Author Archives: SHG

“Fashion” Police Pack a Punch

While the notion has been widely ridiculed, there’s a tendency to underestimate just how strongly people feel about youthful fashion trends that don’t suit their taste.  Particularly fashion trends that are favored by more “colorful” youths.

After all, when Riviera Beach, Florida passed the law against saggy pants, it was by an overwhelming majority.  It criminalized wearing “pants that show skin or underwear.”  Of course, Riviera Beach, better known as Upper Altacacca, where blue hair is the height of good taste, is hardly the measure of cutting edge fashion.  Even though the law was recently held unconstitutional “as applied,” the law remains on the books, with habitual violators facing jail time.

Easy though it is to make fun of such laws, and the locals who are determined to rid their community of unwanted undies, it’s decidedly less funny when a real police officer employs the same approach and methods in dealing with violators as they would with, say, an armed felon. 

No cop would be that much of a jerk, you say? Then watch this:

“With you underwear hanging out, your mine.” 

For the young man, Lorenzo Williams, 18, who was mugging and waving at the camera initially, this could have turned disastrous.  This Deputy, Jeffrey Nation, was sufficiently incensed to strike him in the throat.  Over his pants.  It could have gone much further if Williams was the “thug” that he appeared to be to Nation.

To his credit, Aiken County Sheriff fired Deputy Nation for his actions, and he’s being prosecuted for assault and misconduct in office.  I can’t help but wonder what the outcome would have been had there been no video of this encounter, or had the video never made the news. 

The incident was described by NBC Augusta as follows:

The incident started when Nation stopped the teen and a group of his friends and asked Williams to pull up his pants. The teen was charged with assault and disorderly conduct. Nation alleged the teen attempted to “head-butt” him during the encounter, a claim found to be untrue by the investigation. All charges against Williams were dismissed.

Note that the Deputy claimed and, as can be heard on the video, believed, that Williams was attacking him, thereby justifying his lashing out at the young man.  Note that before hand, Nation was rifling through Williams’ wallet in front of the camera.

Also note Nation’s reaction to another young man, Leon Patterson, off camera, who he states had punched a deputy and, according to Patterson, “beat it.”  He then tells Patterson to empty his pockets and calls in his name.

All this over saggy pants? 

This really isn’t about saggy pants at all.  It’s about the same thing as so many encounters between police and youth, particularly poor or black youth.  It’s about control.  It’s about teaching them who’s boss.  It’s the age-old assertion of authority over those who need a good lesson on who’s in charge.  And Deputy Nation was just the cop to teach that lesson.

Now I don’t care for saggy pants at all.  I think they look ridiculous.  I also think people who wear baseball caps backwards, or sideways, look as if their competency is in issue.  But I think people have a right to look as foolish as they want.

What concerns me far more is how this encounter, had their been no dash camera, would have been sanitized in a report, subsequent complaint and ultimate testimony, to show an officer beyond reproach. 

Saggy pants is just one of the latest battle grounds in one of the oldest wars.  It’s no laughing matter.

H/T J-dog, posting his thoughts at his Livejournal.

Hard Choices Sentencing a Kid Drug Dealer

From Doug Berman at Sentencing Law & Policy comes this New York Times article about the influences surrounding the sentencing of 19 year old Yiskar Caceres by Supreme Court Justice Thomas Farber.

“It’s almost an impossible calculus,” said Justice Farber, who sits in State Supreme Court in Manhattan.

The young man, Yiskar Caceres, had been arrested four times in roughly 15 months for selling or possessing cocaine, and Justice Farber already had given him an opportunity to wipe his slate clean before his most recent arrest, in April.

Judge Farber showed remarkable compassion.  But I can’t help but wonder, under the circumstances of this case, whether this is a good example.

Caceres, at the judge’s direction, prepared a paper explaining “what he was thinking.”  This was probably the first time in Caceres life that he attempted any introspection, making this a very interesting exercise.



Before he was sentenced, Mr. Caceres read the judge a three-and-a-half-page letter he had drafted at the judge’s request, explaining what he was thinking when he committed his crimes.


“I first started selling drugs at the age of 16,” Mr. Caceres said. “I went from one day having nothing to the next day having over $300. It was an unexplainable feeling.”


He added: “While the money was coming in, so did the status of having money and the respect I received from the fact of me having money. All these things made me overlook the wrong I was doing to myself and others.”


So he’s not going to win a prize, but this is remarkable for someone in Mr. Caceres’ position, where the chances are slim to none that he ever considered becoming a drug dealer worthy of a second thought.  Perhaps the most moving aspect of this article, and the thing that influenced Judge Farber, was this:



After The New York Times published an article about Mr. Caceres’s case in July, Justice Farber said, he received many letters. One, which he said was particularly touching, came from a man to whom he had given a life sentence for murder.


The letter said, “Nothing that they say about rehabilitation in state prison is true,” Justice Farber said. The inmate also pleaded with him to “please consider any other options than this human warehouse” for Mr. Caceres.


“It therefore saddens me that I have to sentence Mr. Caceres to state prison,” the judge said.


But there is also an ugly side to this story, that probably wouldn’t occur to anyone who doesn’t spend time in the trenches.  This was Caceres’ fourth conviction in a little over a year.  He was, what we call in New York, a pred, meaning a predicate felon who faced mandatory state prison time. 

And what did his lawyer, Mark Cohen, do for him?  He took his fee, pled him out, and gave him a fresh business card to call back when he got busted again.  Then pled him out again.  I’ve known Mark a long time, having helped him when he came out of the Bronx DAs office and taken him under my wing, until I came to the conclusion that we didn’t share an understanding of the role of a criminal defense lawyer.

Caceres could have been saved.  Instead, he was just another quick fee, plead ’em and weep.  Justice Farber did what he could to help Yiskar Caceres, given the limitations of the law.  It’s a shame that his own lawyer didn’t see his role the same way.  To him, Caceres was just another quick and dirty legal fee.

Bail All You Want, But…

I didn’t cause this crisis, and I don’t want to pay for it.  So if my government wants to use my tax dollars to save the American banking and investment banking system from collapse, to provide liquidity to the markets, to maintain business infrastructure, I understand.  But I have something to ask in return.

All those nice, young broker and banker people who received multi-million dollar bonuses; all those CEOs, CFOs, COOs, GCs and any other initials you can think of, who receive multi-multi-million dollar bonuses;

I want it back. 

Their enterprises are going belly up, and my government is going to save them because “they’re too big to fail,” “they will bring down the economy,” whatever, fair enough.  But the people who were paid millions and are responsible for every bone-headed decision that gave rise to this problem don’t deserve the money.  They sucked their millions out the back door, and now the government is using my money to bail them out through the front.  And they get to keep it?  That’s baloney.

I want it back.

Ill-gotten gains are monies taken but not earned.  Ill-gotten gains are monies taken under false pretenses, by fraud, by lies and deceit.  Sheer stupidity should now be added to the list, not because it’s criminal but because somebody has to pay for that sheer stupidity, and it shouldn’t be me.  I didn’t screw up.  I didn’t blow it.  They did, and they got paid millions for their efforts.

I want it back.

Where’s the incentive for those who held tight the reins of our money markets to make good decisions when it comes risk?  Where the incentive for those who had no say in our money markets to make good decisions when it comes to risk?  Those who didn’t risk are the ones who still have homes and savings.  These are the people who will be paying taxes.  Their taxes will be used to bail out those who made bad decisions.  But the people who made the bad decisions get bailed out by the people who didn’t make bad decisions, and get to keep the millions they were paid while making bad decisions.

I want it back.

And all those foreclosed houses, that will be taken off the books, hide a terrible little secret.  There won’t be anyone paying the property taxes.  The tax base will shrink overnight.  So those who didn’t jump in over their heads, who pay their mortgage, who pay their taxes, will now be paying the taxes for all those who aren’t.  And the banks, who foreclosed, won’t be paying them either, since they will be laying their bad assets off on the government.  And the government doesn’t pay.  So it all falls on the shoulders of those who did it the old-fashioned way, and we will be carrying the load that won’t get paid so that all the others can enjoy the fine services government has to offer on our dime.

I want it back.

But I won’t get it back. 

This morning, we had a discussion about all of this.  Our investment banking friends might be out of work, but they fortunately have earned enough that they can retire and live quite well for the rest of their lives.  And they’re only 29.  I, on the other hand, will still have to work for a living.  Nobody ever paid me a $10 million bonus. 

Sorry for the rant. 

What Does Recession Mean for Criminal Lawyers?

The other day, Mike Cernovich asked a very serious question that bears some equally serious thought: 


How will this credit crisis affect criminal defense law?

As you know, most people charged with a crime do not have large piles of money sitting around to pay a lawyer with. It’s not uncommon for clients to take a loan out against their homes.

With property values being depressed, many people will not have any equity in their homes to borrow against.

As you also know, when economic times are down, crime is up.

What effect, if any, do you think the current credit crisis is going to have on criminal defense? Will people be able to afford lawyers? How?

How many people will slip through the cracks. The people who make too much money to get a public defender, but now who have zero equity to borrow against….

Thoughts?

I gave an off-the-cuff response at the time, but in retrospect, think that there is a lot more to be considered.  The problem, after further deliberation, is that the criminal defense bar is best conceived as a Chinese menu.

Column A: Practice Type

Public Defender
Indigent Defender (18b)
Indigent Defender (CJA)
Private (lower end, state)
Private (higher end, state)
Private (federal)

Column B: Area of Practice

Rural
Suburban
Urban

Column C:  Region of Practice

Pick ’em

Column D: Nature of Offense

DUI/DWI
Street Crime (misdemeanor, non-violent)
Street Crime (misdemeanor, violent)
Street Crime (felony)
Drugs (misdemeanor)
Drugs (felony)
Drugs (federal)
White Collar (state)
White Collar (federal)

These columns, obviously, are hardly exhaustive, but are used to make a point.  There are broad variations in who we are, what we do and where we do it.  Each of these factors will potentially change the equation.

Historically, when the economy tanks, crime rises.  The old joke is that people commit crimes in good times and bad, but the fact is that when people can’t earn a living lawfully, people who would not be otherwise inclined to commit crimes become desperate and make desperate choices.  Not all, and it’s not an acceptable reason, but it happens.

Mike’s question was where will the money come from to pay for the representation of these people.  For some years now, I’ve felt that the private criminal defense practice was on the verge of collapse.  It’s not that there aren’t paying defendants, but that there aren’t enough paying defendants to keep the private criminal defense bar alive. 

There is a small group that has done, and will continue to do, very well.  These are the best know, best-regarded criminal defense lawyers.  These are not always the best lawyers, a point that’s been discussed many times before, but the ones to whom people who couldn’t judge a lawyer if their life depended on it (and it does) flock. 

Others, unfortunately, flounder for much of the time, waiting for the phone to ring with a decent case.  In the meantime, there are plenty of defendants in need of representation, but without the ability to obtain it.  Mike asks about those who paid their fees by taking out a second mortgage on their homes.  This group just disappeared, because there are no loans to be had, and they have joined the indigent.

It’s quite likely that courts, and those who create the construct for eligibility for free legal services, will be behind the times when it comes to determining how to qualify for a fee lawyer.  Own a home worth a couple hundred thou, and you’re one of the rich ones.  Except you can’t pay for a lawyer with the rumpus room, so it’s an asset of no utility.  You fall through the cracks.

In the meantime, there will not be enough funding to pay for enough lawyers to fill the needs of indigent defendants.  This creates a crushing burden, often resulting in massive systemic failures to represent.  As for the “private” lawyers without paying clients, the safety net of indigent defense to fill those empty hours will be slashed as politicians do everything possible to cut budgets.  If you think it was bad before, just wait.

That said, my prediction is that competition for good clients/cases, which has been fierce over the past few years to begin with, will get far worse, and be far more price competitive rather than quality competitive.

For those lawyers who do quality work for lower end crimes, find another practice area.  I predict your business is going to dry up, and that the bottom dwellers, sucking up felonies for $1000, will steal what little business there is.  As for supplementing your private work with indigent defense, I predict that there won’t be enough funding to pay, and vouchers will be cut, payments delayed and the work spread out so far that no one will be able to pay their bills this way. 

Public defenders will still get their paycheck, but their caseloads will double or triple, and their supervisors will shrug because there is nothing to be done.  Plea offers will get worse, because the prosecutors will realize that you don’t have the manpower to carry the load, and pressure will come to bear to clear out cases as quickly as possible. 

My suggestion is that lawyers who do criminal defense exclusively will have to start branching out into other practice areas to maintain revenues.  Most can’t carry the cost of an office, a practice and a family without a regular revenue stream.  If the phone isn’t ringing, you’re in trouble.  Have you saved enough to carry you through a year or two of not being able to make your nut?

Unlike the good old days, when criminal defense lawyers were one of the few groups able to thrive on bad economic times, I think it’s going to be different this time, largely because we had systemic problems going into this recession that hadn’t been the case before.

But that’s just my opinion.  What do I know?




Mafia Cops: Conspirators Forever

The Second Circuit reversed Eastern District Judge Jack Weinstein are reinstated the conspiracy convictions against New York’s “Mafia Cops,” Louis J. Eppolito and Stephen Caracappa.  In a 70 page opinion by Judge Amalya L. Kearse, the Circuit held that the conspiracy to serve the mob, by providing information as well as extortion and murders while Eppolito and Caracappa before their retirement from the NYPD continued on when they engaged in money laundering and drugs in Las Vegas in 2004 and 2005.

This is an example of how an exceptionally ugly case, involving exceptionally despicable defendants, pushes courts to stretch the confines of conspiracy until it’s lost all meaning, and merely serves as a vehicle to get defendants that need getting.

From the New York Times, Judge Weinstein made clear when he tossed the convictions for racketeering conspiracy as being outside the 5 year statute of limitations, that these were very bad men.  But he also did what judges are paid to do:  Apply the law.


Then, saying the five-year statute of limitations for racketeering had run out, the judge overturned the convictions despite what he called “overwhelming evidence” that the two men were “heinous criminals” who were guilty of the “most despicable crimes of violence and treachery.”

Following their retirement from the police force, Eppolito and Caracappa did not suddenly become saints, and years later, they engaged in other crimes.


Although murders and other serious crimes that the men were accused of occurred in Brooklyn in the 1980s and 1990s, prosecutors used more recent and less serious charges — money laundering and narcotics distribution in Las Vegas in 2004 and 2005 — to bring the earlier acts under the umbrella of an ongoing criminal enterprise.

The Vegas crimes, no doubt every bit as real as real and wrong as any other crimes, were used to bootstrap the earlier, and concluded, conspiracy in order to craft a conspiracy that fell within the 5 year statute.  But there was never any question that this was a blatant, transparent effort to manufacture a way to hold these two accountable for a conspiracy that had long since ended. 


Judge Weinstein, in throwing out the men’s convictions, had found that the recent crimes were “singular, sporadic acts of criminality,” and could not be considered part of the earlier conspiracy, which included kidnapping, bribery and obstruction of justice. Because the older crimes dated back more than five years, the men, thus, could not be prosecuted for them.

“The government’s case against these defendants stretches federal racketeering and conspiracy law to the breaking point,” Judge Weinstein wrote.

Judge Weinstein had also decided that the earlier conspiracy ended when the two detectives retired and left the New York area and other co-conspirators were arrested.

But the Circuit disagreed.  While there are few people who will feel much by way of sympathy for Eppolito or Caracappa, the decision is another in that long line of outcome oriented holdings that shows why bad facts make bad law.

Conspiracy, already a concept with so few limitations as to be a catch-all that can ensnare anyone against whom no evidence exists of the actual commission of any crime, has now been stretched yet further on a particularly suspect basis:  Money.


Judge Kearse, in the decision, cited the payments to the detectives as one factor that supported the prosecution’s view that the conspiracy spanned the entire period of the indictment, from 1979 to 2005.


She said that the jury had been told the principal purpose of the enterprise, as the indictment charged, was to generate money for the detectives, through legal and illegal activities.


Judge Kearse also noted that prosecutors had told the jury that the two men had “received money for each crime in New York, and they broke the law for money in Las Vegas.”


Thus, she ruled, the jury could have inferred that the conduct was “sufficiently similar in purpose” to show that “the enterprise that began in New York continued to exist in Las Vegas.”


Let’s follow that reasoning more closely.  These scum committed crimes, ranging from kidnapping to murder, in the 1980s and 1990s for money from the mob.  These scum committed crimes in 2004 and 2005 for money.  This conduct was similar because the purpose was to obtain money.  Therefore, it was an ongoing conspiracy.

Now Judge Kearse isn’t new to the game.  She knows that crimes are often committed for the purpose of obtaining money.  This is not a unique purpose.  So concluding that these crimes were committed for financial gain is, well, ridiculous.  It indicates nothing.  It provides no connection whatsoever between a conspiracy that happened when they were on the NYPD payroll as well as the mobs, and their decision years later to return to committing crimes wholly unrelated to what they had done earlier.

As I walked around the Eastern District courthouse yesterday, I couldn’t find a single person who thought the Circuit’s decision made any sense at all.  I also couldn’t find a single person who was surprised that Judge Weinstein was reversed and the conviction reinstated. 

I also couldn’t find a single person who believed that there was any stopping the government from manipulating the concept of conspiracy to get someone when they had nothing else.  Conspiracy is just a big, black hole into which all those defendants for whom no actual crime applies, fall. 

That Eppolito and Caracappa fell into the hole will not, per se, cause anyone to lose sleep.  That the hole is there should keep all of us up at night.   This is a terrible decision, and worse still that no one is surprised.

Lay Judges, Screw Litigants

When soon to be former Chief Judge Judy Kaye calls for a special commission, we can be assured that it will be “special” indeed.  As the term is used in conjunction with education, I’m afraid.

The verdict is in by the Special Commission on the Future of New York State Courts.  Not guilty by reason of insanity.  What else did you expect?  As explained by Newsday,


A commission yesterday called for overhauling the troubled system of village and town courts, but stopped short of requiring that judges be lawyers.

In a 297-page report, the Special Commission on the Future of the New York State Courts touted judges’ work ethic but criticized the “few bad apples” who abused their authority.

There are examples of judges ruling on cases involving their families, police being ordered not to file charges against a judge’s friend, and judges lacking the legal knowledge to decide complex cases.

The commission also found that some courtrooms outside New York City don’t have security screening equipment or holding areas for prisoners. Trials in rural areas are often in town garages.

Now I haven’t read, and have no plans to read, the 297 page report.  Still, I can’t help but admire the twisted logic that drives the commission to be more concerned about the location where cases are tried, magnetometers for villages with 7 residents, than about the fact that the local pump jockey is charged with safeguarding constitutional rights.  Genius.  After all, no particular reason why lawyers go to law school, whereas judges get to make it up on their way to the town garage.

Why, oh why, with all that we know about the foundational failures of lay judges, did this commission lack the body part necessary to reach a reasoned decision?  Here’s Judy Kaye’s rationale:


“The justice courts are New York’s oldest tribunals, dating back centuries,” Kaye said, “and today continue to serve a critical role in the state’s justice system, handling more than 2 million cases each year and collecting more than $210 million in fees.”

Perfect.  It’s like keeping mom around, even after rigor mortis has set in, just because she’s always been there.  Hey, Norman Bates thought this made sense. 

At the end of the day, the future of New York’s Courts is now made clear.  Prettier courtrooms.  More security.  Judges who know nothing about nothing, but are politically popular because they are one of the locals and a regular Joe Six-Pack, just like the rest of the locals.

Funny.  Where did I hear about this Joe Six-Pack recently.  It will come to me.

How to Impact a Senator? Through His Mercedes

Colin Beavan has a blog called No Impact Man.  But he had a bit of an impact today on New York State Senator Jeff Klein, representing the beautiful Bronx.  Colin, in an effort to leave no carbon footprint behind, rides a bike.  Senator Klein, in an effort to leave as large a footprint amongst his constituents as possible, drives a black Mercedes.  And they met.

As explained in this open letter to Klein, Colin describes the meeting thusly:


With nowhere to go to get out of your way, and to avoid serious injury or death, in desperation, I chose to knock on your window to let you know that I was there and that you should avoid veering further in my direction.


At this point, you brought your vehicle to an abrupt halt, not to avoid hitting me, but because you apparently needed to communicate something to me. You rolled down your window and said, “Get your hands off my car, you fucking asshole.”


I said, “You were veering into me and going to crush me.”


You said, “You better not touch other people’s cars. You might find that touching other people’s cars is more dangerous than traffic.”


Apparently, Sen. Klein is not running for re-election this year.  Or he just really, really loves his car.

But all things considered, his means of expressing his unhappiness with Colin’s decision to knock on his window could use some tuning up.  While this is New York, and New Yorkers are known for their use of colorful, sometimes expletive, language, it would have been wise to calm it down a notch after learning that the knock came only after a near-death experience.


Now, the thing is, Senator, I don’t particularly call you to task for calling me a fucking asshole. If the roles had been reversed, and I had a big black Mercedes and you came up in a purple helmet, knocking on my window, and I didn’t realize I was on the verge of crushing your legs, I might have called you a fucking asshole, too.

I’d like to point out, however, that, as mad as you were about my touching your car window with my hand, you could double or triple that strength of emotion when it comes to how frightening it is to be on the other side of the Mercedes driving wheel, especially when that particular Mercedes is coming toward you. 

Weigh it up: “he might scratch my black Mercedes” against “he might cause my little girl to be left fatherless.”

As for No Impact Man, who is doing everything he can to eliminate his personal negative affect on our planet, this fortuitous event may well be the start of his being Significant Impact Man, if he can get Senator Klein to consider using his obviously strong rhetorical skills for a more beneficial purpose than threatening a Manhattan bicyclist.

And for those of you keeping score, Senator Klein gets no points for this encounter.

“Six-Pack” Scalia Excoriates Liberal Chicago Law School

Apparently, the University of Chicago Law School ain’t what she used to be, according to Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.  Once a hotbed of “conservative ethos” and academic rigor, it’s now chopped liver.  Dan Slater at the WSJ Law Blog posts about my favorite judge’s latest slam against the influence of liberals on the legal educational process.

“I regret it,” Scalia said. “I don’t think the University of Chicago is what it was in my time. I would not recommend it to students looking for a law school as I would have years ago. It has changed considerably and intentionally. It has lost the niche it once had as a rigorous and conservative law school.”

Scalia taught at Chicago from 1977 to 1982, the halcyon days of conservative thought.  Naturally, it could only slide downhill after his departure.  In his speech to 500 members of the Federalist Society in honor of Constitution Day (no irony there), Nino left no doubt about his disappointment in Chicago’s fall from grace.

Oddly enough, this would be the same University of Chicago that went slumming to fill the slot left open by the departure of such luminaries as Scalia.  From the Chicago Sun-Times :


After Scalia left the school, it hired now-Democratic presidential nominee Barack Obama and started offering classes like Obama’s popular “Current issues in Racism and the Law.”

And Justice Scalia similarly had some thoughts on the sort of classes the law school should offer.

Scalia also had advice for students. “I took nothing but bread-and-butter classes, not ‘Law and Poverty,’ or other made-up stuff,” said Scalia, a Harvard law grad. “Take serious classes,” he urged students. “There’s so much law to learn. Don’t waste your time.”

Made-up stuff?  Ouch.  Not that I necessarily disagree with him, but if you’ve got the time to take Law and Pottery, there’s probably something more useful you could do with your time.  Like learn to be a lawyer.

But Nino wasn’t ready to give up the podium just yet.  After all, with 500 fawning sycophants hanging on your every word, this was an opportunity to draw blood by slamming the liberal elitist view that the toxic combination of education and thoughtfulness is the root of all evil.

“What did I learn at Harvard Law School or at my practice in Ohio or in the federal government that qualifies me to determine whether there ought to be — and therefore is — a right to abortion or to homosexual sodomy or a right to suicide?” Scalia asked. “I don’t know any more about that than Joe Six-pack.”

That’s quite an admission.  Anybody wanna bet that he still won’t recuse himself when these cases come before the court on the basis of abject ignorance?

The Outrageously High Price of Special Prosecution (Update)

The Niagara County Legislature approved an expenditure of $216,900 to pay for the special prosecutors who handled the murder case against Richard W. Matt, the Buffalo News reports, wiping out its contingency fund as well as an anticipated $67,900 of anticipated sales taxes. 

The need for special prosecutors to handle the case came about as a result of a quirky situation, with the elected District Attorney having been the former County public defender, whose office represented Matt when he was returned to New York from Mexico, where he completed a nine year sentence for killing a man in a bar fight, after fleeing New York for this murder.

But here’s the rub:


[District Attorney] Violante said [State Supreme Court Justice Richard C. Kloch Sr.] reduced the original bills submitted by Haremski and Mordino, two former Erie County assistant district attorneys. He would not disclose their hourly rate, except to say it was higher than the $75 an hour the state mandates as the pay for court-appointed private defense attorneys.

The special prosecutors, Haremski and Mordino, were former ADAs turned defense lawyers, who were co-opted to handle the prosecution.  Had they been appointed to represent Matt as defense attorneys, they would have received $75 an hour for their time.  As special prosecutors, however, they received more.  Much, much more. 

It’s odd that the District Attorney refused to disclose the hourly fee charged, and the reduced hourly fee approved, for Haremski and Mordino, since this is coming straight out of the public coffers.  But there is no doubt that its a multiple of what private counsel is paid to defend.  While such disclosure would likely cause some displeasure around Niagara County, suffering mightily from this economy, that’s how it works when public monies are spent.

This naturally raises the question that intrigues someone like me.  Why would the special prosecutors be paid at a higher rate than the defense?

Are they worthier because their side better serves the People?  Was this a sweetheart deal cut by the former public defender, now prosecutor?  Does the Niagara County Legislature think that the value of a prosecutor is simply more than that of a defender?

According to District Attorney Violante, price was no object:


“I know it’s a lot of money. I think in my heart, it’s money well spent,” District Attorney Michael J. Violante said. “Richard Matt, if we’re lucky, will die in jail.”

What does he mean?  Should the defense of an innocent defendant have a lower price tag?  Is the value of justice different, according to which side you’re on?  If they had spent half the money, a quarter of the money, would they not have obtained a conviction?  Does cash by a guilty verdict?

For many, it seems only logical that there should be parity in the value of legal services, regardless of whether it’s for the prosecution or the defense.  After all, neither side has a monopoly on justice.  While this has never quite been the case, and there are some relatively sound reasons behind it at times, rarely is there such a lop-sided example of the price tag differential between a prosecution and the defense.

If I was a taxpayer in Niagara County, I would expect some answers.  Since I’m just a criminal defense lawyer, I’ll have to be satisfied by saying that I’m disgusted by the impropriety of paying these special prosecutors so much better than an indigent defense lawyer.

Update:  For the sake of comparison, public defenders make $33,000 a year (plus health benefits) according my latest information.  Gee, I wonder how long the pair of special prosecutors worked on this case?  If only somebody had that information, I would find it very interesting.

H/T to Kathleen, my hinterlands correspondent, for raising my consiousness about this atrocity.

Bunkbenches Save Money at Too High a Price

Via the  New York Lawyer, Tony Mauro  reports that the Judicial Conference has decided to do its share to make the courts more fuel-efficient by having federal judges share courtrooms in the future, a variation on tag-team justice perhaps.

The conference agreed that in future court construction, every two senior judges will have to share a single courtroom. Similar court-sharing will be considered for magistrate and bankruptcy judges, as well as nonsenior trial judges in larger courthouses. The policy for senior judges may have limited impact, since little new courthouse construction is planned in the near future.

Anthony Scirica, chief judge of the 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, said at a press conference following the meeting that the move toward shared courtrooms was part of the judiciary’s ongoing cost containment efforts and a response to congressional pressure to find ways to “use courtrooms effectively.”

To the outsider, this probably sounds like a great idea on a number of levels.  First, recognition by the judicial branch that it too costs money, and that the money comes from overburdened taxpayers, suggests a level of involvement in the fiscal interests of the nation that is rarely seen.  After all, there has been a rash of courthouse construction in the past few years, building large and grand courtrooms with exotic woods and amenities reminiscent of a first class hotel.  Indeed, it’s hard to imagine that there’s any marble left after a new courthouse has popped up. 

The theory has long been that the courthouse, and its courtrooms, are a reflection of the majesty of the law.  They are built to appear impenetrable and overwhelming, to cow the ordinary citizen into appreciating the importance of the law, the court and the judge.  Since judges don’t direct armies, the impact is needed to make people take judicial pronouncements seriously.  Otherwise, who cares what some old guy in a black robe says.

Second, courtrooms are often underutilized, with doors locked and benches empty for hours each day, despite being some of the most expensive real estate in the federal government’s portfolio.  While judges are doing “stuff” in chambers, yet another wood paneled room dedicated to the robed ones, nothing is happening in the courtroom, leaving it wasted space.

But this plan has its problems as well, particularly for the practitioner.  As it stands, cases don’t get tried day after day, hour after hour.  At best, criminal trials happen four days a week now, and at worst there are numerous disruptions reducing a trial to two or three days and a few additional hours here and there.  This creates substantial disruption in the flow of a trial, prolongs trials (resulting in the potential loss of witnesses and jurors) and interferes with the ability to conduct cohesive examinations.

Imagine what would happen if a case was being tried in a shared courtroom, where in the midst of cross-examination, a second judge marched into the room and announced it was her turn to hold court.  The disruption of sharing would be manifest.  Trials could take 2 to 3 times as long, with its concomitant impact on jurors availability and willingness to serve.  Scheduling for lawyers would be impossible, never knowing when witnesses would be needed and having to keep them available for days on end.  The cost for experts would be astronomical.  And, if I may be a bit selfish, the impact on an attorney’s time and fees would be unbearable.

It appears that this otherwise fine idea has failed to take into account the practical problems the judiciary would create for the lawyer.  Of course, since so few federal judges have ever labored as a private criminal defense lawyer, they probably had no one in the room familiar with the issues, and no one to speak up to suggest that this brilliant idea might have some negative consequences.

While judges like having a big, grand courtroom in which to conduct their daily business of telling litigants to come back another day, the fact remains that the reason we need big, grand courtroom in the first place is to conduct trials.  When you make trials to onerous to conduct, you’ve defeated the reason for having courtrooms in the first place.  They are not, contrary to popular belief, just places to make judges feel good about themselves.

It’s not that there are no variations on a theme that would serve to reduce the number of courtrooms necessary, aside from my personal preference that they stop federalizing local crimes and thereby cut the volume significantly.  But the plan as stated simply ignores the impact courtroom sharing would have on the ability of criminal defense lawyers to defend.  That’s definitely not the answer.