Despite having read extensively and listened to numerous elderly experts opine, I have little understanding of what happened to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, or why, or what it means to me that the government has taken control. Beyond the need for security of liquidity in mortgage-backed securities to stabilize the world market in the face of our housing crisis, it’s all very vague.
But there are a few things that seem crystal clear.
First, those who have conducted their financial affairs in a prudent and responsible way will pay for those who have not. While there are people who, aside from the shake-out in the housing market, have suffered personal disasters beyond their control, these are the anomalies in the monumental rise in defaults and foreclosures.
The norm is fairly straight forward. People bought houses they couldn’t afford, agreed to mortgages they couldn’t repay, and did so under the assumption that the housing market would continue to increase, allowing them to refinance when their adjustable rates increased to a more acceptable mortgage rate, or sell and enjoy the windfall profits. In a housing boom, you can’t lose.
This is not, as so many urge, a terrible tragedy, like contracting a terminal disease. It is nothing more than a bad investment decision. We all make bad decisions on occasion. Some of us just suffer the consequences of a bad investment and move on. We don’t like it, and we would love the government to step in and give us a hand, but we know it’s not going to happen. So we move on.
I realize that this seems heartless, but for most of the people who find themselves in default or foreclosure, they haven’t actually lost much, if anything. They put little or no money down on their homes, paid the sucker rate while enjoying the benefit of a roof over their heads as they would had the rented the house for a term, and are now no worse off then they were when they started. They have neither home nor equity, but they didn’t have that when they started. The loss of theoretical equity, like the loss of theoretical profit, isn’t a loss at all. It’s simply not a gain.
Second, the people who packaged, bought and sold these mortgages and mortgage-backed securities did nothing to earn the monies they were paid. Having represented more than a few of these individuals, allow me to state that they made a boatload of money doing this. Stupid money. Crazy money.
Had these individuals not been paid crazy money, they still would have performed the work because they had no other alternative. They possessed no actual skills, so they couldn’t land a job as a carpenter, a teacher or even a lawyer. It’s not as if they had other opportunities available to them. Trust me, if their salaries and bonuses were quartered, they would still come to work the next day. They have nowhere else to go.
This goes for the lot of Wall Streeters, who are desperately enamored with themselves and their brilliance, but for the fact that their skillset spans the ability to have three or more alcoholic beverages and remain relatively coherent. They pretend to understand financial markets. If they did, of course, it wouldn’t swing wildly day to day. And they wouldn’t have bankrupted their employers.
Third, our politicians realize that there is more to be gained by “helping those in need” than by providing an incentive to be responsible, both on a corporate and personal level. This allows them to appear to fix the problem rather than sound like Herbert Hoover. The difference is that no one suggests that they allow the irresponsible to starve for their mistakes, but they shouldn’t be rewarded for bad judgment either. No one is entitled to a guaranteed “win” on every investment decision.
But the people who are “suffering” aren’t just the poor homeowners. If that was the entirety of the problem, the government would possibly provide some pretense of concern and a few pseudo-palliative measures, like the ones already passed by Congress which have done absolutely nothing to help, but sounded good for the moment.
Our politicians may make sounds as if they are protecting the poor, but Fannie and Freddie aren’t really people. They are institutions. The government of the United States of America does not bail out people. It does bail out institutions, because the failure of an institution will undermine confidence in markets. Suddenly, the rest of the world matters to people who disdain anyplace other than America. They’ve never really changed much from the attitude that what’s good for GM is good for America. They have learned not to say it out loud, however.
There will be money to be made on Wall Street today. But responsible people won’t be the ones to make it. We’re too busy working to pay our mortgage and keep it from being in default.
Author Archives: SHG
When Lawyers Get Too Close to Clients
Cherry Hill, New Jersey, isn’t exactly the inner city, a hotbed of crime. But the feds think that there’s one spot in lovely suburban Cherry Hill that may be crime-central for Little Nicky Scarfo and his Philly crew. The problem is that spot happens to be the law office of Donald Manno. According to this law.com post from the NJLJ,
A federal judge has given prosecutors the go-ahead to review computer records seized from the office of a criminal defense lawyer, even if it means looking at files of clients who were not targets of the search.
U.S. District Judge Robert Kugler says the procedure proposed by prosecutors for the review of the records provided adequate safeguards to protect other client files and privileged materials.
Kugler’s ruling stems from a May 8 search of Donald Manno’s Cherry Hill, N.J., law office by FBI agents executing a warrant that authorized the seizure of documents from Aug. 1, 2006, to date that pertained to 43 individuals and entities, including alleged organized crime figure Nicodemo Scarfo.
Whenever the office of a criminal defense lawyer is the subject of a search warrant, alarms go off. The implications are always the same, with the obvious violation of privilege and the impact on other, uninvolved clients. Silly people respond that others can just move to suppress for any evils that might accrue, but realistic people know that there’s no way to figure out who sees what or how they use it. There’s no way to prove harm, and everything boils down to rhetorical, and losing, arguments.
My ilk will go on auto-pilot and pound the keyboard exclaiming how these searches, where the government comes in, seizes everything in sight and sorts it all out later when they can examine every file at its leisure. This blunderbuss approach has been condemned by North Caccalacca criminal defense lawyer Bobby Frederick and West Virginia criminal defense lawyer John Bryan, and their concerns are well-founded.
The problem remains, however, when a lawyer gets too close to his clients, such that he becomes a party to their enterprise. I am not saying this is the case with Donald Manno, as I know nothing whatsoever about him. But I do know that this is true of others I’ve known over the years. It happens.
The law office, by virtue of privilege, is turned into a “safe-house” of sorts, where information and evidence can be placed beyond the reach of law enforcement. Lawyers should never allow themselves to become embroiled in such measures, but it can happen slowly, and as part of the lawyer’s good-will gesture toward good clients. Only afterward can one see how deeply involved the lawyer has become in the criminal enterprise. The lawyer never meant for it to happen that way.
So what is a court to do? In the Manno case, the court approved the following:
The process involves use of a so-called “taint team” or “filter team,” which comprises an FBI agent and lawyer who are not part of the prosecution team, to screen the seized files. First, an FBI agent will conduct a responsiveness review to determine whether the files are within the scope of the warrant.
Those deemed responsive will then go through a privilege review by Assistant U.S. Attorney Matt Smith, who will turn over nonprivileged items to the prosecution team. For possibly privileged documents, Smith is to decide whether the privilege has been waived or the crime-fraud exception applies. If he believes there is a waiver or exception, Smith is to “meet and confer” with Manno to try to resolve the issue.
If they cannot agree, Smith can ask the court to rule before turning the material over to the prosecution team.
This strikes me as a disaster at every turn. It places privilege decision-making into the hands of an FBI agents and prosecutor, even if not the prosecutor who has sought the evidence. Of course, that means the agent and prosecutor still get to see everything they want, privileged or otherwise. This demonstrates a huge misapprehension of privilege; It’s not the “taint team’s” right to breach someone else’s privilege.
Then, if the prosecutor has a doubt, he’s to “meet and confer” with the defense lawyer. Since when is it the prosecutor’s choice, and how can Manno agree to a waiver under any circumstances. It’s not his privilege to waive, any more than it’s the prosecutors.
And finally, unresolved issues go before the judge, who then gets his hands on the privileged evidence, reads it, tries not to spill coffee on it, fondles it between thumb and forefinger, and then decides. Too late. He’s already seen it. This strikes me as a kinda obvious fly in the ointment.
While the favored response to this governmental need to see stuff they shouldn’t is to just say no, reality is that judges are increasingly granting prosecutors demands for a warrant. Given that the lawyers conduct may well justify the government’s general position that the lawyer is in possession of information or evidence that is not privileged, the likelihood of a wholesale prohibition on searching law offices is slim. So is there a better way?
I believe there is. Rather than put a government agent and prosecutor into place as the arbiter of privilege for the clients, the court should appoint a Special Master to conduct the first level of scrutiny. The Special Master should be a criminal defense lawyer with whom the court has confidence, based upon the lawyer’s experience and integrity, that he will conduct his work as an honest broker.
In the best of circumstances, the Special Master will be someone who both sides, prosecution and defense attorney, can agree upon. If not, then the court will appoint someone subject to the arguments of both sides as to the qualifications for the performance of the duty.
It would be anticipated that the Special Master might be a former prosecutor who has come over from the dark side and racked up at least five years experience as a criminal defense lawyer, sufficient to remove the taint of being too closely aligned to the prosecution to confuse his responsibilities.
The Special Master will serve as a buffer between the government and the lawyer. While the privilege is lost to the Special Master, itself not something that should be taken lightly, it’s far better than having an FBI agent and federal prosecutor holding all the cards. This procedure seems to present the best compromise of a bad situation, and hardly seems rather easy to put into place.
I realize that some of my brethren will berate me for taking a position that doesn’t protect the privilege of clients to my dying breath, but given the realities of what is happening, I would rather find a way to reduce the outrageous level of intrusiveness of having the government rifling through my desk drawers than a trusted neutral. Yes, it’s half a loaf. But sometimes that’s the best we can do.
Disappointment Follows when there is No Murderer
When 18 year old Steven Badke drove across the center median at a speed of more than 80 miles per hour, and crashed into a minivan, leaving three people dead in his wake, it naturally follows that someone must be guilty of murder. After all, when people die, someone killed them. Every bad outcome demands a crime.
But Suffolk County Judge C. Randall Hinrichs refused to succumb to the passion of tragedy, and instead dismissed three counts of criminally negligent homicide and one count of assault in the third degree, leaving only a misdemeanor reckless driving counts and VTL violations pending against Badke, according to this Newsday report.
[A]lthough Steven Badke, 18, was accused of driving 82 to 87 mph, then veering across the center divider on Jericho Turnpike in Smithtown, his behavior didn’t amount to criminal negligence. To be found guilty of criminally negligent homicide, a person must create risk – not just fail to perceive it, Hinrichs said. Speeding – without an another factor, like running a red light – is not enough, he said.
This was the holding of the recent Court of Appeals decision in People v. Cabrera, discussed here. The decision was surprising in that it firmly demonstrated intellectual integrity at a time when the public demands, and the trend has followed, the creation of a crime to fit every tragedy.
In an age where statutes suffer from such overt manipulation as in the Lori Drew/Myspace prosecution, or the horrendous Heidgen murder conviction for drunk driving, the pressure on a judge to appease the public bloodlust is enormous.
Since I have no reservation about mentioning a failure to resist the pressure, it’s only right that I similarly note a jurist who has rendered the right decision in the face of ugly circumstances. It can’t be easy, but it’s the right thing to do.
But there is a collateral problem brewing in the background that should not be ignored. As the public’s understanding is that there must be a crime whenever a tragedy occurs, a result like this must necessarily reflect a failure of the legal system. This is the way the father of John Aruanno, 13, who died in the minivan, feels.
“I think he should be held accountable for what he did, but if there’s no law on the books, what are you going to do?” Aruanno said.
He said he is now focused on fighting for laws that would decrease accidents involving teen drivers. They include increasing how many driving hours are required to get an adult license and limiting nighttime driving by teens.
“I’d just hate to see any family go through the pain we’re going through,” he said. “It didn’t have to be my wife and son driving on that road that day. It could have been anybody.”
The impact of the death of a 13 year old son on a father is beyond my comprehension. All things considered, the father has taken Judge Hinrichs’ decision with remarkable equanimity. So while I refuse to fault him for the failure of logic, it remains that his tragedy neither changes nor improves by the prosecution of Badke for homicide.
While prosecutors and law enforcement push their agenda by convincing the bereaved that a crime and harsh sentence will somehow lessen their pain, they present entirely separate issues with entirely separate impacts.
John Aruanno, the father, has channeled his pain into a way to productively save another father from standing at the grave of his son. Rather than demand “justice”, his focus on preventing kids from doing what kids do, behaving stupidly and occasionally causing unintentional grave harm to others.
So this is doubly rare story, in that there are two people to admire despite the face of terrible tragedy.
Judicial Fashionista: Does This Robe Make Me Look Fat?
No, this is not another post about former Nevada District Judge Elizabeth Halverson (WARNING: Photo not for the squeamish). Rather, the New York Times, perhaps in honor of Fashion Week or for lack of any legal news coming out of the Republican National Convention, has chosen to focus on that hallmark of judicial office, The Robe.
In the United States, judges have been less attached to such grand garb. Robes were not even a necessary part of their attire in the decades after the Revolutionary War, though it eventually became the accepted fashion. But even today, New York does not require judges to wear robes, and various judges spurn them altogether from time to time, or at least try to wear them with a bit of flair.
That’s right. New York judges can be mavericks, at least when it comes to the latest judicial fashion. Not so for others, however.
John Jay, a former New York governor and the first chief justice of the United States Supreme Court, is captured in many pictures wearing a scarlet and black robe with silver trim.Robes are, of course, sexist, but then they came about at a time when women were barefoot and pregnant. Of course, it would be undignified to quip about Judge Kaye’s concern about looking “strange”.When John Marshall, who became the chief justice of the Supreme Court in 1801, donned a plain black silk robe, it was actually seen as a radical departure from the scarlet and ermine robes that the other justices wore, according to a biography written by Jean Edward Smith.
The late chief justice William H. Rehnquist wore gold stripes on his sleeves. Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg is known for the lacy jabot around her neck, an accessory that may be more about necessity than style, said Judith S. Kaye, the chief judge of New York. Judge Kaye said the V-cut of robes makes for an awkward fit for women, while a perfect fit for a man with a shirt and tie.
“If you wear an open blouse or something, you look strange,” she said.
For most of us, we’ve never given judicial robes a second thought. There was the raging controversy when Rehnquist put the gold stripes on his sleeves, purportedly in homage to Gilbert & Sullivan, as he was a big opera fan. But having crawled from dissenting outsider to Chief Justice in a political blink of an eye, he had the power to assume the robed persona of a drum majorette for a small midwestern trade school.
When you think about it, the robes worn by judges are one of the few trappings of office maintained in the United States. No other officeholder is expected to wear a costume as proof of their authority, leaving the judiciary to stand alone.
Although the judicial robe’s origin remains uncertain, some believe it has its origins in the church, when the clergy and judiciary were one and the same. Robes appeared in the British judiciary in the 14th century, according to one law journal.While David Dudley Field’s assessment may be more than a little lacking in foundation, that’s not to say that judicial robes serve no purpose. Much like courtrooms themselves, built with the express purpose of conveying the majesty and power of the state so that litigants, particularly criminal defendants, are shocked and awed, robes distinguish the judge from mere mortals.After America won its independence, the judges on the New York Court of Appeals gave up robes to try to get away from the pomp and ceremony of the British, said Albert M. Rosenblatt, a retired judge who is president of the Historical Society of the Courts of the State of New York.
But in January 1884, David Dudley Field, a prominent lawyer, petitioned the court to wear robes, saying, “The garment is no more a badge of monarchial than of republican office.”
While this may make them sound pompous, the fact is that the judiciary is the only branch of government without access to a decent cadre of armed enforcers, leaving them to enforce their decisions largely by virtue of their reason and our respect. Wearing a robe, a reminder that they sit in judgment while the rest of us are just regular folk, helps. Sure, it’s a bit of a stage show for the benefit of the system, but at the same time the system could use such a show to fulfill its purpose of having one person in the room making decisions that everyone else should respect. Theoretically, that’s the way a court should work.
But some judges mistake the trappings of office for the need to earn the respect belying those trappings. We’ve all met such judges, who relish the robe, the gavel, the big chair, the booming yet disrespectful manner of speaking to those standing in the well beneath them, and most of all, the decisions that are unworthy of respect.
Justice [Bruce] Allen said respect for the robe was not to be mistaken for a reliance on it.
“If you can’t pull it off without a robe,” he said, “you can’t pull it off.”
So accessorize your robe any way you want. One judge with whom I was very familiar loved to wear chokers, so that her jewelry could be seen above the unflattering v-neck of her robe. This was the source of many a quip, with more than a bit of sincerity behind them. But while the robe may denote your rank in the courtroom, it’s just a symbol. No matter how colorful your scarf, or how many golden stripes line your sleeves, if you want to be respected as a judge, you still have to earn it.
And black is slimming, so if you look fat in your robe, you have other problems.
Crystal Blue Persuasion, and Other Failings
The ability to be clear and persuasive with the written word is a basic skill for lawyers. But persuasiveness is a subjective matter, difficult to gage until after the fact and even then, usually subject to debate. That is, of course, unless a court includes in its opinion a critique of the lawyer’s writing. Rarely is it complimentary.
From Eugene Volokh comes the decision in Live Nation Motor Sports, Inc. v. Davis , including this little tidbit in footnote 5:
[T]he court notes that Davis’s statements are generally defiant and full of inappropriate hyperbole that do not assist the court in determining the facts. Here are a few examples from Davis’s Mot[ion[] to Quash: “Defendants DO NOT ACCEPT these “Supercross LIVE!” copyright labeling by Plaintiff.” “Plaintiffs have come roaring into this federal court with the overwhelming force and the ethics, or lack thereof, of Ghengis Khan.” “Plaintiff has the gaul [sic] to ask this court to affirm its spoils with a partial summary judgment and preliminary judgment.” “A lie repeated five (5) times becomes the truth. Ten (10) times is this Plaintiff’s version of the truth in this complaint.”
Now let’s be frank. There’s a lot of bad legal writing out there. A lot. But for the most part, it’s bad (and ineffective) without being offensive in a way that compels a judge to make specific note of it, to raise it up to the light and show everyone just how bad it can be. This example was just begging for it.
A few suggestions. If you want to emphasize a point, select words that make your point. Do not use all caps. It’s my practice to never use any means of emphasis, such as underline, bold, italics or caps, to try to make a word or phrase stand out in a legal brief. I see it as a failure of my written word, if I require some cheap tool to accomplish emphasis. If I feel that I need to use one of these tools, then I haven’t written my sentence properly.
Go back and try again. The language has plenty of words, and you just haven’t found the right one yet.
Metaphors and similes are great means of making a point, but only if they fit well. Note the Ghengis Khan metaphor used in the quoted paragraph. Is the point that the plaintiff brought with him a Mongolian horde? The analogy is also extended to question the plaintiff’s ethics for having brought the action. This is always a mistake, impugning the ethics of an adversary (not to mention Ghengis) for simply disagreeing with you.
The writing further emphasizes the one thing that no judge cares a wit about; what the litigant thinks about his own position. Who cares whether the defendant accepts plaintiff’s claims? In fact, who cares what the litigant thinks about anything? The point of legal argument is to persuade a judge, not to tell the judge what you think. You don’t get a vote, and announcing to a judge that you, in effect, don’t care what he rules because you are so firm in your belief that no one can shake it is tantamount to contemptuous behavior. This is not the way to make friends.
The use of hyperbole can be an effective weapon, or a clear indication to the court that you are full of it. By claiming that the other side is the “worst ever in the history of man,” you’ve demonstrated that you are utterly clueless. Young lawyers from the government tend to do this all the time, tossing around their favorite words like “frivolous”, “baseless” and “meritless” rather than responding to substantive arguments. They get away with it only because (1) judges expectations from government lawyers are low, (2) they are from the government and judges realize that the interests of the government surpass the dopiness of its lawyers, and (3) they do it with such regularity that no one even notices anymore.
But lawyers outside the government can’t get away with this type of writing. No, your adversary’s argument is not the worst ever, or the most unethical, or the utterly baseless. It’s not convincing to claim that it’s so. Instead, it just annoys the judge, who then discounts your credibility.
A while back, I had a pissing match debate with some anonymous blogger who called himself MoneyLawyer over something he called the “Conan Brief.” Now, I’m no fan of any self-anointed pundit who lacks sufficient balls to post under his own name and subject his credentials to scrutiny. MoneyLawyer was such an animal. But more importantly, his point was not incorrect, but taken to an unwarranted extreme.
Many lawyers mistakenly structure their arguments so that they demand an emotional investment from judges. Their arguments ask the judge to cheer for them, to grant the relief because the judge wants to grant it. Their prose is emotionally charged, laced with opinions about the facts and attacks on the other side’s reasoning. It conjures images of Conan smiting his enemies with a broad sword. This is a bad way to convince a judge who is charged to remain impartial. Many judges interpret this type of writing as overcompensation for a weak legal position. I have read a lot of Conan briefs, but I have yet to see one obtain the relief it requested.
This view supported the antiseptic approach to legal writing. Cool, calm and deliberate, devoid of emotion or passion. He’s dead wrong on this count, and irony was that his “proof” is that he’s read what he considers “Conan briefs” and he’s never seen one “obtain the relief it requested.” The non-sequitur aside, his hyperbole (never?) belies his lack of credibility. After all, even a clock that’s stopped is right twice a day.
Proffering a strong, substantive argument does not require that you remove all heart from your work. While emotional prose that interferes with your ability to make your substantive point, or lacks the substantive back-up to clearly and convincingly show why you feel strongly, is ineffective, communicating your strong belief in the correctness of your legal position or policy choice creates an internal integrity to your argument.
On the flip side, I note that I was once accused in a decision on my motions in a high profile murder case by a judge with whom I had feuded for years of being hyperbolic. This wasn’t the first time this judge went out of her way to gratuitously attack me, so it came as no surprise given the media coverage that she would take a swipe again.
Knowing that any crack in my argument would be exploited by the judge, I was more than cautious in crafting papers that were beyond reproach. I had others, who were very close to the judge, as well as friendly members of the press, vet the papers before they were submitted, and made sure that they knew that this judge was the type who would use her bench as a platform to launch a personal attack.
When the attack came, the judge was castigated for abusing her position for personal reasons, and for her inappropriate and biased opinion. Using the “6 ‘P’s,” anticipation of attack can be turned around and used to your advantage, provided that you don’t do something stupid in the papers to deserve it.
So be Conan all you want, but be a smart and persuasive Conan. Pissing off the judge just isn’t smart.
With that in mind, consider this:
When Lawprofs Meet Wikipedia
Over at PrawfsBlawg, Cardozo visiting Lawprof Verity Winship (one of the all-time greatest names ever, I might add) questions the use of Wikipedia by her students:
Students have sometimes cited Wikipedia to me in class or by e-mail as their legal reference guide. Along the lines of “As Wikipedia says, Erie means….” Sometimes they’ve even quoted paragraphs of it to me in e-mail. Unfortunately, this brings out the curmudgeon in me. Law school could be a place to start learning some of the good habits (e.g., not citing Wikipedia to partners or judges, not writing e-mails you could live to regret) that will serve them well.
Am I just behind the times? Maybe citing Wikipedia is simply equivalent to citing a study guide/”Civil Procedure in a Nutshell” in class, which I would also discourage. Or maybe there is something special about the way Wikipedia is compiled that makes me want to have students be critical users.
Wikipedia, the fastest, easiest and least reliable resource available. I LOVE Wikipedia. Whenever I have a stupid question, something that isn’t worth spending time to properly research, I whip out my Wikipedia (well, google it, but “googling” lacks the pizzazz of “whipping”) and get a quick and dirty answer.
And that’s the problem. It’s the easy answer, when you want an answer now, but aren’t too concerned with the accuracy of the answer. There are many times a day when I see something that I don’t know enough about, and feel that I really need to know a little more lest I start watching Fox News for all my informational needs. The Wiki works. But verity, it’s not. Nor is it really supposed to be.
If one of Professor Winship’s students seeks to persuade his teacher Procol Harum’s A Whiter Shade of Pale was released in 1967, Wikipedia is the perfect place to go. But not to decipher the holding in a Supreme Court decision. You see, there is already a place to ascertain the meaning of a Supreme Court decision; it’s the decision.
One goes to the heart of what they are there to learn, while the other is the quick and dirty place to get answers to questions when the accuracy of the answers doesn’t really matter that much.
Nor is Wikipedia the internet version of the “nutshell” series with which we are all too familiar from those days of late night libation during law school with a class the next morning. Yes, there were times that we had to compensate for never having purchased the books, but we were never so foolish to admit this to our lawprof. This was not a source of pride, but one of expediency. At least have the dignity to keep it to yourself.
But at least the nutshells were vetted by somebody who somebody else thought was smart enough, clear enough and knowledgeable enough to put into a book. Wikipedia doesn’t have that benefit. Sure, it’s subject to edit by about a zillion people, but you never know whether that zillion has a clue or is just out there pounding the editing button to make sure their personal view of what a Supreme Court case should mean remains intact. Yes, there are people who care that much to manipulate the wiki.
That said, I have bad news for Verity Winship. We have taken a vote of the Curmudgeon’s Club and have determined that she has yet to qualify for membership. Better luck next time.
And now, as if you hadn’t guessed, a musical interlude:
Lawyer Fashionista: When Suits Shrink, Help Somebody Else
I don’t know about you, but my old suits shrink while they’re hanging in my closet. When I go to put on one of my old favorite suits, one that fit like a glove the last time I wore it, it’s inexplicably way too tight. Mrs. Simple Justice implores me to lose weight, but she refuses to understand that this isn’t about me, it’s about the suit.
Now I’m a bold dresser for a lawyer. My suits run the full color gamut, from blue to gray. Some have pinstripes. Some don’t. I have a seersucker for the summer, when I’m feeling particularly wild. I don’t wear it with a bowtie or a boater, however, because that would just be pandering. I’m no Tucker Carlson.
So what should you do when those evil Brooks Brothers have taken back that bit of spare girth?
Help someone out. I’ve done this for years, but I’m reminded by a television promotion by a local mens clothier that there are many people out there who are in serious need of a suit to wear to interview for a job. They have struggled to gain the skills, education or credentials to perform the work, but lack the resources to purchase some decent duds for the interview.
Hey, just because that suit shrunk and no longer fits you doesn’t mean it won’t fit someone else. Most of us have so many suits that they rarely wear out, and are often in excellent shape when they hit the shrinking point. Don’t throw them out. Don’t stuff them in the boxes for used clothing, just to be shredded and baled for some scoundrel pretending to be a not-for-too-much-profit.
Find a place in your community where those who are struggling to improve their lives, overcome adversity and be the type of person we all claim to want them to be goes to find appropriate interview clothing. Ask your gardener, maid, nanny, whoever (see how elistist I can be?), if they know of anyone who could use the suit. Find a way to help. If you can’t do it because it’s the right thing to do, then do it because it’s your obligation to help those less fortunate. Noblesse Oblige, baby. You will feel better for it.
Sermon over.
So Whatever Happened to…Judge Tills and Lori Drew
Remember former Supreme Court Justice Ronald H Tills? At one time, “Tills had the reputation as one of the toughest sentencing judges in Western New York during his 10 years as a State Supreme Court judge,” according to the Buffalo News.
Did this reflect his firm belief in the value of leading a law-abiding life? Nu-uh. See, Tills was a Jester. That’s a Jester, as in the Royal Order of Jesters, the secret, yet mirthful, offspring of the Masons. Now many Jesters and Masons, using what little command of their mother tongue they possessed, arose to defend the honor and dignity of this crowd. I received many comments, informing me of what a poor example of a human being I was for not appreciating the wonderful things they do for society.
But it turns out that, while the judge was throwing the book at others, he was engaging in felony crimes himself.And now Tills is looking at jail time — possibly 21 months or more — after taking a plea deal Thursday before U. S. District Judge William M. Skretny.
An embarrassed-looking Tills, 73, admitted Thursday that he recruited prostitutes for events sponsored by a nationwide fraternal men’s club called the Royal Order of Jesters.
This is just too embarrassing. Take a look at that face. Is that the face of a whoremonger? I ask you. Okay, forget the face. What about the body? Has anybody checked his email for viagra buys?
So what exactly did Judge Tills do?
Tills admitted the following:• He was responsible for recruiting out-of-state prostitutes to work a Jesters meeting in Dunkirk “in or about September 2001,” while serving as director of the Buffalo chapter of the Jesters.
• He recruited an illegal alien prostitute from a North Tonawanda massage parlor to service men at a Jesters event in Kentucky in October 2005.
• He arranged for transporting prostitutes from Buffalo Niagara International Airport to a national Jesters meeting in Niagara Falls, Ont., in the spring of 2006.
For future reference, if you want to know the job duties of the director of a Jesters chapter, now you know.
And what about the Lori Drew motions to dismiss?
The Lori Drew/Myspace case, perhaps the case that draws the most visceral disgust of any involving the use of the internet, finally went before U.S. District Judge George H. Wu for decision on H. Dean Steward’s motions to dismiss. Bear in mind, no matter how much you despise Lori Drew, the implications of this prosecution go far beyond this one instance, making it a critical test of the creation of criminal liability for violating private website terms of service.
I wasn’t overwhelmed with the strength of the defense motions, but then I wasn’t overwhelmed by the government’s response either. Dean Steward was miffed with me for questioning his work. There was nothing to be gained by arguing the point with him, since it wasn’t my call but Judge Wu’s.
So what did Judge Wu think? According to the San Francisco Chronicle :
Wu tentatively rejected the motions claiming vagueness and that prosecutors were overstepping their power.
He plans to mull the motion that prosecutors had failed to state an offense before making a final ruling on all three motions within a few days.
It may not be a win just yet, but it’s not yet a loss either. In fact, getting the judge to give your motion some extra thought is a moral victory, usually denied most litigants. So, the hope for a sound decision remains alive.
And for those who subscribe to the Nancy Grace view of law, where little details like law and theory should never stand in the way of putting the people you really hate behind bars, please bear in mind that no one supports what Lori Drew did, or internet bullying. We’re all in agreement on this point, and we’re all disgusted by someone like Lori Drew. But that doesn’t mean we contort the law to find some way to “get her,” no matter how strained and absurd, because that same contortion will come back to other people who we do not despise to get them as well. So don’t get all twisted.
Where Do Sleazebag Ideas Come From?
How I managed to get on the email list for this fellow, I don’t know. But I have to figure that however it happened, it wasn’t the best idea he ever had. I received this “ezine” from this self-proclaimed lawyer marketing guru, Nader Anise. He says he is “the most important marketing and money-making resource ever created for solo practitioners and small law firms.” At least he’s modest.
He calls the recipients of his ezine “lawyerprenuers,” which should give you some idea of his inherent brilliance right off the bat. I mean, really, doesn’t it make you feel so businessmanish when someone calls you something cute like lawyerprenuer?
This isn’t the first time I’ve noted that this fellow does not reflect my, ahem, ideal of dignity, but this is pure, unadulterated sleaze. “Where’s the proof,” you ask? “Why, right here,” I respond:
From: Nader Anise
Date: Sept. 5, 2008Dear Lawyerpreneur,
There may be an absolutely amazing PR opportunity waiting for you (regardless of your political affiliation).
Here’s what’s up: Unless you’ve been living under a rock or in a cave, or under a rock in a cave, you’ve no doubt heard and seen how Governor Sarah Palin has rocked the world of politics, literally, in a matter of days.
She has become a national phenom.
Why am I telling you this? Because according to media sources, many of Oprah Winfrey’s fans have been emailing her asking her to book Governor Palin on the show. They would love to see an Oprah-Palin interview.
Oprah’s response? No way, no how. According to ABC News, The Big O refuses to use her show “as a platform for any of the candidates.” http://abcnews.go.com/Entertainment/story?id=5736716&page=1
Can you say two-faced? Not my words, these are her fans speaking.
You’ll recall, Winfrey has publicly endorsed Obama and practically launched his career. He’s been on her show twice already.
What’s the matter O, afraid of itty bitty Palin?
Anyway, here’s the PR opportunity. Want to make a huge splash all over the country? How about you write a press release, even announce a press conference, in which you will call on a formal national boycott of the Oprah Winfrey show. That’s right… call on all the Oprah show viewers to immediately BOYCOTT the show unless and until Oprah has Palin on the show.
OK, so is this going to get the $250 million dollar a year media mogul to shake in her boots and suddenly see the error of her ways? Hardly. But that’s not the point. The point is for you to land some serious publicity because you are going up against a powerhouse.
The media loves David and Goliath stories and reward them handsomely with substantial coverage. This is about as close to you’ll get a PR slam dunk.
If you can get this thing out to the media Monday morning… and… if you’re the first to launch this campaign, I can virtually guarantee you some major coverage.
And when you’re being interviewed on CBS or Fox News or whatever… remember who gave you the idea!
If you seriously plan on doing this let me know and keep me abreast of the coverage you get.
Regards,
Nader
If you’ve ever wondered where the lowlife scum of the legal profession get their ideas, now you know. But wait! Nader the Masquerader isn’t done yet. A second missive came shortly afterward, apparently in response to the fact that I was not the only one utterly shocked and apalled by this sleazebag.
Dear Lawyerpreneur,
Wow, my last email seems to have struck a chord! A had quite a few lawyers laud the idea as “brilliant” while others insisted it was “politically motivated” and “beneath me.”
Regardless of what you thought, I do appreciate your feedback.
However let me make one thing very clear: THIS HAD NOTHING TO DO WITH POLITICS!
I recognized a truly special opportunity to receive some major publicity and wanted to pass it along to you. Love it, hate it, it’s up to you how you handle it. Those who see it as an opportunity will seize it. If it’s not your cup of tea, ignore it.
Frankly, — don’t take this the wrong way — I don’t care one iota who you vote for… or even… whether you will vote or not. I SIMPLY DON’T CARE.
The purpose of this ezine is to show you have to market your firm, generate publicity and make more money… and that’s exactly what I was doing.
Listen, I generally don’t talk politics in my ezine. But, at the same time, I’m not afraid to either. Ask me what I think of Obama or Biden, I’m more than happy to tell you. Ask me my opinion about McCain or Palin, I’ll gladly share it with you. But that’s not what I’m doing here.
This is simply a golden opportunity I wanted you to be aware of.
And by the way, whether you’re a Democrat or Republican, you can use this Oprah-Palin thing to your advantage. It’s all depends on what “hook” you use in your press release.
Regards,
Nader
So just in case sleaze, with some modicum of actual purpose, might creep into one’s life, Nader is here to tell you that integrity is for losers; Sleaze is for winners like Nader.
Does it strike anyone else as odd that ol’ Nader sends this garbage out for others to do, and doesn’t actually do it himself? No matter. Come Monday morning, let’s see if there are any sleazebag lawyers who call a press conference to call out Oprah to get their sleazy puss on the morning news shows so they can be the latest and greatest sleazebag of the legal profession.
And if you think this is a really brilliant idea, then you probably shouldn’t be reading this blawg.
Leaving only one real question pending. What does Dan Hull at What About Clients? think of this?
Prisoner Re-Entry, Even with Bells & Whistles, is Still a Problem
From Kathleen, our hinterlands correspondent, comes this Op-Ed from the Buffalo News. It’s written by Gerald T. Balone, who describes himself this way:
A little over a year ago, I walked out of Fishkill Correctional Facility, one of the 17 state prisons where I had been confined for 37 years for my involvement in a robbery in which three people were killed on the East Side of Buffalo.
Now 37 years in prison is a long time, but this isn’t about whether the sentence was right or wrong, long or short, good or bad. He did his 37 years, which means that he lived through many changes in the system, going back to the good old days of 1973, before “tough on crime” became the mantra of anyone who sought election and “the harsher the better” became the penal philosophy.
Although I never thought I would see the outside of a prison wall, I took advantage of every educational opportunity afforded — many of which, unfortunately, are no longer available to inmates — to me in prison.
I earned five college degrees, including two master’s degrees, completed several apprenticeship programs and took virtually every counseling and self-help program available.
I came out of prison an entirely different person, with the goal of repaying society for the trust and confidence placed in me by the New York State Board of Parole.
This short passage is full of details worthy of note. He earned five college degrees? That was at a time when people thought that educating prisoners was a way out of poverty and recidivism. Then came the anger. Why should criminals receive a free education when law-abiding families struggled to pay for college for their children?
There is no bitterness in Balone’s tone. He doesn’t complain that life was unfair or that he was denied justice. Indeed, he expresses appreciation for the “trust and confidence” placed in him by allowing him to walk out of prison. Assuming, as I do, his sincerity, this is what we hope will happen to a person who is sentenced to a term of imprisonment. We desire rehabilitation. We want them to realize the error of their ways and to become law-abiding, productive citizens. This is the point.
I was initially released to a halfway house operated by Cephas Buffalo, and spent my first 100 days living with other ex-offenders in South Buffalo. That was a godsend because it provided me with a gateway into a culture that, as you might imagine, bore little resemblance to the one I was removed from in 1973.
This is the stuff of science fiction novels, entering prison when disco ruled and coming out to find that Microsoft now runs everything. But more than that, society went from the Burger Court to the Roberts Court; the pendulum (if you like this analogy) swung all the way to the other side while Balone was inside. When he went in, he left a society that valued empathy. He returned to a harsh, angry society that cared little for anyone but themselves.
Unfortunately, my education and training have not yielded the employment prospects I had anticipated.
In 1973, there was a belief that people who committed crimes could pay their dues to society and, once paid in full, return to be given another chance. It was up to them to make the most of their time inside, to educate themselves, to become the person they weren’t when they walked into prison.
But if you followed the rules, educated yourself, gained skills and insight, then you would one day be given a second chance. Those on the outside would accept you again as a worthy human being. That was the promise of 1973.
That’s not the world in 2008. Once a criminal, always a criminal. There’s no paying one’s dues anymore. There’s no rehabilitation or forgiveness. While Balone was in prison, society changed the deal.
Re-entry is, at its most basic level, a public safety measure. I understand the political reality of appearing “soft on crime,” but I would urge our elected representatives to view re-entry as an investment in their community.
Ah, the old days of wine and roses, before we turned so mean, angry and foolish. Welcome back, Gerald T. Balone.
