Author Archives: SHG

Inflammatory Rhetoric is Ugly, But Not Criminal

Walter Olson at Point of Law explores the question of whether the inflammatory rhetoric that’s hit the fan this week violates a legal duty, under an incitement to riot analysis as argued by Susan Kuo at Concurring Opinions.


[Do] the GOP candidates might have a “legal duty” to tone down their attacks, lest supporters of theirs commit (still-hypothetical) acts of impulsive rage that would never have taken place otherwise. Invoking the Model Penal Code, she explores the possibility of assigning criminal responsibility to the candidates for not cooling it with their language despite the knowledge that there are unhinged partisans out there.

This is one of the reasons why people hate lawyers.  Too often, we see something that has the possibility of doing harm, and try to fit it into a legal paradigm despite a clearly bad fit, and certain prematurity.  When I first saw Kuo’s post, it seemed too obvious for words that no one in the McCain camp, and most assuredly not McCain himself, sought to incite anyone to violence. 

Did he want to incite them to a passionate support of his candidacy?  Absolutely.  But that’s precisely what all candidates seek.  One doesn’t become an accomplice to a crime because some nutjob in the audience, boiling over with rage and righteous indignation, decides to make a left turn toward harming the other candidate instead of a right turn into the voting booth.

At PrawfsBlawg, Howard Wasserman confronts the ugly lawyer tendency to frame issues in terms of law, distinguishing ugly rhetoric from criminal conduct.


“I cannot buy the notion being floated that anything unlawful is happening. … ugliness is not unlawfulness. And whatever criticism the [Republican] campaign warrants for engaging in personal attacks and riling up the crowd, charges of engaging in ‘borderline incitement’ should not be among them.”

What is happening reflects a judgment issue, where one can properly question whether, in the zeal of the campaign, either strategy or heat has led candidates to push too hard, go too far, turn up the heat too high, so that the net result is beyond their intended goal and will lend itself to going to a place that no rational person wants. 

As I contended yesterday, I believe that John McCain has come to realize that his campaign’s rhetoric has gone too far, giving rise to the wrong reaction in some unhinged supporters.  I believe that he recognizes that he has created a real problem, and would like to rein in the rage, but has to figure out how to do so without making himself and his running mate not look foolish or cause the angry crowd to turn its rage on them.  Being booed at your own rally isn’t easy to do.

But this isn’t a legal issue, and John McCain has not become a “willing co-conspirator,” as he bizarrely  accused some Democratic legislators the other day, in a plot to harm Obama.  It’s just inflammatory rhetoric gone too far, and instead of reflecting poorly on Obama’s judgment, it calls into question his own.

Protecting Our Borders from Cozy Copyright Infringement

The issue of border searches, limitless in scope and restraint, was justified by our Homeland Security Czar, Michael Chertoff, as vital to protect us from terrorism.  And pornography. And now an SUV cozy?

From the Press Republican,

Keene Valley resident Jerilea Zempel was detained at the U.S. border this summer because she had a drawing of a sport-utility vehicle in her sketchbook.  U.S. Customs and Border Protection officers told Zempel they suspected her of copyright infringement.

She was released after more than an hour in custody at the Houlton, Maine, port of entry from New Brunswick, Canada.  Her release came only after she persuaded border guards she was an artist doing a project that involved a crocheted SUV as a statement against America’s dependence on oil and love for big vehicles.

Now if the border guards detained Zempel for artistic reasons, that might be understandable.  After all, “her submission was an SUV cozy on a rented Hyundai Santa Fe,” certainly a dubious choice of artistic endeavors.  But that wasn’t the problem.  The problem was copyright infringement. 

The problem was that they suspected this woman of trying to sneak across the border with an illicit drawing of a Hyundai.  Had they been on the payroll of the Korean automaker, they could not have been more diligent and concerned with the corporate welfare of this manufacturer of vehicles with lengthy warranties.  And what if she possessed a drawing of a Chevy Tahoe?  Would there have been any chance of talking her way out of it.

The fact that United States border officials detained, DETAINED, a United States citizen for this purpose is beyond shocking.  She posed no immediate threat to the security of the nation.  At absolute worst, she posed a threat to competent illustration, lest she bring down the American automobile drawing industry.  Who in the world informed these border officials that it’s their job to seize Americans who they fear might violate a copyright?

Our border control has long been the subject of grave concern, but for its porous nature when aliens enter without proper authorization as well as seizing the personal property of Americans “just in case.”  Now we add the national threat of SUV cozies to the list of potential harms they protect us against.

There has been no reaction from Czar Chertoff, and why should he?  After all, they did let her go.  Eventually.    This isn’t an institutional problem requiring any thought or involvement by very important government officials, is it?

Of course it’s unimportant.  Until it’s you or yours who gets stopped at the border for copyright infringement.  But then, New Jersey has no international borders, does it Czar Chertoff?  And I don’t even know if anyone in your family can draw.

Time for PDs to Let Go of Biglaw Envy

Most criminal defense lawyers, particularly public defenders, pay little attention to the ridiculous happenings in the world of Biglaw.  While the self-proclaimed “best and brightest” were scribbling notes in the library for the first five years of their career, with their bonus checks on auto-deposit, criminal defense lawyers were busily answering the call of the calender and announcing “ready for trial,” for a fraction of the pay.

But the rosy world of Biglaw and Bigmoney is turning a bloody red these days.  As reported by the chronicler of all things juvenile, Above the Law reports, the dissolution of Heller Ehrman, a Biglaw firm from San Francisco with offices in various other cities where Biglaw firms congregate, has not gone well.  In fact, when the firm was forced to dissolve, it promised its lawyers that they would have 60 warning before the checks with all the zeros would cease.  That changed yesterday, when 60 days turned into “today”.


Heller Ehrman LLP Above the Law blog.JPG It is with a great deal of regret that we write to inform you that we will not be able to pay you for work performed after today, Friday October 10 and, as a result, that your employment with the firm will be terminated today. We also expect that we will need to inform other employees over the following two weeks that we are unable to pay them any further and will need to terminate their employment. 

It wasn’t too long ago that the talk was about first year associate salaries hitting the $200,000 mark, not merely a ridiculous notion and an outrageous vanity, but an affront to those who struggle in the trenches doing real lawyer work for real people at less than a quarter of that amount.  Well, the worm has turned.

No doubt some of the Biglaw refugees will be absorbed by other Biglaw firms, even as they divest themselves of non-productive equity partners.  But where will the others go, the ones who were contemplating whether to purchase the Testarossa, Quattroporte or the Murcielago?  Will they be sending in resumes to the five lawyer personal injury firms that advertise heavily on TV?  Will they try to explain to the Legal Aid Society hiring attorney how criminal law was always their first love?  Will they attend Solo Practice University and learn how to hang out their shingle?

Lingering resentment lingers amongst many in the criminal defense practice, particularly the public defenders, for the outrageous salaries enjoyed by their law review-kissing brethren. who never knew the joys of brown-bagging a tuna sandwich to the office for lunch.  But now that their world is coming apart, perhaps it’s time to let go of that anger. 

After all, the deep concern of a first year female associate over finding unwanted facial hair when there’s a possibility that she could otherwise had human contact reflects the depth of their world.  This alone should make you feel superior, as it reflects the most pathetic and infantile approach to life that one could imagine.  While cash might compensate for their immaturity before, the Biglaw crash will show them to be utterly empty vessels.  No one has any use for such insipid wastrels.

There will be, and is, pain in the criminal defense world, as legislatures fail to adequately fund indigent defense, and as caseloads grow and the qualifications for defendants to receive free legal services rise.  But at least you are still needed.  At least you still provide something meaningful to the legal system and to society.  And most importantly, at least you aren’t one of them.

For the time being at least, it looks like the good guys win a round.  Congratulations.

A Lawyer’s Lesson About Inflammatory Rhetoric

When I was a young criminal defense lawyer, I already had a fairly dedicated groups of clients who felt a sense of loyalty to me.  It was a good feeling, but one that I really didn’t appreciate as my influenced spanned the lawyer world into the criminal world.  I learned a very scary lesson.  I think John McCain may be learning that lesson too.

With a particularly loyal client sitting in my office chair, a nice maroon leather Chesterfield chair, I took a phone call.  The call was from a person with whom I was having some difficulties, and who was acting like a real jerk.  It was clear to anyone listening to my end of the call that I was getting increasingly angry with the other person, ultimately hanging up the phone in disgust.  As I did so, I uttered aloud that this person was someone who shouldn’t exist.

I then went on to discuss the case with my client.  At the end of the meeting, he was pleased with my efforts and we shook hands.  He had a broad smile on his face.  As he prepared to leave my office, he said, almost as an aside, “and don’t worry about that guy.  We’ll take care of him.” 

It hit me like a ton of bricks.  Yes, I was angry with this person, but never did I mean him any harm.  My client, on the other hand, understood such anger to mean that extreme action was warranted, and as a favor to me, he was happy to do so.  There was a monumental gap in understanding my intentions, and it was entirely my fault.

I explained to my client, clearly and unequivocally, that no matter how angry I was with someone, I would not wish harm to come to him.  Harm was never a solution to my problem, and I explained in excruciating detail that he was not to “take care of him” in any way whatsoever.

Had my client not said something on the way out the door, something very bad might have happened as a result of my thoughtlessness.  I understood then how cautious I had to be about what I said, and how horrible the consequences of my carelessness could be.

As the electoral race has devolved to inflammatory rhetoric and accusations that some will hear, regardless of what is intended, that Barak Obama (or Osama in some parts of New York), is the embodiment of evil, some people will react with a visceral hatred that they truly believe should be translated into action.  When one hears screams of “kill him” and “terrorist” from members of the crowd, it’s clear that the wrong message has been sent.  When others tell the candidate that Obama is an “Arab” and “Muslim” in an age where these words are tantamount to the murderous enemies in an ongoing war, it is no longer the whispered joke from Florida’s elderly counties. 

Like it or not, there are people out there, often believing themselves to be ultra-patriotic and thus prepared to do anything, anything, for the good of the nation, who will do harm.  When John McCain stopped the woman who told him that Barak Obama was an Arab and took the microphone away from him, it seemed that he had the epiphany.  The joke had gone too far.

While he explained that Obama was a “decent man with whom he had a strong disagreement on some issues,” certainly an effort to diffuse the glaringly erroneous belief, the question remained why McCain did not affirmatively say “Barak Obama is not an Arab or a Muslim.”  Those words were not spoken by candidate John McCain, and those are the words that should have been said.

Even as their are glimmers of the old John McCain, the man who wouldn’t say or do anything to stop the bleeding in his last ditch effort to be President, they are insufficient to clear up the misunderstandings that have been caused and promoted by his campaign staffers and his cute little Yorkie Terrier.  As they continue to put out inflammatory television advertising and whip up the crowds to connect Obama to terrorism, they are unconcerned with the potential consequences of their choices.

Why concern myself with McCain, and ignore Obama’s attacks?  Because there is no one in the Obama audience screaming out their desire to kill John McCain.  There’s nothing in the Obama attack ads suggesting that McCain as president needs killing.  They may claim he’ll make a terrible president, but not that he is an inherently dangerous and evil human being.  The kind that must be killed.

John McCain doesn’t want to be the match that lights the fuse of some lunatic who assassinates a President.  He may not care so much about causing a divisiveness within America that will manifest as four years of partisan hatred.  But he doesn’t want to go down in history as being the Angel of Death. 

But McCain does want to be President, and inflammatory rhetoric is the only cartridge left in his presidential shotgun.  The question is whether his desire to be President is stronger than his desire not to be the Angel of Death.  One might wonder whether winning the Presidency with such tactics is the way John McCain (the real John McCain) would want to do it, but things have gone too far already for consideration of such a subtlety.

While it isn’t John McCain’s fault that this country has people out there who will misinterpret his purpose and hear a message of hatred that commands violence, it is his fault when he knows that to be true and continues to fuel their hatred anyway. 

If he doesn’t want to be the Angel of Death, then he must explain with the same degree of clarity to these people that Barak Obama is not a dangerous and evil person who needs killing, is not an Arab, a Muslim or a terrorist who we are at war against, and that they had grossly misunderstood the message.  Anything less will not suffice.  And if anything happens to Barak Obama, he will bear responsibility.

Southampton Strip Search Policy is Just Plain Nasty

Score one for sanity.  The Town of Southampton on the eastern end of Long Island has a policy of strip searching (with extreme prejudice) all arrested females.  Not all males, mind you, but just women, and without regard to the reason for, or seriousness of, the charge against the women.  But then, it also has a policy of turning on a video camera whenever they strip search females, and broadcast the strip search throughout the police station.  Kinda like cheap entertainment for the troops.

But Stacey Hartline, 21 at the time, was not amused.  Via Newsday, Stacey was arrested for a “B” misdemeanor possession of marihuana (in New York, the law spells marijuana with an “h” instead o a “j”).


According to court papers, Hartline was stopped by a village officer because her truck was missing a rear license plate. The arresting officer said he saw a stem of a marijuana plant on the truck floor and a search found other bits of marijuana. Hartline said the officer never asked her if she had any marijuana or other contraband before arresting her.

Before moving on, let’s consider the claim that the officer observed a “stem of a marijuana plant on the truck floor.”  Anybody want to explain how the officer was capable of discerning that the stem was from a marijuana plant rather than some other plant?  But it appears that nobody discusses the possibility that this allegation is utterly ludicrous, and a wholesale fabrication.  But hey, this is the law, and even nonsense like this becomes real if no one complains about it.

So Stacey, whose stepfather just happens to be a detective in the neighboring town, decides to sue for violation of her civil rights.  The case goes to Eastern District Judge Dennis Hurley, who grants summary judgment to the Town and cops under the theory that they possessed a reasonable individualized suspicion that Stacey had secreted contraband so as to justify the need for a strip search.

Let’s make another pit stop at this point, for those who are confounded by the seeming anomaly between the fact that this strip search was not conducted because of any actual reason, but merely because of a blanket policy.  One of the joys of federal caselaw is that it ignores the real reason things are done, and allows the cops to come up with a pretend reason that never applied in order to justify their conduct.  This is another of those fabulous legal truths that bear no connection to reality, but rather give the police as many possible outs for this misconduct as possible.  Any excuse in a storm.

Despite this judicial largess, the Second Circuit reversed Judge Hurley in Hartline v. Gallo, rejecting Judge Hurley’s conclusion that there was “individualized suspicion” and concluding that there was essentially no basis at all for believing that Stacey should be strip searched. 


Ultimately, if the facts of this case amount to reasonable suspicion, then strip searches will become commonplace. Given the uniquely intrusive nature of strip searches, as well as the multitude of less invasive investigative techniques available to officers confronted by misdemeanor offenders, that result would be unacceptable in any society that takes privacy and bodily integrity seriously.

While the Circuit never says so, my read is that Judge Hurley tacitly crafted the drug/strip search exception to the 4th Amendment, meaning that any time someone is busted for possession of any drug, and here it was merely some alleged marijuana twigs and seeds, this alone provides a legitimate basis to look into dark places where the cops otherwise shouldn’t go. 

Another small detail within the decision, which the Circuit finds sufficient to include but never specifically discusses further, is this exchange between Hartline’s stepfather, Detective Stephen Wilson, and Southampton Chief of Police Jim Sherry:


This evidence included an official report of the incident submitted by Officer Donovan in which she described the strip search of Hartline as done “in the same manner that the undersigned conduct[s] searches of all defendants that are female,” and an affidavit of Hartline’s stepfather Stephen Wilson, who was a detective in a neighboring town attesting that when Wilson spoke soon after the incident to Southampton’s Chief of Police, Jim Sherry, Sherry acknowledged that all female prisoners are strip searched. In response to Wilson’s astonishment, Sherry added, “Steve, you are a cop, you should know . . . . [Y]ou know the guys do it.”

This reflects the part that disgusts me, and hopefully disgusted the Circuit panel as well.  No, strip searches of 21 year old women are not a perk of the job for the police.  This is just plain nasty, and the Circuit did well to reverse Judge Hurley and hold that Stacey Hartline was entitled to a trial.  Let’s hope that every ugly, nasty, disgusting aspect of this diseased policy is thoroughly aired, and let’s hope that the district court doesn’t try to hide the “irrelevant” aspects of what happened here from public scrutiny.

Miami Criminal Defense Lawyer Brian Tannenbaum’s “Truth”

The Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, reviews Miami criminal defense lawyer Brian Tannenbaum’s e-book, The Truth About Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer.  Don’t be put off by it being called a book.  It’s really more of a monograph, at 28 pages plus a nice pic of Brian at the back end. 

Brian asked Bennett to review it, and review it he does.  I wish Brian had asked me, as my scan following Bennett’s review suggests that I would have loved this piece as well.  But since I haven’t yet read it cover to cover, I defer to my Houston brother’s good judgment.

Here’s how Bennett sums it up:



Subtitled, “The whole truth and nothing but the truth, and not the ‘truth that will lead you to hire me.’”, this little book covers much the first-time accused needs to know to have at least a fighting chance of hiring competent counsel, in six chapters entitled:



  • Money (forget about your money problems, and get the money; hire a lawyer you feel comfortable with, who charges more money than you wanted to spend);
  • Advertising (advertising works; don’t fall for it);
  • Prior Results (no two cases are the same);
  • Expertise / Types of Criminal Defense Lawyers (”murder is a six-figure word”);
  • “Former Prosecutors” (if you choose to hire an ex-prosecutor, make sure it’s for his defense experience); and
  • Connections (we all know the judges, and the prosecutors, and probably the cops; none of them are going to sell out).

In the process of educating the public, Brian gives away some of the family secrets. For example:



Do not ever call a lawyer you are thinking of hiring and ask how much he charges. He will immediately think you are cheap, broke, and that you will waste his time in a consultation. On that note, don’t ever ask if there’s a consultation fee. That’s like saying “you’re not going to ask me for $500 are you?” A client who has a problem with $500 is again, perceived as cheap, broke, and a waste of a lawyer’s time.


I’m hooked.  Brian has put together the truth as any honest, competent defense lawyer knows it.  There are some tiny details where I might quibble, such as Brian’s suggestion that clients bring in a little something for the staff whenever they show for an appointment.  I’ll take care of my own staff, and clients needn’t bother.  Be respectful to them, as they must be respectful to the client. 

But there’s no need to butter them up.  In my office, the staff owes the client far more than the client owes the staff.  Without the client, the staff would be sitting home watching The View, so the client has saved them from that horrible punishment.

Mark’s quibble with “high-profile” cases is also worth noting.  Bennett says:


[A]n accused goes shopping for a lawyer armed with the delusive belief that his case is a high-profile (”high-pub”, in the argot) case and that he needs a lawyer who specializes in such cases. Some lawyers even make this part of their schtick. In my experience, the vast majority of people who think their cases are high-profile are engaged in egoistical wishful thinking: “if it’s so important to me, it must be important to everyone else.”

True, and something Brian should consider adding to the second edition.  A corollary is the belief that lawyers who are “household names” are inherently better than lawyers whose names you don’t know.  Another inside secret: Some of the best known lawyers are ridiculed within the profession for being incompetent show-ponies, brilliant at self-promotion and awful at law.  Can you tell?  Just because a name is well known to the public means nothing when it comes to their abilities as a lawyer.  As Bennett explains, real high-profile guys do everything in their power to keep their cases out of the media, putting their client’s interest ahead of self-promotion.

Bennett endorses Brian’s e-book, The Truth About Hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer with an incisive point:


Brian provides an excellent introduction to the task of hiring a criminal defense lawyer. I recommend it to anyone looking to hire his first criminal defense lawyer. Or his second, though getting the right lawyer after you’ve already hired the wrong one is much more costly than getting it right the first time.

I might even take this a step farther.  No matter how much you, the client, think you know about hiring a lawyer, it’s still worth your time to read this and absorb it’s message.  There’s far more in there that will benefit you in hiring and maintaining an appropriate and professional relationship with your lawyer.  Ultimately, it’s all to the client’s benefit to know how best to protect yourself.  Great job, Brian.

Let’s Close Wall Street’s Doors for a Week or Two (Update)

Watching the Dow on the back side of the roller coaster is a sickening experience.  What makes it worse is that it’s not a rational thing, like the law of gravity that forces a roller coaster to fall, but an emotional/psychological thing where a bunch of people in ugly vests pretend to see the future and bet the farm on it.  And it’s our farm they’re betting.

One dirty little secret has been revealed.  The geniuses who run our financial and investment systems don’t really know what they are doing.  They talk as if they do.  They act as if they do.  But they don’t.  Which is why they are doing just as poorly as the rest of us.  They tell us that they have answers, but their answers don’t work.  Then they have new answers.  And they don’t work either.  So they come up with more answers. 

We keep paying for their answers, and losing at an ever-increasing pace the monies we earned, invested and expect to someday enjoy.  So much for the contention that Americans don’t save enough.  To the extent we did, it’s gone.  So who was smarter, the person who saved or the person who spent and enjoyed?  At the end of the journey, neither one is looking so smart, but at least one group enjoyed themselves.  The other?  We’re gasping for breath right now.

So I offer a proposition.  It’s not a solution, but more of an admission of reality.  Let’s take a time out.  Let’s stop trading equities worldwide, acknowledging that we haven’t got a clue what is happening and have no basis to buy or sell anything at the moment.  To keep the markets open and functioning is to engage in sheer recklessness.  They are moving blind, without any idea of what direction to go, and ultimately acting out of mindless fear. 

It’s foolish to lose trillions of dollars of apparent investment from the system, and thus generate ever-increasing fear and anger for the general public, when there is no fundamental reason for it.  Let’s just call it a long weekend, bypass the subway stops at Wall Street, and close the doors of the New York Stock Exchange for a week or two.  Let’s give those who have official charge of the system a chance to catch their breath, think things through and come up with a way to stabilize the system. 

They say that closing doors will cause panic.  Do we not have panic already?  Would it cause greater panic to say that we need to retrench, put some hard thought into how to deal with a transitory problem and not go back until we have some real answers?  It strikes me that this would be appreciated by the public, and not cause them to run screaming to their banks to take out all their money. 

The biggest problem would be that Wall Streeters would not be generating any commissions if we closed the doors.  They might have to take a week or two of vacation without pay.  Bummer.  I think we could live with this.  I think they could as well, and might prefer it over the other option of being in the Lehman Brothers bread line.

What keeps running through my head is that nothing has changed really.  We are still healthy, and have hands to build things to sell to each other.  We have plenty of houses that are empty, but plenty of people to fill them.  They aren’t going to be worth what they were a few years ago, but they will still keep people warm and keep the rain off the heads of beloved children.

In the midst of litigation, when a particularly vexing problem arises, a judge will ask for briefs, take them under advisement and adjourn for a period of time necessary to consider the question.  He will deliberate, and the litigation will wait until the judge has had a chance to render a decision.  I realize that finances aren’t law, and that law isn’t perfect by a long shot, but this may not be an unreasonable analogy.

Why not close the doors for a week or two, let everyone step back and catch their breath, and do nothing else until somebody has a clue how to address our financial system?  What benefit is there to allow things to go as usual and cause needless and irrational market swings to make everyone miserable while providing nothing useful in return?

Why not?

Update:  The Dow swung over 1000 points today for the first time in its history.  To what end?  All that to close down 128?  I don’t get nearly enough appreciation as a financial guru.  Hello?  Anybody listening?

McCain: Frank and Dodd are Criminal Co-Conspirators

This just in from John McCain’s lips at a Waukesha, Wisconsin town hall meeting, with his sidekick, Sarah Palin.  When asked by a realtor in the audience if he would go after, prosecute, and name names of those criminals responsible for causing the housing crisis, John McCain said he would.  The meeting was broadcast on CNN.


“And you know the names…Congressman Barney Frank and Senator Chris Dodd were willing co-conspirators.”

Unless I’m mistaken, McCain has just alleged that they were not merely wrong in their positions, but were part of a criminal conspiracy.  Anybody from Justice listening?   Perhaps you could have your crack investigators try to locate these two dangerous accused felons and arrest them.  Now that would certainly make for some interesting pre-election news.

But did Candidate McCain actually mean to say that these two government officials are criminals?  Or was that John McCain naming names of people in the Democratic party so that the public will stop looking at the Republicans as being responsible for the fiscal disaster?

One should be a little cautious in making criminal accusations.  I hope McCain was throwing these accusations around lightly.

Wiretaps are Great for Parties

Well, all you security and anti-terrorism fans, that didn’t take long.  Brian Ross at ABC News reveals that those secret telephone intercepts that our government just had to do to protect us from terrorism turns out to be a hoot for our bored government employees.  So much for our President’s promise that “that will never happen.”



Despite pledges by President George W. Bush and American intelligence officials to the contrary, hundreds of US citizens overseas have been eavesdropped on as they called friends and family back home, according to two former military intercept operators who worked at the giant National Security Agency (NSA) center in Fort Gordon, Georgia.



“These were just really everyday, average, ordinary Americans who happened to be in the Middle East, in our area of intercept and happened to be making these phone calls on satellite phones,” said Adrienne Kinne, a 31-year old US Army Reserves Arab linguist assigned to a special military program at the NSA’s Back Hall at Fort Gordon from November 2001 to 2003.



Kinne described the contents of the calls as “personal, private things with Americans who are not in any way, shape or form associated with anything to do with terrorism.”



She said US military officers, American journalists and American aid workers were routinely intercepted and “collected on” as they called their offices or homes in the United States.


The problem is that monitoring telephone calls is kind of boring.  Unless, the calls happen to be funny, especially “phone sex” type calls, which are really funny to everyone except the American soldier who thinks he’s having a private conversation with his wife.  While the soldier would likely be remarkably unhappy about it, it seems that the interceptor is having so much fun listening that he can’t help but share it with the rest of the guys:


Faulk says he and others in his section of the NSA facility at Fort Gordon routinely shared salacious or tantalizing phone calls that had been intercepted, alerting office mates to certain time codes of “cuts” that were available on each operator’s computer.


“Hey, check this out,” Faulk says he would be told, “there’s good phone sex or there’s some pillow talk, pull up this call, it’s really funny, go check it out. It would be some colonel making pillow talk and we would say, ‘Wow, this was crazy’,” Faulk told ABC News.

But this could never happen.  Never.  The government swore that it would only listen to calls to protect me from terrorism.  They never even mentioned listening in on fun calls too.

So what does our respected and trusted top NSA official have to say?


The director of the NSA, Lt. General Keith B. Alexander, declined to directly answer any of the allegations made by the whistleblowers.


In a written statement, Gen. Alexander said: “We have been entrusted to protect and defend the nation with integrity, accountability, and respect for the law. As Americans, we take this obligation seriously. Our employees work tirelessly for the good of the nation, and serve this country proudly.”

Well, now I feel better.  Don’t you?

H/T Turley and Dan Solove

Herring Argument Went Great! So we Lost?

When the Supreme Court granted cert in United State v. Herring, a shiver ran down my spine.  This was the sort of case that could easily end in disaster, implicating the conflicting problems of a law enforcement incompetence and a search that revealed drugs and a gun.  This is a volatile combination.  The facts in Herring are:


In this instance, officers in Coffee County, Ala., arrested a man, Bennie Dean Herring, in 2004 after being informed by the Sheriff’s Department in neighboring Dale County that he was the subject of an outstanding warrant. But the warrant, although still in Dale County’s computerized database, had in fact been withdrawn five months earlier. In the 10 or 15 minutes it took for the Dale County officers to realize their error, the Coffee County officers had already stopped Mr. Herring, handcuffed him, and searched him and his truck, finding methamphetamine and an unloaded pistol.

The Supremes heard oral argument this week, and accounts of the argument provided two insights.  According to Orin Kerr :


It was very engaging argument with two excellent advocates, Pam Karlan for Herring and Michael Dreeben for the United States, and the Justices were in top form. Karlan did her best in her opening argument, but Roberts, Alito, and Scalia were relentless. Mid-way through Dreeben’s argument, it was looking like the case was over: The Justices were debating the best way to write the opinion to affirm.

So how did Pam Karlan go so wrong?  Well, it appears that she didn’t.  Not at all, in fact.  From the transcript of oral argument comes this exchange:


CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: So, you would impose a burden on the officer on the street serving a warrant? When he gets the call saying there’s a warrant, he’s supposed to say, “Are you sure? Did you double-check with the clerk? When was the last time they updated the computer system? I don’t want to go through all this if the evidence is going to be suppressed.” At every chain in command, you would impose that burden.
 
MS. KARLAN: No, I would not, Mr. Chief Justice, because if you announce that police error is going to lead to the suppression of evidence, the police will do a better job of maintaining their records.

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: Yes, but I mean I don’t know what the situation is like —

MS. KARLAN: And then you won’t have this problem.

CHIEF JUSTICE ROBERTS: I don’t know what the situation is like in Dale County. They probably don’t have the latest version of WordPerfect, or whatever it is. They are probably making do with whatever they can under their budget and doing the best they can.

MS. KARLAN: But there’s not a Barney Fife defense to the violation of the Fourth Amendment either.

One of the best lines I can remember in a Supreme Court oral argument. 

Why, one might inquire, would Chief Justice Roberts concern himself with the quality of WordPerfect in Dale County?  What business is it of the Supreme Court to adjust its expectations of police under the 4th Amendment to the competency limitations of some local yokel police department?  Does the protection of the Constitution vary in direct inverse proportion to the software budget of law enforcement?

Rarely will we see such a fundamentally misguided focus.  The Constitution wasn’t adopted to protect the reasonably incompetent cop’s ability to screw-up.  It was adopted to protect citizens against the government, which includes the best law enforcement officer as well as Barney Fife.

If there is, in fact, no basis to search an individual, then how does a person’s right (note the word, “right”) to be left alone succumb to the government’s error?

From an incentive standpoint, this encourages the government to be sloppy rather than diligent.  Is this a conservative goal?  Would our Supreme Court not prefer to have police do their job properly? 

The apparent answer is that the Supremes are focused on police who violate the 4th Amendment malevolently, not negligently.  This is based upon its tacit disdain for suppression of evidence, considered too drastic a remedy in the absence of overt deliberate police misconduct.  Since suppression is supposed to be a deterrent, there is nothing to deter if the mistake is accidental.  Stercus accidit, right?

But what about the citizen, who has done no wrong to be subject to a search by the government?  Orin, in his first discussion of Herring, suggested that the outcome depended upon the definition of “who are the police?”  In my view, this isn’t the right question.  The question is who is the government, as the 4th Amendment prohibition against unreasonable searches and seizures is a right of the people against the government.  Nowhere does the 4th Amendment limit its protections to the police.  And when it comes to the “police” as a concept, every person in government is an appendage, not merely the ones wearing a uniform and a shield.

But all of this doesn’t appear to matter to the Supreme Court. Instead, we can look forward to the Barney Fife exception, as if the 4th Amendment didn’t have enough exceptions already.