Author Archives: SHG

As If Money Was No Object

The trial of Brian Nichols for his 26 hours courthouse murder spree has started, and according to the Atlanta Constitution-Journal, there is one additional death caused here for which there will be no trial:  The death of Georgia’s newly formulated indigent defense system.

The destruction caused by the Brian Nichols case has gone beyond the four people he killed and beyond the five he carjacked.

It’s also gone beyond the people he assaulted in the hours between his unprecedented escape from the Fulton County Courthouse on a windy Friday morning and his surrender 26 hours later at a Duluth apartment complex.

Those 26 hours three-and-a-half years ago may have been the death-knell of Georgia’s then-newly created system to eliminate inequities in a hodgepodge of indigent defense systems.

The financial —- and political —- drain of the case has crippled and maybe destroyed the Georgia Public Defender Standards Council, said Bright and Michael Mears, who previously headed the Public Defender Standards Council, the state agency charged with representing capital defendants like Nichols.

According to the ACJ, the cost of trying Brian Nichols, including compensation for two of the victims of his courthouse killings, has reached $13 million.  There are many hidden costs in a case like this, from the juror expense to the court personnel.  But the cost of paying for lawyers to represent Nichols is the one that has drawn the greatest political attention and ire.  

The political passion surrounding this case cost the original judge dearly, though it was his own fault.  According to the New York Times,

The original judge in the Nichols trial, Hilton M. Fuller Jr., resigned in January after telling a reporter for The New Yorker of Mr. Nichols that “everyone in the world knows he did it.”

Awfully foolish thing to say, but even judges get caught up in the passion of the moment.  Not good judges, mind you, but judges.

The Nichols case is clearly an extreme example, but it’s the extremes that test the system.  If the state wants to try him, to put him to death, then the state has to pay for his defense.  It’s a cause/effect calculus.  The problem is that the public sees the cause as a positive, or at least as a necessary evil.  The effect, on the other hand, is just a total waste of money, the public’s money, because as Judge Fuller said, “everyone in the world knows he did it.” 

Why bankrupt a system to help the guilty?  It strikes most people as a foolish waste of money.  In the current economic environment, it raises the question of whether it’s worth it.  Or more precisely, if it’s anywhere close to worth it, since there are few footing the bill in Georgia who think it’s even a close call.

There is a disconnect in our legal system between cost and benefit, where we have certain obligations that transcend their relative value to society.  It’s really not productive to spend this much on a single defendant, particularly when it risks bankrupting the indigent defense system and thereby impairing the system’s ability to provide an effective defense to all the others who need it and are due it.  If one looks at this from the perspective of allocating scarce resources, it’s foolish indeed.

But the prosecution of Brian Nichols leaves no other option.  The deal has two sides, and the harder and bigger the prosecution, the more expensive and involved the defense.  And so there’s a bill that comes due.

Money is always an object.  There are plenty of people clamoring for it. There are plenty of people who don’t want to spend it.  There are plenty of people who think this is just a total waste of time and their money.  And yet this is the deal if we want to maintain a criminal justice system.  You can’t have a prosecution without a defense.

Perhaps the better solution that complaining about the ridiculous cost of defending Brian Nichols, who “everyone in the world knows [] did it” is to consider the ramifications, social, political and financial, before the State of Georgia decided that it had to go for broke on this case.  And indeed, broke may well be what they get.

No doubt many will see the answer as doing away with this pretense called trials, thereby eliminating any need for a defense.  The more enlightened will urge a variation, doing away with trials for those who “we know” are guilty.  How they know this before the trial isn’t hard to fathom, since the police and the media tell them.

This might be a facetious reaction, except it reflects an attitude where the cost of defense just isn’t worth it anymore.  When a defense costs as much as Nichols has, the result may be that the public has had enough and are ready to junk the system.  Of course, that doesn’t apply when it’s their turn, but rarely does this point influence the discussion.  It just costs too much to defend the guilty. 

It will be interesting to see whether the people of Georgia, and elsewhere, support indigent defense once this trial is over and all the numbers are added up.  And then see what is proposed in its place.

Big Blog Bailout?

First it was Concurring Opinions.  Then the Volokh Conspiracy.  But what about us small guys?



Over at Concurring Opinions, Dave Hoffman announces:



Concurring Opinions, like A.I.G. and Fannie Mae/Freddie Mac before it, is now too big too fail. We expect that should our blogging rate slow, or the general market conditions to lead to a run on our host, the Feds will step in ensure market stability.


Ditto for the Volokh Conspiracy: So many blogs rely on this blog that our problems are really everyone’s problems.


Simple Justice is dead meat.  Orin Kerr is right.  I rely on VC all the time.  VC, on the other hand, couldn’t care less if I crash and burn.  If the big guys went under due to their portfolio of bad posts, it would wreak havoc in the blawgosphere.  Where would we turn.  Blawg after blawg would collapse.

But Simple Justice would barely make a ripple in the practical blawgosphere.  Sure, maybe someone would notice after a week or two that there was a big empty hole where once Simple Justice stood, but they would the shrug and move on.  Not even a tear.

Dang.  It’s like being Lehman Brothers, without being able to afford a new Ferrarri.  It’s painful when the big boys make you face reality.  I wonder if I can get a job carrying Kerr’s briefcase?

Electing the New Supreme Court

The New York Times Sunday editorial finally raised an issue that used to loom large in the public debate, but has been largely missing this election season.  What will the Supreme Court look like for the next generation?

Mr. Obama seems likely to pick moderate justices, who would probably not take the court back onto a distinctly liberal path, but also would be unlikely to create an unbreakable conservative bloc.

Mr. McCain has promised the right wing of the Republican Party that he would put only archconservatives on the Supreme Court. Even moderate conservatives like Anthony Kennedy, the court’s current swing justice, would not have a chance.

Given the fact that we’re talking about a branch of government here, it’s a rather big issue despite the fact that the media has largely focused elsewhere throughout the campaign.  Since it’s the Times, it’s not surprising that the editorial uses language that makes it unbearably clear which side they deem reasonable. 

Obama’s choice will be moderate.  McCain’s choice will be archconservative.  Not just conservative, but “arch”, as in “archenemy”.  “All things in moderation,” is an old aphorism, reflecting good and proper.  Ah, the use of language to paint a picture.

But then, what is Obama’s vision of the future of the law, of the Constitution, or a court that understands how its decisions affect this country’s citizens?


At the same time, Mr. Obama has put distance between himself and legal liberals on issues like the death penalty for child rapists and the constitutionality of gun control. As president, Mr. Obama would probably be more inclined to appoint centrist liberals, like Justice Stephen Breyer, than all-out liberals, like William Brennan or Thurgood Marshall.

I find it ironic that the Republican party, at least when it comes to judges reflecting their belief that it is their duty to impose a morality-based jurisprudence on Americans, have neither fear nor shame to stand up for their beliefs.  This has nothing to do with agreeing with their desire to impose a moral code on others, but just their sense of freedom to be what they are.

Obama’s “moderate” stance is the old “half a loaf” position.  He is not the counterpoint to the “archconservatives”, but conservative “light”.  We had a name for Barak Obama 25 years ago:  Republican.  We did better with Richard Nixon in the White House.  Pretty ironic, no?

How the Constitution fell so out of favor over the years, as the atmosphere of fear was carefully cultivated to push God-fearing Americans every closer to a Gulf of Tomkin resolution covering the North American continent is quite amazing.  It was really a miraculous achievement of public relations and psychology.

In the scheme of things, half a loaf is better than no loaf.  Tension on the Supreme Court between those who openly express their favor for security over rights may not result in the unanimity that one hopes for in order to provide long-standing clarity, and will not do much for restoration of rights that have eroded at an increasing pace, but it’s better than a wholesale change in our foundational law to reduce what little remains to vapid platitudes.  So the choice is clear.  But it’s hardly a good choice.

Lawyers arguing on the side of criminal defense and civil rights will step into the well and argue their hearts out.  It would be nice to think that someone is listening, even with only half an ear.

Chicago Cops Feeling Unloved

From Jeremy Richey at the East Central Illinois Criminal Law Blog, comes this AP story of unhappy police officers doing what unhappy police officers do when they become unhappy.  Apparently, cops in Chicago don’t like their new chief.  Why?


In addition to making fewer arrests, police are seizing fewer guns and frisking gang members less often than they did before Superintendent Jody Weis was brought in to clean up a department embarrassed by a string of brutality cases, according to interviews, statistics provided by police and an internal document obtained by The Associated Press.

Clean up the department?  Now why would a cop be antagonistic to a clean department.  Aren’t they all about law and order?  They should be thrilled that a new Police Superintendent has been brought in to get rid of all those “one bad apples” and restore honor, dignity and integrity to the nation’s second largest police department.  But apparently, the Chicago police are less than thrilled.


Since [an incident of beating a cuffed defendant shackled to a wheel chair], “guys feel the superintendent and the administration does not have their back,” said John Pallohusky, president of the police sergeants union.

The mistrust grew after the department announced recently that every police car would be equipped with electronic tracking devices and officers would be asked to submit DNA samples at crime scenes.

“If you don’t feel your bosses support you, are you going to stick your neck out?” Weisskopf asked.

What does it mean for the bosses to “have your back,” to give cops “support”?  After all these are the expectations, or maybe the demands, of the cop on the street if his bosses expect him to “stick his neck out.” 

No matter how hard I try, I can’t repress the smile that keeps popping up.  I so enjoy it when cops feel so unloved, unsupported, that they express the words that they spend the rest of their time denying.  They want bosses who will cover them, no matter what.  They want bosses who will whitewash their beatings and perjury.  They want bosses who will give them the nod and the wink when they “stick their neck out.”

They want to do whatever they do, and they want a boss who will stand up for them no matter what they do.  Is that too much to ask?


The first outsider to run the department in decades, Weis replaced 21 of 25 district commanders. He created a new Bureau of Professional Standards, which oversees the Internal Affairs Division, the unit that investigates officers.

He also started talking about getting police officers in better shape and ordered those on desk duty to hit the streets.

In addition, he asked federal officials to investigate an officer who had already pleaded guilty to beating a handcuffed man shackled to a wheelchair and was serving a two-year suspension. That angered the rank-and-file.

Who wouldn’t be angered?  I mean, really, sometimes you just have to beat those handcuffed perps shackled to wheelchairs.  It happens, you know?  Besides, he deserved it.  I don’t even have to know why the cop beat the handcuffed wheelchair shackled guy, but there had to be a good reason or he wouldn’t have done it. 

This is where the culture of law enforcement and efforts to reform corruption, violence and abuse, have a head-on collision.  There are cops who believe in doing the right thing, but they are a distinct minority in a job where covering their own is predominant.  Any wonder why the arrogance of police in their right to assert dominance over the rest of us remains intact, despite scandal after scandal, video after video, dead body after dead body?

I wish Superintendent Jody Weis the best.  He doesn’t have an easy job.

It’s Good to Work for the LIRR

This expose in the New York Times is absolutely shocking.  Long Island Rail Road allows workers to retire on pension after age 50 with 20 years of service.  Work rules allow some of them to get 4 days pay for 1 days work.  Shocking, right?  No, huh.  Well then, how about this.

Virtually every career employee — as many as 97 percent in one recent year — applies for and gets disability payments soon after retirement, a computer analysis of federal records by The New York Times has found. Since 2000, those records show, about a quarter of a billion dollars in federal disability money has gone to former L.I.R.R. employees, including about 2,000 who retired during that time.

In good years, the percentage goes down to 94.

It’s pretty easy, apparently.  All you need is an MRI and a larcenous dream.  For you youngsters out there, allow me to explain.  After age 50, your back looks like crap on an MRI.  There are these things called disks between the vertebrae, and they bulge, disintegrate and herniate.  It happens to all of us.  Trust me, I know.  And I’ve never done an honest days labor in my life.

So retire at 50, get an MRI showing a bulging disk, and go on disability.  What a great life!


During the workweek, it is not uncommon to find retired L.I.R.R. employees, sometimes dozens of them, golfing there. A few even walk the course. Yet this is not your typical retiree outing.

These golfers are considered disabled. At an age when most people still work, they get a pension and tens of thousands of dollars in annual disability payments — a sum roughly equal to the base salary of their old jobs. Even the golf is free, courtesy of New York State taxpayers.

If it makes you feel better, not all of them play very well.  Some have handicaps in the 90s.  I mean, how much more disabled could you want?

This is an outstanding piece of investigative reporting for anyone who wonders why the LIRR tickets cost so much or where their tax dollars are going.

H/T Kathleen, who’s never been on an LIRR train in her life.

A Victim of Success

Over time, a private criminal defense lawyer gets to represent a lot of people.  For the most part, our clients are repeat clients, coming back because we’ve served them well before, or referring their friends for the same reason.  Eventually, you realize that you’ve got a circle of clients who are all in some way connected to each other.  This connection often has nothing to do with their being in the same book club or knitting circle.

Work hard, represent them well, achieve successful results and they come to you when they are in trouble.  Keep them out of prison and they are repeat business.  Lose their case and they can’t come back to you.  They are otherwise occupied.

This made for a very busy and profitable law practice.  But things changed in the way the prosecution viewed lawyers.  I started hearing the words “house counsel” from the mouths of young prosecutors, who were asking the judge to throw me off the case.  This phrase was popularized during the prosecution of John Gotti, reputed head of the Gambino crime family.  His lawyer, Bruce Cutler, had been too successful in his representation of Gotti, and when Gotti was indicted in 1990 for the murder of Big Paul Castellano outside Sparks Steakhouse in 1985, he wanted Cutler by his side. 

The government came up with the “house counsel” attack, one that had a great deal of visceral appeal, despite its lack of substance.  Gotti retained Cutler again because Cutler did his job well.  That’s how it works.  The fact that he had served Gotti well in his prior trials seems like an awfully good reason to continue to use him, not a justification for precluding Cutler to represent Gotti.  The judge bought it, however, and Cutler was tossed.

In the 1990s, state court prosecutions of my clients individually gave way to massive federal conspiracy indictments of them as part of an “organization”.  I would get the call about a big bust, and walk into a courtroom to see 25 defendants, all of whom I had represented.  Some, I had represented many times.  Their faces lit up when I arrived, though they knew that I would sign on for the top defendant.  Still, they were far more comfortable knowing that I was in charge of the case.  Even though I was not the personal lawyer for everyone in the room, my representation would inure to everyone’s benefit. 

The prosecutor would then inform me that not only had I represented all the defendants named in the indictment, but the snitches as well.  While it’s possible to have current and former clients waive a conflict of interest to allow me to represent one defendant in a multi-defendant case when I had previously represented other defendants in the same case, there was no waiver to be had when I had represented the rats before they flipped.

I tried to argue my client’s 6th Amendment rights to counsel of choice, but it was in vain.  The government would pull out the old “house counsel” chestnut and the judge would get the snarly look on his face, as if I was trying to pull a fast one.

I was never house counsel to any organization.  I was a criminal defense lawyer who, if I did my job well, would enjoy the benefits of repeat business or referral business.  I was never on retainer.  I didn’t do their contracts or house closing or wills.  No one was ever forced to retain me to be their lawyer.  I did my job well, and people came back to me for that reason alone.  They were in trouble and needed a lawyer, and I was the lawyer they chose.  Isn’t this the way it’s supposed to work?

It broke my heart to watch these major conspiracy cases go forward, with my circle of clients sitting together in the room, without me.  It broke my heart not to earn a legal fee for representing them.  It broke my heart to watch good clients, people with whom I had become close during past trials and meetings and telephone calls, with some other lawyer sitting next to them in the seat that should have been mine.

I was a victim of my own success, and it was killing me.  There’s no other business where success would do this to you.

Dear Mr. Lawyer, Please Help, I’m Innocent

You can always tell a letter from a prisoner.  It has the tell-tale numbers on the blank line after the name on the return address.  Of course, the pre-printed name of a correctional institution is a dead give-away as well.  The address has a faded appearance.  That’s because the envelope was prepared on an antique devise that was once in common usage, but has since disappeared, except in prisons — the typewriter.  The characters lack the clarity and precision of a laser printer.

Over the past 25 years, I’ve received literally thousands of letters from prison.  Some are from clients.  Most are from people I don’t know.  Even though decades have elapsed since my first letter from an unknown prisoner, the content is almost always the same.

They are invariably polite, often to the point of being obsequious.  They tell me that a grave injustice has been done to them.  It will include how many years they’ve been there, and how many years they have to go.  Rarely does the letter mention why they are there, omitting such words as “murder” or “rape” or “drug dealing”.

The letter would explain that the prisoner was writing to me because they heard of my reputation and desperately needed a lawyer like me to free them from this wrongful conviction.  It was invariably flattering, if entirely vague.  I assumed that the same flattering language was included in every letter they sent to every lawyer they could find.  Generic flattering phraseology can be easily reused.

In the old days, the complaint was usually about how a cop set them up or beat a confession out of them.  This gave way to the false identification and false scientific tests, ranging from fingerprints to lead-bullet analysis to the failure to do a DNA test.  The letters close with the same assertion:  “I am innocent.  Please help me.”

I’ve received letters from people whose name meant nothing to me, and from people whose name would later become very familiar.  I received a letter from Marty Tankleff many years ago, when he was searching for someone who would believe him.  Even then, his name was familiar as the conviction for the double murder of his parents was big news.

The problem with each of these letters has always been the same.  What am I supposed to do?  When you receive a dozen such letters a month, each of which claiming innocence, it nags at a criminal defense lawyer.  There’s something in our heads that makes us bristle at injustice.  It’s just our nature. 

But the unspoken plea in each of these letters is the same.  They have been convicted.  They have lost their appeal.  Time has gone by and they are still in prison, alone to face their demons.  They are no longer entitled to free legal services.  They have no money to retain a private lawyer.  Their families have moved on to other things.

The unspoken plea is for some private lawyer to take on their cause pro bono. 

The letters complain of the injustice and unfairness of our criminal justice system.  I’m painfully familiar with it, and don’t really need a letter to explain it to me.  But I can’t help them.  Even the time it would take to respond to the letters, to gather sufficient credible information about their situation, would overwhelm my practice.  I mean, I could do it, but then I would be unable to represent the clients who retain me, pay the cost of my daily java and feed my children.  There is only so much time in the day.

Most of these letters, no matter how much effort is applied, reflect situations that will go nowhere.  This isn’t because the letter writers are lying, but they aren’t always entirely truthful either, and are rarely accurate.  After thorough investigation and research, the end result is that there is nothing that can be done.  We have an imperfect system, and not all wrongs can be righted. 

I’ve never figured out a way to determine whether one letter is more worthy of my attention than another.  If you respond to a letter, you’ve invited a prisoner to put his faith in you, and he will do so in spades.  You will continue to receive letters, and pleas, and envelopes full of documents, mostly handwritten notes containing the prisoner’s legal analysis after hours spent in the prison law library, together with copies of decisions that he thinks apply.  There will be loose pages from his case, with explanations about why routine papers prove he was denied due process.  There will be requests that you have expensive tests performed on his behalf, because they will prove his innocence.  If I would just do one more thing, it will prove he is innocent, they write.

In the early days of my practice, I would keep the letters in a pile on the side of my desk.  I would look at them from time to time, wondering whether this one was someone I could save.  My partner at the time, Howie, would give me a smack on the side of the head.  “You aren’t responsible,” he would tell me.  “Stop feeling guilty and worry about the ones you actually represent.”  Howie had practiced 20 years longer than me, and was a killer old-school Irish trial lawyer.  He had been the head of Citywide Narcotics for the Legal Aid Society before going into private practice.  He had heard it all.  He was as tough as they come.  He drank heavily to dull the pain.

These letters still bother me.  Not that I respond to them, for the same reasons that I didn’t before.  But I still feel guilty.  I wish there was a way I could help every defendant fine as much justice as possible.

Colorblind Blawging

As a by-product of a programming screw-up yesterday, I found myself in momentary control of someone else’s blog.  After posting a reply to a comment, my blogging program dashboard put me in a screen that was entirely unfamiliar. After blinking a few times, I realized what had happened:  I was staring at the of a blog called Ask This Black Woman.

After logging out, I thought the least I could do is take a look at the poor person’s blog I had unintentionally accessed.  It was quite extraordinary.  The top post on the front page was This is Your Nation on White Privilege, by Tim Wise.  It was enlightening, both for its truth and for the perspective it gave.

White privilege.  This isn’t a phrase I would think of under normal circumstances.  But then, being white, why would I have to?  For me, this is life as usual.  But while I may have concern, empathy, sympathy and any other ‘thies I’ve left out, it struck me that there is one immutable fact of my perspective of all the subjects I write about:  I’m still white, and I don’t have a clue what it means to go through life being black.

Many want to believe that we aren’t prejudiced.  I’ve never thought that.  I believe that we are all prejudiced to some greater or lesser extent.  It doesn’t mean we don’t like people of other colors or races or nationalities, but that we don’t comprehend the world that others live in.  We can’t, no matter how hard we try or how strongly we argue the point.  So we see the issue confronting others from an outsider’s perspective, and do our best to pretend to get it.  Frankly, the best we can really do is understand that we don’t really get it.

Please take a look at This is Your Nation on White Privilege.  It’s funny, timely and insightful.  A small taste:


White privilege is when you can get pregnant at seventeen like Bristol Palin and everyone is quick to insist that your life and that of your family is a personal matter, and that no one has a right to judge you or your parents, because “every family has challenges,” even as black and Latino families with similar “challenges” are regularly typified as irresponsible, pathological and arbiters of social decay.

Go read the rest.  If nothing else, it will get your brain working, which wouldn’t hurt most of us.

Are the Guidelines the same for Diet Coke?

Via Turley, the latest version of the Pepsi Syndrome, this time a silly story of a clash between a $3.80 diet coke refill and a cafeteria patron at a VA hospital whose anger got the better of her.

From the Idaho Statesman,


[Natalie Walters,] 39-year-old North Idaho resident periodically drives her father, a disabled Vietnam veteran, to Boise’s VA Medical Center for doctor visits. She brings her own mug and fills it with soda in the hospital’s cafeteria. The cafeteria does not have a posted price for refills, and typically the cashier charges her $1 or $1.50, Walters said.


But on Aug. 20, when Walters filled her mug with Diet Coke, the clerk charged $3.80.


“I told her that cannot be right and asked to talk to the manager,” Walters said.


The manager told Walters the price is correct.


Walters decided she didn’t want to pay that much and offered to return the soda, she said. But the manager told her there was no way to accept the returned soda and Walters had to pay. Walters refused, and she said she was angry by this point, and she poured the soda onto the counter.


Little did Ms. Walters know what problems this would cause.  After a thorough investigation, including accessing her father’s medical records in order to identify the perp (so much for HIPAA), Idaho United States Attorney Tom Moss is bring her to justice:


The Bush administration’s top attorney in Idaho is bringing charges against a North Idaho woman for refusing to pay for a Diet Coke and then pouring it out on a counter at a cafeteria at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center in Boise.

Natalie Walters, now facing two counts that each carry a maximum sentence of six months in federal prison, thinks the case is a waste of taxpayer money and plans to fight the charges.

Sure, spill diet coke in a fit of pique and blame the government for wasting taxpayer money.  Seriously, Ms. Walters’ reaction to a charge of $3.80 for a coke refill was inappropriate, though charging $3.80 for a coke refill upon pain of jail should be a crime as well.  But is there no one left in the Department of Justice to say the words, “don’t make a federal case out of this?” 

Common sense is so often vaunted as the save-all of law enforcement, and yet it appears to be a commodity in short supply.  I can’t wait to find out which AUSA is assigned this prosecution, as that will alert the world to the prosecutor who is least admired in the office.

So many of these stories are so ludicrous that one doesn’t know whether to laugh or cry. 

Back to a small point, but a worth a mention.  Since when does a diet coke cost $3.80?  While it seems impossible to believe that a cafeteria, even one run by a government that buys $600 hammers, charges $3.80 for a diet coke, this is in a Veterans Hospital.  Are they capitalizing on a captive veterans audience, with no option to quench their thirst other than to pay $3.80 for a diet coke? 

This does not bode well for those needing assistance from the customer service department at AIG.  I wonder what guidelines angry customers will face there?

Should Landlords be Subject to Free Excercise of Religion?

New York West Side Democratic Congressman, Jerry Nadler, better known locally as the Weeble (cause he wobbles but he won’t fall down), has introduced a law to override the 7th Circuit decision in Boch v. Frischholz, holding that a condominium association had the right to prohibit religious displays, in this case a mezuzah, outside of their units.

According to the New York Sun, Nadler, who is an orthodox Jew, wants to protect the ability of residents of coops, condos and apartment buildings to mount religious objects outside their apartment doors.

“This legislation is a straightforward attempt to clarify the Fair Housing Act and prevent co-op and condo associations and landlords from interfering with residents’ free exercise of religion,” Mr. Nadler, a Democrat, said in a statement e-mailed to The New York Sun. “If not creating a public nuisance, residents should clearly be allowed to affix crosses, mezuzahs, or other religious symbols to their doors, no matter where they live.”

It’s understandable why this would be a cause of great concern for observant Jews, as one of their tenets is the duty to fix a mezuzah to the “doorposts of their house.”  In the effort to make this appear not to favor one religion, it would similarly force landlords to permit crosses, and likely Christmas decorations, on doors as well.

This is not about whether religious symbols belong on doors, and whether you like them or not.  Nor is this about whether landlords should, or should not, chill out and just let people do what they want.  This law is about taking the free exercise clause, a constitutional limitation on government, and imposing it upon private parties.  This is about making private ownership subject to constitutional restrictions on government.

If someone feels strongly that he needs to mount a religious symbol on the outside of his door, it would seem obvious that he should ascertain first whether that is permitted.  If so, no problem and everyone lives happily ever after.  Many landlords and coop and condo associations take no issue with installing a mezuzah, or a cross, and this is a non-issue.

But there are other buildings, as well as communities, that are formed for the purpose of controlling exterior appearances and maintaining a perfect consistency to create an atmosphere where individual tastes and choices are not imposed on others.  Whether or not this is your cup of tea, there are clearly many who desire this atmosphere, as demonstrated by the popularity of this concept. 

These buildings and communities make abundantly clear, up front, that while residents can do as they please within their doors, they can do nothing outside.  This is not thrust upon residents by surprise, but happily promoted as part of the marketing package.  For those who want an atmosphere free of individuality, this is Nirvana.  Unless Jerry Nadler gets his way.

The problem with forcibly extending rights, as this bill seeks to do, is that it comes at the expense of other rights.  In this case, it’s the right of the landlord and other residents to live in a place free from the imposition of other people’s individual choices.  The rights of one side necessarily impinge on the rights of the other.  Those who wish to create such communities, and live in them, should be able to make rules to suit their tastes as well.

I strongly believe that the government has zero business becoming embroiled in religion at all, and this bill strikes me as an unconstitutional exercise of governmental power to force one person’s religious observance down the throats of others.  It further strikes me as an unconstitutional deprivation of property, by forcing the owners to abide a restriction that was intended to apply only to government.

This is not, as Nadler would characterize it, a fight for religious freedom.  Residents are free to practice their religion, and hang whatever they want, on the interior doorposts of their homes.  And the larger aspect of religious freedom is freedom from religion.  People seem to forget this part of the deal.

Why can’t government keep its mitts out of religious issues?  And why can’t those who seek to exercise their religious beliefs show respect to those who don’t share them?