While we rail at abusive, unconstitutional and malevolent conduct by police officers, there remains one constant that provides us a limited degree of comfort: They are subject to the requirements of the law. What is they weren’t?
Paul Ohm at Co-Op gives a chilling vision of world of private police, security forces that serve their employer, not the public. They exist in a fuzzy world where they have many of the accouterments of police, and take actions that police might otherwise take, but without any fealty to the Constitution.
Paul talks specifically about Target, and its retention of a digital forensic expert to examine devices such as cellphones, memory cards, blackberries and other devices seized from shoppers believed to be engaged in retail theft.
Is it proper for the police to delegate its forensic work to Target? The FBI agents I used to work with as a DOJ computer crimes prosecutor kept a tight leash on the data they had seized and were reluctant to share data with state and local cops, much less private parties. They justifiably worried about ensuring that non-FBI analysts were staying within the scope of the warrant, because courts have suppressed electronic evidence obtained outside of the scope of the warrant and have even thrown out all of the evidence obtained if the warrant was executed in flagrant disregard of its terms. I’m not saying that the use of a third-party forensic analyst should automatically result in a flagrant disregard ruling, but it will invite scrutiny.
In the bigger picture, these private police will seize, handcuff, jail and interrogate individuals, just like real cops might. With some very significant differences. All those constitutional-technicality-type-thingies don’t happen, and don’t apply to them.
These are not state actors, but private actors. They have no duty to adhere to the 4th Amendment, or to Mirandize their captives. If I was to have a few goons physically seize you and toss you into a clink that I happened to have behind the pretty, decorated walls of merchandise, it would be kidnapping. But they can do it.
In the olden days, retail stores focused on the simple theft, shoplifting. But they are now shifting into hi-tech theft, involving the use of our must-have devices that contain vast amounts of personal information. So now, when they seize your cellphone and go through every inch of it, they have whatever you put in there, without limitation.
What? How can they do that? They can’t do that!
And how do you propose to stop them? Assert your rights? You have no rights there. They hold all the cards. Might makes right in the backroom, and there isn’t a thing you can do or say to change it.
Sure, there is the possibility of suing them, afterward, for having unlawfully imprisoned you, assaulted you, stolen your possessions, violated your privacy perhaps. As if this changed anything. Abusive conduct by private actors does not result in suppression of evidence. The police (the real ones) take the evidence their private counterparts seize and use it against you in court.
The judge will write a decision denying your motion to suppress, admonishing the abusive, overreaching and improper conduct by the private police, but holding that it’s of no consequences to the prosecution, since this was the conduct of a private actor beyond the reach of this court and not subject to constitutional constraint.
This isn’t a nefarious scheme by department stores to take over the world, but a reaction to the huge problem of retail, and now hi-tech, theft that plagues stores and adds significantly to the prices the rest of us pay for all the little things we need to buy to make us good consumers and Americans. Thieves are killing these stores, and they are sick and tired of taking it on the chin. It’s understandable.
But that doesn’t mean that their reaction to theft should be unfettered. The lack of legal restraint that affects the conduct of private parties to behave as if they had the authority of duly sworn law enforcement officers is an open wound in this scenario.
Or as my mother used to say, two wrongs don’t make a right. This was usually followed by a darn good whupping.



Is someone in the Republican camp missing the point about having a woman as the candidates, rather than the “lady”?