Author Archives: SHG

NYPD Taser Lieutenant Commits Suicide

A few days ago, the story of Imam Morales, who died after being tased while on a Brooklyn ledge, brought sadness to many.  Today, the sadness deepens.

Just in from Newsday;


On his 46th birthday, Lt. Michael Pigot of Sayville shot himself at Floyd Bennett Field, the Brooklyn base for the elite Emergency Services Unit, the sources said. It happened about 6 a.m., according to news reports.

In an interview this week Pigot told Newsday that he was sorry for authorizing an NYPD officer to use a Taser before air bags were placed below the victim.

This compounds one tragedy with another.  Not knowing anything more about Lt. Pigot than I read in the papers, I assume that there were deeper issues in his life than just the Imam Morales death that pushed him over the edge.  But it seems safe to assume that this was the straw that broke the camel’s back.

I’ve argued in the past that the life of a police officer is no more consequential than the life of anyone else.  The corollary, however, must also be remembered:  The life of a police officer is no less consequential.

I am deeply saddened that Lt. Pigot took his life.  I am deeply saddened that he felt this act necessary and that he saw no other option.  My sympathy goes to his family, as it does to the family of all people who die needlessly.

Senate Averts Crisis, And Throws a Party!

Thanks to Mike at C&F for taking the lead in all things cynical with the omnipresent fiscal crisis.  As no doubt everyone has heard, our United States Senate has stepped in to save our financial system from the amorphous crisis that would devastate “Main Street” as it bails out “Wall Street” by a vote of 74 to 25.  Take that, you rogue representatives.  Hah!

But one doesn’t achieve bipartisanship cheap these days.  In order to save us from disaster, apparently not a sufficiently worthy goal in itself, the Senate did what it does best.

The bailout bill contains the following “new” pork:




  • Film and Television Productions (Sec. 502)
  • Wooden Arrows designed for use by children (Sec. 503)
  • 6 page package of earmarks for litigants in the 1989 Exxon Valdez incident, Alaska (Sec. 504)

The bailout bill extends this existing pork:




  • Virgin Island and Puerto Rican Rum (Section 308)
  • American Samoa (Sec. 309)
  • Mine Rescue Teams (Sec. 310)
  • Mine Safety Equipment (Sec. 311)
  • Domestic Production Activities in Puerto Rico (Sec. 312)
  • Indian Tribes (Sec. 314, 315)
  • Railroads (Sec. 316)
  • Auto Racing Tracks (317)
  • District of Columbia  (Sec. 322)
  • Wool Research (Sec. 325)

Here’s the bill (intended as a pun, if you will), for the restoration of order to our financial markets, certainly a primary concern of all right-thinking Americans today.  According to the Kansas City Star, it’s an additional $110 billion.  And that’s without the tip.

So as hard as I try, and I promise that I try very, very hard, it’s really difficult to buy in to this crisis.  Sure, I will be paying the freight together with everyone else, yet again despite the fact that it doesn’t reflect my concerns, but after paying the costs of a war in Iraq, shelling out a little more to cover the cost of someone else’s deep abiding fiscal concerns hardly seems consequential. 

But after the many interests raised in the process of devising a solution to Hank Paulson’s crisis, the innumerable editorials and speeches about who made out like a bandit and who got screwed, about who gets saved and how we’re once again counting on trickle down economics to explain why anybody on Main Street should care whether liquidity of financial institutions is really important to homeless people, our Senate has given us a darn good smack in the face.

We got punked.  They’re handing out cash like candy, and there’s none of it for us.  That’s because they don’t need to pay us off, since they’ve got us by the short hairs with all the fear-mongering and disaster talk.  After all, IF the crisis came, and they didn’t act to prevent it, then it would be OUR fault for stopping the brilliant leaders of our nation from saving the dopey citizens who just didn’t “get it.” 

I’ve been told more than a few times that I just don’t “get it” by some very smart people.  When I disagree, they make fun of me for “ignoring the facts.” I don’t mind being wrong.  It happens.  But when the nervous-Nellies start denigrating anyone who doesn’t succumb to their vision, there’s nothing to do but shrug and move on.  Sticks and stones.  After all, there’s comfort in jumping on the disaster band-wagon.

But now that you see the price of a bailout, an additional $110 billion in pork to persuade our Senators to vote the right way, are you proud of yourselves?  Do you still want to argue that only you see the facts, and anyone who disagrees is just a visceral reactionary?

America has been played by fear too many times in the past.  Our government’s reaction/use of fear to pass some of the worst, most dangerous laws that would otherwise have caused widespread outrage, come in times of hysteria.  Thanks, Senate, for reminding us of the price.

Dershowitz to Wall Street Whiz Kids: Lawyer Up

Via Ken Lammers, former CLTV star and now LX star (whatever that is) at CrimLaw, this Forbes article by reformed lefty lawprof Alan Dershowitz (of the Harvard Dershowitzes).  It’s enough to make one think that there’s a silver lining to this dark fiscal cloud hovering over the nation.  Well, almost.

The biggest growth industry on Wall Street these days is the white collar criminal law firm. As Wall Street financial firms crumble, Wall Street law firms–especially those with litigation departments populated by former U.S. attorneys–will prosper.

Now some might find the latter half of the second sentence somewhat curious.  Why, you wonder, would the Big-D write such a thing?  What is it about former AUSAs at Biglaw that he finds so enticing?   Glad you asked.

Dershowitz, after explaining how white collar criminal law is largely about scapegoating when the feces hits the fan, offers Dershowitz’s First Rule of Criminality:


That is why white collar criminal lawyers are busy preparing their clients for investigations, subpoenas and flipping witnesses. The race to the courthouse has already begun, with lawyers trying to be the first to offer up their clients as witnesses against former friends and colleagues, instead of themselves becoming defendants. The race, however, is not always to the swiftest but rather to the lowest on the totem pole–the underling who can provide evidence or testimony against the higher ups. The first rule of criminality in the U.S. is “always commit crimes with people more important than you are, so that you can turn them in rather than having them turn you in!”

Apparently, the Dershowitz approach to criminal defense differs from mine in a very significant way.  When in doubt, rat. 

Much of what Dershowitz has to say in this article is quite true, particularly the parts about how the public demands someone face criminal accountability whenever things to south, and how federal law is so elastic and vague as to cover pretty much any circumstance where the politicians demand heads on a stake to deflect attention from their own incompetence and failures. 

But rat?  Is that the only possible strategy (not tactic) that Dershowitz sees available from our criminal justice system, or more specifically, from criminal defense lawyers?  Well, apparently so, at least when the cadre of defense lawyers he suggests are those who stepped out of the U.S Attorneys office and into the Biglaw office.  After all, they know all the good restaurants to get lunch in the area.  Those of us not blessed with obsequious desire to continue to curry favor with the government only know the restaurants around the courthouse. 

Bear in mind that this article is in Forbes magazine, subheading “capitalist tool.”  This is what those Wall Street Whiz Kidz, with their ten million (or more) dollar bonuses, read.  This is the message that they are getting from one of the best known Harvard Law Professors cum criminal defense lawyers in the nation.  You have no hope.  No matter what you did or didn’t do, you are dead meat.  Your only option is to cut a deal, plea to the information and rat against someone higher up than you.

This isn’t exactly the message that some, hopefully most, criminal defense lawyers would send.  As we know all too well, the strategy of picking off the low-lying fruit, the young, scared, overly-monied masters of the universe who may have done nothing wrong at all because they were just highly-paid foot soldiers in the Capitalist Army, serves one purpose only:  To get these scared little bunnies to flip on their bosses, and ultimately work their way up the ladder to the Big Guys, the ones who bring positive headlines to the DOJ to prove how well they are protecting America. 

So why does Dershowitz feed into the government’s strategy?  Is he just being pragmatic?  Does he want to be the next Ramsey Clark?  Who knows?  But to the youth of Wall Street, there is another option.  If you didn’t commit a crime, don’t bend your knee to pray to the government gods.  Sure, your buddies who go to Dershowitz’s suggested Biglaw “criminal defense experts” will have them seated in the US Attorney’s waiting room within minutes, but not everybody goes down.  They will lose their fortunes, spend a relaxing 24 months at Club Fed, all for giving it up right away.  They won’t get a free ride, no matter what sales pitch is used.

There is an alternative to following Dershowitz’s advice.  Consider it.

When “One of Our Own” Goes to Prison

Somehow, blawgers get onto lists of people who others think will be interested in their stories.  We get “pitched” to post, in an effort to highlight a particular wrong, be swept into supporting some unworthy mutt, or just become part of a deafening chorus to prevent injustice from going unnoticed.

And sometimes, somebody puts us on the wrong list.  I love it when that happens, as I get to see a side that would ordinarily be hidden from someone like me.  Yesterday, such an email found its way to my inbox.

The email was about the injustice done to Michael Mette, whose appeal, it informed, would be”ruled on” today.  Mette is a former Chicago cop who was tried and convicted for beating a fellow named Jake Gotthard.  He got 5 hard years for his effort, a tragedy according to the email.


As you know, Mette’s story is a big deal for cops here in Illinois and all over the country.  I think your readers would really hearing one of their own tell his own story.

So, kind readers, let’s see if Mette is “one of your own.”  The email referred me to an interview of Mette at WindyCitizen, not to be confused with WindyPundit.  It’s an interesting interview, culminating in this Q&A:



WC: Why do you think that you’re in prison right now?


MM: I am in prison right now because of the corruption inside a Dubuque courthouse. Just read the Judge’s ruling and then Iowa’s code 704.3. How can anyone, let alone a Judge, tell someone, “I understand that you were attacked by this person, but you had no right to defend yourself.” This case has never made much sense to me. Why have laws set in place if we are not wiling to abide by them? And if we cannot trust those who govern to uphold these laws then should we not put someone else in office?


So was this officer railroaded by a corrupt judge and system?  So it would appear.  Unless you look at someone else’s view of what happened.  Accordingly to CNN, there are a few details that Mette’s description of events leaves out.



When police arrived, they found Gotthard lying on the ground with bruises and lacerations on his face, cheek, nose, chin and forehead. Mette, who had blood on his shirt and whose knuckle was bruised and cut, was arrested and charged with a felony.


“[Gotthard] had bruises on the side of his neck, his arms, his elbow, his shoulders, on his back, that were simply not consistent with Mr. Mette’s version that he only struck him once,” said Assistant County Attorney Tim Gallagher.


Dubuque doctors testified the injuries were consistent with someone who had been stomped and kicked.


Well, the Mette one punch argument either suggests that he’s got the singular most spectacular punch ever, or his defense theory is just a wee bit flawed.  

And there are some other claims that come under scrutiny as well, such as Mette’s claim that he was attacked by a drunken Gotthard because Mette and his friends decided to leave a boring party when Gotthard wanted them to stay. 

The CNN report is a little different:


According to court documents, Mette and his friends entered the house party, but decided to leave without paying the required $5 entry fee when they saw the room was mostly empty.

Not the biggest omitted detail in the world, but whenever one neglect to address facts that don’t cut in their favor, there’s a natural reaction that they do so purposefully because it undercuts their claim.  Such omissions emit an unpleasant odor.

The Mette acolytes argue that this former Chicago cop is sitting in a prison cell for doing nothing more than “defending himself” when Gotthard was the initial aggressor.  There’s no question that Gotthard was the initial aggressor, and hit Mette a few times in the chest when he caught up with him.  So does Mette have the right to defend himself?  Absolutely.

Does defending oneself mean a darn good stomping?  I leave that to a Chicago court (or WindyPundit, who speaks fluent Chicagoese).

And is Mette “one of our own?”  Only if the cops come to the defense of my clients from now on too.  And if they do, I’m happy to reconsider.

Even Alaskan Senators Get the Blues

The corruption trial of that nasty, selfish Alaskan Senator, Ted Stevens, took a fascinating turn.  For those who haven’t been following Slater’s updates at the WSJ Law Blog, the trial turned into a bit of a feces storm when a construction foreman, Rocky Williams, contacted the defense lawyers to let them in on a little secret that the government neglected to mention.

Defense lawyers say Williams contacted them over the weekend and provided them with significant evidence that undermines the government’s case. Defense lawyers said Williams told them he spent much less time working on Stevens’s home than Veco’s accounting records indicate. That evidence, they said, “gravely undercuts” the government’s argument that Veco spent $188,000 of its own money on Stevens’s house.

As we are all painfully aware, government lawyers would never withhold Brady material from the defense.  Unless they thought they could get away with it.  The judge, Emmet G. Sullivan, was not amused.


“I’m peeved about that,” Judge Sullivan said. “What gives the government the authority to do that?”

Peeved?  Is that “peeved” as in I’m going to do something about it, or “peeved” as in I’m really annoyed and will feel terrible about it when I sentence him.


In light of the developments, Stevens’s lawyers have asked Judge Sullivan to declare a mistrial or dismiss all charges. Judge Sullivan said he was “not inclined at this point” to take either action, but he indicated that he will recall witnesses who already testified and let Stevens’s lawyers question them again.

Oh, “peeved” as in I’m going to give everyone a do-over.  But there’s a problem, because Rocky Williams is no longer in the building.


Williams had been in Washington, D.C., preparing to testify, but prosecutors sent him to back to Alaska last Thursday, saying they no longer needed his testimony. Prosecutors didn’t alert the defense or Judge Sullivan that Williams was leaving town. Judge Sullivan said he was “flabbergasted” by the government’s actions.

So what does the government have to say about it’s actions?  Slater’s follow-up post explains it all:


[A]ccording to the government’s memorandum in opposition to the request for a mistrial. Williams, they say, was too sick to testify. From the government’s papers:


    True to form, defense counsel continues with their “win at all cost” tactics. . .This time, defendant has gone too far, accusing the government of Brady violations and of proffering misleading evidence at trial. Nothing could be further from the truth . . .At the time when Mr. Williams was subpoenaed, the government anticipated that he would be one of the first witnesses in the government’s case-in-chief. However, when Mr. Williams arrived in Washington, D.C. and met with government counsel to prepare for his testimony, it was apparent to counsel that Mr. Williams had serious, health-related issues that warranted medical attention. . .Mr. Williams had lost a substantial amount of weight, his abdomen was distended (and had been previously drained of excess fluid), he appeared jaundiced, his face was gaunt, he had substantially aged, he had chronic coughing spells, and he was frequently short of breath. . . The government informed Mr. Williams that he should return to Alaska to attend to his health and to meet with his doctors.

I am deeply touched by the government’s concern for Rocky William’s health.  Imagine how badly the prosecutors felt when they had to deny the defense the opportunity to examine Williams and explore the government’s misconduct due to his deteriorating condition.

And who wouldn’t be impressed by the government’s attack on the defense for their “win at all costs”tactics (or is it strategy?) of wanting to produce exculpatory evidence before the jury?  This is a very sick man!  The government says so, and yet the defense cares only about itself.  Bad defense lawyers.  Bad. Bad.

I’m sorry if you detect an undercurrent of glee in all these shenanigans, but the fact that it’s Senator Ted Stevens, the longest serving Republican in the Senate, certainly adds a level of irony, if not delight, to these proceedings.  Does he look back at his tenure as United States Attorney fondly these days?

It remains to be seen what Judge Sullivan plans to do about this mess.  The government’s point that the value of the services isn’t itself a critical issue, provided the amount still fits within the guidelines, has some validity, but the defense’s argument, that this reflects deception and over-reaching, which would entitle the jury to reject the claims in their entirety, not merely lower their estimate of valuation, similarly has merit.

What’s always amazing is how the government never has any Brady, until they get nailed for concealing it.  Now it’s up to the judge to decide whether to do something about this or sweep it under the rug.  Will it be a mistrial, with a double jeopardy motion in the wings, or a mulligan?  We’ll see.

Heller Hasn’t Made it to New York. Yet.

From the New York Law Journal, this decision from Justice Daniel Martin in Nassau County in Leto v. Mulvey, 007560/08, seems as if it’s almost out of a time warp.  The petitioner, John Leto, is a private investigator who is trying to get his pistol license back, after a number of allegations by his ex-girlfriend of threats and menacing.

The decision recites at some length and detail the various threats that brought Leto the attention of the police.  But ultimately, the former girlfriend, Donna Composto decided not to pursue prosecution and all charges against Leto were dropped.  That didn’t mean, however, that the cops were going to give him his weapon back.  And Leto claimed that without his gun, he would be at risk in the performance of his work as a PI.

One wrinkle in the case is that Leto was pro se.  That being the case, it’s somewhat understandable that he wouldn’t be on top of the law.  Normally, a pro se litigant with a colorable claim gets a bit of a helping hand from the judge, who is inclined to make sure that the pro se litigant doesn’t blow the case simply because he’s unrepresented.  But this is Nassau County, New York, not a place where pro se litigants are looked upon kindly.  Still, this isn’t an excuse for the Court to ignore the law in the process.  Or is it?

Judge Martin ruled against Leto, notwithstanding the fact that the police lacked a witness to support their position that Leto did anything wrong, since Composto refused to testify or cooperate with either side.  For the judge, the allegations were enough.  But the Court’s view of the case was off base from the start.  Judge Martin’s discussion of the law begins:


The possession of a handgun license is a privilege rather than a right.  Sewell v. City of New York, 182 A.D.2d 469, Matter of Caruso v. Ward, 160 A.D.2d 540.

Two very fine decisions cited.  Except for one problem.  Justice Martin neglected to mention an intervening decision that’s made a bit of a splash since the two cited decisions were rendered.  That would be D.C. v. Heller, and the problem is that Heller made possession of a handgun a right rather than a privilege.

The law in New York, pre-Heller, was pretty clear.  As long as the police could come up with any rationale, and I mean any, that could justify pulling a gun license, they were free to do so.  Courts gave unbelievable deference when it came to this decision, and almost never intervened with the police department’s decision.  Over the years, a body of law developed that was rife with phraseology and explanations that upheld decisions based upon anything short of “there’s a hole in my tennis racket.”

But that was pre-Heller.  This is post-Heller.  Notice anything missing from the decision?  That would be any mention of Heller.

While it would be arguable that Heller’s application to the states remains unclear, based upon the holes Justice Scalia left in the decision that are big enough to drive a Mack truck (carrying a load of AK-47s) through, it’s inconceivable that a decision could be issued that simply neglects to notice that the possession of a handgun is no longer a matter of governmental kindness, a privilege. 

As argued following the issuance of the decision, Heller should have, could have, changed the Second Amendment world.  It didn’t, courtesy of Justice Scalia’s wholesale give back of all the restrictions previously imposed without explanation of any sort, and it’s smack in the face to his primary holding, that there is a personal constitutional right to possess a weapon.  But at least it seemed that the days of calling it a privilege were over, and that courts were going to have to work a bit harder to continue the cops hegemony over who was allowed to possess, and who was not, a handgun?

Didn’t anybody tell Justice Martin?  Do the other judges know about this?

Paulson’s a Day Trader

When I first heard the words uttered by Congressman Darrell Issa, Republican from the 49th District of California, it made me cringe.  Day Trader.  In the world of finance, few words are as pejorative.  Day Trader.  Ouch.

These words take me back to the dotcom crash, when every moron with a computer spent his time day trading hi-tech stocks in a whirlwind market where one could never lose.  The market only went up, up, up.  Is anything sounding familiar?

The new mantra from Congress is that Hank Paulson, Secretary of the Treasury, is a day trader, not a banker.  Mind you, he was CEO of Goldman Sachs (immediately following John Corzine, New Jersey Governor and seat belt advocate), so it’s not like he was a run of the mill day trader.  He was in fact an extremely successful day trader, and became a fabulously wealthy day trader in the process.  But he was still a day trader.

I spent some time arguing with some lawprofs yesterday about whether there is, in fact, a crisis.  I posited that Paulson put on his Chicken Little costume 10 days ago and ran around screaming the sky is falling.  For the record, it was supposed to fall yesterday.  It didn’t, but I don’t see that as being a critical point.

What was curious was how the disagreement lacked the normal courtesies and nuanced language, and went right for the jugular, contrary to normal lawprof etiquette.  For example, see Jonah Gelbach’s post, Remarkably Wrongheaded, directed at Ilya Somin at VC. This is remarkably strong language. I wasn’t surprised that they would use such a direct attack at me, since I’m a practitioner, but to hurl such missiles at each other is quite remarkable.

But the disagreement shed no light.  Why is this a crisis?  Why is the world about to implode if this bailout doesn’t happen?  Immediately?  The responses were a jumble of one-word answers: libor, freezing, liquidity.  These, I was informed, were the “facts”, and if I just refused to heed the “facts”, then there was no point in discussing it further.  It wasn’t a very interesting discussion, so I saw no point in pursuing it.

But these are dots that lack any connection to real problems.  There’s no distinction between cause and effect.  There’s no comprehension of the difference between perception and reality.  It’s become an article of faith; you either believe or you don’t.  If you don’t, you just don’t “get it.”  This is a rather peculiar mindset for people whose thrust is to scrutinize and test theories, rather than jump into the mix with their eyes wide shut.

Eric Posner argued that the 777 point drop in the Dow was proof that the bailout was necessary, his argument being that the loss of value in equities was far more costly than the infusion of $700 billion into the financials.   Gelbach agrees wholeheartedly.  I think this is just plain foolish. 

The Dow swings up and down on perception, not reality.  It’s whatever the consensus of a bunch of guys in a pit think will happen in the next 5 minutes based upon their quick and dirty grasp of the world.  Would they really base this nation’s fiscal policy on a bunch of guys who routinely wear napkins on their heads at parties?  My first thought was that such an argument can only be seriously made by someone who hasn’t lived through violent market swings before, since the Dow can recover its drop in a couple of days should some other news hit the fan that makes the boys think differently.  But the $700 billion infusion is real money, not Dow points, and once spent would be lost from the nation’s coffers for real. 

Was Paulson’s predication of the destruction of life as we know it real?  Or was Paulson serving his constituency, Wall Street traders and investment bankers, and speaking of how the lack of liquidity would affect them?  The argument has been made about how this affects “Main Street,” a phrase I’ve come to loathe, but that’s just a game, since we know from chaos theory that everything affects everything else, with only the slightest rhetorical stretch. 

Not only have I yet to hear anyone explain why Paulson’s assessment of this dire emergency was correct, but how his solution will stave off catastrophe, if catastrophe is indeed looming.  Over the past 10 days, too many people have forgotten that both the “disaster” and the “cure” have come from the perspective of one man.  While Congress and the White House (to the extent anyone cares that there is a fellow called “Mr. President” living there) have spent many hours tweaking the edges, the basic plan is still right out of Paulson’s noggin.  He created the paradigm, and the rest of us are trying to see if the square pegs will fit into his round holes.

Why have we staked out country’s future on this one person, Hank Paulson?  After all, they guy is just a day trader.

Tasers, It’s A Family Thing

With thanks again to J-dog, who has his finger on the pulse of weaponry of all stripes, comes yet another imaginative use of Tasers.  As Joel put it, “the family that gets tazed together stayzed together.”  That’s his line, so don’t blame me.

From KTVU News, the tale of the Brentwood, California, police response to a 14 year old shooting victim:



The shooting occurred at about 9:15 p.m. near the 7000 block of Brentwood Blvd., where three teenagers were standing. One received at least one gunshot wound and ran with the two others back to the victim’s neighborhood, according to Sgt. Mark Misquez.



Police later arrived and began assisting the victim. The victim’s family and friends gathered at the scene, and, according to Misquez, interfered in the assisting officers’ work. The officers then ordered the family members to step aside and when they did not comply, police responded by tasing some of the victim’s family, including his father and sister.



“As the brother was getting tased the dad approached asked them to stop tasing his son, then they started tasing the dad at that time there were three cops tasing two people who were already on the floor,” said witness Janine Esquivel.


Darn those parents of a 14 year old shooting victim, who just won’t comply promptly.  Don’t they get it?  So what if it’s your son or brother who’s lying on the ground in a pool of blood, a mere child, writhing in pain.  If the cops say jump, you jump.  They have no time for sympathy for the victim’s family, nor understanding, nor tolerance.  They are busy being heroes.  Nobody interferes with a hero.   Not if you know what’s good for you.

Thank God the family wasn’t so appreciative of the cops’ heroic efforts that they hugged them. 

What is particularly shocking (can we still use the word “shocking” in relation to Tasers, where nothing is really very shocking anymore?) is how utterly indiscriminate their use has become.  It’s not merely a substitute for the old cop stand-by, the nightstick, but for talking, or reasoning, or calming as well.  Why repeat yourself when you can Taser somebody in less time. 

In this case, we have a distraught family trying to help a young member.  There’s no clear indication of how long it took police to arrive (note the language, “Police later arrived,” suggesting that it didn’t happen quickly), and the family was there for the young man.  Note further that the compulsion to taser, to subjugate and control, took precedence over victim.  Not satisfied with tasing the family members who were caring for the victim because they didn’t “step aside” when told to do so, the cops then engaged in a second round of tasing those who complained about the first round of tasing.  And what of the victim while this was happening?

What distinguished this story from most is that the family, while not sufficiently complaint with the cops, were not implicated in any independent wrong-doing, such that the apologists can argue that they deserved a good tasing anyway.  That said, however, it doesn’t mean that they got a quick tase and that was the end of it:


The police took several individuals into custody for assaulting and resisting officers, according to Misquez.

But of course!  They assaulted police by viciously throwing their bodies into way of the police tasers.  When I recently wrote a piece for Judicial Reports about how complaints like this appear before arraigning judges, the editor told me to stop kidding around.  He had trouble believing that this was mere hyperbole. If only it was.

As a concession to J-dog, this is not an indictment of the Taser per se, which was a far better choice in this instance than a fully loaded Glock which would likely have caused the deaths of many bystanders (though no one at which is was aimed).  It is, however, an indictment of putting a weapon like this into the hands of children, telling them that it’s non-lethal so that they should feel free to use it whenever it’s convenient, and setting them loose on the street.

Maybe we should just be thankful that the shooting victim survived and his parents were killed for being there.  This outcome is beginning to look increasingly likely.

Why Law Review Articles Were Never Meant for Us (Update)

For years, I’ve suspected it, but now there’s finally confirmation.  There’s a reason why law review articles written by professors of law are both painful and almost invariably useless:  that’s how they are taught to write them.

Dan Markel at Prawfsblawg offers Advice for Beginning Scholars.  If you respect and admire the intellect and scholarship of lawprofs, as I do, you may not want to read any further.  It’s like watching sausage being made.  It isn’t pretty.

Dan offers three suggestions for those practitioners hoping to break into the Academy.  The first is benign enough: use footnotes rather than endnotes.  This hardly seems worth saying, since footnotes are easy enough to do these days, unlike the days when I went to law school and papers were typed on typewriters.  Back then, footnotes were a major pain to produce, and endnotes were so much easier.  With a computer, that problem has been totally eliminated.

The second suggestion is a preview of what’s to come:


The overwhelming burden is to demonstrate to law professors that you think and write like a law professor, not a practitioner.  Be careful, therefore, about not falling into a practitioner’s trap of using case cites to support empirical assertions.  If you are making an empirical assertion, one needs empirical data, or one needs to weaken the point, like “courts are still struggling with the issue.” 

I like that, the “practitioner’s trap.”  But he is, of course, quite correct.  Practitioners are constrained by precedent, and its mere existence is reason enough to rely on a decision for an empirical assertion.  If the court says so, then so it is.  From a scholar’s perspective, however, this is lazy and inadequate.  The fact that a court ruled that the sun rises in the west doesn’t make it so, and no self-respecting scholar is going to rely on such an decision.

But it’s Dan’s third point that is most telling. 


Remember your audience.  It’s not judges or practitioners.  It’s other law professors.  Pure doctrinal work nowadays [is a risk] without sufficient theoretical or social science orientation for a hiring committee to say “whoa, now there’s a practitioner who really gets it.”

First of all, every suggestion that begins with the words “Remember the . . . ” is bound for greatness.  It may not be original, but it works every time.  You may not have a clue what happened to the “Maine”, but you remember the battle cry, right?

Seriously, this is where the rubber hits the road.  We practitioners have suffered from our own self-absorption in thinking that law review articles were written to serve some purpose relative to the law.  Whether to inform lawyers, or persuade judges, to impact and improve the way in which the law served society.  How selfish we are.  How egocentric to think that scholars were talking to us. 

Law review articles are a conversation amongst themselves.  Colloquially, perhaps they are best thought of as a circle-jerk, where neither judge nor practitioner is allowed to rub up against any tweed-covered elbow.  Dan’s suggestions are meant for those practitioners, and I use that word in the broadest possible sense because most have about 12 minutes of practical experience under their belt, who find life in the well of the court distasteful and are looking for a different environment.  Dan’s trying to teach wannabe lawprofs how to shift gears.

For so many of us, Dan’s words come as an epiphany.  Who knew that this was all a big set-up?  Who knew that law review was never meant for the working stiffs, whether in blue pinstripe or black robes, but to curry favor with a secret society of scholars for whom the internal debate was the sole and exclusive end?  I didn’t.  I always thought that these articles were intended to have some application to the law.  I thought that they were meant to actually do something for real people.  I am such a maroon.

And as an aside to all those law students who were deluded by the glossy law porn into believing that their tuition was tendered in exchange for their being taught how to be lawyers, pay careful attention.  The first thing the Academy demands of your “teachers” is that they disconnect themselves from anything having any connection to the law and prove their mettle by devolving into theoreticians of some extra-legal, multi-disciplinary voodoo designed to never serve any purpose for humanity.  No wonder you come out of law school lacking any marketable skills.

I can’t help but wonder whether Jim Chen subscribes to this as well.  Is it really true that entry into the Academy requires the shedding of all semblance of social or legal utility?  Is that the price of scholar-hood?  Is this the best we can do for those students who will some day be expected to actually practice law, an idea so filthy as to bring to a screeching halt any practitioner’s hope of passing along his knowledge and experience to those who will follow in his footsteps?

Update:  Heard from Dan Markel, who informs me that the three points were from Jeff Lipshaw, about whom Dan says:



FWIW, Jeff is someone who was in practice for 25 years as a partner and GC at a major company b/f he became a professor and wrote those comments.


Now that’s really weird.

Update 2:  Heard from Jeff Lipshaw who, with tongue partially fixed in cheek (I think), mentioned something about people in glass houses.  He reminded me that lawyer writing is similarly viewed by the public as a tad, oh, incomprehensible.  So is it the same?

I don’t think we’re living in the same glass house.  For one thing, many of us in the blawgosphere are constantly advocating for better lawyer writing, less legalese and painfully outmoded language, and just better, clearer writing in general.  Second, when we write briefs or motions, it’s done for the purpose of persuading judges because people pay us to do so.  In other words, the brief isn’t the end in itself, but a means to an end.  We write for a greater purpose.

If lawprofs are writing solely for the benefit of acceptance by other lawprofs, then that’s where the game ends for them.  What bothers me most about this is not its insularity, but the waste of so many good minds and so much effort without any greater purpose.  Practitioners try to help one client, and in the process may help many.  Lawprofs could offer so much more, by changing the course of the law.  Why not try to do so?  Wouldn’t they feel pretty good if people were still talking about the “[insert lawprof surname] Rule” one hundred years from now?

House Votes NO (Update)

Led by Republicans, the House of Representatives voted down the bailout.  Wall Street reacted like junkies needing a fix, dropping the Dow over 700 points until they realized that this wasn’t the end of the bill, which will still be in play after some backroom horse-trading.

But two things are clear.  Give these junkies their fix and they will own this government.  The Dow has been down all day, and this bailout is nothing but a salve for the traders.  Once they get this one, they will still need a fix tomorrow.

Second, the House Republicans have rejected McCain and Bush, who put his butt on the line by a rare public appearance to tell his followers to vote for the bill this morning.  They don’t have enough faith in McCain to believe that he will win in November and they will ride his coattails. 

The ride is not over yet.

Update:  From Jonah Gelbach at PrawfsBlawg,

The House has just voted 206-227 to kill the bailout bill. It seem unclear what will happen next.

Unclear, that is, except that if nothing is done, our economy is headed for disaster.

What disaster?  If you know something, Jonah, let us in on it.  If not, is it a disaster because Bush, McCain or Obama says so?  Or are you just playing the Chicken Little du jour?  So explain yourself, why is the economy heading for disaster without this bailout?

Update 2:  House Republicans held a press conference after the vote, and explained that it’s not their fault that the vote failed, as they were just responding to Nancy Pelosi’s partisan speech before the vote, plus the Dems are in the majority and 94 Dems voted no as well. 

So the Republicans are saying that they voted it down not because they were against it, but because they were being partisan because Pelosi was being partisan? 

Update 3:  From Mike at C :


How did Henry Paulson and his corrupt friends comes up with $700 billion?  Here’s how :


“It’s not based on any particular data point,” a Treasury spokeswoman told Forbes.com Tuesday. “We just wanted to choose a really large number.”


And I was worried that they didn’t have a good reason for pulling that number out of their hat.