Author Archives: SHG

Should Federal Judges be Selected by Used Car Salesmen?

A  Wall Street Journal editorial says that used car salesmen would be preferable to lawyers if there was merit selection of judges. 


Some bad ideas never seem to die, especially in the hands of a crafty attorney. That’s the story now playing out at the American Bar Association, which voted at its annual meeting this week to endorse a version of “merit selection” for federal judges. What we have here is the latest lawyer-led attempt to strip judicial selection from future Presidents.

A bit of hyperbolic aplomb.  The merit selection plan endorsed by the ABA wouldn’t strip judicial selection from future presents, but limit it to a group put forth by each states two senators following approval by a merit selection committee. 

Perhaps the WSJ has a problem because presidents are typically so very familiar with local lawyers and their trial experience that they select only the finest to be federal judges?  Not exactly.


But surely he must have heard that merit selection merely takes the partisan politics out of the public eye and into backrooms stocked with political insiders. In states that have adopted the ostensibly nonpartisan system, it has given disproportionate influence to the state trial bars that control selection commissions and have steadily marched state courts to the left.

It strikes me as logical that the people who would be best versed in the competency of a lawyer to serve as a judge would be other lawyers.  It likely has something to do with the fact that lawyers know what lawyers and judges actually do, placing them in a fairly good position to assess the quality of their work.  But that’s really not the WSJ’s beef, now is it?

It’s those darn “state trial bars” again.  Now I’m unfamiliar with how the word “trial” got stuck between “state” and “bar” when it comes to this equation.  In New York, we have a lot of bar associations, one for every group you can think of.  We have ethnic bar associations and practice area bar associations.  We have bar associations for each side of a practice area.  But we also have a state bar association, that is meant to cover all the people in all the other bar associations.  It’s not limited to the dreaded lefty trial lawyers, who aren’t really too lefty but are the subject of some ridicule because they won’t put corporations first.


And the chief arbiter of what qualifies as “merit” soon becomes the lawyers’ club, especially the trial bar. The ABA resolution is explicit on the point that the commissions should be composed of “lawyers and other leaders.” Lawyers might even deserve such pride of place if the judges they chose stuck to judging. But with so many modern judges bent on writing law by fiat, doctors, firemen and used car salesmen are just as qualified to opine on judicial philosophy. In fact, we’d prefer the used car salesmen.

For every plaintiff’s trial lawyer, there’s a defendant’s trial lawyer.  The defense lawyers must be a very shy, retiring group, as no one ever seems to notice they exist.  What’s with that?  One of my best friends has an insurance defense firm, and he’s one of the most gregarious fellows I know.  But he would likely still be a flawed choice, since he would likely chose competency over philosophy. 

The gravamen of this editorial is clear.  If merit selection comes to pass, lawyers can’t be trusted to select people who are slaves to a political philosophy.  Only party leaders can be trusted to do that.  But if it was removed from the hands of those who appreciate that politics is all that matters, at least used car salesmen will focus on political philosophy since they won’t be bogged down by lawyerly concerns like competency.

While the editorial tries to turn the tables on lawyers, as if there was some hidden cabal of greedy trial lawyers pulling the strings behind a curtain to install judges inclined to award massive punitive damages whenever possible, the WSJs effort is a blatant appeal for a judiciary comprised of people who will promote its philosophical position of pro-business, anti-crime and limited access to redress. 

They couldn’t care less about competent judges, as long as they swing the gavel the right direction.  They know what’s right, and they want judicial hacks who will do their dirty work.  All under the guise of “judges who stuck to judging,” and that means outcomes they like.

While I’ve never seen merit selection as a panacea, few editorials have persuaded me to support merit selection more than this one.  But then few have been as crass and obvious.

The “Guilty-Plea” Machine

Over at Balkinization, Brian Tamanaha, in the process of discussing the debacle of 300 guilty pleas in Iowa from “illegals” who were given a script and told to nod their head “si” every 30 seconds, decides to lob a hand grenade:


A colleague of mine once pithily said: “If you want to put people in jail, become a defense attorney.” I made my share of deals with prosecutors as a former Assistant Federal Public Defender (a long time ago). After reaching an agreement, we followed a standard script, usually dictated by the prosecutor and accepted by the judge.

Prosecutors want convictions; judges want to keep the cases moving along; defense attorneys have heavy case loads and don’t get paid much for any particular case; and an overwhelming proportion of criminal defendants have participated in some form of criminal conduct. Mix this all together and what you get is a “guilty-plea machine.” Only wealthy defendants are able to opt out of this system.

That’s the way it is…
There’s nothing more helpful than someone who projects their own inadequacies onto everyone else when it comes to characterizing the criminal defense bar.

Memo to Brian:  You don’t know jack.

There are two primary groups that comprise the larger group we call criminal defense lawyers.  There’s the group that you apparently belonged to, resigned to losing and rationalizing your lack of effort and effective representation by saying to yourself, “oh heck, they’re guilty anyway.”

Then there’s another group.  You probably don’t know about this group, because you were never a part of it.  It’s the group of criminal defense lawyers who try their best to defend their clients in every single case.  These are the people who DO NOT write “guilty plea” on their file before they even meet the defendant.  These are men and women who actually do their job, fulfill their obligation to their client and yes, even win some that you would have thrown in the garbage.  We don’t care if the defendant is “guilty”; We represent those accused of crimes.  All of them. 

If you want to describe your experience, and the quality of representation that you provided when you were a federal defender, be my guest.  But don’t begin to suggest that your little insider joke covers the gamut of the criminal defense bar. There are real lawyers out there who are really representing their clients.  Don’t smear them just because you weren’t one of them.

H/T Skelly

Even Lawprofs Get the Blues (Update)

I know.  It’s not like it’s real law, but sometimes these lawprofs have some really interesting stuff going on.  Two in particular are worth the effort this morning.

Bully Pulpit

The “kerfluffle”, which is a polite way of saying Rain o’ Feces, started by Feminist Lawprof Ann Bartow who argues that anybody who doesn’t do things her way is a “bully”, has gone on to new heights.  Over at Scatterplot, via MoneyLaw, Belle Lettre rolls up her sleeves and gets into the mix.


For what it’s worth, I believe that once you release words to the wind, aether, blogosphere, you own them in the sense that your name is attached to them, but they are no longer completely yours. While I highly value civility and collegiality, I also greatly value the free and spirited engagement of ideas and debate.

Now, us trench lawyers may find this entire “discussion” curious, because we’re inclined to start swinging when someone utters a “vituperative remark.”  The academy frowns on such conduct.  The lawprofs have an unwritten code that everyone is supposed to mask their disdain in subtle language to elevate the level of discussion above attacks and name-calling.  You really have to squint a bit when you read their posts to realize that they are getting down and dirty, but in a fashion far too polite for our brutish ways.

Trying not to be my normal snarky self for a moment, i find the civility and subtlety quite charming, if not just a bit forced at times.  Unfortunately, it only works when all parties to the conversation appreciate that level of subtlety.  Around here, a good club to the head often fails to do the trick.

But what eludes me is that this code of civility seems to apply to all lawprofs, except Bartow.  Why is she alone entitled to engage in ad hominem attacks, up to and including name-calling by leveling the epithet “bully”, but no one else dare indulge in a facial challenge?  If you read some of Bartow’s posts, she’s quite vicious, even against other feminists who don’t tow her line with sufficient precision, and brutally clear about what scum they are should they challenge anything she says.  Why is this okay?

The initial thought is that Bartow can throw the “S” word at anyone who challenges her, striking fear in the hearts of all men who might even consider disagreeing.  No one in the academy wants to be branded with the “S” word.  But does Bartow have such strength that her attack is sufficient to emasculate all comers?  

Civility amongst the lawprofs is a worthy goal, and we would all do better by emulating this.  So why does Bartow alone get a free pass? 

Update:  I’ve shamelessly stolen this from a comment to Dave Hoffman’s post, but I’m leaving the name out so that I don’t bully anyone.  As Randazza notes, this pretty much captures the underlying issue perfectly:


‘When I use a word,’ Humpty Dumpty said, in a rather scornful tone,’ it means just what I choose it to mean, neither more nor less.’

‘The question is,’ said Alice, ‘whether you can make words mean so many different things.’

‘The question is,’ said Humpty Dumpty, ‘which is to be master – that’s all.’

I wish I was as erudite as this.  Maybe then I could be more civil, yet effective.

It’s good to have Your own cop on hand.

Dave Hoffman at Co-Op posts a video which is like one of those  optical illusions, where you see either a dancing girl dancing turning right or left, according to which side of your brain dominates.  Except this one deals with you cultural cognition, whether you’re inclined to perceive the police to rightfully be in control or not.



Howard Wasserman at PrawfsBlawg keeps the discussion going.  Why do you care?  This is at the heart of the recurring issue of our seeing a video of a cop doing something (as in the “don’t tase me bro” video) and having two totally irreconcilable perspectives on who is right and wrong.

Just like I argue to my police buddies around here to consider the other point of view, it’s worthwhile for all of us to consider what we see when we watch these videos and to understand why someone else sees something completely different.  We try to be fair-minded, right?

Government Responds to Lori Drew Dismissal Motion

A few weeks back, dismissal motions were filed on behalf of Lori Drew, an adult whose disgusting conduct resulted in the suicide of teenager Megan Meiers.  Despite the fact that no normal person can feel any sympathy toward her, the prosecution theory is so decidedly misguided that it should strike fear in the hearts of all computer users everywhere. 

In its zeal to find some way to nail Lori Drew to the wall, not a disagreeable purpose, the government has engaged in terrible over-reaching and, for this reason, must be stopped.  But I questioned whether the dismissal motions by Drew’s attorney, H. Dean Steward, were sufficient.  Of course, that’s only the first half of the equation, the second being the government’s opposition papers.  From the WSJ Law Blog, the response is now available.


Yesterday, the government, represented by AUSA Mark Krause, shot back, filing three oppositions to the failure to state a claim motion, to the vagueness motion and to the unconstitutional delegation of prosecutorial power motion.

In the government’s opposition to dismiss for vagueness, AUSA Krause writes that terms in the CFAA, such as “access” and “unauthorized” are “not so imprecise that people of common intelligence must guess at their meaning.” As for claims that the statute is susceptible to being arbitrarily enforced, Krause writes: “Cyberbullying is a relatively new phenomenon, as is social networking. It is, therefore, not surprising that there have been relatively few prosecutions in this area. . . . the statute does not threaten to criminalize widespread conduct. Because the government must show that defendant acted with the requisite criminal scienter, there is no risk of criminalizing innocent, let alone negligent behavior.”

In that special sort of response that only an AUSA can proffer, the predominant word is “unavailing”.  For the most part, Krause’s response meets Steward’s challenge and more, but for one gaping hole.  Krause relies on a 5th Circuit decision, U.S. v. Phillips, 477 F.3d 316, 219 (5th Cir. 2007), for the proposition that “unauthorized use” is determined by exceeding the scope of “the expected norms of intended use or the nature of the relationship established between the computer owner and user.” 

Krause thereupon asserts that this means that when the computer owner adopts rules, those rules establish the norms and, therefore, anything outside the rules exceeds the norms.  Man, did he blow it on this one.

Norms on the internet aren’t established by terms of service, those fuzzy legally-things that no one ever reads but just clicks through to get to the good stuff.  Norms are established by use.  Norms are established by the way real people behave.  Norms are established by the way the computer owner, in this case Myspace, deals with the fact that everybody ignores the TOS and posts about how they are taller, thinner, smarter, richer and more beautiful than they really are.   The norm is clearly established:  people lie about themselves on the internet all the time.  And Myspace is fine with it.

The defense motion on the issue of authorization nibbled on the periphery of authorization, and was one of the prongs that I found to be sadly weak.  But the government’s response, which largely ignored the defendant’s argument and set off on a path of its own, has opened the door wide to a thrashing by the defense.  Thankfully, this goes to the heart of the problem, and the basic argument why this prosecution is so ill-conceived.

Many people engage in online social-networking and are slightly less than accurate in their online persona.  Even if the accuracy is arguable, the government’s position would subject almost every online social-networker to a degree of scrutiny that few could pass, thus putting them within the confines of a criminal statute, where their intent would be the target of a trial. 

Krause’s other argument, that only those with criminal intent will fall within the purview of the law, is true, but unhelpful.   It’s the combination of these unrelated aspects, creating a less than entirely accurate online persona plus some disconnected act during the course of ones life online that the government can arguably assert demonstrates criminal intent, that presents the problem. 

This is the real evil of the government’s indictment of Lori Drew.  It’s certainly not that Lori Drew personally deserves better, but that the desire to find a way to get her, via her deceptive Myspace persona to bring her within the purview of the  Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, 18 USC §1030, provides the predicate basis to prosecute almost every normal computer user. 

The question remains whether the judge will have both the techno-savvy to appreciate that the government’s argument on authorization is substantively ridiculous, and the guts to toss the indictment.  But at least the defense is back in the game.


Solo Practice University Launches its New Home!

Susan Cartier Liebel at Build a Solo Practice has long been at the forefront of promoting manifest destiny for lawyers: Go solo, young man (and woman)!  She’s the Dean (and head janitor) of Solo Practice University, the “Practice of Law” School.

Solo Practice University™ is a revolutionary new web-based educational community that picks up where your legal education left off.

Learn from some of the most progressive lawyers, marketing pros, technology consultants and legal business giants how to:



  • Plan, build and grow your private practice
  • Differentiate yourself from the competition
  • Attract and engage new clients more easily

  •             … and much more. They just can’t teach you that in law school.



  • If you are just starting out on a solo practice, or considering it, this is a concept that will provide you with the tools to achieve your goals.  Go check it out.  Susan has dedicated herself to helping lawyers go solo and has put together an enormous amount of information that will not only smooth your transition into solo practice, but help you to achieve success as a solo in ways that were never before available.

    Don’t pass up this opportunity to control your own destiny and achieve the personal and professional success that brought you to the law in the first place.

    NYC Tracking Plan: Expensive, Intrusive and Pointless?

    Remember Reagan’s Star Wars missile defense plan?  It sounded like just the trick to protect us from the Ruskies when he told us about it.  Alas, the Strategic Defense Initiative, as it was officially called, had one flaw.  It wouldn’t work. 

    New York City has a plan too.  It’s going to track every vehicle coming into Manhattan, across the 16 bridges and 4 tunnels that allow people to enter the center of the universe.  The reason is to stop a terrorist attack.  According to Newsday :



    Operation Sentinel, as the focus on Manhattan-bound vehicles is called, is fairly simple: using the latest technologies, police want to keep track of every vehicle that enters Manhattan over the 16 bridges and four tunnels.

    License plate scanners would relay data to an NYPD command center, where information would be checked to see if the vehicle in question has been linked to suspicious activity or an ongoing investigation.


    Data from vehicles with no such links would be purged from the NYPD’s records after 30 days, police said.


    Now there are a lot of vehicles traveling into Manhattan.  Unlike Star Wars, scanning license plates doesn’t seem to techno-problematic, though processing a few zillion a day could take up a lot of disk space.  But this is going to be a costly system, both to create and maintain, if it is to work on any reliable basis.  If you’ve ever dealt with the Triborough Bridge and Tunnel Authority people, they’re going to need to make scanner that can withstand a lot of abuse (not to mention Boston Creme and raspberry jelly).

    And with this robust scanning system, every license plate will be captured and put into a computer.  This is going to include a lot more non-terrorists than “suspicious people.”  But while Donna Lieberman at the NYCLU states the obvious when questioning the impact on privacy and the right to be left alone, Police Commissioner Ray Kelly is unconcerned:


    Kelly, however, noted that average New Yorkers accept that their picture is taken each day, for instance, whenever they step into a bank or a department store.

    “I think they realize we have to take these steps in this day and age,” Kelly said. “I don’t think anyone should have cause for concern.”

    This day and age is a perfect explanation, at least in New York City.  We had an attack here, you know.  So if people want to come into Manhattan, why should they be worried about being tracked by computer, if they have nothing to hide? 

    Well, there’s a philosophical concern, as Lieberman points out.  It’s another brick in the wall of Big Brother government.  Some might prefer to be able to go where they want without the government knowing, just because they like the free America better than the safe one. 

    But the fact is that government already has access to this information for most people, since E-Z Pass is already used by most people who travel into Manhattan, and while not its purpose, it can well serve the same function.

    However, all of this begs one huge question:  What’s the point of it all?  Tacking vehicles “linked to suspicious activity or an ongoing investigation” tells the police nothing about what the driver or occupants of a vehicle are up to.  Nor does it tell you where they are going or what they are doing once they drive out of the tunnel.  But it’s “an initiative [the NYPD] calls necessary in the age of terror.”

    If there’s reason for the police to stop these vehicles before they enter into Manhattan, why are they letting them drive around beforehand unmolested?  And if there’s no reason to stop them yet, then what good does the scanner do to add reason to stop them?  Do the police plan to covertly follow each of these suspicious vehicles through the streets of New York?  That’s going to eat up a lot of manpower, not to mention wreak havoc on intersections. 

    The best reason I can imagine for employing this expensive, intrusive system is to create evidence of a single fact; that a vehicle entered Manhattan at a particular date and time.  Beyond that, it seems utterly pointless. 

    Perhaps I’m missing something, but I fail to see any legitimate benefit gained by this scheme. 


    Mayor Michael Bloomberg, however, said license plates, by their very nature, “identify you in your car.

    “We have to protect the public,” he said. “If you want to have a civil liberties issue, I suspect you should go to the state and talk about license plates.”

    The best Mike can say is “protect the public?”  Come on, Mike.  What’s this really about? 

    Manhattan still feels the sting of 9/11, and the fear created on that day and inflamed ever since remains in the hearts of many.  They are willing to give up a lot to avoid it happening again, and the police need only tie their latest intrusive plan to the word “terrorism” to get the approval of many New Yorkers.

    Like Reagan’s Star Wars plan, however, it isn’t going to do anything to help stop terrorism.  So why are they doing this?  While everybody is properly concerned with its intrusive impact on privacy and freedom of movement, nobody is questioning the true purpose of this plan as far as I can tell.

    The war on terror?  Nope, I just don’t see how this helps at all.

    But What Do the Experts have to Say?

    Adam Liptak, in furtherance of his series on the American Exception in the New York Times, has discovered that expert witnesses are partisan.  Nothing gets past Liptak.

    In most of the rest of the world, expert witnesses are selected by judges and are meant to be neutral and independent. Many foreign lawyers have long questioned the American practice of allowing the parties to present testimony from experts they have chosen and paid.

    Next week, Liptak discovers that we use an adversary system.  I wonder what foreign lawyers think of that?

    Focusing his keen eye on the obvious, Liptak’s essay questions why America doesn’t have “neutral” experts, paid for by the court and without any financial loyalty to one side or another.  It’s a fair question, but only part of the question.  By ignoring the rest of the question, the article offers nothing new or helpful.

    One solution raised is the Australian method, called “hot tubbing.”  I suspect it’s inclusion is based more on its cute name than the novelty of its concept.


    In that procedure, also called concurrent evidence, experts are still chosen by the parties, but they testify together at trial — discussing the case, asking each other questions, responding to inquiries from the judge and the lawyers, finding common ground and sharpening the open issues.

    Australian judges have embraced hot tubbing. “You can feel the release of the tension which normally infects the evidence-gathering process,” Justice Peter McClellan of the Land and Environmental Court of New South Wales said in a speech on the practice. “Not confined to answering the question of the advocates,” he added, experts “are able to more effectively respond to the views of the other expert or experts.”

    The image of a couple of experts naked in the bubbles is interesting, if not entirely attractive.  But it still ignores some basic factors that are part of the package.

    What makes an expert an expert?  Friends of mine tell me all the time that they defer to my knowledge of the law because “you’re the expert.”  No, no, no.  I’m a lawyer, but that hardly makes me the “expert” in the sense that my word on issues legal is beyond reproach.  We’ve become a society that blindly accepts minimal qualifications as “expertise”.  Every lawyer is an “expert” when it comes to rendering an opinion on the law.  But we all disagree with each other, and we do so all the time. 

    The upshot is that we illuminate nothing, and if one lawyer, neutral to the parties but beholden only to the court and the law, opines on a subject, there is a significant possibility that he will be wrong.  Hey, that’s true of judges, and why we have appellate courts.  So why do we attribute such greater expertise to educated people in other fields?

    The reason we have experts subject to adversarial testing is because they may not be nearly as expert as they claim or we think.  They may be totally full of it.  Not because of partisanship, but because they just don’t know what they are talking about, or their field of expertise is a nonsensical.  But if a court adopts the existence of expertise in an area outside the judge’s, the lawyer’s and the juror’s areas of knowledge, then the expert is an expert, even if he isn’t.

    As for “hot tubbing,” there is an even greater risk created by removing any outside oversight from the “expert” process and letting the “experts” decide on their own expertise for themselves, arriving at some mutually acceptable position which may be accurate, or merely palatable to both experts.  What if the field of expertise itself is dubious?  Do we expect experts to report back that their field of expertise is junk?

    There are some pretty good reasons not to drop our problems into the hands of purported experts to make our decisions for us, and to opine unchallenged and impose their expertise on people via the power of the courts. 

    But if they don’t do that in a hot tub, then it’s probably not worth Liptak’s attention.

    John Lennon’s Killer Denied Parole Again

    There is no one who loved the Beatles more than me.  As much, maybe, but not more.  Yet this is simply not a reason to deny Mark David Chapman parole.  According to CNN, 

    “John Lennon’s killer, Mark David Chapman, was denied parole for the fifth time Tuesday.

    The New York State Division of Parole issued a release saying Chapman’s request was denied “due to concern for the public safety and welfare.”



    Chapman, 53, is serving a sentence of 20 years to life in prison for shooting to death the former Beatle outside his New York City apartment on December 8, 1980.


    The killer has served 24 years of his sentence at the maximum-security Attica Correctional Facility and was previously turned down by the New York State division of parole in 2000, 2002, 2004 and 2006.”

    Chapman’s next appearance before the Parole Board will be August, 2010. What can he do differently to gain parole?  Nothing.  His denial has nothing to do with his conduct since the murder or any threat of risk to the public.  It has to do with love of John Lennon and anger for the crime.  This anger will never go away.


    Yoko Ono, Lennon’s widow, in previous years has submitted a letter requesting that Chapman be denied parole. Calls Tuesday to Ono’s legal representative have not been returned.

    Fifty letters and a petition signed by almost 1,100 people were submitted objecting to releasing Chapman, said Division of Parole spokeswoman Heather Groll. Only three letters were submitted appealing for Chapman’s release.

    Is parole now subject to popular vote?  The Parole Board provides no basis to continue to deny Chapman parole.  His sentence, 20 years to life, presumed at the time it was imposed that in the absence of sound reason to keep him imprisoned, he would be released on parole after 20 years.  That was the sentence imposed by the judge.  The Parole Board, obviously, disagrees with that sentence, and has decided that Chapman isn’t going anywhere.

    Whether this is viewed as tyranny of the majority, the majority being those who loved Lennon versus the few who care at all about Chapman, or a political usurpation of the power of the judiciary by the Parole Board, an arm of the executive, it’s wrong and it’s time to divorce our anger about the crime from the wrongful use of parole denial to add punishment to people whose crime was particularly hated.

    I loved the Beatles.  But denying Chapman parole won’t bring John Lennon back.  It’s time to let go.





    Why Police Can’t Police Themselves

    This post is by Joel “J-dog” Rosenberg, cross-posted from his live journal. 

    Thought Experiment

    Start here , and please don’t click on until you’ve read and thought about the article.  I’ll wait. 

    I told you I’d wait.

    A friend recently pointed this out as an example of a cop who really gets it, and, well, my friends aren’t always right.

    Let’s back up for a moment.  Lawofficer.com , like officer.com and policeone.com , is one of the of-by-and-for-the-cops niche websites.  Its intended audience is, well, cops, and covers things that many folks who wear badges find interesting, whether it’s the benefits of flash drives , the importance of rotating ammo , or how to turn a hunch into a legally defensible stop . 

    [To digress for a moment:  it’s around the margins that these sites are the most interesting, by and large.  The comments here, like the forum over at the editor’s previous gig, are unedited, and often revealing — in both good ways and bad.  This particular article doesn’t have any comments; all that’s another discussion for another time.  Short form, for now:  you can learn a lot about honor and dishonor in police culture in these cop forums and in the comments.  I’m going to post on some of the pretty awful stuff you find under some rocks there some other time, but for the moment, you can find a ray of hope in at least one discussion of the mooched cup of coffee ; look at the comments from “jgb in MN”.]

    What’s most revealing in a lot of this — some of the unwitting naked revelations aside — is what isn’t said.

    But let’s look at what was said and done in a report of an event that my friend pointed out as an example of a cop who really “gets it”:

    We can all lose our cool from time to time, but when someone does, the rest of us should help bring things back under control, not pick fights. We’re supposed to be the professionals.

    Sure.  That’s definitely talking the talk, but let’s look at how the guy actually walked the walk, shall we?

    Bullethead — the fellow from whom the above words of wisdom were dispensed — really likes his job.  He’ll tell you how cool it is — and how cool he and his friends are.  They make warrant arrests of people who definitely committed have been credibly accused of really horrible crimes.  It’s high-profile; they get a lot of ink, and he likes that.  Beyond that, he and his buddies are leaders of men — “When the people in this unit aren’t finding super scum, they’re fielding questions from troops needing mentoring and guidance or conducting training at their own agencies.” 

    All of which is, at least in principle, very cool, indeed. 

    So, upon being informed of the location of a murderer, two groups of these super cops are supposed to converge upon the location and, well, bust the guy.  While Bullethead (hey, I didn’t make up this guy’s handle; he did) doesn’t get into the details, there’s some obvious issues that even an amateur like me can spot — since the perp isn’t nailed down, if they don’t get him now, they may have some trouble finding him later; and they do want to both surprise him (murderers, upon occasion, may prefer not to be arrested and perhaps might choose to commit various naughtinesses upon the persons of the folks trying to arrest him), and they do want to arrive in quantity.

    Which makes sense. 

    What doesn’t make sense starts from the beginning of their little road trip:

    My partner starts flying down residential streets [they’re headed for a “distant suburb.” JR] like a NASCAR driver. This is when amateur hour began. 

    Yup.   And the fine professional law enforcement officer — our own Bullethead — doesn’t say, “Hey, slow the hell down.  Now.” 

    We were a block away from the target when a guy stepped off the curb. My partner didn’t even tap the brakes. I’m not sure what he was thinking, but it was probably “I’m important, so move or I’ll run you down.”

    And Bullethead, having apparently taken his vow of silence after getting into the car, doesn’t break it now.  

    Then the law of unintended consequences jumped up and bit us in the ass.

    Well, no.  The Law of Eminently Predictable Consequences jumped up and bit a lot of folks in the ass.  Let’s read on.

    As my partner speeds past him, the guy turns and throws a bottle at us and shatters our mirror. Not a reasonable response to speeding . . .

    Nor, for that matter, a reasonable response, on balance, to some moron driver just about fucking running a pedestrian over, which is, after all, what the guy was responding to. 

    but something that could have been avoided by tapping the brakes.

    Or, even more easily, by having his partner say — and mean — “This isn’t a NASCAR track.  Slow the hell down, now.” 

    They proceed to arrest the alleged murderer– which only goes off well, according to Bullethead, because everybody else “was still in the game.”   His partner — he calls him “18-years” — is focused on the guy who broke his mirror, and —

    along with Bullethead, whose vow of silence is still firmly in place, and who carefully isn’t saying, “Hey, call it even.  You drove like a self-important asshole; he broke your mirror; think of it as a teaching moment, so when the troops need mentoring and/or guidance, you can give them this as an example of how acting like an asshole is a bad idea”

    — heads back to arrest the kid who he almost ran over, which they do.

    As soon as 18-years snatches the kid up, the family starts coming out and asking questions. Instead of answering them, 18-years goes into defensive mode, telling them to copy his name off of his raid jacket and refusing to answer questions.

    Oh, goodie.  Bullethead, of course, is busy not explaining himself, either.  (We’re not sure exactly what he is doing, although he implies he’s trying to “deescalate things.”)

    Then 10-years cop shows up, and instead of helping me deescalate things, he starts stroking up the family even more, and he ends with a straight challenge to fight the kid’s family.

    At which point, finally, a light goes off over Bullethead’s pointy little, and he orders the two other jackasses to “clear the area.” 

    And, finally, we get to the point that my friend found so impressive.

    What’s the point? First, even seasoned cops in a high-profile unit can turn into complete idiots for very little reason.

    Well, yeah.  In this case, it was because one of the Special People, while acting like an asshole, provoked somebody else to act like an asshole. 

    Second, we should remember why we’re here. The important work we were doing that day was overshadowed by the stupid actions of a couple of jackasses.

    Well, yeah, but you’re missing the point, Bullie; you elide right over it in the next ‘graph.

    We’ll all have to kill time in court because this kid is going to fight us . . . 

    Hope so.  Not because it was okay for the kid to throw the bottle at your maniac-driving partner’s car — it wasn’t — but because the whole damn thing could have been avoided if either of you had acted like a grownup, and been thinking with your brains, rather than your badges. 

    Yup; he drove like a dangerous idiot — and you just sat there and let him. 

    . . . and we’ll probably end up in Internal Affairs as well.

    Waitaminute.  You mean that after your idiot partner almost ran down a kid, and then busted him and — with the help of a ten-year-veteran cop — did his level best to escalate a misdemeanor arrest into a fucking riot, you’re only “probably” going to end up in IA?  You mean to tell me that you didn’t, once you came to your senses, call your partner’s maniac idiocy to the attention of his supervisors, and did your damndest to see that he gets whatever training, supervision, and consequences he needs so that he doesn’t go slamming cars around the fucking streets like they’re a NASCAR track again?  You didn’t even point out to your readers — all cops, like yourself — that you could have prevented the whole thing by shutting down your partner’s idiocy from the moment he started driving like a lunatic?

    Keen eye for the obvious:  doing the right thing in the first place would likely have had a more serious impact than writing it up later on, ending with pious, buttery pronouncements like, say, this:

    On top of that, one more family will forever hate cops for nothing more than the ego of one idiot who still doesn’t get that our power comes from the consent of the people.

    We can all lose our cool from time to time, but when someone does, the rest of us should help bring things back under control, not pick fights. We’re supposed to be the professionals.

    Yeah, you are.  Supposed to be.  A whole lot of supposing going on.