Following up on the 11th Circuit decision that a mere three taser jolts of a hand-cuffed, sobbing, non-violent man sitting on the ground on the side of the road, was not an unconstitutional excessive use of force, comes this video of the incident.
As the title to this post suggests, my favorite line in the video is when the officer says, “I’m a’fixin’ to tase you.” For many, including apparently Chief Judge Edmonton, this was fair warning. It’s not so much about the tasing, as it is about being warned that the tasing is a’comin’. He even counted to three for the guy. What more could you want?
As I watched this video, I couldn’t shake the feeling that it all sounded so familiar. Then it dawned on me. It was like a dogowner who’s wayward dachshund ate his newspaper, smacking the dog in the face with it over and over to teach the dumb critter a lesson to not mess with his master’s paper.
Might the officer, who but for the tasing never lost his cool, have considered that a man sobbing on the side of the road has bigger problems than a speeding ticket?
Author Archives: SHG
When Murder Loses its Meaning
First it was Robert Heidgen. Now, Franklin McPherson, who was sentenced to 25 years to life in prison upon his Nassau County conviction for murder. That’s the maximum sentence, which was imposed yesterday by Judge George Peck.
A jury convicted McPherson, 21, of Deer Park, of second-degree murder in June for killing Leslie Burgess, 44, of Amityville.
McPherson drove his Lexus 5 miles in the wrong direction and killed Burgess when he crashed into his eastbound Jeep last October. He broke his legs in the crash.
It’s not to say that McPherson was an innocent man. He was not. It’s not to say that McPherson’s conduct was excusable. It was not.
But Franklin McPherson did not commit murder. To say he did cheapens the crime for the victims of real murders, and subjects it to the transitory whims of the prosecutor. McPherson was drunk. According to his lawyer, Dennis Lemke, he was far drunker than the .19 claimed by the prosecution. Dennis is a good trial lawyer, but he’s not really a “law man,” as they say. Neither was Steve LaMagna, Heidgen’s lawyer. It’s unclear whether a good “law man” would have had any impact on the trial court. Most of the judges aren’t “law men” either.
The basis for the second degree murder charge was the “depraved indifference” theory:
Penal Law Section 125.25(2) states that a person is guilty of depraved indifference murder, when ‘under circumstances evincing a depraved indifference to human life, he recklessly engages in conduct which creates a grave risk of death to another person, and thereby causes the death of another person.’
For many years, this language confused almost everyone in New York, and led to prosecutors commonly charging murders as both intentional and depraved indifference, under the theory that if it wasn’t the first, it had to be the second, hoping that if they threw both at the wall, something would stick. This changed with the Court of Appeals decision in People v. Payne, where the Court held that depraved indifference referred to the defendant’s state of mind, not to an external view of how horrible his conduct was.
The defendant must have known and appreciated the potentially fatal consequences of his action, and made the active decision to engage in the conduct nonetheless.
The conduct engaged in by McPherson, as well as Heidgen, was drinking alcohol. It was drinking to excess. And then driving a car in this drunken state. But neither the Nassau County District Attorney Kathleen Rice, nor the assistant who tried both the Heidgen and McPherson cases, Maureen McCormick, will say this.
Instead, the explanation goes like this:
After the McPherson verdict, Nassau District Attorney Kathleen Rice said he, like Heidgen, acted in a way that showed he was guilty of depraved-indifference murder, meaning he acted recklessly, knew the risks of his actions and ignored them.
“This defendant’s preventable actions led to this inevitable tragedy,” Rice said.
Who, amongst the public, would disagree with Rice? But that doesn’t make this a murder. And notice how nobody mentions that it’s not like McPherson walks free if he’s not charged with murder. There’s always a 10 year sentence for manslaughter available. Or criminally negligent homicide, though that crime doesn’t have that cool, violent ring to it, and “reckless” isn’t as nasty as “depraved”.
Depraved is perhaps one of the smartest words a legislator every approved. It immediately evokes an image of Freddy Kruger, evil personified. What good is a crime if it doesn’t evoke an image of evil? That’s why misprision of felony is so rarely charged. No visceral reaction. No mental image. It’s boring.
McCormick’s explanation doesn’t add much to the public’s understanding either:
Maureen McCormick, the prosecutor who won both convictions, said, “The Heidgen case was not a fluke or a political stunt, and it was not because it was an adorable little girl who was killed.” She was referring to 7-year-old Katie Flynn, a victim in that crash. “The facts are what made these cases murder.”
As has become so very popular, an appeal to emotion is hidden behind vague things that seem to make sense, provided one doesn’t let things like the law get in the way. This has long been the push by advocacy groups such as MADD to create a growing public intolerance for drunk driving, and create the impression that ever-increasingly harsh charges and punishments are the only way to stop this plague.
The problem is that these groups have been so successful, and politicians have basked in the reflected glow of this success, that when reality gets in the way of these PR campaigns (meaning when convictions for murder do nothing to stem the tide of drunk driving), they need to find yet a deeper, harsher, more horrific penalty to impose. Yeah, if only they got the death penalty, that would fix the problem!
The reason why they are slaying imaginary dragons is that this is not the crime of murder. It never was, and never will be. Drinking too much and getting drunk is not something that one contemplates as part of a violent crime. Driving home drunk, every stinking drunk, isn’t meant to cause harm. It’s meant to get home.
There are no real similarities between shooting a gun into a crowd and driving home drunk. The former serves no purpose other than to cause harm. There is no harmful purpose in the latter. The former has a high likelihood of killing someone. The latter could well kill someone, but has only a minute probability of occurrence. The former is murder. The latter is not.
The forces against drunk driving are empowered by these convictions, and the public appreciation of what a wonderful job they are doing to protect their children from death at the hands of these vicious drunks. I’m no apologist for drunk driving. I think it’s an incredibly wrong thing to do. But I’m also no fan of overcharging, of taking a lesser crime and making it greater to curry ignorant public favor.
No doubt Dennis Lemke will be filing a notice of appeal shortly, and I hope that the lawyer assigned to do the appeal will do an exceptional job. The appeal in Heidgen is still pending. As of now, there’s nothing to suggest that an appellant’s brief has been filed with the Second Department. In all likelihood, this issue won’t be resolved until it reaches the Court of Appeals.
There is absolutely no question that the convictions for murder must be reversed. And this reversal will not be a slap in the face of society, or the prosecution, or the Mothers Against Whatever, but return to grounding convictions in the law rather than the appeal to raw emotion.
Get drunk, turn onto the off-ramp instead of the on-ramp, get convicted for murder. Is this really what you want?
Going for Broke
My buddy Mike from Crime & Federalism, unrepentant Gen-Y slacker that he is, blames us baby boomers for a precipitous decline in his 401(k). He calls us “old guys,” as if he’s not going to need Geritol some day.
But there’s also Tom Friedman’s vision of the problem.
Just like the dot-comers in the 1990s, the financial stocks got inflated to ridiculous levels and salaries for Wall Street executives reached ridiculous heights. You are now watching live and in color that bubble burst: “Thank you for playing, Lehman Brothers.” That’s really sad for a 158-year-old company.
The market is now consolidating this industry, with the strong eating the weak, which will impose its own fiscal discipline. Good. Maybe then more of our next generation of math geniuses will think about going into engineering the next great global industry — energy technology — rather engineering derivatives.
Greed knows no age. Greed only knows that there has to be some way to make more money, whether in good times or bad.
This time around, the bubble came in the form of subprime mortgages to purchase overpriced housing with no money down. And who was doing the buying, Mike? Not us boomers. We already own homes, which we purchased for 20% down with a fixed rate mortgage. If anything, we were selling, not buying. We’re ready to downsize. No need for these extra rooms now that the chickens have left the roost. Unless, of course, they came back after college so mommy could continue to wash their clothing and cook them breakfast.
But as the housing market collapsed, and people couldn’t cover their mortgages or sell their houses, the bonds lost value and, therefore, the banks that held them lost capital, and the whole pyramid started to crumble. This infected the entire housing market, so banks no longer knew the value of their mortgage-backed assets. The result? They stopped lending. Hence, the current credit crunch. This credit crunch is what makes this crisis so lethal. We can’t tolerate a prolonged situation where banks won’t lend to good companies.
It’s much like the hereditary root of insanity: You get it from your children. As the dominoes now knock down the greedy companies, the ones who rolled the dice to win the big prize, they started with newly minted homeowners who firmly believed that life owed them a McMansion even though they hadn’t saved a dime in their lives.
That’s why Congress needs to create another Resolution Trust Corporation like we used to get out of the savings-and-loan crisis of the 1980s. As then, so now, we need a government agency to buy the toxic mortgages off the banks’ balance sheets, hold them and sell them in an orderly way later. That would prevent a fire sale of homes and mortgages now and restore confidence to banks so they start lending again.
This is where Friedman goes astray. He assumes that there will be an orderly way to rid ourselves of these silly, worthless instruments some day. As I’ve said before, Friedman is a starry-eyed optimist. The people who spent their lives saving and investing with some modicum of prudence aren’t interested, and the people who want it all now, now, now, lack the wherewithal. Where is the money to fund the future going to come from? The Slackoisie tell us they’re brilliant, but have empty pockets.
Blaming your parents for handing over a world rife with debt and greed is easy, but it isn’t a generational problem. It’s a greed problem. The boomers aren’t immune from greed, and we certainly needed to accumulate as much wealth as possible to buy all that electronic stuff that our beloved children demanded, while keeping them fed and a roof over their head. You like all that stuff then. You told us you would die if you didn’t get it. So we got it for you. Do you regret it now?
But that was then, and this is now. Where were the Slackoisie when it came time to vote in 2000 and 2004? It doesn’t cost anything to vote. You just have to stop playing x-box long enough to pull a lever.
To be fair, this isn’t about Mike or me. We’re not likely the poster boys of our respective generations, and as criminal defense lawyers, we certainly didn’t get to enjoy the benefits of the bubble like our dear Wall Street friends. We’re just a couple of normal working guys, doing our best to survive. I’m just giving Mike the business because he gave it to me.
But the attitude that gave rise to some of the underlying problems, well before the “greedy Wall Street CEOs” (the evil villain du jour, per John McCain this morning) decided to go for broke, has yet to be addressed. You can’t “have it all” without doing something to earn it. You’re not going to get it all without putting in the effort. Every day isn’t going to be fun.
I read a book in 1966 by Robert Heinlein called “The Moon is a Harsh Mistress.” A theme of the book was an acronym that I never forgot. TANSTAAFL. I never forgot it.
What Not To Wear, Republican Edition
In the aftermath of the Republican National Convention, we learn that the protesters weren’t the only people at risk. One delegate in particular found himself in the crosshairs. No, not of the police, shooting pepper spray and ramming with bicycle tires. Something far more insidious. The target of a beautiful woman.
According to this Pioneer Press piece, brought to my attention by J-dog, aficionado of all things salacious in Minneapolis, the price of a piece was high for RNC delegate and “experience” Colorado lawyer Gabriel Nathan Schwartz, 29.
He met her in the bar of the swank hotel and invited her to his room. Once there, the woman fixed the drinks and told him to get undressed.
And that, the delegate to the Republican National Convention told police, was the last thing he remembered. When he awoke, the woman was gone, as was more than $120,000 in money, jewelry and other belongings.
The thief’s take stunned cops.
We have all seen the strange and ridiculous get-ups worn by delegates to political conventions, but never before did I realize just how highly such outfits were valued.
Now there’s nothing wrong with Gabe, young and single and ready to mingle, hooking up with babe at the bar. Even Republicans are allowed to get some, provided it doesn’t happen in airport men’s rooms. But why would he have $120,000 on him at the RNC?
Well, Gabe claims that the media inflated the figure.
It’s embarrassing to admit that I was a target of a crime. I was drugged and had about $50,000 of personal items stolen, not the inflated number that the media is reporting from an inaccurate police report,” he said.
Darn those inaccurate police reports. Still, 50 grand isn’t chump change either.
The haul included a $30,000 watch, a $20,000 ring, a necklace valued at $5,000, earrings priced at $4,000 and a Prada belt valued at $1,000, police said.
A necklace and earrings? I’m confused. But Gabe was reluctant to elaborate, possibly because he realized that his effort to recoup his loss through his insurance policy at AIG might be seriously jeopardized by further explanation.
Reached by phone at his law office Monday, Schwartz said that because the case still was under investigation, “I think at this point, I don’t want to make a comment on it.”
During the convention, Schwartz wasn’t shy about talking to the media. In an Associated Press article about Sen. John McCain’s acceptance speech, Schwartz was quoted as saying that as far as oratorical skills go, McCain “has more experience in his little pinkie” than Democratic nominee Barack Obama.
But did McCain wear a $20,000 ring on that pinkie? I don’t think so.
It’s perfectly understandable that Delegate Schwartz from the Great State of Colorado, home of Coors Beer and the Denver Broncos, wanted to look sharp and make an impression amongst the very important people he would meet in the Twin Cities, and it’s only natural that his bling would catch the eye of a beautiful woman, since he obviously wasn’t going to score based on his natural good looks.
But there’s a lesson to be learned. Wearing Prada is just asking for trouble. And as can be seen from this video of Schwartz illuminating his views on “less taxes and more war” below, his choice of shirts is suspect as well.
Blawger Victimized by Brooklyn Legal Aid Lawyer (Update!)
While it’s hardly uncommon for some spam website to steal blawg posts and publish them as their own, in order to catch a few eyeballs and steer people toward their ads for counterfeit viagra, this is the first time I’ve seen something like this.
Apparently, the Queen of New York Blawgers, Niki Black at Sui Generis, has a fan who loves her just a bit too much. The fan has a blog (and I use that term loosely). According to the blog, his name is Michael Rehm, and he says that this is how he describes himself:
Hello, my name is Michael Rehm and I am a New York DWI Attorney. I currently practice at the Legal Aid Society in Brooklyn, New York. So…that means I am not a private lawyer, so please do not call and ask me to retain. I cannot accept private cases and it will just make me depressed. But I do believe there is a need for blogs like this to keep the public informed on the current changes and aspects of all New York DWI and Criminal Law. If you are a current client of mine, look around, and see what questions you have and you, and you alone, can call for legal advice. I am going to try and load this blog with as many resources as possible for my clients and for the public in general with the aim that no one who visits this site will walk into court uninformed. Right now, the blog is slim on resources, but that is changing, so keep an eye on this blog and it will meet all expectations. Good Luck!
The Lawprofs Respond: The Slackoisie are Differently Abled
Jeffrey Harrison at MoneyLaw has been gathering data on law student tendencies, reaching the conclusion that the Slackoisie have brought about the New Age of Disability. Of course, since use of the word “disability” is viewed by many as pejorative, we shall reform his language to “differently abled,” having rejected the characterization of “bunch of total losers” as being unduly lengthy.
Following the best of scientific protocols, Jeffrey’s research has produced the following examples:
1. A student asked to have a 2 year old grade changed in order to improve his class rank.
2. A mother called to complain about her son’s grade in a class.
3. A student was devastated by a comment on a paper because it was followed by an explanation point.
4. Two attorneys and one judge have asked “What is going on.” They say they have never encountered students who required as much “hand holding.”
5. Employers visiting to interview complain about student attitudes as signified by wearing shorts and ipods to an interview, being aggressive about what they will and won’t do, lateness, etc.
Of course, we’ve accumulated the same sort of data anecdotally here at Simple Justice. And where we can’t find an anecdote, we just make it up, which is why it’s important that our machinations are verified by properly conducted research.
Jeffrey goes on to note:
If ability means being prepared to contend with the ups and downs of life, being able to shake things off, being determined, to learn from criticism, and to take the initiative to solve difficult problems, it seems like we are well into an new age of disability.
Pondering both the source of this ugly turn for the worst, as well as its implications for law schools, he accepts his share of the blame.
I am pretty sure we play a role in the disabling. In talking to some law professor friends, none could not remember more than a time or two when he or she said in response to an classroom answer “No, actually that is wrong.” Instead, the answer is something that leaves the student feeling good but likely hearing an inaccurate message.
Having offered his mea culpa, because God knows it couldn’t possibly be the fault of the Slackoisie themselves as they cannot, by definition, be responsible for anything in their lives that negatively affects their self-esteem, it seems appropriate that our brethren in the theoretical lanes of the legal superhighway receive the full support of those of us in the far left lane, weaving in and out as suits our disposition.
Shortly after that glorious day when your students toss their mortar boards high in the air, without the slightest care for the return of the deposit on the regalia that was charged to mommy’s credit card, your former law student who has likely never been told by any professor that his response to a question in class was “wrong” or that he was a “blithering idiot” who should consider an alternative career path, will stand up before a judge.
Now judges have changed somewhat since the old days. But not that much. After your former student expresses his most thoughtful and well-prepared argument on behalf of an actual, living client, forcefully and with a passion that can only be mustered by the young and inappropriately healthy, beaming with the glow of knowing that he has crafted a position that fills him with pride as his finest work, he will hear the magic word:
DENIED
No “and”, no pat on the head, no hug. Just denied.
The former law student blinks a few times. His eyes begin to glaze, then water. His face is red, flush with emotion. His head spins. “What could this be,” he thinks, as his mind races to make sense of this new experience. At first, he thinks he must have heard wrong, as he knows how much he loved his argument and that it was the best argument he could possibly make. But as the uniformed court officer grabs him by the shoulder to push him out of the well, he realizes that something is wrong. Very wrong.
In a dream-like state, he walked toward the bench, staggering until he drops to the hard, cold surface. He feels the firm, no harsh, grip on his upper arm, the sense of wet droplets striking his cheek and ear. He realizes his client is next to him, so close that he can smell the odor of his warm, moist breath. Then he hears the assault of sounds, pounding and pounding his head.
“You moron, you idiot, you fool . . . you told me you had this under control…you’ve ruined me…you’ve ruined my life…you suck…you stink… you idiot…”
The problem, you see, is that this former law student is unprepared for this eventuality. He’s never been told before that he can be wrong. His world has never included outright rejection of his thoughts and ideas. He has never experienced the moment when someone says “no” to him, without equivocation or explanation. Throughout his education, he’s been told that if he tries his best, if he believes that he has produced the best work he is capable of, then he has succeeded.
No one ever prepared him for the judgment day. No one ever told him that someday, it will not matter what he thinks, as there will be another person who will judge him. His entire life has been guided by “I think” up to now, and the very notion that what he thinks no longer rules the day will rock the foundation of his existence.
Jeffrey concludes by asking the question, “Is disabling people really a way to be kind or show your respect?”
I guess it’s easier than fielding that call from the vicious helicopter mom. But no, shielding junior from judgment day is not a sign of respect. It’s just the path of least resistance.
So how exactly are the Slackoisie differently abled? Well, actually they’re not. They’re just a bunch of self-absorbed whiners who hides behind their mother’s skirt rather than face the reality that sometimes you win and sometimes you lose, and nobody cares if it makes you feel badly about yourself. And it doesn’t really matter whose fault it is, because eventually everybody has to take responsibility for themselves and stop blaming others for their failings.
Clearance Sale – Burglary is a Loss Leader
The FBI has released its statistics on crime in the United States for 2007, always an interesting read for those struggling with career choices in uncertain economic times. While the rates in general for 2007 show a decrease from the prior year, crime remains a strong industry compared with most other options in a declining economy.
So the natural question for a young man coming of age today, what’s the best career opportunity for me?
The stats clearly show that murder offers little to the up-and-coming criminal, particularly since most are committed against people they already know, meaning that the universe of future growth opportunities are limited. Moreover, crimes of violence against others in general appear to have less appeal in 2007 than the year before, suggesting that anyone seeking a future in crime should steer away from acts of violence.
On the other hand, crimes against property are thriving. But most importantly, the clearance rates for property crimes, and particularly burglaries (or home invasions as has become the fashion), is sitting at a spectacular low.
For less than half that of a robbery, and with significantly reduced operating costs, burglaries present enormous opportunity for the go-getter. While some might think that motor vehicle theft offers similar benefits, it’s important to remember that it’s a crime on the decline, down 8.1% from 2006 and 13.1% from 2003, apparently as a result of high gasoline prices. Remember, the cost of a getaway comes straight out of your pocket.
Of course, for the victims of property related offenses, the news is grim. Chances are good that you won’t be able to get an officer to even talk to you about it, as our good friend Shawn Matlock found out when he decided to take a walk on the wild side while doing research in anticipation of being tapped to take the lead on crime policies for the Republican presidential candidate.
If you would like to read a more thoughtful discussion of the FBI statistics, Grits has parsed the numbers (and presented a terrific chart showing the FBI’s homage to watchmakers) in this post.
Since I’m of the view that these statistics are utterly meaningless, and are largely used as propaganda tool to demonstrate either what a fine job law enforcement is doing or to justify the need for massive increases in budget or manpower, I’m more inclined to consider this an invitation to young men and women select career alternatives.
Lawblog 2008 a Smash in London
Early reports are in from Lawblog 2008, the monster party of law blawgers from the continent. Held yesterday evening at The Harp in London, featuring such luminaries of the legal blawgosphere as Geeklawyer and Charon QC, with the ever-lovely Miss Ruthie as the Grand Wazoo.
For most Yank blawgers, the opportunity to spend a few hours with our cross-water co-conspirators is a dream come true. Not to mention, just the chance to be at the beautiful Harp would be more than most could bear, particularly in contrast to the normal American bastion of blawgospheric meetings, the Cracker Barrel.
Thoughtful conversation and detailed discussion of issues of grave import to the legal world took a back seat to the group’s efforts to ascertain what foreign objects were floating in Geeklawyer’s glass of beer. It was ultimately determined to be irrelevant, as the detritus disappeared when he took a long, hard swig, apparently forgetting that Ms. Ruthie had earlier spewed in a particularly lady-like fashion following a bad dish of bangers and mash.The American blawgospheric representative was none other than Dan Hull, of What about Clients? fame, who has spent the last month touring European capitals in search of dragons to slay. Finding none, Dan was readily available to join Miss Ruthie in leading the Antler Dance, performed early in the evening.

Later that evening, after quaffing a few additional Guinness’s in particularly long necked glasses, Dan requested that the European blawgers observe a minute of silence in memory of the American economy. All complied except Charon QC, who was so deeply moved by Dan’s solemn demeanor that he locked himself in a small white room to be alone with his thoughts.
The quiet was shattered when Dan had enough of the pall he brought over the room by showing everyone the Seattle version of the client appreciation dance, a little something he was taught by Holden Oliver, and which has since become a Hull McGuire staple whenever there’s a full moon. Miss Ruthie was not impressed.

It is hoped that this get-together across the blawgosphere will attract even more blawgers around the world, bringing together their thoughts and ideas on the many and diverse subjects of critical importance in law. In anticipation of this event growing exponentially, Geeklawyer has booked a
larger and perhaps more appropriate venue for September 15, 2009, and sends his heartfelt greetings to all who were unable to attend this year and his wishes that they are able to make it next.But please note, no spouses allowed, although all massively compatible opposite-sex couples will be entitled to one free nuptial, conducted by Charon QC at no additional charge.
Below, Geeklawyer’s impromptu marriage to @jaffne during a pre-Lawblog planning meeting at Covent Garden (which apparently isn’t a garden at all) was captured on film, and is now being used for promotional purposes by Charon QC in his new side-business as Yenta. Contrary to earlier reports, Miss Ruthie was not at all jealous, but in fact quite relieved.
* Images used in this post are for dramatic effect only, and do not reflect actual dancing skills of any individual named herein. No animals were hurt during filming, except for the sacrifice of one goat during Geeklawyer’s marriage to @jaffne, and the goat asked for it.
Today would be a Good Day to go Solo
As all Biglaw associates and wannabes know, Above the Law tracks the goings-on for those who dream of vast wealth and importance. It used to be about how high first year associates salary and bonuses would go. Now it’s about who’s killing their summer associate programs and laying off associates. Equity partners are finding that they’ve changed the locks on the bathroom doors.
There are some problems happening with the Biglaw clients, willing to pay the $12,500 for a couple of partners and three associates to sit for an hour and noodle their self-created dilemmas. Plenty of Biglaw money was made this weekend. But next week, there may not be much to do.
There is still real legal work to be done out there. There are regular people who need lawyers. There are always defendants in criminal cases, though no Biglaw refugees are equipped to represent them. Forget the house closing business, as there’s not much of that to be found.
You won’t have red-welds with your firm name on them. The waiting room won’t be two stories with six different shades of marble. Lunch may come from an umbrella stand, and you will find out that you can still eat a filling meal even though it is not served on a linen table cloth.
While it’s too late to get ahead of the curve, there’s still time to do something about your lot in life before the pink email arrives at your crackberry. Susan Cartier Leibel is about to open the digital doors of Solo Practice University. Carolyn Elefant has written the definitive book on the mechanics of opening a solo practice, Solo By Choice. Kevin O’Keefe offers entrée into the world of marketing oneself when you open the doors and desperately want someone to walk through them.
Not all of you will make it. Not all of you deserve to make it. Some of you belong in a paneled law library getting a check at the end of the week, for as long as the check keeps coming. When it stops, you will find some other use for those Paul Stewart suits. Perhaps as a concierge.
But some of you will see the writing on the wall. Don’t pass up the available opportunity and resources that are here today. It’s decidedly unclear what tomorrow will offer.
Banking and Brokerage Got its Wish
Never before has the old warning, be careful what you wish for, because you just might get it, been so true. Lehman Brothers will announce today that it is going into bankruptcy, as seemed obvious since last March, when Bear Sterns was purchased by JP Morgan Chase. But that’s not all the news that’s fit to print.
According to the New York Times, Bank of America, which last purchased Countrywide Mortgage, is purchasing Merrill Lynch, the retail brokerage giant, while AIG facing a liquidation crunch, needs a loan from the Fed to stay afloat through the close of the day, and Washington Mutual teeters on failure. Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac were lucky to beat the rush last week.
According to the advocates of the view that business is self-regulating and doesn’t need government regulations tying its hands, or lawyers suing it into oblivion to keep it honest, we should be in the biggest economic expansion, business boom, ever in the history of mankind this morning. They got their way.
They wished for a president and congress that would understand them, and they got them. They said that tax cuts would invigorate the economy, and they got them. They said that government regulation was strangling them and they were gutted. They said that we could trust big business to do a far better job running the American economy than government ever could. They got their way.
Today, people will explain what went wrong and pin blame. The subprime mortgage crisis will be a large target, and it’s a darn good one since it makes these large financial institutions the victims rather than the predator. Remember this explanation for the crisis?
Mayor Bloomberg has canceled a trip to visit California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger. He’s going to have his hands full figuring out what to do with Merrill’s 60,000 employees or Lehman’s 25,000 employees. Just watch what happens to the Manhattan condo market, one of the few strong real estate markets left in the country. And Ferrarri futures will tank, naturally.
For a country that was too important to maintain a working class, a manufacturing base, because each and every one of us was entitled to become a master of the universe, we are going to have one heck of a lot of hands doing the devil’s work.
It no longer matters why this happened. The time for figuring things out passed us by a while ago. Historians can someday come up with an explanation that will be taught to our grandchildren, but it’s not going to do anyone any good today. This is the aftermath of a financial hurricane, and now is the time to just try to clean up the mess.
While some very smart people squabble over whether someone is more qualified to be president if they were a mayor or a senator, the policies proffered at the top of the ticket seem pale and lifeless in the face of the storm. It is so fundamentally American to argue about the crucial issues of morality and value while the jobless wander aimlessly and the once-wealthy ponder old net worth statements and wonder where it all went.
But we do know one thing with certainty. Big business got its chance to rule, and it blew it.
Dave Hoffman at Co-Op posted about this last night, and has a quote from Alan Greenspan:
”I can’t believe we could have a once-in-a-century type of financial crisis without a significant impact on the real economy globally, and I think that indeed is what is in the process of occurring.”
You see, the rest of the world, the third-world nations emerging as financial powerhouses, were dependent on us being stupid enough to keep sending them our money. But now that we’ve run dry, they are losing their market. The flip side of this, of course, is that they can’t be our market either. Deven Desai at Co-Op also recaps some thoughts on our status, apparently when he found himself unable to sleep last night.
A smart America would wake up this morning a realize that we’re screwed, stop digging and tighten our collective belts. But we haven’t been a smart America in a long time. We’ve been proud. We’ve been absolute. We’ve placed out faith in platitudes about how we can survive anything because we are the greatest nation on earth. We’ve been told that God loves us better than anyone else, and we believe it. We’ve been told that whatever we do is righteous, and whatever anybody else does, that does fit our mold, is evil. And we’ve been told that if we place our trust in the markets, the markets will save us.
Let’s see who gets saved today.
