For years, I’ve suspected it, but now there’s finally confirmation. There’s a reason why law review articles written by professors of law are both painful and almost invariably useless: that’s how they are taught to write them.
Dan Markel at Prawfsblawg offers Advice for Beginning Scholars. If you respect and admire the intellect and scholarship of lawprofs, as I do, you may not want to read any further. It’s like watching sausage being made. It isn’t pretty.
Dan offers three suggestions for those practitioners hoping to break into the Academy. The first is benign enough: use footnotes rather than endnotes. This hardly seems worth saying, since footnotes are easy enough to do these days, unlike the days when I went to law school and papers were typed on typewriters. Back then, footnotes were a major pain to produce, and endnotes were so much easier. With a computer, that problem has been totally eliminated.
The second suggestion is a preview of what’s to come:
The overwhelming burden is to demonstrate to law professors that you think and write like a law professor, not a practitioner. Be careful, therefore, about not falling into a practitioner’s trap of using case cites to support empirical assertions. If you are making an empirical assertion, one needs empirical data, or one needs to weaken the point, like “courts are still struggling with the issue.”
I like that, the “practitioner’s trap.” But he is, of course, quite correct. Practitioners are constrained by precedent, and its mere existence is reason enough to rely on a decision for an empirical assertion. If the court says so, then so it is. From a scholar’s perspective, however, this is lazy and inadequate. The fact that a court ruled that the sun rises in the west doesn’t make it so, and no self-respecting scholar is going to rely on such an decision.
But it’s Dan’s third point that is most telling.
Remember your audience. It’s not judges or practitioners. It’s other law professors. Pure doctrinal work nowadays [is a risk] without sufficient theoretical or social science orientation for a hiring committee to say “whoa, now there’s a practitioner who really gets it.”
First of all, every suggestion that begins with the words “Remember the . . . ” is bound for greatness. It may not be original, but it works every time. You may not have a clue what happened to the “Maine”, but you remember the battle cry, right?
Seriously, this is where the rubber hits the road. We practitioners have suffered from our own self-absorption in thinking that law review articles were written to serve some purpose relative to the law. Whether to inform lawyers, or persuade judges, to impact and improve the way in which the law served society. How selfish we are. How egocentric to think that scholars were talking to us.
Law review articles are a conversation amongst themselves. Colloquially, perhaps they are best thought of as a circle-jerk, where neither judge nor practitioner is allowed to rub up against any tweed-covered elbow. Dan’s suggestions are meant for those practitioners, and I use that word in the broadest possible sense because most have about 12 minutes of practical experience under their belt, who find life in the well of the court distasteful and are looking for a different environment. Dan’s trying to teach wannabe lawprofs how to shift gears.
For so many of us, Dan’s words come as an epiphany. Who knew that this was all a big set-up? Who knew that law review was never meant for the working stiffs, whether in blue pinstripe or black robes, but to curry favor with a secret society of scholars for whom the internal debate was the sole and exclusive end? I didn’t. I always thought that these articles were intended to have some application to the law. I thought that they were meant to actually do something for real people. I am such a maroon.
And as an aside to all those law students who were deluded by the glossy law porn into believing that their tuition was tendered in exchange for their being taught how to be lawyers, pay careful attention. The first thing the Academy demands of your “teachers” is that they disconnect themselves from anything having any connection to the law and prove their mettle by devolving into theoreticians of some extra-legal, multi-disciplinary voodoo designed to never serve any purpose for humanity. No wonder you come out of law school lacking any marketable skills.
I can’t help but wonder whether Jim Chen subscribes to this as well. Is it really true that entry into the Academy requires the shedding of all semblance of social or legal utility? Is that the price of scholar-hood? Is this the best we can do for those students who will some day be expected to actually practice law, an idea so filthy as to bring to a screeching halt any practitioner’s hope of passing along his knowledge and experience to those who will follow in his footsteps?
Update: Heard from Dan Markel, who informs me that the three points were from Jeff Lipshaw, about whom Dan says:
FWIW, Jeff is someone who was in practice for 25 years as a partner and GC at a major company b/f he became a professor and wrote those comments.
Now that’s really weird.
Update 2: Heard from Jeff Lipshaw who, with tongue partially fixed in cheek (I think), mentioned something about people in glass houses. He reminded me that lawyer writing is similarly viewed by the public as a tad, oh, incomprehensible. So is it the same?
I don’t think we’re living in the same glass house. For one thing, many of us in the blawgosphere are constantly advocating for better lawyer writing, less legalese and painfully outmoded language, and just better, clearer writing in general. Second, when we write briefs or motions, it’s done for the purpose of persuading judges because people pay us to do so. In other words, the brief isn’t the end in itself, but a means to an end. We write for a greater purpose.
If lawprofs are writing solely for the benefit of acceptance by other lawprofs, then that’s where the game ends for them. What bothers me most about this is not its insularity, but the waste of so many good minds and so much effort without any greater purpose. Practitioners try to help one client, and in the process may help many. Lawprofs could offer so much more, by changing the course of the law. Why not try to do so? Wouldn’t they feel pretty good if people were still talking about the “[insert lawprof surname] Rule” one hundred years from now?