Author Archives: SHG

The (Enabled) Lost Cause of Federal Pleas (Update)

Ken Lammers started a blogversation (credit to Scott Hensen at Grits for the word) about the black hole of federal court, picked up by WindyPundit after Ken posted this quote:


The bottom line is, if you are charged with a federal crime, you are probably going to go to prison. If you have been charged with a federal crime your first thought should not be whether you are going to go to trial to prove your innocence. And if you are guilty you certainly should not risk going to trial. Your first thought should be how to keep your prison sentence to the absolute minimum. Leave the question of guilt or innocence to the academics. Make sure your sentence is short enough so you can pick up the pieces when you are released.

This came from a promotional article by Geoff Mousseau, who was once an attorney and now a “prison consultant.”  How does one end up a prison consultant?  In Geoff’s case, he had to go through a 15 month course of study at Lompoc federal prison camp, all expenses paid.  Get the idea?

Ken and Windy’s focus on this Mousseau promotion followed my critique of Alan Dershowitz’s Forbes article that suggested the only winning strategy in federal court is to be a rat.  Thanks for that bit of genius, Dersh.  With that kind of defense advice, why not urge the accused to just slit their throat immediately to avoid the rush?

This sort of self-fulfilling, self-defeatist creates the very problem it attempts to exploit.  That others continue to promote it, or even suggest that this is a lost cause, makes my blood boil.  After 25 years of fighting, I have no plans on letting those who are determined to lose spew their own failure as if there’s no hope for anyone else.  Misery loves company, and people like Mousseau are truly miserable.

Let’s understand the basics first.  The government does not prosecute people at random.  They pick people to prosecute because they believe that the people have (a) committed a crime, and (b) there’s evidence to that effect.  In other words, the process of criminal prosecution begins with a choice that heavily favors the government.  It’s supposed to.  This is a good thing.

So it’s only natural that the vast majority of federal prosecutions (or state, for that matter) should end in convictions.  As they should.

But Les Miserables, like Dershowitz and Mousseau, aren’t satisfied with that.  They want every federal defendant to believe that it’s a lost cause.  For Dershowitz, it’s a cause and effect problem, where he’s spent far too long trying to undo his fringe-lefty image cultivated when he was younger and still had testosterone flowing through his body, so that he can now be the mainstream poster-boy for reasonable criminal media commentary.  He’s traded his soul to be accepted by others, and it buys him articles in magazines like Forbes, the Capitalist Tool.  His mother would be so proud.

Mousseau, on the other hand, has a product to sell, and he knows his audience well.  He is his own audience, and there isn’t much for a defrocked lawyer to do after finishing his time in the joint other than to advise incoming prisoners how to avoid doing the mambo with bubba.  By arguing that innocent people have no choice but to take a fall, he’s offering his services to people who want to maintain the facade of innocence in the face of surrender.  It makes his customers feel better about themselves.

There is no doubt whatsoever that defendants plead guilty when they are not.  But the urgings of Dershowitz and Mousseau feed into the sense of despair and failure, telling those who are innocent that they cannot fight, they cannot win, their only hope is to surrender.  So what do innocent people do?  They surrender in the hope that it will cut their losses.  They turn criminal prosecution into a business decision, and suck all integrity from the system.

In contrast, I rail against this expectation of failure.  If every innocent defendant chose to fight rather than give up, the government would have one heck of a problem on its hands.  It thrives on cooperators, people willing to sell their testimony to save a few months off the back end of their sentence.  It survives on fear, because they lack the time, evidence and ability to be put to the test of proving their overblown claims at trial after trial. The government wins because of the fear it has generated in the public, and those who promote this fear enable the government to do so.  They become part of the root cause of injustice.

Fight the fear.  Reject the failure.  And tell those who promote it for their own ends, whether self-aggrandizement or self-promotion, to get lost.  No, every defendant who goes to trial will not win.  But no innocent defendant who cops a plea wins either.  And some defendants who fight will prevail.  If more fight, more will prevail. 

Do not buy into the idea that every defendant in a federal prosecution loses.  It is a lie.  Do not join the chorus that innocent people must plead guilty or rat to save themselves.  It too is a lie.  Do not enable injustice.

Update:  I was barely done posting this before reading Doug Berman’s post about how the NYLJ predicts a surge in white collar prosecutions stemming from the current financial crisis.  After some cute stuff about how law students should take a course in white collar crime to capitalize on this “surge”, Doug posts:


In addition, all corporate attorneys with old business clients now fearing different kinds of legal problems ought to quickly study up on federal sentencing realities.  As regular readers know well, the first executives to run to prosecutors and offer up information are likely the ones (and perhaps the one [sic] ones) who will escape severe consequences when indictments start rolling in.

I’m praying that he’s just kidding, because I refuse to believe that Doug would seriously suggest anything so utterly absurd. 

It’s Not Easy Being Kevin O’Keefe

The other night, I was honored to be invited to sit with Kevin O’Keefe as part of a panel on blogging at the NYCBA. Not, not the criminal bar association, but the other one, also known as the Association of the Bar of the City of New York. Joining me at the table for the CLE was New York Personal Injury Blogger Eric Turkewitz and Dan Clement from the New York Divorce Report Blog.  It was an experience.

Kevin’s raison d’être is to bring blogging to the masses, provided theu’re lawyers and could use a turnkey blog.  Kevin took a huge risk asking me to join him, since I have this occasional tendency to be slightly contrarian.  But watching Kevin at work was enlightening, both for his mastery of the technical and his passion for turning every lawyer into a blogger.

What I failed to appreciate until the other night was just how difficult Kevin’s job could be.  In a room where people paid good money to learn something about blogging (Kevin hates the cutsie word “blawging”, mostly because it doesn’t play well with Google), the learning curve was a killer.  Those of us who dally in the blawgosphere (oops, sorry Kev, blogosphere) have at minimum a basic working understanding of the gig.  These would-be bloggers had none. 

How much “none” did they have?  Well, how about almost an hour spent on the extraordinarily complex subject of “what’s an RSS feed?”  Ironically, no one mentioned the words “really simple syndication,” which might have insulted the folks busily writing down every word about how to put a blog into a feed.  Yes, I know.  It’s a click and it’s done.  Turk said, “just go home and play with it for a few minutes.”  I said, “it’s something you just have to do, not talk about.”  Kevin had a powerpoint presentation on just this aspect.

Kevin understood something that Turk and I did not.  The people who know that there’s something out there called the blogosphere don’t want to understand it. They want a how-to manually of the technicalities.  They want “Blogging for Dummies.”   Not only that, but some of the audience members were pretty aggressive about the fact that they didn’t want to hear anything about what makes a blog successful, or interesting, or effective.  They wanted to the keys to the car without knowing what to do once they got the sucker moving. And they wanted them NOW.  Of course, this was New York, and some people tend to be a little more assertive around here than in other places.

The CLE turned out to be far less about blogging than remedial computing.  While Turk, Dan and I were sitting around looking pretty, we have little to offer on the RSS feed subject.  We were there to talk about blogging content and etiquette, how to spread the word you exist without pissing off the rest of the blogosphere, how to get others to read what they write.  There was a little of this, but not much.  We were mostly eye candy (I wish) at the front table for the Kevin O’Keefe show.  But it was Kevin’s show, so there was nothing wrong with that.

Kevin and I had numerous disagreements about what path to take to become a blogger, but then we approach the subject from opposite ends of the spectrum.  Kevin promotes blogging as the new means to marketing, and because of this focus, has a clear vision of certain choices a new blogger should make.  Since my view is that marketing should never be a blogger’s purpose, and demeans the blogosphere, I see the choices differently than Kevin.  But both Kevin and I meet in the center when it comes to the point that no blog can succeed without a dedication on providing substance to the blogosphere. 

The primary difference in our approaches was obvious when Kevin told the room that every one of them would be a blogger if they only tried.  I disagreed.  The blogosphere doesn’t want everyone of them to be a blogger.  It wants as few as possible as blogospheric Darwinism takes over.  They can all try, but most will fail, and that’s how it should, and must, be.  The blogosphere cannot accommodate everyone, and will be brutal when it comes to thinning the herd.  But then, I’m not selling turnkey blogs, so I have no reason to be overly optimistic.

But Kevin put himself out there to open the minds of this crowd to the potential of the blogosphere.  It was a terribly difficult task, as the audience proved by question after question that they didn’t understand anything about blogging.  For me, the sense of the audience was captured by a question late in the CLE, “how many hours a week does it take to blog?”

My answer was “how long must a man’s legs be?”  Kevin’s answer was an hour or two was sufficient.  I wondered how many times Kevin has been asked that question before, and how hard he has to bite his tongue when he gives that answer.  But that’s what the people want to know.

Post Script:  After the CLE, we all have dinner at a barbecue joint down the street.  Kevin’s a great guy, with this funny Seattle accent.  You should have seen his eyes grow wide as we walked across Times Square.  If I was going to buy a turnkey blog, it would be from Kevin, but I wouldn’t let him name it for me.

The First Shoe Drops on Maryland Indigent Defendants

Jon Katz at Underdog posts that the well has run dry for indigent defendants who require counsel but are conflicted from representation by the Maryland Public Defender.  Uh Oh.  Baltimore, we have a problem.

It seems that the Maryland Public Defender was responsible for paying the cost of private lawyers, paid at a ridiculously reduced rate, to represent the poor when there were multiple defendants in a case, thereby precluding the Public Defender from representing defendants whose interest conflicted.  This would be the 18B lawyer, in New York parlance.  What they call them in Maryland is beyond me, but the idea is the same.

It’s no shock that this has happened.  We’ve been warning that it was coming for a long time.  It was just a simple allocation of scare resources issue, with indigent defense funding on the slide and a bunch of defendants who were still entitled to a lawyer under Gideon.

Jon provides a link to a letter from Maryland’s Chief Judge, Robert M. Bell, to the head political honchos of the state.  Aside from Judge Bell’s delightful use of such lawyerly favorite phrases as “rendered nugatory” (when was the last time you said that to some hottie at a beer bash?), his answer is to have the Public Defender continue assign lawyers and to fudge the funding from elsewhere.  The purpose of his letter is to persuade the political branches of Maryland government to eek out some additional funding for the PD.

This is really kinda nutty on a number of levels. 

What is it about states’ Chief Judges that makes them think that they have any business becoming embroiled in political battles with the other branches of government?  Our own Judy Kaye tried that on the issue of judicial pay raises, and, man, did she get burned.  Now Judge Bell does it on behalf of Gideon?  It makes no sense.

The judicial branch cannot compete with the political branches based upon cogent, rational argument.  The political branches don’t function based on rationality, which is why they are the political branches.  They appeal to voters, whether rational or not.  They aren’t supposed to be held to a strict rational standard, while the judiciary is.  They just need votes.

But the strength of the judiciary is its ability to put a stop to anything that is done by government that is unconstitutional.  It doesn’t have to please the political branches, or cuddle up to them with a warm and fuzzy appreciation of their political (meaning cashflow) problems.  It just holds that the government either does something the constitutional way or it can’t do it at all.

Jon offers his own solution to Judge Bell’s problem:


[R]adically shrink and reform the criminal justice system into one that legalizes marijuana, prostitution, and gambling; that heavily decriminalizes all other drugs; and that sharpens the teeth of the First, Fourth, Fifth, Sixth, Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution.

This isn’t likely going to do much to help any particular defendant in the near future, and is a matter for the political wings rather than the judiciary to address.

I would offer a simpler, and more attainable, solution:  If the state fails to provide adequate funding for the defense of indigent defendants, then they cannot be prosecuted.  If an indigent defendant appears in court without a lawyer, as required by the Constitution, it isn’t his problem whether the state has enough money to pay the freight. 

The message should be clear.  The judiciary will not, and cannot, tolerate the conduct of unconstitutional prosecutions.  Cure it or dismiss it.  How to do so is a political problem.  That it cannot be allowed to happen is a judicial problem. And that problem is now solved.

Search Warrants: The Mess Left Behind

As anyone who has had the pleasure of being the target of a search warrant knows, as well as any criminal defense lawyer representing the target, it’s ugly business.  When the cops come in to execute a warrant, nothing is sacred.  Not the couch.  Not the walls.  Not the baby’s Teddy Bear.

This is the nature of a search warrant.  Since a judge has decided that the cops are authorized to search, they can look anywhere the object of the search could possibly be hidden. But does this mean that it should result in the needless, pointless, wholesale destruction of someone’s home and possessions?

From Orin at VC, the issue was raised in the Washington State Supreme Court decision in  Brutsche v. City of Kent.  As Orin noted, one would think that this is a common problem and there would be a ton of caselaw on it, but the reality is just the opposite. 

From my perspective, the reasons for this is fairly simple.  Most of the time, the cops come up with something, and the target becomes the defendant.  At this point, the defendant has more important issues at stake than damage to his home and property.  Secondly, even when no evidence is seized, the cost of pursuing an action against the cops for damage just isn’t cost effective.  It’s often difficult to prove damages, and the amounts aren’t so great as to justify the legal fees and costs.  In other words, the target is screwed and there’s not much he can do about it.

So what is the lesson of Brutsche?


We adopt Restatement (Second) of Torts § 214 and conclude that liability in trespass may arise if by intentionally doing an act that a reasonable person would not regard as necessary to execute the warrant and thereby damage the property, or by executing the warrant in a negligent manner and thereby damaging the property, law enforcement officers exceed the scope of their privilege to be on the land to execute a search warrant.

Ah, the old reasonable man person standard.  This fine old concept that expects the good jurors to sit in the place of the reasonable cop and determined whether he’s gone too far in protecting their safety from criminals like the unreasonable plaintiff.  It’s a very hard thing to do, since no one wants to “handcuff” the police in the good faith performance of their sworn duty to protect us.  In other words, the jurors have a vested interest in backing the cops, since they are part of the group that benefits from their actions.

In contrast, Orin enthusiastically supports the opinion by Justice Richard B. Sanders, one of the most libertarian state Supreme Court Justices, wrote a very interesting dissent. Sanders argued that the damage to property should be a taking requiring just compensation under the Washington State Constitution.

Justice Sanders writes that the destruction of property is not an exercise of the police powers, but an act of eminent domain, the taking of private property for a public purpose.  As such, it constitutes a “taking” and therefore requires “just compensation.”


That court failed to recognize the important distinction between the power of the police and the “police power.” Appropriating or damaging property for the public good does not absolve the State from compensating the owner, precisely the opposite.  That is what the takings clause is all about.

Justice Sanders makes a very persuasive argument.  But then, it’s the dissent. What else is new?

Outsourcing Prosecutors is a Step Too Far

In yet another example that New York isn’t all that different from the rest of the country, Bill Grady, the Dutchess County District Attorney decided that it wasn’t all that special to be a prosecutor, and so he decided to let the complaining witness use her own private lawyer to prosecute a case when it wasn’t worth it to put his own assistants on the case.  According to the New York Law Journal :


Dutchess County District Attorney William V. Grady’s designation of a private attorney hired by complainant Jonathan Dallar to prosecute two second-degree harassment charges that Mr. Dallar filed against Patricia Sedore.

At an initial appearance before Fishkill Town Justice Harold D. Epstein, an assistant Dutchess County district attorney advised the court that Mr. Grady’s office would not prosecute the case. Mr. Grady said in an interview that he does not have the resources to prosecute violations, except those involving domestic violence or school incidents.

Mr. Dallar retained a private attorney in Poughkeepsie, Adam G. Kirk, to prosecute the complaint against Ms. Sedore and Mr. Grady formally designated Mr. Kirk as prosecutor.

Obviously, it made sense to Grady.  Fortunately, it didn’t to the Appellate Division, Second Department, which held that this was an improper and unethical delegation of power in  Matter of Sedore v. Epstein.


Canons of professional ethics identify an inherent conflict between the role of attorney and that of prosecutor, the Appellate Division, Second Department, ruled last week in Matter of Sedore v. Epstein, 2007-02296. An attorney’s obligation is to advocate for his client while the prosecutor’s obligation is to the public and the fair dispensing of justice, the panel noted, citing the Code of Professional Responsibility EC 5-1 and DR 7-101(A)(1).

While noting that there were certain situations where a District Attorney could properly delegate his authority, such as cases involving a conflict of interest or using police officers to prosecute in local courts, this one was just off the deep end.

As has been discussed frequently with regard to the victims rights advocates, criminal prosecutions are between the government and the defendant, and do not vindicate individual rights and interests.  That’s why we have a civil court. 

An attorney for a complainant represent the complainant.  A prosecutor represents the interests of society, and always wins since society has no interest in convicting the innocent (okay, but that’s how it’s supposed to work).  Clearly, the two approach a prosecution with different ethical obligations. 

Does anybody else wonder if Dutchess County District Attorney Grady was aware of any of this? 

Does The Rest of the 11th Circuit Agree?

James Cook, representing the extraordinarily sad and depressed human being, Jesse Buckley, who was tasered three times on the roadside with the approval of the 11th Circuit, is offering the court a second chance to show it’s humanity.  Cook’s motion for rehearing en banc was received last night, and it’s an excellent effort.

In his effort to check the pulse of the Circuit, Cook has presented his argument largely by way of a fascinating analogy to the 1960s:


Police use of force became a critical public issue in the U.S. in the 1960’s at the time of the civil rights movement. Newspaper photographs showed police deploying attack dogs and fire hoses against crowds of demonstrators. Cattle prods were also used for crowd control. The late Stokely Carmichael (Kwame Ture) remembered the use of cattle prods by police officers during the 1960’s. ”When those points touched your skin,” he wrote, ”the pain was sharp and excruciating, at once a jolting shock and a burn. You could actually see and smell your skin burning.” Weisbrot, Robert, Stokely Speaks, New York Times, Nov. 23, 2003.

Buckley, you may recall, was stopped for speeding, but rather than cooperate promptly with Deputy Jonathon Rackard by signing the ticket, did the unthinkable.

Financially destitute and homeless, Buckley began sobbing after Rackard pulled him over and gave him a speeding ticket, which Buckley refused to sign.

After warning Buckley twice to sign or he would face arrest, Buckley said, “Arrest me.” Still in his vehicle, he allowed Rackard to cuff him, then exited his car. But as Rackard began walking the still distraught Buckley to the patrol car, Buckley dropped to the ground, crossed his legs and remained there, still sobbing.

After Rackard warned Buckley that he would taze him if he didn’t cooperate, Buckley responded, “I don’t care anymore. Tase me.”   And Rackard did.  Three times.

So is Cook’s analogy to the passive resistance movement of the 1960s accurate?  The answer would seem to depend on whether one looks to the objective conduct or the subjective intent.  Certainly, Buckley was not protesting when he sat on the ground sobbing.  He had lost all hope.  But his conduct was indistinguishable from that of historic figures who used passive resistance to make their point.


The tradition of passive resistance, which migrated from American Henry David Thoreau to Indian pacifist Mohandas Gandhi, back to Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and others, ultimately led Americans at all points of the political spectrum, to adopt passive resistance as a form of peaceful protest. It was used in abortion clinic protests as it was in desegregation demonstrations. Public reaction to police overreaction disciplined public officials and law enforcement officers to show tolerance for this form of protest in causes that frequently attracted young or frail and elderly demonstrators, so that activists could essentially go limp and force officials to have them arrested without fear of clubs or chemicals or electric prods.

As a result of the use of cattle prods, the direct linear ancestor of the Taser, the law prohibited the use of “pain compliance techniques” against those who threatened no harm, but merely refused to happily comply. 

Cook seeks rehearing en banc in this case, notably in light of prevailing before the District Court, and then the stinging 17 page dissent by Judge Beverly B. Martin.  This decision, which was unpublished but highlighted across the blawgosphere because it was so outrageous, reflects a degree of callousness by an appellate court toward citizens that is shocking.  Hopefully, the other judges on the 11th Circuit will recognize just how disconnected the decision by Chief Judge J.L. Edmondson is from the harsh reality of this newfound cattle prod.

This was one sick decision.  Let’s hope the Court sees the light of day, and it doesn’t try to bury the outrage by denying rehearing.

Anyone Can Do It

As an afterthought to a post about President Bush’s approval rating, for which the word “low” no longer suffices, Orin Kerr at VC provides the following snippet of statistical data from Rasmussen Reports:



Here’s another interesting poll, this one on opinions toward Congress:



Only half (49%) [of respondents to the poll] believe that the current Congress is better than individuals selected at random from the phone book. Thirty-three percent (33%) believe a randomly selected group of Americans could do a better job and 19% are not sure.


It’s irrelevant whether those who believe that individual selected at random could, in fact, do better than the current Congress.  What matters is that almost half of the respondents believe it to be true.

This is a frightening example of misapplied logic, and as it happens, is currently at play in the current electoral cycle.  No doubt, the significance of this is the public’s dissatisfaction with the pervasive and seemingly intractable problems facing America.  But the fallacy comes from the rejection of one end of the spectrum, the status quo, to the assumption that the polar opposite would therefore be an improvement.  It shows, yet again, that we are a black and white society, incapable of seeing (or understanding) shades of gray.

The danger of this erroneous assumption is that the public has elevated its vision of the “common man” to mythical status, with ordinary people possessed of something described as “common sense,” one of the most dangerous phrases in the English language.  Everyone believes they have it, though no two people have it the same.  Yet it is exalted as if it provides the right answer to all questions.

Like everyone else, I chat with folks all day long, and lately we’ve been discussing finances and politics.  Half the people I talk to have no idea what’s going on or why.  The other half know exactly what’s going on and have a simple plan to fix everything.  “It’s common sense,” they tell me.  Well, not my common sense, since most of the plans I’ve heard sound remarkably worthless.  But the proponents feel pretty confident that they have a solution.  You see, they aren’t hampered by knowledge, understanding, facts or consequences. 

The problem will not be ordinary citizens storming the capital rotunda to push their fat butts into seats in one chamber or another.  The problem is that the latest craze in political gamesmanship is to promote the “Joe Sixpack” persona, to capture the hearts (though not the minds, as they aren’t involved) of voters by appealing to this irrational devotion to commonness.

Like almost all Americans, I too am dissatisfied with the current Congress (as well as the last 12).  The game of politics is no longer an effective method of distinguishing viable from failed policies and laws.  It’s not that Representatives are inherently stupid, though as Stephen Colbert has proven, some indeed are.  It’s that politics has taken a wrong turn a while back, and people who might very well be effective law makers under certain circumstances are on the road to perdition.

But that doesn’t mean the solution isn’t to elect the “common man” to Congress.  Or the “common woman” to the Vice Presidency.  But it’s far easier for politicians to feed the public’s misperception than correct it, even though it’s fairly clear that this path is taking us farther and farther away from the government that Thomas Jefferson had in mind :  “One cannot underestimate the wisdom of the people.“

Is the ABA Pimping for the FBI?

Shortly after the ABA Journal went online, it became one of the primary repositories of blawgs, currently showing 251 in the “criminal justice” category alone.  One of its features that I’ve found particularly interesting is “The Weeks’s Featured Blawg,” selecting a blawg to highlight at the top of its blawg directory page. 

In the past, the ABA has featured some of the well-known blawgs, like Volokh Conspiracy, as well as some of the smaller but most informative around, such as Deliberations and the Legal Satyricon . (I’m informed by the ABA Journal that they have yet to stoop that low) New York Personal Injury Blawg (which they told me has been featured, though it was too ugly to make it into the ABA Blawg 100).   It’s never been clear to me why certain blawgs are featured, but it provides a chance to take a look at some blawgs that have never made it onto the radar.

This week, however, the ABA’s choice for featured blawg has me stymied, though it has certainly shown me a website that I would likely have never seen otherwise.  The featured “blawg” is now a blawg at all.  It’s not even a website provided by or for lawyers.  This week, the featured blawg is FBI: Gotcha!

FBI: Gotcha! is a product of our friendly government law enforcers, touting their successes.  It comes direct from the FBI press room, and consists of a series of archived audio files about specific cases.  As the home page explains:


Gotcha Archive


The Gotcha series highlights a closed case in which the FBI, often working with local and state police and possibly other federal agencies, solves a crime and makes arrests.

I’ve listened to a couple of the audio files, They don’t say much, and inform even less.  While it’s purpose is unclear, it strikes me as PR directed to a public with extremely short attention spans.  As a lawyer, it was utterly devoid of interest.  In all likelihood, this was the FBIs way of getting rid of some of the excess funding it has received from Congress to protect us.

But why would the ABA select FBI:Gotcha! to be its featured blawg of the week?  Since the online journal has been around less than a year, it hasn’t even made its way through the 251 criminal justice blawgs listed in its directory, no less the many other practice areas it lists. And yet, someone made a decision to ignore the vast array of blawgs produced by lawyers for lawyers, and instead elected to highlight an FBI promotional webpage.

If it was a matter of balance, given that there are far more criminal defense blawgs than prosecutor blawgs, there still remains a host of fine prosecutor blawgs to run through before making the decision to ignore blawgs altogether and start promoting government websites.  Why not Ken Lammers’ CrimLaw?  Certainly Ken, who has been a staple of the blawgosphere for far longer than I’ve been around, is worthy of being featured.


When the ABA got into the business of blawg promotion, there was some doubt in my mind that they would have a clue what they were doing.  They came up with the ABA Blawg 100, which neglected the entire personal injury practice area.  They (the ABA, not the ABA Journal, which I’m informed, is under entirely different management) invited certain blawgs, this one included, to apply for the Silver Gavel Award, which came with a hefty application fee attached, as if this were a profit-making venture.  But at least they provided a directory of blawgs for the benefit of lawyers.

So who came up with this brainstorm?  And since when did the ABA start promoting the FBI over lawyers?  This is just plain screwy, and leaves me to wonder whether anyone over at the ABA has a clue what they’re doing.

Dow 10,000 (Market Close Update)

It felt better the last time this was big news. 

Smart money is on taking whatever you earn and spending it on cheap shiny stuff as quickly as possible.  Stop paying that mortgage immediately.  Do not, under any circumstances sell any stocks, as you will be needing them when the supermarkets stop stocking Charmin.  Incorporate immediately, former subsidiaries for your children as well.  Remember the first $455,000 of their earnings are already spent.

Aren’t you glad we averted disaster?  Don’t you wish everybody did?

Special to the Slackoisie:  This is not a boomer issue.  This is a Republican deregulation issue.  (FYI, Republican refers to one of two primary national political parties, in which President George W. Bush, now completing his second term of office, is a member.) 

In the words written for candidate Ronald Reagan during a debate with President Jimmy Carter, “Are you better today than you were 4 years ago?”

Market Close: Dow -369.88, NASDAQ -84.43.  So where are all those brilliant people who were emailing me before the bailout to tell me what an idiot I was to doubt how the bailout would “avert disaster.”  Haven’t heard from you guys lately.  Wassup?

Remember all those talking heads saying that the bailout would stop the stock market from going into freefall.  Did I not say that this was only the beginning? 

I’m begging you, if you want to get stupid, do it with your own money.  Leave mine out of it.

Thirty Days of Smear

American national politics has devolved to the lowest common denominator.  Don’t vote for the other guy.  I wouldn’t have known about this but for watching cable news this morning, since I’m in New York.  Nobody bothers to air television commercials in New York, as we’re a lost cause. 

The campaigns are being waged elsewhere.  When I traveled south for Parents Weekend at my daughter’s college a couple weeks ago (she’s doing great, thanks for asking), I got to see campaign commercials.  It was jarring, since I hadn’t seen them before.  One after another.  Sometimes, the same commercial would appear three or four times during a half hour on the same channel.  Clearly, someone lacked good executive function skills.

But this mornings news was that the gloves are coming off for the last 30 days.  No discussion of which candidate has the better plan to provide health care, though Paul Krugman has a good op-ed on that today.  Nobody is talking about how they are going to fix the economy, as no one has a plan for that.  Rather, it all comes down to why the other guy is evil.  John McCain has a new add entitled “Dangerous”.  Barak Obama is going for erratic, with an undertone of senile dementia. 

While a rant on the evils of negative advertising would not be inappropriate at this point, I can understand why the great minds running these campaigns are doing this.  It’s all about the undecided voter in the swing state.  They understand something that those of us who follow the news, think about issues, consider the options, do not.  They understand that the undecided voter is too stupid to convince positively, and at best will respond viscerally to the negative.  The best they can hope for is to scare the undecided voter away from the other guy.

The swing voter has been glorified in the past, mostly not to offend stupid people by telling them that they are stupid.  No one wants to hear that.  it makes them feel angry.  They don’t believe they are stupid, and believe that they are every bit as smart and rational as everyone else.  It’s just that they find all this incredibly boring, and not worth their time.  Plus, they are so close to getting a gold star on Super Mario Smash Brothers that it would just ruin the game to stop now.

In the process of persuading the undecided voter that the other guy is evil, many of us will be put off by the overt negativity, not to mention the outright deception.  We’re told that to turn a blind eye to all this, because “our guy” has to win the election first to do the great things he plans to do.  There’s no doubt truth to this, but it stinks.

If only we could find unity in one single point across the political spectrum, that negative campaigning is the refuge of scoundrels and reflects worse on the person offering it than the person getting it up the wazoo.  Of course, it’s likely that we could largely agree with this and get behind it, regardless of whether one leans left or right, except for one relatively small group in this great nation of ours.  The undecided voters.  They just don’t care enough.