Author Archives: SHG

Myspace Suicude / Lori Drew Update

From Slater at the WSJ Law Blog, the case of Lori Drew has taken a fascinating twist.  The case, scheduled to go to trial on October 7 (how do they get to trial so quickly out in California?), now has new issues to develop.  Following H. Dean Steward’s motions to dismiss and the government’s response, U.S. District Court Judge George Wu suggested that the case was going forward, though he had some reservations worthy of greater thought. 

At the September 23rd court appearance, thought to be just another pre-trial conference, Judge Wu brought up some issues of his own, requesting that the parties brief the issues:

    What terms of service matter? Are all violations of the Myspace terms of service tantamount to the “unauthorized access” required by the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act? If not, who decides which violations are relevant? MySpace? A jury? Or the court?


    Where’s the theft? According to Steward, Judge Wu says he’s found some support for the idea that the object of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is to prohibit theft of information. So Judge Wu wants to know what, exactly, Lori Drew stole. According to Steward, AUSA Krause likened Drew’s alleged unauthorized access to a trespass on land. “That’s all well and good,” Steward told the Law Blog, “but then show me in indictment where you allege that Lori Drew stole information.”


    Back to Con law 101: In what Steward says was a surprise to him, Judge Wu wanted to know where “the interstate connection” was, given that the alleged acts occurred in Missouri. The government brought the case in California because MySpace is based in Beverly Hills.


Great questions for the defense, not to mention the rest of the civilized world.  Despite the feelings against Lori Drew for what she did to Megan Meier, this prosecution cannot be allowed to proceed on the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act.  Judge Wu, from the gist of his issues, appears to have a firm sense that the government’s attempt to manipulate the law to cover Lori Drew’s conduct stretches it beyond breaking.  Now, we wait to find out what Judge Wu does about it.

Is Journalism the Cure for Wrongful Convictions?

In a fascinating article, Innocent Until Reported Guilty, published at Miller-McCune Magazine, Steve Weinberg bemoans the death of skepticism in journalism, and accepts the blame on the part of the media for failing to do its part in crime reporting to recognize the failings in criminal prosecutions.

After recounting the case of Ellen Reasonover, a 24 year old single mother convicted of killing a gas station attendant based solely upon the testimony of two jail-house snitches, where the prosecution neglected to mention that their testimony was bought and paid for, Weinberg states:

What I learned stunned me. Questions battled for my attention; one worked its way to the top of the list: Why had the journalists who knew about the Reasonover case failed to question a police investigation, a prosecution and a conviction so obviously flawed? Why hadn’t somebody written an exposé before the guards hustled Reasonover to the waiting prison van? 

For that matter, why had I — a veteran investigative reporter — accepted so much about the criminal justice system on faith for so many years?

For anyone who has had the pleasure of dealing with a reporter during the course of a case, and faced questions that implied blind acceptance of the prosecution’s position as if it were gospel, Weinberg makes an awfully good point.  Why do journalists accept the criminal justice system on faith?

Weinberg proposes something rather novel, which he calls “preventive journalism.”


Until and unless journalists improve their performance, far more innocent people will be imprisoned than the criminal justice system seems likely ever to acknowledge. The logical extension of the preceding statement seems obvious, but I’ll say it anyway: Unless journalists get better at covering the justice system, many criminals will continue to go unpunished, free to murder or rape or rob again. So investigating wrongful convictions is not — as perceived by too many police, prosecutors and judges — an assault by soft-on-crime bleeding hearts. Rather, it is an attempt to serve law and order, to improve the administration of justice and to foster faith in the criminal justice system.

The media is often a major thorn in the side of the defense, essentially convicting a defendant at the outset by repeating police or prosecution allegations without the slightest hint of critical analysis.  This is part of the “balanced” approach, as far as journalists are concerned, where all sides are theoretically given equal play, and all claims, no matter how baseless or unsupported, are expressed as being of equal worth.  Except they aren’t.

The problem arises from the fact that the first announcement will invariably come from the prosecution side of the fence, thus allowing one side to construct the paradigm, set the parameters, create the scene.  Not until the scene has been irreversible established does the media go to the other side for comment.

Only after the scene has been firmly established is the defense asked to “respond”.  The questions posed seek to elicit answers that fit within the “facts” as already laid out neatly by the prosecution.  But what if the “facts” are just some wild allegations that never happened, thus precluding any ability to answer?  What if the answer is that something claimed never happened, but it remains an immutable part of the story anyway?

While noting a number of examples of hard-hitting investigative journalism that exposed corruption and deceit, Weinberg believes most reporters to be nothing more than “enabling stenographers.”


All this progress aside, “enabler” might serve as the best word to describe many journalists assigned to cover the justice system. They should all know the warning signs of wrongful prosecution by now, yet their coverage (and absence of coverage) suggests little learning from experience.

Many journalists who cover the “cops and courts” beat and its unwavering defenders of the criminal justice system will react to this article by saying, “Hindsight is 20/20.” They will contend that if it were easy to spot wrongful prosecutions, they would never happen.

But that doesn’t excuse their failure to try, as far as Weinberg is concerned.

While there can be little doubt that criminal defense lawyers, as well as the public, should welcome true investigative journalism, seeking to go deeper than blind acceptance of the prosecutor’s story and ferreting out bad cops and wrongful prosecutions,  Weinberg may be a little hard on himself and his brethren.  We already have an institution that’s tasked with the responsibility to distinguish good from bad prosecutions.  It’s called the courts.  Weinberg accepts as a given that the courts are simply incapable of doing its job, and thus it falls to journalists to step in to fill the gap.

The solution to this problem is not to expect more from journalists, though we would certainly welcome their skepticism, but to demand more from our courts.  While I can appreciate Weinberg’s concern over the lax approach of reporters toward crime reporting, and their enabling the prosecution’s public dissemination of false allegations because of their lack of healthy skepticism or hearty investigation, the primary responsibility must remain where it belongs, with an institution whose sole purpose is to separate the guilty from the not guilty, to shine light on misconduct and abuse, to hold the government to its burden.

Let’s not let Weinberg take the weight on this one, as it’s our problem before it’s his.

H/T Grits for Breakfast

Once a Vulture, Always a Vulture

Most of us are probably wondering, as we ponder economic collapse and the end of life as we know it unless we do whatever the President proposes, what’s up with Eliot Spitzer.  Thanks to the ever-vigilant J-dog, who’s been busily making Mark’s life miserable by testing the visual fringes of Windypundit, we now know.

From the New York Sun :

Eliot Spitzer, in his first big business venture since he was shamed out of office by a prostitution scandal, is shopping around a plan to start a vulture fund that would scoop up distressed real estate assets around the country, revamp them, and flip the properties for a profit.

Late last month, the former governor of New York gathered a group of high-level Washington, D.C.-based labor union officials in a conference room at the headquarters of his father’s real estate business in Manhattan and pitched them his idea for starting such a fund, a source said.

Rarely does a name so well capture a concept as “vulture fund.”  The image, picking at the carcasses of the dead and dying, is just so Spitzer.  And how does he feel about himself, post resignation?


During the meeting, Mr. Spitzer expressed relief that he was no longer burdened with the frustrations of being governor, according to the source. And, in contrast to his repentant resignation speech that he delivered beside his tearful wife, Silda Wall, he took a more relaxed view of his indiscretions.

He has told friends and associates that he is consoled by passersby who stop him on the city sidewalks and tell him that sex is “no big deal” and that the disclosure that he frequented prostitutes was distorted out of proportion, the source said. Europeans, the former governor has noted, have been especially supportive of him and perplexed by the fallout from the scandal.

Of course, had he been European rather than American, his meteoric rise to political prominence on the backs of businesspeople whose offense was successfully doing what they always did, he might not have been in a position to have a scandal in the first place.

Like most of you, I am heartened by two things.  First, Spitzer’s new take on violating the law being “no big deal.”  Second, that even a disgraced former prosecutor can make a new life for himself as a vulture.  Isn’t it wonderful how one can apply one’s skills to new ventures after a fall from grace.


Mr. Spitzer’s entrepreneurial activities are the latest indication that the former governor is plunging himself more deeply into a life of business, rather than following, for instance, the model set by a former British war minister, John Profumo, who spent the rest of his life volunteering for a charity after he was caught in a scandal involving a prostitute and a Russian spy.

How wonderful that Eliot found someone to model himself after.  And such an appropriate choice.

A Truly Inspirational Speech From Washington

No, not last night’s speech from our President, though it was one of his better ones.  But Orin Kerr reminded me of a speech by Justice Robert Jackson, given when he was a mere 3 months into his tenure as Attorney General in 1940. 

This comes by way of my old buddy, Jackson scholar and St. John’s Lawprof John Q. Barrett.  While this isn’t going to be one of my posts that garners broad attention, as it doesn’t address any of the wild issues of the day and I won’t be expressing any of my “cranky old man” opinions about it, this is really worth reading, and re-reading every once in a while.  Particularly if you happen to be a prosecutor.  Or a judge.  Or alive.

Just to give a flavor, here’s the final paragraph of Jackson’s speech:

The qualities of a good prosecutor are as elusive and as impossible to define as those which mark a gentleman. And those who need to be told would not understand it anyway. A sensitiveness to fair play and sportsmanship is perhaps the best protection against the abuse of power, and the citizen’s safety lies in the prosecutor who tempers zeal with human kindness, who seeks truth and not victims, who serves the law and not factional purposes, and who approaches his task with humility.

Read the whole speech here.  Justice Jackson’s thoughts remain as relevant today as they were when first uttered.

The USA Patriot Bailout Act

The many thoughts about the Bailout proposed by Secretary of the Treasury Henry Paulson permeate the blawgosphere.  But one that may not have received sufficient mention is that this isn’t the first time our country has rushed blindly into an emergency situation with a law under the guise that “something has to be done immediately.”

On October 26, 2001, President George W. Bush signed into law the “Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001,” better known by its acronym, the USA Patriot Act.

This law, coming on the heels of 9/11 at a time when there was no law that could be too tough or restrictive if it served to protect Americans from terrorism, was an amalgamation of the failed wishlist of Justice Department initiatives.  Suddenly, the rejected became the desperately needed.  And no one wanted to be held accountable for leaving the nation open to a terrorist attack.

They didn’t know that the law said.  No one had bothered to read it.  No one had time.  It was an emergency.  We had to act.  NOW!  We had to protect America.  We just had to.

Some think the USA Patriot Act didn’t turn out nearly as well as Congress hoped.  Yet once we jumped off the cliff, eyes closed but heart full of promise, there was no going back.

The economy presents a big problem, commanding attention.  Pat Paulson was tasked to come up with a plan to get us out of this very large ditch.  Some are questioning the plan, particularly the $700 billion blank check that Paulson would hand to himself with no strings attached.  I can’t tell you how relieved I am that somebody read this law before passing it. 

But even as the ubiquitous Barney Frank talks about various tweaks, it’s still Paulson’s plan.  He created the paradigm, and there’s no time for anyone else to craft a competing plan.  While pundits pick at the edges, the essentials remain intact.  Being no economist, I’ve got no clue whether Paulson’s plan will save the day.  But others, more macroeconomically incline than me, should consider whether the concept is, at its heart, sound before jumping on the bandwagon to approve another hastily created plan to address another “sky is falling” emergency.  Just take a few days to think about it, as should have happened before the USA Patriot Act was passed.

Jonathon Adler at VC notes that George Will, one of the few surviving conservative dinosaurs, is none too pleased with Senator McCain’s talking points. 


McCain’s smear — that [Chris] Cox [SEC Chairman] “betrayed the public’s trust” — is a harbinger of a McCain presidency. For McCain, politics is always operatic, pitting people who agree with him against those who are “corrupt” or “betray the public’s trust,” two categories that seem to be exhaustive — there are no other people.

One of the easiest ways to address emergencies is to find a fall guy and burn him.  It’s a tried and true means of quieting the maddening crowd.  While the population is afraid, a villain provides a target for their anger and deflects attention from deeper, more complex causes. 

Today, people still believe that we invaded Iraq because of its role in 9/11.  Once a myth is firmly established, it can be very hard to convince people that it was only a myth.  Is our bailout plan premised upon myth?

George Will, incidentally, reaches an interesting conclusion about Senator McCain:


It is arguable that, because of his inexperience, Obama is not ready for the presidency. It is arguable that McCain, because of his boiling moralism and bottomless reservoir of certitudes, is not suited to the presidency. Unreadiness can be corrected, although perhaps at great cost, by experience. Can a dismaying temperament be fixed?

It’s a Hobson’s choice.  But as Winston Churchill told the ugly woman, “tomorrow I’ll be sober.”

The Old “Stop Having Childen” Condition

From Eugene at VC comes this bit of news from the Austin American-Statesman that Travis County Judge Charlie Baird has ordered Bristol Palin, 17 Felicia Salazar, 20, to stop having children as a condition of her probation.

On Sept. 5, state District Judge Charlie Baird sentenced Salazar, who had no criminal history, to 10 years of probation after she reached a plea bargain with prosecutors…. In addition to requiring Salazar to perform 100 hours of community service and to undergo a mental health assessment and setting other typical conditions, Baird told Salazar not to have any more children.

Having paid a great deal of attention in 8th grade health class, it strikes me that the judge’s order is misdirected.  You see, once a woman gets pregnant, having a child is a somewhat inevitable outcome.  Since we know what causes pregnancy, the key to fulfilling Judge Baird’s purpose comes a little earlier in the process.  This is another example of why judges are never good at making science-related decisions.

Volokh opines that while a condition such as this might be ill-advised, it is nonetheless a constitutional condition:


I can’t speak to Texas law, but generally probation conditions are constitutional — even when they restrict constitutional rights such as the freedom of speech or the freedom of association — whenever they are “reasonably related to legitimate penological interests,” a test that is easy to meet. The theory is that if the defendant is imprisoned, she would lose a great many of her constitutional rights, under the same standard, and the rule should be the same if the judge gives her probation instead of a prison sentence. And this theory would seem to apply to the right to have children as well: If you’re imprisoned, you have no constitutional right to have children or even to have sex, so a court should likewise be able to impose a similar restriction if you’re put on probation.

While Eugene’s point about distinguishing Texas law from that of a subdivision of the United States is well taken, I’m not sure that he’s otherwise accurate.  Prisoners are granted conjugal visits.  While we may not be certain what transpires in those private trailers, it would be fair to assume that there are some prisoners whose loneliness is sated.  Then, of course, there are the occasional prison guard dalliances, though these are frowned upon, despite their being considered a perk of the job by some.

When a female inmate is found to be with child in prison, what’s a warden to do?  While stories of female prisoners being coerced into having abortions, no doubt by the many liberals staffing prisons, the child will eventually appear if the inmate resists these hints.  The warden can’t order the child back in.  Neither can the judge, although some believe they can.

But Eugene’s view differs slightly when the issue shifts from pregnancy to sex.


Some might ask whether a judge could likewise restrict probationers from having sex. The answer, I think, is that the same general rule would apply, but it would usually yield a different result as to probationers’ sexual relations than as to prisoners’ sexual relations, since there’s not much of a legitimate penological interest served by a “no sex even when you’re outside prison” rule.

Science has discovered a link between the act and the outcome, and it’s time that this link be universally recognized.  While science has also discovered a way to break the chain of the inevitable, there are powerful forces at work to compel people to eschew such scientific miracles as against certain fundamental moral precepts.

There are most assuredly people who should not have children.  A lot of them, by my count.  And due to my concern for children, who suffer abuse at the hands of, or under the less than vigilant eye of, such people, I fully support the inventive ways of courts to protect children from these people.  Unfortunately, I’m less than clear that this is an effective method, and even less sanguine that this condition falls within a judge’s authority.

But I don’t fault Judge Baird for trying.

The Value Movement: Should New Associates Pay for the Privilege?

The notion that the real training of young lawyers happens at law firms across the country, where they receive not mere salaries, but astronomical salaries subsidized by corporations (and more than a few quasi-governmental agencies living off federal bailouts) is nothing new.  But when What about Clients? raised the question, eyebrows raised simultaneously.

Why, Dan Hull asked, should we be paying these useless pups when they have zero to offer and we are giving them the tools to become lawyers?  They should be paying us.

This met with catcalls of derision and ridicule.  That Hull guy is “nuts, flip-city, kooby-shooby.”  But all visionaries are treated this way at first.  After all, wasn’t Hull the same guy who predicted that crocs would become a staple for the well-dressed partner?

Holden Oliver, however, immediately recognized the merit in Hull’s outside-the-box thinking.  The fact that Hull pays him played no role whatsoever.  Holden writes :



Here’s a reaction from The Legal Beat blog of Law.line, a CLE site:



Should recent law graduates have to pay law firms for the experience they receive?…


At first glance for any prospective law student, or current law student, this idea seems ludicrous. However, it is a notion that the United Kingdom has been practicing for a hundred and fifty years. Additionally, this is similar to the education structure we have in the United States for doctors. Some argue that if this concept was implemented, only those with a strong passion for law would seek to go to law school.

As I have long been an advocate that the United States produces far too many lawyers, this “thinning the herd” argument resonates.  Becoming an attorney has long been the default profession, for those who either lack an aptitude in math or have little stomach for human bodily fluids. 

When a young person has no clue what to do with his life after clutching that liberal arts sheepskin in his sweaty hand, he goes to law school.  This isn’t exactly the best reason to chose a career in the law.  It tends to produce lawyers who lack much interest in doing the job, and likely contributes to their misery as they feel locked into a profession that cost them a bundle and doesn’t fulfill the promise of social prominence and vast wealth.  They tend not to care as much about their ethical obligations, or their clients’ welfare, since they are in it for themselves rather than to serve.  Some turn out to be really bad lawyers, even though they may be smart people.

From the perspective of serving the client, there’s always the dirty little secret that big firms like to keep to themselves.  When they put a half dozen young’ens on a case (and charge the client fees that would make a 20 year solo practitioner blush), it really isn’t for the clients’ benefit.  They actually bring nothing, other than save an old-timer’s back by carrying his heavy bag.

While this might seem only fair to the newbie lawyer, it’s less than fair to the client who pays for the newbie lawyer to watch life in real courtrooms, or discover the joys of document review, or learn that there are certain words that are commonly expected to appear in certain legal documents, even though they don’t make any sense to the newbie.

If we were to stop worrying so much about the young lawyer, and worry a little more about the client who is subsidizing the young lawyer’s education, would that be wrong?

And if turned out that the default profession had a higher cost of entry so that college students thought twice about studying harder for organic chemistry rather than being forced into the only profession that has absolutely no prerequisites whatsoever, would that be wrong?

Don’t poo-poo this idea so quickly.  There’s method to the madness.


Troy Davis Execution Stayed; Family “Furious”

The family of off-duty police officer Mark Allen MacPhail is “furious” about the stay of execution granted yesterday evening by the Supreme Court, about two hours before the scheduled 7 p.m. execution.  The Atlanta Constitution-Journal reports:


Annelie Reaves, MacPhail’s sister, said the victim’s family was furious but would wait for the execution to be rescheduled.


“It should have happened today,” she said, “but justice will be served.”


At least two members of MacPhail’s family were to witness the execution, and they will return when the execution is rescheduled, Reaves said.


In response to Davis’ hope that the real killer will be found, the officer’s family and friends all laughed. “He knows who the killer is,” Reaves said of Davis.


There is nothing surprising about the family’s reaction.  But the lesson it teaches is precisely why victim’s rights advocates are so terribly wrong in their well-intended by misguided quest to give the family’s of victims a table in the well.

The issue is not whether Officer MacPhail was murdered.  He was.  It is not about whether the murder of a person is a terrible thing.  It is.  The issue is not about whether the murderer of MacPhail should be brought to justice.  He should.  Yes, there is always an issue in capital cases about whether execution is an appropriate punishment, but even this hot-button issue isn’t really at stake in this case.

The issue in this case is whether Troy Davis is guilty of murdering Officer MacPhail.  The family “knows”.  “Ha”, the utter in disdain, “Davis knows he did it.”  Knowing things is easy when one has an absolute belief.  But sympathy toward the victim and his family doesn’t make them right.  At all.  And their refusal to acknowledge, no less appreciate, that there is a very real possibility that the man they so desperately hope to see dead may not be the killer of Officer MacPhail changes nothing.  Not to them.

The Supremes have granted a stay, which may last no longer than a week, to consider whether factual innocence is a good enough reason not to execute someone.  This question will surprise many people, who would expect that innocence is an awfully good reason not to execute someone.  But procedure always comes first in our legal system, and we must respect procedure as if we were all grocery clerks.

Victims want “justice”, just like defendants want “justice”.  That’s why justice is such a great word.  It covers everybody, even though it’s totally opposite in each instance.  To the family of Officer MacPhail, justice means that someone dies to offset the death of MacPhail.  Even if one disagrees with the concept, it is completely understandable. 

We know, from the experiences of the families of other murder victims, that the execution of a person will not end their sorrow and loss.  It doesn’t bring the closure they hope it will.  It ends up being a largely empty experience, failing to meet their expectations.  Some families realize this before the execution.  Some do not. 

The families who believe that another death will end their torment cannot be persuaded otherwise.  It is not a rational belief, but a visceral need to satisfy their lust for vengeance.  I don’t demean this lust, as it is a wholly human need, and likely one that has allowed humans to survive.  But the notion that Troy Davis might not be the killer does not enter into the equation at all.  It’s laughable.

For the rest of us, including the judges, the idea that seven key witnesses have since recanted their testimony that Troy Davis killed Officer MacPhail seems a rather critical consideration.  While recanted testimony is inherently suspect, since the same people previously swore to God that their testimony was true, reducing their credibility to zero, it throws enough of a monkey wrench into the imperfect system to leave an unsatisfying doubt.

Imagine what a judge is to do with this information, contrasted with the victim’s family at a hearing to determine whether he should be put to death.  On the one hand, there is an interest in finality in a verdict.  On the other, there is a serious doubt as to the veracity of the very testimony that resulted in that verdict.  And then there are the victim’s family members, filled with absolute certainty of guilt and bursting with the emotional need to see that “justice” is done.  The only thing that is certain to the judge is that Officer MacPhail is dead and someone murdered him.

What do we expect the judge to say to the victim’s family?  We can all feel their pain and anguish.  No one wants to demean them, to belittle their feelings.  But they add nothing to a rational discussion of the only issue at hand: Whether Troy Davis is the one who murdered MacPhail. 

Does the judge try to explain to the victim’s family that they are being irrational by refusing to understand that this isn’t about whether their loved one was murdered?  Does the judge tell them that their certainty is just a delusion, caused by their desperate desire to see someone put to death?  The depth of their feeling has no place on the issue of guilt, yet the victim’s family has nothing else to offer.

While news of the family’s anger makes for a good emotional counterpoint when crafting an interesting article about the stay of execution, it is wholly irrelevant.  This is why victims have no place in the well of the courtroom, despite the sympathy we have for their loss.

When Burt Pugach Calls, Hang Up. Fast.

Freedom is just another word for nothing left to lose.

                                                            -Kris Kristofferson

Most people outside of New York have never heard of Burt Pugach.  Many who haven’t been around the New York legal world very long haven’t heard of him either.  But he’s a legend.  Now 81 years old, he’s as toxic as he was in 1959, when he became the personification of evil.

From the New York Law Journal :


Mr. Pugach was convicted in 1959 of hiring three men to throw lye in the face of his ex-girlfriend, Linda Riss. Ms. Riss suffered severe injuries, including burns across her scalp and nearly total blindness.

A prosperous Bronx attorney at the time of his conviction, Mr. Pugach returned to the law following his release from the Attica Correctional Facility in 1974, only this time as an assistant to others.

Amazingly, Pugach married Linda Riss after his release from Attica.  I can’t explain it either, but they have lived in marital bliss since, and were even the subject of a New York Times profile whe the movie about his life premiered.


Pugach was quite the operator when he made the decision to have acid thrown on Riss, and he hasn’t slowed down one iota since.

Burt has made the news again because of his toxic affect on Frank Hancock, a Queens lawyer who, inexplicably, decided to be a front for Pugach’s backroom law practice.  The end result was Hancock’s disbarment.

One of the worst kept secrets in Queens was that Burt was still playing lawyer, to whatever extent he could. But when someone needed to appear in court, it couldn’t be him.  So he needed a real lawyer to stand up for him.  That’s where Hancock fit in.


In a decision last week, the Appellate Division, Second Department, found that one of Mr. Pugach’s colleagues, criminal-defense attorney Frank J. Hancock, crossed an ethical line by enabling Mr. Pugach to practice law and by failing to inform courts of various frauds perpetrated by Mr. Pugach.

“[T]he record reveals that [Mr. Hancock] afforded so little regard to his law license as to allow a disbarred felon to use his name freely on court papers and to advertise himself as his paralegal,” the unanimous panel ruled in Matter of Hancock, 06-02769.

The panel disbarred Mr. Hancock, effective immediately.

What compelled Hancock to be party to Burt’s machinations?  Who knows?  The few bucks he made off the deal hardly seems compelling, though you never what someone will do for cash when they don’t think they’ll get caught.

Burt, on the other hand, got a walk on this deal.  What are they going to do to him?  Prosecute him?  Put an 81 year old in prison?  Deny a blind, disfigured wife her mate?  He has got to be chuckling to himself, because he has known what the bottom is like, and there isn’t much more that can be done to bother him.

Burton Pugach is a piece of work in the legal profession.  A real legend.  But if he calls you asking for a small favor, just hang up the phone.  While Burt has nothing left to lose, you do.

Will the Execution Proceed Anyway? (Update: Stay Granted!)

From Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy, news that Georgia is poised to put Troy Anthony Davis to death at 7 p.m. today.  Aside from all the normal reasons why the death penalty is problematic, there is one additional reason that usually touches a nerve, even with proponents.

In July 2007, the state Board of Pardons and Paroles stepped in and stayed Davis’ execution less than 24 hours before it was to be carried out. But on Monday, the board rejected pleas to reconsider its recent decision to deny clemency on grounds there is too much doubt as to whether Davis shot and killed a Savannah police officer.

Davis’ last hope to avoid his 7 p.m. Tuesday execution now appears to rest with the U.S. Supreme Court, where his lawyers have also asked for a stay of execution. Davis, 39, sits on death row for the Aug. 19, 1989, murder of Officer Mark Allen MacPhail. But since Davis’ 1991 trial, seven key prosecution witnesses have recanted their testimony.

Doubt of guilt is one of the fears that impacts even the staunchest supporter of the death penalty.    The Georgia Board of Pardons and Paroles says that it studied this case for a year, and determined that clemency is not warranted.  Is it?  Here’s the AP recap :



Davis was convicted of the 1989 murder of 27-year-old officer Mark MacPhail, who was working off-duty as a security guard at a bus station.


MacPhail had rushed to help a homeless man who had been pistol-whipped at a nearby parking lot, and when he approached Davis and two other men, he was shot in the face and the chest.


Witnesses identified Davis as the shooter, and at the trial, prosecutors said he wore a “smirk on his face” as he fired the gun, according to records. Jurors convicted and sentenced him.


But Davis’ lawyers say new evidence could exonerate their client and prove that he was a victim of mistaken identity.


Besides those who have recanted their testimony, three others who did not testify have said another man, Sylvester “Red” Coles confessed to the killing.


Coles testified against Davis at his trial. He refused to talk about the case when contacted by The Associated Press during a 2007 Chatham County court appearance on an unrelated traffic charge, and he has no listed phone number.


Prosecutors have labeled the witness statements “suspect,” and say the case is closed.


But for the fact that this is a death case, it would not have received anywhere near the level of interest it has.  Like it or not, society accepts the imperfection of the system to the extent that innocent people, or at least people who aren’t as guilty as the government says they are, go to prison. 

We haven’t a better way to distinguish the guilty from the innocent, and so we demand that a few take one for the team.  Sure, the old maxim that it’s better that 100 guilty men go free than one innocent man is imprisoned is often uttered, but the insiders know that we say this to pacify the masses, not because it’s true.  It makes people feel better about our imperfect system, and that’s really what our system of justice is all about.

But throughout our debate over the death penalty, the distinction is often made between those that society feels certain, absolutely positively certain, are guilty and “need killing” as my Texas friend explains to me, and those where the case is less clear.  The problem here is that this is one of those “less clear” cases.  So why are those who have the power to grant clemency toeing the line so closely?

Isn’t this one of those “theoretically too close to call” cases where death penalty advocates say execution is not the proper punishment?  The problem is that no matter where the line is drawn between those for whom death is views as the “right” punishment and those where guilt is too close to call, there will always be a government pushing the envelope to see how close to doubt they can come and still execute someone.  Oddly, it rarely helps when a case becomes a cause célèbre, as this has, since it seems like a challenge to state hegemony, and state’s hate to lose such challenges.

At 7 p.m. tonight, we may have an answer to whether the death penalty is reserved for those who are absolutely positively guilty, or just those we want to put to death anyway.  If the latter, then the discussion over the merits of the death penalty is a silly exercise in futility.

Update:  Stay Granted, at least for the moment.