Author Archives: SHG

Nassau County’s DWI “Wall of Shame” Confusion

Tom Suozzi, Nassau County’s Executive, must have thought this was a great idea, given the outcry that invariably followed the car crashes and deaths involving a drunk driver.  People complained that “something must be done.”  So what he did was create the “Wall of Shame.”  It was a wall with the photograph and identity of each person arrested for drunk driving.  Not convicted, but arrested.  Note the name.  It’s purpose is to shame those accused of DWI.

You would think that Tom would have somebody whispering in his ear that putting up photos of people not yet convicted had its issues, but the word around Nassau County is that Tom does not care to hear from people who disagree with him.  If Tom thinks it’s a good idea, then it’s a good idea.

Alexandra Bursac, however, didn’t think it was a good idea.  Neither did her lawyer, Brian Griffin.  Together, they decided to do something about it.  Bursac was arrested for DWI, with the officer claiming she was .01 over the line.  She disagreed, and pleaded not guilty.  But there she was, picture and all, on the Wall of Shame.

Interestingly, the Wall of Shame wasn’t a mere physical wall, but a virtual wall.  It was put on the internet for all to see.  Worse still, once on the internet, it was there in virtual perpetuity, shaming Bursac for her arrest forever and ever, even if she prevailed against the charges. 

Adding irony to the mix, Newsday, which was editorially critical of the Wall to shame people who were “innocent until proven guilty” was the primary source of the Wall of Shame’s exposure.  Not only did Newsday put the Wall on its website, but it had links to the Wall of Shame all over the place.  And refused to take it down, despite the criticism of shaming the innocent.

Yesterday, Supreme Court Justice William LaMarca agreed with Bursac.


[P]osting Alexandra Bursac’s photo punishes her in a way not authorized by the law. And because of the permanence of the Internet, it imposes an inappropriate penalty by exposing her to “limitless and eternal notoriety.”

Now comes the interesting part.  The County’s knee-jerk reaction to the decision was exactly what one would expect.


County Attorney Lorna Goodman said her office will not remove Bursac’s name and photo, or anyone else’s, from the “Wall of Shame.” She said the county will appeal the decision, which will automatically put the judge’s order to remove the name and photo on hold.

“We are disappointed at the decision of the judge,” Goodman said. “The decision appears to be based on a novel theory that publication on the Internet is different from traditional publication, a theory for which he cites no support. The decision ignores the reality of the digital age.”

We know this because this was reported in a mid-day article (this is a cached link) by Newsday yesterday.  By this morning, the same Newsday article, with the same link, told a very different story.


County Executive Thomas Suozzi insisted that the Wall of Shame has deterred people from driving drunk, and he vowed to appeal State Supreme Court Justice William LaMarca’s decision. But in the meantime, he said he feels it is wise to remove the names to protect the county from a torrent of lawsuits.

“The decision [to post people’s names before they were convicted] was made based upon the information we had at the time,” he said. “But we think this is a prudent course of action.”

Prudent indeed.

Notwithstanding Suozzi’s decision to take down the Wall of Shame, Newsday wasn’t to be cowed, whether by reason or the order of a judge.


Newsday.com has been posting the names and photos from the Wall of Shame since the county began releasing them after Memorial Day weekend. “Our plan is to continue to mirror the county’s presentation of what officials label the ‘Wall of Shame,’ said Newsday Editor John Mancini. “As we have in the past, we will post photos of people charged with a crime that are provided to us by authorities on Newsday.com.”

Freedom of the press is a fine thing, an important thing, to the perpetuation of democracy.  But there is nothing in the First Amendment that forbids the use of wisdom.  Shaming the innocent is bad when Nassau County does it.  It’s bad when Newsday does it.   Tom Suozzi has wised up.  Maybe Newsday should give it a second thought as well.

Talking to Death

Humberto Pepin-Tavares, 44, thought he had a good idea.  Known as Pepin on the street, he was a drug dealer in the Bronx, and caught a 12 year federal sentence for his efforts.  But Pepin had a plan. 

He heard about how people talked their way out of prison.  He heard all the stories on the street about how guys with long sentences would tell the feds about other crimes and be given a pat on the back and a free pass out of prison.  Pepin was no fool.  If others could do it, so could he. 

According to Newsday, shortly after his drug conviction in March, 2002, Pepin made the decision to tell investigator about some crimes.  Serious crimes. Murders.  Surely, this would be of interest to them.  But Pepin’s plan had one flaw.  You see, the murders Pepin had to offer were murders that he committed.

He talked about killing Jose Rosario in 1992 and Carlos Madrid in 1995.  Then he talked about dismembering their bodies to hide the murders.  And once he started talking about the murders, Pepin just couldn’t stop.


“Nothing short of a piece of duct tape across his lips could have kept [him] from confessing over and over again,” said Judge Jack Weinstein in a decision filed earlier in the case.

Pepin was, as one might suppose, charged with the murders.  He offered to plead guilty in exchange for life in prison, but Attorney General Michael Mukasey refused.  Pepin was tried for capital murder in the Eastern District of New York. 

At trial, his attorneys, Lou Freedman and David Lewis, did their best.  Pepin contended that he wasn’t a cold-blooded murderer, but someone trying to defend himself from other cold-blooded murderers.  He was just better at it than they were.


In his defense, Pepin argued that the killings were done in self-defense. Defense witnesses provided evidence that both victims had wanted to kill Pepin.

The jury didn’t bite.  It’s not that unusual that drug dealers want to kill each other, so the victims’ feelings toward Pepin were likely similar to Pepin’s feelings toward the victims.  Pepin was convicted.  Now it’s going to the penalty phase.

I spoke with David Lewis about Pepin yesterday.  Only half-joking, David told me that if I wanted to know all about the killings, I should just ask Pepin.  He’d tell me.  He’ll tell anyone.  He would love to tell the story.  Again and again.  Judge Weinstein’s “duct tape” crack was probably an understatement.  He’d just keep talking under the duct tape.

It may be that Pepin’s openness about the murders, his willingness to talk about them freely to anyone who asks, will work in his favor during the penalty phase.  It may raise implicit questions about his sanity, or perhaps his intelligence, that will sway a jury to think that he shouldn’t be put to death.  The dismemberment part brings a certain “color” to the killings, but Judge Weinstein plans to tell the jurors not to consider it when deciding on penalty.  As if that’s the sort of thing one can easily ignore.

While twelve years in federal prison (not Club Fed, mind you, as that’s not where the Pepin’s of the world tend to be sent) is no fun, but for guys like Pepin, it shouldn’t have come as a great surprise.  They know there’s a risk for doing what they do, and they know that if they stick around long enough, there’s a strong likelihood that they will get caught.

But if ever a person talked himself into the death chamber, it was Pepin.  Not a good plan.

When Did You Stop Bribing Judges? Take 2

Thanks to J-dog, I now have (hopefully) more robust polling software so that we can proceed with the poll started here yesterday which, in short order, failed miserably.  So, let’s try again to find out whether any lawyer has ever been involved in the bribery of a judge. 

Bear in mind, my premise is that while it may happen somewhere (notably in Chicago per Windy), at no time in my 25 years of practice has any member of the judiciary so much as hinted at the interest in a bribe.  But that’s just my experience, and thus the question of whether others have had an experience different than mine.

As before, this poll is for lawyers, not cynical non-lawyers who want to prove that the system is corrupt by skewing the results.  So lawyers, please let me know whether this has ever happened to you.  And bear in mind, this is totally anonymous, so there’s no reason to fear telling the truth.

Have You Ever Bribed a Judge?
Why yes, I have
It’s been “suggested”, but I didn’t do it
It was overtly sought, but I declined
Never
  
pollcode.com free polls

Win the Appeal Battle But Lose the Sentence War

With appreciation to Doug Berman for his relentless coverage of Second Circuit criminal decisions, comes the decision in US v. Ogando (October 20, 2008).  The defendant’s conviction was reversed “for insufficient evidence a set of jury trial convictions for a livery cab driver hired to pick up a drug courier at the airport.”  “Hooray, a reversal?”  Not quite.

The problem isn’t that the Circuit reversed the conviction, which is certainly a good thing given that they held the evidence insufficient.  The problem, as Doug points out, is this:


Ogando was convicted on all four counts.  The Pre-Sentence Report calculated a Guidelines range of 63 to 78 months’ imprisonment.  The court granted the defense’s motion for a downward departure based on aberrant behavior, U.S.S.G. § 5K2.20, and sentenced Ogando principally to 30 months’  imprisonment.  Ogando has completed serving his prison sentence.

The last sentence says it all.  It’s a great win for everybody but Ogando, who already served his 30 months.  No, he doesn’t get the time back.

Why it took so long for the convictions to be reversed on appeal isn’t clear.  What is clear is that an innocent man served his sentence before he received the benefit of review.  Based upon the downward departure, it appears clear that he presented no threat to society had he been allowed to remain free on bond pending review, and based upon the Circuit’s decision, it appears that the evidence against him could not have been overwhelming.  Yet, to jail he went while the appellate process decided his fate.

The basis for bail pending appeal is not whether the defendant poses a threat to others, but (again courtesy of Doug)


as codified in the Bail Reform Act of 1984, defendants who wish to remain out on bail after conviction must prove (among other things) that their appeal will have enough merit such that it will raise at least one “substantial question.”

While there is a debate as to what constitutes a “substantial question” as opposed to a really debatable question, the hurdle is very high indeed.  If you think about it, it requires the trial judge to conclude that he came to the very edge of the precipice of error, by other causing or not stopping something that raises a such a significant potential for reversal on appeal.  If the judge believed that to be the case, then why would he have done it in the first place?

Defense lawyers have long argued in case that involve relatively short prison terms that when there is a real issue for appeal, the defendant should remain at liberty lest they complete the sentence before the case is decided, as happened here.  It’s a good argument.  It generally loses. 

But if you’re a judge, does a reversal like this make you feel that you’ve done your job well?  If so, I’m sure Ogando would really appreciate it if you could explain why.

The 1st Amendment Ends at a Cop’s Eyeballs

Constitutional interpretation is left to the courts, or so we’re taught in law school.  But then, cops don’t go to law school, rendering our finely honed analysis subject to the sensibilities of any given cop on any given day.  One particular cop in Searcy, Arkansas, made this point particularly clear.

From Eugene Volokh,


Just before noon Friday, Barnett was standing at the northwest corner of Beebe-Capps Expressway and South Main, near a former feed store containing numerous Reeves signs, holding a sign. The sign’s four lines said, “Debate Brian! Chicken s***; 1. Kyle Reeves; 2. Monte Betts.”

“You can probably get away with saying he’s chicken, but since he’s an alderman and a member of the city council, you can’t,” Johnson told Barnett. “That word is not acceptable.”

When Sergeant Tom McGee arrived, the three went next door to a tire shop and Barnett could be heard offering to change the sign. Within minutes, however, Barnett was arrested, charged with disorderly conduct, apparently for refusing to obey an officer.

“I asked him on four occasions to remove those letters from that sign,” McGee said. “He did remove the ‘i’ but I asked him to remove the entire word.”

Of course, the irony is that this is precisely the sort of speech that the 1st Amendment is meant to protect.  And precisely why it needs to be protected, since those who wander the streets with guns and shields are likely inclined to believe that those in public office are particularly deserving of their protection. 

A few minutes after his arrest, the police changed their mind, gave Barnett a citation and let him go.  But the harm was done, and he must still answer the citation.  The official police response to questions from the Daily Citizen reporter was that:


“He didn’t comply enough,” said Terri Lee, police spokesman. “The ‘i’ was crossed out with a mark that looked like an “I.” It wasn’t enough. They [the officers] could still read it and they wanted it where it wasn’t offensive to anyone.”

After all, isn’t speech all about what offends the guys with guns?  A common theme amongst our friends with a law & order bent is that people could avoid these silly problems if they just did what they were told by the cops.  It’s all so simple from that perspective.  If the cop says “jump”, you ask “how high?”  Easy.

But with young men and women fighting and dying for freedom in foreign lands, it would be disrespectful to ignore the exercise of those very rights for which they are at risk.  It’s shocking that police officers think so little of Americans in harm’s way.

One might think that law enforcement officers are trained, at least to some limited degree, in the scope of their authority to control the expression of thought.  One might forgive an error on some highly nuanced aspect, particularly where it implicates legitimate law enforcement concerns such as public safety.  But finding a vulgar word offensive, particularly when used in reference to an elected official, isn’t even in the ballpark of valid exercise of the police power.

And then there’s the perpetual police rationalization.  It’s not just that the citizen was doing something that upset the officers sensitive feelings, but that he didn’t comply the way the cop wanted.  It’s “the same situation,”


Like the church
Like a cop
Like a mother
You want me to be truthful
Sometimes you turn it on me like a weapon though
And I need your approval



 

Redux: Following Up on Drew, Davis and Jesse James Hollywood

Sure, I post about plenty of stuff when it’s in my face, but what comes of it later? 

Lori Drew, the MySpace Suicide Prosecution

When last we checked in on this case, one of the most significant cases confronting online criminal liability, U.S. District Court Judge George Wu raised three very interesting issues to be briefed by the parties relating to how the case founds its way into his courtroom.  In light of the issues raised by defense motions to dismiss and the government’s response, this turn of events was quite significant. 

The latest news brings no substantive change in the case, but rather a new player into the mix.  Orin Kerr, lawprof blawger extraordinaire from the venerable Volokh Conspiracy, has joint H. Dean Steward on the Lori Drew defense team.  Pro bono, no less.


In the last two weeks, I have gone an important step further: I have formally joined Dean Steward, counsel for Lori Drew, as Drew’s co-counsel. My participation is pro bono, based on my strong sense that the government’s theory of the case poses a very real threat to civil liberties online.

While Dean Steward is hardly a slouch, Orin brings a level of scholarly depth to the defense that this case demands.  Given how dangerous a precedent this prosecution sets, and the strong potential that Judge Wu might reject the government’s theory, I hope that the combo of Steward and Kerr will prove to be unstoppable.

Yes, I know that there is a significant group who hates Lori Drew for what she did to Megan Meier, and demands that she be punished, and couldn’t care less about the theory of prosecution.  We all understand this, but this isn’t about loving Lori Drew, but preventing a terrible theory of prosecution that will haunt us long after the Lori Drew case is forgotten.

Troy Davis must be executed because . . . of the poignant story of Officer MacPhail?

As noted, the Supreme Court of the United States has denied cert in the Troy Davis case, where 7 of 9 eyewitnesses recanted their trial testimony.  The stay was lifted and the execution will proceed.

Bad enough?  No, not by a long shot.  Former Utah federal judge Paul Cassell, now lawprof and blawger at VC, isn’t satisfied that Troy Davis will die.  Inexplicably, he now finds it necessary to rub salt in the wound by his snide attack on the notion that the decision on this case, having filtered through the system could possibly be wrong.


There has been much ado in the media lately about another “innocent” person about to be executed. Unfortunately, most of the media coverage about the impending execution of cop-killer Troy Davis has spent precious little time discussing the facts of the case. This link contains a fairly complete rebuttal of the claims made by Davis’ advocates, who seem to have little interest in getting at the truth of the case. Even more poignant is this link, which has information about the victim in this case — Officer Mark Allen MacPhail.

The rebuttal is pathetically weak, long on rhetoric and speculation, and substantively vapid.  But falling back on the “poignant” story of Officer Mark Allen MacPhail reflects a disgraceful appeal to irrelevant emotion.  Officer MacPhail was the victim of a killer, but sympathy for Officer MacPhail bears no connection whatsoever to who killed him. 

One wants to, has to, assume that Paul Cassell, a lawprof, a former federal judge, knows this.  Any lawyer would know this.  It’s basic.  Gideon ripped Judge Cassell to shreds for this post.  The comments to the post ripped him to shreds.  All of this begs one question for Eugene Volokh.  Why does Paul Cassell post on VC?  His posts lack the quality and depth one expects from VC.  I realize he is a former federal judge of some note, but now that we see him without his robe, he’s just not up to snuff.

SCOTUS says the “Alpha Dog” prosecutor gets to go “Hollywood”. 

It could not have been easy, born with a name like Jesse James Hollywood.  But if truth is stranger than fiction, then the story of JJH was as strange as they come.  The prosecutor, Ronald Zonen, looking for JJH for the 2000 kidnapping and murder of a 15 year old, decided to turn over his files on the case to Nick Cassavetes, a director and screenwriter, which resulted in the movie “Alpha Dogs,” a box-office mutt.

As a result of Zonen’s involvement in the production, he was recused from prosecuting the case, but later reinstated by the California Supreme Court, which held that Zonen engaged in conduct that was “highly inappropriate and disturbing” but did not rise to the level requiring his recusal for having denied defendant a fair trial.

The defense then petitioned for certiorari to the United States Supreme Court, which yesterday denied the petition, putting an end to this mess.

While no one doubted that Zonen’s conduct, turning over the prosecution file to a movie maker, was wrong, I was never clear how one could connect this dubious act to direct prejudice to the defendant on the part of the particular prosecutor.  But I can assume that Ronald Zonen must be an awfully effective prosecutor, since the defense fought so hard to get him tossed and the prosecution fought so hard to keep him on the case. 

Who’s the Alpha Dog now?

Who Is Stone and Why Won’t He Leave Me Alone?

One day, I started receiving emails to something called the “StoneZone”.  I didn’t subscribe to it, and I didn’t want it.  But still, it came.  My assumption is that this was another of those websites that signs up blawgers on its own to spread it’s name in the hope that someone will care.  I didn’t.

The other day, there was a blawgversation about receiving press releases started by Kevin O’Keefe, which most blawgers could do without.  While not exactly a PR, this is pretty much the equivalent.  So after deleting the first few StoneZone emails, and still they kept coming, I decided to “unsubscribe”. 

After clicking the unsubscribe button at the bottom of the email, it took me to the website, where I was informed that my “request” to unsubscribe had been submitted, but that there was a final step to the process. I would be receiving an email to “verify” my unsubscribe request.  This was a new one on me.

Now intrigued by who, having “subscribed me” against my will, demanded that I perform like a trained seal to stop receiving their self-promotional emails.  You gotta admit, that’s chutzpah.

But chutzpah barely captures this one.  Stone turns out to be someone named Roger Stone, a neocon psychopath.  So enraptured he is with himself, that he has dedicated a page to publications that mention him as being someone so disreputable, such an unmitigated disgrace, that he embodies all that the public despises about politics.  Well, not everyone in “the public,” I guess, since there are some who likely believe he’s the necessary hammer in the war against thinking people.

I admit to reading one of Stone’s posts today.  It was a surreal experience, with no connection between the garbage he spews and any semblance of legitimate thought.  Clearly, he’s got his finger on the pulse of people who have none.  It’s a flagrant play to ignorance, prejudice and anger, seeking nothing more than to contort those inclined to only visceral reactions into paroxysms of hostility.  It would be goofy, but for the potential that someone, somewhere, will heed his intellectual vomit.

Do you get the idea that I don’t care for this fellow’s thoughts?  You are correct.

So StoneZoners, whoever you may be, please stop sending me your promotional emails.  Though by mentioning you here (though note that I’ve not included a link to your main website because you don’t deserve a single eyeball on my account), you will likely be thrilled.  You seem to thrive on being despised.  The more controversy you stir up, the more you exist. 

But you don’t stir up controversy, because you offer nothing legitimate.  You are just a refuge for the ignorant, those who wonder why society’s problems can’t be solved by hating others. 

Now, just leave me out of your warped world, and stop sending me emails.  I will never mention you again.

When Did You Stop Bribing Judges? (Survey Failure)

While I suggested in an earlier post the judicial corruption was largely a myth, it occurs to me that perhaps I’m wrong about this.  In my 25 years, no judge has ever asked for, or even hinted at, a bribe.  But that’s just my experience.  If you’re a lawyer (non-lawyers, please don’t vote and skew the results), please take the poll and let us know about your experience.

Apparently, my free, state-of-the-art, guaranteed to work great poll just up and failed.  If somebody can help me out with a polling program that works, I would very much appreciate it.  Apologies to those who voted for naught.

Not Just Another Dumb Naked Kid

When the story of the 15 year old girl from Licking Valley High spread around the blawgosphere, it seemed like just another goofy story that we share for its shock value.  I first saw it when Turley posted about it, where he commented:



This seems a lot like charging an attempted suicide as an attempted murder.


She may have to register as a sex offender, though it is unclear whether (as both the victim and the culprit) she would get victim notification reports about herself.


Other than to point out its absurdity, it was no more than a curiosity.  But the full story from the Newark (Ohio)Advocate via Don’t Tase Me, Bro!, leads me to be more concerned.  Not so much for the monumentally stupid and infantile act of a young girl publishing a nude photograph of herself to other youths, which is a matter for parents and a competent therapist to address over a lengthy period of time, but for the reaction of this Ohio legislator:


State Rep. Jay Hottinger, R-Newark, wrote the state’s Megan’s Law bill, the predecessor of the Adam Walsh Act, and said this case was not something the legislature envisioned.

“Clearly it was in an illegal act,” he said Tuesday. “Clearly it was an unacceptable act, and there needs to be consequences from that, but we need to make sure the punishment is a reasonable punishment.”

One the one hand, Hottinger says this was not the conduct the legislature had in mind when it enacted the law, yet on the other hand he states that it was clearly “an illegal act” that requires punishment.  Oh no you do-on’t. 

Raising two independent problems, and two problems that create a synergistic third, this can’t be ignored.  First, the failure of legislation to be sufficiently clear as to encompass only those acts that the legislature specifically intends to make illegal reflects a failure of the law, not those caught in the net of unintended consequences.  The point is that there should be no “accidental crimes.”

Secondly, Hottinger’s knee-jerk reaction is that this conduct is “clearly . . . an illegal act.”  And why would it be illegal, no less clearly illegal, if it was never envisioned as a wrong by the Legislature?  Because it fits within the words?  Then the words are bad, not the act.  Because it just feels wrong?  Maybe some remedial legislating courses should be offered in Ohio.  When you’re charged with crafting legislation and face a situation that is encompassed in the language of a law that was never intended, it’s something to fix, not use for mindless political capital.

I would like to think that this situation is an anomaly, but having teenage children of my own, and they’re having teenage friends of their own, I know differently.  There is a swelling desire for fame on Youtube these days, where a video can bring overnight recognition and make someone “important” a la Paris Hilton (without the trust fund).  Nude photos, videos of a sexually explicit nature, are unfortunately not a surprise.  Some of the dumb things that show up on Youtube will make you seriously wonder just how stupid children can be.

This is not a criminal problem, and to the extent it’s subsumed in a poorly drafted law named after one child or another, doesn’t become a criminal problem.  This is a self-esteem problem that has grown from the constant barrage of overnight celebrity for nothing more than being more foolish than the next kid.

Why, then, does Hottinger assume that it must be criminal, it must be subject to punishment?  The trend to seek answers to all problems through the criminal law is monumentally dangerous, particularly when it involves children.  The product is that the forces that are pushing kids to engage in this destructive behavior will not be effectively addressed, both on their end as well as society’s, while creating a new class of unintended criminal out of our own children.

When this story filtered up to Orin Kerr at Volokh (it took a while), I would have expected some biting libertarian commentary. There was none.   Are we that inured to the misuse of criminal law to cover unintentional conduct, aberrant behaviors or anything where the word “nude” and “child” is used?  Have we lost all concern for the underlying purpose of criminal law?  Have we lost all concern for our children?

Sure, this was a bizarre story when it first appeared, but the problems it raises are “clearly” worthy of greater thought than the coverage has suggested.

Malthus Goes to Law School

I have long been of the view that the United States produces far too many lawyers for society to absorb.  Law, being the profession of last resort, takes in the strays that couldn’t hack organic chemistry, or can’t bear the sight of blood.  Law schools, which exist to support the scholarly endeavors of its professorate, needs as many warm bodies with cash as they can squeeze though the door to support its addiction.

The bottom line is miserable Biglaw associates, frivolous lawsuits brought by lawyers whose hands would otherwise be idle, a cause of action for every wrong, no matter who was at fault, and a society with no respect for the law or its practitioners.  Familiarity breeds contempt, and we all know a lawyer.

Since we, the stewards of the legal profession, have neglected to take responsibility for thinning the herd to manageable levels, enough that there is “food” for everyone, nature will do it for us.  Enter my old buddy,  Thomas Robert Malthus. 

According to David Bernstein at Volokh, who cites to Al Brophy at The Faculty Lounge, the current economic situation is having its impact on law schools, resulting in a hiring freeze at William & Mary, with more to come:


I’m expecting freezes on hiring at many universities. I asked a friend at a major law school a few weeks back what he thought the effect of the economy would be on law school hiring. … First, fewer people are going to be retiring; second, schools will be reluctant to fill vacancies. A handful of elite schools will be insulated from the downturn, I suppose. For all the rest of us, get ready for some more belt-tightening…. Maybe the real crunch will be felt next year; that’s hard to know.

Bernstein wonders whether this means that newer (or lesser?) lawprofs should start considering their options.  Polish up that resume, guys.

The implication is that this is a bad thing for legal scholarship, and indeed it is likely to mean that the next class of lawprofs is going to be much thinner and more competitive.  But this is the tacit product of the next class of law students, likely to be smaller and far more select. 

Not necessarily select from the law schools’ point of view, as my bet is that they will take anybody able to pay the freight since student loans may be impossible to find (or afford), but select from the students’ perspective.  Erstwhile law students will think long and hard before saddling themselves with the cost of three years of quasi-education to gain entrée to a declining market for legal talent.

As Malthus, whose harsh theory of population decline applies to so many other things, recognized, nature will not be kind when forced to do the job that we have neglected.  It will cut with a large, blunt blade, keeping the less privileged out of the law while the aristocracy with cash to spend will find law a safe haven.  Law schools could avert this problem, but will they put their supposed purpose ahead of their need to fund their beloved scholarship? 

Jonathon Swift, who thought less highly of Malthus than I do, satirically suggested the solution of eating the babies of the poor to feed Malthus’ wealthy hungry masses.  Who will the law schools eat to work their way out of this situation? 

This might be a good time to help your kid study for organic chemistry.

Perhaps our law school deans will spend less time agonizing over the U.S. News & World Reports rankings and more time considering the monster of too many lawyers they’ve created.  If they do, they will enjoy the deeply-felt appreciation of a grateful nation.