Like most of you, I have been waiting to learn the secret of winning from the Master. I want to win every case I try. What lawyer doesn’t? Since there is only one man in the entire United States who has never lost a criminal case, most of us have waited patiently for him to reveal his secret to the rest of us. Finally, he has done so.
I have been criticized for being “too superficial.” I suppose that means that my own intelligence quotient is dragging behind or at least isn’t on display. But remember, we can think our way to any decision. The reasoning of the U.S. Supreme Court is a good example. The court’s numerous five to four decisions tells us that about half the court have thought themselves into the wrong decision and do so continuously. We can think ourselves into oblivion. Science is already knocking on that door with its invention of nuclear weapons and the manufacture and use of devices that will surely destroy this fragile, pretty little planet.
Don’t think? I didn’t see that coming.
I have said that it is as if the juror is about to embark on a journey through this forest and he or she has to decide which lawyer, as a guide, to follow. That’s why the only thing a trial lawyer has to sell to jurors is credibility. Without it, the most skilled, the most charismatic, the most comely, the best dressed, the highest paid, the lawyer with the highest IQ, the lawyer from the largest firm, even the one the judge seems to favor cannot win without credibility. It is also why the lawyer who may be frightened, inept, less skilled, not so eloquent, even second rate and sometimes befuddled will win every time if he or she is a credible person.
Have credibility? Sounds good. Nobody wants to be the incredible person. So be credible and don’t think.
If the lawyer does not trust the jurors, the jurors will not trust the lawyer. If the lawyer does not like the jurors, the jurors will respond in kind. If the lawyer keeps secret his or her feelings the jurors will secret their own. If the lawyer hides behind big words and tricky tactics the jurors will turn away from him. How hard is this to understand? I keep insisting that our role models should be our children. I have often said I have learned more from my kids and my dogs than from all of the super minds out there.
I’m not clear about the dog part, but I’m beginning to get it. Trust the jurors, be credible and don’t think.
Is that it? Apparently so. You can’t make this stuff up.
All that time and effort wasted on investigation, research, facts and law. But I’m still not clear what to do about the videotape of the defendant selling heroin to the cops.
