For those of you who read posts to the bitter end, you may see my inclusion of a musical interlude at the very end. This begs a question. Does anyone (besides me) notice that they’re there? Does anyone listen to them? Does anyone like them, hate them, care one way or the other?
A little feedback, please.
Author Archives: SHG
Galveston, Oh Galveston (Update)
Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast has a post that would be spectacular as a parody. The only problem is that it’s not. As we know today, Galveston survived the rampage of Hurricane Ike. But we didn’t know that it would before hand. Residents were ordered to evacuate, though many chose to remain. The risk they took was of their own choosing. Now, many of these residents await help in their flooded homes.
But there was a group of people who were given no option to stay or go.
Galveston Island residents were told to flee Hurricane Ike or face “certain death,” but the Sheriff has inexplicably decided not to evacuate 1,000 prisoners from the county jail, even though serious flooding has already begun.
The Sheriff decided that the inmates stay. From the Statesman story :
County officials earlier had ordered a mandatory evacuation for all residents. Sheriff’s officials insisted the prisoners and jailers were safe and sound, in a 2-year-old building designed to withstand hurricanes.
A sheriff’s office spokesman said the plan was for the prisoners and jailers to weather the storm in place — unless an evacuation took place later today. Sheriff’s office spokesman Maj. Ray Tuttoilmondo told the Houston Chronicle that the reason for not evacuating the prisoners is a security issue and cannot be discussed,
Even so, he said, “the prisoners and their safety and well-being are paramount and it will be handled.”
While it always makes me feel confident when a public official announces his deep concern for the welfare of others, particularly those for whom government feels a deep concern like prisoners, I frequently find myself more convinced by acts than words. That’s just the sort of person I am.
Rarely have I heard something so absurd. Is this an incident of Texas stupidity? Is this an example of disdain for criminals? Is this the allocation of scare resources, better put to the benefit of the good citizens of Galveston than the bad?
How dare this Sheriff put prisoners in his custody at risk. How dare he decide that he’s willing to take a chance with their lives.
Even if we assume the absolute best of the Sheriff, that he had such absolute faith in the jailhouse structure to survive the tidal surge, water, fire, wind, loss of electric and all other unknowns that can happen during a hurricane, the lives of these human beings, only prisoners for the moment, are not his to gamble away.
Grits has a number of updates to the original post, concluding with this:
As of this morning, Governor Perry’s spokespers said she “did not know about any Ike-related deaths and did not have any information about inmates at a jail on Galveston that was not evacuated.”
So no one dead as far as we know. Woo hoo. That changes everything.
Which leads us into this natural interlude:
Update: Scott at Grits has posted from DailyKos :
Thankfully, everyone is safe. But this is not an “all’s well that ends up well” situation. The end doesn’t justify the means. That’s like saying that drunk driving is fine, as long as you don’t crash head-on with a school bus. Fortuitous consequences do not justify wrongful conduct.IngeniousGirl who brings this report :
I just talked to Deputy at the jail – here is what I learned. … The Deputy would not give me her name, but she told me that the inmates are safe …
Plenty of heat, food, water, and the facility is 2 years old and is safe
She also said, the jail is not flooded.
Somebody Should Help
I read this post by Dave Hoffman at Co-Op a few days ago, and it’s bothered me since. It comes from a story in the Philly Inquirer.
As the SEPTA subway train rocked forward, a thirty-something guy leaned over near the doorway and gently planted a kiss on the little boy at his side.When the train neared the Fairmount Avenue stop shortly after midnight on Thursday, the man reached out like an adoring parent and directed the 3- or 4-year-old tyke to an open seat.
Then he flew into a monstrous rage.
Without uttering a word, police said, the unidentified man whipped out a double-claw hammer and began bludgeoning a 20-year-old man who was dozing off in his seat.
For five long minutes, SEPTA surveillance cameras captured the deranged attacker – who was still on the loose late last night- digging his hammer into the man’s head and neck.
At this point, Dave breaks from the story to note that random acts of violence upset our sense of order and safety, noting that it particularly upset his as he was on this train two hours earlier.
Through it all, disgusted investigators said, at least 10 passengers stood by and did nothing as the random attack moved from the train to the platform, when the hammer-wielding maniac tried to push his victim down onto the train tracks.When the beating was finished and the suspect fled with the little boy, the victim staggered back onto the train, bloodied, confused and alone, said Detective Kenneth Roach, of Central Detectives.
And even then, no one tried to help him.
“Somebody should have helped this guy,” Roach said. “I understand the [other] guy had a hammer, but they outnumbered him at least 10 to one.”
Dave likens this scenario to Kitty Genovese. I don’t think the situations are the same, though there are similarities in the fact that people refused to get “involved”. But the Kitty Genovese situation didn’t involve people putting themselves at risk, whereas here anyone taking action would have been confronting a man with a claw hammer and the willingness to use it.
I’m sure people who are licensed to carry a handgun will point out that had someone on that SEPTA train been armed, he could have taken out the man without risk to himself. This is no doubt true, but I hope to avoid hijacking this story for the purpose of promoting the benefits of gun possession.
Dave sees the underlying question here as being why the 10 onlookers did nothing, either individually or as a group. He pins the problem in the lack of individual responsibility of the group.
The problem was that there were too many subway riders – no individual person felt responsible for helping to stop the attack. It’s a good reminder that if you ever need help in a group setting, try to get an individual’s attention, and say “You! Yes, I mean you! Help me!”
While this makes some sense, I wonder if it would have been any different had there been only one bystander. In fact, even if there was a armed bystander on the train, would that person have been willing to act, and then suffer the police investigation and interrogation. Probably yes, since the act of possessing a gun suggests a desire to use it. This is meant as a positive, meaning a will to protect themselves and others where people without a gun may suffer from far greater doubt.
But I wonder whether this reflects the abject selfishness that has overcome society. Everything is about “what’s good for me, screw you.” We get away with this attitude because of anonymity, whether in a group, in a car or on the internet. It frees us from any personal responsibility for what we do or say. We never have to see into the eyes of another person if we don’t want to. We can just turn away, whether by turning our heads, hitting the gas or logging off.
The man with the claw hammer seems obviously crazy. This assumption, of course, does nothing to help the victim of his attack. Most of us have a bone in our head that makes us want to be a hero, to help someone. Most of us have another bone in our head that stops us from doing something stupid. Which bone prevails at any given time is a matter of our internal calculus of cost/benefit. Then, there are some with an over-developed bone that compels us to rush in blindly, no matter what the risk or potential harm.
Unless you’ve found yourself on your own SEPTA train, watching some guy about to bring a claw hammer done on the head of another person, you don’t know what you would do. Not for sure.
I’ve found myself in this situation twice in my life. Both time, I reacted immediately, without any thought or hesitation. It was pure reflex. In retrospect, it would probably the wrong move based upon a strict cost/benefit analysis, but I never did the math.
It’s harder for me than it was for Dave (or the Philly cops) to castigate the onlookers for doing nothing. I understand why they froze, why they felt that it wasn’t a good day to die. Each of us has to make the decision for ourselves.
And, as is my way, this seems like a good time for a song:
The Certainty of Simplicity (Hannity/SNL Update)
While one expects an executive to speak with a large degree of certainty in his or her position, to instill confidence and clarity of purpose, one similarly expects that the executive reached his or her decision after recognizing and contemplating the many variables, the complexities, the unknowns, that comprise the important decisions he or she faces.
Having carefully read the interviews of Donald Rumsfeld, Karl Rove, and Robert Draper’s book about George W. Bush, Dead Certain, there is one thread that permeates their decision-making. They are absolutely certain that they know the ultimate right and wrong. There is no room for debate or discussion, nor any place for doubt.
We are living with the product of this, non-decision-making decisions. Choices are simply made, damn the torpedoes.
The ABC interview of Sarah Palin by Charlie Gibson was far from perfect. There are many areas where Charlie’s questions could be well-challenged. But ultimately, this wasn’t a test of Charlie as an interviewer, but of Sarah Palin as a president. The fact that Charlie could have done better has no bearing on Sarah Palin’s performance.
After the hashing of partisans is done, there is one thing that was laid bare by this first interview of the woman who would be president. She is absolutely simple and absolutely certain.
Sarah Palin delivers a speech well. She has many attributes that could make her a fine politician, and perhaps even a fine governor beyond her first two years in office. But she does not have the depth of intellect needed to make decisions that will affect the lives of Americans, and the existence of the United States in the world.
The New York Times editorial recognized one of the foundational problems in American politics:
One of the many bizarre moments in the questioning by ABC News’s Charles Gibson was when Ms. Palin, the governor of Alaska, excused her lack of international experience by sneering that Americans don’t want “somebody’s big fat résumé maybe that shows decades and decades in that Washington establishment where, yes, they’ve had opportunities to meet heads of state.”
Somehow, it’s become fashionable to ridicule education, experience and intellect. This is the flip side of the glorification of “common sense” as the answer to all questions. It’s a view that appeals to common people, because they all believe that they possess it and that each of them, individually, is right.
Of course, being right when chatting with friends and family, but having no responsibility for the welfare of a nation, is a fun game to play. There are no negative consequences of being wrong. But when it comes to making decisions for all the people of the United States, kitchen table solutions aren’t enough, no matter how well they appeal to others of similar intellectual depth.
This has nothing to do with which ultimate answers are right or wrong, but the manner in which those who would govern arrive at their solutions. As we come off a regime that saw thinking as “hard work,” too hard to be worth the effort, and relished in its absolute certainty that it was right, it’s appalling that so many Americans will turn a blind eye to our current situation and try game their way out of repeating the same mistakes.
Ms. Palin talked repeatedly about never blinking. When Mr. McCain asked her to run for vice president? “You have to be wired in a way of being so committed to the mission,” she said, that “you can’t blink.”
Fighting terrorism? “We must do whatever it takes, and we must not blink, Charlie, in making those tough decisions of where we go and even who we target.”
We need to do a lot of blinking before we arrive at a decision. We need to blink long and hard. We need to weigh the many concerns, consequences and impacts. Sarah Palin doesn’t blink. We need someone who does.
Shifting Gears
One of the most interesting and informative blawgs is the Volokh Conspiracy. Until lately. There have been a number of contributors who are obsessed with Sarah Palins, and write about her with a frequency and fervor they’ve never shown toward the law.
The nature of these posts strikes me as not merely grossly partisan, but venturing into becoming Palin Apologist Central. For example, they are in a frenzy to attack Charlie Gibson for the substance and style of his interview, as if attacking Gibson somehow betters Sarah Palin. These are otherwise thoughtful people, so the fallacy of their attacks cannot be excused as the rantings of the foolish or ignorant.
Orin Kerr, who has not succumbed to the Palin disease, posted this :
Palin Palin: Palin palin, palin palin Palin Palin. Palin Palin. Palin palin palin palin — palin. (Palin: Palin)
I wish his fellow VC contributors would have read it. I fear that the lure of politics turns even sharp minds dull.
Update: It appears that Sarah Palins will be subject to a second interview. This time, she will be interviewed by that pillar of journalistic integrity, Sean Hannity. Was Rush too strung out to do it?
Update 2: Because I can’t leave well enough alone…
Barry Kamins Turns Honorable
For the past generation, the demographics of criminal court judges in New York City has changed markedly. For the most part, they are young, inexperienced and have held no job outside of the District Attorney’s office. While there are exceptions, it’s rare to have someone appointed a criminal court judge who comes to the job after having a long and distinguished career in the criminal law.
Well, that’s changed with Mayor Bloomberg’s appointment of Brooklyn’s premier criminal defense lawyer, Barry Kamins, to the bench. Barry, who is not only recognized for decades of superb work, first as a prosecutor in Brooklyn and subsequently as a founding partner in Flamhaft Levy Kamins Hirsch & Rendeiro, is also one of the nicest, most helpful lawyers around.
It’s rather hard to imagine the Honorable Barry sitting on the lobster shift at 100 Centre Street, watching the parade of prostitutes plead guilty and get a day of community service (isn’t that why they were arrested in the first place?). This is a brilliant and distinguished lawyer, who would fit in well in the Southern or Eastern Districts. The criminal court bench seems, well, just a little underwhelming for someone with Barry’s experience.
From the Brooklyn Eagle :
He is a professor at Brooklyn and Fordham law schools, and an acknowledged expert in the area of illegal searches and seizures in the state of New York. He wrote the book on it, in fact; it is called “New York Search and Seizure,” and it is relied on heavily by defense lawyers, prosecutors and judges throughout the state.
Kamins also wrote the Sentencing Guidelines for the New York Penal Law, and is co-chair of the New York State Chief Judge’s Advisory Committee on criminal law. He writes a column for the New York Law Journal, and was recently named chairman of the New York State Bar Association’s task force on wrongful convictions.
For the man who has served as president of the Kings County Criminal Bar Association in the 1980s, president of the Brooklyn Bar Association in the 1990s, and president of the New York City Bar Association last year, the legal résumé goes on and on…
While racking up points on a résumé isn’t necessarily proof of qualifications, any more than all those quaint pieces of parchment we hang on the wall to impress clients, Barry Kamins is the real thing. Though I’m still having trouble seeing him handling misdemeanors, and hope that the Office of Court Administration doesn’t waste his talent and experience in some AP part on the fourth floor (as in, make him an Acting Supreme tomorrow, guys), Barry, I mean the Hon. Barry, is as fine a choice for the bench as exists in New York City.
Congratulations, and I might even take a misdemeanor case if I can try it before the Honorable Barry Kamins.
But it was only 3 Taser Jolts, Judge
Mike Cernovich at Crime & Federalism has the amazing ability to see into the future, as demonstrated by his finding this Law.com post dated 2 days from today. But I’m thankful he did, as this is one decision that we should all be aware of, and wary of.
In a 2-1 unpublished decision in Buckley v. Haddock, an 11th Circuit panel headed up by Chief Judge J.L. Edmondson reversed the district court and held that it was not unconstitutional for a deputy to repeatedly taser a man for sitting on the ground, sobbing, after he had refused to sign a traffic ticket, because the man wouldn’t cooperate by walking to the cruiser.
The appellate ruling stems from a 2004 traffic stop at night on a dark, two-lane highway in Washington County, Fla. Financially destitute and homeless, Buckley began sobbing after Rackard pulled him over and gave him a speeding ticket, which Buckley refused to sign, according to Edmondson’s account of the events in question.After warning Buckley twice to sign or he would face arrest, Buckley said, “Arrest me.” Still in his vehicle, he allowed Rackard to cuff him, then exited his car. But as Rackard began walking the still distraught Buckley to the patrol car, Buckley dropped to the ground, crossed his legs and remained there, still sobbing.
Rackard asked Buckley several times to stand up, then attempted unsuccessfully to lift Buckley to his feet, according to Edmondson’s opinion. When that effort failed, he warned Buckley that he would use his Taser if Buckley refused to cooperate.
When Buckley shouted, “I don’t care anymore. Tase me,” Rackard applied the Taser’s electrodes to Buckley’s back and chest and fired a five-second burst. When Buckley still refused to get up, Rackard discharged his Taser a second time.
Rackard then walked to his patrol car and radioed for backup. When he returned, he again ordered Buckley, who had remained on the ground, to stand up, then attempted a second time to lift the 180-pound, 6-foot-2-inch Buckley to his feet. When that effort failed, Rackard used his Taser on Buckley a third time.
Thankfully, Buckley didn’t shout “just shoot me.” I wonder how that would have played out. But if you think that Rackard’s conduct was scary, it’s nothing compared to Judge Edmondson’s rationale:
Edmondson found that Rackard’s use of the Taser was “not outside the range of reasonable conduct under the Fourth Amendment” because the traffic stop occurred at night on the side of a highway “with considerable passing traffic,” Buckley resisted arrest, and Rackard used the Taser “only after trying to persuade [Buckley] to cease resisting and warned him the Taser would be used.“Although, as the district court observed, the underlying offense of refusing to sign a traffic citation was relatively minor, we nevertheless credit the government with a significant interest in enforcing the law on its own terms, rather than on terms set by the arrestee,” Edmondson wrote.
“The government has an interest in arrests being completed efficiently and without waste of limited resources: police time and energy that may be needed elsewhere at any moment. Even though [Buckley] was handcuffed, he still refused repeatedly to comply with the most minimal of police instructions — that is, to stand up and to walk to the patrol car.”
In a footnote, Edmondson added, “That plaintiff did not attack or menace the deputy does not shield plaintiff from the use of force, even if it might result in pain.”
Apparently, the 11th Circuit’s construction of the Constitution is that people have rights, unless they interfere with the primary authority of law enforcement to make people do what they want. When that happens, all bets are off. The second judge in the majority, Joel F. Dubina, in a single-paragraph concurrence, “agreed that Rackard should be shielded from prosecution by the doctrine of qualified immunity because the constitutional violation ‘was not clearly established’ at the time it occurred.” Would 4 Taser jolts have been clearer?
Sitting by designation, Judge Beverly B. Martin of Georgia’s Northern District wasn’t buying, and issued a strong 17 page dissent:
“[T]he Fourth Amendment forbids an officer from discharging repeated bursts of electricity into an already handcuffed misdemeanant — who is sitting still beside a rural road and unwilling to move — simply to goad him into standing up.
“I also conclude that at the time of the incident, Deputy Rackard was on fair notice that his conduct was unconstitutional,” Martin’s dissent continued. “Not only did Deputy Rackard unnecessarily discharge his Taser gun against Mr. Buckley three times, but each time he did so, he repeatedly prodded Mr. Buckley’s body with the stun gun’s live electrodes — inflicting additional pain and leaving Mr. Buckley with 16 burn scars.”
While it’s long been clear that the Taser has become the means of expediency for law enforcement, this decision not only provides support for the lazy cop’s resort to the Taser as the easiest way to get respect, but elevates this expediency above the right of non-violent people to be free from violent attack by police. It’s just plain screwy how Judge Edmondson perceives the relative constitutional priorities.
Edmondson also rejected the Florida district court’s rationale that if Rackard had simply waited for backup, both officers could have carried Buckley to the patrol car without any use of force.
“A single officer in the deputy’s situation confronting a non-compliant arrestee like [Buckley] need not — as a matter of federal constitutional law — wait idly for backup to arrive to complete an otherwise lawful arrest that the officer has started,” Edmondson wrote. “The federal courts must not dictate through their interpretation of the Constitution how the police should allocate their limited resources. In most circumstances where an arrestee is resisting, a single officer can constitutionally effectuate an otherwise lawful arrest by resorting to the use of moderate, nonlethal force. No constitutional basis exists for requiring two or more officers to make routine arrests, even if deploying more officers might result in less force actually being used.”
So Judge Edmondson’s Constitution puts little weight in protecting people from police violence, and great weight in allowing police to allocate their own resources? And Judge Martin called him on it:
“Chief Judge Edmondson emphasizes the state interest in roadside safety and efficiency in single-officer arrests in concluding that Deputy Rackard’s use of force was constitutionally reasonable. However, the individual interests protected by the Fourth Amendment do not so easily give way. Many police encounters occur on the roadside at night, and each carries risks that could theoretically be reduced if police officers were authorized to inflict pain as a way to expedite their law-enforcement efforts.”
This decision reflects a fundamental misapprehension of the purpose of the Constitution. The Constitution exists to protect the People from government, not to authorize the government to attack people whenever it makes their job easier.
There is a serious plague happening across the United States of police officers turning to their new darling weapon, the Taser, in lieu of exercising sound judgment and restraint. It’s just too easy, and wraps things up so much more quickly. This decision, though not precedent as it’s going unpublished, suggests that the quick and dirty use of Tasers whenever it makes a cop’s life easier has the support of the court.
When did the courts stop focusing on the “use of force” against non-violent citizens and decide to be enablers of police expediency instead? When did compliance with the government become the primary purpose of the United States? How does someone become the Chief Judge of the 11th Circuit with such a warped view of the Constitution?
Coming on the heels of this video from the Republican National Convention, it seems that we’ve got a new war a’brewing: The war on police violence.
AmEx to Disabled Children: Drop Dead
Literally, given the nature of some of the projects that received the most votes in its scam “Members Project” contest. Why have certain top-voted projects inexplicably “disappeared” from the final 25, as discussed here? Was there some reason, any reason, that could provide arguable justification?
Since my last post, I’ve received a response from AmEx, as have a number of readers, particularly some very unhappy parents of children with Fragile X Syndrome, who went to great lengths to have their friends, relatives and supporters register for the AmEx promotion and vote.
The response is corporate rhetorical nonsense at its finest, the sort of nonresponsive response that makes a lawyer’s blood pressure rise:
Thank you for contacting us regarding the Cure Fragile X project.
While we are unable to comment directly on the judging of specific projects,
please know that our selection was based on a variety of factors, including the
number of nominations received and other metrics of popularity and interest on
the Members Project website, a review of achievability, innovation, and broad,
positive impact by our Advisory Panel, and the confirmation of an appropriate
fulfilling organization for the project. You can find more detail on the
criteria in the terms and conditions at http://www.membersproject.com/about/terms.html and additional information about this years Members Project Advisory Panel at http://www.membersproject.com/about/panel.html.
We appreciate your effort and participation in Members Project as great
attention has been drawn to this project. We hope you will continue to be
involved by voting for the project that is meaningful to you.
Ah, the joys of hiding behind the fine print and meaningless rhetoric. For the most part, the parents were unhappy and disappointed, but felt powerless. After all, the corporation said so (which is a variation on the cop said so, but without a good beating). While I doubt they felt satisfied, they are so inured to receiving nonsensical corporate responses that they accepted it at face value. I’m not so inclined.
In an email response to another inquiry, found here, from the same AmEx employee, an additional sentence was included:
We regret you are unhappy with our selection, as we believe these are all compelling projects that are achievable, innovative, and have a broad, positive impact. (Emphasis added)
So, it’s the position of AmEx that the Cure Fragile X project met all theoretical criteria (as in, they had no objective or even articulable basis to exclude it), and yet the number 5 vote getter was dropped from the top 25 for no reason whatsoever? Well, that sure makes the contest seem more legitimate. To the extent that there might have been some hidden, secret legitimate reason that outsiders like me were unaware of, this ends the discussion. There was none. This was a scam.
No doubt there were plenty of caveats in the fine print of the sort that would make any contract action subject to dispute. However, this fails entirely to addresses the fact that American Express engaged in an intentional fraud, gained a tangible benefit, and screwed disabled children, amongst others, in the process.
The terms and conditions notwithstanding, AmEx induced people to vote for their favorite projects by deliberately crafting this promotion to suggest that funding would be the product of popular vote. There was no wiggle in their promotional materials, only in their fine print. In order to vote, people had to register with AmEx, meaning that they had to provide personal information and email addresses. People were willing to do so to support important causes. They assumed that this was legitimate.
Now, the AmEx claim is that the voting was, well, utterly meaningless because it had a proviso in the T&Cs that allowed it to ignore the very thing it told us would be relied upon. If you read the T&Cs, it suggests that the voting, the only quantifiable and objective criterion, would be primary, and the “advisory panel” would be involved only to vet the projects for the purpose of making sure that the projects were achievable, innovative and have a broad positive impact. As the email quoted, and emphasized above, shows, the criteria were met. If this wasn’t a scam, that would have been the end of the story.
Nowhere did it suggest that the voting was purely a subterfuge from the outset. Nowhere did it suggest that AmEx collection of all the data from voters, which it would then have available for its own marketing schemes as well as resale, was solely for AmEx’s financial benefit. When AmEx solicited votes, and urged participants to gather as many votes as possible, it never suggested that the votes were meaningless and worthless as far as the projects were concerned, and only good for AmEx to suck up as much marketable information as possible.
But it gets worse. Much worse.
While removing 5th top vote-getters from the top 25, another project, “New Affordable Treatments,” which ranked 52 after the voting, somehow managed to find its way into the top 25 (since there were some obvious vacancies after the top vote-getters “disappeared”). As I was informed by the president of another well-established charitable organization that was unceremoniously dumped by AmEx, dedicated to eradicating disease in children,
Interestingly, this project is being fulfilled by www.global-cures.org. A new startup organization that only recently received their IRS letter. No 990’s, no organization documents – not even a phone number on the website. The only email address is [email protected], I emailed them Tuesday but have not heard back from them.
So well-established, exceptionally well-run organizations dealing with diseases affecting children that are deeply involved in very promising research are inexplicably tossed from the program, replaced by an organization that suddenly appeared out of nowhere, and has no telephone number, miraculously jumps from number 52 after the voting to the top 25? This isn’t the say that Global-Cures isn’t real, but to the extent that there’s anything behind AmEx’s claims of vetting the top projects for legitimacy, this choice blows it out of the water.
Back to the response by American Express. “While we are unable to comment directly on the judging of specific projects. . . .” Why not? Because you say so? Because the employee responding to angry voters is in the PR department, and has no clue what she’s talking about? Because this is the typical corporate response, assuming that people are so used to organizational arrogance that they will just lie back and accept it?
Or Does AmEx respond this way because it has engaged in an overt deception, obtaining hundreds of thousand of emails and other personal identifying data from this scam, and is now left without an answer because it got caught? American Express intentionally deceived people who support these exceptional charitable organizations to help save the lives of children. And the best it can do is say that it’s “unable to respond?”
To the contrary, your response is painfully clear: AmEx to Disabled Children: Drop Dead.
Oh yeah, and thanks for the free data.
Sitting or Standing, Passengers Lose Again
Just when you thought it was safe to get back in a car, the Appellate Division, First Department has shown that it can still engage in some pretty nifty gymnastics to make sure that there is no 4th Amendment on the streets of Manhattan. Clearly, they’re still pretty spry for a bunch of old judges.
Via Judicial Reports, in People v. Cheatham, the court reversed Supreme Court Justice Charles Tejada’s grant of a motion to suppress, based upon rejection of the claim that the police pulled the vehicle over for changing lanes without signaling, and proceeded to search the vehicle where cocaine was found in the map pocket of the car.
The Appellate decision holds that the police stop was lawful, reaffirming the decision in People v. Rice where they similarly reversed Justice Jim Yates grant of suppression when he blew off the excuse. But the court proceeds to address the issue of standing, and concludes that the passengers in the vehicle lacked standing to move suppress.
While the initial issue, whether police have the authority to pull a car over for changing lanes without signaling, was resolved by Rice in a technical sense, it remains that the underlying issue is really a Whren problem, since there are two things that are universally understood. First, nobody gets stopped for changing lanes without signaling unless the cops want to search a car for other reasons or they are at the end of their shift and need some overtime.
Second, and this goes to one of the many underlying failings of the Whren rule, failure to signal is one of those violations that is proven solely upon a cop’s say-so. Now if we had absolute faith that no police officer would ever claim that a vehicle changed lanes without signaling, perhaps this wouldn’t be a big problem. But no such faith exists, and cops can make the claim any time they want, leaving every human being in a car exposed to being stopped by police at will. There are no atheists in a foxhole, and no rights in an automobile.
But Cheatham turns really curious when the court gets to the issue of standing. The defendants were passengers in the vehicle, and thus have no inherent right to contest the stop. As for the search, it’s impossible to say in this case since there is absolutely no mention by the court of the basis for police to have searched the vehicle once stopped, a separate curiosity in itself.
But where the defendants are charged with possession of narcotics based upon the statutory presumption of Penal Law 265.15, they are granted automatic standing to challenge the search. And the defendants relied on this in making their motion, without a challenge by the prosecution in its response.
The law is clear that when the prosecution relies on the presumption, the passengers get a pass on standing. But when there is a factual basis for alleging possession, the defendant must argue standing based upon the facts. Here, however, the people argue a hybrid, apparently, and the court splits hairs, holding the automatic standing is granted only when the prosecution relies “exclusively” on the presumption.
At the hearing, the prosecution argued, for the first time, that they were not relying solely on the presumption, but had a factual basis for charging the defendants with possession of cocaine. The factual basis is that Cheatham, following his arrest, talked up a storm.
Rather, with respect to Cheatham, they assert that they will rely as well on his statements and his close proximity to the drugs. We need not discuss Cheatham’s proximity to the drugs. If the testimony that Cheatham made the statements is credited by the jury, the People will thus have proved Cheatham’s actual possession of the cocaine.
The sequences of events now becomes critical, since the post-arrest statements are being used to undermine standing to stop, search and arrest. This point is argued on appeal, but rejected by the court.
Cheatham asks that we disregard the statements he allegedly made at the precinct on the ground that they are the fruits of an unconstitutional search, even though the issue in dispute is his standing to contest the search of the car. Thus, he argues that “it turns Millan on its head to say . . . that [his] subsequently obtained precinct statement[s] deprived him of his right to challenge the very violation from which the statement[s] derived.” Although Cheatham cannot invoke the “automatic standing” of Millan because the People at trial will be relying in part on his statements, the making of the statements do not deprive him of the right to seek to establish his standing by “demonstrat[ing] a personal legitimate expectation of privacy in the searched premises” (Wesley, 73 NY2d at 357). Moreover, contrary to Cheatham’s argument, the legality of a search cannot be determined without regard to his standing. A search is unconstitutional not in the abstract but only to the extent it impermissibly infringes on the particular defendant’s reasonable expectation of privacy (United States v Payner, 447 US 727, 731 [1980] [“the defendant’s Fourth Amendment rights are violated only when the challenged conduct invaded his legitimate expectation of privacy rather than that of a third party”] [emphasis in original]).
This makes absolutely no sense at all. The determination of the constitutionality of a search is based upon the facts as they exist at the time the search is performed, not upon things that happen later, particularly as a product of the search in issue.
The court uses after-acquired statements to upset the standing issue, and then concludes that there can be no challenge unless the defendant has standing. It’s beautifully circular, but totally irrational.
The most basic flaw of this decision, however, is the court’s turning the passenger’s right to invoke automatic standing on its head. At various points, the court refers to language in People v. Millan, 69 NY2d 514 (1987), about automatic standing being conferred where the prosecution relies “solely” on the statutory presumption. There reference is used to hold that where there are additional factual bases, then standing isn’t automatic. This is judicial slight of hand of the worst order.
Wholly omitted from the discussion is that the theory of prosecution is an either/or proposition, and that’s what is referred to by the “solely” from Millan. Either the prosecution obtains an indictment via the statutory presumption, or the prosecution obtains an indictment based upon factual allegations. What it does not mean is that the prosecution can enjoy a hybrid theory of possession, relying primarily upon the presumption with a few allegations of fact thrown in for good measure.
There is no such animal, and throwing a few allegations of fact in the air doesn’t change the fact that the prosecution relied “solely” on the statutory presumption because it lacked any state of facts that would have justified the search absent the presumption. Dressing up their claim by some equivocal observations or, worse still, statements made afterward, is absurd.
So while I was beginning to become more sanguine about the possibility of the 4th Amendment returning to use in car stops, a decision like this just sucks the joy right out of me. One step forward and two steps back.
The Bright Line of Privacy Ends at a Brooklyn Stoop
Brooklyn, New York, would be the fifth largest city in the United States, but for the fact that it’s a part of New York City. Still, Brooklyn has a culture all its own. It has its own language, natives and practices. It has its own set of norms. One of these is the sanctity of the stoop.
For those heathens who are unfamiliar with the stoop, allow me to explain. Brooklyn is a city of brownstones, each of which has a set of stairs leading from the main floor of the brownstone to the sidewalk. Picture a split level, with the lower level two or three steps down from the ground and the upper level about nine steps up. That’s why the need a stoop.In the land of Brooklyn, a stoop is very much a material part of a brownstone. It’s where the denizens sit to watch the world go by. It’s where children play stoop ball (yes, there’s a well-known game attached to stoops). On a hot summer evening, the stoop is where people go to escape the heat. One sits on one’s own stoop, and not on anyone else’s stoop, unless personally invited to do so. That’s the rule.
Now, the sanctity of the stoop has been put in issue, by none other than the New York City police. According to the New York Times:
Kimber VanRy was sitting on his stoop in the Prospect Heights section of Brooklyn, drinking a beer and sending e-mail messages on his BlackBerry, when a police car slowed to a stop on the street in front of him.
The time was 11:52 p.m., the date was Aug. 27, and the beer, for the record, was a 12-ounce bottle of Sierra Nevada.
The police officer in the driver’s seat said something to Mr. VanRy. He left the stoop, walked to the car and, several minutes later, was handed a small pink slip — a $25 summons for drinking in public.
This attack on sovereignty has raised quite a stir in Brooklyn. The implications of this full frontal assault on the sacred stoop could undermine the very fabric of Brooklyn society.
Many of the laws in New York are based on, or aggravated by, performing an act in public. It applies to smoking pot as well as drinking a beer. But what constitutes “public” is hardly clear.
The city’s open-container law prohibits anyone from drinking an alcoholic beverage, or possessing and intending to drink from an open container containing an alcoholic beverage, “in any public place.” The law defines a public place as one “to which the public or a substantial group of persons has access, including, but not limited to,” a sidewalk, street or park.
In Brooklyn, the public has no access to a person’s stoop. That’s Brooklyn law, and everybody there knows it. That’s not to say that everybody walking past the stoop can’t see everything that’s happening on the stoop. Obviously, then can. And that’s not to say that kids who think they won’t get caught will climb on someone else’s stoop, or sit down and rest there until the homeowner yells at them and chases them away with a broom. But then it’s the kids who are breaking the rules. Everybody knows that.
Since the stoop is part of the owner’s private property, is it a public place or a private place?
Richard Briffault, a professor at Columbia University Law School and an expert in property and local government law, said Mr. VanRy’s summons illustrated the thin line between private and public property. “It’s quite possible to be on private property and in public at the same time,” he said.
Well that helps. Not. The issue isn’t a matter of mere “private property,” such as a mall or facility where the public is invited in. This is a stoop. This is Brooklyn. This isn’t theoretical, but a matter of long-standing right.
Indeed, last year, a State Supreme Court justice in the Bronx ruled that an apartment building lobby qualified as a “public place” in relation to the open-container law. A police officer had confronted a man who was drinking a beer in the lobby of a building on the Grand Concourse, and Justice Joseph J. Dawson ruled that the officer had probable cause to arrest him.
But that was the Bronx, and all the rules are different in the Bronx. After all, the law in the Bronx is that police can do anything anywhere to anyone. There is no reasonable expectation of privacy in the Bronx. Everybody knows that.
There is no real explanation as to why the officer felt compelled to write VanRy up. Is there a plague of stoop-drinkers wreaking havoc on Brooklyn? Not as far as anyone is aware. I surmise that this was an officer recently transfered from some other borough, unfamiliar with the ways of Brooklyn and who ignorantly stepped into a pile of Brooklyn’s finest.
But one thing is clear: No matter what the NYPD does, no matter what the court does with VanRy’s summons, the good people of Brooklyn will not succumb to the homogenization of their homeland and the usurpation of their stoop. If they want to stop Brooklynites from having a cold one on their stoop, they can pry it out of their cold, dead fingers.
Bob Simels Indicted in Plot to “Eliminate” Witnesses
From the WSJ Law Blog and the New York Times, Manhattan attorney Robert Simels has been arrested in the Eastern District of New York for allegedly trying to “eliminate” and “neutralize” witnesses against a client, accused Guyanese drug dealer, Shaheed Khan.
Bob is a well-known lawyer in New York, having represented some significant clients in his day. Though a bit on the arrogant side (and who isn’t in this business) and not exactly a warm and fuzzy guy, he’s smart and well-respected. That said, the report of his arrest is just shocking.
Represented by Gerry Shargel, who is one of the top players in the New York criminal defense bar, the allegations against Bob, based upon this affidavit in support of the arrest warrant, are ugly indeed.

At one point in the investigation, Mr. Simels was recorded telling the informant that “any witness you can eliminate is a good thing,” according to the complaint. Federal officials said that Mr. Simels told the informant that Mr. Khan would be willing to pay whatever was required to keep the witnesses from testifying.Mr. Simels is said to have offered the home address and employer of one witness, a woman who he said was an important government witness because she was the only one who could tie “so-called drug ledgers” to his client.
“So, you would think that if she didn’t testify, refused to testify, that would be good,” Mr. Simels said, according to the complaint, and that if they could “eliminate” another witness: “Very good.”
During a meeting in June, Mr. Simels provided the informant with $1,000 and orders from Mr. Khan to do “whatever needs to be done,” according to the papers.
“Here’s a thousand dollars to get started,” Mr. Simels told the informant, according to federal officials. He then passed along a warning from Mr. Khan not to kill the mother of one witness.
“The government will go crazy,” Mr. Simels reputedly said.
Shargel, appropriately, responded that ““[i]t’s easy for prosecutors to make an accusation, but it’s quite another thing for them to prove it.” Of course, the government has tapes and emails, according to the affidavit.
Only a few days ago, I posted about the problem of lawyers getting too close to their clients, and doing things they never should do. If the allegations here are true, this is an entirely different story. While Bob’s alleged use of the words “eliminate” and “neutralize” witnesses could mean what the government claims, it could also mean something entirely benign. We use the language of neutralizing testimony all the time, and we eliminate issues and witnesses from the mix to the extent possible to simplify the matters to be addressed. That these words could have other meanings to a fed (and what word doesn’t) in no way impugns Bob’s intent.
However, some of the other allegations, if true and provable, could be hard to explain. This really falls into the “shocking” column.
