Author Archives: SHG

Judy, Judy, Judy

As the era of Kaye comes to a close, Chief Judge Judith Kaye (don’t call her Judy) is eulogized by Jeffry Toobin in the New Yorker, the magazine for people from New Jersey who want to be cosmopolitan.  Despite having served as Chief Judge longer than anyone before her, her legacy is summed up in two words: Jury Duty.

One day in 1993, shortly after Judith S. Kaye became chief judge of New York’s highest court, she received a call from her daughter, who was on jury duty at the State Supreme Court, in Foley Square. “You know, Mom,” she said, “this is a great place to meet guys.” Strolling around that jury-assembly room the other day, Kaye paused, and deadpanned, “That’s when I immediately decided to upgrade the jury pool.”

While it’s not entirely clear, it would appear that the impetus for Judge Kaye’s focus was to improve the quality of people her daughter might meet, date, even marry, while on jury duty.  What mother doesn’t want the best for her child?

Back then, lawyers were exempt from jury duty, as were judges.  This may have taken a particularly tasty bite out of the jury pool, thus limiting the professional flavor of the men to be met. 


When Kaye became chief judge, New York granted exemptions from jury service to people in twenty-two different occupations—from doctors and lawyers to embalmers and the makers and users of prosthetic devices.

The end of exemptions was a very egalitarian move.  No longer were there swathes of New Yorkers who didn’t have to suffer the chairs and vending machines of the jury room.  Judge Kaye’s point was well intended, that there were no New Yorkers who were above the call of jury duty, so that the handful who lacked an Albany lobbyist to get them an exemption would no longer be second class citizens.  It was a very fair notion.

Kaye led a successful fight to abolish all exemptions; now everyone serves. As a result, a total of about six hundred and fifty thousand prospective jurors file, semi-voluntarily, into courtrooms around the state each year. With so many more jurors in the pool, citizens usually serve for a few days, rather than the two weeks that was common in the old days. Kaye’s reasons for promoting jury service range from the pragmatic (“We needed to show people, including the media, that the courts actually did work”) to the romantic (“The opportunity to sit in judgment of others is one of the great privileges of citizenship”).

At the time Judge Kaye began her quest, I thought it pointless.  Who, I wondered, would put a lawyer (no less a judge) on a jury?  As it turned out, over time lawyers found their way onto juries, and turned out not to be bad jurors in many cases.  Sure, their education and experience tended to be problematic, but there were lawyers, on juries, and the world continued to spin.  I can’t speak to the experience with embalmers.

Jury duty, or jury service as those who think it tastes better without the word “duty” attached, is a critical part of the court system.  I have no doubt that Judge Kaye’s focus improved the public perception to some extent, and certainly helped shorten it, at least in some parts of the state.  But what’s remarkable about Toobin’s article is that the legacy ends there.  Judge Kaye was deeply involved in trying to get pay raises for judges, but that never happened.  Even if it had, it would still fall under the heading of housekeeping, and hardly reflect much of a judicial legacy.

Judge Kaye, in person, is a every bit the dowager at age 70.  She carries herself with an air of great dignity, and is no doubt quite a remarkable woman.  She could win an argument with her stare alone.

I can’t help but think, however, how much better the State of New York would have been had her daughter been falsely accused or misidentified as a criminal, rather than called for jury duty in 1993.  Then, perhaps, Judge Kaye’s legacy would have been the continued development of New York’s independent constitutional jurisprudence extending the protection of individual civil rights and liberties in the face of collapsing federal law.  And Jeffrey Toobin might have written a longer eulogy.


No Bail for Jew (Updated: Comments Deleted)

The Conspirator in Chief at Volokh raises a fascinating conundrum from the Magistrate Judge’s denial of bond in  U.S. v. Rubashkin out of the Northern District of Iowa.  The defendant there was detained in a bank fraud case, at least in large part, due to the fact that he is Jewish.  From Eugene’s analysis:

“Under Israel’s ‘Law of Return,’ any Jew and members of his family who have expressed their desire to settle in Israel will be granted citizenship.” 

Nor does the opinion point to other factors that closely link Rubashkin to Israel, the way that any defendant could be closely linked to a foreign country in which he has lived a long time; the focus is on Rubashkin’s ethnicity and the legal consequence that it has in Israeli law, not on his citizenship or his past life history.

The argument proffered by the defense against detention addressed the obvious ramification of the Magistrate Judge’s rationale, that all Jews would be subject to detention if this reasoning was valid.


 [T]here are clearly narrower, tailored measures, that would be effective rather than subjecting Jews to a different set of standards. Rather than locking Jews up with greater frequency, the United States could rely on the general array of bail conditions, and then utilize the valid, streamlined, regularly-invoked extradition treaty with Israel in those few cases where the defendant actually flees. Certainly it is better to have the government on rare occasion be forced to resort to this streamlined extradition treaty than to brand over five million Americans as bail risks.

This argument failed to persuade the magistrate.

Aside from various arguments concerning the operation of the “Law of Return” and extradition, is it constitutional to paint all adherents of a particular religion with being a per se flight risk?  Notably, this comes from the Northern District of Iowa, where I would think there are fewer Jews then one could find on any block in Brooklyn, and may reflect a lack of appreciation that being Jewish may not be quite as odd as some judges think, or that Jews are not particularly likely to abscond and run off to Israel simply because they are Jewish. 

The magistrate concluded that there is no combination of conditions that could assure that the defendant will not flee to Israel.  The fact that he could, if he so wanted, may be true, but it is similarly true of all Jews.  That said, in the absence of any specific basis to contend that this particular defendant would be inclined to do so, it is a rationale for the detention of all Jews.

Of course, the ease with which a defendant can flee the jurisdiction is a consideration at a detention hearing, though it’s usually tempered by some showing of inclination specific to the individual defendant.  There was some additional information that suggested that a potential co-defendant might have fled, and that this defendant might be inclined to flee, though without any basis for the Israeli connection.

Thus, the issue is squarely framed whether it is constitutional to detain Rubashkin for, in essence, being Jewish.  At first blush, it seems that it must be.  How could an individual, based on his being a member of a religion, be denied reasonable bail, as promised by the 8th Amendment?

The government has yet to respond to the defendant’s argument. 

Update:  Numerous comments were posted to the effect that a few people read the Mag’s decision as finding that there was a substantial factual basis to believe that Rubashkin might flee to Israel.  While I totally disagree with this reading of the decision, my problem with these comments is that this wasn’t the gravamen of the issue raised by the post, and I, being the prickly sort of person that I am, was not interested in having what I considered to be a worthless discussion of a non-issue rather than a discussion of the issue raised by the post. Similarly, just because someone raises a tangential argument doesn’t mean I have to explain why they are wrong before asking that the discussion be placed back on track.  For the commenters who disagree with my position, have any discussion you want, just not here. 

For future reference, I will simply ban commenters who insist, and persist, on going onto their own topic.  I know you are all fascinated by your own thoughts, but this is my blawg.  Remember, nobody forces you to come here.   Have I been unclear about this?

By the way, I’m not the only blawger who is getting tired of having commenters assume that they run the show. 

How Quickly They Forget

Remember when gas was at over $4 a gallon and $150 a barrel, with no end in sight?  Wasn’t that back in ’72?  Or was it mid-October, just a couple months ago?  It’s hard to remember today, now that gas is selling under $2 a gallon.

I was smacked upside the head yesterday with a harsh reminder of how we manage to find ourselves in these predicaments.  First, a bit of history.  In early October, Mrs. SJ decided it was time to get a new Prius to replace the old Prius.  She drives a Prius, just like Ted Frank, because she thinks it makes her look sporty.  It’s really not a bad little car at all.  We call it the “pod”.

So we went to the Toyota dealer, where we were informed they had no Priuses available.  Plenty of other cars, but not a Prius to be found.  Of course, we were told (as if we needed to be told) that this was because of gas prices.  It was the only car anyone wanted.  Certainly understandable, given Americans sudden recognition that we might have an oil problem.

Still, while we were there, they urged us to allow them to appraise our old Prius for trade-in, and when a Prius became available, we would be given the trade-in value against the new one.  So we did.

The dealer was supposed to call us when a Prius became available.  We never received a phone call, but Mrs. SJ raised the Prius issue again, and I decided to make some inquiries.  It seems that all the local Toyota dealers now have Priuses in stock.  Not one, in a particularly ugly color, but plenty of them.  It seems that they are no longer flying out the door.  A couple of months have passed, and all is forgotten.  We have no oil crisis.  What were we thinking?

So I spoke with the dealer by phone, negotiated my a deal on a new Prius in the color Mrs. SJ preferred, (dark gray) which was my sole criteria for selecting the particular Prius, and made an appointment later in the day to come in and purchase it.  I thought it was a done deal. 

When I arrived, the lovely young woman I spoke with was preoccupied with something more important, so I was handed off to another salesperson who was unfamiliar with my deal.  He wanted to start from scratch, explaining to me all the wonderful features a Prius had to offer. I explained that we were already familiar with the car, were on a short time frame and really just needed to get the deal done.  I am so naive.

The salesman, after speaking with someone outside our view, returned to explain that the Prius in the color we selected, had just been sold.  But he had another Prius, in another color, that we could have.  Mrs. SJ was not pleased, but has little tolerance for car salespeople and gave me the look to proceed despite her misgivings.

So we shifted toward the completing the deal.  After informing my new salesman, who was actually a very nice guy who looked terribly uncomfortable selling cars and probably was a nuclear physicist six months ago, the “manager” came over to tell me that the price for the new Prius, the one posted on the dealer’s website, was for a mythical non-existent car with no special package.  This car had package number 2 (which included floor mats and tires, I believe) and would cost about a grand more.  I sat there silently.

The manager then informed me that the trade-in value of the old Prius was when everybody wanted Priuses, and that it was impossible for them to take the Prius at that price.  He wanted to explain it to me.  I told him that I wasn’t interested in the explanation.  I was, however, interested in them honoring the value they gave me.

The manager then asked how much I was willing to pay for the car.  I told him I would pay the price advertised.  He said, “no way,” and walked away.  I shrugged and did the same.  Before we could get very far, another manager came over to “explain” to Mrs. SJ, who is less tolerant than me, why they could not sell her the car at the advertised price and take her trade-in at their appraised value. 

Mrs. SJ was not in the mood to be lectured.  While she has never been in the mood to be lectured as long as I have known her, she was particularly unhappy with being lectured by a Toyota manager about why they can’t honor their word and why she should have to pay thousands of dollars more than agreed upon.  I might have intervened at this point, but Mrs. SJ was building up a head of steam and I feared being injured in the cross-fire.  I can tell from the throbbing veins in her temple when Mrs. SJ is best left alone.

Following a few choice words, we left the dealership without purchasing one of the many Prius they had sitting silently on their lot. 
Not only is there no oil crisis, but apparently there’s no economic crisis either at the Toyota dealer.  We were, however, the only customers in the dealership.  When we walked out, there were none.

Weighing the Risk of a Plea Offer

Gideon at A Public Defender, fresh off his international podcast with Charon QC, posits a very interesting concern coming out of the O.J. Simpson conviction. 



One interesting piece of information in this OJ Simpson brouhaha is the revelation that he may have rejected a plea offer for a sentence as low as 3 years. The first word came from a friend of The Juice and it was later confirmed by his lawyer.


The fallen idol’s pal Thomas Scotto said prosecutors made the offer in the last stages of his trial for armed robbery.

But Scotto added: “OJ and his sister told me the prosecution offered him a deal but he and his lawyers turned it down.” Scotto said that Simpson had been adamant he would not serve time and made that point clear to his lawyers.

He added: “He may have given it more serious consideration if he’d known what was coming.”

As Gid notes, it is incumbent upon defense counsel to convey any plea offer to a defendant.  But the duty, under a 1996 Second Circuit decision: Boria v. Keane (with its analog in Connecticut) requires counsel to not merely convey the offer, but to explain to the defendant the significance of the offer, good, bad and otherwise. 

There are only a few decisions left to the defendant in the course of a criminal prosecution.  One such decision is whether to accept a plea offer.  Theoretically, the choices belongs entirely to the defendant.  I say theoretically because it is unbelievably simple for defense counsel to manipulate the information to compel the defendant to make the choice that defense counsel believes is right, whether that means right for the defendant or right for counsel.

Coercion can be as subtle as voice inflection or a raised eyebrow, or as flagrant as telling the defendant to cop out.  Granted, there are times that a case is so bad, or a plea offer so good, that it would be insane not to take it, and that needs to be made clear as well.  But there are also times when it’s nothing more than a matter of risk tolerance, and the decision to go to prison must reside exclusively with the defendant.  After all, the lawyer goes home after a hard day in court.  If the defendant is going to put himself in prison, it has to be his choice.

But the scenario that Gideon considers is hardly unusual.  The defendant, full of bluff and swagger as he stares the indictment down, insists with absolute certainty that he’s going to fight, he’s not going to prison, he’s not going to take a plea.  This is when it becomes critical that the defense lawyer make it painfully clear that there is no guarantees and that prison may be unavoidable.  It’s crunch time, when lawyer and client have the most brutally honest conversation possible, and the very harsh, very real consequences of rolling the dice are made absolutely clear.

It’ my practice to do everything in my power to avoid influencing this decision, when there is a reasonable choice to be made.  Sure, clients ask for advice (meaning, tell me what to do), but I refuse to be lured by the opportunity to substitute my judgment for my client’s.  It’s not that I don’t have a sense of what I think ought to happen, but that I do not believe my level of risk tolerance to be a substitute for my client’s.  It must be the client’s choice, and the client must make that decision based upon a full understanding of all relevant information.  Clients hate this.

In some instances, one that happened quite recently to me, the client makes what would be considered a surprisingly ill-considered decision to accept a plea offer that is inadequate.  The fear of trial, of conviction, coupled with the burning desire to be done with the prosecution, a factor that should never be underestimated, drove the defendant to take what I considered to be a mediocre deal.  I really believed that we could do better, and that he failed to give adequate weight to some serious consequences of the plea. 

The defendant had time to decide whether to cop out or not.  This wasn’t one of those pleas coerced in front of the judge, with a two minute lifespan as good old Judge Harold Rothwax loved to do.  As it turned out, within 48 hours after taking the plea, the defendant began to have misgivings.  Some elements of the plea, which he had poo-pooed before when he felt the unbearable weight of his fear of risk, suddenly rose up to bite him in the butt.  The defendant began to sour on the deal, feeling a bit bolder now that he had been saved from years in a cell next to Bubba, and recognizing that he gave back some things that would prove as burdensome as I had explained.

I understood his displeasure well.  This was precisely why I took great pains to explain to him, clearly and using very small words, the many considerations that he should take into account in reaching his decision.  But he made his call, and there was no question that he knew exactly what he was facing and that the choice was entirely his.

If O.J. didn’t have that option as well, then he was entitled to better counsel.

Harmless Error, The Last Refuge of Scoundrels

From Colin Miller at EvidenceProf Blog, via Grits for Breakfast, a spectacular example of how two words, harmless error, can be used to make all the rules designed to provide a fair trial disappear in a snap.  The case comes from the Beneficent Republic of Texas, as does so many of our most interesting appellate rulings, in Aguilar v. State from the 14th Court of Appeals  in Houston.  I note Houston, because when things happen in Dallas, Texans respond, “Well, sure, that’s Dallas.  What do you expect?”

Though a series of rather bizarre evidentiary twists and turns, the prosecution is permitted to call a witness, Mancias, who they claim heard the defendant confess and provided that information to police, but claimed at a hearing outside the presence of the jury that he had no recollection of it ever happening, for the sole purpose of impeaching him and using him to introduce hearsay evidence of the third hand confession.  It was an evidentiary mess.

After sorting it out (do they know about Crawford in Texas?), and concluding that this should never have been permitted, the Court held that the State should free Aguilar immediately, apologize to him profusely, and consider placing a statue of him outside the courthouse get a free pass for this farcical trial.  Why?  Well, he did confess, didn’t he?

No, it wasn’t done so overtly.  Instead, the Court employed one of the two weapons it keeps hidden away in its bag of tricks to be pulled out when all else fails:  Harmless error.

So, Aguilar won his appeal, right?  Well, actually, the Court of Appeals found the trial court’s error to be harmless.  And how did it reach this conclusion?  

“At trial, Luhan testified that [Aguilar] shot him. Further, Officer David Wiese, an officer who responded to the scene of the shooting, testified that he asked Luhan who shot him and Luhan identified [Aguilar]. Therefore, the court admitted the only damaging evidence from Mancias’ statement, that appellant shot Luhan, through other sources. Because the same evidence was admitted without objection, the error is harmless.”

So there’s no confusion, as law students sometimes read these posts and demonstrate by their comments that they were not paying attention in first year evidence, the relative weight of a confession surpasses everything else at trial.  There is nothing, nothing, more damning.  Eyewitness identifications are hard to attack, but it can be done.  Declarations to police officers are of the same caliber, if not a bit easier.  But a confession is conclusive.  A confession can’t be attacked, except by the testimony of the defendant himself, which means that he must give up his right not to testify, usually a very unwise choice under normal circumstances.

To compare the introduction of a confession to the victim’s account is, in real trial terms, utterly ludicrous.  But with the invocation of those two most nasty and despicable words, harmless error, the appeals court can rule in Wonderland where a blink and a phrase makes everything bad go away.  This wasn’t the “same evidence,” unless the judges of the court have never tried a case and exist in some theoretical world where all evidence carries the same weight and impact.

Or perhaps we can just chalk up this decision to an instance of an appellate court deciding that, although the trial deeply flawed, the defendant was guilty and needed to be put away.  We don’t need no stinkin’ rules.

Police Officers Indicted and Everyone Yawns

The allegations of Michael Mineo, that he was anally raped by police officers, who caught him smoking a joint outside a subway station in Prospect Park, seemed shocking to me.  Echoes of Abner Louima rang in my ears.  Not in yours?  Not in a lot of people’s.  We have apparently reached the age when a police officer shoving an object up someone’s rectum is…ordinary.

According to MSNBC, two, and maybe three, of New York’s Finest will be arraigned today, after a Transit Police officer flipped and testified against them in the grand jury.


Prosecutors have asked two patrolmen to turn themselves in to face charges in the case of a tattoo parlor worker who claims he was sodomized with police equipment during an arrest on a Brooklyn subway platform, the officers’ lawyers said Monday.

Officers Richard Kern and Alex Cruz were to be arraigned Tuesday on charges contained in a sealed indictment, the lawyers said. A third officer also was expected to surrender.

This should be the sort of crime that sends shockwaves through the city.  Instead, it barely makes the news at all.  The New York Times has a short piece on it, with a primary focus on how Richard Kern is described by fellow officers as a “conscientious and fair” cop.


Going forward, much of the focus of the case will fall on Officer Kern because of the allegation that it was his baton that was reported to have come in contact with Mr. Mineo’s rectum. In recent days, the officer’s colleagues stepped forward to say that those accounts are at odds with the conscientious, responsible man they knew.

“He just wanted to be a good cop,” recalled Kevin Clark, a retired officer who worked with Officer Kern for about a year in the 71st Precinct.

Twice previously, Officer Kern was accused of using excessive force. but his lawyer said he was cleared in both cases by the Civilian Complaint Review Board. One of the incidents, in 2007, prompted two lawsuits that the city agreed to settle for a total of $50,000.

Nothing out of the ordinary there.

Some think that every exposure of police corruption or abuse is another nail in the coffin of the cop culture that enables conduct like this.  My fear is that we become increasingly inured to it.  When something like this happens and it barely causes an eye to blink, we are in deep trouble.  What will it take to make people sit up and take notice.  What will it take to make Joe Six-Pack care?

Greybear left a comment that summed things up better than I could:


Just as abused children will retain their attachment to the abusive parent because of their own needs, the vast majority of the population will continue to ignore the abuses by their “protectors.” That denial makes it possible for them to maintain the illusion that they are being kept safe and secure, even when the evidence leads to the inescapable conclusion that they are in more danger from the “protectors” than they are from the bogeymen they are threatened with. I’m afraid I don’t see this changing anytime soon.

If this story makes you yawn, I don’t know what will get your juices flowing.  If anal rape falls into the category of everyday police abuse, we have become too jaded for explanation.  And if anybody comments that if Mineo didn’t want to be “bothered” by the police, he shouldn’t have smoked a joint at the Prospect Park subway station, I’m going to go off on it.  Be warned.

Dreier: The Cupboard is Bare

Just heard from a pal at Lion Button Company, in the midst of a buyout where he was represented by Dreier LLP, that the firm’s escrow account was looted and is, for all intents and purposes, gone with the wind.

Speculation is that Marc Dreier, the sole equity owner of the firm, was up in Canada trying to scam $40 million to cover the gaping hole in the firm’s escrow account.  The problem isn’t the potential collapse of his firm because the founder and owner has gone bonkers, but that the firm is now at the epicenter of perhaps the greatest instance of lawyer dishonesty ever.

The ramifications of this raiding of the escrow account will send shockwaves throughout the legal world.  The Lawyers Fund for Client Protection only covers up to $300,000 in losses, so Lion Button, with $1.6 million missing, is screwed but good, and stands to collapse for loss of its working capital.  Worse still, the faith the businesses repose in lawyer escrow accounts, particularly with Biglaw and Big Deals, may be fatally undermined as a result of this fiasco.

Apparently, the efforts are now being made both internally and externally to shut down the escrow account, preserve what remains of the cash on hand and try to salvage what little is left following this disaster.  Frankly, I hope this information is totally wrong, as the ramifications of this are shocking. 

Sorry, But You’re Not Cut Out For Solo

One curious reaction to my post yesterday about what it means to be a lawyer in the Age of Layoffs was to read into my message that I was another voice in the chorus of “Go Solo, Young Lawyer.”  This is not entirely surprising, since I was Professor Number 1 of Solo Practice University, before being summarily booted out on my butt for being far uglier than the shameless marketers distinguished faculty.

Since I’ll never have the opportunity to shape young minds and help them to take charge of their futures at SPU, I’ll have to make do with an occasional post here to address some of the points that I would have made over there.  It’s just as well, since Susan Cartier Leibel would not have been completely happy with me anyway, my charming personality notwithstanding.

Not everyone is cut out for solo practice.

There.  I’ve said it.

While the practice of law, what we as individual attorneys do on behalf of a client, is unchanged regardless of where we happen to call our home, the nature of our surroundings varies wildly.  Whether we work within a corporate structure, or in your basic 7000 person law firm, with one old friend in the next office or all by your lonesome, we remain lawyers. 

But not everyone is temperamentally suited to being on your own.  Some thrive on the risk and excitement of flying without a parachute, while others can’t bear the pressure.  Some enjoy the control over their world, small though it may be, while others hear only the echo of an empty room ringing in their ears, and that echo can be deafening.

Even those of us who have spent our entire career as solo or small firm practitioners have days when we think about how wonderful it would be to get a paycheck at the end of the week rather than sit staring at the phone, willing it to ring, knowing that the electric bill was due.

The argument that some suffer the burden of crushing law school debt, making it impossible for them to enjoy the panacea of solo practice with the bells and whistles that the solo apostles inform them are minimally required, misses the point.  There is no assurance that you’re going to earn the monster salary that Biglaw dangled before you, but there’s no assurance you won’t either.  If you’re as good as mommy told you, then why fear the marketplace for your talents?  

But it can be lonely practicing solo.  When you hear a funny joke, there’s no one to share it with.  When a client makes your life miserable, who do you turn to?  If you’re pondering deep legal thoughts, where’s the friend to tell you you’re nuts?

There are ways around all of this, of course.  The Sages of Solo will tell you to create a “network”, because the word “network” is one of the premier buzzwords intended to make you overlook your well-founded discomfort.  Networks can be wonderful.  They can also be a disaster, depending on how useful, honest and worthy your network turns out to be.  Most likely, they will have attributes of both, and it will be up to you to figure out which is which.  You’ve got to have great risk tolerance to be a solo.

None of us is so brilliant that, left to our own devices, we will always get it right.

Yet the solo practitioner can take no comfort when the day comes that he screws up.  And it will.  No matter how hard we try, no matter how risk tolerant or risk averse, no matter how deliberative or active, a solo practitioner must ultimately make his own decisions and will make some wrong ones.  Some will make a lot of wrong ones.  These decisions will affect clients.  They will impact business.  It’s tough to come home after a hard day and explain to one’s spouse about the horrendously stupid thing you did today.  It’s much nicer to come home a hero, but it isn’t going to work that way every day.  Get used to it.

The difference between screwing up in a law firm versus screwing up solo is that there’s no one else to blame.  It’s all you, baby.  While some mistakes will be annoying, and some will affect nothing besides your own wallet, some will have dire consequences for people who have bet their life on your making the right call.  These are the hardest, as you can shrug off the consequences of your own errors when you’re paying the full price, but you know, in your heart, that a mistake that affects a client is the one that crushes your very reason for being. 

Then there’s the ringing phone syndrome.  The only proper way to describe this is as a chronic disease, as it never quite goes away no matter how long you practice law. 

Large firms represent large clients who have a never ending stream of legal work to be performed, more closely resembling a never-ending merry-go-round than individualized representation.  Of course, that stops when the large clients goes bankrupt and the firm collapsed under a huge pile of monogram-embossed redwelds, but that’s a story for another day.

Solo practitioners live case by case, client by client.  Some days, the phone rings 10 times, and each ring brings a person in need of your services.  Some days, the phone is silent.  No matter how many years and phone calls you enjoy, no matter how many times you’ve been asked to appear on Fox News or MSNBC, no matter how many notches in your ever-increasing belt, there is one fear that every solo practitioner shares.  That the phone has fallen permanently silent.

It’s not a phenomenon afflicting only lawyers, but having company spanning all professions makes this no more comforting.  After 25 years of living this way, one might assume that I’ve been cured of this chronic disease, knowing that the phone will assuredly ring again, if not today then tomorrow, and bring with it some great new case that will keep me far too busy, giving me yet another reason to complain.  But it doesn’t work this way.  No one is ever cured of this disease.  It stays with you until the day you take your shingle down. 

For those well-suited to a solo practice, the ringing phone syndrome is more of a nagging pain, radiating from your frontal lobe to your fingertips.  You know it’s there, but can shake it off and work through the pain.  For those who are less-well-suited to solo practice, the disease can become a deep fear, causing shuddering, uncontrolled twitching and inexplicably watering eyes when the end of the day rolls around and the phone has yet to ring. 

This is the fear exploited by the marketers, by the way, who promise that they have the secret to making your phone ring.  How wonderful to have someone else take the horrible weight off your solo-shoulders of making that telephone emit the most joyous of all sounds.  One reason that lovers o’ marketing turn sycophantic is that they are no longer truly solo, having found broader shoulder than their own to carry the burden of overwhelming fear.  If the weight of this fear is too much for you to carry alone, then it is likely that you are not cut out for solo.

Perhaps the interested opponents of these thoughts will provide you with a pep talk full of many thousands of warm words and fuzzy ideas.  But I’m not part of the chorus.  I’m a solo.

Will Kopbusters Screw It All Up?

There have been a whole buncha blogs, from  WindyPundit to Balko,  Randazza to Overlawyered,  Crime & Federalism to Turley, posting about some ex-undercover cop who’s decided to become the newest internet hero by exposing corruption by cops in obtaining a search warrant on false info.

As Radley succinctly puts it,


Barry Cooper, the former drug cop turned pitchman for how-to-beat-the-cops videos. He comes off as more of a huckster than a principled whistle-blower, which I think does the good ideas he stands for (police reform) more harm than good.

But damn. I have to hand it to him. This might be one of the ballsiest moves I’ve ever seen.

Granted, this could turn out to be a hoot, if this cop-turned-huckster-turned-whistle-blower pulls off something credible.  That he might have caught the cops in Odessa, Texas, illegally using thermal imaging technology to locate a grow house and then lying about it to fabricate probable cause for a warrant, will stun and amaze everyone.  Kinda.

So why don’t I want to go to the party with my blawgospheric brethren? 

Having seen the harm of police doing what they believe they have to do to get the bad guys off the street for so long, and having experienced the quiet truth that many people really aren’t all that disturbed by the notion that police might occasionally fudge the truth to circumvent what is generally perceived as a plethora of inhibiting rules that protect the criminal at the expense of the citizen, shows like this scare me.  They turn real problems, systemic problems, into a circus.

I know, this Cooper fellow has done the legwork, huckster or not.  He set it up, filmed it, put it together, and added music (maybe, I don’t really know how good his production values will turn out to be).  It should make for some interesting viewing.  But it takes the issue of police corruption and deception to a different place, and I suggest that it’s not a place we necessarily want it to be.

I remember Serpico.  I remember the Dirty 30 and the day Abner Louima was anally raped with a toilet plunger handle in the 70th Precinct, and not a voice was raised.  New York-centric, of course, but real and undisputed.  These were hard demonstrations of systemic pervasive corruption, abuse and deception by police officers that shocked a City, and perhaps a nation.  They changed little, as people became inured to the reality that not all cops are perfect. 

What scared me then was that few people were willing to connect the dots between what undisputedly was happening in these celebrated scandals and what routinely happened behind closed doors in our police departments and on our witness stands,  My psychological analysis was that they didn’t want to, they couldn’t, or the system would collapse upon open recognition that this was not just “one bad apple,” as apologists always insisted.

What scares me now about this freak-show performance is that it will not simply further inure people to these intransigent problems, but turn it from something that is incredibly serious and painful for the real people and families harmed into some half-baked Vaudeville act.  This diminishes the real pain.

It’s not that exposure of wrongdoing by police is not an critical step in informing the public that this is real, it exists and it’s going on daily.  It’s not that clarifying why, in the smaller minds of those who can blink and make it disappear, this is wrong is a bad thing.  But this Cooper is not the poster boy for credibility, and his approach stands an awfully good chance of trivializing the problem and compromising serious efforts to change police culture by turning this into another bit of internet goofiness.

There is no question that things such as Cooper claims happened in Odessa do, in fact, happen.  But it isn’t entertainment.  At least not to the children who grown up without their parents.  When this becomes nothing more than fodder for some huckster’s latest self-promotional venture, does it mean that the battle might be won, or that the battle is over and police misconduct is just the latest sitcom.

It’s not that it isn’t an interesting concept.  But I’m hardly prepared to hitch my wagon to someone like Barry Cooper.

No Layoffs in the Well

Brian Tannebaum, our second favorite Floridian, who has taken captive the name Criminal Defense for his blawg (a reflection of his moral compass perhaps?), happened upon a fascinating idea.  “Lawyers”, Brian argues, “cannot be laid off.”  Only tools can be laid off,


If you are laid off, you are not a lawyer, you are a tool, a device, a big or small firm expendability. Check yourself.

When I first read his post, I challenged Brian to take it further, deeper.  He demurred, but offered me the opportunity to take up the cause.  I do so at his invitation.

It was a given in my youth that one of the greatest things to be was a professional.  The reason, I was told, was that no matter what happened in the world, no one could ever take your profession away from you.  Once you possessed the learning, the skills, the knowledge, it could never be taken away.  It was yours forever.

This came at a time when the pain of the Holocaust was still very real, and when people who had amassed great fortunes lost everything in an instant.  Businesses could be seized. Homes lost.  Paintings and sculpture swept away.  But no matter what group came to power, no matter how powerful they were, they could not take away your knowledge.  This was a powerful lesson.  This was why one became a “professional”.

As blawgs chronicle the layoffs from large law firms, not to mention the self-immolation of large firm owners who seem to lose their minds with some regularity, the world seems to be crumbling around thousands of lawyers who were assured that getting good grades, making law review, kissing butt at interviews, would provide them with a future of wealth and prestige.  This was the way things worked.  Just play the game, get the right summer clerkship, and you will live a life of plenty.


The country is filled with people calling themselves “lawyers” who entered this profession for the wrong reason. Maybe it’s not such a bad idea that they never really achieved what they perceived themself to be, and now find themselves looking for work, as “lawyers.”

Your world has come crashing down around your head, and the best some kid from Miami can do is kick you when you’re down?  No, that’s not what Brian is doing.  He’s challenging the conventional wisdom that took young men and women who entered law school one day with the dream of becoming a lawyer and, by the evil forces of manipulation, were turned into pointless drones to fill the needs of Biglaw.  They received magnificent starting salaries, and all it cost them was their soul. 

While I’m not entirely innocent of some small degree of Schadenfreude, with these wannabe masters of the universe coming face to face with their mortality, I feel badly about the misery caused by your having been misinformed.

You are lawyers.  You were lawyers before.  You are lawyers still.  No one can take that away from you.

What you are not is employed.  What you are not is on the partnership track.  What you are not is guaranteed to get that partnership invitation when your class turns 10.  Things aren’t working out the way they told you they would?  Bummer.

Back in law school, people lied to you.  Hey, they did it in grade school too, when they explained sex to you.  You figured out the latter and will figure out the former as well.  Lawyers do not need employers.  Lawyers are not diminished by the collapse of Biglaw, recession or name-partner psychosis. 

Brian’s lesson is that you have only seen yourself up to now as an employee, a cog in the wheel of profit per partner.  When you stand in the well of a courtroom, no one cared what firm monogram was gold-leafed onto your brief bag.  You were a lawyer, if only for the brief, shining moment.  You spoke in a clear, stentorian voice, and your case rose or fell on your words.  You, and you alone, stood between your client and disaster.  Did it make you feel alive?  That’s what it feels like to be a lawyer.

Only employees can be laid off. 

Lost your job?  Great.  Now you can be a lawyer.  Your mother will be so proud.

As a show of my appreciation to Brian for allowing me to play with his idea, the very least I can do is include this footer that Brian includes after every post at his blawg:


Brian Tannebaum is a criminal defense lawyer in Miami, Florida practicing in state and federal court. Read his free ebook The Truth About Hiring A Criminal Defense Lawyer. To learn more about Brian and his firm, Tannebaum Weiss, please visit www.tannebaumweiss.com

Remember, he’s from Florida (not that there’s anything wrong with that).