth, the Brute.  My favorite part of my response was this:

And if the disconnect is bad at the trial level, the appellate level can be totally disconnected from reality.  It’s like explaining the flavor of food you’ve never tasted. 

I don’t doubt that there are some lawprofs, with adequate real world experience and who can withstand appropriate ideological vetting, who would make superb appellate judges.  But to contend that lawprofs, per se, make for better appellate judges, and to then argue that the rest of the academy should keep their traps shut and support one of their own, is just, well, nuts.

It should be noted, of course, that I have a horse in this race.  Since I represent real people who might have a case that comes before one of these appellate courts, it’s in my professional interest to have judges sitting on the appellate bench who have some degree of recognition that their doctrinal love ultimately impacts actual human beings.  Someone has to stand up for people.