Author Archives: SHG

Post 2000, A Retrospective

This is my 2000th post at Simple Justice.  It seems like only yesterday I quickly pecked out post 1999. 

When I realized I had hit a milepost, I thought it a good time to reflect on the experience.  It’s been a pleasure for me to write.  It’s been an honor for me to have people read what I write.  I never expected that so many people would do so. Up to this post, I have written 1,345,727 words.  That seems like an awful lot, and I feel badly for the ones I harmed and mangled, as I like words a lot.  My posts have been read a total of 1,490,481. 

The most popular post is The Lawyer Look, mostly because it’s searched relative to tattoos and piercings.  It’s also the post that gets the wildest comments, usually angry and frequently profane.  Just yesterday, someone informed me to return to the “Hitler Hole, moron.”  It would have been deleted had it not been so ludicrous that it was funny.  The second most popular post, An Early Morning Knock on the Door, is a more serious, and instructive, post.  It doesn’t get any crazy comments.  People who read it likely aren’t in the mood to assert themselves.

The only post I struggled with was Blawg Review #170.  Writing it was painful.  Others, like Turk and Colin Samuels, are unbelievably good at doing Blawg Review.  I was not.  I did it because I made a promise to Ed. that I would, but I was miserable the whole time.  it was the only time writing a post that I felt that way, and I didn’t care for it.  Still, I appreciate that others do it so I can enjoy their effort.

I’ve met some great people along the way.  Three of my favorite people on the internet, Mark Bennett, Gideon and Norm Pattis, have taught me more in the past year and a half than I had learned in the prior decade of practice.  If you haven’t kept up with Mark and Gid (Norm having taken a sabbatical), you’ve missed a lot.  A newer addition to the group, Joel Rosenberg (or J-dog for short) is not a lawyer, but a renaissance man with remarkable insight.  And David Giacalone is like my conscience, alway there to keep me honest. 

Joel was the one who coined the term, “he’s prickly,” referring to my limited tolerance for things that annoy me.  It was kind of Joel to add the “ly”.  As the number of readers who found their way to Simple Justice increased, the number who understood what this blawg was about, followed regularly and were aware of my views decreased.  A consequence was day-trippers, a name I’ve given people who read an individual post and feel compelled to comment.  I believe that readers of blawgs has increased significantly, primarily as a result of people searching topics and finding them in blawg posts.  I wish they wouldn’t comment.  They don’t add anything (because they don’t know anything) and I respond poorly.

A few fights have broken out on Simple Justice during the last 1999 posts.  The most recent one on marketing ended with one of the participants sending me a demand letter.  I wasn’t troubled by it, for obvious reasons, but I felt bad for the writer.  To the bitter end, he had no clue why it had happened.  In general, the fights have been healthy, airing disagreements and clarifying positions.  I’m rarely afraid to take a position on something.  Sometimes I feel strongly, and others I just do so to test my own thoughts.  Readers sometimes fail to realize that I may not be advocating a position, as much as testing it.  Some view every post as a life or death proposition. 

Many people who have come here over time have demonstrated a misunderstanding of what the blawgosphere is.  It is a place of words and ideas, but it falls far short of reality.  We’re people typing on keyboards, not deciding the fate of mankind.  If our ideas have merit, we may persuade people, perhaps even influence decision-making.  But some see a post as a threat to their way of life.  These people need to get a life.  There’s nothing to win and lose here, just words and ideas.  There’s no prize.

Blawgs posts are, generally, a way to quickly jot down thoughts on a particular subject, whether generic, humorous or topical.  They aren’t law review articles, or features in the New York Times.  I try to put in a good ten minutes on each post, whether I want to or not, but I won’t go back and edit.  When you find typos or dangling participles or mistaken tenses, give me a break.  Of course, the people who post the antagonistic comments neither understand what I’m doing here nor could be bothered to find out.  I’ve had a few inform me that it was my responsibility to enlighten them as to my ways, as they were entitled to do as they pleased.  I banned them.

I’ve banned about a dozen people over time.  Most for using profane language, but some for just being obnoxious or antagonistic.  I’m not the only one who has this problem with commenters, as Orin Kerr and Walter Olson have both recently taken strong positions about ridding themselves of the nuisance.  Walter said it best:



Let’s make it clear right now, though, that this is a moderated comments section. It may resemble a very broadminded letters-to-the-editor column; it is not going to resemble a public-access cable channel, graffiti wall, or Hyde Park Speakers’ Corner if I or DH can help it.


What’s more, it’s moderated for the benefit of this site’s intended audience, bearing in mind that some lines of discussion more quickly become tedious and irrelevant to that audience than others. Up to a point, I have no objection to efforts to save our immortal souls or turn us into leftier-than-thou Kossacks so long as they have decent entertainment value (short, witty, and nonrepetitive all help).


One group we’d be better off without are those who feel that commenting on this site is somehow a matter of right, no matter what the tedium factor, and radiate wounded entitlement when they learn that’s not how it’s going to work. They really would be happier elsewhere.

I make note of this in my 2000th post because it’s the one aspect of this Blawg that makes me think I should hang it up.  It gets unbearably tedious after a while, and sometimes painful to watch a topic veer off onto a tangent because the one commenter didn’t get it (while insisting, always, that he did).  Orin made the point that discretion means the blawger’s discretion, not the readers.  You don’t get a vote. 

The comments are often as much fun than the post itself.  It pains me to acknowledge this, but it’s true.  I enjoy the comments most of the time, and that’s why I engage commenters regularly.  But I don’t enjoy the emails I receive after I ban someone, or delete or edit a comment, accusing me of intellectual rape.  I don’t need this from people who have never contributed to the discussion here and whose thoughts are, in my view, less than worthy of much discussion.  I will tolerate a lot more from people who I like and have been regular contributors, even when they get testy with me.  I won’t tolerate much from people I don’t know or don’t like.  That’s how things work in real life, and they are no different here.  I will defend my friends.  That’s what friends do.

As I write this post, someone has posted a comment openly advertising a discussion on their blawg on the topic of the post, timely leading into my mention that popularity has brought with it monumental efforts at using Simple Justice as a launching pad for others, ranging from commercial products and services to blogs.  I made a decision long ago not to allow my blawg to be used to promote whatever it is that you’re selling.  If I think people ought to know about something, I’ll promote it.  But you can’t.  That’s my rule, and you don’t have to agree with it. 

Readers aren’t aware that I receive a dozen email requests a day, often more, to link to blawgs, promote products, write about news releases, publish “guest posts,” review books, promote protests, highlight injustice and defend the poor and the oppressed.  Many people try to use the popularity of Simple Justice to promote themselves through the backdoor.  I am offended by this.  My reaction is to be harsh about these efforts.  Some don’t understand why and criticize me for not being more easy-going about  people trying to glom some free publicity.  These people don’t realize that it’s not just them, or a couple of tries, but hundreds in the course of a week.  It’s more effort than I’m willing to give.  I do this to post, not play kindly school marm to unwanted pests. 

The blawgosphere is a wonderful place, full of many competing ideas and ideologies presented by some very thoughtful folks.  I enjoy thinking, and they make me think.  On the whole, it’s been a blast.  The friends I’ve made (yes, I’ve made friends) have been people I admire and appreciate.  We haven’t always agreed, and that’s made for some interesting discussions, but I think we have always shown respect and appreciation for each other’s efforts.

All in all, it’s been a good ride so far, and I have no plans to slow down or stop.  I’ll keep trying to negotiate the speed bumps as best I can, and it’s likely that I’ll keep being prickly.  For those who have read Simple Justice and found some value here, thanks.  For those who have don’t like it, stop reading and find someplace else where you feel more at home.  I won’t mind.  And to the good friends I’ve made over 1999 posts, I look forward to the next 2000.

John Ashcroft Explains

Many of us, myself included, have had some difficulty understanding why we don’t see the world the way someone like, oh, John Ashcroft does.  Why, I often wondered, did my government feel it appropriate to detain people taken off the street in other countries in a military base at Guantanamo, Cuba without charges, process or proof?  This struck me as a problem.

Former Attorney General John Ashcroft did not see this as a problem at all, and would see someone like me as clueless.  Until now, I didn’t understand why.  Now I do.  Via Turley, John Ashcroft explains:









Apparently, this is all a matter of how we define “war”, and who our enemies might be.  Sure, the phrase “war on terrorism” has become ubiquitous in public discourse, but it’s just a phrase designed to capture a sense of gravity.  It’s not literal.  At least I thought it wasn’t.  Ashcroft thinks otherwise.

His comparison of captives in Gitmo to captured German soldiers in World War II is less than persuasive.  The soldiers we captured worse uniforms of their country, in a declared war with discrete sides.  We didn’t impugn their integrity for fighting for their country.  They fought for theirs as our soldiers fought for ours.  That’s how real wars work.  Mind you, I’m talking about the foot soldiers, not the masterminds who fashioned The Final Solution, nor those foot soldiers who relished duty that involved inhumanity.  They have a special place in hell.  I’m talking about the regular German who was pressed into service and fought on the battlefield as he was told to do.

There is no comparison with the “war” Ashcroft speaks about.  Some will argue that the soldiers in a jihad don’t wear uniforms, so it’s foolish to argue that the lack of a uniform makes them immune from being prisoners of war.  But this returns us to the question of whether this is a war, or something else.  Terrorists don’t wear uniforms.  Terrorists don’t serve a country.  Terrorists don’t fit neatly within the confines of our historic understanding of war. 

Yet we ignore the Geneva Conventions under the notion that they really aren’t soldiers, entitled to be free from torture, because they are terrorists.  At the same time, we justify keeping them captive without due process because prisoners of war aren’t held because they’ve done any more than fight on the other side of a war. 

This rationale, that anything we chose to call a war thus becomes one, shows a fundamental rift in our American psyche.  We want to be protected from international terrorism, but can’t find a pigeonhole to fit it so that it neatly fits within any recognized paradigm that tells us how to address it.  Certainly, calling it a war doesn’t make it one, any more than announcing a “war on drugs” allows us to hold drug users captive as prisoners.  It’s just a phrase designed by political marketers to make our thinking fuzzy enough to allow the government to do as it pleases.

But John Ashcroft sees this as war, clearly and absolutely.  The people held at Gitmo did nothing wrong other than fight for the other side, and there is nothing to charge them with aside from being soldiers against us.  There is no issue of due process involved, not charges of wrong doing needed.  His conscience is clear. 

The Ex-Prosecutor’s Epiphany

When Dallas criminal defense lawyer Robert Guest started blogging, he called his place I Was The State.  It was his way of letting us know that he was fresh out of the District Attorney’s office, and that his experience there was something worthy of recognition, a valuable asset in itself, now that he was on the side of truth and justice.

More than a year and a half have passed since then, and today, Robert has written his prosecutorial swan song.  Prompted by the efforts of the Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, who is also the current President of the Harris County Criminal Bar Association, as well as the well-deserved front runner for best criminal blawg in the ABA Blawg 100 (have you voted yet?), Robert’s insight offers much to the many men and women whose careers in criminal law began in the prosecutor’s office and wound their way to the defense side.

The longer I defend cases the more I realize that the two skill sets (prosecuting and defending criminal cases) are mutually exclusive. Prosecution can make one a better criminal attorney in general. Creating a better defense lawyer requires defense experience, inter alia.

Does my prosecution experience help my current clients? Yes, but not as much as more defense work would have.

This is a revelation that many former prosecutors would prefer be deep-sixed.  Like a dirty little secret, they know that the public is of the belief that a former prosecutor offers them a benefit, an edge, that they wouldn’t obtain otherwise.  When former prosecutors go out on their own, they heavily promote this status to exploit this public belief.  The benefits are two-fold; it’s a belief that will convince potential clients that the newly-minted criminal defense lawyer has credibility, and it’s the only thing that have to promote.

I’ve posted in the past about the ethics of former prosecutors exploiting this status to get clients.  That being an ex-prosecutor is a fact, part of one’s professional background, is undeniable.  That this fact somehow provides clients with an edge is deceptive and misleading.  Still, it’s a pervasive marketing tool.

The problem is that it’s a lie.  With experience under his belt, Robert proves that he’s made the full transition from being a former prosecutor to being a criminal defense lawyer by his recognition of the significant distinction.  Robert goes through a fairly extensive list of these differences here, and they are definitely worth reading.  They may not be exactly the same as another ex-prosecutor’s experience, but some of the points are universal.

Just yesterday, I welcomed Murray Newman, about-to-be-former Harris County prosecutor, to the defense ranks.  For those of you who plan to switch sides, or have recently done so, give this a lot of thought.  Robert’s final thoughts, aside from the technical differences in the skillset involved, merits special attention:


I do not believe that someone who has been prosecuting serious felony cases for years can not defend a case. The possibility is there. A lifelong ADA would have a better chance than a PI/Bankruptcy lawyer. 

However, only years of zealous defense advocacy can make one a better defense attorney. It’s not just the procedure and penal code. It’s the fundamental belief system that defines each side

Until you realize this, you’re not really a criminal defense lawyer.  Robert Guest is a criminal defense lawyer.  Are you?

Why Not Carry a Taser?

When I was interviewed for college, the interviewer noted that I had taught horseback riding over the summer.  She asked whether I would be interested in being on the school’s polo team.  I thought for a second, and responded that I didn’t think so.  She asked why, and I explained that I trusted horses, but I didn’t trust people wielding clubs.

The hub of the Volokh Conspiracy, Eugene, asks whether there is a justification for states banning citizens from carrying Tasers.

A bunch of jurisdictions — according to a student paper I read, Hawaii, Massachusetts, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, Wisconsin, plus Philadelphia, Baltimore, Chicago, and Washington, D.C. — ban the possession of tasers. Are there any sensible justifications that I’m missing for such bans, and for bans on carrying tasers outside the home?

He lists a number of factors.  On the negative, the obvious reason that they could be used by criminals.  On the other hand, he notes that they can be quite useful for self-defense.





  1. When it’s illegal to carry a gun, whether because carry licenses are generally unavailable, or because the person is 18 to 20, and licenses are only available to those 21 and older.



  2. When there’s a legal obstacle to the person’s possessing a gun, for instance, when the person is an ex-convict (perhaps even someone convicted of a nonviolent felony), is underage for gun purchases, or lives with someone who is an ex-convict and who might be said to “constructively possess” any guns that his housemates possess.



  3. When the defender isn’t willing to use a deadly weapon, even against an attacker.


Acknowledging that Tasers aren’t perfect, in that they are a “one shot” weapon, meaning that you don’t get a second chance to make a first impression, that despite the non-lethal claim, deaths occur nonetheless (oops), Eugene concludes that their benefit for self-defense outweighs the detriment.

While the use of Tasers has been the subject of many posts here, not to mention plenty of great party videos, and I am certainly in favor of things that cause fewer rather than more deaths, I find myself unable to agree.

It’s people.  Without arms, they hurl nasty words and the occasional fist.  Feelings are bruised more often than body parts, but they’ll get over it.  No one ends up lying on the ground, incapacitated, possibly dead. 

People get angry.  When angry, they do foolish things that they later regret.  Give them the tools to do ever worse things when they’re angry, and I fear they will use them.  I don’t want to enable or facilitate people harming each other in the heat of the moment, creating problems afterward for themselves and others that ruin lives.  I don’t trust people.

On the other side of the equation, I don’t see that the need for self-defense is all that great.  I am unaware of an epidemic of minor league violent crime sweeping the nation, such that it’s unsafe for any honest citizen to walk the streets unarmed.  Mind you, Tasers aren’t a particularly good defensive weapon when confronted by a person with a gun, since their shot causes more damage than your shot.  It’s not a good trade-off. 

I’m sure that anyone willing to put in the effort can come up with one hundred instances in the past week where a Taser might have helped defend a person against an attack.  But in the scheme of a fairly large nation, this would be a miniscule number, and statistically insignificant as an example of need.  I just don’t see any real need.

New York City, which provides my view of the world, is filled with angry people.  I’ve met many of them during my 25 years of practice.  Many didn’t wake up in the morning with the intention of committing a crime, harming someone else or ending up arrested, but they did.  Many, many more got themselves into stupid scuffles with other angry people, but shook the dust off afterward and went home to nurse their bruises, whether real or mental.  I dread to think what might have happened if they possessed a Taser.  Angry people demonstrate poor discretion.

No, I think that we’re better off without people walking around with Tasers.  I still don’t trust people with clubs either.

The Face of Justice

Reposted from Mark Bennett’s Defending People, because no 10,000 words I could write could capture this image better.



A DAY IN COURT

By James Kavanaugh © 1979
(From his collection, Walk Easy on the Earth)



The unsmiling judge with wet, flapping jowls,


Dismissing the tears of husbands and wives,


Spitting out consonants, rolling his vowels,


Tearing out hearts and carving up lives,


Slicing the children apart at their bowels,


Believing that justice latterly thrives—


Wiser than Solomon or blinking old owls—


As long as his echoing edict survives.



The unsmiling judge with stern eyes of stone,


Convinced that his honor will salvage our race,


Rages at crime from his emperor’s throne,


With history’s arrogance etched on his face,


Applauding his parents and disciplined home


Where all of the offspring emerged full of grace:


“For that which is reaped is only what’s sown,”


Then he nods to his clerk to begin the next case.


The unsmiling judge can relax a bit now


While lawyers bow humbly like prep school boys,


A touch of a grin unfurls his brow,


Capriciously gone at the hint of a noise.


He lowers his gavel and narrows his eyes,


No Shah or Napoleon sat more entrenched,


Political puppet whose whims govern lives,


Who paid enough ransom to sit on the bench.


The unsmiling judge who decides in our stead


That petulance lives and justice is dead.


I’d rather be judged by the least of our race,


Than the unsmiling judge with the arrogant face.

______________
And it’s because of gifts like this that I ask everyone to vote for Defending People at the ABA Blaw 100.  Please do so.

No Higher Praise Than “Toxic”

The criminal bar of Harris County, Texas, was busy following Life at the Harris County Criminal Justice Center, a blog by an anonymous prosecutor chronicling the doings at the local courthouse.  The author, who called himself A Harris County Lawyer, provides a sort of counter-weight to the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, at Defending People.  While it was more local than most blawgs, there was plenty of substance to read from the prosecutor’s perspective.

An election changed all that.  When Pat Lykos was elected Harris County District Attorney, the campaign promise of no reprisals was immediately forgotten, and A Harris County Lawyer, who supported another for the job, quickly learned a lesson in integrity.  A Harris County Lawyer became Murray Newman, assistant district attorney until the end of the year, when he will turn over a new leaf and join the side of truth and justice.  Still, he had nothing but admiration and praise for his co-workers and they job they did on behalf of the public they serve.

But that wasn’t the last lesson he was to learn about being a prosecutor.


Hell, even today I learned that someone that I considered to be my friend was railing against my “toxic blog” in an e-mail to all the misdemeanor prosecutors. That kind of hurt, but I guess those types of things are going to be expected in the days to come under the Transparent Lykos Administration.

So much for the notion that integrity is a good thing in the DAs office.  Murray was a good prosecutor from everything I’ve heard, particularly from his adversaries (who are usually the best judges of this sort of thing).  It’s understandable that a person who has just survived a tough campaign for public office puts an undue premium on loyalty, confusing the job of prosecutor with that of Illinois governor.  Campaigns can easily skew one’s vision of right and wrong.

But the comment that Life at HCCCJC is toxic is pretty strong.  Toxic as in poisonous.  As it turns out, the new description came from someone with whom Murray was long associated, and who Murray had previously called friend.  This comment, also highlighted at Bennett’s place, explains what came down:


Murray, I am a misdemeanor prosecutor who received Donna Goode’s email calling your blog toxic. I was very disheartened with what she said.

For whatever reason, Donna has found herself in good standing with the new administration (she IS a hard working prosecutor from what I have heard). But, the fact that she sends us an email calling you toxic is disturbing. I guess that is sort of the shot across the bow. Does that mean we aren’t supposed to be seen with you.

It means that there is no greater purity in the prosecutor’s office then anywhere else in government,  When a good, maybe even great, prosecutor gets canned because he wasn’t out waving the flag on day 1 for the candidate who ultimately won (and who he supported in the general election, by the way), the message is clear.  Prosecutors are not immune from politics.  Those who say that are just haven’t learned the lesson yet.

Murray Newman learned the lesson, much to his personal pain as he felt that he contributed to the betterment of the people of Harris County through his work in the District Attorney’s office.  Now, he’ll have to contribute from the other side.  Welcome Murray.

The Worst Ratio in the World

The New York Lawyer has provided a chart to show the distribution of lawyers throughout the various counties of the State of New York.  The chart shows the ratio of lawyers to human beings.  It explains a lot.

In Orleans County, there are 1461 people for every lawyer.  In Hamilton County, there are a grand total of 14 lawyers.  The local bar association has really boring parties. 

In contrast, New York City has 94,270 lawyers, with Brooklyn leading the outerboro pack at 7,050.  There are almost a million more people in Brooklyn than Manhattan.

The state capital, Albany, only has 4,317 lawyers, but the ratio of lawyers to people is 69/1.  And you wonder why the government is a mess.

No county, however, compares with New York County when it comes to a lawyer to human being ratio of 21 to 1.  For every 21 people in Manhattan, there is a lawyer.  The ratio is even higher in saloons.

There are 77,952 lawyers in Manhattan (pre-Marc Dreier).  It’s really just a tiny, little island, with a population of 1,620,867.  All but three people there are Democrats.  But throw a stone and chances are good that it will strike a lawyer.

For many lawyers, the “big fish in a small pond” aphorism applies.  Not for lawyers in Manhattan.  It’s not easy surviving, no less thriving, in an environment so lousy with lawyers.  Hesitate and some other lawyer has just jumped your potential new client.  Have your receptionist take a message and the next one (or 1000) will take the call.

To contrast the situation, Brooklyn is New York City’s most populace county, with 2,528,050 residents.  It has just 7,050 lawyers, a mere tenth of that of its neighboring borough.  And the Court Street lawyers are notorious for being vicious competitors. 

If you are wondering whether to leave Podunk to make your bones in the Big Apple, show the world that you can rise to the top in the toughest legal market in the world, where almost everybody you meet is a lawyer, especially in saloons, you might want to study these numbers first.

Queens, by the way, has only 5,534 lawyers, diverse food choices and enough diners so that there’s always an available seat.  Just think about it.

A Student By Any Other Name

Those of us who went to law school back in the days before computers, cellphones, light bulbs, carry one very similar memory with us when we step into the well of the court.  No professor ever called us by name.  I was routine called “mustache man.”  I believe this had something to do with having a mustache, though another guy was called “blue shirt” and we both had blue shirts.

Back then, it was viewed as one of those quirky oddities that distinguished law school from, oh, kindergarten.  We are being toughened up so that when we stepped into the real arena, the one where real people’s lives were on the line, we didn’t expect to be coddled.  We suspected profs knew our real names, and occasionally one would slip and utter a syllable before correcting himself.  Others just pointed and called us “you”.  These were heady times.

The ABA thinks this is just horrible, and has developed “Best Practices” to “Foster a Supportive Environment.”  No doubt, that’s to simulate the supportive environment students will find when they enter a real courtroom someday as lawyers.  The ABA has promulgated rules :

Learn students’ names. This is perhaps the single most important thing a teacher can do to create a positive climate in the classroom. Call students by name in and out of the classroom. Do not allow them to be anonymous, to feel they can fade out without anyone’s knowing or caring.

Learn about students’ experiences and use them in class. Ask students to provide you with information about themselves: where they are from, undergraduate school and major, graduate degrees, work experience, other experience related to the course, hobbies, and anything else they want you to know. Ask students to share their experiences at relevant times in the course.

Let students get to know you. Introduce yourself at the beginning of the course, letting students know about your professional and personal interests. Fill out the same informational survey you ask the students to complete. Go to lunch with students and attend student events.

“Wipe their noses” and “Serve them milk and cookies” failed to capture a majority vote of the committee. Go figure.

This has caused a raging debate to break out in the academy.  Randazza wants to treat them like human beings. Jay Wexler called his students by their last names when he started professoring, but then his “Doofus Prevention System” kicked in and he’s opted for first names.  The Rickster Esenberg at Co-Op mixes it up, possibly as a result of early onset dementia, while Nate Olman, wannabe curmudgeon, defaults to the formality of last names, but admits his reasoning:

Of course, the sad truth is that I am really bad at remembering names of all kinds, and I regularly screw-up even my own students’ last names. I had been married for several years before I was able to sort out all of the names in my wife’s extended family. I am still working on all of the names in my own. Given that some sizable proportion of the male law student population is named “Matt” I might be better off simply dispensing with last names entirely. Still, I keep last names because I actually think that there is some pedagogical and social value to formality.

Curious how none of these scholars, sufficiently concerned about their choice to mention it, have asked themselves the primary question:  What is the ABA talking about?  Supportive environment?  Why?

Deep within the bowels of the academy, professors, while sipping sherry and adjusting the elbow patches on their tweed jackets, complain about the whininess of their students.  Putting an end to this whining is high on their priority list, yet they thoughtlessly enable this “supportive environment” nonsense because the phrase involves two words currently in vogue. 

So let’s clear this up now.  There is no “supportive environment” in the law.  Our job is done under constant siege, with everyone else in the courtroom out to get us.  That’s why they call it an “adversary system” instead of a “happy friendly system.”  When everybody is being nice to you, it’s either because you have a brain tumor and won’t last the trial or they are setting you up for the fall. 

Do you think this is helping your students, by lulling them into a false sense of warmth and caring?  Turn up the heat.  Turn up the pressure.  If they can’t perform when they’re feeling alone and vulnerable, then this isn’t the job for them.  Or maybe they can take the abbreviated law school curriculum calculated to perfect their skills at document review and leave the rest to the students who can tough it out. 

Gideon just provided a list of the 10 things he didn’t learn in law school.  Let me add to the list, perhaps as number 8(a), that judges may smile warmly at you when you give your appearance, but they don’t really like you.  They don’t feel much of anything at all.  And if you open your mouth and the wrong thing comes out, they will rip your throat out in a flash, some of them still smiling as they do it.  Have you prepared Mr. Jones or Ashley for that?

I realize that pedagogical approaches, like skirt hems, move around all the time so that new lawprofs can write stories about how last year’s approach was wrong.  But in the trenches, things rarely change.  If your students care too much about what you call them, there’s a strong chance that they aren’t going to be able to stand up to the rigors of abuse of a system designed to constantly test their mettle.

Do your students a favor.  Forget their names.  The judge will.

And while you’re at it, make them call you “professor”.  They have to learn not to choke on that, just as they will when the call judges “your honor.”  Consider it a learning experience.

Top 10 Reasons to Twit (An Alternative View)

10.  Because CharonQC twits with a British accent, while Geeklawyer slurs his twits.

9.  Because the constant chirping noise from Brian Tannebaum’s twits is calming, soothing, rythmic

8.  Because you want to be a voyeur, but aren’t yet ready for nudity.

7.  Because you’ve never had an idea that required more than 140 characters anyway.

6.  Because it’s cool to be followed by 138 people you don’t know, some skimpily clad.

5.  Because you’ve always wanted to know the best wines under $7 a bottle.

4.  Because there aren’t enough opportunities in the day to learn about all the things people want to sell you.

3.  Because you now understand why Kevin O’Keefe lives in Seattle, where caffeinated coffee is an art form.

2.  Because it seems like you have people paying close attention to your every twit, even though no one is there.

And the best reason to twit…

Because there is no better way to while away the hours, and hours, and hours…

Dear Judge, I’m Sorry. Signed, Your Lawyer Pal

During the life of Simple Justice, I have occasionally been slightly critical of the decisions of some judges.  Not them personally, of course, as I admire each and every one enormously.  Just the occasional decision.  And only a little critical.  Maybe a smidge.

I now want to apologize if I’ve offended any judge anywhere at any time.  Yes, I know that you’re big boys and girls, and taking a little criticism of your decisions is part of the job, and you have broad shoulders and can handle it.  But still, I’m sorry.

The problem, you see, is that by posting things that don’t make some judges love me dearly, I have made a grievous error that has cost me in ways I didn’t foresee.

From Judicial Reports,


Attorney General Andrew Cuomo should investigate where Feinberg’s millions ended up, The New York Daily News suggests. The scathing editorial includes developments in the case of former Brooklyn Surrogate’s Court Judge Michael Feinberg. While the Surrogate has been professionally punished, the paper thinks Cuomo could use the 13,000 page removal proceeding as grounds to chase his money. The paper explains: “In 2002, the Daily News exposed how then-Brooklyn Surrogate’s Court Judge Michael Feinberg improperly okayed $9 million in fees for his lawyer pal Louis Rosenthal, some $2 million over and above what Rosenthal was due for his work on estates. Feinberg was charged by a state commission with misconduct and bounced from the bench in 2005. Last week, he was disbarred and Rosenthal’s law license was suspended for two years.”

The key words here are “lawyer pal.”  I want to be a lawyer pal too.  Can I be yours?

Up to now, I haven’t been a very good lawyer pal.  I have said things that might have hurt some feelings, ruffled some feathers, made a judge or two not look nearly as good as I should have.  I don’t know what came over me.  I was blinded by this inexplicable desire for integrity, a suicidal concept that likely did nothing to bring us closer together.  I want to make amends.

So what if you can’t be Learned Hand everyday.  And what’s with that name anyway?  It’s not like they are paying you what you’re worth, and we both know how true that is.  Why should you be expected to worry about the inadvertent use of logical fallacy, or maybe just reading only the headnotes instead of the whole decision.  Do the lawyers care how many of their horrendously written motions you have to read?  Sure, they get to bill them out pound for pound, but do they ever think about what all that weight does to you?  No. Of course not.  Lawyers don’t appreciate the burdens they lay on the judge, who (did I mention?) isn’t being paid enough to put up with their inability to structure a basic sentence.

See, I’m trying here.  I appreciate you.  I understand you.  I’m your lawyer pal.  At least, I could be.

I’m not hoping for much.  Not like that Rosenthal guy.  I mean seriously, how good a lawyer pal do you have to be to get an extra $2,000,000 above and beyond the $7,000,000 he (theoretically) was due.  Nobody is that good a lawyer pal.  I think.

I won’t be greedy, I promise.  And whenever you need a lawyer pal to talk to, to hang out with, whatever, I’ll be there for you.  And from now on, mums the word on any bone-headed decisions.  In fact, I might even come up with a few decent excuses, not to mention change my position on “harmless error” and (dare I say it?) lack of preservation.

No need to thank me.  These are the sort of things that one should expect from a lawyer pal.  So when can I expect the check?