Author Archives: SHG

Way Too Much Good Stuff in the Blawgosphere

Following my apologia about my inability to keep up with the wealth of great posts in the blawgosphere, today brings a cornucopia of stuff worthy of everyone’s attention.  Since I’ve sworn off doing more than 27 posts per day in the interest of time and sanity, here’s a survey of the posts since I would be remiss not to post something about them.


The Disparity of the Language of Crime


From Mike at Crime & Federalism, a post about a new book comparing the disparate treatment given in the interpretation of consent to search versus invocation of right to counsel.  A person agrees to let a cop “just look in the trunk” is interpreted as consent to have his car torn apart piece by piece, while a person who says “I think I should probably speak to an attorney first,” is not interpreted as unequivocal invocation of right to counsel. 

Fundamentally Correct Constitutional Interpretation


Orin Kerr at Volokh is really more sarcastic than I am.  He really is.  Referring to Richard Posner’s effort to critique Scalia’s “method and result” in his decision in Heller, Orin smacks back with:

Posner is ridiculously wrong, of course: The fundamental truth of constitutional law is that Justices who agree with me are divining the true Constitution, while the rest are political hacks twisting the document to suit their policy preferences. Thus, my side is always principled.

He is a hoot.  He’s also right, no matter how much lipstick you put on that pig.

Does National Pride Trump a 7 Year Old?


Alleen Barber at Viewsday will break your heart with this poignant description of China’s decision to hide a lovely 7 year old who won a singing contest under the covers and use a “prettier” girl in her place.  The reflection on China’s need to present itself as perfect provides the most telling proof that China, despite the face it presents in the Olympics, has yet to understand the meaning of the word “ugly”.


Bartow’s Definition of an Internet Bully


This is a two-post combo from Dave Hoffman at Co-Op, but follows up the comments to Paul Horwitz at PrawfsBlawg.  It seems that Ann Bartow, that perpetual ray of sunshine in the lawprof blawgosphere, has challenged the rest of the lawprofs to naked co-ed mud wrestling by arguing that anybody who doesn’t provide advance notice, and get prior approval, of a response to a published post (by a female?) lawprof is a “bully”. 

No one can figure out what she’s talking about, though the lawprofs say this very nicely, to avoid annoying Ann. Of course, it doesn’t help, and Bartow throws a hissy fit.  Now I understand completely, since I’ve read Ann’s views on sexual politics.  She just mirrors Orin’s argument on Posner’s rationalization.  Except nobody told her it was a joke.  I might have sent Bartow advance warning of this post and asked her permission to use it, but I’d rather just be a bully.  Grrr. 


Do I Have Your Permission to Destroy Your Stuff?

And again from Mike at C&F (who is just posting one great thing after another), the 8th Circuit decision in U.S. v. Santana-Aguirre, holding that consent to search a trunk somehow incorporates consent to destroy the personal possessions of the person as well.  In this case, it involved destroying two candles.  While adopting the officer’s reasoning for wanting to see whether there was something inside the candles in excruciating detail, there is absolutely no concern for, or rationale behind, the approval of nonconsensual destruction of personal property. 

Who cares how good a reason the officer can create to justify he desire to destroy something?  There was no consent to do so, and the officer’s interest doesn’t extend consent beyond its parameters or give rise to the authority to destroy at will.  This is a fundamental unprincipled decision, but one that you need to know about when they cut the head off your client’s kid’s beloved teddy bear, just to be sure.  Can you say, “No, I do not consent to a search under any circumstances?”

Of Feeds, Time and Courtesy to Fellow Blawgers

A while back, I switched over to RSS feeds in a losing effort to keep abreast of the ever-growing blawgosphere.  This isn’t to say that there are too many blawgs.  It’s to say that there just isn’t enough time in the day.

I’ve just taken a few minutes to add new blawgs to my criminal law blogroll, to better reflect the blawgs I think have much to offer.  I’ve included a few that should have been there long ago, and I somehow neglected to include them way back when.  I know there are still more that I’ve missed, and if I’ve left your blawg off, please remind me so I can add it in. 

But this raises the question, again, of how to keep up on the blawgosphere.  I’ve come to realize that there are some very practical limits, most prominent amongst them being time.  Even with the RSS feed, providing me a blurb from a fairly broad variety of blawgs, I’m losing ground.  I can return from court to find 50 or more new posts on my feed, and a good 6 or 7 minutes to peruse them before my next appointment.

This is offered as an apology to the many other blawgers who have written great posts on topics that I post about here, but I’ve neglected to mention your post or blawg.  I frequently recall having seen a post on a subject before, but can’t quite recall where.  It’s an age thing.  You’ll find out about it. 

I don’t want to be so discourteous and unappreciative of my fellow blawgers.  There is so much great stuff out there, so many interesting perspectives and enlightening posts, that the breadth of conversation has become overwhelming to a dinosaur like me.  If only I had all day to read and write.  How great would that be?

Forgive me if it appears that I’ve neglected your blawg or your post.  If there’s been no mention of you in a while, it isn’t a reflection of anything negative.  I am now coming to appreciate the situation others were in when Simple Justice first appeared, and was roundly ignored by the best and worst blawgs. 

But most of all, it’s important that you know that I am doing my best to follow as many blawgs as possible, and I appreciate your efforts enormously.  I’m just not up to the task of reading as much as I should to be on top of the blawgosphere.

 

Jurors are Jurors, Unless They aren’t On-Board (Update)

The story of Thomas Eddlem, juror in the case of accused mafioso drug dealer, Robert Luisi, is a cautionary tale.  From the WSJ Law Blog :



Thomas Eddlem was part of a jury that began deliberations in Boston federal court in the retrial of Robert Luisi, a reputed mafia lieutenant, for cocaine trafficking. During deliberations, Eddlem reportedly sent a note to the judge, William Young, asking, where “is the constitutional grant of authority to ban mere possession of cocaine today?”


Two hours later, according to a recent memorandum written by Judge Young, the jury sent him two more questions: First, if a juror denies the constitutionality of the prosecution, “preempting consideration of the facts,” can he participate? Second, can the jury continue to deliberate? Judge Young brought the jury in, assured them that the laws at issue were constitutional and sent them home for the day, he wrote.


But the “problem” persisted, and after Judge Young found out that Eddlem was the problem, he was tossed off the jury.


Eddlem, whom the Globe describes as a 42-year-old technology coordinator at a Catholic high school and former John Birch Society official, prompted Judge Young to write a 43-page memo, saying this was the first time he “encountered a juror who has attempted to arrogate to himself the power that our Constitution places in the elected branches of government.” Judge Young ultimately replaced Eddlem with an alternate juror. Shortly afterward, the reconstituted jury convicted Luisi of three cocaine-related charges.

Why?  Eddlem made some peculiar points, upsetting his fellow jurors perhaps, but where is the wrong in that?  Strange people (not to say that Eddlam is strange) end up on juries all the time.  Indeed, ordinary people are often “unusual” in their thoughts, and they are supposed to be on juries.  If they were, why would we need more than one person on a jury?

The difference with Eddlem, of course, was that he was antagonistic to the laws of the United States as currently interpreted.  He doubted the government’s authority.  He questioned its power.  Maybe his theory was just a wee bit fringe.  Okay, a lot fringe, but it was his and he was selected to be a juror and all jurors come to the courthouse with baggage.  Has anyone ever heard of a juror getting tossed because he espoused in the jury room that anyone arrested likely deserved it, no matter what the evidence?

Eddlem wanted to nullify.  Judge Young was determined not to let that happen.  The viability of jury nullification has been discussed here and elsewhere before, so we won’t get into that morass again, but the point remains that Eddlem was tossed because nullification was his intention.  We can’t have that.  While Judge Young might not have been able to change things after the verdict was returned, he could certainly do something about the problem when he received advance warning. 

It’s different, apparently, when the juror’s issues are with the government rather than the defense. 

Update:  Randy Barnett at Volokh, just wee bit late to the party, agrees.  He just didn’t believe it could happen until he heard it from Cato.  I guess I’m just not a credible source.  Sigh.

The Risk of the Witness Interview (Update)

Under normal circumstances, cases have witnesses and witnesses need to be interviewed.  After all, if you don’t speak with the witnesses, you won’t know what they have to say, or whether they are good for you or bad for you.  And regardless of which way they go, you want their testimony locked in so that you can prepare for it.

Sounds simple, but two Baltimore lawyers were forced to take the witness stand to defend their methods after being accused of trying to obstruct, intimidate or manipulate witnesses, according to the Baltimore Sun.


Yesterday, a judge ruled that a jury can hear testimony from a prosecution witness who said defense attorney Leslie Stein urged him to change his story, telling him that “people don’t last long when they snitch.”

Baltimore Circuit Judge Timothy Doory said he didn’t necessarily believe the witness, Christopher Meadows, over the 35-year veteran attorney, who denied the allegations. But the judge thought “there was enough there” that the jury in the murder trial of Stein’s client, Bryant Williams, 24, should be allowed to decide who’s telling the truth.

One of the problems, among many, is that the witness is often a team player, but playing for the other team.  When the defense tries to speak with the witness, they resist.  It often requires a little persuasion to convince the witness that he’s not being disloyal to talk to the other side.  It’s not unusual for the witness to have been told that he is under orders not to speak with the defense. 

But there’s a good chance the a witness, who has already dealt with the police and prosecution, has picked his side and now wants to be a contributing player.  It’s no longer a question of whether the witness will speak with the defense, but what the witness will do within 37 seconds after the interview is over. 

As happened to Leslie Stein in Baltimore, the witness can make allegations of witness tampering and intimidation, accusing the lawyer of trying to suborn perjury.  This can turn into a he said-she said scenario, and guess which side the prosecution will take.  The judge, caught between a rock and a hard place, will usually feel constrained to treat the witness’ claims seriously, and the lawyer will find himself in the last place he wants to be.

The means to avoid this situation are readily available, provided the defense has the funding necessary to use them.  There are two simple steps required:  First, the defense lawyer should never go out to see witnesses alone, but always in the company of an investigator who will serve as a witness to what transpired.  Second, all communications with witnesses should be surreptitiously recorded, from telephone calls to face-to-face interviews. 

Not only will these two steps provide evidence to be used should the witness change his statement when he’s on the stand for impeachment, but it will provide hard evidence to show that there was no improper conduct on the defense’s part in its investigation of the witness.

Easy though this may appear, it has problems for the private practitioner.  While public defenders often have their own investigators available, and well-funded defendants can afford to retain the services of competent investigators, there are a wide swathe of cases where there’s just not enough money to pay for the panoply of ancillary services that are really needed to provide an effective (and safe) defense. 

There’s no easy answer for this problem.  Investigators have children who like to eat too, and they expect to be paid for their services.  When lawyers hit the streets on their own, they can still try to record their own interviews, provided they have the equipment that is needed, but they still won’t have a witness to testify as to what transpired.  So, they’re back on the stand themselves, perhaps with better support than they would have without a recording. 

But few lawyers have the equipment needed to do the job adequately.  Also, few lawyers have the skills to handle an interview with an unwilling witness.  This can be a bit dicey, and may require some very sensitive handling.  If there’s a problem, the lawyer is still the focus and left wide open to criticism and potential prosecution.

The second lawyer in the Baltimore Sun story raises an entirely different problem.


In another case, prominent defense attorney Ivan Bates took the stand Tuesday in the robbery trial of Charles Robinson, 31, one of his former clients. Bates was accused of negotiating a contract in which Robinson would pay a victim $690 in exchange for not pursuing civil or criminal “remedies.”

Buying off the victim is one of the riskiest, and most ethically problematic things a lawyer can do.  To the defendant, it seems like such a natural way out of his problems.  To the victim, it often seems like the perfect solution, or the most heinously cynical attempt to buy the defendant’s way out of prison.  To the lawyer, it is essentially impossible to “resolve” any potential civil claims stemming from a crime without it appearing (and, in fact, being) an effort to buy testimony or lack of cooperation.

Whether the attempt to “settle” starts with the defendant or the victim, who may well reach out to claim damages and offer, in exchange for money, to “drop” the case, I’ve never found a way to accomplish this that doesn’t trample ethical proscriptions.

Bates explained his reasoning to the Sun:


In an interview yesterday, Bates denied any wrongdoing. “That contract had nothing to do with Charles Robinson,” he said. He asserted it was to prevent a civil action.

“I told the victim he would still have to come to court and he would have to tell the truth,” Bates said. “Honest to God that’s what I said.”

This just doesn’t pass the smell test for me.  Not even close.  For those who might be inclined to give it a go, be prepared to take your lumps regardless of whether you’re successful in negotiating a deal or not.  When the victim calls the prosecutor to say he’s “dropping the case,” something that is not necessarily within his power to begin with, the prosecutor or arresting officer may well demand an explanation upon pain of the prosecution turning its attention on the victim for some amorphous wrongdoing.  The victim is going to spill his guts immediately, and then the focus shifts to the lawyer. 

Buying peace is a prescription for disaster.  No matter how sensitively it’s phrased, or how sincere the motive, or how many “Honest to God’s” the lawyer tosses into his testimony, the story emits an unpleasant odor.  Be prepared to take your lumps.

Update:  This is belated update (8/13/09), but one that needs to be done.  Ivan Bates has filed a $13 million libel suit against the Baltimore Sun for this story, claiming that the article mischaracterized what happened, and falsely suggested wrongdoing on his part.  While the Baltimore Sun has pulled the online version of the article, it otherwise stands by its story and has not issued a retraction.

If the Sun story falsely characterized Bates’ conduct and testimony as unethical and improper, than I hope he nails the paper to the wall.  As strongly as I feel about ethical conduct, incompetent or false reporting is no better, and a lawyer’s good name is all he has.  Whether this case ever makes it to trial or achieves a public outcome has yet to be seen, but at least you should know that Ivan Bates has picked up the gauntlet.

The Cop Experience, From the Horse’s Mouth

We can debate how cops think all we want, but we’re still outsiders looking in.  Thanks to Joel “J-dog” Rosenberg for pointing me toward a cop website/blawg called Officers.com, and specifically knuckle-dragging copper, its remarkably civil and thoughtful, even though it reflects such widely disparate understandings of the role of a police officer in society.

Great stuff.

The Return of the Freebie at Starbucks

Is it Starbucks?  A couple of weeks ago, it was Major Garvin in Orlando ready to go to the mats over a frappucino.  Now it’s Barbara Nevers of the Chicago Police Department.  I mean, sure the coffee is good, but is it worth committing a crime?

Via Turley, who has a special interest in this particular Starbucks (as opposed to the one a block away, I guess), another cop who can’t keep her gun holstered when it comes to demanding her vente fix. 



Yet another police officer has been suspended for threatening Starbucks employees with arrest or worst if they did not continue to fork over free coffee. Chicago police officer Barbara Nevers has been suspended for 15 months for allegedly demanding both free coffee and baked goods.


The 55-year-old Nevers allegedly threatened Starbucks employees by screaming at them and flashing her badge, handcuffs or gun when they wanted her to pay. For that, you only get a suspension in Chicago?


The story of coffee in Nevers-land includes the unpleasant condition of a suspension.  Some might wonder why it’s different when a cop threatens with a gun, or when a cop walks out without paying.  For others, this might be considered, oh, a crime?

But then, others will say, at least they did something to her.  After all, a 15 month suspension isn’t chopped liver.  True, but it’s not exactly a criminal prosecution either, now is it? 

What’s interesting about this round of impropriety, when compared to the olden days of cops being offered, and accepting, freebies from local merchants, as was the case in the old Serpico scandal, is that these are merchants offering a cup of joe to appease those who are paid to protect and serve.  They are taking by force.  And when the merchants resist, they have no qualms about using their clout to force the issue.

The oddity is that these same individuals may very well be great cops otherwise.  Brave and strong, willing to save kittens from trees, plenty of ribbons on their chests.  Just because they have a taste for expensive coffee doesn’t mean they are criminals through and through.  Maybe they’re just thirsty.

Or maybe we’re seeing that cultural thing that somehow falls into the law enforcement blind spot, where the same conduct that might give rise to a good whupping, or a taser if one is too stuffed from baked goods to become physically involved, falls within the ambit of a perk of the job. 

The Chicago Sun-Times article includes a list of other decisions by the police board released at the same time.  My personal favorite is the cop with two wives.  Talk about a bad decision.

Even if we assume that these are the “one bad apple” cops that seem to pop up on an hourly basis, where are the partners, the “honest” cops we keep hearing about.  No, no, only kidding.  You know this is just rhetorical.

I want to assume that somewhere, there’s a law enforcement officer, current or past, blushing as they read about these misadventures in policing.  It’s been my position for some time that until a cultural broom sweeps clean the mindset of police that they are entitled to ignore the same laws that they apply to others, nothing changes.  So we keep talking about these crimes perpetrated by police officers on the job. 

Maybe something will eventually sink in.  Maybe.  I can only hope.

The Secret To Winning Meme

As if things weren’t busy enough, Gideon at A Public Defender has chosen to throw down the gauntlet after picking up on the “secret to winning” post by Gerry Spence.


Gideon’s secret to winning: Knowing your rear from your face, or, preparation.

I mean, really, that’s your only shot. Know the State’s case inside out. Know the allegations, the witnesses, the police reports, the statute and your theory of defense. You have to prepare, prepare, prepare.

Having said that, Gid has sent the virus here, to Mark Bennett, the Texas Tornado and to Bobby Frederick.  Bobby was first to respond (and kick the meme to his three choices, Underdog John Katz, Hostis Civitas and Western Justice) with a laundry list of things to do.  While Bobby has a great list, he’s taken a bit much off the table for a meme, and we’ll remember that and pay him back some other time.

My response will be much simpler, and less satisfying.  There is no “secret”.  Lawyers want there to be a secret, something one can do that will spin the loser on its head and make it into a winner.  Lawyers want to win their cases.  Even bad lawyers want to win their cases.  And if there was a magic bullet to doing so, we would all be winners.  But we can’t all be winners.  The nature of a trial is that someone wins and someone loses, split verdicts aside. 

There are two independent factors to consider, the lawyer and the case.  Spence’s approach is to focus on the lawyer.  But I hear that under the covers, he’s a compulsive preparer, though this doesn’t show through from his descriptions.  This tends to make people think that the lawyer’s persona is all it takes to win.  But I suspect that even his most ardent supporter knows that it’s not just the lawyer’s “credibility”, but knowledge, preparation, technical skills and more that add up to the complete package.

Then there’s the case, made up of the law and the facts.  To neglect these aspects, no matter how much the jury loves the lawyer, is foolish.  Would the mystique work trying a basic buy and bust case?  Since it has never been tested as far as I’m aware, we don’t know.  But it’s hard to imagine that one could seriously believe that persona alone trumps facts and law.  If it were only that simple.

What strikes me as missing from these discussions is that every case is different.  While many appear the same on the surface, they never are in truth.  Even the most pedestrian case has a unique element to it, and it’s up to the lawyer to find it.  It may require the lawyer to adapt his persona to the case or defendant or judge or prosecutor or jury.  It may require the lawyer to find the wrinkle in the garden-variety crime that distinguishes it from the others.  There is no magic place to look to find this distinction, but it’s there.  Somewhere.  Just keep looking.

So while I have no “secret to winning” to offer, because this advice will not guarantee anyone the win, my small addition to this meme is to see each case, each defendant, as unique.  Approach it as if it’s the only case you’ve ever done, the only defendant you’ve ever represented, and figure out what makes it different from all the rest.

And now, I pass the baton to my three victims:  Mike Cernovich at Crime and Federalism, Jamie Spencer at Austin Criminal Defense Lawyer and David Tarrell at In the Moment.  Tag, you’re it.

Cocaine Residue Conundrum Goes International

As we are all painfully aware, when the drug dog alerts, the cops have probable cause.   Yes, yes, the dogs are imperfect, but the decisions abound and now it’s just another piece of quasi-junk science that has become part of the law enforcement myth.

But Fox News reports that American paper money has more cocaine residue on it than the cash of any other country.


Paper money contains high traces of cocaine, regardless of whether or not the paper money came into direct contact with the drug.  U.S. bills take the top spot, covered in the greatest amount of the illegal powder, while euro notes issued in Spain are the most highly contaminated in Europe, a new study finds.

“These findings should not be surprising, because cocaine and other drugs are traded using cash, which is handled by the same fingers that directly touch the drugs or wrappings,” chemists Sergio Armenta and Miguel de la Guardia from the University of Valencia in Spain write. “Moreover, many cocaine users use a wrapped banknote to sniff this drug, so inducing direct cocaine contamination of the banknotes.”

It’s not like you need to be a scientist to figure this out, though not a single DEA agent, as far as I’m aware, has yet to testify that cocaine residue on a $100 bill might possibly come from any source other than the defendant in the courtroom.  Go figure.

The kicker to this study is that U.S. bills are more contaminated than those of any other country.  Do we have more cokeheads than the others?  Apparently so, according to the research.  As noted by The Asylum, this means were not only the fattest country in the world, but the dopest as well.  We are number 1!  Woo hoo!  But there is an inherent anomaly:


So, if you’re scoring at home, fill in the U.S. for both the fattest and the most coked up nation on Earth. Given coke’s appetite-suppressing qualities, it sounds as though we’re just not getting enough cocaine to the right people.

There you are, the real drug problem in America is that the people who really need to lose weight aren’t getting enough coke.  Yes, I’m being facetious.

In the meantime, this reminds us of the meaninglessness of dog alerts, as well as the residue findings in the lab reports, that are used to craft a case against defendants when the cops come up empty on real evidence.

I’ve always wanted to do a courtroom demonstration, with the drug dog tested to sniff out the coked-up money.  Ask the judge to contribute whatever currency he’s got on him, as well as the jurors, and then have the dog do his thing.  My bet is that the dog will alert to at least half the tests packages. 

I’ve yet to find any judge foolish enough to let me try this out.  I don’t expect I ever will.



“J” Schools Fail to Keep Up (Update)

Kevin O’Keefe, who must be the busiest man in the blawgosphere since he hasn’t written a decent blawg post at Real Lawyers Have Blawgs in a long time, comes out with a great one.  He contends that universities need to start teaching online journalism. 


The irony is that newspapers and traditional media are laying off high paid senior people and would love to have students with a hungry work ethic skilled in the ways of new media. Instead of these kids getting journalism and media jobs where they’re needed, they’re underemployed serving tables and lattes while begging to get their foot in the door for an opportunity to learn the skills they need.

This is the ugly truth in journalism, that mainstream media is hemorrhaging money and laying off staff right and left.  While this presents a huge problem, the simple fact of it can’t be denied.  The consequence, at least for the time being, is that Journalism Schools are training budding reporters to work in a dead industry, an industry that isn’t going to hire them and will never be able to subsume these fine young men and women in their chosen craft.  Talk about a group defrauded.


The people who should feel guilty are the deans and directors of journalism schools at Universities who took hundreds of thousands of dollars in tuition moneys without telling students and their parents the school will be graduating your sons and daughters without the skills they need to get a job.

Academia historically lags behind the curve, despite its pretensions of being cutting edge.  That is the natural product of being cloistered in the Ivory Tower.  It’s also the by-product of too much time and effort invested in their particular course of study, and the refusal to recognize that change is happening.  Journalism schools are invested in old media.  It’s what they do and what they know.  No upstart like the internet is going to replace their beloved dead trees, right?


When I called the chair of Seattle University’s Communication/Journalism department as a reference and told him about what Rob [La Gatta] would be doing, he bragged that the school doesn’t teach students about things like blogs which are just things used by people ranting on the Internet. When I referenced some of the things LexBlog offered students, he seemed to dismiss them as some sort of ‘tech school skill.’

When I asked the same department chair about what student interns are paid, I was told I would never be able to compete with what newspapers like the Seattle Post Intelligencer paid the school’s journalism interns. Turns out the Seattle PI paid Rob nothing when he interned there before LexBlog and we paid Rob $10 per hour with an increase when he went full time for a quarter.

Dismissing Kevin O’Keefe is something one does at one’s peril.  Kevin is light years ahead of me when it comes to technology, and has pushed the edge of the internet at every turn.  Not that everything he’s done has come out perfect, but Kevin is undeniably one of the best at using the blawgosphere for its highest and best purpose. 

For the professor to demean the blogosphere by saying blogs are “just things used by people ranting” demonstrates how deeply he misapprehends the role it plays today.  A few years ago, there may have only been a handful of serious people presenting serious blogs about serious subjects.  Today, there are not only many, but the influence of the blawgosphere cannot be ignored.

I regularly receive calls from newspaper reporters seeking comment about a case discussed in one of my posts, as do many others in the blawgosphere.  Blawgs are cited in decisions and law review articles.  While blawgs have yet to displace mainstream media, and likely won’t (and shouldn’t), to pass us off as a bunch of lunatic ranters misses the point.  Blawgs are here, and carry some weight. 


And as far as I know, Rob was the only graduate of Seattle University’s Communication/Journalism program who had a job on graduation this summer. A job directly related to the journalism and communication profession.

And that’s the bottom line.  Like the Seattle University’s School of Blacksmithing, a change in demand for certain skills is going to happen no matter what some tweed-jacketed professor thinks.  Even with his dismissive attitude toward the internet, the impending layoffs at the New York Times should tell him something. 

Times are changing.  Journalism, critical to the existence of a viable democracy and an informed populace, needs to change too.  Pay attention to Kevin O’Keefe.  He knows what he’s talking about.

Update:  Interesting side note is a story in today’s New York Times Regional section about Suburban Bloggers.  Apparently, numerous journalists have started blogging on their own, recognizing the vitality of the blogosphere even if their J-profs don’t. 

Moreover, blogging has filled niches neglected by more traditional journalists, such as “hyperlocal” news:


Nearly a decade later, bloggers in the suburbs are starting to answer those questions. Many have let their sites go untended, but a few have built serious local journalism operations, while others have developed a following on certain topics and bask in the muted limelight of Internet fame. These survivors offer newly minted bloggers a pixilated blueprint for how to rise above the chaos of the blogosphere. For readers, the blogs are providing news in ways unseen in traditional local news media.

As has been the case in the criminal blawgosphere, many newcomers fall off the map when they realize what it takes to maintain a substantive blog, and this is necessary to prevent blogospheric overload.  But the few that hang tough and establish a following have an interesting future.

Comments as Lawyer Advertising? Don’t Bother (Update)

Trends develop quickly on the internet.  They die quickly too.  One of the latest that has hit Simple Justice fairly hard is the latest effort in advertising by desperate lawyers, who apparently pay someone else to post comments to a blawg (such as this) with a link to their website.

The name of the commenter is listed as “Miami Lawyer” and the link is to some Miami lawyer’s website.  One might think that the concept would be followed through with some further degree of thought, such as searching for posts that relate in some way to stories about Miami, so that people who read the comments to the story might have a better chance of being interested in Miami lawyers.  Not so.

In the course of a day, I get one individual posting a dozen comments to miscellaneous old posts without any apparent nexus to each other or the geographical or subject matter area of the lawyer.  Each will link back to this “Miami Lawyer’s” website.  But here’s the rub:  The comment is written in broken English and fails to demonstrate any knowledge of the content of the post.

Example: Greet to the webmaster for this wonderful site.Keep up good work.

This is the actual comment left yesterday.  To the Miami Lawyer who paid someone to leave this comment and link to his website, this word of advice.  It makes you look like a blithering idiot.  Is that what you are trying to accomplish?

Of course, this begs the question of how I know it’s spam rather than, well, a lawyer who is indeed a blithering idiot.  The latter can certainly be the case, and sometimes is, but not with this latest scheme.  The trick is that I have access to additional information about the commenter that doesn’t appear on the blawg.  All blawgers have access to this information on people who visit or comment.  And when the email address of the commenter isn’t “miamilawyer”, but “indiasolutions”, it’s kind of a dead giveaway.

While these comments invariably say nice things about the post or the blawg, thus making the blawger somewhat more inclined to leave the comments alone, they are pure unadulterated spam.  I delete them, even if they say that I’m tall, thin and good looking (also a dead giveaway that it’s spam).

So as a public service to anyone foolish enough to pay good money to some advertising “solutions” company that outsources its work to people who will make you look far more pathetic than you are, let me say this.  Don’t do it.

You are wasting your money.  You are not going to get any cases from comments that make you look stupid.  You are going to have your comments deleted, and then I’m going to ban you from here.

If you want to actually read a post (you do read, don’t you?), and want to leave a real comment (in English) with a link to your website, go for it.  I’ve got some of these types here and I let them slide, even though I believe that it’s just to put their links all over Simple Justice to try to freeride a bit. 

But don’t bother with the spam.  It’s not going to happen.

Update:  Regular readers here may recall a commenter who goes by the handles “Joe” and “JT”.  He commented regularly, though his comments were marginally substantive.  His comments were linked to one of two lawyer websites in California.  While his comments rarely added anything, and were largely pro forma restatements of the obvious, they showed some very minimal connection to the posts and I figured that perhaps this was the best Joe could muster.  Hey, dumb people are allowed to have opinions too.

But after posting this post, I realized that it was hypocritical of me to allow Joe/JT to continue to post comments for the sole purpose of making some pocket change by linking his customers websites here.  So even if Joe did read the posts, it was wrong to let Joe get away with it and refuse the same courtesy to others.  So, as of now, Joe is gone, his customers’ links are gone, and all comments by Joe/JT have been deleted.

There is, however, one thing to consider.  Some of you have added comments following Joe’s saying, “Joe is right,” and “I agree with Joe.”  Joe’s comments, at their very best, were a statement of the obvious, reflecting no deeper thought than it took to write a line or two.  Those of you who agreed with Joe may want to consider what’s going through your own heads.