Author Archives: SHG

Sexual Molestation Rejected as Suggestive of Possession of Child Pornography

Orin Kerr at VC has cited a 6th Circuit decision from September that produces an extraordinary result, particularly given the court’s lack of love toward defendants.  In United States v. Hodson, the police obtained a search warrant following an undercover, pretending to be a 12 year old boy, exchanging online messages that culminated in the defendant, who called himself “WhopperDaddy”, suggesting that he wanted to engage in oral sex with the “child”. 

During the course of the communications, WhopperDaddy claimed that he “favored young boys, liked looking at his nine- and eleven-year-old sons naked, and had even had sex with his seven-year-old nephew.”

The police, after identifying the defendant and locating his address, obtained a search warrant for child pornography.

Up to this point, all seems rather reasonable.  But not to the Circuit.


It is beyond dispute that the warrant was defective for lack of probable cause — Detective Pickrell established probable cause for one crime (child molestation) but designed and requested a search for evidence of an entirely different crime (child pornography). Consequently, the warrant did not authorize the search and, barring some other consideration, the evidence obtained during that search must be excluded from trial.

Going further, the Court addressed the Leon good-faith exception by holding:


The question we address here is whether the faceless, nameless “reasonably well trained officer” in the field, upon looking at this warrant, would have realized that the search described (for evidence of the crime of child pornography) did not match the probable cause described (that evidence would be found of a different crime, namely, child molestation) and therefore the search was illegal, despite the magistrate’s decision to the contrary. We conclude that any “reasonably well trained officer” would certainly have come to that realization if presented with this warrant.

Like Orin, my gut inclination would be to accept a reversal on a bad search warrant on face value, particularly coming out of the 6th Circuit.  But also like Orin, I find myself shocked by this outcome.  I feel like a traitor for saying so, but so be it.

While the crimes of child molestation and possession of child pornography are legally distinct, to reject any fact-based nexus seems ludicrous.  Yet the court not only rejected it, but did so with absolute clarity.  While it might be an unwarranted leap of faith to assume that possession of pornography suggests that the passive viewer will act upon his sick interest, that would not be the case in the other direction.  If someone is inclined to engage in the act of molesting a child, it is hardly a stretch to believe that he would also possess kiddie porn images. 

As Orin points out, this is hardly a novel connection.


Even the Supreme Court has linked the two. See Osborne v. Ohio, 395 U.S. 103 n.7 (1990) (“Child pornography is often used as part of a method of seducing child victims. A child who is reluctant to engage in sexual activity with an adult or to pose for sexually explicit photos can sometimes be convinced by viewing other children having “fun” participating in the activity.”).

While I can’t help but applaud any court for seriously scrutinizing the content and good-faith assumed in most search warrants, having seen far too many truly bad warrants rubber-stamped in the first instance and then blindly approved by the issuing judge on review, this is not one where reversal would be expected. 

Does this suggest a greater degree of tolerance from the courts toward child molestation and pornography, historically considered the most vile of crimes?  It seems impossible to imagine, but if you’re defending against a warrant like this, Hodson is certainly a decision to note.

Lawyer Fashionista: Barrister Edition

While my renown for legal fashion here in the states is legend, I’m at a loss about the bare necessities across the pond.  This leaves me little choice but to turn to my barrister colleague, Geeklawyer, who appears to have gotten himself into a bit of a fashion faux pas recently.  If this can happen to GL, then no one is safe.



Geeklawyer was in the High Court last week on matter which was a sad little business – the capitulation of a noble claimant in a valiant, doomed, but worthy cause. He trolled into Court X intending to stand before Mr Justice Hearditallbefore and wave the white flag with whatever dignity his punter could manage, which was, to be frank, not much. Now the rule is, in the Courts where Geeklawyer normally hunts, that wigs are only for trials and not interim matters. And you can guess where this one goes: to his horror all the other counsel – the regular boys, LJ Hearditallbefore’s little posse – were all in full circus outfits. Wigs. Gowns. Bands. The fucking works. What to do? Well naturally a man of honour would ‘fess up to the judge and hope for the best. Geeklawyer did the only thing a man such as he could do:


‘My Lord I am improperly dressed because a pack of feral Solicitor-Inadequates attacked me at the Strand entrance of this Court so as to steal my wig. My Lord, they fled with it and my gown and bands while yelling “We has the precious. We has it, is ours. We wants it, we needs it.” My Lord I assembled a hunting pack of Barristers and we gave chase up Chancery Lane and as far as Holborn Tube but they eluded us.’


Mercifully the otherwise crusty LJ Hearditallbefore was a decent old codger and fell for it hook line and sinker. Even Geeklawyer’s utterly bollocks arguments about the necessity of a detailed costs hearing on a one day matter were allowed comiseratory passage.


What’s amazing is that he writes, even curses, with a British accent.  But what comes clearly through is that there are three important aspects of the Barrister’s attire that GL somehow left behind in his presumptively casual approach to “My Lord.”  And if you thought calling a judge “yer honor” was a bit much, you could choke before “my lord” came out of your mouth.

The Wig
The Gown
The Bands

It had been my understanding that the formal attire for a barrister had been dropped in favor of the more standard business suit.  Apparently, the death of the wig was greatly exaggerated.  Apparently, GL was as clueless as I would have been.  But his facile tongue went into action and saved the day.

In the olden days, when lawyers in the colonies wore white shirts and suits to work regardless of what they had on the docket that day, the emergency call to appear before a judge presented nothing more than a momentary annoyance.  Sure, it interfered with your appointments, but presented no sartorial issues.  We were, always, appropriately dressed.

Times, unfortunately, have since changed, and many lawyers show up in the office in more casual dress.  Forget white shirts, which are largely saved for weddings and funerals, but suits have given way to slacks and, if you’re of a certain age, a sports jacket (now called a blazer).  Some prefer blue jeans and flip flops.

Many of us keep a suit, shirt and tie in the closet in case of emergency.  This was a great idea for younger lawyers, but I found a problem when last I was compelled to change for an unplanned court appearance.  The suit were present and pressed, but hadn’t been worn in over a decade.  As suits will do over long periods of time, it shrunk.  Significantly.  To the point where blood flow was impossible.  Note: Try on your closet suit every few years, just in case.

Our British brothers have it easy.  Rather than require a full body’s worth of clothing, they need only three items.  The wig, which compensates for a bad hair day, seems so inherently ratty as to make concern over its appearance pointless.  The gown, which by definition is ill-fitting, can hang in the closet forever without presenting risk of serious injury.

But what about these “bands”?  From what I understand, the bands are the two strips of fabric that drop from the winged collar that is choking the life out of poor Rumpole.  They are reminiscent of the jabot favored by the former Associate Justice, Sandra Day O’Connor. 

Whereas Justice O’Connor’s fashion sense was grounded in the lack of any other appropriate option for a woman wearing a black gown, though I always thought a turtleneck would look fabulous, the purpose of the bands eludes me.  Beyond pure foppery, they are utterly pointless.

Worse yet, the bands, which replace the tie worn by modern man, are bland.  Sure, white makes choosing which band matches which gown easy, but is there no room for a little individuality? 

The fact that Geeklawyer committed the sin of walking into the courtroom without the appropriate attire for a barrister of his great importance is unfortunate.  The fact that “my lord” bought his cockamamie story, as if feral Solicitor-Inadequates would have any need of his ratty old stuff is ridiculous.

But should any American “barrister” have reason to appear before some “lord” over there, there is one bit of information that should be taken to heart. 



Geeklawyer was rumbled by one local hack who, unconvinced even for a split second, whispered:


“Never mind all that bollocks – if you are after me I’ll lend you my wig.“


This cameraderie mutual respect and brotherly support is what lies at the heart of the English Bar. Geeklawyer declined the offer because the pathetic wreck was a criminal barrister: with Legal Aid what it is he probably couldn’t afford to wash his hair from one month to the next and probably had lice; “No thanks my dear chap, terribly grateful but I’ll wing it before the old buffer.” What’s a brother to do? eh?


Pass on the borrowed wig, notwithstanding Geeklawyer’s antipathy toward legal aid.  Of course, GL is a very particular fellow, so careful about those with whom he associates that he won’t even put me on his blogroll (though he’s got Bennett and that corporate tool Dan Hull prominently displayed there).  So don’t take his slur on legal aid to heart.  It’s likely just the typical British lawyer’s pathological fear of head lice.

What Did Fox Do To Greta?

When Greta Van Susteren was bought by Rupert Murdoch for Fox News, I defended her right to get a new nose, and felt this was an inappropriate basis for attack.  Many people get new noses for varying personal reasons, and Greta was every bit as entitled to a new nose as anyone else.

But what about a new brain?  Now that’s another story.

I happened to turn on Fox News the other night when Greta was interviewing Newt Gingrich.  Today, I see that Walter Olson at Overlawyered picked up on this interview as well.  It deeply saddened me to watch what has happened to someone who was worthy of admiration for her intellect and guts.

A criminal defense lawyer, adjunct faculty member at Georgetown Law School, Greta was no dummy.  When she hosted Burden of Proof with Roger Cossack from 1994 to 2002, her intelligence and wit was on full display.

Then, in 2002, Greta was the subject of a bidding war, with Fox News prevailing.  Then a new Greta emerged, not exactly a sycophant in the manner of a pompous Bill O’Reilly or the sewer-dweller, Sean Hannity, but one who was willing to disconnect intellectual integrity from TV personality.

Greta has a blog called “Gretawire”.  Like most TV connected blogs, it serves primarily as an outlet for her fans to express their love.  It must be nice to be so loved.  But the content, the posts offered to Fox News viewers for their “opinions”, couldn’t possibly have been written by the Greta I knew.  Take a look at this :



It just occurred to me… $150,000 spent …by whom?
by Greta Van Susteren


It has been reported that the RNC spent $150,000 on clothes etc. for Governor Palin….but it just occurred to me, did she do this? was she the shopper?  or was this the RNC?  I just don’t see how Governor Palin could possibly have shopped herself…when? The media would have been trailing her throughout the stores…plus Secret Service…and would not someone in the media have reported it? It would have been a spectacle!  We don’t give the woman one inch to breathe so why would you think the media would let her shop and not report it? it just does not make sense!


In this sometimes nutty business of the media, we keep track of the candidates at all times….24/7….I know where they are..when they take off…when they land…who they are seeing….hours spent studying…..what they say etc.  Our FNC embed producers are emailing us non stop about the candidates…where they are and what they are doing….when would Governor Palin have had a chance to shop?  Never on my blackberry has anyone ever mentioned she was shopping….I suppose it is possible…but a part of me wonders if she is getting “thrown under the bus” on this one ? Who did do the shopping?


Now my first thought is that Greta’s just playing with her fans, knowing full well that there are two very different, and very complete, answers to her query.  First, there are a number of ways that Palin could have shopped outside the view of the media, whether before the announcement of her selection or during the private, after-hours shopping sprees that are provided very important shoppers or through “private shoppers” serving her sartorial needs. 

But, more importantly, the issue has nothing whatsoever to do with Palin having done the physical shopping herself.  Of course, Greta must realize this.  Greta’s no dope.  So why would she post something so, so dopey?

Apparently, the Greta I knew, the lawyer, the thinker, isn’t the Greta we see on TV.  The TV Greta is an entertainer in “this nutty business of the media,” and she’s playing the role on television that she’s paid to play.  If only she could sing and dance, we would have a Greta Extravaganza!  She could be the new Ed Sullivan, with Newt Gingrich playing Topo Gigio.

Likewise, Gretawire is an act in support of her TV personality.  Dumb it down to suit those with limited reasoning ability, and play the crowds like a pro.  And she is awfully good at what she does, portraying the kinda-lefty from a Fox News perspective, to make them feel like even lefty-Greta can’t deny the righteousness of the simpletons.

Way to go Greta!  You are a star.  Just don’t forget that there’s the old, smart, lawyer Greta underneath the TV persona.  Some day, you may want to return to the world of the thinking, and, to paraphrase Dan Quayle, a mind is a terrible thing to waste.

Is Proportionality Dead in Child Porn Cases?

As I’ve made clear many times, I don’t represent defendants in kiddie porn cases because of my personal feelings about the offense.  Despite criticism for this decision, it remains my position.  But that doesn’t mean that all reason is lost, even when discussing unpalatable cases.

The WSJ Law Blog posts about the fact that individuals convicted of viewing kiddie porn are, under the federal sentencing guidelines, subject to punishments that can be more severe than those for people who engage in child molestation or create the porn.

Thanks to a DOJ initiative, more than 2,000 individuals are prosecuted each year for computer-based child exploitation crimes, most of them for downloading or sharing sexual images of minors. Severe federal sentencing guidelines — spurred by Congress in recent years — can push up the recommended sentences to 15, 20 years or longer.

Does that kind of punishment — for viewing but not creating the images — fit the crime? Some federal judges think not and are giving lower-than-recommended sentences.

The concern is not that the people who view child pornography should be allowed to do so, or shouldn’t be subject to punishment.  This isn’t about black or white, but shades of gray.

The government’s view is expressed very clearly.


But Drew Oosterbaan, the DOJ official in charge of these prosecutions says a threat undoubtedly exists from passive viewers of child porn. “[I]f your daughter’s camp counselor is using child porn, common sense dictates there is a threat to your daughter,” he says.

The rationale for treating viewers of kiddie porn as harshly as child molesters falls back on our old friend, “common sense.”  An appeal to “common sense” is employed whenever the government prefers that we apply prejudice in place of reason.  Like the old marijuana is the gateway to heroin argument, the government justifies unduly severe treatment of passive viewers like child molesters because they are tomorrow’s sexual predators.

And judges aren’t necessarily fooled by this slippery slope argument either.


“The fact that a person was stimulated by digital depictions of child pornography does not mean that he has or will in the future seek to assault a child,” wrote William Griesbach, a federal judge in Green Bay, Wisc.

The first comment to this WSJ post, echoing the community reaction discussed in this post about Charles Ethison, makes far more sense then our government’s reasoning:


But since I became a mom, I’ve found that I really don’t care if the laws governing this issue are unfair to the predators, or would be offenders. I would rather the law err on the side of caution here. I think it’s worth a few innocent (?) kiddy porn viewers getting an unfair sentence, to prevent just one kid from getting hurt.

When it comes to children, concerns about fairness, proportionality and reason go out the window.  The bottom line to any reasonable parent, is that their child’s safety is so vastly more important than anyone else’s “rights” that they will happily sacrifice pretty much anything in the world to protect their children.  It’s a perfectly understandable position for a parent to take.

The problem is that the reasonable position from a parent can’t be the official position of the government or the legal system, which is designed to remove the purely emotional reaction to crime and fear and replace it with a broader view of societal impact.

As a parent and someone who finds kiddie porn utterly despicable, I can completely understand the parent’s reaction.  As a lawyer, I know that this is a legally untenable position, and that it clouds the real issues and problems in dealing with kiddie porn. 

While I, like most, am appalled that anyone would have any desire to be a passive viewer of such garbage, refusal to distinguish between mere viewing and its creation, observation and acting upon it, demonstrates both a total lack of proportionality and presents bad penal policy.  If the passive viewer is treated the same, if not worse, than the child molester, than there is no threat of punishment to prevent the passive viewer from acting upon impulse and engaging in an act of sexual molestation of a child.

As much as I am sickened by the idea of people watching kiddie porn, the idea of someone sexually touching a child is much, much worse.  The penalties for each must reflect the relative harm, and not be swept up in the natural tide of fear, anger and disgust.

If There’s Virtual Murder, Is There a Virtual Defense?

Granted, this comes out of Japan, but that’s where the technology starts that makes its way to our shores.  The problem is that the lines between the games played online and the reality of flesh and blood people is blurring to the degree that when a digital character is “murdered”, a real person is arrested.

From the AP via Volokh :

A 43-year-old Japanese woman whose sudden divorce in a virtual game world made her so angry that she killed her online husband’s digital persona has been arrested on suspicion of hacking, police said Thursday.

The woman, who is jailed on suspicion of illegally accessing a computer and manipulating electronic data, used his identification and password to log onto popular interactive game “Maple Story” to carry out the virtual murder in mid-May.

Not being an online game player, perhaps I lack a certain degree of comprehension of how serious some people take their games.  Apparently, bot the “husband” and “wife” in this exercise took it too seriously.

“I was suddenly divorced, without a word of warning. That made me so angry,” the official quoted her as telling investigators and admitting the allegations.

The woman had not plotted any revenge in the real world, the official said.

She has not yet been formally charged, but if convicted could face a prison term of up to five years or a fine up to $5,000.

While the players involved may have lost their perspective about the relative importance of a game as compared to real life, it appears that Japanese law enforcement is no better.  Can you imagine the trial, with the “wife” testifying that the digital husband “needed killin’.”

While Eugene Volokh finds this scenario legally palatable because the claimed wrong is illegally accessing a computer, and some commenters to his post have noted that digital currency actually sells for the real stuff on eBay, proving that people are indeed loopy when it comes to their games, it seems that he’s a bit too focused on the trees to see the forest.  It’s a game.  No real people were harmed in the playing of this game.  It’s not real.

Is this the evil that was to be cured by anti-hacking laws?  Do we really want to imprison people for their virtual crimes?  The fact that prosecutors might be able to squeeze a virtual crime enough to fit within a law existing to prevent some other wrong doesn’t make it proper.  And this one is just off the wall.

I’m sure someone out there plays computer games.  I’m sure someone out there takes their games very seriously.  But do you believe that some digital game is so serious, so real, that it could ever be worth imprisoning someone?  While I doubt anyone will be bold enough to try to explain why this should be taken seriously, I bet that someone will think it, saying, “you don’t get it, I played for weeks and she just ruined my avatar.”  Get out more, will ya?

Of course, this happened in Japan.  It could never happen here, because we’re nowhere near as wacky as they are.  Right?

Kudos to Judges Campaigning Lawfully (Unhappy Update)

Last year, I wrote a post for Judicial Reports about the pervasive problem of judicial candidates posting their smiling faces on every telephone pole from the Queens border to Montauk.  While appreciating the ludicrous position of running for a judgeship, with nothing to offer besides a party endorsement and their best Joe Wapner impression, the effort at achieving name recognition by violating the law seemed so very wrong.


An inherent irony is that those who seek our vote for a position where they swear to uphold the law are busily breaking the law by attaching their signs to poles across the state, but this long-standing tradition passes right over the heads of most voters. And to make matters worse, as signs fall down to live out the rest of their lives as the flotsam and jetsam of our lesser quality of life, or worse yet remain attached after a candidate has lost an election, they serve as a reminder of how these good men and women who seek nothing more than to serve have demeaned themselves to gain our love.

This year, the most remarkable thing has happened.  With a shy two weeks remaining in the campaign, I have yet to see a single poster for a judicial candidate on a telephone pole.  Not one!  There may be one, even two, lurking in places I haven’t ventured, but this is a monumental shift in the approach to judicial campaigning.

I applaud all candidates for judicial office for their restraint, their adherence to the law and the return of dignity to a particularly undignified endeavor.  Way to go. 

I noticed.  I hope others have noticed.  And I believe that all Long Islanders should appreciate that this despicable practice is over, and that this should instill confidence in the quality and integrity of judicial candidates of both parties on Long Island.

Update:  I wrote too soon.  Within hours of posting this, suddenly appeared signs on telephone poles for Robin Kent, Democractic candidate for a Nassau County Family Court judgeship.  A bunch of signs.  Unlawful signs.  If a candidate for the judiciary breaks the law to get elected, they have a problem.  Robin Kent’s signs are unlawful, and people who do unlawful things should not be judges.

Charles Etchison Hasn’t Got a Chance

The police passed out fliers to neighbors.  Sent emails.  Held a meeting in a Roseville City gymnasium for residents to express their anger and outrage.  Charles Etchison had moved in.

Etchison had a horrible criminal history, ranging from a murder with a meat cleaver when he was 17, to sexually assaulting a minor, to forcing three young women to “orally copulate him,” according to the Roseville Press Tribune.  But the day came i 2006 that he walked out of prison.  He married.  He moved to Roseville.  Then all hell broke loose.



On Wednesday, residents expressed outrage that Etchison could be allowed to live so close to local schools and parks.


“It’s soccer season – our parks are in maximum use,” said resident John Vertido, a Roseville parks commissioner who urged police to step up their outreach at local parks.


Blair explained Etchison, who is not on parole, faces no restrictions on residency or movement.


That prompted resident Ken Waterhouse to propose the city investigate adopting a citywide ordinance limiting where sex offenders could reside.


“We really have to watch out for someone with violent behavior on top of the sexual assault,” he said. “It’s his right not life here unfortunately but our right to restrict where he goes.”


The Roseville police were caught in a dilemma.  On the one hand, had they not engaged in such a massive information campaign to alert the good people of Roseville to the convicted killer and sexual predator in their midst, they would be held accountable should anything happen.  On the other hand, they created an atmosphere of mass hysteria.

Etchison says that he has found God, and is no longer a threat to anyone.

The people of Roseville really don’t care enough about Etchison’s welfare to find out whether that’s true.  It’s an awful tradeoff, ripe for a witch hunt should anyone be sexually molested or harmed in Roseville.  Guess whose door will be the first to feel the rap of a cop’s fist?

Recognizing the fact that the various “Megan’s Laws” that wrap around the country have created a permanent underclass of former convicts who will never find a place in society, even though they have “paid their dues,” it does little to comfort people who fail to see why they should trade the safety of their children for the “rights” of criminals.  Once a criminal, always a criminal.  Or more to the point, once a criminal, why take a chance.

Given the extensive police “informational” campaign against Etchison, he never stood a chance of living a law-abiding life in Roseville.  The residents of Roseville, Etchison excepted, are thankful that they know, though disappointed that there is nothing they can do to make Etchison go very far away.

But there’s no place for Etchison to go.  No community welcomes someone like Etchison into its midst.

Whether he has truly turned over a new leaf, escaped his demons, and will live out the remainder of his years as a law-abiding citizen remains to be seen.  Whether the good residents of Roseville have been needlessly whipped in a state of fear and paranoia, undermining their peaceful existence, remains to be seen.  But this situation offers no comfort to anyone. 

Etchison has joined the underclass of people who will never be allowed to escape their past.  And we have no place for them in the present.  And there is no solution to this part of the problem.

Britney Spears Hangs ’em Up

From Anne Skove at Court-o-Rama, I learned that Britney Spears was (1) arrested for driving without a California license, (2) went to trial, and (3) ended with a hung jury.  It was old news when Anne posted it, and it’s even older now.  That’s what I get for not keeping abreast of Britney Spears news.

But the story surrounding the Pop Tart’s trial is fascinating (in the John Stewart sort of way).  From the LA Times :


After three days of deliberations, a dozen citizens threw up their hands Tuesday and said they could not agree on whether the oft-troubled entertainer was guilty of driving without a license during a fender bender last year. Ten jurors wanted to acquit. Two voted for conviction.

Now the ten to two for acquittal is itself unusual, until one realizes why she was being prosecuted.  The problem wasn’t that she didn’t have a drivers license, but that she didn’t have a California drivers license.  She had one from Louisiana, where she claimed permanent residence, but the prosecution contended that she was really a California resident and, therefore, was required to have a license issued by California.

Now I have no particular concern for Britney Spears.  I’m not a follower, and much preferred her when she was a fresh-faced teenager in parochial school clothing.  My daughter was a fan back then.  I thought she aged poorly.  But the notion that a prosecutor pursued a case against Spears on this spurious basis is outrageous.  Beyond trivial.  And then, the case went to trial.


The city attorney’s office routinely prosecutes people for driving without a license — nearly 3,700 this year alone. In the overwhelming majority of cases, the defendant accepts a guilty plea to the misdemeanor or to a traffic infraction. In other cases, the charge is dropped when a defendant obtains a valid license. A trial is virtually unheard of.

The prosecutor said he knew of no other defendants to go before a jury. Spears’ attorney was more definitive.

“Nobody has ever gone to trial on it. Never,” Flanagan said.

And that’s the case even when people drive with no license at all, not merely an arguably valid license issued by another state.

So chalk up one for celebrity prosecutions, where they would never be treated differently than anyone else.  Of course, Brit, woman of integrity, refused to plead out the case because it would be wrong.


The prosecutor tried to settle the case in exchange for a guilty plea. Initially, he offered her 12 months probation and a $150 fine and when her attorney objected to the probation, he said she could avoid probation by paying the maximum fine — $1,000.

Spears’ attorney rejected that, saying that his client did not want “to buy her way out of probation.”

The upshot was a five-day trial.

The good news, of course, was that Spears could afford to take a hard stance.


“It was multiple thousands of dollars that was wasted in this case,” Flanagan said, adding that his own bill to Spears “is probably a world record” for a driving without a license case.

Or, in legal parlance, Spears is what we call “a good client.”  But the most curious aspect of the trial was that there was no defendant in the room.  Now, I can’t speak for California, but in New York, judges have this crazy expectation that misdemeanor defendants appear in court for trial.  It’s not really an optional thing.  Unless, apparently, you’re Britney Spears.


Spears, 26, did not set foot in Superior Court in Van Nuys during the trial. In court papers, her attorney wrote that the singer was “unable to participate meaningfully in this matter.” Her father, Jamie, who has controlled her estate, finances and healthcare since shortly after her January hospitalization in a psychiatric ward, testified on her behalf, but he refused a request from her own lawyer that she take the stand.

“Britney doesn’t like court,” the lawyer, Michael Flanagan, shrugged.

Even without his client on the stand, Flanagan did his job well.  But it has to be interesting to represent Britney Spears.  No matter what anyone says, celebrities are treated differently.

When to Say No to an Interview

Some years ago, someone asked me how much I was paid to do legal commentary on television.  I wasn’t.  They sent a nice black car to pick me up and take me back.  They let me eat whatever I wanted in the “green room,” the name for the place where they make you sit and wait until it’s your turn for 30 seconds of air time even though I’ve never seen one that was actually green. 

Sometimes, I got a t-shirt or coffee mug out of it. Once, I even got a “fair and balanced” tie.  But I was never paid a dime.

Wondering why this was so, I asked a TV reporter friend, who explained to me that lawyers were always available to do commentary for free, so why pay them?  Why buy the cow when you can get the milk for free.  But I challenged, asking why they also kept a coterie of “legal correspondents” on hand who were, unlike me, paid to show up.

These people were different, he explained.  They were the ones who were sufficiently photogenic and available, willing to be there for the 5:00 a.m. spots and to be part of the team.  They weren’t really lawyers, but part of the show.  We had discussed these “lawyers” many times in the past, primarily because I would tell him how wrong they were on a particular subject, to which he invariably responded, “but they looked pretty, didn’t they?”

The truth is that lawyers love to be interviewed.  Often, too much.  Given half a chance, most lawyers will drop everything to get their puss on the TV.  Marketing is usually cited as the reason, though personal ego plays a larger role.  You gain a certain degree of prominence by being on TV, and are often expected to trade your dignity and integrity for the chance.

I’ve been a frequent critic of lawyers opining on topics about which they know very little, sometimes nothing.  I call them media sluts, willing to sell themselves just to be on the air.  They don’t illuminate, but mislead.  They are proffered as experts to the public, but it’s a lie.  And even when the opine on subject they know a great deal about, the media doesn’t let itself to clear or nuanced discussion.  It’s usually the host asking a 2 minute, multipart, presumptive question, and the “expert” left to nod his head like a fool.  The program is geared toward making the host look like a genius.  If you tell the host he’s not, they don’t like you very much.  You may not get a mug.

All of this comes up in the course of a request I received for an interview the other day, from a very nice freelance reporter who was writing an article for a magazine.  As a blawger, I get frequent requests for interviews.  The reporter was writing about a fairly technical legal issue, and the article was particularly appropriate and important to the target audience of the magazine.  But she was on deadline, and needed answers NOW.  So rather than suggest that we chat on the phone, she sent questions in an email for me to answer.

The combination of complex legal issue, deadline, email and the nature of the questions troubled me.  It would have been easy enough to respond, but there was a nagging feeling about the way it all came together.  After some reflection, I realized that the questions reflected the writer’s position at the bottom of the learning curve, unprepared as yet to appreciate what I would have written in response to her questions, the many variables and the scope of application.

As a blawger, I have come to appreciate the limits of the written word as a communication tool, and the unbearably broad scope of understanding of those reading what I write.  Misunderstandings occur constantly, and I usually attribute them to my own lack of clarity.  But the truth is, you can’t write for everyone.  Some will get it, others will not. 

I’m resigned to this fate on my blawg, but I’m not prepared to go out in the real world and have my words misunderstood.  If I can’t help to illuminate, then I accomplish nothing.  My lawyer marketing friends will excoriate me for passing up an opportunity, something they preach a lawyer should never do.  With all due respect, I demur.  I don’t want to read words after my name that don’t reflect what I think or know because another writer, or television host, doesn’t get it.  I passed on the interview, and hope that the writer will get the story right.

Some years ago, on a television program that no longer exists, I was asked do legal commentary on a federal decision of interest to me.  I agreed.  The prep questions were fine, and lent themselves to my responses.  But on air, the first question out of the hostess’ mouth was, “Can you get into the judge’s head and tell us what she was thinking?”  I responded, “No, I don’t have that ability, but I can tell you what she wrote on paper.”  The hostess was not amused.

In New York, at least, no one remembers the lawyer who plays the talking head.  There are just too many to matter, and we come and go so quickly that it’s as if it never happened.  If you feel that you can contribute, then it’s part of our obligation to inform the public.  But if you get that nagging feeling that you will do nothing more than fill airtime, or bring nothing thoughtful to the discussion, maybe it’s a good time to take a pass.  Worse still, if you feel that you will be part of comedy routine that serves to push an agenda and mislead the public, run away. 

These are the times to say no to an interview.  Don’t feel badly for the media.  They’ll find another lawyer easily enough who will be more than happy to be a free media slut.  It doesn’t have to be you.

Another Judge Rips Scalia’s Heller Opinion

First it was 7th Circuit Judge Richard Posner, whose New Republic article challenged the legitimacy of the majority decision in D.C. v. Heller.  Now, Adam Liptak in the New York Times brings us another judge on the warpath against this wild-eyed activist, Antonin Scalia.  Now, it’s J. Harvie Wilkinson III of the 4th Circuit, who has written an article to be published in the Virginia Law Review.

Two prominent federal appeals court judges say that Justice Antonin Scalia’s majority opinion in the case, District of Columbia v. Heller, is illegitimate, activist, poorly reasoned and fueled by politics rather than principle. (Emphasis added.)

Ouch.  Those are harsh words. But the real “dis” isn’t Liptak’s descriptive characterization, but rather the comparison made by Judge Wilkinson.  Heller is the new Roe v. Wade.

Judge Wilkinson’s basic critique is that the majority, like that in Roe, used an ambiguous text to impose its policy preference on the nation, at great cost to the democratic process and to local values. He assumed, as most experts do, that the decision would apply to the states.

“In both Roe and Heller,” Judge Wilkinson wrote, “the court claimed to find in the Constitution the authority to overrule the wishes of the people’s representatives. In both cases, the constitutional text did not clearly mandate the result, and the court had discretion to decide the case either way.”

There is no worse slap in the face, whether in conservative or judicial circles, then comparing a decision’s reasoning to Roe v. Wade.  Why not just ridicule his mother at the same time?  It’s that bad.

Indeed, Judge Wilkinson wrote, “Some observers may be tempted to view Heller as a revenge of sorts for Roe” or “a sort of judicial tit-for-tat.” As Judge Posner put it, “The idea behind the decision” in Heller “may simply be that turnabout is fair play.”

Another punch to the gut, conservative revenge.  But Judge Wilkinson, according to Liptak, raised some substantive aspects of the Heller decision that some of us in the blawgosphere, most notably Doug Berman, have been harping on since the decision came out. 

Judge Wilkinson saved particular scorn for a brief passage in Justice Scalia’s opinion that seemed to endorse a variety of restrictions on gun ownership. “Nothing in our opinion,” Justice Scalia wrote, “should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms.”

Whatever else may be said about the Second Amendment, Judge Wilkinson wrote, those presumptions have no basis in the Constitution. “The Constitution’s text,” he wrote, “has as little to say about restrictions on firearm ownership by felons as it does about the trimesters of pregnancy.”

He’s got a very good point.  If you’re going to present your philosophy as having some basis in intellectual integrity, then you would do well to practice what you preach.  And Scalia’s throw-away paragraph, sweeping aside all the hard questions with the holding, may ultimately prove to be one of the most disgraceful exercises of baseless judicial activism since, well, Roe v. Wade.