Author Archives: SHG

The Slackoisie go to Law School

It’s that time of year again, when Gen Y over-achievers pack up their iPods and flip-flops and bid Mom adieu, as they head off to their first year of law school.  Some of the lawprofs have offered sound, though official and self-serving, advice to these incoming students.  They can’t help it.  They’re lawprofs and vested in the system.

As a counterpoint, allow me to offer some advice of my own.  While I’m sure that each and every one of you is brilliant and bound to be the most successful lawyer ever, take a good look around the room during your first law school class and figure out whether you want to be the suck-up kid who blows off all the really good parties and buckles down to read the casebooks.  Remember how you were all hung up on grades in college? Well, they only matter now if you want to make law review and ultimately find your way to doing document review at some Biglaw firm for far more money than you could possible be worth, until they fire you because of a precipitous drop in profits per partner.

If you’re that kid in the classroom, then don’t bother reading the rest of this.  It doesn’t apply to you and I have no advice for you whatsoever. 

Good.  Now that they’re gone, this is for the rest of you.  Shut up and take your licking like a lawyer.  Grades don’t matter.  Do well enough to stay in school, but beyond that no one cares.  No judge, no client, no juror will ever ask you what grade you received in torts.  I promise. 

Learning the law itself is easy.  It’s a bunch of rules that changes every few years and then is made to appear as if it was always that way even though today’s law may be the exact opposite of yesterday’s.  No point wasting too much time fretting over the rule against perpetuities or the fertile octogenarian rule, except as a curiosity of how little law school has to do with reality.  Worse yet, if you should happen to develop a nuanced understanding of the law, judges will hate you for trying to make them look stupid. 

Spend your time listening to others and figuring out why they are wrong.  They will be wrong most of the time.  Not only will this make you feel good about yourself, but it will force you to think harder to avoid humiliation.  Personally humiliation is one of the core ingredients of a good law school education.  Nothing serves to better motivate a first year law student than the fear of looking like the biggest fool in the class (no small feat, to be sure).  This will serve you well as a lawyer.

Hopefully, your professors won’t be touchy-feely wimps and will use the Socratic method in order to embarrass as many students as possible and assuage their need for control.  This method, particularly when coupled with the refusal to use students names (as in lawprofs calling students “blue shirt woman” or “tattoo man ” rather than Muffy or Skippy) forces the other students to direct their attention to one person to watch as they whither and die for failure to have a clue what the lawprof is asking.  This is another critical component of a good law school education.

Lawprofs Ilya Somin and Orin Kerr over at Volokh argue about whether the Socratic method is better used to teach you to think like a lawyer, is better because it requires you to think on your feet or analyze a fact pattern to parse the relevant facts from the flotsam.  It’s a silly argument, since you have to be able to do both, and anything that embarrasses you will serve that function. 

Bruce Boyden at PrawfsBlawg argues that the Socratic method is a “demonstrably poor teaching technique,” “particularly if the aim is to purposefully confuse or intimidate the students.”  Great.  So if they don’t learn about confusion and intimidation in law school, where else are they supposed to learn it? 

Here’s the real deal.  Other than the handful of Biglaw associates whose hours will spent joyfully in law libraries until their hair turns gray, lawyers have to be able to represent clients.  When you stand up before a judge with another person’s life in your hands, there’s no time to feel sorry for yourself or to whine to the judge that you aren’t prepared to answer the question. 

Up to now, everyone has told you that you are important.  That you matter.  Not any more.  As a lawyer, you are there for someone else.  That person matters.  Some judges will be overtly abusive.  Smarter judges will be subtly abusive.  Tricky judges won’t let on that they’re abusing you at all.  The worst are the judges who abuse your client while making you feel good about yourself.  They’ve got your number.

A well-conceived law school education serves one purpose only: to prepare you to confront the abuse of being a lawyer and prevail.  How to prevail comes later.  You’re not ready for that now.  For now, you need to learn how to toughen up and take abuse without crying and whining.  How to keep a smile on your face and deflect the humiliation that is designed to make even the most macho man shrivel.  If your lawprof doesn’t abuse you, she hasn’t done her job.  If your lawprof doesn’t toughen you up, then you’ve gained nothing.

Up to this point in your educational career, the system has been designed to make you feel good about yourself and build your self-esteem.  If this isn’t changed, it will destroy you as a lawyer.  There is nothing about the legal system that will make you feel good about yourself.  It will challenge your dignity and humanity at every turn.  Your mommy is wrong when she tells you to just go up to the judge after court and tell him that he wasn’t very nice to you and you don’t appreciate it.  This is not a successful strategy.

Why is the law this way?  Well, remember when you looked around the room during your first class, the people who are really dumb are the ones who lick envelopes at the party headquarters for a decade and later become the judges.  True, licking envelopes really isn’t the best qualification for the judiciary, but it’s the only one they have.  And these dumb students are going to turn into mean, petty judges, and want nothing more than to pay you back for the humiliation they suffered in law school by showing you that they are now in control.  Get used to it.

Law school is the time to learn how to beat them at their own game.  Learn this and the rest is a snap.  And if you go to one of those law schools where they are deeply concerned about how you feel about yourself and want to foster a nurturing environment, tell them you want your money back. 

One Part Harmony at the DOJ

At Viewsday, Michelle Chen posts about the FBI’s new plan to “harmonize” its new role in investigating terrorism.  When word of a new plan began to spread, it was met with dread as an effort to open the door to domestic spying, according to the Christian Science Monitor.  Members of the Senate Judiciary Committee were briefed about the plan, which has yet to be released publicly.


The initiative folds into the Bureau’s effort to “harmonize” its investigative guidelines, melding its criminal law enforcement and new anti-terror roles. As Attorney General Michael Mukasey explained in a recent speech in Portland, the Bureau wants to “shift its national security focus from investigating crimes after they occur to collecting the intelligence necessary to detect and prevent attacks before they occur.”

This sounds so much better than saying that the government is going to start spying on people, doesn’t it?  Following the briefing, some Judiciary Committee members “issued a counterpoint” to Mukasey’s sweetness:


“We are particularly concerned that the draft guidelines might permit an innocent American to be subjected to such intrusive surveillance based in part on race, ethnicity, national origin, religion, or on protected First Amendment activities.”

This is how one slides down the slippery slope.  It used to be that racial profiling was bad, bad, bad.  But if they sell it right, use new language like “harmonizing” and connect it up to existing step, such as the beloved USA Patriot Act, it really is just a baby step forward.

Little by little, and with the best of intentions, constitutional rights meld into the interest of safety, security and order.  While 9/11 hysteria has faded somewhat, we’ve become so inured to governmental overreaching “for our own benefit” that another smallish step, like domestic spying based on national origin and political beliefs, seems like such a small thing to give away to protect us.

I can’t wait for the new rules to be publicly released.  It should be interesting to hear the rhetoric that accompanies them.

What Does a Winning Defendant Do?

Why, he starts a blog, of course.

Geoffrey Fleiger was fully of bravado before he became a defendant.  And he’s full of bravado again.  Learn what life is like for Fleiger, ex-post-defendant, at his new blog, FleigerTime.

It appears that we have a new convert to the abuse of government power and the joys of fighting the good fight.

An example of the wit and wisdom:

As I was watching the Olympics, I was reminded of something I said to Gerry Spence when I was visiting  Trial Lawyers College in July:

“Trial law is the only blood sport where you can be an Olympic gold medalist at age 79.”

With four photos of Fleiger across the masthead, looking as if he’s either competing for America’s next top model or in serious pain, this is definitely worth a look.  I wonder what he would have done if he’d lost?

Cops are Cops, 24/7

For better or worse, New York’s Finest are cops all the time.  That means they are there to pull their off-duty weapon and stare down the liquor store bandit when they are there to buy a bottle of pink Catawba, or to teach a passing motorist a lesson in humility.

Enter the NYPDs answer to Thelma and Louise.  From Newsday,


Officers Michelle Anglin and Koleen Robinson were charged with assault, menacing and weapons possession for allegedly pummeling Marlon Smith so badly Friday that he needed 25 stitches.

One of the officers pointed a gun in Smith’s face, Smith told investigators.

“If these allegations prove true, it’s a horrendous case, a horrendous situation,” Police Commissioner Ray Kelly said.

Of course, that’s only what Kelly said in public.  In private, he laughed, “ha, the guy got beat up by two chicks!”  His chest swelled with pride.

The details are just so Bronx. 


Authorities said Robinson, behind the wheel of her Chevy Suburban, was riding with Anglin when she pulled alongside Smith’s parked car in Williamsbridge because his driver’s side door was open.

“Close the door, you –,” one of the cops told Smith, 35, according to the criminal complaint.

Smith responded with an obscenity, and the officers attacked him, according to the complaint. Anglin allegedly squirted pepper spray in his face and Robinson punched him. In the ensuing melee, Robinson allegedly beat Smith with her collapsible baton and Anglin pistol-whipped him in the face.

See how prepared these two police officers were, despite the fact that they had a mere 2 and 3 years on the force.  Always concerned with potential hazards, like an open car door.  A collapsible baton and pepper spray at the ready.  And note the most professional thing about the encounter, that they were careful not to discharge their weapon and thereby risk death when a mere pistol whipping would suffice.

Sure, there was some colorful language involved, but this happened in the Bronx,  Anything less would have been unseemly.

But what these two fine officers mostly kept at the ready was their attitude.  They were cops.  Nobody messes with cops, whether on duty or off.  Nobody.

Marlon Smith found that out the hard way.  And he probably needed a lesson in humility as well, though perhaps our Thelma and Louise should have taught to the test.  Remember, these are New York’s Finest.  Think about what our Worst must be like.

H/T Turley

A Person of Interest

Following up on the issue of why a person “presumed innocent” isn’t deemed actually innocent, what of the person whose name is released to the media, for revelation to the world, that he is a “person of interest, but is never charged?” 

If a person charged with a crime, whether by accusation in a sworn instrument or indictment, is tarred with the perpetual taint of being guilty,even if proof falls short, what of the person who is disclosed to the world as the person the government believes to have committed some heinous crime, but who is never charged? 

Is this better or worse?  Sure, the person is never put on trial, and therefore never runs the risk of conviction.  But on the flip side, his name will forever be associated with the crime, and the fact that the government (which knows everything) believes him to be guilty.  But he never has the opportunity to challenge the government’s accusation, whether to prove his innocence or just refute the allegations and prevail by the technicality of being found “not guilty.”

Consider how this plays out in the normal course:  The government floats its accusations, which become the myth of the case in the media and can be repeated over and over, as if these are irrefutable facts.  The “person of interest” may well have evidence to show that the story is ridiculous, false, totally concocted.  But he can’t use it.

The “person of interest” has an attorney who tries to dispel the accusation by announcing that the person is totally innocent.  This is just typical attorney nonsense as far as the public is concerned.  It means nothing.  The government has provided the media with a laundry list of evil deeds, and the attorney has done nothing beyond a overarching denial of wrongdoing.

Often, the attorney will have plenty of specifics to rebut the allegations in the media, but he’s not going to spill them to the first reporter who calls.  This is what he needs at trial to fight the case, and giving up his information early just gives the government a preview of the defense and a chance to construct its case around it.  If he can disprove a claim, they will circumvent the claim and find a different way to smear the “person of interest.”

It’s a quandary.  But let’s get to the stage where there’s no accusation or prosecution.  Google the name and there it is, in perpetuity.  The government said so.  The media said so.  The poor guy can do nothing about it.  He will never have the chance to counter the allegations and clear his name.

The person of interest is neither presumed innocent nor actually innocent.  Yet he was never charged with any crime ever.  Still, his name will forever be associated with the commission of a heinous crime, with the government’s imprimatur of accuracy, and there will never be an opportunity for him to challenge it. 

Dropping a Kid Off at College

Yesterday, my wife and I drove our daughter through a number of states to arrive at the college.  The Prius was full to overflowing.  A Prius is not meant for this purpose, but it managed.

Today, we will move everything out of the Prius and into a room slightly larger than a typical prison cell.

For those of you who have gone through this, we will soon know what you know.  For those of you who haven’t, I can tell you that it’s been a difficult summer, and the past couple of weeks have been increasingly difficult.  We have a lot invested here.

When my wife and I are alone, we recall things that happened with our daughter many years ago.  We have spoken to her about things we think she needs to know.  She tolerates our discussions most of the time.  But now she’s anxious, unsure what her next phase will bring.

We tell her that it’s going to be great.  The truth is, we’re all anxious.  We want it to be great more than she does. 

So it will be a busy day today.  I hope it goes well.  Either way, there will be one less person in the car when we drive back.  And the two remaining for the drive will likely sound like old, nervous people, talking about life years ago and how our baby is at college only hours after she was born.

Special Prosecutor is not Always the Answer

Reacting to the video in which “police officer Patrick Pogan body-slammed a biker during a Critical Mass ride through Times Square,” Gov. David Paterson is seriously considering appointing a special prosecutor, according to New York Magazine. 

According to the Villager, Paterson has always been sensitive to police-abuse issues — he was arrested in 1999 (while he was a state senator), alongside NAACP president Kweise Mfume and a group of other protesters, for blocking the entrance to NYPD headquarters in protest of the shooting of Amadou Diallo.

I can’t blame Paterson for trying to gain some political benefit from this mess, but a special prosecutor is the “catch-all”solution.  It sounds meaningful, but brings nothing to the table that isn’t already there.  Manhattan District Attorney Bob Morganthau has an official misconduct unit that has no problem going after cops.  But the Pogan situation isn’t about a dirty cop, except to the extent that he perjured himself to cover his violence.

Just as the Amadou Diallo protests changed nothing, neither will a special prosecutor here.  There are problems.  There is a governor interested in dealing with the problems rather than condoning, excusing or explaining them away.  So now, how about someone taking the bull by the horns, calling out the police and court culture that gives rise to, and supports, the problem.  And then doing something real to deal with it.

Not another special prosecutor.  Unless he’s going to go through every cop lie for the past 5 years and prosecute the cops.  But then, who wouldbe left to protect and defend the good people of New York?

H/T The Turk, avid New York Mag reader.

Does Presumed Innocent Mean Less Than Innocent?

Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast poses a great question.  The question arises from a reversal of a conviction on appeal for insufficiency of the evidence.  The defendant then sought compensation, and was denied on appeal because presumed innocence isn’t the same as “actual innocence.”  Scott blogged about this in more depth at the Innocence Project of Texas.

Hence, the question:  Why is presumed innocence less worthy than “actual innocence?”

Lawyers understand the difference implicitly, the former being a failure of proof of guilt and the latter being affirmative proof of innocence.  This reflects lawyers skewed mindset, where we intellectually know the rationale but fail to adequately question the rationale to figure out whether it can withstand scrutiny.  In other words, we all know the rule, but does the rule really make sense?

Aside:  This is one of the things that I find most beneficial from the blawgosphere, where people raise questions or issue that lawyers have taken for granted for so long that we never consider questioning.  It’s a very good question, and without the blawgosphere and Scott’s having raised the question, we might never rethink what seemed too obvious.

The presumption of innocence is one of the law’s many clichés, repeated incessantly but rarely given much thought.  We don’t actually honor it, or believe in it.  I stumbled on Nancy Grace last night, after flipping off beach volleyball, and listened as one ignorant blond after another opined in some hick twang about how evil an accused was, and how she deserved ridiculous high bail because . . . she just did.  They could have mouthed words “presumption of innocence,” but they showed how meaningless the words have become.

The mantra “presumption of innocence” needs to be broken into two parts to be understood.  It is a presumption, in that a defendant need not prove innocence in the first instance.  The burden is on the prosecution to prove guilt.  They can rebut the presumption through evidence, and upon doing so beyond a reasonable doubt (whatever that means), the defendant loses the presumption.

But the second half of the phrase, “innocence”, means exactly what it says.  The defendant is actually innocent in every respect under the eyes of the law.  Fully, totally, completely innocent.  The defendant never has a burden to prove his innocence.  Usually, it’s impossible to prove innocence.  Aside form the rare instances where something like DNA is available, or a mysterious videotape appears, defendants are faced with accusation and denial.  That’s the sum total of the case.

When a court determines that the evidence of guilt is insufficient, that means that the prosecution has failed to satisfy its burden of rebutting the presumption.  It means that the defendant is restored to his position of actual innocence.  He is innocent, totally and completely and beyond question, innocent.  To say otherwise is to create a non-existent legal purgatory, that places the burden of proof on the defendant.  There is not now, nor has there ever been, an obligation of a person against whom an accusation has been levied to prove the accusation false.

The mindless lawyerly approach is to accept the notion, drilled into our heads in law school, that actual innocence is an entirely different animal than presumed innocence.  The animal is very rare, and hardly ever seen.  When it appears in the courtroom, we all look at it intensely, with amazement.  But this highly nuanced approach isn’t about innocence at all, but about the availability of proof of innocence. 

One reaction to the question might be to ask whether we “reward” someone for the prosecution’s failure to prove guilty as opposed to the defendant’s affirmative proof of innocence.  But is it a “reward” for the individual to demand recompense for harm done to him by the government?  This is compensatory, not the lottery.  No innocent person subjected to unproven accusations considers prevailing a windfall. 

But the larger question is what constitutes proof of innocence.  No one forces the government to arrest and prosecute someone.  Unlike the defendant, who has no option but to defend, the government picks and chooses its cases.  Theoretically, the prosecution should never lose a case.  The fact that is does, and that it’s evidence fails, is huge.  It means something when the government subjects a person to all its might and still comes up empty.  It may lack the satisfying certainty that affirmative proof of innocence may possess, but for many cases such satisfaction just isn’t within the realm of possibility.  Should the defendant be penalized because someone else’s accusation isn’t susceptible to negative proof?

How cool is it when there is evidence to affirmatively prove innocence!  Unfortunately, this opportunity isn’t available to all innocent people.  For those people for whom proof of innocence isn’t, and could never be, available, they are sentenced to spend their lives in the legal purgatory of “not guilty” rather than innocent.

Give this question the thought it deserves.  Don’t have the knee-jerk lawyer reaction of showing how you paid close attention in first year crimlaw and subsumed the myths that we’re taught to accept as truths.  How does one recapture innocence after an unproven accusation when there is no way to affirmatively prove innocence.  And why should one have to?

Callousness Toward a Dog is Different

We are a funny species.  We take callousness toward our own with a certain equanimity, capable of rationalizing it by projecting our own self-ambivalence and concluding that the victim of the callousness deserved it.  The same can’t be said for animals, especially pets.

All over the news yesterday, and highlighted by Turley and Mike at C&F was the video of some Texas protectors of the public welfare who showed abject callousness toward a teacup poodle named Missy.  As the dog’s owner, Michael Gonzalez, and his girlfriend, Krystal Hernandez, drove crazy to the veterinarian emergency room to save Missy’s life, they were stopped by San Marcos police officers.

Gonzalez alit from his car like a crazy man, trying to explain that he was driving about 100 miles per hour to get to the emergency room in time to save Missy’s life.  The cops were unmoved.  One told Gonzalez to calm down, it was only a dog and he could get another one.

There are good reasons for the police having stopped Gonzalez, and for someone to take significant issue with his conduct of driving like a maniac to save Missy.  He put the lives of others on the road at risk.  As much as he was concerned for his pet, had he killed some other person, say a sweet young child (because children, like dogs, get special dispensation), it would have changed the perspective of the situation.  But Gonzalez didn’t harm anyone.

Unlike many, I am not particularly fond of pets.  It’s a character flaw, but that’s the fact.  However, I do not want to see harm or pain come to any living thing.  To do so is sick.  It reflects a sadistic mindset, where one can easily pass off needless harm. 

People are prosecuted and punished for harming pets.  This reflects the fact that they are there to comfort our species.  Aside from those that are vicious, they offer only comfort, with no possible moral flaw.  Pets are innocents.  We can’t attribute evil to them, as we can to our own.

So, the pointless death of Missy, the teacup poodle, because of the callousness of police officers, becomes national news. 

But Turley’s post juxtaposes another video of a woman who was stopped and told police that she was pregnant and bleeding. 


Other officers have been accused of such lack of concern in highway stops, such as this video of a pregnant woman who lost her baby when she was stopped while bleeding, click here. A female officer shows utter disregard for her obvious medical emergency — which resulted in the loss of the baby. The tape shows officers virtually mocking the woman in distress. When she asks why they will not let her get medical help, a male officer says “because I think there’s still a little bit more than what you are telling us. You sure are playing hard to get lying to us.” A female officer tell her “Don’t cop an attitude with me. It’s called a menstrual cycle.”

This callousness resulted in the loss of a baby, but it never grabbed the national attention of Missy, the teacup poodle.   I suspect that police officers will explain, over a beer or two, that they hear stories of dire emergencies all the time, and most are lies. They become inured to such claims, and blow them off without much thought.

But the officers couldn’t have thought the Missy explanation was a lie, as Missy was lying there on Krystal Hernandez’ lap.  Missy was right there, barely alive.  Perhaps the callousness comes from seeing too many people with real emergencies that life and death are no longer critical to them.  At least the life and death of someone other than a cop is no longer a tragedy.  If a cop breaks a fingernail, that seems to bring them out in waves of protest.

Some might argue that the life of a pet is not the equivalent of the life of a human being.  Pets, under the law, are chattels, things.  We own them.  But they are still innocent things with feelings.  If the issue was the choice between saving a pet and saving a human, I would have to side with the human.  But that wasn’t the choice once the cops stopped Gonzalez’ car.  The cops then had the opportunity to allow Gonzalez to save Missy, or better yet, help to save Missy.  The cops chose to play their control game as life flowed out of Missy’s body.  They were proud of themselves for having won the game.

We are an odd species.

Tainted by Google Forever

Jason Barney, filling in for Ted Frank at Overlawyered while Ted is on a cross-country tour with Miley Cyrus, posts about the real life problem raised by Dan Solove in his terrific book, The Future of Reputation .

Seattle attorney Shakespear Feyissa was accused of attempted sexual assault while attending Seattle Pacific University in 1998.  He was never charged with a crime and naturally, not convicted.  But since the allegations were covered in the school paper’s online edition they are cached in Google and easily uncovered for anyone who searches his name.

According to Barney, the SPU people agreed to remove the archived article, but Chris Durr, the editor of The Falcon Newspaper refused, calling it censorship.


We explained to them, if they wanted to start down a path of removing historical archives and pulling it from the public sphere, what they’re doing is censorship.  We basically said, sorry, we have principles in journalism that don’t allow us to put stuff in the memory hole and pretend it never happened.

Now it unclear to me whether this should be chalked up to a kid who has yet to grasp the impact of the written word, especially when that word will be available in perpetuity, on real people.  Chance are, he’s full of the “principles of journalism,” swollen with importance over his firm stance in the face of administrative pressure.  Or is this blind adherence to theoretical ethics, ignoring the fact that the paper failed to complete the circle by publishing the part where the allegations never resulted in a prosecution.

From the Seattle Times:


“Shakespear Feyissa may not like the story, but that doesn’t mean he should get to dictate what gets removed from a newspaper’s online archive,” Debra Smith, who wrote the original article, said in an e-mail. She now writes for The Herald in Everett and teaches a journalism class at SPU. “A newspaper serves as the paper of record for a community. I don’t think that function changes when the content moves online.”

But having published damning accusations, there’s a flip side to these principles.  Maybe she missed that day in class.  Removing allegations that have never been proven to be true isn’t censorship, but sound judgment in light of the circumstances.  And as it now stands, the “paper of record” presents only part of a story, the part that harms someone against whom allegations have never been proven.  Not much of record.

Of course, there are other alternatives as well, such as noting in an update to the archived article that the person was never charged or convicted, and therefore has never had the opportunity to refute the charges.  Perhaps noting that allegations are not proof of any wrongdoing.  The point is, they put out the bad stuff and this is the information that will taint him forever. 

This particular issue is close to my heart, having seen many lives destroyed by the wide dissemination of initial allegations against people, with little or no mention when the cases are dropped or the accused is acquitted.  People’s lives are ruined in the first few days after the allegations spread, and there’s no way to put the genie back in the bottle.

It would be censorship to forbid a newspaper, even a student newspaper, to print serious allegations.  But the fact that they are perpetuated through Goggle whenever the accused’s name appears is like stabbing him in the heart again and again.  Forever.

Here’s another “principle of journalism” for editor Durr to consider:  The public is not served by perpetuating undeserved harm.  Figure out a way that Feyissa won’t have to suffer the taint of student ethical bravado for the rest of his life.