Author Archives: SHG

How to Learn If Your Kid is a Junkie

While burgeoning heroin use in the suburbs of Long Island is certainly something to be concerned about, one has to seriously wonder how and why the Nassau County Legislature had to enact a law to let schools and parents know that their kids were junkies.  According to Newsday,


Nassau lawmakers approved a bill Monday requiring police to notify school districts about heroin arrests, and establish an Internet map on the county police department’s Web site to post those charged to create a broader awareness about the highly addictive drug.

The chief sponsor of the bill, Legis. David Mejias (D-Farmingdale), said it was necessary to include the school boards because “a few of them” had refused to recognize they had a heroin problem.

However, he amended the bill to mandate “communitywide dissemination” of heroin arrests by having police create a Web site that would map arrests for possession and sale of heroin.

The theory behind this law was that schools were clueless about heroin use, and needed to be told where heroin was being sold so that they would . . . do what? 


Andrew Malekoff, executive director of the North Shore Child and Family Guidance Center, testified that it was difficult for parents, and even legislators, to confront heroin abuse.

“Public support must replace secret pain, and therein lies the challenge in Natalie Ciappa’s [a Suffolk County teenager who died of a heroin overdose] Law,” Malekoff said. “With this law comes enormous responsibility. School officials will no longer be able to keep a straight face and say, as I have heard countless times, ‘There is no drug problem in my school district.'”

Is the purpose of this law to embarrass school district in denial that they have a drug problem within their community?  Certainly, school boards should engage in measures to recognize and address student drug use, teaching them to steer clear of drugs and to identify students using drugs and help them obtain treatment.  But this seems an awfully heavy-handed way to accomplish this task, given that having a bunch of junkies running around a school is ordinarily viewed as a problem without requiring a public airing.

But this is Long Island, the land of denial.  The school boards don’t like being singled out one bit:


Jay L.T. Breakstone, vice president of the Nassau-Suffolk School Boards Association, objected to having the boards included in the legislation, arguing that singling them out for notification would make them the targets of lawsuits.

And don’t believe that lawsuits are the issue for second.  It’s about school report cards and house prices and pressure to bear on school boards to fix problems with kids that parents leave behind.  Parents on Long Island do nothing wrong.  None ever has.  Just ask one, and he’ll tell you. 

This is a ridiculous law, inspired by a ridiculous situation created by a ridiculous group of people who can’t manage to come to grips with their own personal reality.  How many parents are so fundamentally out of touch with their children that they don’t notice that junior is a junkie?  Since when do school boards have the responsibility of rooting out drug dealing, arresting and prosecuting the perpetrators?  And if they have this significant of a problem, hasn’t everyone in the chain of responsibility already blown it big time?

It’s not to suggest that the Legislature is being disingenuous in trying to do what it can to deal with a problem that schools are apparently ignoring or denying.  However, this hardly seems like an effective to do so, and it remains unclear what the Legislature thinks the school districts are supposed to do about it, other than sit there red-faced.

On the other hand, there’s no mention of how this law will impact those arrested for drug sales, following up on Nassau County’s “Wall of Shame” of those arrested (but not yet convicted) of DWI.  Will these maps only show locations of alleged drug sales (such as Joe Smith’s living room) or will the information include the identities of arrested but presumed innocent “drug dealers.”  It’s a shame that the prime sponsor of this law, David Mejias isn’t a lawyer, aware of the constitutional issues raised by these dubious efforts to rid Long Island of teenage junkies.  Oh wait.  he is.  Never mind.

And, for the record, Newsday supports this law, because children are good and heroin is bad.  Some very deep thinking went into this one.

But For Video, Officer Pogan Indicted

Who can forget the video of New York City Police Officer Patrick Pogan nailing bicyclist Christopher Long during the Critical Mass ride last July.  It was a classic, to be forever remembered as “The Big Shove.”  The New York Times announced yesterday that Pogan has been indicted in New York County, a mere 5 months later, (H/T Turk).

So what if it took the District Attorney five months to indict Pogan, despite the fact that there was a video that conclusively disproved the allegations under penalty of perjury made by Pogan against Long in a criminal court complaint.  What’s five months between friends?  It happened.  Can’t we just be happy about that?  Stop muttering “justice delayed is justice…” 

Stuart London, representing Pogan, had this to say:


“My client denies any wrongdoing in this matter,” Mr. London said in an interview Monday afternoon. “I would have people withhold judgment until all the evidence comes out about the bicyclist’s actions prior to my client taking action.”

But Stu, there’s a VIDEO.  Your guy, the cop, swore that the biker tried to run him down.  There’s a VIDEO that shows that your guy is lying.  Have you given any thought to an insanity defense?  No, your right. Stupidity and insanity are not the same thing.

So why should I be so harsh toward this defendant, when preaching that defendants should be presumed innocent?  It’s true that there’s some dissonance here, but beyond the fact that there’s a VIDEO and that Pogan is a cop, there is one additional factor that removes that bone in my head that makes me want to be a little bit sympathetic. 

The fact that Pogan sought to have Long, the cyclist, prosecuted based on a flagrantly perjurious complaint for a crime that never happened in order to cover up Pogan’s own vicious assault sucks all the sympathy out of me on this one.  But for video, Pogan would have been successful and Long would have gone down.  But for video, no one would have believed that this case wouldn’t travel the ordinary path, where judges, prosecutors, defense lawyers and perhaps even jury just shook their collective heads and assumed that the cop was right, the cyclist was wrong, and then it would be time to share a beer at Forlini’s after the cyclist was sentenced.  Life as usual at 100 Centre Street.

Instead, five months later, Patrick Pogan stands indicted.  But for video, this would not have happened.

The Criminal Mind

Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy posts about an opinion letter from the Washington Legal Foundation entitled, Mens Rea Requirement: A Critical Casualty of Overcriminalization. The problem is set out in the second paragraph:

If you ask a non-lawyer to identify a principle of law, he or she is likely to respond with “Ignorance of the law is no excuse.” For much of our history, this would have been a perfectly sensible response. Traditionally, the purpose of the criminal law was the punishment of those who wrongfully caused harm to others, not the regulation of interpersonal affairs. One does not need notice of what the law requires to know that one should not intentionally harm one’s fellow citizen. The mens rea requirement of the criminal law embodies the fundamental principle that punishment requires personal fault.

As legislative bodies have exhausted every possible permutation of malum in se  offenses, the ones everyone knows or should know are wrong without having to be told in explicit detail, they have increasingly crafted malum prohibitum to be used as a regulatory framework to control more behavior that isn’t inherently wrong, but that they have decided for whatever reason shouldn’t be done.  These offenses don’t necessarily involve any moral fault on the part of the perpetrator, but rather a choice between various options, one or more of which has been denominated a crime.

The concluding paragraph sums up the position nicely:


By passing statutes that criminalize innocent or merely negligent behavior or that are so broadly defined that citizens cannot be sure when they are violating the law, the federal and state governments have significantly eroded the traditional mens rea requirement for criminal conviction. This is a development to be much regretted.  There are many things a liberal government may do to improve social welfare.  Government may properly ask individual citizens to make significant sacrifices for the common good.  However, there are also many things a liberal government may not do.  Visiting the opprobrium and stigma of criminal punishment on those who have not behaved in a blameworthy way is among them.  Such official scapegoating is inconsistent with a liberal legal regime. A just legal system does not permit punishment without fault.  Hence, justice demands the reinvigoration and preservation of the mens rea requirement for criminal punishment.

Even amongst lawyers, even criminal defense lawyers, this has become an increasingly troubling issue.  Criminal law has become result oriented, to the exclusion of any concern about mens rea.  When someone is killed, a crime must have been committed.  When someone is harmed, it must be because of a crime.  The fact that the conduct was innocent or negligent no longer seems to deter the demand for punishment.  It’s all about the outcome and that every harm must have a crime to combat it.

Even Doug Berman has difficulty finding this to be too much of a problem:


Ironically, I am not as troubled as the author of this letter by the use of the criminal law to achieve certain regulatory ends.  What does trouble me greatly, however, is the use of severe criminal punishments in the absence of serious culpability.

Of course, this assumes that once criminal law is used to discourage socially undesirable conduct, the slippery slope tends to encourage increasingly harsh penalties if the effect of the law isn’t easily achieved.  One need look no farther than the draconian War on Drugs to find an example of this affect. 

The notion that innocent or negligent behavior should be criminalized is one of the foundational problems as legislatures continue to increase the number of crimes and the volume of human conduct that subjects people to criminal punishment.  Rarely does anyone ask whether there is any moral culpability attached to the conduct at stake, and rarely does anyone care whether the crime sweeps in the innocent along with the guilty.  We want to stop a result, and we’re prepared to take no prisoners in the effort.  But crime isn’t what comes as a consequence of conduct, but what motivates the conduct in the first place. 

This is indeed a development that compels a return to the basics of criminal law, the mens rea requirement.  This is not to say that law cannot or should not be used to encourage or discourage behaviors that impact on society.  But it is to say that converting otherwise innocent or merely negligent conduct into a crime is not the way to do so. 

The Particular Problem with Crimes Against Children

One of the most vexing conflicts between the defense’s need for sufficient particularity in an accusation and the need to protect children from crime, especially sex crimes, was addressed by the Appellate Division, Second Department in People v. Bennett, via New York Criminal Defense.

In that case, the prosecution charged that a second-grade victim was twice raped within a 7 month window, close to the 9 month window that was previously held to be a per se unreasonable in People v Beauchamp.  The court held that as the window came closer to the 9 months, the court was constrained to apply “heightened scrutiny” to assure that the defense wasn’t stymied by the lack of specificity and that the prosecution took every action possible to provide a clearer time frame for when the crime was alleged to have occurred.


[A] significantly lengthy period is a factor to be considered, with “proportionally heightened scrutiny” given to whether the People’s inability to provide more precise times can be justified as against the important notice rights of the defendant.

Notwithstanding the requirement that a defendant be informed with particularity of when a crime is alleged to have occurred, the courts have long since abandoned the rule when it came to crimes against kids.  Frequently, no one knows that the crime occurred until long afterward, and children are usually unable to specify a date, and frequently even a season, when the crime occurred.  Confronted with this dilemma, something had to give.  Naturally, it was the defendant’s rights that were tossed.

These are nightmare cases.  No one can be unsympathetic toward a child alleged to be a rape victim, and almost everyone wants to see the perpetrator be convicted, not to mention punished harshly.  The minor detail, whether the defendant is the perpetrator, is the rub.  Since children are extraordinarily susceptible to influence, and notoriously bad on providing salient details that one would demand of an adult, these cases  become one huge, fuzzy morass.

When confronted with accusations that are so vague as to provide little to fight against, defendant’s are left to defend against a moving target.  They can’t provide an alibi, since there is no date of offense when it happened sometime within a 9 month period.  It’s impossible to beat up a child on the witness stand, unless one wants to guarantee conviction.  On one side sits the angels, and the devil sits next to the defense lawyer (who is viewed as the devil’s minion at best).  It’s a very ugly situation.

While the Beauchamp 9 month rule provides some limit, it does little to protect a defendant’s right to notice.  The Bennett decision seized upon the fact that the child was able to provide some details that could, with additional investigation, have honed in on the dates when the crime supposedly occurred. 


At trial, the victim testified that the two incidents occurred about two weeks apart when she was in the middle of second grade. The first incident occurred when her mother was at the grocery store with the victim’s brother. The second incident occurred when the mother took the brother to the doctor. The People should have inquired as to when the mother took the victim’s brother to the doctor and/or should have sought to obtain the brother’s medical records to narrow the time frame of the crimes as alleged. The defendant’s ability to prepare a defense was further stymied by the fact that the victim testified that the incidents occurred in the middle of her second grade school year, which would have been during the winter, but the amended bill of particulars provided that the incidents occurred when the weather was warm. Under these circumstances, when the time period charged, namely seven months, approaches the nine-month period found to be per se unreasonable in People v Beauchamp (74 NY2d 639; see People v Sedlock, 8 NY3d at 538), the People are subjected to “proportionally heightened scrutiny” as to whether their inability to provide more precise times is justified (id at 539). There is no indication that the People inquired of the mother or of the doctor of the victim’s brother regarding as to when the brother was treated.

While this is a thin thread to work with, at least the court placed the duty on the prosecution to work a little harder when they allege a 7 month time frame.  What is unclear is whether the court would have placed the same duty on the prosecution had it been a 5 or 3 month period.  After all, the facts suggest that the prosecution could have identified at least the date of one alleged rape through the doctor’s records, and neither the prosecution nor the court offer any explanation for why they shouldn’t have been required to do so rather than charge a vague period of months at all.

The bottom line, particularly in cases where sympathies and prejudice run so strong, is that the less specificity provided the defense, the fewer tools available to address the charges.  If the crime is discrete, then a date and time should be charged so that the defendant can defend the charge.  Without particulars, there is nothing to defend against except vagaries, and this makes for an impossible situation.

It is understandable that children cannot provide the level of detail one would expect of an adult.  It is not understandable, however, that the prosecution is given a pass in providing particulars when, with diligence, it could do so.  This is true whether the period charged is a week or a year.  Why this should vary because of “heightened scrutiny” as the length of the period grows longer makes little sense.  If particulars can be determined, they should be. 

The slippery slope of putting the defendant’s right to notice on a sliding scale lends itself to this sort of mischief.  While the Bennett court no doubt believed it was doing the right thing for the defendant, who was denied his right to specificity and his ability to defend, there is no reason to endorse sloppy investigation or prosecution simply because the victim is a child.  Once the door is opened to sacrificing the defendant’s rights in the name of expediency and sympathy, it’s almost impossible to get it shut again.

Law Students, Do Not Be Misled

As my experience inside the academy is limited to the occasional guest lecture and the Cardozo ITAP program, neither of which involve any degree of scholarship whatsoever and, I assume, the impression left upon students is limited to stifling a yawn,  Thus, Jay Wexler’s piece of advice at PrawsfBlawg shook me to the core.


If your school is one of those where the students put on a musical every year to poke fun at law school life, including the professors, it is in your best interest to take affirmative steps to avoid being portrayed in a negative light during the show.  Believe me, you do not want to be tagged as the “sweaty” professor, or the “smarmy” professor, or the professor who loves to hear himself talk (like a prawf I’ve heard about who was portrayed singing, to the tune of the Divinyls hit song, “When I think about law, I cite myself”).  To avoid this unfortunate fate, I recommend that you early on adopt a very obvious and hopefully charming (or at least harmless) affectation that the students will have no choice but to seize upon when depicting you in their musicals. 

Law schools put on plays?  Mine never put on a play.  At least one that I was told about.  Of course, my classmates may have engaged in a secret pact to keep this information from me, but I don’t think they cared enough to go to such lengths. 

[Editorial note: I am about to embark on a discussion of Jay Wexler.  Since I don’t know Jay, and the name could be masculine or feminine, and I don’t have a photograph to go by, I am constrained to make an editorial choice as to pronoun.  I pick the feminine, giving myself a 70-30 chance of being wrong and insulting Jay and her entire family.  I assume that someone will eventually correct me, at which time I will point to this note and exclaim, “Ha!”]

Jay later explains the she has adopted the affectation of constantly popping candy.


Now I never go anywhere without a roll of Smarties, the delicious sweet-tarty candy to which I am completely addicted.  I have to say that, although no students really know who I am and so never portray me in their musicals at all, I am quite confident that if they ever do put me in one of their plays, they will totally overlook all my negative characteristics and simply show me as a guy popping Smarties. 

Law students, you got that, right?  It’s not that she doesn’t like Smarties.  She does.  It’s that she has an addictive personality and blood sugar issues.  You might want to also inquire about her dental records.  She might have some holes worth looking into there.

As for me, I decided to check out Jay Wexler’s CV at Boston University School of Law.  I note that I am particularly fond of BU as that is where Mrs. SJ got her doctorate (I know, that would make her Dr. SJ, but that sounds so pretentious).  But back to Jay, I immediately noticed that she doesn’t pass the shoe test (mine, not the Iraqi version).  This means that she hasn’t been a lawprof longer than any pair of shoes I own (except my very chic crocks, but they don’t count).

However, Jay’s resume is incredible.  She clerked for Ruth Bader Ginsburg.  I didn’t even go down there to get admitted, assuming that there was a good chance that the FBI would bar me from the building.  She’s written a ton of scholarly works and sat on enough panels to have a seriously flattened derrière.  This is a very impressive person.

So let’s say she drones a bit when teaching.  She’s entitled.  When you’ve accomplished what she’s accomplished, in such a remarkably short time, you get to be a bit pedantic.  So all you law students, who have yet to accomplish more than making it to last call at the local pub, should hang on her every word.  There’s a reason why she’s standing in front of the class and you’re not.  I mean, serious, she graduated Stanford with a 4.08 cum.  She not only bought all the hornbooks, but probably read some of them. 

So if the students at BU are putting on a play, it’s time you took a hard look at Jay Wexler.  And forget about some Smarties joke about her, as if she’s going to get away with the Smarties thing.  If you can’t find something better to use, then you don’t deserve Jay Wexler as your lawprof.  Now go study.

Bill of Rights Day at the Legal Satyricon

I don’t generally post about new blawg reviews, though others do so regularly.  But today’s, hosted by Marc John Randazza and the Satyriconistas, is special.  Today is Bill of Rights Day, and Randazza and the Randazzettes have made it their theme.  As it’s a theme on mine on a rather regular basis, I realized whilst reading Blawg Review #190 why it’s so important that we have a Bill of Rights Day, and how much I appreciate Marc’s choice.

The reason I say this is that despite my continual reference to the Bill of Rights, there are a few of them that I rarely think about.  The founding fathers ended up including ten of them in order to push the Constitution through the colonies.  Had Publius not been so persuasive (and avoided being indicted for using a false identity on MySpace), things might have been different.  But we, the descendants of people with far greater intellect and guts than we can muster from the couch in front of a big screen, flat-panel, hi-def television, came up with ten.

Many of the people who read this post are well aware that there are ten amendments in the Bill of Rights.  Many are very familiar with the first, second and fourth, as well as the fifth, sixth and eighth.  Notice anything missing?

We need somebody to spell out the Bill of Rights from time to time.  Even those of us who work with it regularly, who think we’re pretty aware of constitutional issues and generally on top of things legal, forget that there are those quiet amendments, the ones that lawyers never mention and courts never consider.  The sad truth is, they are the forgotten amendments.

We need to read the Bill of Rights from time to time.  No, I don’t have any particular issue to raise with most of them, though I really can’t get excited by the 7th no matter how hard I try.  The 9th and 10th, on the other hand, present a certain nagging sense that they ought to come into play far more than they do, and I wonder whether the federalists today ought to spend more time thinking about why they don’t.

So a big shout of thanks to the Randazza team for giving me a reason to read through each of the first ten amendments, to remind myself why they are there, and for coming up with a 3d Amendment post, a rather miraculous feat. 

And if you’re wondering why the water is always warm when you dive into the First Amendment, that would be because Randazza keeps the heat turned up.

Practical Blawgosphere: We Are Them

Two posts from the practical blawgosphere over the weekend craft an important paradigm for understanding what criminal defendants (not to mention their lawyers) are up against.  From the Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, at Defending People, comes the story of “RR” (name withheld so that an innocent man isn’t perpetually associated with this crime), cleared of a sexual assault on a child by a DNA kit that sat untouched since 2002.

On the left coast, philanthropist and Fresno criminal defense lawyer Rick Horowitz at Probable Cause posts about institutionalized group think, and its impact on the ability of any individual prosecutor to break away from mold when an individualized review of evidence in a particular case warrants.  As Rick says, a prosecutor’s duty is to do justice, but the institutionalized practice is to convict.

As much as these two posts address very different circumstances, they are both part of a whole that exists throughout the criminal justice system.  Some lawyers, like Bennett and Horowitz fight it.  Others just play along, as though opposition is futile.  The ones who have either failed to recognize the problem, or have simply given up, are as much a part of the problem as anyone.

Bennett’s post notes that the impact of confirmation bias, propounding Bennett’s Third Rule of Investigation:


Enough investigation will tend to support your theory.

Bennett credits Murphy for the rule.  I credit Bennett, because he is too self-effacing and needs to learn to take credit for the things he creates.  The police investigate to prove their perp guilty.  Once that’s done, they stop investigating.  Any more and they could spoil a good thing.  In the “RR” case, it strikes one as amazing that a DNA sample could sit untouched for 6 years while a man was convicted for such a heinous crime.  Somebody decided that DNA was one step too far.

But then, there was a defense lawyer involved on “RR”s behalf as well.  What happened there?  It appears that “RR” had a significant facial disfiguration that went unmentioned in the description of the perpetrator.  Perhaps this led the defense to believe that it had a way to beat the case, and prevented further digging that might have unearthed the untested DNA. 

From the Houston Chronicle, the question was posed how the DNA could go untested:


“That is a really good question,” Assistant District Attorney Roe Wilson said. “It should have been tested. The defense attorney also could have requested testing.”

Rachell’s trial attorney, Ron Hayes, and his current attorney, Deborah Summers, both have said they were unaware of physical evidence that could have been tested years ago.

It’s possible, if not likely, that no one disclosed the existence of this evidence prior to trial, begging the question of how the defense lawyer could request testing when he was unaware that there was anything to be tested.  The prosecution’s response, if that’s the case, is disingenuous.  But then, there remains the question of whether the defense passively accepted the absence of information or whether he tried to investigate. 

This is where Rick’s group-think, acceptance of the routine, lack of individualized consideration, comes into play.  The same group-think that impairs individualized review, investigation and consideration by prosecutors frequently does the same thing with defense lawyers.  Failure to recognize, or admit, that this happens is no less dangerous or wrong.  As the prosecutor in the “RR” case noted, the defense lawyer could have done something about it as well.

Bennett clearly recognized that the same problems that hamper the legitimacy of police investigations can similarly apply to the defense.


We all have preconceptions and prejudices formed by our life experiences. Any of us might unknowingly suffer from confirmation bias that helps us maintain these preconceptions, even if they’re wrong. A prosecutor might rightfully assume that a person accused of a crime committed that crime because — let’s face it — the cops usually get things right, and in the small percentage of cases in which the wrong guy is arrested there’s a defense lawyer who will fight zealously to prevent an injustice.

But, no matter how jaded, a defense lawyer can’t assume that the cops got it right because — let’s face it — the cops often don’t get things right, and in those cases the defense lawyer had better not be prevented, by confirmation bias or anything else, from seeking out the evidence that might save the accused from prison or death.

We are right to point out, as Rick does so well, the injustice that comes from prosecutorial group-think.  But we should never forget Bennett’s admonition that it is an affliction that both sides suffer.  The defense can be guilty as well.

If Shoes Could Kill (Update)

When President George W. Bush made his surprise visit to Baghdad, every precaution was taken. Save one. As the President, Iraqi President Nouri al-Maliki prepared to take questions, an Iraqi reporter, Muntadar al-Zeidi leveled his weapons, both size 10.  That President Bush was unharmed was more a product of his ability to dodge than al-Zeidi’s aim. 

The moment will live on in comedy and politics for quite a while.  As Radley Balko, from whom the video loop was taken, says, it never gets old. My thought is that it should be repeated for each person who dies since America decided to free Iraq.

But shoes can’t kill.  At least not this way.  What they can do is provide the only means for an angry man to express the depth of his outrage at life in his country.  From the AP :


This is a farewell kiss, you dog,” he yelled in Arabic. “This is from the widows, the orphans and those who were killed in Iraq.”

The best explanation for this preposterous attack is that al-Zeidi had few other options to express his anger and outrage.  One of the mantras used to trick a frightened America is that we must bring the war to the terrorists.  That means that we keep the fighting, and hence the pain, away from us.  Certainly that’s better for us.  It’s not necessary better for the people to whom we brought the war.

For those whose memory might be faulty, we were told that we would be greeted as saviors by the people of Iraq, oppressed by Saddam Hussein, who had weapons of mass destruction and was ready to use them.  All old news for us, but still very real to Iraqis.  This was not a mere political debate to those whose died as collateral damage in our war over there.  We were prepared to suffer their deaths.  Nobody asked them what they thought about the subject.  Muntadar al-Zeidi wanted President Bush to know how he felt on the subject.

Many Americans feel the same way about this war, though we do so without having suffered nearly as much pain as the Iraqi people.  We have lost many of our own.  Some believe it was “worth it” while others disagree.  But there’s little denial, whether one is proud of America knowing that The Surge helped or saddened by the fact that we were compelled to surge to begin with.


“This great Arab shoe sums up the history of the criminal Bush, who is responsible for the loss of lives of hundreds of thousands of Islamic sons and who remained arrogant, spiteful and mean-spirited until the last moment of his term,” wrote Abdel-Sattar Qassem, a political science professor at An Najah University in the West Bank town of Nablus, on a Palestinian Web site.

One has to wonder whether this shoe attack, this basic expression of futile outrage, will be seen as a joke or the final commentary on a failure of American ideals and policy.  At Lowering the Bar, Kevin Underhill uses wit to make the point:


Rumors that a third shoe may have also been thrown from a nearby grassy knoll, which if true would implicate a second assailant and thus a possible conspiracy, were dismissed by White House officials.

Bush also played down the incident, saying, “All I can report is, it is a size ten.”  That’s a pretty good line, and I give the president credit for that, and for not automatically trying to link the shoe-thrower to al Qaeda. 

This ludicrous shoe attack may be the perfect closing strain of a presidency that might be viewed historically as ludicrous.  But it’s not just an attack on George W. Bush, but on a nation that elected and supported him in this endeavor. 


According to the New York Times report, “[h]itting someone with a shoe is considered the supreme insult in Iraq. It means that the target is even lower than the shoe.”

If we stop, for a moment, subscribing to the foundational belief that America can do no wrong, maybe we all deserve a shoe in the head.  If nothing else, maybe it will knock some sense into us.

Update:  I have just heard that Muntadar al-Zeidi is being held for questioning.  What exactly are they asking him? 

Where did you get the shoes?
Why a shoe and not a sneaker?
When did you first wear size 10?
Are there other shoes in your closet?
Were you acting alone when you threw the shoes?

Does the claim that he is being questioned strike anyone else as reaching yet a new level of absurdity, just when you thought it wasn’t possible?

Blawgosphere Heroes

The casual reader of blawgs is likely unaffected, but regular readers know that the blawgosphere has reached the point where certain individuals have developed what might be called “blawg cred,” a degree of internal recognition that imbues them with credibility.  For some, it’s attained through their writing, insight and humanity.  But for many, it’s self-ascribed. 

There is no test for membership in the blawgosphere.  Anyone can join the club.  All it takes is a dollar and a dream.  Literally.

Many of the most prominent blawgers have worked their way up the food chain, earning their bones through writing that is often good and occasionally brilliant.  Brilliance speaks for itself, and the blawgosphere is the perfect venue to have your thoughts vetted by your peers.  One can easily believe oneself brilliant (as most of us do), but if ideas can’t pass muster by fellow lawyers in the blawgosphere, then you’ve been tested and failed.

Then there is a swathe of the blawgoshere that offers little by way of ideas, but much about themselves.  These are the Blawgosphere Heroes.  They write about the wonderful things they have done, both in the law and in life.  They attribute greatness, humanity and success in the hope that others will believe.  They create the online persona that they wish they had in real life.  They post about their legal successes, their huge cases and great victories.  If they do so enough, they hope that people will believe them.

You see, it can be quite difficult to verify claims in the blawgosphere.  One can become the great humanitarian one always wished one was by creating a surreal digital world around themselves.  The blawgosphere tends to accept things at face value, particularly when no one’s ox is gored in the process, and it becomes part of the blawgospheric myth. 

The problem is that sometimes these are lies.  Sometimes, claimed victories never happened.  Sometimes, the blawger didn’t save a kitty from a burning building. 

Many blawgers write with a voice of great authority, absolute in their understanding of the law and world, claiming expertise unto themselves.  Some blawgers have never seen the inside of a courtroom, yet pontificate about where each of the chairs should be placed.  Other blawgers, in the zeal to make friends and increase their own prominence, embrace these Blawgosphere Heroes in the hope that they will bask in their reflected glory.  They spread the myth and believe it with all their heart and soul.  The myth becomes a reality, though only in the blawgosphere.

One blawger will write of another that he is the best lawyer in all of Podunk, and in the blawgosphere the latter will be the best in Podunk.  Of course, the former doesn’t actually know the latter, and can’t verify a single thing that the latter has ever claimed.  It’s all a matter of faith confused with reality.  It benefits both.  And if enough people swear to a purported blawgospheric reality, it becomes so.

Beware the Blawgosphere Hero.  You don’t know him.  You can’t possibly know if what he says is true or utter fabrication.  Those who claim to be important, successful, brilliant may be or may not be, but writing so does not make it so.  Of those whose blawging consists of ideas, the process of peer review will distinguish the real from the fiction.  But of those whose blawging serves only to support their claims of personal achievement, greatness, humanitarianism, blind acceptance of self-ascribed attributes is absurd and all claims should be viewed with the utmost suspicion.

This is the blawgosphere.  Anyone can claim to be a hero if they want to.  But they only become a Blawgosphere Hero is you let them.   Be very careful who becomes your hero.

The Morality Gap

Jim Chen at Moneylaw, ironically named given the nature of his post, has taken a step back and seen the forest through the tree, with his brilliant opening line:


Scandal scored a trifecta this week, as heavyweights from the worlds of politics, business, and law were accused of fraud. Illinois governor Rod Blagojevich has been arrested for offering to sell Barack Obama’s open Senate seat to the highest bidder. Bernard Madoff ran his investment firm as a giant Ponzi scheme; losses are thought to approximate $50 billion. And lawyer Marc Dreier bilked sophisticated investors of $380 million. Neither law nor higher education in general can escape responsibility for the behavior of these men. Blagojevich and Dreier held law degrees. Indeed, the New York Times took pains to describe Marc Dreier as “a Yale graduate and Harvard-educated lawyer.”

This doesn’t speak well of lawyers, and no amount of facile denial or rationalization will change that.  To add insult, Madoff went to law school, but didn’t finish. 

Lawyers are taught ethics.  Since 1982, lawyers have been tested on their knowledge of ethics by the MPRE.  What we have yet to figure out is how to instill the legal profession a desire to behave in an ethical and moral way.  Knowing ethics and being ethical are entirely different. 

Jim, being a law school dean, challenges law schools to do something about their role in this mess.  He recognizes that law schools cannot absolve themselves of all responsibility for this situation, being the breeding ground of whatever vision a lawyer has of his role in society.


The diagnosis is simple. Greed kills. One of MoneyLaw’s running themes is that American universities fare rather poorly in identifying, let alone living or inculcating, moral values. As a partial antidote to the poison represented by Blagojevich, Madoff, and Dreier, I thought I would mark the untimely passing of an academic hero : Jan Kemp.

Since Jim’s got the law school exception to the rule covered, and provides great insight as Dr. Kemp paid the price of integrity, I hope to give it a try on the side of the trench lawyer.  As an axiom, we do a miserable job of policing our own profession.  We, each lawyer, at minimum knows someone who fails to fulfill the ethical obligations and disciplinary rules that govern our profession.  We are obliged to act upon this information, but do not.  And we similarly know that if we did, the changes of our disciplinary bodies doing anything serious about it are slim to none. 

This is not an opportunity for non-lawyers to rail against theft by lawyers.  Stealing from escrow is the surest route to disbarment, which may not be a sufficient penalty when the theft exceeds $379 million.  But performing incompetently is rampant.  Sure, it’s a subjective assessment, and the level of technical competence necessary to escape discipline (which in these terms means a nasty private letter) can usually be accomplished by dried out slug.  We know it, but we keep it within the family to maintain the “dignity of the profession.”  Dignity?  This is what dignity means?

Some will remember that I’ve just been engaged in a disagreement with many about the role of using blogs as active marketing tools.  Put aside the marketers, whose job is it to market marketing and therefore have done no wrong by saying anything to persuade lawyers to buy their trinkets.  Think instead about the lawyers who argued vociferously that (1) they had to engage in overt marketing or they would sit home alone all day and starve, or (2) that it was their ethical duty to market themselves or the public would not be aware of their existence, and it was their ethical duty to make the public aware of the fact that they were available to deposit their retainer at a moments notice.

The one thing lawyers are well trained to do is argue.  We wield rhetoric like a sword, using it to cut through walls of ethical and moral that stand between us and money.  We confuse some words, however, like ambition and greed, allowing us to explain away our use of any weapon at our disposal to separate a client from his money, or if we are really good at what we do, someone else’s client from his money.

Maybe law school has done its job too well, giving us the ability to rationalize our way under, over and around the ethical and moral obligations that are supposed to keep us in check. 

But there is no argument that these three individuals, headliners this week for the sheer magnitude of the allege loss, reflect a gaping hole where a lawyers’ heart should be.  Are we this desperate a profession that we can do no better?  Are we this greedy?  Are we this dignified?