Author Archives: SHG

The Bonus for being Main Street (Updates)

The hoopla is back with the news of a new, improved $700 billion dollar bailout.  Listening to the sounds emanating from the mouths of those who want to be our leaders, I keep hearing the words “Main Street” contrasted with “Wall Street.”  Ah, they love to come up with catch-phrases that grab people’s hearts and minds.

But the words “Main Street,” despite their fine juxtaposition with the dreaded “Wall Street,” make me cringe.  First, the implication that these people are fighting for the people in small towns that still have a Main Street strikes me as unbearably disingenuous.  Main Street died long ago, when the Mall of America was built, together with its innumerable relatives across the country. 

Everyone who is not “Wall Street” isn’t necessarily “Main Street.”  In fact, I doubt that anyone is anymore.  In their effort to pigeonhole the rest of us in a single catch-phrase, they reflect the fact that they don’t have the slightest clue who the rest of us are, or that we aren’t one monolithic interest group rooting for our saviors to remember us. 

During the debate, Obama described “Main Street” as being police officers, teachers and nurses.  Notice anything special about these occupations, aside from their shared love of unions?  They all tend to be public employees.  Do we all work for the government?  He didn’t mention farmers.  He didn’t mention lawyers.  On the flip side, McCain didn’t even try to articulate who exactly he thinks “Main Street” might be, but then he hasn’t seen Main Street from any of his many homes in generations.  How would he know?

To prove how much they care about Main Street, we learn (with sufficient plausible deniability that when this plan goes bust by about noon today, they can claim they never really liked it) that there has been some amorphous non-quantifiable limitation placed on the “golden parachute” available to any CEO who accepts the government’s bailout.  (See the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008, at Section 111, page 30.  Notice how this law has no cute acronym?) 

The phrase “golden parachute,” like “Main Street,” was crafted to create a pejorative impression.  The fact that our protectors in government have chosen to fix on this term hardly seems accidental.  It’s the Orwellian use of a phrase that they hope will capture the very small, very confused minds of the denizens of Main Street and, in a mindless flash, assure them that our government is doing all of this to protect them.  “Golden parachute” is bad.  We hear you, Main Street. (This is the point where I can hear them chuckling in the background). We fixed it.  Vote for us.

The problem is that the money has been paid.  The ten million dollar bonus checks already went out, were negotiated, and have since been put to good use at the shower curtain store.  The stock options have vested.  The incentive payments are already built in, and ready to kick in as soon as the stock price hits their mark.  And as for the dreaded “golden parachute,” which phrase is actually used in the law, there is a room full of gnomes working feverishly to come up with another, maybe even cuter, name that will circumvent this law altogether.

Don’t kid yourself.  There will be no CEOs on line at the soup kitchen.

But all this does lend itself to a finer understanding of just what our politicians mean when they utter the phrase “Main Street” over and over.  “Main Street” is a euphemism for people too stupid, too dense, too naive, too uninitiated to recognize when their politicians are treating them like the ignorant lemmings they believe them to be. 

Just keep saying that they’re doing all of this for us, for Main Street, and we’ll believe it. 

This new plan is the proverbial camel, a horse built by committee.  It tries to accommodate all the political fingers that stuck themselves in, providing at least enough to craft a sound bite to prove to their “Main Street” constituents that they are there for them, that they love them, so that next election round they won’t be skewered when this turns out to be a debacle. 

How many people will go beyond the sound bite and read the law?  Twelve?  Maybe Fifteen?  Not too many, that’s for sure.  So it’s all about the sound bite, and “golden parachute” makes for a pretty good one.  But I asked for the bonus back, and no one in Washington heard me.  Not just the parachute, but the billions paid out to fail.  No one is talking about those billions.  And the smart money on Wall Street knows enough to keep a low profile and negotiate the check as quickly as possible.

So as each of our candidates, our President, our congressional leaders, utter the word “Main Street” going forward, make no mistake who they are talking about.  The lemmings.  If you agree, perhaps you should get out of line and avoid the cliff at the end of Main Street, because you don’t have a parachute. 

And if you’re wondering about alternative uses for the $700 billion earmarked for the bailout, which would equate to $3,100 for each American, stop wasting brain cells.  There will be no bonus for being Main Street. 

Update:  It’s 10 a.m.  Do you know how your portfolio is doing?  Apparently, Wall Street isn’t impressed with Washington Street any more than Main Street.  Dow Jones Industrial Average down 292 at the moment.  Glad to see that our $700 bil isn’t wasted.

Update 2:  Last week, J.P. Morgan Chase bought WaMu.  Today, it has just been announced the Citigroup bought Wachovia in an FDIC brokered deal for $1 per share.  Had I known it was going to sell so cheaply, I would have considered it.

So what are the chances that Main Streeters will reach a sympathetic ear when calling Citibank customer service to renegotiate their Wachovia paper?  They used to be so nice to their customers, those deeply concerned Citibankers.

Update 3:  You’re probably asking yourself, but what would Sarah Palins have to say about all this?  Glad you asked.  From David Post at VC :

COURIC: Why isn’t it better, Governor Palin, to spend $700 billion helping middle-class families who are struggling with health care, housing, gas and groceries; allow them to spend more and put more money into the economy instead of helping these big financial institutions that played a role in creating this mess?

PALIN: That’s why I say I, like every American I’m speaking with, were ill about this position that we have been put in where it is the taxpayers looking to bail out. But ultimately, what the bailout does is help those who are concerned about the health-care reform that is needed to help shore up our economy, helping the—it’s got to be all about job creation, too, shoring up our economy and putting it back on the right track. So health-care reform and reducing taxes and reining in spending has got to accompany tax reductions and tax relief for Americans. And trade, we’ve got to see trade as opportunity, not as a competitive, scary thing. But one in five jobs being created in the trade sector today, we’ve got to look at that as more opportunity. All those things under the umbrella of job creation. This bailout is a part of that.

You can breath now.  Breath.

Confusing an Execution with a Right

This time, there can be little doubt that there is a peculiar disease in the air around Laredo, Texas, where the meaning of the Castle Doctrine has become so bizarrely twisted as to reflect a Kafkaesque vision of justice.

From J-dog comes this AP report of the glorious acquittal of Jose Luis Gonzalez:

It took the jury of eight men and four women three hours Friday to find Jose Luis Gonzalez, 63, not guilty of murdering Francisco Anguiano, who was 13 when he and three friends broke into Gonzalez’s trailer to rummage for snacks and soda one night in July 2007.

“I thank God and my attorney, the jury and the judge,” Gonzalez said in Spanish after the verdict. “It was a case where it was my life or theirs, and it’s a very good thing that they (the jurors) decided in my favor.”

Their life of his?  Well then, it certainly seems just that Gonzalez was acquitted for killing the vicious 13 year old Anguiano.  After all, no one wants Gonzalez killed in his own house, right?  Except for one problem.  It seems that Gonzalez’s, and the jury’s, perceptions of right and wrong differ from those of disinterested observers.

The facts of the case tell a very different story.


Gonzalez had endured several break-ins at his trailer when the four boys, ranging in age from 11 to 15, broke in. Gonzalez, who was in a nearby building at the time, went into the trailer and confronted the boys with a 16-gauge shotgun. Then he forced the boys, who were unarmed, to their knees, attorneys on both sides say.

The boys say they were begging for forgiveness when Gonzalez hit them with the barrel of the shotgun and kicked them repeatedly. Then, the medical examiner testified, Anguiano was shot in the back at close range. Two mashed Twinkies and some cookies were stuffed in the pockets of his shorts.

Gonzalez claimed that the 13 year old was about to lung at him when he blew him away.  You know, one of those dreaded backwards killer lunges.  So he shot him in the back.

Up to this point, it’s bad enough.  No, it’s worse than bad enough, but not as bad as it’s about to get.

You see, this was a case that “sparked outrage” in Laredo.  Not because of what Gonzalez did to a 13 year old boy, but because “many thought the man should not have even been charged.” 

Can it even be possible for people to believe so blindly, so absolutely, that killing people is given right, no matter what the facts, circumstances or result?  The problem is not necessarily with the Castle Doctrine, but the doctrinaire way in which some view the power this gives them to murder at will.  And when there is no need to harm another, no less kill them, than shooting them in the back as they kneel before you on the floor is an execution.  But then, they just love executions in Texas.

Imagine the pride one must feel to be a citizen of Laredo in the Sovereign Nation of Texas.

Why the Ferrari? Why?

In most instances, the damage done by police in the execution of a search warrant, though usually needlessly extensive and intrusive, can be repaired.  But there are times when the police are seeking an item so unique, so extraordinary, that it could be almost painful to let them lay hands upon it.  This is one such time.

From Orin Kerr at VC, the Connecticut State Police sought and obtained a search warrant for the garage of a Sharon classic car collector, Paul Hallingby, to seize a 1958 Ferrari 250 GT Pininfarina Series 1 Cabriolet.  There were 40 made.  And they are quite special.  Why would they do such a thing?  From the local CBS affiliate :


Connecticut state police say a rare Ferrari worth millions of dollars that was stolen in Spain 15 years ago has been found in Sharon.

State police say car thieves falsified documents and records for the 1958 Ferrari 250 PF, then sold it in 2000 to an apparently unsuspecting car enthusiast in Sharon for $550,000. It’s worth somewhere between $4 million and $5 million.

State police say they began their investigation in June after learning the car was registered in Connecticut.

Authorities say the thieves smuggled the Ferrari into the United States and registered it in New Jersey in 1994 with a false vehicle identification number. They say the owner is a resident of Switzerland.

But the story, like so many, isn’t necessarily the story, like so many.  But before we even consider the tale behind the purported theft, consider what it’s like to be Hallingby.  He was, if my law school memories serve me well, what we call a bona fide purchaser for value.  He wasn’t involved any alleged theft, and was just a buyer of the car down the line.  He owns a total of 22 classic cars, 5 of which are Ferraris.

Ironically, anyone who knows classic cars knows that Hallingby had the Ferrari.  He showed it at the Greenwich Concours d’Elegance.  The funniest part of this is that the police officer noted this in the warrant, though he couldn’t figure out why it was pictured in the 2005 Concours, but not the next year.  Of course, if he had the slightest clue how the Concours worked, he would know that a car cannot enter two years in a row, but only once every four years.

Nonetheless, the State Police Officer “swore” in the seizure warrant that:


The affiants know through training and experience that individuals who collect high priced collectors vehicle . . . would know to take reasonable steps to confirm the legitimacy of his purchase of the 1958 Ferrari 250 PF with vehicle identification number 0799GT.

Do they teach them all about Ferraris at the police academy?  Perhaps the police and guys like Hallingby hang out together after their shifts?  Maybe the cop swearing out the affidavit has a few classic Ferraris of his own?  After all, at about $4 million each, he could afford them with a little overtime.  But then, he would have seen it at the Greenwich Concours d’Elegance, or at least known something about the show.  Apparently, the judge didn’t either.

But there is another problem with this seizure.  It was based on an interpol report of a stolen car, and a demand for its seizure and return by the person claiming to be its owner, a Swiss national who says it was stolen in Spain. 

But the inside story, known to those who might actually have a clue about classic Ferraris, is a little different than what the cops took as gospel.


The PF Cabriolet was supposedly by owned by two Italians. They got into a disagreement over the car, and one of the partners, the one holding the title paperwork, sold it, and provided the new owner with everything necessary to register the car. However, the seller didn’t give his partner any of the proceeds from the sale.

According to our sources, the other partner was understandably irritated when he discovered he no longer had a Ferrari or any money, and filed a stolen car report. This also might explain why the seller refused an insurance settlement, as to have accepted might have created further legal complications.

Note the crucial detail, confirmed here, that the alleged victim rejected payment of the insurance settlement.  Fifteen years later, and he had still never accepted payment for the loss.  The Connecticut State Police received a “tip” that Hallingby had the car, which was explained as their “confidential  source” who ratted Hallingby out.  Apparently, someone decided to get Hallingby, and used the police to do so.  And police were happy to blindly oblige.

Rather than simply go to Hallingby and speak with him about his car (remember, he was just a purchaser down the line, not an alleged car thief), the cops felt it absolutely necessary to seize it, lest he what?  Spirit it away in the middle of the night?  Why would they assume that some 15 year old dubious complaint from some unknown person in Europe is more likely true than the bona fides of a pretty well-established resident of their state, particularly when his ownership of the Ferrari was widely known?  Why would they treat a bona fide purchaser as a criminal?  Why wouldn’t they show some respect for the car? 

Hallingby kept his cars in garages built for the purpose of preserving them.  The Connecticut State Police are unlikely to have a facility quite as purposed as Hallingby, and are more likely to have one of those great big yards with chain-link fences topped by barbed wire and protected by dogs to hold their seized vehicles.  

We can only hope that this Ferrari 250 GT PF cabrio survives this ordeal.   Please don’t hurt the car.

Full Disclosure:  I am the owner of a classic car (though not a Ferrari and not worth $4 million).  Still, this story strikes at the heart of classic car owners everywhere.

The “Claymore Mine” of Tasers

Woo Hoo!  Taser International has been busy, developing ever more fascinating ways to use their “nonlethal” zapper, and they’ve really come up with a great idea this time, the Shockwave. It’s a “remote area denial system.”  I know, just the name sounds so exciting.

In the past, the use of a Taser required at minimum the active choice of a someone, usually a police officer, to decide that if you didn’t show enough respect, or respect fast enough, a good jolt would usually solve the problem (provided it didn’t kill someone).  But how often does “human error” take a great weapon like Taser and turn it into the misunderstood victim?  After all, some dopey officer would have to taser some individual miscreant.  Such a great weapon, and only one writhing scoundrel on the ground at a time.  How unfulfilling.

Well, Taser (it’s motto is “protect life”, though it doesn’t mention whose life it’s talking about) has solve the problem!  Check this out. 


via videosift.com

The idea, I guess, is that this new taser can zap a whole crowd at one time, no individual discriminatory use potential at all.  You’re there, you’re down.  Media?  Down.  Peaceful protester exercising first amendment rights?  Down.  Off duty cop walking off a heavy night of drinking?  Down.  This sucker doesn’t discriminate.  It drops everyone to the ground.

And if you really want to know what the chicks think of this, just check out this PoliceOne “interview”.  To say the interviewer is gushing is an understatement.  I guess there’s nothing like dozens of zapping tasers to make a gal’s heart go aflutter.

What a shame they didn’t have this in time for the national political conventions.  How much “safer” it all would have been.  For the cops, at least.

H/T to Karl Mansoor, who provided numerous “views” of this marvel of modern law enforcement science.

Grades Make Them Feel Bad

While the world is in turmoil over the financial crisis, Harvard Law School has quietly adopted the Yale law grading method.  According to Eugene at VC, who let the cat out of the bag,


According to the e-mail that I had forwarded to me (and whose authenticity I have no reason to question), Harvard would technically have four grades — Honors, Pass, Low Pass, and Fail. My guess, though, is that Low Pass and Fail would be extremely rare, and 98%+ of all grades would be Honors or Pass, as they are at Yale. The shift then is basically from at least five commonly used grades (A, A-, B+, B, and B-, unless I’m mistaken) to two.

Apparently, Standford already went this route.  Now I was unaware of Yale’s grading system, or Stanford’s change, but now that it’s hit Harvard, another law school a neglected to attend, enough is enough.   Is nothing sacred?

Notice how Eugene described the “five commonly used grades” as involving only two letters of the alphabet, “A” and “B”.  Did the academy have to sell off the other letters to afford lawprof condominiums?  What happened to my good old friends, “C”, “D” and “F”?  Were they excessed?

This exercise in grade inflation happened when the rest of us were busy working, I guess, as my memory of law school was that some students did poorly.  Some flunked out.  Many got a bad grade in one course or another, usually the one involving the professor who insisted on long lectures in barely cognizable English.  That was always a pleasure, and a great opportunity to hone your Times crossword puzzle or Scrabble skills.

This is over, apparently.  All those resumes with astronomical GPAs meant nothing.  You had to be near brain-dead not to look like a star.  To do otherwise would have meant low self-esteem, and we certainly can’t have lawyers with low self-esteem.

This didn’t make sense to me until Orin Kerr stepped in and explained things for a dope like me:

So here’s a puzzle about the psychology of grading. Harvard and Stanford Law schools have recently announced moving from a letter grade system with pluses and minuses to a High/Pass/Low-Pass/Fail system. My sense is that most students like the change: Students perceive that it takes pressure off them.

But imagine a slight change. Imagine that instead of adopting the High/Pass/Low-Pass/Fail system, the schools kept the letter system and simply dropped pluses and minuses and the “D” grade. In other words, the possible grades became just A, B, C, and F.

My sense is that students would object strongly to such a system. They would object that it was too arbitrary and unfair, because a student who earned a very high B or a very high A would get no credit for it: They would just get the flat grade that didn’t reflect their achievement. Indeed, I suspect some students would say that removing pluses and minuses would increase the pressure on students by giving students a single bar to hit rather than more of a sliding scale.

Why is this a puzzle?

Because the two systems are exactly the same.  Only the names have been changed to protect the innocent.  So why are these fine institutions of higher legal learning bothering with a shell game?  And are the brilliant students who attend these find institutions that stupid that they can’t tell it’s a shell game? 

But more importantly, are these same brilliant students, who will one day walk out in the world of lawyering so unbearably fragile that they can’t handle the standard grades that have, for better or worse, managed to characterize academic success and failure all these years? 

There is one thing that the academy has done a particularly poor job teaching, and appears still determined to screw up.  Once these young men and women embark on a career in the law, they will all lose at one time or another.  They need to learn to lose.  They need to learn to fight.  They need to learn to handle adversity and rise up to continue the fight.  As I wrote here :

A well-conceived law school education serves one purpose only:  to prepare you to confront the abuse of being a lawyer and prevail.  How to prevail comes later.  You’re not ready for that now.  For now, you need to learn how to toughen up and take abuse without crying and whining.  How to keep a smile on your face and deflect the humiliation that is designed to make even the most macho man shrivel.  If your lawprof doesn’t abuse you, she hasn’t done her job.  If your lawprof doesn’t toughen you up, then you’ve gained nothing.

If a law student has not done well in a course, then flunk him.  If he’s only done mediocre, then give him a “C”, or even a “C-“.  A client will thank you one day if you do.  Practicing law is not about feeling good about yourself, but learning how it feels to lose, and then still be able to fight again.  Don’t steal this from law students, even though they don’t know that they need it yet.

Debate Lessons, Volume I

I watched the debate as long as nature would allow.  It was hard, as I normally don’t stay up that late.  There’s just so many fun things to do in the early morning, and I’m reluctant to miss any of them.  But I did see enough to realize that if Barak Obama had been a trial lawyer, rather than a law professor, he would have been far less likely to make a rookie mistake.

But first, a quick review.  It was a bore.  Listening to men who would be president facilely avoid answering any actual question by masterful segue into their prepared script of talking points, the same ones that they say over and over and over, is tedious, bordering on painful.  What a shame that they had so many eyeballs and ears at their command, and wasted it by repeating the script.

But McCain, in his twisting answers to fit his talking points, goaded Obama, with phrases like he “doesn’t understand” or “$18 billion in earmarks.”  And Obama took the bait.  A relatively reasonable question by Jim Lehrer turned into an attack by McCain and defense by Obama.  Obama let himself be put on the defense time and again, and let McCain turn question after question into his own.

Had Obama ever stood in the well of a court, he would have known that you don’t let your adversary turn the question to his topic, and thus goad you into limiting your opportunity into defending against his attack.  Obama got owned.  If I was his trial tactics (not strategy, but tactics) teacher, he would get a “C”, except that they don’t give C’s anymore, but that’s a different discussion.

By attacking Obama’s past votes and positions, McCain sought to force Obama do two things:  Spend his time defending himself and spend his time discussing only those things that McCain chose to raise.  Obama was playing on McCain’s field.

The lesson is well known to trial lawyers:  Don’t let your adversary dictate your position. 

The master of this tactic was none other than Ronald Reagan, with his famous, “There you go again…”  When these words came out of Reagan’s mouth, with his amused smile and fatherly demeanor, the game was over.  He owned the point.

It would have only taken Obama about 10 second to preface his response with, “rather than waste the public’s time with responding to John’s tired, false, scripted talking points, I would rather spend my time telling the American public about what the future can be…” or some variation thereon.  Dispute the inaccuracies and move on in one quick move. 

But then there was the opening to go after one of the more bothersome of McCain’s talking points that has thus far been left untouched.  He keeps talking about “corruption” on Wall Street.  The public loves the word corruption, because they are sure that it must be there.  But has anyone else noticed that McCain’s talking points, repeated innumerable times over the past few days, has been studiously vague.  Obama certainly should have picked up on this, and turned it against him.


“Sen. McCain, I’ve now heard you say that Wall Street is “corrupt” dozens of times since last Wednesday.  Who, Senator, is this corrupt Wall Streeter?  Give us a name, just one single name, of that corrupt person you’ve been talking about.  Corruption is a crime, and if you know of a crime, then give us the name of that criminal you’ve been talking about?”

Now that would have been a fun moment.

And if you want to give credit for speed in the face of disingenuousness, try this overnight McCain ad:



Is anybody else tired of vapid rhetoric? 

10 Things I Really Don’t Want to Hear About Today

10.  Whether a fart constitutes an assault on a cop.

9.  What Bill Clinton did not do.


9(a)  Emails from Nigeria about the lottery or my inheritance.

9(b)  Emails imploring me to pray to (insert deity) and my wish will come true.

8.  Anyone else being killed because of a Taser.

7.  A child abandoning a baby, and the baby dying.

6.  Sarah Palins.

5.  Credit card debt.


5(a)  Special lease deals on a new SUV.

5(b)  Requests to swap links or improve my Google standing.

4.  A guidelines plea offer.

3.  Why Obama/McCain is a liar.


3(a)  Why McCain can’t make the debate.

3(b)  How “freedom isn’t free.”

2.  Why a police officer’s life is worth more than anyone else’s.

1.  How everything will work it’s way out.  It always does.

As the day goes on, the list grows.  Sorry.

What is Your Juror Thinking About Today?

Anne Reed at Deliberations posts about the very timely and significant issue of how the economy could impact the willingness of jurors to serve.  As the economy tanked, jurors thoughts were a little more focused on how service affected their own lives.

The selection practice in question wasn’t designed to exclude black jurors.  It was designed to help people.   When prospective jurors in Kent County Circuit Court said that they had transportation problems, child care concerns, or the inability to take time away from work, they usually got to go home, no questions asked.  If jurors gave awards to the nicest court, Kent County Circuit Court would get one. 

While it was awfully thoughtful of the court to take into consideration the troubling consequences of serving on a jury, it left a jury that was, well, somewhat bland in diversity.  No ill-intent involved.  Just the opposite in fact, but the result was the same.  Those who bear the most severe consequences of economic downturn have other things to do that are more important than making sure you get the jury you want.

But things have gotten worse since the jury selection in Smith v. Berguis, and it likely well past the point where child care concerns predominate.  People are scared to death of what will happen to them and their families, and they struggle to make sense of the mass confusion in Washington, Wall Street and the thousand pundit voices that tell a completely difference story every 30 seconds.

This diagram shows Maslow's hierarchy of needs, represented as a pyramid with the more primitive needs at the bottom.And so, in times of turmoil, we return to the work of Abraham Maslow, the Hierarchy of Needs.  When people are deeply concerned that they will be unable to put food on their table, heat their homes, keep their homes, drive to work (if they have a job), obtain medical treatment for their children, guess what they aren’t worried about: Justice.  You.  Your client.

Let’s put this another way, if people aren’t concerned about sexual intimacy, the third level of the hierarchy, your problems don’t even begin to enter the picture. 

Justice falls within the top category of Maslow’s hierarchy, self-actualization.  It is a higher order concern, the sort of thing one feels strongly about once one has the rest of the pyramid under control. 

While particular individuals, those whose basic needs are threatened by the outcome of the criminal justice system, will focus on what they perceive to be issues of justice, the rest of the world is busily trying to survive, and deeply concerned that they won’t.  They are worried about themselves first, and who wouldn’t be?

If there is any possible way to avoid going to a trial now, do it.  Aside from some particularly quirky moments in history that had significant impacts on jurors (like the OJ Simpson murder acquittal, for example), I can’t think of a worse time to ask a jury to elevate the concern of justice, fairness, due process, above their personal concerns.

Justice just doesn’t matter at the moment. Don’t expect your jury to think otherwise.  They have their own problems.

Update:  Bennett thinks that a better idea is to use this concept to fashion one’s argument to meet the juror’s needs, regardless of what level they may be:


When the government asks for “justice” it’s usually talking about safety. When a defense lawyer asks for “justice” she might be asking for fairness or due process or freedom — all of which are at first glance higher-order goals.

But when we talk about fairness and due process we can talk about security of morality (it would do violence to jurors’ sense of right and wrong to treat this man unfairly), and when we talk about freedom we can talk about security of everything else (because if you let the government take away this person’s freedom, your own freedom, and therefore the security of your family, property, employment, health, and resources is at risk).

I think he’s made a valient argument.  But I wouldn’t hang somebody else’s life on it.  While I agree with Mark that mistrust of government is part of the package of concern, I would not make the leap that mistrust of government means that jurors will feel more sympatico with the defendant. 

While we always try to appeal to the sensibilities of the jurors, that doesn’t mean that their primary concern isn’t getting out of that jury room and back to work.

Tattoos; The Next Big Suspect Classification?

One of the most widely read posts here is The Lawyer Look, a polemic against the use of permanent ink, not mention bodily holes, as a means of self-expression by lawyers.  Many of the comments excoriate me as being a closed-minded dinosaur who discriminates against those are “different”.  At least we agree that they are “different”.

The New York Times reports on the continuing saga of the tat people versus the people who have jobs to offer.  One of the problems with getting a tattoo is that it’s a huge commitment, whether viewed as a permanent mark or just one too painful to remove.  So once someone gets tattooed, there is a strong compulsion to then demand acceptance of their choice by others.  Some efforts are quite interesting.

Among the better publicized cases was that of Kimberly Cloutier, a Massachusetts woman who sued for the right to wear her 11 earrings and eyebrow piercings while at work as a Costco cashier. Claiming membership in the Church of Body Modifications, Ms. Cloutier argued her piercings were a form of religious expression. Although she ultimately lost, her case was soon followed by others in Massachusetts and in Washington State.

Mind you, this was a woman who sought the vaunted position of cashier at Costco.  There’s nothing wrong with that job, but it isn’t exactly a life or death position. 

So here’s the message.  It’s not a religion.  It’s not an immutable characteristic.  It’s a vanity.  Do it if you want, even though not everyone will think you are just so cool for having a tat, but be prepared for the fact that you have now marked yourself in such a way that others may disapprove and make assumptions about you, your character, your judgment and your taste.

At one time, tattoos were the domaine of a select few.  Who were they?


A couple of years back you could have narrowed the answer to gang members, prison inmates, members of the Russian mob and the rapper Lil Wayne.

Then young hip people wanted to be cool too, but had the basic sense to place their tattoos in locations where only the chosen few could see them.  Bear in mind, if no one can see it, it doesn’t exist.  But then creep set in.  They creeped above collars and below cuffs.  After all, if no one can see it, it doesn’t exist. 

So now the tats are there, not merely a permanent statement from people who think their skin won’t sag as they age, and that fashions never change, ever, but those who felt the need to show everyone just how cool they were, how counterculture (an interesting concept, given how this is just another in a very, very long line of fads), how hip. 


Defining what the courts in the Cloutier case called a “neat, clean and professional” workplace image becomes more challenging when you consider that in 2006, a Pew Research Center survey found that 36 percent of people age 18 to 25, and 40 percent of those age 26 to 40, have at least one tattoo.

Don’t kid yourself.  The courts were being kind, which they can afford to be considering that there wasn’t a shot in the world that discrimination against tattooed employees was going to prevail.  Tattoos bear no similarity to the classifications protected by Title VII, and they will never, and should never, receive the same protections.

Let’s consider the basic:  People who are born with dark-pigmented skin color have no option (except Michael Jackson) to change it.  People who get tattoos have every choice in the world.  People who are of Hispanic ancestry have no option to change it.  People who get multiple piercings are making a fashion statement.  People who are born with female genitalia don’t get to pick their sex.  People who mutilate their body for a fee have chosen to display themselves to others in a light that they think is brilliant.  No problem, but then be a big boy or girl and live with the consequences.

The pervasive response from the young set is that they don’t see anything wrong with it.  Of course you don’t.  If you did, you wouldn’t do it.  Or you’re suffering from the Stockholm Syndrome, and are psychologically prevented from rational thought by your captive body.

But the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett, himself a victim of a youthful indiscretion, made the point with great clarity.  As lawyers, we do not stand in court on our own behalf, but on the behalf of others.  The reality that others (whom we will call judge and jurors) will view tattoos and piercings as a negative reflection of the person.  You can argue this point all you want.  Tough nuggies.  You don’t get a vote on how other people see you.  If you don’t understand this, it well explains how you ended up with a daffy duck tattoo on you forehead. (But it’s cuuuuuuute.)

So tat yourself up all you want.  Put holes into any body orifice that needs a hole that nature didn’t see fit to provide on her own.  But you have no business foisting your personal choices onto a defendant, opening him or her to a biased jury because you are so caught up with your personal desire to be sexy and rebellious. 

You can do as you please, but you will not find a place in the well next to me if you chose to put your ego ahead of your duty. 

And, since I so enjoy this picture, here’s our happy tat customer redux.



“I hate magnetometers.  I really, really do.”

30 Minutes is All You Get in New York

When Imam Morales went off his meds and got crazy, standing naked on a fire escape in Bed-Sty, then moving to the top of one of the ubiquitous roll-up gates that protect store-fronts from the natives, New York’s Finest were pressed to employ ever tool at their command.  The tool of choice?  The Taser.

According to the New York Times, Morales’ mother tried to persuade the cops to let her calm her son down, as he stood there swinging a fluorescent bulb to keep the cops away.  She was told “it was now a police matter,” six very dangerous words.

For about 30 minutes, Mr. Morales yelled that he did not want anyone touching him, and the police yelled back that they wanted him to come down, witnesses said. Then, an officer approached the man on his perch and fired the Taser at him.

New York is a very fast paced city.  They gave Morales 30 minutes.  Seriously, how much longer could they be expected to dedicate to this one naked man, when there were fresh donuts to be had, not to mention a union-dictated meal break?

So Morales fell on his head and died.  It’s not like the cops shot him.  That would have been deadly force.  This outcome, well, just happened.  Hey, stercus accidit.

City Councilman Peter Vallone, chair of the public safety committee, offered a curious view of events:


“My first take is that while I’m sure there are no experts out there on how to handle a crazy naked man with a weapon on top of a ledge, I’m also sure this wasn’t the right way, ” Mr. Vallone said on Wednesday evening.

But ever the politician, Vallone concluded:


“A situation like that is never going to end in a good way,” Mr. Vallone said after watching the video. “The most important thing is that no innocent bystanders or police got hurt. But clearly, it could have been handled better.”

Why is that, Mr. Vallone?  Why is the most important thing that no police got hurt?  Obviously, the welfare of a police officer exceeds the life of a resident.  Is it that a police officer getting hurt is so significant, or the life of a citizen in the City of New York is so inconsequential?

This is a video of the incident, with commentary by a New York Post reporter, who clearly shows that he’s utterly clueless when it comes to reciting facts accurately.  But in New York, no one expects much of the Post.




It was only a matter of time before Tasers started making news in New York.  After all, we have far more cops than anywhere else on earth, and that means far more poorly trained, poorly paid, tired, annoyed, people with access to Tasers than anywhere else.  Now that Sergeants carry Tasers on their belts as part of the standard uniform, it’s New York’s turn to show the many stupid tricks police can perform with a Taser.

But nowhere does anyone offer a suggestion as to why, after 30 minutes, did the Emergency Services cops, supposedly the elite of the force, decide that enough was enough, and it was time to pull out the Taser and put an end to this.
“His mother called 911,” said Sharonnie Perry, a community advocate who lives down the street. “She called for assistance and the assistance she got was her son being killed.”
Problem solved, New York style.