Author Archives: SHG

When Cops Aren’t Cops at All

While we rail at abusive, unconstitutional and malevolent conduct by police officers, there remains one constant that provides us a limited degree of comfort:  They are subject to the requirements of the law.  What is they weren’t?

Paul Ohm at Co-Op gives a chilling vision of world of private police, security forces that serve their employer, not the public.  They exist in a fuzzy world where they have many of the accouterments of police, and take actions that police might otherwise take, but without any fealty to the Constitution.

Paul talks specifically about Target, and its retention of a digital forensic expert to examine devices such as cellphones, memory cards, blackberries and other devices seized from shoppers believed to be engaged in retail theft.

Is it proper for the police to delegate its forensic work to Target? The FBI agents I used to work with as a DOJ computer crimes prosecutor kept a tight leash on the data they had seized and were reluctant to share data with state and local cops, much less private parties. They justifiably worried about ensuring that non-FBI analysts were staying within the scope of the warrant, because courts have suppressed electronic evidence obtained outside of the scope of the warrant and have even thrown out all of the evidence obtained if the warrant was executed in flagrant disregard of its terms. I’m not saying that the use of a third-party forensic analyst should automatically result in a flagrant disregard ruling, but it will invite scrutiny.

In the bigger picture, these private police will seize, handcuff, jail and interrogate individuals, just like real cops might.  With some very significant differences.  All those constitutional-technicality-type-thingies don’t happen, and don’t apply to them. 

These are not state actors, but private actors.  They have no duty to adhere to the 4th Amendment, or to Mirandize their captives.  If I was to have a few goons physically seize you and toss you into a clink that I happened to have behind the pretty, decorated walls of merchandise, it would be kidnapping.  But they can do it.

In the olden days, retail stores focused on the simple theft, shoplifting.  But they are now shifting into hi-tech theft, involving the use of our must-have devices that contain vast amounts of personal information.  So now, when they seize your cellphone and go through every inch of it, they have whatever you put in there, without limitation. 

What? How can they do that?  They can’t do that! 

And how do you propose to stop them?  Assert your rights?  You have no rights there.  They hold all the cards.  Might makes right in the backroom, and there isn’t a thing you can do or say to change it. 

Sure, there is the possibility of suing them, afterward, for having unlawfully imprisoned you, assaulted you, stolen your possessions, violated your privacy perhaps.  As if this changed anything.  Abusive conduct by private actors does not result in suppression of evidence.  The police (the real ones) take the evidence their private counterparts seize and use it against you in court. 

The judge will write a decision denying your motion to suppress, admonishing the abusive, overreaching and improper conduct by the private police, but holding that it’s of no consequences to the prosecution, since this was the conduct of a private actor beyond the reach of this court and not subject to constitutional constraint.

This isn’t a nefarious scheme by department stores to take over the world, but a reaction to the huge problem of retail, and now hi-tech, theft that plagues stores and adds significantly to the prices the rest of us pay for all the little things we need to buy to make us good consumers and Americans.  Thieves are killing these stores, and they are sick and tired of taking it on the chin.  It’s understandable.

But that doesn’t mean that their reaction to theft should be unfettered.  The lack of legal restraint that affects the conduct of private parties to behave as if they had the authority of duly sworn law enforcement officers is an open wound in this scenario. 

Or as my mother used to say, two wrongs don’t make a right.  This was usually followed by a darn good whupping.

Someone in Washington Who Finally Get’s It?

Speeches are written by speechwriters in backrooms, sometimes before they even know who they are writing for.  But can we learn more about the real person, the person behind the candidate, from what they write in their legal papers? 

If so, then we may have someone in this campaign who actually understands what the criminal justice system is really all about, and doesn’t pray at the alter of law enforcement.  Who could that be, you ask?  Well, check this out:



And more:



This passages come from the submission of Gov. Sarah Palin in response to the Alaska ethics complaint against her. 

Of course, when someone is personally involved, it tends to taint their view somewhat.  But these words could well have been written by any criminal defense lawyer, and it’s good to see them flow from a candidate for high office. 

It would be good to know if these words are a better reflection of the lipsticked bulldog than the speeches crafted for her in advance.  H/T to Walter Olsen at Overlawyered.

On another interesting note, this post at Viewsday by Michelle Chen raises an important question about this photo:

Palin%20Mccain%20photo.jpgIs someone in the Republican camp missing the point about having a woman as the candidates, rather than the “lady”? 

While the first reaction might be to blame Palin for hanging out with the girls, rather than having hubby Todd chatting up recipes and swapping kid stories, this was certainly a photo-op crafted by a political handler intended to show something about the VP pick.  So what was the point?

Does this mean that Todd is tossing back brewskies and smoking cigars with John and George in the Oval Office?  Unlikely.  But it clearly puts Sarah Palin in the parlor with the wimmenfolk.

He Said, She Said, Jon Stewart Version (Update)

Interesting how words come back to bite you in the butt, especially when there’s videotape.

H/T Matt Bodie at PrawfsBlawg, who’s getting a little tired of all this arguing.

Update:  Dan Solove at Co-Op not only appreciates this video, but is mad as hell and ain’t gonna take it anymore:

It seems as though all these pundits and spin doctors are just playing a game, saying things not because they’re true, not because they believe them, not even because they’re plausible — they just make arguments because they support their side. But this is all just noise. Why must we be constantly be bombarded with this inane and phony banter?

Dan offers a modest proposal:

So here’s my plea for the media — stop giving these pundits all the airtime. Yank them off the air. Don’t print their drivel in the papers. Let’s just assume that the pundits for each side are just going to spout off whatever they find expedient. Do we really need to hear more of it?

In the comments to Dan’s post, others urge him to just shut off the telly.  I think they missed Dan’s point. Big time.   The networks, who are allowed use of the public airwaves for the good of the People, need to stop promoting a dis-information machine that undermines what little integrity may still exist in American politics.

Dan’s right.  People (not just Dan, which is why his turning off the TV doesn’t help) cannot maintain a democracy without accurate information.  When all we’re fed is spin and talking points, 24/7 on 359 cable channels plus network, there is a serious problem.

Journalism 101: Don’t Get Busted

A common complaint of the media is that it has a liberal bias, which of course is a reflection of where the complainer is standing.  But two University of Kentucky journalism students learned a little bit about where not to stand while covering the Republican National Convention.

From the Kentucky Kernel (cute name, no?):



Two UK students and the photo adviser for the Kentucky Kernel were arrested at the Republican National Convention Monday afternoon in St. Paul, Minn., on charges of felony rioting. They were photographing the protesting of the convention.


Photographers Ed Matthews and Britney McIntosh and adviser Jim Winn were three of 286 people arrested as convention protests escalated into riots Monday.


All three were arrested are being detained at the Ramsey County Adult Detention Center in St. Paul, until noon, said jail officials.


They will be charged no later than Wednesday, said jail officials. If convicted, Winn, Matthews and McIntosh would receive a minimum sentence of one year in jail and have to pay a minimum fine of $3,000.

It’s hard to take a decent photograph while keeping a decent distance from the action.  But get too close, and…



Unlike  this prior video, we have a bit more information about what compelled the police to use force against the throng.



Photographer Carla Winn, who was with her husband Jim Winn at the convention, said the problems at the Republican National Convention started when a group of protesters broke off from the main group. People started “smarting off to cops,” said Winn, who said she slipped behind a building while her husband got mixed in with protesters.


The police tried to move the protesters back, Carla Winn said, but when they couldn’t, they started spraying people with pepper spray.


Jim Winn and McIntosh obeyed the police order to lie on the ground, Carla Winn said. She didn’t see if Matthews laid on the ground or not.


A friend of the Winns, Jonathan Woods, witnessed the riots as well. Woods, also a photographer, said that the police warned the protesters before using chemical deterrent.


“There was a pretty good volume of tear gas and pepper spray used,” Woods said. “The rubber bullets are what really got people moving.”


Rubber bullets will do that.  Now some will find that the police were fully justified in dealing forcefully with the crowd, since it’s their duty to maintain order and they only escalated their use of force when the crowd failed to comply with their orders.  As one person suggested to me yesterday, if given a choice between the thugs on the street and the thugs in police uniforms, he’d pick the latter. 

The UK journalists wore press passes, identifying them as members of the media rather than member of the horde.  The St. Paul police spokesman has a curious perspective on this detail:


Of those arrested Monday, four were journalists accredited with the Republican National Convention, said Tom Walsh, public information officer for the St. Paul Police Department. However, he said, that does not include journalists affiliated with Republication National Convention-accredited groups, including some bloggers and photographers such as Jim Winn, McIntosh and Matthews.


Such a small group of accredited journalists being arrested means police aren’t targeting journalism, but criminal behavior, Walsh said.


“There are literally thousands of journalists here, and they’ve managed to cover their stories (without getting arrested), which would imply there’s nothing going on there,” Walsh said.


It’s likely  accurate to say that the cops weren’t targeting journalists.  But that’s really not a sufficient statement to appreciate the problem.  They similarly aren’t demonstrating any sensitivity to the fact that journalists are amid the throng in order to take photographs and get their story. 

While most of the “literally thousands of journalists” are inside the theater for the big show, where there are neither protests nor police shooting rubber bullets, there remain a few outside covering the “thugs” who won’t join the local “anarcho-syndicalist” club and protest in an orderly fashion.  And if they are arrested, along with the subjects of their coverage, because of their presence amidst the disaffected, then who’s left to report?

“If journalists are being arrested and the police are not separating them from the rioters, who is going to be there to report on the event itself?” [Kentucky Kernel Editor in Chief Brad] Luttrell said. “Journalists being arrested for doing their job is a form of censorship.”

What are the chances that these journalism students will carry some baggage in the future when reporting on the actions of the police?  This could explain a bit about liberal bias.

After Further Deliberations, I’ve Got Nothing

The first time someone “tagged” me with a “meme”, I was so out of touch that I had to ask Bennett what a “meme” was.  He explained that it was like a virus that ran through the bowels of the blawgosphere.  It didn’t sound any more attractive then than it does now.

The eponymous Ed., of the iron-fisted blawg review Ed.’s, started a new meme the other day, with the catchy title, 5 Blogs & 5 Blawgers.  The idea was to name 5 blawgers who would then identify 5 great blogs (as in non-law blogs) in honor of Blog Day 2008.  This is a lot like Arbor Day, except it does nothing for the environment.

Ed. then named his five favorite blawgers (I was not among them) to propagate the meme.  Anne Reed (who is in fine health, for anyone who might think otherwise after Vicky Pynchon spread those rumors of Anne’s declining condition) of Deliberations was one of Ed.’s selections, and deservedly so.  Anne, in due course, tagged me.

Now, being tagged for a meme is an honor.  At least it beats being totally forgotten by everyone else who was tagged.  And it’s even more of an honor when tagged by someone like Anne, who is the creme de la creme of the blawgosphere, if only she would get back to blawging a bit more.  

Like David Giacalone of f/k/a, also tagged by Anne, I’m stymied this time.  Reading David’s haiku is the closest I come to any regular attention paid to non-law blogs.  I’m ashamed of myself for this, but it’s largely a time thing, combined with my lack of interest in the mystical (since it appears that others favor blogs with the word “zen” in them). 

So, my appreciation that Anne thought of me, remembered me, tagged me aside, I’ve got nothing.  Zero.  Zilch. Zip. Nada (just to break the alliteration).  I’m running on empty.  I bring nothing to the table.  Sorry.

But in the spirit of camaraderie, I offer this haiku:

Gideon and Matlock
post quietly
While Pattis sleeps

I know, but what did you expect?

The Way to Plea

Over time, lawyers get to hear defendants, as well as other lawyers, enter a plea to charges in an open courtroom.   The initial plea is always “not guilty,” though this seems to be a shock to the media which reports the plea as if it could possibly be something else, a serious piece of journalism.  Other people are often surprised by this as well, as if a guilty person is supposed to announce to the world at his initial plea that he is, indubitably, guilty.

In some courts, the lawyer enters the plea for the defendant.  Sometimes, a judge will do it on the defendant’s behalf.  Most of the time, the defendant gets to speak the words for himself.  This is probably the only time the defendant will be expected to speak in open court unless he changes his plea later.

The manner of announcing a plea has long been a subject of debate.  It’s a formality, but when it’s the only chance a defendant has to say something to the judge, some want to seize the opportunity and embellish it a tad.  Far and away, the most common language is limited to the two basic words, “not guilty.”  Clean, clear and to the point. 

When the lawyer enters the plea for the defendant, there’s a greater chance that the lawyer will throw in something to show the client that he’s getting value for his money.  Usually, it includes some grandiose claim, whether involving the Constitution, outrage at the injustice of the prosecution or how they can’t wait for trial to prove the defendant’s innocence.  Such embellishments are often used to provide the media with a better story than a mere “not guilty.”

I’ve often wondered which path was best, or whether it mattered at all, when entering a plea.  There is now an answer to my question, courtesy of United States District Judge Samuel Kent.  From Above the Law :



U.S. District Judge Samuel Kent stood before a fellow federal judge this morning and vehemently proclaimed his innocence of three federal sexual crimes in his indictment.


“I plead absolutely, unequivocally not guilty and look very much forward to a trial on the merits of what I consider flagrant, scurrilous charges,” Kent stated with force to U.S. 5th Circuit Judge Edward Prado.

“For the record I absolutely intend to testify, and we are going to bring a horde of witnesses,” Kent said.


Now if this is the way a plea is handled by a sitting federal judge, you’ve got to figure he knows what he’s doing.  He’s been there, heard that.  He knows what shenanigans worked when he was sitting on the big bench rather than the trench, and he probably thought long and hard about what exactly he would say when his moment came.

Now we all realize that pleading “absolutely, unequivocally” is substantively no different from just plain pleading.  But Judge Kent (who is still a sitting judge, hearing other cases while his indictment pends) apparently knows that a few additional words, turning an ordinary plea into a vehement one, can make all the difference.  And I’m sure the media presence in the room had nothing to do with it.

I do, however, question whether the “horde of witnesses” was a good choice of words.  Horde?  It could have been easily misunderstood.

Does this mean a simple, elegant plea of “not guilty” is a thing of the past? 

Althouse Knows The Inside of the Onion (Update)

Lawprof Ann Althouse has this on her blawg, so it must be true:



This is the special Marc Randazza Memorial version, so if you have tender ears, please cover them as needed.

H/T Volokh (Eugene, not Sasha)  And Justice Holmes,  via Orin Kerr, way to say he’s part of the gang:  “I cling to my preceptor’s hand and follow him through the dark passages to the light.”  The guys at the Volokh Conspiracy must be having a huge party today.  They are in rare form.

Update:  And it just gets better and better.  More from Orin :


VC Commenters On Apples and Oranges: A play in one act, inspired by recent comment threads here at the VC:



Scene: A Volokh Conspiracy comment thread. Enter two commenters, Red and Blue.

RED: I sure like apples.
BLUE: Apples? They’re rotten. Oranges are better.
RED: Are you insane? Oranges are disasters.
BLUE: At least oranges aren’t corrupt fruits that hate America.
RED: Yes they are, in fact Hitler liked oranges!
BLUE: WTF? Hitler was an apple.


                                     The End.

Too Much Information Costs a Chance at Freedom (Update)

Avvo, Lexblog, Martindale-Hubbell, blogs, blogs, blogs.  Information is good.  More information is better.  It can’t possibly be bad to provide the consumer with all the information available out there, accessible at the touch of a button.  Millions and millions of bits and bytes.  The more the merrier.

Sorry, but there comes a point of diminishing returns.  No information precludes consumers of legal services from making intelligent choices.  But too much may be more damaging, and there is clearly too much.  I get emails daily from some new lawyer searching service, offering me the great opportunity to join them (and put their link on my blawg to improve the height of my profile).  How many are there now?  There are the big ones, like Avvo, M-H and the cheating-heart Findlaw, but there are an ever-increasing number of small ones as well. 

What’s gotten me all worked up?  There’s a guy who is sitting in jail, remanded (meaning no bail for you non-lawyer types), even as I write.  He came from out of town, and wasn’t quite equipped to be busted.  He didn’t know who to turn to, and was constrained to leave it to baby mama to do the trick.

Baby mama came equipped with a computer, and did the best she could to find a lawyer for her man.  And she did.  In spades.  Armed with a list, she methodically called lawyer upon lawyer.  She discussed the case, though she had negligible information and conveyed the wrong impression about what the man was facing.  After she would call names on the list, she would go back to lawyers she had already called to discuss questions and issues that were raised during subsequent calls.  It became a vicious circle.

Baby mama’s primary concern, as is almost always the case at this stage of the proceedings, is whether the lawyer could guarantee that he could get her man out.  Some, naturally, were happy to offer that guarantee.  Others told her there was no such guarantee.  Few had a clue why the man was being held, since baby mama didn’t understand the situation well enough to explain it accurately.  None made baby mama feel sufficiently comfortable to take the dive, because there was always another name on the list to contact and she couldn’t commit until she knew for sure.

Typically, baby mama didn’t realize that this process couldn’t happen in real time over a holiday weekend, when lawyers sometimes take their tie off.  This delayed the methodical process.  And then there was the issue of actually retaining a lawyer, which hadn’t occurred to baby mama until she realized that all of the lawyers she was calling would eventually expect to be paid a sum of money for their work.  This hit her like a ton of bricks, because she didn’t have any money, but had to go to her man’s family for some green.

More than a week passed between baby mama’s first telephone call and the man’s appearance in court.  When the moment came to make the bail application, not a single lawyer who spoke with baby mama was in the courtroom.  Her head was spinning.  She tried so very hard.  She wanted to do the right thing for her man.  But she was paralyzed by the wealth of information available to her.  And her man was remanded.

Now baby mama wants to know which lawyer on the list can guarantee that they can undo the damage.

Update:  And like clockwork, along comes today’s newest and grooviest lawyer sucker scam called “Meet the Elite.”  Catchy, no?  Hyped as “

One of NY’s Fastest Growing Legal Networking Sites

Are lawyers really this desperate and pathetic?

Protester Etiquette; Go Quietly into the Night?

There’s a significant difference when someone is on the receiving end of cop love because he’s engaged in an act of malevolence, as opposed to an exercise of a constitutional right.  But this also provides a rough Rorschach test for the degree of deference due law enforcement, or better yet, how highly we value order as compared with freedom.

Following yesterday’s video of the arrest of Amy Goodman, another video has emerged from St. Paul showing a lone officer attempting to arrest one person in the midst of many. 

Orin Kerr at Volokh describes it thusly:

Based on the video, it looks like a single officer was arresting a protester when a crowd surrounded him and starting yelling to let the protester go. The protester being arrested went limp to make the officer drag him away, and then another protester ran over and knocked over the officer so the officer would let go of the protester being arrested. At first the officer responded with pepper spray to try to keep the angry mob away. But the crowd kept coming at him, so he let go of the person he was arresting and backed away to his squad car. The crowd then cheered their victory. Lovely.

What’s curious about this, and notable from Orin’s description, is that the basis for the arrest is unknown, and can’t be discerned from the video.  While it’s possible that the person was seized for having snatched the chain of an innocent bystander, a tourist from Manitoba perhaps, it seems unlikely since such conduct rarely garners much support from the crowd.  Instead of going the zebra route, let’s assume it’s a horse and deem the basis for arrest to be the protester’s refusal to obey the order of the officer to step onto the sidewalk.

After the protester goes limp, another person from the left appears to jump the officer, who adeptly dodges the effort.  The officer then sprays an arc of some chemical substance, likely pepper spray, into the faces of people to his right.  You see people (other than the fellow who tried to jump the officer, who is now out of the frame) holding their eyes.  The officer may have sprayed the jumper, but he clearly sprayed the crowd of people to his right who did not jump.

This video presents three events, each of which tests our tolerance for order versus freedom.  First is the arrest itself, which is in issue because it comes as a result of an exercise of a constitutional right.  Even if we assume that the officer issued a “lawful order,” and arrests the protester for his failure to obey, some (like me) take issue with a police officer’s authority (remember, police have no “rights”) to order to citizens to exercise their constitutional rights in a manner that pleases them, provided that they do not exercise it in a manner that causes an independent bad act, like smashing car windows or burning storefronts.

Second is the jumping of the cop.  At first blush, this would seem to be precisely the type of independent bad act that mandates police action.  But, if one considers the action of the cop in arresting a protester for the basic protected exercise of a constitutional right, then one might view the officer’s seizure as a crime, and the jumper as a good Samaritan simply trying to protect someone from a criminal act.  Cops are no more entitled to commit crimes in uniform than anyone else.

Third is the spraying of the crowd, following the jumper.  At this point, the officer likely fears the crowd, as one jumper can embolden a mob to act similarly.  His fear seems quite reasonable.  But he sprays a bunch of people who are merely standing there, watching.  They’ve done nothing individually to pose a threat to the officer.  They had nothing to do with the jumper.  They were just standing there.  And they were subjected to a chemical spray to their faces.  Does the officer’s reasonable fear authorize him to spray innocent bystanders? Do innocent bystanders have the right not to be sprayed in the face by a police officer?  Who trumps who?

Orin, in response to a comment to his post that question his view, offers a very clear statement of where along the spectrum he falls:

If you think a police officer is arresting you wrongly, the proper response is to wait for your post-arrest preliminary hearing, get out when the police can’t make out probable cause, and then sue the crap out of the police for wrongful arrest.

The improper response is to assault the officer. That just makes you guilty of assault.

This is the official position, the one taught by lawprofs to law students when they question how to respond to adverse situations.  It’s true when the judge orders you to do something you firmly believe you should not have to do (comply now and appeal later), and it’s true when a police officer orders you to do, well, anything.

Aside from the very practical aspect of putting far too much faith in the system for vindication, there is another aspect that doesn’t seem to find its way into Orin’s response:  Does beating the criminal prosecution, and even pocketing some cash down the road, provide an adequate substitute for the immediate exercise of constitutional rights?

What if the government was to hand all the protesters $100, but deny them the right to free speech?  Would that be a constitutionally acceptable trade-off?  Would $1000 do it?  More?

If I’m from the government (note that the government gets its lucre from the People) and can buy off constitutional rights that annoy me or interfere with my ability to put on a play, then this would seem like a really good deal.  The play goes on without a hitch, and no voice from the crowd spoils the song and dance routine.

Is this really the proper way to deal with the exercise of constitutional rights?

Teen Pregnancy is Not a Virtue

No one outside of the Palin family is in a position to have a clue as to the myriad of influences that resulted in one specific teenager getting pregnant.  And in all likelihood (said as the father of a teenage girl), no one but the teenager herself knows what really happened, and even she is likely not entirely clear on it.  So all discussion about what this fact reflects is nothing more than self-serving speculation.

But a discussion is happening aside from the particulars that needs to be addressed.  The spin cycle is attempting to cleanse the taint by turning what is universally recognized as an incredibly bad thing and turn it into a virtue. 

It’s bad enough that a teeny-bopper of some fame has recently birthed a child.  Thankfully, no one tried to use this as a model of marvel for other young women to emulate.  But then, she represented no partisan group that demanded explanations for those too stupid to arrive at any independent thought on the subject of teenage pregnancy.  But our children knew all about it, and they had thoughts of their own.

Some of us had a talk with our kids about Jamie Lynn Spears.  It wasn’t an easy talk, but it was talk that needed to happen.  We thought we had the issue covered.  Not so fast.

Discussion of teenage pregnancy is again on the front burner, but this time it’s very different.  This time it’s being discussed in terms of staunch support, excusing if not justifying its occurrence and from there extolling the virtues of having the child and marrying one’s teenage crush.  With stoic faces, gangs of mothers explain how proud they are of the choices being made.

Discussion is good (though it didn’t have to come so close on the heels of the last prime time example), but only if its positive discussion.  When discussion of teenage pregnancy is subsumed by political partisanship, it is not positive.  It flies in the face of everything we want to teach our children about what not to do.  The malleability of morality doesn’t hinge on which party is doing the excusing.

So let’s make the best of this discussion by recognizing that we are not in a position to condemn anyone for the fact that one teenage girl has become pregnant, but this one fact does not alter the heretofore universal belief that there is absolutely no virtue in teenage pregnancy.

Confidential to Ken Lammers :  This is not a political post, so don’t flame me for it.  I’ve got kids and there are enough bad influences to deal with.  I don’t need any more.