Author Archives: SHG

Defendants Exposed in Courthouse Confessions

Via the New York Times, courtesy of Judicial Reports, a mesmerizing new blog called Courthouse Confessions.

So for the last few months Steven Hirsch, a freelance newspaper photographer, has been photographing and interviewing some of the unheralded defendants who pass through the court system and posting the results on a Web page, Courthouse Confessions.

Mr. Hirsch transcribes recorded interviews, deleting his own questions, so that his subjects’ words are presented to readers in an uninterrupted flow. They talk about what sent them to court and ruminate on the legal systems or their own lives. Many of the interviews have an intimate and confessional tone, as people describe the transgressions they are accused of.

Reading the words (sans Hirsch’s question), I can tell you that this is the real McCoy.  This is what they sound like.  This is how they think.  This is what they tell their lawyer.

What’s fascinating about this is not only what is included, but what is not.  As the Times story notes, some leave out the “unsavory” details that turn them from self-perceived victim of the system to something else, whether liar, animal, schemer or just plain stupid.

These “courthouse confessions” were taken at 100 Centre Street, the primary criminal courthouse in Manhattan.  It’s one of the busiest, ugliest, dirtiest, nastiest places you will ever see, but also one of the most fascinating.  The breadth of humanity walk through its doors, from the wealthiest to the poorest, the celebrity to the unknown. 

The fact that Hirsch got these people to talk to him, and to talk so openly, shows a remarkable need for catharsis, for validation, of humankind.  This need to talk, of course, is the same need that cops capitalize on daily when getting their statements and confessions.  But Hirsch’s photographs and stories are shockingly close to actually being there, seeing it and hearing it as it happens. 

This is a spectacular photo essay.  No doubt many will read the words and be totally unable to comprehend the world in which these defendants live.  But this is definitely life at 100 Centre Street.

The Second Wave of Mortgage Fraud

It was almost exactly one year ago that I posted about the burgeoning criminal defense work stemming from the mortgage fallout.  Last summer, it became clear that the feds were all over this mess, and the first wave of investigations were already well under way.  But that was last summer.

As the Texas Tornado, Mark Bennett notes, the halcyon days of last summer are over.  The second wave is coming to fruition now, and this one is going to be different.  If you didn’t get a phone call last year, then you missed it.  If the phone rings now, don’t expect much.

But mortgage fraud became so easy in the last decade, and the techniques for committing it became so widely known, that it required no special education or training. It was like stealing lawnmowers out of people’s garages. Mortgage fraud became a white-collar crime committed by blue-collar people.

Blue-collar people are often able to hire competent criminal defense counsel for most types of cases. Many of my clients are blue-collar people. But the amount of money required to properly fund the defense of a document-intensive federal case like a mortgage fraud case is much greater than that required for the defense of most any other sort of case (capital murder cases and drug cases involving wiretaps being among the exceptions).

While Bennett puts the time frame (a decade) far longer than I do, we agree on the other points.  In the first wave, the big guys with high profiles were taken down.  These were the ones who made a ton of money off of a mortgage biz where any moron could get rich.  And many a moron did.  All one needed was a clean suit, and winning smile and no scruples.

But these cases require enormous amounts of time because of the monumental volume of documents involves, not to mention the typical disorganization of the documents combined with the government’s preferred means of mass disclosure, which invariably serves to make document review as difficult as humanly possible.  It’s just an organizational wreck, and reconstruction of documents is like death by a thousand knives.  It horrible work, and it takes forever.  It is pathologically boring.  But it has to be done.

Second wave mortgage fraud defendants are a different gang than the first wave.  These are the ones who leased the most expensive Mercedes available, took a few vacations, and wasted every penny they made.  They have been out of work for the past year, since the office shut down when funding disappeared overnight, and have tried desperately to figure out how they can maintain the image of prosperity while hawking their gizmos on eBay to stay afloat.

By the time they get the 6:30 knock on the door, they are a rock.  And you can’t get blood from a rock.  They pull out the suit they used to wear to closing to come to your office with the appearance of solidity, but empty pockets.  One offered me his Rolex watch off his wrist, his last valuable possession. 

Many of the second wave defendants will believe themselves too good to be represented by a federal defender.  They want a private lawyer, because they are prominent businesspeople in their minds.  They will explain to you in detail about how they are not street criminals, and will most assuredly pay for their legal representation.  They just can’t get the retainer together at the moment, but don’t fear.  They will pay.  They promise.  They really, really promise.  And they may even mean it when they say it.

But they won’t and the can’t.  Those days are gone, and there is nowhere for them to turn to earn the money they need to defend themselves.  Their memories of the glory days won’t help them now.  And their hope for fiscal redemption is a pipe dream.


So what happens to them, those who don’t have the wherewithal to pay for a zealous defense? The luckier ones won’t have enough resources to hire lawyers at all; the really unlucky ones will have enough money to hire inexpensive lawyers.

The unlucky ones will find themselves in the perpetual quandary of criminal defense, having given away their Rolex and obtained nothing but quick plea in its place.  Whether the inexpensive lawyer means to do a good job or not, the crushing burden of defending a paper-intensive case will prove far more work than they ever imagined.  For those who want to break into white collar defense, these case will teach you a very important and painful lesson.  These will not be anything like your basic drug conspiracy.

If you are one of the lawyers on the receiving end of the telephone call, bear this in mind.  If you care about your integrity, don’t put yourself in a position where you take what little the client may have when there is no possibility that you can provide the representation he requires.  If you’re a client in need, this is the time to get very real about your status, and not place yourself in a position doomed to fail. 

The Laptop Quarantine (Los Angeles Update)

While the cases of Sebastien Boucher and Michael Arnold raised red flags about the implications for border searches of laptop computers, Homeland Security Czar Michael Chertoff has finally come clean and admitted that it is now official United States Government policy to view the contents of computers at the border because . . . they can.   As report in the Washington Post :

DHS officials said that the newly disclosed policies — which apply to anyone entering the country, including U.S. citizens — are reasonable and necessary to prevent terrorism. Officials said such procedures have long been in place but were disclosed last month because of public interest in the matter.

The policies state that officers may “detain” laptops “for a reasonable period of time” to “review and analyze information.” This may take place “absent individualized suspicion.”

In a simpler age, the rule that there was no right to privacy in ones papers and effects at the border made sense, largely because there was no harm to it.  Technology has changed this forever.  We can now carry our entire lives with us on a hard drive, including our most personal and private information.  But the old rule persists.

While the rest of us recognize that a conflict exists, not so our protectors in the government.


Customs Deputy Commissioner Jayson P. Ahern said the efforts “do not infringe on Americans’ privacy.” In a statement submitted to Feingold for a June hearing on the issue, he noted that the executive branch has long had “plenary authority to conduct routine searches and seizures at the border without probable cause or a warrant” to prevent drugs and other contraband from entering the country.

Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff wrote in an opinion piece published last month in USA Today that “the most dangerous contraband is often contained in laptop computers or other electronic devices.” Searches have uncovered “violent jihadist materials” as well as images of child pornography, he wrote.

In the past decade or so, the nature of “contraband” has changed significantly.  It used to be drugs, or untaxed jewelry, that our border guards sought.  Perhaps the fellow carrying large sums of money without declaring it.  These were hard items, physical items hidden beneath undergarments, which would be found as a federal agent searched a bag at the gate on the way out of the baggage claim area.  No one questioned or challenged their authority to do so.

The 9th Circuit decision in Arnold reflects the problem that we face now, and will continue to face in far more insidious ways going forward.   Most judges don’t get technology.  Many of our old rules simply fail when applied to technological advancements, largely because judges comprehension of how technology works and how it is used by norman people (meaning non-judges) is foreign to their experience. 

While promoting judicial modesty, as if that were an end-goal in itself, through slavish adherence to precedent as applied to limited facts beyond the experience of most judges, courts are left to fit round pegs into square holes.  And people are burned in the process.

One day, someone will find something in a laptop that will make a press release from Homeland Security to show how they saved us from terrorism.  This will be used to prove that this policy works and is necessary to our survival.  There will be no press release about the thousands of laptops seized and searched where nothing of particular interest was found, though federal agents will sit around drinking coffee and having a good chuckle over photographs of some poor guy’s naked wife, perhaps painted like a cow (there’s a bit of irony, for you).

But even the sneak peak, which thus far has been largely used as a weapon in the government’s war on porn, has gone the way of the dinosaur.  It takes time to thoroughly vet a hard drive, and the government has crafted a policy to facilitate it’s own convenience:  They are now entitled to seize and hold laptops until they have had sufficient time to do whatever it is they want to do. 


Civil liberties and business travel groups have pressed the government to disclose its procedures as an increasing number of international travelers have reported that their laptops, cellphones and other digital devices have been taken — for months, in at least one case — and their contents examined.

If it was problematic to have federal agents run through a laptop at the airport, it’s an entirely different problem to have them seize and hold it for months, without cause.  One might, rightly or not, feel that it’s only a minor inconvenience for the agent to take a quick spin though the hard drive and, finding nothing of interest, be on one’s way. 

Our computer and other digital devices are our lifeblood today.  To lose it for a day is devastating.  To lose it for a week, or months, is intolerable.  This can cause massive disruption in one’s business and personal life.  And my guesstimate is that for every digital drive that contains anything even remotely of legitimate interest to the government, 100 thousand are pristine.  Yet our government is unconcerned.

As Marc Randazza points out, there is yet another disconnect between the policy, troubling as it is, and the execution.  Washingtonian policies are ultimately executed on the ground, with discretion left to an individual of dubious competency and intelligence.  These are grocery clerks in uniforms, and yet our lives are put in their hands and left to their sense of propriety.  Once again, the lowest common denominator rules.  Anybody want to argue with the pleasant fellow at the gate about whether he should seize your laptop for as long as he damn well pleases?

This situation, as former federal judge Chertoff correctly notes, is currently permissible under law.  Indeed, if there was any doubt, the 9th Circuit removed in Arnold.  While the Boucher case may give rise to a conflict between the circuits, it may also prove to be the downfall of reason as well. 

It need not be this way.  By going back to the source, the rationale behind the rubric that border searches require no cause, and recognizing the distinction between the content of a computer and the contaminated chicken or untaxed Rolex, there is a logical ledge to stop the slide downhill that our government relies upon for its policy. 

But this would require a degree of understanding of what a search of the contents of a computer implies, rather than easy resort to the old-line border search rules.  Whether courts are up to this level of comprehension is doubtful.  The only hope is that judges may come to appreciate the extent of harm the application of the old rule will cause to millions of travelers who will suffer the consequences despite having done no wrong.  Not that this seems to bother them greatly in other instances.

As technology evolves, and judges lag farther and farther behind, problems like this will worsen.  Will we have to reach the nadir before anyone in our government recognizes the pain it causes its citizens?

Update:  Wonder what worried a young man “coming into Los Angeles” on a big airliner in the 1960s?  Customs has come a long way since then.

Is a Judge Like an Umpire?

Over at Volokh Conspiracy, where the lawprofs need not ponder in despair the lives of actual people but have the luxury of living in the sanitary world of legal theory, they have been arguing over Chief Justice John Roberts analogy of judges to umpires is appropriate.

Jim Lindgren has reposted an old story worth repeating:



First umpire: “Some are balls and some are strikes, and I call them as they are.”



Second umpire: “Some are balls and some are strikes, and I call them as I see ’em.”


Third umpire: “Some are balls and some are strikes, but they ain’t nothin’ ‘til I call ’em.”


The three umpires are intended to reflect the three approaches to judicial reasoning.  Judge Roberts responded to the analogy:



Well, I think I agree with your point about the danger of analogies in some situations. It’s not the last, because they are balls and strikes regardless, and if I call them one and they’re the other, that doesn’t change what they are, it just means that I got it wrong. I guess I liked the one in the middle, because I do think there are right answers. I know that it’s fashionable in some places to suggest that there are no right answers and that the judges are motivated by a constellation of different considerations and, because of that, it should affect how we approach certain other issues. That’s not the view of the law that I subscribe to.


I think when you folks legislate, you do have something in mind in particular and you it into words and you expect judges not to put in their own preferences, not to substitute their judgment for you, but to implement your view of what you are accomplishing in that statute. I think, when the framers framed the Constitution, it was the same thing. And the judges were not to put in their own personal views about what the Constitution should say, but they’re just supposed to interpret it and apply the meaning that is in the Constitution. And I think there is meaning there and I think there is meaning in your legislation. And the job of a good judge is to do as good a job as possible to get the right answer.


Again, I know there are those theorists who think that’s futile, or because it’s hard in particular cases, we should just throw up our hands and not try. In any case — and I don’t subscribe to that — I believe that there are right answers and judges, if they work hard enough, are likely to come up with them.


The lawprofs continue to argue over the merit of the analogy, with Ilya Somin arguing that if baseball umpires make the wrong calls too often, they can be easily fired from the job.  Supreme Court justices are not so easily dismissed.

What strikes me as the greatest failing of the analogy is that appellate judges never actually see the pitch.  They only hear about it from others. 

Trial judges see the pitch, and then describe it through the prism of their own experience. This becomes the reality of the pitch, no matter how well or poorly they made their call.  Should it ultimately find its way to the Supreme Court, the justices will discuss the pitch as if they were there, as if they saw it themselves.  

Do they realize that they never actually saw the pitch?  

Experience as Deep as a Puddle

While Blonde Justice has been on a bit of a food binge lately, the former PD turned high power criminal defense associate complains of her youthful adversaries, 24 year old prosecutors.  Since BJ isn’t much older (she swears she’s not), it was good that she saw what comes into focus with increasing clarity over time:  The discretion involved in prosecuting others requires a depth of understanding that so many young people don’t, as yet, possess.

In discussing cases, both from the perspective of arguing with prosecutors about whether evidence shows that a crime was committed, or that the defendant is the person who committed the crime, as well as what to do with the defendant during plea discussions, I find there is a huge, often insurmountable, wall between us.  Most prosecutors are, as Blondie notes, kids.  They come out of the law school and head straight into a DAs office somewhere, swelling with the importance of their job and pumped up by the introduction of some senior ADA with at best a dog’s year on them about how they are saving the unfortunate victims of crime from misery. 

They are society’s protectors.  That’s a heavy gig for a kid.  It makes them feel very important, very self-righteous.  It is intended to make an impression on impressionable minds.

But in life, and in law, context counts.  Weighing good and evil, right and wrong is a balancing act that requires one to understand relative merit.  Remember the cop lecture where he said that everybody commits crimes?  He was right, as we all know if we have been around long enough to have an opportunity to do so and if we are honest enough with ourselves to admit it. 

But it takes a certain degree of understanding of human nature, human frailty, to appreciate whether a person deserves harsh treatment or made a stupid mistake under peculiar circumstances and deserves to have their life destroyed for it.  Young people see things in black and white because they lack worldly experience needed to see shades of gray.

This is not to say that there aren’t some bad people out there who commit bad crimes and deserve punishment.  This is to say that few young people have the depth of experience in life to make the decisions they are expected to make.  The problem is exacerbated by their being cloistered in a courthouse.

One of the recurring themes is that young prosecutors compare what defendants do to themselves:  Well, I was 18 onces, and I didn’t commit a crime, so the defendant has no excuse for not behaving just like the prosecutor.  Of course, the prosecutor wasn’t raised in the ghetto, with a junkie mother and no father, in abject poverty, going to a school where survival each day was considered a success and where the only way out was to become a basketball star or a drug dealer.  Or a cop.

Even young assistant United States Attorneys, who work a couple of years before getting the gig (and thus believing that they are far worldlier than their state counterparts) show their remarkable lack of depth of experience. In my white collar defense work, their comprehension of business and motivations is almost non-existent.  They know so little about how people who own businesses behave, and overlay child-like assumptions of propriety to reach absurd conclusions.  And they act upon their own certainty in a world of shockingly harsh consequences, and won’t consider that they might just not get it at all.

I agree completely with Blondie that we have put a loaded weapon in the hands of children, one that they are ill-equipped to handle.  Until they have learned that there are others in the world, with educational, cultural, intellectual and psychological differences, they cannot exercise discretion properly.

If this wasn’t bad enough, we have judges who have no greater depth of experience than our young prosecutors.

On the other hand, an old fool is worse than a young fool.

The other day, I was talking to co-counsel on a white collar case in federal court.  He was a former AUSA, having risen to a Chief in the United States Attorneys office, and he bemoaned the choices offered his client, explaining to me that his client had no shot at trial but no option given the harsh plea offer.  His client may well have done wrong, but not in the sense of a murder or rape.  His client’s alleged crime was economic, reducing the profit of a corporation.  The consequence, however, was as severe as if he had brutally murdered someone.

My co-counsel, who is an excellent attorney, was torn between being inured to the lack of options and his deep concern for his client.  He felt that sense of powerlessness because he couldn’t persuade the AUSA to understand how disproportionately harsh this was.  The AUSA felt nothing toward his client. 

As I listened to co-counsel’s complaint, I couldn’t help but think to myself, “when you were a young AUSA, holding enormous power over the lives of others, would you have done anything differently?”  My co-counsel was now qualified to do the job he had done in his youth.

It’s not the hatred of injustice that sticks with you as you age, but the recognition that these are all human beings.  When you are young, everything seems so simple.  It becomes so much more complicated when you start thinking about each one as a real person.

Undecided or Ignorant, The Swing Voter Rules

A fascinating post by Ilya Somin at Volokh asserts that the swing voter is not only likely to be the one who decides an election, but the most politically ignorant.


As I have discussed in various articles (e.g. here and here), most citizens know little about politics. They are rationally ignorant. Because there is so little chance that your vote will be decisive (less than 1 in 100 million in a presidential election), there’s no incentive to acquire political knowledge if your only reason for doing so is to cast a better-informed vote in order to ensure that the “right” candidate wins. Numerous studies find, however, that swing voters – defined as those who are in the ideological center and don’t have any strong identification with either party – are among the most ignorant. For example, in my research using questions from the 2000 National Election Study, I found that self-identified “Independent-Independents” could on average correctly answer only 9.5 of 31 basic political knowledge questions, scoring much lower than self-described “strong Democrats” (15.4) and “strong Republicans” (18.7). Many other studies find similar results.

Thus, the voters who know the least are the ones who tend to determine electoral outcomes. Not exactly a comforting thought.

Intuitively, there’s a perfectly reasonable explanation for swing voters, as individuals who were more even-kheeled, willing to consider candidates with a mind less cluttered by ideological bias so that they were open, even desirous, of learning as much as possible before casting their lot with one side or the other.  Not so, according to Ilya.


Part of the reason why swing voters tend to be ignorant is that they have lower average education levels than committed partisans, and education is correlated with political knowledge. But another important factor is that they tend to be less interested in politics; in most studies, interest in politics is a stronger predictor of political knowledge than any other variable, including education, income, race, gender, etc. Their lack of interest is part of what prevents them from developing strong ideological or partisan commitments in the first place.

As Ilya concedes, the lack of interest in politics is a very rational position, since no individual voter has much of an influence in the outcome, and spending too much personal capital learning about something that you cannot impact is an irrational way to spend one’s time, if the purpose is to be a good citizen.  If it’s morbid curiosity, that’s another matter.

If Ilya’s correct, it suggests that the experiment of democracy is ultimately subject to the lowest (read most ignorant) common denominator, as the least ignorant have long since taken sides leaving the final vote to a group that cares little and knows less.   Which explains a lot when you think about it.

How to Entice a “White Collar Associate”

While it falls well outside the norm for me to raise (or even read) job listings used on another blawg, this one at Above the Law was just too hard to ignore.

Just so you’re clear, ATL has a primary sponsor, Lateral Link, which is a legal headhunder tapping the huge number of Biglaw associates and Biglaw wannabes.  They would probably come to Simple Justice as sponsor, except for the fact that we have a tenth of ATL’s readership and no one that would interest them at all.  Most of the time, anyway.  But check out the “Lateral Link Job of the Week:”


Because there will always be white-collar work…


Position: White Collar Associate


Location: New York, NY


Description: This top firm is seeking a junior to mid-level litigation associate to join its top -ranked white-collar practice. With approximately 50 attorneys, this firm is consistently ranked as the top white-collar boutique in New York. The firm takes on criminal and civil cases that are often front page news. The firm is known for getting their people great front-line work experience in a variety of interesting cases. This firm is also well-regarded as an outstanding stepping stone to the DOJ as well as the US Attorney’s office.


Notice the highlighted teaser in the last sentence?  While my first inclination is to write a screed decrying in excruciating detail what’s wrong with this sentence, I will demur and let you draw your own conclusions.  I will, however, ask a couple of pointed questions.

To those of you who aspire to practice “white collar” defense at a largish law firm, was it you secret hope to use the position to ingratiate yourself with the United States Attorney’s office?

To those of you who sought a “big time” white collar defender, with the hope of having the slightest chance of winning, did you know that your champion was biding his time until he could jump ship to the prosecution, perhaps using you as his wedge to prove how prosecution-minded he is?

There aren’t that many 50 lawyer white collar criminal defense firms in Manhattan.  Anybody want to guess who is looking for a “white collar associate?”

Sympathy for the Biglaw Devil

The very name, Cadwalader, Wickersham & Taft, conjures up images of the whitest of white shoes in the world of law, meaning that it holds neither interest nor relevance to those of us who toil in the nasty trenches of the criminal justice system.  It’s just so, so, waspish.

So this bit of news may have escaped the notice of criminal defense lawyers, as 96 lawyers were laid off from CWT this week.  It seems that they weren’t all that thrilled with the love they were getting there to begin with, as CWT ranked last among Biglaw in associate satisfaction.  Even so, no doubt the lawyers found a bit of cheer when they received their very large paychecks and bonus checks and perks and all the other great stuff that Biglaw lawyers get that trench lawyers only dream about.

It seems that the “carnage”, as David Lat calls it, stems from an 80% drop in “real estate securitization,” also known as mortgage-backed securities.  It went from $314 billion last year to a mere $60 billion this year.  But you probably already know this, feeling the pinch yourself.  After all, this affects our practices too, right?

So what is a second year associate to do when his multi-hundred thousand dollar job disappears and there’s lease payments to be made on that Mercedes?  They aren’t hiring anywhere in Biglaw, though laterals with portfolios of clients to carry around are still dancing with as many partners as they can.  But these youngsters have no friends.  Plenty of company, but no friends.

Criminal defense may be law, but it bears no resemblance to Biglaw.  Other than the handful of former AUSAs who are taken in so that Biglaw can pretend that they do “white collar” defense, defined as marching their scared and shaking CEOs to the US Attorney’s office for coffee and scones for a few million dollars, they sit in sanitary offices and pray that their computers don’t crash in the middle of keeping time sheets on their deep clients thoughts.

As regular readers know, I am a deeply empathetic person.  I care for others.  I feel their pain (not in a Bill Clinton way).  But I’m having a difficult time mustering any tears for the axed 96.  As Icarus learned, flying too high leads to a crash.  The salaries and bonuses paid to young lawyers at Biglaw were astronomical, far in excess of their value under any rational scheme.  These were numbers that would make any public defender angry, and even a federal judge blush.

So 96 lawyers had their day in the sun, a bright, burning sun that led them to believe that their future was secure and that they would live in a world of plenty for the rest of their lives.  And then one day it ended.  How does that compare to the thousands of lawyers who toil in the trenches, whose annual salaries were less than these dilettantes’ bonus checks? 

There should be no satisfaction to be found in the fact that the Biglaw myth has its occasional cracks, and that good people have lost a job and found themselves in unfortunate straits.  But then, it’s hard to forget the smugness of Biglaw associates as they wrapped themselves in the glorious perks of their new jobs while those who went off in the other direction, to public defender and prosecutor offices, where they would barely earn enough to pay off their student loans. 

Maybe Biglaw isn’t all it’s cracked up to be.  And maybe some Biglaw lawyers should consider that their world may some day crash and they will have to go to work in the trenches if they want to survive.  Life is tough in the trenches.  But at least the trenches will always be there.  And that’s where real lawyer work happens, and real people are helped.  But it just doesn’t pay as well, so you may have to put the Ferrari on hold.

What Kind of Idiot… (Twisted Update)

As reported by the WSJ Law Blog, there is something seriously wrong with criminal defense lawyer Carlos D. Romious. Romious, with at least one if not several screws loose, went on a tear against Greene County Missouri Judge Tom Mountjoy and bought himself a 120 day sentence for contempt.  Mountjoy was either being kind or blew it completely.  Which one is unclear.

Here’s a partial litany of Romious’ conduct:





  • Romious “loudly and rudely” asked Judge Mountjoy “if the ‘proceeding was a joke’ and stated to the Court ‘you’re going to sit your a** up there.’ “
  • Romious accused Judge Mountjoy of “corrupting and stinking up the case” and “corrupting this system.”
  • When Judge Mountjoy ordered the attorney to appear in court at 8 a.m. on June 18, Romious said “don’t hold your breath.” When Romious did show up on June 18, he at one point asked the judge, “Are you a pedophile?”
  • The judgment also references an instance where Romious wadded up papers and smashed them with his shoe after taking the documents from his opposing counsel.

    • The fraud trial was scheduled to start on June 19, but Romious did not show up to court. The AP reports that Court records indicate Romious was scheduled to appear as a defendant in a Kansas federal court that day on a charge of assaulting a court security officer. That charge reportedly stemmed from a May incident in which Romious allegedly assaulted a court security officer after he refused to pass through a metal detector in a courthouse in Kansas City.
    • The first question this begs is whether Romious was psychologically competent.  This smells of a psychotic episode, since it’s almost impossible to think that any lawyer would engage in this sort of conduct otherwise.  The assault on the court officer, aside from the issue with Judge Mountjoy, certainly add fuel to the fire.

      Lacking any qualifications to diagnosis Romious, let’s take this story from the position that he was sane.  The man is an idiot.  It doesn’t matter how outrageous he felt Judge Mountjoy may have been, or how frustrated he was with the criminal justice system.  You don’t behave this way.  You don’t accomplish anything by behaving this way.  You get nowhere.  And when your role is to represent another human being, you do not have the right to indulge one’s personal fantasies of rage against the system on the defendant’s back. 

      But if we are to view Romious’ behavior as an indication that this is a seriously unstable individual, then what is he doing practicing law in this condition?  Rather than being held in contempt, he should be held for a psych evaluation. 

      While the WSJ categorized this story under “lawyers behaving badly,” I think they’ve missed the boat.  This lawyer either suffers from a psychological infirmity or is shockingly incompetent.  Psychosis seems the most likely, because the alternative is just too far beyond the pale to accept.   And if Romious’ conduct was the result of psychosis, then the solution isn’t contempt but treatment.

      Even defense lawyers can go nuts.  Maybe even more so than others.

      And now, because it fits, and because I like it…

      Challenging Acquitted Conduct Sentencing

      Doug Berman at Sentencing Law and Policy has been following the efforts of the Federal Defenders to provide background papers on some of the most pressing issues in federal sentencing under the heading of deconstructing the relevant sentencing guidelines.

      Amy Baron-Evans, National Sentencing Resource Counsel at the Federal Defenders, along with Jennifer Niles Coffin, has produced an extraordinary paper on the use of uncharged and acquitted conduct in federal sentencing, and has made the paper available to the rest of us here.

      Under certain portions of the “relevant conduct” guideline and its commentary, judges are required to calculate the guideline range based not only on the crime of conviction, but on separate crimes, comprised of their own elements, of which the defendant was acquitted, with which the defendant was never charged, or which were dismissed.1 The Commission advises judges to find these separate crimes by a preponderance of the “information,” without regard to its admissibility under the rules of evidence, if there is sufficient indicia of reliability to support its “probable accuracy.”2 The guideline range is then increased by the same number of months or years as if the defendant had been charged by indictment and convicted by a jury on proof beyond a reasonable doubt, limited only by the statutory maximum for the offense of conviction. These provisions were a radical departure from past practice in the federal courts and national experience in the states, were not authorized by Congress, and were adopted without empirical support. They have been subject to enduring criticism and calls for reform since their inception, to no avail.

      For anyone whose practice includes federal defense, this paper is of enormous value and will serve your clients well.  Download it, read it, read it again, and save it.  You will appreciate it.  You will use it.

      Kudos to Amy Baron-Evans and Jennifer Niles Coffin, and my thanks for making your efforts available to the rest of us.