Author Archives: SHG

And What Would Loose Originalists Do?

Judge Richard Posner of the 7th Circuit wasn’t impressed with Justice Antonin Scalia’s “originalist” interpretation of the Second Amendment in D.C. v. Heller.  So he decided to publish an article in The New Republic to explain why.

At the end of June, the Supreme Court, in a case called District of Columbia v. Heller, invalidated the District’s ban on the private ownership of pistols. It did so in the name of the Second Amendment to the Constitution. The decision was the most noteworthy of the Court’s recent term. It is questionable in both method and result, and it is evidence that the Supreme Court, in deciding constitutional cases, exercises a freewheeling discretion strongly flavored with ideology.

The majority opinion, by Justice Antonin Scalia, concluded that the original, and therefore the authoritative, meaning of the Second Amendment is that Americans are entitled to possess pistols (and perhaps other weapons) for the defense of their homes. Scalia’s entire analysis rests on this interpretive method, which denies the legitimacy of flexible interpretation designed to adapt the Constitution (so far as the text permits) to current conditions. The irony is that the “originalist” method would have yielded the opposite result.

Bear in mind, this isn’t some lawprof taking cheap potshots at Scalia’s opinion, but a circuit judge who says the Supreme Court “exercises a freewheeling discretion strongly flavored with ideology” in interpreting the Constitution.  Guess who’s not getting invited to the party?

It’s past the point of mattering whether Judge Posner is right.  The case is decided, even though the decision has the teeth of a wet hen.  But it’s a fascinating argument, made even more so by Posner’s willingness to buck the big court so openly and strongly.

But Judge Posner argues a more expansive point.


The Framers of the Bill of Rights could not have been thinking of the crime problem in the large crime-ridden metropolises of twenty-first-century America, and it is unlikely that they intended to freeze American government two centuries hence at their eighteenth-century level of understanding. Because of the difficulty of amending the Constitution, it has from the beginning been loosely construed so as not to become a straitjacket or a suicide pact. The older the constitutional provision and the more the environment has changed since enactment, the more appropriate is the method of loose construction.

Essentially, Posner contends that certain provisions of the Constitution are antiquated as written, and the push to apply them based upon originalist thought misses the mark.  He argues that both sides of the ideological equation use loose construction, but to serve the opposing ends.   He concludes that it’s all a pattern of unprincipled decision-making.


I cannot discern any principles in the pattern of the Supreme Court’s constitutional interpretations. The absence of principles supports the hypothesis that ideology drives decision in cases in which liberal and conservative values collide. If loose construction produces a conservative limitation on government, most conservatives will support it and most liberals will oppose it; and if it produces a liberal limitation on government, most liberals and conservatives will switch sides.

So the debate continues.

At Least They Didn’t Get Medals (Yet)

Lest anyone think that Minneapolis has a monopoly on stupid search warrant executions, consider the thoughtful approach of the Buffalo police.  It was a textbook execution of a search warrant, according to the Buffalo News.  With shotguns poised for business, they battered the door of the lower apartment of a family of eight in search of heroin.

The problem is that the Wednesday evening raid should have occurred at an apartment upstairs.

And, that’s only the tip of the iceberg, according to Schavon Pennyamon, who lives at the mistakenly raided apartment on Sherwood Street with her husband, Terrell, and six children.

Pennyamon alleges that after wrongly breaking into her apartment, police proceeded to strike her epileptic husband in the head with the butt end of a shotgun and point shotguns at her young children before admitting their mistake and then raiding the right apartment.

Rule number 3 of executing search warrants:  Read the address on the warrant. 

Breaking down the door, harming the occupants and traumatizing the children is generally viewed as negative thing by most law-abiding people.  Especially Schavon Pennyamon, who had just moved to the apartment a few weeks earlier to escape a crime-ridden neighborhood.  She said that the police were ignorant and rude.  Hard to imagine what made her feel that way.

Police brass acknowledge that officers with the Mobile Response and Narcotics units entered the wrong apartment.

“As the officers were in the lower apartment, one of the detectives reviewed the search warrant application and realized it was for the upper [apartment],” said Dennis J. Richards, chief of detectives.

“It appears to be an honest mistake and we certainly apologize to all involved,” added Michael J. DeGeorge, Buffalo police spokesman.

How does one define an “honest mistake?”  That they didn’t break into the apartment for the purpose of “getting” the Pennyamons?  That’s likely true, though Schavon has doubts: 


She says officers told her they had “raided the house before” and she believes they felt entitled to do it again — warrant or not.  “The way they make it seem is ‘we can do whatever we want,’ ” she said.

But when given the authority to take actions as extreme as this, would it be too much to expect them to “review” the search warrant before they execute the search warrant?

There are numerous variables that can result in a raid of the wrong premise, despite competent and thorough efforts to avoid it.  The system is designed to address these variables, with the judge supposedly determining the validity of the warrant affidavit, its staleness, the veracity and reliability of the informant. 

The one variable that should never happen, that’s wholly inexcusable, is that the cops don’t bother to check the address before the execution.  This is not an “honest mistake.”  This is abject incompetence.  It seems that Schavon’s assessment, ignorant and rude, hits the bullseye.

And to add insult to injury, when the police raided the right apartment, they came up empty.

The Professional Business of Law

Susan Cartier Leibel posts about her telephone call with a 73 year old man by the name of Jay Foonberg.


If you don’t know who Jay Foonberg is (which would be surprising if you are a solo) he has been called the ‘Dali Lama’ of Solo Practice and the author of the most stolen book out of law libraries ‘ How To Start and Build A Solo Practice.”  among other books and thousands of articles on the subject. My students used his book every semester for the eight years I taught at Quinnipiac University School of Law and for good reason.

I suppose her reference to the Dali Lama means that Foonberg is now in exile, and his supplicants are denied their rights by an oppressive regime. 

Susan stresses Foonberg’s point that the law is a noble profession, and that in the process of practicing law, we forget that part and treat it as if we’re selling twinkies (Susan’s comparison, not mine).


Sometimes we get so caught up in running our practices, our lives, feel weighted down by student loans and obligations we forget why we became lawyers.  We focus in on the payday versus the gratification of how we are one client at a time impacting the lives of others and the future course of one of the greatest legal systems on earth. Without laws people take matters into their own hands.  Anarchy and chaos ensue.

I’ve had many a conversation with an old-timer on this subject.  I’ve also had a few conversations with some new-timers as well.  The old-timers remember when lawyers were respected professionals, the people who were well-respected in town and others turned to in times of need for sage advice.  Back then, one hung out a shingle and people came to speak with them and appreciated their counsel.

The new guys want to know how they are supposed to make the phone ring once they get a telephone number of their own.  Everybody they know is a lawyer, and they are all trying to figure out how to get enough work to keep themselves alive.

The old guys talk about how they wore white shirts, suits and ties when they went to sporting events.  They were lawyers.  They were lawyers at all times, and it was a solemn responsibility to appear to the public as professionals at all times.  New guys want to know why flip-flops are a problem in court. 

Amongst ourselves, we can use platitudes to enhance our professionalism all we want, and pretend that we are the last bastion of defense against chaos.  It’s true.  But that’s not enough anymore.  Times have changed, and for better or worse (and I happen to believe it’s worse), lawyers have changed with the times. 

Lawyer advertising was the second step onto the slippery slope.  The first was the egalitarianization of the law.  That sounds awful, since we are all for egalitarianism.  But in the process of opening the law to people from all walks of life, we opened the door far too wide in terms of sheer numbers.  Rather than keep the number constant but change the composition, we upped the ante by letting far too many people into law school.  We diluted the herd, of course, but worse increased the competition for scarce resources in the process.

This caused an unintended consequence, but one that was pretty darn foreseeable.  Too many lawyers means too many people scratching for the same business.  As we know from Abe Maslow, lawyers whose phone doesn’t ring are lawyers who have a problem putting food on the table.  Since their kids need to eat again today, they have to take more extreme action to make that phone ring.

When the telephone is ringing off the hook, and cases are rolling in the door, and the bank account is swollen from the adoring clients, lawyers can lift their chin up high and spout platitudes about the profession.  When the kids are hungry, and inquiring why it’s spam again for dinner, professionalism isn’t the first concern. 

At the moment, we have far too many lawyers plying their trade.  Yes, trade, because that’s what we’ve made of it when we have lawyers scrambling for work, desperate for a fee and prepared to take any piece of garbage that walks through the door if they have a few bucks in their pocket.  Have you seen lawyer advertising?  Is this the way professionals conduct themselves?

Lawyers are forced to market.  No one becomes a lawyer because they are really looking forward to the chance to call themselves “The Hammer” and gain glory from cheap television commercials.  This is an act of desperation.  Lawyers have turned themselves into the desperate profession.  It’s embarrassing to those of us who never wanted this to happen in the first place, and are forced to suffer the choices of others.  And I reject the resort to high-minded platitudes as if that is a substitute for the ugly reality in which lawyers exist.  Kid yourself all you want; those TV commercials are still playing on cable TVs across the country.

The law is a profession.  Whether or not lawyers are professionals is a matter of personal choice.  Some lawyers conduct themselves, and address the needs of their clients, as professionals.  Other lawyers are twinkie salesmen.  Of the latter group, some sell because they see no other option, and some sell because twinkie salesman is the best they will ever be.

Jay Foonberg’s admonition is a worthy effort to remind lawyers of who we are and what we do.  While we no longer need to wear suits and ties to cut the lawn, as they did years ago, to remind us that we hold a position of respect, we need to show respect for ourselves, our education, our function in society. 

While too many law schools churn out too many lawyers, some of whom are unworthy of the trust to care for the lives of other people, however, we encourage the degradation of the profession.  No platitude will compensate for this situation.  As long as lawyers’ phones don’t ring, lawyers will do desperate things to feed their children, a concern that is far superior to professionalism under the circumstances.

Legal Darwinism may help, but it may also backfire.  The strong who survive may end up being the ones who call themselves “The Hammer,” not the ones who behave with the dignity one would expect from a professional.  It’s really up to those of us in the profession to decide whether to keep talking tough while letting it slide all the way down the slope, or face up to the harsh reality and make some hard choices.  Do we want lawyers to be professionals? Do we really?

Cops Just Can’t Catch a Break

Even when a cop does the right thing, chances are pretty good that he’ll wind up in a jam. 

Cop pulls over a speeder on Route 1 in New Jersey, where the speed limit is 50 miles per hour.  The speeder, driving a 1994 Honda Accord, is an attractive middle age woman, who takes her lumps like a champ.  The radar showed her going 70-something, but she was cooperative.  So the cop writes her as driving 69, thus avoiding the jump in penalty and mandatory court appearance had he written her going 20+ miles over the speed limit.

So what, you ask?  This is the way it happens everyday.  These are the little niceties that a police officer does to lighten the load on an ordinary person, write ’em up but cut a few miles off the top.  No big deal.

True that.  Except when the woman happens to be the Attorney General of the State of New Jersey.

Attorney General Anne M. MilgramFrom the New York Times article, Anne M. Milgram comes out of this speeding scenario looking pretty good.  Sure, she was speeding, but regular, law-abiding people drive faster than they should from time to time.  It’s not a morality type offense.  At the same time, she didn’t pull rank, took her ticket and, curiously, was driving a 14 year old Honda.  How can you think ill of a big-time public official who’s so frugal as to drive a 14 year old Honda?

When the ticket was first reported, it was a mere curiosity, since Milgram’s predecessor,  Zulima V. Farber, had lost the AG post because she had 12 speeding tickets and 4 bench warrants for failure to appear.  She may have gone over the line.

The cop, David Krause, didn’t fare as well.  The problem stems from the ticket itself (shown below in a very cool viewer that let’s you zoom in on it) that has the number “69” written over a number that begins with a “7” in the portion that alleges the speed.  Now it’s a matter of “changing the speed,” which apparently smells different than having written in “69” in the first place.  Even though we all know that the “69” was a made-up speed to bring her in below 70 miles per hour, regardless of how fast she was driving.


A spokesman for Milgram says that the officer told her 69 in the first place, and it was always 69 as far as she was aware.  He was apparently unaware of her Miranda rights.


A spokesman for the North Brunswick Police Department, Lt. Roger Reinson, described Officer Krause as an outstanding, veteran officer. Officers have discretion, he said, in how they write up an offense, regardless what their speed guns might show.

“I don’t know the thought pattern of the officer and if he, in fact, he did the change the ticket, it’s still a four-point” violation, Lt. Reinson said.

[Update: Later today, Joseph Battaglia, deputy chief of the North Brunswick police, called to say that he had spoken to Officer Krause. “He said the speed was 69. He wrote 69, and advised her it was 69,’’ he said. “That ticket was not overwritten or anything like that.’’]
What is it?  The ticket is obviously overwritten.  Take a look, there it is.  A mistake?  Not likely.  An exercise of discretion, as might be done for anyone in that situation?  There’s nothing wrong with that. 

The initial reaction of the police spokesman, noting that the officer has some leeway, seems to be a perfectly fine response.  Why couldn’t they just leave it at that?  Why insist that an obviously overwritten ticket isn’t overwritten? 


P.O. Krause did his job.  He stopped a speeder and wrote her.  He exercised discretion for someone who didn’t present a problem and has an otherwise unblemished record.  If he was playing favorites, he could have let her go without a ticket at all.  He has that discretion too, unless he does so because of the AG’s assertion of her position, which changes everything.  From all accounts, she didn’t try to pull rank and he didn’t salute her.

I’m not suggesting that Krause get a medal for doing his job.  He gets a paycheck, and that’s sufficient.  But he performed his job properly and well, and leave the guy alone.

As for Milgram, one has to wonder what she was doing driving a 1994 Honda Accord?  Doesn’t the attorney general of New Jersey get a decent car as part of the compensation package?





Read this document on Scribd: njticket2

Teach Your Judges Well (Update)

Judicial independence and impartiality are always the mantra, but within the cloistered walls of the judiciary, there’s a little judicial activism that no one talks about.

The National Center for State Courts is supposed to be an educational resource for judges.  When it comes to drunk driving, however, the lesson plan is written by prosecutors.  From The Newspaper.com, billed as a journal of the politics of driving, comes a post entitled Judges Taught to Help Prosecutors in DUI Cases :


While most Americans might believe judges are expected to consider all cases with equal impartiality, a prominent judicial standards organization suggests courts should treat differently any case involving driving under the influence of alcohol (DUI). Former Chief Justice of the United States Warren E. Burger founded the National Center for State Courts in 1971 to provide educational services for members of the judiciary. The group is now working in concert with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to promote “efficient disposal of traffic cases.”

The center opened a website covering “The Court’s Role in Reducing the Incidence of Impaired Driving” as a well-documented multimedia resource. It urges lower court judges to adopt advocacy or “problem solving” roles.

I may be old fashioned about this, but I can’t help but think that judges really shouldn’t be taught that they are advocates in the war on drunk driving. 

It’s not that some judges, many judges, personally see themselves as the avenging angels of order, using the robe to impose their personal vision of retributive justice whenever possible.  But we have name for these types of judges:  Bad Judges.  Do we want the fair ones taught that being biased is part of the job?


“A partnership with law enforcement is a necessity for problem-solving courts…. Coordination on such matters as a concentrated enforcement event, like a saturation patrol, is useful so courts can be prepared for an increase in caseload. Any partnership must be careful to avoid the perception that courts are another agency of enforcement and ensure that courts retain their role as neutral arbiter.”

How exactly does one become a “partner” while retaining the role of neutral arbitor?  Apparently, this is easily accomplished when neutral arbitor means law enforcement facilitator.


“In DWI cases, courts can have a much broader role than in many other types of cases,” the site teaches. “Through its interaction with law enforcement, prosecutors, defense attorneys, defendants, the public, and the press, the court establishes a tone toward DWI cases in the community. This is evident when the court… explains to law enforcement procedural shortcomings following unsuccessfully prosecuted cases.”

After all, if the judge isn’t there to tell police how to better nail defendants, who is?

What makes this substantially more troubling is the fact that this isn’t MADD with another of its manufactured promotions to save humanity, but the NCSC, formed and existing to educate judges.  This is one of those places where we send our judges to learn how to better fulfill their duty.  And they are being told that their duty is to be part of the “drunk driving solution” and that it is legitimate for judges to assume an activist role.

But, in fairness, the NCSC drunk driving website does caution judges not to “go too far.”  That’s a relief.  We wouldn’t want any judges getting crazy while vindicating the public demand to convict.

Update:  Mike at C&F has a video from the NCSC of prosecutors judges talking shop about drunk driving.  Very serious.  Very sober.  Very misguided.  No matter how heinous you feel a particulr offense is, judges are still supposed to be judges, not the saviors of the public welfare.

With that in mind, a little traveling music.

2d Circuit On a Roll

Two decisions out of the Second Circuit show that someone has a heart at Foley Square. 

In the rendition case of Maher Arar, where he was sought to sue officials for having falsely linked him to Al Qaeda and then spirited him off to Syria to be tortured (after all, it’s not like we torture people on American soil), the end of the line had come with a split Circuit decision that he failed to state a cause of action.  But the death of his case may have been greatly exaggerated, according to the Toronto Star.

The Second Circuit Court of Appeals announced yesterday it would convene at least 13 judges in December for another hearing for Arar, the Ottawa engineer who was tortured and jailed in a Syrian prison after being whisked out of JFK Airport in September 2002, under a U.S. practice known as “extraordinary rendition.”

A three-judge panel dismissed Arar’s lawsuit in June, but the dissenting judge said the ruling gave the U.S. government license “to violate constitutional rights with virtual impunity.”

What is truly extraordinary about the Circuit’s decision to reconsider the case “en banc” is that it was not at the request of Arar, but sua sponte.  This doesn’t happen very often.  It’s an amazingly significant development that the court, on its own, decided that review the decision of the split three-judge panel, perhaps signifying its disgust at rendition, one of the most offensive (and least known) weapons in the war against humanity.

In another decision, via Doug Berman (who’s finally back from vacation and hard at work bringing us the latest and greatest in sentencing decisions), the 2d Circuit in US v. Darden rejected the use of certain New York drug convictions under the Rockefeller Law as predicate convictions under the Armed Career Criminal Act, which required a conviction for a crime with a punishment of 10 years or more.

These four appeals, heard in tandem and consolidated for disposition, raise the same legal question: whether a prior conviction for a New York drug offense can serve as a predicate “serious drug offense” under the Armed Career Criminal Act (“ACCA”) where New York’s Rockefeller drug laws prescribed a maximum sentence of at least ten years for the offense at the time it was committed, but where New York non-retroactively amended the Rockefeller drug laws, prior to the federal sentencing in these cases, to reduce the maximum sentence for the same offense conduct to less than ten years. We conclude that, under the plain terms of the ACCA, we must look to the current sentencing laws of the state to determine whether the drug offense is “serious.”  We further conclude that under current New York law, the maximum sentence prescribed for these offenses is less than ten years.

One of the great curiosities of practicing law in New York is that the federal courts, hardly criminal coddling on their own, have long had a tendency to look askance at the ways of the state courts.  While issues of due process in the district courts were given short-shrift, a defendant stood a much better chance of getting relief from the Circuit because of its disdain for the methods employed down the block at 100 Centre Street.

In this decision, the 2d Circuit’s implicitly follows its “lenity for thee but not for me” in dealing with the draconian Rockefeller drug laws, the only aspect of state sentencing that makes the federal sentencing guidelines appear reasonable.  But we’ll take it where we can get it.

ICE Screws Up, Someone Dies

ICE, the new combined Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency with the silliest looking shield of any law enforcement agency ever, primarily deals with a different sort of target, aliens.  Because of this, two attitudes prevail.  First, they can do no wrong.  Second, no matter how much wrong they do, they can just ship it out of the country and make it disappear.  If ever an agency was designed to promote callousness and incompetence, ICE is it.  Thus, its motto:  Protecting National Security and Upholding Public Safety.  How exactly does one “uphold” public safety?  Read on and find out.

From the New York Times via Turley :


Hiu Lui Ng was a New Yorker: a computer engineer with a job in the Empire State Building, a house in Queens, a wife who is a United States citizen and two American-born sons.

Ng was in the process of obtaining his green card.  He was one of those aliens doing what all the chest-thumping “illegal” haters demand, following the law.  What did he get for his troubles?


But when Mr. Ng, who had overstayed a visa years earlier, went to immigration headquarters in Manhattan last summer for his final interview for a green card, he was swept into immigration detention and shuttled through jails and detention centers in three New England states.

In April, Mr. Ng began complaining of excruciating back pain. By mid-July, he could no longer walk or stand. And last Wednesday, two days after his 34th birthday, he died in the custody of Immigration and Customs Enforcement in a Rhode Island hospital, his spine fractured and his body riddled with cancer that had gone undiagnosed and untreated for months.

In 2001, Ng had missed an appointment with Immigration when his visa expired, resulting in a deportation order.  But the notice of hearing was sent to a non-existent address, so Ng never knew about it.  In the meantime, he had married a citizen and began the process to petition for a green card, a process that took 5 years before he was called in for his interview.  It was at this interview that he was seized and imprisoned.

While his family struggled to help him in a complicated fight, since the system is ill-equipped to address its own failures under the presumption that the government is incapable of doing anything wrong, Ng stayed in prison.  Things didn’t go well for him there:


[Ng] complained of severe pain that did not respond to analgesics, and grew too weak to walk or even stand to call his family from a detention pay phone, officials accused him of faking his condition. They denied him a wheelchair and refused pleas for an independent medical evaluation.

Instead, the affidavits say, guards at the Donald W. Wyatt Detention Facility in Central Falls, R.I., dragged him from his bed on July 30, carried him in shackles to a car, bruising his arms and legs, and drove him two hours to a federal lockup in Hartford, where an immigration officer pressured him to withdraw all pending appeals of his case and accept deportation.

No one from ICE would provide a legitimate reason why Ng was taken to Hartford on July 30, but it is believe that the trip was intended to prove that Ng was faking his condition.  He wasn’t. 


On Aug. 1, Mr. Ng was taken to a hospital, where doctors found he had terminal cancer and a fractured spine. He died five days later.

At least torturing prisoners at Gitmo serves some logical, albeit disgraceful, purpose.  Ng suffered torture in the hands of ICE as a product of sheer stupidity and callousness.  It just didn’t seem possible to our beloved government employees that a man with a fractured spine and cancer might be in need of medical care. 

And of course, there’s the grand irony that Ng’s imprisonment came as a result of Immigration’s screw-up of sending notice of hearing to a non-existent address in the first place, while he was busily filling out forms and doing everything the proper way.  A lot of good that did him.

Before some badge-licker (as J-dog likes to call them) opines “stercus accidit,” consider how many people, from ICE agents to prison staff, to the judge before whom Ng’s case was brought by his desperate attorneys, had an opportunity to correct this situation during his year in ICE custody.

But hey, it’s not like he was 110% American and deserving of being treated like a human being, right?

Why Must Juries Be Unanimous Anyway?

PrawfsBlawg regular, Ethan Lieb, guest-blogging at Freakonomics, part of the New York Times group of opinion blogs, takes another sacred cow and tips it over. 

The unanimity of a jury verdict is one of those things that we all take for granted, assuming that it’s a critical part of the criminal justice process.  I’ve never before considered why we require a unanimous verdict, or whether the sky would fall if we didn’t.

Before my brethren rain down on me with the obvious, consider that yesterday’s hung jury could have been an acquittal, but for this requirement.  Sure, we love the unanimous verdict when there’s one holdout that stops the other 11 from proclaiming the defendant guilty within 10 minutes after the lunch order arrives, but what of the 11 to 1 to acquit?  Unanimity turns that into a hung jury rather than an outright acquittal. 

Consider Ethan’s top-ten list of reasons why unanimity isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.  He’s not Letterman, but then who is?



Here are a few facts that make unanimity a non-obvious choice for juror decision-making.


1) We don’t require unanimity for any other important decision in our pluralistic polity. Our Supreme Court doesn’t decide by unanimity and neither do our legislators.


2) No other modern country (save Canada and a few jurisdictions in Australia) requires it.


3) We require unanimity to acquit as well as convict, so the idea that it contributes to protecting defendants is not fully accurate.


4) The symmetrical unanimity requirement contributes to inefficiency by giving us hung verdicts more than necessary.


5) Our juries have gotten more diverse as we’ve made it harder to get out of service and as we’ve grown more inclusive in our political system. With that diversity, majoritarianism seems more appropriate.


6) Empirical evidence tends to support the view that verdicts don’t change all that much when you change the decision rule. So the idea that unanimity contributes to certainty is probably overblown.


7) There is also empirical evidence suggesting that people assigned a unanimous decision rule will often agree to decide by supermajority (albeit unanimously) — meaning that in such cases, there is no difference between the two rules, except that some jurors agree to pretend that they agree with a verdict from which, in fact, they may strongly dissent.


8) We all know that many people are willing to falsify their preferences by changing their votes to agree with the majority; the incentives for doing so are especially high when one is a holdout juror being berated by other jurors because everyone wants to get home faster.


9) We don’t have such stringent unanimity rules in the context of the civil jury or courts martial, yet both those systems are respected and deemed legitimate by the public. Moreover, the few states that have experimented with relaxed jury-decision rules for the criminal jury — Oregon and Louisiana — do not suffer especial deficits in legitimacy.


10) Unanimity is often an illusion. Suppose a jury hangs, leading to a retrial. The second jury empanelled to try the defendant then convicts unanimously. Despite this second “unanimous” verdict, the truth is that, of a total of 24 jurors who heard the evidence, fewer than 24 were persuaded to convict. Indeed, it’s possible in theory that only thirteen — a bare majority — were persuaded, if in the first trial the holdout favored conviction, not acquittal.


Now this list doesn’t quite make me want to take up arms for a less than unanimous jury, but does raise thoughts that the unanimity requirement may be little more than one of the those quirky rules that someone came up with in the early days that have since become a bedrock principle, except that it doesn’t really have any particularly good reason to be chiseled in stone.

It’s days like this that I miss Anne Reed at Deliberations the most.  She would explain to me why this is all wrong.  Until Anne returns from her stint in Beijing as beach volleyball star under her nom de guerre, Misty May somebody, I’ll just have to ponder Ethan’s challenge.

What Heller Hath Wrought? (Update)

Eugene Volokh has been keeping track of all the post-Heller gun decisions, and has graciously put them altogether in one place. 

So after all the hoopla, the 437 amicus briefs, the monumental Scalia decision at a minute before midnight at the end of the term, let’s take a look at how Heller has changed the world.

[Silence; vision of tumbleweed rolling down the main street of a ghost town]

That’s right.  Nothing.  Even Dick Heller was denied his gun permit.  How bad does that suck?

I think Heller should get a refund.  I think all the people who contributed to the cause should get their money back too.  And cancel the order for the statue of Antonin Scalia with the AK47 in his hands. 

But then, I told you the decision was a bust, so no refunds here.


But it will take time Scott.  It’s a start.  It’s a first step.  Every journey begins with a single step.

Just keep telling yourself that, and keep your membership in the NRA current.  Hope springs eternal.

Update:  Wrong, wrong, wrong.  As I learn from the WSJ Law Blog (via ajc.com) this very day, there is a school district in Texas that wants to let staff in carrying, and in Georgia, there’s a bill pending to allow people to carry their weapons into church.  Well that’s certainly understandable. Praise the lord and pass the ammunition indeed. 

Church is for sinners, right?

Okie DA Wants Names of his Critics (Update: Texas Comp)

As a New Yorker, I feel obliged to make fun of states like Oklahoma.  With that in mind, did it occur to Pittsburg County District Attorney Jim Bob Miller that the reason Okies post anonymously is that they can’t remember their names?  Okay, enough fun.  Except . . . “Jim Bob?”  Please.  Okay, now I’m done.  This is serious.

Tulsa criminal defense lawyer Glen Graham sent me a link to Tulsa World (as if I don’t read it on my own religiously) about the plight of Harold King, who runs a website called the McAlester Watercooler.  This is a place where the citizens of McAlester (and for those of you who are just plain ignorant, McAlester is in Pittsburg County.  Duh.) can talk about local issues, including how much they hate DA Jim Bob.  Now King and Jim Bob have a history.  Mike at C  and Kipesquire post about this (who knew that Oklahoma nastiness was on so many people’s minds these days?).

It seems that Kings website has a bunch of comments from Okies who prefer to post anonymously rather than risk the wrath of Jim Bob.  Jim Bob is pissed about this.  After all, he’s a very important fellow.  Plus, he’s the District Attorney, and that means that he’s got some clout to smack the crap out of these cowardly, lying Okie malcontents.

So Jim Bob has some of his cops serve a subpoena on King for the identity of these nasty anonymous Okies.  Don’t be too concerned about the fact that the cops were busy serving a subpoena rather than patrolling the streets for hardened criminals.  The only serious crime they have in McAlester is criminal libel, and Jim Bob’s right on top of that.

So Jim Bob, just doing his job eradicating the plague of criminal libel in McAlester, goes after his old enemy King for the names of his anonymous enemies. 


King said he researched posts under those pseudonyms and found one common denominator: All had written critically about Pittsburg County District Attorney Jim Miller.

Miller said by telephone: “I can’t comment on any investigation, and whether one’s going on or not.”

An advocate of open government said he’s concerned the subpoena could have “a chilling effect.”

These Okies are a shifty bunch.  So if Jim Bob can’t comment on an investigation (say Jim Bob, why is that?), can he comment on the abuse of his authority to issue a subpoena to get the names of his political enemies?  It’s a different question, you know.

Kip does a great job discussing the 1st Amendment issue of anonymous political criticism.  Most of us view this as a sort of bedrock thing, that people can express criticism of public officials without fear of prosecution.  Would the disclosure of the anonymous posters have “a chilling effect.”  Why yes, it might indeed.  And Harold King isn’t going to let that happen.

But Jim Bob, the powerful guy, isn’t going to let King get away with that either, and so he’s now filed a criminal libel complaint against King.


The offense description in the report cites a state statute and follows with a description of the offense as a communication “to any person of a false rumor or report of a slanderous nature, slander.”

A narrative report states “Victim said the suspect is criminally libel for his comments and other people’s comments on the ‘mccooler.’”

Except for the fact that all of this is actually happening in McAlester, Oklahoma, the monumental stupidity of Jim Bob’s actions would make for a very funny story.  I’m sure it’s no joke to Harold King or the 35 anonymous posters at the McAlester Watercooler.  And now that the real world knows about how Jim Bob Miller handles his position as Pittsburg County District Attorney, perhaps he will get that hard smack he so well deserves.

Who knew that there was such drama to be found in McAlester?

Update:  Lest my use of the name “Jim Bob” repeatedly raise any more temperatures than necessary, it’s nothing compared with one of the singular most peculiar names around.  This honor belongs to the gentlemen from the Sovereign Nation of Texas, Jew Don Boney, Jr.

Funny, he doesn’t look Jewish.

H/t Eugene, who knows of whence he speaks.