The first Monday in October is only a big thing for lawyers. Most of the time. This time, however, it’s huge for everybody, though it’s not yet clear that the rest of the country realizes it. In fact, it’s not clear that lawyers realize it, even criminal defense lawyers.
As this court-o-rama run down of the upcoming Supreme Court term, opening today with all the pomp and circumstance of a middle school health day assembly, shows, there isn’t a whole lot on the docket that will crank up the criminal defense bar. And yet, this may be the biggest day we have in a generation. No, there isn’t any Heller lurking in the wings, and Gideon isn’t up for reconsideration.
Up to now, political discussion has largely ignored the impact that the next president will have on the make-up of the court. The constitution of the Constitution is decidedly unsexy when pocketbooks are at stake. But the say will pass when the crisis is left out of the dialogue, and we’ll still be plying our trade in the trenches.
Today stands to be the one day when the main stream media, usually referred to these days as MSM, three letters used as a derogatory expression of Karl Rove’s view of uncooperative media, will talk about the Court. Today’s New York Times’ lead editorial is all about the opening of the term. Will anybody care?
The next appointee or two will either cause a major shift toward a constitutional view that order trumps law, cops trump criminals, procedure trumps substance and security trumps freedom. The new view will predominate for at least a generation, and will remain as a yoke around our collective necks for far longer due to our lawyerly love of stare decisis. Our indoctrination to elevate precedent over right is hard to shake.
The discussion of the court has centered on one case for so long that it has come to represent the entirety of the issue to most Americans. Indeed, one vice-presidential candidates can’t name a single other case. Ironically, the iconic decision, Roe v. Wade, is one of the worst reasoned decisions in the history of the court, and yet the fundamental rights of a nation hinge on it.
Even though Roe has nothing to do per se with criminal law, the connection between the social policy incorporated in the decision has traditionally gone hand in hand with the view that personal freedom must be protected in the face of a society that would happily forfeit all of your rights for their safety, convenience and moral point of view. It disturbs me greatly that the only interest an ordinary person has in the judicial philosophy of a potential justice is whether he would reverse Roe v. Wade.
But since we can’t seem to get people to care otherwise, we’ll have to take it where we can.
If the first Monday in October can’t generate a little interest and discussion about how the choice of president will affect the Supreme Court of the United States, then I doubt anything else will between now and the election. I’m not terribly sanguine about the Democratic candidate’s position, but I am downright fearful of the Republican’s.
I realize that there are many who feel similarly about constitutional rights and freedoms, but who have other interests that cause them to prefer the candidate who has sworn to turn the court to the very far right. The trade-offs are always hard. The court composition is just not the primary concern this time around for many people, as it is for me and perhaps many other criminal defense lawyers.
So let’s see if the discussion happens today, the first Monday in October. If it doesn’t, then it will not happen at all, and the outcome of the election will be determined by other interests and concerns, with the appointment of the next few supreme court justices playing no role.
Either way, we will live with the consequences. It would be far better, in my view, for America to consider those consequences rather than just suffer them as an aside to some transitory issue for which no one has an answer.
Author Archives: SHG
Worth Doing Right
As I was packing up a hard disk drive to ship to Larry Daniel yesterday, I was asked why I make it look so clean and professional. I fell back on the old adage, anything worth doing is worth doing right. But this has a curious application to the world of the solo practitioner, for whom doing things right presents a dilemma because it comes as a cost.
One of the first observations one has of Biglaw is that they look professional. They look good. From their yellow pads to their redwelds with their firm name on the top, they exude professionalism. They always have pristine looking exhibit tabs at the bottom of their papers, and even their 32 file copies of papers use original bluebacks. They look good.
For the solo, these things can present issues. Everything costs money, and somebody has to pay that money to get the good stuff. For the solo, there’s no diffusion of expense, spread around 3000 partners and associates so that no one feels like it comes out of their personal pocket. They can spend like drunken sailors without the slightest concern that it will reduce their take-home at all. Solos feel differently.
Every expense comes straight off the bottom line. We pay it. We feel it. It’s our net revenue that pays the price of some fancy legal pad. And as every solo knows, the name on the top of the legal pad doesn’t make the writing on the page any more insightful. We follow the sage advice of Benjamin Franklin that a penny saved is a penny earned.
But this frugality is often misconstrued to mean that we can present ourselves as a low rent operation. That’s a grievous mistake. Being solo has no correlation with being unprofessional. I’ve seen many friends slide down that slippery slope of trying to save money at the expense of maintaining as professional a practice as any Biglaw firm in Manhattan. The two are not mutually exclusive.
Much of the appearance of professionalism comes at a relatively high cost (such as redwelds with your name on them) relative to their benefit. But that doesn’t mean that you should walk into court with a plain manila folder with ragtag papers hanging out of both sides and scribbles covering the front and back. Save the worthless cost of vanity printing, but get the tools necessary to walk into the courtroom with the same professional appearance as any big firm lawyer. This isn’t frivolous, but a critical piece of the providing the representation your clients rightfully expect.
While there is truth to the proposition that appearances have no inherent correlation with competence or quality of representation, appearances do impact perception, including the judge and adversary, as well as the client and his family and friends. If you go to court in a shabby, tattered, ill-fitting poly-blend suit, with black Nike referee-sneakers where shoes ought to be, you will be treated as you deserve. You may be sufficiently well-known despite your sartorial challenges to overcome the deficit, but you will most assuredly not receive the same immediate respect given a lawyer walking into a courtroom who looks like a million bucks. If you think this false, you’re deluding yourself.
The same is true of your work product, which is a reflection of your pride, attention to detail and, yes, competency. When papers go out with old, mangled, reused exhibit tabs, it sends a message. I reuse exhibit tabs like any other solo, but only the ones that remain clean and unbent. The nasty ones get deep sixed. They don’t reflect who I am as a lawyer. I save where I can, but not at the expense of looking slovenly. I take enormous pride in my work, and I will not allow that to be undermined by carelessness in appearance.
Pick and choose amongst the many bells and whistles available to lawyers to allow us to present ourselves as we want. We don’t need to compete with Biglaw for the stupid stuff, the pure vanity that compels them to bill their clients like there’s no bottom to the pit. Recognizing what makes you appear professional and focusing your efforts on maintaining a highly professional appearance adds only a minor cost while producing significant dividends.
Mostly, it’s a frame of mind. It’s about caring about everything you do. It’s about paying attention to detail. Every detail. It comes back to the old adage, if it’s something worth doing, it’s worth doing right. Just do it right.
Women Blawg Just Fine
Since I don’t think in terms of who blawgers are as much as what they have to say, the thought hadn’t occurred to me. But C.C. Holland at Law.com asks, “Where Are All the Female Law Bloggers?” The question, obviously, suggests that they are missing. Anne Reed, Niki Black, Anne Skove, Carolyn Elefant, Susan Cartier Liebel, Blonde Justice and many others. They are all women, as far as I can tell, and I read everything they post.
Granted, Ruthie fell off the face of the earth, but that was only after her spurned love for Charon QC, and the vicious advances of Geeklawyer, all deeply personal and hardly reflective of a trend. But it doesn’t matter, since Holland is unaware that the blawgosphere crosses borders and oceans, so drama amongst female British blawgers plays no role in her analysis.
But as Holland points out, in the broader blawgosphere, there appear to be more men than woman blawging.
Sites such as Above the Law (David Lat), How Appealing (Howard J. Bashman) and Balkinization (Jack M. Balkin) are each authored or edited by one man. The China Law Blog is written by Dan Harris and Steve Dickinson of Harris & Moure. The Volokh Conspiracy, another popular law blog, list 18 contributors, none of whom are female. The woman blogger whose name comes up most frequently in the legal space is law professor Ann Althouse, but her blog isn’t primarily about legal issues.
So what’s behind this seeming disparity?
This universe of six blogs falls a bit short of proof. But Holland notes some statistics:
Joe Hodnicki, co-founder of the Law Professor Blogs Network and co-editor of the Law Librarian Blog, says about 30 percent of his network’s 100 or so bloggers are female law professors.
BlawgWorld 07’s list of the 77 most influential “blawgs” (legal blogs) includes just 13 (16.8 percent) authored by women.
LexMonitor’s directory of AmLaw 200 blogs, approximately 157 of the blogs’ individually named contributors are male, but only 48 — or 23 percent — are female.
I’m beginning to see part of Holland’s problem. She is stuck in the BigBlawg frame of reference, meaning those handful of blawgs that make it onto the radar of clueless people who know squat about blawging. Yet, that doesn’t mean she isn’t right, even if she hasn’t proven it.
Despite her lack of basis, Holland pursues three theories to explain the “no women ’round here” phenomenon. One explanation is that proffered by Holland is that women don’t have time to blawg, because they are too busy with family responsibilities.
Another explanation is that it’s more dangerous for women to blawg, as they are more likely to be subject to personal attacks than men. The corollary to this is that women can’t handle the negative reactions, ranging from “I disagree” to “you’re an idiot” to threats of violence.
But the explanation I find far more reasonable is that:
Women law bloggers are out there, you just don’t see them. “There are more women (law) bloggers than you think,” says Carolyn Elefant, an attorney in private practice who writes the MyShingle blog (and is a Law.com blogger as well). “I think they predominate in the practical blogosphere. I think this myth of there being fewer female bloggers got started because the focus was more on the big-name sites, which tended to be (run by) men.”
Carolyn understands something that Holland appears not to get at all. You don’t just “open a blawg” and go on the Johnny Carson show the next night as the toast of the blawgosphere. It doesn’t work that way for anyone, male or female. Note that Carolyn refers to the “practical blogosphere,” a phrase coined by the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, distinguishing us second-wave blawgers, practicing lawyers who post about real life experiences and issues as opposed to the academic blawgers who monopolized the first wave of blawging.
Holland misconstrues the issue by considering it as a problem:
One explanation for the apparent lack of female voices is that while they’re out there, they’re not as well-promoted as the male bloggers. “Folks tend to link to their friends, and it’s especially hard for a newer blogger to break into that closed circle,” says Dudziak.
“Trying to get links requires being a little extroverted,” says Kimberly Amick, co-author of the California Appellate Law Blog and a senior associate at Archer Norris. “It can be a little intimidating, but it’s really no different than walking up to someone and shaking their hand.”
And, says Hodnicki, “It’s a crowded blogosphere now, so it’s harder to acquire an audience.”
So who exactly is “well-promoting” male blawgers but leaving the females in the dust? And does Amick really think that you get links by asking for them? I don’t think this is what either meant, but it’s how Holland misinterpreted their words.
Hodnicki is right, the blawgosphere is getting crowded, which means that weak blawgs will not get readers and will not survive. This is how it should be. This is pure meritocracy. No one can make someone go to a blawg and read. They do it only if they want to. And it doesn’t matter how many links you have from friends, if the content sucks, no one will come back. Anyone can blawg, but not everyone will survive.
As for blawging “friends”, we make them all the time, not because we physically hang out and have a beer with them, but because we read their stuff and appreciate it. That’s how friendships happen, and I have NEVER seen anyone care if the blawger is male or female, white or black, tall or short. That’s because it’s all about the posts, and we never actually see or touch anyone. I can’t tell if another blawger is tall or short, gay or straight, so there is no inherent bias at all. I can ignore someone just like me as well as someone completely different, if they don’t have the goods.
There is no barrier to entry to the blawgosphere. All it takes is a dollar and a dream (literally) to become a blawger. But after that, it’s purely a matter of creating content that someone wants to read. All the friends in the world won’t overcome lack of content or bad content. No one opens a blawg and proclaims, “I’m male, read me.”
I offer no explanation for the phenomenon of there being fewer women blawgers, if that is in fact the case. It can be a tough gig, but if women want to blawg, I say blawg. Many, perhaps most, of the new blawgs that will appear in the next year will not attract a following. They didn’t last year either.
But as far as I can see, there are some darn good female blawgers who can hold their own with any male in the blawgosphere, if not beat most of them to a pulp. Too bad Holland doesn’t know they exist. I do.
13 Years to the Day After (Update)
So they finally got O.J.
Late yesterday afternoon, a Vegas jury returned a verdict of guilty against O.J. Simpson and his last remaining co-defendant, Clarence Stewart. Kidnapping and armed robbery replaced the conviction for murder. It may not be enough, but it’s better than nothing. O.J. was remanded awaiting his December 5th sentence.
The verdict, which comes 13 years to the day after Mr. Simpson was acquitted in the highly publicized murders of his ex-wife and her friend, concluded a four-week trial that many have seen as a proxy for those unsatisfied by that 1995 outcome.
This trial, over whether O.J. and his gang of 5 intended to rob two sports memorabilia dealers in a Vegas hotel room, sparked little interest. But then, this wasn’t the old O.J. of the “H’s”, Heisman Trophy and Hertz Rent-a-Car. This was the O.J. who got away with it.
I didn’t follow the trial any more than most, though I heard enough to know that the prosecution relied upon rat testimony of his own peeps, which offered that they not only had guns, but that one said it was at O.J.’s request. That means that O.J. knew about the guns, that were supposedly pulled upon entry into the hotel room.
One doesn’t usually need to pull guns to retrieve ones own personal items. But then, who said there was anything usual about this. After all, if “usual” was the touchstone, most of us don’t have personal memorabilia that would interest anyone besides our kids, and then only briefly.
On the other side, if O.J. was going to get 5 of his closest friends to pull off a hotel room heist, why go with them? His face is somewhat recognizable, and he’s more than a bit notorious. It’s possible that he’s just a self-absorbed moron, who forget that he’s the object of derision 13 years later, but I suspect he’s not. At least not a moron.
But the 800 pound gorilla in the room was always the same, the acquitted murder of his wife. There can be rational person who doubts that this influenced people. On the other hand, there was likely nothing the judge could do to alter the smell of death in the courtroom. And certainly, this taint was no reason to give O.J. a free pass on any future crimes. It was a tough situation.
His attorney, Yale Galanter, said:
“We knew this was going to be very difficult, we knew the jury was going to be very difficult, we knew the jurisdiction would be very difficult.”
For O.J., there was no choice. Adding to his problems, there were no blacks on the jury. They were all probably working a showgirls and croupiers and couldn’t get the time off. For Galanter, you take your cases where you find them, and try to do what you can. Representing high profile defendants, and losing, really stinks.
The co-defendant, Clarence Stewart, 54, was put in an interesting and untenable position by the curse of O.J.
Throughout the trial, Mr. Stewart’s attorney E. Brent Bryson asked repeatedly for Mr. Stewart to receive a separate trial because associating with Mr. Simpson was poisonous to the defense. Each of his severance motions was denied.
“If there was ever a trial in the history of American jurisprudence that should have been severed, it was obviously this trial,” a stunned and dazed Mr. Bryson said. “There’s a spillover effect here. There’s a gentleman by the name of O.J. Simpson who was sitting across the table. Mr. Simpson has a certain history that followed him into the courtroom and, unfortunately, it engulfed Mr. Stewart also.”
As my Alaskan buddy, Sarah Palin, would say, “you betcha.” The spillover prejudice to Stewart was palpable from the start, and there was little way he couldn’t be tainted by the smell. But judicial economy, trying to cases where the evidence is the same so that a judge’s time wouldn’t be wasted by doing it twice, always trumps fairness. In the scheme of important courtroom concerns, the judge’s time is paramount.
Appeals will be forthcoming, of course, and perhaps the appellate court gods will not feel the pressure to make O.J. pay for the murder of his wife. Whether there are good appellate issues remains to be seen. Without having followed the trial closely, I wouldn’t know.
What’s most troubling about this is that O.J. Simpson was acquitted of that murder, after the most highly public, most highly scrutinized trial ever. But O.J. was convicted of murder in the court of public opinion, and from that there is no appeal.
Update: I just happened to turn on MSNBC and saw two very pretty young women, one a defense lawyer and the other a “former prosecutor,” apparently no longer working, discussing this case. The hostess asked them to “read the tea leaves.” They were happy to do so, in a puppy like way with heads a-bobbin.
Who are these young women? Why are they announcing the O.J. is going to lose on appeal (“because a jury found them guilty, and no court is going to ignore that”)? How about, “how should I know, I wasn’t there.” But that would make for bad TV.
And we wonder why the public understands so little about the criminal justice system.
Does Your Tushie Hurt?
At the final seconds of the house vote, as it became clear that the bailout was going to pass, the Dow was up around 250 points. It closed today down 157, about a 400 point swing.
Within minutes after coverage of the vote concluded, CNN had some amorphous female explaining that the bailout wasn’t going to save this country, but was necessary to keep the recession at “very bad” rather than “very, very bad.” “And of course, this is just the beginning,” she said with a sincere look on her 30ish looking face. “It’s going to cost us a lot more. A LOT more.”
So are all the people who argued with the utmost sincerity that this was the solution, that this had to be done, that this would stave off the crisis, happy now? You got what you wanted. And the rest of us got punked.
Why did the Dow fall 400 points? Was it just the old Wall Street maxim, buy the rumor, sell the news? Or is it “what have you done for us lately?” They got their bailout, and now they’re on to their next demand. The junkies will always need another fix. That’s just how junkies are.
Our economy is in the toilet, of this there is no doubt. Did you really think they would be happy with $700 billion? Did you really think this would stop once they knew that we would blink? This isn’t economics. This is psychology.
And which of our presidential candidates knows what to do to fix it? That’s right, neither one has a clue. Whaddaya think, Champ? I dunno, Joe. It’s all so cute, like there are real people inside.
Much as I try, I can’t remember all the Wall Street pundits talking about how this $700 billion was just the beginning, barely an appetizer to the huge 7 course dinner ahead. I can’t remember them saying that this infusion wasn’t going to actually do anything. I seem to recall people talking about how we had to do this to avert the crisis.
Avert the crisis? Apparently, this wasn’t to avert the crisis. This was a test to see how gullible we were, how easily our government and people could be manipulated and played. How just a little fear, coupled with vague hints of impending disaster, would make the toughest people shake, the smartest people spout drivel. And we passed the test! We proved that we can be as dumb and scared as any society on the planet. We can be cowed by the merest hint of crisis. America, the land of dumb and afraid.
To borrow from good old H.L. Mencken, we’re got what we deserved, good and hard. Are you happy now?
The Court is Persuaded. So What?
United States District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan was said to be the type of judge who wouldn’t put up with government shenanigans. Time to re-evaluate. This is a prime example, for numerous reasons, of what’s fundamentally wrong with the application of due process in general, and Brady in particular. What makes this example particularly spectacular is that it involves the trial of a United States Senator. If a Senator can’t get a fair shake, then who?
This is the second Brady issue arising from the Stevens trial. This time, the government turned over redacted witness statements that omitted the parts that contradicted the government’s argument. After all, who wants the other side to know that you’re lying, right? This follows on the heels of sending the witness with favorable information for the defense off to Alaska because of failing health. That sure made sense.
Slater at the WSJ Law Blog was all over this yesterday, from the initial arguments for mistrial and dismissal to the ultimate ruling. But the story is made clearer by the Washington Post :
“Although the court is persuaded there is a . . . violation, the court is not persuaded that dismissal of the indictment or mistrial is the appropriate remedy,” said U.S. District Judge Emmet G. Sullivan. He added that the government’s actions had broken his trust in the prosecutors and ordered them to give Stevens’s attorneys copies of all witness interviews.
“The court has no confidence in the government’s ability” to meet its obligations to ensure a fair trial, he said.
And…so…the court did what? Ordered the prosecutors to provide the unredacted statements that they should have provided in the first place. Woo hoo!
To clarify how goofy this is, consider the following: The government is required to provide all information that is exculpatory to the defendant or can be used to impeach the testimony of a government witness, all falling under the rule of Brady v. Maryland, and known as Brady Material. The government has some. The government makes a deliberate decision, as evidenced by the act of redaction, to conceal this from the defense.
The trial proceeds. During the trial, the defense fortuitously (it’s always fortuitous) learns that Brady material exists. The government tried to break the law and got caught. The remedy is a vicious tongue lashing and an order to do what the government was supposed to do in the first place, even though the defense has now been irreparably harmed by the concealment of the Brady material.
So now, you inquire, how exactly does this remedy provide an incentive to the government not to break the law, since the only thing it does it require them to do what they should have done in the first place?
It doesn’t.
Then you ask, how exactly does this undo the damage to the defense, which has prepared its theory, its case, its witnesses, its opening, its cross-examination, based upon the disclosures made by the government as to what their witnesses will say?
It doesn’t.
Finally, you question whether the judge might be more concerned that the trial proceed at all costs, despite his expressed outrage and conclusion that the government has failed to fulfill their legal duties, than anything else.
You think?
Like I said, if even a Senator can’t get a fair shake, then what are the chances for the rest of us?
How Low Can We Go?
Having been raised on the Walter Cronkite school of news, I have certain expectations of decorum in an interview broadcast on a major network. I cannot recall ever watching one that devolved to the level of Bill O’Reilly’s interview of Rep. Barney Frank. It is outrageous.
Putting aside the issue of whether Barney Frank was right, wrong or otherwise about Fannie and Freddie, the manner in which Bill O’Reilly addressed a guest invited onto his show, who is a member of Congress, was beyond disgraceful. The vitriol was beyond anything I’ve ever seen before, making this the single lowest point in political discourse with the media. Ever.
Initially, O’Reilly is the host of a television program that purports to present the news. As the host, he has a great deal of control over how the voice of his guests are presented, both by way of normal courtesy as well as the dials on the microphones. A host does not scream at a guest that he’s a coward and a liar.
Understand, this does not mean that a host cannot pursue things he believes to be untrue, disingenuous or deceptive. But pursing these matters does not mean that the host gets to act like an animal. Bill O’Reilly behaved like an animal.
Barney Frank, whether you love him or hate him, is a Congressman. Remember those who railed about respecting the presidency even if you don’t like the President? That would be, uh, O’Reilly? Well, the same is true for a member of Congress as well. Who is O’Reilly to speak this way to anyone?
The level of public discourse took a damaging blow with this exchange. Perhaps “Joe Sixpack” thinks O’Reilly a hero, for screaming like a lunatic at Barney Frank, since that’s the way Joe makes his point. But it’s a mere few steps from Joe getting all riled up over this sort of public exchange with an elected official, pulling out his shotgun and blowing a hole in this lying coward.
I’ve written in the past that I believe that physical attacks on judges are a direct reaction to the neocons ripping the judiciary off the bench and vilifying them for decisions they don’t like. Once the cloak of respect has been ripped away, they are fair game for every nutjob with a weapon.
This is one of the most dangerous attributes of the media, and the influence of the media on public perception cannot be understated. O’Reilly plays to an audience that is already frothing at the mouth, looking for any opportunity to justify the seething hatred they have for those whom they blame for their miserable existence. His conduct is intolerable. He is a danger to democracy, not because of his beliefs but because he is a despicable animal.
As a postscript, I found this O’Reilly video at Crime & Federalism. Mike has taken a rather bizarre view of politics lately, closer to anarchy than anything else. It seems that he believes everyone in government is a liar. Not merely wrong, but sociopathic. This is what Mike has to say about the video:
Barney Frank is amazing. He’s makes great points – if only he were telling the truth. His lack of shame and ability to remain clam while lying is strong evidence of his sociopathy.
Mike’s conclusion that Frank is lying is an article of faith lately. He has fallen under the spell of the American Enterprise Institute, which has become his primary source of credible information. I don’t know who is lying, or if anyone is lying. But regardless, O’Reilly’s conduct is inexcusable. Mike didn’t seem to be troubled by it at all.
OT: My Delivery Issues with Newsday
I receive a number of newspapers delivered to my home each morning. Not surprisingly, each is delivered by a different carrier. One carrier, far more so than any other, presents problems, and that would be my Newsday delivery. This has long raised an issue between me and Newsday. When they fail to deliver a paper, what are the damages?
The typical response, delivered with a sweet computerized voice, is to credit me for the missed delivery. If missing a paper was a rare occurrence, it would likely be more than sufficient. But it had been a regular occurrence for me, and so I sat down one day and gave it some thought. Here’s what I came up with:
I contract with Newsday for home delivery. I assume a duty to pay the monthly cost of the paper. They assume the duty to have a paper waiting for me at the end of my driveway every morning. I am entitled to rely on Newsday sitting quietly on the edge of my driveway when I go out to pick it up. That’s why I contract for home delivery.
So when I go out to retrieve my newspapers, and there’s no Newsday to be found, Newsday has failed to fulfill its end of the bargain. The credit they give me one missed paper does not address their breach of contract. Clearly, they cannot charge me for a paper they failed to deliver. But their failure goes beyond the mere missed delivery. The failure goes to my contractual expectation of having a Newsday waiting for me.
The way I see it, the deal is not that they deliver a paper if they feel like it, and I pay for it if they do. I have a right to see a paper waiting for me everyday. If they fail to deliver, then there is a measure of damage for their failure to deliver, on top of not being charged for a paper not received.
It strikes me as fair that I should receive a credit of two days for each paper missed. Of course, customer service at Newsday does not see it this way, but that’s to be expected. On the other hand, the issue could be avoided in its entirety if they just deliver the paper every day (like the New York Times), but that appears beyond a possibility.
So, I ask your thoughts. Am I right or wrong? For those of you who think I have way too much time on my hands by pondering questions like this, tough nuggies. I can ponder any darn thing I want, even when it isn’t of earth-shattering importance, and I don’t need your permission.
Video Appearances: Gain or Loss?
From Anne Skove at the least dangerous blawg, this article from the Argus Leader about how video court appearances are catching on in South Dakota.
Judges are setting bail through TV screens at local jails; lawyers are taking depositions from witnesses in different states; and clerks in Pierre are taking the official record of who is saying what in the courtrooms of surrounding counties.
The technology is saving money and time and has helped some suspects bond out of jail faster. But some worry that turning defendants into faces on a TV screen is hurting the justice system.
The use of videoconferencing has been going on for years now, and has become an increasing important tool for court administrators to get bodies before the judge without actually needing to move bodies. But it implicates a host of concerns as well, and these can’t be forgotten in the process.
Obviously, if defendants can appear in court by videoconference, it saves the system the cost of transporting defendants from jail to courthouse and back. Proceedings can be handled more expeditiously, resulting in a more effective use of court time as well. It’s a logistical boon the administrators.
This is obvious in less populous states like South Dakota, but is surprisingly true in densely populated areas like New York City as well. Defendants are woken at 5 a.m. to make the trip from Rikers Island to 100 Centre Street for an appearance, and hopefully show up in the courtroom holding cells by 10 a.m. Often, they aren’t there until much later in the day, especially if something goes awry along the way.
For defendants, this trip is long, tedious and often rather pointless, when it’s a routine court appearance and nothing whatsoever happens for any number of reasons. Defendants grow tired of the early wake-up and lousy cheese sandwich they get to eat for yet another court appearance that goes nowhere. But then, it’s never clear when a court appearance will result in significant action, as opposed to a 3 second “people not ready” or “no grand jury action” announcement.
But when a defendant remains at the jailhouse and his attorney stands in the courtroom, there are issues to be considered. As noted in the article, the defendant is merely a face on the screen, not a living human being in the same room as the judge. Most judges will recognize this, and not be affected. To the extent that they fail to see defendants are human beings in the first place, even when they are standing before them, it won’t make them less of a person.
The lawyer, however, cannot confer during the appearance with his client, the whispers that usually occur and the personal assurance that reminds a jailed person that someone knows they exist. The lawyer can’t feel the tug on his sleeve when the defendant has no clue what just happened to him. Communication isn’t something done only on jail visits, but constantly. The defendant is entitled to communicate with his lawyer, and it’s hard to do so via a videoscreen.
The defendant must also comprehend the significance of seeing the courtroom, his lawyer and the judge by way of a screen rather than in living color. I’ve seen defendants who would know far better than to speak in open court misapprehend who can hear his utterances during a videoconference. Think of the person screaming at the TV during a football game. To the defendant in jail, this is a television show. Some don’t realize that they can be heard in the courtroom. By everybody. They think they’re talking to themselves. Surprise!
Anne reminded me of some additional problems when dealing with mental health proceedings, including people whose psyche is fragile to begin with having the TV talk back to them. This can really mess up the head of a person whose grasp of reality is shaky in the first place. As we know, criminal defendants frequently have mental health issues, ranging from psychoses to post-trauma issues to low intelligence. All of these problems are exacerbated by use of videoconferencing.
While the benefits of video are clear for court administrators, and frequently aid the defendants as well, it’s critical for the criminal defense lawyer to remember that it comes at a price. It’s our responsibility to make certain that the defendant’s rights, ability to communicate and understanding of the technology are clear and intact. If there is an issue of whether a physical appearance in court is necessary to preserve the defendant’s rights, then it is our duty to make sure that our client is standing next to us.
Don’t expect court administrators to put our client’s right first. That’s our job.
Debate Lesson, Volume II
There was only one purpose to watching the Vice-Presidential debate, to see if Sarah Palin had an SNL moment. Republican’s held their breath hoping. Democrats held their breath hoping. It didn’t happen. The rest is of no political consequence. Back to the main event.
The expectations game was the primary driver of the debate. Most people describe expectations of Sarah Palin as being low. I saw the opposite. I saw high expectations, very high indeed. Not that she would present as a person worthy of the presidency, but that she would come off as the ignorant hick who lost it in the midst of some question that tests basic knowledge. People expected her to be a disaster.
Palin was not a disaster. Whether you thought she did well is a very subjective thing, as some were critical of her failure to actually answer questions posed, preferring to rely on coached talking points that often had only the slightest relationship to any subject involved in the question. But no one can say that Tina Fey has an easy job this weekend.
Joe Biden, on the other hand, certainly failed to show up this ignorant Alaskan, and given his experience with the subject matter put on the table by Gwen Ifill, it isn’t as if he didn’t have the tools available. But he did not do so, and made a few substantive gaffes, not to mention tripped on his words numerous times. Still, he did an overall adequate job.
The questions posed by Gwen Ifill were eminently fair, if not somewhat obvious. She’s no Katie Couric. Dodging questions was easy enough, and no there was no follow up to attempt to obtain an answer to the question posed. This makes the concept of debate seem rather pointless, since it allowed the candidates to remain within their comfort zone of canned answers.
If anything, Biden put himself at a disadvantage by actually trying to answer some of the questions, and positing some rather controversial positions, while Palin’s answers, to the extent they were tested against Biden’s, lacked any clarity. Notably, Alaskan gubernatorial opponent, Andrew Halcro, said of her responses during a debate:
I didn’t understand a word that she said in 90 minutes, yet the crowd just absolutely loved her.
His point was that she connected with people, notwithstanding her inability to articulate a clear concept. This reflects on both Palin as well as the public, but is more a condemnation of democracy than the candidate. There is nothing wrong with being loved by the crowd.
Biden’s manner came off as old school politician, pedantic and overly-emphatic at times, despite his efforts to be an everyman. When he got slammed by Palin for “looking backward,” he could have explained to her (and us) that we learn from our mistakes, and tossed in George Santayana’s quote for good measure. Instead he said something like “As you know Gwen, the past is prologue.” Not inspiring.
Palin’s manner was in stark contrast, appearing as a cutsie, no-nothing populist who is “just like us” in that she doesn’t have to “know nothing about birthin’ no babies,” as long as she’s one of us common folk. It made me nuts that she ends sentences with the word “also”, and does that little eye twitch/wink. I found her manner to be akin to eating twinkies. The “Joe Sixpack” referenced must have been vetted within an inch of its life, though it make me feel included.
Biden’s use of cliché political phrases, while clear to lawyers, sounded obtuse to others. Since most people are unable to discern responsiveness, Palin’s lack of a clear substantive answer flew over the heads of many. I suspect many will think her answers to be quite good, even though they had nothing to do with the questions.
The lesson from this debate is that winning can be as simple as not losing. Sarah Palin enjoyed a benefit from Tina Fey’s caricature of her, creating the expectation that she was incapable of making it through this debate without melting into a big puddle of stupid on the floor. But she was well coached, and studied hard, and made it to the end without a hitch. The problem will be whether she can do the same if and when she is interviewed again and some tougher questions are posed. Coaching is one thing. Knowing has yet to be seen.
The lesson for Biden is that he’s no Lloyd Bentsen, and he failed to capitalize on the few openings he was given to contrast his knowledge and experience with hers. I suspect he was instructed not to try, for fear that he could implode if he attempted to smack her.
Sarah Palin won the debate because she did not crash and burn. While this debate failed to prove that she is qualified to be president, it failed to disprove it as well. Hung jury.
