Author Archives: SHG

With Barely a Whimper, the FBI Now Spies on Americans

In the beginning of October, Attorney General Michael Mukasey approved new guidelines for the FBI to investigate.  Normally, we would expect there to be something on the end of the previous sentence, as in “to investigate . . . what?”  But that’s the problem with these new guidelines.  The simple answer is anything they please.

The new guidelines were the subject of a New York Times article that explained them like this:

Attorney General Michael B. Mukasey approved the new guidelines after a review of several months that sought to consolidate different and sometimes conflicting standards within the F.B.I. that govern when agents can use informants, do undercover surveillance, interview witnesses or use other investigative techniques.

The new guidelines, reflecting the evolution of the F.B.I. in the seven years since the Sept. 11 attacks, state that “the F.B.I. is an intelligence agency as well as a law enforcement agency.” They are also one of the final steps by the Bush administration to extend its far-reaching counterterrorism policies into the next administration and beyond.

As I read this article, it meant little.  It didn’t tell me what difference these new guidelines made, what it authorized agents to do, how it would/could be used.  I waited for more, but there wasn’t any more to be had.

Today, the Times has an editorial about these guidelines, which provides more information than the previous article. 


Under the new rules, agents may engage in lengthy physical surveillance, covertly infiltrate lawful groups, or conduct pretext interviews in which agents lie about their identities while questioning a subject’s neighbors, friends or work colleagues based merely on a generalized “threat.” The new rules also allow the bureau to use these techniques on people identified in part by their race or religion and without requiring even minimal evidence of criminal activity.

After a bit, it dawned on me why this had was so insidious; its lack of a smoking gun aspect that causes people to rise to their feet and scream out their outrage.  These new rules convert the FBI into the domestic CIA, a government arm designed to conduct essentially limitless spying on Americans, without cause or reason.  Talk about smooth. 

This rule eviscerates the basic constraints placed on the FBI, that it would never conduct generic spying on its own people.  The American people would never, but never, be the subject of our own government spies, who had free rein to investigate whatever and whoever they felt deserved investigation. 

Up to now, the criteria for initiating an investigation had been the belief that a crime had been committed.  The FBI investigated crimes.  While there were issues about the lengths to which such an investigation should go, the intrusion into the fabric of society in the course of such investigations, it had a minimum threshold for the involvement of our government against us, the commission of a crime.

Under these new rules, which the Times notes come in the waning hours of the Bush administration, our federal law enforcement apparatus has been disconnected from its original purpose and has now been given approval to go forth and spy.  On us.

The government’s reaction to criticism has been the usual, trust us.  We wouldn’t do anything wrong.  We wouldn’t listen to pillow talk between our soldiers and their wives, or overseas calls by reporters.  We won’t become the secret police of the United States. 


Mr. Mukasey has promised that investigations conducted under the new rules will be consistent with the Constitution. Clearly, the Bush administration cannot be trusted to find the right balance between law enforcement and civil liberties. Even before this administration the F.B.I. had its own long history of abusing its powers to spy on civil rights groups and antiwar activists.

The difference this time is that these changes have happened at a time when few of us were watching, when our attention was focused elsewhere.  They slid this one in the side door.  There’s was no hot case to connect it to, or particular bit of outrageous conduct to coalesce opposition.  This happened, and no one noticed, and it is now the officially approved operating methodology of the Federal Bureau of Investigation.

It’s unlikely that this will pose an immediate threat, given that FBI resources are stretched too thin trying to appease the lust for Wall Street criminals at the moment.  The saving grace of grandiose government law enforcement schemes is that they still aren’t particularly effective in accomplishing their goals.  This is one instance where law enforcement focus on political issues works to our advantage, since it keeps them away from most Americans while the focus on the handful of billion dollar bonus babies, whose only crime is negotiating deals that were really good for them.  In other times, we would call this “the American way.”

But the new rules are in place, and the next administration will have a decision to make on January 21st, whether to maintain a national internal spying agency or go back to the old way of doing things, where Americans need not fear their own government spying on them.

What do our Presidential candidates say about this?  Who will reverse this stealthily approved set of rules and return us to a nation where our government doesn’t spy on us?  Who will maintain an internal spying agency? 

Despite the lack of urgency about these new guidelines, this may be one of the most significant changes from the Bush administration that will rend the fabric of American society.  And almost no one knows or cares. 

Criminal Defense Advertising. What Works and What’s Right (Update)

As I was riding the train home after teaching an ethics CLE yesterday, I thought about a discussion a few days ago with one of our most respected legal marketers in the blawgosphere about the propriety of certain self-promotional techniques.  While I promised not to post about the specific individual about whom I questioned, the general concept remains fair game.

There seems to be relative universal agreement that the future of legal advertising is the internet.  The yellow pages, Martindale-Hubbell, all the old-school methods, are dead.  While the latter seems pretty clear, not that M-H was ever a viable source for criminal defense lawyers since few defendants have much call for checking Martindale-Hubbell, the former seems to work fairly well in some niches of criminal defense, such as DWI.  However, the nature of criminal defense demands a certain immediacy, and searching the internet doesn’t help much to find someone NOW.  I’ve discussed in the past how use of the internet can actually paralyze someone in their search for counsel.

But this hasn’t stopped criminal defense lawyers from creating websites for the purpose of marketing themselves.  The question remains, however, what can be said to distinguish one from another.

They all say that we fight hard for our clients.  I’ve yet to see anyone try to promote themselves by claiming, “we’ll take your money and plead you out at the first possible opportunity.”  They all say that we are experienced.  No one says, “I’ve never actually tried a felony, but I would really like to try.”  All in all, websites offer almost no basis for distinguishing competence from incompetence, rendering them a utterly meaningless and a total crapshoot for the legal consumer.  I have one.  I hate it.  I wish I didn’t have one.  I can’t bear to look at it, and I think it’s awful.

But there is one variation on a theme that seems to have far greater impact than others, and this is the one that troubles me greatly.  Here’s the pitch:  I am a former prosecutor, and therefore I can do things for you that other people can’t.

Let’s take a hard look at this.  The pitch is intended to capitalize on a basic misperception by the public, that the skills one develops as a prosecutor, characterized as “experience in criminal law,” translate into the skills one requires as a criminal defense lawyer.  As has been discussed ad naseum, there is no intrinsic connection between the two.  Indeed, the transition from the dark side to the light is often painful for former prosecutors, who mistook the love they received from the court as personal rather than institutional.  Suddenly, all those things that made their efforts successful as a prosecutor were gone, and they found the defense side to be painfully difficult.  While some former prosecutors make spectacular criminal defense lawyers, some are miserable failures.

What of the ethical duty on our parts as attorneys to not mislead the public?  Knowing, as we do, that experience as a prosecutor is not the equivalent of experience as a criminal defense lawyer, is it ethical to feed into this misapprehension and exploit the public’s ignorance?  Sure, it helps the former prosecutor to get clients when the truth would not, but ethics aren’t suspended because income is on the line.

The answer is clear.  We cannot ethically mislead the public.  See DR 2-101 :


A lawyer shall not, on behalf of himself, his partner, associate or any other lawyer affiliated with him or his firm, use or participate in the use of any form of public communication containing a false, fraudulent, misleading, deceptive, self-laudatory or unfair statement or claim

No matter how effective it may be to capitalize on common misperceptions, we can’t do it.  We shouldn’t do it.  Yet it’s done all the time. 

But this isn’t the most insidious aspect of marketing oneself as a former prosecutor.  A secondary implication, which is often suggested, and sometimes overtly claimed, is that by being a former prosecutor, a criminal defense lawyer has some inside track to getting his old buddies to let him have special sweetheart deals, or that he’s got some special friendships with the judges before whom he appeared day after day after day, who will do him (and therefore you, dear client) special favors that would not come your way but for his inside connections.

For those of you who promote yourselves as former prosecutors, don’t pretend this isn’t the case.  Some use the “wink and nod” method shamelessly.  Most acquiesce in the implication at minimum.  Who amongst you tells clients that you, as a former prosecutor, have no greater access to “favors” than anyone else? 

This is an outrage and affront to everything that we do.  You suggest, if not scream, to the public that the criminal justice system is overtly corrupt, a game of back-scratching where prosecutors dole out deals to friends and judges put favors above duty.  You demean what little dignity there is left to the law, and feed into the public perception that we are all engaged in one big scam on the public.  It’s not what you know, but who you know.  It’s not hard work, but cronyism.  It engenders cynicism at its worst.

To suggest that the criminal justice system, the courts, the judiciary is corrupt, and that one lawyer can exert special influence, is a disgrace.  Yet this is precisely what comes of promoting that, as a former prosecutor, you have something “special” to offer.  How ironic that someone who promotes her efforts to enforce the law would engage is such unethical conduct to make a buck on the back of those efforts.

I raise this issue not because I hope to influence the innumerable former prosecutors turned defense lawyers who are trying to woo clients through the use of the one tool available to them, not matter how unethical.  You aren’t going to pay any attention to me, and will mutter as you read this how wrong I am, what an idiot I am, and how dare I challenge your use of your very valuable prior service in demonstrating your worth to potential clients.  You are a lost cause, and nothing I say is going to interfere with your desperate attempt to snag as many clients as possible. 

Rather, I post this for the benefit of the many people in the blawgosphere who are engaged in the promotion of marketing and practice.  Too often, your zeal to promote marketing efforts and initiative ignores how these efforts impact on our ethical duties as attorneys.  The law is not just a business.  The law is not like any other business.  What may be a brilliant business move may also be quite unethical.

Please consider the ethical implications of who, and what, you are promoting as you highlight individuals, websites, blawgs and tactic around the blawgosphere.  I know that you are all about business, and mean well in your efforts to help attorney further their practices and break away from the yoke of servitude.  But we are still lawyers, bound by a code of ethical considerations and disciplinary rules.  You just can’t ignore this, and by promoting those who ignore their ethical duties, you are complicit in the death of professionalism.

Market all you want.  Just do it ethically, even if it means giving up something that works.

Update:  The Texas Tornado, Houston criminal defense lawyer Mark Bennett, chimes in on this subject and raises an excellent corollary:  If your ex-prosecutor cum criminal defense lawyer is busy cutting sweetheart deals in the backroom with his buddies, what makes you think he’s not trading off freedom for one client for prison for another?  Remember, cutting unethical deals works both ways.

On the other hand, WindyPundit isn’t ready to buy into this argument just yet, writing “Surely an ex-prosecutor who thinks his experience helped him is entitled to say so?”  Well, no.  This is one of those things where a non-lawyer fails to appreciate what professional ethics means, and the duties it imposes.  By accepting the monopoly of the right to practice law, one gives up a certain degree of freedom, including the freedom to misrepresent, as well as the freedom to pick and chose one’s reality in order to ignore unethical conduct.

WindyMark also points out that since his home town, Chicago, has a history of judicial corruption, there’s nothing wrong with advertising that one has an advantage with corrupt judges.  It’s not that Windy thinks well of people who do, or that it will work to the clients advantage as suggested, but that there may be truth to the marketing technique.

I realize that being an ethical lawyer sounds almost Pollyanna-ish to non-lawyers, who are filled with cynicism and disdain for lawyers.  Indeed, the client may be fearful of the ethical lawyer, who (in his mind at least) won’t break the rules to help the client.  But I will reiterate two things: First, rampant corruption doesn’t exist.  It’s a myth.  Yes, there are instances of ocassional corruption, but these are extremely rare, and certainly not something that one should desire or count on, no matter how many clients ask if we can bribe the judge. 

Second, the goal of ethical lawyers is to improve the legal system, not play it for all it is worth.  I have seen things, impropriety, between lawyers and clients that would make your hair stand up.  Terrible abuse, outrageous lies, outright theft.  When unethical conduct flourishes, the client is always the one who gets burned.  Always.  The dice are loaded, and lawyers will win in a challenge to ethics everytime.  That’s not okay with me, and my purpose is to illuminate unethical conduct and, hopefully, to put a stop to it. 

Good, competent, ethical lawyers do well enough without having to cheat the clients.  Don’t feel sorry for them.

Should the Constitution Enshrine Prejudice? (Update)

After the Supreme Court of California held that the refusal to marry same-sex couples was unconstitutional, the saviors of marriage mobilized to stop the end of life as we know it, and California’s Proposition 8 made its way onto the ballot.

Prop 8, entitled the “California Marriage Protection Act,” provides for a constitutional amendment that states “only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.”  After some wrangling by the attorney general, it ended up looking like this in the voter guide:


ELIMINATES RIGHT OF SAME-SEX COUPLES TO MARRY. INITIATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT. Changes the California Constitution to eliminate the right of same-sex couples to marry in California. Provides that only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California. Fiscal Impact: Over next few years, potential revenue loss, mainly sales taxes, totaling in the several tens of millions of dollars, to state and local governments. In the long run, likely little fiscal impact on state and local governments.

The word out of California is that it appears that the initiative will pass, and that California voters will approve a change to their Constitution that will “constitutionalize” what their Supreme Court has held to be unconstitutional.

Aside from complaint that the anti-Prop 8 forces have gotten their butts kicked by the opposition, and sought to pursue an “agnostic” course that neglected to mention gays and barely mentioned marriage in the fight (which I take to mean that they fought like a bunch of pansies), it seems almost anachronistic that this issue remains so important to some people.  They must hate gays and lesbians so very much that they are willing to throw enormous angst and cash into this fight.  I can’t help but wonder what they are so afraid of?

Still, the legal issue of whether a state Constitution can incorporate a facially prejudicial term presents a very curious question.  Does this mean that a proposition can be put forth that a marriage between a black man and a white woman shall not be “valid or recognized” in California? 

It doesn’t matter that some call gay marriage an abomination.  We all have things we consider “abominations”, though they tend to vary wildly.  Why is your abomination better than mine?  If the constitutional proposition commands discrimination that would deny equal protection to a specific class, then it creates an internal constitutional conflict.  We can’t discriminate, but we must discriminate, hardly seems to make for an acceptable situation (personal abominations aside). 

But what will happen if (when?) Prop 8 is approved, and challenged as it will most certainly be?  How to reconcile a new constitutional provision that is inconsistent with existing constitutional interpretation?  And adding even more fuel to the fire, what becomes of it if (when?) it goes to the Supreme Court of the United States?  Can the federal Constitution dictate what a state Constitution can or cannot say?  Not state laws, which it obviously can, but a Constitution.  And one can only imagine what the Supreme Court of the United States, given its political influences, will do with such an issue.

It seems both unfathomable that this remains a crisis in the eyes of the supporters of Prop 8, largely religious groups whose faith demands hatred of homosexuality, as if gay marriage has much of anything to do with them, the fight is real and they are going to the mats.  Interestingly, this comes as Connecticut has held it unconstitutional to deny the right to marry to same-sex couples.  The sun still rose the next day, and little changed for male-female married couples.  They were still miserable.

So if, after Prop 8, California shuts its doors to gay couples, they are just going to have to go somewhere else to marry.  It changes nothing, and cannot stop the horrible reality that gay marriage is a done deal no matter what the bible has to say or how many explanations are given that it’s just not natural. 

There is one lesson to be learned from the Prop 8 fight.  The efforts to rationalize the existence of homosexuality have failed for those who are against it because it’s “evil”.  Reason will never win this battle, and the fear of “in your face” politics exacerbating the hatred and opposition has proven to be a losing position.  This is just basic bigotry, and no one need fear that by asserting one’s right to be whoever you are, and to be treated without prejudice, you might rile up the bigots.  Rile them up.  Face the fight squarely and stare the bigots down. 

The rallying cry was once, “we’re queer, we’re here, get used to it,” the gay version of veni, vidi, vici.  It served its purpose well.  We really need to get beyond this fear that someone else’s sexuality threatens our own.  There are just too many other problems that require our attention to keep battling this lost cause.  Gay marriage is a reality.  Gay marriage does no harm to straight marriage.  Get over it.

Update:  Great minds think alike?  Greater minds think of it first, and Gideon beat me to the punch on the question of constitutionality of an unconstitutional amendment.

Hey Blawgers, Look at Me!

Kevin O’Keefe, the zen master of legal blogging, reveals that the old “press release” method of getting people in the blawgosphere to write about you is dead. At the mothership of Lexblog, Kevin writes:



Someone in New York City emailed this morning asking if I had any suggestions of bloggers who might be interested in a press release he was sending out today.

I responded that it’s difficult or impossible to suggest bloggers who would like to receive his press release. Most bloggers are put off by typical press releases.

I do not recall any releases that I have referenced in this blog – and I get 10 a day. I delete the emails and if I have second, I click the opt-out at the bottom of the email so that I am not bothered again. When there’s no way to opt-out of the continued emails, following press releases just remind me to dislike the sender.

It’s not that blawgers (Kevin hates the word “blawg” in any of its formulations, and insists on using “blog” because of its search engine consequences) are callous, or that we get way too many people we don’t know sending us emails asking us to promote them, their cause, their product, their blog.

Unlike Kevin, I read some of the emails I receive.  Some interest me.  Most do not.  I wonder whether this is from someone who has read my blawg, thinks that they have something that will actually be of interest, or are just mass-emailing to everyone they can get their hands on. 

Most of the time, the contents of the email are flagrant self-promotion.  I don’t begrudge them the attempt, though I tend to be a bit grumpy about wasting my time when they try to spin it as if they’re doing me a favor.  Some are totally legit emails from real people, and if the story or link is interesting, and moves me to think, it stands a very good chance of making it into a post.

Sometimes, the email has the makings of something potentially interesting, but lacks enough information for me to decide that I want to take their message under wing.  The other day, I received an email about the top 20 criminal justice stories. Their purpose was to promote their new blog, but the idea sounded interesting.  My problem was that it gave me no idea of the credibility of the blogger came up with this top 20 list, and what made their list any more relevant than anyone else’s list.  So I asked some questions to find out who they were and why their list should mean anything to anyone else, and whether they sent this email to other blawgs as well.

The response to the first question was disappointing, to say the least.  He misunderstood the question, and first responded that these were stories from the media (duh) and that he had come up with the list.  He did say that he was a professor of journalism, as if that should have shut me up.  And yes, I was told, he had sent the email to others. 

My interest in his email died a quick and painful death.  I had taken a look at his stories, and really wasn’t impressed.  But more importantly, if he wanted me to post about him, then he really should have made an effort to respond to my concerns.  I find it funny how people seek my favor, then act as if I’m bothering them. 

But the most important lesson was that I’m not interested in posting a story that has been sent to everyone in creation.  There’s no barrier to emailing a story to a million blogs.  For those that have nothing better to post, maybe they will take the free fodder and throw it against the wall.  That’s not my way.  This is why a well-prepared press release will almost invariably never make it past my delete button. 

Ironically, I haven’t seen this story posted by any of my brother criminal law blawgers. 

So while you may not stand a chance in capturing Kevin’s attention, little guys like me may be willing to give you a shake.  But if you do, please bear two things in mind.  You aren’t doing me a favor by putting me on your mass-email PR list, and if you are sending your self-promotion to everyone under the sun, chances are good that no one will have any interest.  I’m always interested in a fascinating story on criminal justice issues, but it’s not because I owe you a spot on my blawg or have a deep desire to promote you or your agenda.  Your desire for free publicity is about the last thing that will interest me in what you offer.

I have enough to write about already, thank you.  And I have my own agenda.  I’m not looking for a new one.



Free Joe! Free Joe! Let Joe the Plumber Go!

Based upon my memories, Ronald Reagan perfected the art of using the common man as the archetypal political example, the everyman whose issue, concerns, interests and deeds could be held out to America as the embodiment of all that was good.  About Reagan, that is.

In the final debate of the 2008 presidential election cycle, a new American hero was born.  Joe the Plumber.  I never gave it much thought in the past, assuming that the candidates/officials obtained the permission of their heroes before holding them out to the public.  Even so, never was one so abruptly thrust into the spotlight as Joe, or exploited so shamelessly. 

In the day hours minutes following the debate, Joe became a sensation, with his name uttered by every pundit and embossed upon t-shirts by struggling entrepreneurs.  No one could have anticipated just how huge this fellow would become, or how quickly he was thrust upon the pedestal of public attention. 

But as most newfound heroes learn, adoration carries a high price.  Not just the total loss of privacy, but the digging for dirt, the public vetting, that invariably seeks to knock him off the pedestal.  So it happened with poor Joe.  By the next morning, news outlets reported that Joe was not really a plumber, that Joe had an IRS tax lien, that Joe wasn’t netting a quarter million dollars a year.

What did Joe do to deserve this? 

As John McCain first invoked the name of Joe the Plumber, I wondered whether Joe knew that he was about to become an icon in a nasty, vicious campaign.  Joe asked a question of Senator Obama at a rally.  He had every right to ask a question, to wonder what Obama’s policies meant for him.  But that wasn’t an invitation to become the darling of the other side, to be held up to the entire nation as proof of . . . something. 

McCain spoke of Joe the Plumber as if he was his best friend, though from his speech patterns, it seems that everyone is his friend though he’s never invited me to dinner.  It seemed as if McCain knew Joe well, the intricacies of his life, his finances, his goals and dreams.  Was Joe prepared to have his life spread open to the public?  Would he have asked Obama a question knowing that it would lead to the media proctologists conducting a very thorough examination?

I don’t think Joe deserves to be in this position.  He may not be perfect, but there aren’t too many of us whose life is so clean that we can withstand such scrutiny.  Nor should an ordinary person who has done nothing more than ask a fair question of a candidate be made the centerpiece of a presidential debate.  He never sought the limelight. 

To the extent that his occupation, financial condition and concerns were broadcast to the nation, it wasn’t by Joe.  He never held himself out as an exemplar.  John McCain is the one who laid claim on Joe, and one could surmise from McCain’s having not known Joe’s last name that he really wasn’t as close with Joe as he made it appear. 

McCain may not have known Joe at all, in fact, and may only have used the few details whispered in his ear by a staffer.  Perhaps he didn’t invite Joe to dinner either, though I suspect if he did, he would have called him, “my friend.” 

So get out of Joe’s life.  Leave Joe alone.  Stop picking him to shreds, you vultures of the trivial, exposing his every foible to public scrutiny.  Joe never asked for it.  Joe did nothing to seek it.  If you want a person to examine, use the one who claimed Joe, without Joe’s permission, and exploited him unmercifully. 

I don’t know Joe, but I know that no regular person needs to be ripped apart in an effort to find some lie, some deception, some deceit.  Joe didn’t deceive anyone.  If there was misrepresentation, look to the person who invoked his name, but leave Joe the Plumber out of it.  Joe is innocent of any wrongdoing.

Let Joe Go!  Let Joe Go!  And get back to things that matter.

H/T Lowering the Bar for the post-debate pic of the candidates.  In fairness, Kevin airs a goofy pic of Obama as well.

Fear of Flying, Bullets Edition

As possession of handguns has become a badge of constitutional honor, the question remains whether, and how, to deal with our “carrying” brethren at the facility that generates the most attention and angst in America, the airport.

None other than J-dog, also known around Minneapolis as Joel Rosenberg, has emerged as the voice of reason in this AP article discussing the conundrum.  But first, the hysterical view:

Some anti-terrorism experts say that is a glaring security loophole that could endanger airport workers, passengers and people waiting to pick them up or see them off. Some suggest that allowing guns in terminals is practically asking for them to be smuggled aboard a plane.

“If your airport is not secure, then the security of your airplanes is jeopardized,” said Rafi Ron, former security chief at Ben Gurion Airport in Israel who now works as an aviation consultant. “You cannot separate the two.”

But calmer voices suggest otherwise:


Other authorities say the nonsecure areas of the terminal are no different from other public venues and do not warrant special restrictions.

“It’s really not more of a concern than at a mall or a train station,” said Philadelphia police Lt. Louis Liberati.

So where does the big Dog lie down?



Joel Rosenberg, a firearms instructor in Minneapolis, said he regularly carries a gun to the city’s airport and has not heard of any problems caused by the policy.

“People who are law-abiding are going to be law-abiding whether they have a .38 snubby on their hip or not,” he said.

Guns don’t kill people.  Bullet fired from guns kill people.  People kill people.  But having a gun makes it a whole lot easier, if you’re so inclined.

Seriously, the analogy between the mall and the terminal seems to me a good fit.  The guns aren’t allowed beyond the security checkpoint and onto the plane, but why is an airport terminal any greater risk than any other place in America where large numbers of people congregate.  We have a far greater sensitivity to danger at airports because of 9/11, but if another attack comes, and next time at a shopping mall, then our focus will shift to magnetometers at the door to Nordstrom.  That’s just how appeasing/fanning the public fear works.

The article goes on to discuss the relative worth of toting a gun at the airport:


Gun rights supporters say law-abiding citizens with guns could fire back and cut short a gunman’s rampage. But Ron, the Israeli security expert, said the last thing airport security agents need is a hail of bullets and no idea who the bad guy is.

“That leads to chaos,” he said, “and that can lead to tragedy.”

But Joel tells me that the wise gun-carrier makes every effort to safeguard himself and his family first, and avoid whipping out the ol’ snubby at the first opportunity.  If all gun-carriers were as reluctant to draw their weapon and insert themselves into a potential firefight as Joel, I might feel a whole lot more comfortable with the idea of plenty of regular folks walking down the street have a weapon hiding behind their gut. 

Something tells me that Joel is a bit more thoughtful and trustworthy than most.  But as long as they can carry the gun into the mall, there’s no rational basis to distinguish the airport terminal.  Past the security checkpoint, of course, is an entirely different matter.

Lawyer Fashionista: ElectionWear

While I normally fix my stary fashion gaze and incisive observations on such vital fashion issues as litigator décolletage, Timothy Zick at Concurring Opinions has raised the very timely question of what to wear to the polls when voting for your fav candidate.  With the election less than 3 weeks away, and given time for proper tailoring, such important decisions must be made immediately. 

Zick, a ConLaw prof at William & Mary, naturally looks to his local fashion peer group for guidance:

The Commonwealth of Virginia is the latest state to impose restrictions on what voters may wear when they go to the polls in early November. According the AP report:

The State Board of Elections yesterday voted to ban clothing and hats as well as buttons and other paraphernalia that directly advocate the election or defeat of a specific candidate or issue.

The American Civil Liberties Union argued that the ban violates the First Amendment’s right to free speech. The board, however, said it has to weigh that against the right to vote free of undue influence or the tension that candidate advocacy might create.

Not to be rude, but when has anyone looked to the ACLU for exemplary fashion sense?  Imagine what they’d come up with if they applied the 9th Amendment to high heels?  Scary.

Zick likens the issue to clothing worn by kids at school, clearly not a place where any self-respecting fashionista wants to go.

The controversy over election apparel reminds me of the problems that are constantly arising in public schools regarding t-shirts and other apparel students are permitted — or not permitted — to wear during school hours and on school grounds. But there administrators and courts are at least generally guided by principles like the Tinker “disruption” standard. By contrast, the states that have imposed apparel limitations appear to take the position that simply wearing a button may “unduly influence” voters and interfere with the franchise. Considering that those at the polls are adults, and further considering that there is nothing intrusive or disruptive about merely wearing one’s support on one’s sleeve, or head, or jacket, this strikes me as overbroad.

While the analogy may make some sense when the concerns are limited to the question of whether campaign clothing is “disruptive” to the polling place, creating “sites of political unrest” as Zick describes it, my sense is that it misses the fundamental point.  While no one hopes for t-shirt wars, it need not go anywhere near that far to present the problem that apolitical attire seeks to address.  Isn’t plain old good taste reason enough?  No?  Sigh.

Voting takes place at a polling place, a refuge from the campaign that is meant to be free of political influences, neutral in every respect, allowing voters to exercise the franchise free from any sense of political pressure or influence.  The idea that the free speech of voters is infringed by their wearing of buttons or clothing that endorses a candidate or promotes a position or party may be true in the smallest sense, there are few aspects of a democracy that are more compelling in its fundamental need for freedom from pressure and influence than the polling place.

Ironically, the comparison between the polling place and school falls apart even more distinctly when one considers that a school is a place where its primary function is to promote thought and ideas, which can compete in the marketplace (or lunch room) and elevate the consciousness of students and their concern for issues of consequences in their lives.  That school officials find idea “disruptive” is itself a bit of a fashion problem for me.

On the other hand, the voting booth exists for the explicit purpose of expressing one’s freedom, not by screaming it with garish buttons or hats or t-shirts, but by pulling a lever (assuming they still pull levers in Virginia).  Would we support the fellow who votes slowly, singing “Obama’s an arab” or “McCain’s senile” during his lengthy stay in the voting booth? 

No, there is nothing wrong with wearing a t-shirt as one enters the polls, or even a hat assuming that it’s raining, but to garnish one’s attire with political messages for the purpose of defiling the one refuge from politicking is both unnecessary and, frankly, quite tacky. 

Let’s save the buttons for the rallies, and demonstrate some restraint when dressing for the vote.  Please.

A Lesson in Criminal Defense Economics

Since economic discussions are in vogue, the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, has turned his eye away from the ordinary culprits toward a very big law firm that is fighting for truth, justice and its $12 million dollar legal fee for representing former McAfee CFO Prabhat Goyal.  WilmerHale (no ampersand needed; it’s so old school).

Dallas law firm Rose • Walker is representing software company McAfee in its suit against New York (?) law firm WilmerHale for overbilling McAfee while losing the securities fraud case of its former CFO, Prabhat Goyal. WilmerHale’s team of former prosecutors billed McAfee $12 million to lose Goyal’s case in federal court in San Francisco. (To their credit, they did try the case rather than rushing Mr. Goyal in to chat with the U.S. Attorney, though a cynic might wonder whether that was because the company was paying the bill.)

And what’s wrong with a $12 million legal fee?  Well, nothing per se, unless it reflects about twice what it would have cost with the finest legal defense team that could have been assembled had anyone given it the slightest degree of thought whatsoever.

As Mark points out, the nature of Biglaw work is that they will keep throwing warm bodies into a case for as long as a client, or the cash machine covering the client, will continue to make the cha-ching sound.  They refer to the “handful of associates” who were used to do document review of 1.2 million pieces of paper.  Sounds like a lot of paper, though experience in complex white collar cases is that there are vast areas of overlap and duplication which allows many documents to be reviewed in less than a half second. 

But the way the fees creep up is the cost plus nature of the business.  I’ve taken issue in the past with Biglaw associates getting salaries that are equivalent to small business CEOs, even though most will never get a corner office at the firm and few, if any, have the capacity to contribute anything more than a quick return from Starbucks with the right mix of steamed milk.  These “best and brightest” young lawyers hate hearing this, but then they do think the world of themselves and their brilliant future potential.

While the firm pays these young’uns dearly, the client even more so.  Whatever ridiculous sum is reflected in their Friday paycheck, it’s a mere fraction of the number that appears on the client’s bill.  Associates do have a purpose beyond carrying briefcases; they are a profit center when billed properly.  Without this, how would one increase partner profits?

So McAfee, footing the bill for the defense of its CFO, is a big business and is used to seeing big bills.  No doubt that there was a huge degree of comfort in having a big law firm wrapping  their CFO in the warmth of big resources by big time lawyers.  It all must have made enormous sense to somebody at the time.  It was all so predictable.

Had anyone sat down and given the situation much thought, however, the good people at McAfee, not to mention their CFO at the eye of the storm, Prabhat Goyal, might have chosen to try an entirely different path.  Rather than travel the well-worn path to monstrous fees and dubious representation, they could have chosen from a universe of the finest criminal defense lawyers working in their small firms and solo practices, because that’s where the finest criminal defense lawyers can be found, and put together a team (if they still felt the need for quantity in the face of quality) for a fraction of the cost.

Real criminal defense lawyers do this every day, making no big deal about representing white collar defendants for under your basic $12 mil.  Heck, they probably could have gotten me and Bennett together for half that price, and we would still have enjoyed a pretty comfortable stay in San Francisco.  Plus, imagine the impact of having some real criminal defense lawyers on Goyal’s chances for winning.

Twice the firepower for half the price.  Not a bad deal.

2d Circuit’s Judge Newman Explains. Again

It would be hard to write with a straight that there are any judges on the 2d Circuit who are particularly sympathetic to the issues facing a criminal defendant, though some are more sensitive than others.  But this doesn’t mean that a gem isn’t produced every once in a while, that serves as a reminder that a lack of sympathy isn’t the same as a lack of intellectual integrity. 

One such gem was produced in 1993, with Judge Jon O. Newman’s Madison Lecture. Beyond “Reasonable Doubt“, 68 N.Y.U. L. Rev. 979, 983 (1993).  This was a watershed moment, when no less than the then-Chief Judge of the Second Circuit openly acknowledged that “beyond a reasonable doubt” had been reduced to a meaningless mantra, without any cognizable definition.  We’re no closer to having a real definition today.

Judge Newman is now in senior status, as he’s been for more than 10 years, but he proved yesterday that he can still swing the bat.  In U.S. v. Huezo, he’s hit it out of the park again in a concurrence, joined by the other two panel judges, to address another troubling bit of federal rubric that has lost purpose and meaning.  His opinion begins on page 22 of the decision.

I write separately, however, to take issue with one argument advanced by the
Government.  Although that argument accurately states a proposition that has
often been repeated in the case law of this Court, I believe the proposition and
a related formulation of it are incorrect, entered federal jurisprudence
improvidently, have been routinely repeated without consideration of their
infirmity, and should be discarded.

Judge Newman then scrutinizes the oft-stated rule that once a conspiracy is shown, “evidence sufficient to link another defendant to it need not be overwhelming.”  The favored phraseology, however, is that “only slight evidence is needed to link another defendant with it.” 

Judge Newman’s opinion rejects the repeated use of this phrase, the rationale having long since been forgotten, to restate that proof of every element of an offense must be proven beyond a reasonable doubt.  There is no “slight evidence” exception for conspiracies, distinct from the rules for all other elements. 

His point was that the “slight evidence” language had been turned into a quantitative rule, used by the government over and over to contend that they need only proffer a small quantity of evidence to sweep additional defendants into the web of their claimed conspiracy.  Repeated often enough, this became the application of the law.  In Huezo, Judge Newman sought to put a stop to this misapplication.

The process by which the “slight evidence” standard insinuated itself into federal court decisions, which in this instance was detailed with exceptional clarity by Judge Newman, results in one of my ongoing themes, where courts “remember the rubric but forget the rationale.”  Indeed, this was just discussed with regard to the misapplication of Molineux’s common scheme or plan, and presents one of the most intractable problems in the law.

As for the Huezo decision itself, I wish I could be so upbeat.  After trial, Southern District Judge Samuel Conti  granted a motion for acquittal, the basis being that no rational juror could have concluded that the defendant was guilty by proof beyond a reasonable doubt that Huezo possessed the requisite knowledge and intent to commit the crime of money laundering and conspiracy to commit money laundering.  On appeal, Judge Sonya Sotomayor agreed with Judge Conti, and dissented on the merits.

So here how the stats work out:  Two judges, Walker and Newman, hold that a rational juror could convict on the evidence.  Two judges, Sotomayor and Conti, think not.  One judge, Conti, actually heard the evidence.  Three judges, Walker, Newman and Sotomayor, did not.  Result: reversed and conviction reinstated.

What gives me pause is not merely the lack of deference in a close call to the trial judge, but the fact that the four judges who considered the question of whether a rational juror could convict split 50-50.  Does that not imply that the two judges who would hold that no rational juror could convict on this evidence are irrational? 

Or more pointedly, given our fidelity to the burden of beyond a reasonable doubt, the fact that two judges out of four conclude that the evidence could not meet that burden should compel a conclusion that the evidence was inadequate to suffice.  If it can’t muster a unanimous appellate panel to reverse the trial judge’s decision, the evidence just couldn’t have been all that great.  Under the rule of lenity, and with due deference to the fellow who had to sit through the evidence, that ought to be enough to state that this conviction shouldn’t stand.

Yet it does.  So Huezo turns out to be a pretty darn good decision, except for Huezo.

H/T Doug Berman, who just happened to have been Judge Newman’s law clerk about the time of the Madison Lecture.