Author Archives: SHG

The Secret to Winning, Finally Revealed!

Like most of you, I have been waiting to learn the secret of winning from the Master.  I want to win every case I try.  What lawyer doesn’t?  Since there is only one man in the entire United States who has never lost a criminal case, most of us have waited patiently for him to reveal his secret to the rest of us.  Finally, he has done so.


I have been criticized for being “too superficial.”  I suppose that means that my own intelligence quotient is dragging behind or at least isn’t on display. But remember, we can think our way to any decision.  The reasoning of the U.S. Supreme Court is a good example. The court’s numerous five to four decisions tells us that about half the court have thought themselves into the wrong decision and do so continuously. We can think ourselves into oblivion. Science is already knocking on that door with its invention of nuclear weapons and the manufacture and use of devices that will surely destroy this fragile, pretty little planet.

Don’t think?  I didn’t see that coming.

I have said that it is as if the juror is about to embark on a journey through this forest and he or she has to decide which lawyer, as a guide, to follow.  That’s why the only thing a trial lawyer has to sell to jurors is credibility.  Without it, the most skilled, the most charismatic, the most comely, the best dressed, the highest paid, the lawyer with the highest IQ, the lawyer from the largest firm, even the one the judge seems to favor cannot win without credibility.  It is also why the lawyer who may be frightened, inept, less skilled, not so eloquent, even second rate and sometimes befuddled will win every time if he or she is a credible person.

Have credibility?  Sounds good.  Nobody wants to be the incredible person.  So be credible and don’t think.


If the lawyer does not trust the jurors, the jurors will not trust the lawyer.  If the lawyer does not like the jurors, the jurors will respond in kind.  If the lawyer keeps secret his or her feelings the jurors will secret their own.  If the lawyer hides behind big words and tricky tactics the jurors will turn away from him.  How hard is this to understand?  I keep insisting that our role models should be our children.  I have often said I have learned more from my kids and my dogs than from all of the super minds out there.

I’m not clear about the dog part, but I’m beginning to get it.  Trust the jurors, be credible and don’t think.

Is that it?  Apparently so.  You can’t make this stuff up.

All that time and effort wasted on investigation, research, facts and law.  But I’m still not clear what to do about the videotape of the defendant selling heroin to the cops.

The Price of Texas Bravado (Update)

As most people know, the Sovereign Nation of Texas executed Jose Medellin.  What a tough, macho group they are, beloved of football, cheerleaders and killing people.  When even their favorite son, George W. Bush asked them not to do it, they still killed Medellin.  It must have been very important for them to ignore Bush. 

Scott Henson at Grits for Breakfast wrote a very thoughtful and moving postscript to the execution of Medellin.


I hope Medellin’s death will bring the victims’ family closure – whatever that means. But since his execution cannot bring back their lost loved ones, I doubt seriously those painful memories are “closed” for the victims’ family and friends any more this morning than at this time yesterday.

The legal debate over Medellin may end here for now, waiting to be renewed the first time some American is held incommunicado overseas and our government complains their Vienna rights were violated.

You can almost hear future officials from some corrupt government telling the United States “I’m sorry Mr. Ambassador … local authorities made the decision to violate your citizens’ rights, so even though we have a treaty saying she could speak to the consulate, they didn’t tell her she could do so and we have to abide by their decision. Our hands are tied.”

How extraordinary that all the fine people involved in the Texas decision to put one man to death ignored the implications for so many other Americans.  As Scott notes, we can only hope that this act is not ultimately proven worthless as well as foolish, and we hope that the victim’s family wakes up this morning feeling better.  Experience is otherwise, but each family is different and perhaps this one will find closure.

But the sad reality is that the United States has once again sent a curious message to the rest of the world, from petty dictators to emerging democracies, that only our rules count, not theirs.  Nothing binds the United States to the rest of the world, and we need not adhere to the same set of rules that we demand others apply.  It’s an unfair game, and America must always win.

After the Medellin execution, I received a comment to an earlier post on the case.


The president cannot make law: nor can he enter into an agreement with other countries that trumps the law enacted by voters in California or Texas. To put it in a way you might appreciate, Bush cannot enter into an anti-abortion treaty and then insist it trumps Roe. get it?

Oh..and the big “danger to US citizens abroad.” I am not going to let some politically unaccountable “world court” decide how people are tried here. I am sure our citizens get fair treatment in mos places. If you decide to travel to those thatd on’t, don’t do crimes.

Aside from all that, there is no suggestion that he was innocent or that intervention would have changed a thing. Typical law professor bs.

My guess is that this comment is a fair example of the thought processes of those Texans supporting the Medellin execution.  While it wallows in ignorance from the outset, that’s not the biggest problem.  People are allowed to be ignorant.  It’s the American way, even when applied to the Sovereign Nation of Texas.

It’s the second paragraph that embodies the most dangerous flaw.  The abject jingoistic myopia is stunning.  My reaction to this comment was, as Joel Rosenberg J-dog likes to call me, “prickly”.  There is no explaining to someone so fundamentally ignorant why it’s not all about him and whatever feels good to him at any given moment.  This mindset has its advantages, of course, because ignorance knows no constraint by facts or consistency of reasoning. 

When some American is nabbed in the country of Absurdia, he will be the first to scream that we should invade it and protect our American citizen from some tin-horn despot.  How dare some petty government challenge the great and powerful US of A.  We can just send in a few bombers and blow them to smithereens.  Problem solved.

Perhaps this is “typical law professor bs,” even though I’m no lawprof.  Perhaps rational thinking, foresight and a naive hope for international relations built on reason, fairness and consistency is just some Ivory Tower notion.  But the alternative is the world this commenter urges, one where might makes right and the United States can do whatever it pleases.  As long as we remain the toughest hombre on the planet, we don’t need to suffer the limits of reason. 

For the sake of the next American to be seized in some foreign country, I hope that the people of other countries don’t think like this fellow.  But I feel confident that this fellow won’t lose any sleep worrying about the problem.

Update:  The Blind Guy has pointed out that this may all fall on the shoulders of Salmon P. Chase, a former Treasury Secretary under Lincoln during the Civil War, for having wrongly decided Texas v. White in 1869.  After all, if Lysander Spooner rejected the Court’s reasoning, who are we to disagree?

Not the Way to Influence a Federal Prosecutor

From Fox News via Walter Olson at Overlawyered, former Alaska Senator and Democratic presidential candidate Mike Gravel explained to a crowd in Washington, D.C. the way to “persuade” an Assistant United States Attorney, Gordon Kromberg, from the Eastern District of Virginia, to drop a case:


In the tape, Gravel can be heard telling people to pressure Gordon Kromberg, an assistant U.S. attorney in the eastern district of Virginia, to drop the charges against Sami Al-Arian.

“Find out where he lives, find out where his kids go to school, find out where his office is, picket him all the time,” Gravel said, in an audio tape obtained by the Investigative Project on Terrorism and provided to FOX News.

“Call him a racist in signs if you see him. Call him an injustice. Call him whatever you want to call him, but in his face all the time.”

No.  Do not do this.  Under no circumstances should you do this.  No matter how strongly you disagree with the way in which he is performing his duty do you go to his children’s school.  What is Gravel thinking?

The underlying case is one with which I’m unfamiliar, but perhaps one that has and should raise deep concerns.


Al-Arian is a former Florida professor who in 2006 pleaded guilty to providing goods and services to the Palestinian Islamic Jihad. Prosecutors had tried him on more serious charges, but that ended in a hung jury, so Al-Arian took a plea.

He later was charged with contempt for refusing to testify before a grand jury in Virginia.

That’s as far as the Fox article goes, and I’m not inclined to research it further because this post isn’t about whether Al-Arian’s prosecution is proper or not.  It’s about how one deals with perceived improper prosecutions, regardless of which case is involved.

Whether it’s prosecutor, cop, defense lawyer or judge, their involvement is not a personal issue but part of their professional responsibility.  Feel free to question, challenge and criticize their professional performance, but distinguish their personal lives, and the lives of their family, from the performance of their duty. 

Apparently, Gravel realized the error of his ways, and later tried to back track.

Gravel told FOX News that he doesn’t want people to break the law and that he personally wouldn’t do the things he’s recommended — but that it could be an effective way to change the behavior of U.S. officials.

“How do you deal with this kind of an injustice? I wouldn’t protest. I don’t believe in protesting. I think it demonstrates the failure of representative government. My answer to that problem is, I want to empower you as a lawmaker. … Don’t rely on your elected officials,” the former senator said.

Many will agree that we are suffering “a failure ot representative government” these days.  The more you know about the representatives, the more you wonder who the lame-brain was that came up with the idea.  But the failure of the Executive branch and its functionaries to exercise a level of discretion expected of them is not an excuse to start stalking people’s children.  That’s just sick.

There are many “effective” ways to change behavior that are grossly improper.  There are proper ways that are ineffective.  There are people in our government who do not perform their functions the way we would prefer, though we should bear in mind that other people will applaud the way they perform their jobs and are just thrilled by overbearing law enforcement when directed against people they perceive as enemies of the state. 

Regardless, Gravel’s resort to political vigilantism was outrageous and wrong.  Fight the good fight, if that’s what you’re up for, but this is not the way to do it.

A Silly Millisecond Longer

On occasion, I may have mentioned that judges deal rather poorly with the adaptation of law to new technology.  So it should come as no surprise that it’s happened yet again.

From the Washington Post,


In August 2007, Judge Florence-Marie Cooper, in the Central District of California, ruled that the alleged hacker, Rob Anderson, had not intercepted the e-mails in violation of the 1968 Wiretap Act because they were technically in storage, if only for a few instants, instead of in transmission.

 The implication of this decision is staggering.


The issue boils down to the judicial definition of an intercept in the electronic age, in which packets of data move from server to server, alighting for milliseconds before speeding onward.

“Anderson’s actions did not halt the transmission of the messages to their intended recipients. As such, under well-settled case law, as well as a reading of the statute and the ordinary meaning of the word ‘intercept,’ Anderson’s acquisitions of the e-mails did not violate the Wiretap Act.”

Ah, the Wiretap Act.  What Judge Cooper held is that the interception of emails, when there is a millisecond interceding, is not wiretapping.  What it is, she doesn’t say.  But what “it isn’t” is of huge concern.  Am I overstating the issue?


“It could really gut the wiretapping laws,” said Orin S. Kerr, a George Washington University law professor and expert on surveillance law. “The government could go to your Internet service provider and say, ‘Copy all of your e-mail, but make the copy a millisecond after the email arrives,’ and it would not be a wiretap.”

Now while I may be slightly inclined toward the civil rights end of the law enforcement spectrum, you can’t make that claim against Volokh Conspirator Orin S. Kerr (the “S” stands for “Stand-up”).  If anything, he’s “a little bit country” to my “little bit rock and roll.”  And if Orin says it could “gut the wiretapping laws,” we have good reason to worry.

So, once again we have a court making a decision on whether the ability of technology, in this instance server to server with transitory storage, should renders every email susceptible to interception without a warrant.  An appeal of this decision has been filed in 9th Circuit, where we know at least one judge with a little (maybe too little) computer savvy. 

The ramifications of affirmance are clear, but the question of whether the Circuit will be prepared to try something different, to try not to ram that square peg into that round hole, is another matter.  Bottom line is that old law can’t keep pace with new technology, and we are feeling the impact case by case of law that at one time made sense (usually), but no longer satisfies the rationale in the face of the constantly changing face of modern technology. 

Uh oh.

“War for Oil” Comes Back to Bite Us

From Turley, CNN reports that Iraq is sitting on an $80 billion dollar oil surplus while we keep paying for its reconstruction.  How wonderful to be a superpower, so fabulously wealthy that we can indulge our fantasies around the world.


Leading members of Congress, noting that Washington is paying for reconstruction in Iraq, expressed outrage at the assessment. One called the findings “inexcusable.”

Baghdad had a $29 billion budget surplus between 2005 to 2007. With the price of crude roughly doubling in the past year, Iraq’s surplus for 2008 is expected to run between $38 billion and $50 billion, according to a report from the U.S. Government Accountability Office.

The United States has put about $48 billion toward reconstruction since the 2003 invasion of Iraq, auditors reported. About $23 billion of that was spent on the oil and electricity industries, water systems and security.


Raise your hand if you feel that we are doing so spectacularly well that we have money to burn.  Everyone with their hand raised need read no further. 

The Iraqi government is of the view that the oil surplus is theirs, and the job of reconstructing a country we invaded and forces into turmoil is ours.  While the United States may be in a position to disagree and force the issue, we haven’t as yet.  This begs the question of why we are using our tax dollars to rebuild Iraq when they have their petro dollars available to do so.


The issue raised the hackles of several members of Congress earlier this year — particularly because Bush administration officials said on the eve of the war that Iraqi oil money would pay for reconstruction.

In 2003, then-Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz told the House Appropriations Committee: “We’re dealing with a country that can really finance its own reconstruction, and relatively soon.”



When Paul Wolfowitz spoke, people assumed the worst.  This proved that the invasion of Iraq was just a cynical excuse to steal their oil; this was war for oil, the mob cried.  Now, in the waning days of the Bush Administration, with all the players except the big guy himself gone from the scene, fear permeates the air.  George W. Bush does not want to leave office proving that the mob was right, that his legacy was war for oil.  They wouldn’t touch that oil money with a ten foot pole. 


Rep. Henry Waxman, D-California, said Tuesday’s report “is going to make a lot of American families very angry.”

“The record gas prices they are paying have turned into an economic windfall for Iraq, but the Iraqi government isn’t spending the money on rebuilding,” said Waxman, the chairman of the House Oversight and Government Reform Committee.

But if the Democrats demand it, force the issue, bring it to the table, that’s different.  We can’t blame that one on Bush.  We can’t claim that it’s part of the Wolfowitz scheme of world domination.  And the Democrats need only point to the cost of gas at the pump to prove how unfair this is.

The notion that the invasion of Iraq was all about oil never appealed to me.  It was the cabal of Wolfowitz, that the United States take its rightful place of making the rest of the world our playground, asserting our superiority without shame or fear, that drove our philosophy.  Others will disagree. 

It never struck me as disingenuous in the least to use Iraqi oil money to rebuild that country, assuming that the Iraqis weren’t terribly unhappy with us for turning their world upside down without permission.  Even so, their money would be used there, for their benefit to the extent it was sucked up by favored American contractors and diverted to the Sovereign Nation of Texas. 

It similarly did not disturb me that my tax dollars were not shipped to Iraq.  I had no say in the decision, and didn’t feel any particular obligation to pay for it.  Those who provided their vociferous support to our President, the people who put “freedom isn’t free” bumper stickers on their car, should be required to pay for it, on the other hand.  They should pay the price for their beliefs, and leave me out of it.

But we are now at a different stage in time, where all the excuses, explanations and arguments, both for and against, have become so muddled that most Americans neither remember nor care how we got into this mess and just want to get out.  Perhaps the time has come to draw a line, apologize for all the stupidity that happened before and announce that we need to act in our own self-interest despite our foolish and self-serving ways.

We were wrong to get in.  Even the people who voted for President Bush are largely of that view now.  And we don’t know how to get out.  But one thing has become clear to Americans:  We can’t afford to play this game anymore.  If we don’t stop pretending that we are so powerful and fabulously wealthy that this doesn’t matter, we will end up asking Iraq for a loan to cover our savings bonds.

The only way to rationally address this is to admit that we made a mistake and that we are now compelled to rectify it by telling Iraq that we are done shipping money over there.  The well is dry.  I would like to take this a step farther, and reimburse ourselves for the expenses paid to date.

This is not a principled position.  We are far too late for that.  This is a position taken by a desperate nation that has compounded its mistakes over the past 8 years to take a wealthy and strong nation and turn it into a third world wannabe.  But it doesn’t bother me, because I never agreed to go along with the program in the first place, and I feel no reason to suffer the consequences now.  I never screamed that this was war for oil, and couldn’t care less about President Bush’s legacy.

Let the Bush supporters pay.  Let Iraq pay.  Let the “war for oil” crowd pay.  But I don’t want to pay.  This is not what I signed on for.

Conflict of Laws: California versus United States

Via Windypundit, the Los Angeles Times reports that Charles Lynch was convicted of distributing more than 100 kilos of marijuana.  He did so, and never claimed otherwise.  Stop here, and it would appear that justice was done. 

But Charles Lynch ran the Morro Bay medical marijuana dispensary, called Central Coast Compassionate Caregivers, in California.  He sold marijuana to people with cancer, who had medical authorization to use marijuana to relieve their pain and suffering.  He sold it to children with cancer.

Charles Lynch had the support of local elected officials.  He violated no California law.  But the United States of America has its own set of laws, and they have come to include purely local acts through application of the commerce clause stretched and contorted to cover every breath taken by every citizen no matter where it occurs.  With the overwhelming support of the public, the federal government has achieved hegemony over criminal law.

For reasons that only a cynic could admire, marijuana has been classified as a drug lacking any legitimate medical benefit.  It is, and will remain, a nefarious drug under federal law, and selling it to anyone, no less minors, is a crime.  So the clash of cultures was clearly fixed.  The good people of California decided that marijuana served a legitimate medical need for cancer patients, and the good people of the United States decided otherwise.



Cultivating, using and selling doctor-prescribed medical marijuana are allowed in some instances under California law. But they are outlawed entirely under federal law, which supersedes those of the states.

Lynch’s lawyers told jurors that their client had the blessing of elected officials in Morro Bay before opening his Central Coast Compassionate Caregivers, and they argued that he was he was told by a U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration official that he would avoid prosecution as long as he obeyed local laws.


But jurors rejected that argument.

Kitty Meese, the jury forewoman, said the panel concluded it would have made no sense for a DEA official to give such advice.


I have no doubt that Kitty Meese (relation to Ed?) reached her conclusion in good faith.  No self-respecting DEA official (whatever that means) would admit in court that he told someone he would be left alone even though he would be committing a crime.  That could cost him a pension, and no government employee would risk a pension.  Not for anything.

But her assumption is flawed.  The DEA turns a blind eye every day to crime for a variety of reasons, foremost of which is that they criminal provides them with some degree of information which entitles the criminal to commit crimes with impunity, and sometimes even with complicity, of the DEA.  Crime may be shocking to the general public, but it’s routine to the DEA.

That a DEA official gave Charles Lynch “the wink” comes as no surprise.  That the rest of the federal government decided to make Charles Lynch the whipping boy for his efforts comes as no surprise either.  Somebody had to take the fall to make sure that the good people of California understood that the federal government was bigger and stronger than the land of Schwarzenegger, home of starlets and the liberal elite.  The good people of Idaho do not agree with the good people of California, and they expect their federal government to put the left coasties in their place to save the Union from Godlessness.

Charles Lynch no doubt understood that he was taking a huge chance.  He tried everything he could to avoid the risk, but couldn’t be terribly surprised when “the wink” didn’t protect him, and the DEA official denied the wink was ever given.  Anyone who believes a government official’s wink is foolish. 

Rarely do we have a decent test of federalism in this country anymore.  People have come to view the federal government as the one that ultimately controls everything.  History reminds us that it was supposed to be a government of limited power, with only that handful of authority that the states allowed it.  The balance of authority resided with the states, where local government could decide for itself how to address issues within its jurisdiction. 

This nuanced vision of how power is balanced between the states and the federal government is an historic relic.  While some historians and lawprofs may recognize it, the People do not.  The People makes demands on Congress to cure their ailments, and Congress is only too happy to respond.  It gives them a way to return to their districts and prove what a great job they’re doing.

Hopefully, Lynch’s conviction will go before the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals, where many very smart lawyers (and perhaps even some lawprofs) will assert that the federal government has no business interfering in affairs that only involve the State of California.  Hopefully, they will argue forcefully that the rhetorical games that have stretched the commerce clause to reach Morro Bay have gone too far. 

We live in a flat world.  The country is flat as well, and the distinctions that our forefathers struggled with over the scope of federal authority have been wasted in a country where one government can approve of the use of medical marijuana while another government can imprison someone for relying on that approval. 

It’s time for the People to be reminded that the federal government was never meant to be omnipotent.  It’s time that the federal government got its hand smacked for reaching into California’s affairs.  This could be the opportunity to teach America a history lesson.  Americans are very bad at history and need constant reminders.

I hope Charles Lynch remains at liberty while this argument is being made, and I hope that those cancer patients don’t suffer too much while federal government officials flex their muscles to prove that they are in complete control.

Breaking News: John Gotti Arrested. Again.

This just came across the wire :



Source: Gotti arrested on murder conspiracy charge


NEW YORK (AP) — A law enforcement official says John A. “Junior” Gotti has been arrested on a murder conspiracy charge.


The official says the charge stemmed from a federal investigation originating in Tampa, Fla. The official spoke on condition of anonymity because the charge had not been officially announced.


Gotti has had three criminal trials end in mistrial. He is expected to make an appearance in federal court in Manhattan on Tuesday for a removal hearing.


A call to his attorney seeking comment was not immediately returned.


While “going after Gotti” has the makings of a terrific reality show for one of the lesser cable networks, this has got to stop.   First, John Gotti isn’t called “Junior” by anyone except the media.  Is it impossible for them to not attribute some sort of nickname to anyone who is connected, whether in reality, fiction or by birth, to the mob?

Second, if some government official is going to make an announcement of yet another law enforcement “coup”, can they at least have the guts to give their name?  And if not, then why are they talking to the media at all?

Third, the arrest came down sometime in the wee hours of the morning, as arrests such as this always do.  Did they think that John Gotti’s lawyer sleeps in his office just in case somebody from the AP calls?  Did they think the feds called the lawyer up in advance to give him the heads up that Gotti would be arrested?  Chances are, the lawyer had no idea that his client was arrested, and certainly no clue what he would have been arrested for.  What possible comment could he offer?  “Duh, beats me.”

And finally, there has to come some point in time when the son of John Gotti gets left alone.  I know, they can’t stand the fact that they have been incapable of convicting the guy, and there will always be some prosecutor somewhere who wants to become a legend by putting a Gotti in prison.  But it smells like persecution already. 

When does it end?

Don’t Ignore the Sentencing Floor

In Doug Berman’s vacation absence, a gang from Proskauer Rose has taken the reins at Sentencing Law & Policy.  While they haven’t exactly filled Doug’s shoes for the most part, a “practice tip” from former New Jersey AUSA, now Proskauer partner,  Matthew Queler is quite good and certainly something that every defense lawyer involved in multi-defendant cases should be aware of.


Intra-case proportionality is, like gravity, an unseen force that will have an important impact on where your client comes to rest.Most judges employ their own personal rough sense of justice – consciously or not.As important as downward departures and § 3553 are, there is one almost immutable reality:the ringleader is not going to get less time than the mid-level supervisor, who is not going to get less time than the mope.(The one arguable exception is where criminal history categories are materially different.)If you represent the ringleader, once the less culpable defendants are sentenced, you are at the mercy of the job the other defendants’ attorneys did.

The concept of intra-case proportionality is critical to sentencing, as one of the strongest arguments available to both sides is where a defendant fits within the structure of the criminal enterprise.  This applies with equal force, perhaps even greater force, in general criminal cases as well as white collar, even though many lawyers don’t think of a drug gang as an enterprise in the sense of a corporation.  But indeed, establishing where your defendant fits within the scheme of the group will prove to be one of the most significant factors in the sentence imposed.

In order to maximize the benefit (and of course, minimize the detriment) of being hurt, it behooves counsel in multi-defendant cases to work together so that sentencing occurs in a rational rather than random fashion.  Queler presents a hypothetical where you represent the company President, who is to be sentenced after the company accountant:


The accountant doesn’t have a lot of money, and is represented by a mediocre defense attorney, who walks his client into sentencing without preparing a sentencing submission, and does a ho-hum job extolling his client’s virtues.His client gets 16 months.Now, it’s your turn.Even though you put together the most compelling sentencing submission of all time, and the Judge’s law clerk actually cries while reading it, guess what?It won’t matter.Your client is going to do more than 16 months.Probably substantially more.After all, and as the Judge will probably ask you:How can your client get less time than the accountant when your client was the mastermind and ringleader?

That’s how the sentencing floor is established.  When the little guy goes first, his sentence mandates that your client, whose conduct is by definition more culpable because of his position in the enterprise, must receive a more severe sentence.  As Queler notes, it doesn’t matter if you’re the best lawyer on the face of the earth.  The floor has been established and you are now stuck with it.

The solution, which is always worthy of the effort even though it can’t always be accomplished, is to work together to have the top defendants sentenced first, and subsequent defendants sentenced in descending order of culpability and position within the enterprise.


The key is to try to work with the Judge’s Deputy and the other defense attorneys – even if some of the defendants have cooperated against the others – to arrange it so that the co-defendants are sentenced in order from most culpable to least, assuming of course you can all agree on what that order is.That way, everyone can build off the others’ efforts and each sentence lowers the ceiling for the next co-defendant, but no one’s sentence creates a floor.

While Queler’s tip is directed toward federal practice, and he uses white collar for his examples, the concept is applicable to every multi-defendant case regardless of court or crime.  The principle of avoiding the “sentencing floor” is one that every criminal defense lawyer needs to consider.

Maybe these Proskauer lawyers aren’t so bad after all?  Or maybe they just have too much experience with sentencing?  Naw, that’s not nice.  Kudos to Matthew Queler for posting about this great tip.

Teaching “Justice,” Prosecutor-Style

Mike at Crime & Federalism has posted a video that was the subject of an appeal before the Pennsylvania Supreme Court in Commonwealth v. Cook, per this law.com story.  At issue was whether Assistant District Attorney Jack McMahon struck black jurors from the panel in this 1988 death penalty case based upon prejudice.  Would Jack do that?

The four-member majority in Commonwealth v. Cook, including Chief Justice Ronald D. Castille and Justices J. Michael Eakin, Seamus P. McCaffery and Debra Todd, found in its July 24 opinion that Philadelphia Common Pleas Judge Carolyn E. Temin correctly determined that defendant Robin Cook didn’t meet his burden to prove that Assistant District Attorney Jack McMahon had exercised his peremptory challenges during Cook’s 1988 trial in a discriminatory manner.

“Appellant was required to establish a prima facie case of purposeful discrimination in certain peremptory challenges made by the Commonwealth before the Commonwealth was required to provide race-neutral reasons for those challenges,” Castille wrote for the majority.

While this wouldn’t be a particularly unusual issue normally, there was one interesting bit of evidence impugning McMahon’s motives, an old, graining videotape of McMahon training young prosecutors in the art of selecting a jury.  Apparently, this video was made public when McMahon ran for Philadelphia District Attorney in 1997.  Bet he didn’t see that coming.

Saylor quoted an excerpt of the training videotape in which McMahon said: “‘If you go in there and any one of you think you’re going to be some noble civil libertarian and try to get jurors, ‘Well, he says he can be fair; I’ll go with him,’ that’s ridiculous. You’ll lose and you’ll be out of the office; you’ll be doing corporate law. Because that’s what will happen. You’re there to win.'”

This quote was hardly the worst in the video, in my opinion.  Whether the Supreme Court’s decision was right or wrong is one issue, and of course the video, while providing fascinating insight into McMahon’s view of jurors and blacks, doesn’t prove that he violated Batson during Cook’s murder trial.  But for those of you who wonder why W.C. Fields preferred death to Philadelphia, watch this video.

And for those of you who want to believe that all prosecutors feel a deep desire to fulfill their ethical and legal obligations to seek justice rather than just get a conviction, this is a wake-up call.

This is not to say that McMahon reflects the attitude and approach of all prosecutors.  But then, it’s not to say that he’s a lone wolf either.

Mimi Coffey Asks: What About My Kids!

When the phone rings after office hours, it’s usually a person in distress.  This call was no different.  A woman doing her best Nancy Grace imitation started talking after I said “hello” and just kept going until she needed to take a breath.  Man, could she hold her breath.

She started out telling me she was Mimi Coffey and that I knew who she was.  I didn’t.  As my mind raced trying unsuccessfully to figure out who Mimi Coffey could be, I listened as she told me that I probably didn’t realize this, but children read my blawg, and those children turned out to be hers.  She was calling because she was “from Texas, and us Texans talk straight,” she informed me.  Them Texans also sound like Nancy Grace to this Yankee, which made it awfully hard not to laugh.

When she finally took a breath, 17 minutes later, I had the picture.  The caller was Tarrant County, Texas lawyer, Mimi Coffey, who was the subject of a post of last February.  She was honored for her efforts on Fox News channel opining on the subject of the McCartney/Mills divorce, calling Heather Mills a “gold digger,” despite the fact that she was a DUI lawyer who lacked any expertise in matrimonial law.  But that never stopped a lawyer when there’s a TV camera around.

My post was the by-product of a post by fellow Tarrant County lawyer Shawn Matlock.  While informing me that they must like what she has to say on Fox because they keep asking her back, her purpose was to tell me that one line in the original post made her angry because her kids read it and didn’t I realize that children read this blawg?

Shawn Matlock (formerly Young Shawn) wasn’t on slut patrol when he plopped his butt down to watch TV.  Sometimes, it just happens that way.
Slut patrol. 

Mimi Coffey took no issue with my having pointed out her willingness to take to the airwaves on a topic in which she possessed no qualifications and called Heather Mills a “gold digger,” but I called her a “slut” and now, she asserted, her children think she is sexually promiscuous.  Let me be painfully clear about this: I have no idea whether Mimi Coffey is sexually promiscuous or not.  But let me be similarly painfully clear that she is promiscuous when it comes to the media.  Apparently, the word “slut” in Tarrant County has only one connotation, a reflection perhaps of undue emphasis on sexual repression? 

This raised some interesting issues in my mind.  If she’s so concerned about what her children see on the internet, why are they cruising the web without parental supervision?  Could it be that Coffey should spend more time at home and less time waiting outside the door of the Fox News studios, in case they need someone to appear on air on the subject of, oh, geriatric law.  After all, octogenarian porn is all the rage in Tarrant County from what I hear.

Then Coffey informed me that she could sue me for “slander” for calling her a “slut” (I know it’s libel when written, but she said slander and I must be accurate in recounting the call).  I strongly urged her to do so if she felt she was harmed.  She immediately switched gear, apparently recognizing that yet again opined on a subject about which she was clueless.

Her point was that I should censor Simple Justice because “children read your blawg” and they should not have to read words like “slut” associated with her.  Didn’t I have children too, she asked?  Yes, Mimi, I have children too.  And I would have used this opportunity to teach my children that a person who was desirous of going on TV to present themselves to others as an expert when in fact they were not is a media slut, not a sexual slut.  I try to never pass up a learning opportunity.  It’s just the type of guy I am.

I have no plans, however, to censor this blawg to compensate for another person’s failure to teach their children properly.  Next time, you explain to your children that the word “slut” can refer to different forms of promiscuity, and sexual isn’t the only one.  Next time, keep your eye on your kids when they are online googling your name to see what a star their mommy has become.  Next time, limit your television appearances to a subject you know something about, and then you won’t find yourself the target of a blawg post somewhere.  But then, you like the limelight a little too much for that, don’t you?  And for God’s sake, stop sounding like Nancy Grace when you talk.  It’s just wrong.

But I’m not heartless.  Since Mimi thought it better to call me to whine about the language in my post, it seemed like the least I could do to help Mimi Coffey out was to fill in the neglected parental role and remove the taint of sexual promiscuity that so offended her.  Always happy to be of help, Mimi.  No need to thank me.